Epstein Röportaj — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00seen there's been 115 billion people
- 0:02roughly that have lived on the earth. Uh
- 0:05and of that 115 billion new
- 0:07>> are you sure that's a number? That
- 0:08sounds a lot very high. We only have
- 0:09seven now.
- 0:11>> I I think in the history of the earth I
- 0:13think I I'll I'll pull I'll pull up the
- 0:15the stat for you but I think it's 115
- 0:17billion people they figure
- 0:18>> that probably is inflation. That's why
- 0:20>> have have lived through have lived
- 0:21through the have lived on earth but he's
- 0:23one of the handful of the most
- 0:24important.
- 0:26>> What did he solve for? Why is he so
- 0:29important for how we live today? And
- 0:30then we want to go through Libnetss and
- 0:33the other two or three other major ones
- 0:34that get us to Santa Fe.
- 0:36>> Well, that's a long it's a long journey.
- 0:38>> It's this is the heart of the this is
- 0:40the heart of what we're trying to do.
- 0:41>> Let me take a bit of a detour just a
- 0:43second.
- 0:44>> What if you if you went to high school
- 0:46and the last year in your high school
- 0:50you took calculus.
- 0:52So Isaac Newton sort of invents
- 0:54calculus. But that sounds vents. You
- 0:56know, mathematicians
- 0:57>> to torture to torture seniors in high
- 0:59school before they graduate.
- 1:00>> Yes, but obviously no. Yes, the answer
- 1:02is yes. Certain people can't could never
- 1:04do calculus. Uh
- 1:06>> why why is that? Why is calculus so why
- 1:09is that the dividing line between you
- 1:12know to me people who can handle that
- 1:14and can go on to do certain things and
- 1:17people just hit the wall even if they
- 1:19know math. It seems to me that there's
- 1:21that that that calculus is the is the
- 1:23thing that changes it. It it it it
- 1:26bridges. That's because it's about the
- 1:27the about the theory of change and the
- 1:30theory of how things change. It it's a
- 1:33great question. But in fact, what
- 1:35calculus does is it's it's somewhat
- 1:38philosophical. That's why mathematics is
- 1:40is you know they used to Newton wasn't a
- 1:42mathematician. He was called a geometer.
- 1:44That's what they used to call
- 1:45themselves. they understood geometry and
- 1:48and numbers. But there was an there's an
- 1:51old
- 1:53conundrum
- 1:55uh where it says if and during
- 1:58Pythagoras days Zeno's paradox it's
- 2:01called where they said well if I take if
- 2:04the wall is 2 feet away from me and I
- 2:06take one step that's halfway to the wall
- 2:10that'll be one foot away and if I take
- 2:12another step that's half again that'll
- 2:13be half a foot away then a quarter of a
- 2:15foot. I could walk forever but never
- 2:18touch the wall.
- 2:20Doesn't sound realist. Doesn't make any
- 2:22sense in our real lives of the physical.
- 2:26But what Newton understood is many
- 2:28problems were like that. Many things
- 2:30approached the wall or in his in
- 2:33calculus approached the limit
- 2:36but never really reached it. So he said
- 2:39it's okay. You don't have to reach it.
- 2:41We can do lots of the mathematics as if
- 2:43it was so close it was almost there.
- 2:48And we could do lots of mathematics
- 2:49almost being at the limit. And this is
- 2:52really important, Steve, for today
- 2:55because most of the science up until
- 2:57today
- 2:59was things that are starting to approach
- 3:01the limit.
- 3:04this. You were taught in high school
- 3:07that if you had 1 divided by 0.
- 3:13If you remember your high school
- 3:14algebra, you were told, "What's the
- 3:17answer to that?" Is there an answer to
- 3:18one divided by 0? No. If you were in
- 3:21high school, it's like stay away from
- 3:23it's the boogeyman. Uh you could write
- 3:25it down as it's undefined.
- 3:29It's not able to be determined.
- 3:32that there's a bunch of things
- 3:35but in fact one divided by zero is a
- 3:38strange things happen. It's a world of
- 3:40the strange. And what I'll explain to
- 3:43you after is that when you get one
- 3:46divided by zero, you get into a world we
- 3:48don't know what happens. The answer is
- 3:49it's not explainable. We can give it we
- 3:52can call it things like undetermined.
- 3:54This is what we can give have a
- 3:55convention to say it it's x y or z. But
- 3:58in real life we don't know what happens
- 4:00when you are actually at the limit.
- 4:05So that's an Newton thought the same
- 4:08concept is that the limits were Philip
- 4:10God. You got close to God but you can
- 4:12never be God. He had this sort of
- 4:14religious interpretation.
- 4:16>> Okay, I want to go back to Newton. Why
- 4:18is Newton such a big dividing line in
- 4:21mankind's history? What is it about
- 4:23Newton? What is about what he trying to
- 4:24solve? What did they not know
- 4:26beforehand? And what the because we live
- 4:29to a degree in a non Newtonian universe
- 4:32although I realized later sub sub
- 4:34particle atomic physics but at least for
- 4:37a while it was Newtonian. So what's the
- 4:39dividing line? Why is he so important?
- 4:41Why is he an inflection point in
- 4:42mankind's
- 4:44movement from the swamp to the stars?
- 4:46>> It's a great question.
- 4:48Stars was by Kepler. What what Newton
- 4:50starts to allow us to do is to make
- 4:54prediction accurate predictions.
- 4:55Remember that we've got talked about
- 4:57that with money about the things in our
- 5:00physical world. How cars he didn't have
- 5:04cars then. How horse carriages moved.
- 5:06How things how bowling balls moved. How
- 5:09pool cues and pool excuse me pool table
- 5:13balls?
- 5:14>> People tried to solve that before
- 5:15Newton. Many
- 5:17>> Heracitis or or or you know Platinus
- 5:20Pythagoras had had these greats that we
- 5:23hear about. Had they tried to solve the
- 5:25same problem?
- 5:26>> Not the same problem. They try to again
- 5:28what Pythagoras does he starts to figure
- 5:31out this relationships
- 5:33in triangles. For example, everyone
- 5:35knows the A square plus B square is
- 5:37equal to C square. That Pythagorean
- 5:39theorem which is basically says these
- 5:43shapes in a triangle each side of the
- 5:46triangle has a fixed relationship with
- 5:50the other two sides.
- 5:52That's strange. He knew again, but it
- 5:55was all numbers. This was a a system of
- 5:58things in the physical world. And
- 6:00Pythagoras says, "We can start putting
- 6:02numbers on things that help you predict
- 6:04how they will behave. You can add two
- 6:06triangles and make a square, some
- 6:09different shapes." They were looking at
- 6:11geometric forms. Newton says, "Well, I
- 6:14want to know how planets move. I want to
- 6:16know how things around me move. Can we
- 6:19find formulas? Can I find formulas that
- 6:23explain what I see in the physical
- 6:26world? How physical things interact and
- 6:30how they describe one another.
- 6:33Again, that the fact that two things,
- 6:35two solid masses, for some very strange,
- 6:40unknown reason, unknown today, attract
- 6:42one another no matter what they are.
- 6:45People have seen the experiment you hang
- 6:46of something two little metal balls from
- 6:48a string.
- 6:50They move towards each other. In fact,
- 6:54there's a they move towards each other
- 6:56was a very I'm very specific. So when
- 6:59you drop
- 7:02the ball to the floor of this room,
- 7:06Newton says in fact the room came up a
- 7:08bit to meet the ball. The room moved.
- 7:12It's impercept. you can't really
- 7:14perceive that motion but they attracted
- 7:17each other with certain ratios. So he
- 7:18started to be able to measure things in
- 7:21the physical world and that was
- 7:24great advances. It also now you wanted
- 7:27to move move very quickly. Unfortunately
- 7:30most people especially in the 20th
- 7:32century 19th century said well like
- 7:34Newton let's measure everything.
- 7:38Let's measure
- 7:40people's behavior. Let's measure their
- 7:42psychology. Let's measure their health.
- 7:44You go to the We could have my blood
- 7:47test. Let's measure everything. Measure
- 7:48Wall Street.
- 7:49>> Their their voting habits.
- 7:51>> Measure. Measure. Measure. Can we put a
- 7:53number on how much I care for my wife?
- 7:56Can I put a number on how I feel?
- 8:00And we tried unfortunately we ma tried
- 8:04to mathematize the the finer things in
- 8:06life and then recognized that there are
- 8:10things that unfortunately just fall
- 8:12outside. Everyone Schroinger wrote a
- 8:16very famous book about what is life. He
- 8:18was trying to figure out a way can he
- 8:21describe the difference formulaically
- 8:26between things that are alive and things
- 8:27that are dead. The answer is no. The
- 8:29things that are alive in my world are
- 8:32miracles, not magic. Magic has a bad
- 8:35connotation.
- 8:37>> You don't believe in the spirit or the
- 8:39soul. That's what animates people is
- 8:40your spirit or your soul. That's what
- 8:42But you've Have you ever seen someone
- 8:43die? When they die, their spirit leaves.
- 8:45>> The soul leaves. No question. So in
- 8:47fact,
- 8:47>> there's no question to you about that.
- 8:49>> No question.
- 8:49>> What? There's no question to you that
- 8:51there is some animating life force
- 8:54within us that leaves when you're dead.
- 8:56>> Yes. In fact, I refer to the soul this
- 8:59obviously a certain the questions in the
- 9:02past even during
- 9:03>> people would normally think you were
- 9:04soulless. So thank you to have you no
- 9:07but have you talk about you actually
- 9:09believe in it
- 9:10>> and have done some thinking about it is
- 9:12pretty shocking in its own right isn't
- 9:14it? Well again mathemat linets and
- 9:18linets thought said
- 9:20>> you know Newton was at Cambridge and he
- 9:22was the head of the math department
- 9:23right he's a professor essentially
- 9:24>> but linenets who was lineness a German
- 9:27professor
- 9:27>> yes but what linenets said is
- 9:31the soul is so strange that because God
- 9:34took chemicals which is simply the
- 9:37material like tables and he somehow made
- 9:41this material able to have a thought how
- 9:44strange changes that not only does it it
- 9:46have a soul but this some way it was put
- 9:50together that this material substance
- 9:53can is able to think. So when you say to
- 9:57me it's obvious to everyone that there's
- 10:00such a thing as a soul. Now if you're
- 10:03part of the charlatanville you'll try to
- 10:05explain it to people. The soul I
- 10:08describe is the dark matter of the
- 10:11brain. Why is it dark matter? Because in
- 10:14high energy physics nowadays you hear
- 10:17terms of dark matter, dark energy.
- 10:20Again, terminology complicated term. Why
- 10:23is it dark matter? Because we can't see
- 10:24it. That's all. What? What do you mean
- 10:26you can't see it? Well, somehow we see
- 10:30something moving towards this area of
- 10:32darkness. Something I can see this
- 10:35thing. This appears to me to be empty.
- 10:38It's just black. But I see it being
- 10:40drawn this way. So I say, well, I know
- 10:44if this were matter, that would follow
- 10:47that equation. If this was solid, it it
- 10:50would explain the way this particle
- 10:52moves,
- 10:54but I can't see anything here. So I'll
- 10:57just call it dark matter. And we'll say,
- 11:00I don't know what it is, but it behaves
- 11:02as if there was something there. The
- 11:04soul is obvious to everyone
- 11:08that there's something different between
- 11:10things that are alive and things that
- 11:11are not alive. But we have no idea what
- 11:13it is. It's currently unexplainable. I
- 11:17believe we need an entirely different
- 11:20system of analysis to try to figure out
- 11:24>> but no with Newton you know with all his
- 11:28alchemic study alche chemical studies
- 11:31and and and and things he worked on
- 11:33spiritual side libnets that just talked
- 11:35about the soul Schroeder talked about
- 11:37what is life. If a modern scientist or
- 11:40someone that you funded at MIT or
- 11:41Harvard or one of these things talked in
- 11:43those types of terms, they would be
- 11:46considered to be a wing nut today,
- 11:47wouldn't they? They would not be they
- 11:49would not be on the path uh for tenure,
- 11:52right?
- 11:53>> Unless they were in the philosophy
- 11:55department.
- 11:56>> That this is exactly my point. We're
- 11:57talking about three of the greatest
- 11:58mathematicians in mankind's history that
- 12:01have really changed mankind. Talking
- 12:03like this, what happened? How do we get
- 12:05to a situation where they could not be
- 12:08in the high physics, you know, they
- 12:10could not be in the mathemat in the
- 12:11mathematics department or working in
- 12:14>> high energy physics.
- 12:15>> Good. It's an easy answer.
- 12:16>> Newton was a combination of
- 12:18mathematician or geometry then and
- 12:21philosopher and as time went on that
- 12:24those disciplines seemed to move apart.
- 12:26We had philosophy who some of the
- 12:28philosophers can't do math and some of
- 12:30the mathematicians and again
- 12:32mathematicians often break into two
- 12:33categories. People that solve problems
- 12:36those are more like geometries and the
- 12:38old is just problem solvers. And then
- 12:40there's thinkers, theoreticians. They're
- 12:43more like the old movement towards
- 12:46philosophy. But neither one of those two
- 12:49groups have been able to figure out why
- 12:52something is alive as opposed to
- 12:54something that's not alive. No one's
- 12:55been able to describe what the soul is,
- 12:57but we all know it exists.
- 13:01And my I I think um what we need is a
- 13:05new science is a bad word. I I think
- 13:07science only describes the things we
- 13:10already know about the physical world.
- 13:12In fact, there's an argument that the
- 13:14physical world that we see has been
- 13:16created out of our systems to be of
- 13:20mathematics.
- 13:21Mathematics. Everyone knows mathematics
- 13:23describes the physical world much
- 13:26greater than it should. Unless you my
- 13:29view the physical world really comes out
- 13:32of conscious beings that have
- 13:35mathematics. So they create it. This
- 13:37table appears to you and I to be solid
- 13:41to a bat. It or if because we have light
- 13:45that's bouncing off the table into my
- 13:47our eyes. It appears solid. If instead
- 13:51of eyes that responded to wavelengths of
- 13:55visual light, our eyes responded to
- 13:58radio waves,
- 14:01the radio frequencies. It's not
- 14:03different. It's the same type of
- 14:04frequency is light with different um
- 14:07speeds. The table's invisible. We know
- 14:11that we our phone works in this room. So
- 14:14the waves are coming through the
- 14:16windows. The waves are coming through
- 14:17the walls. So the walls are invisible to
- 14:21that type of radiation, that type of
- 14:23energy. The walls are I can see them
- 14:27because my eyes
- 14:29a physical system determines that the
- 14:33walls are there. you
- 14:36with with Murray Gel, you founded or
- 14:39with the original donor and what had the
- 14:42idea of Santa Fe Institute
- 14:45in 10 or 15 years later that effort to
- 14:49study the complexity of systems
- 14:52mathematically?
- 14:53>> Yes.
- 14:54>> Is it a total failure?
- 14:56>> A total failure.
- 14:57>> Total failure.
- 14:58>> Why is that? It it's the failure of
- 15:00science because in fact if if to some
- 15:03extent science doesn't describe romance.
- 15:06I don't know why I'm attracted to
- 15:08somebody. I don't know people are
- 15:11attracted to each other and some
- 15:12everyone has the same feeling. They've
- 15:14seen someone walk in the room and they
- 15:15say oh that person gives me the a creepy
- 15:18feeling.
- 15:19Science has tried to describe science
- 15:21doesn't describe what creepy feelings
- 15:23means. They just know it's a creepy
- 15:26feeling. I think women, as I said the
- 15:29last time,
- 15:31have an intuitive sense. What is
- 15:33intuitive? They have intuition. They
- 15:35have feelings. And they're able to deal
- 15:37in the realm of things that men,
- 15:41especially men like myself, find
- 15:43unexplainable. They have great women
- 15:46have intuition.
- 15:48Men see things a bit differently. They
- 15:50men want to measure everything. Women
- 15:52are not really that interested in
- 15:54measuring.
- 15:58in in what you're saying in macro terms,
- 16:00you actually think science,
- 16:03mathematics, maybe ultimately technology
- 16:05is moving to that more intuitive.
- 16:08I think science and math are
- 16:10old-fashioned.
- 16:12And unfortunately, people are still
- 16:14taught that they have to learn algebra
- 16:16in school and certain things in school
- 16:19as opposed to learning to give have an
- 16:22emotion. What is this? What Larry
- 16:24Summers was trying to get at? Maybe he
- 16:25didn't say it perfectly enough, but what
- 16:28he was trying to get to in that system,
- 16:31the systems we study today, the way
- 16:33mathematics is either taught or
- 16:35understood that women just haven't
- 16:37gotten up to the highest realms of
- 16:40engineering or physics or mathematics
- 16:42because of that. And you're you're
- 16:43actually implying that there's a either
- 16:45new branch of science or we've hit an
- 16:47inflection point like in Newton that's
- 16:49going to go in a Newton took mankind in
- 16:52a different direction because he was
- 16:53able to measure. Then you had subatomic,
- 16:56you know, non-Newtonian physics later.
- 16:58Are you saying that you think there's
- 17:00another developing field that's coming
- 17:02up that may take us I don't know how
- 17:04many decades to get our hands around,
- 17:06but that that's what's evolving out of
- 17:08this?
- 17:08>> Yes. Yeah. In in fact I think that
- 17:12mathematics it's not the end of science
- 17:15and every year someone says it's the end
- 17:16of we can't discover it everything
- 17:18there's lots to discover with
- 17:19relationship to the physical world but
- 17:21we know a lot already with in respect to
- 17:24the unexplainable world we almost know
- 17:27nothing women again sense it and instead
- 17:31of Larry Summers I'll just I won't
- 17:34digress too much but Howard Gardner
- 17:37early on said there's not one form of
- 17:40intelligence. It's not mathematical
- 17:42intelligence. There's emotional
- 17:44intelligence that there's kinesthetic
- 17:46intelligence. You know, there there's
- 17:48this argument that I reject that black
- 17:52people are less intelligent than white
- 17:53people. It's not true.
- 17:56We know, for example, that if you if I
- 17:58was in a in the forest and I had to run
- 18:01from the lion or figure out a way not to
- 18:04be eaten and my com competition is a
- 18:07local African, I'm going to I'm the one
- 18:11who's getting eaten because they have
- 18:12the intelligence to deal with their
- 18:14local environment.
- 18:16So, it's just different. It's not
- 18:18better, it's not worse, but there's many
- 18:20differences amongst different types of
- 18:22people. And so people have different
- 18:24intelligences and they excel in some
- 18:26intelligences usually and less so in
- 18:29others.
- 18:30>> When did it come to because the world of
- 18:33high finance is a world of pure reason
- 18:37or is it is it a lot of emotion and gut
- 18:39checks and and and you know on trading
- 18:42desk and central banks when these
- 18:44decisions get made? Is it is it that
- 18:46high church like the high church of
- 18:48science of of high energy physics or is
- 18:51it as much emotion that comes in as as
- 18:54much as the mathematics and the reason?
- 18:56>> It's a great question. I think if you
- 18:59talk to really experienced and
- 19:01successful traders and you ask them how
- 19:04they know what's going on, they can't
- 19:06give you an answer. They don't know.
- 19:09They feel it. They can feel the way the
- 19:11market's moving. I can feel the way this
- 19:13stock's moving. And that these are not
- 19:15very well-defined terms. It's not it's
- 19:19difficult to put in mathematics terms,
- 19:21how did I feel it? You could look back
- 19:22and make guesses what I was seeing. But
- 19:26great traders feel it and then act on
- 19:28their feelings. That's the difference.
- 19:31Many people feel it but are afraid
- 19:33because they want a mathematical
- 19:35justification before they take that next
- 19:38step. When you first got on the trading
- 19:39desk at Bear Sterns in the late '7s or
- 19:42mid70s, were you shocked by how little
- 19:45actual understanding of mathematics that
- 19:47the traders comprehended? Yeah. Again,
- 19:50we had a Texas Instrument calculator.
- 19:52Most most stock brokers in the
- 19:54especially before 1975, if they were
- 19:57good stock brokers, could add. That's
- 20:00about it. They could multip if you could
- 20:02multiply, you were already in the top
- 20:0315% of stock brokers.
- 20:06Stock broker simply meant I there's a
- 20:08great there's a story when I went to to
- 20:10the first person I I had no money and I
- 20:13said how much money do you make a year
- 20:16and he said $400,000
- 20:19said impossible I'm I'm making $10,000
- 20:22>> that's probably more in your family he
- 20:23had made in his entire existence
- 20:25>> yes and he makes it in a year I said
- 20:27what do you do and he said it's too
- 20:30complicated for you to understand
- 20:34which is what the main thrust of Wall
- 20:36Street people, they they want to tell
- 20:38you it's too complicated
- 20:40because if if you understood that that
- 20:42person was simply he had a
- 20:44brother-in-law, in fact, in this case,
- 20:45who ran the pension fund of General
- 20:47Motors, his brother-in-law would call
- 20:49him and say, "Buy a,000 IBM." He'd hang
- 20:52up the phone, he'd write it out on a
- 20:53ticket and walk it to a window. That was
- 20:57his entire skill set. Hello. Write what
- 21:00my brother-in-law says, walk it to a
- 21:02ticket window.
- 21:04G give me an example when you were on
- 21:05the trading desk in the early days at
- 21:07Bear Sterns of a time that you felt
- 21:09either complete uncertainty or you saw
- 21:11total panic where people something was
- 21:14happening that people couldn't foretell
- 21:16and that they were like in a in an
- 21:18airplane cockpit where it's going wrong.
- 21:21Walk us through that.
- 21:24In 1978 I think it was um across the
- 21:28newswires uh there had been a collapse
- 21:30of the currency in Thailand.
- 21:34on the other side of the world had no
- 21:37relationship to me. I wasn't sure where
- 21:38Thailand was. But the fact that a
- 21:42currency, a country's
- 21:44money had all of a sudden dropped
- 21:47tremendously in value affected the rest
- 21:50of the world's markets. And people
- 21:53panicked because they never had they had
- 21:56never seen that before.
- 21:58a very small part of a very complex
- 22:00system had a shock throughout the whole
- 22:02system. So prices on Park Avenue
- 22:05apartments, the bond markets, the stock
- 22:07markets, every started to gyate. You
- 22:10know, there's an old mathemat
- 22:12mathematics expression that if a
- 22:14butterfly wings in Mexico make the wrong
- 22:17turn, it spins out and eventually when
- 22:20it by the time it gets to Canada, it
- 22:21turns into a a tornado.
- 22:24So these are part of complex systems. So
- 22:27yeah, Wall Street in in certain parts.
- 22:30>> Santa Fe Institute was supposed to
- 22:31actually come up with a formula for that
- 22:33for the butterfly wings. Wh why in 15
- 22:36years did you reach the end of of at
- 22:38least that experiment?
- 22:40every attempt to my that's why it's so
- 22:42exciting now because we I think certain
- 22:46people are starting to realize that
- 22:49there's so many things that are
- 22:51unexplainable
- 22:54that that we have to think about them
- 22:56differently. Music is a great example.
- 22:59Just a it's a common man's example. You
- 23:03know, when you hear a certain song, it
- 23:05makes you feel a certain way.
- 23:09How does it do that? We don't know. We
- 23:13can't mathematize it. And even that
- 23:15music, Steve, nowadays, we compress
- 23:18music. When you have a violin, it's
- 23:21compressed onto your iPhone.
- 23:24So, what does compression mean? I'm
- 23:25taking lots of information and I'm
- 23:28cutting it into lots of pieces and
- 23:30squishing it together. And when I squish
- 23:33it or compress it, I have to take out
- 23:35lots of pieces. But I say that they're
- 23:38not very important pieces.
- 23:41It's those pieces that we take out when
- 23:44we compress data to me are the most
- 23:48interesting parts of life. You just said
- 23:51a while ago part of this new search for
- 23:53science may have may go back to when
- 23:55people were actually talking about a
- 23:56soul and you said there no doubt in your
- 23:58mind that there is a soul. Describe for
- 24:00me what you mean by that. What do you
- 24:02mean by soul? What do you mean soul
- 24:04different than the physical analog body
- 24:06that we're we're seeing on film right
- 24:08now. It's it's it's difficult to
- 24:10describe in words. I mean I I'm not a
- 24:12I'm not a poet. Poems get a little
- 24:14closer to what that really means. But we
- 24:17can even the concept of what is life
- 24:20becomes complicated when you deal with
- 24:22plants and seeds. Is a seed alive? I
- 24:26don't know. Certain people would say no,
- 24:28it's dead. When when you're a banana, my
- 24:32one of my favorite examples is the
- 24:34banana that's sitting on the countertop
- 24:35in your kitchen today. Is it alive or
- 24:37dead?
- 24:38>> What do you think about human life? When
- 24:39is what what is human? Tell me about
- 24:40human life.
- 24:41>> But your banana is alive. That banana is
- 24:43breathing. It's on your you say that's
- 24:45impossible Jeffrey. No.
- 24:48>> Is the banana conscious?
- 24:50>> Um all these word these are words. So
- 24:53you're tr everyone's trying to fit a
- 24:55very complicated concepts into a very
- 24:57small box called cons conscious or
- 25:00alive. It's these don't fit in that way.
- 25:03So if you put your banana in a bag and
- 25:06put another fruit in with it, the fruit
- 25:08ripens faster because the banana
- 25:10breathes with it. That's how we don't
- 25:13understand most of those things. So you
- 25:16asked the question
- 25:17>> you talk about the life. What about
- 25:19human life?
- 25:20>> What about it?
- 25:21>> What? Tell me what what do you think?
- 25:22What do you think human life is?
- 25:24>> It's a miracle. We It's a miracle. And
- 25:27when I say miracle, I can't I can't
- 25:29explain it and I make no attempt to
- 25:32explain it at the moment. This we don't
- 25:33know how to think about it. And anyone
- 25:36again another one of the Fineman quotes
- 25:38when he was talking about quantum
- 25:39physics. He said, "Anyone, Jeffrey, who
- 25:43says they understand quantum physics and
- 25:45quantum mechanics and quantum behavior,
- 25:49you know, they're lying." Let's talk
- 25:50about it. That's post Newtonian. Talk
- 25:52talk about what's the difference. Who
- 25:54founded quantum mechanics? Why is
- 25:56quantum mechanics taking Newtonian
- 25:59physics and taking it to the next level?
- 26:01>> It it's forms a much broader category.
- 26:04>> Let's go back to this desk. You you use
- 26:06the thing of Newton using this desk.
- 26:08What is sub? Why can't Newton's theory
- 26:11explain everything? Why did subatomic
- 26:14quantum mechanics or quantum physics
- 26:16have to come in to explain explain this?
- 26:18Well, qu So let's let's go right back to
- 26:21square one. Why is it called quantum
- 26:24physics? So quant is a word that simply
- 26:27means packet small amount. So it's
- 26:30quantized. So we recognized when we
- 26:33recognized that this this table appears
- 26:36appears another very complicated word
- 26:38solid to us it has it's really made up
- 26:41of molecules or atoms
- 26:44and atoms we've given lots of names to
- 26:48what some of the behaviors when if you
- 26:50were in school when you and I were in
- 26:51school in the 50s the model was a little
- 26:54center thing in the middle and electron
- 26:57went around and around it
- 27:00it was seen as a ball that went around
- 27:02and around it. And as we started to look
- 27:04at say, well, let's see what this ball
- 27:06looks like. I want to be able to examine
- 27:08that little thing called an electron. We
- 27:11found out there was nothing there. There
- 27:13wasn't the thing.
- 27:15It it was simply a cloud of energy that
- 27:20we can call an electron. So we already
- 27:23started to see mysterious things as we
- 27:25go into very super small quantities.
- 27:28Quantum physics. So quantum physics
- 27:31started to go into the very small and at
- 27:33very small
- 27:35distances
- 27:37we we see things that we can't explain.
- 27:40We just cannot explain. How am I doing
- 27:42on time?
- 27:43>> Uh four minutes.
- 27:46>> Fine. Um and to summarize, no sorry um
- 27:51let's go back to human life. When do you
- 27:53think human life starts?
- 27:57>> It's not this. So you see this is the
- 27:59question you're asking me to measure
- 28:00something again. It's does
- 28:03>> it can't be measured. You're just you
- 28:04just hate making commitments to me say
- 28:08I I'm I'm peeling this onion back a
- 28:11layer at a time. All your and
- 28:13happy target can't be measured can't be
- 28:15measured like that is that to say
- 28:17measure makes it's a commitment. You
- 28:18don't even like a commitment when you
- 28:20answer a question.
- 28:22>> I don't
- 28:22>> as a saying in golf commit to the shot.
- 28:24>> I don't know what it means to be
- 28:26measured. it. You do know what it means
- 28:28to be measured. You're one of the
- 28:29leading currency traders, uh, hedge fund
- 28:32guys or stock market financial wizards.
- 28:34You're in the high priesthood of high
- 28:35finance. You certainly know how to
- 28:36measure. That's why you're a
- 28:38billionaire. Any other answer besides
- 28:40that is total and complete And
- 28:42you know it.
- 28:43>> I know very few things.
- 28:46>> You you know things can be measured. You
- 28:48measure every day. You weigh and measure
- 28:49every day. You weigh and measure people.
- 28:52You weigh and measure leaders. You weigh
- 28:53and measure economies. You weigh and
- 28:55measure politics.
- 28:56You weigh and measure. You weigh your
- 28:58hang your whole life in fact is
- 29:02measuring.
- 29:03>> It's that's so what you've now done is a
- 29:05great thing is you've used the word
- 29:08measure a mathematic term in a common
- 29:11vernacular and abused it. So I don't
- 29:13even recognize what it means. It's so
- 29:15abusive to my field.
- 29:19>> Why? Let's go to that. In in mathematics
- 29:22measure means and measure means what
- 29:24specifically? That's there there's no
- 29:26spec. It's it's a an approximation or
- 29:29give it giving something a number. If I
- 29:32Einstein said
- 29:32>> we're not asking you to go to the ninth
- 29:34decimal point on
- 29:35>> Oh, not you didn't say that before.
- 29:36>> No, you're not going to the nth.
- 29:38>> I don't What if I say measure how how
- 29:39tall are you?
- 29:41>> You'd say six foot.
- 29:43>> But is it six foot one inch?
- 29:46>> Give or take six between 5'11 and six
- 29:49feet.
- 29:49>> But what's that? But I want But so the
- 29:51question is I want an accurate
- 29:53>> Zenos. I got Zeno's paradox.
- 29:55>> I don't even know what it means to
- 29:56measure you. Is that am I measuring the
- 29:57top of your hair, the top of your skull?
- 30:00Which and the the finer the more
- 30:02>> you're getting you're getting that's
- 30:03you're being rebbitical. This is like
- 30:05>> I took I shaved my beard off. I used to
- 30:06be
- 30:07>> No, my point is isn't that what isn't
- 30:09that going through the Torah where you
- 30:10where you're you're you're you're
- 30:11parsing every every uh every definition.
- 30:15>> No,
- 30:15>> you do you however we broadly define
- 30:18measure. Your life literally is about
- 30:21measurement, is it not? It's about get
- 30:23putting numbers on things so that I can
- 30:25try my best
- 30:27>> I you can call it whatever you like if
- 30:29that if that makes you feel better
- 30:30>> you know back to your scientific inquiry
- 30:35>> no it even a a number it it people don't
- 30:38a number is is a complicated
- 30:40>> when did you come when did you come to
- 30:42this in when did you come to this aha
- 30:44moment was when it was in when it was in
- 30:47your solitary confinement when the
- 30:48biggest financial crisis in world
- 30:51history was going on in your 7 by9 jail
- 30:54cell with your metal bed and your and
- 30:56your two brushes cuz you were trustee
- 30:58with the brown uniform on trustee
- 31:00spelled wrong. Is that the moment of
- 31:03clarity that you had about science and
- 31:06and and Newtonian physics and everything
- 31:08that we can measure is really not going
- 31:09to be the way we go forward. It's going
- 31:11to be some more much more esoteric uh
- 31:14emotional intelligence thing. Is was
- 31:16that your was that your moment of
- 31:18clarity? I wish it was because it would
- 31:20make such a great story for this
- 31:22interview, but it it's not. It's the
- 31:24fact that I lead such a privileged life
- 31:26to come across
- 31:28>> When did you If it didn't happen then,
- 31:30when did it or did it happen before?
- 31:31>> I was going to hopefully get to the I
- 31:33I'm in a privileged position to have
- 31:35some of the world's smartest people come
- 31:37to my house and tell me what they think
- 31:39about different subjects. And I finally
- 31:42realized that the thing that they had
- 31:45most in common was there was this area,
- 31:48this area, no matter how smart they
- 31:50were, that
- 31:53when I asked them the questions, they
- 31:54said they'd have to resort to a 500 or a
- 31:58thousand-year-old response to that
- 32:00question, which was,
- 32:02I don't know.
- 32:04>> You know who um who else found that out?
- 32:09in
- 32:09>> Socrates.
- 32:11That's what Socrates kept doing, right?
- 32:13Socrates kept asking all the experts,
- 32:17>> he would go through, you know, question
- 32:19after question after question and
- 32:20realize at the end they didn't really
- 32:22know under they really didn't basically
- 32:24understand what they were talking about.
- 32:25And one of the things that people won't
- 32:27enjoy, it turns out that potentially one
- 32:31of the bad things to teach children is
- 32:33how to write.
- 32:36It's imp writing, reading and arithmetic
- 32:38was supposed to be everyone's supposed
- 32:39to be taught. But writing forces you
- 32:42into a very narrow channel of thinking
- 32:44you have to write certain in a certain
- 32:47form in a certain way in a certain
- 32:48linear pattern. So your thinking becomes
- 32:51somewhat narrow. The most interest the
- 32:53reason I brought up writing is one of
- 32:55the recent discoveries of mine with
- 32:57respect to Socrates, Plato's and
- 32:58Aristotle is they never wrote anything.
- 33:02They spoke and people around who could
- 33:06write wrote. Socrates could think. So
- 33:10that that that was
- 33:11>> Jesus of Nazareth was the same way,
- 33:13right? Never wrote anything.
- 33:15>> I thought he was a carpenter.
- 33:17>> He he was a carpenter.
- 33:18>> Didn't he need like a little carpenters
- 33:19to I don't get that.
- 33:21>> But at least his written record. One
- 33:24last thing. Um
- 33:26>> thank you for having me to to your
- 33:28house.
- 33:30Um,
- 33:34>> vegetable juice.
- 33:34>> Let's go. Let's go with vegetable juice.
- 33:36>> When when did when did that
- 33:38>> the beginning of that was there any one
- 33:40aha moment in all these great thinkers?
- 33:42Did it happen before 2008? Was it after
- 33:45that came up over I know many years but
- 33:47when did you actually realize hey
- 33:49something new got to something new's got
- 33:51to be developed? Yeah, that's great. is
- 33:53that I've w because um again I'm
- 33:56privileged enough to have people around
- 33:58me who've given lots of philanthropic
- 34:01gifts to uh institutions of higher
- 34:04learning and when I said
- 34:07the impact have you jud how do you judge
- 34:09the impact of your giving and we sat
- 34:12down and said no new no really new ideas
- 34:15have come out and I realized that of
- 34:18course it hasn't come out because we've
- 34:20been looking at using science
- 34:23and mathematics and it's the wrong tool.
- 34:25It's obvious.
- 34:27>> Institutions that are set up and try to
- 34:30put forward knowledge and and
- 34:33understanding and truth, should they
- 34:36take your money?
- 34:41>> Derek Bach at Harvard said taking money
- 34:44for good causes is a good thing.
- 34:47So if Hitler if Hitler took all the gold
- 34:50out of the out of the teeth of the Jews
- 34:52and said I want to give this to H
- 34:54Highleberg University to fund the
- 34:56Libnets chairs uh so I can study high
- 34:59energy physics. Derek Bach would say
- 35:01that was fine.
- 35:04Again it's these questions are questions
- 35:06where peop sides like your
- 35:09Charlottesville
- 35:11could differ. I I don't I don't know the
- 35:13answer. So tell so so tell us tell us
- 35:15the two give us the two answers. What
- 35:17the one answer why it shouldn't be and
- 35:19then the one answer Derek Bach says I'll
- 35:21take essentially take cash from anybody
- 35:23because I got so many projects so many
- 35:24good guys and this is the way I'll do
- 35:25it. So I'm indifferent to where the cash
- 35:28comes from. Money is money and if I got
- 35:30good guys I'm the fiduciary says these
- 35:32are good people and this is good
- 35:33research. Okay, I'll take the cash from
- 35:36however from any source including you.
- 35:40What's the other argument? Now, let me
- 35:42give you that that I know in in my case
- 35:44I've
- 35:45>> Is your money dirty money?
- 35:46>> If you live
- 35:48>> I just ask a question. Is your money
- 35:49dirty money?
- 35:49>> No, it's not. So, in fact,
- 35:52>> why is it not dirty money?
- 35:54>> Because I I earned it my heart.
- 35:57>> But you you earned it. You earned We
- 36:00went back to this before. You earned it.
- 36:01You earned it
- 36:03advising the worst people in the world,
- 36:06right? That do enormous bad things. uh
- 36:10and just to make more money.
- 36:12>> So if I instead of asking me the
- 36:15question, should you take the money?
- 36:17Because I think it's a legitimate
- 36:18question.
- 36:18>> Do you think it's a legitimate question?
- 36:20>> Yes. No question. Because what I because
- 36:22I think about I think you have ethics is
- 36:25always a complicated subject. But I can
- 36:27tell you that with the money I gave to
- 36:30help try to eradicate polio
- 36:32in Pakistan and India, instead of asking
- 36:36me whether that money was should be
- 36:38given to these children for vaccines, I
- 36:42think you might want to ask their
- 36:43mothers who who received the vaccine who
- 36:46know their child now won't get polio and
- 36:49ask them if Epstein should have helped
- 36:52these people. If we walked if we walked
- 36:55in you're you're a mathematician you're
- 36:57a ma you're a mathematician. We walked
- 36:59into that clinic
- 37:00>> where they're giving that money out to
- 37:02these people that are in the most dire
- 37:04rates of poverty and and and and
- 37:05sickness and told them that the money
- 37:08was coming from a what are you class
- 37:10three sexual predator?
- 37:12>> Tier one.
- 37:12>> Your was tier tier one's the highest and
- 37:14worst.
- 37:15>> No. I'm the lowest.
- 37:16>> You're the lowest. Okay. Tier one.
- 37:18You're the lowest.
- 37:19>> Um but a criminal.
- 37:21>> Yes. that the money came from what what
- 37:23percentage of people do you estimate I
- 37:25understand you don't like probabilities
- 37:26do you estimate would say I don't care I
- 37:29want the money for my children
- 37:30>> I would say everyone said I want the
- 37:32money for my children
- 37:33>> did they know where the money came from
- 37:34>> if I think if you told them if I told
- 37:37him the devil the devil
- 37:38>> himself
- 37:39>> the devil himself said I'm going to
- 37:41exchange some dollars for your child's
- 37:43life
- 37:44>> do you think you're the devil himself
- 37:47>> no but I I do have a good mirror
- 37:50>> it's a serious question. Do you do you
- 37:52think you're the devil himself?
- 37:54>> I know. Why would you say that?
- 37:56>> Because you have all the attributes.
- 37:57You're incredibly smart. You remember
- 37:59the devil is somebody knows what the the
- 38:01devil's brilliant. You read Milton's you
- 38:03read Milton's Paradise Lost.
- 38:04>> No, the devil scares me.
- 38:06>> This Satan is Satan is the is the he he
- 38:09he is the he is at the number one or two
- 38:14archangel. And the reason he goes to
- 38:18hell and leads the rebellion is because
- 38:20he can't be the top guy.
- 38:22>> And his thing is, I'd rather I'd rather
- 38:24reign in hell than serve in heaven.
- 38:25>> I saw that in a movie once called
- 38:28American Dharma. I don't remember who
- 38:30said it. Okay, we have to go.
- 38:32>> Okay, good. Okay, that was good.
- 38:35>> Before we get into the deep stuff, let's
- 38:36just talk let's give some basics or some
- 38:39things I want to do inquiry from the
- 38:40others. Walk me through the Santa Fe
- 38:42Institute. What what was it about
- 38:45the time at the math? And this was in
- 38:47the late 90s. So, they're not going to
- 38:50hear me on this part, right? We're going
- 38:52to do it both ways.
- 38:53>> It will not be on the video, but we do
- 38:55have you recorded.
- 38:56>> Fine. Remember, when you're answering
- 38:58the qu on these questions, I'm not in
- 39:00the shot and they're never going to hear
- 39:02my voice. So, a little bit, you got to
- 39:03repeat the in your answer, you got to
- 39:06repeat what my question was.
- 39:07>> Oh, okay.
- 39:09>> Um, Santa Fe Institute. Why when you're
- 39:13at the top of your game on Wall Street
- 39:15do you decide to finance which was at
- 39:17the time or endow or become the donor
- 39:19sponsor however you want to say it for
- 39:21what was considered the most cutting
- 39:25edge group of mathematicians in the
- 39:27world action so Santa Fe Institute in
- 39:31the late 80s early 90s I was interested
- 39:34as I was on the board of Rockefeller so
- 39:36that starts Rockefeller it's university
- 39:40formed by John D. Rockefeller to sort of
- 39:42give back to the community. It's east
- 39:45side of Manhattan except it was old. It
- 39:48was sort of old-fashioned. They were
- 39:50talking about medicine and medicine by
- 39:53itself was again subject to the ideas of
- 39:56science. They were trying to find use
- 39:58science to find cures for disease.
- 40:02And I said no, we need to do something
- 40:04different. We need to start
- 40:06interdisciplinary work. in most
- 40:10>> how did a schmuck like you get on the
- 40:12board of Rockefeller? What year was
- 40:13that?
- 40:14>> I don't remember late I think 89 or 91.
- 40:17>> So that's one of the most prestigious
- 40:18research places in the world. Correct.
- 40:21>> Yes.
- 40:21>> Okay. How did a guy like you get on the
- 40:23board of rock a blueblood
- 40:25internationally known internationally
- 40:27known uh hard research Nobel Prize
- 40:31winners all over the place. How do they
- 40:33pick a a guy like you, a trader from or
- 40:37basically some guy from Bear Cerns?
- 40:40>> Good question. So, I was asked to be on
- 40:42the board of Rockefeller and I think it
- 40:44was I was on the board of Rockefeller.
- 40:46Uh there was a money manager who said
- 40:49Rockefeller needs someone with financial
- 40:52expertise because the university is
- 40:54growing and there's lots of new things.
- 40:57You have to again we go back to the the
- 40:59original discussion the last time in the
- 41:02up until the mid 80s or sort of early se
- 41:05mid70s the most important thing was your
- 41:08name. If you were Rockefeller you
- 41:09already were considered to be brilliant.
- 41:11If you were a head of General Motors it
- 41:13was your reputation. It was who you knew
- 41:16who your family was. What was your
- 41:19character? And then in the mid70s
- 41:22basically if you remember you probably
- 41:24had a calculator. It was very advanced
- 41:27in those days to have a Texas instrument
- 41:29calculator where it could by putting in
- 41:31the numbers it would multiply for you do
- 41:34square roots and that was the first and
- 41:36everyone who had a calculator was
- 41:38already advanced on Wall Street a simple
- 41:41almost like your accountant.
- 41:45The most important parts of business
- 41:47were really now going to calculations.
- 41:50So it's not only mathematics but it's
- 41:52things that could be calculated.
- 41:55reputation couldn't be calculated. I
- 41:57could give you, are you a 10 on a
- 41:59reputation scale, an eight? What does it
- 42:01mean to have a measurement of your
- 42:02reputation?
- 42:04We'll get to that later. But people,
- 42:07places like Rockefeller needed someone
- 42:08to say, "Look, we are entering a
- 42:10different world where numbers and the
- 42:12numbers of companies portfolio
- 42:14management was going to be balanced. It
- 42:17was going to be statistical. Jeffrey,
- 42:19could you come on the board
- 42:22potentially sit on the finance
- 42:23committee?" Nancy Kissinger and a bunch
- 42:25of other people. And David Rockefeller
- 42:28and I got along very well. He was just
- 42:31he was this unbelievable human being.
- 42:36Respectful to everyone. He introduced
- 42:38his driver as his colleague. Not his
- 42:41driver. He would never say this is my
- 42:43driver. He said it's my colleague. And
- 42:45David started to explain to me
- 42:48world politics.
- 42:51So David would say, Jeffrey, money is
- 42:54going to be sort of the most important
- 42:56things. People don't understand money.
- 42:57You seem to have this knack for money. I
- 43:01said to David, tell me about your life.
- 43:03What was the worst and the best part of
- 43:04your life?
- 43:06So David said, "When I grew up, everyone
- 43:10knew I was a Rockefeller.
- 43:12They didn't know that my father told me
- 43:14he would not leave me a dime.
- 43:17No money. But every time we went out to
- 43:19eat, me and my five friends at school,
- 43:21they would leave me the bill. They would
- 43:23expect me to pick up the check because I
- 43:25was a Rockefeller. And he said, "I was
- 43:28chairman of Chase Bank." And he said, "I
- 43:30remember like it was yesterday, one of
- 43:32the headlines in Time magazine said,
- 43:35David, please fire yourself."
- 43:39So he thought that there was a a world
- 43:43that existed
- 43:45in that would be a combination of both
- 43:47politics and business
- 43:50and leadership. What do I mean? He
- 43:54formed something called the trilateral
- 43:55commission.
- 43:57The trilateral commission is some spooky
- 44:00stuff. People said it was something the
- 44:02people that the Illuminati there some
- 44:04mystery about it. People that ran the
- 44:06world.
- 44:08it was politicians. But David said most
- 44:12countries the politicians get elected
- 44:15for four years or eight years separate
- 44:18from the royal families in England or in
- 44:20the Middle East. Someone's there for
- 44:22four years and then they're not there
- 44:23anymore. The most important people to
- 44:27have stability and consistency would be
- 44:29businessmen. So he formed this
- 44:31trilateral commission of businessmen
- 44:35and politicians from three major
- 44:37continents. So it was the North
- 44:40Americans, the Europeans and the Asians.
- 44:44So he said to me, "Would you like to be
- 44:45on the trilateral commission?" Now I was
- 44:4930 years old, 32 years old. I said,
- 44:52"Great." And he said, "Well, you have to
- 44:55fill out this application so they have
- 44:58your bio." And I looked at the list of
- 45:01people and it was Bill Clinton, former
- 45:04president of the United States,
- 45:07um Paul Vulkar, every great leader in
- 45:11America, the Asians, the Japanese, and
- 45:14with a a very long
- 45:17description of their history. And they
- 45:20asked me to fill in what I would like to
- 45:21have written. And I wrote Jeffrey
- 45:23Epstein,
- 45:25just a good kid, which I thought was
- 45:28funny. nobody else did.
- 45:30Um, so answer to what your question at
- 45:33that time I recognized around the world
- 45:35that monies and currencies
- 45:39were not really well understood but
- 45:41again it was only numbers. So numbers
- 45:46and I'll get to the fact that it was bad
- 45:49thinking. It's numbers are very good.
- 45:52Are most people are most people you meet
- 45:54even on trilateral commission when you
- 45:55meet most people do you find most
- 45:57leaders financially illiterate
- 46:01>> economically illiterate
- 46:04most again most political leaders don't
- 46:07come out of a background of finance most
- 46:10political leaders come out of a
- 46:12background of being popular so in some
- 46:15of the countries in some the African
- 46:16countries for example they might have
- 46:18been a military person they were a
- 46:19general in some of the African countries
- 46:22they might have been a disc jockey or in
- 46:24our country they would have been an
- 46:26actor.
- 46:27The knowledge of money isn't they don't
- 46:30have expertise. They have no degrees in
- 46:32finance. They really what and this is
- 46:34one of the major problems.
- 46:37Their expertise if they have any
- 46:40financial knowledge is of their own
- 46:42checking account or bank account and
- 46:44filling in their own taxes.
- 46:47So many world leaders who don't really
- 46:50have a financial underpinning make
- 46:52fundamental errors when it comes to
- 46:55money on a country or institutional
- 46:58level. Let me give you an example.
- 47:02If you Mr. Bannon
- 47:04if I said your assets increased last
- 47:07year
- 47:09you'd say that's well that sounds pretty
- 47:11good. And I said what does that mean to
- 47:14you? You'd say, 'Well, I have more
- 47:16money. I guess I'm I'm wealthier. I'd
- 47:19say yes.
- 47:22And if you had if your debt increased,
- 47:26would you would you feel wealthier or
- 47:28poorer? You say, "Well, I don't want to
- 47:31have increased debt. I don't like the
- 47:32idea of that sound increased debt."
- 47:36Now, that and world leaders understand
- 47:39when their assets go up, they feel
- 47:41better.
- 47:43However, institutions like banks, things
- 47:47that people don't really understand are
- 47:49financial underpinnings of banks.
- 47:54When I say your bank, Mr. Bannon, you
- 47:57have the Bannon bank, you doubled your
- 48:00assets.
- 48:02Sounds good. But what does it really
- 48:03mean?
- 48:05It means people owe you more money. You
- 48:09don't have any money. More money.
- 48:12What? Yeah, a bank's assets
- 48:17are how much it is owed by other people.
- 48:22That's crazy. So if the bank went goes
- 48:26from a $2 billion of assets to 10
- 48:28billion, it means people owe it an
- 48:32additional $8 billion and they but their
- 48:34assets have gone up.
- 48:37So the terminology of assets and
- 48:40liabilities is different for banks. It's
- 48:42not natural. And what most people and
- 48:44you ask questions about world leaders
- 48:47there's many people I think your old
- 48:49boss Mercer understood. There's a
- 48:52fundamental part of money which is
- 48:54called fractionalized banking.
- 48:58And fractionalized banking is something
- 48:59that finance people understand. And the
- 49:02people on the street and when I say
- 49:03people on the street that's where I was
- 49:04when I started on Wall Street would find
- 49:07it impossible to believe. Impossible.
- 49:12Why?
- 49:15Bang and bank. I give you $1.
- 49:20Just one single dollar.
- 49:23In our system of banking, I would say,
- 49:26"Okay, Steve, I gave you a dollar. How
- 49:29much could you lend out to your
- 49:30friends?"
- 49:32And your natural reaction would be,
- 49:34"Probably something less than a dollar
- 49:35because I want to keep something in my
- 49:37pocket."
- 49:39The way our system works is if I you as
- 49:42a bank are holding my dollar,
- 49:45you can lend out an additional eight or
- 49:48nine dollars.
- 49:50No, it's impossible. I only have a
- 49:52dollar, Jeffrey.
- 49:54We have something called fractionalized
- 49:56reserves, which is if you have one, you
- 49:58can lend out nine. That's the way our
- 50:00system works. And so not only do world
- 50:03leaders not understand banking, but the
- 50:05man on the street, my father who worked
- 50:07in the park department, it it would be
- 50:09beyond his imagination that people could
- 50:12lend out more money than they actually
- 50:14had in their pocket.
- 50:17>> Next question. But how how did this in
- 50:21in in understanding that when you got on
- 50:24something like the trilateral
- 50:25commission, you're on the board at
- 50:26Rockefeller, which is the most advanced
- 50:27research, you get brought to the to the
- 50:30trilateral, which is the elite of the
- 50:32elite.
- 50:33>> How since you're only at that time
- 50:36>> 30 something,
- 50:38eight years from teaching at Dalton,
- 50:40right? You're 10 years 10 years teaching
- 50:43at Dalton.
- 50:43>> Yes.
- 50:44>> Walk us through I mean, put us in the
- 50:46room. Walk walk walk walk walk walk walk
- 50:47walk walk walk walk walk walk walk walk
- 50:47walk walk walk walk walk walk walk walk
- 50:47walk walk walk walk walk walk walk walk
- 50:47walk walk walk walk walk walk walk walk
- 50:47walk walk me through exactly what it
- 50:49felt like what it felt like being on the
- 50:50board at Rockefeller you got these Nobel
- 50:52laureates and you're sitting there
- 50:54making decisions and you start to meet
- 50:55these people on at Rockerfeller and you
- 50:57start to meet these people the
- 50:58trilateral commission what what did it
- 50:59feel like?
- 51:02>> That's a great question. So what did it
- 51:04feel like
- 51:04>> I'm in the business of asking
- 51:06>> what did it feel like meeting some of
- 51:07these people like Kissinger or
- 51:09Rockefeller and those are two
- 51:12extraordinary people but in general I
- 51:15think the question the people on Wall
- 51:17Street I tell the story the first day
- 51:21one of the first days when I was in Wall
- 51:22Street someone said to me would you like
- 51:24to buy ATV
- 51:28and I could I was looking in the
- 51:30brochure and I I couldn't figure out
- 51:31what stock had a symbol of ATV.
- 51:36And when I finally said, "Well, I I
- 51:38can't find it." And they said, "What the
- 51:40what's the matter with you?"
- 51:42Do you want to buy a TV? Which is he he
- 51:46was selling hot televisions, stolen
- 51:48televisions from the floor of the
- 51:49American Stock Exchange, referred to in
- 51:52common as the televisions fell off the
- 51:54truck. That's so I knew what that phrase
- 51:57meant from Coney Island.
- 52:00But what I found was most people what be
- 52:03it in business in normal life or in the
- 52:07world leaders don't really understand
- 52:10money. It is something they think about.
- 52:14They have a sense of what it is. They
- 52:16certainly want more of it but they also
- 52:20make statements like we want more money
- 52:21but we don't want more debt which just
- 52:24shows a misunderstanding of what money
- 52:26at its core really is. So they don't
- 52:28most people don't they want to make it
- 52:30they want to save it but to understand
- 52:33it in intimately is is not a normal
- 52:36character
- 52:37>> at the at the the first trilateral
- 52:45>> or something.
- 52:45>> Yeah.
- 52:46>> Just just give me approximate you you
- 52:48joined the trial commission.
- 52:50>> It might be
- 52:51>> and we'll be able to show the the we'll
- 52:52pull down the the chart of where your
- 52:54name was but just give me roughly when
- 52:56it was. I think it could be 90. I don't
- 52:58remember.
- 52:58>> Let's say early 90s. Yes.
- 53:00>> When you got on the trilateral
- 53:01commission
- 53:02>> and had the fir where was the do you
- 53:03remember the first meeting was?
- 53:04>> It was in Tokyo.
- 53:06>> In Tokyo. In what hotel?
- 53:08>> I would like to say the Hilton, but it's
- 53:10probably not.
- 53:11>> Um and it's a three-day four day
- 53:14three-day event. And
- 53:15>> walk me through the whole thing. Starts
- 53:17with a dinner. Good. Take me. Just walk
- 53:18me through it.
- 53:19>> It was boring. I can't I
- 53:21>> You couldn't possibly think it was
- 53:22boring. It's It was boring.
- 53:23>> You had to be stars in your eyes.
- 53:25>> No. Oh, did you fly over privately?
- 53:27>> Um, yes, but it wasn't my plane.
- 53:30>> So, it didn't count.
- 53:31>> No.
- 53:32>> Um,
- 53:34you you fly over?
- 53:36>> Yes.
- 53:36>> And
- 53:36>> and it was
- 53:37>> who who are the first like when you
- 53:38first met those leaders, you had to be
- 53:40wowed.
- 53:41>> No.
- 53:41>> You're 10 years out of Coney Island.
- 53:43>> No, I am not wowed by people of
- 53:46position. I'm wowed by people of great
- 53:48ideas. And I don't care if it's the bus
- 53:50driver. I don't care if it's the student
- 53:53I had who has teeth strict coming out.
- 53:55>> Well, these guys have to have great
- 53:56ideas of the leaders of the three great
- 53:58continents of the world, North America,
- 54:00Europe, and the and and Japan.
- 54:02>> No, many of these world leaders become
- 54:04world leaders because they're popular
- 54:06and they were able to get votes or they
- 54:07were able to convince people to vote for
- 54:09them. I learned later um many of them
- 54:14were just
- 54:16like good at what they did in terms of
- 54:18politics. Remember, world leaders are
- 54:20politicians in general. They're not
- 54:22scientists. They're not intellectuals.
- 54:25They're not great thinkers. They're
- 54:26great politicians. At the at the first
- 54:28Trilateral Commission meeting that you
- 54:30remember in Tokyo in sometime in the
- 54:33early 90s. Do you remember what were the
- 54:35big issues of the day that they were
- 54:37talking about and what did you think
- 54:38about it? Yeah. In fact, it was funny
- 54:40because they they were talking about
- 54:41inflation and they were worried that
- 54:44what would happen they how do you
- 54:46control inflation
- 54:49and I as a mathematician I didn't
- 54:51understand the concept. I don't
- 54:52understand the concept today.
- 54:55How's that possible? Well, when you talk
- 54:58about most things to do with money, they
- 55:02really money is meant to be local. It's
- 55:04US dollars. Then I understand what it
- 55:07means. If inflation, it means my dollar
- 55:09today
- 55:11inflates and it doesn't buy as much as
- 55:14it did a couple of years ago. The price
- 55:18the prices go up. I don't have as it
- 55:22seems that everything is great, but in
- 55:24fact, my dollar is shrinking in value.
- 55:26>> If if you
- 55:28and you're the financial genius here,
- 55:30I'm just a I'm just a lonely M&A guy.
- 55:33>> Um, if you let me if you let me finish
- 55:35the thought. Go ahead.
- 55:37>> So if if you're in America, you start to
- 55:39you can feel inflation. You have
- 55:41salaries gone up, but you don't buy as
- 55:43can't buy your same car. In fact, it
- 55:45starts to feel weird because the value
- 55:46>> that's why I wanted to answer the
- 55:47question that this is my point.
- 55:48>> Sure.
- 55:49>> The the central the people who live and
- 55:51breathe this the central banks have been
- 55:53haunted by the spectre of inflation
- 55:55since the late 70s.
- 55:57>> Yes.
- 55:58>> First off, tell our audience how did
- 56:00that happen? The two great uh the two
- 56:03great financial events
- 56:07in the 20th century, I'm not going to
- 56:08get to the 21st, were the the the the um
- 56:12the great inflation in Europe after
- 56:14World War I, the the Great Depression,
- 56:16the hyperinflation in Germany that led
- 56:19to the rise of Hitler, and then this
- 56:21inflation in the mid70s. What was before
- 56:24you go explain inflation? Why is why is
- 56:26a spectre of inflation always the
- 56:28central thing in central bankers minds?
- 56:32>> Because it goes back to this the first
- 56:34concept I said the weird concept of
- 56:36fractionalized reserves.
- 56:38The system is not well understood and
- 56:42will most systems in fact are not well
- 56:44understood. We don't know how our
- 56:45digestive system
- 56:46>> stop this is impossible. That's
- 56:47impossible. The most the most the the
- 56:50world banking system, the world currency
- 56:51system, the world monetary system has to
- 56:54be so well understood by the green spans
- 56:58of the world and the Bernani of the
- 56:59world and the and the
- 57:01>> and you uh right the the currency
- 57:04traders, the the the the guys making
- 57:08billion dollar bets every day, the the
- 57:10legendary guy on Wall Street in the late
- 57:1290s, Solomon Brothers, um
- 57:15>> Liveri,
- 57:16the guy wrote the money uh
- 57:18>> Michael Weser.
- 57:20>> Yeah, Lars Poker. Who's that about that
- 57:22great trader?
- 57:23>> L Reeri.
- 57:24>> No, the guy that ran the desk that
- 57:26eventually ran the the hedge fund that
- 57:28went long-term capital.
- 57:30>> Ah, yes. I don't remember.
- 57:32>> Who's the guy?
- 57:33>> I want to say I don't remember. I'm
- 57:34sorry.
- 57:35>> Luminary is big. But those guys have to
- 57:36understand the system perfectly.
- 57:38>> No, they don't understand the system.
- 57:39They understand the local part of the
- 57:41system. So for example, why is not only
- 57:44inflation, most bankers are terrified to
- 57:47if the public understood that the bank
- 57:49really doesn't have their money at any
- 57:53one time. There's one of the things
- 57:55during the depression there were runs on
- 57:56the bank. The reason the banks don't
- 57:59keep much money in the actual bank is
- 58:02they assume that not everyone's going to
- 58:03want their money on the same day. So
- 58:06that's not really the fear of inflation.
- 58:07The fear is a run on the bank. Everybody
- 58:10wants to take out something that doesn't
- 58:12really exist.
- 58:15Inflation is tied to interest rates.
- 58:18It's a more complicated example. But
- 58:21when your money doesn't buy the same
- 58:23amount of product this year that it did
- 58:26last year, if it buys less and less like
- 58:27it happened, you use the term
- 58:28hyperinflation.
- 58:30There's h certain countries that are not
- 58:33managed well like in Africa at the
- 58:35current a$undred
- 58:37billion dollar bill a hundred billion
- 58:41dollar bill in Zimbabwe
- 58:43is worth one American cent
- 58:47that's the perfect example of
- 58:49hyperinflation
- 58:51it goes up it doubles every day so
- 58:54people are afraid that their value and
- 58:56the system starts to break down but so
- 58:59if I said to Does your doctor you
- 59:02understand your body system?
- 59:07You'd say, "Well, I hope so because I
- 59:09want him to keep me healthy."
- 59:11But you could have a kidney infection.
- 59:13You could have a heart attack. You could
- 59:15have a broken knee. There's lots of
- 59:16pieces of this system. And in fact, when
- 59:19you ask the question, very few doctors
- 59:22understand your entire body. There's a
- 59:24specialist for your knee. There's a
- 59:25specialist for your polyidal cyst.
- 59:27There's a specialist for your head. And
- 59:28now we have specialists in different
- 59:30areas. So in and I'm going to get to
- 59:33your first question about Santa Fe
- 59:34Institute. The world economy and your
- 59:38body are both comprised of little
- 59:41systems interacting with each other and
- 59:44making one big
- 59:46>> you you you this is what's stunning for
- 59:49all the little guys out there, the
- 59:51populist movement, the little guys that
- 59:52that haven't had a pay raise in in 30
- 59:54years. They think that these elites,
- 59:58you know, have everything. The the guys
- 59:59in the room making the decisions, the
- 1:00:01the the party of Davos guys. You're
- 1:00:04sitting there and you don't think many
- 1:00:05people today really understand the
- 1:00:08complexity and really all the moving
- 1:00:10pieces and how they interconnect of the
- 1:00:12world's financial system. No, the nice
- 1:00:15not only don't they understand the
- 1:00:17complexity and that's goes back to Santa
- 1:00:19Fe Institute was an attempt of trying to
- 1:00:22see if there was a way to mathematize
- 1:00:24formularize or algorithmically
- 1:00:26understand what the term complexity
- 1:00:29means. That's that goes back to the
- 1:00:31original question. Complex systems are
- 1:00:35complex by definition, but there's not
- 1:00:38necessarily it's not one level of
- 1:00:39complexity is we might say, well, our
- 1:00:42fingers are complex, the movements, the
- 1:00:44muscles of our hands, but it's not as
- 1:00:46complex as the blood system. Now, I have
- 1:00:49a circulatory system. I have systems on
- 1:00:52top of systems. So, that there's no one
- 1:00:56group of or person that really
- 1:00:58understands the way the body works.
- 1:01:00There's no one group that understands
- 1:01:02the way the financial systems work. You
- 1:01:05might understand US bond markets. Now
- 1:01:07you've asked about the trader long-term
- 1:01:09capital. That was a bond fund very small
- 1:01:14part of this very complex system. So the
- 1:01:17goal of the Santa Fe Institute was to
- 1:01:19see is there a way to get in somehow
- 1:01:23understand how complex systems interact.
- 1:01:28Fast forward, Steve, to
- 1:01:31today where Google and these other um
- 1:01:37engine companies, the other tech
- 1:01:38companies are trying to build artificial
- 1:01:40intelligence.
- 1:01:42The strangest thing that they found, one
- 1:01:45of the strangest things is that the
- 1:01:46systems that they design, this
- 1:01:48artificial intelligence, which a lot of
- 1:01:49people have heard about, is they design
- 1:01:51a bunch of systems. They're called
- 1:01:54neural nets.
- 1:01:56terms simply taken out of brain work.
- 1:01:59Neur neurons in the brain. Nets because
- 1:02:01they actually look like a net. They put
- 1:02:04in some inputs.
- 1:02:07The computers work spit out an answer.
- 1:02:11Sounds normal to you. It's because
- 1:02:13you're thinking about that calculator
- 1:02:15you had in 1976 on your desk. When you
- 1:02:18ask the person who designed the system,
- 1:02:21how did it come to that answer? How did
- 1:02:25your neural net? Can you show me the
- 1:02:27calculations? They say, "No, we don't
- 1:02:30know. We don't know how the thing we
- 1:02:34designed
- 1:02:35actually came up with that answer."
- 1:02:37That's pretty strange.
- 1:02:39They take the same neural net now and
- 1:02:42they put it in front of a video game.
- 1:02:44No, no learning, nothing. They said to
- 1:02:46the computer, they say, "Sit in front of
- 1:02:48the your video game and learn how to
- 1:02:50play."
- 1:02:52It seems the computer learns better than
- 1:02:54any human in history, faster than any
- 1:02:57human in history, beats any human in
- 1:02:59history. But when you ask the designer
- 1:03:01how did it do it, no one knows. It just
- 1:03:06did it. So that's the first little touch
- 1:03:09of things that we already have gotten to
- 1:03:12a place where we don't understand it and
- 1:03:13we build it.
- 1:03:18on Sunday afternoon,
- 1:03:23September 14th, 2008. Where were you?
- 1:03:28>> Sorry.
- 1:03:29>> It was the night they put Lehman
- 1:03:31Brothers in bankruptcy in London.
- 1:03:32>> I was in jail.
- 1:03:35>> Seriously?
- 1:03:36>> Yes.
- 1:03:36>> So, the financial crisis of 2008
- 1:03:39happened when you were in jail? Yes.
- 1:03:40>> Oh, this is going to be so amazing.
- 1:03:43>> This is going to be so amazing. Um, I
- 1:03:46take it you couldn't you didn't have
- 1:03:47your Wall Street Journal dropped off to
- 1:03:49you in the morning, your Financial
- 1:03:50Times.
- 1:03:51>> No.
- 1:03:51>> How did you hear about the How'd you
- 1:03:53hear about Because I want the I'm
- 1:03:56>> I forgot about this, but yes,
- 1:03:58>> I'm trying to get this is going to be
- 1:03:58amazing. This is Let's go back and do
- 1:04:01that again. uh um Sunday afternoon
- 1:04:05because I want to find out about
- 1:04:08people the geniuses understanding the
- 1:04:10complexity of the financial system
- 1:04:12because I think the best example we have
- 1:04:13is the financial crisis of the crash of
- 1:04:152008.
- 1:04:17Sunday afternoon September 14th I think
- 1:04:19it was 2008
- 1:04:21is when they were working feverishly in
- 1:04:23Midtown Manhattan at the Lehman Brothers
- 1:04:25offices and at various law firms around
- 1:04:27town and with the secretary treasury
- 1:04:29about in the Federal Reserve what
- 1:04:31they're going to do with Leman. decided
- 1:04:32they weren't going to save it and so
- 1:04:34they prepared to put it into bankruptcy
- 1:04:36at the open of the market in London the
- 1:04:38next day.
- 1:04:41How did you hear about what was going to
- 1:04:43happen to Leman Brothers? And what did
- 1:04:44you immediately think when you heard
- 1:04:46there was going to be put into
- 1:04:47bankruptcy?
- 1:04:49I'm glad you asked that question. I was
- 1:04:52in solitary confinement
- 1:04:56September 14th
- 1:04:58and unbe again some of the public
- 1:05:01stories about the wonderful time I had
- 1:05:03in jail and my work release which didn't
- 1:05:06come till months after. I'd been there
- 1:05:08since June in an 8 by10 cell with a bed
- 1:05:13in the back, a six-foot bed in the back,
- 1:05:16a
- 1:05:18uh chrome sink with toilet attached to
- 1:05:21it, and a little piece of metal sticking
- 1:05:23out that was supposed to act as a table.
- 1:05:26Now, since I was in jail, there were no
- 1:05:28books.
- 1:05:29Why? There's no library. No library, but
- 1:05:32you're in jail. No, I was in jail, not
- 1:05:35prison. So in jail I was in a place was
- 1:05:38called the special housing unit which is
- 1:05:41for the roughest, toughest, meanest
- 1:05:43people.
- 1:05:45They had put me there, they said my own
- 1:05:46protection.
- 1:05:49So I was in a 8 by10 cell with a little
- 1:05:51slit in the door where they would serve
- 1:05:54my food on a on a tray about 9 in by 4
- 1:05:58in. And then soon as I finished eating,
- 1:06:02they would take the tray and close it
- 1:06:03down. And one of the guards said, "Do
- 1:06:07you understand? There's a cr there's
- 1:06:09Wall Street's crashing. I'm I'm worried
- 1:06:11about my pension fund. What should I
- 1:06:14do?"
- 1:06:15And I said, "Sorry, Wall Street's
- 1:06:18crashing. What's happened?" And he said,
- 1:06:20"There's some crisis and some companies
- 1:06:23are going bankrupt."
- 1:06:25I said, "Are you sure?" And he said,
- 1:06:28"Yeah, it's all over the papers.
- 1:06:29Everybody's ter we're all terrified.
- 1:06:31We're going to lose our life savings
- 1:06:32because we have either a 401k or our
- 1:06:35pension funds. We don't know anything
- 1:06:36about money. Mr. Epstein, can you tell
- 1:06:38us like what's going on? Am I going to
- 1:06:41am I going to be able to afford my
- 1:06:42children's education? Am I going to be
- 1:06:43bankrupted like this company called
- 1:06:45Lehman Brothers?
- 1:06:47And there's another company in the front
- 1:06:49page today
- 1:06:51called Bear Sterns.
- 1:06:54Oh no, I said. Why? because that's the
- 1:07:00company I was a partner in and in fact
- 1:07:03that was a company I had a very large
- 1:07:05investment in.
- 1:07:07So, as a great story,
- 1:07:10I I didn't have my Wall Street Journal,
- 1:07:13but in the early mornings, you're
- 1:07:16allowed to make two phone calls.
- 1:07:18Collect. And when you you pick up the
- 1:07:21phone,
- 1:07:22you can dial a number and when the
- 1:07:25person picks up, they say, "You're
- 1:07:26getting a call from the Palm Beach
- 1:07:28County Jail. Will you accept reverse
- 1:07:31charges?"
- 1:07:32And the person either says, "Yes." and
- 1:07:35they call goes through or the person
- 1:07:36says no.
- 1:07:38The person I had called was Jimmy Kaine,
- 1:07:41the president of Bear Sterns.
- 1:07:44And I said, "Tell me what's going on."
- 1:07:47And so that my knowledge of the
- 1:07:49financial crisis happened with Jimmy who
- 1:07:51was at the center of the storm telling
- 1:07:54me about what Lehman had gone under and
- 1:07:58they were trying to figure out a way
- 1:08:00should they bail out Bear Sterns.
- 1:08:04the um
- 1:08:06did it strike you at the time of
- 1:08:10the mess you had made of your life to be
- 1:08:12in a situation that you're one of the
- 1:08:14greatest financial minds in the world
- 1:08:15looked at by world leaders and uh asked
- 1:08:19their you know uh you're thinking by the
- 1:08:22most prominent and important people in
- 1:08:24the world and here you are in solitary
- 1:08:27confinement you can't even you can't
- 1:08:29even you got to make a collect call to
- 1:08:31somebody did did it did it strike you at
- 1:08:33the time how
- 1:08:36how all the threads of your life had
- 1:08:39come together and and and and put you in
- 1:08:42a position or you had put yourself in
- 1:08:43that position.
- 1:08:45>> No.
- 1:08:49So it never struck you when you had to
- 1:08:50make a collect your one collect call one
- 1:08:52of your two 50% of your collect calls
- 1:08:54that day you call the president or the
- 1:08:56head of the CEO of Bear Sterns the
- 1:08:59biggest financial
- 1:09:01event in your life is taking place of
- 1:09:06which one
- 1:09:08every important person in the world
- 1:09:10would be seeking your opinion. Number
- 1:09:11two would be a uh a once in a-lifetime
- 1:09:15opportunity to apply your craft. Number
- 1:09:18three, it would be a once in a lifetime
- 1:09:19opportunity to make money if you were
- 1:09:21smart. And obviously you're smart.
- 1:09:23You're telling me here truthfully that
- 1:09:26it never
- 1:09:28hit you at all of how you had ended up
- 1:09:30in a place where you had to make a
- 1:09:33collect phone call from a jail cell that
- 1:09:36was 6x9 with a steel bed and your food
- 1:09:40being passed into through a slot.
- 1:09:43>> The question you want to ask is who was
- 1:09:46the other call to?
- 1:09:48Who was the other call to? The other
- 1:09:50call was to my friend at JP Morgan
- 1:09:53who was then I didn't know it at the
- 1:09:54time trying to buy Bear Sterns. So at
- 1:09:57one point I had two phones. It was
- 1:09:59difficult because they're afraid people
- 1:10:01are going to hang themselves with the
- 1:10:03phone cord. So they don't actually come
- 1:10:05together and they're pretty short. So I
- 1:10:07was actually going between two phones
- 1:10:09talking to BTS and JP Morgan at the same
- 1:10:11time. So I found it amusing.
- 1:10:15>> And it never struck you about how to end
- 1:10:17up in a situation like this?
- 1:10:19>> No. That would be probably means I would
- 1:10:20be too self-aware.
- 1:10:23>> You can't possibly expect me to believe
- 1:10:25this.
- 1:10:26>> I know. I don't believe it. It's even
- 1:10:29you're telling me that and during that
- 1:10:31day
- 1:10:32>> you never had a moment you sat there and
- 1:10:35go what the have I done with my
- 1:10:37life that I'm in a 6x9 jail cell when I
- 1:10:41should be on a trading desk or I should
- 1:10:42be in my $250 million uh you know
- 1:10:46greatest townhouse in New York City
- 1:10:49taking calls from the king of Saudi
- 1:10:51Arabia, the president of China, the head
- 1:10:53of Russia, the president of the United
- 1:10:55States to uh save uh the world's
- 1:10:59population from a financial debacle.
- 1:11:01You're honestly expect me to believe
- 1:11:02that you that never happened?
- 1:11:04>> You're suggesting I was somewhat
- 1:11:06depressed and how how could this
- 1:11:08happened to me? I
- 1:11:08>> I'm not saying depressed. I'm saying a
- 1:11:10moment of awareness of how could I get
- 1:11:12myself into this situation?
- 1:11:13>> No, I would just say how strange that
- 1:11:16this happens. Just it's strange.
- 1:11:19I'm wearing a jumpsuit and flip and flip
- 1:11:22flops.
- 1:11:22>> What color was the jumpsuit?
- 1:11:24>> Brown.
- 1:11:26>> Brown. Brown jumpsuit.
- 1:11:27>> Yes.
- 1:11:28>> I notice I don't see you in a lot of
- 1:11:30brown.
- 1:11:30>> No.
- 1:11:31>> Brown jumpsuit and flip flops.
- 1:11:33>> Flip flops. Yes.
- 1:11:34>> With no access to books, no access to
- 1:11:36newspapers.
- 1:11:37>> No access to anything.
- 1:11:38>> You had lived on information
- 1:11:39>> except my Almond Joy bars. I had extra
- 1:11:41Almond Joy bars.
- 1:11:43>> Did you eat Almond Joy bars and things
- 1:11:45like that because you're afraid of what
- 1:11:46the the cooks did to your food?
- 1:11:49>> Yes.
- 1:11:50>> Is that because of of that you were in
- 1:11:53for the crimes that you were in for? No,
- 1:11:56it was just be in fact I was
- 1:11:58>> because you're wealthy.
- 1:11:59>> Yes.
- 1:12:00>> How did it how did you know that?
- 1:12:02>> Well, people people would constantly
- 1:12:04come if I was passing by or have to go
- 1:12:07for my medical, people would either ask
- 1:12:09to borrow money or make some other types
- 1:12:11of comments about
- 1:12:12>> in the beginning.
- 1:12:13>> What were the comments
- 1:12:15>> at the beginning? What were the
- 1:12:16comments? It
- 1:12:17>> it's it serves you rich guys
- 1:12:19right that you're here next to me.
- 1:12:21>> There was nothing about your crimes.
- 1:12:23>> No. So, all this rumor you hear all the
- 1:12:27time uh about people in prison that
- 1:12:30commit the type of crimes you commit,
- 1:12:32that's you're saying in your personal
- 1:12:34thing is not true.
- 1:12:35>> No,
- 1:12:36>> it was all because you were rich.
- 1:12:38>> Yes.
- 1:12:38>> And it was all because they wanted to
- 1:12:40borrow money.
- 1:12:40>> Well, get advice.
- 1:12:43>> Yes.
- 1:12:44>> Where they get advice to to go long to
- 1:12:47go long. Are you telling me? You're
- 1:12:49telling me in solitary confinement
- 1:12:50they're they're interested in going
- 1:12:52long?
- 1:12:53Yeah, they want to know why.
- 1:12:56>> What does that say about human nature?
- 1:12:58>> Well, what I think the people find one
- 1:13:00of the reasons they wanted to keep me in
- 1:13:02solitary confinement was they're afraid
- 1:13:03that everybody would want to know which
- 1:13:05stocks to buy
- 1:13:07and but what happened was after this
- 1:13:10crisis now it's on the front page of
- 1:13:11every
- 1:13:12>> I don't want to leave lose this day.
- 1:13:14>> Sorry. Sorry. When you first heard that,
- 1:13:15did you
- 1:13:19>> Was it Bear Bear Sterns had been kicked
- 1:13:21into bankruptcy what 6 months before?
- 1:13:23>> No. No. This is the same time. This is
- 1:13:25part of the same deal.
- 1:13:27>> I thought I thought No, no. Bear Sterns.
- 1:13:28They said the Bear Sterns they Oh, they
- 1:13:30saved Beer Sterns and didn't save
- 1:13:32>> uh Leman Brothers. That's six months
- 1:13:34before they had bailed out Bear Sterns.
- 1:13:36But Bear Sterns was still a zombie.
- 1:13:38>> A what? For a shell of its former self.
- 1:13:40>> A former self. But they had quote
- 1:13:42unquote saved him. They admit why did
- 1:13:44they make the decision in your mind? Why
- 1:13:46did Hank Pollson and Bernani this what's
- 1:13:49this concept of moral hazard? Explain to
- 1:13:52the audience what moral hazard is and
- 1:13:54why why did they save Bear Stern six
- 1:13:56months before and why did did the
- 1:13:58smartest guys in the room decide not to
- 1:14:00save Leon Brothers?
- 1:14:05It's a good question. The real issue is
- 1:14:07is I'd have to go back when you have
- 1:14:09these systems to the way your doctor
- 1:14:12responds to any type of emergency in
- 1:14:15your body. If they might decide to save
- 1:14:18your kidneys and let your gallbladder go
- 1:14:20because the gallbladder is less
- 1:14:21important to your overall system. it
- 1:14:24people if at that time
- 1:14:28even it's it's not that long ago the
- 1:14:32boogeyman
- 1:14:33was when said what really happened
- 1:14:36Jeffrey what really happened why what is
- 1:14:38this financial crisis and you know the
- 1:14:40some of the progressives and the
- 1:14:42right-wing blame it on the banks it was
- 1:14:44the bank's fault and it's the fault of
- 1:14:47this very esoteric unknown concept of
- 1:14:52derivatives
- 1:14:53It was really the derivatives that
- 1:14:56caused
- 1:14:57this financial crisis because the
- 1:14:59derivatives got somehow out of control
- 1:15:01and like the in the Mickey Mouse
- 1:15:03>> and that was the way you started your
- 1:15:05financial your financial your your road
- 1:15:07to a billionaire went right through
- 1:15:09derivatives.
- 1:15:10>> Yes. But it's but derivatives were not
- 1:15:13the cause. Derivatives were not the
- 1:15:16cause at all.
- 1:15:19It's like saying your hair was the cause
- 1:15:21of your heart attack because it was on
- 1:15:22the top of your head. What was the
- 1:15:23cause?
- 1:15:26>> There isn't,
- 1:15:28let me say, there's no one specific
- 1:15:31cause. There's a system collapses. So
- 1:15:34when many times when they have to make
- 1:15:36your death certificate
- 1:15:38when you say, well, what did he die
- 1:15:39from? They'll say heart failure. But if
- 1:15:42you say what was the cause of his heart
- 1:15:43failure? Well, he had blood pressure.
- 1:15:46His sugar was high. He was diabetic. He
- 1:15:48had all these other problems. But he
- 1:15:50said, "No, no, no. We need a word on
- 1:15:52your death certificate. Did he die from
- 1:15:54brain damage? Did he die from heart
- 1:15:56failure?" That's the financial crisis.
- 1:15:58Many said people said, "Well, what
- 1:16:00caused it?" They wrote like on its death
- 1:16:02certificate derivatives, but derivatives
- 1:16:05were not a fundamental derivatives are
- 1:16:08not a fundamental cause of anything.
- 1:16:10>> On the So, the was it Sunday or Monday?
- 1:16:12I can take it was Monday morning when
- 1:16:14you made your two collect calls and
- 1:16:15you're talking to Bear Sterns on one
- 1:16:17hand and Morgan Stanley the other.
- 1:16:18>> JP Morgan.
- 1:16:19>> JP Morgan. Did you That was Monday
- 1:16:22morning. Did you Jeffrey
- 1:16:25uh
- 1:16:29being one of the financial geniuses in
- 1:16:31the world? Did you understand what
- 1:16:33Lehman Brothers going into bankruptcy,
- 1:16:35the domino effect that by Thursday the
- 1:16:38financial system would be under such
- 1:16:41extremis if it didn't have a trillion
- 1:16:43dollar cash infusion in the United
- 1:16:45States it might collapse? Did you know
- 1:16:47that at the time? Did you view that at
- 1:16:50the time?
- 1:16:50>> Yes,
- 1:16:52>> you did.
- 1:16:52>> Yeah.
- 1:16:53>> Why? Again, I I I don't want to bore you
- 1:16:57or the audience with the the idea of
- 1:16:59it's a medical procedure, but you had
- 1:17:02system failures. So, you'd recognize
- 1:17:04that if I said to you, did you realize
- 1:17:06when your father was on the ground and
- 1:17:07he was clutching his chest and he
- 1:17:09couldn't breathe? Uh it was a bad
- 1:17:12situation. He he could die. That's how I
- 1:17:15saw it.
- 1:17:15>> Did you Did you know did you immediately
- 1:17:18think about the commercial paper market?
- 1:17:19I mean the the mechanical triggers that
- 1:17:21actually had to you had to blow through
- 1:17:23these circuit boards. Did you know the
- 1:17:25circuits? Did you understand the
- 1:17:27circuits or did you have a concept of
- 1:17:29the circuits that were going to get
- 1:17:30blown through? Yes, but only because of
- 1:17:33an analogy to a body. And in fact, from
- 1:17:35my se my telephones against the wall
- 1:17:38with my little metal wires because the
- 1:17:40next day I talked to another person in
- 1:17:42Washington about the issues of what I
- 1:17:44thought was happening and I made the
- 1:17:46same discussion about the
- 1:17:47>> they were at the Treasury Department.
- 1:17:49>> Yes.
- 1:17:49>> So in a in a 6x9 cell in
- 1:17:54>> the phones were outside the cell
- 1:17:55>> in Connie in in in Palm Beach County,
- 1:17:58California.
- 1:17:58>> West Palm Beach, Florida. West Palm
- 1:18:00Beach, Florida.
- 1:18:00>> That's what the juice diet.
- 1:18:01>> West Palm Beach, Florida. West Palm
- 1:18:03Beach, Florida. West Palm Beach,
- 1:18:05Florida. Uh, you're making a call to
- 1:18:09Washington DC to talk to some deputy
- 1:18:12deputy secretary Treasury.
- 1:18:13>> Someone in Treasury,
- 1:18:14>> right? Someone in Treasury,
- 1:18:15>> right?
- 1:18:17>> And that does not
- 1:18:19the night before before you go to bed,
- 1:18:22it doesn't dawn on you at all. You never
- 1:18:24have a moment of self-reflection that
- 1:18:26how did I end up on this metal cot when
- 1:18:29I should be at the center of things?
- 1:18:31>> No, I had a telephone. So, I've said I
- 1:18:33can talk to it makes no difference where
- 1:18:35I am. In fact, I'm still talking to the
- 1:18:37same person if I was at my home in Palm
- 1:18:39Beach, but I'm here in home in Palm
- 1:18:41Beach.
- 1:18:41>> I can dial my own phone.
- 1:18:42>> That's that's No, but you can
- 1:18:44also make a thousand phone calls here.
- 1:18:46You got to make one and he's got to take
- 1:18:48>> Think how much better that was. I had to
- 1:18:49decide who was the right person to call.
- 1:18:51That was unusual for me because I would
- 1:18:53have called 20 people.
- 1:18:54>> And what was this? What was the advice
- 1:18:55you gave her?
- 1:18:56>> I said we have you have a sick patient
- 1:18:58and it's very much like a sick patient
- 1:19:01in the emergency room. Don't you can't
- 1:19:02think about it like your car. People in
- 1:19:06normal walks of life think about money
- 1:19:07and things as a machine. And
- 1:19:10unfortunately, so if your car breaks,
- 1:19:12cars are always easy to fix.
- 1:19:15my jets, my cars, if it breaks, I know
- 1:19:19it can be fixed because it simply
- 1:19:20follows the same pattern. If this part
- 1:19:22breaks, you replace the part and the
- 1:19:23thing works again. People and the
- 1:19:27financial system are not machines. They
- 1:19:30can't be fixed the same way. You can't
- 1:19:32simply take out the B, put some more
- 1:19:35juice into the commercial paper market,
- 1:19:37and that's like replacing the carburetor
- 1:19:38on the car. It's much more I have a
- 1:19:41patient who can't breathe, has a stomach
- 1:19:44problem, can't see, looks bleeding at
- 1:19:46the same time. What do I do first? I
- 1:19:48have to think about it as a system.
- 1:19:51Where's the most logical place? What's
- 1:19:53the most dangerous place? If your heart
- 1:19:55stopped, we have to start your heart
- 1:19:57again. If the in the equivalent to the
- 1:20:01money market,
- 1:20:04why do I have to start your heart again?
- 1:20:06I need to get your blood flowing. If
- 1:20:08your blood stops
- 1:20:10the you're dead. If liquidity,
- 1:20:14which is the equivalent of blood in the
- 1:20:17financial system, dries up.
- 1:20:20>> What's liquidity is basically cash
- 1:20:22putting cash into the system.
- 1:20:23>> Forget about what it is.
- 1:20:24>> Okay?
- 1:20:24>> Liquidity is liquidity. It allows the
- 1:20:27system, it's the blood of the system.
- 1:20:29You need to pump blood hard into the
- 1:20:33body of the economy to keep it flowing.
- 1:20:36And if you if you especially when you're
- 1:20:37worried about someone dying, you're not
- 1:20:39going to be worried about the nicities
- 1:20:41of well, you got the shirt dirty and
- 1:20:42there was some damage. Pumping that
- 1:20:45blood, keep that.
- 1:20:46>> When you talked to to the person in
- 1:20:47treasury on Tuesday the 16th, did you
- 1:20:49get a feeling as you were sitting in
- 1:20:52your 6x9 jail cell in West Palm Beach,
- 1:20:55Florida, that they were on top of
- 1:20:58things?
- 1:21:00>> No, you can't. It's impossible to be on
- 1:21:01top of things. There's no such thing.
- 1:21:04It's again the doctor watching the
- 1:21:06patient die. You hopefully have some
- 1:21:08confidence that he's seen it before. He
- 1:21:12recognizes that there are some steps he
- 1:21:14has to take first before he bandages the
- 1:21:16guy's finger or worries about what shoes
- 1:21:18he has on. So you hope that the people
- 1:21:20in charge, your doctors who are working
- 1:21:22on the emergency patient, have enough
- 1:21:24experience and frankly judgment to try
- 1:21:28to keep the patient alive. Did you think
- 1:21:30that they did you think that they
- 1:21:32>> had those things? Patience and judgment.
- 1:21:34>> They had pretty good judgment and you
- 1:21:36needed a lot of luck. Just like in the
- 1:21:38dead patient, you need to hopefully you
- 1:21:41put that blood in and it's not too late
- 1:21:43and you maybe you make some mistakes,
- 1:21:45but you have to know you're going to
- 1:21:46have to give it a shock.
- 1:21:47>> In the run-up to uh the September crash
- 1:21:50of 2008. Yeah.
- 1:21:51>> I guess you weren't occupied with
- 1:21:52finance that whole summer. How long had
- 1:21:54you been in jail?
- 1:21:55>> I got went to jail June 30th.
- 1:21:57>> So the entire summer? Yes.
- 1:21:59>> Before you went into jail, you were
- 1:22:01still very active in the financial
- 1:22:02markets.
- 1:22:03>> Yes.
- 1:22:03>> When I say active, you trade currencies
- 1:22:06every day. You trade stocks every day.
- 1:22:07When when people someone like you or you
- 1:22:10give you give advice to people to trade
- 1:22:12stocks or trade currencies?
- 1:22:14>> I I don't trade every day. I I think
- 1:22:16that's like Woody Allen said, it's you
- 1:22:19can't beat the bank. So, I I try to pick
- 1:22:22my spots. You know, George Soros picked
- 1:22:25his spot in the when the pound
- 1:22:26collapsed. This would have been a great
- 1:22:28money-making opportunity that passed me
- 1:22:30by when I was in jail, but that's not
- 1:22:32how I think.
- 1:22:33>> In the run-up to that, in the spring of
- 1:22:352008, were you that's when Bear Sterns
- 1:22:38got in problems, I think, in in the
- 1:22:39spring of 2008 and they decided to bail
- 1:22:41it out.
- 1:22:42>> Did the Bear Sterns guys talk to you for
- 1:22:44advice at that time when the big crisis
- 1:22:46in Bear Sterns? No, the see again
- 1:22:49unbeknownst to most people
- 1:22:52and it's easy to blame people for the
- 1:22:55financial crisis like you'd blame the
- 1:22:57someone for giving your father the drink
- 1:22:59before he had his heart attack.
- 1:23:02But what really happened
- 1:23:05the real enemy of the finance system was
- 1:23:09Bill Clinton. And if if you ask me what
- 1:23:12and who caused the financial crisis, I
- 1:23:15would tell you it was Bill Clinton
- 1:23:17>> because of what Bob Rubin and he did to
- 1:23:19the financial deregulate the financial
- 1:23:21system.
- 1:23:22>> No,
- 1:23:24because as of the last time we had our
- 1:23:2660-minute interview, you talked to me
- 1:23:29about home ownership
- 1:23:31and you asked me whether everyone should
- 1:23:33own a home and I told you no, it's too
- 1:23:36risky.
- 1:23:38So, the financial collapse of 2008 is
- 1:23:40because of hardworking
- 1:23:42African-Americans, Hispanics, and and
- 1:23:44and and whites who wanted to have a
- 1:23:47piece have a ownership stake in in in
- 1:23:51the society that all rest on their
- 1:23:52shoulders. They're the culprits.
- 1:23:55>> No, not at all.
- 1:23:57>> Okay. Then
- 1:23:57>> I I didn't say they were the C. I was
- 1:23:59pretty clear it was Bill Clinton.
- 1:24:01>> Okay.
- 1:24:01>> Why was it Bill Clinton? because Bill
- 1:24:04Clinton wanted to get votes from those
- 1:24:06people and he sold them the idea that
- 1:24:11instead of renting in a house and
- 1:24:13historically the values of houses has
- 1:24:16gone up and he said you guys in these
- 1:24:19local communities who haven't been able
- 1:24:20to afford a house before,
- 1:24:23I'm going to show you a way. I'm going
- 1:24:25to give you away because I'm sure you
- 1:24:28I'll get your vote
- 1:24:30that you can own a house because I want
- 1:24:34your vote. So, what we're going to do is
- 1:24:37I'm going to let you buy a house, Mr.
- 1:24:40Bannon, when you really you it's you're
- 1:24:43right on the border maybe or not even on
- 1:24:46the border. You your credit is not good.
- 1:24:50Okay, let's let's be honest. And it's
- 1:24:53not my fault or it's not Bill Clinton's
- 1:24:55fault, but whatever happens at the
- 1:24:57moment your credit score or whatever it
- 1:24:59is, your credit's not good.
- 1:25:02Now, normally you come to me and you're
- 1:25:05a want to borrow money. I'm a bank
- 1:25:10and I say, "I'm sorry, Mr. Bannon. I
- 1:25:12can't lend you money
- 1:25:14because your credit score is not up to
- 1:25:18where it needs to be. Hopefully, if you
- 1:25:20work harder and clean up some of your
- 1:25:21problems, it will be.
- 1:25:26But no, what I say to you is I'm going
- 1:25:28to figure out a way to lend you lend
- 1:25:31you, not give you, I'm going to lend you
- 1:25:33money anyway, though you don't have a
- 1:25:35good credit score.
- 1:25:37And don't worry, I'm going to get a rid
- 1:25:40of the term that you don't have bad
- 1:25:43credit. Bad credit sounds projorative.
- 1:25:46You don't want to be a person.
- 1:25:47>> Sounds judgmental. Yeah, sounds
- 1:25:49judgmental.
- 1:25:50So, what we're going to do is we're
- 1:25:52going to call your credit situation.
- 1:25:56Subprime.
- 1:25:59Oh, nobody knows what that means.
- 1:26:02Subprime.
- 1:26:05That means prime is good credit.
- 1:26:09Subprime
- 1:26:11is not good credit. Less than good
- 1:26:13credit. So, we'll call it something that
- 1:26:16people really won't follow. And we'll
- 1:26:18tell you what, we're going to have
- 1:26:20people lend you money though you are a
- 1:26:22subprime
- 1:26:25borrower
- 1:26:27and I
- 1:26:29will figure out some government agencies
- 1:26:31to guarantee your loan though I don't
- 1:26:34think you're a good risk.
- 1:26:37So the banks say no no no no we don't
- 1:26:40want initially the bank said sorry this
- 1:26:44is too risky Mr. president for us.
- 1:26:48We're in the business of managing risk.
- 1:26:50It's not our money. It's the hardworking
- 1:26:53people's money sitting in our bank. We
- 1:26:56can't lend to people whose credit is not
- 1:26:58prime. You're asking us to lend to
- 1:27:00people who are subprime.
- 1:27:03And he says, here's the key.
- 1:27:06If you don't, Mr. Bannon, I am going to
- 1:27:09make sure the Justice Department charges
- 1:27:12you with discriminatory lending.
- 1:27:16because you refuse to lend to my
- 1:27:20subprimers.
- 1:27:22In business terms, you should never lend
- 1:27:24to. But what we'll do is we're going to
- 1:27:27I'm going to form an agency called Fanny
- 1:27:29May and Jinny May. Just another agency
- 1:27:32names. They'll guarantee your loan. So
- 1:27:35don't worry.
- 1:27:37Don't worry. You don't have to pay it
- 1:27:39back anymore.
- 1:27:41Even though you and maybe you don't even
- 1:27:43have to work as hard anymore. It's
- 1:27:45that's probably a harsh statement, but
- 1:27:47these players, these two big firms,
- 1:27:50Fanny M will guarantee the fact that
- 1:27:52that bank will receive its money.
- 1:27:57Now the bank says, "Wow, best deal in
- 1:27:59history.
- 1:28:01I refuse to lend to Mr. Bannon, but now
- 1:28:04he has the big brother uncle, his uncle
- 1:28:06Sam." He went to his uncle Sam, and
- 1:28:08Uncle Sam says, "I'm guaranteeing it."
- 1:28:12The bank says,"I want everybody. Give me
- 1:28:15as many people as you can give me
- 1:28:18because Uncle Sam is the best credit in
- 1:28:20the the world. Not only it's the United
- 1:28:22States government. We'll take it all.
- 1:28:24We'll take as much subprime
- 1:28:29as we can handle because it's the best
- 1:28:32investment for the moment. It's a
- 1:28:34strange investment because it has
- 1:28:35politics that has inserted its way into
- 1:28:38the numbers.
- 1:28:41politics doesn't belong in the in the
- 1:28:42markets. But now we're going to have I
- 1:28:45want the votes. We'll make guarantees
- 1:28:47that you who can't get a house normally
- 1:28:49will be able to get a house from the
- 1:28:52bank. The bank says this is the best
- 1:28:54deal in history. We will package
- 1:28:59a 100, 300, a thousand of you subprimers
- 1:29:02and we'll sell it off to somebody else.
- 1:29:04And the whole system becomes mired in
- 1:29:08subprime mortgages. That's becomes the
- 1:29:12the issue.
- 1:29:12>> What do you mean mired?
- 1:29:14>> Does too much supply is a supply demand
- 1:29:17problem? You got too much supply.
- 1:29:18>> No, it it's a very good question. What
- 1:29:22does too much supply mean? Well, then
- 1:29:25you get the people go back to your first
- 1:29:27question to me.
- 1:29:30Government leaders.
- 1:29:32Government leaders know if they're good
- 1:29:37if and they can do mathematics, they can
- 1:29:39balance their checkbooks. So certain
- 1:29:42people in Congress said, "Well, how do
- 1:29:44you value these subprime mortgages?"
- 1:29:48The banks say, "We've we've been valuing
- 1:29:50them the same way we've always valued
- 1:29:53them for the past 20 years."
- 1:29:56the accounting firms. There's something
- 1:29:58in in this country called GAAP
- 1:29:59accounting, which is a a standard type
- 1:30:01of accounting.
- 1:30:04And we account for them the same way
- 1:30:06we've always accounted for them. If we
- 1:30:08paid
- 1:30:10$1,000 for your mortgage
- 1:30:15last night,
- 1:30:17when we put it on our books today, we're
- 1:30:19going to say its value is $1,000.
- 1:30:23Makes sense. I paid for it last. What's
- 1:30:25its value?
- 1:30:27It's $1,000. That's what I paid for it
- 1:30:29last night. No, the Congress people said
- 1:30:33that's not really a good answer. You
- 1:30:35know, that does that doesn't give us
- 1:30:38confidence that you know what you're
- 1:30:40doing because
- 1:30:43what happens if you have to sell it
- 1:30:44tomorrow morning?
- 1:30:47If I you there's a something's happened
- 1:30:49and you have to sell it. Remember
- 1:30:50there's kinds of stress tests.
- 1:30:53would you be able to value it at what
- 1:30:56you paid for it the day before?
- 1:30:59And Wall Street says that's not the way
- 1:31:01you can think about this. This is crazy.
- 1:31:04We always value things at the cost from
- 1:31:06the day before. And they changed the
- 1:31:08accounting method. In essence, to say
- 1:31:11not what it was worth yesterday, but if
- 1:31:14I have to sell,
- 1:31:17what would it be worth?
- 1:31:20That's impossible. So what happens is
- 1:31:22every bank now has to value something
- 1:31:25they bought yesterday at lower than they
- 1:31:28paid.
- 1:31:29Never before in 20 years did they have
- 1:31:31to do this.
- 1:31:33So something they bought at a,000 on
- 1:31:35their books was a,000 is now 990.
- 1:31:41That starts to you asked the question
- 1:31:43about what did I start to think about?
- 1:31:46Something's a,000 and 990. This person
- 1:31:48now has to value it at 980. When did you
- 1:31:50first start to get nervous understanding
- 1:31:53Bill Clinton in all this? Did you change
- 1:31:55glasses?
- 1:31:56>> Yes.
- 1:31:56>> Okay.
- 1:31:57>> I changed shirt.
- 1:31:59>> I saw the black.
- 1:32:01>> Um
- 1:32:02>> are you okay with the
- 1:32:03>> Yeah, great. I think we're going to have
- 1:32:04all kind of changes.
- 1:32:05>> I'm experimenting. Okay.
- 1:32:06>> Um
- 1:32:09when did you get a feeling? Did you ever
- 1:32:11anticipate
- 1:32:14before it happened something like 2008
- 1:32:15could happen?
- 1:32:16>> No.
- 1:32:18How could that be?
- 1:32:21Because anticipated
- 1:32:25to death is that it's very much like a
- 1:32:28would I expect anticipate I'll have a
- 1:32:30heart attack tomorrow? Unlikely.
- 1:32:33>> Was 2008 a heart attack or stroke?
- 1:32:35Debilitating.
- 1:32:37>> Um it's a better um
- 1:32:41I don't to it was both.
- 1:32:45But why was it both? because in fact as
- 1:32:47I said the blood was getting dried up in
- 1:32:49the system and the head which is sort of
- 1:32:51the central bank wasn't working.
- 1:32:54So to some extent it was a combination
- 1:32:56it was did you see that building up over
- 1:32:59time?
- 1:33:00>> It's it's always been lurking in the
- 1:33:01background. I mean if if you have an
- 1:33:03older parent would you say it's possible
- 1:33:08did you anticipate him having a heart
- 1:33:09attack today? No. You hope things are
- 1:33:11going to go better and maybe they'll fix
- 1:33:12it up. um the system was getting too
- 1:33:15complex and it wasn't based on
- 1:33:18derivatives because what people keep
- 1:33:19forgetting and as I was just explaining
- 1:33:23Wall Street and in many professions
- 1:33:26including Wall Street, Wall Street makes
- 1:33:28it sound complicated. They don't want
- 1:33:30the little guy to understand what they
- 1:33:32do because they make so much money and
- 1:33:34they don't do very much. So they they
- 1:33:37couch it in words like derivative and
- 1:33:39stock options and commodity futures and
- 1:33:44different types of contracts. It's all
- 1:33:47fairly everyone is capable of
- 1:33:49understanding it. It is not complicated.
- 1:33:52But Wall Street because they make so
- 1:33:54much money from doing fairly simple
- 1:33:55things needs to make it more complicated
- 1:33:57than it really is.
- 1:34:01the we had a a very big recession in the
- 1:34:04early 90s based upon real estate and and
- 1:34:07and at Japan basically imploding.
- 1:34:10>> Let's again you had a recession in the
- 1:34:13'9s. I don't know what it's based upon.
- 1:34:16It it's always interesting to look back
- 1:34:17and say separate from there's certain
- 1:34:20triggers like there in the 70s there was
- 1:34:22a
- 1:34:22>> what do you think it was based upon in
- 1:34:24the '90s downturn? It's clearly there
- 1:34:25was a huge downturn. No, I I just I know
- 1:34:28there was a downturn. That's what I know
- 1:34:30for sure.
- 1:34:31>> That's a fact. What
- 1:34:34>> everything else is is sort of
- 1:34:35speculation about why why did he have
- 1:34:37>> understand that, but there's some
- 1:34:38speculation that has 0% probability of
- 1:34:41being true and there's others that have
- 1:34:4490%. In in the r in the range when you
- 1:34:47look at the range of alternatives of
- 1:34:49what could have caused it of in 90 and
- 1:34:53what I'm trying to do is get you all the
- 1:34:54way up to 2008. Look, you're the
- 1:34:56smartest guy in the room, right? You
- 1:34:58know that.
- 1:34:59>> Do you think there's anybody in the
- 1:35:01world today?
- 1:35:02>> Oops. That's this gonna be this is going
- 1:35:04to be a bad question. No, no, but do you
- 1:35:06s do you think anybody in the world
- 1:35:07today, the Allen Greenspans, the
- 1:35:09Bernankees, any C, is there any central
- 1:35:11banker you know, any partner of any Wall
- 1:35:13Street firm, any guy running a trading
- 1:35:15desk, and I would take it that would be
- 1:35:17or anybody at a Larry Frink at Black
- 1:35:19Rockck, uh Steve Schwarzman at at
- 1:35:22Blackstone, the top hundred
- 1:35:25financial guys, and let's throw in a
- 1:35:27couple of Nobel economists and let's
- 1:35:28throw in the best professors at the at
- 1:35:31Wharton and at Harvard, at Stanford. Do
- 1:35:33you think that there's anybody that
- 1:35:36understands money or understands the
- 1:35:39world's financial system as good as you?
- 1:35:42>> There must be.
- 1:35:44>> But it doesn't come to the top of the
- 1:35:45head.
- 1:35:46>> No.
- 1:35:46>> Okay. Fine. Now,
- 1:35:49>> now that Now that Okay, now that I've
- 1:35:50gotten that, no, now that I've gotten
- 1:35:52that, let's go back to 1990. In that arc
- 1:35:54from 90 from the fall of the Berlin Wall
- 1:35:56to 2008.
- 1:35:58>> Good. We had we started with the the
- 1:36:01implosion in Tokyo of the Japanese
- 1:36:04economy, Japanese financial markets. We
- 1:36:07had the huge run up in in internet
- 1:36:08stocks, right? We had the implosion of
- 1:36:11that in 2000.
- 1:36:13uh the um you know the the the
- 1:36:16bankruptcy of bar of uh of Drexel
- 1:36:19Burnham in 90
- 1:36:21>> implosion of Japan huge runup in equity
- 1:36:24markets for the internet implosion the
- 1:36:26internet 2000 10 years later roughly
- 1:36:28>> and then this runup through the Iraq war
- 1:36:31and all that the runup to 2008 every 10
- 1:36:33years it seems like we're in some sort
- 1:36:35of
- 1:36:3710 years before the 1990s was was the 70
- 1:36:40am I
- 1:36:40>> you sound like an astrologer Okay.
- 1:36:43>> And not a financial
- 1:36:44>> I'm usually a mathematician. It just
- 1:36:46seems to me a pattern of every 10 years.
- 1:36:48>> That's that's misleading. That's exactly
- 1:36:49right. Because people like to see
- 1:36:51patterns. People like to see patterns
- 1:36:52where there are none.
- 1:36:54>> So a pattern of a financial crisis every
- 1:36:5610 years is just in my mind.
- 1:36:57>> Yes.
- 1:36:59>> Long-term capital. Long-term capital
- 1:37:01that had to be bailed out back in the
- 1:37:04late 90s when everybody panicked. And
- 1:37:06that wasn't a big that bailout today
- 1:37:08would look small and was it $5 billion
- 1:37:10or was $30 billion.
- 1:37:12>> People businesses fail all the time,
- 1:37:15>> but they long-term capital and the
- 1:37:17Federal Reserve stepped in.
- 1:37:18>> But I'm saying they f things people go
- 1:37:20bad. Things go bad all the time.
- 1:37:23>> Yes. The the the local the You're
- 1:37:25correct. The audience that's watching
- 1:37:27this, the little guys, they go bankrupt
- 1:37:28all the time and nobody gives a
- 1:37:30You know why? They're a little guy. But
- 1:37:32when long-term capital management goes
- 1:37:34bankrupt or Bear Sterns goes bankrupt or
- 1:37:36Leman Brothers goes bankrupt, people
- 1:37:37care because it
- 1:37:39>> No, it's a it's an unfair
- 1:37:40characterization.
- 1:37:41>> Why do you say that?
- 1:37:41>> Because again, it's the complexity of
- 1:37:43the situation. If you think about the
- 1:37:46think you have a complex system, you
- 1:37:47have your body. Now, in fact, the little
- 1:37:50guy is my finger.
- 1:37:52This this is
- 1:37:53>> Bear Sterns is your heart.
- 1:37:54>> That's correct. The banking system is my
- 1:37:56heart. the system. I can't risk my my
- 1:37:59because remember it's not only
- 1:38:00>> you haven't been able to name you
- 1:38:02haven't no hang
- 1:38:04>> I was trying to hang I wanted to see if
- 1:38:05the hang on worked
- 1:38:06>> you haven't been able you're not good
- 1:38:07enough yet you're like junior junior
- 1:38:09wizard trying to do it you you haven't
- 1:38:11you haven't since we can't name another
- 1:38:14guy that's as as as good as you there
- 1:38:16may be a couple out there you're not
- 1:38:17you're not bragging you're you're humble
- 1:38:21>> it had to be sometime please tell me
- 1:38:23there was some time before you went to
- 1:38:27jail and and and basically got cut off
- 1:38:29from daily information in the summer of
- 1:38:302008. Um that you started to get very
- 1:38:34nervous that this complex system that
- 1:38:37something was deeply wrong.
- 1:38:39>> Okay, first let's go back. When I say no
- 1:38:42one understands the system better than I
- 1:38:44do, it doesn't mean I
- 1:38:45>> You always sound like a doctor you're
- 1:38:46afraid is going to get sued for giving a
- 1:38:48a thing. You're not you're not taking on
- 1:38:50any liability. There's no contingent
- 1:38:52liability here for
- 1:38:53>> your No, no, no. But the word understand
- 1:38:54is the problem. I don't understand the
- 1:38:56system. So that's I don't understand the
- 1:38:59financial system.
- 1:39:00>> Please stop. You cannot sit here and
- 1:39:02tell me what we just went through. I'll
- 1:39:04go through again the hedge fund
- 1:39:05managers, the money managers, the
- 1:39:07central bankers, the commercial bankers,
- 1:39:09the heads of the investment banks, the
- 1:39:10heads of all the trading desks, the top
- 1:39:13uh economists, and I'll throw in the
- 1:39:15business school lectures of Stanford. Of
- 1:39:17all the top 200, 250, you can't name off
- 1:39:20the top of your head. The guys are at
- 1:39:22least at your level. You have to
- 1:39:24understand it somewhat.
- 1:39:26>> No, sorry. We all don't understand it.
- 1:39:30No one understands it. It's a miracle.
- 1:39:33It's this this that's part of the
- 1:39:35problem. It's impossible to understand.
- 1:39:38That word understand simply means if
- 1:39:41this happens here, that will happen
- 1:39:44there. It's predictable. Understanding
- 1:39:46means it's predictable. It's not
- 1:39:48predictable. That's the problem. It's
- 1:39:49very in complex systems. That was the
- 1:39:52fascination. Is there a way to tease out
- 1:39:54some level of predictability?
- 1:39:56>> So,
- 1:39:57>> in fact, you ask, you would ask the
- 1:39:59question, it's a great question, which
- 1:40:01was, was it a stroke or a heart attack?
- 1:40:03Now, most people don't know that before
- 1:40:05they were going to have a stroke, they
- 1:40:06had a stroke. Did they
- 1:40:09just have a stroke? Do did they
- 1:40:11understand why? In hindsight, you go
- 1:40:13back and you can make lots of
- 1:40:15explanations. It might sound good. And
- 1:40:17if you're talking to the the working
- 1:40:19man, you're using language that he'll
- 1:40:22never understand. It's complex. So he
- 1:40:24just like going to his doctor. He says
- 1:40:25he has a gastrointestinal problem or he
- 1:40:28has diverticulitis as opposed to saying
- 1:40:30you had a stomach ache. You ate bad
- 1:40:32food. People don't like to say it in in
- 1:40:34normal everyman terms. The system had a
- 1:40:38stroke and we don't know why.
- 1:40:40>> But you just okay hardworking people and
- 1:40:42and there's a great social benefit.
- 1:40:44Would you not agree
- 1:40:47with having people having ownership in
- 1:40:50the system?
- 1:40:51>> When you say ownership in the system, it
- 1:40:54doesn't mean
- 1:40:54>> Let's start over.
- 1:40:55>> Okay.
- 1:40:56>> Flip over your phone, too, because I
- 1:40:58don't want anyone to see on your phone.
- 1:41:01>> So, maybe flip it down or something.
- 1:41:02>> Yeah. Yeah.
- 1:41:03>> Yeah. Who knows what the comes up
- 1:41:04with that phone?
- 1:41:05>> That's correct.
- 1:41:06>> We don't want to send your
- 1:41:07>> KSA. I can't even get I can't not
- 1:41:09believe I've got the magic moment when
- 1:41:11you're in prison or jail
- 1:41:12wherever the it is in solitary.
- 1:41:14>> Now there's a funny part of that we
- 1:41:15missed which is said go ahead tell
- 1:41:17>> the funny part is what you asked me
- 1:41:19>> is there anything funnier than that
- 1:41:21>> for black humor it's
- 1:41:23>> I don't I don't make any black comments
- 1:41:24sorry uh you asked me what I was
- 1:41:28wearing.
- 1:41:28>> That's right. You're too wrapped up in
- 1:41:29the me too movement.
- 1:41:30>> Yes. So, I was wearing a brown
- 1:41:34jumper and a brown pair of pants given
- 1:41:37to me by the jail with the word trustee
- 1:41:40on the back
- 1:41:41>> because you you had qualified to be a
- 1:41:43trustee.
- 1:41:44>> Well, the funny part was it was spelled
- 1:41:46trust s y. So, I wasn't really sure.
- 1:41:51Uh I'd been a trustee in many different
- 1:41:53operations, but it was the first time it
- 1:41:55was actually printed on my back and
- 1:41:56spelled incorrectly.
- 1:41:59probably had a higher level of of being
- 1:42:01a trustee at at that than you had at all
- 1:42:03the all the boards that you were
- 1:42:05trustees, right?
- 1:42:06>> Yes. Because if the trustee meant you
- 1:42:08get two um devices to clean your toilet
- 1:42:13as opposed to one.
- 1:42:14>> Yeah. But it also meant that you you had
- 1:42:16some sort of personal fiduciary
- 1:42:18own responsibility for oneself, right?
- 1:42:21>> In the jail, you mean?
- 1:42:22>> Well, that's what being a trustee is.
- 1:42:23That's why they give you two.
- 1:42:26>> Yes. you get two cleaners.
- 1:42:30I was a trustee in the jail because I
- 1:42:31was able to teach some of the kids from
- 1:42:34TR to help them get their GED. So that's
- 1:42:37how they gave me a trustee job.
- 1:42:40>> There's no time I got to go back to this
- 1:42:42because it's it's I'm like a dog with a
- 1:42:44bone in this thing.
- 1:42:46>> Yes.
- 1:42:47>> You can't
- 1:42:50There's something deeply up with
- 1:42:51you.
- 1:42:53>> At least something.
- 1:42:54>> Well, we know there are things deeply
- 1:42:55up with this. you will get
- 1:42:56through in this film. But
- 1:42:59you cannot possibly have to sit there
- 1:43:03knowing that you came from nowhere,
- 1:43:05knowing that you went to the very top of
- 1:43:07what is considered outside of science
- 1:43:09and maybe physics the thing people most
- 1:43:12admire because it's like alchemy
- 1:43:14understanding high finance
- 1:43:17to sit there in what will be the
- 1:43:19defining financial crisis
- 1:43:22of our time like like Black Friday and
- 1:43:25or Black Monday whatever it was in the
- 1:43:27Great Depression and be there at that
- 1:43:29exact moment
- 1:43:32triggered in part by a firm that you
- 1:43:34used to be a partner in and knew
- 1:43:36intimately well and it created much of
- 1:43:38your initial net worth because of
- 1:43:41>> and know that you couldn't someone who
- 1:43:43lives on a phone,
- 1:43:44>> right? Yes.
- 1:43:45>> Because you do live on a phone, right?
- 1:43:46>> Correct.
- 1:43:49>> You had to make collect just two collect
- 1:43:52calls. You cannot tell me sometime
- 1:43:54during that day, you did not have that
- 1:43:57conversation with yourself of how the
- 1:43:59did I do this to myself to put
- 1:44:01myself in West Palm Beach in a 6 by9
- 1:44:04cell with a metal bed with a
- 1:44:06brown shirt that said trustee spelled
- 1:44:07wrong.
- 1:44:09>> So, did I find it amazing that I was
- 1:44:11there? That's a
- 1:44:12>> not amazing. I don't want to say it was
- 1:44:13not funny. Oh, I thought it wasn't
- 1:44:15funny.
- 1:44:16>> Right.
- 1:44:16>> Not amazing.
- 1:44:18>> It was incredible.
- 1:44:18>> Inc. Incredible in what way?
- 1:44:20>> Incredible. Like how do I do this to
- 1:44:22myself?
- 1:44:23>> No, it's as incredible as me sitting
- 1:44:25here in this house.
- 1:44:28They are both just two sides of the
- 1:44:29coin.
- 1:44:31That's how I think about it. That my
- 1:44:33life today is incredible.
- 1:44:35>> Do you consider yourself a stoic?
- 1:44:38>> No, I consider myself a hermit.
- 1:44:43Stoic's not very happy. you being a
- 1:44:47hermit then being in that 6 by9 cell
- 1:44:51being in the cell qua the cell was not
- 1:44:53the problem right
- 1:44:54>> correct
- 1:44:56>> what was the problem
- 1:45:00the eating the almond joy bars
- 1:45:02>> because you couldn't eat the food
- 1:45:03>> no right
- 1:45:08and but remember my my life is
- 1:45:11>> did that ever strike you that I gota I
- 1:45:13can't eat the food because somebody
- 1:45:14might have done something to it. I got
- 1:45:16to eat. I got to live off an Almond Joy
- 1:45:17bar. One a day or two a day or whatever.
- 1:45:20How many ever sneak in a day?
- 1:45:22>> No sneaking in.
- 1:45:24>> You're one Almond Joy bar. Did that not
- 1:45:26It did not hit you at some time. How the
- 1:45:29did I do this?
- 1:45:31>> No.
- 1:45:35>> Let's go back to the spring of of 2008.
- 1:45:37Were you so wrapped up in your personal
- 1:45:39issues at the time you were not spending
- 1:45:40enough time on the financial markets or
- 1:45:41were you deeply involved in the
- 1:45:43financial markets like you normally were
- 1:45:44in I would normally I was involved.
- 1:45:47>> And you and you So we're saying that the
- 1:45:49smartest guy in the room didn't see it
- 1:45:52coming.
- 1:45:53>> No, of course not.
- 1:45:54>> The bankruptcy of Bear Sterns you just
- 1:45:56thought was a Bear Sterns problem.
- 1:45:58>> You didn't see it as systemic.
- 1:46:00>> I I know you keep hopping on it, but
- 1:46:02it's it's not
- 1:46:03>> because you're a mathematician
- 1:46:04understands systems. It seems that
- 1:46:05anybody that understands that they had a
- 1:46:07systemic problem, you at least be the
- 1:46:09first on the early search radar. If if
- 1:46:12you're not going to see it, then then
- 1:46:14you're then I'm really afraid because
- 1:46:16that means that that I always assume
- 1:46:18there's at least a set of guys out there
- 1:46:19that have some sort of sense that
- 1:46:21something's not right.
- 1:46:24Imagine
- 1:46:26the guy who has a a stroke or had the
- 1:46:28heart attack when you ask him, "Did did
- 1:46:31you feel funny the day before?"
- 1:46:33He's going to tell you, "Yeah, I didn't
- 1:46:35feel right. Something was off. I didn't
- 1:46:37feel right. I had a my my stomach was
- 1:46:39right. I felt a little dizzy. I felt a
- 1:46:41little weak. But if you asked him the
- 1:46:44day before, do you think you're going to
- 1:46:45have a heart attack tomorrow? He'd say,
- 1:46:47no, I just feel a little weak. I'm a
- 1:46:48little dizzy. My stomach hurts. So the
- 1:46:51these systems and that's the issue of
- 1:46:54complexity. What complexity says is that
- 1:46:57in fact this everything seems to go
- 1:46:59along and people have seen that. One of
- 1:47:01the great examples of complex systems is
- 1:47:05sand dunes.
- 1:47:07In fact, the sand keeps building up.
- 1:47:08People have seen some and all of a
- 1:47:10sudden one more sand drop and the thing
- 1:47:15start all the sand starts running down
- 1:47:17the hills. That's the way I see the
- 1:47:20financial market.
- 1:47:20>> But you funded uh Santa Fe in the early
- 1:47:2390s or late ' 80s?
- 1:47:24>> I believe it was early 90s. I can get
- 1:47:26back
- 1:47:26>> but but early 90s Santa Fe was funded
- 1:47:30for the study of complexity theory.
- 1:47:32>> It was a math. So let's let's back up.
- 1:47:36So why did I buy a ranch in New Mexico
- 1:47:381993? So that's gives you some sense. So
- 1:47:41I would have funded it in 1990.
- 1:47:44Uh Los Alamos, which was the high energy
- 1:47:48lab up in New Mexico, was losing all its
- 1:47:51scientists.
- 1:47:53>> Los Alamos, it was where Oppenheimer
- 1:47:55where the where the a lot of the the
- 1:47:57nuclear weapons program, the bomb,
- 1:47:59>> that's where Manhattan Project
- 1:48:00>> Manhattan Project was as Los Alamos. And
- 1:48:03you bought your property out in New
- 1:48:04Mexico to be near that. Yes, because the
- 1:48:06scientists were going to be they cut the
- 1:48:08funding for high energy physics, but the
- 1:48:12people who worked in Los Alamos would
- 1:48:13still be in the Santa Fe area.
- 1:48:15>> They cut that because the end of the
- 1:48:16this was the cold war dividend, right?
- 1:48:19>> I don't remember exactly why. It was
- 1:48:21because again people thought there was
- 1:48:23that physics and high energy physics
- 1:48:24really wasn't that important
- 1:48:26>> because that was about nuclear weapons.
- 1:48:27>> No, it was because they were trying they
- 1:48:29decided was maybe not right. This was
- 1:48:31the same time that Murray Galman came up
- 1:48:34with the term quark. Q U A R K. He he
- 1:48:38picked it out of a old poem, the word
- 1:48:41quark. But it was something it was
- 1:48:42mysterious. So they were starting to
- 1:48:45understand in the '9s that the in the
- 1:48:47our world of the physical world there
- 1:48:50was things that were just unexplainable.
- 1:48:53They called it strange things. You gave
- 1:48:55it a name. You gave it some
- 1:48:56characteristics. You called it it had
- 1:48:58charm was one of the term. It had a
- 1:49:00charm. It had a flavor. It had a color.
- 1:49:03But nobody really No one, Mr. Bannon,
- 1:49:07understood what it was,
- 1:49:10just like the financial system.
- 1:49:12>> And you wanted to investigate that.
- 1:49:14>> I I wanted to see if we could build
- 1:49:16tools so others smarter than me could
- 1:49:18help investigate it.
- 1:49:19>> And that was the beginning of your
- 1:49:21concept of the Santa Fe Institute.
- 1:49:22>> Yes. in Santa Fe Institute was founded
- 1:49:24to do study in this type of
- 1:49:27>> can you can these areas of strange
- 1:49:31things be described by some form of
- 1:49:34mathematics.
- 1:49:37So that's what I'm trying to get at. The
- 1:49:38the the the the foundational thought,
- 1:49:40the organizing principle
- 1:49:42>> of Santa Fe in the high physics lab at
- 1:49:46um at Los Alamos, which had created the
- 1:49:50been the the headquarters of Manhattan
- 1:49:51and the Trinity Project, right? The
- 1:49:53bomb.
- 1:49:53>> Yes.
- 1:49:53>> So you're talking about the the elite,
- 1:49:55the high priest
- 1:49:56>> of physics.
- 1:49:57>> Of physics.
- 1:49:58>> Yes, sir.
- 1:49:58>> Which high priest of physics, some
- 1:50:00subset of that is also mathematics.
- 1:50:03>> Yes. They're both similar. project out.
- 1:50:06One of the tools you want to do is to
- 1:50:07make sure that in this complex system,
- 1:50:10the finance system, I'm doing a lot of
- 1:50:11this for philanthropy and a lot for the
- 1:50:13good of mankind, but also to be able to
- 1:50:15understand this complex system, the most
- 1:50:17complex outside of maybe our body of of
- 1:50:20the financial world.
- 1:50:22>> Yes.
- 1:50:23>> Did they create tools or were you a were
- 1:50:25you smarter in than the mid as 15 years
- 1:50:31later than you had been then because of
- 1:50:33work that was done at Santa Fe? No, I
- 1:50:35thought was it was great. But in fact
- 1:50:38most of the money most of my
- 1:50:39philanthropy in the area of can you
- 1:50:42describe things that appear to be
- 1:50:44unexplainable
- 1:50:47by mathematics
- 1:50:48and can can you fund people who have new
- 1:50:51ideas and unfortunately when someone
- 1:50:53thinks they've been able to there's a
- 1:50:56man Steuart Calfman when they think that
- 1:50:58okay I figured out how to be able to
- 1:51:01predict the unpredictable what appears
- 1:51:03to other people to be unpredictable but
- 1:51:05my system in those days it was called
- 1:51:07genetic algorithms can predict the what
- 1:51:10things will happen then they all want to
- 1:51:12make money so they use their systems to
- 1:51:14try to figure out they know they have
- 1:51:17figured out the way to make money
- 1:51:19because they figured out the
- 1:51:20unexplainable they try they go bankrupt
- 1:51:23and we start again so in with a cold
- 1:51:26view what I've come to realize is that
- 1:51:29the the attempt to mathematize formulize
- 1:51:33or what in your prior work to understand
- 1:51:36What really is in today's world still
- 1:51:39unexplainable
- 1:51:41is impossible. They're miracles.
- 1:51:46>> The uh your first head of Santa Fe was
- 1:51:49Christopher
- 1:51:51>> Langden. I think
- 1:51:51>> Langden from from Austral
- 1:51:56the the the rock.
- 1:51:57>> Yes. He was the rock. He was a Nobel
- 1:51:59Prize winner.
- 1:52:00>> Yes.
- 1:52:00>> Yes. And and a wonderful guy. He came
- 1:52:02out and helped us with the biospher 2
- 1:52:04project. He came with Chris Landon.
- 1:52:06Yeah. Chris Landon was the operator the
- 1:52:09dayto-day.
- 1:52:09>> Chris was doing artificial life. Murray
- 1:52:12tried to lead his own artificial life.
- 1:52:14>> Yes.
- 1:52:16>> When Chris came to Biosphere 2 for the
- 1:52:18for the first um big conference we had
- 1:52:21in 1994, he was one of the most
- 1:52:23impressive guys there among all the
- 1:52:25world's elite. Q Gardens, the Lawrence
- 1:52:28Liverour lab, the the the labs at
- 1:52:30Sandia, um you know, all the all the
- 1:52:33major universities, Lamont Dy, uh all
- 1:52:36the big earth observatories, Woods Hole.
- 1:52:38What set Langden apart I thought and the
- 1:52:41reason I invited Santa Fe to be part of
- 1:52:42it was Langden actually made a
- 1:52:44presentation that everything and he was
- 1:52:47making this to scientists a lot of
- 1:52:48marine biologists a lot of people that
- 1:52:50just beginning Wally Broker and people
- 1:52:51who were just beginning the study of
- 1:52:53climate change at that time called
- 1:52:54global warming that he made this
- 1:52:57compelling presentation that
- 1:52:59everything's really mathematics
- 1:53:01>> it's all just back to math
- 1:53:03>> and you have to all these experiments
- 1:53:05you do you're not one of the reasons
- 1:53:07they're
- 1:53:08considered by the high priest in physics
- 1:53:10as being real experiments is that they
- 1:53:13don't have a mathematical basis to it
- 1:53:15and everything has a mathematical basis
- 1:53:17to it. Langden seemed like a radical
- 1:53:21visionary.
- 1:53:22What happened to that concept?
- 1:53:26>> You go back 350 years.
- 1:53:30So you have Isaac Newton, you have
- 1:53:32linenets
- 1:53:34from move forward. You have think people
- 1:53:36like Heisenberg and Gdell Gur and what
- 1:53:40every one of those mathematicians
- 1:53:43and philosophers came to understand is
- 1:53:46that there's something with there's
- 1:53:49numbers can describe certain things.
- 1:53:52approximate certain things
- 1:53:55but in fact trying to put measurements
- 1:53:58and numbers on other things that are
- 1:54:00really unexplainable
- 1:54:02is folly.
- 1:54:04It's so 300 years ago they said that
- 1:54:08unexplainable realm was God
- 1:54:11and people who attempted in fact to
- 1:54:14explain the unexplainable who said yes I
- 1:54:17understand the unexplainable
- 1:54:20were charlatans they were the occults
- 1:54:22they were the astrologers
- 1:54:24they were the conmen alchemist
- 1:54:27>> yes well no alchemist was in fact they
- 1:54:30believed that there was a way to
- 1:54:32transmute one metal into another in fact
- 1:54:35they always wanted to see if they can
- 1:54:36create gold. There's no reason if you
- 1:54:38think about it they recognize that one
- 1:54:40metal
- 1:54:42is different than another metal because
- 1:54:44it has some additional pieces to it has
- 1:54:45additional neur neutrons or protons or
- 1:54:48electrons. So because they thought it
- 1:54:52was a machine, they believed it was a
- 1:54:55machine. If I can take five protons and
- 1:54:57add five, that gives me 10. I should be
- 1:54:59able to get gold. The move everything
- 1:55:02around inside these systems, the
- 1:55:03molecules transmute
- 1:55:06one molecule into another. And if this
- 1:55:08molecule I've transmuted it into is
- 1:55:10gold, I'm a rich man. It's back to
- 1:55:12money. But there's something strange
- 1:55:16happens.
- 1:55:18Isaac Newton says, "This is really
- 1:55:21weird. If if I want to push a ball on
- 1:55:24the table, I have to touch it. I could
- 1:55:27maybe I have to blow on it, but I
- 1:55:29actually have to push one side of the
- 1:55:31ball or the book to move that side. I'm
- 1:55:35pushing here." And obviously the this
- 1:55:37thing is what appears to us humans to be
- 1:55:41solid. So it moves as one thing. But the
- 1:55:44only way to get something to move was to
- 1:55:46touch it or put a force against it.
- 1:55:50Okay, seems to make sense. Everybody has
- 1:55:52that experience. I want to lift a glass,
- 1:55:54I lift it. If I want to push a ball, I
- 1:55:56push it. If I want to pull a ball, I
- 1:55:57pull it. But he recognized when the ball
- 1:56:02fell off the table, fell off the table,
- 1:56:06it went in a different direction. How is
- 1:56:08that possible? Nobody pushed the ball
- 1:56:10down. And he says, "This is crazy. Why
- 1:56:14did the ball go down?" I didn't push it.
- 1:56:18I just let it go.
- 1:56:20So someone's pushing the ball because I
- 1:56:23know I am confident that the only thing
- 1:56:26that gets something to move is with a
- 1:56:28force that pushes. So there's a force
- 1:56:29that's pushing the ball down. In fact,
- 1:56:34he never he called it gravity. He
- 1:56:37measured how fast it was pulled. but
- 1:56:43never was able to explain why it
- 1:56:45happened. How is it? What is gravity?
- 1:56:48It's this. Everybody says, "Well, why
- 1:56:50did the ball fall to the ground?"
- 1:56:51Because gravity took it. But what's
- 1:56:52gravity? That's as Fineman would say,
- 1:56:55that's the name of the thing we have no
- 1:56:57idea what it is.
- 1:56:59This goes to Santa Fe. They were trying
- 1:57:01to put explain the unexplainable.
- 1:57:05Can we measure? Can we figure out a way
- 1:57:08to predict the stock markets
- 1:57:10using these types of chaos complexity?
- 1:57:13>> Before we get there, let's walk back
- 1:57:14through. Let's let's go let's let's go
- 1:57:16back to Newton.
- 1:57:17>> Sure.
- 1:57:18>> Pre-N Newton and then Newton. What did
- 1:57:20Newton solve that for millennia up to
- 1:57:24Newton had not been solved. Then I want
- 1:57:26to go forward all the way to Santa Fe.
- 1:57:28What they were trying to solve. Let's
- 1:57:28start with just two or three of the
- 1:57:30basic guys. But let's go with Newton.
- 1:57:32What pre- Newton it was what? And then
- 1:57:34why is Newton such a
- 1:57:37>> a genius
- 1:57:38>> in such a in in the I think
- 1:57:41mathematically they told me one time
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Epstein Röportaj by Ozek Production, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 20,142 words across 3,115 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.