Free State Of Jones Review — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00[Music]
- 0:09hello and today my name is laven this
- 0:11week i watched 'free state of jones and
- 0:14it's a tough watch it's one of those
- 0:17movies so free state of Jones is
- 0:19directed by Gary Ross now I didn't
- 0:21realize until doing my preparation work
- 0:23for this that I'd actually seen a few of
- 0:24his other films like Pleasantville from
- 0:271998 and Seabiscuit from 2003 and more
- 0:31recently one of the Hunger Games free
- 0:33state of Jones is a whole new ballgame
- 0:34for him though it's set in 1862 and is
- 0:37based on the true story of new tonight
- 0:40played by Matthew McConaughey who was a
- 0:42deserter from the Confederate Army in
- 0:44the American Civil War he goes on the
- 0:46run and bumped into some runaway slaves
- 0:49eventually they're joined by some other
- 0:51deserters and form a rebellion to take
- 0:53on the Confederate government which
- 0:55eventually leads to the free state of
- 0:58John so the first thing i will say about
- 0:59this film is that the trailer does spoil
- 1:01a lot of the key scenes now i know
- 1:04that's kind of ironic coming from me
- 1:05because i do use a lot of the trailer
- 1:07footage in my reviews so i'm going to
- 1:09try and keep it to a minimum in this now
- 1:11it doesn't spoil the overall narrative
- 1:13but certain scenes i was sitting there
- 1:15thinking I know exactly what's going to
- 1:17happen because I've actually seen it
- 1:19happen our bad marketing I definitely
- 1:22think that some of the key scenes
- 1:23weren't quite as impactful as they were
- 1:26supposed to be for me because I'd
- 1:28already seen it the film itself I
- 1:30thought was okay it's one of those films
- 1:33that is interesting from a historical
- 1:34perspective but it's not one that you
- 1:37really enjoy it's one that you endure
- 1:40because of the subject matter IE the
- 1:43horrors of war and the slave trade and
- 1:46it doesn't pull punches on either of
- 1:48those fronts it's pretty brutal yeah not
- 1:50exactly humanity's finest hour I think
- 1:53this film feels like even more of a slug
- 1:54because of pacing issues as well there
- 1:56are moments where it slows to a complete
- 1:58cruel but then it will jump forward in
- 2:00time a few months maybe even a year and
- 2:03it will fill us in on certain events by
- 2:05showing us text or photographs of actual
- 2:09historical events it just completely
- 2:10mess with the flow of the film for me I
- 2:13think the reason behind it was to really
- 2:15ran home the fact that this was an
- 2:17actual thing that it actually happened
- 2:19but it made it really disjointed for me
- 2:22I think the real root of the problem is
- 2:23that they tried to be too ambitious with
- 2:25the amount of story that they're trying
- 2:27to tell in two and a half hours as I say
- 2:29it starts off in 1962 and goes all the
- 2:32way through to the end of the war and it
- 2:34also jumps further in time and tells
- 2:36another story in parallel to the main
- 2:39story which is connected but again it
- 2:42just felt a bit too disjointed for me
- 2:44there are some really good action and
- 2:46war battle sequences I really get the
- 2:48impression that Ross wanted to do for
- 2:50his Civil War battles what Steven
- 2:52Spielberg did for World War two battles
- 2:55in Saving Private Ryan the only problem
- 2:57is there a bit few and far between and
- 2:59once again most of it has been spoiled
- 3:02by the trailers rubbish marketing there
- 3:04are some really good performances in
- 3:06there as well I really gravitated
- 3:08towards a character called Moses played
- 3:09by maha saleh ali i hope i pronounced
- 3:13that right and also really likes rachel
- 3:15play by and battle or who becomes
- 3:17matthew mcconaughey's love interest I
- 3:19also really like Thomas Francis Murphy's
- 3:21performance as one of the generals of
- 3:23the Confederate government despite the
- 3:25fact that there's no character
- 3:26development other than he's a bastard
- 3:28and he is a bastard Matthew McConaughey
- 3:32who I thought was okay as night there is
- 3:34a sense of Oscar bait around his
- 3:36performance and throughout the entire
- 3:38film if I'm honest I swear to god there
- 3:40is a scene where he's giving a typical
- 3:42motivational speech to his troops and he
- 3:45ends by looking straight down the barrel
- 3:46of the camera I was like oh my god it is
- 3:49like we don't have a wrong country and
- 3:52add a shared we're gonna have to be a
- 3:53wrong country all right all right or add
- 3:56that's the Oscar clip right there so
- 3:58that's my thoughts on free state of
- 4:00Jones and pause the video if you want to
- 4:02take a closer look at my enjoyment
- 4:03tracker now as I say I do think that
- 4:06this film was okay and i think it
- 4:07probably would have worked better as a
- 4:09TV series just because of the scope of
- 4:12the story that they're trying to tell in
- 4:14the same way that we think of band of
- 4:16brothers as saving private ryan the
- 4:18series we could have looked at this as a
- 4:20series of 12 years a slave and i do
- 4:23think that the makers of this film are
- 4:24trying to hit the same be and reach the
- 4:27same emotional peaks as films like 12
- 4:30years a slave and Schindler's List both
- 4:32of which i think are superior films to
- 4:34this on a storytelling level it is crazy
- 4:37to think that 150 years later this
- 4:40is still relevant that's the real
- 4:42tragedy here anyway thanks very much for
- 4:45watching my review of free states of
- 4:46Jones I really do appreciate it if you
- 4:49like the video please don't forget to
- 4:50give it a like and don't forget to share
- 4:53the lave all right all right all right
- 4:55[Music]
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Free State Of Jones Review by iwatched..., generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 963 words across 131 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.