YouTube2Text

Eveline Herfkens on Millennium Goals at Kapuscinski development lectures (full video) — Transcript

by UNDP Eurasia · 4,652 words · 856 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00okay let me
  2. 0:01let me go back uh today another summer
  3. 0:04started but i wanted to start my speech
  4. 0:06with
  5. 0:06taking you back to the summit in the
  6. 0:08year 2000
  7. 0:10when the millennium development goals
  8. 0:12were conceived
  9. 0:14um at that year all the world leaders in
  10. 0:17new york came together and they signed
  11. 0:19the millennium declaration in which they
  12. 0:21pledged we will spare no effort
  13. 0:24to put an end to extreme poverty we will
  14. 0:27spare no effort to get every kid to
  15. 0:29school we will spare no effort to
  16. 0:32radically reduce child mortality
  17. 0:34maternal mortality to reverse the aids
  18. 0:36pandemic etc all by the year 2015.
  19. 0:40and it was a great start of the
  20. 0:43the century of the 21st century this
  21. 0:45millennium
  22. 0:46because indeed
  23. 0:47for the first time in the history of
  24. 0:50mankind we have the means
  25. 0:52we have the resources and we have the
  26. 0:53knowledge to actually achieve these
  27. 0:56development goals and what happened in
  28. 0:58the year 2000 was this miracle that was
  29. 1:00even political consensus at the highest
  30. 1:04level across the globe about who should
  31. 1:07be doing what
  32. 1:08and how they should be implemented
  33. 1:10developing countries acknowledge that
  34. 1:12they are primarily responsibly
  35. 1:15responsible for achieving the goals but
  36. 1:17for the first time the rich countries
  37. 1:19really acknowledged publicly
  38. 1:21that they
  39. 1:22have to do a better job helping poor
  40. 1:25countries and that without that poor
  41. 1:27countries will not achieve these goals
  42. 1:30and these commitments are in the eighth
  43. 1:32goal and i will get back to
  44. 1:34that but let me first look at what we
  45. 1:37did over the last 12 years and actually
  46. 1:40i think there's a lot of good news you
  47. 1:42know we always tend to accentuate the
  48. 1:44negative the uh is really good at that
  49. 1:47but i think once in a while we should
  50. 1:48also celebrate progress
  51. 1:51and definitely the medium goals have
  52. 1:53enormously spurred action all across the
  53. 1:55globe many poor country governments have
  54. 1:59improved their governance
  55. 2:01they improved their policies and indeed
  56. 2:04rich countries have taken some not
  57. 2:06enough steps to increase the level and
  58. 2:09increase the effectiveness of their aid
  59. 2:10programs
  60. 2:11and you see there's progress across a
  61. 2:14large number of countries a large number
  62. 2:16of indicators
  63. 2:17the goals have helped to lift hundreds
  64. 2:19of millions of people out of poverty
  65. 2:21save life ensure that children attend
  66. 2:24school and they have reduced maternal
  67. 2:26death
  68. 2:27and expanded opportunities for women
  69. 2:30increased access to clean water freed
  70. 2:32many people from deadly and devastating
  71. 2:34diseases
  72. 2:35and in fact the number of people living
  73. 2:38in extreme poverty has declined in all
  74. 2:41regions all over the world and thus thus
  75. 2:43the first goal
  76. 2:45of halfing it proportionally has already
  77. 2:48been achieved
  78. 2:49and in education the second goal major
  79. 2:52advances have been made in getting
  80. 2:54children through school in many of
  81. 2:56particularly the poorest countries most
  82. 2:58of them in sub-saharan africa beating
  83. 3:00every historical record of acceleration
  84. 3:03of number of kids going to school
  85. 3:05the sixth goal is in reach
  86. 3:07new hiv aids infections are declining
  87. 3:10led by sub-saharan africa
  88. 3:13as are the number of age-related deaths
  89. 3:15thanks to huge increases of people
  90. 3:17receiving treatment and the same is true
  91. 3:19for melania for tuberculosis and
  92. 3:22actually the safe drinking water gold
  93. 3:24has already which is part of goal seven
  94. 3:26has already been achieved five years ago
  95. 3:30alas the two goals the news is a little
  96. 3:32bit more mixed child and maternal
  97. 3:35mortality
  98. 3:36child mortality has been reduced by a
  99. 3:38third which is actually incredible news
  100. 3:41given historical records that is huge
  101. 3:44progress but the goal actually was to
  102. 3:46reduce it
  103. 3:48by
  104. 3:49two-thirds and of course that were not
  105. 3:51attracted to me
  106. 3:52seeing with maternal mentality the sixth
  107. 3:54goal the number of women dying in
  108. 3:56childbirth
  109. 3:58and related complications
  110. 4:00has almost half again that is great news
  111. 4:04but over a quarter a quarter of a
  112. 4:06million women every year still die in
  113. 4:09pregnancy at a great presently we have
  114. 4:12we will not achieve the goal of reducing
  115. 4:15maternal mortality by three quarters
  116. 4:18now partly this lagging of the child and
  117. 4:21maternal authority goal has to do with a
  118. 4:22more general problem problem that
  119. 4:25progress
  120. 4:26tends to bypass
  121. 4:27those that are lowest on the economic
  122. 4:29ladder or are otherwise disadvantaged
  123. 4:32because of their sex their age
  124. 4:33disabilities ethnicity
  125. 4:36and also hardcore poverty continues to
  126. 4:39exist in sub-saharan africa
  127. 4:42but i don't want you to feel discouraged
  128. 4:44by those who claim
  129. 4:46that many poor countries are off track i
  130. 4:48actually hate that term
  131. 4:51because the marine development goals
  132. 4:52were never meant
  133. 4:54to be achieved individually in every
  134. 4:56single country that would not have been
  135. 4:58fair otherwise poorest countries would
  136. 5:01have been placed at a huge disadvantage
  137. 5:04for instance if you have to half the
  138. 5:05proportion of your poor
  139. 5:07that means a much higher level of
  140. 5:09performance from a country that starts
  141. 5:11with 80 percent of your people in
  142. 5:13extreme poverty than when it's only 20
  143. 5:16so instead of monitoring progress per
  144. 5:19country in terms of how much off track
  145. 5:21or on track they are in terms of the
  146. 5:23global goals you should actually try to
  147. 5:27see what the commitment of these
  148. 5:29countries are as measures
  149. 5:31by the effort to accelerate
  150. 5:34progress in achieving the goals and if
  151. 5:35you apply that method
  152. 5:37then
  153. 5:38if you compare the rate of improvement
  154. 5:40of indicators before
  155. 5:43and after
  156. 5:44then the storyline is dramatically
  157. 5:46different in fact eight of the top 10
  158. 5:49countries whose progress with the goals
  159. 5:51has accelerated most rapidly are in
  160. 5:54sub-saharan africa and progress among
  161. 5:56the least developed countries on average
  162. 5:58is better than faster than among
  163. 6:02non-ldc's
  164. 6:03so let's avoid laboring any countries as
  165. 6:06failures when they fall short of exactly
  166. 6:09being the global target at their
  167. 6:11national level now this progress that
  168. 6:13has been spurred by the millennium
  169. 6:15development goals is unprecedented
  170. 6:17if you look at the history of the united
  171. 6:19nations over the last 60 years
  172. 6:21multiple goals for economic and social
  173. 6:24development have been set everywhere
  174. 6:26but the degree in
  175. 6:28which
  176. 6:29the goals set became goals met
  177. 6:33dependent on the degree that these goals
  178. 6:36were known
  179. 6:37and owned publicly
  180. 6:39beyond the u.n bureaucrats and the
  181. 6:43development agencies and from that
  182. 6:45perspective the millennium goals have
  183. 6:47actually broken all records they have
  184. 6:49proven to be to have enormous popular
  185. 6:52power because they are clear
  186. 6:54concise they're time-bound and they put
  187. 6:57a human face on development and have
  188. 6:59proven to be a fantastic value as a
  189. 7:02framework to mobilize citizens and
  190. 7:05citizens mobilization is key
  191. 7:07because we live in a world of sovereign
  192. 7:09states
  193. 7:10and action is decided by national
  194. 7:13policies
  195. 7:15and actions
  196. 7:16country by country
  197. 7:18on the first seven goals by developing
  198. 7:20countries among eight by rich countries
  199. 7:23the u.n can create
  200. 7:25a platform an opportunity for
  201. 7:27governments to make
  202. 7:28commitments but it cannot enforce
  203. 7:31compliance the secretary general cannot
  204. 7:33send the police to austria if it fails
  205. 7:36to live up to the 0.7 that's been
  206. 7:38promising for decades
  207. 7:40it is only the citizens of this country
  208. 7:43and their representative in parliament
  209. 7:46that can hold their government to
  210. 7:47account for the promises that they make
  211. 7:50at international conferences
  212. 7:52and governments both north and south
  213. 7:55south just need up need to live up to
  214. 7:58what they promise internationally but
  215. 8:00they will only translate these promises
  216. 8:03in national policies
  217. 8:05when persistent and well organized
  218. 8:07constituencies domestically demand that
  219. 8:11so citizen support for anything agreed
  220. 8:14at the u.n is key in terms of having it
  221. 8:16implemented and if you then look at the
  222. 8:18goals you see in developing countries
  223. 8:20how these goals continue to inspire
  224. 8:23civil society to empower citizens to
  225. 8:26demand from their governments to deliver
  226. 8:29and to be accountable for these promises
  227. 8:32and i think governance is ultimately the
  228. 8:35most important factor to end poverty
  229. 8:39and it only improves governments in poor
  230. 8:41countries not by lectures of foreign
  231. 8:44donors
  232. 8:45and conditions but only when their own
  233. 8:47citizens
  234. 8:48force them to start acting recently
  235. 8:52and in many rich countries the goals
  236. 8:54have been used by civil society
  237. 8:57to educate citizens in rich countries
  238. 8:59about global poverty and they
  239. 9:01contributed to this emerging consensus
  240. 9:04in rich countries
  241. 9:05that actually the persistence of extreme
  242. 9:08poverty
  243. 9:09in an affluent world is actually morally
  244. 9:13unacceptable
  245. 9:14and these campaigns have helped to
  246. 9:16cement the political will
  247. 9:18that has led to unprecedented
  248. 9:20commitments by european union members to
  249. 9:23finally achieve the 0.7 with the time
  250. 9:25path
  251. 9:26um even if they haven't implemented it
  252. 9:29it really has created a breakthrough
  253. 9:32and i think this public support for the
  254. 9:34goals have been a crucial element to
  255. 9:36make that possible so the key
  256. 9:38achievement of the median goals is the
  257. 9:39extent that they have mobilized public
  258. 9:41opinion and political support
  259. 9:44now today two and a half years left
  260. 9:46until the
  261. 9:48we end up the in 2015 and you see
  262. 9:51that the debates already have started
  263. 9:53across the globe what do we do after
  264. 9:552015.
  265. 9:57now to me one thing is clear
  266. 10:00any post 2015 agreement needs to
  267. 10:03maintain that popular momentum we should
  268. 10:06not throw away
  269. 10:08that enormous capital of
  270. 10:10public
  271. 10:12support for these goals
  272. 10:14but also
  273. 10:15the goals objectives that you know were
  274. 10:17limited half reduced by two thirds
  275. 10:20reduced by three quarters so there is a
  276. 10:23large unfinished post 2015 agenda but
  277. 10:27that doesn't mean that in the run of
  278. 10:282015 we shouldn't evaluate on how to
  279. 10:32improve these instruments to achieve the
  280. 10:34goals and there's one flaw that has been
  281. 10:37already widely recognized and that is
  282. 10:39that the goals as such the way they are
  283. 10:42used
  284. 10:43they ignore
  285. 10:44inequality progress is measured in
  286. 10:47averages global level national level
  287. 10:50that ignores inequality issues
  288. 10:53and that is lethal
  289. 10:54because partly if the goals will not be
  290. 10:56achieved it is in partly because
  291. 10:59of disparities within countries
  292. 11:03or where they achieve rng the much of
  293. 11:05latin america for instance
  294. 11:07progress might have left totally out the
  295. 11:09very poor the very vulnerable
  296. 11:12if you only measure national leverages
  297. 11:15then progress might reflect advances
  298. 11:18for those populations just under
  299. 11:22under the line
  300. 11:24under the thresholds and it puts a
  301. 11:26premium for government action to lift
  302. 11:28those up and then in fact
  303. 11:31the inequality between these and those
  304. 11:33left behind might even increase
  305. 11:35so progress
  306. 11:37in these averages masks
  307. 11:40what is also called the ugly underbelly
  308. 11:42of globalization
  309. 11:44growing inequality and equality i was
  310. 11:47there was not on the agenda in the year
  311. 11:492000
  312. 11:51and we also had no proper data on it at
  313. 11:54the time and without data you can't make
  314. 11:57policies right
  315. 11:58but since a whole a lot of research has
  316. 12:01been done and it gained huge currency if
  317. 12:03you look at the summit in 2010
  318. 12:06where heads of states looked at progress
  319. 12:09there's very strong language about
  320. 12:11everybody's concern with inequality
  321. 12:13so there's a growing consensus the need
  322. 12:16to move away from averages but focus on
  323. 12:19lifting the floor
  324. 12:21for the most vulnerable and unprotected
  325. 12:23and that brings me to the subject of
  326. 12:26social protection as you said in the
  327. 12:28introduction i remember of the i'm a
  328. 12:29member of the bachelet group of the who
  329. 12:33and the
  330. 12:34and the ilo who written report about it
  331. 12:37to promote the concept
  332. 12:39to ensure that no one on earth should
  333. 12:41live below a certain income level and
  334. 12:44that everybody should have access to at
  335. 12:46least basic social services
  336. 12:49and social protection makes sense
  337. 12:51exactly for the poorest and most
  338. 12:54vulnerable because the essence of
  339. 12:56poverty is
  340. 12:57more than anything else
  341. 12:59the permanent lack of security
  342. 13:02where does your next meal come from
  343. 13:04what is the next health catastrophe
  344. 13:07in our family gonna cost me
  345. 13:09and the poor don't have resources to
  346. 13:12fall back on
  347. 13:13now of course social protection sounds a
  348. 13:15bit like okay that's great for rich or
  349. 13:17middle-income countries and indeed
  350. 13:20poorer border countries financial
  351. 13:21options are somewhat limited but it's in
  352. 13:24but you see that by now
  353. 13:26even some of the poorest countries in
  354. 13:28africa have successful examples
  355. 13:32of social protection
  356. 13:34um
  357. 13:35for instance
  358. 13:37cash transfers or what happened in
  359. 13:39rwanda
  360. 13:44they have
  361. 13:45extended basic health education basic
  362. 13:48health to basically
  363. 13:49near universal coverage i always like to
  364. 13:52make this example of the united states
  365. 13:55but for us it's an issue of civilization
  366. 13:57to have basic health insurance for
  367. 13:59everybody
  368. 14:02and as economies grow and fiscal space
  369. 14:05grows then you can expand the levels of
  370. 14:08social protection and across the
  371. 14:10developing world you see incredibly good
  372. 14:12examples
  373. 14:13of success
  374. 14:15stories like the brazilian bosa familia
  375. 14:18which provides basic income security for
  376. 14:21poor families in the form of cash
  377. 14:23transfers
  378. 14:24now
  379. 14:25so that's one issue that should be on
  380. 14:28the agenda
  381. 14:29in the post 2015 discussion the other
  382. 14:32issue is and i'm
  383. 14:34answering a bit of this because you had
  384. 14:36asked me to
  385. 14:37at the summit starting today
  386. 14:40the whole debate on sustainable
  387. 14:42development the whole debate on climate
  388. 14:43change
  389. 14:44should not should that not be one way or
  390. 14:47another be incorporated in the 2015 post
  391. 14:502015 consensus
  392. 14:53now i'm afraid that
  393. 14:56what is starting today in leo
  394. 14:58is call the earth summit but will
  395. 15:00definitely not
  396. 15:01save the earth
  397. 15:03the whole debate now for everybody who
  398. 15:05follows us knows this is more about
  399. 15:07preventing further steps back
  400. 15:10not about progress and there's the
  401. 15:12absolute usual deadlock between north
  402. 15:15and south and which countries are trying
  403. 15:18to whittle out of the commitments they
  404. 15:20made in rio 20 years ago
  405. 15:23they don't want to reconfirm these
  406. 15:26principles they agreed on them on
  407. 15:28financing on transfer of technology
  408. 15:31and on this
  409. 15:33principle of common and differentiated
  410. 15:35responsibilities which demands that more
  411. 15:38efforts will be made by rich countries
  412. 15:40not just because they can fork can
  413. 15:42afford them better but also give the
  414. 15:44responsibility of us rich countries for
  415. 15:46so much of the present pollution
  416. 15:49the emissions and the resource depletion
  417. 15:51now
  418. 15:52so i just don't see anything happening
  419. 15:55there the coming week
  420. 15:57but what i found interesting is that
  421. 15:59some countries have
  422. 16:00tabled a new concept about
  423. 16:03sustainable development targets
  424. 16:06to complement and reinforce the
  425. 16:08millennium development goals
  426. 16:10but there is no consensus on that
  427. 16:12whatsoever developing countries are
  428. 16:14extraordinarily suspicious
  429. 16:16that which countries want to dilute
  430. 16:19the development dimension of sustainable
  431. 16:21development
  432. 16:22and you know the lack of action of which
  433. 16:24countries on the millennium development
  434. 16:26goal on goal 8 i'll get back to that
  435. 16:28labor doesn't really help to build much
  436. 16:32confidence
  437. 16:33but even if this difficult impossible
  438. 16:35political situation can be overcome let
  439. 16:38me tell you i've been there it takes
  440. 16:40years and years let alone having heads
  441. 16:43of states and governments sign up to a
  442. 16:45detailed framework to actually get
  443. 16:47global consensus on concise goals on
  444. 16:50clear goals timeout on targets
  445. 16:53indicators etc so this is a process that
  446. 16:57alas not sure how long the earth can
  447. 16:59wait but it's not going to happen soon
  448. 17:01so
  449. 17:02i don't feel that those who care about
  450. 17:04the environment should actually wait
  451. 17:05until the uh cemetery delivers anything
  452. 17:08and what i always want to mention as a
  453. 17:11european when i make speeches in europe
  454. 17:14i always feel that we can just set some
  455. 17:16examples ourselves and blatant example
  456. 17:19that i always like to mention is
  457. 17:21agriculture
  458. 17:22this sector causes almost a third of the
  459. 17:24global greenhouse emissions
  460. 17:27why can't we just set the example as
  461. 17:29europeans
  462. 17:30put an end and eliminate all the
  463. 17:33damaging farm subsidies
  464. 17:35and changing our common agriculture
  465. 17:37policies would also be extremely helpful
  466. 17:40to reach out to the developing countries
  467. 17:43showing that we care about their
  468. 17:45development because
  469. 17:47two out of three
  470. 17:49poor people in the world
  471. 17:51are actually depending on agriculture
  472. 17:54giving rural areas and they won't lift
  473. 17:56themselves out of our poverty as long as
  474. 17:59our agricultural partners policy
  475. 18:01continues to destroy the markets that
  476. 18:03they depend on
  477. 18:04and it is the present food crisis is
  478. 18:07partly the result of decades and decades
  479. 18:11of trait distorting subsidies
  480. 18:13particularly european
  481. 18:14and high terrors here that have
  482. 18:16discouraged any investment in african
  483. 18:19agriculture
  484. 18:21and in fact already millennium
  485. 18:23development goal 8 does refer but in
  486. 18:25very vague terms to the need for us to
  487. 18:28open our markets for products from our
  488. 18:30country to reduce barriers particularly
  489. 18:33for agriculture products so it would be
  490. 18:34wonderful if we could move a bit on that
  491. 18:38and this brings me to go right because
  492. 18:40whatever the future framework
  493. 18:42of um
  494. 18:44the millennium development goals they
  495. 18:46will simply not be reached
  496. 18:48particularly nano subs in africa
  497. 18:51if we rich countries don't adhere to our
  498. 18:53promises
  499. 18:55and if you compare
  500. 18:56your judge progress to the goals
  501. 18:59what poor countries have been doing
  502. 19:01to implement them and what we have been
  503. 19:03doing
  504. 19:04then the verdict is really clear also by
  505. 19:06the heart-moved economists of the imf
  506. 19:09from the world bank
  507. 19:10that
  508. 19:11that we the rich countries are lagging
  509. 19:13in implementing our part of the deal
  510. 19:16to achieve 0.7 of our national income
  511. 19:19for gate to improve the effectiveness
  512. 19:21rate and to help to change the rules of
  513. 19:23international trade
  514. 19:25and i'm not saying i'm always very
  515. 19:27blonde and open about this
  516. 19:29and otherwise it would be helpful
  517. 19:32that
  518. 19:33austria frankly is among the eo 15 above
  519. 19:36the worst performer ultra committed
  520. 19:38itself as you know as a member of the eu
  521. 19:40to achieve 0.51 in 2010
  522. 19:44added
  523. 19:45to 0.7 2015
  524. 19:47but it's filled and it's failing its
  525. 19:49promise with only 0.27
  526. 19:53spent last year
  527. 19:54you actually rank even lower than spain
  528. 19:57and portugal
  529. 19:58and only within the eu
  530. 20:0115 only greece is doing worse than you
  531. 20:05and this is particularly
  532. 20:07disturbing because most economists
  533. 20:10strongly feel
  534. 20:11that country like austria and the
  535. 20:13numbers in germany by the way
  536. 20:14given all the historic austerity and
  537. 20:16deflationary policies in part of the
  538. 20:18eurozone are in a superb position to
  539. 20:21raise spending a view of inadequate
  540. 20:23global demand and what would be a better
  541. 20:26way
  542. 20:27to do so than increase your development
  543. 20:29cooperation budget
  544. 20:31now let me also say a few words about
  545. 20:34the quality of aid because i think that
  546. 20:35is at least as important as the volume
  547. 20:39alas again austria lags on its
  548. 20:41commitments to improve aid effectiveness
  549. 20:43if you i just can refer you to the
  550. 20:46peer reviews of the oecd
  551. 20:49development assistance committee
  552. 20:51but a more updated and very good tool to
  553. 20:54assess quality of aid among osd
  554. 20:55countries has been developed by the
  555. 20:57center for global development and it's
  556. 21:00called quota the quality of oda and you
  557. 21:02can find it on the website cgdef.org
  558. 21:06and then you will see that austria
  559. 21:09scores well below the average
  560. 21:12in the oecd
  561. 21:14on all dimensions of inequality that
  562. 21:16they measure and let me just mention a
  563. 21:18few examples
  564. 21:20first and most importantly
  565. 21:22austria fails to deliver aid in a way
  566. 21:25that enables poor country
  567. 21:27to take charge and use it for their own
  568. 21:30programs to achieve their end goals
  569. 21:32more than 80 percent
  570. 21:34of ocean aids cannot be used by
  571. 21:37developing countries to fund their
  572. 21:38programs
  573. 21:39of this indicator among osd countries
  574. 21:42and that includes korea etc
  575. 21:44the worst performance except for greece
  576. 21:47secondly it doesn't go
  577. 21:50to poor countries that need it now i
  578. 21:52understand that there's always a bit of
  579. 21:53geopolitics in any budget
  580. 21:55but in this case it's only 20
  581. 21:58of all of your eight budget that goes to
  582. 22:00low income countries so a whopping 80
  583. 22:04goes to countries that don't need
  584. 22:06external conceptual resources at all
  585. 22:08and some of them are striving
  586. 22:10economically while the rest of us and
  587. 22:12reception and they become donors
  588. 22:14themselves
  589. 22:15china turkey is still on the list of
  590. 22:17recipients
  591. 22:19third points
  592. 22:20that austria actually
  593. 22:22the most
  594. 22:23best way to face is the way i did it in
  595. 22:26switzerland because
  596. 22:27austria switzerland share this
  597. 22:30um this this point
  598. 22:32is a substantial recipient of its own
  599. 22:36aid
  600. 22:37you know that administrative costs to
  601. 22:40run your aid budget are paid out of that
  602. 22:42same a budget that's meant to fall you
  603. 22:45know poverty reduction out there and
  604. 22:47you've got the highest administrative
  605. 22:49costs and you know so there's
  606. 22:51on top of that
  607. 22:53except for korea and again greece you
  608. 22:56square the worst on time of it so a lot
  609. 22:59of irrated countries are forced to spend
  610. 23:03uh
  611. 23:05products procured in austria this
  612. 23:08is a very bad practice
  613. 23:10and it's also very corruption grow pro
  614. 23:13so most donors got rid of it but again
  615. 23:16together with korea and greece
  616. 23:19you're not doing well
  617. 23:21now this is not an easy time and i you
  618. 23:24know everybody in this audience will be
  619. 23:26allies on this
  620. 23:27uh to actually advocate
  621. 23:30to the for for the world's poor
  622. 23:32and you see across europe a legitimacy
  623. 23:35crisis of official development
  624. 23:37resistance even in countries like mine
  625. 23:39where there used to be for decades a
  626. 23:42very strong constituency
  627. 23:45um and that support of audience is
  628. 23:47taking a deep dive and i find that
  629. 23:50extremely tragic
  630. 23:51because yes
  631. 23:52it was wasted in the past
  632. 23:55but the international community over the
  633. 23:57last decade has taken enormous csv steps
  634. 24:00international grade steps to improve aid
  635. 24:03effectiveness today there is an
  636. 24:05internationally broad consensus
  637. 24:07based on evidence
  638. 24:09of well-documented lessons of half a
  639. 24:11century of aid part of which failed
  640. 24:14so today at least the donors know and
  641. 24:17acknowledge that they are part of the
  642. 24:19problem and they've committed themselves
  643. 24:21to become part of the solution
  644. 24:24and concrete action has been agreed
  645. 24:27lastly
  646. 24:28in the fall conference in busan
  647. 24:31and the eu member states last month
  648. 24:34now all the owners struggle with
  649. 24:36implementation of these lessons but
  650. 24:38again austria remains below the average
  651. 24:41in implementing them
  652. 24:42and let me tell you a bit about what
  653. 24:44these lessons are because part of it is
  654. 24:47that the public doesn't know what
  655. 24:48quality of aid is
  656. 24:51now the most important issue that is
  657. 24:53reflected in that new consensus
  658. 24:56is that donors must realize
  659. 24:58it is not us the donors it's not our aid
  660. 25:02that develop developing countries
  661. 25:05developing companies develop themselves
  662. 25:08and they are responsible
  663. 25:10and they have to be in charge of their
  664. 25:13development and without that ownership
  665. 25:16by developing countries of the process
  666. 25:19no aid yields lasting results
  667. 25:22now the traditional
  668. 25:24mode of aid
  669. 25:26was all kind of individual projects
  670. 25:29subjected to the donors procedures
  671. 25:32often ignoring the overall policies and
  672. 25:35responsibilities of developing country
  673. 25:37governments
  674. 25:38and this donor-led approach project
  675. 25:41approach to development led to this raft
  676. 25:44of very small uncoordinated donor
  677. 25:46projects with even when they were
  678. 25:48successful never really made a dent
  679. 25:52on development you see these projects
  680. 25:54where tiny items of perfection and
  681. 25:56oceans of despair
  682. 25:58but they collapsed back into the ocean
  683. 26:02um the moment the donor left because you
  684. 26:04can build your little school or hospital
  685. 26:06but who is gonna pay the salaries for
  686. 26:08the teachers and the church and the
  687. 26:10nurses and the maintenance
  688. 26:12so
  689. 26:13it didn't work and that old-fashioned
  690. 26:15aid also inhibited good governance
  691. 26:18accountability to us donors
  692. 26:21the pay master replaced about ability
  693. 26:24where it should be
  694. 26:26to their own citizens and to their own
  695. 26:28parliaments and this project approach is
  696. 26:30also enormously wasteful they're a huge
  697. 26:34transaction but you should realize that
  698. 26:36in today's world there are 225
  699. 26:40bilateral donors agencies and even more
  700. 26:43multilateral one and again also is part
  701. 26:46of the problem because you don't have
  702. 26:47one agency recipients have to deal with
  703. 26:50several
  704. 26:51and imagine that you're a poor recipient
  705. 26:53so you're working in the finance
  706. 26:55minister of a poor country you have to
  707. 26:57deal with all the different donor
  708. 26:58interests
  709. 26:59each with their different procedures
  710. 27:01each you have to report to
  711. 27:04and ask questions while they often
  712. 27:05operate in exactly the same direction uh
  713. 27:08sector you have to have meetings with
  714. 27:10them wine and dining
  715. 27:11take them for photo opportunities to
  716. 27:13their little projects
  717. 27:15now
  718. 27:16already scarce capacity in poor
  719. 27:18countries should be focused on managing
  720. 27:22their development
  721. 27:23not their donors programs
  722. 27:25and we donors we have to stop thinking
  723. 27:29about our austria or our dutch projects
  724. 27:33we should start
  725. 27:34thinking about their policies their
  726. 27:37education those are mixed education
  727. 27:39policies rwanda's health policies so we
  728. 27:43have to move away from building our
  729. 27:45schools and hospitals
  730. 27:47and we should stop
  731. 27:49are imposing our agendas and our
  732. 27:52priorities now despite all the lip
  733. 27:54service over a decade
  734. 27:56donors still continue to be addicted to
  735. 27:59micromanage their heroes now how come
  736. 28:02i think as a former minister that at the
  737. 28:05root of this is
  738. 28:07that parliaments and taxpayers want to
  739. 28:10know
  740. 28:11where did my tax euro go
  741. 28:15did it reduce poverty
  742. 28:17and i know that is
  743. 28:19information which is critical
  744. 28:20to maintain support for development
  745. 28:22cooperation
  746. 28:24now how do you then reconcile that
  747. 28:26factor
  748. 28:28with
  749. 28:29the critical need of allowing recipient
  750. 28:31countries to be in charge
  751. 28:34my
  752. 28:35idea is and it is in the bachelorette
  753. 28:37report why don't we use more of our aid
  754. 28:40to fund social protection programs then
  755. 28:44your aid directly helps to lift people
  756. 28:47out of poverty families out of poverty
  757. 28:50and by funding social protection for the
  758. 28:53poor and vulnerable
  759. 28:55you can both adhere
  760. 28:57to the respect ownership of the
  761. 29:00developing country but ensure your tax
  762. 29:02payers your parliament yes our tax
  763. 29:05heroes help lift people out of poverty
  764. 29:08now
  765. 29:09then why do i i'm summarizing vienna a
  766. 29:13bit longer
  767. 29:14why am i spending so much time about
  768. 29:16what austria should be doing
  769. 29:19um your government should be doing i'm
  770. 29:22sure some of you are involved in
  771. 29:23non-governmental efforts
  772. 29:25and these contribute to the millennium
  773. 29:27development goals and i think that each
  774. 29:29individual life improved by these
  775. 29:31efforts
  776. 29:32is worth celebrating
  777. 29:34but however much multiplied
  778. 29:37these efforts will never ever add up
  779. 29:40to compensate for the missing billion
  780. 29:44every year yes in the case of austria
  781. 29:46and missing billions of dollars every
  782. 29:48year
  783. 29:49that your own government promised and is
  784. 29:52not delivering
  785. 29:55and for the waste of millions of age
  786. 29:57funds
  787. 29:58because you're not implementing the aid
  788. 30:00effectiveness agreements
  789. 30:02it is only ultimately
  790. 30:05comprehensive government action that can
  791. 30:08make
  792. 30:09achieve the development goals
  793. 30:12and the most important contribution that
  794. 30:14citizens can make
  795. 30:16is to hold their own government into
  796. 30:18account
  797. 30:20so
  798. 30:20in many onlines i say when there are
  799. 30:22ngos around
  800. 30:24the issue basically is and i'm saying
  801. 30:26this very performatively it's not about
  802. 30:28raising funds it's about raising voices
  803. 30:33and why it's kind of interesting that in
  804. 30:34germanic languages including my own
  805. 30:37the the word for voices and votes is the
  806. 30:40same
  807. 30:42and it is actually what it's exactly
  808. 30:44about
  809. 30:45because the real problem is that
  810. 30:47government leaders step into their plays
  811. 30:50fly to international meetings make
  812. 30:53beautiful speeches and promises and then
  813. 30:55take the plane back home to business as
  814. 30:57usual
  815. 30:58and they get away with it as long as
  816. 31:01their citizens let them get away with it
  817. 31:04and living up to these promises thus
  818. 31:06requires public awareness citizens
  819. 31:09advocacy suggesting to political leaders
  820. 31:12that they will win votes not lose them
  821. 31:15if they support the right things if they
  822. 31:18help achieve the management development
  823. 31:20goals
  824. 31:21so raising voices
  825. 31:23telling your politicians that you want
  826. 31:25all shia to keep its promise to achieve
  827. 31:280.7 by 2015
  828. 31:31and that you want to see a credible time
  829. 31:33path budgetary leading to that from now
  830. 31:35on
  831. 31:36tell your politicians that you want your
  832. 31:38taxpayers money to be spent effectively
  833. 31:41for poverty
  834. 31:43reduction
  835. 31:44and that you want them to implement
  836. 31:46these commitments on aid effectiveness
  837. 31:48and that you want development data
  838. 31:50delivered in a fashion that enables poor
  839. 31:53countries to achieve these blame goals
  840. 31:55and that you want that age to go to the
  841. 31:58poor countries that actually need it
  842. 32:01and that you want that aid to be used
  843. 32:04not
  844. 32:04for financing austrian experts
  845. 32:07i mean you got the lowest unemployment
  846. 32:09the whole europe why would you need
  847. 32:12to use your meager aid budget to create
  848. 32:15jobs at home
  849. 32:16and you also should tell them to act now
  850. 32:19because we only have two and a half
  851. 32:20years left
  852. 32:22in the home stretch of the median
  853. 32:23development goals and we have to act i
  854. 32:26mean poor
  855. 32:27children poor women cannot wait thank
  856. 32:30you

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of Eveline Herfkens on Millennium Goals at Kapuscinski development lectures (full video) by UNDP Eurasia, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 4,652 words across 856 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.