Gene Scheer In Conversation with Beck Weathers - Everest — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00hi everyone thank you so much for being
- 0:01here tonight uh my name is Daniel Javi
- 0:04I'm the artistic and Community manager
- 0:05for upper parallel
- 0:07um and it's my great pleasure to welcome
- 0:09you to this conversation this evening
- 0:11um so just to give you a little context
- 0:13on about why we're here tonight if
- 0:15you're if you're not aware uh op is very
- 0:18excited to be presenting our next
- 0:19production which is called Everest and
- 0:21immersive experience which is opening
- 0:23next Friday February 3rd at z-space here
- 0:25in San Francisco
- 0:27um it's running through to February 12th
- 0:28and there's plenty of different
- 0:29performance times and plenty of great
- 0:31tickets available still
- 0:33um check out our website for those
- 0:34that's operaparallel.org Everest
- 0:38um so to start with I just want to tell
- 0:39you a little bit about the background of
- 0:41this production
- 0:42um so Ops Productions will always take
- 0:44you on a journey that's guaranteed
- 0:46um and this production itself has had
- 0:48its own Journey uh so when we started
- 0:52developing the product the sorry the
- 0:53concept of a graphic novel opera or
- 0:56combining the two mediums of graphic
- 0:57novels and Opera together we decided
- 0:59developing that Concept in 2012 uh with
- 1:02when our creative director Brian staff
- 1:04and Bill and conductor an artistic
- 1:06director of Nicole paymore uh
- 1:07commissioned a short Opera and did a
- 1:09presented a workshop performance of that
- 1:11using graphic novel images uh as part of
- 1:14the the background and the scenery for
- 1:16that Workshop
- 1:17um that that concept sort of was put to
- 1:19bed for a few years in 20 after 2012 uh
- 1:22but then it was brought back in 2020
- 1:24during the pandemic uh in 2020 we
- 1:26decided to to do an excerpt from Everest
- 1:29uh for our virtual Gala uh and we did a
- 1:3310 minute scene uh presented in the
- 1:35style of a graphic novel Opera and it
- 1:38was it was such a great hit uh people
- 1:40loved it and we we loved it as well uh
- 1:42that we decided to really to keep going
- 1:44and do the whole Opera and turn it into
- 1:46a feature-length animated film uh which
- 1:49we premiered in 2021 uh with the Dallas
- 1:51Opera
- 1:52uh and then you know as as Opera
- 1:55parallel likes to do we keep pushing
- 1:56ideas further and further and we we
- 1:58decided to use all the assets that we
- 2:00created for the film in 2021 and turn it
- 2:03into this immersive experience that that
- 2:05is opening uh next week uh so we using
- 2:08all the illustrations the recording uh
- 2:10and the performances from our incredible
- 2:12cast and putting them into a full 360
- 2:14degree projected experience with the
- 2:16audience in the middle uh and with
- 2:18special surround sound design so it
- 2:20feels like you're really there uh in in
- 2:22the middle of the action quite literally
- 2:23in the middle of the action
- 2:25uh so
- 2:27please do make sure you get your tickets
- 2:29for for that
- 2:30um but before any of that happened
- 2:32before any before before we even had
- 2:34that idea the story really started with
- 2:36our two guests who were here today
- 2:39um so it's my great pleasure to welcome
- 2:40uh virtually at least to Upper parallel
- 2:43these two guests to share their
- 2:44incredible stories
- 2:46uh so with us is Gene shear Gene Shear
- 2:50is a celebrated librettist Lyricist and
- 2:52songwriter uh and is of course the
- 2:54liberatist for the Opera Everest his
- 2:57other operatic Works include Therese
- 2:59Racine with Tobias picker Moby Dick and
- 3:02It's a Wonderful Life with Jake Hagee
- 3:04and Cold Mountain with Jennifer Higdon
- 3:07Gene was Jean also wrote the song
- 3:10American Anthem which has gone on to
- 3:12become a well-loved part of the
- 3:14Contemporary American Songbook
- 3:16and was also recited by President Joe
- 3:18Biden in his inaugural address
- 3:21ing Gene in conversation tonight is of
- 3:24course BEC Webbers
- 3:25Beck is a retired pathologist based in
- 3:28Dallas Texas and author of the book left
- 3:30for dead my journey home from Everest
- 3:33which describes his incredible
- 3:35experiences as a survivor of the 1996
- 3:37Mount Everest disaster
- 3:39Beck and Jean met while Gene was
- 3:41researching and developing the Libretto
- 3:43for the Opera Everest and backstory
- 3:46story forms one of the central
- 3:48storylands of the Opera
- 3:50so without further Ado uh please join me
- 3:53in welcoming Jean Shia and Beck weathers
- 3:56we started discussing subjects and I had
- 3:59been thinking about
- 4:01um the story of uh what happened on
- 4:03Everest in 1996 for a while of course I
- 4:06read the book as many people had because
- 4:08it was a big bestseller Into Thin Air
- 4:10John krakauer's book so I knew the
- 4:13outline of the story and I I posed the
- 4:16idea to Joby and he was instantly uh
- 4:20taken with the idea I think if Joby were
- 4:22here he would say that the first thing
- 4:24that sort of uh sort of uh caught his
- 4:28imagination was the idea of depicting
- 4:31through music what it's like to be in
- 4:33the death zone that and that can speak
- 4:35to what the death zone is but it's this
- 4:38place at a this very high altitude where
- 4:40it's it's uh you can't you there's
- 4:43almost no oxygen and it's very very hard
- 4:45to breathe and that kind of incredible
- 4:47effort to uh to move your body uh a few
- 4:51feet with something that Jacoby thought
- 4:53that music could really explore anyway
- 4:56so I we we uh soon sort of said on the
- 5:00idea of doing this story and
- 5:02um rather than I had the idea of rather
- 5:05than uh using John krakauer's book I
- 5:08mean there were other issues with that I
- 5:09don't think John cracker or spec can
- 5:11speak to this at this point uh at time
- 5:14wanted any more to do with uh the story
- 5:18um there's so there's I'll let Beck uh
- 5:20describe that if he wants
- 5:22um uh but so I decided to go around the
- 5:26country uh hopefully to go around the
- 5:28country and then go around the world
- 5:29through there wasn't Zoom but through
- 5:31telephone calls and that in-person
- 5:32interviews and interview as many
- 5:35um some of the survivors as I could and
- 5:38you know it's uh what happens is when
- 5:42when someone just phone call you get a
- 5:44phone call from someone with this crazy
- 5:45idea of doing an opera uh it's and then
- 5:48people are very very busy and uh it's
- 5:51it's very hard to get any sort of
- 5:53purchases as you say to get any uh yeah
- 5:55uh anyone to take you seriously but
- 5:58luckily Beck uh Beck was uh was open to
- 6:03the idea he lives in uh he lives in
- 6:05Dallas and it was from the Dallas Opera
- 6:07and um he was incredibly generous uh
- 6:11with his time and uh I went over to
- 6:14Beck's house and we started what turned
- 6:16out to be 30 hours of conversation in
- 6:18multiple visits and he allowed me to
- 6:20record him and much of what he said well
- 6:22his whole story but much of his even his
- 6:25language wove its way into into the
- 6:27Opera so uh and then the way it works is
- 6:31once I had back that I could call other
- 6:33people and said hey I got back and they
- 6:35said you talked to Beck weathers I said
- 6:36well then I'll talk to you too and so I
- 6:38uh Neil beitelman and Aspen I parked my
- 6:42car and I had an hour he said I'll give
- 6:44you 30 minutes and I and I parked my car
- 6:47in an hour a lot in an hour a lot and at
- 6:504 and a half hours later uh you know I I
- 6:53finished my interview with Neil
- 6:54beitelman who was one of the guides on
- 6:56the South Pole and Beck can speak to
- 6:58that story and then it went off from
- 7:00David Brashears and reaching out to Jan
- 7:02Arnold uh in New Zealand and uh uh and
- 7:06and and and others uh uh all the way
- 7:09through I got I got through to as many
- 7:11as I could but but this whole story
- 7:13started with uh Beck and his incredible
- 7:16generosity to me so without further Ado
- 7:18I should uh have a shut up and let back
- 7:20sorry to tell this story in fact I asked
- 7:23you I'll start with this what was it
- 7:24like when I called you to say I want to
- 7:26do this were you ever thinking this was
- 7:28going to be an Opera
- 7:30well I got to say of all the many things
- 7:32that came after 96 Everest uh and there
- 7:36were a lot of unusual appearances you
- 7:39know you have to meet the great the
- 7:41mighty and you go all sorts of places
- 7:42you can sort of expect in a story that
- 7:45captivates people's imagination the way
- 7:48that particular event did that those
- 7:51were sort of slow-ons that you would uh
- 7:53think would be perfectly reasonable but
- 7:55when you called me up
- 7:57that came totally out of the blue and I
- 7:59was absolutely intrigued just with the
- 8:02whole idea of it and of course I but we
- 8:06sat down and we started talking and it
- 8:10was such an easy conversation uh it was
- 8:13such a you know it's just like somebody
- 8:15you know in your entire life and you
- 8:17just sit there and you pour your guts
- 8:20out and you tell your story and you tell
- 8:22you what you're what you were thinking
- 8:24and what got you there and the the
- 8:26trials and tribulations the upsides the
- 8:29downsides the the horror and the and the
- 8:32jubilations and all the full gamut of
- 8:36emotions that this kind of a story
- 8:38entails uh and so
- 8:41uh
- 8:43I still didn't know how this was going
- 8:44to turn out and eventually you came back
- 8:47with a recording
- 8:49uh that so I could get a listen to how
- 8:53this was going to sound
- 8:54uh and I was so moved I basically kind
- 8:59of just shook me uh to the core and I
- 9:01and I just really uh
- 9:06had trouble holding it together it was
- 9:08such an emotional event
- 9:10hearing the story and done in such a way
- 9:12with such beautiful words and such
- 9:15beautiful music
- 9:17uh that I you know I thought it was
- 9:19it was a singular experience and then of
- 9:22course we got to see this
- 9:24uh when the Opera premiered uh in uh
- 9:29Dallas in 2015.
- 9:32and seeing it with the full staging and
- 9:36all the Magnificent voices uh and the
- 9:39great score that goes with it I was just
- 9:41overwhelmed and it really is one of the
- 9:44highlights
- 9:45of my last years and it just been
- 9:48wonderful and I got a chance to see into
- 9:52a world uh with such creativity and
- 9:55interesting people that was not part of
- 9:58my experience normally uh but it was you
- 10:01know it's just a fantastic experience
- 10:04and it turned out to be a great Opera
- 10:07well thank you so much I appreciate that
- 10:09and if it's if it's any of those things
- 10:11it's in large measure due to your help
- 10:13with it you know one of the things I
- 10:14think you all might be interested to
- 10:16know is that you know when I'm
- 10:18interviewing someone like backdoor when
- 10:20I'm when I interviewed back of course I
- 10:22wanted to know the story I wanted to
- 10:24know it from you know the person who
- 10:26experienced it and and I'm sure you
- 10:29actually all know the the basic outline
- 10:31of this story uh we can we can go over
- 10:33that some but we talked Beck and I talk
- 10:35a lot about
- 10:36um his work as a pathologist I asked him
- 10:41things I don't think he was probably uh
- 10:43because I don't you you never know uh
- 10:45when you're writing what is going to
- 10:47weave its way and what tributary is
- 10:49going to weave its way into this river
- 10:51that you're uh that you're you know you
- 10:53know Sailing sailing forth on and so
- 10:56like just one thing that sort of Pops to
- 10:57mind as I'm sort of casting my mind back
- 10:59on this was I remember I said I said
- 11:01well Beck tell me uh uh tell me about
- 11:05what you do uh when you're in the lab
- 11:07and uh um and he was explaining he said
- 11:11to me something which wound up being in
- 11:13the Opera when he said uh well you have
- 11:15to understand Gene when you're looking
- 11:17at cells and back help me out here you
- 11:19you can't see them unless you add dies
- 11:22to them to uh suit suit to sort of
- 11:25discern what is uh uh what's there and
- 11:29uh and it seems and not I wouldn't say
- 11:32all of a sudden but as I was doing my
- 11:34work it seemed like an incredible
- 11:36metaphor for Beck's life who as he was
- 11:40you know he Everest was the die that
- 11:43allowed him to see and recontextualize
- 11:45his life I don't want to put words in
- 11:46your mouth back so you can jump in at
- 11:48any time but you know I think that uh
- 11:51used with the interesting thing maybe
- 11:53you can speak to this is that you've
- 11:54said in in
- 11:57um I'm gonna bungle to this whatever's
- 12:00kind of saved your life in a way uh and
- 12:02not just the experience of it but it
- 12:04changed your life and maybe you could
- 12:05speak to that
- 12:07but well I think there's a tendency to
- 12:10look at Everest and see this as just a
- 12:13bunch of ciphers going up there trying
- 12:16to bag a mountain so they can pound
- 12:18their chest uh and you know
- 12:22declared themselves to the world but the
- 12:26reality of the individuals who are there
- 12:28is vastly more complex than any of those
- 12:32kind of simpleton stories would suggest
- 12:35uh because these are real people and
- 12:37every single one of them brings their
- 12:40own hopes and dreams and problems uh and
- 12:44searching for something uh to in their
- 12:48life to you know Find meaning
- 12:51uh and you know certainly in my own case
- 12:55every it was a long journey to get there
- 12:59this was not a one-year event to go in
- 13:03this Sunday go climb a mountain this was
- 13:05a very long period uh and it came out of
- 13:09a uh a fairly long lifelong uh
- 13:14depression and trying to struggle and
- 13:16stay alive during all those uh years
- 13:19uh and the exertion and the physical
- 13:24Drive
- 13:26was very healing and that really got
- 13:28expressed in my going into the mountains
- 13:32where just the sheer physical drive
- 13:34would was calming uh to me into my soul
- 13:39and to
- 13:41being able to put out the pain of the
- 13:45day-to-day existence and so much of what
- 13:49I you know was seeing when we were
- 13:51talking we were talking about the world
- 13:53that I exist in which is an artificial
- 13:55one in so many ways uh because what I do
- 13:59is an idiot savant skill that has no
- 14:02real
- 14:04uh counterpart in essence in the real
- 14:07world I I know what a human being looks
- 14:09like in three dimensions cut at five
- 14:12microns from birth to Resurrection in
- 14:15health and in thousands and thousands of
- 14:17diseases and that has absolutely no use
- 14:20whatsoever unless you do what I do
- 14:24uh and I think and it's all done with
- 14:28dyes and you know artificial cuts and
- 14:32that and it's in that world provides
- 14:35real answers but through a very
- 14:38artificial lens and so as we
- 14:42talked about this we were able to
- 14:45incorporate some of those images
- 14:48uh from just the my own life struggles
- 14:53and the day-to-day reality that I you
- 14:56know have as a physician and and then to
- 15:00weave those into the story and often all
- 15:04those conversations are very much
- 15:05represented uh in the in the Opera
- 15:09there's even things like I asked Beck
- 15:11about the most beautiful or these or
- 15:14Most Beautiful Moments and also these
- 15:16unusual moments in his climbing career
- 15:18because as Beck just uh suggested or
- 15:21just mentioned this wasn't a one-off he
- 15:23had climbed you know or many of the
- 15:26significant uh you know climbs in the
- 15:28world and he talked to me about the
- 15:31quiet in Antarctica and how he could
- 15:33feel his heart he could hear his heart
- 15:35because there's no sound there and I I
- 15:38thought that was a and seeing three sons
- 15:40in the sky this this kind of uh those uh
- 15:43what are they called it's in the Opera
- 15:45dog Sun dogs and they and that's sort of
- 15:49what was like the most beautiful this
- 15:51incredible image that he uh described to
- 15:53me in that woven uh into the Opera as
- 15:56well but when he's you know sort of
- 15:58giving him so that the audience and the
- 16:00Opera understands the context of this is
- 16:02again not a one-off that this is Beck's
- 16:04uh this is part of the Arc of his uh
- 16:07climbing uh climbing career the the uh
- 16:11it was you know one of the other things
- 16:12that we had to choose or I had to choose
- 16:15um you know what I I think if anyone's
- 16:17going to since there have been
- 16:18dramatizations I haven't seen the film
- 16:20but I know that there's a film now and
- 16:22stuff and Beck's story is clearly uh
- 16:24Beck and and Jan and Rob Hall's uh story
- 16:27are the are the are incredibly dramatic
- 16:29uh stories and I can see why I you know
- 16:32chose them and I can see why others have
- 16:34as well because they're so uh they're so
- 16:36compelling and and but there's but so
- 16:39many stories that of everyone who was
- 16:42there are very compelling and the story
- 16:44of Doug uh which is also Chronicles or
- 16:47cited in the Opera and his relationship
- 16:50to Rob Hall is something that was just
- 16:52sort of heartbreaking for those of you
- 16:54who don't know and you can speak to this
- 16:56because you knew him uh back but uh Doug
- 16:59was a climber who had climbed in 1995 uh
- 17:04he was a working-class guy a lot of the
- 17:07people who who were there were uh are
- 17:10sort of major professionals who could
- 17:14afford to take the time off and also the
- 17:17the 65 000 fee in the 1960s in the 1990s
- 17:20but Doug was a postal worker and he
- 17:22mortgages house and in 1995 he he got
- 17:25300 vertical feet from the uh top of
- 17:29Everest and they then he was turned uh
- 17:32turned around and uh um and uh one of
- 17:36the things one of my conversations was
- 17:38with Ed visters who is one of the great
- 17:40maybe the greatest BEC you can speak to
- 17:42this but he's certainly one of the
- 17:44greatest climbers in American history
- 17:45and in 1995 Ed was the uh guide for Rob
- 17:52Hall and it's like you know it's like uh
- 17:55you imagine you're on a team and you're
- 17:57and you've hired as your support person
- 17:59Michael Jordan and uh and when the
- 18:02decision was made to turn Doug around
- 18:04and this is actually not in that this is
- 18:07not in this is actually not part of the
- 18:08Opera but it's kind of interesting thing
- 18:09but Doug's story is part of the Opera
- 18:11but what I'm about to tell you is not
- 18:12but I Ed beasters told me this when I
- 18:14had my long conversation with him in
- 18:16Seattle
- 18:17they were 300 this is 1995 one year
- 18:20before uh this The Climb that we were
- 18:22talked that's in the Opera and uh
- 18:25they're 300 feet from the top 300
- 18:27vertical feet from the top and uh
- 18:31Rob looks at Ed and says can he make it
- 18:34and Ed went like this we have to turn
- 18:36him around and it got him back to uh and
- 18:39Ed told me they got him back to the
- 18:40tents on Camp four uh just within a
- 18:43whisker and now it's a year later and
- 18:46Rob has called uh uh Doug has sorry Rob
- 18:49has called Doug multiple times and said
- 18:52you can do this you can come back I
- 18:54won't charge you the extra fee just get
- 18:55yourself here and I'll get you up there
- 18:57you know I'll get you up the mountain
- 18:58and he clicks off of the line and Rob
- 19:01comes over to him and and says something
- 19:03in his ear and all you know all of a
- 19:05sudden he's back in the line and uh they
- 19:08wind up you know tragically uh pushing
- 19:10past the turnaround time of two o'clock
- 19:13they don't get to the top of the
- 19:14mountain until four and then of course
- 19:16all hell breaks loose when the weather
- 19:17turns bad so there's uh there's there
- 19:20there are there are these all these
- 19:22stories are sort of converging
- 19:25um but uh it's well one of the things
- 19:27which I found just to jump back to back
- 19:29I mean one of the things that just kind
- 19:30of Bloom be away it was when I was
- 19:32asking Beck about you know because Becca
- 19:34and you can speak to this spec had an
- 19:36issue with his eyes which
- 19:38um uh he wasn't expecting and all of a
- 19:41sudden he wasn't able to see
- 19:43um uh when the sun was at a certain
- 19:45height in the sky and Beck you can
- 19:47describe that but uh when the sun wasn't
- 19:50at the certain height you could see
- 19:51beautifully and so he was on the balcony
- 19:53of Everest which is a this place that's
- 19:55before the the summit but this beautiful
- 19:58place again Beck was there I'll let him
- 20:00describe it and he's talking about he's
- 20:02having this great day like you know he
- 20:04had he didn't Summit he didn't get to
- 20:06the top but it was a it was an
- 20:08incredibly beautiful experience one of
- 20:10the most beautiful things uh that you'd
- 20:12ever seen back why don't you can't why
- 20:13do you hand the Baton to you and you can
- 20:15describe what it was like to be on the
- 20:16balcony and uh and that experience
- 20:19okay well uh I had radio keratotomy done
- 20:24in Dallas because uh
- 20:28Mountain weather and Eyeglasses simply
- 20:30don't mix at all and I had too many
- 20:31experiences where the glasses that I'd
- 20:34be wearing would be totally covered in
- 20:36ice and I little couldn't see anything
- 20:39other than my feet uh and so I had this
- 20:43done hopefully to improve my ability to
- 20:47work in that environment but it turns
- 20:50out and I didn't know this that nobody
- 20:53in Ophthalmology in the United States
- 20:55knew this they were couple of letters to
- 20:58the editor that said that you know we've
- 21:01just learned that people go to very very
- 21:03high altitudes they vision changes
- 21:06dramatically uh and it's a metabolic
- 21:09injury to the front of the eye of course
- 21:12I didn't know that but I hadn't noticed
- 21:14that when I got to Everest my vision was
- 21:16changing uh based on the altitude and we
- 21:19started up on the summit day uh and as I
- 21:22got higher and higher my vision went
- 21:25progressively worse until uh till in the
- 21:30middle of the night when we got to you
- 21:32know make a Traverse I couldn't see the
- 21:35mountain at all I couldn't even see my
- 21:36own Footprints uh and so I knew just
- 21:41because I had experience as a kid with a
- 21:43pinhole camera that if the sun gets
- 21:46fully out your pupils go down so far
- 21:49that everything is infinitely in focus
- 21:51and I thought well no problem I'm just
- 21:53going to wait till the sun comes up and
- 21:55when it gets bright enough I don't care
- 21:56how bad had my eyes are I'll be able to
- 21:59see
- 22:00and so sure enough the sun started to
- 22:03come up my vision improved I go up to
- 22:07the balcony which is at 27 500 feet
- 22:10uh and I tell Rob I've got this serious
- 22:13problem with my vision
- 22:15uh but I think if I just wait a little
- 22:18bit it's going to be good enough that I
- 22:20can go ahead and finish climbing up and
- 22:22he said okay you got 30 minutes you can
- 22:25do it in 30 minutes you're good to go if
- 22:27you're not you ain't climbing and I
- 22:30agree to this and I stay on the balcony
- 22:32but and when the sun comes up it is just
- 22:34a gorgeous day it is warm uh it is sunny
- 22:39the wind is not blowing you're looking
- 22:42at the most magnificent views a human
- 22:44being that even
- 22:45imagine and his wildest dreams and as
- 22:49the whole world stretches out underneath
- 22:51your feet and I'm just sitting there as
- 22:53happy as I can be and I certainly didn't
- 22:55want to go down and sit in a tent I
- 22:58thought you know they'll go up they'll
- 23:00do their thing when they come down I'll
- 23:02come down with them but right now it
- 23:05doesn't get any better than this this is
- 23:07just beautiful but one of the things
- 23:09that happened everyone is that the storm
- 23:11that came it came from below isn't right
- 23:14back it did not come from above and
- 23:15that's why this was this beautiful day
- 23:17you're looking up the sky is beautiful
- 23:19but I think it came off of the uh it
- 23:21came out came out from below and uh and
- 23:24of course by you know by four o'clock it
- 23:25was getting bad and by five or six it
- 23:27was it was really bad and then then all
- 23:30hell broke uh broke loose so I have a
- 23:33question
- 23:36you don't know what a thunderstorm looks
- 23:39like uh when it's beneath you and so
- 23:41you're sitting there in Clear Blue Skies
- 23:43and when the thunderstorm Rises up to
- 23:46the level you are it just completely
- 23:49rolls across the space of a couple of
- 23:51minutes and you go from being in warm
- 23:54sunny Pleasant conditions to barely
- 23:56being able to hang on to the mountain at
- 23:58all it is just blowing you uh without
- 24:01such force and the driving ice into your
- 24:04face that you can't see
- 24:06I mean I mean for for everyone who's
- 24:09tuning in here and only watching the
- 24:11Opera this is an incredible opportunity
- 24:13to ask Beck about this but uh it's
- 24:15portrayed in the Opera but of course
- 24:17Beck as is the title of his book called
- 24:19Left for Dead
- 24:20um Beck was left for dead twice on the
- 24:22mountain once on the on the South Pole
- 24:24and uh and as Beck said
- 24:27um he understand I think there was a the
- 24:29person who first saw you he was a
- 24:31physician wasn't he back he was a I
- 24:33think who uh who examined you and said
- 24:36made the triage decision to leave you
- 24:38and then of course you got up and uh and
- 24:41then then but wanted is this is this is
- 24:44just too good a chance back for everyone
- 24:45not to hear it for me wrong your own
- 24:48words but like what that moment was like
- 24:51when uh I mean you told me it was very
- 24:54moving to me I tried to portray it in
- 24:55the Opera but I want to hear from you
- 24:57about when was you know all those hours
- 25:00later you're laying you know in a coma
- 25:03and you've you've and you wake up what
- 25:05what happened
- 25:07to the expense it's the best and I know
- 25:09and you even told me you don't know
- 25:10exactly but what's your what's your take
- 25:13on it what's how would you experience it
- 25:15that you go out of your memory of it
- 25:17well I went into hyper coma
- 25:21it was
- 25:23there's no there's no thought there's no
- 25:25dreams there's there's just absolutely
- 25:27uh a void and something in that day and
- 25:31maybe it's the sunshine forming on the
- 25:34suit which is designed to pull in the
- 25:36sun uh
- 25:38I have other explanations I don't know
- 25:40the answer but late that afternoon
- 25:43[Music]
- 25:46for the audience here how many hours had
- 25:48you been out
- 25:4915 hours unconscious
- 25:51and I'd been examined but during the
- 25:54time that I was unconscious and they
- 25:56determined that there was no way that I
- 25:58could live uh since nobody ever had in
- 26:01this circumstance so I was triaged to
- 26:03die
- 26:04uh and late that afternoon I managed to
- 26:07wake up
- 26:09and I realized that I
- 26:12I was somewhere
- 26:14on that mountain I had no idea where I
- 26:16was
- 26:17uh and that I was pretty sure that
- 26:20nobody was going to come out there and
- 26:22help me because I was if they were going
- 26:24to do it that had been there they would
- 26:26have done it and if I did not move then
- 26:29I was certainly going to die and
- 26:33it was a rather
- 26:36clear
- 26:37but and Searing experience because I
- 26:42really could see directly in front of me
- 26:44my wife and children
- 26:46and it sounds so cliched
- 26:50uh but I would put to you the notion
- 26:53that if you absolutely knew and I did
- 26:56but I was going to be dead within an
- 26:58hour
- 26:58because the sun is 15 degrees above the
- 27:01Horizon and moving down at 15 degrees an
- 27:03hour that when the sun hit it was over
- 27:07yeah what would you think about if you
- 27:10have one hour to live and you know that
- 27:12you're going to be dead at the end of
- 27:13that hour
- 27:15what do you think about it and that's
- 27:16what I thought about and it absolutely
- 27:18drove me to my feet and I didn't care
- 27:23whether I fell and could not I just was
- 27:26going to move until I physically
- 27:28mentally
- 27:30spiritually could not move any longer
- 27:34and I was driven
- 27:36uh to stagger and stumble into the
- 27:39direction of the wind and that's how I
- 27:41kept my going in One Direction because I
- 27:44thought the camp had to be up when so I
- 27:47just kept the force of the Wind on my
- 27:49face
- 27:49and even though I couldn't see more in
- 27:51about six feet
- 27:53I could just keep moving as long as I
- 27:55kept my face into the wind and then I
- 27:58walked into the camp yeah it's just it's
- 28:00just an incredible story and one other
- 28:03aspect of the Opera just to share with
- 28:05you with you all is that um you know one
- 28:07of the things that I learned about
- 28:09mountain climbing and about Everest in
- 28:11particular is that it it resembles
- 28:14baseball in this one way which is that
- 28:16it's uh the history of everyone who
- 28:18played is because always on the field
- 28:21like you know what for those of us who
- 28:23love baseball we're thinking about like
- 28:25you know that catch that Willie Mays
- 28:27made when I was at Candlestick Park in
- 28:29the 60s or or these you know you just
- 28:31you're thinking about and then Babe Ruth
- 28:33and all the history and the thing about
- 28:35Everest is that um more than almost
- 28:37anything uh Everest the history is all
- 28:41there because the um those who perished
- 28:44on Everest are still there and that was
- 28:46one of the sort of points of departure
- 28:48for the telling of the story is that as
- 28:50this action is taking place people are
- 28:52walking through through
- 28:54the the remains the bones the the dust
- 28:59of those who came before and it started
- 29:02in 19 well the first uh expedition was
- 29:061920
- 29:07four but they did a survey expedition in
- 29:101922 and in 1922 some Sherpas passed
- 29:14away in that in that thing and then of
- 29:16course Mallory Irvine and Mallory
- 29:18famously passed away in uh 24 in that on
- 29:21that expedition and uh and then and then
- 29:25then many others over the course of the
- 29:27piece so as you'll see and when you're
- 29:29seeing if you haven't seen it before
- 29:30there's a chorus
- 29:33that um it's it's it I I wouldn't I
- 29:37don't know if Greek chorus I don't know
- 29:38what that you know if that really
- 29:40conjures what it really is but you you
- 29:42there is there seem to be like the
- 29:44spirit of the mountain or the spirit of
- 29:46the some sort of omniscient spirit and
- 29:48at the end of the piece you do you
- 29:50discover that they are though uh they're
- 29:53everyone who died on Everest and when
- 29:55Rob and Doug die the way their deaths
- 29:58are announced as they become part of the
- 30:00chorus and they come to get back uh
- 30:04because but Beck has other ideas and as
- 30:07he just described he's walking uh away
- 30:10from uh away from death and into uh uh
- 30:14uh to to the Salvation of the camp and
- 30:16to be ultimately to be reunited with the
- 30:18world and his family so it's uh um you
- 30:22know it's quite a I think it's a
- 30:23dramatic telling but I think it's one of
- 30:24the things that that I wanted to portray
- 30:27and Joby wanted to portray was to have a
- 30:29sense of the history of this uh of this
- 30:32mountain I mean for those who are
- 30:34there's so many wonderful books I mean
- 30:35uh Beck's book John's crack hours book
- 30:38talk about these 96 Expedition but
- 30:41they're a wonderful
- 30:42um uh book I read a lot of books about
- 30:44this the whole experience and uh there's
- 30:48one that's called into the silence which
- 30:49is about the 1924 uh about Mallory and
- 30:53Irvine which is really a fantastic book
- 30:56um uh I forgot who wrote it but it's
- 30:58it's a we can we can sort of post it but
- 31:00it's a great another great book about a
- 31:02really contextualizes how this all began
- 31:04as a sort of response to World War one
- 31:07and how these these guys who had
- 31:09experienced World War One were uh uh
- 31:12couldn't stop there's some inner clocks
- 31:15that needed some sort of simulation and
- 31:17then when the Chinese government opened
- 31:19up to bet they were able to start uh
- 31:22trying to go uh for the tallest mountain
- 31:24in the world so that's that's what so
- 31:26the history of this is also sort of
- 31:27woven into the piece it's not we don't
- 31:29hit it too heavy I don't think in terms
- 31:31of it's not a history lesson but it's
- 31:33it's also it's part of it my in large
- 31:36measure mostly this is about the the I
- 31:39always say operators are really
- 31:40emotional archeology that's kind of what
- 31:42they are it's not it's not uh telling
- 31:44you the we're not we're not doing a
- 31:46documentary uh if you want to know what
- 31:48happened the blow by blow read Beck's
- 31:51book that'll that'll tell you what
- 31:52happened Blow by blow what we tried to
- 31:54do is use the Majesty of music and the
- 31:58human voice to uh describe what it felt
- 32:01like uh and uh and so that's it I will
- 32:04ask you this back you know this has been
- 32:06you obviously this is an incredibly
- 32:07famous story now it's almost it's become
- 32:10part of the cultural you know fabric of
- 32:13uh the world at this point and the world
- 32:16I mean all over all over the world what
- 32:18I'm not asking about the Opera I'm not
- 32:20I'm not I'm just saying what what do we
- 32:23not get and what what can I guess
- 32:25obviously we can't know what it's like
- 32:26to be in the experience you had but what
- 32:30has uh the world got wrong about what
- 32:33happened there
- 32:35well I I think they don't generally get
- 32:38a clear notion of just who these
- 32:41individuals were right uh it's easy to
- 32:44paint this and kind of broad stereotypic
- 32:48ways without being able to
- 32:51uh see Doug
- 32:54uh see yasco a number
- 33:00Rob and his
- 33:02dying call to his wife I mean the sheer
- 33:05Humanity of these people is is you know
- 33:09these are people you you know
- 33:12these are good human beings these are
- 33:15caring individuals these are not a bunch
- 33:18of
- 33:19Adrenaline Junkies who got to oh I I
- 33:22really yeah
- 33:24a mountain I mean in my own case I was
- 33:28turning 50. the likelihood that I was
- 33:31actually going to summon was pretty dead
- 33:33gun low the by that time the summit
- 33:36ratio was maybe 15 percent of
- 33:40individuals each year who tried with at
- 33:42that point could manage to get up there
- 33:45and that's all covers you talked to the
- 33:4850 year old guy that's not going to be
- 33:51in the top tier right who's going to hit
- 33:54the summit first you don't go there to
- 33:55do that you go to experience it you go
- 33:58to be part of the mountain be part of
- 34:01its history be part of the
- 34:03uh Buddhist culture uh you know this
- 34:07this just whole Mythic of this place
- 34:10and each of the individuals who are
- 34:12there are real people
- 34:15uh
- 34:16yeah I I really felt that about about
- 34:19everyone that I've talked to and and and
- 34:22and also just even intuitive like with
- 34:24Rob I mean I also think there was a
- 34:26class aspect of this too I think Rob's
- 34:28you know desired to help I mean Rob
- 34:31Rob's help desire to help I'm sorry uh
- 34:34to help Doug get up uh even without him
- 34:36bringing him back without having him pay
- 34:38the full fee and and so forth there was
- 34:41he really I mean the road to the hell is
- 34:44truly paid with good intentions I think
- 34:46he really wanted to Rob to uh sorry he
- 34:48was
- 34:49fixing the fiddling with the names Rob
- 34:52wanted to help Doug get to the top and
- 34:54it and it was motivated by the best
- 34:56um you know best intentions and the you
- 34:59know the reason why Jan wasn't there for
- 35:00those of you don't know Jan was a doctor
- 35:02and she normally went on these
- 35:04Expeditions but she was of course
- 35:06pregnant with their first child and uh
- 35:09um so who has since uh summited
- 35:13Kilimanjaro
- 35:18she's now whatever 1996 what she's 24 20
- 35:22what a 27 I guess right and uh you've
- 35:25got to be going on 27. yeah yeah and uh
- 35:29so she
- 35:31um yeah right and so she actually I
- 35:33don't think she's going to do these uh
- 35:34deaths on uh uh the uh tracks but she
- 35:39did actually because her her father had
- 35:41done it and she wanted to do it so it's
- 35:43uh she's very much around and uh and
- 35:47that's that's what's happened so uh well
- 35:49um maybe we should uh I don't know
- 35:51should we uh open it up to questions or
- 35:53there was a clip you want you want to
- 35:55play a clip for everyone or or yeah
- 35:58I could have done it in the context but
- 36:01I think the clip that that's going to be
- 36:02shown is a from this incredible graphic
- 36:05novel uh uh version of the Opera and
- 36:09this is uh this is as if I believe it's
- 36:12uh I'm correct this is the section where
- 36:14we we're back and I we talked about
- 36:16earlier when Beck described being on
- 36:18this on the on this on the balcony of
- 36:21Everest when he he couldn't uh go
- 36:24further but rather than being depressed
- 36:26about it he was taking in the beauty of
- 36:28of all that was around him on this on
- 36:31this gorgeous day
- 36:32so play this little clip and then I
- 36:34asked him some questions yeah I'll play
- 36:36this and then we'll open it up to
- 36:37questions if uh as some folks are
- 36:39already doing if you have some questions
- 36:40feel free to put them in the chat
- 36:42um and I will ask them ask them for you
- 36:45[Music]
- 36:52[Music]
- 36:59[Applause]
- 37:01[Music]
- 37:03every Pig
- 37:08[Music]
- 37:21foreign
- 37:23[Music]
- 37:53was referencing before is The Souls of
- 37:56the mountain and that's how they're
- 37:57portrayed in in uh op's version as the
- 38:00these sort of ghostly figures that
- 38:03surround surround the characters as and
- 38:05they they sing the chorus Parts in in
- 38:08our version
- 38:09um in the original version just which
- 38:12we're not we're doing here but uh about
- 38:15the end all of the names of everyone
- 38:17who's died on Everest are projected on
- 38:19the set and then we add
- 38:21um Rob's name and and Doug's name and
- 38:24you can see that this these hundreds of
- 38:27names of those who are still there so
- 38:30there was some there was some talk of
- 38:32trying to to bring Rob's body down
- 38:35because they know where it was and
- 38:37that's another whole story and Jan said
- 38:38just leave it you just just it's no one
- 38:41should risk their lives going up there
- 38:42in order to do that so that's what
- 38:45happened so anyway I'll be quiet and
- 38:47answer any questions uh so I think the
- 38:49first question we had was from Evelyn uh
- 38:51for Beck uh what was the other
- 38:53near-death experience that happened on
- 38:55Everest I think uh Gene mentioned there
- 38:56was two times that that you were left
- 38:58for dead uh
- 39:04well actually they were
- 39:06uh three times because when Anatoly
- 39:09bookra came out and brought in the
- 39:11Fisher climbers that were part of the
- 39:13Huddle uh he also uh basically declared
- 39:19that yasko and I were Beyond saving and
- 39:23so we were left at that point then when
- 39:26the doctor out of our group came and
- 39:28pronounced that we were Beyond salvation
- 39:31uh that was the second time and in the
- 39:36third time I managed to get to camp and
- 39:41they placed me in a tent alone
- 39:45uh to die because they were absolutely
- 39:48certain I could not possibly live
- 39:50through the night and nobody wanted to
- 39:52have any part of having to experience
- 39:54that
- 39:55and so I
- 39:57wound up uh
- 40:00had some very difficult circumstances in
- 40:03the tent alone uh abandoned because
- 40:07they knew I was dead and so they were
- 40:10very surprised when once again the
- 40:13following morning I was still there
- 40:15and uh I guess I just
- 40:19you know ever ready bad or you just die
- 40:21hard I just did was not going to give up
- 40:23on that so uh it is there were multiple
- 40:27opportunities that things could have
- 40:29changed but in the grand scheme of
- 40:31things uh you know I
- 40:34came back and life is good and the
- 40:41being able to come back to my family
- 40:44after that I always say that if you
- 40:47can't learn something from by dying
- 40:50you're a really slow study
- 40:55a good heart
- 40:57thank you back
- 40:59um the next question we have is from
- 41:01Stacy as for Jean um how did you choose
- 41:04how many people's stories to portray in
- 41:07the Opera she says the Opera feels so
- 41:09balanced with the focus on the two main
- 41:10story lands but was there another
- 41:12person's story you were considering
- 41:13including
- 41:15oh that's a great question and you know
- 41:17it's the reality of Opera and how many
- 41:19soloists you're allowed to have for a
- 41:23particular production that's just the
- 41:24dimensions of the budget and all those
- 41:26things come into it um uh
- 41:30I think well Scott Fisher's you know uh
- 41:34story is also there's so many dramatic
- 41:36stories that there that are taking place
- 41:38uh because all these people who passed
- 41:41away and who were were doing all of uh
- 41:44doing their best I mean I think
- 41:47um it's why Scott Fisher's
- 41:49Widow and her his daughter came to the
- 41:52production in Everest and they were very
- 41:54they were very moved and they weren't
- 41:56upset that he wasn't portrayed actually
- 41:57they just liked the entire uh show I was
- 42:00very gratified by that but um I think I
- 42:04think that that is
- 42:05um you know I I don't know I I I don't
- 42:09really think about in this particular
- 42:10case I don't think about what we missed
- 42:12I just think about what we did um but
- 42:14there are other stories and again there
- 42:16are other they're beautifully chronicled
- 42:17in a lot of the books
- 42:19um uh about her people's uh people's
- 42:22lives there so
- 42:25thank you
- 42:26uh the next question is from Michael uh
- 42:29I think this one is uh aimed at Beck uh
- 42:32he says I have heard reports of people
- 42:34passing by dying climbers in order to
- 42:36reach the summit as it's typical of me
- 42:39thought how Callison and Humane I'm
- 42:41beginning to change my mind but how does
- 42:43one justify leaving a human to die
- 42:46it's a it's a big question
- 42:49well it is a big question in some cases
- 42:52it is just that it's it's callous and
- 42:55it's horrible and it shouldn't happen
- 42:58and uh morality
- 43:02doesn't stop at a given altitude and and
- 43:05you can't
- 43:07you know forgive uh actions where they
- 43:11could have actually helped somebody but
- 43:14part of this is there are certain things
- 43:15that we know to be true that aren't
- 43:18uh for instance that one of the reasons
- 43:21that I was left to die was because it
- 43:25was absolutely known as a truth that
- 43:28once you go into this stage of
- 43:29hypothermic coma nobody has ever lived
- 43:31through it
- 43:32and so to a certain extent that's
- 43:35self-fulfilling so if you have somebody
- 43:37that's in that level of extremist and
- 43:41you leave them they die
- 43:43uh and so you know you have no idea if
- 43:48really if somebody could come back if
- 43:50you'd helped them out but but you can't
- 43:54also realize just how exhausted how
- 44:00known how mentally
- 44:04you know
- 44:05paralyzed you become with the hypoxia
- 44:09and the drive uh it is becomes very in
- 44:14some ways very animalistic
- 44:16uh and
- 44:18you hope
- 44:20that in
- 44:21bad moments that you'll rise above that
- 44:25uh you hope that you know if you get
- 44:28into horrible circumstances that you'll
- 44:30behave as an honorable person but you
- 44:33don't always know that you don't know
- 44:35until you put yourself in that
- 44:37circumstance and then you see how you
- 44:38respond
- 44:40and we would always like to think that
- 44:42we would not be somebody
- 44:43who would
- 44:45uh not do
- 44:48you know for others what you would want
- 44:50done for you
- 44:51uh
- 44:53but you really don't know until you put
- 44:56yourself out so far
- 44:58and you feel so
- 45:01vulnerable
- 45:02in these moments uh part of it you know
- 45:07people don't want to take you back
- 45:09because the effort to do so endangers
- 45:13your life that's right that's right
- 45:16I was going to say that you know on it's
- 45:19as Beck just said I mean clearly it's
- 45:21it's it it's it's like a fingerprint
- 45:24each one is different each situation is
- 45:26different
- 45:27um in
- 45:29Everest Rob Doug dies and Rob is very
- 45:34strong you know professional climber and
- 45:36has incredible will to live and he lives
- 45:38even longer and and as one of his last
- 45:40conversations he says send someone up
- 45:42for me in the morning I'll make it
- 45:43through the night which of course is not
- 45:46true but they do I I don't know this is
- 45:48not part of the Opera but the the base
- 45:50camp they do send they take some
- 45:52thermoses and they head up to try to get
- 45:55to they know where he is
- 45:57but they can't make it and at some point
- 45:59they turn around because they're gonna
- 46:01as Beck just said they're gonna be
- 46:02risking their own lives to save uh Rob
- 46:06who is uh you know uh Mama certainly
- 46:09dead at that point so it's it's there's
- 46:11a I'm sure there's there's a calculation
- 46:13that's happening it was happening uh on
- 46:16that day about who they uh you know who
- 46:19who could be saved and I bet Bucharest
- 46:22you know was you know how many I mean
- 46:25book reps that's a whole other story too
- 46:26remember his I mean which I won't go
- 46:29into now but you know after rushing down
- 46:32the mountain because he wasn't using
- 46:34oxygen uh and then and then going going
- 46:37to the South Coal I mean he could he
- 46:39could save only as many people as he
- 46:41could save and that was also because of
- 46:42you know maybe because of how he climbed
- 46:44uh so that there's these things sort of
- 46:47like they Cascade on one another but
- 46:49it's uh it's complicated and each
- 46:51situation is different I think it's just
- 46:54my take from living with this for so
- 46:56long
- 46:58thank you
- 47:00um so the next question uh it's from
- 47:02Bruce and uh she mentions and I'm not
- 47:05sure who this person is but there is
- 47:07another person on the zoom apparently
- 47:08who has been on Everest
- 47:10um and maybe they would like to answer
- 47:11this as well as quick
- 47:13um but uh she asks what for those who
- 47:17have been on Everest what is what is the
- 47:18motivation to go like what what drives
- 47:21you to go and I think this is something
- 47:23that uh is sort of the big question of
- 47:25the Opera as well like why why do people
- 47:26do this what drives you to go to Everest
- 47:30Pippa can you unmute yourself
- 47:35yes okay golly this is so amazing
- 47:40um first of all my story is a little bit
- 47:43quite a lot different actually
- 47:45um I had always dreamed of going to
- 47:48every space camp I didn't actually want
- 47:50to go any higher
- 47:52um and I have two sons and we were
- 47:54coming back from New Zealand and we'd
- 47:55had our shots and we were ready to go uh
- 47:59they were quite quite little but anyway
- 48:00uh I was then called back to a job uh at
- 48:05the national ski Academy and I thought
- 48:07it doesn't matter we can do this anytime
- 48:10and
- 48:11um shortly after that I was diagnosed
- 48:14with MS
- 48:15I ended up in a wheelchair and um my
- 48:19sons kept saying well we're going to go
- 48:22to Everest Base Camp we're going to go
- 48:23to Aerospace never night lifting really
- 48:25I don't think so and they discovered
- 48:29something uh called a Trail Rider
- 48:31and uh in 2006
- 48:36um uh they gathered a team together and
- 48:40they took me to the base camp without
- 48:42Everest at the Trail Rider which is the
- 48:46a cross between a rickshaw
- 48:48and a wheelbarrow
- 48:50and we got to base camp uh but having
- 48:54said that
- 48:55uh I feel a bit silly telling this this
- 48:59story however I understood so much what
- 49:02you were saying is the challenge it's
- 49:04the people it's the journey
- 49:07uh since my life changed going into a
- 49:11wheelchair uh everything
- 49:14is
- 49:15off before Everest or after Everest
- 49:18because it was Monumental in our lives
- 49:21and a huge Challenge and
- 49:24um an amazing accomplishment and it also
- 49:27it was the team that got me there and it
- 49:30was tough because of the altitude
- 49:33and uh they did they could have actually
- 49:36gone by themselves they didn't have to
- 49:37push push me
- 49:39um so yeah that was my Everest Base Camp
- 49:42true yeah but anyway nothing compared
- 49:45with I'm loving everything you're saying
- 49:48uh I've followed you so much
- 49:51um and I think the Opera is going to be
- 49:53amazing we're very lucky because we're
- 49:55coming uh next week so
- 49:57thank you wonderful thank you that's
- 50:01brilliant thank you did you want to
- 50:03respond back
- 50:05well that that is once again when I was
- 50:09the point that I was making about the
- 50:12individuality of every story of the
- 50:14people who go there this is not some
- 50:16monolithic uh event and some often when
- 50:20it's portrayed in in television uh they
- 50:24they flatten all of this out so that you
- 50:27don't have any idea of the kind of
- 50:30struggles that people have and what they
- 50:33put and what they project uh into the
- 50:37significance of their own struggle to do
- 50:39this because I know a lot of people who
- 50:42summoned Everest and for the most part
- 50:44nobody gives a rat's patootie about any
- 50:47of that you know you may think it would
- 50:49be a big deal but it's not uh that that
- 50:54most all of this is done not for
- 50:58somebody else it's done for the struggle
- 50:59that you have in your own life and your
- 51:02own view of
- 51:05what you're capable of accomplishing and
- 51:09and what kind of person are you when you
- 51:11do this that you know that as a I was
- 51:14trying to State this earlier and
- 51:17probably did make it clear is you
- 51:20climbing you get harder and harder and
- 51:23harder
- 51:24goals uh and each time you put yourself
- 51:29out to a place that you've never been
- 51:32before and each time that you do it you
- 51:34don't know how you're going to react and
- 51:37that is part of the mystery of doing it
- 51:40is just to see
- 51:42what who am I what kind of person am I
- 51:45well if things get difficult
- 51:47uh and it gets hard uh
- 51:51am I going to be a good person
- 51:54am I going to be who I would like to be
- 51:57or am I what I fear I might be
- 52:03and so that that's that's the struggle
- 52:06that you have yeah
- 52:09thank you back
- 52:11anyone else having been uh to base camp
- 52:14or
- 52:16climbed it I won't tell much
- 52:20[Music]
- 52:22um so we we do have a world I'm gonna
- 52:25really about 10 more minutes or so we
- 52:26don't want to keep our guests too late
- 52:28they are on in later time zones than we
- 52:30are in in San Francisco
- 52:32um but uh before I ask this next
- 52:35question
- 52:36um if anyone does have questions and
- 52:38can't use the chat or is having
- 52:39difficulty using the chat um I will open
- 52:41it up for folks to just ask questions
- 52:43verbally as well
- 52:45uh one more question here uh from Cheryl
- 52:49um for Beck and she asked uh do Everest
- 52:52alumni so to speak uh tend to get
- 52:55together frequently or do they tend to
- 52:57hold the experience more in an isolated
- 52:58memory
- 53:00uh they hold it nicely in memory this is
- 53:03this is not an a get together with a big
- 53:07rah-rah and like I said you do this for
- 53:10individualistic reasons yeah that yes
- 53:13it's selfish uh anybody that goes there
- 53:17and puts this puts themselves at risk
- 53:19and the and in so doing also risks other
- 53:24individuals your family
- 53:27uh your wife your kids uh
- 53:31and all of the other people that love
- 53:33you it's a selfish event there's no way
- 53:36to get around that but you also at some
- 53:39level
- 53:40you feel driven to do it
- 53:42uh and whether that's healthy or not
- 53:46uh it's it I think it is common within
- 53:50the individuals that do this I don't
- 53:52care how laid-back or our Shucks they
- 53:55may be these are driven people now
- 54:02um would anyone else like to ask a
- 54:03question uh you can if you if you would
- 54:05like to just unmute yourself and ask a
- 54:07question to either of our guests a
- 54:09little more time
- 54:12and say one of the things about doing
- 54:14these projects the the project like this
- 54:16is that you know it is
- 54:19um you know who are the people you meet
- 54:21along the way and uh this has been a
- 54:23particularly uh wonderful project of
- 54:25course uh Nicole uh conducted the
- 54:28premiere and uh so and that's how I got
- 54:31to know and become such good friends
- 54:33with Nicole and colleagues and that
- 54:35we've done a number of projects
- 54:37including recently the English national
- 54:38Opera that she just conducted but of
- 54:41course getting to know Beck uh and uh
- 54:44Neil beidleman is uh who's not portrayed
- 54:46in the Opera but gave me lots of
- 54:47information he's uh one of these and and
- 54:50others um it's just been a real a real
- 54:53joy and just you know it's it's it's
- 54:55funny I feel the same way back when you
- 54:57said it was easy to talk like we talked
- 54:59before the the zoom talk then it's like
- 55:01it's like like an old friend who just
- 55:03sort of resume the conversation with and
- 55:05uh it's uh it's it's been one of the
- 55:08nicest uh things about that and of
- 55:10course working with Joby we're doing
- 55:12another Opera right now for doubt for
- 55:14Dallas Opera actually for based on the
- 55:16diving bell on the butterfly which is
- 55:18going to open in the fall
- 55:19and uh it's all because of what happened
- 55:21and and also because Beck kind of opened
- 55:23the way for this without Beck this never
- 55:25would have happened I really use Beck as
- 55:28leverage as I said at the beginning of
- 55:29this to get to the other people and I
- 55:31needed all that information uh in order
- 55:33to do it and so you just need that one
- 55:35person who's uh sort of opens the door
- 55:37and in this particular project it was
- 55:40certainly back so uh it's great to see
- 55:43him again and to see the piece happening
- 55:46here and it's also happening in London
- 55:48uh a stage version a
- 55:50um concert version with the BBC Symphony
- 55:52and the BBC chorus is happening uh next
- 55:55June and Nicole is conducting so that'll
- 55:58be wonderful as well so we're it's been
- 56:01a it's been a really a happy project one
- 56:03I'm really proud of and uh and also it's
- 56:05been a lot of fun
- 56:07so any other questions
- 56:10um there's a couple in the chat and I
- 56:11have one quick one myself personally
- 56:13that I would love to ask
- 56:15um I'm just going to jump in and throw
- 56:17that one in there quickly and it's full
- 56:18back
- 56:19um so your story has been told in so
- 56:21many different mediums across across the
- 56:23years the films and the books and and an
- 56:26opera and now an immersive Opera uh what
- 56:28what is that like I can't even imagine
- 56:30what it must be like to see your own
- 56:33story on you know presented in in so
- 56:36many different ways
- 56:38well it's it started off as a very
- 56:40interesting media experience because
- 56:43this was the first time that a story had
- 56:46ever broken worldwide on the internet uh
- 56:51there were no reporters or cameras or
- 56:53anything up there and so these people
- 56:55learned about this it was being followed
- 56:58in real time uh on the Internet by real
- 57:02time reporting and so in that sense it
- 57:04was a very unique uh introduction to the
- 57:08world of the story by a totally new form
- 57:13of uh reportage uh and it's been in a
- 57:18dozen books three movies uh and of
- 57:21course the most unique one of all which
- 57:24is the Opera
- 57:26and now it's uh it wound up as a graphic
- 57:29novel Opera uh which is takes it Beyond
- 57:33uh the my expectations for any of this
- 57:36and I'm just
- 57:38I love to see in other people's worlds
- 57:41and the creativity and the Artistry and
- 57:44the Magnificent voices uh and so I was I
- 57:48would listen to the Opera again today
- 57:51via the graphic novel and I was uh each
- 57:57time I see it in different modes I see
- 58:00something new uh because some when I saw
- 58:03it initially I was overwhelmed by the
- 58:04Magnificent staging just the physical
- 58:07presence and then I heard it in concert
- 58:10and then listening more to the voices
- 58:12and then you see it in the graphic novel
- 58:14uh and you're able to to follow a story
- 58:19better than you can in either the other
- 58:21Medias uh presentations and of course
- 58:25I'm sitting there with my big headphones
- 58:26on and the voices are such that I can
- 58:29the person is sitting in my lap as I
- 58:32listen to them sing and it's just so
- 58:34magnificent and like I said each time it
- 58:38I watch it
- 58:40it grips me it is so emotional
- 58:46thank you Becky yeah and and I think in
- 58:49the immersive version it's going to be
- 58:50you know even more so that you'll really
- 58:52feel like you're you're in in the in the
- 58:55experience with with you which is going
- 58:57to be very exciting
- 58:59um I have uh one more question here uh
- 59:03about about the Opera itself and about
- 59:05new Opera and how often um there are
- 59:08changes that happen during uh during the
- 59:10process after a number of performances
- 59:13um and this person's wondering were
- 59:14there changes in Everest uh after the of
- 59:16the first few performances
- 59:18um and if so what changed and why
- 59:22um the the odd changes do happen in
- 59:24operas
- 59:25um uh but not that much changed in
- 59:28Everest in terms of the score and the
- 59:30libretto I might be missing something
- 59:33but I don't think
- 59:34um uh this actually
- 59:37um this this piece is pretty much the
- 59:41way it was I think that is the material
- 59:44is pretty much the way it was on opening
- 59:45night
- 59:46um but that doesn't you know when things
- 59:48need to be changed we changed them we
- 59:50felt that this one was solid within with
- 59:52um uh It's a Wonderful Life which we
- 59:54opened in Houston that Jake and I did
- 59:56Jake Hagee and I did we changed it we
- 59:59changed it significantly by the time it
- 1:00:01got to San Francisco and now it's kind
- 1:00:04of codified in the in the place we like
- 1:00:05in but the English national Opera just
- 1:00:07did is was the the version the this
- 1:00:10there was a different production but the
- 1:00:12material was what we had in San
- 1:00:14Francisco we did three Productions to
- 1:00:16get it to the West there are there there
- 1:00:19are certain things in terms of the
- 1:00:21staging and the uh the production uh I
- 1:00:24think that I mean the director who
- 1:00:25directed this Leonard Folia says it
- 1:00:27takes three times to get it you know
- 1:00:28sort of the way you really really want
- 1:00:31it uh even if the production is the same
- 1:00:33just so that the lighting and and the
- 1:00:35staging and everything is really uh is
- 1:00:37on point and I think so there were some
- 1:00:40small changes but with Everest now we
- 1:00:41were pretty happy uh with it there might
- 1:00:44be forgetting some small change that we
- 1:00:46made but this one was pretty much uh uh
- 1:00:49we were happy with it when it opened and
- 1:00:51we're still happy with it it's a very
- 1:00:53solid solid work solid type 70 minutes
- 1:00:56of Opera which is the perfect length I
- 1:00:58think
- 1:01:01so I'm going to combine two questions
- 1:01:02here both for Beck
- 1:01:04um uh the first question was uh for Beck
- 1:01:07whether you're still uh mountaineering
- 1:01:10um and also uh who who rescued you or
- 1:01:13was there someone who rescued you from
- 1:01:15the tent when uh like from uh when you
- 1:01:19when you were left there
- 1:01:21well let me start with the second
- 1:01:23question first uh when I managed to wake
- 1:01:26up in the tent still alive uh the camp
- 1:01:29was pretty much deserted there were only
- 1:01:31three other people there beside myself
- 1:01:34but one of them was John krakauer and I
- 1:01:37managed to get his attention and he
- 1:01:40called over Pete Athens and Todd
- 1:01:42Burleson who are both professional
- 1:01:44guides and they helped me down about a
- 1:01:48quarter of the way uh toward camp three
- 1:01:51and then the IMAX
- 1:01:53uh film crew David beshears and Ed
- 1:01:58visters uh
- 1:02:01were there to take Dogwood back into
- 1:02:03Camp too uh then we hit the next day we
- 1:02:06had the world's highest helicopter
- 1:02:07rescue so it was we were doing a lot of
- 1:02:09interesting things in the short period
- 1:02:11of time but basically I walked out on my
- 1:02:14own legs uh I'm just uh
- 1:02:18still in pretty decent condition
- 1:02:20considering the degree of damage uh I
- 1:02:24don't do mountaineering anymore I wasn't
- 1:02:26holding my paws up but the degree of
- 1:02:29frostbite that I suffered was uh pretty
- 1:02:32severe it took off the center part of my
- 1:02:35face both of my hands uh and the like
- 1:02:38and uh so I can't stand the uh the
- 1:02:44insult of cold
- 1:02:45uh
- 1:02:47the way I used to be able to do so and
- 1:02:50so I that really is not the risk reward
- 1:02:53on that is just uh not worth considering
- 1:02:56all right
- 1:02:58it's very unsettable
- 1:03:01um all right I'm gonna throw it over for
- 1:03:03one more question and then we do have to
- 1:03:05let our guests go if there is any final
- 1:03:07final questions
- 1:03:10uh for the group from the group
- 1:03:12yeah
- 1:03:14do you still keep in touch with Matt and
- 1:03:16Casey
- 1:03:19uh I'm not
- 1:03:22talked to him in a fair while uh he's
- 1:03:27obviously an extraordinary human being
- 1:03:30uh and we did have an opportunity to
- 1:03:33spend several times together
- 1:03:35uh after that uh he became quite famous
- 1:03:39uh throughout the world and famous
- 1:03:42certainly within Nepal uh and he was
- 1:03:48and when I talk about this story
- 1:03:51my statement generally is the of all the
- 1:03:55people involved he's the one that is
- 1:03:57most impressive to me uh and
- 1:04:02some of this is is kind of funny we went
- 1:04:05together to see the IMAX film Everest at
- 1:04:09the Fort Worth Science Museum uh and of
- 1:04:12course we're sitting there and as
- 1:04:15you know hey pictures of him flying the
- 1:04:19uh helicopter uh one of the only people
- 1:04:22in the world that could do such a thing
- 1:04:25and somebody was out front with a toy
- 1:04:27helicopter uh flying it around and I'm
- 1:04:31thinking to myself these people have no
- 1:04:33idea that they're you know standing next
- 1:04:36to such an extraordinary
- 1:04:39human being uh and one of the things
- 1:04:43that I remember so particularly about
- 1:04:46that because I was I really you know was
- 1:04:49very grateful to him uh and he you know
- 1:04:53and later visits and stuff he said you
- 1:04:55know
- 1:04:56uh you're one of the very few people
- 1:04:58that ever really thanked me for saving
- 1:05:00them
- 1:05:01uh I guess we just expect
- 1:05:04that our heroes are always going to be
- 1:05:06there
- 1:05:08and for me he was and he's just an
- 1:05:11amazing person
- 1:05:12uh and so
- 1:05:14uh Madan is just a
- 1:05:17you know
- 1:05:19I I you can't give him enough credit
- 1:05:23uh for what he did just with not just
- 1:05:26there but in all the Myriad times that
- 1:05:30he helped people out and save people and
- 1:05:32rescued people and that's uh and that's
- 1:05:35true for so many of the individuals
- 1:05:37whose lives work is to do exactly what
- 1:05:40he does every day
- 1:05:42so no
- 1:05:44foreign
- 1:05:48I think we do need to wrap it up here uh
- 1:05:51I think I thank you all for
- 1:05:53um for joining us this evening the last
- 1:05:55question that I see here was about the
- 1:05:56recording of this this program which we
- 1:05:58will be sharing on our website
- 1:06:00um on our preparallel.org on the the
- 1:06:02enhance your experience page
- 1:06:04um which is kind of is has a whole bunch
- 1:06:06of resources and videos and information
- 1:06:07about the production
- 1:06:09um and we'll be adding this this
- 1:06:10incredible conversation
- 1:06:12um so please join me in thanking uh our
- 1:06:14wonderful guests Gene shear and Beck
- 1:06:16weathers for being with us tonight thank
- 1:06:18you so much thank you folks appreciate
- 1:06:20it
- 1:06:22appreciate it thank you so much and uh
- 1:06:25we'll see you hopefully all of you at uh
- 1:06:28at Everest in the most experience uh in
- 1:06:30the coming weeks thank you have a good
- 1:06:32night I'll give you a call soon okay
- 1:06:37take care all
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Gene Scheer In Conversation with Beck Weathers - Everest by Opera Parallèle, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 11,168 words across 1,573 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.