【中国EVは本当に危険?】日本人が作るシナリオは全部ウソ!BYDの完璧すぎる戦略を解説【マイキー佐野 投資学】 — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:02They’re starting to see massive
- 0:03profits, but the company itself has
- 0:05actually run out of cash. That’s
- 0:09where this comes in.
- 0:10Hi, everyone, it’s Kei. I’m filming
- 0:12for YouTube again today.
- 0:13Let’s do it.
- 0:13Let’s do it.
- 0:14Today, we’ve been talking about
- 0:16China's BYD every single day, and there
- 0:17was news about them again yesterday.
- 0:19BYD.
- 0:20What did you think? BYD.
- 0:22Since we’ve been talking about them
- 0:23in our videos, when you look at the
- 0:25market, there are negative opinions,
- 0:26like they’re not actually selling
- 0:28well or they’re in the red
- 0:29domestically. Looking at the comment
- 0:31section, people say Chinese
- 0:33manufacturers are going under because
- 0:35they’re in the red, so I’d like to
- 0:37hear your analysis, Mayu, on the real
- 0:39strengths of the Chinese industry.
- 0:41You know, there are tons of reports
- 0:42about "red ink" and "bankruptcy risks,"
- 0:44but aren't there many cases where
- 0:45they're intentionally operating at a
- 0:46huge loss to move more vehicles?
- 0:48Even if positive news about China comes
- 0:50out, those people still pop up;
- 0:51honestly, they’re just sad people who
- 0:53don’t understand industrial structure
- 0:55. Yeah. For example, they highlight
- 0:58things like reporting an operating loss
- 1:00of 5,600 dollars per vehicle, or how
- 1:02they continue to stay in the red in the
- 1:04end—we've seen plenty of that. They
- 1:07only look at those headlines, but if
- 1:09you look at the structure of China's
- 1:11auto industry, it’s not a problem to
- 1:12be in the red. If you say that every
- 1:15company in the red is failing, well,
- 1:17then Tesla would be gone too.
- 1:20Unfortunately, far from collapsing,
- 1:22China’s EV industry is seeing its
- 1:23tech development speed increase
- 1:25dramatically, and they’re boosting
- 1:27domestic market share while
- 1:28simultaneously growing their global
- 1:30presence. Just look at Southeast Asia;
- 1:33most taxis have switched over, and
- 1:34they’re selling way more than
- 1:36Japanese manufacturers, so there are
- 1:37things you just can't see if you only
- 1:39live in Japan.
- 1:40That's true.
- 1:41It’s a fact that China's EV industry
- 1:42is already in a price war domestically,
- 1:44and profit margins are shrinking. That
- 1:46is a fact. But only the companies that
- 1:49have survived through that are the ones
- 1:50left standing. Let’s start from the
- 1:52early days. China was heavily supported
- 1:56by subsidies and tax incentives from
- 1:57both central and local governments.
- 2:00Around 2018, it's said that there were
- 2:02500 startups alone. These EVs existed,
- 2:04but most of them ended up disappearing.
- 2:06Then, after 2020, we entered a phase of
- 2:09consolidation. The central government
- 2:12began reducing or eliminating purchase
- 2:14subsidies for vehicles. The market
- 2:17shifted from government-led to fully
- 2:19market-driven competition. Companies
- 2:23that could scale, like BYD, NIO, Geely,
- 2:26and Xpeng, survived, but 400 companies
- 2:29vanished between 2018 and 2025. They
- 2:33either ceased operations, went bankrupt
- 2:35, or withdrew from the market. About
- 2:37100 companies remain now, but analysts
- 2:40expect that number to drop below 50 by
- 2:422030, and I only cover about a dozen on
- 2:44my channel. These are the ones that
- 2:46have survived this brutal environment.
- 2:49Because of this, their development
- 2:50efficiency is incredibly high, and they
- 2:52are constantly boosting cost
- 2:54competitiveness; the average EV model
- 2:56development time is said to be about 18
- 2:58months until mass production. Compared
- 3:00to American, European, or Japanese
- 3:01firms, which take 36 to 48 months, they
- 3:03are achieving this at more than double
- 3:05the speed. And on top of that, there is
- 3:07the battery pack cost. This has been
- 3:08significantly reduced, hasn't it? The
- 3:10recent Zeekr announcement became famous
- 3:11for its ability to ultra-fast charge in
- 3:13just a few minutes, even at -30 degrees
- 3:14. This has now become a practical
- 3:16reality. The costs themselves have been
- 3:17brought down to the same level as
- 3:19gasoline vehicles within China. They
- 3:20are seeing significant sales success in
- 3:22Southeast Asia and other overseas
- 3:24markets. While some say they won't sell
- 3:26in Japan, they are selling extremely
- 3:28well abroad. Even so, there is still
- 3:29talk about whether they are running at
- 3:31a loss. Direct subsidies are gradually
- 3:34being phased out, but the most
- 3:35significant development isn't subsidies
- 3:37, but market entry, specifically the
- 3:39full-scale introduction of the "double
- 3:41credit" system. The first is what they
- 3:45call CAFC. These are credits based on
- 3:48meeting average fuel economy standards
- 3:50for gasoline vehicles, and the other is
- 3:52called NEV. These are credits based on
- 3:54the target production ratio of EVs and
- 3:56other new energy vehicles relative to
- 3:58total production volume. These two
- 3:59things exist. What this means is that
- 4:01there are many manufacturers that
- 4:02cannot meet these fuel efficiency
- 4:04standards for the vehicles they produce
- 4:05. They are required to purchase credits
- 4:07from EV manufacturers on the market.
- 4:09They use these credits to offset their
- 4:10excess emissions. Companies that cannot
- 4:12manage these credits face very strict
- 4:14standards in China, including the
- 4:16suspension of sales. Secondly, the
- 4:18average price of these credits has
- 4:20tripled, jumping threefold between 2020
- 4:22and 2021. This has become a source of
- 4:25non-operating income for EV companies.
- 4:27Tesla was also earning from this; in
- 4:292020, Tesla China, specifically.
- 4:31Yes.
- 4:32They made 1.5 billion dollars just from
- 4:34selling credits alone. If they hadn't
- 4:36earned this credit revenue in China,
- 4:37they would have ultimately been in the
- 4:39red. In 2021, it was 2.9 billion
- 4:41dollars. BYD also sold about 3.4
- 4:43billion yuan—around 50 billion yen—
- 4:46worth of credits, using them to raise
- 4:48cash. Operating in parallel with the
- 4:51central government's policy design are
- 4:52the local governments. They aim to
- 4:55cluster regional industries, secure
- 4:57employment, and increase tax revenue,
- 4:59supporting this through local funds.
- 5:02They are injecting capital into EVs
- 5:04through state-owned investment
- 5:06platforms. A famous story from around
- 5:082020 is that NIO, which is now starting
- 5:10to generate significant profits,
- 5:12actually saw its cash reserves dry up.
- 5:14That is where Hefei comes into the
- 5:16picture. Do you remember Hefei? It has
- 5:18become a hub for China's semiconductor
- 5:19memory industry.
- 5:20Yes.
- 5:21The Hefei government fund made a direct
- 5:23investment of 7 billion yuan. They used
- 5:26that to attract the company to their
- 5:28region. In exchange for moving their
- 5:30headquarters and production base to
- 5:31Hefei, the city invested in them, and
- 5:33this is how NIO recovered its
- 5:34performance. Consequently, Hefei itself
- 5:36achieved a capital gain. Hefei is also
- 5:39a cluster for memory, motors, smart
- 5:41devices, and suppliers, building an
- 5:43ecosystem that improves their
- 5:45production efficiency. To summarize,
- 5:48these Chinese EV makers are heavily
- 5:50supported by their local governments.
- 5:53They can also secure low-interest loan
- 5:55quotas from state-owned banks,
- 5:57constantly creating a situation where
- 5:59they can continue facility investments
- 6:00and store expansion even when in the
- 6:02red, thanks to significant external
- 6:04funding. The news saying Chinese
- 6:06companies won't last just because they
- 6:08report losses is merely looking at
- 6:09headlines; are you actually looking at
- 6:11their accounting? You can't really tell
- 6:13without looking this deep, right? That
- 6:14would be the final net profit or loss.
- 6:16Something you have to look at
- 6:17simultaneously, of course, is the gross
- 6:19margin. Another thing you must look at
- 6:21regarding profit is capital. Basically,
- 6:23most media outlets are focusing only on
- 6:25the net profit level. However, if you
- 6:27look at the cost structure of major
- 6:29Chinese EVs, the cost of manufacturing
- 6:31a single vehicle is not in the red. It
- 6:34is not a structural deficit where they
- 6:36lose money per unit; they are in the
- 6:38red because they are making significant
- 6:40upfront fixed investments in areas like
- 6:42R&D, fast-charging infrastructure, and
- 6:44building company-owned stores. As you
- 6:46can see from the case study I just
- 6:48mentioned, the sales growth rate is 33%
- 6:51between '24 and '25. It was growing.
- 6:53That's 87.4 billion yuan. Gross margin
- 6:56has also improved significantly, from
- 6:599.9%to 17.5%. And since the gross
- 7:02margin for the vehicle alone has gone
- 7:04from 12.3%to 18.1%, it proves that mass
- 7:06production spreads out fixed costs,
- 7:08ultimately lowering the break-even
- 7:10point and leading to improvement.
- 7:13Xiaomi itself made headlines for
- 7:15posting an operating loss of $ 5,600
- 7:18per unit, but what does this include?
- 7:21Initial factory construction costs and
- 7:23R&D for new car models. These are just
- 7:25calculated figures with R&D expenses
- 7:27added on top. They've delivered 23,000
- 7:30units in 10 months, and fixed costs are
- 7:32falling significantly, so that's the
- 7:34structure I'm judging them by. Now, are
- 7:36you looking at the supply chain? Major
- 7:39Chinese EV companies have a powerful
- 7:41financial mechanism that prevents them
- 7:42from running out of cash, even when
- 7:44they're operating at a loss. And what
- 7:47is this? It's their bargaining power
- 7:49over suppliers. They extend their
- 7:51accounts payable. For companies like
- 7:53BYD or Tesla's Shanghai plant, over 90%
- 7:55of it is localized. In the supply chain
- 7:58, automakers hold significant
- 7:59bargaining power over parts
- 8:01manufacturers. And that's where these
- 8:03promissory notes come into play.
- 8:04They're referred to as "passing the
- 8:06bucket," which essentially means
- 8:07forcing losses onto the downstream
- 8:09companies. So what happens if those
- 8:11downstream companies go bankrupt? As I
- 8:13mentioned before, China tries to
- 8:14prevent even loss-making companies from
- 8:16going under, because otherwise, they
- 8:17wouldn't be able to collect taxes.
- 8:19The question is, are you looking as far
- 8:21as those local suppliers? To put it
- 8:23simply, the moment they sell a car, the
- 8:25automaker gets 1 million yen. But
- 8:27you're told that payment isn't due for
- 8:28a few months. So, you receive a 1
- 8:30million yen deposit. But you're told
- 8:32the parts cost can be paid in three or
- 8:33six months. As you grow, it
- 8:35energetically shifts to 1, 2, 3, 4, or
- 8:385 million yen.
- 8:39So, your balance increased by 3 million
- 8:41yen. Your sales went up. If you have to
- 8:43pay 800,000 yen after three months, do
- 8:45you see how different it is paying that
- 8:46from 1 million versus paying it from 3
- 8:48million?
- 8:49It’s completely different.
- 8:51Since cash is piling up, they're
- 8:52pouring it into equipment investments.
- 8:55Between construction costs and
- 8:56depreciation, they're recording
- 8:58development expenses, so they show a
- 9:00loss on paper. One key point is whether
- 9:06you're effectively managing your cash
- 9:08conversion cycle, or CCC. That's a key
- 9:14point, but the scary part is what
- 9:16happens if a growth manufacturer’s
- 9:18growth suddenly stops; that’s why
- 9:19reports on why assets are low focus on
- 9:21this system. If the rate keeps dropping
- 9:26, cash liquidity worsens, and that’s
- 9:28the scariest part. It doesn't mean
- 9:33they'll go bankrupt just because
- 9:34they're in the red for a quarter; it
- 9:36only gets dangerous if it's negative
- 9:38long-term, but they also have strategic
- 9:39investments from foreign funds and bank
- 9:41backing. Their funding pipeline is
- 9:47robust, reinforcing the company's
- 9:48strength, which is why China won't
- 9:50collapse right now. At this stage, yes.
- 9:53They’re unlikely to go under. Reports
- 9:58about Chinese EV deficits are just
- 10:00looking at a single P&L calculation,
- 10:02ignoring that they have profit engines
- 10:04while money is pouring in from the
- 10:05outside. So, they have the funds.
- 10:10That’s why they won’t go bankrupt.
- 10:11Actually, Chinese manufacturers have
- 10:13accelerated their development speed
- 10:14significantly and are aggressively
- 10:16targeting the global market. You hear
- 10:17it all the time—Japanese
- 10:18manufacturers are losing their footing
- 10:20in Southeast Asia precisely because
- 10:21Chinese brands are moving in. Once you
- 10:23lose ground, it’s incredibly
- 10:24difficult to win it back. Exactly. In
- 10:26the long run, as they continue to
- 10:28capture the Japanese market, it becomes
- 10:30easy for companies to operate in the
- 10:31red, and they have the state support to
- 10:33keep funding them until that happens.
- 10:35Oh, absolutely. The thing about China
- 10:37is that they take a long-term view.
- 10:39They have this ultimate trump card
- 10:40where the state continues to subsidize
- 10:42them even through years of losses, or
- 10:44they have the ability to raise massive
- 10:45amounts of capital from outside, making
- 10:47them very hard to crush.
- 10:48So you're saying we have to look at
- 10:49government policy as well.
- 10:50That’s exactly right. That’s the
- 10:52situation we find ourselves in. For
- 10:53those of you who watched until the end
- 10:54today, I’ve put together a report
- 10:55with more detailed information on what
- 10:57we discussed. If you'd like to receive
- 10:58the report, please grab it via our
- 11:00official LINE account. Also, if you
- 11:01found today’s content educational or
- 11:03useful, please be sure to subscribe to
- 11:05the channel and leave a comment. I
- 11:09happened to be watching the news on NHK
- 11:11yesterday, and BYD was holding a press
- 11:13conference. The vice president or
- 11:14someone like that was giving a
- 11:16presentation in really impressive
- 11:17Japanese, talking about hitting 10
- 11:19million vehicles.
- 11:2010 million vehicles sold.
- 11:21Yeah, that was the one.
- 11:22Well, it’s only a matter of time
- 11:24before they overtake Toyota.
- 11:25Is that so? You can even see that far
- 11:27ahead? Talking about the hierarchy?
- 11:29They were actually promoting their "
- 11:30height" as a selling point, and I
- 11:31thought, "Hey, this is exactly what
- 11:33Mikey was talking about a month ago."
- 11:35They were saying that at the press
- 11:36conference. As expected of Mikey,
- 11:38you're always ahead of the curve. It
- 11:40finally reached Japan a month later.
- 11:42I’ve been keeping an eye out, and I
- 11:44do see BYDs around now.
- 11:45Oh, really? I never leave the house, so
- 11:47I wouldn't know.
- 11:48There’s a BYD parked right behind my
- 11:50place.
- 11:50Maybe there's one in my apartment's
- 11:52parking lot, too.
- 11:53Though the parking lot at my building
- 11:54is mostly Lamborghinis, Ferraris, and
- 11:56Rolls-Royces.
- 11:57Must be nice living in such an
- 11:58insufferable place.
- 11:59The bad parts.
- 12:01Well, if you guys find that BY-Bari,
- 12:03let me know in the comments.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of 【中国EVは本当に危険?】日本人が作るシナリオは全部ウソ!BYDの完璧すぎる戦略を解説【マイキー佐野 投資学】 by マイキーの非道徳な社会学, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 2,200 words across 375 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.