YouTube2Text

Finishing Cardano — Transcript

by Charles Hoskinson · 4,910 words · 886 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00Hi, this is Charles Hoskinson,
  2. 0:02broadcasting live from warm, sunny
  3. 0:04Colorado. I wanted to make a quick video
  4. 0:06to talk a little bit about some
  5. 0:08statements I made and um
  6. 0:11just where we're at in Cardano. You
  7. 0:13know, I uh was in an AMA and I was asked
  8. 0:15about finishing Cardano and I said yes,
  9. 0:17the road map is done, my job is done
  10. 0:19with Cardano.
  11. 0:21And what I've noticed is there's this
  12. 0:23enormous tsunami wave of people floating
  13. 0:25around saying, oh well that's the rug
  14. 0:27pull, Charles scammed us, Charles is
  15. 0:29evil, he he failed, Cardano is a failed
  16. 0:31project, Charles is leaving Cardano.
  17. 0:34And you know, the thing about it is that
  18. 0:36you can't win with
  19. 0:38what people say and do. But you know, I
  20. 0:40I want to make sure that there's
  21. 0:42absolutely no ambiguity whatsoever with
  22. 0:45my statements.
  23. 0:46And hang on a second, I just lost my
  24. 0:49screen. [sighs]
  25. 0:52Sorry everybody.
  26. 0:55My AI opened up something.
  27. 1:00There we go. Okay, I want to make sure
  28. 1:02there's absolutely no ambiguity with my
  29. 1:04statements.
  30. 1:05So
  31. 1:06let's look at 2015.
  32. 1:08There was a crowd sale conducted by
  33. 1:10Emurgo
  34. 1:12to sell ADA into Japan.
  35. 1:15The price for this was less than 0.2
  36. 1:18cents per ADA. This is publicly
  37. 1:20verified. There was an independent audit
  38. 1:22done by BDO and by MWE.
  39. 1:25All the facts and circumstances, well
  40. 1:27more than 100 pages of documentation
  41. 1:29showcasing all of that. And Bitcoin was
  42. 1:31actually used as the settlement system
  43. 1:33for this. They bought in yen and sold in
  44. 1:35Bitcoin.
  45. 1:36So there's even on-chain records of the
  46. 1:38sales tranche. The total amount of money
  47. 1:40raised was $72 million.
  48. 1:43We got $36 million
  49. 1:45input output.
  50. 1:47And we got 8% of the supply of ADA.
  51. 1:50At that valuation,
  52. 1:52which there was no liquidity, wasn't
  53. 1:54listed anywhere, the ICO price, it was a
  54. 1:56you know, less than $6 million,
  55. 1:58give or take.
  56. 2:01And it got listed on Binance and
  57. 2:02Bittrex, um and for a long, long time
  58. 2:04ADA sat at 4 cents or less.
  59. 2:07There were three entities
  60. 2:09involved in the founding of Cardano, the
  61. 2:11Cardano Foundation, Emurgo, and Input
  62. 2:14Output.
  63. 2:15It was very clear what the division of
  64. 2:17responsibilities were between these
  65. 2:18three entities. No ambiguity whatsoever.
  66. 2:21We, Input Output, were responsible for
  67. 2:24engineering, science,
  68. 2:27and getting the protocol functional.
  69. 2:29Launching the protocol.
  70. 2:31So anything technical
  71. 2:33came to our side.
  72. 2:34The Foundation was supposed to set up
  73. 2:36the governance of Cardano and be
  74. 2:38responsible for aggregating the
  75. 2:40community and all things community
  76. 2:42and also the government relations.
  77. 2:45And Emurgo was responsible for adoption.
  78. 2:48There was a 20% pre-mine.
  79. 2:5112% of the entire supply was allocated
  80. 2:54to CF and Emurgo.
  81. 2:56The other $36 million was given to the
  82. 2:59CF and Emurgo in Bitcoin.
  83. 3:03The total amount of Bitcoin was over
  84. 3:05100,000 Bitcoin because Yen at the time
  85. 3:07and Bitcoin at the time, that's just the
  86. 3:09way the Forex worked.
  87. 3:11So more than 50,000 Bitcoin went to
  88. 3:13Emurgo and the CF.
  89. 3:16Okay? 12% of the supply of ADA, 50%
  90. 3:20of that for their duties and
  91. 3:21responsibilities.
  92. 3:23So what did we do with it? We built a
  93. 3:24network that went from a $72 million
  94. 3:26valuation to the all-time high, $100
  95. 3:29billion. Even in its deflated,
  96. 3:32everybody's saying it's destroyed and
  97. 3:33it's a dead coin and all these other
  98. 3:35things, it's $6 billion. It went from 72
  99. 3:37to 6.
  100. 3:40We delivered a fully decentralized
  101. 3:41ecosystem,
  102. 3:43recursively self-improving.
  103. 3:45We left behind a community led and owned
  104. 3:49Treasury that at the all-time high had
  105. 3:51$4 billion of value in it.
  106. 3:55And initiated a constitution.
  107. 3:58So every user has rights.
  108. 4:00So So have D-Reps, a constitutional
  109. 4:01committee,
  110. 4:03a treasury that at the all-time high had
  111. 4:04$4 billion,
  112. 4:07and built multiple governance
  113. 4:08organizations like Intersect, for
  114. 4:10example, a members-based organization.
  115. 4:14And I've dedicated 11 years of my life
  116. 4:17since 2015 to now
  117. 4:20to watch all this go through.
  118. 4:22Every scandal,
  119. 4:24every fork, every bug,
  120. 4:28Gary Gensler suing and subpoenaing
  121. 4:30everybody, I was there for every single
  122. 4:32moment.
  123. 4:34And I had to step into roles again and
  124. 4:36again that we were never comfortable
  125. 4:37with or compensated for.
  126. 4:39We did not receive the 50,000 plus
  127. 4:41Bitcoin and the 12% of the ADA supply
  128. 4:44for marketing and adoption,
  129. 4:46but we tried
  130. 4:47for over 11 years, every step of the
  131. 4:49way, to do some of these things.
  132. 4:52So I deliver the protocol that grows
  133. 4:54from 72 million to now 6 billion at the
  134. 4:56all-time high, four times larger than
  135. 4:58Honda.
  136. 4:59We invent brand new technology like
  137. 5:01Ouroboros and extended UTXO and the
  138. 5:04first to bring uh a Turing complete
  139. 5:06programming language to
  140. 5:08UTXO, Plutus.
  141. 5:10We built an entire on-chain governance
  142. 5:12system, wrote a constitution, got the
  143. 5:14entire community involved, and created a
  144. 5:16recursively self-improving system that's
  145. 5:18fully decentralized, the most
  146. 5:19decentralized cryptocurrency on the
  147. 5:21planet.
  148. 5:23And then you say I'm a scammer and we
  149. 5:25have failed.
  150. 5:27And you say it because adoption didn't
  151. 5:29happen.
  152. 5:30I was never given
  153. 5:32the billions of dollars, the many
  154. 5:34billions of dollars that were allocated
  155. 5:36for adoption.
  156. 5:38Had I been given that,
  157. 5:39then you could of course fairly judge me
  158. 5:42for these things.
  159. 5:43But it was never given to me.
  160. 5:45It unambiguously and verified by audit
  161. 5:48was given to the Cardano Foundation and
  162. 5:50Emurgo and you, the community,
  163. 5:54with a treasury that at its all-time
  164. 5:55high had billions of dollars of value in
  165. 5:57it.
  166. 5:59Along the way, I'd make recommendations
  167. 6:00like let's start a sovereign wealth
  168. 6:02fund.
  169. 6:03You, the community, rejected these
  170. 6:04things. Not me.
  171. 6:08So you have to
  172. 6:09separate the forest from the trees here,
  173. 6:11and you have to understand that we as an
  174. 6:13engineering company did our job.
  175. 6:15And
  176. 6:16100% of the time, 10 out of 10 times, if
  177. 6:18given these facts, somebody said at the
  178. 6:21beginning, would you bet on IO to
  179. 6:22deliver? They'd say yes, because we
  180. 6:25delivered.
  181. 6:26And we went above and beyond
  182. 6:28many things.
  183. 6:31And I have to draw a line here.
  184. 6:33Then I say Cardano is complete in that I
  185. 6:35can build things that I want to do on
  186. 6:37it, the things to bank the unbanked, the
  187. 6:40things to give you your privacy back.
  188. 6:42And I'll tell you, I built Midnight, we
  189. 6:44put it on Cardano, and the very same
  190. 6:46people who said I've defrauded the
  191. 6:48community say that Midnight is not a
  192. 6:50Cardano project.
  193. 6:53I don't understand
  194. 6:56the purpose of Cardano then, if Midnight
  195. 6:58is not a Cardano project.
  196. 7:00Cardano is a smart contract system.
  197. 7:04The intention of the system is for
  198. 7:06people to write applications that run on
  199. 7:09it.
  200. 7:10The Glacier Drop used Hydra.
  201. 7:13100% of the night's supply is on
  202. 7:16Cardano.
  203. 7:18So
  204. 7:19everything about Midnight was built
  205. 7:21around Cardano.
  206. 7:23If this is not a Cardano application,
  207. 7:27I have to honestly ask you then,
  208. 7:29what is?
  209. 7:32And why would anyone in their right mind
  210. 7:34want to build on Cardano? Why?
  211. 7:37What is the purpose of it?
  212. 7:40You cannot treat your builders this way,
  213. 7:42and you can't say these things.
  214. 7:45We did not receive any venture capital
  215. 7:47as a result of the Cardano affiliation
  216. 7:48for building Midnight.
  217. 7:51We were behind on the integrations.
  218. 7:54Many cases in Ireland.
  219. 7:56We didn't receive any support from the
  220. 7:58foundation of Cardano to build on
  221. 8:00Cardano, but we still chose to do so
  222. 8:03to bring users into Cardano, new users
  223. 8:05into Cardano, new TVL, new volume into
  224. 8:08Cardano.
  225. 8:09We're a builder on the Cardano
  226. 8:11ecosystem, Midnight.
  227. 8:15So
  228. 8:17I'm sorry, it's tough love.
  229. 8:20You complain that adoption hasn't
  230. 8:22happened,
  231. 8:23yet do not hold accountable the entities
  232. 8:25that were given literally billions of
  233. 8:27dollars to do that.
  234. 8:29You come and attack the protocol
  235. 8:30developer that built the foundations
  236. 8:32upon which everything sits, who
  237. 8:34delivered the roadmap.
  238. 8:36And then when the protocol developer
  239. 8:38goes into the adoption business to bring
  240. 8:40adoption into Cardano,
  241. 8:43you then attack the protocol developer
  242. 8:46for bringing adoption into Cardano.
  243. 8:49What the is wrong with you?
  244. 8:52Honestly speaking,
  245. 8:56you have to stop.
  246. 8:59You are killing any
  247. 9:01effort or semblance to make this
  248. 9:03protocol successful.
  249. 9:05You have to stop.
  250. 9:07Take a step back and de-escalate. Stop.
  251. 9:13You're making this an actively hostile
  252. 9:15ecosystem to build on.
  253. 9:17You have to stop.
  254. 9:19It's become untenable.
  255. 9:21The Ada Vouchers scandal, the pathetic
  256. 9:25pettiness with the foundation, the fact
  257. 9:28that we take a VC disadvantage and an
  258. 9:30integration disadvantage again and again
  259. 9:32and again.
  260. 9:33These are hard things to deal with as a
  261. 9:35builder.
  262. 9:37And I try my best to navigate them, but
  263. 9:39I can't also have people then say we've
  264. 9:41rug pulled the community, and then when
  265. 9:43we go to build to create adoption in the
  266. 9:45community,
  267. 9:46that this is a problem.
  268. 9:49If Midnight is successful, a Cardano
  269. 9:52project is successful.
  270. 9:56Isn't that the purpose of Cardano to be
  271. 9:58built on?
  272. 10:02So you got to stop.
  273. 10:05You really have to.
  274. 10:07I'm very proud of my record, and I'm not
  275. 10:09going to allow the record to be
  276. 10:11tarred and feathered.
  277. 10:13And I'm very proud of the work that our
  278. 10:15people have done and the enormous effort
  279. 10:17that has gone into
  280. 10:19building a cryptocurrency,
  281. 10:20decentralizing a cryptocurrency, and
  282. 10:23training up a group of people who can
  283. 10:24actually run it independent of us, as
  284. 10:27evidenced by the independent nodes, the
  285. 10:29Constitution, the D Rep, the
  286. 10:31Constitutional Committee, and the fact
  287. 10:33that we can coexist with factions and
  288. 10:35entities that disagree with each other
  289. 10:37philosophically and fundamentally.
  290. 10:39I'm very proud that off of a $36 million
  291. 10:42budget, we were able to build a
  292. 10:44multi-billion dollar ecosystem.
  293. 10:47Very proud of that through many
  294. 10:49different challenging economies,
  295. 10:51through the scandals and fraud of FTX
  296. 10:53and Luna,
  297. 10:54through Gary Gensler burning us all
  298. 10:56down, through COVID.
  299. 10:5999% of projects that were started in
  300. 11:012015 are dead today. Cardano is still
  301. 11:03alive today. And we had many
  302. 11:05disadvantages. And I'm proud to be a
  303. 11:08builder on Cardano.
  304. 11:11This community has to acknowledge its
  305. 11:13builders, invest in its builders, and
  306. 11:15believe in its builders, or else they'll
  307. 11:17go.
  308. 11:19So now I'm going from building Cardano
  309. 11:22to building on Cardano.
  310. 11:25The road map is not being abandoned.
  311. 11:27There are dozens of firms that we worked
  312. 11:29for over two years painstakingly with to
  313. 11:32get them into a readiness state so that
  314. 11:35every line of code they understand and
  315. 11:37every line of code they can write.
  316. 11:38And they want to take over these parts
  317. 11:41of the protocol.
  318. 11:42Daedalus stagnated under input output.
  319. 11:45Now it is thriving under Seven Labs.
  320. 11:47With multi-node uh implementations, you
  321. 11:50now have choices with Rust and with Go
  322. 11:54and Haskell.
  323. 11:56There's multiple languages. You have the
  324. 11:58old school Plutus and you have Aiken and
  325. 12:00other things. You have choices.
  326. 12:04And those choices are being built not by
  327. 12:06one company, not by one founder, but by
  328. 12:09dozens of companies, dozens of founders
  329. 12:12held accountable by
  330. 12:14coalitions,
  331. 12:15by members based organizations.
  332. 12:19That is decentralization. That is a
  333. 12:21choice. That's an option. And that's the
  334. 12:22infrastructure of Cardano.
  335. 12:24And once Leos is in, the last parts of
  336. 12:27what we're responsible for are over.
  337. 12:30The next chapter is input output, the
  338. 12:32builder
  339. 12:33on Cardano.
  340. 12:35The things on Cardano.
  341. 12:38And Midnight is the vanguard.
  342. 12:40It's our most exciting product alongside
  343. 12:42Midnight City.
  344. 12:44And it brings agents and privacy and all
  345. 12:46kinds of amazing and wonderful things
  346. 12:49into the Cardano orbit.
  347. 12:51Alongside Bitcoin DeFi brings lots of
  348. 12:53wonderful things into the Cardano orbit.
  349. 12:56That's where our primary focus is. The
  350. 12:58success of these things will bring
  351. 13:00millions of users and billions of
  352. 13:01dollars into the Cardano orbit.
  353. 13:05You are complaining that Cardano is a
  354. 13:07dead project based upon its DeFi volume,
  355. 13:10its TVL, and its transactions.
  356. 13:13And then you come and attack me and say
  357. 13:15I'm doing nothing when literally I'm
  358. 13:17pivoting to spend my entire life
  359. 13:19building these types of things.
  360. 13:24And you provide no funding, no support.
  361. 13:31What the hell do you want?
  362. 13:35It's an extraordinary thing. It's just
  363. 13:37extraordinary. And
  364. 13:39I understand that the space is so
  365. 13:42pathologically corrupt and there's so
  366. 13:44many dishonest people, you can no longer
  367. 13:47distinguish good from bad, fact from
  368. 13:50fiction. And you just assume armchair
  369. 13:52that everything's a lie.
  370. 13:54You know what? We have to be different.
  371. 13:56If Cardano is going to survive and
  372. 13:58thrive, we can no longer admit this type
  373. 14:02of behavior and tolerate it.
  374. 14:04We have to be a different ecosystem.
  375. 14:07We have to be a place where people are
  376. 14:09willing to build, and when they build,
  377. 14:11it's acknowledged.
  378. 14:13And And to be a place that is
  379. 14:15fact-based.
  380. 14:18I'm not running from a responsibility
  381. 14:20that I had.
  382. 14:2250,000 Bitcoin
  383. 14:25and 12% of the supply of ADA was
  384. 14:28allocated to those responsibilities for
  385. 14:30other entities.
  386. 14:33Go talk to them and ask them for a
  387. 14:34report card over the 11 years that they
  388. 14:38were responsible for doing this.
  389. 14:40No reasonable human
  390. 14:43would say that when you're building a
  391. 14:45house
  392. 14:46that because the electrician didn't
  393. 14:48deliver that you should go sue the
  394. 14:50plumber.
  395. 14:51No reasonable person would do that.
  396. 14:54I did my job. I built the infrastructure
  397. 14:57alongside thousands of people who
  398. 14:59dedicated a decade of their life.
  399. 15:03We got the science done. We built novel
  400. 15:04and interesting protocols and we were
  401. 15:06ahead of the curve with non-
  402. 15:08non-custodial liquid staking. We were
  403. 15:10ahead of the curve with extended UTXO,
  404. 15:12ahead of the curve with our layer two
  405. 15:13model in Hydra, ahead of the curve with
  406. 15:16our on-chain governance.
  407. 15:17Hundreds of things we were ahead of the
  408. 15:19curve on.
  409. 15:21We had prescience.
  410. 15:23And where we were not where we needed to
  411. 15:25be was on adoption and marketing.
  412. 15:29Our competitors were able to take
  413. 15:30advantage of that and they used it to
  414. 15:32make Cardano a meme
  415. 15:34and attack us.
  416. 15:36And there was nobody on the other side
  417. 15:37to fight back.
  418. 15:39And I was alone for many years
  419. 15:42here behind this microphone doing AMA
  420. 15:44after AMA, fighting as hard as I could
  421. 15:46and traveling over 200 days a year
  422. 15:50as my grandparents died,
  423. 15:52missing my family,
  424. 15:53watching my parents get older
  425. 15:57in the trenches, in the field fighting
  426. 16:00Cardano, Cardano, Cardano, Cardano,
  427. 16:02Cardano. I wasn't paid to do that.
  428. 16:05I did it because I believed in the
  429. 16:06protocol and I believe in the vision.
  430. 16:10And I believe in the technology. I
  431. 16:11believe we have something special.
  432. 16:14And after 11 years of doing that, I said
  433. 16:16I now have to on to other things,
  434. 16:19building on Cardano,
  435. 16:22building cryptocurrency projects,
  436. 16:24solving new problems,
  437. 16:26because there's people now to solve the
  438. 16:27old problems who are better, more agile,
  439. 16:30more cost effective, and more
  440. 16:32representative of the community as a
  441. 16:34whole.
  442. 16:35This is not a new thing. You've been
  443. 16:37told this
  444. 16:39in 2023, in 2024, in 2025, and now again
  445. 16:43in 2026.
  446. 16:47For years and years and years, we have
  447. 16:48said this.
  448. 16:50We have worked. We have planned. We have
  449. 16:52done these things.
  450. 16:55There's overwhelming evidence for that.
  451. 16:59So grow up
  452. 17:02and understand you have been given a
  453. 17:04decentralized ecosystem
  454. 17:06with decentralized governance and a
  455. 17:08decentralized treasury.
  456. 17:10You pick and choose your leaders and you
  457. 17:11hold them accountable accordingly.
  458. 17:16And you also have to understand there
  459. 17:18were three entities in the beginning,
  460. 17:20and you can give each of those entities
  461. 17:22a report card.
  462. 17:24I take full responsibility for the
  463. 17:25protocol mistakes. I take full
  464. 17:27responsibility for the inflexibility of
  465. 17:30certain things such as the languages or
  466. 17:32certain approaches. I take full
  467. 17:34responsibility for slow delivery. I take
  468. 17:36so full responsibility for not getting
  469. 17:39things out as quickly as we needed.
  470. 17:41Absolutely fair.
  471. 17:44I cannot take responsibility for the
  472. 17:46lack of adoption
  473. 17:48because it was not our responsibility.
  474. 17:51It never was.
  475. 17:53You can never find a single document,
  476. 17:55statement otherwise.
  477. 17:58It makes no sense.
  478. 18:02And even though it wasn't our
  479. 18:03responsibility, we did what we could.
  480. 18:06We tried
  481. 18:08with the Cardano effect.
  482. 18:11We did what we could with Cardano 360.
  483. 18:13We did what we could with the AMAs. We
  484. 18:16did what we could
  485. 18:18going to the conferences and
  486. 18:19representing. We did what we could the
  487. 18:20thousands of interviews. We did what we
  488. 18:22could working with the ambassadors, the
  489. 18:25ITN members, and every other person
  490. 18:27along the way.
  491. 18:29We did what we could
  492. 18:31with our former employees going and
  493. 18:33starting firms and building things. We
  494. 18:35did what we could with the $25 million
  495. 18:37that we put into the C fund. Again, none
  496. 18:39of this was our obligation, legal or
  497. 18:41otherwise, responsibility, but we chose
  498. 18:43to do this over 11 years.
  499. 18:45And it slowly drained the life out of my
  500. 18:47company.
  501. 18:49I had to be a protocol builder, a
  502. 18:51scientist, a marketer,
  503. 18:53a governance expert,
  504. 18:55a government bureaucracy, and a startup
  505. 18:57all at the same time.
  506. 19:00We didn't complain about it. We worked
  507. 19:02at it. We put a lot of effort into it,
  508. 19:04and every day we showed up for more than
  509. 19:06a decade. And my reward
  510. 19:08was to have this community, some members
  511. 19:10of it, accuse us of stealing money with
  512. 19:13the Ada vouchers. And after exonerated,
  513. 19:15no apologies were ever given. The
  514. 19:17governing foundation of this ecosystem
  515. 19:20knew beyond a reasonable doubt that we
  516. 19:22never stole any money,
  517. 19:23yet did not make any effort
  518. 19:26to dampen the fires
  519. 19:28because they thought they could get
  520. 19:29political points.
  521. 19:30That was my reward for these investments
  522. 19:32that we've put in.
  523. 19:34And I told you, after that event, things
  524. 19:36are different now
  525. 19:38and will forever be different now.
  526. 19:41And I have to look and judge Cardano by
  527. 19:43what it does today
  528. 19:45in its competitive capabilities today.
  529. 19:47And despite these things, I chose to
  530. 19:49build Midnight on Cardano.
  531. 19:54I told you I was going to build these
  532. 19:55things.
  533. 19:57In 2016, I wrote a paper called Why
  534. 19:59Cardano?
  535. 20:01And in it, I had Cardano SL and Cardano
  536. 20:03CL. And I said there's one settlement
  537. 20:05chain and there's multiple control
  538. 20:06layers.
  539. 20:08And I said the partner chains model
  540. 20:10for over 10 years.
  541. 20:12Every day we showed up and told you that
  542. 20:15we want to build control layers,
  543. 20:16secondary systems. This is what Cardano
  544. 20:19is built for.
  545. 20:21Despite these things, then you say we
  546. 20:22launch midnight. Midnight has nothing to
  547. 20:24do with Cardano.
  548. 20:27This is my lived experience.
  549. 20:31And if you ask any objective independent
  550. 20:34builder to have this lived experience on
  551. 20:36our system when there are 18,000 other
  552. 20:37options,
  553. 20:39you have to honestly ask yourself,
  554. 20:41do we have a future?
  555. 20:43So you have to stop.
  556. 20:45And you have to start using the ballot
  557. 20:47box to hold people accountable
  558. 20:50who are accountable, who purport to be.
  559. 20:54You have to start using the ballot box
  560. 20:56to get people into positions to be
  561. 20:58responsible for that growth and
  562. 21:00adoption.
  563. 21:02And you have to start using the ballot
  564. 21:03box to really make decisions about the
  565. 21:05people you want to lead the ecosystem as
  566. 21:07a whole.
  567. 21:09And for the people who are agents of
  568. 21:11chaos and spread chaos and lies, you
  569. 21:14have to make decisions whether you
  570. 21:15legitimize them or
  571. 21:17block them.
  572. 21:19There was no reason for the ADA voucher
  573. 21:21scandal to have existed. It was
  574. 21:23manufactured
  575. 21:25and used by the enemies of the protocol
  576. 21:28to damage our ecosystem.
  577. 21:32And in many ways, they were deeply
  578. 21:33successful.
  579. 21:35There was no reason for many of the
  580. 21:37things that have happened.
  581. 21:39And they were amplified by the current
  582. 21:41state of affairs.
  583. 21:43So look, I'm done
  584. 21:45apologizing. I 'm done being diplomatic.
  585. 21:49I'm going to do things now. I'm building
  586. 21:52midnight.
  587. 21:53That's my life. I'm building Midnight
  588. 21:55City. That's my life.
  589. 21:57If there's interesting and good research
  590. 21:58that we can do or there's stuff involved
  591. 22:00in the transition
  592. 22:02from Cardano to, you know, us and to
  593. 22:05these other firms, absolutely we're
  594. 22:06there every step of the way.
  595. 22:08Our people care
  596. 22:10and we want to make sure that this
  597. 22:11protocol is handed off in a responsible
  598. 22:14way. It's our job to do that and we're
  599. 22:16going to do it better than it's ever
  600. 22:18been done before.
  601. 22:20But every day I wake up now, I wake up
  602. 22:21and say, how do I get adoption into the
  603. 22:24applications I build?
  604. 22:26How do I get users? How do I get
  605. 22:28transactions? How do I get TVL?
  606. 22:31That's where I'm at.
  607. 22:33That's where my mind's at. I got to work
  608. 22:34on new problems. I can't keep coming
  609. 22:36after 11 years
  610. 22:38back to the same set of complaints, the
  611. 22:41same set of actors, and the same set of
  612. 22:42people who are bitter.
  613. 22:44And I know some of you bought it at $3,
  614. 22:46but you have to understand something.
  615. 22:50There's no way to win.
  616. 22:53It's impossible.
  617. 22:54Cuz if you bought it at three, you want
  618. 22:55it to be five.
  619. 22:57If it gets to five,
  620. 22:59then somebody else comes in at five and
  621. 23:01they want it to be seven. If it gets to
  622. 23:02seven, somebody else comes in at seven,
  623. 23:04they want it to be nine.
  624. 23:06So if the job defines that 100% of the
  625. 23:08people that used the protocol made a
  626. 23:10profit,
  627. 23:12who speculated on it made a profit,
  628. 23:14that's like saying a gold miner
  629. 23:17has to make sure that everybody who does
  630. 23:19stuff with gold makes a profit. It's an
  631. 23:21absurd standard. It cannot be satisfied.
  632. 23:24It's by its construction
  633. 23:26falsifiable.
  634. 23:28It cannot be satisfied. That was never
  635. 23:30our obligation. We did not sign up for
  636. 23:32it. We would have never agreed to do it.
  637. 23:33I would have spent my life doing other
  638. 23:35things if I knew that that was the
  639. 23:37standard upon which our success would be
  640. 23:39handled.
  641. 23:40We wrote the code. We decentralized the
  642. 23:42ecosystem. The protocol is sound and
  643. 23:44stable and secure.
  644. 23:46People use it every single day. Millions
  645. 23:48of people have used it. It has liquidity
  646. 23:50on hundreds of exchanges, and it is
  647. 23:52self-determining and self-governing. And
  648. 23:54there's a strong bench of members-based
  649. 23:57organizations, independent governance
  650. 23:59foundations, and dozens of developers
  651. 24:01actively waking up every day to build
  652. 24:04core nodes,
  653. 24:05explorers, wallets.
  654. 24:08It's vibrant and thriving,
  655. 24:10and we've left behind a system that is
  656. 24:11infinitely scalable as LEOs turns on.
  657. 24:15I'm proud of that.
  658. 24:17And it's useful for us as a builder to
  659. 24:20build on. And that's what we're doing
  660. 24:22now.
  661. 24:23And we will continue building on
  662. 24:25Cardano. Let me be very clear about that
  663. 24:28because people love to lie.
  664. 24:30We enjoy building on Cardano. We love
  665. 24:32the people we build with. We love the
  666. 24:33relationships and partnerships we have,
  667. 24:36and we think this is a strong and
  668. 24:37vibrant ecosystem.
  669. 24:39But there are elements of the ecosystem
  670. 24:41that are behaving irresponsibly. There
  671. 24:43are elements of the ecosystem that are
  672. 24:46absolutely unreasonable,
  673. 24:48and those elements if embraced and
  674. 24:50allowed to grow and thrive will kill the
  675. 24:52ecosystem. They will drive out every
  676. 24:54builder, they will destroy every
  677. 24:56competitive advantage, and they will
  678. 24:57prevent the ecosystem from thriving.
  679. 25:01So it's a warning.
  680. 25:03Don't let the vampires in.
  681. 25:06And grow up.
  682. 25:07Be adults.
  683. 25:09Recognize that the industry as a whole
  684. 25:11is damaged.
  685. 25:12Recognize that the vast majority of
  686. 25:14projects are down from their 2021
  687. 25:16all-time highs.
  688. 25:18Recognize that consumer confidence in
  689. 25:20cryptocurrencies as a category
  690. 25:22is badly damaged. Recognize that trust
  691. 25:25is badly compromised, and recognize that
  692. 25:28many people have lost money and been
  693. 25:30defrauded,
  694. 25:31and they have legitimate grievances with
  695. 25:33the industry as a whole.
  696. 25:35This is a fact.
  697. 25:37Also recognize that the industry has
  698. 25:38committed many self-inflicted sins.
  699. 25:42Meme coin mania, NFT mania,
  700. 25:45pump and dumps, scams.
  701. 25:48No regulator did these things.
  702. 25:50No outside party did these things. We
  703. 25:51did these things to ourselves.
  704. 25:54This is the macro upon which Cardano has
  705. 25:57had to survive.
  706. 25:58And this is the macro upon which Cardano
  707. 26:00has had to find a way to thrive.
  708. 26:03Despite the fact that it is as old as
  709. 26:06pretty much any project around, Cardano
  710. 26:08is still around, still has revenue
  711. 26:10relevance, still invited to conferences,
  712. 26:12still considered to be a legitimate
  713. 26:15project,
  714. 26:16which in itself is truly impressive
  715. 26:18because very few have met that milestone
  716. 26:21year after year in such a rapidly
  717. 26:23changing industry, so filled with
  718. 26:25scandals and chaos.
  719. 26:29And And is the only ecosystem,
  720. 26:31really truly the only one, not Solana,
  721. 26:33not Ethereum, not Bitcoin,
  722. 26:35that has the ability to be
  723. 26:37self-determining.
  724. 26:39Every part of the stack is
  725. 26:41decentralized. As an ADA holder, you
  726. 26:43have a vote, you have a voice, you have
  727. 26:46representation. This is not the case
  728. 26:48with Bitcoin, this is not the case with
  729. 26:50Ethereum, this is not the case with
  730. 26:52Solana.
  731. 26:54You have a voice.
  732. 26:57Use that voice.
  733. 26:59If you want it to grow,
  734. 27:01then vote in that direction for
  735. 27:03constitutional committee members and D
  736. 27:05reps
  737. 27:06and for institutions to be funded to do
  738. 27:09these things.
  739. 27:11That is what you've been given.
  740. 27:14And if the protocol becomes more
  741. 27:16successful, there's more money in the
  742. 27:18treasury, more resources to double down
  743. 27:21and recursively improve things.
  744. 27:24So use that.
  745. 27:26Don't go and berate, belittle, attack
  746. 27:29me.
  747. 27:32There's only so many times that I've
  748. 27:33been called evil, immoral, fat, ugly,
  749. 27:37stupid, unethical, sociopath,
  750. 27:40pathological liar before at some point
  751. 27:42you just throw your hands up and say,
  752. 27:44why am I doing this?
  753. 27:46I don't need to be here.
  754. 27:48I just don't.
  755. 27:50I'm a human being, god damn it.
  756. 27:53And I'm not allowed to be successful.
  757. 27:55I'm not allowed to earn money. I 'm not
  758. 27:57allowed to have success. I'm not allowed
  759. 27:59to write papers.
  760. 28:01I'm not allowed to write code. I'm not
  761. 28:03allowed to do anything to demonstrate my
  762. 28:05creativity
  763. 28:07and express myself because every single
  764. 28:09time I do it, there's someone somewhere
  765. 28:12that says that's evidence of me being
  766. 28:14evil,
  767. 28:16bad, narcissistic,
  768. 28:18fraudulent.
  769. 28:24No one
  770. 28:25should sign up for that.
  771. 28:28I 'm sorry for many of you that the
  772. 28:31cryptocurrency industry didn't turn out
  773. 28:33the way that you wanted it to.
  774. 28:36I really am.
  775. 28:37And I'm sorry for the behavior of this
  776. 28:39industry as a whole. It's been
  777. 28:40deplorable. I agree with you and I'm a
  778. 28:42kindred spirit in that respect, which is
  779. 28:44why I don't have a lot of friends
  780. 28:45because I tell hard truths.
  781. 28:48But I will never be sorry for founding
  782. 28:50Cardano and I will never be sorry for
  783. 28:52the things that we built
  784. 28:54and I'll never be sorry for the progress
  785. 28:55that we've made.
  786. 28:57We, because we exist, changed the course
  787. 29:00of this industry as a whole. That's an
  788. 29:02undeniable fact
  789. 29:03that our critics will never admit, but
  790. 29:06it's true.
  791. 29:08And we stand at a very important
  792. 29:10inflection point.
  793. 29:11We as a community can make decisions to
  794. 29:13embrace our builders and treat them
  795. 29:15appropriately
  796. 29:17and as a community can make a decision
  797. 29:18to be less divisive
  798. 29:21and to embrace respecting each other and
  799. 29:23treating each other with a basic decorum
  800. 29:26or we can choose to embrace the angels
  801. 29:29the the demons of our nature.
  802. 29:31And if we do that, everything we've
  803. 29:33established, everything we've built will
  804. 29:35come to an end
  805. 29:36and everyone will leave.
  806. 29:39I know many of you say, well Charles
  807. 29:41attacks builders and there are some that
  808. 29:42perhaps I was unfair to.
  809. 29:44But in all of those things,
  810. 29:47those builders engaged first.
  811. 29:50In all of those things,
  812. 29:53either to try to defund us,
  813. 29:55to attack the integrity of our people,
  814. 29:58to lash out at us, to say that we didn't
  815. 30:00give them something or we didn't honor
  816. 30:02something.
  817. 30:03It's been nothing but chaos and war.
  818. 30:08And I'm held to some standard that
  819. 30:10somehow when a project attacks my
  820. 30:12company, my people, our integrity,
  821. 30:15actively votes to defund the things we
  822. 30:17propose, we're not allowed to have an
  823. 30:19opinion on it. We have to just turn the
  824. 30:21other cheek.
  825. 30:23Again, it's an impossible position.
  826. 30:25Just take the abuse
  827. 30:28and if you ever react to it,
  828. 30:30well then you're the bad person.
  829. 30:33It's pretty sad.
  830. 30:36And you look at these what have they
  831. 30:37done for you?
  832. 30:39What have they built for you other than
  833. 30:41being divisive?
  834. 30:43And complaining and complaining and
  835. 30:45complaining. You have no conception of
  836. 30:47how many messes I've had to clean up
  837. 30:49behind the scenes
  838. 30:51where they could have been mega
  839. 30:52scandals, but we resolved them.
  840. 30:57You know, and every day we just show up
  841. 30:59and we're there for people.
  842. 31:00We invite them to the office, we're nice
  843. 31:02to them, even people that have said and
  844. 31:04done terrible things to us.
  845. 31:06Again, because we just want the
  846. 31:08ecosystem to be successful, not because
  847. 31:10we were paid to do that, because it was
  848. 31:12the right thing to do.
  849. 31:15That's the value add of Charles
  850. 31:17Hoskinson and input output in your
  851. 31:19ecosystem.
  852. 31:21There's certainly downsides, but that's
  853. 31:23the value add.
  854. 31:26So decide what you want to do, guys. I'm
  855. 31:28done with it. I really am.
  856. 31:31I'm just done with it.
  857. 31:34Midnight is going to be incredibly
  858. 31:35successful.
  859. 31:37I wake up every day
  860. 31:39and I say, what's the next thing I can
  861. 31:41build there? What's the next milestone?
  862. 31:42What's the next thing we can achieve?
  863. 31:44And I'm very proud of the night force.
  864. 31:46I'm very proud of the Midnight
  865. 31:47Foundation. I'm very proud of all of our
  866. 31:49partners. I'm very proud of all of our
  867. 31:51engineers, and I'm very proud of the
  868. 31:53enormous effort that people have put in.
  869. 31:56And I'm proud of the fact that Cardano
  870. 31:58works with Midnight.
  871. 31:59It's a testament to the hard engineering
  872. 32:01of many of the people that worked for us
  873. 32:03and with us
  874. 32:04throughout the years.
  875. 32:05I'm proud we got to a point where we
  876. 32:07could build something like Midnight.
  877. 32:09That's an amazing thing.
  878. 32:11That's where my headspace needs to be.
  879. 32:14That's where our company needs to be,
  880. 32:16and that's where the people building
  881. 32:18need to be. They deserve better, and
  882. 32:20they don't deserve any connection to
  883. 32:22this chaotic hellscape of past.
  884. 32:26They need to move on.
  885. 32:27You need to move on.
  886. 32:29It's time to turn the page.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of Finishing Cardano by Charles Hoskinson, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 4,910 words across 886 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.