Gina Hinojosa Said WHAT About Texas Gun Owners?! — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Texas just elected a governor who once
- 0:02wrote an entire article explaining that
- 0:04Texans don't really care about guns. And
- 0:06she even gave me the perfect phrase to
- 0:09describe it. All hat and no cattle. In
- 0:13Texas, we have a saying for putting
- 0:15style before substance. All hat and no
- 0:18cattle. Gina, I could not agree more.
- 0:21So, let's talk about your article. On
- 0:23November 3rd, Gina Henosa beat Greg
- 0:26Abbott and became the first Democrat to
- 0:28win the Texas governor's race since Anne
- 0:30Richards. And since the win, she's been
- 0:33pretty quiet on guns for the most part.
- 0:35So, people have been wondering whether
- 0:37she's really that far out there on the
- 0:39Second Amendment. Well, I was doing some
- 0:41reading in my other office and I found
- 0:43the answer. She wrote it herself back in
- 0:462019. The title is The False Narrative
- 0:49of Texas Gun Culture. You don't have to
- 0:52guess where she stands. She already
- 0:54wrote it down for you. She opens by
- 0:56telling you how Texan she is. Horse as a
- 0:59kid, UT Austin, Dr. Pepper. Then she
- 1:03tells you what guns in Texas are
- 1:05actually for. Guns are part of our
- 1:07strong connection to the land and nature
- 1:09and as such have always been used for
- 1:12food, sport, and protection. Not
- 1:15protection from other Texans, but from
- 1:17wild animals. Not protection from other
- 1:20Texans. I have put out more defensive
- 1:22gun use videos than I can count. A lot
- 1:24of them come out of Texas. So, Governor
- 1:27Elect, who are those people defending
- 1:29themselves from? Tourists from Wyoming?
- 1:31A rattlesnake that learned to pick a
- 1:33deadbolt? Those were Texans defending
- 1:35themselves from other Texans because
- 1:38Texans are the people who live in Texas.
- 1:41And the best part is she makes my
- 1:44argument for me later in her own article
- 1:46with 88% of Texans living in
- 1:49metropolitan areas. 88%. So, the
- 1:52overwhelming majority of Texans live in
- 1:54cities. And her model for how Texans
- 1:56should think about guns is grandma on a
- 1:59farm outside of Brennham shooting
- 2:01rattlesnakes. If you're in a Dallas
- 2:02apartment at 2 in the morning, a
- 2:04rattlesnake isn't anywhere near the top
- 2:06of the list of things that might come
- 2:07through the door. Then she says this,
- 2:09"Texans carried shotguns, not handguns.
- 2:12And most self-respecting Texans would
- 2:14never carry an assault weapon. Where's
- 2:16the sport in that? Where's the sport in
- 2:18that, ma'am? When somebody kicks your
- 2:20door in at 2:00 a.m., nobody is keeping
- 2:22score. Defending your life has never
- 2:25been a sport. And the Second Amendment
- 2:26was never written around hunting. That's
- 2:29the trick they keep trying to pull. Get
- 2:31you to look at the Second Amendment from
- 2:32inside a deer blind. Once you accept
- 2:35that view, anything more than a shotgun
- 2:37starts to look excessive. And
- 2:39self-respecting Texans. This is the
- 2:41state where the Mexican government gave
- 2:44the town of Gonzalez a canyon, then sent
- 2:47soldiers to take it back. And the Texans
- 2:50put that cannon on a flag and wrote,
- 2:52"Come and take it under it." That story
- 2:55about refusing to hand over a weapon is
- 2:57one of the founding legends of this
- 2:58state. And now she's telling Texans
- 3:00they'd be embarrassed to own an AR-15.
- 3:03Ma'am, we told the Mexican government to
- 3:05go themselves when they tried to
- 3:07take back a cannon they gave us. The
- 3:08only reason a Texan would be embarrassed
- 3:10to own an AR-15 is that it isn't an
- 3:12actual machine gun. Now, watch the
- 3:14goalpost move. For years, the line was,
- 3:17"Nobody needs an AR-15. A handgun is
- 3:19plenty for self-defense." Now, it's
- 3:21Texans carried shotguns, not handguns.
- 3:24And if that sounds familiar, it's
- 3:26because we've heard it before. If you
- 3:28want to protect yourself, get a double
- 3:30barrel shotgun,
- 3:32have the shells, a 12 gauge shotgun, and
- 3:35I promise you, as I told my wife, we
- 3:38live in an area that's wooded and
- 3:40somewhat secluded. said, "Jill, if
- 3:43there's ever a problem, just walk out on
- 3:45the balcony here or walk out, put that
- 3:47double barrel shotgun and fire two
- 3:50blasts outside the house.
- 3:53>> Fire two blasts outside the house."
- 3:55Legal advice from Joe Biden when
- 3:57someone's breaking in. Step out onto the
- 3:59balcony, fire two warning shots into the
- 4:02air, and hope the guy coming through
- 4:03your door is impressed.
- 4:05>> You don't need an AR-15.
- 4:07It's harder to aim. It's harder to use.
- 4:10And in fact, you don't need 30 rounds to
- 4:13protect yourself. Buy a shotgun.
- 4:16>> Congratulations, Gina. You took Joe
- 4:18Biden's just buy a shotgun and gave it a
- 4:20Texas accent. And look at how it moves.
- 4:23The AR-15 is too much. Then the handgun
- 4:26is too much. Next year, someone will
- 4:28write an op-ed about the true Texan
- 4:30tradition of the slingshot. Every time
- 4:32you give them an inch, they come back
- 4:34for more. Look at the next demand. It's
- 4:36always smaller than the last thing they
- 4:38said was reasonable. Then she tries to
- 4:40back it up with history. In my part of
- 4:42the world, no Texas civilian ever
- 4:43carried a handgun for self-p protection
- 4:46until fairly recently that was illegal.
- 4:48In fact, Texas was the first state to
- 4:50ban the carrying of handguns in 1871. In
- 4:53my part of the world, that's the
- 4:56giveaway. Your social circle doesn't get
- 4:59to stand in for the entire history of
- 5:01Texas. First state, Kentucky banned
- 5:04carrying concealed weapons in 1813. To
- 5:06be fair, Kucky's law covered concealed
- 5:09carry, and Texas went after open and
- 5:11concealed carry. That difference
- 5:13matters. But if you're going to call
- 5:15yourself first, you'd better be right.
- 5:17And the 1871 law she's leaning on, it
- 5:20had exceptions. Your own home, your
- 5:23place of business, travelers carrying
- 5:25arms in their baggage, and anyone with
- 5:27reasonable grounds for fearing an
- 5:29unlawful attack on his person that was
- 5:31immediate and pressing. An unlawful
- 5:34attack. Rattlesnakes don't commit
- 5:36unlawful attacks. Now, that exception
- 5:38was narrow. You couldn't just say, "I
- 5:41carry for protection." The danger had to
- 5:43be immediate and pressing, serious
- 5:45enough to alarm a person of ordinary
- 5:47courage, and you had to carry the gun
- 5:49openly, which means you got arrested
- 5:51first and explained your fear to a jury
- 5:53later. And the Supreme Court noticed
- 5:54what that sounds like. In Breuan, the
- 5:57court said the Texas rule works a lot
- 5:59like New York's proper cause
- 6:01requirement. We acknowledge that the
- 6:02Texas cases support New York's proper
- 6:05cause requirement, which one can
- 6:07analogize to Texas reasonable ground
- 6:09standard. So, the law she's holding up
- 6:11as authentic Texas is the great great
- 6:14grandfather of the exact law the Supreme
- 6:16Court struck down in 2022. Prove to the
- 6:18government you deserve to protect
- 6:20yourself or leave the gun at home. And
- 6:22here's the kicker. If nobody was
- 6:24carrying handguns, why did they need a
- 6:26law against it? The governor who pushed
- 6:28for it answered that himself. Governor
- 6:31Edmund Davis told the legislature that
- 6:33universal habit of carrying arms was
- 6:36largely to blame for the killings in
- 6:37Texas. The man who wanted the ban
- 6:39described Texas as a place where
- 6:42everybody carried. And 150 years later,
- 6:45she wants you to believe nobody did. Gun
- 6:47restrictions in Texas were originally an
- 6:49effort to keep guns out of the hands of
- 6:51blacks and Latinos, but they stayed on
- 6:53the books for 125 years. Racist gun laws
- 6:56are real. I've made videos about them.
- 6:58But a specific claim about this specific
- 7:00law needs evidence about that law. A
- 7:02detailed study in the Texas&M law review
- 7:05argues that reconstruction Republicans
- 7:07passed these restrictions to protect
- 7:09freed slaves from racial violence. And
- 7:11that study is posted on Every Town Law's
- 7:14own website. So the push back on her
- 7:16history comes from the gun control side.
- 7:18You can argue with that reading. You
- 7:20can't act like the question is settled
- 7:22because your paragraph needs it to be.
- 7:24So which one is it, Henosa? You're
- 7:26pointing to an 1871 handgun carry ban
- 7:28like you've caught modern conservative
- 7:29Texas contradicting itself. So, let's
- 7:32tell the whole story. The ban was pushed
- 7:33by a Republican governor and passed by a
- 7:35reconstruction Republican legislature
- 7:37with every black legislature voting yes.
- 7:39The opposition came mostly from
- 7:41Democrats and conservative Republicans,
- 7:44a lot of them former Confederate
- 7:46officers. And when the Democrats took
- 7:48Texas back a few years later, they tore
- 7:50down most of what that governor built
- 7:52and kept the carry ban, which stayed on
- 7:54the books for more than a century. So go
- 7:56ahead and try to hang that law on
- 7:58today's party labels. The people who
- 8:00passed it, the people who fought it, and
- 8:03the people who kept it don't line up
- 8:05with anybody's modern bumper sticker.
- 8:07Anyone who skips that part is giving you
- 8:09the date and leaving out the politics.
- 8:11And here's what she really leaves out.
- 8:13The Supreme Court has already looked at
- 8:14this exact law. In brewing, New York and
- 8:17the federal government pointed the court
- 8:19to the 1871 Texas law. And I'll be fair
- 8:21here because the court was. It admitted
- 8:24the Texas cases support New York's side.
- 8:26Then it said this, "But the Texas
- 8:29statute and the rationale set forth in
- 8:31English and Duke are outliers. Only one
- 8:34other state, West Virginia, passed
- 8:36anything like it before 1900, and the
- 8:38court refused to rewrite a
- 8:40constitutional right around one state's
- 8:42law. Apart from a few late 19th century
- 8:44outlier jurisdictions, American
- 8:46governments simply have not broadly
- 8:48prohibited the public carry of commonly
- 8:50used firearms for personal defense. Now,
- 8:52pay attention to who the outlier was.
- 8:54The court was talking about the
- 8:55government of Texas. As for the people
- 8:57of Texas, 2 years after that law passed,
- 9:00the state's own judged
- 9:06outside the more populous counties. So,
- 9:08the government of Texas broke from the
- 9:09American tradition for a while, and a
- 9:11whole lot of Texans responded by
- 9:13ignoring it, which might be the most
- 9:15Texas thing I've ever heard. She went
- 9:17digging through Texas history and found
- 9:19the exception and tried to sell it to
- 9:21you as the rule. It wasn't until after
- 9:23George W. Bush unseated Governor Anne
- 9:25Richards in 1994 that handguns were
- 9:27legal to carry in the state of Texas.
- 9:29Texas passed its concealed handgun
- 9:31licensing law in 1995, and the state
- 9:34started issuing licenses January 1st,
- 9:361996. that opened up licensed carry for
- 9:38ordinary people. It didn't create the
- 9:40first armed Texan. A ban tells you what
- 9:43the government allowed. It doesn't tell
- 9:44you what people did, what they believed,
- 9:46or what they needed to stay alive. And
- 9:48then she gives the whole thing away. I
- 9:50couldn't tell you if many Texans started
- 9:52carrying guns after the law was passed.
- 9:54No one I knew did. She couldn't tell
- 9:56you. The woman who wrote an article
- 9:58explaining Texas gun culture to the rest
- 10:00of the country couldn't tell you whether
- 10:02Texans were carrying guns. Speaking of
- 10:03Texans who aren't going anywhere, this
- 10:06is Keep America Tactical, the state
- 10:08specific gear. And yeah, the Texas line
- 10:10hits different right now. We've got a
- 10:12govern who thinks we only carry for
- 10:14snakes. So wear something that tells
- 10:17Austin exactly who still lives here. And
- 10:19if you're not in Texas, your state is in
- 10:21there, too. All of them. Shirts, hats,
- 10:23drinkear, everything at
- 10:25shop.mmcolon.com.
- 10:27There's one more thing about this
- 10:28article. She wrote a whole piece about
- 10:30guns in Texas and never mentioned the
- 10:32Second Amendment. Not one time. She
- 10:34described a Texas where the right
- 10:35doesn't exist, where a gun is a farm
- 10:38tool you tolerate until the snakes are
- 10:40gone. The Supreme Court said in Heler
- 10:42that self-defense is the core of this
- 10:44right. Her article spends its whole
- 10:45length explaining that self-defense
- 10:47against people was never part of the
- 10:49Texas story. And she ends here. Today,
- 10:52the sight of someone carrying a gun
- 10:54still seems unnatural to me. That's the
- 10:57woman about to take office as governor
- 10:59of Texas. Gina, you wrote this article
- 11:01because Texas has the reputation it has
- 11:03and Texas earned that reputation. So,
- 11:06you were right about one thing. All hat,
- 11:08no cattle. You just pointed it at the
- 11:10wrong people.
- 11:14One thing's for certain and two things
- 11:15are for sure. Politicians and tech
- 11:17giants don't want gun content to be
- 11:19recommended to you. And we're all
- 11:21fighting this culture war together. Now,
- 11:23you can help do your part by liking,
- 11:25commenting, subscribing to the channel,
- 11:27but most importantly, sharing this video
- 11:29with at least one person. Together, we
- 11:31can stop the suppression of our two-way
- 11:33rights. And don't forget to click the
- 11:35link in the description section of this
- 11:36video for the products that I mentioned
- 11:38in this
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Gina Hinojosa Said WHAT About Texas Gun Owners?! by Colion Noir, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 2,113 words across 318 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.