Facebook Paid $5 Billion. Why Wasn't Zuckerberg Fired? — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:01$5 billion.
- 0:03Same CEO.
- 0:04In 2019, Facebook agreed to pay that
- 0:07much to settle a federal privacy case.
- 0:09[snorts] Mark Zuckerberg kept his job.
- 0:11At Tesla, Elon Musk lost one title and
- 0:14kept the other. At Uber, Travis Kalanick
- 0:17resigned. So who actually gets to decide
- 0:20whether a CEO stays?
- 0:22Start with two words.
- 0:27August 7th, 2018. Elon Musk posts nine
- 0:31words.
- 0:32I'm considering taking Tesla private at
- 0:35$420.
- 0:36Funding secured.
- 0:38Tesla stock closes up nearly 11% that
- 0:41day. [music]
- 0:427 weeks later, the SEC files its
- 0:45complaint. Musk had not even discussed,
- 0:48much less confirmed, key deal terms,
- 0:50including price with any potential
- 0:52funding source. In plain words, the
- 0:54funding wasn't secured.
- 0:57The SEC asks the court to bar him from
- 1:00serving as an officer or director of any
- 1:02public [music] company. That includes
- 1:04Tesla.
- 1:06The SEC had offered him a settlement
- 1:07before it filed. He turned it down.
- 1:10[music] 2 days later, he settles anyway
- 1:12on tougher terms without admitting or
- 1:14denying the charges.
- 1:16He gives up the chairman seat for 3
- 1:18years instead of 2. He and Tesla pay $20
- 1:21million each. Two independent directors
- 1:24join the board, and Tesla now has to put
- 1:26new controls on what he posts.
- 1:30[music] 5 days after the deal, Musk
- 1:32posted about the agency again.
- 1:34The Short Seller Enrichment Commission
- 1:36is doing incredible work.
- 1:40I thought he was leaving.
- 1:42The chairman's office and the CEO's
- 1:45office?
- 1:47Same guy.
- 1:50Short of a court order, the CEO job
- 1:53belongs to the board. A company's board
- 1:55hires and fires the chief executive, and
- 1:58the shareholders elect board.
- 2:00Tesla's board kept him.
- 2:03In 2013, the shareholders of America's
- 2:05biggest bank got a vote of their own.
- 2:07[music]
- 2:102012, a JP Morgan trader in London made
- 2:14bets so large that other traders called
- 2:16him the London whale.
- 2:19The bets were meant to protect the bank
- 2:20from risk.
- 2:21In April, as the first reports came out,
- 2:24Jamie Dimon, the bank's chairman and
- 2:26CEO, described them like this,
- 2:29a complete tempest in a teapot.
- 2:32Four weeks later, he announced a $2
- 2:35billion loss. It kept growing past $6
- 2:38billion.
- 2:40In January 2013, his board cut his pay
- 2:43in half from $23 million
- 2:45to 11 and 1/2 million.
- 2:48As CEO, Mr. Dimon bears ultimate
- 2:50responsibility for the failures that led
- 2:52to the losses.
- 2:54The board took half his pay. It kept him
- 2:56in both jobs.
- 2:58That May, shareholders voted on a
- 3:00proposal to split the two jobs between
- 3:03two people so that someone other than
- 3:05Dimon would chair the board that watches
- 3:06him.
- 3:07About 32% voted yes.
- 3:11Four months later, regulators fined the
- 3:13bank about $920 million.
- 3:16In a rare move, it admitted wrongdoing.
- 3:19By then, the ballot box was packed away.
- 3:23Dimon's supporters had a fair answer.
- 3:26Even with the loss, JP Morgan reported a
- 3:28record profit for 2012, and they wanted
- 3:30to keep the man running it.
- 3:33At JP Morgan, every share carried the
- 3:35same vote. At Facebook, they never did.
- 3:41In 2018, Mark Zuckerberg sat in front of
- 3:44Congress.
- 3:45A firm called Cambridge Analytica had
- 3:47gotten hold of Facebook data on millions
- 3:50of people.
- 3:51By Facebook's own count, up to 87
- 3:54million.
- 3:55It was my mistake, and I'm sorry.
- 3:59A year later came the $5 [music] billion
- 4:01settlement, the largest privacy penalty
- 4:04the FTC had ever imposed.
- 4:06Facebook also had to add a privacy
- 4:08committee to its board.
- 4:10He kept the job because of how the
- 4:12company's shares are built.
- 4:14Facebook, which renamed itself Meta in
- 4:172021, has two classes of voting stock.
- 4:20[music] Class A trades on the market and
- 4:22carries one vote a share. Class B
- 4:24carries 10 and Zuckerberg holds almost
- 4:27all of it.
- 4:29100 shares. How many votes? Which class?
- 4:33There are classes?
- 4:35Class A, 100 votes. Class B, 1,000.
- 4:40As of October 1st, 2026, Zuckerberg
- 4:43owned about 13.4% of Meta.
- 4:47He controlled 60.6% of the votes.
- 4:50With more than half the votes, he elects
- 4:53the board. That board is the one that
- 4:55decides whether he stays.
- 4:57If you own an S&P 500 index fund, you
- 5:00own a small piece of Meta. Your fund
- 5:03holds class A shares, one vote each. The
- 5:06man running the company gets 10 for each
- 5:08of his.
- 5:10The same setup runs older empires.
- 5:13In July 2011, Britain's News of the
- 5:15World shut down.
- 5:17Its journalists had hacked people's
- 5:19phones, including the voicemail of a
- 5:21murdered school girl, Milly Dowler.
- 5:24A committee of British lawmakers later
- 5:26wrote by a divided vote that Rupert
- 5:28Murdoch was not a fit person to exercise
- 5:31the stewardship of a major international
- 5:33company.
- 5:35Murdoch controlled about 40% of News
- 5:37Corporation's voting shares. He stayed
- 5:39in charge.
- 5:41Travis Kalanick had 10 vote shares, too.
- 5:45Uber gave 10 vote shares to some of its
- 5:47earliest insiders.
- 5:49Kalanick, its co-founder and CEO, was
- 5:52one of them.
- 5:53In February 2017, a former Uber
- 5:56engineer, Susan Fowler, published an
- 5:58account of sexual harassment she said
- 6:00she faced at the company and of how her
- 6:02reports to HR were handled.
- 6:05Investigations followed.
- 6:08In June, the law firm of former attorney
- 6:10general Eric Holder delivered its
- 6:12recommendations to the board, and
- 6:14Kalanick took a leave of absence.
- 6:17Kalanick and two other early insiders
- 6:19held enough 10-vote shares to control
- 6:21Uber, one investor told Reuters.
- 6:24On June 20th, five of Uber's investors,
- 6:27Benchmark among them, signed a letter.
- 6:30Two Benchmark partners flew to Chicago,
- 6:32where Kalanick was interviewing a
- 6:34candidate to be his deputy and handed it
- 6:36to him in person
- 6:38and asked him to resign immediately.
- 6:42There was no shareholder vote. There was
- 6:44no board meeting to remove him.
- 6:46The same day,
- 6:48he resigned
- 6:50so that Uber can go back to building
- 6:52rather than be distracted with another
- 6:53fight.
- 6:55He kept his shares and his seat on the
- 6:57board.
- 6:59Here's how it looks from the numbers.
- 7:01Uber was still a private company. In
- 7:032016, it lost about $2.8 billion,
- 7:07not counting China, by its own figures.
- 7:10A company losing that much needs its
- 7:12next check.
- 7:13Its next check had to come from
- 7:15investors, and the letter came from
- 7:17investors.
- 7:19The votes were still his. The money
- 7:21wasn't.
- 7:23The fight didn't end there.
- 7:25In August, Benchmark sued him over his
- 7:27power to fill board seats.
- 7:30That December, as part of a large
- 7:31investment from SoftBank, Uber's board
- 7:34agreed to end the 10-vote shares.
- 7:36One share, one vote.
- 7:41A scandal moves a CEO only when it moves
- 7:44the people who hold the votes or the
- 7:45money.
- 7:47Musk and Diamond kept their boards and
- 7:49their shareholders.
- 7:51Zuckerberg holds the votes himself.
- 7:53Kalanick needed the money.
- 7:56Meta has planned for that last problem.
- 7:59In October 2026, it set out a third
- 8:02class of stock,
- 8:03Class C,
- 8:05no vote at all.
- 8:08There was no shareholder meeting.
- 8:10Holding companies tied to Zuckerberg
- 8:12approved it in writing.
- 8:14Their votes were enough.
- 8:16Every existing share gets one class C
- 8:19share.
- 8:20Meta can then sell more of them to raise
- 8:22money.
- 8:23Meta's own filing says it could raise up
- 8:25to about $700 billion this way over
- 8:28several years, while Zuckerberg keeps
- 8:30more than half the votes.
- 8:32Meta's side has a fair answer.
- 8:35Founder control lets a company make
- 8:37long, expensive bets without asking
- 8:39permission every year.
- 8:41This year alone, Meta expects to spend
- 8:43up to $145 billion on data centers and
- 8:46computing, much of it for AI.
- 8:50The cost falls on everyone else's vote.
- 8:53In May 2026, Meta's shareholders voted
- 8:56on a proposal about the two-class
- 8:58structure.
- 8:59It failed.
- 9:01The new charter that creates class C is
- 9:03set to take effect on January 19th,
- 9:052027.
- 9:09$5 billion,
- 9:11same CEO.
- 9:13The next shares Meta sells are built to
- 9:15bring in money without bringing in a
- 9:17single vote.
- 9:26>> [music]
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Facebook Paid $5 Billion. Why Wasn't Zuckerberg Fired? by Shady Lines, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 1,280 words across 235 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.