Forensic Files - Season 4, Episode 10 - Core Evidence - Full Episode — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:10in 1996
- 0:11more than a dozen children in seattle
- 0:14washington were seriously ill and
- 0:16fighting for their lives all gripped by
- 0:19a mysterious illness
- 0:21when one of the children died officials
- 0:24feared more deaths would follow
- 0:26and medical detectives frantically
- 0:29searched for the cause
- 0:33[Music]
- 0:56terry and kelly beverly both worked in
- 0:58the computer industry and have two
- 1:01children a son michael and a daughter
- 1:03bettina
- 1:05after a leisurely day of playing in the
- 1:07woods
- 1:08michael complained of pain in his
- 1:11stomach later he had uncontrolled
- 1:13diarrhea
- 1:14when his diarrhea contained blood
- 1:17his parents became alarmed
- 1:19he was just laying on the couch
- 1:21just still
- 1:23having bloody diapers every
- 1:27every 30 minutes and
- 1:29just very painful and
- 1:32it was just just changing him just heart
- 1:34looking at his little body it was
- 1:35turning itself inside out
- 1:38the beverly's took michael to a hospital
- 1:40emergency room where doctors discovered
- 1:43that his blood count had dropped to
- 1:45dangerous levels his kidneys were
- 1:47failing and life-threatening clots were
- 1:49forming in his blood
- 1:51acute bloody diarrhea and otherwise
- 1:53healthy child is an important medical
- 1:56problem
- 1:57and
- 1:58physicians here and elsewhere work that
- 2:00up very aggressively take that very
- 2:01seriously
- 2:03michael's stool sample was sent to the
- 2:05laboratory for testing
- 2:07doctors were alarmed when they found a
- 2:09potentially deadly pathogen known as e
- 2:12coli
- 2:13o157
- 2:15it's a bacteria usually found in the
- 2:18intestines of both humans and animals
- 2:21when an individual becomes infected
- 2:24there is no cure
- 2:26e coli o157 infects more than 20 000
- 2:30people each year killing 500 of them
- 2:35in 1993
- 2:37four people died after eating e coli
- 2:40tainted hamburgers from the
- 2:42jack-in-the-box fast food chain
- 2:45fully cooking hamburgers can kill the e
- 2:48coli bacteria but these burgers had not
- 2:51been fully cooked
- 2:53when i found out it was
- 2:55the strain of e coli and
- 2:57i asked him if it was the same strain
- 2:59that affected the kids in jack in a box
- 3:01he said yes michael has the same strain
- 3:03and i said oh my god
- 3:05when he call il-157 is in a widely
- 3:07disseminated vehicle
- 3:09out for out in the population for
- 3:11general consumption
- 3:12it's like a serial murderer is
- 3:14potentially loose in the population
- 3:18was one of the children infected with e
- 3:20coli 0-157 from an undercooked hamburger
- 3:24purchased at the jack-in-the-box
- 3:25restaurant
- 3:27she was in a coma for six weeks
- 3:30the e coli produces cytotoxins which
- 3:34kill other cells breaking through the
- 3:36endothelial layer of the intestines
- 3:39spilling poisons into the bloodstream
- 3:42that complication is called hemolytic
- 3:45uremic syndrome
- 3:47although brienne kiner eventually came
- 3:50out of her coma most of her major organs
- 3:52were damaged and she'll need a kidney
- 3:55transplant when she's older
- 3:57michael beverly also developed hemolytic
- 4:00uremic syndrome which can cause brain
- 4:02damage kidney damage sepsis and death
- 4:07doctors immediately placed michael on
- 4:09kidney dialysis to cleanse his body of
- 4:12toxins hemolytic uremic syndrome is
- 4:14life-threatening of all the kinds of
- 4:16diarrheas a child an otherwise healthy
- 4:19child is can get in north america
- 4:22almost none will
- 4:24cause a death or could cause a death
- 4:26except for this one that's why this one
- 4:28is so uh fearsome once it gets into a
- 4:31person the kidney specialist came in and
- 4:33he said it's very serious and he might
- 4:35not pull through the night it's up to
- 4:36his little body and then that's when i
- 4:38just broke down i came out and i started
- 4:40crying immediately i just i said this is
- 4:43it
- 4:44as michael beverly lay near death in a
- 4:46seattle hospital
- 4:48medical investigators were still trying
- 4:50to figure out how he came into contact
- 4:54with this deadly pathogen
- 4:56[Music]
- 4:59as two and a half year old michael
- 5:01beverly lay unconscious and near death
- 5:03in a seattle hospital 12 more children
- 5:06were admitted to local hospitals all
- 5:09diagnosed with the same deadly pathogen
- 5:12e coli o157
- 5:17since there is no cure for e coli o157
- 5:21investigators needed to find the source
- 5:23of the outbreak before even more people
- 5:26were infected
- 5:27my biggest concern
- 5:29was that the
- 5:32cases we were seeing every other day
- 5:35were just the very beginning of a much
- 5:37larger outbreak
- 5:40medical investigators suspected that
- 5:42food was the probable source
- 5:45but the e coli might have been in one
- 5:47food source or many
- 5:49dr mansour samadpur's job was to see if
- 5:53he could identify the exact strain of e
- 5:56coli that infected the children
- 5:59to find out he turned to something
- 6:01usually used for criminal investigations
- 6:04dna testing
- 6:06when we say e coli 157 it's a very large
- 6:09clan very large family or tribe in the e
- 6:12coli
- 6:13species
- 6:15when we do genetic fingerprinting we can
- 6:16go to the individuals in that family so
- 6:20instead of saying that some you know
- 6:23someone with the last name of smith
- 6:27killed someone else we can say that
- 6:30john smith with social security number
- 6:31of such and such living in such and such
- 6:33place committed to crime
- 6:36like human beings a pathogen like e coli
- 6:40has its own genetic fingerprint
- 6:42using what is called micro restriction
- 6:45fingerprinting the e coli samples were
- 6:48placed in a buffer of restriction
- 6:50enzymes which break the cells open
- 6:53then the dna strands are cut into
- 6:56smaller pieces making them easier to
- 6:59analyze
- 7:00the fragments are placed into a gel with
- 7:02a dye
- 7:04and after a process called
- 7:06electrophoresis the genetic profile
- 7:09appears similar to a barcode
- 7:12the results indicated that all of the e
- 7:14coli strains were the same
- 7:17in other words
- 7:18all of the sick individuals had been
- 7:20infected from the same source
- 7:24we had nine patients that had e coli
- 7:26o157s in them with the same genetic
- 7:29fingerprint definitely that that shows
- 7:31that you have a growing outbreak
- 7:33e coli o157 has a long incubation period
- 7:38five to seven days far longer than most
- 7:41food-borne illnesses
- 7:43dr russ alexander's job was to figure
- 7:46out what was causing the outbreak the
- 7:49standard method is to employ what's
- 7:51called a case control study
- 7:53investigators questioned all of the
- 7:55patients families to find out what the
- 7:58victims had consumed five to seven days
- 8:00before first developing symptoms
- 8:03they also compared those answers to what
- 8:06others in the same family consumed who
- 8:08were not infected
- 8:10our early thinking was that this was
- 8:11probably a meat sauce because that's
- 8:13what mostly is what it is so we
- 8:15are looking for everything they've eaten
- 8:17and what kind of restaurants they've
- 8:19been to what kind of fast food
- 8:20restaurants in particular but the
- 8:22initial interviews did not reveal any
- 8:25one food item that all had consumed
- 8:28there was something in common with these
- 8:31individuals that made these individuals
- 8:33ill
- 8:34on the other hand the preliminary
- 8:36interview did not produce any obvious
- 8:40sources of infection
- 8:42but when investigators looked more
- 8:43carefully over their initial results
- 8:46they found a clue
- 8:49one of the sick children
- 8:51was a vegetarian
- 8:53we had this one case that was a
- 8:55clear-cut case it was a
- 8:57vegetarian family and there was no
- 8:58chance of any meat in this particular
- 9:00instance so we
- 9:02quickly realized we were into something
- 9:04else
- 9:05this time another more detailed
- 9:07questionnaire was designed with meat
- 9:10excluded as the possible cause
- 9:13the new questionnaire centered on fruits
- 9:15vegetables dairy products and related
- 9:17food sources
- 9:19not until we had gotten enough cases uh
- 9:22coming in with this uh extended
- 9:25questionnaire that we began to see
- 9:27something else that was in terms of the
- 9:29source
- 9:30by the end of the week we were
- 9:32already pretty sure that
- 9:35there was that there was one thing that
- 9:36was standing out
- 9:38the second set of interviews revealed
- 9:40that the victims had all consumed
- 9:43apple juice
- 9:45but with hundreds of brands on the
- 9:47market
- 9:48investigators feared it would be
- 9:50difficult to find out
- 9:52which one
- 9:57when seattle health officials discovered
- 10:00that apple juice was consumed by the e
- 10:02coli patients they needed to find out
- 10:05which brand and there were hundreds of
- 10:07brands on the market
- 10:09but their next clue came from an
- 10:12unexpected source
- 10:14in denver colorado
- 10:16doctors were treating a desperately ill
- 10:1916 month old girl named anna gimistad
- 10:24anna also had an e coli 0157 infection
- 10:28and her parents told doctors that they
- 10:31had been in seattle just one week
- 10:33earlier
- 10:35the gimmick dads recalled feeding anna
- 10:37some apple juice a brand she preferred
- 10:40because of the bright rainbow colors on
- 10:42the label
- 10:43odwalla
- 10:47the beverly family also recall feeding
- 10:50their son michael the same brand from a
- 10:52neighborhood coffee shop
- 10:54this one particular sunday i went up and
- 10:56stood in line
- 10:58and you know to order our drinks and
- 11:00i saw them prepare it and i last went
- 11:03you use old walla for the kids and they
- 11:04go well yeah
- 11:06so i'm like oh
- 11:08further investigation revealed that the
- 11:10other victims also consumed odwala apple
- 11:14juice five to seven days before
- 11:16developing symptoms
- 11:19the odwalla company manufactures and
- 11:22distributes juice products in seven
- 11:24states and british columbia
- 11:27it's a brand known for its freshness
- 11:31most fruit juices are pasteurized which
- 11:33means they're heated to a temperature
- 11:35high enough to kill any bacteria
- 11:38but odwalla juice was not pasteurized
- 11:41the company believed that pasteurization
- 11:44hurt the taste of their juice
- 11:46the company's mission statement read
- 11:49if it's not fresh squeezed then it's not
- 11:52odwalla
- 11:54just nine days after the outbreak health
- 11:57officials asked the odwalla company to
- 11:59voluntarily remove their product from
- 12:01store shelves the company complied even
- 12:04though there was no conclusive proof
- 12:06that odwalla was the source of the
- 12:08outbreak
- 12:09as you know
- 12:10immediately upon hearing of the
- 12:12possibility of consumer health risks
- 12:14we recall our products contain apple
- 12:16juice our primary concerns for the
- 12:18health and welfare of our consumers
- 12:21the news that the source may have been
- 12:23apple juice
- 12:24was little relief to the gimmistad
- 12:26family in evans colorado
- 12:29sixteen-month-old anna was taking a turn
- 12:31for the worse
- 12:32like some of the other victims anna
- 12:35developed hemolytic uremic syndrome a
- 12:38complication of the e coli infection
- 12:40that produces toxins that shut down the
- 12:43kidneys
- 12:45less than two weeks after anagemist had
- 12:48consumed the odwalla apple juice
- 12:50she died
- 12:52for the beverly's news of anna
- 12:54gimistad's death was terrifying
- 12:57just knowing that there was a 16 month
- 12:59old that died i was very that just to me
- 13:02i knew he was i thought he was going to
- 13:04die to be frank i said this is it he's
- 13:06going to die
- 13:07and although investigators discovered
- 13:09that all of the affected individuals had
- 13:12consumed o'dwalla juice there was no
- 13:14proof that the juice was the source of
- 13:16the outbreak
- 13:17the proof if there was any
- 13:20would be in the juice itself
- 13:23thousands of bottles of odwalla juice
- 13:25were tested for e coli 0157 but the
- 13:29deadly pathogen could not be found
- 13:32medical investigators were starting to
- 13:34wonder whether they were ever going to
- 13:37find scientific proof that the apple
- 13:40juice was the source of the outbreak
- 13:46all of the e coli victims remember
- 13:48drinking odwalla apple juice shortly
- 13:51before getting sick
- 13:53but investigators couldn't find the e
- 13:55coli bacteria in any of the odwalla
- 13:58juice bottles they tested but on
- 14:00november 4 1996
- 14:03at the odwala distribution center
- 14:05investigators found one bottle of apple
- 14:08juice that tested positive for e coli
- 14:12o157
- 14:14the question now was whether the bottle
- 14:16contained the same strain that caused
- 14:18the death of anna gimistad and infected
- 14:21michael beverly and the other children
- 14:24to find out
- 14:26investigators turned once again to dna
- 14:29testing
- 14:30the dna profile on the left is the e
- 14:33coli strain from michael beverly
- 14:36on the right
- 14:37the dna profile of the e coli found in
- 14:40the bottle of odwalla apple juice
- 14:43the profiles were identical
- 14:46scientific proof that the odwalla juice
- 14:50was the source
- 14:52being able to identify the same genetic
- 14:55strain of e coli in a bottle of unopened
- 14:59odwalla juice given that an estimated 40
- 15:01thousand of these bottles
- 15:04it's not finding a needle in a haystack
- 15:05it's finding a needle out of about a
- 15:08hundred haystacks spread across most of
- 15:10western united states
- 15:13the label revealed the juice had been
- 15:15bottled on october 7 1996 three weeks
- 15:19before the outbreak
- 15:20company records identified the orchard
- 15:23whose apples were used to make the juice
- 15:25that day
- 15:27dr sarah cody an epidemic intelligence
- 15:30officer with the california department
- 15:32of health went to the orchard to
- 15:34investigate
- 15:35we were wandering in the orchard
- 15:38and what we noticed was along the edge
- 15:40of the orchard there were a number of uh
- 15:43deer prints in the sand
- 15:46and near the deer prince were deer
- 15:49droppings a potential source of e coli
- 15:52o157
- 15:55dr cody wondered whether some of the
- 15:57apples had fallen to the ground had come
- 16:00into contact with the deer droppings and
- 16:03then were picked up and sent to the
- 16:05juice processing plant
- 16:08dr cody collected samples which were
- 16:11sent to the lab for testing
- 16:14the e coli from the deer droppings was
- 16:17then sent for dna testing but it did not
- 16:20match the e coli strain that infected
- 16:22the 13 children
- 16:24it's possible that there could have been
- 16:27one deer or a number of deer that were
- 16:29shedding one strain or more than one
- 16:30strain so perhaps we just isolated the
- 16:33wrong strain or perhaps we got the wrong
- 16:36deer perhaps we've got the wrong orchard
- 16:38the odwalla company says that it's
- 16:40against their policy to purchase apples
- 16:43that were picked up from the ground even
- 16:46though oddballah claimed to have
- 16:47documents signed documents from their
- 16:49suppliers that they did not use ground
- 16:52apples or apples from the ground
- 16:55we found that it's virtually impossible
- 16:57to verify that or to enforce it
- 17:00especially when workers are paid by the
- 17:02bin
- 17:03in 1996 the u.s army considered serving
- 17:07odewala juice to military personnel but
- 17:09after an inspection of the odwalla
- 17:11processing plant military investigators
- 17:14stated that odwalla's plant sanitation
- 17:17program does not adequately assure
- 17:20product wholesomeness for military
- 17:22consumers
- 17:23the army rated the bacteria levels in
- 17:26the juice as too high
- 17:28a copy of the us army report found its
- 17:31way into the hands of the attorney
- 17:33representing the victims of the e coli
- 17:36outbreak
- 17:37william marler adwala was trying to sell
- 17:41adwala jews to the u.s army no not as a
- 17:44bacteriological weapon
- 17:47but the amount of bacteria that were
- 17:49that was in
- 17:50the finished product samples were in the
- 17:53millions
- 17:54where any
- 17:57possible
- 17:58responsible company would have had
- 18:01it in the the tens
- 18:04the united states attorney general's
- 18:06office took the unprecedented step of
- 18:08indicting odwalla in a criminal
- 18:11prosecution the charge delivering
- 18:14adulterated food products for interstate
- 18:17commerce
- 18:19and when we find a company that has
- 18:21knowingly placed contaminated food into
- 18:24the
- 18:25stream of commerce we're going to
- 18:26prosecute that company and we're going
- 18:28to put the individuals
- 18:30in jail
- 18:32and that's a very strong lesson and it's
- 18:33one that
- 18:34that the people that manufacture food
- 18:37in this country ought to take to heart
- 18:40in july of 1998 odwala pleaded guilty
- 18:45and was fined one and a half million
- 18:48dollars the largest penalty ever imposed
- 18:51in a food poisoning case
- 18:54odwala products are now pasteurized and
- 18:57carry warning labels
- 18:59but for the family of 16 month old and
- 19:02against dad
- 19:03that was too little too late
- 19:06there's no amount of monetary penalty or
- 19:08jail time that is ever going to bring
- 19:10back
- 19:11little anna
- 19:12or
- 19:13make the other dozen or so children that
- 19:15were severely injured whole again
- 19:18so from that standpoint i don't think
- 19:19that there
- 19:20was a possible settlement that would
- 19:22have been satisfactory
- 19:24e coli 0157 can cause serious diseases
- 19:28there's other food borne pathogens out
- 19:30there that can cause serious diseases
- 19:32we have the technology to prevent many
- 19:35of these
- 19:36problems this
- 19:39the consumption of unpasteurized apple
- 19:41juice
- 19:42in the 1996 outbreak was a dramatic
- 19:46example of how
- 19:48a safe effective technology was not
- 19:50employed
- 19:51to the detriment of children in the
- 19:53northwest
- 19:55the families of the victims filed suit
- 19:57against odwalla and settled with the
- 19:59company before going to trial
- 20:01the terms of that settlement were not
- 20:03disclosed
- 20:05michael beverly now appears to be in
- 20:08good health but he and the other
- 20:10children still face the possibility of
- 20:13future medical complications from their
- 20:16e coli 0157
- 20:18infection what was it that almost killed
- 20:21michael
- 20:24it was e coli
- 20:25it was the effects of e coli toxin in
- 20:28his body eating up his his system
- 20:31that's what almost killed him
- 20:34unfortunately i see it a little
- 20:35different i see it i see it as what
- 20:38almost killed him was
- 20:40a company's negligence and
- 20:42irresponsibility
- 20:44and this shouldn't have happened
- 20:46the smoking gun in this case was the
- 20:48science it was what the forensics gave
- 20:50us odwalla had no wiggle room
- 20:53it was conclusive it was a matter of
- 20:54scientific principle that ode wallace
- 20:57product had e coli o157 h7 in it and
- 21:01that that was the same exact
- 21:03bacteria which was in the victims
- 21:07[Music]
- 21:22[Music]
- 21:30[Applause]
- 21:34[Music]
- 21:49you
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Forensic Files - Season 4, Episode 10 - Core Evidence - Full Episode by FilmRise True Crime, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 2,823 words across 522 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.