***FULL DEBATE!*** Mohammed Hijab vs. David Wood | Tawheed vs. Trinity — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:22Um before we start, we're going to have
- 0:24a Quran or recitation by
- 0:27uh for a few minutes.
- 0:51[Music]
- 0:56Bismillah. for
- 1:26inch. for
- 1:53[Music]
- 1:56Allah. for
- 1:59[Music]
- 2:08[Applause]
- 2:12[Music]
- 2:26for
- 2:50the
- 2:52speech. for
- 3:03[Music]
- 3:22the
- 3:36for
- 3:52for
- 4:00[Music]
- 4:19what you for
- 4:30[Music]
- 4:51foreign.
- 5:05[Music]
- 5:13[Music]
- 5:29What else?
- 5:54Allah
- 6:01[Music]
- 6:08who love you.
- 6:15Alhamdulillah.
- 6:21York College Muslim Student Association
- 6:24is very proud to present this event. And
- 6:26before we start this event, we actually
- 6:28want to thank our sponsors uh grassroots
- 6:30da uh Muslims giving back and uh Salam
- 6:35initiative. So we have brother Muhammad
- 6:37Hijazzi who's going to give us one
- 6:39minute speech before we start. Go ahead
- 6:42brother.
- 6:49Alhamdulillah
- 6:52your brother Mustafa.
- 6:55Um so I'm basically here to represent
- 6:58the and introduce the co-sponsors mainly
- 7:01we have grassroots daen NYC Muslims
- 7:04giving back and salam. So just to run
- 7:09through each of them. So Grassroots
- 7:10DAWAN NYC is a DA organization more
- 7:14focusing on street DA initiatives in the
- 7:17tri-state area mainly New York City. And
- 7:20so what we do is we go out and we convey
- 7:22the call and uh basically set up da
- 7:26booths in our New York areas and popular
- 7:31areas such as Union Square Park, Time
- 7:33Square, different areas in the Bronx, in
- 7:36the Queens, everywhere that you could
- 7:37possibly think of in in the New York
- 7:39burrows. And so this is a call to invite
- 7:43each and every one of you to join this
- 7:45initiative. Allah subhana t says in
- 7:47surah alan in chapter 3 verse 104
- 7:51where Allah says um let there arise from
- 7:54you a small group or a nation that
- 7:56enjoins in good and forbids evil and
- 7:58they are the successful
- 8:00and Allah also tells us in chapter 3 64
- 8:04the same surah
- 8:12it says all people of the scripture come
- 8:14to common terms between us and you that
- 8:16we worship the one true God and not
- 8:19ascribe any partners to him. And so this
- 8:22is highly relevant to to today's debate.
- 8:25Uh this is essentially a DA initiative
- 8:28and there are much more to come. So
- 8:30please join this join the effort. Uh
- 8:33visit our Facebook uh grassroots daenyc
- 8:36for more information. As for Muslims
- 8:37giving back similar work da but they
- 8:41also focus on uh providing to the
- 8:43homeless and the needy. So if you're
- 8:44interested, visit uh MGB MGB inshallah.
- 8:48And finally, Salam is actually the
- 8:50organization that Muhammad Hijab and Ali
- 8:53Dawa work uh closely with. In fact,
- 8:55they're the founders and initiators of
- 8:58of that organization. And so you can
- 9:00find more information by going on uh
- 9:03their site. uh specifically I think uh
- 9:06it would be of interest to look into
- 9:07their podcast which deals with a lot of
- 9:09the palemics and misconceptions
- 9:12um in Islam today and so and may Allahh
- 9:17make this a fruitful evening.
- 9:26Uh coming up next introducing him
- 9:28himself is brother brother Ali Dawa.
- 9:33[Applause]
- 9:36[Music]
- 9:42Before I start I want to praise Allah
- 9:43subhana wa tala the most merciful, the
- 9:45most just. All praises, glory and
- 9:47gratitude belong to him for the works
- 9:48that we do. Um, as you guys know from
- 9:51the YouTube videos that we do, uh, for
- 9:53the past couple of years, alhamdulillah,
- 9:55we've reached a vast amount of people.
- 9:57Alhamdulillah, in total, we've reached
- 9:5852 million people. Every month, we reach
- 10:012 to3 million people. We've set up this
- 10:03organization, not just me, myself, and
- 10:04Muhammad. We shouldn't just get the
- 10:06credit. We have our teachers, Sheh
- 10:08Muhammad, Sheh Muhammad, and the whole
- 10:10team. May Allah bless every single one
- 10:12of them. Salam stands for sharing,
- 10:14affection, love, and mercy. at the times
- 10:17that we live um sadly a lot of people
- 10:19have hijacked our religion and be it the
- 10:22extremist Muslims don't need to mention
- 10:24their name you guys know what I'm
- 10:26talking about and be it non-Muslims who
- 10:28lie about religion on a constant basis
- 10:30so Islam is there to give the people a
- 10:32pure understanding by deconstructing
- 10:35false narratives and reconstructing
- 10:37purer minds so people can understand the
- 10:39true essence of Islam so that is what
- 10:41salam is about you can check out our
- 10:42website inshallah you can check out
- 10:44check out our YouTube know and that's
- 10:46exactly what we're here to do and
- 10:48today's debate is inshallah a start of
- 10:50that and we thank every single one of
- 10:51you guys who have come here today may
- 10:53Allah bless you guys make dua inshallah
- 10:55this go successful and that's about may
- 10:57Allah grant you guysam
- 11:04thank you very much brother Alawa so
- 11:06before we start this event I want to
- 11:08make sure uh to inform people why we are
- 11:10hosting this event as your college
- 11:12Muslim student at MSA we're so we're
- 11:14seeking to host a respectful ful and
- 11:15friendly dialogue debate between two
- 11:17keing figures David Wood and Muhammad
- 11:19Hijab. Both of these respected figures
- 11:21have expertise in their core beliefs.
- 11:24That said, the topic of the debate will
- 11:25be trinity or the debate will focus on
- 11:28the essence of God from both Christian
- 11:30and Muslim perspectives. It will be a it
- 11:33will be an educational discussion
- 11:34platform expanding on core theological
- 11:37concepts. There will be significant
- 11:39references exchanged both from the Quran
- 11:41and the Bible. Uh so before we start I
- 11:45just want to make sure that the audience
- 11:46has have this clear. Uh uh we there are
- 11:50going to be multiple opinions in this in
- 11:53this debate. So I don't want anyone to
- 11:55feel offended. This is we're here to
- 11:57learn about each other's p uh each
- 11:59other's opinions. If you feel easily
- 12:01offended please do not react. And at the
- 12:04same time if any of the speakers make
- 12:06any uh make any statement that you feel
- 12:08that is a very good statement or you
- 12:10feel that you agree with clapping is
- 12:12sufficient. We don't want any verbal
- 12:14cheering or something like that. This is
- 12:16a very this is a very educational
- 12:17debate. Clapping is sufficient. So
- 12:20without further ado I would like to
- 12:21introduce my co-odderator
- 12:23uh Bareim Raheem.
- 12:26[Applause]
- 12:32Uh so this is how the format of the
- 12:34debate is going to start. Um we're going
- 12:36to have 20 minute opening statements for
- 12:39each speaker. Then is there there's
- 12:41going to be 12-minute first rebuttals
- 12:42and then 8 minute second rebuttals. Then
- 12:44crossfire examination where where the
- 12:46speakers will be asking each other
- 12:48questions. Each speaker will have six
- 12:50questions to ask the other speaker and
- 12:51they will take two minutes to answer
- 12:53each of the questions. Then we're going
- 12:54to have five minute conclusions. Then as
- 12:56you can see there are mics in at the
- 12:58front where there's going to be a Q&A
- 13:00session where you can ask uh where you
- 13:02can ask uh our brothers uh our brother
- 13:06Muhammad Hijab and David Wood any
- 13:09questions if you have please keep
- 13:10everything respectful. If there's if
- 13:13there are any any disrespectful remarks
- 13:15you you will be escorted out. So without
- 13:18further ado introducing our first
- 13:20speaker Dr. Dr. David Wood.
- 13:23[Music]
- 13:24[Applause]
- 13:29So, just a little background on Dr.
- 13:30David Wood. He's a Christian evangelist
- 13:32and preacher. David Wood is a member of
- 13:34a society of Christian philosophers, the
- 13:36Evangelical Philosophical Society, and
- 13:39the Hume Society. He was a former
- 13:41atheist. David became a Christian after
- 13:43examining the historical evidence of the
- 13:44resurrection of Jesus. He's a
- 13:46contributor to the books Evidence for
- 13:49God, 50 Arguments for Faith from the
- 13:52Bible, History, Philosophy, and Science.
- 13:54Defending the resurrection and true
- 13:56reason, Christian responses to the
- 13:58challenge of atheism. David has a PhD in
- 14:01philosophy from for Ford for Fort
- 14:03University and has been in more than 60
- 14:05moderated public debates with Muslim,
- 14:07atheists, and other Christians. And
- 14:09that's a little background on our first
- 14:11key speaker, Dr. David Wood. And without
- 14:13further ado, introducing our uh his
- 14:16opposition uh brother Muhammad Hijab.
- 14:19[Applause]
- 14:25[Music]
- 14:27A little background on uh Muhammad
- 14:29Hijab. He's an academic researcher and
- 14:31media host. Uh he is a debater and
- 14:33public speaker who engages in
- 14:35discussions in pymics on wide variety of
- 14:37topics including religion, politics and
- 14:39society. He completed a politics degree
- 14:41and a master's in history from Queens
- 14:43Mary University. He has taught and
- 14:44instructed courses on humanities and
- 14:46languages in many contexts. He has
- 14:48numerous a jazz and some Islamic
- 14:50sciences and has studied in multiple
- 14:52Islamic seminaries in including the
- 14:54Shankiti Institute which employs a
- 14:56traditional Maisian style of teaching
- 14:58the sacred sciences. Mr. Hijab is
- 15:00currently doing further post-graduate
- 15:02research in Islamic studies at the
- 15:03school of advanced study university of
- 15:05London. Uh so uh like I said just please
- 15:09keep everything that I said in mind and
- 15:12uh I think we will start with u um
- 15:15brother Muhammad Hijab giving us his
- 15:1720-minut opening statement.
- 15:20[Applause]
- 15:20[Music]
- 15:23[Applause]
- 15:24[Music]
- 15:26You know, the Quran tells us
- 15:34the first thing we're asked to do when
- 15:35we're engaging with Christian people is
- 15:37to come to common terms that we worship
- 15:40none but Allah subhana wa ta'ala. And
- 15:41that's something we really need to think
- 15:42about. We need to think about the common
- 15:45grounds that we have with Christians.
- 15:47There's lots in common.
- 15:49We believe in Jesus Christ. We believe
- 15:50in the Messiah. We believe in him. We
- 15:53love the Messiah. We believe Jesus. We
- 15:56believe that he was born from the Virgin
- 15:58Mary. There's a whole chapter in the
- 15:59Quran dedicated to her.
- 16:02But of course, the elephant in the room
- 16:04or the difference of opinion is in the
- 16:07fact that we as Muslims do not believe
- 16:10that Jesus was divine or that the Holy
- 16:13Spirit is divine.
- 16:15Today's discussion, ladies and
- 16:17gentlemen, is about tohed and trinity.
- 16:21[Music]
- 16:23is monotheism
- 16:25to believe and worship in one god. The
- 16:27Quran says
- 16:30that say he is Allah one and only the
- 16:32eternally besought of all the sovereign.
- 16:35The trinity is defined by the aanasia
- 16:38creed in 500 AD athanasian creed as one
- 16:43divine person that one divine being
- 16:46divided into three divided persons the
- 16:48father the son and the holy spirit. The
- 16:49father is God. The son is God. The holy
- 16:53spirit is God. But there are not three
- 16:55gods but one god.
- 16:57It goes the father is almighty. The son
- 17:00is almighty. And the holy spirit is
- 17:02almighty. But there are not three
- 17:03almighties. There's one almighty. This
- 17:05is what the aanian creed says. Now to be
- 17:09honest with you, I've heard David Wood
- 17:11speak before. And I've noticed that
- 17:13there are three common fallacies that he
- 17:15falls into quite often. One of them is a
- 17:18fallacy called the tukoqui fallacy which
- 17:21is an appeal to hypocrisy.
- 17:23Another one is a straw man and a third
- 17:25one is the red herring. These three
- 17:28fallacies are employed by him quite
- 17:30often and he talks about Islam
- 17:34extensively as you guys may know in a
- 17:36negative way. Salam initiative has put
- 17:39up a database
- 17:41of all of the major misconceptions
- 17:44against Islam being answered and this
- 17:46can be seen in the link below.
- 17:48I also want to give credit to
- 17:51um one team member who has made a
- 17:54website called many prophets one message
- 17:57which can also be seen in the link
- 17:58below. You can see more information
- 18:00about that. Now to cut straight into it,
- 18:04the question now is this.
- 18:08The question is
- 18:10when we look at the Old Testament,
- 18:13do we find this idea of the Nyian
- 18:16Trinity? Because the Nyian trinity is
- 18:19very specific after the Constantinople
- 18:22creed in 381. The idea that the father,
- 18:25the son, and the holy spirit are three
- 18:27co-equal
- 18:29co-eternal independent beings. Remember
- 18:32those words co-equal co-eternal
- 18:34independent
- 18:36persons of the one being of God. This is
- 18:40the nian understanding of the trinity.
- 18:43Now having said that guys when you look
- 18:45at the old testament
- 18:47do we see this? Because when we look at
- 18:48the Old Testament, we find the shapter
- 18:516:4 She is Adonai
- 18:55here. O Israel, my Lord, our Lord, is
- 18:58one Lord.
- 19:00Here when you look at the first
- 19:02commandment, chapter 20:3 of Exodus, you
- 19:05find there's no God beside me. I your
- 19:07Lord and there's no God beside me. You
- 19:09find in Isaiah 43:1,
- 19:12once again, the discussion of I am your
- 19:14God and besides me there is no savior.
- 19:18Now, someone might argue, but the word
- 19:20Elohim, and this is the weakness of the
- 19:23argument, it's a weak linguistic
- 19:25argument. The word Elohim is a majestic
- 19:26plural, they would argue.
- 19:30Look, there are 9,000 pronouns in the
- 19:34Bible which relate to God's name. Let's
- 19:37take for example Genesis 1:1.
- 19:46Ba. Elohim. The word Ba means he
- 19:50created. Whenever you find a pronoun in
- 19:55the Old Testament referring to Elohim,
- 19:59you will always find it in third person
- 20:03male
- 20:05singular.
- 20:06One more time. Third person male
- 20:09singular. You don't find a plural
- 20:11version of that.
- 20:12You don't find a pronoun which is
- 20:14pluralized.
- 20:16So now the question would be is this a
- 20:19Jew who is acquainted with the Torah
- 20:20with the Old Testament. Why would one
- 20:23ask him to realign his belief his
- 20:25theological doctrines into believing in
- 20:28a triune God when in fact he's been
- 20:32instructed quite explicitly in fact in
- 20:34the Old Testament not to break the
- 20:36commandments.
- 20:39You see, it gets a little bit more
- 20:42interesting even when you look at the
- 20:43New Testament. Now, we know the New
- 20:44Testament
- 20:46has different authors. There's 27 books
- 20:48of the New Testament. You've got Paul
- 20:50who's written from 7 to 13 books. And
- 20:52there's dispute as to exactly how much
- 20:54he's written. John written many books.
- 20:56Who is John? We don't know who John is,
- 20:57by the way. We don't know who John is.
- 20:59But yes, Paul had a kind of exaltation
- 21:03Christology. There's no doubt he did
- 21:06believe that Jesus was divine. And a
- 21:08good example of that is the second
- 21:10Philippians the hymn.
- 21:13But he believed in a kind of
- 21:15subordinationism. And how do we know
- 21:17that? Because if you look at line 9 to
- 21:1911, it's quite explicit that God gives
- 21:23him the name. So he didn't have it
- 21:25before. Jesus did not have the name
- 21:27before and he makes it above all names.
- 21:30So that he believes in a kind of
- 21:31subordination. Now what is
- 21:32subordinationism? It's a hierarchy
- 21:34within the trinity. Remember we said the
- 21:35nian trinity is three co-equal
- 21:38co-eternal
- 21:40persons of the the godhead. Paul didn't
- 21:42believe this. He believed in a
- 21:44hierarchy. John believed in an
- 21:46incarnation christologology.
- 21:48In the beginning was the word and the
- 21:49word was with god. Everyone knows the
- 21:51prologue. John chapter 1. Yeah.
- 21:55But the question is this. Who is who is
- 21:56John? His his gospel was found some 95
- 21:59AD. This is the time it was found. 95
- 22:01AD. That's some 65 years after Jesus's
- 22:05disappearance. The irony of all
- 22:09is that you'll find in the Gospel of
- 22:11John,
- 22:13for example, passages like John 17:3
- 22:18where it explicitly mentions that the
- 22:20father is the only true God. Explicitly
- 22:23mentions this. And this was such a thorn
- 22:26in the side of the church fathers that
- 22:30Augustine,
- 22:31a major church father who died 430 AD
- 22:35and who wrote who wrote an ex Jesus on
- 22:38John, do you know what he said? He
- 22:41rearranged the words of John 17:3. He
- 22:46changed the word order so as to make
- 22:49Jesus and the father the true gods. This
- 22:52is how severe it was.
- 22:55When you find Mark 12 29,
- 23:00the Jew came to Jesus asking how to be
- 23:03saved. And what did Jesus say? Did Jesus
- 23:06say, and Mark, by the way, is the most
- 23:08ancient manuscript of all of the
- 23:11gospels, most ancient gospels.
- 23:15What did Jesus say? Did he say you have
- 23:18to believe in the father, the son, and
- 23:19the holy spirit as co-equal, co-eternal,
- 23:21independent beings? He said no. He said
- 23:25he referred him to the shema chapter 6:4
- 23:28of Deuteronomy. That's what he referred
- 23:31him to. He didn't tell him believe me as
- 23:33God or believe the Holy Spirit is God or
- 23:35all these things. No. So you see really
- 23:39and truly the question is where do
- 23:40people Christians today where do they
- 23:42get their information of the Trinity?
- 23:44You'll find that in Matthew 28:1 19, it
- 23:50talks about it's it's called the
- 23:52baptismal formula where the father, the
- 23:54son, and the holy spirit is mentioned.
- 23:55Go in the way baptizing the way the
- 23:57father, the son, and the holy spirit.
- 23:59And so Christians use this as to prove,
- 24:01okay, the trinity is in the bible now.
- 24:04They use this to say, look, the trinity
- 24:06is in the bible now. But why don't they
- 24:08look at Luke 9:26?
- 24:11Because Luke 9:26 has a different
- 24:13triadic formula where there's the
- 24:15father, the son, and the holy angels.
- 24:18Yes, the holy angels, not the holy
- 24:21spirit. So why don't we infer a trinity
- 24:24from this? This is the question.
- 24:27Now,
- 24:29we've had these debates before and
- 24:30they've been done before and it's
- 24:33usually, okay, we'll get a vague verse
- 24:34here, an ambiguous verse here, and we'll
- 24:36start talking about these things. But
- 24:38here's an interesting question. Now,
- 24:41how did the earliest generations of
- 24:44Christians interpret the New Testament
- 24:47corpus?
- 24:49You have church fathers who are the most
- 24:52learned men of Christendom,
- 24:56people like Clement of Rome, Polycarp
- 25:00Origin,
- 25:02people like those individuals.
- 25:05None of those church fathers for the
- 25:08first 300 years, listen to what I'm
- 25:11saying, none of those church fathers for
- 25:15the first 300 years of church history
- 25:19inferred a nyan trinity from this. Can
- 25:24you imagine 300 years?
- 25:2910 minutes. Even Tertullion who died 240
- 25:33AD. Tertullan who dubbed or coined the
- 25:36term trinitas
- 25:38which was later translated into trinity.
- 25:41He was a subordinationist.
- 25:43He believed the hierarchy within the
- 25:46different persons of the godhead.
- 25:50The interesting point here is you have
- 25:53someone like
- 25:56you have someone like Helopoulos.
- 26:00He
- 26:02was taught by Iranius,
- 26:04massive church father. Justin Martr,
- 26:07massive church father. He taught origin
- 26:09of Alexandria, massive church father.
- 26:12And he writes in his book against the
- 26:13heresies in chapter 22. What does he
- 26:15write? He talks about this group called
- 26:17the Ebianites who were around around 70
- 26:21AD,
- 26:2440 years after the disappearance of
- 26:26Jesus. and they believed that Jesus was
- 26:30not God, that he was a prophet
- 26:34and that he was the Messiah.
- 26:38There were other groups like the
- 26:39monarchists who believed the non-ivinity
- 26:42of Jesus. It wasn't just the Ebianites.
- 26:44Some monarchists also believed that
- 26:45Jesus was not divine in the way that
- 26:48trinitarians make it out to be.
- 26:50No one spoke about the Holy Spirit being
- 26:53God co-equal and co-eternal and
- 26:55independent with the father and the son
- 26:58in the first 300 years. That discussion
- 27:00is completely gone.
- 27:04So this is quite interesting ladies and
- 27:07gentlemen. Do you know why? Because you
- 27:09could say from this that where the
- 27:13Islamic position of the non-ivinity of
- 27:16Jesus and the non-ivinity of the Holy
- 27:18Spirit
- 27:20was represented in the early church. The
- 27:24Nyian trinitarian position was not say
- 27:27that one more time. He wants to hear it.
- 27:31Okay.
- 27:33where the Islamic position
- 27:36of the non-ivinity
- 27:39of Jesus Christ was present and the non-
- 27:43divinity of the Holy Spirit was present
- 27:45in early Christian church history. The
- 27:48Nyian
- 27:50trinitarian understanding of the
- 27:51postconstant creed was not. Prove me
- 27:55wrong, David. Prove me wrong. Give me
- 27:58one person for the first 300 years of
- 28:01church history that detailed co-equal,
- 28:04co-eternal, independent, father, son,
- 28:07holy spirit. Give me, silence me. Prove
- 28:11me wrong. I want to be proven wrong
- 28:13today. I want to be proven wrong today.
- 28:16Silence me.
- 28:18Tell me one church father for the first
- 28:20300 years of church history that said
- 28:22the Holy Spirit was co-equal,
- 28:24co-eternal, independent with the father
- 28:26and son. Please, please give me the give
- 28:29me the records. It's a historical
- 28:30investigation. Just give me one. I will
- 28:32be quiet. I will apologize. I will
- 28:34apologize in front of everyone.
- 28:36I will apologize in front of everyone.
- 28:38Yes.
- 28:41Now,
- 28:43it gets a little bit more sticky than
- 28:44that because if you look at a book
- 28:46called the Christian doctrines, early
- 28:48Christian doctrines by J& D. Kelly,
- 28:49conservative Christian scholar, he
- 28:51details exactly how this trinitarian
- 28:53nian trinitarian uh thing came about. If
- 28:56you look at chapter 5, it's a very
- 28:57interesting read. Go and read it. It
- 28:59says that you had for example Athanasius
- 29:01who was a very ardent trinitarian around
- 29:04Nyian times. And then you have Hillary
- 29:06of Pontiers. They were advocating the
- 29:08trinitarian position. Then you had the
- 29:09Capidoshian fathers who are Greg Gregory
- 29:12of Nisanas, Gregor of Nissa and Basel
- 29:14the Great. And they Basel the soal
- 29:16great. They are the ones who advanced
- 29:18the trinitarian position. The question
- 29:20is who gave those guys the authority to
- 29:21to interpret text like this and to
- 29:25overrule all the things that came
- 29:26before? Why? Now
- 29:30the last thing I want to talk about is
- 29:31the rationality of the trinity because
- 29:33this has to be mentioned. Now the the
- 29:35trinity as Thomas Jefferson mentioned is
- 29:38an unintelligible
- 29:39this is what he says an unintelligible
- 29:42idea of platonic mysticisms that three
- 29:45are one.
- 29:47It's a contradiction, ladies and
- 29:48gentlemen, that you have fathers
- 29:50almighty, son almighty, uh, holy spirit
- 29:53is almighty, but there are not three
- 29:55almighties, but one almighty.
- 29:58That's a contradiction. That's why
- 29:59Randolph Ros Ross wrote in his book,
- 30:01Common Sense Christianity, talking about
- 30:03the hypothatic union because now you
- 30:05have Jesus who's 100% man and 100% God.
- 30:09Tell me what is a contradiction if that
- 30:11isn't. It's like saying X is 100% a
- 30:14square and 100% a circle.
- 30:19Rand Frost, he dismissed it. He says
- 30:20impossible. I can't believe this. He's a
- 30:22Christian.
- 30:24Now, as is mentioned in 5 minutes left
- 30:26in
- 30:26in the introduction, in the
- 30:27introduction, he he mentioned that David
- 30:30Wood is part of the Evangelical
- 30:31Christian Philosophical Society. his
- 30:33boss and superior someone called Paul
- 30:34Copen Paul Copen wrote a whole thing
- 30:37talking about because talking about
- 30:39social trinitarianism and basically he
- 30:41tries to reason in the same way as Nabil
- 30:43Kureshi did in his previous debate by
- 30:44the way with Shabir Ali he says that
- 30:45look the way it works is he said look
- 30:48I'm a being and you're a being yes I am
- 30:51Muhammad hijab I'm a being I'm a human
- 30:54being David is a human being but how is
- 30:58differentiated from who that's what he
- 31:00said how is differentiated from This is
- 31:02the idea that Paul Copen and William
- 31:04Lane Craig and these social trinitarians
- 31:07believe in that how is differentiated
- 31:09from who.
- 31:11That's not correct. That's false. You
- 31:13know why? Because you can only
- 31:14differentiate from how from who when you
- 31:17have a multiplicity of instantiations in
- 31:19any given genus. Say that one more time.
- 31:21When you have a multiplicity of
- 31:22instantiations in any given genus in any
- 31:25given class, let me tell you what I
- 31:26mean. I can't differentiate between me,
- 31:29Muhammad Higab, and David Wood,
- 31:32unless there's two of us. Because if
- 31:35there was one human being, the how, the
- 31:38who would be that the what. Say that one
- 31:40more time. If there was one human being,
- 31:42the who would be the what and the what
- 31:44would be the who. There would be no
- 31:46differentiation. You have to establish.
- 31:48Now and this is the third thing I want
- 31:49to say. How you can have a
- 31:51differentiation from who and how without
- 31:54having a multiplicity of instantiations
- 31:57in any given genus
- 32:00which means you have to admit first that
- 32:02there was more than one God for you to
- 32:04differentiate between them as persons.
- 32:07And by the way this is an unbiblical
- 32:08unscriptural thing. The differentiation
- 32:10between person and a being. It's an
- 32:15unbiblical thing. I would like to see if
- 32:16it is in the Bible where it is in the
- 32:18Bible. So, just to summarize what I've
- 32:21said because I've only got 3 minutes
- 32:22left.
- 32:24These are the questions I want the
- 32:26answers to today. Question one,
- 32:30why is it that in the Old Testament you
- 32:33do not find the Trinity mentioned or
- 32:36inferred?
- 32:38And if it was inferred, why haven't the
- 32:40rabbis, the Jewish scholars for 4,000
- 32:44years of Hebrew history inferred it?
- 32:47That's question one. Question two,
- 32:50how is it the case that if the Trinity
- 32:54is explicit in the New Testament that
- 32:56for 300 years of church history, Nyian
- 33:00trinitarianism was not inferred by the
- 33:03church fathers?
- 33:06Question three.
- 33:08Where? Give me one person of the first
- 33:12300 years that says that the Holy Spirit
- 33:15was co-eternal, co-equal, independent
- 33:18with God. One name. I will apologize in
- 33:22front of everyone today. Yes, I will
- 33:25apologize.
- 33:26Question four,
- 33:29how is it the case
- 33:32that how can you rationalize
- 33:35this contradiction of the trinity when
- 33:38you have a hypoatic union, someone who's
- 33:41100% man and 100% God? Are you telling
- 33:44me to believe in a squared circle today,
- 33:46sir?
- 33:48Is that the is that what you have for
- 33:51me? You want me to become a trinitarian
- 33:53square circle and then you have another
- 33:55thing. The father is almighty. The son
- 33:58is almighty and the holy spirit is
- 33:59almighty. The Quran refuses. Chapter 23
- 34:00verse 91.
- 34:04If this was the case, they would have
- 34:05tried to outstrip each other. Deal with
- 34:07the Quranic argument. You like to attack
- 34:09the Quran. You will see today that the
- 34:11Quranic argument will suffocate you. It
- 34:13will suffocate you.
- 34:18Number
- 34:19[Applause]
- 34:24five. One minute left.
- 34:27In fact, I think four questions is a lot
- 34:31for this man. If you could do with four,
- 34:34I'll be grateful to him. I want to say
- 34:36one thing before I before I You might be
- 34:40thinking, why are you being quite firm
- 34:41with this man today?
- 34:43You know James White, he's a very
- 34:44respectable scholar of Christianity and
- 34:46he's a good man. Yes, he is. And he
- 34:50refuted this man because of his mockery.
- 34:52This man makes mockumentaries against
- 34:54Muslims. And he refuted him on the basis
- 34:57of a verse in the Bible, 1 Peter 3:15,
- 35:00where it says, "Be respectful and
- 35:02honorable." What is the point of causing
- 35:04social discohion?
- 35:07What is the point of attacking a people,
- 35:09making a mockumentary of Muslims,
- 35:11drawing the prophet, uh, putting him in
- 35:13the thumbnail, all those things? And,
- 35:15you know, it's going to offend the
- 35:16Muslim community. Isn't it high time in
- 35:18the age of
- 35:20Isn't it high time in the age of
- 35:21Islamophobia and racism that we stop
- 35:23this?
- 35:30[Music]
- 35:33[Applause]
- 35:35Uh thank you very much uh brother
- 35:38Muhammad Haj for that wonderful opening
- 35:39statement. And now without further ado
- 35:42we have Dr. David Wood with his first 20
- 35:44minutes of opening statement.
- 35:49[Applause]
- 35:50[Music]
- 35:51[Applause]
- 35:53[Music]
- 35:55He jammed this thing in there.
- 35:58All right, I'll just leave it like that.
- 36:00Can't overcome that strength.
- 36:03All right. Well, good evening. I'd like
- 36:05to thank uh Muhammad Hijab for
- 36:09challenging me to this debate and for
- 36:11crossing the Atlantic Ocean so that uh
- 36:13we can share our thoughts with you. Uh,
- 36:15I'd also like to thank uh Grassroots
- 36:17Dawa and the Muslim Students Association
- 36:20and uh all the other groups that were
- 36:22involved in organizing and uh planning
- 36:26and hosting. Um my prediction is that
- 36:30tonight will be what uh what young
- 36:33people call epic.
- 36:36See now what's the difference between
- 36:38the trinity
- 36:40and
- 36:43well one is admittedly
- 36:46so utterly confusing that people wonder
- 36:49how it can possibly be true. The other
- 36:53is the trinity.
- 36:55Yes, you're going to find out that
- 36:58I think that the doctrine of talhed
- 37:00which oddly enough we didn't hear much
- 37:02about in Muhammad hijab's opening
- 37:04statement. Uh, I'm convinced that the
- 37:06doctrine of at least as it was taught by
- 37:08Muhammad is vastly more confusing than
- 37:11we hear about today. So, let's compare
- 37:15them. And we'll start with the trinity.
- 37:18Why do Christians believe in the
- 37:20doctrine of the trinity?
- 37:24We believe it because we are forced into
- 37:26this view by the triune God. Not because
- 37:29of uh church councils. The church
- 37:31councils were forced into that view by
- 37:34the triune God. Um
- 37:40for Christians,
- 37:42we have certain amount of data that we
- 37:44work with. Everyone has some data,
- 37:46right? We look around, we see the world,
- 37:47we see that it's organized in certain
- 37:49ways. We know that there's a moral law.
- 37:50There are hundreds of millions of people
- 37:52in the world today who believe that they
- 37:53have witnessed miracles. All of this uh
- 37:56helps us formulate a concept of God. Uh
- 37:58but Christians also have the scriptures,
- 38:01the Old Testament and the New Testament.
- 38:03And when we start reading uh the
- 38:06scriptures, things get very interesting
- 38:08very quickly. Um so these are the first
- 38:11two verses of the Bible long before
- 38:12Christians came along. In the beginning,
- 38:15God created the heavens and the earth.
- 38:17And the earth was without form and void.
- 38:20And darkness was over the face of the
- 38:22deep. and the spirit of God was hovering
- 38:26over the face of the waters.
- 38:29So, we've got God, but then there's a
- 38:31distinction. It says, "And the spirit of
- 38:32God was
- 38:35hovering over the face of the waters."
- 38:38Later in the same chapter, opening
- 38:40chapter of the Bible, verse 26, we read,
- 38:43"Then God said, let us make man in our
- 38:48image after our likeness."
- 38:51Now, two obvious questions. One, who is
- 38:54he talking to? And two, why does he say,
- 38:57"Let us plural, make man," plural, I
- 39:00mean, make man in our plural image,
- 39:04the plural of majesty, right? Well, the
- 39:07Jews didn't use the plural of majesty.
- 39:09So, why is he using this? It's just a
- 39:12mystery so far. Um, we don't know yet,
- 39:15but as we continue reading, the mystery
- 39:19gets deeper. In Isaiah 9:6, the prophet
- 39:22delivers a prophecy.
- 39:25For to us a child is born, to us a son
- 39:28is given, and the government shall be
- 39:29upon his shoulder, and his name shall be
- 39:32called Wonderful Counselor, Mighty God,
- 39:36Father of Eternity, Prince of Peace. A
- 39:39child is born, a son is given, and this
- 39:42child is said to be the mighty God. How
- 39:45is a child going to be the mighty God?
- 39:49In Isaiah 48:16,
- 39:52Yahweh is speaking. Yahweh is the
- 39:53speaker. And he says, "Draw near to me.
- 39:57Hear this. From the beginning, I have
- 39:59not spoken in secret. From the time it
- 40:01came to be, I have been there. And now
- 40:04the Lord God has sent me and his
- 40:08spirit."
- 40:10Yahweh is speaking and Yahweh says that
- 40:13he has been sent by Yahweh along with
- 40:15the spirit of Yahweh.
- 40:18How can God be sent by God along with
- 40:20the spirit of God? Well, we just don't
- 40:23know. Still later in the Old Testament,
- 40:25Zechariah 12:10, Yahweh is again
- 40:29speaking and he says, "I will pour out
- 40:31on the house of David and the
- 40:33inhabitants of Jerusalem a spirit of
- 40:35grace and supplication.
- 40:37They will look on me, the one they have
- 40:39pierced, and they will mourn for him as
- 40:42one mourns for an only child, and grieve
- 40:44bitterly for him as one grieavves for a
- 40:46firstborn son. Yahweh will pour out a
- 40:49spirit which causes people to repent,
- 40:51and they will look on Yahweh, whom they
- 40:53have pierced, and mourn for him as one
- 40:55grieavves for a lost son. How can an
- 40:59immaterial God be pierced
- 41:02unless he takes on a body?
- 41:05So, the Old Testament concludes and
- 41:07leaves us with a lot of questions about
- 41:09how to reconcile the claim that there is
- 41:11only one God with some intriguing hints
- 41:15at plurality.
- 41:18Then Jesus comes along.
- 41:21Jesus tells his followers that he's the
- 41:23final judge of all people. Even though
- 41:25the Old Testament says that Yahweh is
- 41:28the final judge of all people,
- 41:31Jesus says that he's the one who raises
- 41:34the dead at the resurrection. Even
- 41:36though the Old Testament says that
- 41:38Yahweh is the one who raises the dead at
- 41:41the resurrection,
- 41:43Jesus calls himself the Lord of the
- 41:45Sabbath. He claims to be the Lord of the
- 41:47prophet David. He claims to be the I am
- 41:50of the Exodus. He claims to be greater
- 41:53than God's temple. Jesus tells us that
- 41:55he has an absolutely unique relationship
- 41:58with the father, that he can answer
- 41:59prayers, that he's present wherever his
- 42:01followers are gathered, that he is with
- 42:03his followers forever, and that he has
- 42:06all authority in heaven and on earth. He
- 42:10even makes the startling declaration
- 42:11that all things that the father has are
- 42:15mine.
- 42:17But Jesus also prays to the father and
- 42:22he claims to be from the father. Why
- 42:25would Jesus make claims that only God
- 42:27can make yet also be drawing attention
- 42:30to God as the father?
- 42:33In John 14-16, Jesus says that after he
- 42:36returns to the father, he and the father
- 42:39will together send the holy spirit.
- 42:42The spirit is sent and yet as we've seen
- 42:47the spirit was with the father at
- 42:49creation. Psalm 104:30 says that the
- 42:52spirit creates the universe. The spirit
- 42:55is omnisient in 1 Corinthians
- 42:58omnipresent in Psalm 139 and eternal in
- 43:02Hebrews 9. These are divine attributes
- 43:05and the the spirit is distinct from the
- 43:08father and the son. So what do we do all
- 43:12with all of this? Well, if the father is
- 43:15God and the son is God and the spirit is
- 43:18God and the father is not the son and
- 43:20the son is not the spirit and the spirit
- 43:22is not the father
- 43:26and there's only one god.
- 43:29The trinity is the only way out. And
- 43:31that's why I said that we were forced
- 43:32into this view by the triune God
- 43:35himself.
- 43:38Now, my Muslim friends tell me that this
- 43:40concept of God is absurd, even though we
- 43:43got it from God through the missions of
- 43:45the son and the spirit.
- 43:48My Muslim friends tell me that I should
- 43:50reject this confusing concept of God and
- 43:53believe in something much simpler, the
- 43:54Islamic concept of God.
- 43:57But I've been going through your sources
- 43:59for a good little while now and I see
- 44:03some serious problems with the doctrine
- 44:05of let me give you a few examples.
- 44:08First, Allah prays.
- 44:12People ask, "Jesus is God. Why does he
- 44:15pray?" I have to remind them that we're
- 44:18trinitarians. Makes perfect sense for
- 44:19the son to speak to the father. makes
- 44:22much less sense given the Islamic
- 44:24concept of God for Allah to pray in
- 44:26surah 33:56 of the Quran we read surely
- 44:31Allah and his angels pray for the
- 44:34prophet oh you who believe pray for him
- 44:37and salute him with a worthy salutation
- 44:40Allah and his angels pray for the
- 44:43prophet translators try to hide this by
- 44:46translating it as Allah and his angels
- 44:49send blessings or show mercy
- 44:52or they praise him. The problem here is
- 44:55that what it says Allah does is salah.
- 44:59And you know what that means? You know,
- 45:00there are perfectly good Arabic ways of
- 45:03saying all of those other things. Every
- 45:05Arab speaker in the world knows that
- 45:07salah means prayer. And it says that
- 45:09Allah does salah. So who is Allah
- 45:12praying to?
- 45:16Second, according to the Quran,
- 45:19most of Allah's parts will die. The
- 45:23Quran and the Hadith refer to Allah's
- 45:26face, his hands, two right hands, in
- 45:28fact, fingers, waist, shin, feet, and so
- 45:31on. Now, there's a tendency to interpret
- 45:34scriptural statements about God's bodily
- 45:36parts figuratively. If we say God's eyes
- 45:39see everything, no one thinks we're
- 45:40saying that God has eyeballs.
- 45:43But there are mus Muslim scholars
- 45:47themselves are the ones who are arguing
- 45:49that descriptions of Allah's face and
- 45:53hands and feet and so on have to be
- 45:55interpreted literally
- 45:57not simply anthropomorphically.
- 45:5910 minutes left.
- 46:02So Allah has a literal face, literal
- 46:04hands and so on.
- 46:06And yet we read in the Quran surah 28:88
- 46:11everything will perish
- 46:14except Allah's face
- 46:18which means if you are if you are taking
- 46:19these parts literally and the only thing
- 46:22that survives is Allah's face then
- 46:24Allah's face has different attributes
- 46:26from the rest of his parts uh perishable
- 46:29versus imperishable.
- 46:31Third, the Quran
- 46:34is an eternal person.
- 46:39While Orthodox Islamic theology insists
- 46:42that the Quran is the unccreated speech
- 46:44of Allah and co-eternal with Allah, that
- 46:47would be interesting enough. We can't
- 46:49forget that according to Muhammad, the
- 46:51Quran is also a person who intercedes
- 46:53for Muslims. In Sahim Muslim 1874,
- 46:57Muhammad says to his companions, "Recite
- 46:59the Quran, for it will come on the day
- 47:02of resurrection, interceding for its
- 47:05companions." Now, how can a book
- 47:07intercede for people? Muhammad explains
- 47:10in Muslim Ahmed and Sunnb Maja where he
- 47:13says, "The Quran will meet its companion
- 47:16on the day of resurrection when his
- 47:18grave is opened for him in the form of a
- 47:21pale man."
- 47:23The Quran will say to him, "Do you
- 47:25recognize me?" He will say, "I do not
- 47:26recognize you." It will say, "I am your
- 47:28companion." The Quran who kept you
- 47:30thirsty on hot days and kept you awake
- 47:32at night. So the Quran, which is eternal
- 47:35and uncreated, appears as a pale man
- 47:37speaks to Muslims and then speaks to
- 47:39Allah on their behalf. Again, this
- 47:42person, this pale man is eternal.
- 47:48Fourth, the Quran isn't just personal,
- 47:52it's multi-personal. And I hear from
- 47:54Muslims that that's impossible.
- 47:57Even though the Quran is an eternal
- 47:59person who appears as a pale man and
- 48:01intercedes for Muslims, there are
- 48:03actually multiple persons within the one
- 48:04nature of the Quran.
- 48:07In Sunn Abu D
- 48:101400, Muhammad said there is a surah in
- 48:13the Quran which consists of 30 verses.
- 48:16is referring to surah al-mok. It will
- 48:19intercede for its companion until he is
- 48:22forgiven.
- 48:24So a specific chapter of the Quran can
- 48:26appear and intercede for those who read
- 48:29it. But Muhammad isn't done. Sahem
- 48:33Muslim 1874 he tells his followers to
- 48:35recite surah al bakr and surah al Imran
- 48:38because these suras will come as two
- 48:41flocks of birds on the day of
- 48:43resurrection pleading on behalf of the
- 48:46Muslims who recited them.
- 48:49Since Muhammad mentions three different
- 48:52suras of the Quran which have their own
- 48:54distinct personalities, their own
- 48:56knowledge, I think we can say that all
- 48:58of the suras of the Quran have their own
- 49:01distinct personalities. The Quran
- 49:03Muslims read today is thus one in
- 49:06essence as the word of Allah but 114 in
- 49:09person. The personal chapters come as
- 49:12flocks of birds pleading on behalf of
- 49:15Muslims. I see lots of Muslims smiling
- 49:17and laughing at this. This is what your
- 49:18prophet said. This is your prophet.
- 49:21I think it's funny, too, but I try to I
- 49:23try to I try to hide that a little bit.
- 49:26Fifth,
- 49:28the multi-personal Quran has a mother.
- 49:33Christians claim that Jesus is the son
- 49:34of God. The Quran responds in surah 6
- 49:37vers 101, how can Allah have a son when
- 49:39he has no wife?
- 49:41Notice that the Quran assume assumes
- 49:43that filial terms talk terms referring
- 49:46to offspring have to be interpreted in a
- 49:48biological sense.
- 49:50Well, if we can only understand these
- 49:52terms biologically, we have to ask about
- 49:54the Quran's mother. Surah 13:39, Allah
- 49:58blotss out what he wills and confirms
- 49:59what he wills and with him is the mother
- 50:02of the book Um Al- Katab.
- 50:05The Quran's mother is in the presence of
- 50:07Allah. I would normally be happy with
- 50:10some metaphorical meaning of something
- 50:12like that. But it's the Quran itself
- 50:14which says that we have to interpret
- 50:16claims about Jesus being the son of God
- 50:18biologically. So if we have to interpret
- 50:21these claims biologically then I have to
- 50:23say if the Quran has a mommy who's the
- 50:27daddy.
- 50:29Six. Allah's spirit who is eternal and
- 50:34the co-creator of life
- 50:37is a person. According to Islamic
- 50:40theology, nothing that is a part of
- 50:42Allah or that originates from within
- 50:44Allah is created.
- 50:47But the Quran says that Allah breathes
- 50:49out his spirit. This means that like
- 50:51Allah's eternal speech, the spirit comes
- 50:54from within Allah and is thus uncreated
- 50:57and eternal.
- 50:59Allah creates man in surah 15 by
- 51:02fashioning a body out of clay and then
- 51:03breathing a spirit. The Quran says that
- 51:06Allah uh strengthens Jesus by the spirit
- 51:08and that uh that uh he strengthens all
- 51:11true believers with the spirit.
- 51:14But the spirit is a conscious agent who
- 51:17can appear in the form of a man. The
- 51:19spirit appears to Mary and speaks to her
- 51:21in surah 19 and then breathes into her
- 51:23just as Allah breathed into clay to
- 51:26create Adam.
- 51:28So the spirit is an uncreated eternal
- 51:31co-creator who is sent by Allah in the
- 51:33form of a man to perform certain tasks.
- 51:37And if he can uh strengthen believers
- 51:41wherever they are, he would have to be
- 51:44omnipresent. Got some divine attributes
- 51:46all over the place here.
- 51:49Seventh, Islam
- 51:51deifies Muhammad.
- 51:54When Muhammad would spit, his companions
- 51:57would rush to collect the spit and they
- 51:59would rub it on their faces.
- 52:04They would struggle to ha to save his
- 52:06used ablution water. If a hair fell off
- 52:09his head, they would rush to grab it.
- 52:11After the battle of Uhud, Muhammad's
- 52:13companions, a man named Malik,
- 52:16collected the blood that ran from
- 52:17Muhammad's wound and drank it. Muhammad
- 52:21said, "The fire will never touch you."
- 52:25This isn't how you treat someone you
- 52:26regard as a mere human being.
- 52:30Today, however, no one can drink
- 52:33Muhammad's blood or rub his saliva on
- 52:35their faces. But Muslims still address
- 52:38him directly in their prayers.
- 52:41Most of the time when Muslims are
- 52:42praying, they're reciting words that are
- 52:44directed towards Allah.
- 52:46But there's a part of their daily
- 52:47prayers where they say assalamu alaykum
- 52:50au.
- 52:53Now that does not mean God please bless
- 52:57Muhammad.
- 53:00That is peace be upon you Muhammad.
- 53:04They're speaking. They're laughing and
- 53:06they're speaking directly to Muhammad in
- 53:07their daily prayers. They're talking
- 53:09directly to Muhammad in their daily
- 53:11prayer. just assumes that he can hear
- 53:12them and so he hears them all over the
- 53:14world in which case he must be
- 53:17omnipresent. Interesting for a mere
- 53:19human being.
- 53:22Eighth, Islam deifies
- 53:25Jesus without even realizing it. Allah
- 53:28is uncreated and eternal. But as we've
- 53:30seen, there are two uncreated and
- 53:33eternal persons with Allah. His word,
- 53:34his eternal speech, and the spirit that
- 53:36he breathes out. And yet in surah 4
- 53:39verse 171, even when the Quran is
- 53:41asserting that he's only a prophet, it
- 53:43refers to Jesus as Allah's word and as a
- 53:46spirit from Allah. As if this weren't
- 53:50enough, Jesus goes on to create life in
- 53:53exactly the same way Allah creates life.
- 53:56Allah fashions a man out of clay and
- 53:58then breathes his spirit into it. What
- 54:00does Jesus do? He fashions a clay bird
- 54:04and then breathes his spirit into it.
- 54:06And this gives life, Jesus's co-creator.
- 54:10No wonder his followers started
- 54:12worshiping him.
- 54:14Ninth, Islamic worship draws extensively
- 54:18from the polytheism of 7th century
- 54:20Arabia.
- 54:22During the time of Muhammad, the
- 54:24polytheists of Arabia would perform to
- 54:27walking circles around the Cabba. And
- 54:29why did they do that? Because they were
- 54:30following Abraham?
- 54:32No. They believed in seven planetary
- 54:35deities who circled the earth. And so
- 54:38they walked seven circles around the
- 54:40Cabba in order to honor these seven
- 54:42planetary deities. Muslims do the same
- 54:43today, but not realizing where the
- 54:45practice came from.
- 54:48There's also the black stone.
- 54:51This was one of the pagan idols. It
- 54:53became part of Islam. You kiss it and it
- 54:55can be an expeation for your sins. But
- 54:58according to Muhammad, the black stone
- 55:00itself is conscious.
- 55:02One minute left.
- 55:04We read in ib Maja. The messenger of
- 55:07Allah said concerning the stone, by
- 55:09Allah, Allah will bring it forth on the
- 55:11day of resurrection and will have two
- 55:13eyes with which it will see and a tongue
- 55:16with which it will speak and it will
- 55:17testify in favor of those who touched it
- 55:19in sincerity. So this isn't a random
- 55:21lifeless idol. This is a living
- 55:24breathing idol.
- 55:30So, in the Quran, we've got Allah
- 55:32swearing by literally
- 55:36uh everything. We'll be talking about
- 55:37that in a little in a few moments. Um
- 55:42given that we find these things in the
- 55:44Muslim sources,
- 55:46I'm truly interested in how we can sit
- 55:49here and poke fun at the doctrine of the
- 55:51trinity. Now, the real basis I find uh
- 55:56for reconciling these texts with the
- 55:59doctrine of is that Muslim scholars
- 56:03don't let you know this stuff, which is
- 56:04why you think it's funny when you're
- 56:05hearing it.
- 56:06Time is up, Dr. Wood.
- 56:13Uh now we're going to start our second
- 56:15part, which is the the 12minute
- 56:17rebuttal. And going first is Mr.
- 56:19Muhammad Hijab. You can go ahead. I
- 56:22think David would have said some career
- 56:23ending embarrassing statements today. I
- 56:25mean to be honest with you
- 56:32after 20 years of researching Islam, you
- 56:35come with this. Okay, let's deal with
- 56:38one one by one.
- 56:40Spirits of God hovered over the uh
- 56:44hovered over after the God created the
- 56:46heavens and the earth. Okay, no problem.
- 56:48If if it's that's meant to be God, no
- 56:50problem. Let's go to Zechariah's
- 56:53in Old Testament chapter 6 verse 5.
- 56:55There are four spirits. So are there
- 56:57seven gods now? Because the word in in
- 56:59Hebrew is and you wouldn't know about
- 57:02Hebrew because look, I I think not only
- 57:05do you not know Arabic, but you don't
- 57:07know Hebrew, and you're making a big
- 57:08mistake by trying to interpret the the
- 57:10biblical text in this way. There's two
- 57:13words for spirits in Hebrew language
- 57:15which is the same as the Arabic and the
- 57:16word is here in in Zechariah
- 57:206:5 talking about four spirits. So tell
- 57:22us why if that is a spirit and it's God
- 57:24then how comes there's only three gods
- 57:27three persons of God and uh and there
- 57:30isn't seven for example he says
- 57:34that for that Jesus this is called the
- 57:37ethmology fallacy that's you know he's
- 57:40been referred to as Emanuel etc. God is
- 57:42with us. Elijah is also the word Elijah
- 57:45in the in the Hebrew language means God
- 57:46is with us. So if if that makes Jesus
- 57:49God, then Elijah is also a God. We move
- 57:52on.
- 57:54What else did he say? I am statement. If
- 57:57you look at the New International
- 57:58Version of the Bible, uh the I am is
- 58:01actually not translated as I am, but I
- 58:03will be. And there's a whole discussion
- 58:06on that. And to be honest with you,
- 58:08frankly, I don't even take the Gospel of
- 58:10John to be completely authoritative and
- 58:12neither do the majority of biblical
- 58:14scholars anyways. 95 AD,
- 58:18it's a long way. He says Allah says
- 58:21uh that Allah and he's here saying that
- 58:24he prays to the prophet. There's a
- 58:27difference between
- 58:29and in the Arabic language. I knew this
- 58:32was going to happen. I knew this was
- 58:34going to happen.
- 58:38I knew I was going to have to give you a
- 58:39free Arabic lesson here today.
- 58:43I knew it. And that's why the
- 58:45translators put for, not to the prophet.
- 58:49You don't know what the the words in
- 58:50Arabic mean. Don't hit speak. Come on,
- 58:53please don't embarrass yourself. Allah
- 58:55has parts. He says Muslim scholars say
- 58:57we should take this literally. Which
- 58:59Muslim scholars?
- 59:02Which Muslim scholars? Uh he says in in
- 59:06surah chapter 28 of the Quran means
- 59:08everything is destroyed except for his
- 59:10face and this means that Allah all his
- 59:12body parts will be destroyed he has body
- 59:13parts in these things first of all the
- 59:15word in Arabic doesn't necessarily mean
- 59:17alli wrote a book
- 59:20and he said and he shows with examples
- 59:22that the word doesn't mean all I'll give
- 59:24you an example in chapter 46 of the
- 59:26Quran
- 59:33that the
- 59:34destroyed everything the same words here
- 59:37inas
- 59:38everything was destroyed except for
- 59:40their houses if it meant every single
- 59:42thing it wouldn't have been their houses
- 59:43would not be there so the word kul
- 59:44doesn't mean that in Arabic language
- 59:45once again it's a problem with language
- 59:50he says that this is exactly his words
- 59:52he said the Quran is eternal person tell
- 59:54me one scholar in the history of Islam
- 59:55who said that this is a lie
- 1:00:01he says the Quran
- 1:00:03is a you have to it will come as a shafi
- 1:00:06on the day of judgment. So if this is
- 1:00:08the question I'll put it better for you.
- 1:00:09I'll help you. Yeah. If the Quran is an
- 1:00:12attribute of God, how can it intercede
- 1:00:14for you? This is what he's saying.
- 1:00:15Right. It's a good question. This is a
- 1:00:16good question. But it's not a proper
- 1:00:19understanding of the hadith. This is the
- 1:00:20only good question you had. I'll give it
- 1:00:22to you. This is the only good question
- 1:00:23you had. The the hadith saysquran.
- 1:00:28So it's not that the Quran i.e. the
- 1:00:30attribute of Allah that will intercede
- 1:00:32for you on the day of judgment but it is
- 1:00:34your of the Quran and the tawb that you
- 1:00:36get of the Quran which means the reward
- 1:00:37you get from the recitation of the Quran
- 1:00:39not the Quran as an attribute of Allah
- 1:00:41yeah
- 1:00:45he says therefore there's 114 persons of
- 1:00:48the Quran two coquay fallacy twoqu
- 1:00:51fallacy I told you he would do it and
- 1:00:52appeal to hypocrisy so here are you
- 1:00:54admitting that having more than one
- 1:00:56person of a being of god is wrong
- 1:00:58because you should leave trinitarianism
- 1:01:01But obviously as we know there's no one
- 1:01:03in the history of Islam that referred to
- 1:01:04the surah of the Quran as persons. This
- 1:01:06is wrong. You don't know about Islam.
- 1:01:08Here you're being educated.
- 1:01:10He said
- 1:01:12he didn't know the Arabic. But I'm going
- 1:01:13to give him the the Arabic in chapter 6
- 1:01:15vers 108 of the Quran. But Allahh says
- 1:01:17that Allah did not have a mate. So does
- 1:01:20this mean? What does this mean that
- 1:01:23biological? We had a discussion about
- 1:01:24biological. Really and truly how can you
- 1:01:26have a begotten son? There's only three
- 1:01:28options. Number one, biology. Number
- 1:01:30two, adoption. And number three,
- 1:01:32metaphor. And if you say it's not
- 1:01:34biology and it's not adoption, it must
- 1:01:35be a metaphor. So Jesus is not a son of
- 1:01:37God.
- 1:01:41[Music]
- 1:01:42[Applause]
- 1:01:43Okay.
- 1:01:45And then he says that the prophets they
- 1:01:47they played, you know, they tried to get
- 1:01:48his hair and the spit and these things.
- 1:01:50Okay. Well, if you think spitting on
- 1:01:52someone makes you a god, well, that's
- 1:01:54what it implies. And I wonder why you
- 1:01:56look at every other verse of the Bible
- 1:01:58as implying that Jesus was God. Because
- 1:02:00for you a spit
- 1:02:04that's that's making me a god now.
- 1:02:08I mean
- 1:02:10don't embarrass yourself in front of me.
- 1:02:15He said this means that he's interceding
- 1:02:17because it's a narrative voice.
- 1:02:20We say this in the every time it's a
- 1:02:22narrative voice. However, let's not say
- 1:02:24it's a narrative voice. Let's give it to
- 1:02:25him. He says this must mean that the
- 1:02:27prophet Muhammad is omnipresent. Yes,
- 1:02:30he's omnipresent. Let's let's have fun
- 1:02:32with him today. There is a hadith in
- 1:02:34Bkari which says that whenever one
- 1:02:36person does salah on the nebi which
- 1:02:38means blessings and praise on the
- 1:02:41prophet blessings on the prophet the
- 1:02:43angel will carry that and give it to
- 1:02:45him. It doesn't mean that he's hearing
- 1:02:47it everywhere. The angel is moving it
- 1:02:49around. This is from the will of Allah.
- 1:02:52And if you didn't know that, now you do.
- 1:02:56He says that
- 1:02:59the area being referred to as the word
- 1:03:01of Allah must mean that he is divine. So
- 1:03:04although the Quran says clearly that
- 1:03:06he's not divine, no, it makes a mistake.
- 1:03:07He is divine. Well, you're all over the
- 1:03:10place. You're fumbling all over the
- 1:03:11place. It's embarrassing.
- 1:03:13Is is defined in chapter 3:58 of the
- 1:03:15Quran where Allah subhana wa ta says,
- 1:03:265 minutes left.
- 1:03:27He said to him, "Be and he was." The
- 1:03:29word is defined in the Quran as be. So
- 1:03:31Allah says, "Be and things are." Just
- 1:03:33like he said, "Be with Adam." He said,
- 1:03:35"Be with Jesus and he was."
- 1:03:38He says that there are seven planetary
- 1:03:40things in Arabia and these things. I
- 1:03:42mean, how can you make a a judgment?
- 1:03:45First of all, I haven't got a reference
- 1:03:46for that. I didn't see a ref. He didn't
- 1:03:48say yes I give you a reference here it
- 1:03:49says bkari whatever even if he's got a
- 1:03:51reference how do you know that the
- 1:03:52practice originated from that and not
- 1:03:54from Abraham after all Abraham even in
- 1:03:57the old testament
- 1:03:59yes he existed pre-existed before Jesus
- 1:04:02even though you have yeah you know the
- 1:04:04physical Jesus and he was there in the
- 1:04:06desert and you have in the book of
- 1:04:08psalms mention of pilgrimage so if this
- 1:04:11is the case then I wonder why uh this is
- 1:04:14mentioned now this is I think this is
- 1:04:15all that he kind of mentioned
- 1:04:17I want to give you one principle ladies
- 1:04:19and gentlemen that will destroy
- 1:04:20everything he said. The Quran says
- 1:04:21chapter 42:11
- 1:04:25that there's nothing like him. You
- 1:04:28cannot do
- 1:04:29or temp of Allah. Anything that we see
- 1:04:32in the Quran talking about the hand,
- 1:04:35talking about the face, all of these
- 1:04:36things, you can rest assured because of
- 1:04:39this verse and the other verse
- 1:04:41that this means, yes, this means it
- 1:04:45cannot be compared to anything you
- 1:04:46imagine
- 1:04:51in the Quran anyways. I mean, every
- 1:04:52Muslim know this. But the idea is is
- 1:04:55there's implicit admission here that
- 1:04:57I've lost. This is this is what he come
- 1:04:59up with. I've lost. Yes, we know
- 1:05:01trinitarianism is so confusing, but I'm
- 1:05:03going to show you how much you know is
- 1:05:05confusing as well. I have admitted
- 1:05:07defeat. Therefore, I'm going down. I'm
- 1:05:09going down. I'm going to try and take
- 1:05:10you down with me. That's that's really
- 1:05:12what you're trying to say to me. David
- 1:05:13would I know by the look of your face
- 1:05:15here, you would probably agree with me.
- 1:05:16Let's be honest. Look at his face.
- 1:05:18Everyone, ladies and gentlemen, take a
- 1:05:20look at his face. Yes. Anyways, I've got
- 1:05:23a few minutes left. Let me recite some
- 1:05:24Quran because I've done with this guy.
- 1:05:26Allah subhana wa ta'ala.
- 1:05:28He says in chapter number 19 verse
- 1:05:30number 31
- 1:05:32about Jesus. This is what we believe
- 1:05:34about Jesus.
- 1:05:47for
- 1:06:16for
- 1:06:42Allah.
- 1:06:44for
- 1:07:03the said Jesus according this is guys
- 1:07:06Christians
- 1:07:09this is what Allah says in the Quran
- 1:07:10listen to it tell me if this is not a
- 1:07:12better model for you be honest this This
- 1:07:14is Jesus. He says, "I am the slave of
- 1:07:17Allah, of God. He gave me the book and
- 1:07:20he made me a prophet." Just like in
- 1:07:22chapter 8 of Mark verse 1 minute left.
- 1:07:26Yes. 48. People thought Jesus was a
- 1:07:29prophet in in the Old Testament in the
- 1:07:32New Testament time in the time of Jesus
- 1:07:33when he was alive.
- 1:07:37He made me blessed wherever I am. This
- 1:07:40is what we believe of Jesus. He made me
- 1:07:42blessed wherever I am.
- 1:07:44You know,
- 1:07:48and he told me to pray and to give
- 1:07:50charity so long as I am alive. You know,
- 1:07:54this is what we believe about Jesus
- 1:07:56Christ.
- 1:07:57I was good with my mother.
- 1:08:01I wasn't an arrogant person.
- 1:08:04And peace be upon me the day I was born
- 1:08:06and the day I die and the day I will
- 1:08:08come back to life. That is Jesus son of
- 1:08:11Mary. The one who you differ about
- 1:08:17[Applause]
- 1:08:24uh before we start on uh Dr. David
- 1:08:27Wood's rebuttal, I'd just like to remind
- 1:08:29uh our fellow audience uh verbal
- 1:08:32cheering is please please refrain from
- 1:08:35verbal cheering. Clapping is sufficient
- 1:08:36enough. And we just like to remind both
- 1:08:38speakers to stay on topic and be
- 1:08:40respectful towards the other speaker.
- 1:08:41Thank you. And Dr. Lewood, you have the
- 1:08:43floor.
- 1:08:44[Applause]
- 1:08:48[Music]
- 1:08:49[Applause]
- 1:08:55Thank you again, Muhammad. Uh in my
- 1:08:58opening statement, I laid out a basic
- 1:09:01case for the doctrine of the trinity and
- 1:09:04I claimed that the Islamic concept of
- 1:09:06God is a more confusing than what we're
- 1:09:10normally told. Um I pointed out that
- 1:09:13Allah prays and he said, "Well, there's
- 1:09:16a difference in the meaning of the verb
- 1:09:18here." Well, the Quran says repeatedly
- 1:09:20that Allah prays and guess what?
- 1:09:24He prays in the hadith as well. And
- 1:09:27what's interesting is there are even
- 1:09:28Muslim translators who are acknowledging
- 1:09:30this and translating these passages as
- 1:09:34Allah prays. So Aisha Buli, I've got a
- 1:09:37ton of Islamic books translated by her,
- 1:09:40respected around the world
- 1:09:42[Music]
- 1:09:44from Riyad Salahim.
- 1:09:47The messenger of Allah said, "Allah and
- 1:09:49his angels and the people of the heavens
- 1:09:51and the earth, even the ants in their
- 1:09:54rocks and the fish pray for blessings on
- 1:09:59those who teach people good." So Allah
- 1:10:02prays. Who is he praying to?
- 1:10:06Al a hadith als
- 1:10:09translated again by a Muslim translator.
- 1:10:12Hadith number 216. The Israelites said
- 1:10:14to MS, "Does your Lord pray?"
- 1:10:19MS said, "Fear Allah, oh sons of
- 1:10:21Israel." Allah said, "Oh, MS, what did
- 1:10:24your people say?" Musa said, "Oh my
- 1:10:27Lord, you already know." They said,
- 1:10:29"Does your Lord pray?" Allah said, "Tell
- 1:10:32them, my prayer for my servants is that
- 1:10:35my mercy should precede my anger. If it
- 1:10:38were not so, I would have destroyed
- 1:10:40them."
- 1:10:42Allah prays that his mercy will triumph
- 1:10:45over his wrath. Now if Allah is praying
- 1:10:48what's he's praying for self-control
- 1:10:50here apparently right he wants to punish
- 1:10:51them but he prays for self-control.
- 1:10:55This is not me. This is these are your
- 1:10:57hadiths and your translators translating
- 1:10:59these passages as Allah praying. Why?
- 1:11:02Because that's what salah means.
- 1:11:07If I'm wrong, give me give me the
- 1:11:08linguistic basis for for saying
- 1:11:10otherwise.
- 1:11:12Second, I said that Allah has various
- 1:11:14parts, but only his face is
- 1:11:16imperishable, which means that different
- 1:11:18parts of Allah have different
- 1:11:19attributes. Um, that's just what it
- 1:11:22says. It says everything will perish
- 1:11:25except his face. So, if you're
- 1:11:28interpreting the parts as literal parts,
- 1:11:32you've just got a problem here, right?
- 1:11:34It gives the qualification. It's saying
- 1:11:35everything will perish. And I understand
- 1:11:37it can say, you know, everything this or
- 1:11:38everything that. It's saying that
- 1:11:39everything perishes except his face.
- 1:11:41It's drawing the only the only exception
- 1:11:44there, which would mean that certain
- 1:11:46parts are
- 1:11:50parts with different attributes,
- 1:11:52unless Allah is just not clear in his
- 1:11:54Quran, which he claims to be clear over
- 1:11:56and over again. Um, third, I said that
- 1:11:59the Quran is an eternal person.
- 1:12:02He's Allah's eternal word, but he also
- 1:12:04takes the form of a pale man. Now, um
- 1:12:07it's kind of hard to hear because uh
- 1:12:09over there, but I think um Muhammad
- 1:12:11replied that it's your own recitation
- 1:12:13that appears to you. Now, that's
- 1:12:14interesting enough. Uh if your own
- 1:12:16recitation of the Quran is uh is
- 1:12:18appearing as a pale man. Um but uh I
- 1:12:23don't think that's what it means because
- 1:12:24of the next point, which is that
- 1:12:26individual chapters of the Quran appear
- 1:12:29as flocks of birds to intercede for you.
- 1:12:31So if individual chapters of the Quran
- 1:12:34are appearing and pleading for you,
- 1:12:38then why wouldn't the entire Quran as a
- 1:12:41whole also be appearing to you? So it
- 1:12:42seems that it's not just talking about
- 1:12:44your own uh good recitation or something
- 1:12:46like that, but uh the book itself. He
- 1:12:48says, "I am the Quran."
- 1:12:51Um now, by the way, this is uh very
- 1:12:54interesting. Um and I I think it might
- 1:12:56be a source of problem here. Um,
- 1:13:00Muhammad
- 1:13:01says, "Well, who who refers to these
- 1:13:03Quran chapters as persons?"
- 1:13:06And I think there's a little difficulty
- 1:13:08here. This might be why he's uh having
- 1:13:09trouble understanding the doctrine of
- 1:13:11the Trinity. Uh, if he's if he's
- 1:13:12misunderstanding this word uh person
- 1:13:14here and and and how it's applied. Um,
- 1:13:18if a flock of birds can talk and has
- 1:13:23knowledge and this flock of birds knows
- 1:13:27what you've been doing, they know that
- 1:13:29you've been reciting the Quran. They
- 1:13:31intercede for you. They plead to Allah
- 1:13:34on your behalf.
- 1:13:36Well, those are qualities of of what we
- 1:13:39call a person in philosophy, right? It
- 1:13:41it's communicating like that. It it has
- 1:13:43it has certain kinds of knowledge. it it
- 1:13:45appeals to people in certain way. This
- 1:13:47is what we mean by the term uh person.
- 1:13:50And by the way, because we're talking
- 1:13:53about origins of of Islamic practices,
- 1:13:55if you um go to the early Islamic
- 1:13:58history, um there were goddesses, there
- 1:14:02were many people in Arabia who believed
- 1:14:04in
- 1:14:06um in a in a kind of hierarchy, right?
- 1:14:09where they believed in Allah and they
- 1:14:10believed that Allah was the main deity
- 1:14:12but they believed in lower deities and
- 1:14:14these were intercessors. Now Allah, Aloo
- 1:14:17and Manat were three goddesses and they
- 1:14:20were called the exalted cranes. They
- 1:14:22were the birds that would carry your
- 1:14:24prayers to Allah or they would fly up to
- 1:14:26Allah and intercede for you. Now why is
- 1:14:29this interesting? Well, the goddesses
- 1:14:31are described in terms of birds who go
- 1:14:33and intercede for you. But Muhammad
- 1:14:37after introducing
- 1:14:39says that it's actually chapters of the
- 1:14:41Quran that do that for you. Now they
- 1:14:43appear as flocks of birds to go up to
- 1:14:46Allah and intercede for you.
- 1:14:49Now if I asked any Muslim in here, hey,
- 1:14:51if someone believes that there's God and
- 1:14:53then there are these other beings who uh
- 1:14:56intercede and fly up to him and inter
- 1:14:58and intercede for you and plead for you,
- 1:15:00is that polytheism or monotheism? Every
- 1:15:03Muslim would say that's polytheism.
- 1:15:05Okay. Well, if there are these flocks of
- 1:15:07birds around
- 1:15:09and they are the eternal speech of Allah
- 1:15:11and they fly up and intercede for you
- 1:15:14and they plead on your behalf, what is
- 1:15:16that? It's pure monotheism.
- 1:15:19That is very interesting.
- 1:15:23He says, "No one refers to uh the Quran
- 1:15:25as a person or or chapters the Quran as
- 1:15:28as as a person." Again, if you
- 1:15:29understand how we use the term, that
- 1:15:31should end the confusion.
- 1:15:34Um, as for the Quran, having a mother
- 1:15:38alab,
- 1:15:39now he pointed out that, well, if you're
- 1:15:42if you're saying it's not literally
- 1:15:45biological, then you must be saying it's
- 1:15:47it's merely metaphorical.
- 1:15:50And no, not in the Jewish or Christian
- 1:15:53scriptures.
- 1:15:55Son of is used in a variety of ways. And
- 1:15:58so the appropriate response
- 1:16:00the appropriate response to Christian
- 1:16:03theology would be explain to you explain
- 1:16:05to us what Jesus sunship means. And that
- 1:16:08would be explained in terms of the
- 1:16:10doctrine of the trinity. But no
- 1:16:12Christian has ever meant
- 1:16:15that Jesus is the biological son of the
- 1:16:19father. So if Allah is telling Muslims
- 1:16:22in the Quran, and I bring this up
- 1:16:23because I hear this from Muslims almost
- 1:16:25every day. Well, how can you believe
- 1:16:26that God had sex with Mary? Well, never
- 1:16:29heard of a Christian believing that.
- 1:16:31Where are you getting that idea from?
- 1:16:32Getting it from the Quran. From Allah.
- 1:16:34So, the point here is if Allah knows
- 1:16:39what the Christian doctrine is, why
- 1:16:41doesn't Allah say what the Christian
- 1:16:43doctrine is and then explain why it's
- 1:16:46wrong? He just never does. Allah tries
- 1:16:49to refute the Trinity. Doesn't know what
- 1:16:50the doctrine of the Trinity is. He
- 1:16:52thinks it's it's Allah, Jesus, and Mary,
- 1:16:54who are three separate beings who just
- 1:16:55work together.
- 1:16:57That's not the doctrine of the Trinity.
- 1:16:59What's he responding to? Likewise, with
- 1:17:01the sunship of Jesus, he gets it all
- 1:17:03wrong.
- 1:17:04So, you've got a problem here. Either
- 1:17:06your God doesn't know what we believe,
- 1:17:09in which case he lacks knowledge, or he
- 1:17:12does know what we believe and he's
- 1:17:13deliberately making fun of it or
- 1:17:15misrepresenting it.
- 1:17:18If he's deliberately mis misrepresenting
- 1:17:19it, then that would be an ethical
- 1:17:21problem.
- 1:17:23Um, six, I said that Allah's spirit is
- 1:17:25an eternal person who takes the form of
- 1:17:28a man to carry out tasks. Um, again,
- 1:17:32having trouble hearing down there. If
- 1:17:33there was a response to that, please
- 1:17:34remind me.
- 1:17:36Seventh, I said that Islam deifies
- 1:17:38Muhammad. Uh, said, "Well, you know,
- 1:17:40Muhammad spitting and stuff doesn't
- 1:17:42what's that got to do with him being
- 1:17:43God?" That's not that's not the point.
- 1:17:45The point was Muhammad's just a man. The
- 1:17:47Muhammad's just a man. Muhammad's just a
- 1:17:49man. And then you see how his followers
- 1:17:52acted towards him. And it's clear he was
- 1:17:55much more than a man to him. When a
- 1:17:57normal human being is walking down the
- 1:17:59street and spits, you don't say, "Oh, I
- 1:18:00have to rub this all over my body."
- 1:18:02Muhammad's companions did. If a hair
- 1:18:04falls off a normal human being's head,
- 1:18:06you don't say, "Ooh, I need to grab
- 1:18:08this. I need to save this." If someone
- 1:18:10is bleeding, a normal human being is
- 1:18:13bleeding, you don't say, "Hey, let me
- 1:18:14get that running blood and drink it."
- 1:18:17This was acceptable behavior from
- 1:18:20Muhammad and his followers.
- 1:18:23And how if you saw anyone doing this, if
- 1:18:27I said, "Hey, there's this place
- 1:18:28somewhere in South America or something
- 1:18:31and they've got this guy down there and
- 1:18:33whenever he spits, they rub it on their
- 1:18:36faces. Whenever he washes himself, they
- 1:18:38collect the water so they can rub it on
- 1:18:39themselves. Whenever he bleeds, he gets
- 1:18:42cut. They drink it." You say, "H, look
- 1:18:44at this idolatry. Look at this paganism.
- 1:18:47That's exactly how Muhammad expected his
- 1:18:49followers to act. And for some reason,
- 1:18:52whenever it's in Islam, it's still just
- 1:18:54pure monotheism.
- 1:18:57I said that Islam accidentally deifies
- 1:19:00Jesus,
- 1:19:02calls Jesus Allah's word and a spirit
- 1:19:06from Allah. Now, keep in mind those are
- 1:19:08the two eternal cocreating
- 1:19:12co-eternal beings with Allah. his word
- 1:19:15and his spirit. Now this is interesting.
- 1:19:20Muhammad said hijab said that the Quran
- 1:19:23calls Jesus the word because Allah said
- 1:19:26be and he was. So Allah said be and he
- 1:19:31was and this makes him Allah's word. Now
- 1:19:34that's very interesting because uh
- 1:19:36according to chapter 16 vers 40 of the
- 1:19:38Quran that's how Allah creates
- 1:19:39everything. That's how Allah creates me.
- 1:19:44So Allah created me by saying be and
- 1:19:46according to Muhammad hijab, that's how
- 1:19:47you can identify someone as the word of
- 1:19:49Allah. What's that make me?
- 1:19:53I am the word of Allah according to
- 1:19:54Muhammad hijab. So if you reject
- 1:19:57anything I say,
- 1:19:58one minute left.
- 1:19:59If you reject anything I say for the
- 1:20:00rest of the evening,
- 1:20:02you're guilty of rebelling against
- 1:20:04Allah's word.
- 1:20:07As far as Islam drawing its uh worship
- 1:20:10from um its basic practices from the
- 1:20:13pagans of Mecca, there's really no dis
- 1:20:17you can read in the Muslim sources that
- 1:20:18the pagans are are walking these circles
- 1:20:20and kissing the black stone and so on.
- 1:20:23You can also read that they believed in
- 1:20:24these seven planetary deities that are
- 1:20:27circling the earth. So you can read all
- 1:20:29about their worship. What you have to
- 1:20:30believe if you want to reconcile this
- 1:20:32with Islam is you have to say Abraham
- 1:20:34set that up walking the seven circles
- 1:20:36and then the pagans misinterpreted it at
- 1:20:38some point and they started walking
- 1:20:40seven circles around the Cabba for a
- 1:20:42completely different reason. Um so you'd
- 1:20:44have to believe that. And then as far as
- 1:20:45the black stone, well it was a black
- 1:20:47stone and then it became part of their
- 1:20:49pagan worship and then got brought back.
- 1:20:51But keep in mind this is
- 1:20:525 seconds
- 1:20:54a rock that is going to appear with eyes
- 1:20:56and a mouth and you kiss it.
- 1:20:59Thank you very much Dr. David Wood.
- 1:21:03Now we're going to enter into our second
- 1:21:05phase of rebuttals which each speaker
- 1:21:07will have eight minutes each. Uh you can
- 1:21:09go ahead doc Mr. Muhammad Hij.
- 1:21:12He mentioned again this issue of salah
- 1:21:14and I've told you the difference. I
- 1:21:16don't know why I kept repeating it. He
- 1:21:17says person. I'm going to try and do
- 1:21:19this in 3 minutes. Yeah. He says person.
- 1:21:22Uh this this shows you that the surah he
- 1:21:25thinks he says he thinks this means that
- 1:21:27the chapters of the Quran are persons. I
- 1:21:29wanted I've always wanted to do this.
- 1:21:30Yeah. To take a word from Dwayne the the
- 1:21:33Rock Johnson. It doesn't matter what you
- 1:21:35think. It doesn't matter what you think.
- 1:21:39I mean
- 1:21:43flock of birds and the the man who comes
- 1:21:45the pale man. Yes, this is in good
- 1:21:47deeds. And this proves my point once
- 1:21:49again that the of the Quran is what is
- 1:21:52represented the you get the rewards for
- 1:21:56doing the good and it comes that's what
- 1:21:57the hadith is talking about the man
- 1:21:59comes in a in a good form this is the
- 1:22:01hadith in Bkari
- 1:22:03he says
- 1:22:06come as birds intercession means
- 1:22:07policyism well
- 1:22:11chapter 2 verse 255 of the Quran who
- 1:22:14will intercede with God except with his
- 1:22:16permission it's one part of a verse
- 1:22:18which refutes all of your claims about
- 1:22:20intercession. In fact, uh he says om
- 1:22:22means mother. It doesn't only mean
- 1:22:24mother. Don't tell me about Arabic
- 1:22:25language. You ask me about Arabic
- 1:22:26language in this in this forum. You ask
- 1:22:29me, you don't tell me. You ask Muhammad,
- 1:22:31what does the word mean? You don't tell
- 1:22:34me means this. No, I tell you it means
- 1:22:36mother. Yes, it doesn't only mean
- 1:22:37mother. We say the the the main books.
- 1:22:40It means something foundational.
- 1:22:43The Quran says the main cities. Come on,
- 1:22:45man. Don't waste my time with this.
- 1:22:47He says
- 1:22:49salah he said he actually asked me for
- 1:22:51something linguistic. He said what's the
- 1:22:52linguistic basis that the the word salah
- 1:22:54what is what does it come from
- 1:22:55ethmologically the word salah comes from
- 1:22:57the word silah means connection. So it
- 1:23:00can be any connection. It doesn't
- 1:23:01necessarily always have to be prayer.
- 1:23:02And the word actually salah means dua.
- 1:23:05Yes this is the root word but it comes
- 1:23:07from the ethmological root word which
- 1:23:09means connection. It could mean any
- 1:23:10connection for example connecting with
- 1:23:13your family members. You don't know
- 1:23:14these things. He says the Quran gets the
- 1:23:16trinity wrong. And he's talking about
- 1:23:18chapter 5 verse 116 of the Quran where
- 1:23:20it talks about did you tell your mother
- 1:23:22that you can take two of us as as lords
- 1:23:24beside God. It's not talking about the
- 1:23:25trinity in this verse. Where does it say
- 1:23:27this is the trinity and then describe
- 1:23:28it? The only the verses that describe
- 1:23:30the trinity for example chapter 4 verse
- 1:23:32171 of the Quran other places of the
- 1:23:34Quran like chapter 5 where the brother
- 1:23:35was reading it never tells you what the
- 1:23:37trinity is which is why for example many
- 1:23:39scholars like
- 1:23:41many scholars actually did say that the
- 1:23:42trinity was the father son and the holy
- 1:23:44spirit but some scholars differed with
- 1:23:46them in ex Jesus it doesn't matter the
- 1:23:48word three in Arabic means all of the
- 1:23:51kinds of trinities that all of the
- 1:23:52Christians have ever believed in in all
- 1:23:53of history so the word in Arabic is all
- 1:23:56comprehensive it doesn't say that the
- 1:23:58word trinity Mary, it doesn't say that
- 1:24:00in the Quran. You have lied against the
- 1:24:01Quran. And then he says here the the of
- 1:24:06Allah subhana wa ta'ala this you have to
- 1:24:08understand basic basic rules of grammar
- 1:24:10of Arabic but
- 1:24:13means the camel of Allah is that another
- 1:24:15person. I will help you. I will help
- 1:24:16you. It means
- 1:24:19actually I'm not going to go into it to
- 1:24:20be honest with you. It's go to a basic
- 1:24:23Arabic uh you know textbook. What is
- 1:24:25mudaf?
- 1:24:26is the first thing the Arab students
- 1:24:28learn. Let's not waste my time with this
- 1:24:30please. You've come here 20 years of
- 1:24:31research and this is what you present.
- 1:24:32Don't waste my time. It says here Islam
- 1:24:36accidentally dearifies Jesus because he
- 1:24:39is.
- 1:24:41Why does the Quran call him the
- 1:24:43stressing the fact that Allah said be
- 1:24:45and he was to make it an emphasis a
- 1:24:48point of emphasis for Christians who
- 1:24:50believe otherwise.
- 1:24:52And then the pagans uh pagan sources he
- 1:24:55didn't give any. Now realize ladies and
- 1:24:57gentlemen this man put Christianity
- 1:24:59under the bus. He threw Christianity
- 1:25:01under the bus today. I asked him four
- 1:25:03questions. None of those questions were
- 1:25:05answered.
- 1:25:07None of those questions were answered. I
- 1:25:11asked where is the Trinity in 300 years?
- 1:25:15If it is a basic natural inference of
- 1:25:19the Old Testament, how could you have
- 1:25:214,000 years of Hebrew history? No one
- 1:25:24has inferred it. If it's a natural
- 1:25:27reading of the New Testament, how comes
- 1:25:29you have 300 years, 300 years, and no
- 1:25:35church father believed in nine
- 1:25:36trinitarianism the way that you believe
- 1:25:38today? Why are you back projecting
- 1:25:40anacronistically superimposing
- 1:25:44this idea that was advanced and
- 1:25:46crystallized by the Capidosian fathers
- 1:25:48in 381 and putting it and forcing it?
- 1:25:51You're the one forcing it. Forcing it on
- 1:25:53the New Testament more egregiously.
- 1:25:54You're forcing it in the Old Testament.
- 1:25:56You have put you have done a shameful
- 1:25:58service today for the for the
- 1:25:59Christians. You have not defended
- 1:26:00Christianity today. You should have
- 1:26:02brought James White with you or someone
- 1:26:04like that. Seriously, you should have
- 1:26:06brought someone who could have helped
- 1:26:08you. You were saying me and Adnan and
- 1:26:10Ali versus you, man. You should have
- 1:26:12brought someone with you. Seriously,
- 1:26:14what's going on here? 20 years of
- 1:26:16attacking Islam. 20 years of attacking
- 1:26:19Islam. 99% of your content is
- 1:26:21anti-Islam. And all of those things you
- 1:26:23brought today were dismissed in 4
- 1:26:25minutes.
- 1:26:30You couldn't handle the questioning. I
- 1:26:33gave you four. I gave you four
- 1:26:36questions. I did the service, sir, of
- 1:26:39answering all of your questions. You
- 1:26:41didn't even answer one of mine. How dare
- 1:26:43you?
- 1:26:46How dare you?
- 1:26:49What is this? Seriously. And the reason
- 1:26:51why, once again, I apologize to all the
- 1:26:54other Christians here. Why? This man,
- 1:26:56he's made mockumentaries against Islam.
- 1:26:58He's attacked Muslims, aggravated
- 1:27:00Muslims. We know his story. He's not any
- 1:27:03regular Christian. Ladies and gentlemen,
- 1:27:04the Quran says, better. The Christians
- 1:27:07are not all the same. If it was James
- 1:27:08White, I would have shown him the utmost
- 1:27:10respect. If it was William Lane Craig, I
- 1:27:12would have showed him the utmost
- 1:27:13respect. If it was any of those guys, I
- 1:27:14would have showed them the utmost
- 1:27:15respect. But this man, no, no, no, no,
- 1:27:19no, no.
- 1:27:22Read the Bible. I will teach you the
- 1:27:24Bible today. Mr. Please stay on topic.
- 1:27:27Okay, no problem.
- 1:27:31I've got two 1 minute and a half and
- 1:27:34I've I'm pretty much done. I can't
- 1:27:35believe it.
- 1:27:37Should I give it as a charity to him?
- 1:27:40I'll give it as a charity to you. Have a
- 1:27:43minute and a half. Charity from Muslim
- 1:27:45to you. Go ahead.
- 1:27:52Starting our second rebuttal. 8 minutes.
- 1:27:54Dr. David Wood, you may start.
- 1:27:56Uh, that's nine and a half. He said I I
- 1:27:58got it as as charity.
- 1:28:04Thank you. Thank you. I take I take all
- 1:28:06the charity. All right. Well, I guess
- 1:28:08we'll start off with the four questions.
- 1:28:10I always I knew we had more rebuttal
- 1:28:12time and I didn't think they were too
- 1:28:13terribly difficult to uh to answer. So,
- 1:28:15let's go through them.
- 1:28:18Question number one, why isn't the
- 1:28:20Trinity mentioned in the Old Testament?
- 1:28:24Well, I I pointed out multiple passages,
- 1:28:26multiple passages where you find a
- 1:28:29plurality. And the question is why you
- 1:28:31have this plurality if
- 1:28:34it's just this pure monotheism that
- 1:28:37Muslims believe in. I quoted Isaiah
- 1:28:4048:16 where Yahweh is speaking and
- 1:28:43Yahweh says that he has been sent by
- 1:28:44Yahweh along with the spirit of Yahweh.
- 1:28:48How do you make sense of that? Now to be
- 1:28:50clear that is not that is not a clear
- 1:28:56statement of the doctrine of the
- 1:28:58trinity. But to say that these passages
- 1:29:00refute the doctrine of the Trinity, that
- 1:29:02the Old Testament refutes the doctrine
- 1:29:03of the Trinity. Wait a minute. We'll
- 1:29:05keep this time.
- 1:29:19Even the go-to verse, right? You have
- 1:29:21lots of verses that sound like
- 1:29:23plurality. You have to interpret those
- 1:29:25away if you don't want to believe that
- 1:29:26the Old Testament is actually calling
- 1:29:29for saying that God is plural in some
- 1:29:31sense. But even the go-to passage, the
- 1:29:34Shama,
- 1:29:37which he said it in in the Old Testament
- 1:29:40and the New Testament, that's the goto
- 1:29:42verse. That's the go-to verse
- 1:29:47that proves this pure monotheism. You
- 1:29:51know what the the Shama actually says?
- 1:29:56Shama Israel, Yahweh Elohu, Yahweh.
- 1:30:00Now, we insert extra words in there to
- 1:30:02make that a complete sentence. What that
- 1:30:05actually says here, O Israel, Yahweh,
- 1:30:08it's the name of God. Elohu means our
- 1:30:11God. Yahweh means our that's God one.
- 1:30:17That's what it says here. Oh Israel,
- 1:30:21Yahweh, Elohu, Yahweh, one. That's what
- 1:30:24it says. Names God three times and then
- 1:30:28says one.
- 1:30:29Now, this is a Jewish commentary on the
- 1:30:34Torah.
- 1:30:36Wanted to quote this because this is a
- 1:30:38commentary on the Shama itself.
- 1:30:42They're commenting and they say, "Here,
- 1:30:43O Israel, Yahweh Elohu, Yahweh is one.
- 1:30:48These three are one. How can the three
- 1:30:51names be one? Only through the
- 1:30:54perception of faith in the vision of the
- 1:30:57Holy Spirit and the beholding of the
- 1:30:59hidden eyes alone.
- 1:31:02Now that the by the way these are
- 1:31:04unarians here but the fact that they're
- 1:31:07discussing a kind of triunity in the
- 1:31:11go-to passage for Muslims around the
- 1:31:14world to say this refutes the doctrine
- 1:31:16of the trinity and they're describing it
- 1:31:20in
- 1:31:22trinitarian terms again not the
- 1:31:24Christian trinity but triunity of the
- 1:31:26names there if that's your best you're
- 1:31:30going to need something better. So, you
- 1:31:32find plurality throughout the Old
- 1:31:34Testament in various passages. Why
- 1:31:36doesn't the why doesn't God specifically
- 1:31:39say trinity? Well, I think it's very
- 1:31:42similar to um what you find when Moses
- 1:31:44comes along and God says to him, uh
- 1:31:48Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob knew me, but
- 1:31:51they did not know me as Yahweh. Now,
- 1:31:54this isn't just talking about the name.
- 1:31:56It's talking about God's character. So,
- 1:31:59think about this. God is bringing a
- 1:32:01covenant. God is bringing a covenant to
- 1:32:03the children of Israel with Moses. And
- 1:32:07then he says, "I'm revealing more about
- 1:32:09myself than I did to Abraham, Isaac, and
- 1:32:12Jacob." Now, think about this. According
- 1:32:14to Muhammad, we'd have to say, "Ah,
- 1:32:16well, why didn't they know this earlier
- 1:32:17stuff then? Why didn't they have the
- 1:32:18same knowledge?" Well, Christians and
- 1:32:21Muslims believe in progressive
- 1:32:22revelation. God can give more. Now,
- 1:32:24think about what God did there. He's
- 1:32:26giving a covenant, a new covenant back.
- 1:32:28We call it the old covenant now, but
- 1:32:30back then it was a new covenant. He's
- 1:32:32giving a new covenant
- 1:32:35and he says, "I'm giving you a new
- 1:32:37covenant and I'm going to reveal more
- 1:32:38about myself to you."
- 1:32:42So, according to the Old Testament, what
- 1:32:44does God do when he brings a new
- 1:32:45covenant? Well, the pattern is he gives
- 1:32:48them a deeper understanding of who he
- 1:32:50is.
- 1:32:52So, why doesn't the Trinity just clearly
- 1:32:54define I mean, why doesn't the Old
- 1:32:56Testament clearly define the doctrine of
- 1:32:57the Trinity? Well, in the Old Testament
- 1:33:00as well, Jeremiah chapter 31, a new
- 1:33:02covenant is coming. It's prophesied in
- 1:33:04the future. The big one is coming. The
- 1:33:07big covenant is coming.
- 1:33:09Well, don't you think God's got some
- 1:33:11more information in store for the people
- 1:33:13of the new covenant when this new
- 1:33:15covenant comes? I do. And who brings the
- 1:33:19new covenant? Well, Jesus. It's Jesus
- 1:33:22entering the world and then the Holy
- 1:33:25Spirit being poured out where we find
- 1:33:28out about the inner life of God. And
- 1:33:31this is correlated with God's plan of
- 1:33:34salvation.
- 1:33:354 minutes left.
- 1:33:37So why isn't it clearly mentioned? Well,
- 1:33:40that that's how God works. He
- 1:33:42progressive revelation. He does this
- 1:33:43throughout the Bible. He keeps giving
- 1:33:44them more and more information,
- 1:33:46especially when he's giving a new
- 1:33:47covenant.
- 1:33:49Muhammad Jav says, "Well, why didn't the
- 1:33:51church fathers from the second, third
- 1:33:54century and so on give fourth century
- 1:33:56descriptions of the doctrine of the
- 1:33:58trinity?" Now, think about this. In the
- 1:34:00first century, the books of the Bible
- 1:34:03are passed out and they're they're sort
- 1:34:05of individual books. They're there's not
- 1:34:07a collection yet.
- 1:34:10So, in the first century, you've still
- 1:34:12got books circulating as individual
- 1:34:14books. By the second century, they start
- 1:34:16getting collected. But think about who
- 1:34:17Christians are. They're they're you've
- 1:34:19got farmers, you've got fishermen and so
- 1:34:20on. You don't have this early on this
- 1:34:24professional class of theologians that
- 1:34:26builds up over time.
- 1:34:30And for the first three centuries,
- 1:34:31Christians are an Christianity is an
- 1:34:34illegal religion and persecuted. They
- 1:34:36can't get together for big conferences
- 1:34:37to do stuff and to um and to have
- 1:34:41discussions like this. The first time
- 1:34:44they're able to get together and have
- 1:34:45these big these big councils is in the
- 1:34:48fourth century and that's what they do
- 1:34:50and it gets ironed out very quickly. So
- 1:34:53the problem as far as what's revealed to
- 1:34:56the Christians they have revelations
- 1:34:58about the father about the son about the
- 1:35:02spirit these things are given to them.
- 1:35:06One they need the tools of exigesis for
- 1:35:09saying this is what the holy spirit did.
- 1:35:11This is what Jesus did. How do we
- 1:35:14understand the eternal nature of God
- 1:35:15based on this? Well, that's kind of
- 1:35:18difficult work to do, ladies and
- 1:35:20gentlemen. It's kind of difficult work
- 1:35:21to do.
- 1:35:23So, that sort of thing takes a while.
- 1:35:25And they don't have the terminology. How
- 1:35:27are you describing God being one in
- 1:35:28essence or nature uh and three in
- 1:35:31person? They don't have the they don't
- 1:35:32even know what language to apply to the
- 1:35:34eternal God. They eventually settle on
- 1:35:36some, but that takes time.
- 1:35:39But throughout this, father is God, holy
- 1:35:42spirit is God, son is God. This is
- 1:35:44revealed in scripture. If every church
- 1:35:46father in the history of the world had
- 1:35:47gotten it wrong, that wouldn't change
- 1:35:48what the Bible teaches. And and by the
- 1:35:51way, just imagine if if we're going to
- 1:35:53be discussing uh the nature of the Quran
- 1:35:55or something like this. And I said, "Oh,
- 1:35:56you know, we got Sunnis and Shia and and
- 1:35:59uh these earlier heretical groups and
- 1:36:01everyone's getting stuff wrong and so
- 1:36:02on." Well, Islam should be defined by
- 1:36:05the the Islamic sources and the
- 1:36:07teachings that you could draw from them.
- 1:36:08Just like Christianity should be defined
- 1:36:09by Christian sources.
- 1:36:12Question three was who says that the
- 1:36:14Holy Spirit is co-equal and co-eternal.
- 1:36:18Which part of he's God? Don't you
- 1:36:21understand? Right? If the Holy Spirit is
- 1:36:25God, you say, "Ah, where do you say
- 1:36:28co-equal and co-eternal with the father
- 1:36:31like later creeds say? Where does it
- 1:36:32say? Where did they say that earlier?"
- 1:36:35One minute left.
- 1:36:36He's God.
- 1:36:38If I say
- 1:36:41the Holy Spirit has the attributes of
- 1:36:43God, you can ask, well, what about all
- 1:36:46these later distinctions that became
- 1:36:48very important to them later on when
- 1:36:49they're dealing with various kinds of
- 1:36:50heresies? They come up with the terms to
- 1:36:52respond to the heresy, but all of these
- 1:36:54are based on going back to the
- 1:36:56scriptures and seeing what lines up with
- 1:36:57them.
- 1:37:00And finally, how can we reconcile the
- 1:37:02contradiction of the trinity? Um, I
- 1:37:03don't know what you mean by
- 1:37:04contradiction. Uh contradiction is
- 1:37:06saying that a statement is both true and
- 1:37:08false at the same time in the same
- 1:37:10sense. Um no Christian says that God is
- 1:37:13one and three in the same sense. Never
- 1:37:15met a Christian who said that. We say
- 1:37:17that God is one in essence or being or
- 1:37:20nature and three in person. And if you
- 1:37:23say that's false, well I mean think even
- 1:37:24Islam believes that God is one in one
- 1:37:26way, more than one in another way. God
- 1:37:28is one on the level of being more than
- 1:37:30one on the level of attribute. His mercy
- 1:37:32triumphs over his wrath. You don't say
- 1:37:33that's another God. Why? Because that's
- 1:37:34the level of attribute. We have the
- 1:37:36level of person.
- 1:37:37Dr. Red, your time is up.
- 1:37:42Does he have anything else? That's it.
- 1:37:44Crossfire, right?
- 1:37:47Uh Mr. Hijab.
- 1:37:48Yeah.
- 1:37:49Uh if you want to stay seated for the
- 1:37:50crossfire, that's
- 1:37:51Oh, is there no conclusions?
- 1:37:53No conclusions.
- 1:37:54We're actually about to do the crossfire
- 1:37:56questions first.
- 1:38:00Uh so you can go ahead ask the first
- 1:38:02question to Dr. David Wood and he will
- 1:38:04have two minutes to respond.
- 1:38:07Well, let's let's start with the
- 1:38:08questions you did not answer. Which
- 1:38:10church father for the first 300 years
- 1:38:14explicitly mentioned that the Holy
- 1:38:16Spirit is co-equal, co-eternal with God?
- 1:38:21Go ahead, Dr. Wood.
- 1:38:23Again, from the Bible on, the Holy
- 1:38:26Spirit is God. Now, here's what I don't
- 1:38:29understand. If you take someone like
- 1:38:30Tertullian or something like this and
- 1:38:32say who calls the Holy Spirit God and
- 1:38:35the question then becomes well when did
- 1:38:38he say he's co-equal or co-eternal? What
- 1:38:40do you think God what do you think these
- 1:38:42guys mean when they say the Holy Spirit
- 1:38:44is God? What do you think the Bible
- 1:38:45means?
- 1:38:47The Bible calls him eternal. What do you
- 1:38:49mean co-eternal? If he's eternal then
- 1:38:52he's obviously co-eternal with the
- 1:38:54father.
- 1:38:55So I'm not under. It's like it's like
- 1:38:57saying if I tell you I am the current
- 1:38:59president of the United States and you
- 1:39:01say aha but where where are you claiming
- 1:39:03to be Donald Trump? Well, if I claim to
- 1:39:05be the current president of the United
- 1:39:07States, I would be claiming to be Donald
- 1:39:09Trump, right? I don't have to say that
- 1:39:11other thing, right? So if you say so and
- 1:39:13so is God or so and so has the
- 1:39:16attributes of God,
- 1:39:18it just doesn't make it just doesn't
- 1:39:19make sense to say, well, where is he
- 1:39:21co-equal with the father or co- this?
- 1:39:22These are
- 1:39:23one minute.
- 1:39:24These are terms. These are terms. This
- 1:39:26is language that was used
- 1:39:30in later councils
- 1:39:33to clarify, right? To clarify. I mean, I
- 1:39:36can turn right around and say, where
- 1:39:37does the Quran say that the Quran is
- 1:39:40eternal? Well, that's a conclusion you
- 1:39:42draw, right? That's a conclusion you
- 1:39:44draw from various things that the Quran
- 1:39:45says. It doesn't say that, right? You
- 1:39:48have to interpret it that way. I don't
- 1:39:49understand why you can say, okay, well,
- 1:39:51the Bible says that the father is God,
- 1:39:53the Holy Spirit is God, the son is God,
- 1:39:56and therefore, as far as the essence,
- 1:39:58the as far as their essence, they're all
- 1:40:00God. They're all Yahweh. And therefore,
- 1:40:02in that sense, they are co-equal.
- 1:40:04So, what you have is later church
- 1:40:06fathers saying, okay, if they all share
- 1:40:08the same essence, then in that sense,
- 1:40:10they're co-equal. Why would they why
- 1:40:12would you expect someone in the first
- 1:40:14century to use a word that came about to
- 1:40:16clarify something in the 4th century? I
- 1:40:19don't know.
- 1:40:20Thank you very much, Dr. Bud.
- 1:40:25You may ask your first question towards
- 1:40:26Mr. Hijab.
- 1:40:29Uh yes. Uh going back to Allah praying
- 1:40:32because I'm not just trying to mess with
- 1:40:34you guys here. I really I'm really
- 1:40:35confused, right? Um because as I pointed
- 1:40:39out, you have Muslim translators
- 1:40:41translating passages in the hadith
- 1:40:44saying that Allah and his creation
- 1:40:46praise and you look at the Quran and
- 1:40:49it's using similar word but this is
- 1:40:50different. This is the Quran and you
- 1:40:52know it's multiple passages and then
- 1:40:54Muslim translators are translating it as
- 1:40:56praise and then you have I think it's
- 1:40:58termed which which use it and it it
- 1:40:59won't translate it as anything. It just
- 1:41:01says Allah performs his salat, right?
- 1:41:03They won't say what it means because if
- 1:41:04you say it means praise, then you're
- 1:41:06you're going to be confused. And if you
- 1:41:07translate it as something else, well, it
- 1:41:10you're then you're going to have to nail
- 1:41:12down a definition of the word. So, what
- 1:41:14should this word mean? What should this
- 1:41:17in the in the Quran and the Hadith? How
- 1:41:19should this be translated?
- 1:41:21And why are even Muslim translators now
- 1:41:26translating as praise if there's this
- 1:41:27clear other meaning?
- 1:41:29I have two minutes. I don't think I need
- 1:41:32two minutes to be honest with you. I
- 1:41:33think I've dealt with that extensively.
- 1:41:34Um the word
- 1:41:37is different and there's these are
- 1:41:40basically these are certain
- 1:41:43prepositional words that come after the
- 1:41:46verb and depending on which of those
- 1:41:49words come it differentiates the meaning
- 1:41:51completely. So because it says salah and
- 1:41:53you'll never find anywhere in the Quran
- 1:41:55where it says Lee for example after the
- 1:41:57word salah in respective to the prophet
- 1:41:58Muhammad wasallam linguists and Muslims
- 1:42:02uh clearly concludes that um it means
- 1:42:07blessings etc. Now obviously just
- 1:42:09looking at the Quran on a cursory level
- 1:42:11if you read it in English the
- 1:42:13translations of the meanings you'll find
- 1:42:15that there are certain verses of Quran
- 1:42:16if you are just if you respect your
- 1:42:19intellect you will see that it does not
- 1:42:22tell you to pray to prophet Muhammad
- 1:42:23does not because it tells you only the
- 1:42:26Quran says only God is worthy of worship
- 1:42:29you know these things so one minute
- 1:42:32I appreciate that you've come a bit more
- 1:42:33humble this time and you said I'm
- 1:42:35confused I hope I hope you have
- 1:42:38understood this now and if you don't I
- 1:42:40think you should blame your intellect
- 1:42:41and your lack of knowledge and that's
- 1:42:43that's that's the state it should be
- 1:42:44right now but just to just to kind of
- 1:42:46touch upon what you said cuz I do have a
- 1:42:48bit of time about Tatulian he was a
- 1:42:49subordinationist Tertullian was a
- 1:42:51subordinationist he died 240 I don't
- 1:42:53actually think you read his works I I
- 1:42:56don't believe you read his works his
- 1:42:57primary source materials all stipulate
- 1:42:59he does use the language of the 4th
- 1:43:01century men but he does not use it in
- 1:43:02the context of the Holy Spirit and so
- 1:43:05therefore I conclude that to And that's
- 1:43:07why he's deemed as a heretic by the
- 1:43:09Catholics. He's and and by the
- 1:43:10Protestants he's deemed and other people
- 1:43:12are deemed as heretics. So it's a back
- 1:43:14projection based on later developments
- 1:43:16of the church. And this is something you
- 1:43:18could not deal with basically in this uh
- 1:43:2110 seconds
- 1:43:21in in in this particular in this
- 1:43:23particular debate.
- 1:43:29Thank you very much Mr. Kab. You may go
- 1:43:31forward with your second question.
- 1:43:32All right. So you you spoke about the
- 1:43:34attributes of um you spoke about the
- 1:43:37attributes of the holy spirit etc. I'm
- 1:43:39I'm just going to give you one example.
- 1:43:40I mean it's a very easy question. In
- 1:43:43Mark chapter 13 verse 32 it says only
- 1:43:47the father knows when the hour is. Now I
- 1:43:50understand why the son might not know
- 1:43:51because it's the human side. You see
- 1:43:53it's the human side. So he you know the
- 1:43:55the god side might know but the human
- 1:43:57but what about the holy spirit? Why does
- 1:43:59the holy spirit not know when the hour
- 1:44:01is?
- 1:44:03[Applause]
- 1:44:06We have two minutes. Dr. Wood.
- 1:44:09Well, the Holy Spirit is included. Uh we
- 1:44:12have elsewhere that the Holy Spirit
- 1:44:14searches the mind of God knows
- 1:44:15everything that God knows. Um if you
- 1:44:17look at what Jesus is doing there when
- 1:44:19he says um when he says no one, he's
- 1:44:22referring to the level of human beings.
- 1:44:24By the way, if you if you guys like that
- 1:44:26verse, that's uh if you believe Jesus
- 1:44:29said that, then Islam is false. Because
- 1:44:31notice you've got father and son there.
- 1:44:33According to the Quran, Allah is a
- 1:44:34father to no one. The highest
- 1:44:35relationship you can have with Allah is
- 1:44:36a slave to master relationship. So um if
- 1:44:39you believe that then Islam is false. Um
- 1:44:42but if you look what he says there
- 1:44:44already he sets up a hierarchy says the
- 1:44:48day of the time. He says no one knows
- 1:44:50referring to the level of men. And then
- 1:44:52he says not even the angels.
- 1:44:55So that's the entire created order. No
- 1:44:59man knows. Not even the angels,
- 1:45:02not even the son, only the father. So
- 1:45:05even in this verse you're quoting, he's
- 1:45:08putting himself
- 1:45:09one minute left.
- 1:45:10He's putting himself above all of
- 1:45:12creation. He's putting himself above all
- 1:45:15of creation. And so the question is, why
- 1:45:18wouldn't why would Jesus say that he
- 1:45:19doesn't know the hour? Well, there's
- 1:45:21there's a long explanation um which I'm
- 1:45:24not even sure is correct. Uh but usually
- 1:45:27we would we would explain this in terms
- 1:45:29of
- 1:45:31give me the easier one here. Hey, you're
- 1:45:33interfering with my time here. The
- 1:45:36straightforward one um is Christians
- 1:45:38also believe in the canosis when Jesus
- 1:45:41takes on human nature. They find this in
- 1:45:43John 1 uh and uh what Muhammad mentioned
- 1:45:46earlier um the the uh hymn to Christ in
- 1:45:49Philippians where it says he was in the
- 1:45:51form of God but he made himself nothing
- 1:45:54taking on the nature of a servant. We
- 1:45:56believe he actually took on the nature
- 1:45:58of the servant and limited himself in
- 1:46:01that way. If you believe it's a problem
- 1:46:02by the way I mean think about it. The
- 1:46:04Quran doesn't contain verses that the
- 1:46:06eternal Quran has and yet you still
- 1:46:07believe you have the Quran even though
- 1:46:10certain things have been withheld from
- 1:46:12you. So
- 1:46:13thank you very much Dr. Woods
- 1:46:21verbal reactions.
- 1:46:23Uh you can start your second question
- 1:46:24right now. Uh yeah. Um I'm confused by
- 1:46:29this
- 1:46:30uh claim which you made earlier that
- 1:46:32that Jews u Jews have regarded the
- 1:46:35doctrine of the trinity as polytheism.
- 1:46:37Jews never saw any plurality uh in the
- 1:46:39Old Testament. That's simply false. U
- 1:46:42before the end of the 2nd century AD it
- 1:46:44was very widespread to see a plurality
- 1:46:46within the one God. Um, this is from
- 1:46:48Benjamin Summer, uh, from the Jewish
- 1:46:50Theological Seminary in New York, who
- 1:46:52writes, "No Jew sensitive to Judaism's
- 1:46:55own classical sources can fault the
- 1:46:57theological model Christianity employs
- 1:47:00when it avows belief in a God who has an
- 1:47:02earthly body as well as a Holy Spirit
- 1:47:04and a heavenly manifestation. For that
- 1:47:06model, we have seen, is a perfectly
- 1:47:09Jewish one. A religion whose scripture
- 1:47:11contains the fluidity traditions whose
- 1:47:13teachings emphasize the multiplicity of
- 1:47:16the sheckchina and whose thinkers speak
- 1:47:18of the sephero does not differ in its
- 1:47:21theological essentials from a religion.
- 1:47:23That's a question or is it sorry that's
- 1:47:25a question or
- 1:47:26yeah it's a question. If Jewish scholars
- 1:47:28who are acknowledging that uh the turn
- 1:47:31to uh unitarianism only arose in the
- 1:47:34second century as a reaction to
- 1:47:35Christianity to set themselves against
- 1:47:37the Christians more um how can you say
- 1:47:40that Jews never saw this when it's
- 1:47:41widely understood that they did.
- 1:47:43Okay, you have two minutes.
- 1:47:46Thank you for that question.
- 1:47:48He talked about in the last part of his
- 1:47:50speech the shama and how it could mean
- 1:47:52three gods. Now he's speaking about he
- 1:47:54spoke about 3 minutes about Prophet
- 1:47:55Muhammad spitting. I believe believe you
- 1:47:58me I I I think that genuinely speaking
- 1:48:00if you s if you gave your exeutical
- 1:48:02interpretation to a rabbi I think he
- 1:48:04would spit at you. Um because I don't
- 1:48:06think anybody of the Jewish in in 4,000
- 1:48:10years of Hebrew history has ever
- 1:48:12believed in in what you say that they
- 1:48:15believed. Give me one primary source of
- 1:48:18any Jew that believed in the Trinity.
- 1:48:21one. Don't give me Benjamin Summers.
- 1:48:23He's he's a secondary source material.
- 1:48:25You're meant to come here with academic
- 1:48:26uh information at hand. I've only I've
- 1:48:28only mostly quoted you primary source
- 1:48:31materials. You're an academic. You
- 1:48:32understand how it works in academia.
- 1:48:34Give me a primary source material of a
- 1:48:36Jew who believed three co-equal
- 1:48:40co-eternal
- 1:48:42independent beings. You will never or
- 1:48:45persons of a of one God. You will never
- 1:48:48find this.
- 1:48:48One minute left.
- 1:48:50Okay. Okay. In that minute, what since
- 1:48:52since to be honest with you, I mean, it
- 1:48:55was pretty easy to answer his his
- 1:48:57question.
- 1:48:59Actually, I'll give it to him, man. I
- 1:49:00don't need to. I'll give it to him. I'll
- 1:49:02give it to him.
- 1:49:04[Music]
- 1:49:08Is it my turn to ask?
- 1:49:09Yeah. Go ahead.
- 1:49:13Okay.
- 1:49:14I'll give you a primary source material.
- 1:49:17Justin Marta was a um was a church
- 1:49:21father as you know who was very early I
- 1:49:25think he died 110 or something like that
- 1:49:26AD and he wrote a book called the first
- 1:49:28apologies.
- 1:49:30In chapter 21 of this book,
- 1:49:33Justin Martr was having a conversation
- 1:49:35with a pagan. Okay? And he said to the
- 1:49:39person, the pagan, he said to him
- 1:49:43that just as you believe that Jupiter is
- 1:49:46God and there are sons of Jupiter,
- 1:49:50we believe that the father is God and
- 1:49:53Jesus is the son of God. My question to
- 1:49:56you is this.
- 1:49:59How can you assure us today that in the
- 1:50:02first 300 years of Christian history
- 1:50:05that there has not been a Greek
- 1:50:08mythological influence
- 1:50:11in the formulation of the Trinity?
- 1:50:16You have two minutes, Dr. Wood.
- 1:50:21Well, um,
- 1:50:24we we have first century documents,
- 1:50:27right? Um, with the the possible
- 1:50:30exception of of Luke, they're all devout
- 1:50:33Jews. They had utter contempt for the
- 1:50:37religions of the pagans, of the
- 1:50:40polytheists. Um, the scriptures that
- 1:50:42they appealed to are the Old Testament.
- 1:50:45These guys were thoroughly Jewish. They
- 1:50:48appealed to Old Testament prophecies.
- 1:50:50They are devout monotheists.
- 1:50:55Um the the views they came to have about
- 1:50:57Jesus and the Holy Spirit came from
- 1:51:00Jesus and the Holy Spirit. They didn't
- 1:51:02go up to Europe and get something about
- 1:51:04Zeus or something like that. Um so we
- 1:51:07know where their beliefs came from,
- 1:51:08right? Jesus comes in the world. Jesus
- 1:51:10makes all kinds of claims. Um these
- 1:51:12guys, many of these uh early Christians
- 1:51:14went to their horrible bloody deaths
- 1:51:18proclaiming that Jesus is Lord.
- 1:51:21One minute left.
- 1:51:22If they were just sort of trying to
- 1:51:24compromise or picking up something they
- 1:51:26heard uh in in the market,
- 1:51:29um they they wouldn't have to deal with
- 1:51:32that sort of thing. Um, as for as for
- 1:51:34for Justin Martyr, now Justin, everyone
- 1:51:36acknowledges that Justin Martyr makes a
- 1:51:38bad comparison, but he's actually
- 1:51:39appealing to the Roman leaders to stop
- 1:51:41persecuting Christian. He's he's making
- 1:51:44a plea here. Stop killing us. Stop the
- 1:51:47persecutions, please. We're begging you.
- 1:51:49And in this, it's well, you know, we
- 1:51:53believe Jesus is the son of God. You
- 1:51:54believe in sons of God. So why why are
- 1:51:55you guys out here? Why why are you guys
- 1:51:57out here persecuting us? um you can't
- 1:52:00draw a tremendous amount uh of that
- 1:52:02about our uh theology coming from them
- 1:52:07especially when you have Old Testament
- 1:52:09passages about the son the Messiah uh
- 1:52:13and the Messiah being the son and the
- 1:52:15son being the mighty God.
- 1:52:18Thank you very much Dr. Wood. You may
- 1:52:20ask your third question.
- 1:52:27Yes. um tawhed. Um
- 1:52:32Mhm.
- 1:52:33when we look at all the things we have
- 1:52:34here, we have the uh eternal word of
- 1:52:37Allah, which is co-eternal. And so he's
- 1:52:39got his co-eternal word with him. Uh
- 1:52:40we've got a spirit. We've got all of
- 1:52:43these different things going on. And
- 1:52:46then you have the wordhed
- 1:52:49to describe it, which doesn't simply
- 1:52:51mean oneness as I understand it. So I so
- 1:52:53since you're uh talking about the Arabic
- 1:52:55here um as I understand it comes from
- 1:52:58wahada which means to unify and
- 1:53:01therefore means the unification. But if
- 1:53:04you're unifying something then you're
- 1:53:05bringing different things together. And
- 1:53:08so if we look and we see these flocks of
- 1:53:11birds taking the place of the pagan
- 1:53:13goddesses and uh interceding for you and
- 1:53:16things like that. Um,
- 1:53:20could this wordhed mean something beyond
- 1:53:23oneness here when we see all of these
- 1:53:25different thing? If if Allah is trying
- 1:53:27to avoid anything buted and you've got
- 1:53:29all of these different things and things
- 1:53:31that are co-eternal with him and
- 1:53:33interceding flocks of birds,
- 1:53:36uh,
- 1:53:38how do we reconcile all this?
- 1:53:40Okay, thank you. Um,
- 1:53:44is a what you call a must in the Arabic
- 1:53:46language. Yes, you're right to say it
- 1:53:47comes from the Arabic word
- 1:53:50uh which means unifying something and it
- 1:53:53could mean different things in different
- 1:53:54context for sure. Now the Quran, let's
- 1:53:57look at what the Quran actually says.
- 1:53:58The Quran says
- 1:54:01one more time.
- 1:54:03One more time.
- 1:54:04Thank you. One more time.
- 1:54:06One more time. Okay. Okay.
- 1:54:12In Arabic language means the one and
- 1:54:14only.
- 1:54:16Yes, there was there's a difference
- 1:54:17between wah and wahed could mean
- 1:54:20something which is cardinally counted.
- 1:54:22There's cardinal numbers one the first
- 1:54:25second third. Yes.
- 1:54:28Yeah. But
- 1:54:30a can never be. So it means one and
- 1:54:33only. That's what the Quran says in one
- 1:54:35of the smallest chapters. Um when you
- 1:54:39say that the the Quran 1 minute left
- 1:54:42the Quran this is this is a musf. Okay.
- 1:54:44These are pages and this this is these
- 1:54:47are pages, right? We don't believe these
- 1:54:49pages and this ink is co-eternal. We
- 1:54:52don't believe that. Do you do you
- 1:54:55understand what I'm saying? These pages
- 1:54:56and this ink this this is not we don't
- 1:54:59believe Muslims have never said no
- 1:55:01Muslim has ever said in history that
- 1:55:02this is co-eternal. It's never there.
- 1:55:04Not even the maz have said this by the
- 1:55:06way from
- 1:55:08died 133 AD ah. So no one has said that.
- 1:55:12What we believe is that the calam of
- 1:55:14Allah which is the words of Allah are an
- 1:55:16attribute of God without we don't make
- 1:55:19we don't liken it and that the Quran
- 1:55:23spoken from Allah is a subset of that
- 1:55:26attribute that's our belief not this
- 1:55:28physical thing here that you see the
- 1:55:31papers and things we don't believe in
- 1:55:32that
- 1:55:33thank you very much Mr. Hijab
- 1:55:38before Mr. Hijab says his fourth
- 1:55:40question just a friendly reminder uh
- 1:55:42please turn your cell phones off or keep
- 1:55:43it on silent so it won't distract the
- 1:55:45speakers. Thank you very much. You may
- 1:55:46go ahead Mr. Hab.
- 1:55:49Thank you very much.
- 1:55:52The question I have is
- 1:55:55um looking at a lot of your content
- 1:55:56online in the past week or two I found
- 1:55:59that
- 1:56:01seemingly I mean you can correct me if
- 1:56:02I'm wrong. Yeah. you seem to make a
- 1:56:05moral case for uh Christianity and a
- 1:56:08moral case against Islam. I watched one
- 1:56:11of your videos with someone called Ali
- 1:56:12Atai, I think his name was, and he he
- 1:56:14made the point. He he asked you a
- 1:56:15question. It's on the record. He said,
- 1:56:18"If Jesus," and this is what we've been
- 1:56:20talking about today, uh is the author of
- 1:56:23the Old Testament. If Jesus is the
- 1:56:25author of the Old Testament, how can you
- 1:56:28explain all of the things which is
- 1:56:30deemed as immoral? Because as a a divine
- 1:56:33command theorist, I would expect you to
- 1:56:36believe that all of the things in the
- 1:56:37Old Testament in terms of injunctions,
- 1:56:39if they had been made by Jesus, who is
- 1:56:41meant to be the author of the Old
- 1:56:42Testament, God, the triune God,
- 1:56:45would have been good. But you actually
- 1:56:47said it's bad. There are lots of bad
- 1:56:49these are your words. There are lots of
- 1:56:50bad things in the Old Testament. Now, if
- 1:56:53Jesus is God and he's the author of the
- 1:56:55Old Testament
- 1:56:57and he has bad injunctions,
- 1:57:00how can you reconcile the fact that God,
- 1:57:03a maximally perfect good being, could
- 1:57:06give us bad injunctions?
- 1:57:12Dr. Wood, I have two minutes.
- 1:57:14Yeah, I don't recall saying uh bad
- 1:57:16things. I'll have to take a look at the
- 1:57:18clip. Um, I did acknowledge that there
- 1:57:20are all I said there are all sorts of
- 1:57:21things in the uh in the Bible that
- 1:57:23bother me. I do I do recall saying that.
- 1:57:27And what I mean by that is I'm a
- 1:57:28philosopher. I'm a former atheist. When
- 1:57:31and this would go for the Quran as well.
- 1:57:33When when you know things that passages
- 1:57:36talking about hell or something like
- 1:57:37that, eternal torment or uh warfare,
- 1:57:40something like that. Well, those things
- 1:57:42bother me. That doesn't mean I reject
- 1:57:44that they're from God. But okay, those
- 1:57:45are I I I've noticed a mindset in Islam
- 1:57:48that if you accept Islam, you you can
- 1:57:50never really think critically about it.
- 1:57:53And I I I I can't I can't be like that.
- 1:57:56So, uh always I'm always wrestling with
- 1:57:59issues um Old Testament and New
- 1:58:02Testament um and with the Quran as well.
- 1:58:04So as far as as far as the the the moral
- 1:58:06case
- 1:58:08if we're talking about uh Old Testament
- 1:58:10passages looking at those things yeah I
- 1:58:12would say these things are these things
- 1:58:14ah the you know the the
- 1:58:16one minute left
- 1:58:16entering the land of Canaan and fighting
- 1:58:18the Canaanites and so on those things
- 1:58:20those things uh they make me wonder
- 1:58:22sometimes but um if you believe that
- 1:58:25Jesus rose from the dead then you have
- 1:58:28to say okay if Jesus rose from the dead
- 1:58:29then if I'm going to listen to anyone
- 1:58:31tell me about God I'm going to listen to
- 1:58:34Jesus. And so if he's Lord, then hey, if
- 1:58:38something bothers me, that's my problem,
- 1:58:40right? That's that's my problem. That's
- 1:58:41something I have to wrestle with. God
- 1:58:43accepts that we have to wrestle with
- 1:58:44things. The Psalms are filled with
- 1:58:45people really really wondering why
- 1:58:47certain things are happening. And uh I
- 1:58:49don't think that's a bad thing. And I
- 1:58:51don't think God thinks it's a bad thing.
- 1:58:52Uh when we look at something and go,
- 1:58:54"Ah, that's really rough. Now I really
- 1:58:55want to I really want to think about
- 1:58:56that." So I don't see that as any big
- 1:58:58problem. If something bothers me, but
- 1:59:01I'm convinced that I have good reasons
- 1:59:03to believe in Christianity, then
- 1:59:0410 seconds.
- 1:59:05I don't really see the problem. Uh, and
- 1:59:07that's why I would still accept it.
- 1:59:10Because Jesus rose from the dead.
- 1:59:13Thank you, Dr. Wood. You may ask your
- 1:59:16fourth question.
- 1:59:18[Music]
- 1:59:18[Applause]
- 1:59:20Yes. in the hadith. I'm I'm wondering um
- 1:59:24because when Allah says, however you
- 1:59:26want to translate it, he says uh he
- 1:59:29prays and the angels pray therefore you
- 1:59:32pray. It's like he's setting himself up
- 1:59:33as a model. So, however you want to
- 1:59:34translate that, that's not the point.
- 1:59:35I'm going to talk about that. Um but
- 1:59:37he's setting himself up as a kind of
- 1:59:38model for behavior. But in the hadith,
- 1:59:40we read Muhammad saying that uh if you
- 1:59:44swear by
- 1:59:45any which hadith?
- 1:59:46Yeah, there's a question. If you swear
- 1:59:47by anything other than Allah, you're
- 1:59:50committing shik and setting it up as a
- 1:59:52partner with Allah. So if Muhammad says
- 1:59:54that swearing by anything is committing
- 1:59:56shik. And in the Quran, Allah swears by
- 1:59:59literally everything. He swears by all
- 2:00:00kinds of things and then says he swears
- 2:00:02by the seen and the unseen.
- 2:00:05Then if Muhammad says doing this is shik
- 2:00:08and Allah then does it with literally
- 2:00:10everything. Uh, doesn't this sound more
- 2:00:14like pantheism than if everything is set
- 2:00:16up with a part as a partner with Allah?
- 2:00:18So, it it's mainly about what sort of
- 2:00:20things Allah has to do when Muhammad
- 2:00:22lays down rules like that.
- 2:00:23You have two minutes, Mr. Thank you. Uh,
- 2:00:27shik by definition can only be done by
- 2:00:31other than Allah.
- 2:00:33by definition
- 2:00:37because shik it means associating
- 2:00:40partners with Allah.
- 2:00:42You can't that's what that's what shik
- 2:00:44is associating partners with Allah. So
- 2:00:47Allah can not it's not within Allah's
- 2:00:51attributes to do shik it's not possible
- 2:00:54that's not a possibility right so the
- 2:00:56question that you ask is about how comes
- 2:01:00Allah
- 2:01:03all this in the world and all this. He
- 2:01:05makes what we call he does oaths in the
- 2:01:08Quran. Well, Allah even does an oath by
- 2:01:10himself.
- 2:01:16So the point is why does Allah have the
- 2:01:19ability to do to make an oath with
- 2:01:22anything he wants and we can only make
- 2:01:24an oath with Allah? Because Allah owns
- 2:01:26everything.
- 2:01:27One minute left
- 2:01:28and to Allah we belong. This is the
- 2:01:30reality. Yeah. So, and the scholars say
- 2:01:34And the scholars say whatever Allah
- 2:01:36makes an oath of that becomes what you
- 2:01:38call it becomes an important thing in
- 2:01:41the Sharia. Okay. Now, really and truly
- 2:01:44just to because some Muslims might be
- 2:01:46confused with is it true that someone
- 2:01:48does with other than Allah that they've
- 2:01:50committed major shik. This is not the
- 2:01:53view of the majority of scholars. All
- 2:01:55right? So they say that this is a minor
- 2:01:56kind of shik just for the
- 2:01:59things. Don't make of your friends that
- 2:02:01saying oh on my mom's life. Yes. Don't
- 2:02:03do an excommunication of them. Um so
- 2:02:05that hopefully answers your question.
- 2:02:09Thank you Mr.
- 2:02:11You may ask your fifth question.
- 2:02:13Oh yes. This was really interesting.
- 2:02:17It's a follow-up from what you said
- 2:02:18before because it seems to me that it
- 2:02:21was not a satisfactory answer. You were
- 2:02:23saying that you were wrestling with with
- 2:02:25these things in the Bible. Wrestling
- 2:02:27grappling in your mind about these
- 2:02:28things in the Bible in the Old
- 2:02:30Testament.
- 2:02:31You seem to think that morality Yes. can
- 2:02:36be achieved. You're a philosopher. Yes.
- 2:02:39Can be achieved from other than a
- 2:02:42objective moral. This is your suggestion
- 2:02:43that an objective morality can be
- 2:02:45achieved from other than the objective
- 2:02:48law.
- 2:02:50So I want to understand
- 2:02:52as a are you a divine command theorist?
- 2:02:55Do you believe that the injunctions of
- 2:02:57God must be perfect? And if if you do
- 2:03:01believe this, how can you explain and
- 2:03:03you did say bad? It can easily be
- 2:03:05retrieved on the internet. I listened to
- 2:03:07it just yesterday. You said the the the
- 2:03:08Old Testament has bad things in it. You
- 2:03:10said this. Yes. How can you explain that
- 2:03:13a maximally perfect good God
- 2:03:18at one point and time
- 2:03:23put forward injunctions which could be
- 2:03:26bad or which otherwise bother you? Can
- 2:03:29you explain?
- 2:03:33You
- 2:03:33have got two minutes, Dr. Wood. Oh,
- 2:03:35well, I mean, if you mean, hey, you
- 2:03:37know, there's all kinds of really bad
- 2:03:39things going on in the Old Testament.
- 2:03:40Yes. very very bad things going on in
- 2:03:42the Old Testament, right? It's it's a
- 2:03:43it's a history, right? But I mean, you
- 2:03:45you can take any history book and say,
- 2:03:47"Oh, look at all these uh bad things
- 2:03:48going on." If you mean the things that
- 2:03:50you know that uh that I say when you
- 2:03:53know, hey, you know, I'm wondering about
- 2:03:54this. That's not just me. I mean, I'm a
- 2:03:58diagnosed psychopath, right? I don't
- 2:04:00have I don't have uh bad feelings uh
- 2:04:03about these kinds of things. Uh the
- 2:04:05reconciliation is that in the New
- 2:04:07Testament, God is defined as love,
- 2:04:09right? We're told God is love, which we
- 2:04:12only understand in a trinitarian, it it
- 2:04:14makes no sense for God to be love from
- 2:04:17all eternity. Uh but in the light of the
- 2:04:21doctrine of the trinity with father,
- 2:04:22son, and holy spirit. Now, we can see
- 2:04:23how how God can be love from all
- 2:04:25eternity, not just uh not just uh one
- 2:04:29person within God. So if Jesus says that
- 2:04:33if we're told that that God loves
- 2:04:35everyone,
- 2:04:36one minute left,
- 2:04:37that we are to love everyone, that we
- 2:04:39are to harm no one, that we are to seek
- 2:04:43peace with everyone, we're told these,
- 2:04:46then I have to obey these kinds of
- 2:04:48things. And so the difficult part, the
- 2:04:52difficult part then becomes, well, what
- 2:04:54do I do about these wars and so on given
- 2:04:57what I now believe about God? And so
- 2:04:59that's where the struggle comes in. Uh
- 2:05:01fortunately uh the Bible does deal with
- 2:05:03that, right? Jesus says Jesus says Moses
- 2:05:06allowed divorce in these certain in in
- 2:05:09these circumstances because of the
- 2:05:10hardness of your heart. But from the
- 2:05:12beginning it was not. So now look at
- 2:05:14what he said here. This is not the will
- 2:05:16of God. God is allowing certain things
- 2:05:18at certain times because of the hardness
- 2:05:20of your heart. So even according to the
- 2:05:22Bible that is not the ideal situation.
- 2:05:24That is not God's will for humanity. God
- 2:05:27looks down and sees a world of sinners
- 2:05:30and then has to deal with that, right?
- 2:05:33And it's not always it's not always
- 2:05:35going to be pretty. But the New
- 2:05:36Testament affirms that the the the
- 2:05:38situations in the Old Testament were not
- 2:05:39always ideal.
- 2:05:41Thank you, Dr. Wood.
- 2:05:42[Music]
- 2:05:43[Applause]
- 2:05:45You may ask your fifth question.
- 2:05:48Um yes.
- 2:05:51Chapter 61:E14
- 2:05:53of the Quran. Um, Allah says that he
- 2:05:56aided the true followers of Jesus until
- 2:05:59they became uppermost. Now, I suppose
- 2:06:02you can interpret that in different
- 2:06:02ways. Commentators such as Ysef Ali
- 2:06:04interpreted it specifically to mean that
- 2:06:07Christians, the Christian followers of
- 2:06:09Jesus took over the Roman Empire and
- 2:06:11that that's how that's how they became
- 2:06:13uppermost and uh and more powerful than
- 2:06:16the Jews who rejected Jesus. But we know
- 2:06:19that the Christianity that that took
- 2:06:21over Europe, took over the Roman Empire
- 2:06:23believed in Jesus death, resurrection,
- 2:06:26and deity and the Trinity by the time
- 2:06:28they did. And so why would Allah help
- 2:06:31the the wrong Christians if there were
- 2:06:33earlier Christians who believe the right
- 2:06:35thing? Why did Allah help the wrong ones
- 2:06:36according to the Quran?
- 2:06:38According to the Quran,
- 2:06:40thank you. According to the Quran, the
- 2:06:43disciples of Jesus, the were Muslim.
- 2:06:47This is the answer. Okay. The Quran says
- 2:06:49about the in chapter 3 of the Quran,
- 2:06:55let us know. Let be bear witness that we
- 2:06:58are Muslims. Meaning what? Not that they
- 2:07:00believed in Prophet Muhammad. No, that
- 2:07:02they were submitters to God in the same
- 2:07:03way that Jesus was in John 5:30. I don't
- 2:07:06submit myself to my own will, but the
- 2:07:08will of God. So why did Allah help the
- 2:07:12inah in chapter 61 of the Quran or in
- 2:07:16chapter 3 of the Quran? Because they
- 2:07:18followed Jesus and he was a prophet of
- 2:07:21God. And so therefore Allah he helped
- 2:07:24them because he they followed the true
- 2:07:26prophet at that time. And that true
- 2:07:28prophet which we believe in as the
- 2:07:30Messiah was Jesus Christ. So it was
- 2:07:32nothing to do with the Roman Empire.
- 2:07:33This tap is null and void. You will not
- 2:07:35find it anywhere of surah. this thing
- 2:07:38about the Roman Empire. No, no, this is
- 2:07:40one minute left. You will not find this
- 2:07:41in you'll not find this in you'll not
- 2:07:43find this in you will not find this in
- 2:07:45any of the works is something I don't
- 2:07:48know where you've got it from. But here
- 2:07:49the the the initial point is that the
- 2:07:52disciples we have good opinion of them.
- 2:07:55Yes. And that is why I say to you and
- 2:07:57I've been saying to you for the for the
- 2:07:58whole discussion you will not find a
- 2:08:01apostolic succession for your beliefs as
- 2:08:04a Christian. You will not find apostolic
- 2:08:07um you will not find an apostolic
- 2:08:09provenence back to Jesus Christ for what
- 2:08:12you believe. You have to go further back
- 2:08:13in time. You have to back project. You
- 2:08:15have to take the ideas of the later
- 2:08:17people and basically in in in Islamic
- 2:08:20terms make you have to render heretical
- 2:08:23the earlier people. We as Muslims we
- 2:08:26believe that the earlier peoples of the
- 2:08:27prophets were the best and then they
- 2:08:29became worse as it goes on. You as
- 2:08:31Christians believe in the opposite and
- 2:08:32that's a disaster of a belief.
- 2:08:37[Music]
- 2:08:39Thank you, Mr. Hijab. You may ask your
- 2:08:41sixth and final question
- 2:08:43related to this.
- 2:08:45I want to just ask this question one
- 2:08:48last time cuz I've given him many times
- 2:08:50in this debate an opportunity to ask
- 2:08:52this question. Okay. My question is
- 2:08:55simple. I appreciate that early church
- 2:08:59fathers believed that Jesus was God.
- 2:09:03Some of them did believe that. Some of
- 2:09:04them believed he was God but not
- 2:09:07co-equal that he was in a hierarchy.
- 2:09:09Some of them believed he was God but not
- 2:09:12in the same level as like
- 2:09:12subordinationism. Right?
- 2:09:15I am asking a question. If they could
- 2:09:19designate Jesus as God co-equal and
- 2:09:23co-eternal and they use that language
- 2:09:26respective to Jesus, can you give me one
- 2:09:28person who has interpreted the New
- 2:09:31Testament? Yeah, for in the first 300
- 2:09:34years who has said the same thing about
- 2:09:37the Holy Spirit because if you cannot
- 2:09:41the frank truth is you have a baseless
- 2:09:44foundation for your belief for 300 years
- 2:09:47people would have been the farmer as you
- 2:09:49in your word the farmer the fisherman
- 2:09:51the you know the butcher the teacher all
- 2:09:54of those individuals are damned to hell
- 2:09:57despite the fact that they had the
- 2:09:58gospels in front of them because they
- 2:10:01couldn't make the natural inference of
- 2:10:02the Holy Spirit being God. Can you give
- 2:10:04me one person church father first 300
- 2:10:07years who designated the Holy Spirit as
- 2:10:11co-equal, co-eternal, independent? The
- 2:10:15same language that they use in na for
- 2:10:17the Holy Spirit. Please do so.
- 2:10:22[Applause]
- 2:10:24I'm shocked that people still take this
- 2:10:25serious. Who called the Holy Spirit
- 2:10:27co-eternal? The Bible calls him eternal.
- 2:10:30Amen.
- 2:10:31The Bible calls him eternal.
- 2:10:36That language that specifically he he
- 2:10:39said here's a council in the 4th century
- 2:10:41that came up with a specific way of uh
- 2:10:44phrasing things. Well, that was to help
- 2:10:46people avoid confusion here. So, if
- 2:10:49we're saying that the Holy Spirit uh is
- 2:10:52God, Father is God, the Son is God, if
- 2:10:55this is revealed in scripture, there's
- 2:10:57only one God, guess what? That's what
- 2:10:58they are believing, right?
- 2:11:00If someone objects at some point and
- 2:11:02says, "Uh, I believe that the Holy
- 2:11:05Spirit is not eternal." Well, then in
- 2:11:08your creed, you need to clarify, hey,
- 2:11:10this guy doesn't know what he's talking
- 2:11:11about. The Bible says that he's eternal,
- 2:11:13so he's co-eternal with the father. And
- 2:11:16so, they put it in a creed. Just to be
- 2:11:19clear, creeds have no authority beyond
- 2:11:21the scripture.
- 2:11:23One minute left.
- 2:11:24There's the scripture, but it's a lot.
- 2:11:28It's 66 books, covers,500 years, 40
- 2:11:32different authors, right? There are
- 2:11:34threads running throughout the
- 2:11:36scripture, right? The purpose of the
- 2:11:38creed is to say, here's a little short
- 2:11:41list of the essentials.
- 2:11:43Here's a short list of the essentials to
- 2:11:45make sure that you're on the right side
- 2:11:47of being an Orthodox Christian. And so,
- 2:11:50they put a little creed there just
- 2:11:52because, oh, so and so is coming to a
- 2:11:54different position and he's
- 2:11:55contradicting the Bible. Therefore, we
- 2:11:56need to me we need to make sure we
- 2:11:57mention co-eterneternal here, right? But
- 2:12:00the co-eternal does not come from the
- 2:12:02council. The co-eternal comes from the
- 2:12:04Bible, right? And all of the claims
- 2:12:06about the equality of the father, the
- 2:12:08son, and the holy spirit, those come
- 2:12:11from the scripture acknowledging them
- 2:12:13all as Yahweh. 10 seconds. And so you're
- 2:12:16you're basically saying, hey, why why
- 2:12:18are you using language of clarification
- 2:12:20later on that you didn't use earlier?
- 2:12:23Well, the earlier people would have said
- 2:12:25we understand he's God. So,
- 2:12:28five minutes.
- 2:12:32Uh before we start uh our Q&A, uh each
- 2:12:36speaker will have 5 minutes for
- 2:12:37conclusions.
- 2:12:38Hey, wait. He started. Why shouldn't I?
- 2:12:40You can go ahead.
- 2:12:41What's that? No, no, no. I mean, he
- 2:12:42started with the question. So,
- 2:12:44yes.
- 2:12:45Oh, yeah.
- 2:12:46I wasn't counting. So, I wasn't
- 2:12:47counting. But
- 2:12:48you have the sixth question. Sixth and
- 2:12:49final question.
- 2:12:50Okay. Um, this is kind of a side issue,
- 2:12:53but I was wondering about it because um,
- 2:12:55uh, Muhammad, you mentioned the
- 2:12:58Ebianites as, uh, early as an early
- 2:13:02group who didn't believe in the deity of
- 2:13:05Christ. Uh, the Ebianites,
- 2:13:08as I understand them, were a group, they
- 2:13:10didn't have the Bible. They only had
- 2:13:12part of the Gospel of Matthew. So, they
- 2:13:14had part of the Gospel of Matthew. And
- 2:13:16in that part of the Gospel of Matthew,
- 2:13:18they didn't have the beginning. But they
- 2:13:19also rejected the virgin birth. They
- 2:13:22didn't believe that prophets actually
- 2:13:24got revelations from God. The prophets
- 2:13:26spoke on their own wisdom. So if we're
- 2:13:27taking the Ebianites as the true
- 2:13:30followers of Christ here, won't we have
- 2:13:32to reject Islam as well? Okay. Thank
- 2:13:36you. Um, now I have never made the claim
- 2:13:39that the Ebianites are the true
- 2:13:40followers of Christ. That's something
- 2:13:41you have said. That's not something I've
- 2:13:43said. I've just made the point that they
- 2:13:44had the Islamic position on two aspects.
- 2:13:47the non- divinity of Jesus Christ and
- 2:13:48the non- divinity of the Holy Spirit.
- 2:13:50Now, they didn't have the Bible. Do you
- 2:13:52know why? Because they came before John.
- 2:13:55They came on 70 AD. John came 95 AD.
- 2:13:59[Applause]
- 2:14:01[Music]
- 2:14:02I don't know what to say. They only had
- 2:14:04the Gospel of Matthew because only Mark,
- 2:14:06Matthew, and Luke, the synoptic gospels
- 2:14:08were available to them. They had those
- 2:14:10synoptic gospels. Now the thing is when
- 2:14:13you when you talk about what they
- 2:14:14actually believed in I gave you a
- 2:14:16primary source material Hippolitus he
- 2:14:19said who who was the the student of
- 2:14:22Iranius and who was the student of
- 2:14:24Justin Martr and who taught origin of
- 2:14:27Cle origin of Alexandria he said in
- 2:14:30against the heresies chapter 22 what
- 2:14:33they believe you can go and check it if
- 2:14:35you don't believe me it's a primary
- 2:14:36source material now
- 2:14:371 minute left
- 2:14:38I've got a minute I will use a minute
- 2:14:40now the point you here about the Holy
- 2:14:42Spirit is absolutely null and void. Do
- 2:14:45you know how many things in the Bible
- 2:14:46are co are eternal? Look at Milchisik.
- 2:14:49Milchisik, he didn't have a mother. He
- 2:14:52didn't have a father. In the book of
- 2:14:53Hebrews, he was eternal. Bring him into
- 2:14:55the trinity. Bring him into the trinity
- 2:14:57today. Bring him into the trinity today.
- 2:14:59If that's your only parameter, if that
- 2:15:00is the only thing you have, you said God
- 2:15:03just because something is referred to as
- 2:15:04theos in the Greek, it must be a
- 2:15:06co-exist co-eternal, then bring Paul in.
- 2:15:10bring the devil in because they're
- 2:15:11called theos as well.
- 2:15:14[Applause]
- 2:15:18Now, as it relates to the How long have
- 2:15:20I got left?
- 2:15:21You got 20 seconds.
- 2:15:22Okay. As it relates to the Holy Spirit,
- 2:15:24Gregory of Nisanas and Gregory of Nissa,
- 2:15:26they quote in church documents, primary
- 2:15:28source materials, you can check the
- 2:15:29website, many prophets, one message, it
- 2:15:31has all the references. They quote, "We
- 2:15:33didn't know. People were disputing about
- 2:15:35what the Holy Spirit is. Some said it
- 2:15:37was a creature. Some said it was God.
- 2:15:39Some said it was this, some said it was
- 2:15:40that. We did not know. That's what they
- 2:15:42said. It's not an argument from silence
- 2:15:44I'm making. It's an argument from
- 2:15:45evidence.
- 2:15:52Thank you very much, Mr. Hijab. Uh Dr.
- 2:15:55Wood, you may start your fivem minute
- 2:15:57conclusion. We're switching.
- 2:16:13Well, thank you. Uh, thank you again. A
- 2:16:15couple side notes here. He says, "The
- 2:16:16Ebianites were too early." Our earliest
- 2:16:18reference to the Ebianites was from 140.
- 2:16:22Um, of course, they they they could be
- 2:16:24earlier, but the point is these were
- 2:16:26people who had one part of one gospel.
- 2:16:31And there were certainly there were
- 2:16:33certainly the rest of the gospels um
- 2:16:35around during the time but they they're
- 2:16:37regarded as a a radical offshoot of
- 2:16:40Judaism. Um so to lay them down as
- 2:16:42authoritative again these are these are
- 2:16:44guys who didn't believe that prophets
- 2:16:46spoke from God. Um they didn't believe
- 2:16:48in the virgin birth and so on. So uh if
- 2:16:50these guys are the closest to the true
- 2:16:51Jesus then uh we have to reject the
- 2:16:54Islamic Jesus. He said Melkisedc was
- 2:16:56eternal. Now, you have to understand
- 2:16:57what what the author of of Hebrews is
- 2:17:00doing there. He's talking about the
- 2:17:01descriptions, right? Uh we we don't have
- 2:17:04really time to go into this. Uh if
- 2:17:05someone wants to bring it up in the Q&A,
- 2:17:07ask about MelkiseDC when we can actually
- 2:17:09go what he's doing there. He is not
- 2:17:10saying that MelkiseDC Melkazedc is
- 2:17:12eternal. Uh certainly not claiming that.
- 2:17:15Um so, uh and the last point, just
- 2:17:19because something is called um a god in
- 2:17:21scripture doesn't mean it's uh you know,
- 2:17:23it has divine attributes and is not God.
- 2:17:26Yes, we understand the term theos and
- 2:17:28the the term Elohim in the Old Testament
- 2:17:30can mean various things. The question is
- 2:17:32how are these terms used of Jesus? How
- 2:17:34are these terms used of the father? How
- 2:17:37are these terms used of the Holy Spirit?
- 2:17:40The Holy Spirit is creating the world in
- 2:17:43the Bible. The Holy Spirit is eternal in
- 2:17:46the Bible. So to just brush that off and
- 2:17:48say, "Well, other things are called
- 2:17:49God." Yeah. Not in the same not in that
- 2:17:51way, right? You could say, "Oh, those
- 2:17:52are false gods. There you're calling
- 2:17:54them. You're you're saying they're
- 2:17:56they're gods in some way. You're using
- 2:17:57the term, but you're not applying it
- 2:17:59seriously.
- 2:18:00When we have father, son, and holy
- 2:18:02spirit, these are used uh seriously of
- 2:18:07father, son, and holy spirit. Um so as
- 2:18:10far as what we have what we have tonight
- 2:18:13um again we see in the Old Testament we
- 2:18:16see from the opening verses of the book
- 2:18:19of Genesis and throughout the Old
- 2:18:21Testament various uh claims of plurality
- 2:18:24within the one God. Jewish commentators
- 2:18:29have mentioned this. Uh, modern experts
- 2:18:32in Judaism acknowledge that prior to the
- 2:18:36end of the second century where the
- 2:18:39Jewish community swung very hardly in a
- 2:18:43uh unitarian direction, there was
- 2:18:45widespread agreement in the Jewish
- 2:18:46community. And Muhammad Hijab, how did
- 2:18:48he respond? Well, show me where they say
- 2:18:51co-equal, co-eternal, father, son, holy.
- 2:18:53No one's claiming they knew that. The
- 2:18:55point was you think they had this
- 2:18:58tahhedish belief and they just didn't.
- 2:19:02Right? What did what did the scholars
- 2:19:03say and what do various Jewish scholars
- 2:19:04say that the doctrine that Christians
- 2:19:07believe in would have fit in very
- 2:19:09comfortably with what Jews prior to the
- 2:19:11second century had fit in? There would
- 2:19:12have been nothing there for for a Jew to
- 2:19:14claim about uh to complain about in
- 2:19:17terms of theology. They would reject
- 2:19:18they wouldn't reject it by saying oh
- 2:19:20that's a confusing doctrine of God is
- 2:19:22the point. They would say we reject
- 2:19:23Jesus as the Messiah. That would be the
- 2:19:25main complaints of uh Jews during the
- 2:19:28time.
- 2:19:29Um
- 2:19:31and what have we seen on the other side,
- 2:19:33right? And here's what's interesting. Um
- 2:19:35Christians have a lot of data, right? We
- 2:19:38have the Old Testament passages. We have
- 2:19:40Jesus coming into the world and we see
- 2:19:43the various things that Jesus did and
- 2:19:45the claims he made. And since he rises
- 2:19:47from the dead, we have to take those
- 2:19:48claims seriously. So when he's claiming
- 2:19:49to be the final judge of all mankind or
- 2:19:51when he's claiming to be the one who
- 2:19:54raises the dead at the resurrection, we
- 2:19:57recognize the kinds of claims that he's
- 2:19:59making. And then when we find various
- 2:20:01claims about the Holy Spirit, we take
- 2:20:02those seriously and we say, "All right,
- 2:20:04everything that God has revealed to us,
- 2:20:05we have to take seriously."
- 2:20:08And the only way to take it all
- 2:20:09seriously is with something like the
- 2:20:10doctrine of the Trinity.
- 2:20:13One minute left. We turn to Islam and we
- 2:20:16find all kinds of things that are just
- 2:20:18confusing. I you know I I I talk about
- 2:20:21Allah praying and ah it means sending
- 2:20:23blessings. There are perfectly you say
- 2:20:25baraka right we know how to say that.
- 2:20:28Why does he use the word that's prayer
- 2:20:29so so confusing so confusing that even
- 2:20:32Muslim translators are now translating
- 2:20:34it as Allah praying in a variety of
- 2:20:36different circumstances. Allah praying
- 2:20:37for self-control so that his mercy can
- 2:20:39triumph over his wrath. And we find this
- 2:20:41over and over again that you have an
- 2:20:43eternal word that there is a spirit that
- 2:20:46proceeds from within Allah that you have
- 2:20:50a man that his followers were were
- 2:20:53drinking his blood. All of these things
- 2:20:55if we said uh again goddesses are
- 2:20:57interceding with you with Allah you
- 2:20:59would say polytheism but the Quran is
- 2:21:01doing it in the form of birds who know
- 2:21:02things who talk and it's pure monotheism
- 2:21:04seconds left. And so when we see this
- 2:21:07over and over again, Islam looks like
- 2:21:10it's trying to copy Christianity but
- 2:21:12just doing a really bad job of it.
- 2:21:16Thank you very much, Dr. Wood.
- 2:21:19Hello. 5 minutes.
- 2:21:25David Wood has been more interested or
- 2:21:27more concerned with trying to disprove
- 2:21:29Islam today than defending Christianity.
- 2:21:34He talks about the Ebianites as being a
- 2:21:36radical offshoot. This is an ahistoric
- 2:21:39way of rendering history. One man's
- 2:21:41orthodox is another man's heresy. Gospel
- 2:21:44gospels. He says in one other time he
- 2:21:45says the gospels were not present at the
- 2:21:47time of the church father. This is a
- 2:21:49this is a lie or a misreading or
- 2:21:50misunderstanding. He should be reading
- 2:21:52his primary source materials. Almost all
- 2:21:53of them refer to the four gospels. All
- 2:21:55of the major church fathers refer to the
- 2:21:57four gospels. Let's say from Justin Mart
- 2:21:59onwards 100%. This is something
- 2:22:01wellknown. Look at their works.
- 2:22:04Athanasius, he's the one who made a
- 2:22:06short list of what is going to be the
- 2:22:08Bible, right? He made a short list in
- 2:22:10mid 4th century the 27 books of the Old
- 2:22:13Testament. Now, the question we could
- 2:22:15ask is who gave him the authority to do
- 2:22:16that to include in God's word to take
- 2:22:18out of God's word. This is God's word.
- 2:22:20This is not God's. Why is the Gospel of
- 2:22:22Thomas not in the Bible? Why is this
- 2:22:24he's making the decision? It then became
- 2:22:26quite popular and it was an organic
- 2:22:27thing. It wasn't in a council that these
- 2:22:29are the 27 books of the Old Testament.
- 2:22:30That's another issue. When we talk about
- 2:22:32the Bible, what are we really talking
- 2:22:34about? There's issues with the Bible.
- 2:22:37There is no chain going back to Jesus.
- 2:22:39Everything that we have called a hadith,
- 2:22:42an authentic hadith, has a chain going
- 2:22:44back to Prophet Muhammad or Allah. And
- 2:22:46that's what you don't have. And that's
- 2:22:47why our books are preserved and yours
- 2:22:49are not. That's another issue.
- 2:22:53He says he believes in progressive
- 2:22:55revelation in the in the New Testament.
- 2:22:59That's very good. You know why? Because
- 2:23:02I agree with him on this point. I want
- 2:23:03to end with this. I agree with him. I
- 2:23:05believe he's right. Yes, the Bible does
- 2:23:07talk about a progressive revelation,
- 2:23:09which is why it talks about the upcoming
- 2:23:13prophet.
- 2:23:18And that's why if you read Isaiah 42,
- 2:23:21ask answer me this. Who in history has
- 2:23:25come to the Kadarites, the Arabs,
- 2:23:28has made the people of Salah, the
- 2:23:30mountaintops, rejoice?
- 2:23:32Who in history went to the Arabs and
- 2:23:34made the Arabs rejoice defeating his
- 2:23:36enemies in military warfare? And this is
- 2:23:39not something we're shy about, by the
- 2:23:40way. This is something we're very proud
- 2:23:41of. Very proud of.
- 2:23:46This is something we're very proud of
- 2:23:47because our prophet
- 2:23:50is a winner. a military winner. It's
- 2:23:53part of his prophecy that he was going
- 2:23:54to do that. That's what Deuteronomy
- 2:23:56chapter 18 says that there was going to
- 2:23:57be one of the ways to to tell a true
- 2:23:59prophet is through prophecy. Every
- 2:24:00single one of the prophets Muhammad's
- 2:24:02prophecies came true. Look at the Quran.
- 2:24:04It's a way that a Christian, an honest
- 2:24:07Christian could come to terms who is
- 2:24:09this man, Prophet Muhammad sallallahu
- 2:24:10alaihi wasallam. Do the research. Why?
- 2:24:12He's right. There is progressive
- 2:24:13revelation. But it did not end with
- 2:24:14Jesus.
- 2:24:16It continued to prophet Muhammad
- 2:24:18sallallahu alaihi wasallam.
- 2:24:23And that is why in the Quran it doesn't
- 2:24:26mention progressive revelation.
- 2:24:28He's the final prophet. If you really
- 2:24:30want salvation wall, all that's said and
- 2:24:33done, 20 years of attacking Islam,
- 2:24:35mockumentaries, uh you know, making fun
- 2:24:37of Prophet Muhammad, dressing up as a
- 2:24:39woman and these things, no problem.
- 2:24:40Wall, I believe, I'm speaking on behalf
- 2:24:43of all the Muslims here. Yes, I will
- 2:24:45forgive you and the Muslims will forgive
- 2:24:46you if you repent today. I will forgive
- 2:24:49you. And we will forgive you if you
- 2:24:51repent today.
- 2:24:53I want to give you one piece of advice.
- 2:24:56Sorry, I'm just making comment. I want
- 2:24:58to I want to give the Muslims in my
- 2:25:00concluding speech one piece of advice
- 2:25:03which is you'll find it in first Peter
- 2:25:05chapter 3 verse 15 that if someone asks
- 2:25:08you a question you know about what you
- 2:25:11what you hope you know then speak speak
- 2:25:14to them respectfully.
- 2:25:16Yes. honorably, respectfully, mocking
- 2:25:19Muslims, you know, dressing like them
- 2:25:21and these things, that's not respectful.
- 2:25:23Be like James White, be like William Le
- 2:25:25Craig. We can have we can have more we
- 2:25:28can have more fruitful cohesion in our
- 2:25:30communities, man. We want to have
- 2:25:33cohesion.
- 2:25:35We as Muslims, I'm putting the Yes, I'm
- 2:25:37putting the olive branch now to the
- 2:25:39Christian community. We don't want to.
- 2:25:41We will never. The Quran says
- 2:25:45chapter 68. Do not curse their gods.
- 2:25:48We're not allowed to curse the gods or
- 2:25:50other people. The Bible is the same,
- 2:25:53ladies and gentlemen. The Bible says,
- 2:25:55don't don't curse. Look at First Peter
- 2:25:583:15. Don't curse us. Don't mock us.
- 2:26:01Because like today, you will be shown
- 2:26:04the truth in a very harsh manner. You'll
- 2:26:06be shown the truth in a very very
- 2:26:09embarrassing manner. And that is the
- 2:26:11reality. Ladies and gentlemen,
- 2:26:14come humbly
- 2:26:16and you will come humbly and you'll be
- 2:26:18received humbly. Give us your hand and
- 2:26:21we will shake it only if you respect us
- 2:26:23in the first place.
- 2:26:28[Applause]
- 2:26:36Thank you very much Mr. Hijab. We would
- 2:26:38like to thank both of our speakers. Uh
- 2:26:40we're going to start taking questions
- 2:26:42right now. So for any questions for Dr.
- 2:26:45Wood forum on the right. Any questions
- 2:26:47for Dr. Mr. Hijab forum over here
- 2:26:50please. No.
- 2:26:54All right is here.
- 2:26:58Oh, okay.
- 2:27:25I'm only allowed to ask one question.
- 2:27:31Okay.
- 2:27:40Oh, what are the rules for?
- 2:27:43I mean,
- 2:27:46I want to make sure that the question
- 2:27:48there's no offensive question at all.
- 2:27:51No, I mean about my time and stuff like
- 2:27:52that.
- 2:27:55So it's just sort of lay back sort of
- 2:28:14if we can all be try to be as quiet as
- 2:28:17we can. We're going to start our Q&A
- 2:28:19right now.
- 2:28:22Is it working?
- 2:28:23Testing. Nice.
- 2:28:24Okay.
- 2:28:32First question is going to be to brother
- 2:28:34hijab
- 2:28:36on the right over here.
- 2:28:37This is Oh, this is for
- 2:28:38this is for brother hijab. This question
- 2:28:40any questions for Mr. Hijab? You can
- 2:28:42start over here.
- 2:28:46Questions for Mr. Hijab. Just to
- 2:28:48clarify. Questions for Mr. Hijab over
- 2:28:49here. Question for Dr. Wood will be over
- 2:28:52there.
- 2:28:54You can still ask if you want to.
- 2:28:57She had it confused. She thought.
- 2:28:59All right. Well, we we'll start the
- 2:29:00first question. He's going to do two.
- 2:29:02All right. Yeah, sure. Okay.
- 2:29:04Is the mic working? Okay.
- 2:29:07Okay. Please, if we can stay as quiet as
- 2:29:08possible so we can hear the question.
- 2:29:12So, one thing that Dr. would brought up
- 2:29:14multiple times during both your intro,
- 2:29:15your rebuttal as well as your conclusion
- 2:29:17was the fact that uh Muslim scholars
- 2:29:19claimed that companions drink the
- 2:29:21prophet's blood. Um with your level of
- 2:29:23intellect, I mean with Dr. Wood's level
- 2:29:25of intellect and profession, I'm sure
- 2:29:27you're well aware of one of the most
- 2:29:28basic teachings of Islam, which is
- 2:29:30regarding our diet, which is halal and
- 2:29:31haram. We're forbidden to eat any or
- 2:29:34drink any type of blood in any form. Um
- 2:29:36if you, you know, have any doubt, you
- 2:29:38can look at surah 6, ayah 145. So um you
- 2:29:41know with the claim about a Muslim schol
- 2:29:44scholar saying that the prophet the
- 2:29:46companions did indeed drink the
- 2:29:47prophet's blood. Can we get one credible
- 2:29:50name that of a scholar that did in fact
- 2:29:52say that?
- 2:29:53[Applause]
- 2:29:58I'm having trouble hearing here. Do you
- 2:30:00can you repeat like
- 2:30:01basically she was basically she was
- 2:30:03saying there's a verse in the Quran that
- 2:30:04stated that drinking blood or eating any
- 2:30:07type of
- 2:30:08Yeah. So she she asked if you can
- 2:30:10provide an actually proven scholar that
- 2:30:13states that the that the Sahaba or the
- 2:30:16companions actually drank the blood of
- 2:30:18the prophet. Is that was that your
- 2:30:21question? Yes, that that was the
- 2:30:22question. So
- 2:30:23Oh, yeah. No, I'll I'll give you the
- 2:30:25source.
- 2:30:26Okay, go ahead.
- 2:30:26You want to ask another Well, okay.
- 2:30:28Whoops.
- 2:30:28Take your time. Don't worry about that.
- 2:30:33Oh, that that's uh that's in uh that's
- 2:30:37in um Kadi Ilia. I'm sorry.
- 2:30:40Kadilia give you Okay. Um,
- 2:30:45I can give you the uh
- 2:30:48I think the reference
- 2:30:55um
- 2:30:59okay so this is uh
- 2:31:05Ashifa by Kadi Iliad says um Muhammad
- 2:31:09Iban Sad uh Alwaki scribe And I related
- 2:31:12that Aisha said to the prophet when you
- 2:31:13come from relieving yourself we do not
- 2:31:15see anything noxious from you. He said
- 2:31:17Aisha do you not know that the earth
- 2:31:19swallows up what comes out of the
- 2:31:20prophets so that none of it is seen.
- 2:31:23Although this tradition is uh not famous
- 2:31:25the people of knowledge still notice the
- 2:31:28people of knowledge still mention the
- 2:31:29purity of his feces and urine. There was
- 2:31:32also the time when Malik Hibban drank
- 2:31:35his blood on the day of Uhood and licked
- 2:31:37it up. The prophet allowed him to do
- 2:31:39that and said the fire will not touch
- 2:31:42you. So this is uh pages 35 through 37
- 2:31:46of uh Ashifa.
- 2:31:48Thank you very much Dr. Wood.
- 2:31:51Next question for Mr. Kab. Go ahead.
- 2:31:54Uh hi.
- 2:31:57Um good debate and thanks. uh you
- 2:31:59throughout your debate you kept saying
- 2:32:01that there was no apostolic succession
- 2:32:04for the trinity and basically until the
- 2:32:06nine uh the council of nine there was
- 2:32:08nothing about the trinity no church
- 2:32:10father has said anything between Jesus's
- 2:32:12death and 300 and whatever AD or
- 2:32:16whatever that occurred uh one question
- 2:32:18for you then can you name one person
- 2:32:21between 33 AD and 583 AD who said
- 2:32:25anything about Islam because there was
- 2:32:27no apostolic succession for Islam
- 2:32:30either. Sorry, what's the I can't I I
- 2:32:32can't hear exactly what you're saying.
- 2:32:33Can you can you repeat?
- 2:32:34He was basically saying that if you can
- 2:32:36mention uh if you can mention a source
- 2:32:39from 3 AD from 33 AD from 33 AD from
- 2:32:42Jesus's crucifixion to about the time of
- 2:32:45583 AD when uh the when your prophet
- 2:32:48began.
- 2:32:48Can you repeat what he said?
- 2:32:50Actually, I'll give
- 2:32:52Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, please.
- 2:32:54But he was started in 583.
- 2:32:58You can actually speak into this mic.
- 2:32:59It'll be
- 2:33:02this won't go.
- 2:33:03Just let him come up.
- 2:33:05They might just need to turn that mic
- 2:33:06up.
- 2:33:08Hi. So, I was asking if you know one of
- 2:33:11your core questions were, you know,
- 2:33:13what's the apostolic succession between
- 2:33:15the trinity? You're talking about the
- 2:33:17trinity. There was nothing mentioned by
- 2:33:18the church fathers between Jesus's
- 2:33:21crucifixion and the council may scene.
- 2:33:24Um, can you mention one person
- 2:33:27historically who has talked about the
- 2:33:30the possib succession of Islam between
- 2:33:3333 AD and 583 AD when your prophet
- 2:33:36began?
- 2:33:38When my prophet began, sorry, is it
- 2:33:39what? I don't I don't get it. Sorry.
- 2:33:41What? What were you saying? He's
- 2:33:42basically asking for a reference from 33
- 2:33:45AD to 583 to 583 where it was mentioned
- 2:33:49that the prophecy Islam was coming.
- 2:33:52What? Sorry, I'm really I'm not doing
- 2:33:54this on purpose. I'm not
- 2:33:56He wants a source where or any any
- 2:33:59Is he talking about Islam or
- 2:34:00Christianity?
- 2:34:01He's talking about Islam during 33 AD.
- 2:34:0333 AD is not Islam.
- 2:34:04Yeah, I know. I know. Yes. Was there a
- 2:34:06reference to Islam? Something to portray
- 2:34:08that would say that Islam is coming.
- 2:34:10That's basically what he's asking. Islam
- 2:34:12means submission. There's a reference to
- 2:34:13that in the Bible, John 5:30, cuz it
- 2:34:16says, "I don't submit myself to my own
- 2:34:17will, but to the will of the father."
- 2:34:19That is Islam. Linguistically, that's
- 2:34:20what Islam means. So that's in the
- 2:34:22Bible. We don't need to go to 33 AD. Is
- 2:34:25that is that right? I mean, is that a
- 2:34:28question?
- 2:34:31Yeah. Yeah. Sorry, one more one more
- 2:34:32time. I'm not understanding the
- 2:34:33question. You're saying that there's
- 2:34:35there's nothing about the Trinity
- 2:34:36between 33 AD and about the time of the
- 2:34:38council of Nine. This is your this is
- 2:34:40the crux of your argument or one of the
- 2:34:42things you said the most.
- 2:34:43But by that same definition, we have
- 2:34:45nothing between 33 AD that speaks
- 2:34:47anything about anything well not
- 2:34:49anything in the Quran but most of things
- 2:34:50in the Quran or Islam. So basically the
- 2:34:53gospels did not succeed in that. Yes.
- 2:34:56Okay. As Muslims we don't believe that
- 2:34:59the Quran was revealed to Jesus. We
- 2:35:01believe it was revealed to Prophet
- 2:35:02Muhammad. Right. So obviously the Quran
- 2:35:04because it was not revealed to Jesus,
- 2:35:06there would be no reference to it
- 2:35:08because it was a final testament that
- 2:35:09came afterwards. You see? So when I made
- 2:35:12my argument, I wasn't I did not make the
- 2:35:14argument that the trinity was not
- 2:35:15mentioned. Yeah, the trinity was
- 2:35:17mentioned by Tertullian. I did I
- 2:35:18mentioned that I mentioned the Nyian
- 2:35:21trinity of 381 and after that which
- 2:35:26stipulates very spec specific parameters
- 2:35:28as to what the trinity is and what the
- 2:35:29trinity isn't. That was my argument.
- 2:35:32Yeah. So I didn't say the trinity is not
- 2:35:33there in the first uh whatever 300
- 2:35:35years. I said the nian trinity wasn't
- 2:35:38there. As for Islam my my point was that
- 2:35:41if you don't believe that Jesus is
- 2:35:42divine and you don't believe that the
- 2:35:43holy spirit is divine like many monarch
- 2:35:45monarchists and evenites didn't believe
- 2:35:49then by definition you believe there's
- 2:35:51only one god worthy of worship right and
- 2:35:52if that if if that's what you believe
- 2:35:54then you're a Muslim in a sense because
- 2:35:56you you're submitting yourself to one
- 2:35:57god. So from that perspective I think
- 2:35:59the case can be made.
- 2:36:01Thank you. Thank you. Thank you very
- 2:36:02much.
- 2:36:04[Applause]
- 2:36:06One question over there for Dr. Wood.
- 2:36:09All right. So, um, can you hear me
- 2:36:10properly, Dr. Wood? I just want to make
- 2:36:11sure a little bit. All right.
- 2:36:13I I don't know if I'm in a bad spot.
- 2:36:15That's the only mic I could, uh, hear
- 2:36:17really well. Just say it loud.
- 2:36:18Am I better now?
- 2:36:20All right. Perfect. Um, so my question
- 2:36:22is regarding the equality among the
- 2:36:24Trinity. So um in Matthew 28 um verse 18
- 2:36:30Jesus says that all authority is given
- 2:36:32to him and on the in the heavens and in
- 2:36:34earth and then in John um chapter 16
- 2:36:38verse 13 it states that but when the
- 2:36:41spirit of truth comes he will be um he
- 2:36:44will guide you into all truth for he
- 2:36:46will not speak on his own authority but
- 2:36:48he will speak on what he hears. So if
- 2:36:50the holy spirit is guide why doesn't he
- 2:36:52have any authority to speak? Thank you.
- 2:36:57[Music]
- 2:36:59Uh if you look at if you look at how um
- 2:37:02the gospel of John uh is using these
- 2:37:05terms, it's that the emphasis in these
- 2:37:08passages is not is not uh that the Holy
- 2:37:13Spirit is not God or that Jesus is not
- 2:37:17God.
- 2:37:19He's trying to show that they they are
- 2:37:22one. Right? In other words, in John
- 2:37:24chapter 5, right? Muslims love to bring
- 2:37:26up John chapter 5 where Jesus says, uh,
- 2:37:28"Of my own self, I can do nothing."
- 2:37:30Check. Check. It's working. He says, "Of
- 2:37:32my own self, I can do nothing." They
- 2:37:33say, "Aha." Right there. Which is
- 2:37:35parallel to the spirit doesn't speak on
- 2:37:38his own on his on his own authority.
- 2:37:40Right? If you look at what's actually
- 2:37:42going on there, um, at the beginning of
- 2:37:44John, I mean earlier in John chapter 5,
- 2:37:47because Jesus is calling himself the son
- 2:37:50and saying that, uh, he can work on the
- 2:37:54Sabbath because the father does. Notice
- 2:37:56Jews are not allowed to work on the
- 2:37:57Sabbath. Jesus says, "But the father
- 2:37:59works on the Sabbath and so do I."
- 2:38:01Right? When he said that, they accused
- 2:38:03him of claiming to be another god.
- 2:38:05Right? He's a rogue deity. Right? He's a
- 2:38:08he's separate. So what he does there in
- 2:38:13the rest of John chapter 5, that's where
- 2:38:15he claims to that he's the one who
- 2:38:16raises the dead at the resurrection. He
- 2:38:19says that he's the one uh who is the
- 2:38:22final judge. And he says that um we have
- 2:38:25to honor him just as we honor the
- 2:38:28father. Right? So keep in mind we have
- 2:38:31to you would only honor someone the same
- 2:38:33way you honor the father if he has the
- 2:38:35same na nature and attributes as the
- 2:38:37father. So when he says when he says
- 2:38:39that he can do nothing of himself or
- 2:38:41when the holy spirit does not not speak
- 2:38:44on his own authority what these are
- 2:38:46saying is they don't do these things
- 2:38:49separately as separate deities from the
- 2:38:52father cuz that's the accusation as soon
- 2:38:54as you start saying some things are
- 2:38:55divine they start accusing of saying
- 2:38:57there's other gods so the emphasis is he
- 2:38:59doesn't do this on his own
- 2:39:02right all right thank you very much Dr.
- 2:39:03would uh we're past the halfway mark
- 2:39:05right now and Q&A so we're going to try
- 2:39:07to speed it up as much as we can. So
- 2:39:09we'll we'll limit each answer to one
- 2:39:11minute uh for both speakers. So I think
- 2:39:14uh the next the question is for Mr.
- 2:39:16Hijab and go ahead and speak.
- 2:39:17Yes. Uh I have a question for Mr. Hijab.
- 2:39:19I was wondering since the thrust of your
- 2:39:21argument hinges on David's inexpert
- 2:39:25flawed knowledge of Arabic, don't you
- 2:39:27think it's a little odd that the will of
- 2:39:30God can only be discerned by people who
- 2:39:33speak an esoteric language spoken by
- 2:39:36less than 5% of the world population and
- 2:39:40which has many dialects and isn't even
- 2:39:43spoken by the majority of self-professed
- 2:39:46Muslims. And what do you think of the
- 2:39:48fact that there are people who are very
- 2:39:51learned in Arabic who were even born in
- 2:39:52Arabia who have the same
- 2:39:54epistemological,
- 2:39:55moral, scientific and historical
- 2:39:57critiques of the Quran.
- 2:40:00Thank you for your question. Um your
- 2:40:02question was about the Arabic language
- 2:40:04of the Quran and you were saying that is
- 2:40:06it is it the case that only Arabs can
- 2:40:08access the Quran in a nutshell? Is it
- 2:40:10why is it that only 5% of the population
- 2:40:12can access this and the rest cannot? Now
- 2:40:15there's a difference between
- 2:40:16understanding the fundamentals of a
- 2:40:17religion. Yes. And trying to do ex
- 2:40:20Jesus. Yes. Exesus is when you try
- 2:40:23hermeneutically to go into the text and
- 2:40:26understand it holistically. And for that
- 2:40:31you require language ability. For that
- 2:40:34you require whether you're doing it with
- 2:40:35the Bible or the Quran, you're required
- 2:40:37to have some kind of ability to
- 2:40:39understand the language. Otherwise your
- 2:40:41hermeneutic will be necessarily limited.
- 2:40:44Now just quickly as I do have a little
- 2:40:46bit of time answering the question on
- 2:40:48the point on on John uh that uh that
- 2:40:51David talked about John John chapter
- 2:40:53John John 10:34 Jesus clearly says why
- 2:40:56did you call me God? I mean they were
- 2:40:58about to stone him and he said this and
- 2:41:00he's he's referencing Psalms 82. So if
- 2:41:03he really believed he's God then why is
- 2:41:05he saying didn't
- 2:41:07you say this of old like ye are gods?
- 2:41:11You ye are gods. In other words, it's a
- 2:41:13language of the people and that's one of
- 2:41:15the biggest problems.
- 2:41:16Sorry, Dr. Sorry.
- 2:41:18Apological
- 2:41:20[Music]
- 2:41:30parts, but I assure you that it's just
- 2:41:31one question.
- 2:41:32Try to keep it to one. We're trying to
- 2:41:33get as much resp.
- 2:41:46You can go ahead.
- 2:41:47Can I ask it? Go ahead.
- 2:41:50Would you agree that the concept of the
- 2:41:52Trinity has evolved over time? What do
- 2:41:55you say about Revelation 22 18-19 where
- 2:41:59it says, "I warn everyone who hears the
- 2:42:01word of the prophecy of this book. If
- 2:42:04anyone adds to them, God will add to him
- 2:42:06the plagues described in this book,
- 2:42:09etc., etc. And can you explain Matthew 7
- 2:42:1321-23 where Jesus says I never knew I
- 2:42:17never knew you get away from me.
- 2:42:21Well there he says not everyone who says
- 2:42:24not everyone who says to me Lord Lord
- 2:42:26will enter the kingdom of heaven but
- 2:42:28only those who do the will of my father.
- 2:42:30Um so he will say um I I never knew you.
- 2:42:34Uh I don't understand what what the
- 2:42:36problem is there. Um Jesus calls himself
- 2:42:38Lord, but he's saying not not you don't
- 2:42:40just call him Lord and then and then
- 2:42:42you're fine. Um what was the other part?
- 2:42:45Um what do you uh would you agree that
- 2:42:47the concept of Trinity has evolved over
- 2:42:49time?
- 2:42:49Oh no, the the the clarification of the
- 2:42:51concept, right? Keep in mind whether
- 2:42:54you're talking about the Quran, whether
- 2:42:55you're talking about the Bible, you have
- 2:42:57historical events, you have uh
- 2:43:00revelations from prophets, statements,
- 2:43:02and so on. Um, and if you're coming up
- 2:43:05with the creed, you're trying to clarify
- 2:43:08it. You're trying to make it as concise
- 2:43:09as possible. So, uh, yeah, they had to
- 2:43:12they had to figure out how to say things
- 2:43:15in using certain terms in language, but
- 2:43:19uh, I I the triune God is eternal,
- 2:43:22right? The triune God is eternal. Our
- 2:43:24our descriptions our descriptions may
- 2:43:28take time, but that's not that's not the
- 2:43:30trinity evolving. That's our concepts
- 2:43:32being clarified.
- 2:43:33And what about the third part where I
- 2:43:35said, "What do you say about Revelation
- 2:43:3722:18 to 19 where it says, "I warn
- 2:43:40everyone who hears the words of the
- 2:43:42prophecy of this book. If anyone adds to
- 2:43:44them, God will add to him the plagues
- 2:43:47described in this book, etc., etc." Has
- 2:43:49Well, the the the the book of
- 2:43:50Revelation, the author didn't know he's
- 2:43:52going to be writing the last book of the
- 2:43:53Bible. He's talking about his prophecy,
- 2:43:55his prophecy and book of Revelation.
- 2:43:56Don't take my prophecy and add a bunch
- 2:43:57of words to them. So he's just saying,
- 2:43:59"Hey, don't add to my prophecy here and
- 2:44:01and act like it's my prophecy." That
- 2:44:03doesn't mean you can't clarify uh
- 2:44:05concepts, right? So
- 2:44:07all right. Thank you very much. Uh
- 2:44:10question for Mr. Hijab.
- 2:44:11Yes, I have a question for Mr.
- 2:44:14I'm sorry.
- 2:44:15I have a question for Mr. Wood.
- 2:44:17For Mr. Wood, we would have to take a
- 2:44:19question for Mr. Hijab first. Anyone
- 2:44:20wants to answer a question? You can go
- 2:44:22ahead.
- 2:44:22Hello, Mr. Hijab. I had a question for
- 2:44:25you. Uh
- 2:44:26yes. Um are you certain that you will be
- 2:44:29going to heaven? Uh Janna as according
- 2:44:32to Islam says you yourself.
- 2:44:35No.
- 2:44:36Does that concern you?
- 2:44:38Maybe David will go to heaven and I will
- 2:44:39go to hell. Does that
- 2:44:41that's a possibility?
- 2:44:42You know I mean I as a Muslim as a
- 2:44:44Muslim I can't guarantee and you know
- 2:44:47Christians say Christians say that you
- 2:44:49know God this is one of the arguments
- 2:44:51that you can't guarantee yourself the
- 2:44:52kingdom of heaven. Yeah. Yeah. That's
- 2:44:54true. That that that's true. What? Why
- 2:44:56is that amount to the falsity of Islam?
- 2:44:58I mean, what logical reasoning is that?
- 2:45:00Anyways, the point is say for instance,
- 2:45:02you're a Christian and you believe that
- 2:45:04if you're a Christian, you're going to
- 2:45:05go to heaven. But even according to your
- 2:45:07own belief system there is a possibility
- 2:45:09a logical rational possibility that for
- 2:45:11instance you'll die upon Hinduism or
- 2:45:13atheism or or Judaism and in which case
- 2:45:15you will have to you have to conclude
- 2:45:18that you cannot be perfectly sure that
- 2:45:20you're going to uh heaven because that
- 2:45:23would mean that you have perfect
- 2:45:24knowledge of the future and not only uh
- 2:45:26do you not have that perfect knowledge
- 2:45:27not not even the holy spirit had that
- 2:45:29knowledge.
- 2:45:30Thank you very much Mr. Hijab.
- 2:45:34You may ask your question for Dr.
- 2:45:36Oh, real quick. Yeah. You said in the
- 2:45:38beginning that God uh was in the heaven
- 2:45:40and he was his the spirit was hovering
- 2:45:43uh over the heaven and it was a mystery
- 2:45:46and the mystery was supposed to be uh
- 2:45:48revealed but it went on and more into
- 2:45:51dark the mystery never got explained. If
- 2:45:53I am if I'm pushed towards believing God
- 2:45:56to be a mystery, it would be Hinduism
- 2:45:58wherein God comes through multiple
- 2:46:00incarnations to earth in order to fix
- 2:46:03people. Uh does that mean Christianity
- 2:46:06is a subset of Hinduism wherein it
- 2:46:08claims Jesus came as the incarnation of
- 2:46:10God?
- 2:46:11Did you get that?
- 2:46:12I can't like have
- 2:46:14no
- 2:46:17[Music]
- 2:46:18you can come speak into this.
- 2:46:26If in Hinduism it is a common belief
- 2:46:28that God comes as incarnations
- 2:46:31and I suppose you also believe that
- 2:46:34Jesus came as incarnation of God onto
- 2:46:37the earth to fix people and to teach the
- 2:46:39morality. Does that mean Christianity is
- 2:46:42a subset of Hinduism in terms of its
- 2:46:45beliefs?
- 2:46:49No.
- 2:46:52uh you can't say anyone who believes in
- 2:46:54an incarnation is a subset of Hinduism.
- 2:46:57Uh if someone who's never heard one
- 2:47:00single thing about Hinduism, which would
- 2:47:01have been first century Jews, uh believe
- 2:47:04in an incarnation uh has nothing has
- 2:47:07nothing to do with uh with Hinduism.
- 2:47:10Just because you have um some sort of
- 2:47:13parallel in some way uh like ah but
- 2:47:16there are many religions that believe in
- 2:47:18rising from the dead doesn't mean they
- 2:47:20all stole it from each other. Um so no
- 2:47:30right
- 2:47:33uh next question for Mr. Hijab.
- 2:47:36Oh yeah. Oh yeah guys uh thank you for
- 2:47:38coming. Uh thanks David Muhammad. And uh
- 2:47:42so my question is like there was a
- 2:47:43question that David Wood asked about the
- 2:47:46fact that the Quran says that
- 2:47:48sorry.
- 2:47:48Oh uh the Quran says that uh the
- 2:47:50followers of Jesus were supposed to be
- 2:47:52uppermost.
- 2:47:53Yes.
- 2:47:54And uh and so like I I was wondering
- 2:47:56what your understanding of that is cuz I
- 2:47:58thought that them being uppermost would
- 2:48:00be that they're the ones who are going
- 2:48:02to overcome over the disbelievers. And
- 2:48:05so we obviously know that the Christians
- 2:48:07who were there during Muhammad's time
- 2:48:10believed in the Trinity. And so like I
- 2:48:12was just wondering what happened to
- 2:48:14Jesus's disciples according to Islam.
- 2:48:17And why did they why were they not able
- 2:48:19to counter the false disciples?
- 2:48:22Well, in the Quran it says about this.
- 2:48:25It says
- 2:48:29talking about the it says that we're
- 2:48:31going to make them higher than those who
- 2:48:33have disbelieved until the day of
- 2:48:35judgment. Yes. So it's talking about the
- 2:48:37disciples of Jesus. We believe that
- 2:48:39those early Christians were on the
- 2:48:42truth. Let me repeat the Quran says very
- 2:48:45clearly that those Christians will go to
- 2:48:48heaven. Those Christians will go to
- 2:48:50heaven. They believed in Christ. They
- 2:48:52will followed Christ. they believed in
- 2:48:53his law etc. Now there's a difference
- 2:48:56now there's a point of demarcation
- 2:48:58between the early Christians the
- 2:49:00disciples and then the church fathers
- 2:49:02and then those who came after those. So
- 2:49:04the the point is as Muslims our creed is
- 2:49:07we believe Jesus was innocent of all of
- 2:49:09this that his followers were innocent of
- 2:49:11all of this and that and that they are
- 2:49:14people who are honored in Islam and
- 2:49:16whoever says anything wrong about the
- 2:49:17disciples in Islam has left Islam
- 2:49:20because there's something in Islam. Yes.
- 2:49:23Which is very clear. It's a it's a clear
- 2:49:25point of for us. Yes. If anyone curses
- 2:49:27the the
- 2:49:29disciples, this is because Allah he says
- 2:49:33which means disbelief.
- 2:49:38At the same time Allahh says
- 2:49:43the ones who say that Jesus is God they
- 2:49:46are disbelievers as well. So it can't be
- 2:49:48both ways. Can't be both.
- 2:49:50Thank you very much.
- 2:49:53One question for Dr. Wood.
- 2:49:55Uh before I begin, David Wood said that
- 2:49:58the companions of the prophet deified uh
- 2:50:01the prophet. Well, when he died, Abu
- 2:50:03Bakr told the people, he told the people
- 2:50:06that the prophet has passed away, but
- 2:50:08God is alive and he can never die. Sahib
- 2:50:11Bkari book 64 hadith 472. Now before
- 2:50:14that was just a clarification. My
- 2:50:16question is in the Old Testament God
- 2:50:19says he is not a man. Hosea 11:9. And he
- 2:50:21is not the son of a man. Numbers 23:19.
- 2:50:24And he has full knowledge. Psalms 147.
- 2:50:27Jesus is a man. He calls himself the son
- 2:50:30of man and he doesn't know everything.
- 2:50:32Christians will say that was before he
- 2:50:34took on a body and he took on the
- 2:50:35attributes of man. But doesn't this
- 2:50:37contradict Malachi 3:6 where the Lord
- 2:50:39says he does not change?
- 2:50:45It
- 2:50:51was like 12 things.
- 2:50:53Yeah, it was one thing.
- 2:50:54Try to answer whatever you can.
- 2:50:56All right. Uh, as far as Yeah, we I
- 2:50:58understand that Muhammad has died. The
- 2:51:00the problem is that Islam keeps taking
- 2:51:02these things like the Black Stone and
- 2:51:04the Cabba and Muhammad and treating them
- 2:51:07in a way that is far beyond what you
- 2:51:09would expect for a for a mere creation.
- 2:51:10So, you understand, you know, Muhammad
- 2:51:12died and he's not a god in that sense.
- 2:51:14I'm saying they're showing reverence
- 2:51:16that should never be shown to a mere
- 2:51:17human being. Um, as far as uh God not
- 2:51:20being a man or the or the or the son of
- 2:51:22man, uh, if you look what's what's being
- 2:51:24said there, God is asked to change his
- 2:51:27mind. He said God is not a man that he
- 2:51:28should that he should change his mind.
- 2:51:30Um, so it's saying his character is not
- 2:51:32going to change, which is the same thing
- 2:51:33you find in Malachi. God is not going to
- 2:51:35change his character or in that way. It
- 2:51:37doesn't mean God can never do something
- 2:51:39different in some way or that God uh
- 2:51:41can't um can't enter creation. He starts
- 2:51:44he enters creation repeatedly in
- 2:51:46Genesis, right? He walks in the garden
- 2:51:48with Adam. He appears to Abraham. So God
- 2:51:51does that's not what they're talking
- 2:51:52about as far as um as far as God
- 2:51:55changing.
- 2:51:57That was the best question I could do in
- 2:51:57one minute.
- 2:52:02One question for Mr. Hijab.
- 2:52:03Uh thank you. Great debate. Mr. Hijab,
- 2:52:06sorry. Yes,
- 2:52:07sorry.
- 2:52:08If Yes. Um, if
- 2:52:11the prophet Muhammad sallallahu alaihi
- 2:52:12wasallam uses the Bible as his basis to
- 2:52:17validate his prophethood, especially in
- 2:52:21the words of Jesus Christ where Jesus
- 2:52:22Christ said, "I'm going to the father
- 2:52:24and I will send you a comforter, the
- 2:52:26spirit of truth who be with you and
- 2:52:29teach you into all truth." like one of
- 2:52:32your famous apologist Amdat refers to
- 2:52:35that scripture as the validation for
- 2:52:38prophet Muhammad's like prophethood. Now
- 2:52:40what do we make of what Jesus Christ
- 2:52:44said emphatically to his disciples that
- 2:52:47they should go and wait upon him in
- 2:52:50Jerusalem and then the spirit will come
- 2:52:52on them. And in the book of acts we
- 2:52:55witness a spectacle where the Holy
- 2:52:57Spirit comes to the disciple as clothing
- 2:53:00tongues on fire. And we see a
- 2:53:02significant transformation
- 2:53:04from in the lives of the disciples. And
- 2:53:08from there even the Roman government
- 2:53:11could not resist the power and the
- 2:53:13demonstration of the Holy Spirit at work
- 2:53:16in the disciples. And over the years,
- 2:53:19Christianity has spread not by sword but
- 2:53:22by the demonstration of the love power
- 2:53:24of the Holy Spirit. How do we reconcile
- 2:53:27these demonstrations of the Holy Spirit
- 2:53:30in reference to what Muhammad said
- 2:53:32things in there? So, let me try and
- 2:53:33cover them.
- 2:53:35Just one request. I think we're going to
- 2:53:38after this we're going to have to take
- 2:53:39just two more questions and try to keep
- 2:53:41your questions like like you know as
- 2:53:44simple as possible. cuz you know we're
- 2:53:46trying to take as much question as we
- 2:53:47can but you know it's impossible with
- 2:53:49you stretching the questions like that
- 2:53:50cuz we have limited time so
- 2:53:52okay so there are a few points first
- 2:53:54thing he said is about taking the Bible
- 2:53:56as an authority yes the Quran says the
- 2:53:59Torah but the original one sent to Moses
- 2:54:01and Jesus and the evidence of that is
- 2:54:02chapter 5:46 where it talks about
- 2:54:07and then it goes
- 2:54:10the lamb here is
- 2:54:12says this meaning it goes back to the
- 2:54:14previous passage And the next verse 5:48
- 2:54:16says Muhamm that the Quran is a guardian
- 2:54:19over the Bible. Yes, this book is a
- 2:54:21guardian over this. So it is an
- 2:54:22authority in as much as it does not
- 2:54:24contradict the Quran according to the
- 2:54:26Quran. Now that's point one. Point two
- 2:54:28about Christianity not being spread by
- 2:54:30the sword is a misreading of history.
- 2:54:32Actually if you look at Constantine and
- 2:54:34the Theodosian code actually the only
- 2:54:36way Christianity spread through the
- 2:54:38Roman Empire was through the sword. Look
- 2:54:40at the uh primary source material about
- 2:54:42the Theodosian code from Theodosian
- 2:54:45Theodosius II. He enforced Nyian
- 2:54:48trinitarianism by force according to all
- 2:54:51of the historians across the whole of
- 2:54:53the Roman Empire until the pagan
- 2:54:55religions of the Romans were completely
- 2:54:56dissipated. Not to mention, of course,
- 2:54:58colonialism. Not to mention, of course,
- 2:55:00the Spanish the colonists. Not to
- 2:55:03mention, of course, one of the biggest
- 2:55:05one of the biggest casualties in war in
- 2:55:07human history. Yes. One of the biggest
- 2:55:10was when the Spanish Empire and the
- 2:55:12French Empire and the British Empire
- 2:55:14spread. It's your country in Africa. It
- 2:55:17spread it everywhere. Don't tell me it
- 2:55:19wasn't spread by the sword. Don't tell
- 2:55:20me it wasn't spread by the sword. What
- 2:55:22are you talking about?
- 2:55:25The difference between Islam and
- 2:55:26Christianity in this regard was that
- 2:55:28Islam spread organically. Whereas
- 2:55:31Christianity required a man who was an
- 2:55:33empire at that time to spread it
- 2:55:35forcefully. We fought as Muslims the
- 2:55:38bigger enemy. You were the bigger enemy
- 2:55:40fighting the smaller people. That's the
- 2:55:42difference. Don't tell me about these
- 2:55:44things. This is a don't misread history.
- 2:55:49Thank you brother Hijab for your answer.
- 2:55:51Uh we'll take a question for Dr. Wood.
- 2:55:57Dr. Wood, it's an honor to be here. I
- 2:55:59want to first thank you.
- 2:56:00Can you speak closer to the mic, please?
- 2:56:02I want to first thank you. I converted
- 2:56:04to Christianity this year, January 1st,
- 2:56:06and part of it was because of the
- 2:56:08answers that you have given me. So,
- 2:56:10thank you. Um, I've watched a lot of
- 2:56:12your debates with Shabir Elli and
- 2:56:14others. Mr. Hijab is talking about
- 2:56:17William Link Craig and how respectful
- 2:56:19they are. But, I mean, if this doesn't
- 2:56:21work out, maybe you can do some standup
- 2:56:23comedy.
- 2:56:24But you asked me, you asked, somebody
- 2:56:26asked about Melkisedc. So, could you
- 2:56:27please explain who Melkisedc was in the
- 2:56:29Old Testament? Thank you.
- 2:56:31Oh, with with MelkiseDC. Um well, we're
- 2:56:34down to 1 minute now, but uh if you look
- 2:56:36at what uh the author of Hebrews is
- 2:56:38doing, um he's saying that the the Jews
- 2:56:42already had their own uh uh priesthood,
- 2:56:45the the Levitic priesthood, but the
- 2:56:47Messiah is going to be from the order of
- 2:56:49MelkiseDC. So he basically says, what
- 2:56:52are the differences in the descriptions
- 2:56:54in scripture? He he this is a guy who
- 2:56:56reads kind of codes into the Bible,
- 2:56:58right? He he's looking for codes in the
- 2:57:00scripture. They took this very
- 2:57:01seriously. Um, so he says, "What's the
- 2:57:03difference in the description textually
- 2:57:05between MelkiseDC and uh and Levi?" And
- 2:57:10that's going to tell us something about
- 2:57:11the Messiah. So he starts doing this.
- 2:57:13Aha. Well, we have a genealogy for Levi.
- 2:57:16We have none from Melkazedc, right? And
- 2:57:18so he starts going down the list and
- 2:57:19then he draws a meaning out of it. He's
- 2:57:21not actually saying that he's eternal or
- 2:57:23something like that. He's saying
- 2:57:24according to these passages, we can
- 2:57:25learn something. And his conclusion is
- 2:57:27that the Messiah is eternal. Not that
- 2:57:29not that not that uh MelkiseDC is.
- 2:57:32Thank you.
- 2:57:34Thank you Dr. Wood for your answer. Um
- 2:57:37so uh Mr. President I'm I'm sorry Mr.
- 2:57:39President
- 2:57:41[Music]
- 2:57:42Mr. President. So this is the final
- 2:57:44question. Yes.
- 2:57:47Okay.
- 2:57:48Uh a question for
- 2:57:50Okay. Yeah. A question for Muhammad
- 2:57:52hijab.
- 2:57:53Yeah. Uh you sir have been uh
- 2:57:57complaining that David W uh mocked
- 2:58:00Muslims.
- 2:58:01Sorry.
- 2:58:02You have complained that Mr. Wood have
- 2:58:05mocked Muslims.
- 2:58:06Yeah.
- 2:58:07And you have been mocking him all night.
- 2:58:10Yes.
- 2:58:13Yeah. That's right.
- 2:58:17My question goes around to authority.
- 2:58:19You have been attacking the authority of
- 2:58:22Christians on which authority we base
- 2:58:25our faith on Trinity.
- 2:58:28Sorry.
- 2:58:31You've been attacking the authority on
- 2:58:33which they base the trinity on.
- 2:58:35Yes.
- 2:58:36Okay. And you seems like you believe in
- 2:58:40church more than Christians do.
- 2:58:43And let me tell you why. Because you ask
- 2:58:45for church authorities, church scholars,
- 2:58:50Christians who have somehow in certain
- 2:58:53time talked about
- 2:58:56uh the trinity. Let me tell you and
- 2:58:58teach you something about Christianity
- 2:59:00tonight.
- 2:59:04I'm willing to learn from you.
- 2:59:06Our authority number one is Jesus
- 2:59:09Christ.
- 2:59:11Our
- 2:59:13authority is the Bible.
- 2:59:16So when we site scriptures, we're citing
- 2:59:19a lot more than Augustine that you
- 2:59:22worship.
- 2:59:23Okay.
- 2:59:25Okay. Can you put the question?
- 2:59:26Mr. Wood said
- 2:59:29uh Genesis 126. A woman can speak here,
- 2:59:33right?
- 2:59:34Um is
- 2:59:35okay. So
- 2:59:36I'm sorry. Let her let her pose her
- 2:59:38question. Go ahead. Genesis 1:26
- 2:59:41says, "Then God said, let us make
- 2:59:44mankind in our image, in our likeness."
- 2:59:48And 27 says, "So God created mankind in
- 2:59:52his own image, in the image of God, he
- 2:59:56created them. Male and female, he
- 2:59:58created them.
- 3:00:00God is speaking by himself."
- 3:00:03Sorry, he's plural.
- 3:00:06He calls himself him.
- 3:00:09So either you believe in Genesis,
- 3:00:12if you believe in Moses, which wrote the
- 3:00:15Genesis,
- 3:00:16or you don't believe and you're a bad
- 3:00:18Muslim, too.
- 3:00:19[Music]
- 3:00:22Okay. Um,
- 3:00:23and this goes the question to authority.
- 3:00:25Go ahead. Sorry.
- 3:00:26Of your faith.
- 3:00:28I want to understand how that you claim
- 3:00:32authority on Muhammad.
- 3:00:35Yeah. who
- 3:00:39had in among multiple wives a wife Aisha
- 3:00:44according to some 6 years old according
- 3:00:46to others
- 3:00:47settle down please please settle down
- 3:00:49I want to understand I want to
- 3:00:52understand
- 3:00:53because because I've heard him before in
- 3:00:56a video
- 3:00:56excuse me excuse me miss you either ask
- 3:00:58a question this is not a debate you're
- 3:01:00not you are not debating you either ask
- 3:01:02a question or you leave
- 3:01:03that's my answer that's my You either
- 3:01:06ask a question or you leave. Thank you
- 3:01:07very much. Okay. No. No. No. Actually,
- 3:01:11behind you. No. Am I not going to answer
- 3:01:14a question?
- 3:01:14Can I can I answer a question? Actually,
- 3:01:16before before that happens, we have Mr.
- 3:01:18Hijab. He wants to answer the question,
- 3:01:19you know.
- 3:01:20Yeah.
- 3:01:21Uh why do I why why am I firm and
- 3:01:24assertive with David Wood? is because he
- 3:01:26spent 20 years of his life mocking
- 3:01:28Muslims and Islam, accumulating more
- 3:01:31than 50 million 60 million channel views
- 3:01:35attacking Muslims in Islam, which has
- 3:01:37led to brothers and sisters of mine
- 3:01:40being attacked on roads in this country,
- 3:01:42exacerbating Islamophobia. This man is
- 3:01:45not going to get nice treatment from me.
- 3:01:47He's not going to get it. This guy is
- 3:01:49not James White. This guy is not William
- 3:01:51Lane Craig. This guy is not respectable.
- 3:01:54So he will not be treated with respect.
- 3:01:56Now he now just because your boy was
- 3:01:59smashed to use Kabib's words.
- 3:02:05It doesn't mean now that you you're
- 3:02:07going to give me a Can you please settle
- 3:02:08down? Please settle down.
- 3:02:09Yes. Now point number two. Point. Yeah.
- 3:02:13Point number two. She mentioned many
- 3:02:14things. Multiple wives. Oh look at look
- 3:02:17at the Old Testament please. You talk
- 3:02:19about the Old Testament. Abraham had
- 3:02:20three wives. Solomon had 300 wives.
- 3:02:24I mean, look, you're very lucky that
- 3:02:27Islam kept it at four because if it was
- 3:02:29in Solomon's time, there would be 300.
- 3:02:32Now, really and truly now, I don't
- 3:02:34understand
- 3:02:36why why you must be very upset with me
- 3:02:39like this. I mean, why were you not
- 3:02:40upset with David Wood when he was
- 3:02:42mocking the Muslims for for for 10
- 3:02:43years? Why? You're a hypocrite. You miss
- 3:02:47are a hypocrite. Okay, get the next
- 3:02:49question. Okay, Mr. Okay, I I want
- 3:02:54I want to end this
- 3:02:56[Applause]
- 3:03:00I want to end this on a good note. So we
- 3:03:02have one question. No, no, this side.
- 3:03:04This side. This side. This side.
- 3:03:06We're trying to get him first. We'll get
- 3:03:08We'll get you after.
- 3:03:09Go ahead.
- 3:03:12Mm. Um, what percentage
- 3:03:15what percentage of Christians had
- 3:03:19memorized the entire Holy Bible?
- 3:03:23[Applause]
- 3:03:28I guess you
- 3:03:34follow the rules and everything. This is
- 3:03:39all right. Can you please can you please
- 3:03:40settle down so Dr. Would you like to
- 3:03:42answer the question?
- 3:03:43What what I know is that uh most of the
- 3:03:46Muslims memorize the Quran quickly. And
- 3:03:48do you know any Muslims that any
- 3:03:51Christians that memorized the Bible
- 3:03:53quickly or uh any any% of them?
- 3:03:56Well, the the Quran is designed for an
- 3:04:00oral culture to be memorized easily.
- 3:04:02Right. I mean,
- 3:04:04right. Okay. No. No. Please settle down.
- 3:04:07Please settle down. Be respectable.
- 3:04:08Please.
- 3:04:12There are hundreds of thousands of
- 3:04:13people who have memorized Dr. Seuss's
- 3:04:16Green Eggs and Ham. Does that make it
- 3:04:18the word of God? Ladies and gentlemen,
- 3:04:19I'm trying to be respectful here to to
- 3:04:22because these are young guys here.
- 3:04:24Christian in Christianity, the Bible is
- 3:04:27meant to be a book that's read, right?
- 3:04:29That that's the idea. They they they
- 3:04:31wrote creeds and you would memorize
- 3:04:33creeds. We have some of them. They wrote
- 3:04:35songs. They memorize songs. But the the
- 3:04:38books of the Bible are written down to
- 3:04:40be books and to be read in public. The
- 3:04:43Quran the Quran is meant to be is meant
- 3:04:46to be is meant to be memorized. So
- 3:04:48they're different kinds of scripture.
- 3:04:50Why you would say oh a book that's more
- 3:04:54memorizable or something like that is
- 3:04:56must be more the word of God or
- 3:04:58something. Again, that would make green
- 3:04:59eggs and ham much much more the word of
- 3:05:01God than the Quran because it's much
- 3:05:03much easier to understand.
- 3:05:06By by the way, a little side note as far
- 3:05:08as mocking Muslims because it's been
- 3:05:10brought up like a thousand times. I
- 3:05:11haven't I haven't uh I haven't
- 3:05:12responded. Um I mock teachings of
- 3:05:16Muhammad, right? Like like dunking flies
- 3:05:19and drinks and uh things like that. And
- 3:05:22if you say that's not what I read about
- 3:05:25mockery in the Muslim sources, right? I
- 3:05:27mean when there was a polytheist there
- 3:05:29Abu Bakr said go suck Allot's close your
- 3:05:32ears if you're a child he said go suck
- 3:05:34Allot's clitoris to one of the
- 3:05:36polytheists they're mocking the beliefs
- 3:05:38of the polytheist over and over again we
- 3:05:40find them mocking the beliefs if mockery
- 3:05:43is bad then you've condemned your own
- 3:05:46god and your own prophet so okay please
- 3:05:49settle down please settle down please
- 3:05:52settle down
- 3:05:54please settle down seriously this is not
- 3:05:56you You guys claim to be Muslims. This
- 3:05:57is not how Muslims act. This is not how
- 3:06:00Muslims act. You guys want to represent
- 3:06:02Islam, we have brother Muhammad Hijab
- 3:06:03here. He's done a a very excellent job.
- 3:06:05You're basically undoing everything that
- 3:06:07he has done tonight.
- 3:06:09Please be respectful. And we're going to
- 3:06:12end our Q&A session right here. Thank
- 3:06:14you very much for coming. We're going to
- 3:06:16have food in a cafeteria right across an
- 3:06:18academic court building. Thank you very
- 3:06:20much for coming. York College Muslim
- 3:06:21Student Association. Thanks both Dr.
- 3:06:23Wood and Brother Muhammad Hijab. Thank
- 3:06:26you so much.
- 3:06:28I got nobody's
- 3:06:32going up. Nobody's going up.
- 3:06:35Nobody's going up.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of ***FULL DEBATE!*** Mohammed Hijab vs. David Wood | Tawheed vs. Trinity by Mohammed Hijab, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 28,931 words across 4,500 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.