Former FBI Agent Explains Criminal Profiling | Tradecraft | WIRED — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00people often ask whether its nature or
- 0:02nurture that creates a serial killer
- 0:04well it's actually both and more I like
- 0:07to say that genetics loads the gun
- 0:09personality and psychology image and
- 0:12your experiences pull the trigger your
- 0:15genetics give you the potentiality to be
- 0:18killer but your personality and
- 0:19psychology are the filter through which
- 0:22you experience and they can change how
- 0:24you come away from any event in your
- 0:26life
- 0:33I'm Jim Clemente I'm a retired FBI
- 0:36Supervisory Special Agent and profiler
- 0:38in the Behavioral Analysis Unit as a
- 0:40profiler my job was to hunt down child
- 0:43abductors
- 0:44serial rapists and serial killers we
- 0:47help out where forensics fail if we look
- 0:50at how the crime was committed that
- 0:52leads us to why the crime was committed
- 0:54and that leads us to who committed the
- 0:57crime the FBI's Behavioral Analysis Unit
- 1:00is part of the National Center for the
- 1:03analysis of violent crime and as such we
- 1:05study all violent and sexual crimes
- 1:07across this country and much of it
- 1:09around the world so that we can then
- 1:11train law enforcement so that they can
- 1:13get the benefit of our research in our
- 1:16training the original FBI profilers dick
- 1:22all John Douglas Roy Hazelwood Robert
- 1:25Ressler Pete's Merrick they gain this
- 1:27body of knowledge by actually going into
- 1:29prisons and interviewing convicted
- 1:31serial killers they interview them in
- 1:33great detail about what they did and
- 1:36also how they grew up and how they felt
- 1:39during the entire time that they were
- 1:41killing people developing this criminal
- 1:44expertise and that they were getting
- 1:45away with these crimes
- 1:47for example form ed Kemper they learned
- 1:49that he had a very difficult
- 1:50relationship with his mother so he
- 1:52started killing surrogates in place of
- 1:54her and then he killed his mother David
- 1:56Berkowitz showed how sexual frustration
- 1:59can be taken out on innocent people on
- 2:02the streets of New York
- 2:03from Ted Bundy they learned that he was
- 2:06a sexual sadist that he got off on
- 2:08causing and witnessing the pain and
- 2:10suffering of others but he did that many
- 2:12times by using his psychopathic charm to
- 2:15lure in victims and he feigned injury so
- 2:18that it was the people who wanted to
- 2:20help him that he ended up killing so now
- 2:23we have an amazing volume of
- 2:24institutional knowledge about these
- 2:26offenders and it tells us how they
- 2:29killed and why they killed and it helps
- 2:31us to hunt them down criminal profiling
- 2:35is basically reverse engineering a crime
- 2:38we look at the victimology the choice of
- 2:41the victims we look at the crime scene
- 2:43we look at the organization level and
- 2:45then pre and post offense behavior and
- 2:48together all those things tell us the
- 2:51kind of person who committed the crime
- 2:54victimology is the study of the victim
- 2:57their life their desires their education
- 3:00their daily routine because an offender
- 3:02picks a particular victim at a
- 3:04particular place at a particular time in
- 3:06a particular manner for a particular
- 3:08purpose and all those choices leak out
- 3:10information about the offender about
- 3:13their skills and abilities about their
- 3:15desires and they can lead us right back
- 3:17to the offender the crime location can
- 3:20tell us a lot did the crime occur on a
- 3:22farm in the middle of Iowa where the
- 3:24only potential witnesses are a bunch of
- 3:26cows and pigs or did it happen in New
- 3:29York City's Times Square where at any
- 3:31given moment there may be fifty to a
- 3:33hundred thousand potential eyewitnesses
- 3:36pulling off a crime in either of those
- 3:38locations tells you a lot about the
- 3:41offender at the crime scene we look at
- 3:43the offender's behavior how much time
- 3:45did they spend there what was their
- 3:47interaction with the victims and what
- 3:49was their criminal sophistication level
- 3:51the choice of weapons that an offender
- 3:53uses at a crime scene reveals a
- 3:55tremendous amount of information about
- 3:57them did the offender use a gun and kill
- 4:00somebody from a distance or did they get
- 4:02up close and personal and use a knife
- 4:04that's
- 4:05different kind of person who typically
- 4:07is engaged in different kinds of
- 4:09profession than somebody who will not
- 4:11get up close and personal next we look
- 4:14at the offenders organization level the
- 4:16two types of offenders that we see are
- 4:18on a spectrum between organized and
- 4:21disorganized the organized offender will
- 4:23plan it in advance fantasize about
- 4:25committing the crime and then bring all
- 4:27the implements necessary to commit the
- 4:29crime and then take them away with him
- 4:31after the crime whereas the disorganized
- 4:34offender is impulsive it don't plan the
- 4:36crimes out in advance they may have
- 4:38lowered inhibitions because of drug or
- 4:40alcohol use and they basically pick up
- 4:42the implements along the way and may
- 4:44leave them behind leaving a lot of
- 4:46forensic evidence for law enforcement to
- 4:48find if an offender doesn't have a very
- 4:50high skill level in terms of getting
- 4:52access to victims they'll pick victims
- 4:55who lead very high-risk lives
- 4:57prostitutes and drug addicts whereas a
- 4:59very sophisticated offender will be able
- 5:01to acquire victims in the privacy and
- 5:03security of their own homes it takes a
- 5:06much different level of criminal
- 5:08sophistication to be able to accomplish
- 5:10those two different crimes the next
- 5:12level of criminal behavioral analysis is
- 5:14looking at pre and post offense behavior
- 5:16if they're organized offenders they
- 5:19probably did pre offense surveillance to
- 5:21check out the location maybe even
- 5:23surveil potential victims and stalk them
- 5:26also we find that offenders after they
- 5:29commit a serious criminal offense will
- 5:32have behavioral changes that people
- 5:34around them might see for example if an
- 5:36offender has committed an abduction and
- 5:38murder they would likely leave the area
- 5:40making up an excuse in emergency to get
- 5:43out of town and they wouldn't return
- 5:45until everything calmed down and they
- 5:47felt it was safe to come back building a
- 5:50profile is simply taking all of those
- 5:52five factors and looking at what
- 5:55information the offender leaks out by
- 5:57behaving in those particular waves
- 6:05[Music]
- 6:08when I analyze a crime scene I look at
- 6:11various types of evidence some of which
- 6:13we have here pictures inside the house
- 6:16where the crime occurred crime-scene
- 6:18photographs autopsy pictures as well as
- 6:21an affidavit summarizing the facts of
- 6:24the case and the crime scene description
- 6:26typically I'd like to ask a lot more
- 6:28questions and get much more data but I
- 6:32think we have enough at least now to
- 6:34start a preliminary profile so I'm
- 6:38looking at a case of a double homicide
- 6:40of a male and female the male appears to
- 6:42be in his early 20s he was shot about
- 6:45five times he has an unknown
- 6:47relationship to the female victim who
- 6:49appears to have been pregnant and she
- 6:52was shot seven to eight times in her
- 6:54face and head and upper torso it also
- 6:58appears that the male may have scrawled
- 7:00in grease several letters he's found on
- 7:05the floor of the back room by the back
- 7:08door she's found in a room next to it
- 7:10half hanging off the bed with her head
- 7:12on a couch that's pushed up right next
- 7:15to the bed it appears that she was first
- 7:17shot while she was laying on her back on
- 7:19the bed
- 7:20and that she either rolled over to try
- 7:22to get away or was flipped over by
- 7:25someone and shot again where she died in
- 7:29place my first impressions are that the
- 7:31male victim was killed first that he was
- 7:34a practical kill to get him out of the
- 7:36way whereas the female victim was shot
- 7:39multiple times in the chest and at least
- 7:42once in the face and another time in the
- 7:45head she appears to be the main target
- 7:47of this attack so if we start with
- 7:50victimology we know that the first
- 7:52victim the male grew up in this town and
- 7:54had left town for
- 7:56several years and came back he's got no
- 7:58known criminal history yet in this house
- 8:01$11,000 in cash was found three and a
- 8:04half pounds marijuana was found and
- 8:06powdery substance that appeared to be
- 8:08drugs was also found that tells me that
- 8:11they were engaged in a high-risk
- 8:13activity drug trafficking but the fact
- 8:16that the drugs and the money were left
- 8:18behind tells me there's a high
- 8:20probability that this was not a
- 8:22drug-related hit I believe that if drug
- 8:25dealers were involved in this they would
- 8:27have taken the drugs and they would have
- 8:28taken the cash this tells me there's a
- 8:31level of immaturity in this offender
- 8:33somebody who didn't have the presence of
- 8:36mind to search for these things or
- 8:38didn't even think that they might be
- 8:40there I would put the intelligence level
- 8:44of the offender at mid to low because
- 8:46they made a flimsy attempt at cleaning
- 8:49up after themselves and that could also
- 8:51mean that their inhibitions were
- 8:54diminished by drugs or alcohol something
- 8:57that's particularly unusual in this
- 8:59crime scene is the letters that are
- 9:01scrawled on the floor apparently by the
- 9:03male victim with grease that was
- 9:06squirted onto the floor they attempt it
- 9:08appears to spell out a name jmf and then
- 9:12under that the ope sort of a last dying
- 9:16declaration this could indicate either a
- 9:19person or some kind of motive as a
- 9:21criminal behavioral analyst I want to
- 9:24determine whether this is an actual
- 9:26message that was left by the dying male
- 9:29or whether this is staging in order to
- 9:31misdirect investigators so I'd like to
- 9:34know if he had grease on one or more of
- 9:36his hands or fingers and whether or not
- 9:38he was left-handed or right-handed and
- 9:40whether or not that was the hand that
- 9:42had the grease on it the organization
- 9:45leveled this crime is fairly low even
- 9:47though the offender brought the gun he
- 9:49used to commit the murders with him he
- 9:51left forensic evidence behind and that
- 9:53tells me he doesn't have a
- 9:55high level of forensic or criminal
- 9:57sophistication we look at pre and post
- 10:02defense behavior since it doesn't look
- 10:04like he's very criminally sophisticated
- 10:05this could be one of the only times he
- 10:08committed a crime like this and I
- 10:10believe that he may have gone into a
- 10:12panic afterwards I would think that
- 10:14somewhere between where he committed
- 10:16these crimes and where he went you would
- 10:19find the weapon in a dumpster a body of
- 10:22water or a place he thought it would be
- 10:25hidden I would also expect somebody like
- 10:28that to make an excuse to either leave
- 10:31the area or leave town for a period of
- 10:33time until everything calms down so in
- 10:36this case I believe that how the victims
- 10:39were killed tells us a story I believe
- 10:42he was a practical kill and she was the
- 10:44target of this double homicide also the
- 10:46fact that she was pregnant may indicate
- 10:49that the why was jealousy and that there
- 10:52was another person sort of a love
- 10:55triangle here and that the person
- 10:57responsible was the third person in this
- 10:59love triangle or a family member
- 11:04in the DC sniper case the entire
- 11:07Washington DC area was terrorized for 23
- 11:11days a number of random people were shot
- 11:13and killed or injured it turns out this
- 11:16was a longer spree that had started in
- 11:18the state of Washington and spanned the
- 11:20entire country so I became involved in
- 11:22the case because I was working the
- 11:24Behavioral Analysis Unit at the time and
- 11:26we consulted on the investigation
- 11:29immediately this case presented as if it
- 11:31were a spree killing six murders in the
- 11:34space of 27 hours so we didn't think he
- 11:37was targeting a particular type of group
- 11:39the victimology was completely random
- 11:41typically in Spri cases the offender is
- 11:44on the run and commits murder after
- 11:46murder after murder but he compensates
- 11:48over that time the rush of adrenaline
- 11:51and the excitement and the fear of
- 11:53getting away all those things can cause
- 11:56an offender to make more mistakes as
- 11:58time goes on but in this case that
- 12:00wasn't happening the shootings
- 12:01themselves indicated that there was pre
- 12:04attack surveillance this offender
- 12:06planned and executed six murders within
- 12:09the space of 27 hours it was a ghost no
- 12:13one even saw him that told us right away
- 12:16that he had a certain level of calm cool
- 12:18and collected news that he was probably
- 12:20in his mid to late 40s and had police or
- 12:23military training but more than that he
- 12:26must have actually had experience on the
- 12:28streets as a police officer or on the
- 12:31battlefield because pulling the trigger
- 12:34on a paper target is one thing but
- 12:36taking the life of an unknown individual
- 12:39is a whole nother matter so when we
- 12:41started the profile we based it only on
- 12:44statistics and statistically snipers are
- 12:47in their 40s or 50s white males and they
- 12:50have a grudge against society or
- 12:52somebody in particular that they take
- 12:54out on their victims
- 12:55another thing about snipers is that they
- 12:58have a god complex they want to take
- 13:00life from afar and above so they can
- 13:02feel omnipotent like God and because of
- 13:06that it's very important to appease them
- 13:10not challenge them unfortunately that's
- 13:12not what law enforcement was doing at
- 13:15the time they called them in coward
- 13:17and they said the streets are safe and
- 13:19the schools are safe so the sniper shot
- 13:21a kid walking into school the next day
- 13:24but they left a tarot card the death
- 13:27card and on that car there was
- 13:29indications of duality first of all it
- 13:31said call me God which reinforced our
- 13:34opinion that the sniper had a god
- 13:36complex
- 13:36and it went on to say this is for you
- 13:39mister police and that looks as though
- 13:41the writer is looking up to the police
- 13:43calling them mister police it also has
- 13:46its origins in a number of reggae songs
- 13:49so that could mean that the offender had
- 13:51a Caribbean influence but then it said
- 13:53do not release to the press and press is
- 13:57an older word something that older
- 13:59people use which is consistent with the
- 14:01level of sophistication of planning and
- 14:03executing these crimes but not
- 14:05consistent with looking up to the police
- 14:07so for the first time we had to consider
- 14:10whether this offender was calm cool and
- 14:12collected when he plans and executes his
- 14:15murders but he decompensates when he's
- 14:18writing or for the first time in US
- 14:20history we have a sniper team one older
- 14:24in his mid 40s and one younger in his
- 14:27teens but the fact is that we know that
- 14:30because snipers have a god complex they
- 14:32don't work well together so i theorize
- 14:34that the older one was actually
- 14:36controlling the younger one and I went
- 14:38as far as saying that he may be
- 14:40controlling him through sexual
- 14:41victimization because that would give
- 14:43him complete control over the younger
- 14:46person in fact 10 years after they were
- 14:49caught and convicted Malvo disclosed
- 14:51that Mohammad had been sexually
- 14:53victimizing it the whole time so in the
- 14:55end our profile was that of two snipers
- 14:58working together both African American
- 15:01one in his mid 40s
- 15:03having police or military training and
- 15:05experienced one in his teens
- 15:07once we released that profile and
- 15:09because of other work that the FBI was
- 15:11doing
- 15:12that reinforced our profile Muhammad and
- 15:15Malvo were arrested within 24 hours
- 15:17developing the profile in the DC sniper
- 15:19case was groundbreaking because in the
- 15:22vast majority of previous sniper cases
- 15:24in the United States of America they
- 15:26were committed by lone offenders who
- 15:28were white male who were in their 40s or
- 15:3050s with a particular grudge and this
- 15:33case blew that profile to pieces as
- 15:37criminal behavioral analysts we look at
- 15:39how the offender committed the crime and
- 15:41determine why they committed the crime
- 15:43and that leads us to who committed the
- 15:45crime in many of these cases local law
- 15:47enforcement has absolutely no idea who
- 15:50committed the crime and no leads but
- 15:52criminal behavioral analysis can
- 15:54generate leads as to the type of person
- 15:57who committed the crime and in many
- 15:58cases across the country criminal
- 16:00behavioral analysis has led to the
- 16:02identification arrest and conviction of
- 16:05the offenders
- 16:07[Music]
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Former FBI Agent Explains Criminal Profiling | Tradecraft | WIRED by WIRED, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 2,720 words across 399 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.