YouTube2Text

Fon Skandalı: Turpun Büyüğü Heybede! Paralara Ne Olacak? Halka Arzlar İncelenmeli | Atilla Yeşilada — Transcript

by Mesele Ekonomi · 5,255 words · 832 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:02Amen.
  2. 0:09Hello, Mr. Atiye.
  3. 0:12Hello, dear Semiş. Hello, our dear
  4. 0:15viewers. Welcome to our humble home.
  5. 0:18The home hasn't changed. It's the same
  6. 0:19home, but we've moved to a different
  7. 0:21part of the house.
  8. 0:22The setting has changed. Our elders say
  9. 0:24, "there is benefit in every cloud."
  10. 0:26Yes, Mr. Atilla, our agenda today is
  11. 0:28the one everyone expected. The
  12. 0:30investment fund crisis, or what we can
  13. 0:32call a fund crisis.
  14. 0:33We can call it a scandal.
  15. 0:34How would you define a scandal?
  16. 0:36A scandal.
  17. 0:37A scandal.
  18. 0:37Walking right into a trap. I have been
  19. 0:39involved with the stock market in one
  20. 0:41way or another for 35 years. I have
  21. 0:43seen many crises or upheavals of this
  22. 0:45nature. For example, the takeover of
  23. 0:48banks during the 2001 crisis and the
  24. 0:50failure to pay small investors 'shares.
  25. 0:53But this was known. Most of those who
  26. 0:56invested in those funds—I'm not
  27. 0:58saying all of them—those committing
  28. 0:59this crime, the CMB, Mehmet Şimşek,
  29. 1:01they all knew what was happening.
  30. 1:04Therefore, this is a scandal, and
  31. 1:05unfortunately, as this topic hits the
  32. 1:07agenda in different ways every day, the
  33. 1:09wounds it has inflicted on the stock
  34. 1:11market will not heal. It will get much
  35. 1:13worse. How can I pass the word to you
  36. 1:15by saying, "the biggest trouble is yet
  37. 1:16to come"?
  38. 1:16I am very curious about the "biggest
  39. 1:17trouble," but let's start with the
  40. 1:19stock market. Of course, there are
  41. 1:21issues within the money market funds,
  42. 1:22but the main problem is in the stock
  43. 1:24market. Yes.
  44. 1:25Our viewers already know this; they
  45. 1:27have learned it. We did many broadcasts
  46. 1:29. You did, too. We explained how this
  47. 1:31system works, why it exploded, and why
  48. 1:33it had to explode. Now, if we talk
  49. 1:35about what comes next, you also did a
  50. 1:36broadcast on your own channel. There,
  51. 1:39you said the stock market intervention
  52. 1:40worked and that the market turned back
  53. 1:42from the edge of the abyss.
  54. 1:44Why did you say that, and do you stand
  55. 1:45by that opinion?
  56. 1:46Now, let's first describe the abyss. I
  57. 1:48mean, what was the worst that could
  58. 1:49have happened? The worst would have
  59. 1:51been the suspension of all trades due
  60. 1:53to a lack of buyers in the stock market
  61. 1:55and the market being closed for a few
  62. 1:56days. Second, a run on all fund
  63. 1:59management companies, and since none of
  64. 2:01them have enough liquidity—which is a
  65. 2:04natural situation. All of them falling
  66. 2:06into default. Third, this would have
  67. 2:10spread first to participation finance
  68. 2:12institutions or Islamic finance
  69. 2:14institutions, and then to the banks.
  70. 2:18Because there are financing
  71. 2:19relationships between participation
  72. 2:21companies and banks. Now, the decisions
  73. 2:25made by the authority prevented these,
  74. 2:27but when we look at stock prices or
  75. 2:30investment potential, I think the real
  76. 2:33crisis is starting now.
  77. 2:35What kind of a crisis, and why is it
  78. 2:36starting now?
  79. 2:37Right now, 13, no, 130 funds are in
  80. 2:39liquidation. I hope no others emerge,
  81. 2:43but one must follow the detentions that
  82. 2:45hit the press headlines every day. I
  83. 2:48don't want to name names. Some of these
  84. 2:51are companies that were never involved
  85. 2:53in rumors about this subject before. We
  86. 2:57don't know what their situation is. It
  87. 2:59is a catastrophe right now. Despite the
  88. 3:01assurances from Mehmet Şimşek and the
  89. 3:03CMB, another fund exploding would be
  90. 3:05the end. But the real issue is these
  91. 3:08130 funds. You know which companies are
  92. 3:10in their portfolios. You also know that
  93. 3:13these have to be sold. No one will buy
  94. 3:16them.
  95. 3:16They aren't buying them today as it is.
  96. 3:17They aren't buying. Yes. They are all
  97. 3:19hitting the floor. Well then, of course
  98. 3:21, the CMB said we would liquidate them
  99. 3:23in 3 months. They extended it to 6
  100. 3:25months. I think 6 months is difficult,
  101. 3:27or rather, it's difficult in this way.
  102. 3:28I mean, you lower the price to near
  103. 3:30zero, then a buyer will appear. But I
  104. 3:32think Kerim Rota is saying that, too. I
  105. 3:34hope I'm not mistaken, but when all of
  106. 3:36this is resolved and it comes time to
  107. 3:38distribute the shareholders' rights, if
  108. 3:40they get 20 cents for every 1 lira,
  109. 3:42plus they waited 6 months. They are
  110. 3:45lucky. This creates a general crisis of
  111. 3:47confidence. I mean, I have honestly
  112. 3:50seen this in the past. It started in
  113. 3:531990. The stock market even hit the
  114. 3:56ceiling 32 days in a row. Then Saddam
  115. 3:59Hussein invaded Kuwait. For a year and
  116. 4:01a half, no one looked at the stock
  117. 4:03market. I am afraid that such a
  118. 4:04situation might happen again. It's not
  119. 4:06a small number, Semih. They are talking
  120. 4:08about 500,000 investors. If it stays
  121. 4:10limited to that. The total number of
  122. 4:12investors is 7 million. Now these
  123. 4:14people will talk to those around them,
  124. 4:16and I don't think it has dawned on them
  125. 4:18yet that they won't get their money
  126. 4:19back. They think the state will save
  127. 4:22them somehow. Which, if you ask me, is
  128. 4:25impossible. Technically impossible.
  129. 4:27These people will put very serious
  130. 4:29pressure on the political system.
  131. 4:31Politically, we saw that IYI Party
  132. 4:33deputy Erhan Usta submitted a
  133. 4:35parliamentary question. Who are the
  134. 4:37criminals? He is right to ask who made
  135. 4:39money so it can be revealed. But our
  136. 4:41dear Minister of Justice won't answer.
  137. 4:43He hasn't answered any questions so far
  138. 4:45anyway. But I bet you. Within this week
  139. 4:48, we will see comments in the
  140. 4:50opposition press, whether true or false
  141. 4:52, claiming that people close to the
  142. 4:54government or some members of the
  143. 4:56ruling party made huge money from this
  144. 4:58business and fled before the scandal
  145. 5:00broke. All of this completely destroys
  146. 5:04trust. Of course, the public authority
  147. 5:05is also in a very difficult position.
  148. 5:08After so much outcry and so many
  149. 5:10victims, you have to not only shut down
  150. 5:12the funds but also detain those who
  151. 5:15committed these crimes or pursue legal
  152. 5:17action in some way. Fair enough. But
  153. 5:20every piece of news that comes out
  154. 5:22tires people a bit more and causes a
  155. 5:24further decrease in trust. Lastly, I
  156. 5:27don't know how many years it's been,
  157. 5:29but if you open Google and type in
  158. 5:32Turkey, 20 pages of fund scandals come
  159. 5:34up. We have become the talk of the
  160. 5:36whole world. Yes.
  161. 5:38Currently, there is no demand at all
  162. 5:39for stocks from countries like ours
  163. 5:41among emerging market funds. I fear
  164. 5:44that sell-offs will follow from this
  165. 5:46point on. In summary, when it becomes
  166. 5:49clear that these grievances cannot be
  167. 5:51properly compensated, that is when the
  168. 5:54real big outcry will happen. Second, I
  169. 5:57say this based on my past experience
  170. 5:59and hoping I am wrong. No matter how
  171. 6:02cheap the stock market is, no matter
  172. 6:04how much good news comes from outside,
  173. 6:06inside, the economy, or politics, I
  174. 6:08don't think investors will return for a
  175. 6:10year or a year and a half. Because a
  176. 6:12generation of investors has been
  177. 6:14sidelined.
  178. 6:14And why can't the loss be compensated?
  179. 6:18I mean, everyone entered at a different
  180. 6:20price. What is a fair price? Okay, for
  181. 6:23those who entered at very low prices
  182. 6:25and made money, fine. Maybe even take
  183. 6:28back a portion of their earnings. But
  184. 6:30what is the fair price of this stock?
  185. 6:32You want to compensate people at that
  186. 6:34price.
  187. 6:36Do it. Well, for example, someone who
  188. 6:37entered 6 months ago and left 2 months
  189. 6:39ago. They made some serious money there
  190. 6:40. But I guess you can't go and take
  191. 6:42their money.
  192. 6:42So, as I said, there is no remedy. My
  193. 6:45dear former colleague and current owner
  194. 6:48of Marmara Investment, Haydar Hacı,
  195. 6:50has a proposal. The assets of those
  196. 6:52found guilty in all of this should be
  197. 6:54confiscated by court order. It could be
  198. 6:57distributed, but then you face another
  199. 6:59liquidation problem there.
  200. 7:00Yes. It is a long process.
  201. 7:02Yes. In summary, at what price did they
  202. 7:04buy for 500,000 people? What is the
  203. 7:05correct price? Let us compensate the
  204. 7:08losers. It is almost technically
  205. 7:10impossible. Therefore, a
  206. 7:12one-size-fits-all approach will be
  207. 7:14applied, and according to my
  208. 7:16liquidation logic, once sufficient cash
  209. 7:19is gathered—that is, when the fund's
  210. 7:21entire net asset value is liquidated—
  211. 7:24it will be distributed equally among
  212. 7:26these investors. Maybe they won't give
  213. 7:29anything to those who made a high
  214. 7:30profit. They might only distribute to
  215. 7:32those who suffered losses. But even
  216. 7:34then, there won't be enough money to
  217. 7:36recover half of that loss.
  218. 7:38But there is no perfect solution. So
  219. 7:40this will be a situation where everyone
  220. 7:41loses, right? At the end of the day.
  221. 7:43Yes, for everyone. Also,
  222. 7:44Fatih Atar said 10 percent. He said it
  223. 7:47would be good if people could get back
  224. 7:4810 percent.
  225. 7:4910 or 20 percent, that is. Yes. And the
  226. 7:52figure is very large. We are talking
  227. 7:54about a total investment there of
  228. 7:57between 18 and 24 billion. Dollars.
  229. 8:00Let’s put this into perspective. This
  230. 8:02corresponds to 1 to 1.5 percent of
  231. 8:04Turkey's annual national income. It
  232. 8:07cannot be paid from the budget either.
  233. 8:09Meaning all balances would explode,
  234. 8:10potentially leading to a credit rating
  235. 8:12downgrade.
  236. 8:13What was the "big problem" you were
  237. 8:14referring to?
  238. 8:14Well, this was the "big problem." I
  239. 8:16think those who are currently
  240. 8:18stakeholders in funds subject to
  241. 8:20liquidation do not know how much they
  242. 8:23will lose. Also, perhaps it is my
  243. 8:25personal perception, but I am saying
  244. 8:28this by evaluating the news I read.
  245. 8:30There are politicians involved among
  246. 8:32these investors, or rather, involved in
  247. 8:34this business. Therefore, there was a
  248. 8:36belief that "our President will save us
  249. 8:38somehow." I think that was also
  250. 8:40destroyed after these recent detentions
  251. 8:42. Therefore, this event will continue.
  252. 8:44I interrupted you. A brief
  253. 8:46Not at all.
  254. 8:47Let’s open a brief OKXTR parenthesis.
  255. 8:49Ah, of course.
  256. 8:50OKXTR has a new campaign. There is a 20
  257. 8:53percent discount on crypto trades. All
  258. 8:55you need to do is sign up for OKXTR
  259. 8:58using the link in the description and
  260. 9:00make your first transaction. After that
  261. 9:02, your 20 percent discount coupon will
  262. 9:04be valid. You will be able to use it,
  263. 9:06and the maximum discount amount is 470
  264. 9:08Turkish Liras. Let’s mention that too
  265. 9:10. And you can open an account with the
  266. 9:12MS economy code from the link under the
  267. 9:14video and start investing immediately.
  268. 9:16We also thank our sponsor very much.
  269. 9:18Now, you meet with foreign investors a
  270. 9:20lot. Of course, I don't know if you met
  271. 9:21them after that month. It’s only a 3
  272. 9:23to 5-day or week-long affair. They ask
  273. 9:24you, and we always talk about Turkey's
  274. 9:26center of attraction or need for hot
  275. 9:28money. You mentioned this a bit, but
  276. 9:30seriously, for the bond market, for
  277. 9:31example, the impact on foreign
  278. 9:33investors coming only to the stock
  279. 9:34exchange.
  280. 9:35Now, among our clients, not many people
  281. 9:37invest in stocks. We generally deal
  282. 9:40with derivative transactions and bonds,
  283. 9:42that is, money market and credit
  284. 9:43transactions. But one or two questions
  285. 9:45came in. As to where this will end. We
  286. 9:47also wrote about it in our weekly
  287. 9:49report. No, I think the interest of
  288. 9:52foreign investors in the bond market,
  289. 9:55especially the local currency bond
  290. 9:58market, will continue. There could be
  291. 10:01only one exception to this. Regardless
  292. 10:03of the market, since foreign investors
  293. 10:05know Turkey's classic current account
  294. 10:07deficit problem, they definitely look
  295. 10:09at Central Bank reserves before making
  296. 10:11an investment decision. Last week, we
  297. 10:13saw the money that could flee the stock
  298. 10:15market flocking to the Central Bank,
  299. 10:17that is, to foreign currency, and the
  300. 10:18Central Bank selling reserves. Look at
  301. 10:21the Central Bank's reserves; we are in
  302. 10:22September, so there should be a very
  303. 10:24strong tourism season income. It has
  304. 10:26been falling for 3 weeks. It is also
  305. 10:28falling even after excluding gold. The
  306. 10:30figures it has dropped to so far are
  307. 10:32not at a level that would unsettle
  308. 10:34foreigners or anyone else. But people
  309. 10:36—and I mean this is just a hypothesis
  310. 10:39, it’s not just the fund victims. If
  311. 10:42the general investor base has lost
  312. 10:44confidence in the stock market and
  313. 10:46wants to sell at any cost and invest
  314. 10:49elsewhere, at least 40%of this will go
  315. 10:51into foreign currency. The loss so far
  316. 10:55is 12 trillion in the stock market, a
  317. 10:56loss of value, man.
  318. 10:58And it looks like it will continue.
  319. 10:59So, this means about 5 trillion of it
  320. 11:01could go into foreign currency and it
  321. 11:03will continue. Yes. I mean, I'm being
  322. 11:05very clear. I mean, there is no point
  323. 11:07in thinking, "Is it cheap or expensive?
  324. 11:10What's the story here? This stock will
  325. 11:13invest like this, it got a new contract
  326. 11:16like that." This is a full-blown macro
  327. 11:18issue.
  328. 11:19I suppose there won't be any IPOs for a
  329. 11:20long time either.
  330. 11:21Today, there was a very nice article by
  331. 11:23Turhal, who writes for Ekonomim. The
  332. 11:26IPO index has lost about 40%of its
  333. 11:28value. We've lost that area too. So,
  334. 11:32will any companies be interested in
  335. 11:33going public after this? Or I'm not
  336. 11:36sure if the Capital Markets Board will
  337. 11:38dare to permit it.
  338. 11:39Or will people dare to buy them?
  339. 11:41People definitely won't come. I mean,
  340. 11:43up until now, the place where you could
  341. 11:46make money in the stock market even if
  342. 11:48you were blind and threw a dart at the
  343. 11:50board was IPOs. They were all hitting
  344. 11:52the ceiling in reality. I think they
  345. 11:54should be investigated as well.
  346. 11:56Yes.
  347. 11:57Since we've started. These small—and
  348. 11:59when I say small, many of the stocks
  349. 12:02being played on the board are companies
  350. 12:04that recently had IPOs.
  351. 12:06I mean, if the market value of the
  352. 12:08amount a company offers to the public
  353. 12:09is 10-15 million dollars, I've
  354. 12:11coincidentally met investors in Turkey
  355. 12:13who turn over 100 million dollars a day
  356. 12:15. Now, naturally, the method for these
  357. 12:17people is also very simple. You place
  358. 12:19orders through seven different
  359. 12:20brokerage firms. You don't follow it
  360. 12:23very closely, but there is serious "
  361. 12:24information" on this stock. There is
  362. 12:26depth, too, they say. They continue to
  363. 12:29buy even though the price is inflated
  364. 12:31after the IPOs. And the worst part is,
  365. 12:33if I remember the research correctly,
  366. 12:35more than 50%of those who participated
  367. 12:37in the IPOs are rookies investing in
  368. 12:38the stock market for the first time.
  369. 12:41That's why they say a generation has
  370. 12:43been sidelined. Let me remind you of
  371. 12:45that event once more. I mentioned it,
  372. 12:47but it is very important in terms of
  373. 12:49being an example. The 2001 crisis, the
  374. 12:51IMF arrived, and about 20 banks were
  375. 12:54seized. Most of these had gone public,
  376. 12:57and the state said, "I will not pay for
  377. 12:59the shares in circulation on the stock
  378. 13:00market." Even though it was a very
  379. 13:02small figure and could have easily been
  380. 13:04covered by the banks 'balance sheets.
  381. 13:07Again, hundreds of thousands of
  382. 13:08investors were victimized, and after
  383. 13:10that, if I remember correctly, despite
  384. 13:12the Turkish Lira gaining strong value
  385. 13:13for 1.5–2 years, there was no
  386. 13:15movement in the stock market. I am very
  387. 13:18afraid that we have entered such a
  388. 13:19period.
  389. 13:20How would this affect the economy? We
  390. 13:22have entered such a period, for
  391. 13:23instance.
  392. 13:23Well, that's very interesting. I'm glad
  393. 13:25you brought it up. Hakan Kara, an
  394. 13:27academic and central banker I highly
  395. 13:29respect, likely thinks there will be a
  396. 13:32negative contagion to economic activity
  397. 13:35here, so he says the Central Bank
  398. 13:37should cut rates by 100 points in
  399. 13:39October. I strongly disagree with this.
  400. 13:44There is an endless debate here, both
  401. 13:46among the Central Bank and economists.
  402. 13:49How significant is the wealth effect? I
  403. 13:52mean, 800 billion liras or whatever
  404. 13:55have been lost on the stock market. Are
  405. 13:59people consuming less because they feel
  406. 14:01poorer? I find it very hard to believe
  407. 14:05that. Or I think, if I lose 100 liras,
  408. 14:07maybe I'll reduce my consumption by 10
  409. 14:09liras. Therefore, this is not an event
  410. 14:12the Central Bank needs to intervene in.
  411. 14:14It won't have major repercussions on
  412. 14:16the economy either. If it remains here,
  413. 14:18the reflection, in my opinion, comes
  414. 14:20from the subject not being discussed.
  415. 14:23Right now, 90%of the conversation
  416. 14:26regarding this fund scandal is about
  417. 14:28stocks and stock funds; what happened
  418. 14:31to my home in the participation housing
  419. 14:33schemes? The real problem is there. I
  420. 14:37mean, these are institutions considered
  421. 14:38to be banks. How much loss is there?
  422. 14:40Detentions have started there as well.
  423. 14:43I don't even know the number of
  424. 14:45investors, that is, depositors or
  425. 14:48participants, there. If very serious
  426. 14:50losses occur, it could frankly damage
  427. 14:53economic activity.
  428. 14:54But it seems like the public will
  429. 14:55handle that, will pay for it.
  430. 14:57Emlak Bank supposedly took it over. I
  431. 14:59don't know how much of a loss will
  432. 15:00emerge from these. I mean, the scale
  433. 15:02could be 1 billion dollars or it could
  434. 15:04be 10 billion dollars. One also needs
  435. 15:06to consider this. It’s a problem on
  436. 15:10the minds of all central banks, not
  437. 15:12just our Central Bank. The oil prices
  438. 15:15we see on the screen are falling, but
  439. 15:17the price of diesel per ton has reached
  440. 15:20200 dollars. Rationing has started in
  441. 15:22America. I mean, they aren't giving
  442. 15:24everyone as much diesel as they want.
  443. 15:27Natural gas, perhaps the unit of
  444. 15:29measure, will go up to 5 euros.
  445. 15:32Therefore, even if the Strait of Hormuz
  446. 15:34or Bab-el-Mandeb were to open right now
  447. 15:36, an unimaginable inflation shock
  448. 15:38awaits countries that import energy on
  449. 15:40a large scale, like Turkey, this winter
  450. 15:42, and there is nothing that can be done
  451. 15:44against it. Therefore, I don't see it
  452. 15:46as very logical to cut interest rates
  453. 15:48just because this event might weaken
  454. 15:50domestic demand.
  455. 15:51We were also always talking about how
  456. 15:53financial stability is as important as
  457. 15:54inflation in the interest rate cut
  458. 15:56decision. Certainly.
  459. 15:57Well, financial stability in Turkey is
  460. 15:59currently not stronger than it was a
  461. 16:01week ago.
  462. 16:02But as you said a moment ago, reserves
  463. 16:04have decreased. Regardless of what
  464. 16:05happens, there will be a crisis of
  465. 16:06confidence. Even if the scale is not
  466. 16:09fully clear right now, couldn't cutting
  467. 16:12rates in this environment make people
  468. 16:14think, "Has the time finally come?"
  469. 16:17Well, there, too, a flight back to the
  470. 16:20dollar could occur. It could get even
  471. 16:22worse. Now, it depends on how you look
  472. 16:24at financial stability; if we are
  473. 16:26talking about the stock market, there
  474. 16:28is no financial stability, but the
  475. 16:30dominant financial institution in
  476. 16:32Turkey is commercial banks. I am sure
  477. 16:34they might have lent some money to
  478. 16:37brokerage houses or funds, but I don't
  479. 16:39think this would exceed a few percent
  480. 16:42of their total loans. Therefore, there
  481. 16:45is no such thing as a breakdown of
  482. 16:46financial stability in Turkey at the
  483. 16:48moment. In my opinion, there is no need
  484. 16:50to take measures regarding that either.
  485. 16:52You are saying there is no systemic
  486. 16:53risk, just like Mehmet Şimşek, right?
  487. 16:55No. There is definitely no systemic
  488. 16:56risk. In the economy as we understand
  489. 16:59it, systemic failure means the
  490. 17:01disruption of financial flows and the
  491. 17:04loss of capital adequacy by
  492. 17:06institutions with a massive customer
  493. 17:09base or deep connections to other large
  494. 17:12entities. I mean, the fund industry,
  495. 17:15pension funds, and participation banks
  496. 17:17have grown, but they remain a drop in
  497. 17:19the ocean compared to commercial
  498. 17:22banking. I don't see any risk of
  499. 17:23contagion from there to the rest of the
  500. 17:25system. Honestly.
  501. 17:27At Bey, you've been in the market since
  502. 17:29the late 80s, right?
  503. 17:30Uh, since October of 90, exactly. I've
  504. 17:32been in the market.
  505. 17:3390. And where would you rank this?
  506. 17:35Among the scandals in the Turkish
  507. 17:37financial system, what else do you
  508. 17:39recall? The biggest.
  509. 17:41This is the biggest one. Ah.
  510. 17:42Well, the amount is also growing,
  511. 17:43naturally. You'll get past it.
  512. 17:45No, no, this is truly the biggest one.
  513. 17:47In terms of the number of people who
  514. 17:51lost money and, according to my model,
  515. 17:54the ripple effects, we are facing a
  516. 17:57danger with a very long tail. After
  517. 18:01that, I’d place the 1994 crisis.
  518. 18:03Because that also stemmed from the
  519. 18:04stupidity of the public sector. Meaning
  520. 18:06, we caused our own crisis. Because.
  521. 18:08The banker crisis was earlier, right?
  522. 18:10The banker crisis.
  523. 18:10The banker crisis. Yes. It was in 1984.
  524. 18:15As far as I could examine it, the
  525. 18:16public sector didn't understand what
  526. 18:18was going on. For example, the Fed
  527. 18:20didn't understand the subprime crisis
  528. 18:22in 2007 either. Back then there was no
  529. 18:24Capital Markets Board, no Banking
  530. 18:26Regulation Agency. The Central Bank was
  531. 18:29looking into these matters. I mean, the
  532. 18:31banker crisis is very interesting. The
  533. 18:33reason is this. Back then, there were
  534. 18:35interest rate caps. These bankers had
  535. 18:39companies issue bonds. And then they
  536. 18:42discounted them. Meaning, the bond's
  537. 18:46issue rate was 40, but they offered the
  538. 18:48citizens an 80 percent return. As long
  539. 18:53as the system continued, meaning as
  540. 18:54long as more citizens arrived, you paid
  541. 18:56that 80 percent. It explodes at some
  542. 18:58point, of course.
  543. 18:59Imar Bankasi, Imar Bankasi, Adabank.
  544. 19:01That's not exactly the same thing, but
  545. 19:03it was also fraud.
  546. 19:04That one. Yes. No one got hurt there.
  547. 19:07What were the complaints?
  548. 19:09None. The state paid for everything. As
  549. 19:11far as I know, in all bank crises since
  550. 19:14the 80s, the only ones who didn't get
  551. 19:16their money back were those who
  552. 19:19borrowed in Japanese Yen to buy houses.
  553. 19:22Oh, there's Dogayan.
  554. 19:23Yes. Other than that, the state paid
  555. 19:25everyone's money. In my opinion, that
  556. 19:28is a fraud that will go down in world
  557. 19:30history. Because the bank had two
  558. 19:33separate balance sheets. Beyond what it
  559. 19:37showed the state, it had collected and
  560. 19:39stolen about 20 billion in deposits.
  561. 19:41And even today, Hakan Uzan is still
  562. 19:43considered a reputable person in Turkey
  563. 19:45. Maybe that's why these crises recur,
  564. 19:49and the entire cost was paid by the
  565. 19:51public and taxpayers, of course. But it
  566. 19:55wasn't limited to just that. I mean,
  567. 19:57there was fraud in the Digiturk
  568. 19:59football tender as well. When Hakan
  569. 20:01Uzan's or a member of the Uzan family's
  570. 20:04villa was raided, millions of Telsim
  571. 20:07cards were found. I mean, that was
  572. 20:09something else entirely.
  573. 20:10This won't be the last, of course.
  574. 20:11Would you call this the final crisis in
  575. 20:12the current system? I mean, will Turkey
  576. 20:14learn such a lesson from this that
  577. 20:16something like this won't happen in
  578. 20:17financial markets again?
  579. 20:19Well, if the political connections of
  580. 20:20the incident are pursued, it won't
  581. 20:22happen again. Because it can be known
  582. 20:23that much. Look, let's recount the
  583. 20:25events one more time.
  584. 20:26Politics from the public sector.
  585. 20:27Politics.
  586. 20:28Can something of this scale be done
  587. 20:30without the role of politics?
  588. 20:31It cannot. Look, just last November,
  589. 20:35Mehmet Şimşek—and I don't remember
  590. 20:37if the CMB chair had changed then.
  591. 20:39There is manipulation in the funds. He
  592. 20:41said we will take measures. Then a
  593. 20:43communiqué was published. It couldn't
  594. 20:45be made official for 8 months. Now,
  595. 20:47don't anyone tell me there are no
  596. 20:49political connections here. I can't see
  597. 20:50any other reason for it, honestly. The
  598. 20:52two most authorized people on this
  599. 20:54matter probably went and told the
  600. 20:57President, or they told Mr. Cevdet
  601. 20:59Yılmaz, or as far as I know, one of
  602. 21:01the state ministers is in charge of the
  603. 21:04CMB. I'm not sure if that still exists.
  604. 21:06They must have told him too. Tell me,
  605. 21:08how else can this lack of action be
  606. 21:10explained? I really can't find an
  607. 21:12answer in my head.
  608. 21:13Of course.
  609. 21:14If politics hadn't interfered, or if it
  610. 21:16doesn't interfere, I think the CMB and
  611. 21:18BDDK are quite competent institutions,
  612. 21:21and they are aware of the situation.
  613. 21:24They wouldn't allow this. But I think
  614. 21:26their hands were tied.
  615. 21:28By the way, Atilla Bey, there is also
  616. 21:30the matter of...Now, as you know, there
  617. 21:31was a group within the government that
  618. 21:33opposed and criticized Mehmet Şimşek.
  619. 21:35It exists, we know it. We see it in the
  620. 21:37headlines and in their statements. They
  621. 21:39are undermining him at every turn.
  622. 21:40Yes. For a long time, there has been a
  623. 21:43group that criticizes Mehmet Şimşek
  624. 21:45even more harshly than the opposition.
  625. 21:47I was looking a bit into the past. You
  626. 21:49said Mehmet Şimşek had said this last
  627. 21:50November, but he couldn't do it. He
  628. 21:52didn't have the power, and it just
  629. 21:53didn't happen. One must mention the
  630. 21:55infighting within the AK Party here.
  631. 21:58Because some of the people who
  632. 22:00criticized Mehmet Şimşek so harshly
  633. 22:03back then are more or less actors in
  634. 22:05this structure—this fund scandal we
  635. 22:08are talking about. That must be said.
  636. 22:12Yeah. It could be some kind of purging,
  637. 22:13too. Perhaps Mehmet Şimşek wanted to
  638. 22:16do something about them—this is
  639. 22:18purely speculative, of course—but...
  640. 22:20The power within them tried to prevent
  641. 22:21this. Because the rumors that "Mehmet
  642. 22:24Şimşek is going, he's gone, he's
  643. 22:25going" never ended, and these rumors
  644. 22:26came from both the opposition and from
  645. 22:28within the government.
  646. 22:29Yes. So, within the AKP, Mr. Erdoğan
  647. 22:32is not as in control of everything as
  648. 22:34he used to be. We see this conflict on
  649. 22:38many issues. Like the detention of Cem
  650. 22:41Küçük and so on. I think it happened
  651. 22:45just as you said. Actually, if the
  652. 22:47Ministry of Justice really wants to do
  653. 22:50a good deed here, they should
  654. 22:52investigate the relatives and friends
  655. 22:54of those who invested in these funds at
  656. 22:57very low prices. Because they wouldn't
  657. 22:59do it under their own names. They would
  658. 23:01act through those connections. But I
  659. 23:03don't think that will happen at all.
  660. 23:05Yes. In the current state of affairs in
  661. 23:07Turkey, I don't think that's possible.
  662. 23:08Yes. So, has everything become
  663. 23:10difficult for Turkey now, I mean after
  664. 23:12this fund crisis?
  665. 23:15No, although the stock market occupies
  666. 23:17a lot of the agenda, it is not a very
  667. 23:19strong institution in terms of the
  668. 23:21Turkish economy or its political
  669. 23:23sociology. It is more of a niche
  670. 23:26product. If, God forbid, rumors and
  671. 23:28troubles arise regarding commercial
  672. 23:30banks, that would be different, but...
  673. 23:32You don't expect something like that?
  674. 23:34No, I don't, but the state of the
  675. 23:36economy is not good. I think I
  676. 23:38mentioned the economy before. It’s
  677. 23:40not fragile; it’s just sluggish and
  678. 23:41not functioning properly anymore.
  679. 23:43Hmm.
  680. 23:44Well, the capacity utilization rate was
  681. 23:46released today; it has increased. Real
  682. 23:49sector confidence has declined.
  683. 23:52Bloomberg's consumer confidence index
  684. 23:54has fallen. I mean, it's just
  685. 23:57fluctuating where it is. It's going
  686. 23:59nowhere. I don't think it's going
  687. 24:01anywhere after this, either. As I said,
  688. 24:05if a fuel crisis rather than an oil
  689. 24:08crisis hits this winter, especially if
  690. 24:10a natural gas shortage starts, we can
  691. 24:13get it from Russia, but its price is
  692. 24:16also oil-indexed.
  693. 24:19We could take a serious inflation shock
  694. 24:21.
  695. 24:22The biggest risk for the coming autumn
  696. 24:24and winter is fuel.
  697. 24:26Yes.
  698. 24:27Of course, you say it will be fuel
  699. 24:28prices. It will be energy prices. But
  700. 24:30now you talk a lot on Yunus Emre. You
  701. 24:32do broadcasts about this on Friday.
  702. 24:34There isn't much left until the
  703. 24:35midterms.
  704. 24:36Is the period from now until then
  705. 24:38critical, or is the period after that
  706. 24:41more critical?
  707. 24:43Now, if Trump's Republicans lose one
  708. 24:45wing of Congress, or perhaps even both,
  709. 24:48Congress will stop the war. It has
  710. 24:51enough material in its hands to
  711. 24:53blackmail Trump. Iran has already
  712. 24:56suffered a lot, too. It won't prolong
  713. 24:59this war. Let's say the way opens the
  714. 25:01very next day. It won't open
  715. 25:02immediately, though. It might open
  716. 25:04within a month. It's too late. The
  717. 25:06reason is very simple. Stocks are
  718. 25:07depleted. Now, first of all, everyone's
  719. 25:10calculation is different right now.
  720. 25:13Through the Strait of Hormuz and
  721. 25:15Bab-el-Mandeb, 60%of the normal traffic
  722. 25:18of oil and natural gas passes. Now,
  723. 25:21first the oil price on the screen will
  724. 25:24drop, but refineries, petrochemical
  725. 25:27plants, especially China, will need to
  726. 25:30replenish their stocks that have
  727. 25:33dropped almost to zero. So, oil demand
  728. 25:37will soar well above normal once that
  729. 25:39place opens. It will take 2-3 months
  730. 25:43for this to be reflected as a discount
  731. 25:47in diesel—which has a direct impact
  732. 25:50on CPI—jet fuel, or fuel oils used in
  733. 25:53homes or power plants. By then,
  734. 25:57inflation will have already spiraled
  735. 25:58out of control. I don't want to drown
  736. 26:02people by going into too much detail,
  737. 26:04but there's also the shipping,
  738. 26:06fertilizer, aluminum, and plastics
  739. 26:08dimension. I mean, it's not just oil
  740. 26:11that can't get out of the Gulf. Prices
  741. 26:14have risen and stocks have decreased
  742. 26:16everywhere. So, I'm saying it clearly,
  743. 26:20if Brent drops to $ 50 in 2027, don't
  744. 26:23be surprised at all. That would be very
  745. 26:26good for Turkey. But it won't save this
  746. 26:28winter. It will be too late in the
  747. 26:30winter. And all major central banks,
  748. 26:34including our Central Bank, will face a
  749. 26:37very serious problem. Will they say
  750. 26:40this inflation shock is temporary? Oil
  751. 26:42prices are falling. Should we stop
  752. 26:44raising interest rates now? Or will
  753. 26:46people's inflation expectations rise,
  754. 26:49as is the case in Turkey, when the
  755. 26:52headline remains high? Will they hike
  756. 26:54rates again, saying we can't get to the
  757. 26:56bottom of this? If they hike rates,
  758. 26:59then things will get even more
  759. 27:01difficult.
  760. 27:02Well, what if it doesn't fall? You said
  761. 27:03there's a chance it won't fall, right,
  762. 27:042020...
  763. 27:04Let's say yes. Uh...
  764. 27:07Well, then a financial crisis is coming
  765. 27:09, first and foremost. I mean, this is a
  766. 27:11very serious fear. Now let's look at
  767. 27:13the state of the markets. Emerging
  768. 27:16markets have gained nearly 30%this year
  769. 27:19. The Dow Jones is falling, but the
  770. 27:21Nasdaq and S&P are still very close to
  771. 27:23their peaks. So what is fundamentally
  772. 27:25supporting this? Artificial
  773. 27:27intelligence is supporting it. We all
  774. 27:30hear these artificial intelligence
  775. 27:31stories. I mean, most recently, even
  776. 27:34Google admitted it. Artificial
  777. 27:37intelligence is escaping the lab, man,
  778. 27:39and there are no measures to understand
  779. 27:41it. Therefore, that story is very
  780. 27:43cloudy. The fuel crisis is not being
  781. 27:46considered in any way. The biggest
  782. 27:49danger in the American elections is
  783. 27:51Trump interfering; he will do it. I
  784. 27:54mean, you read serious things, sources
  785. 27:57like The New York Times, The Guardian;
  786. 27:59they say he is considering sending
  787. 28:01federal officers to seize ballot boxes.
  788. 28:04This would be unthinkable. Because the
  789. 28:07election would never end. So, who wins
  790. 28:09or loses becomes secondary. About 30 of
  791. 28:12these 50 states in America are under
  792. 28:15Republican control. Meaning both the
  793. 28:18governor and the legislature have a
  794. 28:20Republican majority. They could file
  795. 28:23lawsuits to cancel the election. This
  796. 28:26could be something unprecedented in
  797. 28:27American history. Therefore, I am very
  798. 28:30afraid of three things. Things that
  799. 28:32will lead to a financial crisis. 1. The
  800. 28:34Fed raises interest rates again in
  801. 28:36October. 2. AI companies agree among
  802. 28:40themselves to declare a moratorium on
  803. 28:43new model development. 3. Trump refuses
  804. 28:46to recognize the election results. And
  805. 28:49fourth, the fuel crisis causes
  806. 28:51unthinkable price hikes during the
  807. 28:54winter months. This directly hits bonds
  808. 28:58, and interest rate hikes in the bond
  809. 29:01market affect stocks first, then the
  810. 29:03world economy. What scares me the most
  811. 29:06is this: Crises don't happen when
  812. 29:08everyone is expecting them. This time
  813. 29:10you read it. Strategists whose opinions
  814. 29:13I highly trust. They say there will be
  815. 29:15a historic rally in the S&P 500 in the
  816. 29:17final quarter. Maybe they are right, I
  817. 29:20don't know, but the atmosphere that led
  818. 29:24us to the 2007-2008 crisis was the same
  819. 29:27. I sense the same smell and I am very
  820. 29:29afraid.
  821. 29:29Meanwhile, we are holding an election
  822. 29:31to get President Erdoğan re-elected.
  823. 29:33Yes. I mean, I was very worried. There
  824. 29:36were rumors going around that maybe he
  825. 29:37wouldn't be a candidate or something.
  826. 29:39Elected one. Thank you very much. We
  827. 29:41will continue to talk to you about the
  828. 29:43days ahead anyway. About what is
  829. 29:44happening both in Turkey and in the
  830. 29:46global economy. Take very good care of
  831. 29:47yourselves.
  832. 29:48It won't get any better. Ah man.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of Fon Skandalı: Turpun Büyüğü Heybede! Paralara Ne Olacak? Halka Arzlar İncelenmeli | Atilla Yeşilada by Mesele Ekonomi, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 5,255 words across 832 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.