YouTube2Text

Fondo pensione e riscatto laurea: quando battono gli ETF — Transcript

by The Bull · 4,292 words · 715 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00€ 5,300.
  2. 0:03That is the amount we can contribute to
  3. 0:05a pension fund starting this year and
  4. 0:06deduct from the income on which we pay
  5. 0:08taxes.
  6. 0:09With a gross salary of € 40,000, this
  7. 0:11means that the following summer the
  8. 0:13State returns over € 1,700 to us, or
  9. 0:16directly in our paycheck.
  10. 0:18With a salary of € 60,000, instead, we
  11. 0:19are talking about nearly € 2,300.
  12. 0:22If we have set aside a few thousand
  13. 0:23euros by December, what should we do?
  14. 0:26Do we put them in the pension fund? Do
  15. 0:28we use them to buy back university years
  16. 0:30, or do we invest them in our nice ETF
  17. 0:32portfolio?
  18. 0:34I'll spoil the answer for you right now
  19. 0:35.
  20. 0:36On the first € 5,300, if the fund has
  21. 0:38low costs, the pension fund almost
  22. 0:39always wins, at least from an arithmetic
  23. 0:41standpoint.
  24. 0:43Above that amount, however, ETFs almost
  25. 0:45always win.
  26. 0:46University buy-backs, on the other hand
  27. 0:48, can buy years of freedom or cost a lot
  28. 0:50without offering much of an advance.
  29. 0:52The common thread tying these two things
  30. 0:54together, however, is the same: the
  31. 0:56State gives us a tax break, and in
  32. 0:58exchange, asks us to lock up our money
  33. 1:00for, say, 30 years.
  34. 1:02The question is whether the discount is
  35. 1:03worth the cage.
  36. 1:05In this episode, therefore, we will run
  37. 1:06all the numbers.
  38. 1:08First, the three numbers that determine
  39. 1:10everything, and we'll see where to find
  40. 1:11them on our pay stub and in the pension
  41. 1:13fund regulations.
  42. 1:15Then we'll pit the pension fund against
  43. 1:17ETFs and calculate when an open fund is
  44. 1:19better than a category one, especially
  45. 1:21for employees.
  46. 1:24Finally, the university buy-back,
  47. 1:26including cases where paying tens of
  48. 1:27thousands of euros makes us retire 3
  49. 1:29years later.
  50. 1:31Do you want to know where it's best to
  51. 1:33put your next euro before the end of the
  52. 1:35year?
  53. 1:36Well, watch the video and I'll explain
  54. 1:37it to you.
  55. 1:38In this podcast, we talk about finance,
  56. 1:40investments, and markets to help anyone
  57. 1:42invest better and build the life they
  58. 1:44want.
  59. 1:45If you haven't already, follow the
  60. 1:47channel on YouTube, Spotify, and Apple
  61. 1:49Podcasts. It costs you nothing, and for
  62. 1:51me, it allows me to keep the whole thing
  63. 1:53running.
  64. 1:54There are about 6 weeks left until
  65. 1:56December 31st, and in these 6 weeks,
  66. 1:58three windows close.
  67. 2:00First, pension fund contributions are
  68. 2:02deductible in the year in which we make
  69. 2:04them. 2026 is the first year with the
  70. 2:06deductible limit raised from € 5,164 to
  71. 2:09€ 5,300. This year's opportunity, after
  72. 2:12December 31st, is lost.
  73. 2:15Second, the subsidized university
  74. 2:17buy-back costs 6,206 euros and 64 cents
  75. 2:19, to be precise, for each year on 2026
  76. 2:22applications.
  77. 2:24From 2027, it is estimated that it will
  78. 2:26rise by about 180 euros per year.
  79. 2:29Third window: starting at the end of
  80. 2:30October, the employer's contribution
  81. 2:32follows us even if we leave the industry
  82. 2:33pension fund for an open-ended fund.
  83. 2:36Until yesterday, for an employee, the
  84. 2:38question of industry fund versus
  85. 2:40open-ended fund practically didn't exist
  86. 2:41; now, it does.
  87. 2:45If you want to know where to put your
  88. 2:46TFR (severance pay), I suggest you watch
  89. 2:48episode 335 that appears somewhere here
  90. 2:50.
  91. 2:51Today, instead, we are talking about all
  92. 2:53the extra savings.
  93. 2:54A brief summary of the rules of the game
  94. 2:56.
  95. 2:56To choose between a pension fund and
  96. 2:58ETFs, you need three numbers.
  97. 3:00The first is the tax rate we enter with
  98. 3:02.
  99. 3:02What we contribute to the pension fund,
  100. 3:05up to 5,300 euros per year, is deducted
  101. 3:07from the income we pay income tax on, so
  102. 3:09the discount is worth as much as our
  103. 3:11marginal tax rate, the one we pay on the
  104. 3:14last euro earned.
  105. 3:1623%up to 28,000 euros, 33%up to 55,000
  106. 3:19euros, 43%above that.
  107. 3:22And keep in mind that the 5,300 euros
  108. 3:24also includes the employer's
  109. 3:25contribution, while the TFR does not,
  110. 3:27obviously.
  111. 3:28The second number, however, is the tax
  112. 3:30rate we exit with.
  113. 3:32When we cash out, on the deducted
  114. 3:34contributions we pay 15%, which drops by
  115. 3:360.3%for each year of enrollment in the
  116. 3:38pension fund beyond the 15th, down to a
  117. 3:40minimum of 9%.
  118. 3:42Meanwhile, the fund pays 20%on returns
  119. 3:45each year and 12.5%on the portion in
  120. 3:47government bonds.
  121. 3:49Yes, unfortunately, this is the bad
  122. 3:51thing about pension funds that eats away
  123. 3:53a bit of compound return, even if the
  124. 3:54tax benefits more than compensate for
  125. 3:56this downside.
  126. 3:58The third number is how much the fund
  127. 3:59costs.
  128. 4:00COVIP measures it with an indicator
  129. 4:02called ISC, which is the synthetic cost
  130. 4:04indicator.
  131. 4:05And on average over 10 years, it is 0.47
  132. 4:08%for industry funds, which are the
  133. 4:10categorical ones, 1.36%for open-ended
  134. 4:13funds, and 2.17%for PIPs, which are
  135. 4:15individual insurance plans.
  136. 4:17On the other side of the ring, instead,
  137. 4:19there are ETFs.
  138. 4:20No discount when we buy, profits taxed
  139. 4:23at 26%, a 0.2%annual stamp duty, and a
  140. 4:26management cost of roughly between 0.1%
  141. 4:29and 0.2%.
  142. 4:31In return, they are ours, we sell them
  143. 4:33when we want, and taxes are only paid
  144. 4:35when selling.
  145. 4:38Now let's put these numbers against each
  146. 4:40other.
  147. 4:41Before the calculations, however, a
  148. 4:42fundamental premise: what we say applies
  149. 4:44to money intended for retirement.
  150. 4:46The fund's tax benefits come at a
  151. 4:48precise price, which is illiquidity.
  152. 4:51Before retirement, money only comes back
  153. 4:54for serious medical expenses, or after 8
  154. 4:57years, up to 75%for a first home and 30
  155. 4:59%for any reason, taxed at 23%.
  156. 5:03Now, for a family that manages to invest
  157. 5:05perhaps € 1,000 a month, € 12,000 a year
  158. 5:08, the problem isn't particularly
  159. 5:10significant, because it likely makes
  160. 5:12sense to put up to € 5,300 into a
  161. 5:14pension fund and then put the remaining
  162. 5:16€ 6,700 into an ETF portfolio.
  163. 5:20But if, on the other hand, I'm someone
  164. 5:21who manages to put away, say, € 300 a
  165. 5:23month, well: putting all of that into a
  166. 5:25pension fund means not having that
  167. 5:27capital available for perhaps 20 or 30
  168. 5:28years.
  169. 5:30And before retirement, you have to
  170. 5:31account for the fact that houses,
  171. 5:33children, and maybe a job change come
  172. 5:34along; there are many variables.
  173. 5:36So, from now on, when we say that the
  174. 5:38fund wins, we mean this: it wins for
  175. 5:40money that can wait until retirement,
  176. 5:42and not in an absolute sense.
  177. 5:45That said, if our tax rate is, let's say
  178. 5:47, 33%—the intermediate one—if we put €
  179. 5:491,000 into the fund, the following
  180. 5:51summer we get back € 330, or it's
  181. 5:53deducted directly from our paycheck.
  182. 5:55Those € 1,000, therefore, only cost us €
  183. 5:58670.
  184. 5:59The income tax refund isn't an extra
  185. 6:01gift; it's the fund's lower price.
  186. 6:03The right comparison, therefore, is €
  187. 6:061,000 in a pension fund versus € 670
  188. 6:08invested in ETFs.
  189. 6:10And inside both, we put the same
  190. 6:12portfolio; otherwise, we're comparing
  191. 6:14apples to oranges.
  192. 6:16Let's use the classic 60%stocks and 40%
  193. 6:18bonds, which is more or less what you
  194. 6:19find in the most dynamic section of an
  195. 6:21industry pension fund.
  196. 6:23Let's assume stocks return 7%a year and
  197. 6:26bonds 3.5%. With these premises, the
  198. 6:28negotiated pension fund almost always
  199. 6:31wins.
  200. 6:32With a 23%tax rate, it wins by 12-18%;
  201. 6:35at 33%, by about 1/3; and at 43%, by
  202. 6:38more than half.
  203. 6:39And the number to take home is this: €
  204. 6:425,300 a year for 30 years with a 33%tax
  205. 6:45rate. In the negotiated fund, we reach
  206. 6:48about € 215,000 in today's money.
  207. 6:51The same money in ETFs, net of the
  208. 6:54refund, would only reach about € 158,000
  209. 6:56.
  210. 6:57There is a € 57,000 difference with the
  211. 7:00same portfolio and the same market.
  212. 7:03Now, where does this extra money from
  213. 7:04the pension fund come from?
  214. 7:07The entry discount, that 33%, which is
  215. 7:09much larger than the exit tax, which
  216. 7:11after 30 years of enrollment is about
  217. 7:1310.5%.
  218. 7:14That’s more than 20 percentage points
  219. 7:16gifted on day one.
  220. 7:18And the rest of the comparison is almost
  221. 7:20even, because the negotiated fund costs
  222. 7:22just a little more than an ETF, and the
  223. 7:2320%paid each year is worth just a little
  224. 7:25more than the 26%paid at the end.
  225. 7:28From this comes the rule we need.
  226. 7:30The pension fund wins if the entry
  227. 7:32discount is worth more than the extra
  228. 7:33cost we pay each year, accumulated over
  229. 7:35all those years.
  230. 7:37By doing the math, we can estimate the
  231. 7:39maximum cost a pension fund can have to
  232. 7:41break even with an ETF investment over
  233. 7:4335 years.
  234. 7:45It is 0.87%with a 23%income tax bracket
  235. 7:49, 1.35%with a 33%bracket, and 1.91%with
  236. 7:52a 43%bracket.
  237. 7:54Below these thresholds, the fund wins;
  238. 7:56above them, an ETF portfolio wins.
  239. 7:59Theoretically, a negotiated fund, which
  240. 8:01costs an average of 0.47%per year,
  241. 8:03always wins regardless of the tax
  242. 8:04bracket.
  243. 8:06In short, a pension fund is not an
  244. 8:08investment; it is a tax break with an
  245. 8:10investment inside.
  246. 8:12And if the costs eat up the tax break,
  247. 8:14we are left with nothing but the cage,
  248. 8:15which is why keeping costs under control
  249. 8:16is essential.
  250. 8:18But here we come to the question that
  251. 8:20many of us will truly be asking
  252. 8:21ourselves from the end of October.
  253. 8:23In our simulations, we spoke in general
  254. 8:25terms and did not consider the
  255. 8:27accelerator available only to employees
  256. 8:29: the employer contribution.
  257. 8:32With the Commerce collective agreement,
  258. 8:34for example, if I contribute at least
  259. 8:360.55%of my gross salary, the employer
  260. 8:39adds 1.55%.
  261. 8:40If I have a gross salary of € 40,000, my
  262. 8:42employer puts € 620 of their own money
  263. 8:45into my pension fund, which is also
  264. 8:47deductible up to the total € 5,300 limit
  265. 8:49.
  266. 8:51Until yesterday, however, an employee
  267. 8:53leaving the industry fund lost this
  268. 8:54employer contribution, so there was no
  269. 8:56real choice.
  270. 8:58Now, however, after two years, I can
  271. 9:00switch to an open-ended fund and that
  272. 9:01contribution follows me.
  273. 9:03The open-ended fund therefore becomes a
  274. 9:05real alternative for employees as well.
  275. 9:08Open-ended funds cost more, averaging
  276. 9:101.36%compared to 0.47%, but in theory,
  277. 9:13they have a higher expected return in
  278. 9:15sectors with greater equity exposure.
  279. 9:19In equity lines over the last 10 years,
  280. 9:21they have yielded 5.1%per year against
  281. 9:234.8%for negotiated funds, already net of
  282. 9:25costs.
  283. 9:27They cost more and in theory return more
  284. 9:29, but this is only due to asset
  285. 9:30allocation, not because they are better
  286. 9:32.
  287. 9:33The equity line of an open-ended fund
  288. 9:35can reach up to 93%in stocks, while the
  289. 9:38growth compartment of a large negotiated
  290. 9:41fund sits between 45%and 65%.
  291. 9:44Now let's compare them, keeping the
  292. 9:46money invested equal.
  293. 9:48Let's take an open-ended fund with 93%
  294. 9:50stocks and 1.36%in costs versus a
  295. 9:52negotiated fund with 60%stocks and 0.47
  296. 9:55%in costs.
  297. 9:57If stocks beat bonds by 3.5 points a
  298. 10:00year, after 35 years the open-ended fund
  299. 10:02has just 3%more; that is, effectively 33
  300. 10:05more points of equity weight and the
  301. 10:07risk that comes with it, but the costs
  302. 10:09eat almost all of it up.
  303. 10:12We can also look at the calculation from
  304. 10:13the other side, which might be clearer.
  305. 10:15An average open-ended fund only beats
  306. 10:17the occupational fund if we believe
  307. 10:19stocks will outperform bonds by over 3.2
  308. 10:21points per year for 30 years straight.
  309. 10:24An affordable open-ended fund, on the
  310. 10:26other hand, costing maybe 0.90 instead
  311. 10:28of 1.7, becomes more cost-effective.
  312. 10:32If, however, the advantage of stocks
  313. 10:33over bonds drops to two points—an
  314. 10:35entirely possible future scenario—the
  315. 10:37average open-ended fund loses 10%
  316. 10:38compared to the occupational one.
  317. 10:42What about against ETFs instead?
  318. 10:44With the same portfolio at 93%stocks and
  319. 10:46a 33%tax rate, the average open-ended
  320. 10:49fund wins up to 30 years and loses at 35
  321. 10:51.
  322. 10:52With a 23%tax rate, it loses at 30 years
  323. 10:54already.
  324. 10:56If, however, besides the fund we also
  325. 10:58have an ETF portfolio, there is a way to
  326. 11:00get the best of both, which is to view
  327. 11:01them as a single portfolio.
  328. 11:04So, for one part, we keep the
  329. 11:06occupational fund with the tax break and
  330. 11:08low cost, and we buy the extra stocks we
  331. 11:10want outside through ETFs.
  332. 11:13So the total exposure to stocks is the
  333. 11:16same, but paying 1.36%instead of 0.47%
  334. 11:19on the same portfolio eats up about 20%
  335. 11:22of the assets over 30 years.
  336. 11:26The rule that emerges is very simple: an
  337. 11:29open-ended fund makes sense if we don't
  338. 11:31have access to an occupational fund, or
  339. 11:33if we want significant equity exposure
  340. 11:35and invest in a low-cost pension fund—
  341. 11:37and you can still find some with costs
  342. 11:39under 1%.
  343. 11:42So far, it seems like the pension fund
  344. 11:44always wins.
  345. 11:46But that is not the case because there
  346. 11:47are four scenarios where it loses. Let's
  347. 11:49see them quickly.
  348. 11:50The first is PIPs, individual plans sold
  349. 11:52by insurance companies.
  350. 11:54With an average cost of 2.17%and a 23%
  351. 11:57tax rate, they lose against an ETF
  352. 12:00portfolio over 20 years by 12%on average
  353. 12:02.
  354. 12:03To beat them at 30 years, you need a 43
  355. 12:05%tax rate. In practice, a PIP is only
  356. 12:08worth it for a few people, and usually
  357. 12:10not for those being offered one. The
  358. 12:12second is, obviously, savings over €
  359. 12:145,300, where the tax discount disappears
  360. 12:16; without the discount, the pension fund
  361. 12:19loses its unique advantage, and you are
  362. 12:21left with the 20%paid every year versus
  363. 12:23the 26%paid only when you sell, plus the
  364. 12:26money being locked up.
  365. 12:28The third are the flat-tax regime
  366. 12:29earners, generally anyone with no income
  367. 12:31tax to deduct.
  368. 12:32Income from the flat-tax regime is not
  369. 12:33subject to standard income tax, so
  370. 12:35contributions to the fund cannot be
  371. 12:36deducted, unless you have other income.
  372. 12:39The fourth is for those who choose a
  373. 12:40conservative sub-fund.
  374. 12:42Over the last 10 years, guaranteed bond
  375. 12:44sub-funds have returned less than 1%per
  376. 12:46year against the 2.5%from TFR left with
  377. 12:48the company.
  378. 12:50Even with the tax discount, we are
  379. 12:51paying for a cage to hold onto money
  380. 12:53that isn't working for us.
  381. 12:55So, practically speaking, who should do
  382. 12:58what?
  383. 13:00If we are employees, severance pay and
  384. 13:02the minimum contribution to the industry
  385. 13:04fund grant the right to a free,
  386. 13:06tax-deductible employer match, which is
  387. 13:08a no-brainer.
  388. 13:11If we are neither employees nor under
  389. 13:13the flat-tax regime, a low-cost pension
  390. 13:15fund likely makes just as much sense,
  391. 13:17especially for those in the 43%tax
  392. 13:19bracket who can maximize the tax
  393. 13:20deduction.
  394. 13:23For those under the flat-tax regime,
  395. 13:24however, there is no deduction, so the
  396. 13:25magic of a pension fund fades a bit.
  397. 13:28Here, what matters is only the seniority
  398. 13:29for early withdrawals and for the days
  399. 13:30when you exit the flat-tax regime.
  400. 13:33Opening a pension fund can be useful,
  401. 13:34but contributing money consistently
  402. 13:36while under the flat-tax regime maybe
  403. 13:38not so much.
  404. 13:40That said, the way I see it, the logical
  405. 13:42order to follow should be as follows.
  406. 13:46First, a cash cushion for emergencies,
  407. 13:48like the one we talked about in episode
  408. 13:50342, for example.
  409. 13:52Second, if we are employees, severance
  410. 13:53pay and the minimum contribution to the
  411. 13:55industry fund. The employer's
  412. 13:57contribution is the only free lunch that
  413. 13:59exists in this entire discussion.
  414. 14:01Third, money for goals that come before
  415. 14:03retirement, such as for children, a gap
  416. 14:05year, a career change, whatever it may
  417. 14:07be; these must go into an ETF portfolio
  418. 14:09because they must remain ours and
  419. 14:11accessible.
  420. 14:13Fourth, whatever is left goes into the
  421. 14:15pension fund up to the € 5,300 threshold
  422. 14:18.
  423. 14:19Fifth, everything else back into ETFs.
  424. 14:23In general, for most people, opening a
  425. 14:25good, low-cost pension fund almost
  426. 14:27always makes sense, and taking advantage
  427. 14:29of the tax benefits makes a lot of sense
  428. 14:31.
  429. 14:33How much to contribute, however, is more
  430. 14:35a matter of personal preference and
  431. 14:37goals.
  432. 14:38Before we move on to the other topic,
  433. 14:39which is Laura's pension redemption,
  434. 14:41there is one thing that needs to be
  435. 14:43addressed, just in case, you know, we
  436. 14:45kick the bucket early and never actually
  437. 14:47make it to retirement.
  438. 14:49I mean, if I drop dead right here in
  439. 14:50front of the cameras, I couldn't care
  440. 14:51less about retirement, but I have a
  441. 14:53family to provide for, right?
  442. 14:56And so, in the absence of seven magic
  443. 14:58dragon balls to bring me back to life,
  444. 15:00we have to think about those left behind
  445. 15:02, which is why my friends at Square Life
  446. 15:04, sponsors of this episode, created
  447. 15:06Turtle Neck, a completely digital,
  448. 15:07affordable life insurance policy that
  449. 15:09I've arranged to let you know if it's
  450. 15:11effective, should I die prematurely.
  451. 15:15With Turtle Neck, it only takes a few
  452. 15:17minutes to fill out the online
  453. 15:18questionnaire and activate insurance
  454. 15:20coverage for up to € 400,000.
  455. 15:23Each year, the premium is recalculated
  456. 15:24and before the policy renews, the
  457. 15:26client's confirmation is requested, but
  458. 15:28above all, each year Turtle Neck returns
  459. 15:30the money it didn't have to use for
  460. 15:32payouts if fewer people died than the
  461. 15:33actuarial estimates suggested, and with
  462. 15:35the money saved, you can put it into a
  463. 15:37pension fund or a degree buyout if you
  464. 15:39like, or use it for whatever you want.
  465. 15:43In the description, you'll find a link
  466. 15:45to learn about Turtle Neck and evaluate
  467. 15:47if it's a solution that might work for
  468. 15:48you, and naturally, ensure you've
  469. 15:50understood how it works before signing
  470. 15:51up and contact Turtle Neck directly to
  471. 15:53get all the information you need before
  472. 15:55deciding.
  473. 15:57Let's look at the degree buyout, which
  474. 15:59is a bit of an odd thing to manage.
  475. 16:02Redeeming your degree means paying
  476. 16:03contributions today for the years we
  477. 16:05spent hitting the books, so that the
  478. 16:06INPS counts them as working years.
  479. 16:09There are two methods. The ordinary
  480. 16:11buyout costs 33%of your income for each
  481. 16:13year, so with a € 40,000 gross salary,
  482. 16:15that’s € 13,200 per year.
  483. 16:18The subsidized buyout, which applies to
  484. 16:20study years from '96 onwards, costs a
  485. 16:22fixed amount: € 6,206.64 for each year
  486. 16:24in 2026, though it will increase in
  487. 16:26coming years.
  488. 16:28For 5 years of university, you therefore
  489. 16:30need € 31,000.
  490. 16:32In both cases, the expense is
  491. 16:33tax-deductible and can be paid in 120
  492. 16:35interest-free monthly installments.
  493. 16:38With that money, however, we are buying
  494. 16:40two different things, and it is worth
  495. 16:41separating them.
  496. 16:43The first is the pension check.
  497. 16:46Every euro we pay enters our
  498. 16:47contribution pool, is revalued based on
  499. 16:49GDP, and ultimately becomes an
  500. 16:50inflation-adjusted pension for life.
  501. 16:54We calculated the return on this
  502. 16:56investment, including deductions and
  503. 16:58taxes on the pension, which is between
  504. 17:000.5%and 2.3%per year above inflation.
  505. 17:04A global equity ETF, under the same
  506. 17:06assumptions and after taxes, has a net
  507. 17:08expected real return of around 3%.
  508. 17:12As an investment, the buyout isn't
  509. 17:14exactly a scam; it's simply like a
  510. 17:15lifelong indexed bond with a return that
  511. 17:18is likely lower than that of an equity
  512. 17:20ETF.
  513. 17:21Retirement age, on the other hand, is
  514. 17:23the second thing we are buying, which is
  515. 17:25perhaps what really matters.
  516. 17:28According to Smile Economy simulations
  517. 17:30for Corriere della Sera updated to 2026
  518. 17:32, consider a thirty-year-old who started
  519. 17:34working at 24 with a continuous career
  520. 17:36and no gaps.
  521. 17:38By redeeming 5 years, they retire 5
  522. 17:41years and 4 months earlier.
  523. 17:43A woman in the same situation retires 5
  524. 17:45years and 6 months earlier.
  525. 17:47Well, in short, let's make a proper
  526. 17:48comparison using the same person, the
  527. 17:50same amount, and the same schedule.
  528. 17:53Now let's imagine someone with a
  529. 17:55continuous career starting at 24,
  530. 17:57beginning with a € 28,000 salary,
  531. 17:59reaching € 40,000 in 10 years, deducting
  532. 18:0233%, with 5 years of subsidized
  533. 18:04redemption costing about € 20,800 net
  534. 18:06over 10 years of installments.
  535. 18:10If instead we put those same
  536. 18:12installments into a stock ETF yielding 3
  537. 18:14%annually above inflation, net of costs
  538. 18:16and taxes as assumed, at 61 years and 8
  539. 18:19months, you end up with about € 46,600
  540. 18:21in today’s value, adjusted for inflation
  541. 18:23.
  542. 18:26But we must consider how the pension
  543. 18:28changes, because retiring earlier means
  544. 18:30a lower pension forever, as the
  545. 18:31coefficient that converts your nest egg
  546. 18:33into a pension is lower the younger you
  547. 18:35retire.
  548. 18:37With the redemption, we retire at 61
  549. 18:40years and 8 months with about € 1,620
  550. 18:42net per month.
  551. 18:43Without the redemption, everything
  552. 18:45depends on a threshold: early
  553. 18:47contributory retirement at 64.
  554. 18:50If that door is closed because the
  555. 18:52pension doesn't reach the threshold or
  556. 18:54because the rules change, without the
  557. 18:56redemption we retire at 67 with about €
  558. 18:581,830, which is 13%more.
  559. 19:01But the redemption covered 5 years and 4
  560. 19:03months of pension, while the ETF only
  561. 19:06covers a little over two years.
  562. 19:08Here, the redemption wins by about €
  563. 19:1124,000 in today's terms and would stay
  564. 19:13ahead even if the ETF yielded more, like
  565. 19:154%net real return.
  566. 19:18If that door is open—and with this
  567. 19:20salary under current rules it is, since
  568. 19:22the pension exceeds the threshold at 64
  569. 19:24—we retire at 64 anyway without the
  570. 19:26redemption.
  571. 19:29The redemption only buys us 2 years and
  572. 19:304 months, which the ETF covers almost
  573. 19:32entirely, and the pension is practically
  574. 19:34the same, so the result is essentially a
  575. 19:36tie, varying by a few thousand euros
  576. 19:38based on small variables.
  577. 19:41So ultimately, the redemption is
  578. 19:43insurance for one specific door: it’s
  579. 19:45very valuable if we couldn't otherwise
  580. 19:47retire at 64, but worth almost nothing
  581. 19:48if that door remains open.
  582. 19:51And since that door depends on rules 30
  583. 19:53years from now, and the threshold is
  584. 19:55already rising as of 2030, no one knows
  585. 19:58which scenario they will face.
  586. 20:00Moreover, you have to actually be able
  587. 20:02to use those redeemed years; with the
  588. 20:04same 5 years redeemed, someone who
  589. 20:06started working at 27 gains at most 2
  590. 20:08and a half years, and someone who
  591. 20:10started at 30 gains none.
  592. 20:12An ETF, however, always works regardless
  593. 20:14of when you start investing, and it
  594. 20:16remains yours—you can sell it or use it
  595. 20:18for your children, unlike the redemption
  596. 20:20.
  597. 20:21There are also cases where the
  598. 20:22redemption actually causes harm.
  599. 20:24Just a few examples.
  600. 20:26Those who started working after 1996 but
  601. 20:29redeem university years prior to '96
  602. 20:31actually risk retiring even later.
  603. 20:35This is because INPS would see
  604. 20:36contributions before that date, losing
  605. 20:38the "purely contributory" status and the
  606. 20:41chance for early retirement at 64.
  607. 20:44There are simulations, like those by
  608. 20:46Corriere, showing that even if you
  609. 20:47redeem 4 years, you end up retiring 3
  610. 20:49years later.
  611. 20:51Another case is if your career is
  612. 20:53interrupted after the redemption, the
  613. 20:55contribution gap can eat up the head
  614. 20:56start we bought.
  615. 20:59Generally, for those who started working
  616. 21:02after 1996 around age 24, right after 5
  617. 21:04years of university, the idea of a 5-
  618. 21:07year reduction is fairly well-founded.
  619. 21:11That is the theory.
  620. 21:14But then there is the reality.
  621. 21:16And the reality is the risk that you
  622. 21:18don't fit any simulation because these
  623. 21:20are legal rules that can easily change
  624. 21:22over the next 20, 30, or 40 years.
  625. 21:25Requirements for early retirement will
  626. 21:28rise by 1 month in 2027 and another 2 in
  627. 21:302028; according to Corriere's
  628. 21:32projections, 44 years and 10 months of
  629. 21:34contributions will be needed by 2041.
  630. 21:38The redeemed years remain ours, but the
  631. 21:40exit doors keep moving and sometimes
  632. 21:41disappear.
  633. 21:44For example, with the 2025 budget law,
  634. 21:46pension funds could help reach the
  635. 21:48threshold for exiting at 64, but the
  636. 21:512026 law abolished it before it even
  637. 21:53started.
  638. 21:55Redemption can make arithmetic sense in
  639. 21:57various situations, but it assumes a
  640. 21:59gamble on what the rules will be in 20,
  641. 22:0130, or 40 years.
  642. 22:03An ETF plan, on the other hand, does not
  643. 22:05rely on these rules.
  644. 22:07Let's break it down into three questions
  645. 22:08.
  646. 22:09To answer them, you need your payslip,
  647. 22:11the pension fund regulations, and your
  648. 22:12INPS account statement—nothing else.
  649. 22:15First question: what is our marginal tax
  650. 22:17rate and how much does our fund cost?
  651. 22:20If we pay income tax and have an
  652. 22:21industry fund, for money that can wait
  653. 22:23until retirement, the fund wins up to
  654. 22:25the 5,300 euro annual cap.
  655. 22:27If we have an open fund, check two
  656. 22:29numbers: the synthetic cost indicator
  657. 22:31must be under 1%and the equity
  658. 22:33percentage must be high, otherwise it's
  659. 22:36not worth it.
  660. 22:37If we have an insurance-based plan (PIP
  661. 22:39), check the cost before contributing
  662. 22:40another euro; it’s likely not the most
  663. 22:42efficient solution.
  664. 22:44Second question: have we already hit the
  665. 22:465,300 euro limit, including employer
  666. 22:48contributions?
  667. 22:50If so, everything else should probably
  668. 22:52go into ETFs.
  669. 22:54Third question: does the redemption let
  670. 22:56us exit earlier, and by how much?
  671. 22:58If it buys us many years and we actually
  672. 23:00use those years to retire early, it’s on
  673. 23:03par with ETFs.
  674. 23:04It determines how stocks will perform,
  675. 23:06but we can't know that in advance.
  676. 23:07If it doesn't buy us any, that money
  677. 23:09will certainly perform better in an ETF
  678. 23:11.
  679. 23:13And watch out for those who studied
  680. 23:14before '96 and started working later;
  681. 23:16get a simulation done before signing
  682. 23:18anything, or you risk getting burned.
  683. 23:21The gist, if you will, is in one line.
  684. 23:25The State gives us a discount even if we
  685. 23:27lock up the money, and the discount is
  686. 23:28worth it when it's substantial, low cost
  687. 23:30, and buys something we can't get
  688. 23:32elsewhere, which is either tax euros or
  689. 23:34years of work.
  690. 23:36In all other cases, the freedom of an
  691. 23:38ETF plan is likely worth more.
  692. 23:41Well, my friends, that's the end of
  693. 23:42today's episode.
  694. 23:44I hope it was useful for making one of
  695. 23:46the most important decisions regarding
  696. 23:48our long-term future, which is what to
  697. 23:50do to best enhance our pension, because
  698. 23:52if we rely solely on the State's, we're
  699. 23:54out of luck.
  700. 23:57While waiting to reach retirement,
  701. 23:59however, I invite you as always to
  702. 24:00follow and turn on notifications on
  703. 24:02YouTube, Spotify, and Apple Podcasts to
  704. 24:04support us and allow us to continue
  705. 24:05producing new content that explains how
  706. 24:07the State gives you a discount only if
  707. 24:09you promise not to touch the money until
  708. 24:1167, and then we'll see.
  709. 24:14For this episode, that's really all, and
  710. 24:17we'll see you in a few days for a new
  711. 24:19appointment together, always right here
  712. 24:21, naturally with The Bull, your personal
  713. 24:24finance podcast.
  714. 24:26>> A production of Cora S, Social Media
  715. 24:28Company.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of Fondo pensione e riscatto laurea: quando battono gli ETF by The Bull , generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 4,292 words across 715 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.