Foreword to The Gulag Archipelago: 50th Anniversary — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:01earlier this year I was invited by Nick
- 0:04Skidmore editor of vintage classics at
- 0:07penguin to write the foreword to the
- 0:1050th anniversary edition of the single
- 0:13vol abridged version of Alexander
- 0:15Solzhenitsyn 's The Gulag Archipelago
- 0:18this was perhaps the single greatest
- 0:20honor that has ever befallen me given
- 0:23the historical importance of
- 0:25Solzhenitsyn's book as well as its great
- 0:27personal impact on me the Gulag
- 0:31Archipelago
- 0:32in its full form was a three volume text
- 0:35originally written between 1958 and 1968
- 0:39it first saw publication in 1973 and was
- 0:43translated into English
- 0:45a year later it describes life in the
- 0:49Soviet forced labor camp system the
- 0:51gulag through a narrative compiled from
- 0:54interviews personal statements from
- 0:56inmates Diaries legal and historical
- 0:59documents and the author's own
- 1:02experience as a gulag prisoner following
- 1:05its appearance the book circulated
- 1:07underground in the Soviet Union until
- 1:09its formal publication in 1989 in the
- 1:12literary journal Novi mirror which
- 1:15published a third of the work and three
- 1:16issues since the Soviet Union dissolved
- 1:20the entire book has been published and
- 1:22has been made mandatory reading in the
- 1:25Russian school curriculum the 50th
- 1:28anniversary edition is slated for
- 1:30release
- 1:31November 1st 2018 here's a brief
- 1:37biography of the author Alexander
- 1:39Solzhenitsyn
- 1:41from the book Solzhenitsyn was born in
- 1:461918 and grew up in rostov-on-don
- 1:49he graduated in physics and mathematics
- 1:52from rostov University and studied
- 1:54literature by correspondence course at
- 1:56Moscow University in World War 2 he
- 2:00fought as an artillery officer attaining
- 2:02the rank of captain in 1945 however
- 2:06after making derogatory remarks about
- 2:09Stalin in a letter he was arrested and
- 2:12summarily sent
- 2:13to eight years in forced labor camps
- 2:16followed by internal exile in 1957 he
- 2:20was formally rehabilitated and settled
- 2:22down to teaching and writing here's a
- 2:26description of the book from the back
- 2:28cover the officially approved
- 2:31abridgement of the Gulag Archipelago
- 2:33volumes 1 2 & 3
- 2:35a vast canvass of camps prisons transit
- 2:41centers and secret police of informers
- 2:44and spies and interrogators but also of
- 2:48everyday heroism the Gulag Archipelago
- 2:50is Alexander Solzhenitsyn Grandmaster
- 2:53work based on the testimony of some 200
- 2:56survivors and on the recollection of
- 2:58Solzhenitsyn zone 11 years in labor
- 3:01camps in exile it chronicles the story
- 3:03of those at the heart of the Soviet
- 3:06Union who opposed Stalin and for whom
- 3:09the key to survival lay not in Hope but
- 3:11in despair a thoroughly researched
- 3:15document and a feat of literary and
- 3:17imaginative power this edition of The
- 3:19Gulag Archipelago was abridged into one
- 3:22volume at the author's wish and with his
- 3:24full cooperation Doris Lessing 1919 to
- 3:302013 a British novelist playwright
- 3:34librettist biographer and short story
- 3:36writer and winner of the 2007 Nobel
- 3:40Prize for Literature says of the Gulag
- 3:42Archipelago it helped to bring down an
- 3:45empire its importance can hardly be
- 3:48exaggerated
- 3:51this is Solzhenitsyn's own foreword to
- 3:54the original abridgement I dedicate this
- 3:58to all those who did not live to tell it
- 4:00and may they please forgive me for not
- 4:03having seen at all nor remembered at all
- 4:06for not having divined at all if it were
- 4:10possible for any nation to fathom
- 4:12another people's bitter experience
- 4:14through a book how much easier its
- 4:16future fate would become and how many
- 4:19calamities and mistakes it could avoid
- 4:22but it is very difficult there always is
- 4:26this
- 4:27fallacious belief it would not be the
- 4:30same here here such things are
- 4:32impossible alas all the evil of the 20th
- 4:37century is possible everywhere on earth
- 4:39yet I have not given up all hope that
- 4:42human beings and Nations may be able in
- 4:44spite of all to learn from the
- 4:47experience of other people without
- 4:48having to live through it personally
- 4:50therefore I gratefully accept professor
- 4:53Erickson suggestion to create a
- 4:55one-volume abridgement of my
- 4:57three-volume work the Gulag Archipelago
- 4:59in order to facilitate its reading for
- 5:02those who do not have much time in this
- 5:04hectic century of ours
- 5:06I thank professor Ericson for his
- 5:08generous initiative as well as for the
- 5:11tactfulness the literary taste and the
- 5:13understanding of Western readers which
- 5:15he displayed during the work on the
- 5:18abridgement Edward II Erickson jr. 1939
- 5:24to 2017 who served as the editor of the
- 5:28abridged single-volume version of The
- 5:30Gulag Archipelago was professor emeritus
- 5:32of English at Calvin College and the
- 5:35author of many other books including the
- 5:37Solzhenitsyn reader the apocalyptic
- 5:40vision of Mikhail Bulgakov's the master
- 5:43and margarita and the soul and barbed
- 5:46wire an introduction to Solzhenitsyn
- 5:49this is what he had to say when he
- 5:51introduced the abridged version in 1994
- 5:56after 20 years of forced exile in the
- 5:58West Alexander Solzhenitsyn returned to
- 6:01Russia at one town meeting held on his
- 6:04trans-siberian Whistlestop tour to
- 6:07reacquaint himself with his homeland he
- 6:09was confronted by this rebuke it is you
- 6:13and your writing that started it all and
- 6:15brought our country to the verge of
- 6:16collapse and devastation Russia doesn't
- 6:19need you so go back to your blessed
- 6:22America Solzhenitsyn instantly replied
- 6:26that to his dying day he would keep
- 6:28fighting against the evil ideology that
- 6:31was capable of slaying one-third of his
- 6:33country's population the meeting erupted
- 6:36in applause that sort of exchange was on
- 6:40the matter
- 6:40when the present abridgement of the
- 6:42Gulag Archipelago first appeared in 1985
- 6:45almost no one expected then that within
- 6:48a few years the soviet union would
- 6:50collapse and almost in a day like the
- 6:53legendary one-horse Shay yet now the
- 6:56dramatic events that put the closing
- 6:58punctuation mark on the Soviet
- 7:00parentheses in Russian history have also
- 7:02we may say brought an end to what the
- 7:05great Russian poet Anna Akhmatova called
- 7:08the true 20th century this foreshortened
- 7:12century running from 1914 to 1917 to
- 7:161989 1991 was the era when utopian
- 7:21dreams rooted enlightenment optimism
- 7:23came to rely on brute force to make
- 7:26ideological schemes prevail the 20th
- 7:30century is proven in quantitative terms
- 7:33at least the most murderous in human
- 7:35history as governments killed their
- 7:37subjects at record rates for decades the
- 7:40word Holocaust served as shorthand for
- 7:43modern man's inhumanity to man then one
- 7:47lone man added a second such term gulag
- 7:50which now appears in dictionaries as a
- 7:53common noun
- 7:54Solzhenitsyn was one of the precious few
- 7:57who did anticipate the demise of the
- 7:59Soviet experiment and he thought his
- 8:01book would help oh yes gulag was
- 8:05destined to affect the course of history
- 8:06I was sure of that on one of his darkest
- 8:10days February 12 1974 the day before he
- 8:14was forced into exile and precisely
- 8:16because the gulag had appeared in the
- 8:18West he mused you Bolsheviks are
- 8:21finished there are no two ways about it
- 8:24what satisfaction he felt then when some
- 8:27early reviews such as one from the
- 8:30frankfurter algemene a leading German
- 8:32newspaper caught his intentions the time
- 8:36may come when we date the beginning of
- 8:38the collapse of the Soviet system from
- 8:40the appearance of gulag American
- 8:43diplomat and scholar George F cannon
- 8:45hailed the work as the greatest and most
- 8:48powerful single indictment of a
- 8:49political regime ever to be leveled in
- 8:52modern
- 8:53one sure to stick in the craw of the
- 8:57Soviet propaganda machine with
- 8:59increasing discomfort until it has done
- 9:02its work Solzhenitsyn
- 9:05has proven prescient on other matters as
- 9:08well not only did he reiterate in the
- 9:10teeth of the prevailing opinion of
- 9:12Western specialists on Soviet affairs
- 9:14that he was absolutely convinced that
- 9:16communism will go he also insisted most
- 9:20resolutely and against all seeming
- 9:22reason that he expected to be reunited
- 9:24with his beloved Russia in a strange way
- 9:28I not only hope I'm inwardly convinced
- 9:31that I shall go back I mean my physical
- 9:34return not just my books and that
- 9:37contradicts all rationality his
- 9:40improbable prerequisites were that his
- 9:42citizenship be restored that the charge
- 9:45of treason against him be dropped and
- 9:47that all his books be published in his
- 9:49homeland after his prophecies were
- 9:52fulfilled a friend of his reminisced it
- 9:55seemed crazy to me at the time but it
- 9:58was a real conviction a poet's knowledge
- 10:01he sees the man seized however
- 10:06historians ultimately apportioned the
- 10:08credit for ending the Cold War
- 10:10Solzhenitsyn indubitably played a part
- 10:12in bringing the Soviet edifice down to
- 10:15rubble his writings D legitimized
- 10:18communism in his homeland and
- 10:20discredited it abroad he was much too
- 10:23modest in depicting himself as a little
- 10:25calf foolishly budding a mighty oak and
- 10:28thinking this could bring it down as
- 10:30David Remnick editor of The New Yorker
- 10:33declares in terms of the effect he has
- 10:37had on history
- 10:38Solzhenitsyn is the dominant writer of
- 10:40the century who else compares Orwell
- 10:45Kessler Remnick concludes that to some
- 10:50extent you have to credit the literary
- 10:52works of Alexander Solzhenitsyn with
- 10:54helping to bring down the last Empire on
- 10:57earth so after that introductory
- 11:02material my forward
- 11:06it begins with an excerpt from the
- 11:09speech delivered by Solzhenitsyn to the
- 11:11Swedish Academy on the occasion of his
- 11:14acceptance of the Nobel Prize for
- 11:15Literature once we have taken up the
- 11:20word it is thereafter impossible to turn
- 11:23away a writer is no detached judge of
- 11:27his countrymen and contemporaries he is
- 11:29an accomplice to all the evil committed
- 11:31in his country or by his people and if
- 11:35the tanks of his fatherland have
- 11:37bloodied the pavement of a foreign
- 11:39capital then rust-colored stains have
- 11:42forever be spattered the writers face
- 11:44and if on some fateful night a trusting
- 11:48friend is strangled in his sleep
- 11:50then the palms of the writer bare the
- 11:53bruises from that rope and of his
- 11:57youthful fellow citizens nonchalantly
- 11:59proclaimed the advantages of debauchery
- 12:02over humble toil if they abandon
- 12:05themselves to drugs or seize hostages
- 12:08then this stench too is mingled with the
- 12:11breath of the writer have we the
- 12:14insolence to declare that we do not
- 12:16answer for the evils of today's world
- 12:20the simple act of an ordinary brave man
- 12:23is not to participate in lies not to
- 12:26support false actions his rule let that
- 12:32come into the world let it even reign
- 12:36supreme
- 12:37only not through me but it is within the
- 12:42power of writers and artists to do much
- 12:44more to defeat the lie for in the
- 12:47struggle with lies art has always
- 12:49triumphed and shall always triumph
- 12:52visibly irrefutably for all lies can
- 12:56prevail against much in this world but
- 13:00never against art one word of truth
- 13:04shall outweigh the whole world first you
- 13:10defend your homeland against the Nazis
- 13:12serving as a twice decorated soldier on
- 13:14the Eastern Front in the criminally
- 13:16ill-prepared Soviet Red Army
- 13:19then you're arrested humiliated stripped
- 13:23of your military rank charged under the
- 13:25auspices of the all-purpose article 58
- 13:28with the dissemination of anti Soviet
- 13:31propaganda and dragged off to Moscow's
- 13:34infamous Lubyanka prison there through
- 13:38the bars of your cell you watch your
- 13:41beloved country celebrating its victory
- 13:43in the Great Patriotic War then you're
- 13:47sentenced in absentia to eight years of
- 13:50hard labor but you got away easy it
- 13:54wasn't so long afterward the people in
- 13:56your position were awarded a tenner and
- 13:58then a quarter of a century and fate
- 14:01isn't finished with you yet not by any
- 14:04means you develop a deadly cancer in the
- 14:07camp endure the exile imposed on you
- 14:10after your imprisonment ends and pass
- 14:13very close to death despite all this you
- 14:16hold your head high
- 14:17you refuse to turn against man or God
- 14:20although you have every reason to do so
- 14:23you write instead secretly at night
- 14:27documenting your terrible experiences
- 14:29you craft a personal memoir a single day
- 14:34in the labor camps and miracle of
- 14:38miracles the clouds part the Sun shines
- 14:42through your book is published and in
- 14:46your own country it meets with
- 14:49unparalleled acclaim nationally and
- 14:51internationally but the sky darkens once
- 14:55again and the Sun disappears the
- 14:57repression returns you become once again
- 15:01a non-person the secret police the dread
- 15:06KGB seize the manuscript of your next
- 15:09book it sees the light of day
- 15:12nonetheless but only in the West there
- 15:16your reputation grows beyond the wildest
- 15:18of imaginings the Nobel Committee itself
- 15:22bestows upon you its highest literary
- 15:25honour the Soviet authorities stripped
- 15:28of their camouflage are enraged they
- 15:31order the secret police to poison
- 15:33you you pass once again near death but
- 15:37you continue to write driven solitary
- 15:41intolerably inspired your Gulag
- 15:45Archipelago documents the absolute and
- 15:47utter corruption of the dogmas and
- 15:49doctrines of your state your empire your
- 15:53leaders and yourself and then that is
- 15:59printed to not in your own country but
- 16:03in the West once again from copies oh so
- 16:06dangerously hidden and smuggled across
- 16:09the borders and your great book bursts
- 16:11with unparalleled and dreadful force
- 16:13into the still naive and unexpected
- 16:16literary and intellectual world you're
- 16:19expelled from the Soviet Union stripped
- 16:22of your citizenship forced to take
- 16:25residency in a society both strange to
- 16:27you and resistant in its own way to your
- 16:30prophetic words but the power of your
- 16:33stories and the strength of your morals
- 16:35demolish any remaining claims to ethical
- 16:38and philosophical credibility still made
- 16:41by the defenders of the collectivist
- 16:43system that gave rise to all that you
- 16:46witnessed years pass but not so many
- 16:51from the perspective of history then
- 16:55another miracle the Soviet Union
- 16:59collapses you return home your
- 17:02citizenship is restored you write and
- 17:05speak in your reclaimed homeland until
- 17:07death claims you in 2008 a year later
- 17:12the Gulag Archipelago is deemed
- 17:14mandatory reading by those responsible
- 17:16for establishing the national school
- 17:18curriculum of your home country
- 17:21you're impossible victory is complete
- 17:28the three volumes of the Gulag
- 17:30Archipelago one continuous extended
- 17:34scream of outrage are paradoxically
- 17:37brilliant bitter disbelieving and
- 17:41infused with awe awe at the strength
- 17:45characterizing the best among us in the
- 17:47worst of all situations in that
- 17:51monumental text published in 1973
- 17:54alexander solzhenitsyn conducted an
- 17:56experiment in literary investigation a
- 17:59hybrid of journalism history and
- 18:03biography unlike anything ever written
- 18:05before or since
- 18:07in 1985 the author bestowed his approval
- 18:11upon Edward II Erickson Jr's
- 18:14single-volume abridgement republished
- 18:16here on the 50th anniversary of the
- 18:18completion of the full three volume
- 18:20edition and centenary of the author's
- 18:22birth and sold some 30 million copies in
- 18:2635 languages between the pages of
- 18:31Solzhenitsyn's book apart from the
- 18:34documentation of the horrors of the
- 18:36legions of the Dead counted and
- 18:38uncounted and the masses whose lives
- 18:41were torn asunder are the innumerable
- 18:43soul chilling personal stories carefully
- 18:47preserved making the tragedy of mass
- 18:49betrayal torture and death not the mere
- 18:53statistic Stalin so disdainful II
- 18:56described but individual real and
- 19:00terrible it is a matter of pure
- 19:04historical fact that the Gulag
- 19:06Archipelago played a primary role in
- 19:08bringing the Soviet Empire to its knees
- 19:11although economically unsustainable
- 19:14ruled in the most corrupt manner
- 19:16imaginable and reliant on the slavery
- 19:19and enforced deceit of its citizens the
- 19:22Soviet system managed to stumble forward
- 19:24through far too many decades before
- 19:27being cut to the quick the courageous
- 19:30leaders of the labor unions in Poland
- 19:32the great pope john paul ii and the
- 19:35american president ronald reagan with
- 19:37his blunt insistence that the West faced
- 19:40an evil empire
- 19:41all played their role in its defeat and
- 19:43collapse it was Solzhenitsyn however
- 19:47whose revelations made it positively
- 19:49shameful to defend not just the Soviet
- 19:52state but the very system of thought
- 19:55that made that state what it was it was
- 19:58Solzhenitsyn who most crucially made the
- 20:00case that the terrible excesses of
- 20:02communism could not be conveniently
- 20:04blamed on the corruption of the Soviet
- 20:07leadership the cult of personality
- 20:09surrounding Stalin or the failure to put
- 20:11the otherwise stellar and admirable
- 20:13utopian principles of Marxism into
- 20:16proper practice it was Solzhenitsyn who
- 20:20demonstrated that the death of millions
- 20:21and the devastation of many more were
- 20:24instead a direct causal consequence of
- 20:28the philosophy worse perhaps the
- 20:31theology driving the communist system
- 20:34the hypothetically egalitarian
- 20:37Universalist doctrines of Karl Marx
- 20:39contained hidden within them sufficient
- 20:42hatred resentment envy and denial of
- 20:46individual culpability and
- 20:48responsibility to produce nothing but
- 20:50poison and death when manifested in the
- 20:53world for Marx man was a member of a
- 20:58class an economic class a group that and
- 21:03little more and history nothing but the
- 21:06battleground of classes and groups his
- 21:09admirers regarded continued to regard
- 21:13Marx's doctrine as one of compassion
- 21:15moral by definition virtuous by Fiat
- 21:19consider the working classes in all
- 21:22their oppression and work forthrightly
- 21:25to free them but hate may well be a
- 21:28stronger and more compelling motivator
- 21:30than love in consequence it took no time
- 21:34in the aftermath of the Russian
- 21:36Revolution for solidarity with the
- 21:38common man and the apparently laudable
- 21:41demand for universal equality to
- 21:43manifest its unarticulated and ever
- 21:46darkening shadow first came the most
- 21:51brutal indictment of the class enemy
- 21:54then
- 21:55came the ever-expanding definition of
- 21:57that enemy until every single person in
- 22:00the entirety of the state found him or
- 22:02herself at risk of encapsulation within
- 22:04that insatiable and devouring net the
- 22:08verdict delivered to those deemed at
- 22:11fault by those who elevated themselves
- 22:13to the simultaneously held positions of
- 22:16judge jury and executioner the necessity
- 22:21to eradicate the victimizers the
- 22:23oppressors in toto without any
- 22:26consideration whatsoever for reactionary
- 22:29niceties such as individual innocence
- 22:32let us note as well this outcome wasn't
- 22:35the result of the initially pristine
- 22:37Marxist doctrine becoming corrupt over
- 22:40time but something apparent and present
- 22:42at the very beginning of the Soviet
- 22:43state itself
- 22:45Solzhenitsyn cites for example one
- 22:48Martin Latsis writing for the newspaper
- 22:51read terror November 1st 1918 we are not
- 22:57fighting against single individuals we
- 23:00are exterminating the burgeois z as a
- 23:02class it is not necessary during the
- 23:06interrogation to look for evidence
- 23:08proving that the accused opposed the
- 23:10Soviets by word or action the first
- 23:13question you should ask him is what
- 23:15class does he belong to
- 23:17what is his origin his education and his
- 23:20profession these are the questions that
- 23:22will determine the fate of the accused
- 23:25such is the sense and essence of red
- 23:29terror it is necessary to think when you
- 23:34read such a thing to meditate long and
- 23:37hard on the message it is necessary to
- 23:39recognize for example that the writer
- 23:41believed that it would be better to
- 23:42execute 10,000 potentially innocent
- 23:45individuals than to allow one poisonous
- 23:48member of the oppressor class to remain
- 23:50free it is equally necessary to pose the
- 23:55question who precisely belonged to that
- 23:59hypothetical entity the bourgeoisie it
- 24:03is not as if the boundaries of such a
- 24:05category are self-evident
- 24:07therefore the mere
- 24:08thieving they must be drawn but where
- 24:11exactly and more importantly by whom or
- 24:16by what if it's hate inscribing the
- 24:20lines instead of love they will
- 24:22inevitably be drawn so that the lowest
- 24:24meanest most cruel and useless of the
- 24:28conceptual geographers will be justified
- 24:30in manifesting the greatest possible
- 24:33evil and producing the greatest possible
- 24:36misery members of the bourgeoisie beyond
- 24:41all redemption they had to go as a
- 24:44matter of course one of their wives
- 24:47children even their grandchildren off
- 24:52with their heads too all were encouraged
- 24:57oblique errupted by their class identity
- 24:58and their destruction therefore
- 25:00ethically necessitated how convenient
- 25:04that the darkest and diarist of all
- 25:06possible motivations could be granted
- 25:08the highest of moral standings that was
- 25:11a true marriage of hell and of heaven
- 25:14what values what philosophical
- 25:17presumptions truly dominated under such
- 25:20circumstances
- 25:21was it desire for Brotherhood dignity
- 25:24and freedom from want not in the least
- 25:29not given the outcome it was instead and
- 25:32obviously the murderous rage of hundreds
- 25:36of thousands of biblical canes each
- 25:38looking to torture destroy and sacrifice
- 25:42their own private Abel's there is simply
- 25:45no other manner of accounting for the
- 25:48corpses what can be concluded in the
- 25:51deepest most permanent sense from
- 25:54Solzhenitsyn's anguished gulag narrative
- 25:57first we learn what is indisputable what
- 26:02we all should have learned by now what
- 26:04we have nonetheless failed to learn that
- 26:07the left like the right can go too far
- 26:11that the left has in the past gone much
- 26:14too far second we learn what is far more
- 26:18subtle and difficult how and why that
- 26:21going too far
- 26:22we learn as Solzhenitsyn so profoundly
- 26:26insists that the line dividing good and
- 26:29evil cuts through the heart of every
- 26:30human being and we learn as well that we
- 26:33all are each of us simultaneously
- 26:36oppressor and oppressed thus we come to
- 26:41realize that the twin categories of
- 26:42guilty oppressor and justice seeking
- 26:45victim can be made endlessly inclusive
- 26:48this is not least because we all benefit
- 26:52unfairly and are all equally victimized
- 26:55by our throne as' our arbitrary
- 26:58placement in the flow of time we all
- 27:01accrue undeserved and somewhat random
- 27:04privileged from the vagaries of our
- 27:06place of birth our inequitably
- 27:08distributed talents our ethnicity race
- 27:10culture and sex we all belong to a group
- 27:14some group that has been elevated in
- 27:17comparative status through no effort of
- 27:19our own this is true in some manner
- 27:22along some dimension of group category
- 27:24for every solitary individual except for
- 27:29the single most lowly of all at some
- 27:32time and in some manner we may all in
- 27:34consequence be justly targeted as
- 27:36oppressors and may all equally seek
- 27:39justice or revenge as victims even if
- 27:45the initiators of the revolution had
- 27:47therefore in their most pure moments
- 27:49being driven by a holy desire to lift up
- 27:52the downtrodden
- 27:54was it not guaranteed that they would be
- 27:56overtaken by those motivated primarily
- 27:58by Envy hate and the desire to destroy
- 28:02as the revolution progressed
- 28:05hence the establishment of the hungrily
- 28:08growing and most often fatal list of
- 28:10class enemies right from the very first
- 28:12moments of the Communist revolution the
- 28:16demolition was aimed first at the
- 28:17students the religious believers and the
- 28:20Socialists continuing under Stalin with
- 28:23the old revolutionaries themselves and
- 28:25was followed soon thereafter by the
- 28:27annihilation of the successful peasant
- 28:30farmer kulaks and this appetite for
- 28:35destruction was
- 28:36of the type to be satiated with the
- 28:38bodies of the perpetrators themselves as
- 28:41Solzhenitsyn writes they burned out
- 28:45whole nests whole families from the
- 28:47start and they watched jealously to be
- 28:50sure that none of the children 14 10
- 28:54even 6 years old got away to the last
- 28:58scrapings all had to go down the same
- 29:01road to the same common destruction this
- 29:06was driven by the perceived even self
- 29:09perceived guilt of all how else was it
- 29:12possible for the hundreds of thousands
- 29:14or perhaps even millions of informants
- 29:17prosecutors betrayers and unforgivably
- 29:21mute observers to Pring and unforgivably
- 29:25mute observers to spring so rapidly into
- 29:29being in the tumult of the Red Terror
- 29:34thus the doctrine of group identity
- 29:38inevitably ends with everyone identified
- 29:40as a class enemy an oppressor with
- 29:43everyone unclench ibly contaminated by
- 29:45bourgeois privilege unfairly enjoying
- 29:48the benefits bequeathed by the vagaries
- 29:50of history with everyone prosecuted
- 29:53without respite for that corruption and
- 29:56injustice no mercy for the oppressor and
- 30:00no punishment too severe for the crime
- 30:03of exploitation
- 30:05expiation becomes impossible because
- 30:08there is no individual guilt no
- 30:10individual responsibility and therefore
- 30:13no manner in which the crime of
- 30:14arbitrary birth can be individually
- 30:17accounted for and all the misery that
- 30:20can be generated as a consequence of
- 30:22such an accusation is the true reason
- 30:25for the accusation when everyone is
- 30:30guilty all that serves justice is the
- 30:33punishment of everyone when the guilt
- 30:36extends to the existence of the world's
- 30:38misery itself only the fatal punishment
- 30:42will suffice
- 30:45it is much more preferable instead and
- 30:49much more likely to preserve us all from
- 30:52metastasizing hells to state
- 30:54forthrightly I am indeed throwing
- 30:58arbitrarily into history I therefore
- 31:02choose to voluntarily shoulder the
- 31:04responsibilities of my advantages and
- 31:06the burden of my disadvantages like
- 31:10every other individual I am morally
- 31:12bound to pay for my advantages with my
- 31:15responsibilities
- 31:16I am morally bound to accept my
- 31:19disadvantages as the price I pay for
- 31:21being I will therefore strive not to
- 31:26descend into bitterness and then seek
- 31:28vengeance because I have less to my
- 31:30credit and a greater burden to stumble
- 31:32forward with than others is this not our
- 31:38or even the essential point of
- 31:41difference between the West for all its
- 31:43faults and the brutal terrible
- 31:45egalitarian systems generated by the
- 31:48pathological communist doctrine the
- 31:51great and good framers of the American
- 31:54Republic were for example anything but
- 31:56utopian they took full stalk and full
- 32:00measure of inner Attica Balu Minh
- 32:02imperfection
- 32:03they held modest goals derived not least
- 32:07from the profoundly cautious common-law
- 32:09tradition of England they endeavoured to
- 32:12establish a system the corrupt and
- 32:14ignorant fools we all are could not
- 32:17damage to fatally that's humility that's
- 32:22clear-headed knowledge of the
- 32:23limitations of human machination and
- 32:26good intention but the Communists the
- 32:31revolutionaries they aimed grandly and
- 32:35admirably at least in theory at a much
- 32:39more heavenly vision and they began
- 32:41their pursuit with the hypothetically
- 32:43straightforward and oh so morally
- 32:46justifiable enforcement of economic
- 32:49equality wealth however was not so
- 32:53easily generated the poor could not
- 32:56simply become rich but the
- 32:59riches of those who had anything more
- 33:00than the greatest pauper no matter how
- 33:03pitiful that more was that could be
- 33:06redistributed or at least destroyed
- 33:10that's equality to that sacrifice in the
- 33:15name of heaven on earth and
- 33:17redistribution was not enough with all
- 33:20its theft betrayal and death mere
- 33:24economic engineering was insufficient
- 33:26what emerged as well was the overarching
- 33:30and truly totalitarian desire to remake
- 33:33man and woman as such the longing to
- 33:37restructure the human spirit in the very
- 33:39image of the Communists preconceptions
- 33:42attributing to themselves this divine
- 33:45ability this transcendent wisdom and
- 33:47with unshakable belief in the glowing
- 33:51but ever receding future the newly
- 33:53minted Soviets tortured thieved
- 33:56imprisoned lied and betrayed all the
- 33:59while masking their great evil with
- 34:01virtue
- 34:02it was Solzhenitsyn and the Gulag
- 34:05Archipelago that tore off the mask and
- 34:07exposed the feral cowardice envy deceit
- 34:11resentment and hatred for the individual
- 34:14and for existence itself that pulsed
- 34:18beneath others had made the attempt
- 34:22Malcolm Muggeridge reported on the
- 34:24horrors of dekulakization the forced
- 34:27collectivization of the all too recently
- 34:30successful peasantry of the Ukraine and
- 34:32elsewhere that preceded the horrifying
- 34:34famines of the 1930s in the same decade
- 34:38and in the following years George Orwell
- 34:41risked his ideological commitments and
- 34:43his reputation to tell us all what was
- 34:45truly occurring in the Soviet Union in
- 34:47the name of egalitarianism and
- 34:49brotherhood but it was Solzhenitsyn who
- 34:53truly shamed the radical leftists
- 34:55forcing them underground where they have
- 34:58festered and plotted for the last forty
- 35:00years
- 35:00failing unforgivably to have learned
- 35:03what all reasonable people should have
- 35:05learned from the Cataclysm of the 20th
- 35:07century and its egalitarian utopianism
- 35:10and
- 35:12day despite everything and under their
- 35:15sway almost three decades since the fall
- 35:18of the Berlin Wall and the apparent
- 35:19collapse of communism we are doing
- 35:22everything we can to forget what
- 35:23Solzhenitsyn so clearly demonstrated to
- 35:26our great and richly deserved peril why
- 35:30don't all our children read the Gulag
- 35:33Archipelago in our high schools as they
- 35:35now do in Russia why don't our teachers
- 35:38feel compelled to read the book aloud
- 35:42did we not win the Cold War where the
- 35:45body's not piled high enough how high
- 35:49then would be enough why for example is
- 35:56it still acceptable and in polite
- 35:58company to profess the philosophy of a
- 36:01communist or if not that to at least
- 36:03admire the work of Marx why is it still
- 36:06acceptable to regard the Marxist
- 36:08doctrine as essentially accurate in its
- 36:10diagnosis of the hypothetical evils of
- 36:12the free-market Democratic West to still
- 36:16consider that doctrine progressive and
- 36:18fit for the compassionate and proper
- 36:20thinking person 25 million dead through
- 36:26internal repression in the Soviet Union
- 36:28according to the black book of communism
- 36:3160 million dead in Mao's China and an
- 36:34all too likely returned to autocratic
- 36:36oppression in that country in the near
- 36:38future the horrors of Cambodia's killing
- 36:41fields with their two million corpses
- 36:44the barely animate body politic of Cuba
- 36:48where people struggle even now to feed
- 36:50themselves Venezuela where it has now
- 36:55been made illegal to attribute a child's
- 36:57death in hospital to starvation no
- 37:02political experiment has ever been tried
- 37:05so widely with so many disparate people
- 37:07in so many different countries with such
- 37:10different histories and failed so
- 37:13absolutely and catastrophic Lee is it
- 37:17mere ignorant Al biet of the most
- 37:20inexcusable kind that allows today's
- 37:23Marxist to flaunt their content
- 37:25allegiance to present it as compassion
- 37:28and care or is it instead envy of this
- 37:33successful in near infinite proportions
- 37:36or something akin to hatred for mankind
- 37:39itself how much proof do we need why do
- 37:45we still avert our eyes from the truth
- 37:50perhaps we simply lack sophistication
- 37:53perhaps we just can't understand perhaps
- 37:57our tendency toward compassion is so
- 37:59powerfully necessary in the intimacy of
- 38:01our families and friendships that we
- 38:03cannot contemplate its limitations it's
- 38:06an ability to scale and it's propensity
- 38:09to mutate into hatred of the oppressor
- 38:12rather than allegiance with the
- 38:13oppressed perhaps we cannot comprehend
- 38:17the limitations and dangers of the
- 38:19utopian vision given our definite need
- 38:22to contemplate and to strive for a
- 38:24better tomorrow
- 38:26we certainly don't seem to imagine for
- 38:29example that the hypothesis of some
- 38:31state of future perfection
- 38:33for example the truly egalitarian and
- 38:36permanent brotherhood of man can be used
- 38:38to justify any and all sacrifices
- 38:41whatsoever the pristine and heavenly and
- 38:44making all conceivable means not only
- 38:47acceptable but morally required there is
- 38:51simply no price too great to pay in
- 38:53pursuit of the ultimate utopia and this
- 38:56is particularly true if it is someone
- 38:58else who foots the bill and it is
- 39:01clearly the case that we require a
- 39:03future toward which to orient ourselves
- 39:05to provide meaning in our life
- 39:08psychologically speaking it is for that
- 39:12reason we see the same need expressed
- 39:14collectively on a much larger scale in
- 39:17the judeo-christian vision of the
- 39:19promised land and the kingdom of heaven
- 39:21on earth and it is also clearly the case
- 39:24that sacrifice is necessary to bring
- 39:26that desired end state into being
- 39:28that's the discovery of the future
- 39:31itself the necessity to forgo
- 39:33instantaneous gratification in the
- 39:35present to delay to bargain with fate so
- 39:39that the future can be better twinned
- 39:41with the necessity to let go to burn off
- 39:44to separate wheat from chaff and to
- 39:47sacrifice what is presently unworthy so
- 39:50that tomorrow can be better than today
- 39:52but limits need to be placed around who
- 39:55or what is deemed dispensable and it is
- 40:00exactly the necessity for interminable
- 40:02sacrifice that constitutes the
- 40:04counterpart of the utopian vision heaven
- 40:07is worth any price but who pays
- 40:12Christianity solved that problem by
- 40:14insisting on the sacrifice of the self
- 40:17insisting that the suffering and
- 40:19malevolence of the world is the
- 40:20responsibility of each individual
- 40:23insisting that each of us sacrifice what
- 40:26is unworthy and unnecessary and
- 40:28resentful and deadly in our characters
- 40:30despite the pain of such sacrifice so
- 40:34that we could stumble properly uphill
- 40:36under our respective and voluntarily
- 40:38shouldered existential burdens but it
- 40:42was and is the opinion of the
- 40:44materialist utopians that someone else
- 40:46be sacrificed so that heaven itself
- 40:48might be attained some perpetrator or
- 40:51victimizer or oppressor or member of a
- 40:55privileged group a cynic might be
- 40:58forgiven in consequence for asking is it
- 41:01the City of God that is in fact the aim
- 41:03or is the true aim the desire to make a
- 41:06burning sacrificial pyre of everyone and
- 41:09everything and the hypothesis of the
- 41:11coming brotherhood of man merely the
- 41:14cover story the camouflage perhaps it is
- 41:18precisely the horror that is the point
- 41:20and not the utopia it is far from
- 41:23obvious in such situations just what is
- 41:26horse and what is cart it is precisely
- 41:29in the aftermath of the death of a
- 41:31hundred million people or more that such
- 41:33dark questions must be asked and we
- 41:36should also note that the utopian vision
- 41:39dressed as it is inevitably in
- 41:41compassion is a temptation particularly
- 41:44difficult to resist and may therefore
- 41:46offer a particularly subtle and
- 41:48insidious justification for mayhem here
- 41:52are some thoughts know some facts every
- 41:58social system produces inequality at
- 42:00present and every social system has done
- 42:03so since the beginning of time the poor
- 42:06have been with us and will be with us
- 42:09always analysis of the content of
- 42:12individual Paleolithic grave sites
- 42:14provides evidence for the existence of
- 42:17variance in the distribution of ability
- 42:20privilege and wealth even in our distant
- 42:23past the more illustrious of our
- 42:26ancestors were buried with great
- 42:28possessions hoards of precious metals
- 42:31weaponry jewelry and costuming the
- 42:34majority however struggled through their
- 42:36lives and were buried with nothing
- 42:39inequality is the iron rule even among
- 42:42animals with their intense competition
- 42:45for quality living space and repre
- 42:47ducked Ivana Hmong plants and cities
- 42:51even among the stellar lights that dot
- 42:54the cosmos themselves where a minority
- 42:56of privileged and oppressive heavenly
- 42:58bodies contain the mass of thousands
- 43:00millions or even billions of average
- 43:03dispossessed planets inequality is the
- 43:06deepest of problems built into the
- 43:09structure of reality itself and will not
- 43:11be solved by the presumptuous ideology
- 43:14inspired retooling of the rare free
- 43:17stable and productive democracies of the
- 43:20world the only systems that have
- 43:23produced some modicum of wealth along
- 43:25with the inevitable inequality and it's
- 43:27in tendency along with the inevitable
- 43:30inequality and its attendant suffering
- 43:34the only systems that have produced some
- 43:37modicum of wealth along with the
- 43:39inevitable inequality and its attendant
- 43:41suffering are those that evolved in the
- 43:43West with their roots in the
- 43:45judeo-christian tradition precisely
- 43:47those systems that emphasized above all
- 43:50the essential dignity divinity and
- 43:52ultimate responsibility of the
- 43:54individual in consequence any attempt to
- 43:57attribute the existence of inequality to
- 44:00the functioning of the productive
- 44:01institutions we have managed to create
- 44:03and protect so recently in what is still
- 44:06accurately regarded as the free world
- 44:08will hurt those who are weakest and most
- 44:10vulnerable first the radicals who
- 44:14conflate the activities of the West with
- 44:16the oppression of the downtrodden
- 44:18therefore do nothing to aid those whom
- 44:20they purport to prize and plenty to harm
- 44:22them the claims they make to act under
- 44:25the inspiration of pure compassion must
- 44:28therefore come to be regarded with the
- 44:29deepest suspicion
- 44:31not least by those who dare to make such
- 44:33claims themselves the dangers of the
- 44:37utopian vision have been laid bare even
- 44:40if the reasons those dangers exist have
- 44:42not yet been fully unacceptably
- 44:44articulated if there was any excuse to
- 44:47be a Marxist in 1917 and both
- 44:50Dostoyevsky and Nietzsche prophesied
- 44:52well before then that there would be
- 44:54hell to pay for that doctrine there is
- 44:56absolutely and finally no excuse now and
- 44:59we know that mostly because of Alexander
- 45:02Solzhenitsyn and the Gulag Archipelago
- 45:05thank heaven for that great authors
- 45:08outrage courage and unquenchable thirst
- 45:11for justice and truth it was
- 45:14Solzhenitsyn who warned us that the
- 45:16catastrophes of the Soviet state were
- 45:18inextricably and causally linked to the
- 45:21deceitful blandishments of the marxist
- 45:23utopian vision it was Solzhenitsyn who
- 45:28carefully documented the price paid in
- 45:30suffering for the dreadful communist
- 45:32experiment and who distilled from that
- 45:34suffering the wisdom we must all heed so
- 45:37that such catastrophe does not visit us
- 45:39again perhaps we could take from his
- 45:43writing the humility that would allow us
- 45:45to understand that our mere good
- 45:47intentions are not sufficient to make us
- 45:49good men and women perhaps we could take
- 45:53from his writing the humility that would
- 45:56allow us to understand that our mere
- 45:58good intentions are not sufficient to
- 46:01make us good men and women perhaps we
- 46:04could come to understand that such
- 46:05intentions are instead all too often the
- 46:08consequence of our unpardonable
- 46:10historical ignorance our utter willful
- 46:13blindness and are voracious hidden
- 46:15appetite for vengeance terror and
- 46:18destruction perhaps we could come to
- 46:21remember and to learn from the
- 46:22intolerable trials endured by all those
- 46:25who pass through the fiery chambers of
- 46:27the marxist collectivist ideology
- 46:31perhaps we could derive from that
- 46:33remembering and learning the wisdom
- 46:35necessary to take personal
- 46:37responsibility for the suffering and
- 46:39malevolence that still so terribly and
- 46:42unforgivably characterizes the war
- 46:44world we have been provided with the
- 46:48means to transform ourselves and do
- 46:51humility by the literary and moral
- 46:53genius of this great Russian author we
- 46:56should also pray most devoutly -
- 46:59whatever daddy guides us implicitly or
- 47:01explicitly for the desire and the will
- 47:04to learn from what we have been offered
- 47:07may God himself eternally failed to
- 47:10forgive us if in the painstakingly
- 47:12revealed aftermath of such bloodshed
- 47:15torture and anguish
- 47:16we remain stiff-necked in cautious and
- 47:21unchanged
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Foreword to The Gulag Archipelago: 50th Anniversary by Jordan B Peterson, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 6,160 words across 1,002 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.