Every Level of Awareness — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Self-awareness doesn't make any sense.
- 0:03When psychologist Tasha Eurich asked,
- 0:0595% of people claimed to be self-aware,
- 0:09and that's not surprising.
- 0:11You know what makes you laugh, or what
- 0:14makes you snap at people, the songs you
- 0:16skip, and the friend who you will drop
- 0:19everything for at 3:00 a.m.
- 0:22But after a decade of research, she
- 0:25discovered that only 10 to 15% of people
- 0:29actually are.
- 0:31And here's the strange part. The people
- 0:33who are wrong feel exactly the same as
- 0:36the people who are right. That's because
- 0:38self-awareness isn't it's not black and
- 0:41white, it's not on or off, it's a
- 0:43ladder. And every rung feels like the
- 0:46top. So, most of us stop climbing, never
- 0:49knowing that there's [music] more above.
- 0:52So, let's see the whole ladder. Along
- 0:55the way, we will find the rung that
- 0:56traps almost everyone, and what it takes
- 0:59for us to climb past it, and [music] why
- 1:01a man whose brain was literally split in
- 1:04half holds the key to unlocking [music]
- 1:07the final level.
- 1:12At the bottom of the ladder, there is no
- 1:14you at all, just a living thing
- 1:16responding to whatever's in front of it.
- 1:19From the outside, it's like a baby
- 1:20reacting to light in a hospital. There's
- 1:23a stimulus and a response. From the
- 1:25inside, it's like a drop of water
- 1:27trailing downwards. The droplet doesn't
- 1:30have a why or a goal. It's just going,
- 1:32and that's that.
- 1:34>> [music]
- 1:34>> At this rung, there is no you yet, no
- 1:38line between what's happening and
- 1:40whatever it's happening [music]
- 1:42to.
- 1:43Everyone has stood on this rung at some
- 1:45point, [music] even if no one really
- 1:47remembers it.
- 1:49But the droplet only takes us so far.
- 1:52See, the droplet doesn't feel [music]
- 1:54anything, but a newborn might. Somewhere
- 1:57between reflex and experience, [music]
- 2:00a someone starts to show up and
- 2:03we don't really know exactly when that
- 2:05happens.
- 2:07What we can say is when that someone
- 2:09first [music] recognizes itself.
- 2:15Now, odds are you don't remember it, but
- 2:17there was a moment when you finally
- 2:19noticed something. [music]
- 2:21You stared out in front of you and you
- 2:22were drawn to these strange objects that
- 2:25obeyed your commands.
- 2:27Your parents later called them fingers,
- 2:29but you didn't really fully know what a
- 2:32command was, either. You only got here a
- 2:34few months ago, after all.
- 2:36All you knew was that you imagined
- 2:38something and these things made it
- 2:40happen.
- 2:42It's why your baby stretches its arms
- 2:43out at a bottle and attempts to
- 2:45>> [music]
- 2:45>> telekinetically bring it closer.
- 2:48Of course, it doesn't work, but at this
- 2:50stage, everything and anything is fair
- 2:54game.
- 2:55That's why the famous game of got your
- 2:56nose is still a huge deal within the
- 2:59baby community. As far as they can tell,
- 3:01a nose is detachable.
- 3:04This isn't just limited to babies,
- 3:06though.
- 3:07At level two, an entity begins to
- 3:09develop a boundary between what they can
- 3:11control and what they can't.
- 3:14In 1970, psychologist Gordon Gallup
- 3:16found a way to test where that boundary
- 3:19begins.
- 3:20He let chimpanzees get used to a mirror
- 3:22and then put them under anesthesia and
- 3:24painted a red mark on their brow.
- 3:27When they woke up and saw their
- 3:28reflections, they reached for the marks
- 3:30on their own faces, not the ones on the
- 3:32glass. So, these chimpanzees understood
- 3:35that the reflection was them.
- 3:38So, researchers soon ran the same test
- 3:40on children using just a dab of rouge
- 3:42right there on the nose.
- 3:44Most pass this [music] test between 18
- 3:46and 24 months.
- 3:48Apart from humans, only a handful of
- 3:50animals can manage this. The great apes,
- 3:52some dolphins, Asian elephants, and
- 3:54magpies. For most animals, though, the
- 3:57creature in the mirror is a stranger.
- 4:00Science often treats the mirror test as
- 4:02the moment a me appears, and once it
- 4:05does, that feels permanent.
- 4:08But, that me is less solid than it
- 4:12seems.
- 4:13In 1998, psychologists Matthew Botvinick
- 4:17and Jonathan Cohen showed how easily
- 4:19that concept can bend.
- 4:21So,
- 4:23imagine that you are sitting at a table.
- 4:25Your real hand is hidden behind a
- 4:27screen, and a rubber hand sits in front
- 4:29of you where yours should be.
- 4:31Someone strokes both hands with
- 4:32paintbrushes in perfect time.
- 4:35Within a minute, something inside of you
- 4:37begins to shift. You start to feel the
- 4:40brush where you can see it, on the
- 4:42rubber hand.
- 4:43Ask participants to point to their real
- 4:45hand, and many point closer to the fake
- 4:48one.
- 4:49Later, researchers pushed this even
- 4:51further.
- 4:52When they bent back a rubber finger or
- 4:54jabbed at the fake hand with a needle,
- 4:56people's bodies reacted as if they were
- 4:58under threat. They flinched, their palms
- 5:00began to sweat, brain regions tied to
- 5:03anxiety lit up. All the while, they knew
- 5:06perfectly well the hand was rubber.
- 5:10The result of the rubber hand illusion
- 5:11is a brain deciding what counts as mine
- 5:14by using matching signals.
- 5:16When what you can see aligns with what
- 5:18you can feel, it lands as if it's
- 5:20literally happening to you.
- 5:22That's why you can get a jump scare from
- 5:24watching a horror movie, even when you
- 5:26are 100% certain about what you're
- 5:28getting into.
- 5:30As it turns out, the concept of mine is
- 5:33only a conclusion the brain reaches, and
- 5:35conclusions can be wrong. And I want you
- 5:38to remember that.
- 5:40The last piece of level two is time.
- 5:43In 1996, psychologist Daniel Povinelli
- 5:46played a game with young children and
- 5:48while praising them secretly stuck a
- 5:51large sticker to their heads.
- 5:53A few minutes later he showed them a
- 5:55video of it happening. Most
- 5:57four-year-olds reached up to pull the
- 5:58sticker off. Most three-year-olds
- 6:01didn't, even though they could pass the
- 6:03mirror test. To them, the kid in the
- 6:06mirror was them, but the kid in the
- 6:08video from before wasn't.
- 6:11At three, the concept of me only exists
- 6:14in the present tense. The self that
- 6:16stretches from yesterday into tomorrow
- 6:18has to be built and researchers still
- 6:22can't fully say what clicks between
- 6:24three and four,
- 6:26but it does.
- 6:28By the end of level two, you have a body
- 6:30that's yours, a face that you recognize,
- 6:33and a self that carries from yesterday
- 6:35into tomorrow.
- 6:37You know where you are and when you are,
- 6:40but you still don't know what's going on
- 6:43inside, and that turns out to be far
- 6:45more difficult to read than any
- 6:50This second level of self-awareness is
- 6:52very close to what babies experience,
- 6:54but it's also something that animals
- 6:56like magpies, dolphins, and elephants
- 6:58seem to share. And some evidence
- 7:01suggests that pigs aren't far behind.
- 7:04They can learn to use a mirror to find
- 7:05food in just a few hours.
- 7:08Yet pigs are among the animals that we
- 7:09treat the worst in animal factories.
- 7:12Yes,
- 7:13you got it. This is a sponsored segment.
- 7:16But I genuinely want you to take a
- 7:17moment to sit through this because this
- 7:20isn't about selling you anything or
- 7:22getting you to try out a silly game.
- 7:25It's about making the lives of millions
- 7:26of animals, many of whom have varying
- 7:29levels of self-awareness, much better.
- 7:31For every human on Earth, there are
- 7:34roughly 13 farmed animals, and most of
- 7:37them live their entire lives in factory
- 7:39[music] farms. These are living
- 7:41creatures capable of fear and stress and
- 7:44suffering, yet their lives are mostly
- 7:46invisible to us, trapped in systems
- 7:49designed for efficiency and not for the
- 7:52well-being of the animals. Thanks to the
- 7:54sponsor of today's episode, Farm Kind,
- 7:57you can do something about this.
- 7:59Farm Kind recommends expert-reviewed
- 8:01charities that are proven [music] to be
- 8:03effective at improving the lives of
- 8:05farmed animals. Some of these charities
- 8:07work to free chickens from cages so they
- 8:09can actually move around. Others push
- 8:12for laws that allow mother pigs to live
- 8:14outside of crates so they can care for
- 8:16their babies. And some focus on
- 8:18transforming the food system so factory
- 8:20farming becomes less common in the
- 8:22future.
- 8:24Something I really appreciate about Farm
- 8:25Kind is that they don't take a single
- 8:27cut of your donation.
- 8:29100% of your donation goes directly to
- 8:32the charities that help animals.
- 8:34Even small contributions can make a real
- 8:37difference. Just 50 cents a day, about
- 8:39$15 a month, can spare roughly [music]
- 8:42350
- 8:44animals each year from some of the worst
- 8:47suffering in factory farming.
- 8:49And if you use my code Aperture
- 8:51Thinking, your monthly donations will
- 8:53receive a 50% boost. So, if you donate
- 8:56$15 a month, you can get an extra $7.50
- 9:00added to your donation.
- 9:02If you want to learn more or see how
- 9:04[music] much of a difference your
- 9:05donation could make, you can check out
- 9:07the link in the description. Even small
- 9:09actions can change lives.
- 9:12Now, back to our story.
- 9:16In 2015,
- 9:18Pixar released Inside Out. Inside a
- 9:21girl's head, five emotions take turns at
- 9:23a control panel: Joy, Sadness, Anger,
- 9:26Fear, and Disgust. Whoever holds the
- 9:29controls decides how she feels, and the
- 9:31audience always gets to know who's in
- 9:33charge.
- 9:34It's a fantasy, but it rests on real
- 9:37science.
- 9:38The filmmakers consulted emotion
- 9:40researchers, including Paul Ekman, who
- 9:42argued that humans share a handful of
- 9:45basic emotions, each with a facial
- 9:48expression recognized across cultures,
- 9:50and [music] that's where the five came
- 9:51from.
- 9:53The film makes it look really simple.
- 9:55Something happens, an emotion takes the
- 9:56reins, and you get to know as the
- 9:58audience exactly which one it is.
- 10:01So, most people assume they passed level
- 10:04three long ago.
- 10:06But, not everyone can tell who's at the
- 10:09console.
- 10:11In 1973, psychiatrist Peter Sifneos gave
- 10:14this a name, alexithymia, from the Greek
- 10:17for no words for feelings. It varies in
- 10:21strength, and roughly one in 10 people
- 10:23score high for it. When someone has high
- 10:26levels of alexithymia, they do have the
- 10:29ability to feel things, [music] and even
- 10:32feel them strongly.
- 10:33The difference between them and the
- 10:35average person lies in their ability to
- 10:38identify what they're feeling.
- 10:40They struggle to identify what counts
- 10:42[music] as an emotion versus a bodily
- 10:45sensation. So, when they are asked how
- 10:48they feel, they'll say, "Tired." [music]
- 10:50Or, "Off."
- 10:51It comes down to a weaker interoception,
- 10:54[music] the sense of what's happening
- 10:56inside the body.
- 10:57Most people can notice their heartbeat,
- 11:00or their hunger, or their tension, but
- 11:03for them, they can't really tell what's
- 11:05what. If they feel really hungry, it
- 11:08might read as anger or sadness, and not
- 11:11the actual sensation of hunger that
- 11:13they're experiencing.
- 11:14>> [music]
- 11:15>> Now, sure, most people know what it's
- 11:17like to be hangry, but for alexithymic
- 11:19individuals, there's nothing indicating
- 11:22that the source is hunger, and the
- 11:24solution is food. It's just a sudden
- 11:26feeling with no warning or labels
- 11:28attached. That rumbling in your stomach
- 11:31that happens at 1:00 p.m. doesn't tell
- 11:33them to go grab a sandwich. They
- 11:35>> [music]
- 11:35>> actually don't even have a mental space
- 11:38for the rumble or its meaning. It's
- 11:40[music] an overwhelming and chaotic wave
- 11:42of discomfort that seemingly appears out
- 11:45of nowhere.
- 11:47Now, even outside the realm of
- 11:49alexithymia, there are many cases where
- 11:51poor readings of feelings have led to
- 11:54very interesting results.
- 11:56In a 2018 study, psychologists Jennifer
- 11:59McCormick and Kristen Lindquist found
- 12:01that hungry people judged neutral images
- 12:03more negatively and got more irritable
- 12:06after a frustrating task. Now,
- 12:09what they noticed was that the effect
- 12:10was strongest when they weren't paying
- 12:12attention [music]
- 12:13to their feelings.
- 12:15Hunger turned into anger when they were
- 12:17too distracted to check the label on
- 12:19what they were feeling.
- 12:20Feelings tend to arrive to us just like
- 12:22messages in a language that we only
- 12:24partly speak.
- 12:26>> [music]
- 12:26>> A cancer patient can't suddenly tell
- 12:28that a lump in their chest is cancerous.
- 12:31The body isn't perfectly translating
- 12:33everything that happens to us. We just
- 12:36do the best we can to understand what we
- 12:38consistently experience through trial
- 12:40and error.
- 12:42This mislabeling of feelings also
- 12:44happens in romantic settings.
- 12:47Constantly.
- 12:48Back in 1974, a study by Dutton and Aron
- 12:52involved an attractive female researcher
- 12:54who was tasked with stopping men at a
- 12:56swaying suspension bridge.
- 12:58Her goal was to get them to fill out a
- 13:00short questionnaire, which she followed
- 13:03up with by handing them her phone
- 13:04number, quote, "in case they had any
- 13:07questions." Far more men called after
- 13:09meeting her on the swaying bridge than
- 13:12those who met her on the less scary,
- 13:14solid bridge. [music]
- 13:15It was one in eight for the solid bridge
- 13:17versus about half from the swaying
- 13:19bridge, and that is a huge gap in
- 13:21numbers.
- 13:22Here's what it came down to. Their
- 13:24hearts were racing, not from her
- 13:26charming looks, but rather the swaying
- 13:29and dangerous feeling bridge.
- 13:30>> [music]
- 13:31>> It came from fear and yet their brains
- 13:33filed it as attraction.
- 13:36Psychologists recognize this as
- 13:39misattribution of arousal, where your
- 13:41body gets worked up for one reason while
- 13:44your brain credits that feeling to
- 13:46something else.
- 13:48So yes, there are moments that felt
- 13:50magical that might have actually
- 13:53happened due to completely different
- 13:55factors. It turns out that when we
- 13:58aren't actively looking at what we're
- 13:59feeling, we mislabel quite frequently.
- 14:03So, remember that console from Inside
- 14:05Out? Well, psychologist Lisa Feldman
- 14:08Barrett thinks it gets something
- 14:09fundamentally wrong.
- 14:11The usual view is that we're born with a
- 14:14set of emotions, each waiting to fire
- 14:16when it's triggered.
- 14:17Barrett's theory of [music] constructed
- 14:19emotion says there is no such thing.
- 14:22Instead, your brain assembles each
- 14:24emotion in the moment from body signals,
- 14:27context, and past [music] experience.
- 14:29There is no labeled origin underneath.
- 14:33The reading of the feeling is the
- 14:35feeling.
- 14:36Now, this theory is still debated, but
- 14:38it does raise a very strange
- 14:40possibility.
- 14:42Follow me on this one.
- 14:44Bees see ultraviolet patterns on flowers
- 14:47that are invisible to us. The patterns
- 14:49are there, we just don't have the
- 14:51biological equipment to see them.
- 14:54Well, what if emotions work the same
- 14:56way? And the words that we learn decide
- 14:59which feelings we can notice at all?
- 15:01Right now, nobody can say for certain
- 15:04whether you detect an emotion or you
- 15:06build one. This is where emotional
- 15:08granularity comes in, how finely you can
- 15:11tell your feelings [music] apart. For
- 15:13some people, irritated or disappointed
- 15:16or anxious are three different things.
- 15:19But for others, they all collapse into
- 15:21[music]
- 15:22bad.
- 15:24But even the people who are best at this
- 15:26are only making better guesses. [music]
- 15:27Nobody gets direct access.
- 15:31So, a lot of people live on this rung
- 15:33without knowing [music] it. They feel
- 15:35hunger and they call it anger. They feel
- 15:37fear and call it attraction. They
- 15:39misread the signals inside of them then
- 15:42live by the labels that were never
- 15:43[music] true.
- 15:45If you've learned to stop and check the
- 15:48signal, well, congratulations. You may
- 15:50have climbed past this rung.
- 15:53But that only brings you to a much more
- 15:55difficult problem.
- 15:58If you can misread your own heartbeat,
- 16:00something physical and measurable,
- 16:03what happens when you try to read
- 16:04something with no physical signs at all?
- 16:06These are your thoughts, your motives,
- 16:08and your reasons.
- 16:10That's level four. It's the rung that
- 16:12feels like the top and it's where almost
- 16:15everyone gets stuck.
- 16:20So, what traits come to your mind when
- 16:22you hear the term self-aware?
- 16:24Perhaps you think, well, I know I get
- 16:26defensive often or I'm a perfectionist
- 16:29or I get jealous quite easily.
- 16:32It's like a breath of fresh air when
- 16:33someone is able to admit things about
- 16:35themselves without a whole argument or a
- 16:38debate.
- 16:39Who wouldn't want to be friends with a
- 16:41person that can look back at a fight and
- 16:43see their own part in it?
- 16:45This is called introspection. It is a
- 16:47hugely valuable trait because it allows
- 16:49you to reflect on your own thoughts,
- 16:52your motives, and your reasons that
- 16:53drive your behavior.
- 16:56But there's one thing people rarely
- 16:57bring up about introspection, and it's
- 17:00the way it often tilts towards
- 17:02negativity.
- 17:04Being self-aware presupposes knowing
- 17:06your flaws. Therefore, the ability to
- 17:08list your own weaknesses feels like
- 17:10proof that you have done the work, and
- 17:13in fairness, it is a huge step compared
- 17:16to every rung that came before it. It
- 17:19takes real effort to recognize this,
- 17:20especially for anyone viewing it from
- 17:23the outside.
- 17:25However,
- 17:26on the inside, things aren't as solid as
- 17:29you might think.
- 17:30First off, this rung is hugely disarming
- 17:33in a way. It feels like the top step. In
- 17:36level three, your feelings had to be
- 17:37read from body signals, and you did a
- 17:39good job with that.
- 17:41But thoughts and decisions are a
- 17:43different thing entirely. Because you
- 17:45were there when the choice was made, so
- 17:47you feel confident in your understanding
- 17:49of those choices.
- 17:51Especially because nobody else can step
- 17:53into your mind and know your reasons
- 17:55better than you.
- 17:57Right?
- 17:59Well, here's a random question.
- 18:02Do you know how a bicycle works?
- 18:05Odds are there's a chance you said yes
- 18:06to that.
- 18:08You probably rode a bicycle when you
- 18:09were only a kid, and you've seen them
- 18:11thousands of times, and maybe you can
- 18:14even perform some quick fixes if the
- 18:16pedals don't work or the chain hits a
- 18:18snag.
- 18:19But
- 18:20psychologist Rebecca Lawson noticed
- 18:22something about the people who felt
- 18:23confident in their knowledge.
- 18:26In 2006, at the University of Liverpool,
- 18:28she asked people to finish a simple
- 18:31sketch of a bicycle by adding the frame,
- 18:34the pedals, and the chain.
- 18:36A huge number of participants [music]
- 18:38ended up getting it wrong, and the
- 18:40mistakes were blatant.
- 18:41Chains looping around both wheels,
- 18:43frames that would lock the steering,
- 18:46pedals attached to the front wheel.
- 18:48If you try to ride any of these bikes,
- 18:50you would create a hazard for both
- 18:52yourself and anyone around you.
- 18:55But the weirdest part was that many of
- 18:57these people had ridden bikes their
- 18:59entire lives.
- 19:01So you can apply that idea to any other
- 19:03everyday object, and you can see how it
- 19:05begins to take shape.
- 19:06Do you know how a toilet works?
- 19:09Are you sure?
- 19:11Okay, explain it step by step.
- 19:15Suddenly, what you were sure you knew a
- 19:17few seconds ago falls apart. Researchers
- 19:20call this the illusion of explanatory
- 19:22depth, where we believe we understand
- 19:25something in detail [music] when we only
- 19:27really know it well enough to use it.
- 19:30That's the strange thing about
- 19:31familiarity. We can experience it so
- 19:34deeply, we feel they're an extension of
- 19:37ourselves.
- 19:38But, we only really understand them
- 19:40according to how we individually
- 19:42perceive them.
- 19:43Not as a whole.
- 19:45You can't build a bicycle out of scraps.
- 19:47You can't build a toilet, even if the
- 19:49best materials were laid out in front of
- 19:51you.
- 19:52Seeing or using something often is not
- 19:55knowledge, despite how much it feels
- 19:57that way.
- 19:59Now, when you turn that lens inwards to
- 20:01your own self, it gets slightly more
- 20:03uncomfortable.
- 20:05You've lived with yourself your whole
- 20:06life. You know your favorite hobbies,
- 20:09the songs you hate, your best friends,
- 20:11the things that give you the ick, and
- 20:13the stuff that makes your heart skip a
- 20:15beat. This feels like a lot more than
- 20:17familiarity. This is you. Sure,
- 20:20familiarity only creates the feeling of
- 20:22understanding, but nothing nothing
- 20:25should feel more understood by you than
- 20:28you.
- 20:30Yet, becoming the subject doesn't spare
- 20:32you the consequences of a misguided
- 20:35sense of mastery.
- 20:37When you make choices and reflect on
- 20:38them in your head, are you reporting
- 20:40what happened, or are you sketching a
- 20:42bicycle from memory?
- 20:45Picture yourself in a clothing store.
- 20:47You are shown four pairs of jeans laid
- 20:49out in a row, and then you are asked
- 20:51which one is the best quality. So, you
- 20:54you lean in. You can bring whatever you
- 20:56like, a flashlight to check the
- 20:57stitching, a magnifying [music] glass to
- 21:00inspect the seams, and you are given as
- 21:02much time as you want to thoroughly
- 21:04investigate.
- 21:05So, you take your time, and then you
- 21:07lean back and you point to the pair
- 21:09furthest down to the right.
- 21:11At least 20 other people come in and are
- 21:14asked to inspect for the best quality.
- 21:17When the results are collected, it's
- 21:19discovered that people are four times
- 21:21more likely to pick the pair on the
- 21:23extreme right over the one on the
- 21:26extreme left. And here's the real
- 21:28kicker.
- 21:29All four pairs of jeans are exactly the
- 21:32same.
- 21:33Yet, the data skews heavily to a
- 21:35specific pair. This is what happens
- 21:37behind the scenes in your head.
- 21:39It's something called the position
- 21:41effect, and it's what happens when
- 21:42people choose something partly because
- 21:45of where it sits, regardless of what it
- 21:48is.
- 21:48At a hot dog stand, you're not going to
- 21:50go for the one placed right in front of
- 21:52you. It's like there's some part of you
- 21:54that believes the fresher ones [music]
- 21:56are at the back, even if there's no
- 21:58evidence for which one is which.
- 22:01Similarly, when people picked a pair of
- 22:03jeans, they pointed to what they thought
- 22:05were the deciding factors, the texture,
- 22:07color, the seams.
- 22:09But, when they were questioned, they
- 22:10didn't even mention whether the order of
- 22:13the presentation may have played a part,
- 22:15and almost everyone denied it.
- 22:17This scenario is based on a paper by
- 22:20Nisbett [music] and Wilson from 1977.
- 22:23In that version of the experiment,
- 22:25people even gave [music] the interviewer
- 22:27a weird look when he brought up the
- 22:29order of the presentation.
- 22:31The looks they gave were similar to what
- 22:33you would give a madman. They were so
- 22:35sure, yet objectively misguided.
- 22:40Despite all of the other factors feeling
- 22:42so real, the true cause of the choice
- 22:45remained invisible to the people making
- 22:47it. Nobody said, "Well, I'm not sure."
- 22:50They were confident, and they gave
- 22:52confident reasons that sounded right to
- 22:54them, even when they weren't the actual
- 22:57reason.
- 22:58Now, the scenario with the jeans demands
- 23:00that you make a choice.
- 23:02But, two researchers from Lund
- 23:04University asked this in 2005.
- 23:08What happens if you're handed something
- 23:10that you didn't choose?
- 23:12How would it sit with you
- 23:13psychologically?
- 23:15Peter Johansson and Lars Hall devised a
- 23:17scenario where participants were shown
- 23:20two photos of faces and then they were
- 23:23asked to pick the more attractive face.
- 23:26But, there's always a twist.
- 23:28Using a quick slide of hand, the
- 23:30researchers were able to occasionally
- 23:32swap the cards and give people the face
- 23:34that they had rejected. Then, they asked
- 23:37participants to explain their choice
- 23:39even when presented with a swapped face.
- 23:42The results were not what you'd expect
- 23:44[music] if you were faced with the same
- 23:45scenario.
- 23:47Only about 13% of the swaps were
- 23:50noticed. Meanwhile, most were
- 23:52confidently defending a choice that they
- 23:55hadn't made with specific reasons
- 23:58attached like the earrings or the smile.
- 24:01The arguments were only drawn from the
- 24:02face that was actually in front of them,
- 24:05not any factors from the face that they
- 24:06originally picked. And across the board,
- 24:09these false explanations all came with
- 24:11the same confidence as those who
- 24:13actually made a choice.
- 24:17The researchers documented it and came
- 24:18up with the term choice blindness.
- 24:21The inability to notice that the outcome
- 24:23of a choice has been changed and then
- 24:26justifying it anyway.
- 24:28The two studies that we've highlighted
- 24:30in level four are all pointing to the
- 24:31same thing and [music] that thing exists
- 24:33inside of you.
- 24:35There's something in you whose job it is
- 24:37to explain your behavior and it doesn't
- 24:40have access to the actual inner workings
- 24:42of the things that you observe. It's not
- 24:44omniscient or all-knowing, but it feels
- 24:47that way because of how much confidence
- 24:49that we need in our decisions to survive
- 24:52our day-to-day lives. [music]
- 24:54So, this thing inside you sees what you
- 24:56did and then produces a reason, much in
- 24:58the same way a friend watching you
- 25:00would.
- 25:01The big difference between it and a
- 25:03friend is that it's never unable to
- 25:04provide an answer and it is never
- 25:06uncertain.
- 25:08The truth about level four is
- 25:11uncomfortable.
- 25:13"I know why I did that." really means "I
- 25:16have a very confident story about why I
- 25:18did that [music] and I have no way to
- 25:20check it from the inside."
- 25:22A real reason and an invented one arrive
- 25:25in the same way, instantaneously, fully
- 25:27formed and so, so certain. There's no
- 25:30moment where you can tell them apart
- 25:32because that moment
- 25:33it doesn't exist.
- 25:35Even your list of flaws comes from the
- 25:37same narrator, the one that defended a
- 25:39face that you never chose.
- 25:41Saying that you're a perfectionist might
- 25:43be true. It might also be the most
- 25:46flattering story that you could tell
- 25:48about yourself.
- 25:49And from the inside, you have no idea
- 25:52which is which.
- 25:53And this is where most people stop.
- 25:55Remember the 95% who said they were
- 25:57self-aware?
- 25:59This is the rung that most of them are
- 26:00standing on currently. It feels like the
- 26:03top because the narrator says so and the
- 26:06narrator never doubts itself.
- 26:08But confidence isn't proof. Certainty is
- 26:11simply what the narrator produces.
- 26:13That's what makes level [music] four so
- 26:15hard to escape. Looking inward isn't
- 26:18useless. Noticing what your body is
- 26:20doing and naming your feelings is
- 26:22exactly how you climbed the lower rungs.
- 26:25But here, every tool that you would use
- 26:27to climb out, whether it's reflection or
- 26:29journaling or asking yourself why, all
- 26:32of these things run through the same
- 26:34narrator and thinking harder using that
- 26:37narrator more isn't going to get you
- 26:39past it. It's just
- 26:41handing the narrator more material.
- 26:44Think about proofreading your own
- 26:45[music] work. You can read a paragraph
- 26:47five times and miss the same typo
- 26:50because you see what you meant to write,
- 26:52[music]
- 26:53but someone else can spot it in seconds.
- 26:55Reading it more carefully isn't going to
- 26:57fix it. The problem doesn't come down to
- 26:59effort.
- 27:00It's that you can't stop seeing what you
- 27:03intended.
- 27:04Eurich's research found the same thing.
- 27:07People who spend the most time thinking
- 27:09about [music] themselves aren't any
- 27:11better at knowing themselves, and in
- 27:12fact, some end up worse off. The only
- 27:15way up is to stop looking inward.
- 27:18The next rung needs information that you
- 27:20cannot [music] produce yourself, and it
- 27:22can only come from other people.
- 27:24And that sounds easy
- 27:27until you realize how little of it ever
- 27:30reaches you.
- 27:31We pick [music] friends who agree with
- 27:33us, and we hear criticisms as an attack.
- 27:36The people around us soften the truth to
- 27:38keep [music] up the peace.
- 27:40And the higher that you rise, the fewer
- 27:42people are willing to tell you anything
- 27:44at all. I mean, think of the boss whose
- 27:47jokes always get a laugh. Nobody, least
- 27:50of all him, knows whether he is actually
- 27:53funny.
- 27:54And at the very end, we'll catch the
- 27:56narrator in the act.
- 27:58A man whose brain had been cut in half,
- 28:01who stood up, walked out of a room, and
- 28:04explained exactly why.
- 28:07His reason was invented on the spot,
- 28:10>> [music]
- 28:10>> and he never noticed.
- 28:15In the 1960s, some surgeons began
- 28:18treating severe epilepsy by cutting the
- 28:20corpus callosum, the bundle of nerve
- 28:23fibers that connects the brain's two
- 28:24halves. It stopped seizures from
- 28:26spreading.
- 28:28It also stopped the two halves from
- 28:30sharing information.
- 28:31In most people, speech is controlled by
- 28:33the left half of the brain. So,
- 28:36researchers could show something to the
- 28:38right half alone, and the person would
- 28:40have no words for what they'd seen.
- 28:43In one test, a researcher flashed a
- 28:45single word to a split brain patient's
- 28:48right hemisphere,
- 28:49>> [music]
- 28:49>> and that word is walk.
- 28:51The patient stood up and headed for the
- 28:53door. When he was asked where he was
- 28:55going, he didn't hesitate. He said,
- 28:57"Well, I'm going to get a Coke."
- 28:59The talking half of his brain never saw
- 29:01the word. It only saw his body moving,
- 29:04so it invented a reason on the spot.
- 29:06And he wasn't lying. He believed [music]
- 29:08every word,
- 29:10but none of it was true.
- 29:12Neuroscientist Michael Gazzaniga, who
- 29:15studied these patients for decades,
- 29:17called this system the interpreter. A
- 29:20process in the left hemisphere that
- 29:21watches what you do and then writes a
- 29:23story to explain it. That is the
- 29:26narrator from level four.
- 29:28And the surgery didn't create a narrator
- 29:30from nothing.
- 29:31>> [music]
- 29:32>> It just cut it off from the truth, so
- 29:34everyone could see it working.
- 29:36But look at who actually knew why he
- 29:39stood up.
- 29:40Not him.
- 29:41The researcher.
- 29:43The only person in the room with the
- 29:45full picture was standing outside of his
- 29:47head.
- 29:48That's the key to level five.
- 29:51Some truths about you cannot be reached
- 29:53from the inside, no matter how hard you
- 29:55look. They can only be seen by someone
- 29:57watching.
- 29:59Psychologist Tasha Eurich splits
- 30:00self-awareness into two kinds: internal,
- 30:03how well you know your own values, your
- 30:05feelings, and reactions, and external,
- 30:08how well you know how other people see
- 30:11you. And she found the two are almost
- 30:13unrelated. [music]
- 30:14You can be excellent at one and terrible
- 30:16at the other, which means everything
- 30:18that you learned on the lower rungs
- 30:20buys you almost nothing here.
- 30:23Think of the friend who has no idea they
- 30:25light up a room. The one everyone waits
- 30:27for before the Discord call starts. The
- 30:30first name that comes up when there's a
- 30:32plan for the weekend. Chances are they
- 30:35have no idea. Someone on level five
- 30:37would know, including the parts that
- 30:39they would rather not.
- 30:41Most people only get to glimpse the
- 30:43outside view when they hear their own
- 30:45recorded voice and
- 30:47it sounds wrong. But that recording is
- 30:49the voice that everyone has heard all
- 30:51along. The version you know reaches you
- 30:54partly through your own skull.
- 30:56Everything about you works this way.
- 30:57Your tone, your face, your timing. You
- 31:00experience yourself from the one angle
- 31:03that nobody else ever sees.
- 31:05And once you know your own intentions,
- 31:07you can't imagine yourself without them.
- 31:10Psychologists call this the curse of
- 31:12knowledge.
- 31:14And that gap runs in both directions.
- 31:16In 2018, Erica Boothby and colleagues
- 31:19paired strangers for short conversations
- 31:21then asked each person to guess how much
- 31:24the other person liked them.
- 31:26People consistently underestimated it.
- 31:29The same gap held among university
- 31:30roommates over several months.
- 31:33Your narrator isn't just a flatterer or
- 31:35just a critic. It's wrong both ways,
- 31:37about your flaws and about your warmth.
- 31:41So, the outside view absolutely exists.
- 31:44It just lives in other people's heads
- 31:46and even what they share arrives
- 31:48filtered through their politeness or
- 31:50their fears or their affection.
- 31:52Even perfect feedback would only ever be
- 31:54a reflection.
- 31:56To get poetic, an eye cannot see itself.
- 31:59A camera can't photograph its own lens
- 32:01without a mirror. The ladder doesn't end
- 32:04at the summit. It ends at a wall made
- 32:07entirely of you.
- 32:09Which brings us back to the man walking
- 32:11out of the room.
- 32:13Every rung of this ladder has been the
- 32:14same thing, a brain reading signals and
- 32:17telling a story. Where your body ends,
- 32:20what you're feeling, why you chose, and
- 32:22how you came across.
- 32:24The interpreter writes all of it,
- 32:26whether you're watching or not.
- 32:28That's why the 95% felt so sure.
- 32:32Certainty was never a sign of
- 32:34self-awareness. It's just a byproduct of
- 32:36having an internal narrator.
- 32:38The 10 to 15% aren't the people who
- 32:40finally see themselves clearly.
- 32:43Nobody does.
- 32:45They're the people who stopped trusting
- 32:46the story and started asking people
- 32:48outside of the room.
- 32:50Because somewhere right now someone
- 32:54knows exactly [music] why you stood up
- 32:56and it wasn't to get a Coke.
- 32:59But asking only works if someone is
- 33:01still there to answer. And the people
- 33:02who see you most clearly, the ones who
- 33:05knew you first, rarely leave after one
- 33:08big fight. They drift, [music] one
- 33:11unanswered message at a time.
- 33:13>> [snorts]
- 33:13>> To understand why that happens and what
- 33:15it quietly takes [music] from you, watch
- 33:17this video next.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Every Level of Awareness by Aperture, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 5,358 words across 902 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.