George Saunders — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:01Tetro Grammaton.
- 0:09Tetro
- 0:21authentic or it gets spit out by by
- 0:24process. So that's interesting because I
- 0:26sometimes I'll say well I'm starting a
- 0:28story to demonstrate this aspect of my
- 0:29worldview and the story goes no you're
- 0:31not we don't do that here you know so
- 0:33you start tweaking it and working with
- 0:34it then at the end it says something and
- 0:36you're like oh I is that what you mean
- 0:38to say and
- 0:40>> the way you check that is you you know
- 0:41you check all the all the seams and and
- 0:44if everything holds up you you squeeze
- 0:47it all tight and then that's what you
- 0:49set and is it your worldview it's I
- 0:51think it's a leader it sometimes will
- 0:52show me what I ought to be thinking
- 0:54Yeah.
- 0:54>> Yeah.
- 0:55>> In a swim in the pond, there's a lot of
- 0:58detail on structure. Do you think that
- 1:01the writers wrote knowing those things
- 1:04or no?
- 1:06>> Depends how we define knowing. I think
- 1:09not intellectually. I don't think they
- 1:10said I'm going to do this.
- 1:11>> They couldn't explain it to you.
- 1:12>> No. I And they I would even say they
- 1:15might not even know that they did it.
- 1:17>> Yeah.
- 1:17>> But um
- 1:18>> but somewhere you think inside they
- 1:20knew.
- 1:21>> I think Yes. And I think is through my
- 1:23theory is and again all this is just
- 1:25based on my you know my my thing but may
- 1:28may and I'd love to hear how it is in
- 1:30the studio because sometimes you just
- 1:32keep microchoosing this over that this
- 1:34over that this over that and I would say
- 1:36being a a great artist has something to
- 1:38do with creating the optimum the maximum
- 1:41number of choice points you know
- 1:43>> that's great heard anyone say that
- 1:45before and that's
- 1:47>> that sounds right.
- 1:48>> Yeah because if you're choosing one time
- 1:51Yeah. that's only one dollop of you. But
- 1:52if you're choosing a thousand times over
- 1:54the course of the thing, a lot of you is
- 1:56getting in there and you don't
- 1:57necessarily vet those things. You just
- 2:00go you prefer A to B. A. So
- 2:04I think with uh these great Russian
- 2:06writers, I think they did things. I
- 2:08think they laugh at me talking about it
- 2:10as analytically as I do.
- 2:12>> But it doesn't mean it's, you know, it's
- 2:13not still.
- 2:15>> It may be accurate.
- 2:16>> Yes. A friend of mine once said that
- 2:17Jimmyi Hendris, you can tell from his
- 2:19guitar playing that he was an amazing
- 2:20mathematician.
- 2:22>> And I said, well, I know a lot of
- 2:23musicians who are great musicians and
- 2:24and none of them are great
- 2:25mathematicians. And I'm pretty sure
- 2:27Jimmyi Hendris was not. I don't know
- 2:29that for sure,
- 2:30>> but I wouldn't assume that because of
- 2:32the musical structure of what he's
- 2:33playing, the mathematical structure of
- 2:35what he's playing.
- 2:36>> Yes. So, there are ways of knowing that
- 2:38are deeper than the ones that you and I
- 2:40can explicate it right now. Yeah. Yeah.
- 2:42And that's for me the the beautiful
- 2:43thing is I don't you know at 66 I'm kind
- 2:46of I'm kind of know this guy and I'm
- 2:48like yeah yeah okay he's I can predict
- 2:50his neurotic behavior to some extent but
- 2:52the person that comes out when I'm doing
- 2:54this this writing process is more more
- 2:57interesting. So, I think you can have a
- 3:00um by having micro attention to the
- 3:03thousands of cho choosing points. Um and
- 3:07and even then you're not saying what
- 3:09fits my theme or what you're just saying
- 3:11I like the depth. I like this better
- 3:13than that. If you do that a thousand
- 3:15times in six pages, there's a lot of you
- 3:18in there and it's not this you, it's
- 3:20some other you. So to me that's the
- 3:22enduring kind of addictive thing is you
- 3:25to keep luring
- 3:27better parts of yourself out onto the
- 3:29page. Oh that's you know
- 3:31>> would you say that's the editor part of
- 3:32you?
- 3:34>> Yes. Although at this point I don't
- 3:36really make much separation between I
- 3:38mean I think I've been thinking lately
- 3:41if I had to boil down creativity I'd say
- 3:44it's reaction. So, I crank out some crap
- 3:48this morning. Doesn't matter what.
- 3:49Tomorrow, I look at it and I react to it
- 3:51with a pencil in my hand. That seems to
- 3:54me where creativity actually happens.
- 3:56Not so much in that first.
- 3:58>> Yeah.
- 3:58>> Well, also I've kind of been thinking
- 4:00lately that one of the things we do with
- 4:02craft is, at least for me, is I'm trying
- 4:03to get my anxiety down. I'm very anxious
- 4:05person.
- 4:06>> So,
- 4:07>> my artistic approaches aren't
- 4:09necessarily true, but they are anxiety
- 4:12reducing. M
- 4:12>> so for me to say don't worry about what
- 4:15you put down on the blank page. That's a
- 4:16real anxiety reducer.
- 4:18>> Yeah.
- 4:19>> Type any old thing because you're such a
- 4:21good revis you'll look at that mess and
- 4:24go a poor baby, you know, and you'll
- 4:26start tweaking and and you'll find
- 4:28something in there that's got some life
- 4:30on and on and on. Um so yeah, it's
- 4:32editing, but I don't really make a at
- 4:35this point a big distinction between
- 4:36editing and writing. It's just all
- 4:37>> Is anxiety a big issue in your life? Uh
- 4:40it's kind of a it's been an slightly
- 4:42under the surface issue my whole life
- 4:44and to which I would say when I was
- 4:46young I responded by being very jovial
- 4:48you know like just always I can do it
- 4:50you know public energy. Um
- 4:52>> but yeah it is it is and especially
- 4:54artistically it was cuz when I was
- 4:56younger I had that you know terrible
- 4:58lock up of like which artist am I going
- 5:00to be? I have to decide and then you
- 5:03can't be any of them except the one that
- 5:04you haven't found yet.
- 5:05>> Yeah.
- 5:06>> Yeah. Uh so there's a lot of of like you
- 5:09know obsessing over which lineage and
- 5:11should I be funny or not and so on and
- 5:14so I think as an older person I can kind
- 5:17of say well that that's all that
- 5:19deciding is in the realm of conceptual
- 5:21thought which can be helpful but it can
- 5:24also kill you you know because I don't
- 5:26think what we do works on I mean you can
- 5:29describe it conceptually but I'm not
- 5:30sure you can make it conceptually I
- 5:32don't know what writer I am I don't know
- 5:33what lineage I don't know whether I'm
- 5:35going to be funny you're experimental
- 5:37and to keep saying that till you're
- 5:38dead. That that seems to me the tricky
- 5:40part, you know, to say I I'm going to
- 5:42start a story tomorrow.
- 5:44>> As much as I can manage, I don't have
- 5:45any any concepts about it.
- 5:48>> I'm going to go to it and see what it
- 5:50wants to tell me, you know? So, that's
- 5:51all good. And but then, of course, I I'm
- 5:54sure you felt this. You're you're a
- 5:56master.
- 5:57>> So, don't you have some theories? No.
- 6:00>> Yeah. Well, I do. I don't trust them.
- 6:03You know,
- 6:03>> when you sit down with the blank page
- 6:06>> and you write some not great stuff like
- 6:09may have happened this morning,
- 6:11>> where does the starting point come from?
- 6:13What's h what happens?
- 6:15>> It's usually as little as possible. You
- 6:18know, if I just hear somebody say
- 6:19something funny, put that down and like
- 6:21in biology, the seed crystal, you put
- 6:23the seed crystal down and it kind of
- 6:25just spontaneously accretes outward.
- 6:27That's the best case. Some little funny
- 6:29line of dialogue. You don't even know
- 6:30who said it. you put it down and you
- 6:33react to it over and over. But other
- 6:34times there are bigger um like with that
- 6:37Lincoln and the Bart was just like a
- 6:39twoline outline. Lincoln comes to the
- 6:41crypt, interacts with his son's body and
- 6:43leaves. Meanwhile, the son shouldn't be
- 6:46here and he is. That's it. If the thing
- 6:48is frontloaded with meaning, then I
- 6:51don't like it because I know I'm going
- 6:52to
- 6:53>> it'll get undermined at some point
- 6:55>> or or worse yet, you'll do it. Yeah,
- 6:58there's that whole thing that um
- 6:59Einstein I don't think
- 7:00>> it'll be it'll end up um being too
- 7:02narrow. It sentence already did that.
- 7:04It's like why continue?
- 7:05>> He wrote your book already.
- 7:06>> Yeah.
- 7:07>> There's that thing I I I always quote
- 7:08Einstein. I don't think he said this,
- 7:09but it was no worthy problem is ever
- 7:11solved in the plane of its original
- 7:13conception.
- 7:13>> Yeah.
- 7:14>> So if you do that, it's a buzzkill for
- 7:15everybody. So, I think that's part of
- 7:17the
- 7:18>> as a young person with with literary
- 7:20aspirations, you think your job is to be
- 7:22super smart, have a worldview, and then
- 7:24just [ __ ] it down on people, you know,
- 7:26and that's how they'll know you're
- 7:27powerful, and then it turns out that's
- 7:30not it.
- 7:31>> I I love the idea of the reaction being
- 7:33what creation is about. Also, I haven't
- 7:36thought about it in that way before, and
- 7:38it's um it's a helpful framing for
- 7:41moving forward. And it's true. It's like
- 7:44everything we do is in reaction to
- 7:45something. And I love the idea of
- 7:48writing a sentence and then the next
- 7:50sentence is a reaction to the last
- 7:52sentence. Right.
- 7:53>> That's a different way of looking at the
- 7:55process.
- 7:55>> Yeah. And it also I think it mimics what
- 7:57the reader is doing. The reader now you
- 7:58have a sentence that's a little wobbly
- 8:00on its feet.
- 8:01>> Yeah.
- 8:01>> The reader notices. So what do you do
- 8:04with the reader noticing? That's that's
- 8:06the reaction too. So um
- 8:09>> I don't know. Is it true in like in the
- 8:10studio is there are there analoges to
- 8:12this?
- 8:13>> How do you mean?
- 8:14>> Well, ask specifically and I'll tell you
- 8:16>> is is are you when you're producing
- 8:18somebody are you reacting or Yeah,
- 8:21>> always.
- 8:21>> Yeah.
- 8:22>> Always either if if whatever's happening
- 8:24makes me lean forward and want to hear
- 8:27what happens next. It's good.
- 8:29>> And if something happens I wasn't
- 8:30expecting, it's very good.
- 8:32>> Yeah.
- 8:33If it starts and I lean back and nothing
- 8:37happens, chances are I want to stop it.
- 8:40>> Because I'm thinking about this in terms
- 8:41of my teaching. What What does the
- 8:44corrective look like or the the
- 8:47>> can't describe what the thing is that
- 8:50pulls you? Because it could be a lot of
- 8:51different things. There is some sense of
- 8:54it
- 8:56of it being something. It can't just be
- 8:59the thing you've heard before done in
- 9:01the same way. If you hear that, even if
- 9:03it's good, it ends up not being
- 9:05interesting very long.
- 9:06>> If I'm playing for you and I do that,
- 9:07how do you correct me?
- 9:08>> I would say, what what else can we
- 9:10listen to? What else do you have
- 9:12>> in that case?
- 9:13>> That's that's Yeah, that's I mean,
- 9:14>> or I would listen to the whole thing and
- 9:16say,
- 9:17>> "It got interesting to me at this point.
- 9:19How do we make how do how do we make the
- 9:21whole thing feel like this?"
- 9:23>> Yeah. See, that's something in my I
- 9:25teach at Syracuse and I talk a lot about
- 9:27uh specificity of response because you
- 9:29know in a workshop if someone says this
- 9:31is boring, you can't it's hurtful and
- 9:34also you you can't work with that. But
- 9:35if you push down and say where is it
- 9:36boring and do you have a different word
- 9:38for boring?
- 9:39>> Yes.
- 9:39>> Then oh it's repetitious on page six.
- 9:42Yes,
- 9:42>> we can fix repetition.
- 9:43>> Yes. Agreed. By the way, on on
- 9:45specificity,
- 9:46when I'm making notes, the more specific
- 9:49I can be in any comments that I give,
- 9:53the more helpful they are.
- 9:54>> Yeah.
- 9:55>> And in early in my career, I would state
- 9:58what I thought the solution was. And now
- 10:00I don't do that.
- 10:01>> Yes. Now that's
- 10:01>> and and the solutions turn out to be
- 10:03much better, but I'm not suggesting
- 10:05them.
- 10:05>> See, that's another a beautiful idea
- 10:06because I think part of the reader
- 10:08writer thing is is intimacy and trust.
- 10:10So if I say um I don't Yeah. something
- 10:14on page six h then all the energy goes
- 10:17to the writer and they usually know
- 10:19actually so that move where I say I
- 10:22trust you to find out that's
- 10:24>> you know and it's likewise if I'm
- 10:25writing something and I and I do three
- 10:28repetitions of the same idea because you
- 10:30might not get it my theory is you
- 10:32suddenly feel that as condescension
- 10:35>> which is disengagement
- 10:36>> and you like me a little less so if I a
- 10:39lot of the editing is going you know
- 10:40let's pretend that my reader is actually
- 10:4312% smarter than me.
- 10:44>> Yeah.
- 10:45>> Make cuts on that basis.
- 10:47>> A little scary cuz sometimes you might,
- 10:49you know, have to trust more than you
- 10:51feel like it. But if it works, then you
- 10:52get that thing where the the reader is
- 10:54having a normal day, picks up the book
- 10:56and goes, "Oh [ __ ] this this person
- 10:58likes me and respects me." And we we
- 11:01have um this experience is coming out of
- 11:04a a shared pool of of experience. We've
- 11:07both been here. He knows that and he's
- 11:10speaking to the higher me. So the higher
- 11:12me comes out and you get this kind of
- 11:14engagement of of uh I always think of it
- 11:17as ghosts like ghosts coming out of the
- 11:19writer and the reader and they meet up
- 11:21in that beautiful high territory where
- 11:23and then afterwards they go back and
- 11:24>> how did you come to that? um just
- 11:28through feeling feeling it like going
- 11:30into a it's not it's like nothing
- 11:32mystical but the you know the
- 11:34>> the the kind of sacramental space of
- 11:36hard work like bearing down on the
- 11:39manuscript and you look up and you go
- 11:40whoa that ghost did some good [ __ ] you
- 11:42know and uh and then and also feeling
- 11:45that you you would
- 11:47>> um meet people at readings and they
- 11:49would talk about a certain story and I'm
- 11:51like we we met in another place the two
- 11:53of us you know so that's
- 11:55>> I love the idea that you talk about the
- 11:57writer and the reader ghosts come out of
- 12:00each of them and meet but it's nothing
- 12:03mystical or metaphysical it's completely
- 12:06like okay I understand
- 12:10very quotidian quotedian ghost yeah
- 12:13>> yeah um tell me about your spiritual
- 12:15life
- 12:16>> uh well I'm uh uh practice Tibetan
- 12:20Buddhism and the Ningma tradition I'm a
- 12:22little lapsed at the moment I don't
- 12:23quite know why but we we lived my wife
- 12:26and I lived um near a a community for
- 12:29many years and had at that time a really
- 12:31intense 3 four hour a night meditative
- 12:34thing which kind of changed my life
- 12:35>> when did you get into it?
- 12:36>> Uh well it I was about 40 and my wife
- 12:39went to uh she actually she was turned
- 12:42on the ticknahan by a Catholic nun.
- 12:44>> Yeah. And then she went to a Tibetan
- 12:46empowerment which was very exotic and
- 12:49strange and then um came out kind of
- 12:52saying ah that's that's pretty weird
- 12:53stuff and then started practicing and
- 12:56there was this big change in her that I
- 12:58you know as a husband you're like how
- 13:00come we're not having fight 9A anymore
- 13:02you know and I thought I want some of
- 13:04that. So, I started kind of messing
- 13:06around with kind of just homemade
- 13:07meditation and then we eventually found
- 13:09a teacher and and um and it seemed to me
- 13:12I mean so much like that I'd already
- 13:15been a Buddhist before I knew what it
- 13:17was just from from writing. So, that's
- 13:19been a real interesting crossfiring, you
- 13:21know, to say um that this aspect of of
- 13:25dharma has a correlary in writing. Maybe
- 13:28this one doesn't quite as much yet, but
- 13:30I could try, you know. And then
- 13:31>> did you have any spiritual life growing
- 13:33up? Catholic very and like seriously
- 13:36beautiful Catholic experience southside
- 13:39of Chicago kind of Dorothy day uh
- 13:41progressive Catholicism and I remember
- 13:44getting into some kind of meditative
- 13:45state during the long masses and then
- 13:47there would be you know stations of the
- 13:49cross which were very visual they were
- 13:51visualizations basically and so and I
- 13:54think I also I remember kind of being
- 13:57stunned by some of those stories about
- 13:58Jesus being super empathetic like the
- 14:01woman at the well you know and and the
- 14:02way what I took from that I don't know
- 14:04whether a nun told me this or I just
- 14:05took but is that that Jesus was sort of
- 14:08a a novelist in that sense because he
- 14:10could approach this person that other
- 14:13person other people didn't like and
- 14:15judged and just by being in the presence
- 14:18he could pick up on a lot of data that a
- 14:20normal person couldn't pick up on and
- 14:22that increased data made him fond of her
- 14:25and the fondness made her open up and
- 14:28then brought up a ghost you know so so I
- 14:30I love that idea and I think when I
- 14:32started to read more. I thought, oh,
- 14:34that's kind of yeah, that's kind of what
- 14:36my job as a novelist is. I I can put
- 14:38anybody in front of in front of me, even
- 14:40if in real life I'm can't stand them.
- 14:43And by
- 14:45contemplating them through revision,
- 14:47basically, I can find a way in and sort
- 14:50of recognize that they're me on a
- 14:52different day briefly, you know, while
- 14:54on the page.
- 14:55>> Do you have to do that to be able to
- 14:56write them? I don't think so because I
- 14:58think there are a lot of people who do
- 14:59it a different way but I like to do one
- 15:02of okay you know there's that flamcon
- 15:05thing she says writer can choose what he
- 15:07writes but he can't choose what he makes
- 15:08live so you can have all the plans for
- 15:11how you're going to be but if it doesn't
- 15:13work then you have so for me it what
- 15:15works is uh I call it third person
- 15:18ventriloquist where it's like if I'm
- 15:20going to write your story I'm I'll start
- 15:22off Rick's sat in the yard you know but
- 15:25then I have to quickly get into your
- 15:26voice and your head also your
- 15:28limitations and your aspirations and all
- 15:30that. So it's it's more of a voice
- 15:32thing. If I if I do that if I say okay
- 15:34I'm now this person the voice comes
- 15:37alive in a way that it doesn't if I if
- 15:39I'm me out here looking at them. So just
- 15:41a kind of a
- 15:42>> it's still always your
- 15:44imagination of who that person is. It's
- 15:47not really who that person is.
- 15:48>> You're not channeling them,
- 15:49>> right? And mostly they don't exist
- 15:51anyway. I mean, if I write about
- 15:52Lincoln, I don't have any idea what I
- 15:54mean, the real Lincoln would be kind of
- 15:55unknowable to us, but you could say I'm
- 15:58I'm me in a Lincoln suit, you know, that
- 16:01kind
- 16:01>> when you write about when you write
- 16:03characters, are they often based on
- 16:05people, you know, or no?
- 16:07>> No. So, so a story will be going along
- 16:09and it has a certain need at a certain
- 16:12point. So, I need somebody like in
- 16:14Lincoln, you be Lincoln would be walking
- 16:16across the graveyard and I need him to
- 16:18turn over turn over here and see a
- 16:20ghost. I don't I don't have any thoughts
- 16:23about who which one just somebody start
- 16:25talking to me. I think, oh, okay, the
- 16:28word hunter comes into my mind and I
- 16:30start saying, okay, he's a hunter. What
- 16:31would a hunter's afterlife look like?
- 16:33And suddenly, spontaneously, there's
- 16:34this big pile of dead animal, all the
- 16:36animals he's killed in his life. So
- 16:39that's just it's not anybody I ever
- 16:42knew, but it's kind of just being
- 16:45generated. But other times I will see
- 16:49that I put someone's speech patterns in
- 16:51there. Somebody I know or an anecdote
- 16:53that somebody told me will get in there.
- 16:55But I think with stories there's always
- 16:57like why do you need this thing? So the
- 17:02quality of the thing would be colored by
- 17:03why you need it. So, let's say that I
- 17:06need somebody to um
- 17:08the the hero has a goal and I need
- 17:11somebody to impede him for moral
- 17:13reasons. Well, that person has to have
- 17:17that quality. And so then once I figure
- 17:20that out, I start throwing in bits from
- 17:22my own life. And it could be something
- 17:23from you and something from my uncle
- 17:25even put into the same package.
- 17:27>> So I'm not I'm not answering very
- 17:28clearly, but I don't I'm not a writer
- 17:30who says I want to write a book about
- 17:32this person. Mhm.
- 17:33>> Uh but sometimes they just stuff just
- 17:35gets in there and uh if it's if it's
- 17:39authentic then a like there's a story
- 17:41called Seoke and there's a the moment in
- 17:43the story was the character who's a real
- 17:46working-class guy has got a girlfriend
- 17:48who's a little bit above him and he's
- 17:49going to have to lose her and he's going
- 17:51to have to lose her for class reasons.
- 17:53That that was just the way that it
- 17:54wasn't an idea but that's the way the
- 17:55story was set up. So, I was looking for
- 17:58something that could happen to somebody
- 18:00for class reasons. And I thought back to
- 18:02my own youth. I had a friend who was a
- 18:04alcoholic. And one time I was on the
- 18:06couch with this girl I was really in
- 18:08love with who was a couple notches ahead
- 18:09of me. And this guy comes in, just
- 18:11blunders into the house and starts
- 18:12pissing on the wall, you know,
- 18:14>> and and I'm there with this really.
- 18:17>> It really happened. Yeah. And there's
- 18:18this and there was this person I really
- 18:19kind of cherished you know and she's
- 18:20seeing this and I'm you know and so all
- 18:22I could really say is you know this
- 18:24doesn't usually happen or you know but
- 18:26so that was a painful you know
- 18:28embarrassing memory. Well Seo comes
- 18:30along and I need something I'm like okay
- 18:33that's you're in
- 18:35>> but at the same time I'm going to alter
- 18:37it to make it appropo of that situation.
- 18:39So it was different.
- 18:47>> As nutrition science advanced through
- 18:48the midentth century, researchers began
- 18:51to understand that modern eating
- 18:53patterns, limited variety, processed
- 18:55foods, and time constraints could leave
- 18:58small but meaningful gaps in daily
- 19:00micronutrient intake. Today, large
- 19:03population studies confirm that
- 19:05approximately 90% of adults fall short
- 19:08on one or more essential vitamins or
- 19:10minerals. AG1 was formulated in response
- 19:14to those findings. Each daily serving
- 19:16provides clinically informed amounts of
- 19:18commonly underconumed essentials with
- 19:21more than 75 vitamins, minerals, and
- 19:24whole food source nutrients, including
- 19:27vitamins A, C, E, B6, B12, magnesium,
- 19:33zinc, selenium, and iodine delivered in
- 19:37forms the body can readily access.
- 19:40Because utilization depends on
- 19:42absorption, AG1 also contains probiotics
- 19:46to support gut health and digestive
- 19:48function, helping the body make
- 19:49effective use of what it receives. AG1
- 19:53contains no gluten or dairy, uses no
- 19:56genetically modified ingredients or
- 19:58artificial sweeteners, and is suitable
- 20:00for a wide range of dietary approaches,
- 20:03including plant-based, paleo, keto, and
- 20:07low carbohydrate diets.
- 20:10Available in single serving packets for
- 20:12when you're on the go. Manufactured
- 20:15under strict quality controls. Every
- 20:18batch of AG1 is tested to confirm its
- 20:21composition, nutrient levels, and the
- 20:23absence of contaminants, ensuring
- 20:26reliability from one serving to the
- 20:28next. It's no wonder AG1 is trusted by
- 20:32the world's top athletes and experts.
- 20:35What was once a futuristic concept,
- 20:38daily nutritional support in a glass, is
- 20:40now the result of applied science. Learn
- 20:43more at drinkag1.com/etra.
- 20:48Do it today.
- 20:56>> How much of a story do you know before
- 20:58you start?
- 20:59>> Ideally, none. Literally the best
- 21:01stories are the ones I just start with a
- 21:02little something and then it it grows
- 21:04outward. Sometimes I mean there are
- 21:06times when I I do know a little more
- 21:08than that. But but I think the move for
- 21:10me is to look really a scance at that
- 21:12idea like okay yeah yeah you you claim
- 21:15you're the story but can you just wait
- 21:16out here a little bit while I
- 21:17investigate?
- 21:18>> And then um Gerald Stern said if you
- 21:20start out to write a poem about two dogs
- 21:22[ __ ] and you write a poem about two
- 21:24dogs [ __ ] then you wrote a poem about
- 21:26two dogs [ __ ] you know. So, so I
- 21:28think mostly the ideas I'm I'm really
- 21:30dubious. I just stay out, you know.
- 21:33>> So, it it sounds like you could
- 21:36literally start with anything and the
- 21:39story that you are to tell
- 21:43will reveal itself regardless of where
- 21:45you're starting.
- 21:46>> That's exactly it. Again, it's anxiety
- 21:48reducing because I don't have to have
- 21:49any ideas. I just have to have a first
- 21:51line.
- 21:51>> Yeah. I I always say, you know, if you
- 21:53if we wanted to write a story, we could
- 21:56make that coffee cup talk, that glass of
- 21:58water talk, and your baseball hat talk.
- 21:59>> Mhm.
- 22:01>> And whatever if we spend enough time on
- 22:03it, all of our personal stuff would come
- 22:05out. Of course, it would because if you
- 22:08revise enough, I mean, what are you
- 22:10revising from? Your own stuff. So,
- 22:13again, that for me is a real I I I think
- 22:16a lot of young writers, and I certainly
- 22:18did, get you get locked up on this idea
- 22:19of what's my great idea? I need a great
- 22:21idea and you won't get one because
- 22:23there's no such thing actually. There's
- 22:25no the great the great idea is the one
- 22:27that allows you to um uh grow it, you
- 22:30know, and and it becomes a different
- 22:32idea and it you know um is that is that
- 22:34I mean I'm wondering is musically if
- 22:36someone just goes in and plays a riff
- 22:38>> does that can that sometimes lead to
- 22:41>> absolutely. Yeah. Even when an artist
- 22:44has well-written material, I might
- 22:46suggest that they spend time just
- 22:48jamming
- 22:49>> and then out of the jams something comes
- 22:52up unexpected. No one's no one's trying
- 22:55to write a song,
- 22:56>> right?
- 22:56>> They're having fun making music and from
- 23:00that something happens,
- 23:01>> right?
- 23:02>> Because I know in literature it's it's
- 23:03kind of like it's not really that you
- 23:05know the first line. It's you okay, I
- 23:08throw the first line at you, you go,
- 23:09"Oh, okay." you throw it back at me and
- 23:11I throw it back at you and it and it
- 23:12it's the it's the path that the story
- 23:14follows that's actually interesting. So
- 23:15that again that's cool because it means
- 23:18>> there are no um beautiful ideas there,
- 23:21you know, or if there was you could put
- 23:23it in there, but the story's going to
- 23:25start poking at it and it's going to
- 23:26start tearing it apart and it's going to
- 23:27be so so in this sense a story is a
- 23:30dynamic. It's like a linear temporal
- 23:33experience that unfolds this way and
- 23:36like a roller coaster. You're not on the
- 23:38roller coaster going, "What does this
- 23:39mean?" You know, you're just going, "Oh
- 23:41[ __ ] we're going up." You know,
- 23:42>> do you ever think about what does it
- 23:44mean? Or not until after it's all done.
- 23:45>> The kind of purist answer is no. Never.
- 23:47But of course you do. Because you want
- 23:49to finish it and you want it to be good.
- 23:51So the voice that says, "I know what it
- 23:53means. Would you like to know?" You're
- 23:54like, "Yeah, okay. Come on in. It's
- 23:56about patriarchy." Oh, all right. Duly
- 23:59noted. Step out in the hall again. We'll
- 24:01we'll find out.
- 24:02>> But it would be silly to not let that
- 24:05guy in. you know, he knows something
- 24:06about it.
- 24:07>> When that happens, do you say, "Okay, I
- 24:09know it's about patriarchy now." Or do
- 24:11you think, "Okay, it might be about
- 24:12patriarchy."
- 24:13>> I Yeah, I know it's all about patriarchy
- 24:14now. Yes.
- 24:15>> But we're going to see if it if it want
- 24:18to be. Yeah. There there's a great
- 24:20Chicago writer named Stuart Dybeck and
- 24:21he said, "The story is always talking to
- 24:23you, but you just have to listen."
- 24:25>> And that I think is so the story is
- 24:27saying, "I think I'm about patriarchy."
- 24:28Yeah.
- 24:29>> And you see you might, good for you. You
- 24:31know, you might very well be. I hope you
- 24:32are. But at the same time is the minute
- 24:35I say yes it is then what happens with
- 24:37me is okay so like procedurally you know
- 24:40you have five pages and it's about
- 24:42patriarchy all right then since you know
- 24:44that you now know the next five pages
- 24:47and you're dead because that's a the
- 24:49reader feels when you checked out and
- 24:51went on autopilot. So, so you have to
- 24:53say yes, conditionally you are, but
- 24:56let's keep going and and stay fresh and
- 24:59see what else you want to be about. You
- 25:00know, and to me the fascinating thing is
- 25:02that that's not even that's not
- 25:04theoretical. It's it's in this rereading
- 25:06process, you know, you're a little meat
- 25:08in your head. I like it. I like it. I
- 25:09like it. And suddenly I don't like it.
- 25:12So to say in the spirit of specificity,
- 25:14okay, that's we don't have to panic. You
- 25:16know, we're not suddenly a bad artist.
- 25:18It's having difficulty on page eight.
- 25:21and then kind of lean in. I always like
- 25:24have an imaginary voice to the story
- 25:25like a what's going on, you know, and
- 25:29the story says nothing. Just I'm fine.
- 25:30Just keep going. No, no, really, what's
- 25:32what's happening? Well, I'm kind of
- 25:35boring. You are boring. Poor baby. You
- 25:37know, and then then you can kind of go,
- 25:39well, yeah, let's just not use boring
- 25:41and let's look a little closer. And then
- 25:43the story will say, it's basically
- 25:45saying, I'm discontent with your
- 25:47overmanagement of me
- 25:48>> and therefore I put in a cloudy section
- 25:51or I put in an alien invasion or some
- 25:53weird [ __ ] because I don't like where
- 25:54you're going and I'm I'm stopping in in
- 25:57the road. So I I kind of developed this
- 25:58idea of avoidance moments which is if a
- 26:01a story has uh yeah like bad language or
- 26:05sometimes a factual error will get in
- 26:06something that couldn't be true or or
- 26:09like an unwarranted flashback or forward
- 26:11or change of point of view. That's often
- 26:13the subconscious being very smart and
- 26:15saying I want the best for you. If you
- 26:19keep going you're going to [ __ ] up the
- 26:20story. So can we pause here? I'm going
- 26:22to make you pause by injecting something
- 26:24yucky. Um, and in in a traditional
- 26:28workshop format that would be an error
- 26:29and you would fix it. But now I'm like,
- 26:31no, that's actually your layers of your
- 26:34subconscious process revealing. This is
- 26:36a a this is a draft six tendency.
- 26:40Totally honorable. Let's just note it.
- 26:42You got to be continued. Sign up there
- 26:45on page six and one on 11 and one on 12.
- 26:47Um, don't panic. Just remember they're
- 26:49there.
- 26:50>> Yeah.
- 26:50>> And weirdly, those places often speak to
- 26:53each other. If you fix one, you know
- 26:54them. Mhm.
- 26:55>> Do you note them?
- 26:56>> Yes, very much. Yeah. And and I note
- 26:58them and I also provide a technical
- 27:00description of why I stopped, what what
- 27:02why it affected my reading energy. So
- 27:04sometimes it's often semantic. It's just
- 27:06a the sentence goes haywire.
- 27:08>> Just so I just make that correction and
- 27:10then
- 27:11>> and as you were saying, I used to fix
- 27:13it, but now I just say, you know, this
- 27:14leave it alone.
- 27:15>> Yeah. And nine times out of 10, the
- 27:18writer already knew it. You know, they
- 27:20knew. And so you just say
- 27:21>> page nine and a half. I know. I know.
- 27:23You know,
- 27:24>> I love the idea that roadblocks along
- 27:26the way speak to each other. That's
- 27:28really a
- 27:29>> really a helpful idea because then it
- 27:32it's the opposite of when it coming up
- 27:34you feeling like, oh, you failed. It's
- 27:35more like, oh, another clue.
- 27:37>> Yes.
- 27:38>> Another clue to unlock the whole
- 27:39picture.
- 27:40>> Exactly.
- 27:40>> It's great.
- 27:41>> Yeah. And there's also I noticed a
- 27:42pattern to that. Like as I get uh
- 27:44further along the revision process,
- 27:46those become more specific. They glow.
- 27:48Like I've got three now. I I've been
- 27:50working on this for six months. I've got
- 27:52three places that, you know, on a scale
- 27:54of 1 to 10, when I hit them, they're
- 27:56like sixes.
- 27:57>> The rest of the story might be eight or
- 27:58nine. Just six.
- 28:00>> So, at first you say, well, we can have
- 28:02a few sixes, can't we? But then you say,
- 28:03well, you can, but what if you don't?
- 28:05You know, those are always sort of like
- 28:08um I wouldn't say thematically, but
- 28:10they're causally related. If you fix
- 28:13one, it throws light on the other two
- 28:15and limits the range of possibilities
- 28:18that you could do to solve them, you
- 28:20know. So that's cool because then when
- 28:21you have problems you're like in a
- 28:24certain way the more problems I have and
- 28:27the more unsolvable they are the better
- 28:29the story is going to be. It's got kind
- 28:31of bigger shoulders. It's like it's like
- 28:33Houdini you know like if Hoodi said I'm
- 28:34going to now I've got a windbreaker on
- 28:36I'm not going to take it off. You'd be
- 28:37like okay you know but if he really you
- 28:40know it's got chains and he's at the
- 28:41bottom of the Hudson and he's drunk or
- 28:43whatever then he's got a real problem to
- 28:45get out of. So whenever now whenever I
- 28:47get a story that has really impossible
- 28:49problems that I would have that would
- 28:52cause me to bail when I was 30, I'm
- 28:54like, "Oh, good. Now we're now we're the
- 28:57the uh the subconscious is giving me a a
- 29:00higher place to go on the mountain."
- 29:02>> Love that.
- 29:03>> Amazing.
- 29:04>> Still frustrating, but but in the back
- 29:06of my mind, I'm like, "Yeah, it is." But
- 29:07>> are you the best judge of your own work?
- 29:10>> Yeah. Um
- 29:12well I think I mean yes because well
- 29:16only only I mean maybe not once it goes
- 29:17out in the world then no but but I'm
- 29:19>> during the process.
- 29:20>> Yeah. I'm a late shower. I don't I show
- 29:22nobody anything for a really long time.
- 29:24And it's interesting because I don't
- 29:25know how this must be in
- 29:26>> music because it's so communal. But for
- 29:28me to keep it private for a really long
- 29:30time
- 29:31>> cuz then I can make those choices with
- 29:33complete um openness that like if
- 29:35someone says I love your story
- 29:37>> I can't change it. You know it's harder
- 29:39to change it. Yeah.
- 29:40>> Someone says, "I hate it. I just feel
- 29:41like throwing it out." So if it's me in
- 29:43private for a long time with it, I can
- 29:45mess it up. I can fix it. I can mess
- 29:47this part up and fix that part. And
- 29:49there's a lot of freedom.
- 29:51>> And then weirdly at some point all that
- 29:53iteration, it starts to solidify, you
- 29:55know, like at some point like, "Yeah,
- 29:57okay. I'm not worried about that
- 29:58anymore. That's fixed itself." And then
- 30:00you get just these three little issues
- 30:02or four. And then I still feel like,
- 30:04yeah, I I everybody stay out. I I'm
- 30:06going to decide this. Um, and then at
- 30:08some point when I'm really done, I think
- 30:10I give it to my wife and she reads very
- 30:13my work very emotionally. She knows me.
- 30:16She knows my cheap tricks. So if she has
- 30:19an emotional reaction, then I'm good to
- 30:20send it out. And if she says, "Oh, yeah,
- 30:23pretty good." You know, then I'm like,
- 30:24"Oh, damn it."
- 30:25>> Yeah.
- 30:26>> Start over.
- 30:27>> Would she give you specific comments
- 30:28like, "I was with you up until page 40
- 30:30or something like that."
- 30:31>> Not really. No. No. She just at the end
- 30:32she's either moved or she isn't. And I
- 30:34really value that because cuz she's
- 30:36right and she knows. And so and we we
- 30:38both kind of came from um kind of
- 30:40working-ass backgrounds and art was a
- 30:42very specific thing for us, very
- 30:44important, you know. So and I think the
- 30:47um the kind of emotional aspect of it
- 30:49was important to us. We we weren't
- 30:51necessarily taken with wild
- 30:53postmodernism, but like Raymond Carver
- 30:55that and Tobias Wolf's, you know, uh so
- 30:58so I trust her emotional reaction to it.
- 31:01uh she she's somebody who really doesn't
- 31:04she wants to work hard to be about
- 31:05something that we share that people
- 31:07share instead of just like a pyrochnics.
- 31:10>> Do you ever stop along the way to do
- 31:13research on something that you're
- 31:15writing
- 31:16>> sometimes? But I
- 31:17>> What would be an example where you would
- 31:18do that? Well, with Lincoln and the
- 31:20Bart, I had to I had to do just some
- 31:22real basic I I try not to get too in the
- 31:23weeds, but like um so I knew the date
- 31:26that that happened. So I had to kind of
- 31:29research what happened the two weeks
- 31:30before and what happened the next two
- 31:32weeks to see if some ideas that were in
- 31:34play were made sense,
- 31:35>> which weirdly they they did, you know. I
- 31:38uh but before I did that, it was just
- 31:40Lincoln on a graveyard on any old night.
- 31:42And then it it it improved in
- 31:45specificity cuz he was in a graveyard.
- 31:48uh I think three weeks before the uh
- 31:51emancipation proclamation
- 31:53um and he was there four days after a
- 31:56big battle at Fort Donaldson where a lot
- 31:57of like the northern casualties were
- 31:59higher than they had ever been. So that
- 32:01so then that that specificity he says oh
- 32:04I'm telling out of all the stories about
- 32:06Lincoln in a graveyard I'm telling this
- 32:07particular one.
- 32:08>> Yeah.
- 32:08>> Yeah.
- 32:09>> But I don't I don't really um
- 32:12I think I think I'm more of a cartoonist
- 32:14really. Like I don't I don't think there
- 32:15are some novels who do great research
- 32:17and you feel all that history and I'm
- 32:18more of a
- 32:19>> I I one of my big early things is
- 32:22Charlie Brown that you know the peanuts
- 32:24thing and that still works for me like
- 32:26kids with heads that are too big you
- 32:28know and know the sidewalks come and go
- 32:30you know and I I love that
- 32:32>> and all of that in service of something
- 32:33that's that's kind of deep when you get
- 32:35down to it but it's it's cloaking the
- 32:37deep the depth in a lot of sort of
- 32:39surface
- 32:40>> is writing fiction and non-fiction the
- 32:42same thing. It ultimately kind of is I
- 32:44feel I feel less freedom with
- 32:47non-fiction as you would but it's kind
- 32:49of the same except with non-fiction I go
- 32:51out and do a trip for 10 days and then
- 32:54just have a bunch of notes you know and
- 32:56and recordings and stuff and then
- 32:59>> start writing it all and whatever glows
- 33:01gets in the story. So the structure gets
- 33:03made by glow like these four things are
- 33:05even this one that shouldn't be
- 33:07important it's it writes really well so
- 33:09you're in the story and then the
- 33:10structure is just okay how do I connect
- 33:12those so that they kind of make sense
- 33:13and then sometimes with that you arrange
- 33:16the six glowing items and you go oh oh
- 33:18that's the meaning of that trip that I
- 33:20didn't even realize. Uh whereas with
- 33:22fiction you're creating the incident and
- 33:24then trying to make it glow. And so one
- 33:26of the real problems is which incidents
- 33:28are essential and which aren't. You know
- 33:31there's this uh do you ever know Stuart
- 33:33Cornfeld? He was in LA.
- 33:35>> He was Stuart
- 33:36>> Stuart Cornfeld's really good he had
- 33:37been a producer for a while and he had
- 33:39this idea he told me once that was like
- 33:41in narrative every structural unit has
- 33:44to do two things. It has to be
- 33:45entertaining in its own right and it has
- 33:47to contribute to the meaning of the
- 33:49story in a non-trivial way. So sometimes
- 33:52in fiction you you write something
- 33:53that's got a lot of jokes and it's funny
- 33:55and it's fast but it's just not it
- 33:58doesn't know what it's there for. So
- 34:00that has to come out
- 34:01>> always.
- 34:02>> Well, or you have to figure out why it's
- 34:04there. And so that what I'll do is I'll
- 34:07take something like that and keep it in
- 34:08the back. Like you're really good. I But
- 34:10stay outside of
- 34:11>> Is there ever a reason that a digression
- 34:14from the main story
- 34:17>> even if you don't understand it stays.
- 34:20>> Yes. But but then kind of circularly
- 34:22that therefore isn't isn't meaningless.
- 34:25It's just got a complicated meaning, you
- 34:26know?
- 34:27>> Yeah. You just don't know it,
- 34:28>> right? or we only know it in rereading
- 34:30like yeah it has to be there that it's
- 34:33it's because you know one of the things
- 34:34with fiction we tend to reduce it to
- 34:36meaning but it's given off like a piece
- 34:38of music given off incredible
- 34:40frequencies of of
- 34:41>> nuance that it's not really meaning but
- 34:44it's flavor its quality all that stuff.
- 34:46So the beautiful thing is a reader even
- 34:48a just a kind of above average reader
- 34:50will catch all that stuff
- 34:52>> and she'll take it to the next thing.
- 34:53So, we wouldn't want to reduce meaning
- 34:55just to theme. It's it's the whole thing
- 34:57you've received. You're taking it to the
- 34:58next bit. Sometimes I say this in a way
- 35:00that makes it sound more mathematical
- 35:02than it is. But, for example, if I had a
- 35:05really good bit, I would be really open
- 35:08to the ways it was contributing even if
- 35:10they weren't linear, you know, or um you
- 35:12know,
- 35:13>> can fiction be more true than
- 35:14non-fiction?
- 35:15>> For me, it Yes. Yes. Because
- 35:20>> and I don't know why exactly. I don't
- 35:22like writing anything that would hurt
- 35:23someone's feelings. So if I was writing
- 35:25a profile of you, it would be so
- 35:27complimentary. There would and I would
- 35:28never have that impulse to go look
- 35:30what's the dark side. I just don't I
- 35:31don't like it.
- 35:32>> But with fiction, I don't feel that
- 35:34compunction. So I can I can
- 35:37>> let a certain uh polyianaish part of me
- 35:40step aside for a minute and I can let
- 35:42the darkness and the kind of neg
- 35:43negative veillances come in. M
- 35:46>> and then also there's something about a
- 35:47short story that is so free you know
- 35:49there's no like
- 35:50>> once upon a time what anything you know
- 35:53uh and then so in a certain way it's
- 35:55almost like a mirror because if you
- 35:56start a totally madeup story which in my
- 35:59case is kind of cartoonish
- 36:02>> then well what's the fuel of that story
- 36:05it's 100% my phenomenon you know it's
- 36:08there's nothing else it could be so I I
- 36:10like that freedom and for me there
- 36:11there's something uh I was raised
- 36:13Catholic always was kind of a good kid,
- 36:16which is nice, you know, like socially
- 36:17it's okay, but when you artistically
- 36:19there's a um it takes a lot for me to be
- 36:22really honest actually, you know.
- 36:24>> So, fiction it's uh under the guise of
- 36:27being funny or entertaining, a lot of
- 36:29weird stuff comes out that I didn't know
- 36:30I
- 36:30>> Do you think of yourself as a writer or
- 36:32a storyteller?
- 36:34>> I think a writer because I know a lot of
- 36:35people who can tell better stories than
- 36:37I a lot.
- 36:38>> Yeah.
- 36:38>> Uh and I my stories I I don't have any
- 36:40good stories except when I start working
- 36:41on them. And again, the ones I make up
- 36:44are good. the ones that like here's
- 36:45something that happened to me before
- 36:47they're they're not good. Yeah. So I
- 36:48think writer
- 36:49>> How are writing short stories different
- 36:51than writing a novel?
- 36:52>> I think with the novel at least I've
- 36:53only written one and there's one coming
- 36:55out and the first one had a lot of white
- 36:57space so I'm not sure but I for me it
- 36:59was that the novel has some kind of
- 37:02through line like with Lincoln you know
- 37:05that I'm going to put on there and then
- 37:06I'm going to have fun fulfilling the
- 37:08through line. But I don't really know
- 37:09what it means. I don't know how I'm
- 37:10going to do it with a story. In the best
- 37:12case, it's just putting something down
- 37:13and then reacting to it. And and
- 37:16>> the beautiful thing is is out of that
- 37:19very playful process, something really
- 37:22serious going to come out, you know,
- 37:23that something shaped and kind of
- 37:25momentous. So for me, the story is a
- 37:26little more it's harder actually because
- 37:28you don't know that it's going to work.
- 37:29It's like a joke sort of. And the story
- 37:32doesn't really like a novel, you know,
- 37:33if I say there's this guy named Gatsby
- 37:34and he wanted to meet his, you know,
- 37:36give his little girlfriend to go, okay,
- 37:38did it work? And then I tell you and 280
- 37:41pages later you find out. But with a
- 37:43story you're not even sure what you're
- 37:44asking. The story starts it creates its
- 37:46own context and its own meaning and then
- 37:49it lands itself in a funny way that you
- 37:51couldn't you couldn't have predicted. I
- 37:53think there's an overstory which is
- 37:54willak
- 37:56get a new overcoat and that's kind of
- 37:58novelistic. But then with a good short
- 38:00story there's an understory that's
- 38:02coming up all the time that the writer
- 38:04doesn't even understand until it bursts
- 38:07through the surface. And and that's when
- 38:09that story is a story when you realize
- 38:11we were writing we were telling a story
- 38:12about this over here but actually all
- 38:14along we were talking about this thing
- 38:15and
- 38:16>> without knowing it while you're doing it
- 38:17>> without knowing. Yeah.
- 38:18>> Based on that would you say writing is
- 38:19an intellectual process or no?
- 38:22>> For me it's the intellectual part is
- 38:24secondary or tertiary. I I had a a long
- 38:27time of thinking it was
- 38:28>> Yeah.
- 38:29>> And I confused myself. I had written I
- 38:31guess Hemingway stuff for many years
- 38:33which is all the stuff I'm talking
- 38:34about. It was intellectual. It was
- 38:35conceptual. It was copycat. It was all
- 38:37that stuff. And then one day at work, I
- 38:40I was bored and I uh was on a conference
- 38:43call and I wrote these poems, a kind of
- 38:44scatological Dr. Seuss kind of real
- 38:46silly stuff. And then I would finish the
- 38:48poem and I'd write a picture, draw a
- 38:50picture and and that night I took it
- 38:52home and I just threw it on the table
- 38:53and my wife
- 38:55from I was in the other room. She's
- 38:57reading it and suddenly she's laughing
- 38:58aloud which I hadn't gotten a positive
- 39:00reaction like that in a long time for
- 39:02that Hemingway stuff.
- 39:03>> And so something just clicked like oh so
- 39:05it's not intellectual. It's uh
- 39:07entertainment, it's experiential, it's
- 39:10all those other things. And and you
- 39:12know, when I was writing those, I I
- 39:14didn't have a thought in the world. I
- 39:15just was trying to make it rhyme and
- 39:16make it kind of funny.
- 39:18>> So that that kind of um
- 39:22that space I was in at that time, which
- 39:24was kind of generous and playful, well,
- 39:28come to find out that transfers to the
- 39:30reader if you can be in that space. So
- 39:32that was that's where I kind of got a
- 39:34little bit like the intellectual stuff
- 39:35is there, but I think it's it's
- 39:38secondary, you know, at least in the
- 39:39creative part, it's it's secondary.
- 39:41>> Yeah.
- 39:44>> In a world of artificial highs and harsh
- 39:46stimulants, there is something
- 39:48different, something clean, something
- 39:51precise. Athletic nicotine.
- 39:55Not the primitive products found behind
- 39:57convenience store counters. Not the
- 39:59aggressive buzz that leaves you jittery,
- 40:02but a careful calibration of clean
- 40:04energy and focused clarity. Athletic
- 40:07nicotine. The lowest dose tobaccof free
- 40:10nicotine available. Made entirely in the
- 40:13USA. No artificial sweetener. Just pure
- 40:17purposeful elevation. Athletic nicotine
- 40:20is a performance neutropic. Athletic
- 40:22nicotine is a tool for shifting
- 40:24mindsets. Athletic nicotine is a partner
- 40:27in pursuit of excellence. Slow release,
- 40:31low dose, gradual lift, sustained
- 40:34energy, soft landing, inspired results.
- 40:39Athletic nicotine, more focus, less
- 40:42static. Athletic nicotine. More clarity,
- 40:46less noise. Athletic nicotine.
- 40:50More accuracy, less anxiety. Athletic
- 40:54nicotine. From top athletes pushing
- 40:56their limits to artists pursuing their
- 40:58vision, Athletic Nicotine offers the
- 41:01lift you've been looking for. Learn more
- 41:04at athleticnicotine.com/tetra
- 41:07and experience next level performance
- 41:09with Athletic Nicotine.
- 41:12>> Warning, this product contains nicotine.
- 41:14Nicotine is an addictive chemical. I
- 41:16read that your first published short
- 41:18story was one that basically was
- 41:21recounting a dream that you had. Is that
- 41:23true?
- 41:23>> That's true. Tell me about that.
- 41:24>> Good research.
- 41:26>> Yeah. It was it was called a a lack of
- 41:28order in the floating object room and
- 41:29I'd been doing Hemingway Hemingway
- 41:31Hemingway Joyce Hemingway, you know, and
- 41:33then I had a dream of a um it was kind
- 41:36of a like a theme park where uh you go
- 41:39in there, they press a button and
- 41:40gravity gets suspended and stuff starts
- 41:42floating around. So the the narrator was
- 41:43the guy who runs that that place. So
- 41:46that that place came to me in my mind,
- 41:48but also there was a narrating voice
- 41:49that that gave me these sentences that
- 41:51were very unlike the ones I've been
- 41:53writing too modern and kind of you know
- 41:56and so I just ah that's weird. And I got
- 41:58up and started writing it down and found
- 42:00that I could continue in that mode and
- 42:02wrote for you know three or four pages
- 42:04and is done you know and that's the
- 42:06story I got into Syracuse with. So that
- 42:09was the first time I ever had that
- 42:10experience of of intuition being part of
- 42:13the
- 42:14>> the game you know but it was in a way it
- 42:17was kind of bitter because I didn't it
- 42:18didn't sound anything like Hemingway. It
- 42:19didn't sound like anything
- 42:21>> classic or anything, but you know that
- 42:22feeling of like, oh, I don't know what
- 42:24that is, but it's new.
- 42:26>> And in that newness, I like, well,
- 42:28that's there's something of me in there
- 42:29that I didn't that I maybe don't even
- 42:32like, but that. So, that's that's kind
- 42:34of what I've been hunting ever since is
- 42:36this that feeling of of I guess it's
- 42:38like blurting out. I had a dream the
- 42:40other night of um I I did an event with
- 42:44in New York with Zadeie Smith last week
- 42:45and on stage she mentioned that book
- 42:47Civil Warland and and the voice of it.
- 42:49So in the dream she was kind of saying,
- 42:50"You know what? You should go back to
- 42:52that." I'm like, "How do I do it?" And
- 42:54and the answer was the I had in the
- 42:58dream I had the same feeling I had while
- 43:00I was writing that book, which was [ __ ]
- 43:02meaning, [ __ ] structure. Sound sound.
- 43:06That's it. If if a sentence doesn't make
- 43:08it sense, if it's if it sounds good,
- 43:10it's in and the sense will find me
- 43:13later, you know? So, that's kind of a
- 43:14fun
- 43:15>> Yeah.
- 43:15>> Yeah.
- 43:16>> In general, is are you looking at the
- 43:19way the words look on the page or is it
- 43:21the way they sound?
- 43:22>> I never read aloud, but it's like
- 43:25there's a voice reading it in my head
- 43:28that is also taking note of the the
- 43:30look. It's kind of hard to explain, but
- 43:31it's But um
- 43:32>> you purposely not read it out loud.
- 43:34Yeah, because I don't my voice is kind
- 43:36of I would mangle whatever I you know.
- 43:39Um and also I think I I I'm a obviously
- 43:42a fast talker and I have a very quick
- 43:45monkey mind which is sometimes a real
- 43:47curse. But
- 43:48>> uh when I'm reading on the page or when
- 43:52I'm doing this thing we're talking about
- 43:53where I'm kind of reading in it feels
- 43:54like I'm reading in the back of my
- 43:56throat while I'm not
- 43:57>> uh I'm going a little faster than I
- 43:59could read it out loud and be
- 44:00understood.
- 44:01>> Are you mumbling it
- 44:03>> even silently? Because you see, you're
- 44:05reading it faster than you can read it.
- 44:07>> Yeah.
- 44:07>> So, are you getting every word or not?
- 44:10>> Yeah. I more so than if I read it aloud,
- 44:12weirdly. And and I can also
- 44:15>> it's hard to talk about, but I can feel
- 44:17the inefficiencies in it as I'm
- 44:19scanning, you know, and
- 44:22>> uh
- 44:22>> how important is rhythm in that?
- 44:24>> It's Yeah, it's everything like so like
- 44:27sometimes there'll be a sentence that'll
- 44:28go like
- 44:31like that last part. lop that off and
- 44:34you then you have the first rhythm da da
- 44:35da
- 44:36>> and then another rhythm will
- 44:38>> the correct rhythm will present and then
- 44:40words will come in to fill that
- 44:41>> like writing a song.
- 44:42>> Yeah. Yeah.
- 44:42>> Is it like right have you written songs?
- 44:44>> I want to talk to you about that. I've
- 44:45never written a good song and I I I
- 44:47because in songwriting the literal thing
- 44:50takes over and I start telling a you
- 44:53know a conventional I I I on line two
- 44:55and I think oh what should line three
- 44:56be?
- 44:57>> Yeah. Have a good exercise for you to
- 44:59try.
- 44:59>> Oh I'd love to have it.
- 45:00>> Yeah. Based on something you said it's
- 45:01amazing. You said the exact same thing
- 45:03as the exercise I'm going to tell you
- 45:04for songwriting.
- 45:05>> It's the same thing that you talked
- 45:06about the parts that blow instead of
- 45:08typically when we write a song there'll
- 45:11be let's say there are three verses and
- 45:12the three verses each have four lines
- 45:15>> and when you're writing the words
- 45:17there's it's a huge limitation. It's
- 45:19like you're
- 45:21>> it's like doing a a cross word puzzle in
- 45:23a way,
- 45:23>> right?
- 45:25Instead, if you write what the song's
- 45:30about, like a story, write 10 pages of
- 45:33the of the story,
- 45:35>> right?
- 45:36>> And then see which are the parts that
- 45:37glow
- 45:38>> and then take those parts and make them
- 45:40into lyrics.
- 45:41>> Oh, that's that makes perfect sense.
- 45:43>> Makes perfect sense, right?
- 45:44>> That does.
- 45:45>> But then as you're making them lyrics,
- 45:46you have to kind of alter them in terms
- 45:48of
- 45:48>> well, you you know where the energy in
- 45:51the story lies. I I just came up with
- 45:54this recently because I was working with
- 45:55an artist who wrote a song
- 45:59that I I listened to it and I felt like
- 46:03she didn't care about it. That was my
- 46:05listening to the words. It sounded like
- 46:07she's not talking about anything
- 46:08significant in her life. Why is this
- 46:10song even exist?
- 46:12>> And I said, "Is the song about something
- 46:13important to you?" And she's like,
- 46:14"Absolutely." And I said, "It's not
- 46:15coming through in the lyrics."
- 46:17>> And then she told me a little bit of the
- 46:19story. And then I said, "Why don't you
- 46:20write the whole story, not as a song,
- 46:22just write the story
- 46:24>> and then find where the charged moments
- 46:26are."
- 46:27>> Oh, wow.
- 46:27>> And then apply them to the song.
- 46:30>> Right.
- 46:30>> You know, one of I'm going to try that.
- 46:32But one of the things that for me I
- 46:33notic is I have a like an aversion to
- 46:38autobiography. Like if someone says,
- 46:39"Write a song about where you are." And
- 46:40I'm like, "None of your [ __ ]
- 46:41business." You know? So that's why the
- 46:43stories are so strange because I I I am
- 46:45somewhere and I you know I have a strong
- 46:48experience but I want to u reflect it
- 46:50out onto another surface and have it
- 46:52come to you.
- 46:53>> So songwise I always have a problem like
- 46:56you know I I talked like I'm a friend of
- 46:57Jeff Tweety and he's really good about
- 46:59coaching you know.
- 47:00>> Yeah. Yeah.
- 47:01>> But I don't I don't have any interest in
- 47:05how I feel right now. I mean, I do
- 47:07except not not I don't think it's a
- 47:09value particularly like it feels a
- 47:10little bit
- 47:11>> so it's that kind of like if I write
- 47:14about the two cups I'll know how I feel,
- 47:16you know, that kind of Yeah. No, I'll
- 47:18try that though because that I had
- 47:19somebody took one of my stories. A
- 47:21student took a story and excerpted from
- 47:23it and made a pretty cool like set of
- 47:25lyrics, you know. But but it's it's nice
- 47:27for me to have that kind of uh an art
- 47:30that I love and perpetually fail at is
- 47:33really fun for me because then then when
- 47:34I go to write it like okay, at least I I
- 47:37can finish this, you know.
- 47:38>> So there is it's it is sound and somehow
- 47:42uh reading it faster than I it helps me
- 47:45figure out the sound better. It's almost
- 47:47like turning up the the the speed of a
- 47:49tape and you hear the rhythm a little
- 47:50more acutely or something.
- 47:52>> So yeah, I never I never thought about
- 47:54this before, but yeah. Yeah,
- 47:56>> sometimes when you in music when you
- 47:59slow the music down, you can learn more
- 48:01about the rhythm than when you speed it
- 48:02up.
- 48:03>> Speeding it up tends to fix the the
- 48:07slightest imperfections.
- 48:10>> Slowing it down amplifies the
- 48:11imperfections.
- 48:12>> I think there's a correlary. I Yeah,
- 48:14because sometimes, you know, Oh, here's
- 48:16the other I I I kind of wanted to talk
- 48:17to
- 48:18>> Maybe by speeding it up though, you you
- 48:19don't get hung up on it. Maybe that's
- 48:21good.
- 48:22>> Right. Right. Okay. So you So I'm
- 48:24reading the work from yesterday
- 48:27and there's lately I notice there's a
- 48:30second part of my brain that steps aside
- 48:32and goes, "How's your reading mine
- 48:34today?" And some days I'm just I'm just
- 48:37skimming it. I can't read it. I've read
- 48:39it so many times I can't process it
- 48:40anymore and I don't like it.
- 48:42>> This guy goes, "Okay, just note that
- 48:44you're in a shitty mood today. You hate
- 48:46everything.
- 48:46>> Yeah.
- 48:47>> Duly noted.
- 48:48>> Okay. Then other days I'm like, "Wow,
- 48:51I'm the greatest. Every even this coffee
- 48:53stain is so good." You know?
- 48:54>> Do you ever put something aside when you
- 48:56have that feeling of nothing's good?
- 48:57>> Not really. I usually just note that I
- 48:59feel that way and work through it.
- 49:01>> Yeah. And and I I'm like a little less
- 49:03uh willing to make a change maybe.
- 49:06>> But part of the value of this approach
- 49:08is that even if you mess it up on
- 49:09Wednesday, you can fix it on Thursday.
- 49:10And I remember where I've where I've
- 49:12altered it, you know. But so the idea
- 49:14that you have some control also over
- 49:17your or some awareness of how adept you
- 49:21are at reading that day.
- 49:23>> Yeah.
- 49:23>> And then the the dream day is when
- 49:25everything is landing kind of like
- 49:27you're a first- time reader like oh I
- 49:28can really hear this today. And those
- 49:30days I just try to keep like reading
- 49:32reading reading because I really trust
- 49:34trust that.
- 49:35>> Do you only ever work on one thing at a
- 49:37time?
- 49:37>> No. I I will work on with stories. It's
- 49:39usually like I'll have in a perfect
- 49:41world I have three or four going and
- 49:43then I just kind of go in the morning
- 49:44like
- 49:45>> which one
- 49:45>> anybody fun you know and if one says no
- 49:48but I'm you should finish me I'm like
- 49:49yeah no I'm not
- 49:50>> if one isn't working that day you
- 49:53wouldn't stop working on it to start
- 49:55working on a different one
- 49:56>> sometimes sometimes yeah and I mean I
- 49:58always feel lately I I I've got one
- 50:00story at home that might be an exception
- 50:02but um if I start something
- 50:04>> I feel like I'll finish it it might take
- 50:07six 15 years even but if if something
- 50:09presented. Yes.
- 50:10>> And I like any part of it, then I'm just
- 50:12going to keep, you know, but but I
- 50:13don't.
- 50:14>> And if you finish it, it means you'll
- 50:15finish it or it means you'll finish it
- 50:17and share it with the world.
- 50:18>> If I finish it, I'll share it. That's
- 50:20kind of my psychology.
- 50:21>> Okay.
- 50:22>> If there's four things, I want the most
- 50:24fun one to come. The one that I feel
- 50:25like, oh yeah, I can do something with
- 50:27that.
- 50:27>> Whereas if it seems tedious or it seems
- 50:29like, ah, that's the one I'm locked up
- 50:30on, then I just wait. You know,
- 50:33>> is there a market for short stories?
- 50:35>> Yeah. Yeah. I mean, the New Yorker is
- 50:38the best place and then I published one
- 50:40the Atlantic this year and then
- 50:41collections will tend to sometimes they
- 50:43catch on. They sometimes sell and what
- 50:45I'm finding out with the subst because
- 50:46it's all about the short story and they
- 50:48are like amazing readers of stories.
- 50:50people who really kind of live their
- 50:52life by by short stories and they and uh
- 50:55so we you know we we'll put a story up
- 50:57there like this week we did a tall story
- 50:59thing and we get hundreds of comments
- 51:01and they're so like measured and
- 51:04courteous and smart and then sometimes
- 51:06I'll say does anybody speak Russian yeah
- 51:08they do and can you look at this part in
- 51:11the Russian are we misreading it you are
- 51:14you know or sometimes it said any
- 51:15neuroscientists out there yes there are
- 51:17you know so it's it's really I mean it
- 51:19gives me a lot of uh hope because you
- 51:21can certainly feel that there's not a
- 51:22market for stories.
- 51:23>> Yeah.
- 51:24>> And it's not a huge market, but I think
- 51:25the people who are into them are really
- 51:27into them and they tend to be pretty
- 51:29interesting people.
- 51:30>> You have any other interests or hobbies
- 51:32outside of writing?
- 51:33>> Not really.
- 51:34>> It's all writing.
- 51:35>> I have my family and we have a nice dog,
- 51:36you know, who's sick right now. But it's
- 51:38it's been I mean because for me
- 51:39everything folds into writing anyway,
- 51:41you know, if it if it's uh
- 51:44>> Yeah. Yeah. No, I it's it's something I
- 51:46realized the last few years I don't
- 51:47really have any other interest. guitar I
- 51:49like but it's you know but I just like
- 51:51writing.
- 51:52>> Interesting. Yeah.
- 51:52>> Well, it's true true love.
- 51:54>> Well, and and you know, Buddhism. I'm
- 51:56in. But again, that doesn't seem to me
- 51:58separate. It's just it's the same.
- 51:59>> Tell me about your relationship to
- 52:01school over the course of your life.
- 52:02>> I was a real weeny good Catholic boy. Uh
- 52:07loved Catholicism, loved the nuns,
- 52:09pretty good student. Very.
- 52:11>> So, was a Christian school you went to?
- 52:12>> It was No. Yeah, it was a Catholic St.
- 52:14Damian Catholic Catholic school. And
- 52:16then somehow when I got to high school,
- 52:17I just
- 52:19couldn't be bothered. I didn't study a
- 52:21lick. Um
- 52:23>> because of what what else was happening?
- 52:25>> Music. Music was happening. Uh
- 52:27weightlifting was happening. Everything
- 52:29seemed really uh boring. But then
- 52:32luckily for me, there was a great
- 52:34teacher named uh Sher Williams was her
- 52:36English teacher. And she had a way of
- 52:38teaching novels and stories that I I
- 52:41really it really spoke to me. And then
- 52:43she had a at that point a boyfriend that
- 52:45she married named Joel Limble, a geology
- 52:47teacher. And they kind of took an
- 52:48interest in me and uh basically
- 52:51persuaded me to go to college and he
- 52:52actually called and got me in. He
- 52:54literally called the school of minds in
- 52:55Colorado and said this you won't see it
- 52:58in this kid's record like he's worth a
- 52:59look.
- 53:00>> Wow.
- 53:00>> And so yeah and this being the 70s they
- 53:02went okay um
- 53:04>> have him go to summer school for 18
- 53:06hours take all the technical stuff and
- 53:08if he gets this grade point he can come.
- 53:10So I did I did it and I never I
- 53:12literally had never worked at anything
- 53:14except guitar a little bit in sports.
- 53:17>> So I I went out there and and the funny
- 53:19thing was I had my transcript and I went
- 53:20out to the school of minds in Colorado
- 53:22and they said basically you know I'm
- 53:24George I'm here for college and they
- 53:26were like uh okay hold on a second and
- 53:28they took the transcript in the back
- 53:29room and came I said okay you're you're
- 53:32in but that was for engineering because
- 53:34he was a geologist and I admired him so
- 53:36much that I just I just thought I'd do
- 53:38what he did. Did you want to be a
- 53:40geologist or No,
- 53:40>> no, not really.
- 53:41>> Did you when did you decide to become a
- 53:43writer or And did you want to be do
- 53:45something else before that?
- 53:46>> Yeah, I think before that I mean I I
- 53:48think I wanted to be a musician really.
- 53:50And in fact, I was in a band right
- 53:52before I met this couple. Uh and the guy
- 53:55he was a really good guitar player and
- 53:57he knew somebody who knew somebody who
- 53:58knew somebody in the Eagles. That was
- 54:00the thing. And he thought he could get
- 54:01us on as the opener for the opener. So,
- 54:04all right. So, that's my career plan.
- 54:05and we practiced for a couple months and
- 54:07then I just then I met these teachers
- 54:09and I just thought I got to uh but I
- 54:12didn't want to be a geologist but I also
- 54:14I had a a couple of experiences that
- 54:17made me realize I was kind of full of
- 54:18[ __ ] and that was very helpful. Like I
- 54:21took a a classical guitar lesson at this
- 54:24community college in Chicago and I I had
- 54:26um I had kind of quote unquote learned
- 54:29this that Caprico or Rab that beautiful
- 54:31classical piece was way above my level
- 54:33but I could sort of play the first part
- 54:35and
- 54:36so I went into this guy and I played and
- 54:38I just wanted a mentor so badly, you
- 54:40know, somebody because I could tell I
- 54:42>> I I was a drift. So, I played it for him
- 54:45and I played it probably the best I ever
- 54:46had. But, you know, so I was waiting for
- 54:49him to kind of put the crown on my head,
- 54:51you know, and he said, uh, he leaned
- 54:52away and he said, "I'm going to tell you
- 54:54something." He said, "If if you don't
- 54:56change the way you're living, you're
- 54:58going to be a very unhappy adult."
- 55:01And it just, I mean, it stung
- 55:02>> based on your guitar playing.
- 55:03>> Yeah. Yeah. And I And he must have seen
- 55:07that I was kind of stung by it. And he
- 55:08and and then he explained that my
- 55:10>> I think anybody would be stunned by that
- 55:12based on guitar play. 17, you know, I do
- 55:14my best.
- 55:15>> But it but it was interesting because I
- 55:17still think about that guy and that was
- 55:18a long time ago. And I think what he and
- 55:20then what he did was he gave me those
- 55:21siggoia scales, you know, it was really
- 55:23slow and he he gave me a metronome
- 55:25setting that was insultingly slow. It
- 55:27was so slow, you know.
- 55:29>> Okay. So, I started doing it and sure
- 55:30enough, my tone got better and I could
- 55:34see that I wasn't a thoughtful player. I
- 55:35was just a, you know, doing it fast. And
- 55:38so, so he did me a favor, but I had a
- 55:40grudge against him and I couldn't really
- 55:42continue. But that so that was one big
- 55:43thing. And then that teacher Joel
- 55:45Lindlam took me to a uh kind of an all
- 55:48Chicago city science fair with kids my
- 55:51own age were doing this stuff and he was
- 55:53such a sweet guy and he just took me
- 55:55there and and I hadn't done any work
- 55:57literally no work and these kids were
- 55:59building you know nuclear power plants
- 56:01and I don't know everything and I he
- 56:03just you know we just walked around and
- 56:06he let that sink in you know that these
- 56:07are people my age who were applying
- 56:10stuff. Yeah. But he the thing that I
- 56:12love so much is I get very moved by this
- 56:14because he never there was not a single
- 56:16touch of judgment you know he just let
- 56:18me look at it.
- 56:19>> Yeah. Did you get inspired or inspired?
- 56:22>> Well actually the first reaction was oh
- 56:23[ __ ] I haven't done this.
- 56:24>> Yeah
- 56:25>> and they have
- 56:27>> how does that you know what does that
- 56:29say about what I'm doing?
- 56:30>> Yeah.
- 56:30>> Uh and then
- 56:32>> it wasn't really that I could but I had
- 56:34to try. That was the feel. And so then
- 56:37>> a lot of my ambition and I had a lot it
- 56:40got channeled into not flunking out of
- 56:42engineering school and um
- 56:44>> so I went to this place called the
- 56:45Colorado School of Minds in Golden which
- 56:47is a uh I studied geophysics so it was
- 56:49all all science all the time. That was
- 56:51deep because I wasn't good at it. I
- 56:53really wasn't good at it and I worked
- 56:54really hard.
- 56:55>> Yeah.
- 56:56>> Which was
- 56:58>> great for an artist, you know, to learn
- 56:59that effort
- 57:01>> doesn't equal results.
- 57:12LM NT
- 57:15element electrolytes.
- 57:19Have you ever felt dehydrated after an
- 57:21intense workout or a long day in the
- 57:23sun? Do you want to maximize your
- 57:26endurance and feel your best? Add
- 57:28element electrolytes to your daily
- 57:30routine.
- 57:32Perform better and sleep deeper. Improve
- 57:35your cognitive function.
- 57:38Experience an increase in steady energy
- 57:40with fewer headaches and fewer muscle
- 57:42cramps.
- 57:44Element electrolytes. Drink it in the
- 57:47sauna.
- 57:51Refreshing flavors include grapefruit,
- 57:53citrus, watermelon, and chocolate salt.
- 57:57Formulated with the perfect balance of
- 57:59sodium, potassium, and magnesium to keep
- 58:02you hydrated and energized throughout
- 58:04the day, these minerals help conduct the
- 58:07electricity that powers your nervous
- 58:09system so you can perform at your very
- 58:11best.
- 58:13Element electrolytes are sugar-free,
- 58:16keto friendly, and great tasting.
- 58:20Minerals are the stuff of life.
- 58:24So visit drinklmnt.com/tra
- 58:28and stay salty with elementel
- 58:30electrolytes lmnt.
- 58:36When did you start teaching writing
- 58:39>> years later? Uh so I was writing a
- 58:41little bit there but I wasn't reading
- 58:42well. I was reading like kind of weird
- 58:45self-help stuff and and um Khalil
- 58:47Gabbron and kind of so I didn't start
- 58:50teaching until many many years. I'd been
- 58:52out of uh the Syracuse program uh was
- 58:56working as an engineer and wrote my
- 58:58first book and had a chance to go teach
- 58:59there for a year and I sensed correctly
- 59:02that that would be uh it would give me a
- 59:04lot more time to work.
- 59:05>> What was the first book?
- 59:07>> It was called Civil Warland and Bad
- 59:08Decline book of short stories and uh
- 59:10wrote it at work actually.
- 59:11>> And was it wellreceived?
- 59:13>> It was critically it didn't sell very
- 59:14much but it was critically had a couple
- 59:16of good reviews that kind of made it
- 59:19>> and then um yeah and I wrote that one at
- 59:21work. I was just at this engineering job
- 59:22and stealing time here and there. So, it
- 59:24was a big and I was 38 so it wasn't I
- 59:26wasn't a prodigy, you know. Uh but so
- 59:28that got me this chance to teach at
- 59:30Syracuse for a year which then grew into
- 59:32a full-time full-time gig. It was nice
- 59:34because by that time we had our two kids
- 59:35and I already had a sort of a you know a
- 59:38life being a tech writer. And so um it
- 59:42there was uh a lot of the stuff that I
- 59:44still write about was already in my in
- 59:46my experience you know from from being
- 59:48>> How do you learn to teach writing?
- 59:51Uh I think it was a uh gradually you
- 59:57know you you first you think
- 1:00:00the job is to find mistakes and fix them
- 1:00:02per your value system that doesn't work
- 1:00:05and then slowly
- 1:00:08uh what you see what works I guess it
- 1:00:10must be like you see if I do it this way
- 1:00:12the kid stiffens up and leaves in a huff
- 1:00:15you know if I do it this way they lean
- 1:00:17in and the next draft is more
- 1:00:19interesting. So it it became less and
- 1:00:22less talking and more listening over the
- 1:00:24years.
- 1:00:24>> Yeah. How long did it take to get good
- 1:00:26at teaching it?
- 1:00:27>> I think I'm still working on but I would
- 1:00:29say there was a big jump after five
- 1:00:31years or so because then I just got kind
- 1:00:33of sick of of my
- 1:00:36the sound of my voice heranging
- 1:00:38somebody, you know, or coaching
- 1:00:40somebody.
- 1:00:40>> And I noticed that if if you like if I
- 1:00:43had a conference with somebody, we were
- 1:00:45talking about their work. If I could
- 1:00:47just shut up for the first 3 minutes,
- 1:00:50they would tell me what and they would
- 1:00:52always identify exactly what I had
- 1:00:55identified if I gave them enough time.
- 1:00:56>> Yeah.
- 1:00:57>> Then you're not the person saying
- 1:00:59there's something,
- 1:01:00>> you know, you're not the doctor saying
- 1:01:01you're sick.
- 1:01:02>> You're the doctor saying, "Oh, you feel
- 1:01:04that you're sick."
- 1:01:06>> Then your advice is
- 1:01:07>> Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
- 1:01:08>> Yeah. But that's it took a long time
- 1:01:09because the insecurity of being somebody
- 1:01:11who wasn't exactly trained in English,
- 1:01:13you know, in English education. Uh being
- 1:01:16faced with these inc we get like 700
- 1:01:18applications and picked six people. So
- 1:01:20they're great. So early on I was so
- 1:01:23intimidated by that that I thought the
- 1:01:24only way to counter the intimidation is
- 1:01:26with
- 1:01:27>> Yeah.
- 1:01:27>> information, you know. Um so that's been
- 1:01:29a sweet part of it is to go, oh yeah,
- 1:01:31actually uh 98% of the work is being
- 1:01:34done by the student.
- 1:01:35>> Yeah.
- 1:01:36>> Yeah. Is that is that something that
- 1:01:38rings?
- 1:01:38>> Absolutely. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. The less
- 1:01:41my fingers are involved in the process,
- 1:01:44the better it's going to be.
- 1:01:45>> Yeah.
- 1:01:46>> It's only like in an emergency situation
- 1:01:49do I step in,
- 1:01:50>> right? Right.
- 1:01:51>> When uh you know, if someone's drowning,
- 1:01:53>> right? Right.
- 1:01:54>> In the best versions, it sort of happens
- 1:01:56by itself. And if there's something that
- 1:02:00I feel when I'm listening, I can share
- 1:02:03what I'm feeling,
- 1:02:04>> but it's it's never mistakes or what
- 1:02:09could be better. It's more like let's
- 1:02:11look at this part like this part may not
- 1:02:14be as good as the rest. Why why is that?
- 1:02:16It seems like there's a better way to do
- 1:02:18this.
- 1:02:18>> Yeah.
- 1:02:19>> You know,
- 1:02:20>> what about I mean what about this the
- 1:02:22sonic things? And I think there's a
- 1:02:23correlary in writing. There are things
- 1:02:25happening off the page in a sense.
- 1:02:26They're they're very real and they're
- 1:02:28actually what makes great and good
- 1:02:30different.
- 1:02:31>> Yeah.
- 1:02:32>> Uh but with with what I do, you just
- 1:02:34kind of it's there and you let it stay
- 1:02:37or you subtract from. But when you're at
- 1:02:38some point, you're making decisions on
- 1:02:40how what the sonic landscape looks like,
- 1:02:43right? What to add? Are you you know,
- 1:02:46>> I I try to have it be as whatever they
- 1:02:50bring. Like there was a time
- 1:02:52>> earlier in my career when we would try
- 1:02:56to make it sound like something that we
- 1:02:58like the way it sounded,
- 1:02:59>> right?
- 1:03:00>> And we don't do that anymore. Like the
- 1:03:02idea of well the snare drum wants the
- 1:03:04the best snare drum sound is on this
- 1:03:06album. So if we make this if we try to
- 1:03:08make our snare drum sound like the sound
- 1:03:10on that album that's going to be best.
- 1:03:13>> Yeah.
- 1:03:13>> That is never best.
- 1:03:14>> That's my Hemingway ears. And and that's
- 1:03:16that thing about about
- 1:03:17>> Yeah. It's always for what we have.
- 1:03:20What's the what's the best version of
- 1:03:23what it is?
- 1:03:24>> Mhm.
- 1:03:24>> Not trying to make it anything else.
- 1:03:26>> Right. Right. Yeah. That's
- 1:03:29>> same.
- 1:03:30>> Same.
- 1:03:31>> Yeah.
- 1:03:31>> Yeah. I find that with that mindset, you
- 1:03:33can let it be a lot more things at the
- 1:03:35outset than you
- 1:03:36>> for sure. And and it also takes patience
- 1:03:38because
- 1:03:39>> it's um it's not formulaic in any way.
- 1:03:43it it
- 1:03:44>> becomes what it wants to be over time,
- 1:03:47>> right?
- 1:03:48>> And in the early days, you know, every
- 1:03:50time I've been doing it for 40 years and
- 1:03:52if I start a new album tomorrow,
- 1:03:56there'll be a lot of apprehension.
- 1:03:58>> Yeah.
- 1:03:59>> In the beginning, not because I I don't
- 1:04:03know that it won't eventually be good. I
- 1:04:05know it'll eventually be good because
- 1:04:06I'm patient and we won't stop until it's
- 1:04:09good,
- 1:04:09>> right? But if there's any expectation
- 1:04:11it's going to be good today, tomorrow or
- 1:04:14in a week, that's totally out of our
- 1:04:17control.
- 1:04:18>> Right. Right. Yeah.
- 1:04:19>> So, but and there's apprehension around
- 1:04:21that. It's like everybody wants it to be
- 1:04:23good and it's totally out of our
- 1:04:25control. What's going to happen? Scary.
- 1:04:28>> Yeah. Scary. Right. And I think that's
- 1:04:30what a listener feels is that you went
- 1:04:32to the scary place and you you know
- 1:04:34there I was um I think Tony Morrison, my
- 1:04:36my wife studied with Tony Morrison at
- 1:04:38one point. She says something about in
- 1:04:39the early part of her books, she's kind
- 1:04:41of digging out a foundation and it it
- 1:04:43she doesn't control how deep it goes,
- 1:04:45but the deeper it goes, the higher the
- 1:04:47building.
- 1:04:47>> Yeah.
- 1:04:48>> And the reader feels that somehow this
- 1:04:51>> is there is there something I'm I was
- 1:04:53always curious about this cuz
- 1:04:55>> uh as a n natural introvert, I only have
- 1:04:58to fight with myself, you know, which
- 1:05:00I'm
- 1:05:01>> okay with. But when you're in you have
- 1:05:03these powerful personalities who come in
- 1:05:05with their ideas and that talk about
- 1:05:09that moment of when you you feel you
- 1:05:13want to influence or you want to
- 1:05:14interject.
- 1:05:16Are you doing that in different flavors
- 1:05:18for different artists? You must be
- 1:05:19>> always different. Yeah. It's whatever is
- 1:05:22necessary in that particular
- 1:05:24>> and one of the things I found that's
- 1:05:25helpful is to depersonalize the process.
- 1:05:28I talk about it in the book. If you play
- 1:05:29me a song and I say your song's no good
- 1:05:32or you're no good because you wrote that
- 1:05:34song,
- 1:05:35>> that's a bad that won't work.
- 1:05:37>> So, what do you say?
- 1:05:38>> What else can we listen to? We listen to
- 1:05:40things until there's like a spark.
- 1:05:42>> Mhm.
- 1:05:43>> And once the spark happens, the first
- 1:05:45spark, even if it turns into something
- 1:05:48totally different, I totally relax cuz
- 1:05:51at least something happens, it's like,
- 1:05:54okay, there's a clue.
- 1:05:56This could be interesting now. Let's see
- 1:05:58where it goes.
- 1:05:59>> And if it turns in from that in
- 1:06:01something totally different, that's
- 1:06:02fine.
- 1:06:03>> Yeah.
- 1:06:03>> I will say each step of the way, we will
- 1:06:07note how good that moment is. And if it
- 1:06:12turns into something else, the hope
- 1:06:13would be it's something else and it's as
- 1:06:16good or better than that moment. If it's
- 1:06:18not, maybe we're not following the right
- 1:06:21thread.
- 1:06:21>> Right. That's very familiar.
- 1:06:23>> Yeah.
- 1:06:23>> Yeah. Yeah. because I'll have uh pages
- 1:06:26of just blah and then suddenly there'll
- 1:06:28be one spark and you're like okay so
- 1:06:30>> we're going to honor that spark and
- 1:06:32>> that's the starting point
- 1:06:33>> and and the thing is once you have that
- 1:06:35that's where the reaction comes in
- 1:06:37because if I and and also those in pros
- 1:06:40those sparks have um thematics about
- 1:06:44them you know the first time something
- 1:06:45happened you go oh wow I like that well
- 1:06:48the story has then narrowed its path a
- 1:06:50little bit and it's not about everything
- 1:06:51anymore it's about that one thing which
- 1:06:53then gives your reactions is more oomph
- 1:06:55because you're reacting to a very
- 1:06:57specific moment that you've
- 1:06:58inadvertently, you know, inadvertently
- 1:07:00made.
- 1:07:01>> How important is setting when you're
- 1:07:03writing? I don't mean where you are, but
- 1:07:05>> where the story takes place.
- 1:07:07>> For me, not that much. And I think
- 1:07:09that's actually a reflection of a kind
- 1:07:11of value system I have. Like I don't
- 1:07:13really
- 1:07:15write very well. Like I had to describe
- 1:07:16this beautiful place, I I couldn't. It
- 1:07:19would be kind of It's so beautiful, you
- 1:07:20know.
- 1:07:21>> So you say it's not a you don't have a
- 1:07:22descriptive style. I don't really uh
- 1:07:25except what happens is so I so that
- 1:07:27means I have to emphasize something else
- 1:07:29which is usually action or dialogue
- 1:07:31something happened
- 1:07:32>> then a lot of times a description will
- 1:07:35come in just very lightly almost just
- 1:07:38like one line of something that sets you
- 1:07:40in a certain place. So I had a line in a
- 1:07:42store called Com which guy's walking
- 1:07:44through some woods. Woods I don't know
- 1:07:47anything about trees you So I just said,
- 1:07:49"Well, there's uh I don't remember the
- 1:07:51line, but it's like there's three toilet
- 1:07:52seats with price tags on them there." So
- 1:07:55that's setting, you know. So I don't
- 1:07:57really I I don't I think what I do a lot
- 1:07:59is I assume that if if I say graveyard,
- 1:08:02you give me a graveyard. And then there
- 1:08:04can be some individualization of the
- 1:08:06graveyard.
- 1:08:07>> Yeah.
- 1:08:08>> But um I mean I'm not a big
- 1:08:10>> And in um earlier you you gave an
- 1:08:12example of Abraham Lincoln notices
- 1:08:15something, he looks and you say it's a
- 1:08:17hunter. you decide it's a hunter. If
- 1:08:19your first thought is it's a hunter,
- 1:08:22>> is it always a hunter from for the rest
- 1:08:24of the story? Or do you ever say, "Okay,
- 1:08:27it's a hunter." And then you play that
- 1:08:28scenario out and then you realize, "No,
- 1:08:30you know, it's not a hunter. It's going
- 1:08:32to be something else."
- 1:08:33>> It could. Yeah. Some, you know, it's
- 1:08:34funny. Sometimes those ideas, they come
- 1:08:36in through the window and they trip.
- 1:08:37>> Yeah.
- 1:08:38>> And and it's ever more it's an idea that
- 1:08:41tripped and it's got a little it doesn't
- 1:08:42quite communicate. So those I I
- 1:08:44definitely will adjust. But in the ideal
- 1:08:46case like that one, it was a ghost of
- 1:08:48this guy, a hunter. The idea came up and
- 1:08:51the words just came right in behind it
- 1:08:53and that had a kind of a had a kind of
- 1:08:54authority that that doesn't go away, you
- 1:08:56know. So So there's um
- 1:08:58>> that right Russian writer Isaac Babble
- 1:09:00said something like uh a good sentence
- 1:09:03is like you you you throw the switch
- 1:09:06once and there it is, you know. Uh
- 1:09:08whereas a a less good sentence is you
- 1:09:11you're kind of deciding and you're
- 1:09:12thinking and you're conceptualizing and
- 1:09:13it kind of comes up a little
- 1:09:15>> lumpy. But for me there's there's a
- 1:09:16there's a moment where the you you asked
- 1:09:19earlier about how the words look on the
- 1:09:20page and I think that is important.
- 1:09:23Sometimes the the the image or the
- 1:09:26thought and the sentence wrapping come
- 1:09:29just at the same moment and that has
- 1:09:32authority
- 1:09:33>> and authority that excuse me authority
- 1:09:36in that sense
- 1:09:38it's also respect for the reader somehow
- 1:09:40and that it's the glue that pulls them
- 1:09:42in. So there are times when that just
- 1:09:45happens and you go just leave it alone,
- 1:09:46you know, and other times that you have
- 1:09:48to work towards it, I think a little
- 1:09:49bit, but
- 1:09:49>> it happens. You didn't decide that it
- 1:09:52happens.
- 1:09:52>> It happened. It just happened. Yeah. But
- 1:09:54it's almost like two trains coming into
- 1:09:56the station at once, you know, the the
- 1:09:57idea and the sentence and boom, they're
- 1:09:59just there and then and I can go through
- 1:10:03hundreds of drafts and that sentence
- 1:10:04just stays there because it's it it's
- 1:10:06authentic, you know?
- 1:10:07>> Yeah. Would your creative writing class
- 1:10:11be similar to other creative writing
- 1:10:14classes or is yours your creative
- 1:10:15writing class and has nothing to do with
- 1:10:17what anyone else does or teaches? I
- 1:10:18think it's pretty it's that workshop
- 1:10:20model so it's pretty similar and the
- 1:10:22only thing that I think it's not just me
- 1:10:23but a lot of people do are doing now is
- 1:10:25kind of critiquing that method because
- 1:10:28it's a little bit of a I mean it's an
- 1:10:29economic construct that they came up
- 1:10:30with in the 60s to get writers and
- 1:10:32readers paid you know uh and you know
- 1:10:35you think about like the way we're
- 1:10:36talking about this if there were seven
- 1:10:38people here and we're talking about
- 1:10:40Fred's story it it's it's all that that
- 1:10:44discourse is always
- 1:10:46u beneath the level of mystery
- 1:10:48you know, you're articulating and so
- 1:10:50you're, you know, so there it's a little
- 1:10:52bit good to be suspicious of the form
- 1:10:54itself. So, we do a lot of talking about
- 1:10:56how are we doing as a group? Are there
- 1:10:58things we're missing? Uh, something I've
- 1:11:00done lately is is to say, let's not go
- 1:11:02longer than we have to because that's
- 1:11:04one thing in those kind of meetings is
- 1:11:06you got an hour and a half. So, you do
- 1:11:09all the essential work in 45 minutes and
- 1:11:10then suddenly you're talking about the
- 1:11:12color scheme or something. It's not it's
- 1:11:13more
- 1:11:14>> content. So I think I just try to be a
- 1:11:16little wary of the um how yeah how far
- 1:11:19below the activity the articulation
- 1:11:22falls you know like um if you're having
- 1:11:25a session that's really like up here and
- 1:11:27then someone oh that was good and you
- 1:11:29start yapping about it somehow it's not
- 1:11:31it's not and it's okay I think it's okay
- 1:11:33to talk about it but at the same time
- 1:11:35like if you if you
- 1:11:37>> just had your peak sexual experience you
- 1:11:39could talk about it and maybe you would
- 1:11:40like to but it's not the same it's not
- 1:11:43the same thing. Are there any accepted
- 1:11:45rules of writing that it would be better
- 1:11:47not to learn?
- 1:11:48>> I think don't worry about plot. That
- 1:11:50that is a word that gives people a lot
- 1:11:51of conions and I don't think it's
- 1:11:53>> avoid plot
- 1:11:54>> or or the word plot. You're still going
- 1:11:56to have plot. But I think a lot of the I
- 1:11:58mean a lot of the ways that we talk
- 1:12:00about writing are
- 1:12:03postwriting descriptions of things that
- 1:12:05happened that were magical and now we're
- 1:12:07going to name them.
- 1:12:08>> Yeah.
- 1:12:09>> So that's okay and I that's criticism
- 1:12:11and it's important. But then when you
- 1:12:12think about the moment that you did it,
- 1:12:15I'm not ever thinking about plot.
- 1:12:17>> Yeah.
- 1:12:17>> Or theme or character. That's not how it
- 1:12:19works. So it's I think it's you do a
- 1:12:22student a disservice if you say, "Well,
- 1:12:24how's your plot?"
- 1:12:25>> You know, who could do that? So So it's
- 1:12:28interesting because the one thing that
- 1:12:29might be different in my class is I I
- 1:12:31really want to talk about, as you did in
- 1:12:33your book so beautifully, what does it
- 1:12:34feel like in the moment of creation?
- 1:12:37What's your mind doing? And and what can
- 1:12:39we do to nurture that state? What are
- 1:12:41the things that that peck at it and and
- 1:12:44take us down from that state? Uh hard
- 1:12:46hard to talk about. But when you with
- 1:12:48writing it's nice because you have the
- 1:12:50text.
- 1:12:51>> So in editing it you can sort of say
- 1:12:56if if six people are editing a text and
- 1:12:59everybody loves page three, then you can
- 1:13:01say to the writer,
- 1:13:03think think about where were you? You
- 1:13:06know, what was going on when you wrote
- 1:13:07that? That's probably a good state for
- 1:13:08you. You know, that kind of thing. Um
- 1:13:10but it's it's I think of it as a
- 1:13:12telescope like there's the critical end
- 1:13:13of the telescope which describes and uh
- 1:13:16you know elucidates and analyzes and
- 1:13:20that's really useful and it can help the
- 1:13:21creative but the other side of the
- 1:13:23telescope is something much more
- 1:13:26>> mysterious you know
- 1:13:27>> are you superstitious?
- 1:13:29No, I I I got rid of that because I that
- 1:13:32first book I wrote at work. So there was
- 1:13:34like there was no
- 1:13:37uh time for I couldn't I couldn't design
- 1:13:40the ideal writing moment that so I just
- 1:13:43said forget it. And I also
- 1:13:44>> superstitious about anything in life.
- 1:13:46>> I'm OCD which is which is kind of
- 1:13:48similar but no I'm not I I
- 1:13:50>> describe the OCD.
- 1:13:52>> H
- 1:13:52>> describe the OCD. Um, in the positive
- 1:13:55sense it's rewriting
- 1:13:57with no limit. In the negative sense,
- 1:13:59it's kind of a self- suspicion, I guess.
- 1:14:02Kind of a which is very close to being a
- 1:14:04good editor, but not quite.
- 1:14:06>> Are you a perfectionist?
- 1:14:08>> Yes. Yes. Yeah. But but I think also
- 1:14:11honestly I I would say maybe from
- 1:14:14Buddhism I've become a merciful
- 1:14:16perfectionist, which is to say perfect
- 1:14:18really is the enemy of good. So pretend
- 1:14:21to be a perfectionist until you start
- 1:14:23being a pain in the ass and then stop
- 1:14:24because you're going to drive yourself
- 1:14:25into the ditch.
- 1:14:26>> I mean, a lot of a lot of what I I I I
- 1:14:29because I published late, I had a real
- 1:14:32palpable period where I was like, "Okay,
- 1:14:34all your life you thought you're going
- 1:14:35to be a writer. It looks like you're
- 1:14:36not. Are you okay with that?" You know,
- 1:14:40and so once I got going, I was like,
- 1:14:42"Okay, I'm I'm not going to Somehow I
- 1:14:44just said, I'm not going to let neurosis
- 1:14:46get in the way of productivity. Can we
- 1:14:48agree on that?" And for once in my life
- 1:14:50he said I agreed with myself. Yeah, we
- 1:14:51can't. So I I don't tend to be
- 1:14:53superstitious or like if I have a a book
- 1:14:56that's successful
- 1:14:57>> I have about two days of going oh no you
- 1:15:00peaked and I'm like that's so babyish.
- 1:15:02Don't do that. That's not that's selfish
- 1:15:04and it's kind of contradictory to the
- 1:15:05experience you had while you were
- 1:15:06writing it which was you the self went
- 1:15:08away. Yes.
- 1:15:09>> So don't be all babyish about that. This
- 1:15:12>> you you've got some gifts to keep
- 1:15:14giving. So don't so so in many many ways
- 1:15:16there's a kind of a high functioning
- 1:15:18productivity mind that says if if that's
- 1:15:21going to get us in the weeds let's not
- 1:15:22do that.
- 1:15:22>> Are you OCD outside of your work
- 1:15:25>> a little bit probably not clinically but
- 1:15:27like
- 1:15:27>> in in what ways might it show up in
- 1:15:29>> uh mostly just I'll I'll go to a party
- 1:15:31and say something and go oh my god what
- 1:15:33did I say you know or read I'll feel
- 1:15:36negative about things that I've said or
- 1:15:37done that in the light of day weren't
- 1:15:39much. So, I think that's a form of ego
- 1:15:41actually. You know, I I and and
- 1:15:43perfectionism. You know, I couldn't
- 1:15:45possibly be the guy who says something
- 1:15:46stupid at a party. That would be, you
- 1:15:48know, do do you have any any of that?
- 1:15:50>> Um,
- 1:15:51>> I think politeness would say you have to
- 1:15:52say yes.
- 1:15:53>> No, I'll say that I've had I had
- 1:15:55something happen recently where
- 1:16:00I was asked some questions. I answered
- 1:16:02the questions. It was in a public way.
- 1:16:04>> They were things I didn't know about.
- 1:16:06The answers came up. The answers were
- 1:16:08fine. And then later that night, I woke
- 1:16:10up in the middle of the night with much
- 1:16:11better answers than the ones that came
- 1:16:14>> in the moment. I wasn't mad at myself,
- 1:16:16but it was just like, hm, it's much
- 1:16:18better answers.
- 1:16:19>> If it's not catastrophic, then it's
- 1:16:21>> wasn't catastrophic.
- 1:16:22>> Yeah. I remember as a little kid even
- 1:16:23having that kind of mind, like a little
- 1:16:25bit uh kind of it's sort of a, you know,
- 1:16:28devil angel. Like there's a there's a
- 1:16:30real high sense of responsibility and a
- 1:16:32desire to be good. And then there's also
- 1:16:34the the shadow side which is super
- 1:16:36self-critical. There's a line you say
- 1:16:38somewhere. Let me see if I can find it.
- 1:16:40There's partner swim in the pond where
- 1:16:42you're commenting on a section of Toltoy
- 1:16:45and you say um the writing leaves you
- 1:16:48with envy and resentment.
- 1:16:50>> Yeah.
- 1:16:51>> Was that sarcastic?
- 1:16:52>> No.
- 1:16:53>> Tell me about that.
- 1:16:54>> It's, you know, that's actually receding
- 1:16:55a little bit as I get older, but when I
- 1:16:57was young, it killed me when somebody
- 1:16:59was so good.
- 1:16:59>> Really?
- 1:17:00>> Yeah. Yeah. I thought, why can't you
- 1:17:01know? And again, that I I just thought
- 1:17:03Yeah. It was very um egotistical. I just
- 1:17:05I just want to be the only good one. I
- 1:17:07think that was
- 1:17:07>> Wow.
- 1:17:08>> Yeah. And then as you get
- 1:17:09>> are you are you competitive in life?
- 1:17:12>> Yes. Although less and less I I think at
- 1:17:14that point I hadn't done anything.
- 1:17:15>> I see.
- 1:17:16>> So I just want to be the best at this
- 1:17:17thing I'd never tried. And then as I as
- 1:17:19you get into it it's a deealing
- 1:17:22practice. And so you go well it doesn't
- 1:17:24it doesn't matter if if uh if I did it.
- 1:17:27It matters that it got done.
- 1:17:28>> Yes.
- 1:17:29>> And of course that comes and go. Then
- 1:17:30when you're done you're like I did it.
- 1:17:31>> Yeah. But no, for sure I I I think um I
- 1:17:34read Toltoy now and I'm like, "God, but
- 1:17:36for the first time in my life, I'm like,
- 1:17:37"Yeah, he's great. He's greater than
- 1:17:40you'll ever be." And that's okay. But
- 1:17:41when I was younger, that really got
- 1:17:42under my skin somehow, you know, but the
- 1:17:44more I did it, the less that feeling
- 1:17:46was.
- 1:17:47>> Do you pray?
- 1:17:48>> Uh meditate, which is Yeah. Very
- 1:17:51similar. Yeah.
- 1:17:52>> And how do you meditate?
- 1:17:54>> Well, uh lately not enough. Um but we
- 1:17:57have practices that are called pujas.
- 1:17:59They're kind of they're actually very
- 1:18:00similar to a Catholic mass. So, they're
- 1:18:02kind of guided uh visualizations with
- 1:18:04chanting and you just uh
- 1:18:06>> Do you listen to something or No,
- 1:18:08>> yes, I I do because I don't uh it's in
- 1:18:10Sanskrit and so I there's a text and
- 1:18:13then there's a a tape or a recording.
- 1:18:15>> And do you sing along or do you do it
- 1:18:16internally?
- 1:18:17>> I do out out loud.
- 1:18:19>> Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
- 1:18:20>> And is it melodic? Is it chanting? Uh,
- 1:18:22it's kind of melodic but and in uh kind
- 1:18:25of pentatonic, you know, it's like it's
- 1:18:27not it's not wildly melodic, but it's uh
- 1:18:30>> Yeah.
- 1:18:30>> Would you say it's hypnotic?
- 1:18:33>> Not really. No, no. I I don't know how
- 1:18:35actually, you know, I'm I had a friend
- 1:18:36who was a really serious practitioner.
- 1:18:38and he said, "Well, I would describe you
- 1:18:39as a fellow traveler." You know, so I'm
- 1:18:40a and I I talk too much about it and
- 1:18:42know too little, but for me, it seems
- 1:18:45like it's um
- 1:18:47uh it's really similar to the Catholic
- 1:18:49mass, which was a um
- 1:18:51>> as I experienced it, it was a
- 1:18:55you were imagining
- 1:18:57uh making offerings, you were imagining
- 1:18:59getting blessings. Yes. And somehow the
- 1:19:02effect of that when when I was doing it
- 1:19:04more was that a certain kind of ambient
- 1:19:08negative part of my mind that I thought
- 1:19:09was me would kind of just go quiet and
- 1:19:12then I oh look it there's something else
- 1:19:14there you know so it was a it was a like
- 1:19:16a deidentification process and then in
- 1:19:19the absence of that strong
- 1:19:21identification with self something else
- 1:19:23would come up that was you know very
- 1:19:25positive. If it wasn't for your time in
- 1:19:28the church, would you be a different
- 1:19:31person today?
- 1:19:31>> Oh, yes. Yes. Because I think that was
- 1:19:34the first time um I I think the
- 1:19:36sacraments and the it's the first time
- 1:19:38that you realize your everyday mind
- 1:19:40isn't the only
- 1:19:41>> Yeah.
- 1:19:42>> And so you go there every week to just
- 1:19:44get that reminder every week. And I had
- 1:19:46some
- 1:19:46>> It's like practice like any sitting
- 1:19:49practice. Same
- 1:19:49>> cuz it's funny how quickly you just go
- 1:19:51back to your old regular self. But then
- 1:19:53the ghost, you know, you you see that.
- 1:19:55Did you would you were you a spiritual
- 1:19:57young fellow? Were you
- 1:19:58>> I learned to meditate when I was 14.
- 1:20:00Wow.
- 1:20:00>> And I was always interested in
- 1:20:02metaphysical things before that, but I I
- 1:20:05didn't really know I didn't have a form
- 1:20:07to practice. And then when I learned to
- 1:20:09meditate, it it took over. And it was a
- 1:20:12real miracle that I got to learn because
- 1:20:13no one no one in my family did it. No
- 1:20:15one I knew did it. It just worked out.
- 1:20:18>> And what tradition are you would you
- 1:20:19>> I learned TM at that time.
- 1:20:21>> Yeah. It's amazing. I mean
- 1:20:22>> amazing. I just remember the first time
- 1:20:24I was out 40 and we had our kids and I
- 1:20:26did a I didn't want any I didn't have a
- 1:20:29technique but I was just trying to I was
- 1:20:30trying to make my thoughts stop. That
- 1:20:31was the goal.
- 1:20:32>> And um just that noticing that little
- 1:20:35split second between thought and speech
- 1:20:37suddenly just oh what a blessing when
- 1:20:39you have little kids you know you can
- 1:20:41have an urge to correct and go you know
- 1:20:43that that's incredible.
- 1:20:46>> Yeah. Or the need to say how you think
- 1:20:48it is.
- 1:20:49>> Yeah.
- 1:20:50>> Right.
- 1:20:51>> Who cares? you care and if you don't say
- 1:20:53it, the moment goes by and you
- 1:20:54>> Yeah. What's something that you don't
- 1:20:58believe now that you believed when you
- 1:20:59were younger? M so many well it's it's a
- 1:21:02it's kind of what we were just talking
- 1:21:04about the when I was younger uh came
- 1:21:07from Chicago kind of working class had a
- 1:21:09little macho periods and I think I was
- 1:21:11much more
- 1:21:13uh a believer that one did great things
- 1:21:18one must you asserted yourself by
- 1:21:22talking and acting and and that
- 1:21:25thankfully has has started to fade you
- 1:21:27know and one of the things about having
- 1:21:29a the public life is that that kind of
- 1:21:31gets that that delusion gets uh
- 1:21:35reinlivened. Sometimes you get a lot of
- 1:21:36attention. You're like, "Oh." But I I
- 1:21:38really like the fact that if I looked at
- 1:21:41myself at 18, I just wanted to be
- 1:21:44noticed and wanted to be great at
- 1:21:45something and I it was all me me. And
- 1:21:48thankfully it's kind of a little more
- 1:21:49like you can sort of watch the river go
- 1:21:51by and just the river still goes by and
- 1:21:54you don't have to
- 1:21:55>> um the river doesn't care that you're
- 1:21:57watching it, you know, or that you're
- 1:21:59talking about it. But so that so in
- 1:22:01writing it's interesting because then it
- 1:22:03purifies the activity
- 1:22:06to where maybe even 10 years ago I I I
- 1:22:08was on a kind of a
- 1:22:11a productivity. I wanted to write my
- 1:22:13great book and then now I'm kind of
- 1:22:16like, well, yeah, I do, but only to see
- 1:22:20if it can be done, you know, because
- 1:22:21it's that feeling of something secret
- 1:22:24then flowing out through process and
- 1:22:26being real. I love that. And whether
- 1:22:28it's credited or not or whether I did it
- 1:22:30or not, I don't care as much. I I I
- 1:22:32would actually like to just finish that
- 1:22:34one and do that do the next one. And
- 1:22:36>> tell me something you've changed your
- 1:22:38mind about recently.
- 1:22:42Well, it would have to do with
- 1:22:45uh we we have a dog at home who's sick
- 1:22:47and I can feel my
- 1:22:51sense of myself as being a flawless
- 1:22:54person or a flawless caregiver giving
- 1:22:57way and to like what it's hard you know
- 1:23:00she's old you're going to make mistakes
- 1:23:02you know and so that that I mean that's
- 1:23:04an ongoing thing but the but if on the
- 1:23:06good days I feel like I'm such a great
- 1:23:08owner such a loving compassionate person
- 1:23:10and then on the bad I'm like, "Ah,
- 1:23:11you're [ __ ] everything up."
- 1:23:13>> And I'm a little more comfortable with
- 1:23:14that flux now. Like, oh, yeah. So, so
- 1:23:16whoever you are,
- 1:23:18>> you're not exclusively either one of
- 1:23:19those two things.
- 1:23:21>> And uh and then noticing the way that my
- 1:23:24sort of day-to-day pleasure has to do
- 1:23:27with identifying with the first one
- 1:23:29>> and subduing the second one. And and so
- 1:23:31I'm trying I'm thinking I wonder what
- 1:23:32it'd be like if I really was really free
- 1:23:36of ego and really could say that guy's
- 1:23:38going through a hard time or that guy's
- 1:23:40doing a good job.
- 1:23:40>> Yeah.
- 1:23:41>> Instead of um
- 1:23:43>> you know denying the difficult
- 1:23:44veillances and I'm I'm not sure if that
- 1:23:46makes sense but that's so I've changed
- 1:23:48my mind about well one thinking of
- 1:23:50myself as someone who never never [ __ ]
- 1:23:52up but two with that that might be you
- 1:23:55know okay. Yeah. Yeah.
- 1:23:57>> In general would you say you're hard on
- 1:23:58yourself?
- 1:23:59>> Yes. Yeah.
- 1:24:00Except when I'm way too easy. But yeah,
- 1:24:03I think I'm I think I'm pretty hard on
- 1:24:04myself.
- 1:24:04>> And would you say you're equally hard on
- 1:24:06other people or No, it's only you. No.
- 1:24:08>> In fact, one of the things I sometimes
- 1:24:09will do if I get myself in a spiral is
- 1:24:11go, okay, if this was your friend,
- 1:24:13>> Yeah.
- 1:24:13>> What would you say? What would you say?
- 1:24:14You know,
- 1:24:15>> but I think you know I my students I
- 1:24:17talk about this that whatever
- 1:24:20manifest in yourself
- 1:24:23>> it's not I mean naturally we judge it
- 1:24:24but we can also use it. So, so for me
- 1:24:27like I'm very hard on myself which in
- 1:24:30editing is a great blessing.
- 1:24:31>> Yeah.
- 1:24:32>> I don't know h how I would do it
- 1:24:34otherwise. So that so in that arena I'm
- 1:24:37going to accept it. Let let me have it.
- 1:24:40>> Then when you get into some other area
- 1:24:43can you be a little bit easier and
- 1:24:45actually you can you know you can
- 1:24:47>> uh yeah
- 1:24:50let me ask you something. When you get
- 1:24:52up in the morning and you're thinking
- 1:24:53about work, what's the what's motivating
- 1:24:56you now at this point in your life?
- 1:24:58>> Just whatever is on the schedule for
- 1:25:00that day. I I don't think past
- 1:25:03>> it just would you describe yourself as
- 1:25:05ambitious still or ambitious ever or is
- 1:25:08that a word that doesn't
- 1:25:10>> uh I want to do good things. I feel like
- 1:25:13my to live up to my purpose, there's
- 1:25:16work to do.
- 1:25:16>> I love that.
- 1:25:17>> Yeah.
- 1:25:18>> Yeah. Yeah.
- 1:25:20And
- 1:25:20>> ambitious is not the word I would use
- 1:25:22though,
- 1:25:23>> right? I like that
- 1:25:23>> because ambitious somehow implies
- 1:25:26outcome and I don't think it's
- 1:25:30it's
- 1:25:31ambitious would be what am I going to do
- 1:25:34to make the outcome happen
- 1:25:36>> and that's not what it is.
- 1:25:37>> Right. When you look at a let's say a
- 1:25:39day a day in the studio or whatever
- 1:25:41you're doing.
- 1:25:41>> Yeah.
- 1:25:42>> What are the
- 1:25:45pleasures? What are the peak pleasures?
- 1:25:47>> Yeah. When nothing sounds good and then
- 1:25:50all of a sudden it comes together, it's
- 1:25:52the most exciting feeling.
- 1:25:54>> And you know that when it happens,
- 1:25:55>> feel it. Everybody feels it.
- 1:25:57>> Yeah. Everybody feels it.
- 1:25:58>> Yeah. It's very exciting feeling. It's
- 1:25:59like it's it's it's probably the reason
- 1:26:02to continue doing it. That the
- 1:26:06>> feeling of nothing's happening and then
- 1:26:10all of a sudden something's happening.
- 1:26:11That moment of spark of creation
- 1:26:14>> is so exciting.
- 1:26:16>> Yeah. Thrilling. It's like magic.
- 1:26:18>> Yeah. And you're having it with other
- 1:26:19people, which is beautiful.
- 1:26:20>> Not always. Sometimes I could be working
- 1:26:22on an idea myself, right?
- 1:26:24>> And it it just comes together,
- 1:26:26>> right? Right.
- 1:26:27>> But most often it's with other people.
- 1:26:29>> I call that the in the story. It's when
- 1:26:30this the the face comes out of the
- 1:26:32stone. It's just been some words and
- 1:26:34suddenly it's an actual pile.
- 1:26:36>> Is there So I'm I'm I keep coming back
- 1:26:39to this, but I mean Okay. So I can
- 1:26:40answer this question. What makes music
- 1:26:42good? And I can say presence,
- 1:26:45authenticity, blah blah. But is there a
- 1:26:47is there a stratum of descriptors above
- 1:26:50that?
- 1:26:50>> Authenticity is a big part of it because
- 1:26:53when you hear it,
- 1:26:54>> you hear the
- 1:26:57the artist's belief in what they're
- 1:26:59doing
- 1:26:59>> doesn't have to be true. What they're
- 1:27:01doing
- 1:27:02>> has nothing to do with truth.
- 1:27:04>> It has to do with
- 1:27:06their truth.
- 1:27:07>> Right? If someone is
- 1:27:10spilling their guts about something you
- 1:27:13don't agree with, it's still moving.
- 1:27:15It's still moving to us. It's that
- 1:27:17>> it's someone being human
- 1:27:20>> and sharing being human, what that feels
- 1:27:23like,
- 1:27:23>> right?
- 1:27:24>> And it it could be good or bad.
- 1:27:26>> Okay. So, David Foster Wallace used to
- 1:27:28talk about um uh he said with young
- 1:27:32writers, there's there's some people who
- 1:27:34think if they're feeling it while
- 1:27:35they're writing it, it's good writing.
- 1:27:37And then the more advanced ideas, well,
- 1:27:40you could use that feeling, but it has
- 1:27:41to convey feeling to the to the reader.
- 1:27:44In other words, if if I just feel like
- 1:27:46I'm in a I'm stoned and I'm typing,
- 1:27:48>> doesn't necessarily communicate to you.
- 1:27:51So, if let's say that somebody's playing
- 1:27:53a guitar solo,
- 1:27:54>> they are they
- 1:27:59I mean, presumably they could be
- 1:28:01thinking about something totally
- 1:28:03different
- 1:28:04>> and yet authenticity is still there.
- 1:28:06Yes.
- 1:28:07>> So, I mean, again, I know there's not an
- 1:28:09answer, but I think about like that uh
- 1:28:11that solo and reeling in the years, you
- 1:28:13know, that that thing
- 1:28:14>> I have to I have to get to the solo if
- 1:28:16if I sing really in the years.
- 1:28:18>> Uh yeah. Oh,
- 1:28:24>> right. But so, I mean, the person who's
- 1:28:26playing that, they I mean theoretically
- 1:28:29they don't even in in what way is that
- 1:28:31authentic?
- 1:28:31>> Well, that doesn't sound like a
- 1:28:33spontaneous moment to me. It might be,
- 1:28:36but it doesn't sound like spontaneous
- 1:28:37authenticity, like a blues solo,
- 1:28:40>> right?
- 1:28:41>> It sounds more like a crafted
- 1:28:46like a like a piece of orchestral music
- 1:28:49that's being performed well.
- 1:28:50>> Right.
- 1:28:51>> That's what it sounds like to me. I
- 1:28:52don't know if that's true,
- 1:28:52>> but but I mean in a solo that that I
- 1:28:56guess I'm trying to like I understand I
- 1:28:58can understand the songwriter emoting
- 1:29:00authentically and being in the moment,
- 1:29:02but say for uh a mix or for an
- 1:29:05instrumentalist,
- 1:29:09why was one solo sell and the other one
- 1:29:12doesn't or sell or move you?
- 1:29:15>> Um
- 1:29:15>> I know it's kind of you know when you
- 1:29:17see it, but
- 1:29:17>> yeah, I don't think it's an answerable
- 1:29:19question. That said, I now think, and
- 1:29:23this is a new thought, it might have
- 1:29:25more to do with rhythm than anything
- 1:29:26else.
- 1:29:28>> There was a time I would have thought,
- 1:29:29well, it could be the melody, could be
- 1:29:31the tone, could be uh the context.
- 1:29:35>> I'm feeling more and more
- 1:29:39the internal rhythmic
- 1:29:44field
- 1:29:45>> is maybe the most important thing of
- 1:29:47anything. Now, that's Does that have a
- 1:29:49relation to presence?
- 1:29:51>> Because, in other words, if I'm kind of
- 1:29:52a
- 1:29:54>> uh
- 1:29:54>> I don't know. I don't know if it does.
- 1:29:56Maybe something else. Presence is
- 1:29:59>> another one of the things that you when
- 1:30:02you feel it, you know it.
- 1:30:04>> It's hard to say what it is.
- 1:30:06>> Yeah.
- 1:30:06>> But you can feel it.
- 1:30:08>> It's It's almost like I would describe
- 1:30:10presence as someone
- 1:30:12truly inhabiting whatever the thing is,
- 1:30:15right?
- 1:30:18almost as if who they are is no longer
- 1:30:20around
- 1:30:22>> and just this thing is appearing. I
- 1:30:25would call presence like uh God steps
- 1:30:27in.
- 1:30:28>> Yeah. So that has nothing to do
- 1:30:30necessarily with the meaning of the
- 1:30:31song. It just has to the moment of it.
- 1:30:33>> Yeah.
- 1:30:33>> Yeah. No, that's beautiful. I love that.
- 1:30:35God steps in.
- 1:30:37>> And but I but like in writing terms
- 1:30:39there there is a correlary because if if
- 1:30:41I'm present then you know that moment we
- 1:30:43talked about where the trains come in
- 1:30:44together. If I'm on the track going,
- 1:30:46"No, no, no." So, you know, even a
- 1:30:48little bit, it it impacts the the
- 1:30:50feeling, which I wonder if that has
- 1:30:51something to do with this rhythmic idea.
- 1:30:52Like, if somebody is fully
- 1:30:54>> if someone's thinking about it, it won't
- 1:30:56be good,
- 1:30:56>> right?
- 1:30:57>> It can't be.
- 1:30:58>> Right.
- 1:30:58>> The the best version is they're gone.
- 1:31:01>> Yeah.
- 1:31:01>> And then only when they get to hear it
- 1:31:04back do they understand what happened.
- 1:31:07>> But so,
- 1:31:09>> transcendent experience.
- 1:31:10>> Yes.
- 1:31:12But see for me that it's interesting the
- 1:31:14transcendent I when I if I would have
- 1:31:16heard that a few years ago I would have
- 1:31:18thought oh you're just like in some
- 1:31:19crazy mystical state but in writing it's
- 1:31:21not at all. It's just you just step out
- 1:31:24of the room and for a second and then
- 1:31:25you're you're back you know.
- 1:31:26>> Yeah.
- 1:31:27>> That's interesting.
- 1:31:29>> But you know you're not in control of it
- 1:31:32happening.
- 1:31:33You can certainly get in the way of it
- 1:31:35happening but you can't make it happen.
- 1:31:38>> Right. Right.
- 1:31:38>> You just have to wait.
- 1:31:39>> Yeah. Yeah,
- 1:31:41>> it won't happen if you're not
- 1:31:43participating,
- 1:31:44>> right?
- 1:31:45>> You can't just think it'll happen
- 1:31:47sometime, go out and live your life and
- 1:31:50think it'll happen.
- 1:31:51>> You have to show up.
- 1:31:53>> Yes.
- 1:31:53>> But you can't make it happen.
- 1:31:55>> And in writing, that's right. And in
- 1:31:56writing, one of the ways you you make it
- 1:31:58happen is to be a little conceptual.
- 1:31:59You're kind of going, "Oh, this is a
- 1:32:01story about patriarchy." And then at
- 1:32:02some point, your mind goes,
- 1:32:04>> "Step back. I got Yeah. It's
- 1:32:06incredible." How about for you? What is
- 1:32:08What does And I'm going through this
- 1:32:09right now. What is the process of well
- 1:32:12is this is this a thing to um
- 1:32:17kind of like widen the shoulders of your
- 1:32:19craft? Like for me I it's always a
- 1:32:22pressure like okay the next book I
- 1:32:23wonder if there's a way I can I think of
- 1:32:26it like broaden it should get more into
- 1:32:28it. Is that something you think about at
- 1:32:30all consciously or is it in
- 1:32:32>> I think if I were to think about that it
- 1:32:33would get in the way. I think it's more
- 1:32:37the thing that's going to make me lean
- 1:32:39forward is not the same thing that made
- 1:32:41me lean forward before. It can't.
- 1:32:43>> We've done that,
- 1:32:44>> right?
- 1:32:45>> So that that
- 1:32:48there has to be something
- 1:32:51I want to say novel about it, I think,
- 1:32:55>> or it has to be an extremely good
- 1:32:58version of something that you've
- 1:33:00experienced before and maybe that would
- 1:33:02be okay.
- 1:33:02>> Yeah. Yeah. I also have a feeling
- 1:33:04sometimes if you you if you immerse
- 1:33:06yourself in this project what that means
- 1:33:09is you're you're accepting an aesthetic
- 1:33:11model for a few years.
- 1:33:12>> Yes.
- 1:33:13>> And then when you're done you're like ah
- 1:33:14god let me away from that one you know
- 1:33:16like a kind of
- 1:33:17>> maybe it's like yes and then you start
- 1:33:20writing and the very best thing that
- 1:33:22comes out is just like the last one
- 1:33:24>> it's not up to you.
- 1:33:25>> Right. Right. I mean, you can have a
- 1:33:27desire
- 1:33:29>> and you can set an intention, but it but
- 1:33:32what happens is not in our control.
- 1:33:34>> Yeah. Yeah.
- 1:33:34>> And if it's good, whatever's good,
- 1:33:37follow it.
- 1:33:38>> Yeah. Yeah. That's it.
- 1:33:41>> I think anything we think about what
- 1:33:43it's supposed to be undermines it,
- 1:33:45>> right? Could and would and or or could
- 1:33:47and should. Those are the words that are
- 1:33:49Yeah. Yeah. It's so hard. It's it's it's
- 1:33:52it's
- 1:33:53I think that's where it kind of it kind
- 1:33:55of brushes up against the meditative
- 1:33:57because in a given writing
- 1:33:59hour.
- 1:34:00>> Yeah.
- 1:34:01>> You're doing all the things wrong and
- 1:34:02all the things right. And it's kind of
- 1:34:04uh
- 1:34:05I I can I can be working and just
- 1:34:07literally be gone, do something and go,
- 1:34:10"Ooh, the New Yorker is going to love
- 1:34:12that. I'm back." So,
- 1:34:15>> do you write for one hour is that you
- 1:34:17>> No, I write for whatever I What's your
- 1:34:18what's your schedule or rhythm?
- 1:34:20>> It's kind of loose. I I mean on a
- 1:34:22perfect day I would just get up and walk
- 1:34:25the dog and then come up and just spend
- 1:34:26five or six hours. But I there's kind of
- 1:34:28a inner rhythm like if uh I can feel
- 1:34:32after. Okay. So the the thing is I have
- 1:34:35a hard copy marking it up and then put
- 1:34:39it in once, read it again and do that
- 1:34:41about three times and then at some point
- 1:34:43I start to make mistakes. I can tell I'm
- 1:34:46just not the sharpness isn't there. this
- 1:34:48quick, but it I can go easily four or
- 1:34:49five hours.
- 1:34:50>> But when you say you put it in, is it
- 1:34:54a page, a finished work?
- 1:34:57>> It if it's a story, I I'll read it from
- 1:34:59the beginning and the marks get heavier
- 1:35:01towards the end because it's messy. And
- 1:35:03then I'll I'll uh get through the whole
- 1:35:05say eight pages, read the whole thing,
- 1:35:06then start putting them in manually. And
- 1:35:08then at some point where where the river
- 1:35:10is a little wider, I'll start just free.
- 1:35:12>> That makes it sound like every time you
- 1:35:13sit down to work, it's on a finished
- 1:35:15piece. It's or it's on a nearly finished
- 1:35:17piece.
- 1:35:18>> It's it's on whatever I have at hand.
- 1:35:20Yeah. Yeah. But mostly I mean Yeah.
- 1:35:22Sometimes it's just two pages and then
- 1:35:23that will happen. But uh then I put it
- 1:35:25in manually and I don't want to read it
- 1:35:28on the screen. Just read it on the page.
- 1:35:29>> Do you ever when you're not working have
- 1:35:32an idea and make a note?
- 1:35:33>> Yes.
- 1:35:34>> Right.
- 1:35:35>> How often?
- 1:35:36>> Uh not too often. And because what I've
- 1:35:38it's a little like I uh when I was
- 1:35:41younger, I'd always be thinking about it
- 1:35:43and then have an idea, which is
- 1:35:44different than if the idea just comes, I
- 1:35:46find. Yes.
- 1:35:47>> So I don't try I don't I tend to just if
- 1:35:48an idea comes to me out of nowhere,
- 1:35:51>> there'll be a split-second reaction like
- 1:35:53oh yeah,
- 1:35:54>> then I'll do it. But there's a slight
- 1:35:55degradation of that which is a little
- 1:35:57more of a know-it-all feeling like
- 1:35:58here's what you should do, you know? And
- 1:36:00if that comes to me, I know it's not
- 1:36:02going to work because it's, you know,
- 1:36:03it's almost like I think certain ideas
- 1:36:05come uh purely out of the subconscious
- 1:36:10and they don't
- 1:36:12>> then when you go to put in it just folds
- 1:36:13in perfectly and others are like put me
- 1:36:15in, put me in and you it doesn't the
- 1:36:17surface doesn't want it in there, you
- 1:36:19know? So I kind of learned a little bit
- 1:36:20to be really skeptical. Same with
- 1:36:22dreams. Like most dreams aren't stories
- 1:36:24but
- 1:36:24>> do you write your dreams?
- 1:36:25>> No. Unless it's a good one.
- 1:36:27>> Yeah. But I had the thing one after that
- 1:36:29Lincoln and the Bartau came out. I just
- 1:36:31had a tour and I was so happy but also a
- 1:36:34little bit anxious about the next thing.
- 1:36:36And I had a dream and in the dream I
- 1:36:38could see the second book. It was just
- 1:36:40huge book and everything. And I woke up
- 1:36:43and I should write this down. No, I'll
- 1:36:45just write down the title. That'll be
- 1:36:46enough. And the title was Kuster in the
- 1:36:48Bardo.
- 1:36:51That didn't work out. But yeah. Do you
- 1:36:54dream Do you ever do you dream music? Do
- 1:36:56you do you dream? No. No,
- 1:36:57>> no.
- 1:36:59>> And um I I rarely remember the dreams
- 1:37:03unless I'm in the practice of
- 1:37:04remembering them. If I if I I've done
- 1:37:06that where I'll keep a dream journal and
- 1:37:08write down the dreams every day and it's
- 1:37:10fascinating, interesting, and I only
- 1:37:12came to understand what they meant years
- 1:37:14later.
- 1:37:15>> You know, the writer Gino Diaz, he he's
- 1:37:17really good and he had a first book of
- 1:37:19stories that was really beautiful and he
- 1:37:21had a dream one night of of the eight
- 1:37:23stories in the book and they were all
- 1:37:24colorcoded. different sections were
- 1:37:26color gold and he understood that I
- 1:37:28don't remember like all the purple stuff
- 1:37:30could be cut
- 1:37:32>> and he went in and took it off. Yeah.
- 1:37:34That was like really bad stuff.
- 1:37:36>> Does your knowledge of past writers
- 1:37:38shape your work?
- 1:37:40>> Yes.
- 1:37:41>> How
- 1:37:42>> uh
- 1:37:44probably well these days just it's like
- 1:37:47I read Google
- 1:37:49and I think oh god I love this about
- 1:37:52that. Let's try to get in that party a
- 1:37:55little bit. Just just like that. Just
- 1:37:56almost like they're up on this high
- 1:37:59level. And
- 1:38:00>> you say inspired by
- 1:38:02>> Yeah. Or per, you know, I think a lot
- 1:38:03about permission giving. Like I read
- 1:38:05Google and his [ __ ] is so crazy really,
- 1:38:07you know, and it just makes me think,
- 1:38:09okay, so that you can you can do that.
- 1:38:12You can you can go there. But I honestly
- 1:38:15the last couple years I'm kind of like I
- 1:38:17I read them just to be kind of reminded
- 1:38:20that greatness exists and go okay I
- 1:38:22can't go there in that flavor but I can
- 1:38:25go there in my flavor so let's I hope I
- 1:38:27can you know just like that.
- 1:38:29>> Do you do you are you somebody do you
- 1:38:31ever do you have um certain works that
- 1:38:32you go back to and listen to for
- 1:38:35>> No. Yeah.
- 1:38:37>> Rarely.
- 1:38:38>> Yeah.
- 1:38:38>> Rarely unless there's a reason like
- 1:38:40there would have to be a specific
- 1:38:41reason.
- 1:38:42>> Yeah. If we're working on something and
- 1:38:44it reminds me of something from the past
- 1:38:47and like there's a reference that might
- 1:38:49be helpful for what we're doing, that'd
- 1:38:50be the only time I would do it.
- 1:38:51>> Yeah. Well, sometimes there's that Isaac
- 1:38:53Babble I mentioned earlier, he's an
- 1:38:54incredible writer and some I'll read him
- 1:38:56just to go because because I it's easy
- 1:38:58for me to think uh writing is meaning,
- 1:39:02but he's the reminder that writing is
- 1:39:03sound. So if I read him even in English
- 1:39:05translation, I go, "Oh, yeah, that's
- 1:39:08sound is not." Regarding Toltoy, you
- 1:39:10said uh after a series of fact
- 1:39:14statements,
- 1:39:15simple opinion stated in the same way
- 1:39:18has more credibility.
- 1:39:20>> Is that a a
- 1:39:24>> is that a usable trick or is it just
- 1:39:26something you noticed in the writing?
- 1:39:28>> I I think it's true because if Okay, so
- 1:39:30in fiction, you know that I'm making it
- 1:39:32up.
- 1:39:32>> Yeah.
- 1:39:33>> And so if I say something really high
- 1:39:36concept and personal, you're going to
- 1:39:37go, "Oh, maybe." But that's your
- 1:39:39opinion. But if I describe this the
- 1:39:41light on the table very well and for you
- 1:39:43to see it not and I describe three three
- 1:39:45or four other things that are very
- 1:39:46familiar to you, then you're kind of
- 1:39:48sitting over here with me. And if I then
- 1:39:50say, you know, blah blah blah.
- 1:39:52>> Yeah.
- 1:39:53>> You know, but also also he he would be
- 1:39:55incredibly objective about even
- 1:39:57psychological states. So you couldn't
- 1:39:59quite you know, he was so good at it
- 1:40:01that that it it landed in the same
- 1:40:03register as a description of a horse. So
- 1:40:05you you know and but and even when he
- 1:40:08>> would kind of cross over into opinion he
- 1:40:11does it in the same syntactical thing.
- 1:40:13So it's a little tricky. He can he can
- 1:40:14fool you a little bit with that you
- 1:40:15know.
- 1:40:16>> And do you think he knew what he was
- 1:40:17doing or No.
- 1:40:19>> I think he had I think he was a person
- 1:40:20with a lot of authority a lot of of
- 1:40:22confidence. So whatever he said he said
- 1:40:25it in a simple objective sentence
- 1:40:27because he knew it was true including
- 1:40:29God and everything. I think he and when
- 1:40:31you read descriptions of him, people
- 1:40:32really were like taken by his charisma
- 1:40:34and his his certainty. So I think I
- 1:40:37think he but but the thing about him
- 1:40:39that's amazing is he can do that
- 1:40:43in one character and then he can run
- 1:40:46around to the other side of the table
- 1:40:47and do it from another character's point
- 1:40:49of view too. And they both sound equally
- 1:40:50certain and equally real. So I think
- 1:40:52that's what makes him so amazing is he's
- 1:40:53not he's God. He's he's he's God going
- 1:40:56into your head
- 1:40:57>> and accepting everything he finds and
- 1:40:59describing it in these
- 1:41:00>> pre precise sentences. Then he comes
- 1:41:03over here in mine. He does the same
- 1:41:04thing and then he just lets it sit
- 1:41:06there, you know, and you're kind of
- 1:41:07like, "What's true?" And he said, "I'm
- 1:41:09God. It's all it's all true."
- 1:41:11>> On some level, would you say you're all
- 1:41:14of the characters in your stories?
- 1:41:16>> Yeah. Because otherwise, I mean, where
- 1:41:18do you where would they
- 1:41:20you could understand the story? It's
- 1:41:22just you an argument
- 1:41:24uh objectified. You know, you you have a
- 1:41:27a story that takes up this topic and you
- 1:41:29let a bunch of people opine on it, but
- 1:41:31they're all coming from from you. And I
- 1:41:33what I'm starting to think now is that
- 1:41:35the highest level of that craft is like
- 1:41:38I just described to let all those voices
- 1:41:40come out, calibrate the arguments so all
- 1:41:42of them are substantial and then just
- 1:41:45let that you know instead of like when
- 1:41:48you're younger you want to put your
- 1:41:49finger on the scale and say this is my
- 1:41:51belief.
- 1:41:52>> Yeah.
- 1:41:52>> But the check off in that book at
- 1:41:54Gooseberry he just is happiness is good
- 1:41:56or bad?
- 1:41:57>> Yeah. you know that that's
- 1:42:00>> you have to believe what you're writing.
- 1:42:04>> You have to believe
- 1:42:07in it from the point of view of the
- 1:42:09person who's saying it. I think you know
- 1:42:10that
- 1:42:11>> they have to believe it.
- 1:42:12>> They have to believe and and and you
- 1:42:13have to really get on their team.
- 1:42:16>> Yeah.
- 1:42:16>> And let them believe it and articulate
- 1:42:18it in in a way that's genuine to them
- 1:42:21that and that's
- 1:42:24and that's I mean it's tricky because
- 1:42:26it's it's stage craft. I mean, if I'm if
- 1:42:28I'm trying to be a Trump supporter, I
- 1:42:31can get pretty far there, but but then
- 1:42:33there's a little bit of mystery and I
- 1:42:35and I and so at that point, you can make
- 1:42:37some mistakes. You can make somebody
- 1:42:40more sympathetic than they should be.
- 1:42:42You can make them less sympathetic. You
- 1:42:44can give them a reason that isn't
- 1:42:46authentic. So, it's it's tricky work,
- 1:42:48you know, that inhabiting other people.
- 1:42:49But I think in in to go back to the
- 1:42:51Charlie Brown thing, I mean,
- 1:42:53>> if if I put six people around the table,
- 1:42:55none of them are real. They're all
- 1:42:56emanations of me. And what we're doing
- 1:42:58is not trying to make it a catalog of
- 1:43:00real people. We're trying to get some
- 1:43:02energy going, you know? That's
- 1:43:04>> I think sometimes a story is like a like
- 1:43:05a a board and it it controls light, you
- 1:43:09know? So, you're just adjusting the
- 1:43:10things to make the most light come off
- 1:43:12of the work of art.
- 1:43:13>> Yeah.
- 1:43:13>> What does it mean? I don't know. But
- 1:43:14that's the brightest I can make it, you
- 1:43:16know, like that.
- 1:43:17>> Have you ever written anything and come
- 1:43:19to realize it means something different
- 1:43:20than you thought it meant?
- 1:43:22That's the actually the goal I think you
- 1:43:24know or or maybe to find out there were
- 1:43:26overtones that you didn't know were
- 1:43:27gonna come out you know and
- 1:43:29>> if you write something and everyone who
- 1:43:31reads it thinks it means the same thing
- 1:43:33have you succeeded or failed?
- 1:43:37>> Uh you know Christmas Carol everybody
- 1:43:39knows what that means and they're right
- 1:43:42you know so I think it can go either
- 1:43:44way. Uh I'm I in my personal thing, I'm
- 1:43:47trying to get more where there's less
- 1:43:49agreement because my story sometimes
- 1:43:51will be you know where you stand, you
- 1:43:54know where I stand, we all and it
- 1:43:56happens, you know. Uh and this new book
- 1:43:58I just wrote, it's I'm it's interesting.
- 1:44:00It's it's giving off complicated light,
- 1:44:02which I was happy about, you know.
- 1:44:04>> Yeah, that sounds more honest like pink.
- 1:44:07>> Yeah,
- 1:44:08>> life's complicated.
- 1:44:08>> It's like said you work of art doesn't
- 1:44:11have to solve a problem. It just has to
- 1:44:13formulate it correctly.
- 1:44:14>> Yeah. Is it is there when you when you
- 1:44:16finish a piece, do you know where the
- 1:44:18pops are? Like if in in six minute
- 1:44:21piece, do you know where the reader's
- 1:44:24going to or the listener's going to go?
- 1:44:26>> Yeah. I don't know. I just know where I
- 1:44:29feel it and I assume they'll feel it in
- 1:44:30the same places. But but I don't if they
- 1:44:33don't or if they feel it somewhere else,
- 1:44:36>> nobody's wrong, you know? Just is what
- 1:44:38it is.
- 1:44:39>> Yeah.
- 1:44:39>> The only thing I have to go on is how I
- 1:44:41feel. Yeah, that's my only metric,
- 1:44:43>> right? Yeah. But what I've I think I
- 1:44:46believe this is that if I So if I'm
- 1:44:49reading my work or reading your work,
- 1:44:50anybody's
- 1:44:52>> uh and I respond on let's say it's I'm
- 1:44:55writing I'm revising my own piece. I
- 1:44:57read something happens on page five
- 1:45:00>> when I I kind of assume that you're
- 1:45:02going to feel that too. And that's part
- 1:45:04of that that communication thing like if
- 1:45:06I if my heart rolls at this place I
- 1:45:09think my imaginary reader's heart is
- 1:45:11going to write rise at that place.
- 1:45:12>> Yeah.
- 1:45:13>> Uh that that's the contract I think that
- 1:45:16I have to I have to have that idea. But
- 1:45:18in practice it's just watching myself
- 1:45:20you know. Yeah. Yeah.
- 1:45:22>> You can't know.
- 1:45:23>> You can't.
- 1:45:24>> What do you think it was about Khalil
- 1:45:25Jabbr that spoke to you when you were
- 1:45:26younger? H
- 1:45:30>> well I think at that age I had a real
- 1:45:31desire to know something that nobody
- 1:45:33else knew
- 1:45:34>> and he seemed to know that he seemed to
- 1:45:36be that guy you know and also the my
- 1:45:38friends wouldn't have liked him so there
- 1:45:40was a little bit of elitism
- 1:45:41>> it felt more like it was yours
- 1:45:43>> that didn't really but I just felt like
- 1:45:45he was I I like that he was seem to be
- 1:45:47speaking about something that wasn't
- 1:45:49just quotidian he was uh
- 1:45:51>> and I I at that age I really was a kid
- 1:45:54who wanted wisdom I wanted I was looking
- 1:45:57around So like uh Zen the art of
- 1:45:59motorcycle maintenance and then later a
- 1:46:01rand you know that was big for me. So I
- 1:46:03wanted I I thought that the purpose of
- 1:46:05literature was to tell you how to live
- 1:46:07>> and Louis Brown seemed to be to be doing
- 1:46:10that you know and um but I didn't but I
- 1:46:12hadn't really um I hadn't developed any
- 1:46:15ability to see what things felt like to
- 1:46:17me and then gauge at work by that. It
- 1:46:21was all just, well, that sounds really
- 1:46:23big, you know, big. And and if I if I am
- 1:46:25a Cleo Gabbronite,
- 1:46:28nobody can touch me because I know more
- 1:46:29than everyone else, you know, that kind
- 1:46:31of thing.
- 1:46:31>> Funny you say that cuz um I made a note
- 1:46:34in your teaching. There's a great deal
- 1:46:35of wisdom. I use the word specifically.
- 1:46:38It's bigger than information. Where do
- 1:46:40you think the wisdom you hold comes
- 1:46:42from?
- 1:46:43>> It's there. I'm telling you, it's there
- 1:46:45as I'm reading it.
- 1:46:46>> I'll accept it. I I think I think it
- 1:46:48comes from a kind of um
- 1:46:52uh trial and error. So
- 1:46:56um to to have read as many stories I've
- 1:46:59read, especially student stories, and go
- 1:47:01okay, take take your knowing mind down a
- 1:47:04notch and just listen, see what's
- 1:47:05actually happening there. Uh okay. And
- 1:47:09after 20 30 years of that, you you do
- 1:47:12kind of know some things.
- 1:47:14So I think I think to offer
- 1:47:17information conditionally is kind of
- 1:47:19like wisdom, you know. So if I say that
- 1:47:22that's that sentence is no good, that's
- 1:47:25too certain. If I say I it feels to me
- 1:47:28as if that sentence goes hazy at the
- 1:47:30end, more like wisdom because I'm not
- 1:47:32sure. You know that
- 1:47:33>> I feel like I'm talking more about the
- 1:47:35actual content, not the writing.
- 1:47:38>> The Russian book as an example. Well,
- 1:47:41that that that has to do with with 20
- 1:47:43years of teaching those stories because
- 1:47:46you can have a a class in 1992 that goes
- 1:47:49off the rails and is no good. 1994 you
- 1:47:52correct it and you know and then you
- 1:47:54start noticing that every time you talk
- 1:47:55about that story, these are the issues
- 1:47:56that come up.
- 1:47:57>> Yeah.
- 1:47:58>> So, you honor that and and think and
- 1:48:00then um Yeah. So, it's it's anticipatory
- 1:48:03I think a little bit. you I know that
- 1:48:05I've had you know eight groups of really
- 1:48:08brilliant kids have read that Tanya
- 1:48:09story and gone god you know so then part
- 1:48:12of your approach is say I know what you
- 1:48:14think you think it's boring and then so
- 1:48:16maybe that feels like wisdom of some
- 1:48:17kind but
- 1:48:19>> but I mean I'm sure you know for you
- 1:48:21like you
- 1:48:22>> you must have understanding of this
- 1:48:25stuff that is
- 1:48:26>> yeah I have understanding I don't know
- 1:48:27where it comes from but I I feel it
- 1:48:30>> yeah yeah I think I think for me it's
- 1:48:32it's a bit of Um, it's it's okay. So, it
- 1:48:36is it's repetition, but it's also
- 1:48:38trusting.
- 1:48:40It sounds weird, but it's trusting other
- 1:48:42people. So, I've had all those
- 1:48:43generations of students.
- 1:48:45>> Yeah.
- 1:48:45>> They come in, they come in, they come
- 1:48:47in, they react um, authentically to
- 1:48:50these pieces.
- 1:48:52And so, there's a crossover there. If
- 1:48:54you're a bad teacher, you go, "Well,
- 1:48:55these students reacted correctly and
- 1:48:57these reacted incorrectly." And I only
- 1:48:59want to talk about the ones who react.
- 1:49:01If you're a good teacher, you go, "Huh,
- 1:49:02there's a range of reactions." Yeah.
- 1:49:04>> Okay,
- 1:49:05>> let's lean into that. And then and then
- 1:49:07with with years, you you start to see
- 1:49:09that that's a reliable
- 1:49:11>> thing and it has something to do with
- 1:49:14that story.
- 1:49:15>> Yeah.
- 1:49:15>> And then you can track that down. So, I
- 1:49:17think it's it's
- 1:49:18>> I mean, I'm glad you feel that way. I
- 1:49:20don't I don't I don't feel particularly
- 1:49:21wise, but I do know I used to feel wiser
- 1:49:24and I used to be much more free with my
- 1:49:26wisdom.
- 1:49:26>> I think now you're getting wiser.
- 1:49:27>> Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I'm saying
- 1:49:30>> because you get to see these really
- 1:49:33brilliant young writers year after year.
- 1:49:37Would you say there's some part of it
- 1:49:39that they're mostly good at and some
- 1:49:42part of it that they're mostly not good
- 1:49:44at or is it always case by case? Any
- 1:49:47trends?
- 1:49:48>> Yeah.
- 1:49:49>> In new writers?
- 1:49:51>> Not not that I can discern, but there's
- 1:49:52a trend in all writers. Yes. which is
- 1:49:56we we all think we don't know the secret
- 1:49:59and we're faking it and all our writing
- 1:50:02lives we've been faking it better than
- 1:50:03most but we are faking it because of
- 1:50:06that we're avoiding certain things
- 1:50:07whether it's content or or voice or
- 1:50:10something we're avoiding something so
- 1:50:12for me the job is to just say the minute
- 1:50:14the student comes in I don't say it but
- 1:50:16I know you you think you're not good
- 1:50:19enough
- 1:50:20>> now let's find out what flavor you think
- 1:50:21you're not good enough and then I'm
- 1:50:23going to do some judo and I'm going to
- 1:50:25show you that the thing you aren't good
- 1:50:27at is actually a unity with the thing
- 1:50:29you're good at and the only problem is
- 1:50:31you're denying so energetically the
- 1:50:34thing you're not good enough that you're
- 1:50:36you're stifling yourself. So so to kind
- 1:50:39of say um I mean practically what that
- 1:50:42means is I I'm quiet long enough for you
- 1:50:45to tell me what's bothering you about
- 1:50:46your story and then I say oh yeah that
- 1:50:49makes sense. That's that's I think
- 1:50:50everybody has that kind of fear. Yeah.
- 1:50:52>> Uh, what are some things you might
- 1:50:54>> No, you're describing a psychological
- 1:50:56state and I I was guessing you were
- 1:50:59going to talk about something technical
- 1:51:00about writing. That's interesting. Is Is
- 1:51:03there anything on the
- 1:51:06not on the
- 1:51:08how they're thinking about what they're
- 1:51:10doing, but what they're actually doing,
- 1:51:12what's on the page.
- 1:51:13>> Yes. I mean, well, sometimes there's
- 1:51:15there's first order imitation. They're
- 1:51:16imitating somebody and you can see it.
- 1:51:18uh they're um avoiding like we talked
- 1:51:22about earlier sometimes they're they're
- 1:51:24the story wants to go here but for some
- 1:51:26reason usually it's an intellectual
- 1:51:27reason they don't want to go for it
- 1:51:29somewhere else
- 1:51:29>> yeah so that so so sometime and also
- 1:51:31what I find with my students is
- 1:51:33sometimes they
- 1:51:34>> they are really afraid of being corny
- 1:51:38and so at a moment which is actually
- 1:51:42going to be an emotional moment they're
- 1:51:44afraid of being schmaltzy and so they
- 1:51:45take it off into some other so as an
- 1:51:48older person, you can kind of go, "Well,
- 1:51:49I love that moment. That was so moving."
- 1:51:52And then I think you kind of got
- 1:51:53distracted from it. And they'll go,
- 1:51:54"Yeah, yeah." So, so it's almost like
- 1:51:57maybe the wisdom has to do with seeing
- 1:51:59that pattern over and over again.
- 1:52:01Someone who has come to literature
- 1:52:02because it's has all the stuff in it,
- 1:52:04all the feelings, but they they're a
- 1:52:06little afraid of being sentimental, so
- 1:52:08they veer away from that. And you just
- 1:52:10gently saying, "Oh, no, actually that's
- 1:52:11that's what we do." You know, I would
- 1:52:13say I can see
- 1:52:15>> somebody before they do a little bit.
- 1:52:17Yeah.
- 1:52:18>> And go, "Oh, okay. I I get this." And
- 1:52:19then then you can skillfully I'm sure I
- 1:52:22mean it sounds like exactly what you're
- 1:52:23telling earlier. You can skillfully move
- 1:52:25it to the point where they can discover
- 1:52:26it for themselves and then you bless it.
- 1:52:28And yeah, it always has a technical
- 1:52:30tell. You know, the the story goes off
- 1:52:32track or the language falls apart or
- 1:52:34your interest just kind of goes, I
- 1:52:36thought we were talking about this and
- 1:52:37now you're talking about that for eight
- 1:52:38pages. Uh but that but there's always
- 1:52:41something psychological under that. Um
- 1:52:43but but I think what it has to do is
- 1:52:45having confidence. That that's what it
- 1:52:47is.
- 1:52:49In the old days, I think I felt students
- 1:52:51didn't know what didn't know how to be
- 1:52:55emotionally in touch and I had to tell
- 1:52:57them how to do it. And now I'm just like
- 1:52:59of course they know how to do that. They
- 1:53:01just haven't brought it into this realm
- 1:53:02yet.
- 1:53:03>> Yeah.
- 1:53:04>> So the confidence that you I know that
- 1:53:06you're a fully emotionally formed person
- 1:53:09now. Your art is impeding you a little
- 1:53:10bit, but that's okay. That's normal. you
- 1:53:12know that then that I think they feel
- 1:53:14that confidence that you know of course
- 1:53:16you can get there you know
- 1:53:17>> would you say you're sometimes you have
- 1:53:20the confidence for them that they don't
- 1:53:21have for themselves
- 1:53:23>> I think so and and sometimes I even will
- 1:53:25be a little overconfident just so they
- 1:53:26can just to lure them out a little bit
- 1:53:28yeah that
- 1:53:29>> I think we share that that's part of the
- 1:53:32>> right
- 1:53:32>> part of the process part of the
- 1:53:34mentoring really
- 1:53:35>> I think so because I know from my own
- 1:53:37experience if I like if I um this is so
- 1:53:39sort of pathetic but if I go on tour and
- 1:53:41I get a bad review, I'm flinchy. If I go
- 1:53:44on tour, I get a good review, I'm
- 1:53:45confident, you know. So,
- 1:53:46>> what is on tour?
- 1:53:48>> It just it means like book tour, you
- 1:53:49know, on book tour. So,
- 1:53:50>> and what does that look like?
- 1:53:52>> It looks like in this case it looks uh
- 1:53:54kind of like
- 1:53:55>> the last one you did.
- 1:53:56>> Yeah, 18 days. 18 cities in 20 days just
- 1:53:59going to uh a bookstore and then usually
- 1:54:02these days it's a Q&A. It's like this.
- 1:54:04You just sit in front of people, do Q&A,
- 1:54:06sign books, go to the hotel, go to the
- 1:54:07next place.
- 1:54:08>> Do you enjoy it?
- 1:54:09>> Yeah, I I actually love it. Yeah, I
- 1:54:11maybe enjoy it a little too much, but I
- 1:54:12love the meeting the people because then
- 1:54:14you're like
- 1:54:15>> if you have any temptation to project
- 1:54:17negatively about your audience or
- 1:54:18fearfully,
- 1:54:19>> that washes it all away. They're so nice
- 1:54:21and you know,
- 1:54:22>> are would you say most of the people in
- 1:54:25all the different places you go are
- 1:54:26relatively the same or is it different
- 1:54:29area by area?
- 1:54:30>> Well, they tend to be left-leaning and
- 1:54:32they tend to be literary. Uh, and we I
- 1:54:35don't get a lot of people across the
- 1:54:38political spectrum, I don't think. Um,
- 1:54:41but I mean in general they're they're
- 1:54:45really nice. I mean really open to ideas
- 1:54:47and very uh
- 1:54:49>> and and that that kind for me that's
- 1:54:51kind of built up over the years. So it's
- 1:54:52a very welcoming
- 1:54:53>> and they're coming there because they
- 1:54:54like you otherwise they wouldn't come.
- 1:54:55So
- 1:54:56>> yeah, I have to some sometimes before I
- 1:54:57start something I have to say that like
- 1:54:58they they came here you know.
- 1:55:02When you write something funny, do you
- 1:55:03laugh out loud
- 1:55:04>> the first time?
- 1:55:06>> And then usually never again. Just kind
- 1:55:08of go, "Okay." But that got a laugh back
- 1:55:10in 1990, so you can leave it in there.
- 1:55:13>> Yeah. Yeah. When you sit down to write,
- 1:55:15do you have what's your expectation when
- 1:55:17you sit to write? I
- 1:55:19>> I guess uh not much actually. I mean, I
- 1:55:22think to improve something somewhere,
- 1:55:23but
- 1:55:24>> uh more I'm looking at at how how well
- 1:55:27I'm reading that day.
- 1:55:28>> Start reading.
- 1:55:29>> How well am I reading? Am I getting it?
- 1:55:31Am I am I like if you imagine um
- 1:55:34>> do you equate how well you're reading it
- 1:55:37to how well you can write?
- 1:55:39>> Yes. In other words, if I can if I'm
- 1:55:41reading it
- 1:55:43well, I'm correcting well.
- 1:55:45>> I see.
- 1:55:46>> Cuz I cuz then I'm reading it the way
- 1:55:47you'll read it some. Yeah. Yeah. And if
- 1:55:49I'm a little out of touch with it, then
- 1:55:50I'm it's almost like driving a little
- 1:55:52bit blind, you know?
- 1:55:54>> How are speaking and writing the same
- 1:55:56and how are they different?
- 1:55:58Uh,
- 1:56:01well,
- 1:56:03writing is speaking over and over. You
- 1:56:06know, I I can sometimes blurt out
- 1:56:07something kind of good, but if I talk
- 1:56:10for 10 minutes, it'll just be one little
- 1:56:11thing, then come back. And so, it's it's
- 1:56:14I don't really I don't I know a lot of
- 1:56:15people think, you know, one of the
- 1:56:17things that young writers are obsessed
- 1:56:18with is finding their voice. And I I
- 1:56:20really was, too. And we always think
- 1:56:22it's voice. It's whatever you blurt out.
- 1:56:24But what I love is the idea that voice
- 1:56:26is achievable by uh subtraction. You
- 1:56:29know, you can have a page of mediocre
- 1:56:30writing and by lining it out, you can
- 1:56:33make it really unique just by cutting,
- 1:56:35you know. That's cool.
- 1:56:36>> Yeah. Yeah.
- 1:56:38>> You think if you have some mediocre
- 1:56:39writing and two different people edit
- 1:56:41it, you'll get two very different
- 1:56:42things.
- 1:56:43>> I think if they're good if they're good
- 1:56:44editors. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I think so.
- 1:56:46>> And might both of them be good?
- 1:56:48>> Sure. And in fact, I think I mean the
- 1:56:50the the really weird thing is you you
- 1:56:52can be both people.
- 1:56:53>> Yeah. So Monday you can edit it in a
- 1:56:55certain flavor,
- 1:56:57>> Tuesday you come back and add a
- 1:56:58different flavor. And my theory is that
- 1:57:00over time that model stabilizes and
- 1:57:04you're getting the benefit of all your
- 1:57:05people. You know, you're so grouchy,
- 1:57:07you're so funny, you're self skeptical,
- 1:57:09you're self, you know,
- 1:57:09>> that's a really exciting idea.
- 1:57:10>> And but when you're young, it's scary
- 1:57:12because it doesn't work that way. You
- 1:57:13just keep changing it. But then over
- 1:57:14time now I I can kind of like
- 1:57:17>> let whoever's here today come and work
- 1:57:21>> and won't they won't hurt it
- 1:57:22>> and tomorrow we'll do something else to
- 1:57:24it and in the end it starts to kind of
- 1:57:26lock lock in.
- 1:57:27>> How different are you from day to day?
- 1:57:29>> Not not that different but it's almost
- 1:57:31like around the edges there there are
- 1:57:32certain like I I'll I'll go by a line 97
- 1:57:35times and the 98th time I'll find the
- 1:57:37joke like oh of course boom. So it's
- 1:57:39almost like um I guess like if you were
- 1:57:42in the yard looking for treasure, you
- 1:57:43just look and look and look and look and
- 1:57:45look and most days you don't find
- 1:57:46anything and then one day you find
- 1:57:47something. But there, you know, so
- 1:57:49that's where the iteration comes in.
- 1:57:51>> And when you're looking for treasure, is
- 1:57:52it something that's already there
- 1:57:54usually?
- 1:57:56>> No, it's usually Well, it's something
- 1:57:57that is a reaction moment. There there's
- 1:57:59a little something that I didn't see and
- 1:58:02then you react
- 1:58:03>> and then you react to it. So it's the
- 1:58:05new thing that you're adding
- 1:58:06>> usually. Yeah. Or or just as valuable,
- 1:58:09you'll have a phrase, a three beat
- 1:58:12phrase, and you go, that middle section
- 1:58:14is redundant. Cut it out and the the the
- 1:58:17two beat phrase is much better. And the
- 1:58:20third is already is implied and you have
- 1:58:21to say it. That that can be even even
- 1:58:23and then that can sometimes teach you
- 1:58:25the voice of the whole piece. Once you
- 1:58:26find one line that that sounds the right
- 1:58:28way, then you're like, okay, the rest of
- 1:58:29you guys have to respond to this in some
- 1:58:32way.
- 1:58:32>> Is there anything that can't be put into
- 1:58:34words?
- 1:58:34>> Sure. Everything.
- 1:58:37So then what do you do?
- 1:58:38>> You just try your, you know, it's just I
- 1:58:39mean that's to me it's a it's a fun game
- 1:58:41we're playing together. You know, I
- 1:58:43can't put everything words that's
- 1:58:44important. I know I can't, but let me
- 1:58:46try. And then we get a sort of a
- 1:58:48simulation of that, right? Like I mean
- 1:58:50that
- 1:58:50>> must be I mean I would imagine
- 1:58:52>> it's an album, right? I mean like it's
- 1:58:54it's it's it's an attempt to say a bunch
- 1:58:56of stuff, but you don't I mean you never
- 1:58:58quite
- 1:58:58>> you never know
- 1:58:59>> get there. Yeah.
- 1:59:01>> Tell me about causation in fiction.
- 1:59:04>> I believe in it. I believe in it. It's
- 1:59:06uh it's just how does it work? I think
- 1:59:08it works. I I think it's another fancy
- 1:59:10word and what it really means is
- 1:59:12>> when I read you four lines,
- 1:59:14>> it changes your location and now you're
- 1:59:17ready to receive something and I'm
- 1:59:19alertly looking at you to see where I
- 1:59:21put you and then I do the next thing.
- 1:59:24That's causation. So, uh, and on a
- 1:59:26larger scale, if I, if the first section
- 1:59:28of a story is, you know, Jerry had been
- 1:59:32in love for 50 years and never doubted
- 1:59:35his love, you're like,
- 1:59:38>> "All right,
- 1:59:40you know what? Some Yeah, something has
- 1:59:42to respond to that." So, causality
- 1:59:44really is just the
- 1:59:45>> the the parts of the story being in
- 1:59:47alert communication with each other.
- 1:59:50>> Yeah. you know that this this this part
- 1:59:52of this the I almost said song but this
- 1:59:54part of the story has done something
- 1:59:56it's clarified itself and it's doing
- 1:59:59some doing something to you as a reader
- 2:00:01and as a writer I can't make the next
- 2:00:03section as if it this hadn't happened
- 2:00:06but as we said earlier that could be
- 2:00:07quite complicated but it has to take it
- 2:00:09into account in some way
- 2:00:11>> just a learn it's just narrative
- 2:00:12alertness I think
- 2:00:13>> does a writer need to have something to
- 2:00:15say
- 2:00:16>> they everyone everyone does I think I
- 2:00:19but also It's not I I think a story
- 2:00:21isn't what you say, it's how you say it.
- 2:00:24>> So if you have a method of saying
- 2:00:26something, that's that's it, you know.
- 2:00:28So I think everyone has something to
- 2:00:30say, but I wouldn't want to hear it. I
- 2:00:31don't want to hear what I have to say
- 2:00:32cuz I hear that every day.
- 2:00:34>> But when you're writing, you're doing
- 2:00:36something else. It's you're making an
- 2:00:37object that gives off energy or
- 2:00:40something. And you know,
- 2:00:41>> are you ever confused by strong emotions
- 2:00:43that come up when you're reading and not
- 2:00:45understand them?
- 2:00:49Yes, but not in a like troubling way.
- 2:00:52Just uh we we I just taught a story
- 2:00:55called um A Fabulous Animal by this
- 2:00:57writer Samantha Schweblin and it's so
- 2:00:59good and I got to the end and I
- 2:01:02couldn't have said what I was feeling
- 2:01:05except a kind of gratitude like wow you
- 2:01:07picked me up and lifted me and you never
- 2:01:09let me down until the very end. And then
- 2:01:11I then the analyzing is to go back and
- 2:01:12go all right why
- 2:01:14>> okay well also where where did those
- 2:01:16things happen
- 2:01:18>> where were my expectations fulfilled and
- 2:01:20subverted in that cool way and then at
- 2:01:22the very end after that you can go okay
- 2:01:23now what does this mean
- 2:01:26but yes I think that confusion is in a
- 2:01:29good work of art I think you feel a lot
- 2:01:31and you don't know why then maybe if you
- 2:01:33want to you can go back and kind of try
- 2:01:34to sus it out but
- 2:01:36>> it's the I I think the roller coaster
- 2:01:38designer is the best metaphor you you
- 2:01:40get off the thing and you're not exactly
- 2:01:44analyzing it. You're just feeling it.
- 2:01:45>> You just had the experience.
- 2:01:46>> Maybe you want to go on it again. And if
- 2:01:48you wanted to, you could sit, you know,
- 2:01:50with some paper and go, "Oh, this is
- 2:01:52why." But
- 2:01:53>> um
- 2:01:54>> yeah, I think so. So So the trick is you
- 2:01:56as a story writer, you're trying to make
- 2:01:57that magical thing happen uh and not be
- 2:02:00reductive for a few minutes and then
- 2:02:03then they can analyze it if you want.
- 2:02:05it.
- 2:02:06>> Are there any any basic rules about
- 2:02:08writing that are pretty good? Like
- 2:02:11shorter sentences are better than longer
- 2:02:13sentences, anything like that?
- 2:02:15>> The only I mean I the only thing that I
- 2:02:17honor in my work is it it there's a kind
- 2:02:19of a hierarchy of of
- 2:02:22complication. So I always want to start
- 2:02:24with the simplest. So first person,
- 2:02:27present tense, continuous time, one
- 2:02:30character. That's the first
- 2:02:32>> just because it's just like it's
- 2:02:33classic. like grounding.
- 2:02:35>> It's grounding and it's simple and I'm
- 2:02:36not there's no tricks. Then at some
- 2:02:39point if the story says you know what
- 2:02:40this really shouldn't be first person
- 2:02:43you feel obstructed. Okay. Okay. It's a
- 2:02:46third person story one character
- 2:02:47continuous time. H about draft 15. You
- 2:02:51need a second voice here. Do I really? I
- 2:02:54don't think I do. Okay. Have another
- 2:02:56couple weeks then. Then you go oh
- 2:02:57actually I do need a second voice then.
- 2:02:59So in other words you only go up the
- 2:03:00chain of complexity as the story demands
- 2:03:03it. I I'd say that's something I've
- 2:03:04internalized. Uh I don't like I mean I
- 2:03:07don't like slop like if somebody doesn't
- 2:03:10is making a mistake and they don't know
- 2:03:11it. I don't like that so much and just
- 2:03:13in syntax and stuff but other than that
- 2:03:15I think it's you know since the story is
- 2:03:17mostly
- 2:03:19language responding to language you can
- 2:03:22do anything you I I had a kid one time
- 2:03:24one of my students he was uh analyzing
- 2:03:27the metamorphosis by Kofka and he his
- 2:03:29essay the first sentence was um upon
- 2:03:31upon peroving this work of literature I
- 2:03:34felt myself at a distinct tilt I'm like
- 2:03:37wow so I so I put that in a story I
- 2:03:39started writing around that and it
- 2:03:41generated did a whole story with really
- 2:03:43[ __ ] up syntax. But so, so really
- 2:03:45there aren't any rules except I think
- 2:03:47you have to be aware of what you're
- 2:03:48doing. You know, if you're if you if you
- 2:03:50did something and it was slightly
- 2:03:51irregular, fine. As long as you know it
- 2:03:53and then you can build it into your
- 2:03:55response, too.
- 2:04:05Tiff.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of George Saunders by Tetragrammaton with Rick Rubin, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 25,621 words across 3,763 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.