YT YouTube2Text

YouTube2Text → Transcripts → “Get Out! We’re Better Off Without You!” My Daughter-In-Law Slapped Me At Christmas Dinner. 2 Hou...

“Get Out! We’re Better Off Without You!” My Daughter-In-Law Slapped Me At Christmas Dinner. 2 Hou... — Transcript

by Blood And Boundaries · 3,667 words · 609 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Open in transcriber Summarize with AI Download SRT/VTT

Full transcript

0:00Get out.
0:01We're better off without you. Samantha
0:04screamed it so hard the stemware on my
0:06table rattled and then she hit me.
0:09It was an open hand across my left cheek
0:12loud as a book dropped on a tile floor.
0:15The whole dining room stopped.
0:18Samantha's mother, Marilyn, had her fork
0:20halfway to her mouth. My 11-year-old
0:23granddaughter, Olivia, stood frozen in
0:26the hallway with a plate of cookies and
0:28my son, Corey, looked down at the
0:31cranberry sauce on his plate like it had
0:34personally asked him a question.
0:36My name is Darlene Barnes. I'm 66 years
0:40old and I've been a widow for 8 years.
0:44Until that Christmas night, I was also
0:46the reason my daughter-in-law lived in a
0:49four-bedroom colonial in Westerville,
0:51Ohio without ever writing a rent check.
0:55Before we get into it, write the name of
0:57your town in the comments for me.
1:00I didn't touch my face. I didn't cry. I
1:03just looked at Samantha, at the red wine
1:06on her lip, and the fury in her eyes and
1:08thought, "So, this is who you've been
1:11all along."
1:12It had started over a kitchen.
1:14Samantha wanted new quartz counters, a
1:17six-burner range, and an island the size
1:21of a pontoon boat.
1:23$41,000
1:25from a company called Lewis Builders.
1:27She denounced over the turkey that she'd
1:30already signed the contract and that I'd
1:32be covering the deposit and the rest.
1:35When I said quietly that I wouldn't be,
1:38that this was something she and Corey
1:40could save for, her whole face changed.
1:43"You're sitting on a fortune," she said.
1:46"Your grandkids live in this house and
1:49you can't spare a few dollars so they
1:51have a decent kitchen?"
1:53"The kitchen is fine, Samantha," I said.
1:56"I'd be glad to help you plan for it.
1:58I'm not writing a check tonight.
2:00Marilyn made a little sound in her
2:02throat.
2:03Well, you did push her, Darlene.
2:06That was Samantha stood up.
2:09Nobody said a word after the slap. Then
2:11I put my napkin on the table, folded it
2:14once, and stood. I took my wool coat off
2:17the back of my chair.
2:19Corey finally lifted his head.
2:21Mom, he said, Mom, wait. She's just
2:24stressed.
2:25Is that right? I said.
2:28Samantha crossed her arms and lifted her
2:30chin.
2:31She'd done this to me for years.
2:33She would blow up, and I would smooth it
2:35over. And the next morning there'd be a
2:38casserole dish on my porch like a peace
2:40treaty.
2:41She was waiting for me to start
2:43apologizing.
2:45I could see it on her face.
2:47Fine, I said. You won't have to see me
2:49again.
2:51I walked out into the cold.
2:53I didn't slam the door. I've learned
2:55that the quietest exits are the ones
2:58people can't argue with.
3:00Corey followed me out to the driveway
3:02without his coat. Snow was coming down
3:04in slow, fat flakes settling on the hood
3:08of my Buick. Mom, don't do this tonight.
3:11It's Christmas. Just come back in, have
3:14some pie, and we'll sort it out
3:16tomorrow.
3:17She hit me, Corey.
3:19I know.
3:21I know, and it was wrong. But you know
3:24how she gets, and if you just wouldn't
3:26bring up money in front of her mother
3:29I looked at my son, 40 years old, 6'1,
3:33an analyst at Snyder Analytics with a
3:36good salary and a gentle heart. And he
3:38was standing in the snow explaining how
3:41I should behave so his wife wouldn't be
3:43upset again.
3:45Go inside, honey, I said. Your children
3:48are watching from the window.
3:50I drove home. It's a 15-minute drive
3:53from that house to mine, past the church
3:56with the plastic nativity and the gas
3:58station where Richard and I used to buy
4:01lottery tickets.
4:03I made it home with my hands steady on
4:05the wheel. It was only when I turned the
4:07key in my own front door that my knees
4:10went soft and I had to sit down on the
4:13bottom stair with my coat still on.
4:16I let myself shake for about 4 minutes.
4:19Then I got up, made a pot of decaf, and
4:22opened my laptop on the kitchen table.
4:25I should explain what Samantha didn't
4:27understand and what Corey had never
4:30really let himself look at.
4:33When Richard passed, he left me
4:35comfortable. He'd spent 30 years running
4:37a small commercial roofing company. And
4:41when I sold it, the number surprised
4:43even me. In 2019, I bought that colonial
4:47outright.
4:48In my name alone, so Corey's family
4:51could have a yard and a good school
4:52district. I told them they could live
4:55there for as long as they liked. I never
4:58asked for rent.
5:00I paid the property taxes, nearly $8,000
5:03a year. I paid the homeowner's
5:05insurance.
5:07I paid the lawn service, the cleaning
5:09crew every other Friday, the internet,
5:13the cable, and the private school
5:15tuition for Olivia and her little
5:17brother Ezra. I'd put Samantha on a
5:19credit card years ago to help her build
5:22her credit. That card had quietly become
5:25her grocery money, her Pilates money,
5:28and her weekend away money.
5:31I'd called it helping. I'd called it
5:33family.
5:34So I went through my accounts one by
5:36one, the way Richard had taught me to
5:38read a balance sheet without feeling
5:41anything. First the credit card,
5:43authorized users, Samantha Barnes,
5:46remove, confirm.
5:49Then the house maintenance account.
5:51I'd opened it jointly, so Samantha could
5:53handle a plumber
5:55or a roofer if I was traveling.
5:58There was $23,000
6:00in it.
6:01Her name was on it only for convenience.
6:04I moved every dollar into my own
6:07checking account and then I scrolled
6:10through the transaction history because
6:12I wanted to see what I was leaving
6:14behind.
6:15I had assumed it would show shoes and
6:18spa days. It did, but there was
6:20something else recurring on the first of
6:23every month going back almost 3 years.
6:26$1,200 Zelle to a name I knew very well,
6:30Marilyn Peters.
6:32I looked at that line for a long time.
6:3536 payments. $43,200
6:40from the account I'd created for the
6:42roof and the water heater quietly
6:45redirected to Samantha's mother.
6:47I didn't cry over that either. I closed
6:50the laptop and drank my decaf. When I
6:53glanced at the clock on the stove, it
6:56had been exactly 1 hour and 52 minutes
6:59since I'd walked out of that house.
7:02At the 2-hour mark, my phone rang.
7:05I let it ring four times, then I
7:07answered. Hello Samantha.
7:09Darlene.
7:11Her voice was thin and cracking, nothing
7:14like the voice from the dining room.
7:16Behind her, I could hear Marilyn saying
7:18something sharp and fast.
7:20Darlene, please.
7:22The Lewis Builders portal just declined
7:24the deposit. We have a $12,000 payment
7:28due by midnight to hold the January crew
7:30and the card isn't working.
7:33Something is wrong with it. Nothing is
7:36wrong with it, I said.
7:38I removed you from the account.
7:40A silence. Marilyn's voice went up
7:42behind her. Tell her to fix it, Sammy.
7:45Tell her it's an emergency.
7:48Why would you do that? Samantha
7:50whispered. Darlene, I'm sorry about
7:53tonight, okay? I'm sorry. It got out of
7:56hand, but you can't just leave us like
7:58this. Please, just come back. We can
8:01talk and you can bring your checkbook
8:03and we'll
8:05You "You me you were better off without
8:07I said, 'I'm taking you at your word.'"
8:11"I didn't mean it."
8:13"You meant it enough to say it in front
8:15of my grandchildren, and you meant it
8:17enough to hit me."
8:19I kept my voice even. It surprised me
8:21how easy that was. It surprised me how
8:24easy Samantha. Then I've you're better
8:26off without
8:27then I'd imagine you'll you'll be fine
8:29without my credit card, too. Good night.
8:32I hung up and turned the phone face down
8:35on the table.
8:37I didn't sleep much.
8:39Around 2:00 in the morning, I sat up in
8:40bed thinking about the girl I'd welcomed
8:43into this family 12 years ago. The one
8:46who'd cried at my husband's funeral. And
8:48I thought, "She isn't the same woman."
8:52Or maybe she was never what I wanted her
8:54to be.
8:55I let myself grieve that for about an
8:57hour. Then I turned the lamp off.
9:01Corey came at 8:00 the next morning. I
9:04saw his silver Honda pull into my
9:06driveway through the kitchen window.
9:08He sat in it for several minutes before
9:11getting out the way a man does when he's
9:14rehearsing something.
9:16I opened the door before he could knock.
9:18He looked like he hadn't slept, either.
9:22There were gray circles under his eyes,
9:24and his coat was buttoned wrong.
9:26wrong
9:27"Come in, honey." I said. "I'll make you
9:30some eggs."
9:31He sat at the same kitchen table where
9:34I'd done my banking the night before. He
9:36couldn't look at me at first. When he
9:39did, his eyes were wet.
9:42"I let her hit you, Mom."
9:44"You did."
9:46I didn't move. I just sat there.
9:49He pressed the heels of his hands
9:51against his eyes.
9:53"I've been sitting there for years,
9:55haven't I?"
9:56"Every time she says something to you, I
9:58tell myself it's not the right time to
10:00say anything. And then, there's never a
10:03right time."
10:05I set a plate of scrambled eggs in front
10:08of him and sat down across the table.
10:11I'm not going to tell you that you're
10:12blameless, Corey.
10:14You aren't.
10:15But, I'm not going to tell you you're a
10:17bad man, either.
10:20I raised a good one. I just think you
10:22got used to peace that I was paying for.
10:24He took that without arguing.
10:27Then, I slid a manila folder across the
10:29table.
10:30Inside was a ledger I'd built from my
10:32bank statements since I bought the
10:34house. Tuition, taxes, insurance, the
10:38cleaning crew, the credit card, the
10:40Lexus lease I'd co-signed for Samantha
10:43in 2023,
10:45the maintenance account, and a separate
10:47page, highlighted in yellow, listing 36
10:51monthly transfers to Marilyn Peters.
10:54"287,000
10:56dollars," I said, "give or take,
11:00since I stopped counting the birthday
11:01gifts."
11:03Corey stared at the bottom line. He'd
11:05gone pale. "I knew you were helping. I
11:08didn't know it was."
11:10He turned to the yellow page.
11:12"What's this?"
11:13"That's your mother-in-law's allowance
11:15to ants, out of my roof money."
11:18He closed his eyes. "Samantha told me
11:21Marilyn's pension was just late some
11:23months, and she was lending her a
11:26little."
11:27"It's been 3 years."
11:29He looked at me for a long time.
11:32"What do you want me to do?"
11:34"Nothing yet.
11:35I want you to sit with it.
11:37I'm not asking you to choose between us,
11:40honey. I'm just asking you to see
11:42clearly what's been happening in your
11:44own house."
11:46He nodded slowly.
11:48Then, he ate his eggs, because he was my
11:50son and had never once in his life
11:53turned down breakfast. And I felt
11:55something in my chest loosen for the
11:57first time in a long while.
12:00They came at noon. I'd been expecting
12:02them. Samantha, Marilyn, and behind
12:05them, Corey, who'd driven home and come
12:07back. Samantha had put on makeup and her
12:10good camel coat. Marilyn wore her pearls
12:13and a look of tight, wounded dignity.
12:17I let them into the living room. I did
12:19not offer coffee.
12:21Darling,
12:22Samantha began, and I could hear her
12:24working to sound soft.
12:27I want to apologize for the way things
12:29ended last night.
12:30Emotions were high. Obviously, I
12:33shouldn't have raised my hand, and I'm
12:35sorry.
12:36But what you're doing now is cruel.
12:38You're punishing the children over a
12:40misunderstanding.
12:42There's no misunderstanding, Samantha.
12:45You hit me.
12:46Because you provoked her, Marilyn said.
12:50I turned to her.
12:51I'd like you to stay out of this,
12:53Marilyn.
12:54I will not. That is my daughter, and
12:58you've been dangling that house over her
12:59head for years.
13:01The house I bought for her family, free
13:04and clear, and let her live in without a
13:06dime of rent. I kept my tone mild. That
13:09house?
13:11Marilyn's mouth pinched shut.
13:14I walked to my desk and brought back two
13:16stapled documents.
13:18I handed one to Samantha and one to
13:21Corey.
13:22That's a lease.
13:24Market rate for that neighborhood is
13:26$2,900 a month. But I've written it at
13:302,600
13:31because they're my grandchildren.
13:33Starting February 1st, you'll pay
13:37rent, you'll pay the utilities and the
13:40lawn service in your own names, and
13:42you'll cover the cleaning crew if you
13:44decide you still want one.
13:46I'll continue to pay the property taxes
13:48and the insurance because I own the
13:50house. The tuition, I'll pay directly to
13:53the school every semester as I always
13:55have.
13:57Olivia and Ezra will not lose their
13:59classmates because their mother lost her
14:02temper.
14:03Samantha stared at the paper.
14:05$2,600?
14:07We can't afford that.
14:09Corey earns a good salary, and you have
14:11a college degree.
14:13You have options.
14:15You can't do this to us," she said, and
14:17now her voice cracked for real.
14:20"This is abuse."
14:21"No," I said. "Abuse is what happened at
14:24that dining table. This is paperwork."
14:27Marilyn rose from the sofa, quivering.
14:30"If you think my daughter is going to
14:32let you walk all over her, if you think
14:35you can keep Olivia and Ezra from"
14:39"I'd never keep them from anyone," I
14:41said. "They're welcome here anytime,
14:44with Corey or with you. It's your
14:47decision whether you bring them, but I'm
14:49no longer funding the household, and I'm
14:52not going to pretend that I am."
14:55Samantha looked at Corey, expecting him
14:57to say something.
14:58He looked back at her. It was a long,
15:01strange look. I'd never seen him look at
15:04her like that.
15:06"Sign it,"
15:07he said quietly, "or we find somewhere
15:09else."
15:10"But I'm not going to keep letting my
15:12mother pay for the privilege of being
15:14hit."
15:15Samantha's face did something I'd never
15:17seen it do. It folded like a paper bag.
15:21They didn't sign that afternoon. They
15:24left in silence.
15:26And I stood at the window and watched
15:28Corey open the passenger door for his
15:30wife, who got in without looking at me.
15:34The week after Christmas, I went to see
15:36the attorney who had handled Richard's
15:39estate, a patient woman with reading
15:42glasses on a chain, and we went over my
15:44ledger line by line. By the first week
15:47of the new year, we had documented every
15:50cent.
15:51She looked at the 36 transfers for a
15:54long time.
15:55"The account was opened for home
15:57repairs," she said.
15:59"Samantha was an authorized user for
16:02that purpose only.
16:04Moving this money to her mother for
16:05personal use isn't a family
16:07misunderstanding, Darlene. In this
16:10state, it can be theft. And what
16:13happened at your dining table is
16:14assault."
16:16"I know," I said. "I don't want to put
16:18my son's wife in handcuffs. I want my
16:21money back and I want it to be over."
16:24So, she drafted a letter and on the
16:26second Tuesday of January, Samantha,
16:29Marilyn, and Corey sat down across from
16:32me at a long conference table downtown.
16:35Marilyn had not yet flown home to Tampa.
16:38She wore her pearls again like armor.
16:41The attorney slid a copy of the transfer
16:43history in front of each of them.
16:46"43,200
16:48dollars," she said.
16:50"36 payments each sent by Samantha
16:52Barnes to Marilyn Peters.
16:55Mrs. Peters has two options. We resolve
16:58this today in writing
17:00or I send this file to the county
17:02prosecutor along with the report of the
17:05assault on Christmas night."
17:07"That money was a gift," Marilyn said at
17:10once. "Darlene is a wealthy woman.
17:13She knew perfectly well what her family
17:15was doing."
17:17"Did I?" I said. "Show me where I agreed
17:19to it."
17:20Marilyn opened her mouth and closed it
17:23again.
17:24Samantha hadn't looked up from the page.
17:27Her fingers were pressed flat against
17:29the table and I saw them trembling. "I
17:32told her it was from Corey's bonus," she
17:34said very low.
17:36"Back then,
17:38when I started sending it, I told my
17:40mother it was our money."
17:42Corey turned his head. "Sammy."
17:45"I know."
17:46She finally lifted her eyes to him, then
17:48to me. "I took it. Nobody made me. Every
17:52month I told myself I'd put it back
17:54before anyone noticed."
17:56"Samantha, stop talking," Marilyn
17:58snapped.
17:59"Don't you say another word without a
18:01lawyer."
18:02"I don't need a lawyer, Mom. I need you
18:05to stop."
18:06Samantha's voice cracked straight down
18:09the middle.
18:10"You asked me for the money and I gave
18:12it to you and I let Darlene pay for it
18:15and then I hit her for saying no."
18:17Nobody moved. The attorney laid a single
18:21document on the table.
18:23"This is a promissory note," she said.
18:26"Mrs. Peters borrows $43,200
18:30from Ms. Barnes.
18:32She repays $1,200 on the 1st of every
18:35month for 36 months, and the note is
18:38secured by a lien on her condominium in
18:40Tampa.
18:41Samantha signs as guarantor. If a single
18:44payment is missed, the lien is enforced,
18:48and a criminal referral goes forward."
18:51Marilyn stared at the page. "$1,200 a
18:53month. I can't."
18:56"You found it for 3 years," I said. "It
18:59was just going the other direction."
19:01That landed.
19:03For a moment, I saw Marilyn without the
19:05pearls and the dignity. A woman in her
19:08late 60s who taught her daughter that
19:10someone else's generosity was a natural
19:13resource, like water.
19:15I almost felt sorry for her. Almost.
19:19She signed. The pen scratched very
19:21loudly. Samantha signed under her, and
19:24her hand shook so badly the signature
19:27came out crooked. Corey signed as a
19:29witness without a word.
19:31When it was done, Marilyn stood and
19:34gathered her purse.
19:36"I hope you're proud of yourself,
19:37Darlene. Humiliating family in a
19:40lawyer's office."
19:41"I'm not proud, Marilyn. I'm finished,"
19:45I said. "You won't be welcome in my home
19:47again or at any table where I'm sitting.
19:51You can see your grandchildren at your
19:53daughter's house, if she wants you
19:54there. But not at mine."
19:57She looked at Samantha, waiting for her
19:59to object.
20:01Samantha looked at the table.
20:03Marilyn walked out alone, and I listened
20:06to her heels all the way down the hall.
20:09She flew back to Tampa that weekend,
20:11convinced the nightmare was behind her.
20:14On the 1st of February, the $1,200
20:18did not arrive. On the 5th, my attorney
20:21called Marilyn's number and went
20:23straight to a disconnected tone. By the
20:2610th, we learned that Marilyn had listed
20:29her Tampa condominium for a quick cash
20:32sale, hoping to pocket the equity and
20:35vanish before the county clerk finished
20:38recording the lien.
20:40She didn't make it to closing. My
20:42attorney
20:43froze the title transfer on a Thursday
20:45morning and handed the entire file to
20:49the Franklin County prosecutor that
20:51afternoon.
20:52Two weeks later, Corey called me at 7:00
20:55in the morning, his voice shaking,
20:58asking me to come over and sit with
21:00Olivia and Ezra before the police
21:02arrived. I was standing in the foyer of
21:06the Colonial with a cup of decaf when
21:09two county cruisers pulled into the
21:11driveway and the detectives knocked.
21:13Marilyn was there, too. She had driven
21:16up from Florida in a panic the night
21:18before to demand Samantha give her cash
21:22to hire another lawyer.
21:24When the detective read the warrants for
21:26felony theft by deception and domestic
21:29assault, Marilyn backed against the
21:31stairs, clutching her pearls. "Tell them
21:35it was a family loan, Darlene," she
21:37shrieked, her face bouffant and wild.
21:41"Tell them right now. You can't ruin our
21:43lives over money you don't even need.
21:46I told you in January what would happen
21:49if a single payment was missed," I said
21:52quietly.
21:53Samantha didn't scream.
21:55As the officer clicked the cuffs around
21:58her wrists, she looked at the kitchen,
22:01the perfectly good cabinets she had
22:03hated, the island that wasn't big
22:06enough, and then at Corey, who was
22:09standing in the hallway with her packed
22:11suitcase at his feet.
22:13"Corey, please," Samantha whispered,
22:15tears cutting tracks through her makeup.
22:18"Call your cousin. Post my bail. Don't
22:21let them take me like this."
22:23Corey didn't take a step toward her.
22:26"I already filed for divorce this
22:28morning, Sammy," he said, his voice dead
22:32calm. "And Lewis Builders sent the
22:35$8,000 cancellation bill in your name.
22:38You can figure out how to pay it from
22:40the county jail." "You're monsters,
22:43both of you," Marilyn spat as a second
22:46officer took her arm to lead her out.
22:49"She's the mother of your children."
22:51"And that's my mother," Corey replied,
22:54opening the front door for the police.
22:57"Goodbye, Marilyn."
22:58I watched the red and blue lights
23:01disappear down the snowy street, and for
23:03the first time since Christmas night,
23:06the sting in my left cheek finally
23:08faded. In May, both Samantha and Marilyn
23:12took plea deals. Probation, community
23:15service, permanent felony records, and
23:18court-ordered restitution pulled
23:21straight from the forced sale of the
23:23Tampa condo. Every penny of the $43,200
23:28went back into my roof account. By June,
23:31Corey kept primary custody of Olivia and
23:34Ezra, and he insisted on signing the
23:37$2,600 lease himself, paying his own way
23:41down to the last dime. If you've ever
23:44been the one who keeps the peace, the
23:46one who pays and smooths things over so
23:50the holidays go smoothly, I hope you'll
23:52hear this from me. Love that can only
23:55survive if you keep paying for it is not
23:57love. You can give with an open hand and
24:00still close the door. And the people who
24:03truly care for you will still be there
24:06when you do. Thank you for spending this
24:08time with me. If any of this sounds
24:11familiar, I'd love to hear from you in
24:14the comments. I read everyone. Until
24:17next time, take care of yourselves,
24:20and never be afraid to say no.
24:22Giving generously to our children comes
24:25naturally until the way they treat the
24:26people we love forces us to draw a hard
24:30line.
24:31Have you ever had to pull back your
24:33support after a grown child or their
24:36in-laws cross that line?

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of “Get Out! We’re Better Off Without You!” My Daughter-In-Law Slapped Me At Christmas Dinner. 2 Hou... by Blood And Boundaries, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 3,667 words across 609 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.