FNAF 2 makes sense now — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:02[music]
- 0:04>> Hello.
- 0:05Hello, hello.
- 0:08Hello and welcome to your new summer job
- 0:10as the new and improved Freddy Fazbear's
- 0:12Pizza. Now, I want you to forget
- 0:15anything you may have heard about the
- 0:17old location, you know. Fazbear
- 0:19Entertainment is committed to family fun
- 0:21and above all, safety. You're only the
- 0:23second guard to work at that location.
- 0:25The first guy finished his week but
- 0:27complained about conditions.
- 0:30We switched him over to the day shift.
- 0:32So just every once in a while, switch
- 0:34over to the Crowd Counter video feed and
- 0:36line it up for a few seconds.
- 0:38This doesn't seem to affect all of the
- 0:39animatronics, but it does affect
- 0:42one of them.
- 0:43Something else worth mentioning is kind
- 0:45of the quirky modern design of the
- 0:47building.
- 0:53>> I've always been an active FNAF enjoyer
- 0:55since FNAF 1 released, and there's been
- 0:58some ideas that the community has put
- 0:59forth as relative facts that I've always
- 1:02seen as
- 1:04weird, specifically with regards to FNAF
- 1:062 and FNAF 4. If the DCI happened, why
- 1:09don't we ever hear about them again
- 1:11after FNAF 2? And if the DCI didn't
- 1:12happen, then what's the actual
- 1:14significance of FNAF 2 as a whole? Bite
- 1:16of '87 that doesn't ultimately change
- 1:18anything other than telling us when the
- 1:20animatronics stopped being able to free
- 1:21roam during the day. It's kind of just
- 1:23an event that happened in 1987. If later
- 1:26that night is the same night as
- 1:27Charlie's death, how is there enough
- 1:29time for Charlie's possession of the
- 1:30puppet give gifts give life and an
- 1:32animatronic to seek out the runaway? If
- 1:34Afton was caught in 1985 but let go for
- 1:36some reason, how is he able to get a job
- 1:37in FNAF 2 if Henry would recognize him?
- 1:40And if that's somehow not true, does
- 1:41that mean the FNAF 1 newspapers aren't
- 1:43canon anymore? I think I've come to a
- 1:45pretty good understanding about FNAF 2
- 1:47now that solves most of my own
- 1:49questions. If my explanation is received
- 1:52in basically any capacity
- 1:55at all, I'll start thinking about FNAF 4
- 1:57questions because that is my my pride
- 1:59and That's my my white whale, my magnum
- 2:02opus, my Moby Dick. Um, I don't think
- 2:05I'll ever understand FNAF 4, but I
- 2:06really really really want to try. And I
- 2:08want to try to find a way to do it
- 2:09without including shatter victim or god
- 2:12victim or anything like that just cuz I
- 2:14there's no way that could have been the
- 2:15original intention. There's no way god
- 2:17victim was the original intention, but
- 2:19it could be the current intention. That
- 2:21could be a Scott con. Anyway, I I think
- 2:23I have a solid idea of what actually
- 2:25happens surrounding that building now.
- 2:27So as my 200 subscriber special, and I
- 2:30hope that that's comically low, as a
- 2:32result of this video, I'll try to answer
- 2:34my own most burning questions.
- 2:37First, I want to briefly talk about
- 2:38canonicity within FNAF and how I handle
- 2:41it within my own personal theorizing.
- 2:43Essentially,
- 2:44whatever medium information comes from
- 2:45should be most important to the
- 2:47continuity of that medium. Game
- 2:49information is the most important when
- 2:51trying to understand [music] the games.
- 2:52Book information is most important when
- 2:54trying to understand the books, but
- 2:55information in any medium means that
- 2:58that is something that Scott is okay
- 3:00with being true.
- 3:02Meaning if something happens in the
- 3:03books is at the very least physically
- 3:06possible
- 3:07to have happened in the games unless
- 3:09contradicted by game lore. For example,
- 3:11in the games the puppet is possessed by
- 3:13Charlotte Emily, whereas there is no
- 3:15puppet in the books. So things about
- 3:16Charlotte Emily in the books should not
- 3:18override game canon. However, Charlie
- 3:20dying in 1982 in FNAF 2, if it doesn't
- 3:24explicitly trump any game lore,
- 3:27means that Scott is okay with Charlie
- 3:29dying in 1982. And if we find game
- 3:32evidence to support that, we could say
- 3:34Charlie 82. I just want to get that out
- 3:36of the way off rip. I'm going to start
- 3:38with the question that's been itching at
- 3:39me for a long time.
- 3:41What is the point of FNAF 2? FNAF 1 was
- 3:44the first. It wasn't intended to have a
- 3:45sequel. FNAF 3 gave us the personal
- 3:47showdown between the audience and
- 3:49Springtrap and introduced us to what
- 3:50Springlocks even are. FNAF 4 was
- 3:52supposed to end the franchise by
- 3:53explaining Golden Freddy, but when that
- 3:55wasn't understood,
- 3:57Sister Location was made. And that
- 3:58expanded the franchise to a point where
- 3:59it was clear a face off between Michael
- 4:02and William needed to happen. Pizzeria
- 4:03Sim gave us that showdown and ended in a
- 4:06blaze of glory, and UCN showed us that
- 4:08Afton is indeed suffering for his
- 4:10crimes.
- 4:11So how does FNAF 2 fit into any of that?
- 4:14Yes, it gave us the toys, but they were
- 4:16immediately dismantled and only showed
- 4:18up again in the Clickteam era in FNAF 3,
- 4:20dismantled in the office, and FNAF 4
- 4:22mini games in possibly the most
- 4:24confusing way. It gave us a whole new
- 4:26restaurant which we seemingly never see
- 4:28again, a protagonist we know can't be
- 4:30Michael for most of the game, a major
- 4:32incident that isn't even confirmed to be
- 4:34a new dead children incident or a
- 4:35continuation of the missing children's
- 4:37incident.
- 4:38But I think I've finally put it all
- 4:40together in a way that I find agreeable,
- 4:42and it all starts with Charlie and the
- 4:44phone calls.
- 4:48In the FNAF 2 phone calls, we learn that
- 4:50this is our first week in a new
- 4:51location, but that the current day guard
- 4:54worked our night shift the week prior to
- 4:56the game, and that
- 4:57>> Uh the first guy finished his week but
- 4:59complained about conditions.
- 5:02Uh we switched him over to the day
- 5:04shift. So hey, lucky you, right?
- 5:07Uh mainly he expressed concern that
- 5:08certain characters seemed to move around
- 5:10at night and even attempted to get into
- 5:12his office.
- 5:14Now, from what we know, that should be
- 5:15impossible. Uh that restaurant should be
- 5:17the safest place on Earth.
- 5:19>> From a storyteller's perspective,
- 5:20especially one as efficient as Scott was
- 5:22when making these first few games,
- 5:24what is the objective of telling us this
- 5:26information?
- 5:27Why is it important that we know A,
- 5:28someone worked
- 5:30only the week prior to us, and B, that
- 5:33same person is now the day guard? Well,
- 5:35it gives us a brief timeline
- 5:37by telling us that
- 5:38>> You're only the second guard to work at
- 5:39that location.
- 5:40>> And
- 5:41>> Uh the first guy finished his week
- 5:43>> The first guy finished his week means
- 5:45that this Freddy Fazbear's Pizza is only
- 5:47on its second week of operation.
- 5:49And before explaining that week, let's
- 5:51establish the information given to us
- 5:52within the phone calls. The week before
- 5:54the events of FNAF 2, the previous night
- 5:55guard worked his shifts and was then
- 5:58moved to the day shift. Ralph tells us
- 6:00that the engineers have a working theory
- 6:01as to why the animatronics might be
- 6:03trying to get into the office and that a
- 6:05temporary solution is to wind up the
- 6:06music box, because the animatronics will
- 6:08hear the music and move towards it
- 6:10instead of the player.
- 6:11He also tells us,
- 6:12>> And as for the rest of them, we have an
- 6:14even easier solution.
- 6:16You see, there may be a minor glitch in
- 6:17the system, something about robot thing
- 6:19you is an endoskeleton without a costume
- 6:22on and wanting to stuff you into a suit.
- 6:25So hey, we've given you an empty Freddy
- 6:27Fazbear head. Put it on and solve. You
- 6:29can put it on anytime and leave it on
- 6:31for as long as you want.
- 6:33>> One of the last things he tells us is
- 6:35>> Uh something else worth mentioning is
- 6:36kind of the quirky modern design of the
- 6:38building. You may have noticed there are
- 6:41no doors for you to close.
- 6:43Uh but hey, you have light and even
- 6:45though your flashlight can run out of
- 6:46power, the building cannot.
- 6:48>> So at the very least, the inside of the
- 6:50building is new.
- 6:52On night one, the only active
- 6:53animatronics are Toy Freddy, Toy Bonnie,
- 6:55Toy Chica, and the Puppet. On night two,
- 6:57Ralph tells us about the withered
- 6:58animatronics, but only one of them
- 7:01becomes active that night, withered
- 7:02Foxy. We're told that the withereds have
- 7:04some of the new technology retrofitted
- 7:06into them.
- 7:07>> They even started retrofitting them with
- 7:08some of the newer technology, but they
- 7:10were just so ugly, you know? And the
- 7:12smell. Uh
- 7:15so the company decided to just go in a
- 7:16whole new direction and make them super
- 7:19kid-friendly.
- 7:20>> And that the Freddy head trick should
- 7:21work on them too,
- 7:23but that it specifically won't work on
- 7:25withered Foxy. Finally, he tells us,
- 7:27>> I'll be honest, I never liked that
- 7:29Puppet thing. It's always
- 7:31thinking that it can go anywhere.
- 7:34Uh I don't think the Freddy mask will
- 7:36fool it. So just don't forget the music
- 7:39box.
- 7:39>> So for the sake of our information, it
- 7:41should be noted that for some reason,
- 7:43Foxy and the Puppet need special methods
- 7:45of deterrence, and that phone guy
- 7:46knowing about it means that at the very
- 7:48latest, this was also happening on day
- 7:50five of the previous week. Now, night
- 7:52three is where our two-week timeline is
- 7:54called into question. Ralph tells us
- 7:56that
- 7:56>> They tried to remake Foxy, you know? Uh
- 7:59they thought the first one was too
- 8:00scary, so they redesigned them to be
- 8:02more kid-friendly and put them in kids
- 8:04cove, but kids these days just can't
- 8:07keep their hands for themselves.
- 8:09The staff literally had to put Foxy back
- 8:11together at the end of every shift.
- 8:13Eventually they just stopped trying and
- 8:15left them in some kind of take apart put
- 8:17back together attraction. Now it's just
- 8:20a mess of parts.
- 8:21I think the employees refer to them as
- 8:23just the Mangle.
- 8:25>> This being the night three call means
- 8:26that at the very most there are only
- 8:28nine possible days for Mangle to be
- 8:30introduced into the restaurant and
- 8:31ripped apart so many times that the
- 8:34staff gave up and changed its purpose
- 8:35altogether. I'm saying nine is the
- 8:37absolute maximum assuming the previous
- 8:39week began on a Monday and that night
- 8:40three is the next Wednesday night and
- 8:42it's only nine if Freddy's for some
- 8:44reason doesn't close on weekends.
- 8:46Editor's note, this timeline is wrong.
- 8:49We get the paycheck dated November 12th,
- 8:521987.
- 8:53That falls on a Thursday. We get that on
- 8:57night five.
- 8:58If that's true that means night three is
- 9:01actually on a Tuesday
- 9:03which means night one is on a Sunday. So
- 9:06Freddy's at the very least isn't closed
- 9:09on Sundays. We can assume that it's open
- 9:11on weekends. So this part of the
- 9:13timeline was actually wrong but
- 9:16the rest of it should still be correct.
- 9:19But we know that it can't be more than
- 9:21seven days because we can see Mangle in
- 9:23Kid's Cove on night one meaning at the
- 9:25absolute latest the staff decided to
- 9:27stop trying to put Mangle back together
- 9:29on the day of night one.
- 9:31But for the sake of the video let's
- 9:32assume that what Ralph tells us is
- 9:33actually true. Mangle is just the toy
- 9:36version of Foxy not messing with any fun
- 9:38time shenanigans here. But this isn't
- 9:40even really the significant part of
- 9:42night three.
- 9:44>> Oh hey before I go I wanted to ease your
- 9:46mind about any rumors you might have
- 9:47heard lately.
- 9:49You know how these local stories come
- 9:50and go and seldom mean anything. I can
- 9:53personally assure you
- 9:55that whatever is going on out there
- 9:57however tragic it may be has nothing to
- 10:00do with our establishment. It's just all
- 10:02rumor and speculation people trying to
- 10:04make a buck you know. Our guard during
- 10:07the day has reported nothing unusual and
- 10:09he's on watch opening till close.
- 10:12So at the very latest, on day three,
- 10:14rumors of something have started
- 10:17circulating around the restaurant, but
- 10:20not inside of it.
- 10:22>> That whatever is going on out there
- 10:24>> So something happened outside the
- 10:25building, but people aren't sure what it
- 10:26is yet.
- 10:27And Fazbear Entertainment doesn't know
- 10:29what it is yet either because the day
- 10:30guard hasn't reported anything
- 10:31suspicious. Night four tells us that
- 10:33there's been an investigation opened
- 10:35into whatever the rumors were about. And
- 10:37Ralph tries to downplay the severity of
- 10:39it.
- 10:39>> Uh there's been somewhat of an
- 10:41investigation going on. We may end up
- 10:43having to close for a few days. I don't
- 10:46know.
- 10:47Uh I want to emphasize though that it's
- 10:49really just a precaution. Fazbear
- 10:51Entertainment denies any wrongdoing.
- 10:54These things happen sometimes.
- 10:56Um it will all get sorted out in a few
- 10:57days. Just keep an eye on things and
- 11:00I'll keep you posted.
- 11:01>> So whatever happened is publicly
- 11:03noticeable enough for rumors to form and
- 11:05spread and have enough credibility for
- 11:07at the very least an internal
- 11:09investigation, if not also an
- 11:10investigation by law enforcement. Moving
- 11:12on, Ralph tells us to
- 11:14>> Try to avoid eye contact with any of the
- 11:16animatronics inside if you can. Uh
- 11:19someone may have tampered with their
- 11:20facial recognition systems. We're not
- 11:22sure. But the characters have been
- 11:24acting very unusual, almost aggressive
- 11:27towards the staff.
- 11:28Uh they interact with the kids just
- 11:29fine, but when they encounter an adult,
- 11:31they just
- 11:33stare.
- 11:35>> It can be inferred that whatever the
- 11:36rumors are about has somehow affected
- 11:38the animatronics and the way they
- 11:40interact with adults, notably the staff.
- 11:42So whatever happened at the latest on
- 11:43day three is credible enough because
- 11:45we're seeing changes in the
- 11:46animatronics. Or Phone Guy is right and
- 11:49someone has tampered with them. Night
- 11:51five brings things to a boil. We're told
- 11:52the building is on lockdown with no one
- 11:54allowed in or out, seemingly except for
- 11:56the player character. Phone Guy
- 11:58specifically mentions not to let any
- 11:59previous employees in and that the day
- 12:01shift guard is no longer employed by
- 12:03Fazbear.
- 12:03>> Uh from my understanding, the building
- 12:05is on lockdown. Uh
- 12:07no one is allowed in or out, you know,
- 12:09especially concerning any previous
- 12:11employees.
- 12:12Um when we get it all out, we may move
- 12:15you to the day shift. That position just
- 12:16became
- 12:18available.
- 12:19>> His next line is actually what
- 12:20originally sparked this entire video
- 12:22years ago.
- 12:24>> Yeah, we're going to try to contact the
- 12:25original restaurant owner. Uh, I think
- 12:28the name of the place was
- 12:30Fred Bear's Family Diner or something
- 12:32like that. They've closed for years
- 12:34though, I doubt we'll be able to track
- 12:35anybody down. Uh, so just get through
- 12:38one more night. Uh, hang in there. Good
- 12:40night.
- 12:42>> Okay.
- 12:44This night is a short call but a dense
- 12:46one. The day shift guard is gone. The
- 12:48building is on lockdown. We can put two
- 12:50and two together, see that the events
- 12:52are connected. Whatever happened is
- 12:54somehow connected to that guard. Ralph
- 12:56is telling us not to let him into the
- 12:58building, implies that they are arrested
- 13:00yet, so they are only at the very least
- 13:02suspected of being connected to the
- 13:03incident. I want to make a special note
- 13:05that Ralph does not mention police or
- 13:06law enforcement, just that the building
- 13:08is on lockdown.
- 13:10As I continue, I want you to question
- 13:11why it would be necessary to talk to the
- 13:13owners of Fred Bear's.
- 13:16If night five was a boil, night six is a
- 13:18geyser.
- 13:19And I'll just play it in its entirety.
- 13:25>> Hello, hello. Uh,
- 13:27what on earth are you doing there?
- 13:29Didn't you get the memo?
- 13:31Uh, the place is closed down at least
- 13:33for a while.
- 13:34Someone used one of the suits.
- 13:37We had a spare in the back, a yellow
- 13:38one.
- 13:39Someone used it.
- 13:42None of them are acting right. Listen,
- 13:44just finish your shift. It's safer than
- 13:46trying to leave in the middle of the
- 13:47night. Uh,
- 13:49we have one more event scheduled for
- 13:50tomorrow, a birthday. You'll be on day
- 13:53shift. Wear your uniform.
- 13:55Stay close to the animatronics and make
- 13:57sure they don't hurt anyone, okay? Uh,
- 14:00for now just make it through the night.
- 14:02Uh, when the place eventually opens
- 14:04again, I'll probably take the night
- 14:05shift myself.
- 14:07Okay, good night and good luck.
- 14:09>> Okay.
- 14:09Between nights five and six, someone
- 14:11used a spare yellow suit in the back of
- 14:13the restaurant, and that made the
- 14:15animatronics go haywire. There's a
- 14:16birthday on day seven that the player
- 14:18will be working at, and it's the final
- 14:20event that can publicly happen at this
- 14:22Freddy's for the year 1987 cuz we know
- 14:24the building closes down after this, the
- 14:26toys get scrapped, and the paycheck
- 14:28tells us it's in November, leaving no
- 14:29chance of reopening before the end of
- 14:31the year.
- 14:32Because the animatronics have been
- 14:33walking around during the day this
- 14:34entire time, this day seven party must
- 14:36be the bite of 87. This is not new
- 14:38information. I want you to question one
- 14:40more thing before I move on to some
- 14:42relevant information. If the building is
- 14:44locked down with no previous employees
- 14:46allowed inside,
- 14:48how did the previous day guard get
- 14:50inside [music] to move the suit?
- 14:54This is the security puppet minigame in
- 14:56Pizzeria Sim where we are shown that a
- 14:59child with a green wristband is killed
- 15:01outside of a restaurant in the rain.
- 15:20The puppet tries to follow the girl in
- 15:21the rain
- 15:32and collapses on top of her.
- 15:54This is take cake to the children.
- 16:02A minigame in FNAF 2 where we see a
- 16:04purple man driving up to an isolated
- 16:06child outside the building, kill them,
- 16:08and drive away.
- 16:35>> It's not some grand reveal to say that
- 16:37these two minigames are showing the same
- 16:38event, the death of Charlie and Emily.
- 16:40[music]
- 16:41Isn't even new ground to say that this
- 16:43is the FNAF 2 Freddy's location. Editors
- 16:45note, when I wrote this I fully thought
- 16:48that that was [music] a much more common
- 16:50idea, but I have since found that it is
- 16:52not a very common idea to say that
- 16:55this takes place at the FNAF 2 building.
- 16:58I had forgotten that most people think
- 17:00Charlie 83, which can't happen at the
- 17:03FNAF 2 building, [music] at least during
- 17:05operation. It may not be super common to
- 17:08say that, but I think it is because of
- 17:10[music] reasons that I will get into.
- 17:12Editors note, over. But something that
- 17:15isn't brought up a whole lot, which is
- 17:18seemingly really obvious and probably
- 17:19just taken for granted, is
- 17:22both of these minigames are happening
- 17:23during the day. There's still kids
- 17:25running around. They shift.
- 17:27FNAF 2.
- 17:29Killer drives away without suspicion.
- 17:32This has to happen the week before
- 17:33[music] FNAF 2. Again, it's not a new
- 17:36take to say that Charlie's death is the
- 17:37rumor in FNAF 2, but I've recently been
- 17:39hearing that Charlie dies on night two
- 17:41of the game, and that just can't happen.
- 17:45Ralph already doesn't like the puppet.
- 17:47>> I'll be honest, I never liked that
- 17:48puppet thing.
- 17:49>> He literally says
- 17:51I never liked [music] that puppet thing,
- 17:52implying he's disliked it for more than
- 17:54just one day. Very late, Charlie must
- 17:56die on Friday of the previous week, and
- 17:58at the earliest on Monday, the first day
- 18:00of operation of the New Freddy's.
- 18:02And I think it was on that first day of
- 18:04operation.
- 18:06I'll get to why I think Charlie was
- 18:07killed sooner rather than later in a
- 18:08second, but let's briefly move on to
- 18:10FNAF 4. This is the FNAF 4 minigame map
- 18:13showing the crying child lives close to
- 18:15Fred Bears.
- 18:16Minigames like this have never been to
- 18:18[music] scale, so this one shouldn't be
- 18:19treated as such either.
- 18:21We don't think the Aftons literally live
- 18:23right next to Fredbear's,
- 18:25just that they live close to it.
- 18:27And the Sister Location breaker room map
- 18:29confirms this layout with a simplified
- 18:31map showing the house is close to the
- 18:33Fredbear building and the separate but
- 18:35still connected location houses the FNAF
- 18:374 gameplay house. And we know for a fact
- 18:39that these are real rooms from the
- 18:41Sister Location private room because
- 18:43William is watching them on the cameras.
- 18:45Separate but connected.
- 18:50The bunker can be accessed from inside
- 18:52of Fredbear's.
- 18:56Why is Ralph trying to contact the
- 18:58Fredbear owners?
- 19:00Midnight Motorist is possibly [music]
- 19:02the most infamous minigame in FNAF.
- 19:04We don't have confirmation on anything
- 19:06from this minigame.
- 19:07After speeding down the highway, the
- 19:08player can take a hidden off-ramp where
- 19:10the visual style changes.
- 19:12We see that it's raining as we're
- 19:13driving home. And on the way home, we
- 19:16can stop at what's called the mound.
- 19:18There's no indication that the player
- 19:19knows what it is. There's no dialogue,
- 19:22nothing.
- 19:23All that we, the audience, know
- 19:25is that a grouping of pixels are
- 19:27different from the rest on the ground.
- 19:30After that, we can stop at a building
- 19:31called Junior's
- 19:33where we are stopped at the door and
- 19:34refused entry.
- 19:36The player is not allowed inside.
- 19:39After that, we go home and see someone
- 19:41on the couch watching TV and get told
- 19:43leave him alone, he's had a rough day.
- 20:00At which point we find a way around the
- 20:02back of the house and find a window
- 20:03broken,
- 20:05footprints leading away from the window,
- 20:07and a lone set of animatronic footprints
- 20:10that appear and disappear.
- 20:14I am going to make some claims and I
- 20:16want you to follow me here.
- 20:18Yellow Man is William Afton. Again, I am
- 20:21not treading on any new ground here.
- 20:238-bit mini games can only convey so much
- 20:24information. He's yellow because William
- 20:26Afton has two major colors attributed
- 20:28with him, being both purple for Purple
- 20:30Guy and yellow for Springtrap. To
- 20:31clarify, I'm not saying that he's
- 20:33Springtrap in this mini game, just that
- 20:35it is William Afton.
- 20:37And to show him as purple might have
- 20:39caused some confusion in the timeline
- 20:40because in just the previous game we saw
- 20:43another purple guy, his son Michael.
- 20:46And showing such a simplistic purple
- 20:48sprite would have caused even more
- 20:49timeline confusion than Midnight Motors
- 20:51already has. Also, the rest of the mini
- 20:53game is at night. From a dev
- 20:54perspective, making your main character
- 20:56visually difficult to see is a pretty
- 20:58big no-no.
- 20:59Yellow just contrasts really well. So
- 21:00yes,
- 21:01yellow William.
- 21:02I'll be honest, I'm not entirely sure
- 21:04who the couch person is.
- 21:06I'm inclined to believe that it's Mrs.
- 21:07Afton, but the evidence for it
- 21:09is just that we know that Mike later
- 21:11takes the same pose and [music] watches
- 21:13TV. Maybe it was something he used to do
- 21:14with his mom. But ultimately, I don't
- 21:16think we were ever supposed to give a
- 21:18[ __ ] about who the couch person is.
- 21:20They are a narrative device to show that
- 21:22William is not a good father.
- 21:24Couch person only exists to shut down
- 21:26Will care.
- 21:28I'll tell you who I think it absolutely
- 21:30is not,
- 21:31and that's Henry,
- 21:32which I'll get into in a bit.
- 21:36Finally, the runaway. Not new territory
- 21:38here, but I think it's Michael Afton.
- 21:41Now, I want to clarify that just because
- 21:42I think that Michael Afton is the
- 21:43Midnight Motors runaway does not mean
- 21:46that I think Michael Afton at the time
- 21:47of Midnight Motors is still a child or a
- 21:49younger teenager. Today it is quite
- 21:50common for adults in their early 20s to
- 21:53still be living with their parents, but
- 21:54this was not a common thing in the '80s,
- 21:57which is why I also don't believe that
- 21:59Michael is in his early 20s. Afton's
- 22:01dialogue to me makes it seem like
- 22:02Michael is just barely not old enough to
- 22:04move out yet. So I'd put him at around
- 22:0717 to 18 [music] years old,
- 22:08which lines up
- 22:10with what I'm about to say.
- 22:12I'm pretty sure Midnight Motors takes
- 22:14place during FNAF 2 in 1987. Let's look
- 22:17back at what we've established just from
- 22:19these games and try to paint a picture.
- 22:20When the building goes on lockdown, we
- 22:21are explicitly told not to let in
- 22:23previous employees.
- 22:24>> No one allowed in or
- 22:25>> you know,
- 22:26especially concerning any previous
- 22:28employees.
- 22:29>> Now I ask you,
- 22:31if you were directing a minigame
- 22:32designed to show us the FNAF 2 building,
- 22:34how would you, with the most limited
- 22:36information possible,
- 22:37show the player that this is indeed the
- 22:39FNAF 2 building?
- 22:41Well,
- 22:42the FNAF 2 location is notably the grand
- 22:44reopening, presumably being the first
- 22:46location opened after Prime Freddy's
- 22:47closed. The animatronics specific to
- 22:50this location are much more
- 22:51kid-friendly.
- 22:52>> So Fazbear decided to just go in a whole
- 22:54new direction and make them super
- 22:56kid-friendly.
- 22:58Uh they thought the first one was too
- 22:59scary, so they redesigned them to be
- 23:01more kid-friendly and put them in Kids
- 23:03Cove.
- 23:04>> There's a Kids Cove instead of a Pirates
- 23:06Cove, and they brought back the security
- 23:08puppet to prioritize children's safety.
- 23:10>> Fazbear Entertainment is committed to
- 23:12family fun and above all, safe.
- 23:14>> In all aspects, this location is a
- 23:16Junior Freddy's. So what does Scott do?
- 23:19He slaps a big [ __ ] Junior's sign in
- 23:22the Midnight Motors to tell us that this
- 23:23is an operational FNAF 2 building. But I
- 23:26hear you commenting. Bruv, if Midnight
- 23:28Motors is in 1987 and Afton gets a night
- 23:30entry based around a timeline, that
- 23:32means later that night isn't referring
- 23:34to Charlie. What does that mean?
- 23:35Yes, I hear you and I know. Let me
- 23:37explain. I did not misspeak earlier when
- 23:40I claimed that Charlie dies the week
- 23:41before FNAF 2. We know that at the very
- 23:43least the puppet being active on night
- 23:45one means that Charlie at the latest has
- 23:47to be killed on day one. But we also
- 23:49know based on Ralph's dialogue that it's
- 23:51been at least more than one day since
- 23:53the puppet started acting weird. So at
- 23:54the very latest, she dies the week
- 23:55before.
- 23:56>> I'll be honest, I never liked that
- 23:58puppet thing.
- 23:59>> And the reason I think she dies earlier
- 24:00in that week, specifically on the first
- 24:02day of the location's operation, is
- 24:04because of what I think William Afton's
- 24:05motivation was during this game.
- 24:08This brings me to what I think is almost
- 24:10certainly a massive Scott con.
- 24:12I don't think Scott had concrete
- 24:14motivations in mind for what William was
- 24:16doing during FNAF 2 other than just
- 24:18being an evil bastard. But I think that
- 24:20now, with all the context of the later
- 24:22games, we can say that FNAF 2 definitely
- 24:25has a purpose, and that purpose is
- 24:27Fazburger.
- 24:28If you're unaware, Fazburger is a recent
- 24:30theory that concludes that every major
- 24:31FNAF location is actually on the same
- 24:34plot of land and that Fazbear
- 24:36Entertainment's laziness has just had
- 24:38them reusing old buildings for new
- 24:39purposes.
- 24:41Remember that sister location map I
- 24:42showed you?
- 24:44If Fredbear's became connected to the
- 24:45sister location bunker, I don't think
- 24:47it's a stretch to say that
- 24:49there's probably an entrance to the
- 24:51bunker in that building. We've known for
- 24:53a while now
- 24:54that Mike needs to take an elevator down
- 24:56to get into the bunker, but we've never
- 24:58known where it is.
- 25:00Why would Ralph need to talk to the
- 25:03owners of Fredbear's? Because it's the
- 25:05same building.
- 25:08The FNAF 2 building is a renovated
- 25:10Fredbear's.
- 25:12Remember, Ralph specifically mentions
- 25:15>> Uh talking of worth mentioning is hand
- 25:17of the quirky modern design of the
- 25:19building.
- 25:20>> So we know at the very least the inside
- 25:21of the building is new.
- 25:23It's recently renovated. He tells us.
- 25:26I've always thought that the implication
- 25:28of searching for the owners
- 25:30was supposed to mean that Ralph is going
- 25:31[music] to ask about the spring lock
- 25:32suits.
- 25:33>> Uh we're going to try to contact the
- 25:35original restaurant owner. Uh I think
- 25:37the name of the place was [music]
- 25:39Fredbear's Family Diner or something
- 25:41like that. They've closed for years now.
- 25:43I doubt we'll be able to track anybody
- 25:45down.
- 25:45>> But what would that actually tell us
- 25:47other than Fredbear's existence?
- 25:50Doesn't tell us anything other than a
- 25:51name. Editors note, not only would it
- 25:54not tell us anything in relation to
- 25:56that, but it also happens
- 25:59before the suit gets moved. So we didn't
- 26:02know that there was a suit. We get told
- 26:04about Fredbear's on night five and we
- 26:06get told that the suit is moved on night
- 26:08[music] six. So the timeline wouldn't
- 26:10even match up for that. But if it's the
- 26:11same damn building,
- 26:14it makes me wonder if the investigation
- 26:16found something.
- 26:19Something no one knew about.
- 26:23Something William Afton wanted to keep
- 26:25to himself.
- 26:30I'm going to come right out and say it.
- 26:33I think William Afton's actions if and
- 26:35after were all directly motivated by
- 26:37keeping the sister location bunker and
- 26:39nightmare experiments a secret.
- 26:41When he heard that a new location was
- 26:42being opened in the same building
- 26:44connected to his bunker, he came up with
- 26:46a plan to shut it down on its first day.
- 26:49So he got a job
- 26:50as a guard. But the FNAF 1 newspaper
- 26:52said that William was already caught.
- 26:53Henry would have recognized him.
- 26:56That might be true if it was William who
- 26:58was caught.
- 27:00Henry took the fall for the MCI.
- 27:03Not willingly.
- 27:05But Henry was taken in and presumed to
- 27:07be responsible for the missing kids.
- 27:10Henry wasn't at FNAF 2 to be able to
- 27:11recognize William because Henry was in
- 27:13prison for a crime he never committed.
- 27:16That's why William was able to get a job
- 27:17as the night guard. That's why Ralph had
- 27:19to go looking for the previous owners
- 27:21because no one at the building
- 27:22recognized that a previous owner was in
- 27:25the [ __ ] building. But the killings
- 27:27started happening again
- 27:31while Henry was in prison.
- 27:34And it started with his own daughter.
- 27:39Charlie was the first at this location.
- 27:42She was being picked on and pushed out
- 27:43of the building because it had become a
- 27:44local rumor
- 27:46that her father murdered five children
- 27:47at the previous Freddy's.
- 27:50On the establishment's first actual day
- 27:52of operation, William was the night
- 27:53guard.
- 27:54And we've established that Charlie was
- 27:55killed during the day outside of
- 27:56Freddy's.
- 27:58Remember what we clearly established at
- 28:00the beginning.
- 28:01What does Ralph say?
- 28:03He doesn't say we're the second night
- 28:04guard to work here.
- 28:05>> You're only the second guard to work at
- 28:06that location.
- 28:07>> He says we're the second
- 28:09guard to work here. There was no day
- 28:11guard during the first week. That's how
- 28:13William did it. No one was watching him.
- 28:19Charlie was the first.
- 28:20And the puppet crawled towards her
- 28:21trying to do what it was programmed to
- 28:23do.
- 28:25But it couldn't get through the rain and
- 28:26it collapsed on her corpse.
- 28:30William thought this would certainly
- 28:31close the building [music] down.
- 28:33Under any normal management, it would
- 28:34have. But this is Freddy's.
- 28:37And this is their grand reopening. It
- 28:39would absolutely ruin them if the MCI
- 28:41happened again
- 28:43or anything like it.
- 28:47But thankfully, there's not a precedent
- 28:48for cover-ups.
- 28:59Ah, [ __ ]
- 29:06>> Hello.
- 29:07Hello, hello.
- 29:09I wanted to record a message for you to
- 29:11help you get settled in on your first
- 29:13night. Let's see. First, there's an
- 29:15introductory greeting from the company
- 29:18that I'm supposed to read.
- 29:20It's kind of a legal thing, you know.
- 29:22Fazbear Entertainment is not responsible
- 29:24for damage to property or a person. Upon
- 29:27discovering that damage or death has
- 29:28occurred, a missing person report will
- 29:30be filed within 90 days or as soon as
- 29:32property and premises have been
- 29:34thoroughly cleaned and bleached and the
- 29:36carpets have been replaced. Blah, blah,
- 29:38blah. Now, that might sound bad, I know,
- 29:41but there's really nothing to worry
- 29:42about.
- 29:43>> Fazbear Entertainment found her.
- 29:46Someone in the company found her.
- 29:50And they hit her.
- 29:52They can't report it. It would instantly
- 29:54shut the building down
- 29:55and they'd probably never open again.
- 29:58They would be finished.
- 30:01So they hit the body.
- 30:03[snorts]
- 30:11Buried her in the woods [snorts] near
- 30:12the restaurant.
- 30:14Charlie is the mound.
- 30:17Now, I know that's a massive claim, but
- 30:19let's think about it for a second. I'm
- 30:21not here to try and tackle the MCI
- 30:22itself, so I'll be as all-encompassing
- 30:24as I can be for this. But within reason,
- 30:27I think there's only two people that the
- 30:29mound could be, the fifth MCI kid or
- 30:31Charlie. I have my own reasons for
- 30:34thinking that it is absolutely not the
- 30:36crying child that I will be saving for
- 30:38if I'm demanded to make a theory about
- 30:40FNAF 4.
- 30:41That being said, if you believe in MCI
- 30:4385, then you reasonably believe that the
- 30:46MCI takes place in a completely
- 30:47different building from this. Therefore,
- 30:49the mound probably isn't the 5th MCI
- 30:50kid. Burying the body of one of your
- 30:53child murder victims both near your
- 30:55house and near a building you either own
- 30:57or have previously owned is straight up
- 30:59stupid on William's part. I know that
- 31:01something just being dumb isn't really
- 31:03good evidence to disprove something, but
- 31:05it would be out of character because
- 31:07that would very easily tie him to the
- 31:08body if it was the 5th MCI kid. And if
- 31:11you believe in MCI 83, then this
- 31:13actually could be the 5th MCI kid. As
- 31:15we've established, the FNAF 2 building
- 31:17is Fredbear's. Like I said earlier, the
- 31:198-bit minigames have such a small amount
- 31:20of possible detail. Seeing the mound and
- 31:22saying, well, we can see it, therefore
- 31:25it must be fresh, meaning it can't be
- 31:27from the MCI, is also not a great
- 31:29argument to disprove because if you
- 31:32couldn't see it, you would have no idea
- 31:34it was even there.
- 31:35In other words, if you couldn't see it,
- 31:37it wouldn't exist as a usable piece of
- 31:38information. It existing does not say
- 31:41anything about its freshness. But again,
- 31:43burying the body both near the building
- 31:45itself and your house is the opposite of
- 31:48a smart plan, which is why I don't think
- 31:50William buried this mound.
- 31:52I think someone at Fazbear did it to
- 31:55cover up Charlie's found body.
- 31:58>> Fazbear Entertainment is not responsible
- 32:00for damage to property or a person. Upon
- 32:03discovering that damage or death has
- 32:04occurred, a missing person report will
- 32:06be filed within 90 days or as soon as
- 32:08property and premises have been
- 32:10thoroughly cleaned and bleached and the
- 32:12carpets have been replaced. Blah, blah,
- 32:14blah.
- 32:14>> I'd like to believe it wasn't Ralph
- 32:16because he genuinely sounds surprised
- 32:18and out of the loop in the phone calls.
- 32:20>> Ho, ho, ho.
- 32:22What on earth are you doing there?
- 32:24Didn't you get the memo?
- 32:25>> But if it was Ralph, that could low-key
- 32:27explain why he dies in FNAF 1.
- 32:31Ralph being the person to bury Charlie
- 32:35could also be the incident that
- 32:37disillusions him.
- 32:40We see his progression as a character of
- 32:43someone who very much drinks the Fazbear
- 32:45Kool-Aid into someone that knows.
- 32:49>> The only parts of me that would likely
- 32:50see the light of day again would be your
- 32:52eyeballs and teeth when they pop out the
- 32:53front of the mask.
- 32:56Yeah, they don't tell you these things
- 32:57when you sign up.
- 32:58>> This could be it. We've always wondered
- 33:00what it was other than just seeing
- 33:02little things over the years. This would
- 33:04be a pretty big [ __ ] thing to see,
- 33:07not just see, but to do.
- 33:09I think with everything we've
- 33:10established, Charlie makes sense from a
- 33:13narrative perspective and a time
- 33:15perspective. Someone in Fazbear hides
- 33:17the body and continues operating as
- 33:19normal, but eventually someone outside
- 33:23notices that Charlie is missing.
- 33:25I think it's important that genuinely no
- 33:26one sees the murder and that hiding the
- 33:29body goes off without a hitch, otherwise
- 33:31I don't think the rumors would spread
- 33:33the way that they did.
- 33:35A kid going missing starts rumors.
- 33:38Finding a kid body gets the place shut
- 33:40down. Even further than that,
- 33:43a kid going missing with her last known
- 33:46location being the newly reopened
- 33:48restaurant that has a family history of
- 33:51missing kids,
- 33:54that sets rumors on fire. Regardless of
- 33:57who,
- 33:58the body is hidden,
- 34:00which is why William continues working
- 34:01at the building. He needs to shut it
- 34:03down or else his experiments will be
- 34:04found.
- 34:06So he does something that he knows will
- 34:08get it shut down.
- 34:11He commits the DCI.
- 34:14Five dead bodies spaced throughout the
- 34:16restaurant.
- 34:18There's no way the building doesn't shut
- 34:20down.
- 34:22And I think it's purposefully five.
- 34:25It's not the MCI.
- 34:27It's specifically supposed to look like
- 34:29the MCI.
- 34:31I think something that everyone has just
- 34:32assumed about William
- 34:35is that Charlie was some sort of revenge
- 34:36killing or ego killing.
- 34:39What if Charlie wasn't on purpose at
- 34:41all?
- 34:42What if Afton was always going to kill
- 34:45the first kid he saw?
- 34:47And Charlie being there was just a
- 34:48coincidence.
- 34:51I don't even think Afton knew who
- 34:54Charlie was when he killed her.
- 34:57And I think him committing the DCI
- 35:00could be interpreted as supporting that.
- 35:02Five dead kids in the newly opened
- 35:05restaurant.
- 35:06Henry's in jail for the MCI and just
- 35:08doing it exactly the same would tell the
- 35:10police that they've got the wrong man.
- 35:11So William only makes it similar to the
- 35:14MCI.
- 35:16That's why it's five new dead kids.
- 35:19That's why the DCI ultimately never
- 35:21shows up again. The goal was never
- 35:23possession.
- 35:24He purposely didn't stuff the bodies.
- 35:27The whole point was to make it look like
- 35:29there was a copycat killer, but William
- 35:31messed up
- 35:33and killed the wrong kid,
- 35:35Henry's kid. Charlie going missing
- 35:38is what gets Henry released. Now, I know
- 35:40that me saying that everyone just
- 35:42assumed William would recognize Charlie
- 35:44and that she was specifically killed
- 35:46because her dad is Henry has just as
- 35:48much evidence as me saying that he did
- 35:50not recognize her and that [music] it
- 35:52was not on purpose. Again, I think this
- 35:55is probably a Scott con. Hell, we know
- 35:57that Charlie as a whole is surrounded by
- 35:59Scott cons because Charlie was
- 36:00originally a boy in Take Cake. I don't
- 36:02think it's very ridiculous to guess
- 36:05something that is equally as likely as
- 36:07the first thing
- 36:08to be the real interpretation. I think
- 36:10there is just as much evidence that
- 36:12William knew who Charlie was and killed
- 36:15her because of who she was as there is
- 36:17evidence that he did not know who she
- 36:20was and he just killed the first kid
- 36:22that he saw on their own. Anyway,
- 36:24the DCI shuts down the building and
- 36:26later that night William goes home and
- 36:29finds that his son Michael has run off.
- 36:31Michael being the runaway begs the
- 36:33question, where is he running off to?
- 36:37If Charlie is the mound, then he's
- 36:38probably not running to the mound and
- 36:40I have reason to think the crying child
- 36:43is somewhere else entirely. I think he's
- 36:46running to the FNAF 2 building. When the
- 36:48DCI happened, Charlie called on the one
- 36:52thing that can teleport in and out
- 36:55to go find the nearest person that they
- 36:57could,
- 36:58Golden Freddy.
- 37:01Golden Freddy appeared in front of
- 37:03Michael Afton's window,
- 37:05beckoning to follow. So Michael did
- 37:08because of his history with that
- 37:10character.
- 37:14And when he got to the building,
- 37:15he finds five bodies,
- 37:18six pools of blood.
- 37:20Not literally, but that's what we are
- 37:23shown
- 37:24in the minigame.
- 37:27We were supposed to know
- 37:30there's a body missing.
- 37:33Michael has heard the rumors of the
- 37:35missing girl.
- 37:38And when he doesn't find her,
- 37:41he comes back the next night as the new
- 37:43night guard,
- 37:44Fritz Smith. He tampers with the
- 37:45animatronics looking for and gets fired.
- 37:49But
- 37:50he won't be able to find her
- 37:52cuz she's already be buried
- 37:55and gone.
- 37:58Yes, I fully understand that William's
- 38:00reaction to finding out that Michael is
- 38:01about to find the DCI bodies does not
- 38:04make sense if that's what's happening.
- 38:05But let's think about what that even
- 38:07means. We know William does not care
- 38:09about his kids, and there's no way for
- 38:11Michael to figure out that William is
- 38:12responsible.
- 38:13After all, he was just speeding home on
- 38:15the highway. To him, no one could figure
- 38:17out that it was him. If this is the way
- 38:19it went down, I think it's entirely
- 38:20possible that William just did not care
- 38:23if Michael found the bodies because A,
- 38:25there's no way for Michael to directly
- 38:26connect it to William, and B, William's
- 38:29plan was going to work this time.
- 38:31So it wouldn't matter anyway cuz he's
- 38:33going to get what he wants. I'm trying
- 38:35very hard to avoid assuming character
- 38:37traits like ego or drunkenness because
- 38:39that gets away from facts and it gets
- 38:42very fan ficky. But ego is a trait we've
- 38:45seen William demonstrate. For example,
- 38:46in Pizzeria Sim's dialogue.
- 38:48>> What
- 38:48>> a deceptive calling.
- 38:51I knew it was a lie the moment I heard
- 38:53it, obviously. But it is intriguing
- 38:57nonetheless. How can I resist
- 39:00a promise such as this?
- 39:04That was easier than I thought it would
- 39:07be.
- 39:07>> So it's not an out of nowhere
- 39:09characteristic to say his ego and belief
- 39:11in his own abilities could make the tone
- 39:13of his Midnight Motorist dialogue make
- 39:15more sense.
- 39:19Okay, that was
- 39:21a lot.
- 39:23Like
- 39:23a lot, a lot longer than I was expecting
- 39:25it to be. But I really like the place
- 39:27this ends and what it tells me about
- 39:29FNAF 2 as a whole. The game has always
- 39:31felt like it lacked a purpose
- 39:33narratively other than telling us events
- 39:35leading up to the bite. There's been so
- 39:37many versions of what the rumors were
- 39:38and what got the building locked down.
- 39:41And
- 39:42I think I've been able to answer them as
- 39:43well as answer a few more questions, but
- 39:45most notably, Scott has gone out and
- 39:48said that he
- 39:50doesn't really
- 39:52like the way he made specifically FNAF 2
- 39:56and that that was a really stressful
- 39:57time for him. I think, like I said, that
- 40:00he made the game before making the
- 40:04story. But regardless of what the
- 40:06original intention was,
- 40:08unless he comes out and says, hey, I'm
- 40:10making FNAF 2 again,
- 40:12here's the new game, take this one as
- 40:14canon,
- 40:16we have to deal with what's left in this
- 40:18game. So I think this ends up Scott
- 40:21conning quite a lot in order to
- 40:24make the timeline make a bit more sense.
- 40:27Um
- 40:28I want to bring up the most valid
- 40:30criticism I could think of with this. If
- 40:33Charlie was found and her death was
- 40:34covered up, then what actually gets
- 40:36William fired in the first place?
- 40:39And to that I say, William was tampering
- 40:42with the animatronics. We've seen that
- 40:44tampering with them is an immediately
- 40:46firable offense [music] and the way that
- 40:48the dialogue in Midnight Murderer shows
- 40:51if I was a bouncer and the person that I
- 40:54needed to shoo away
- 40:56was suspected of killing a kid,
- 40:59I would not talk to them that way. I
- 41:01would talk to them differently. While
- 41:03yeah, that might be personally me, it
- 41:05almost seems like William was caught
- 41:07doing something that was against HR. It
- 41:10does not seem like he was caught doing
- 41:12something as serious as murdering a kid.
- 41:14Now, most of this is probably wrong, but
- 41:16it was really really fun to think about
- 41:17this as a theory and as a video to
- 41:19actually make. I've tried making a FNAF
- 41:21theory before and I ended up debunking
- 41:22my own theory while writing that,
- 41:25which is why the video was never made,
- 41:26but I figured for my 200 subscriber
- 41:27special that I should make something
- 41:29that I find really special and
- 41:30officially make myself a part of the
- 41:32theory community I watched from afar for
- 41:35over a decade now and it's really cool
- 41:37that I'm technically now a part of it,
- 41:39even if the entire theory itself might
- 41:41be dog [ __ ] Anyway,
- 41:42if you like it, make sure to tell me by
- 41:44liking and subscribing and commenting.
- 41:46Specifically comment because then you
- 41:48can actually tell me thoughts.
- 41:50Anyway,
- 41:51that's about it.
- 41:52See you.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of FNAF 2 makes sense now by Bruv2425, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 7,458 words across 1,204 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.