YouTube2Text

Episode 4: The MOU Is Dead! Can a Blockade Save Us? — Transcript

by John Mearsheimer - Offensive Realism · 4,307 words · 720 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00And if the first blockade failed,
  2. 0:03why should we expect the second blockade
  3. 0:06to succeed?
  4. 0:08What's changed here?
  5. 0:10>> The West is leading Ukraine down the
  6. 0:13primrose path.
  7. 0:14>> Israelis are executing a genocide in
  8. 0:18Gaza.
  9. 0:18>> It's not China's fault that it wants to
  10. 0:21be powerful. So, if you get into trouble
  11. 0:25and you dial 911, there's nobody at the
  12. 0:27other end.
  13. 0:29>> Hi, this is John Mearsheimer. Today is
  14. 0:32August 17th, 2026.
  15. 0:35And today is the day that the memorandum
  16. 0:38of understanding that was signed by Iran
  17. 0:41and the United States on June 17th
  18. 0:44expires. Uh the original memorandum of
  19. 0:48understanding called for 60 days of
  20. 0:51negotiation.
  21. 0:53And it was assumed that at the end of
  22. 0:54those 60 days, there would be an
  23. 0:56agreement. Uh and at that point, the uh
  24. 1:00uh the memorandum would expire. Well, 60
  25. 1:03days have gone by and there's obviously
  26. 1:06been no agreement. But the memorandum of
  27. 1:09understanding has definitely expired.
  28. 1:12Uh and there's no effort being made to
  29. 1:15extend it.
  30. 1:17So, the question is where are we today
  31. 1:20in the absence of the memorandum of
  32. 1:22understanding? And it seems quite clear
  33. 1:24that what
  34. 1:26uh has happened is that the United
  35. 1:28States has decided that it's going to
  36. 1:30depend on its [clears throat] naval
  37. 1:32blockade of Iran
  38. 1:34to achieve its goals. So, what I'd like
  39. 1:38to do today is just talk about um
  40. 1:42what a naval blockade today is likely to
  41. 1:46be able to achieve for the United
  42. 1:49States, given that we don't have any
  43. 1:51prospect of uh a new memorandum of
  44. 1:55understanding.
  45. 1:57Uh what can blockade do for the United
  46. 1:59States? Is it a viable alternative uh
  47. 2:02for getting our way? Now, the best way
  48. 2:05to start is just talk about what our
  49. 2:08goals are uh and then talk about what
  50. 2:11Iran's goals are. And you want to
  51. 2:13remember that when we talk about Iran's
  52. 2:15goals, we want to talk about the United
  53. 2:17States thwarting Iran's goals. So, the
  54. 2:20United States, in very important way,
  55. 2:22has two sets of goals here. One is to
  56. 2:24achieve what to achieve its own goals,
  57. 2:27and number two, to thwart Iran from
  58. 2:30achieving its goals. So, let me start by
  59. 2:33talking about what America's goals are,
  60. 2:36and then look at um Iran's goals, and
  61. 2:39then we can talk about how well suited
  62. 2:41blockade is at this point in time
  63. 2:44uh
  64. 2:45for us, the United States, achieving its
  65. 2:47goals.
  66. 2:49Uh when the war started back on February
  67. 2:5228th of this year, the United States had
  68. 2:54four goals.
  69. 2:56Uh
  70. 2:57number one was uh regime change. Number
  71. 3:00two was to put an end to Iran's nuclear
  72. 3:04enrichment capability.
  73. 3:06Number three was to put an end to Iran's
  74. 3:09long-range missile capability.
  75. 3:12And number four was to end Iranian
  76. 3:15support for the Houthis, Hezbollah, and
  77. 3:18Hamas. Those were the big four goals.
  78. 3:21The United States, uh of course, has
  79. 3:23achieved none of those goals. None of
  80. 3:27them have been achieved, and there is no
  81. 3:29chance that any of the four are going to
  82. 3:32be achieved. So, the question we then
  83. 3:34have to ask ourselves is what are
  84. 3:37America's goals at this point in time?
  85. 3:40And Vice President Vance said last week
  86. 3:43very clearly that we have two goals. He
  87. 3:46said that the first and most important
  88. 3:49goal
  89. 3:50is
  90. 3:51to open the strait.
  91. 3:53He said the second goal is to get a
  92. 3:57nuclear deal. This is actually quite
  93. 3:59remarkable because when we went into the
  94. 4:02war, what mattered more than anything
  95. 4:04else was the nuclear issue.
  96. 4:07And of course the strait was opened on
  97. 4:10February 27th, so the whole idea of
  98. 4:13opening the strait was not even on the
  99. 4:15table
  100. 4:17right before the war started.
  101. 4:19It was the nuclear issue that really
  102. 4:21mattered. So here's Vice President Vance
  103. 4:24saying that our principal goal is to
  104. 4:28open the strait and our secondary goal
  105. 4:31is to get a nuclear deal. By the way,
  106. 4:35President Trump's spokesperson
  107. 4:37has said that as far as President Trump
  108. 4:40is concerned, those two goals are
  109. 4:43co-equal. So he has a slightly different
  110. 4:45view of things than Vice President Vance
  111. 4:48does. But nevertheless, you can see how
  112. 4:50important it is for us
  113. 4:52to open the strait as soon as possible
  114. 4:55and that is obviously for economic
  115. 4:57reasons.
  116. 4:58Now, what we want to do is switch gears
  117. 5:01and we want to talk about what Iran's
  118. 5:03goals are. And you want to keep in mind
  119. 5:05that what the United States wants to do
  120. 5:08is make sure that Iran does not achieve
  121. 5:11any of its goals if that's possible or
  122. 5:14all of its goals
  123. 5:16are denied.
  124. 5:18Now, let me put it differently. That we
  125. 5:19want to make sure that Iran doesn't
  126. 5:21achieve all its all of its goals and
  127. 5:25in the best case to minimize the number
  128. 5:27of goals that Iran achieves. Okay.
  129. 5:32The Iranians do want to open the strait.
  130. 5:34There's no question about that. Like us,
  131. 5:36they want to open the strait. Like us,
  132. 5:37they understand it's in their economic
  133. 5:39interest to open the strait.
  134. 5:41But the Iranians say that they won't
  135. 5:43open the strait unless the United States
  136. 5:47meets a number of other demands, not
  137. 5:51through negotiation, but right away. In
  138. 5:54other words, the Iranians say, "We'll
  139. 5:56open the strait if you agree to lift all
  140. 6:00sanctions on Iran.
  141. 6:02>> [snorts]
  142. 6:02>> If you agree to freeze all of unfreeze
  143. 6:07all of our frozen assets.
  144. 6:10If [snorts] you agree to pay
  145. 6:12reparations.
  146. 6:14If you agree that we control the strait.
  147. 6:18If you agree that we can collect fees.
  148. 6:21If you agree to remove American military
  149. 6:24forces from the Gulf region." These are
  150. 6:27the demands
  151. 6:29that the Iranians have. And the Iranians
  152. 6:32are saying
  153. 6:33the United States has to meet all those
  154. 6:34demands before they will open the
  155. 6:36strait.
  156. 6:38Now, obviously, the United States is not
  157. 6:41interested in accepting all of those
  158. 6:44demands.
  159. 6:46But the Iranians have made it clear that
  160. 6:48the United States has no choice. What we
  161. 6:51want to do is minimize the number of
  162. 6:53demands that we are forced to accept.
  163. 6:57The Iranians say, "There will be no
  164. 6:59minimization. You have to accept all of
  165. 7:02those demands before we will agree to
  166. 7:06open the strait." And again, you want to
  167. 7:07remember that America's principal goal
  168. 7:10is to open the strait.
  169. 7:12So,
  170. 7:14the question is, how can we achieve our
  171. 7:17goals?
  172. 7:19And uh
  173. 7:22blockade is the strategy of the day. But
  174. 7:26I want to say a few words about what our
  175. 7:28strategy has been in the
  176. 7:31entire war so that we can put where we
  177. 7:34are today with blockade into a broader
  178. 7:36context.
  179. 7:38As you remember, the war started on
  180. 7:42February 28th.
  181. 7:43And we started with a major strategic
  182. 7:46bombing campaign, an air campaign that
  183. 7:49lasted for 40 days. Went from February
  184. 7:5128th to April 8th.
  185. 7:54Then there was a ceasefire on April 8th.
  186. 7:57There were some negotiations that went
  187. 7:59nowhere. And then on April 13th, the
  188. 8:02United States moved to a naval blockade.
  189. 8:06So you see, this is the first time we
  190. 8:08tried blockade. And the blockade that is
  191. 8:11now in place is the second instance of a
  192. 8:13blockade.
  193. 8:15So, we went from an air war in the first
  194. 8:1740 days of the war up until April 8th.
  195. 8:20Then on April 13th, we moved to the
  196. 8:22first blockade. And that first blockade
  197. 8:25lasted from April 13th
  198. 8:28up [snorts] until June 17th, when the
  199. 8:30memorandum of understanding was signed.
  200. 8:33So that's a way of saying that the first
  201. 8:36blockade lasted about
  202. 8:40two plus months.
  203. 8:42And it did not work.
  204. 8:44We ended up signing a memorandum of
  205. 8:46understanding on June 17th, and that
  206. 8:48MOU, of course, is what put an end to
  207. 8:51the blockade, the first blockade. But
  208. 8:53that memorandum of understanding was
  209. 8:56extremely favorable to the Iranians. It
  210. 9:00was a memorandum of understanding that
  211. 9:02the United States did not like because
  212. 9:04the United States understood it was a
  213. 9:06surrender document. But nevertheless,
  214. 9:08the United States signed it. And the
  215. 9:10United States signed it because the
  216. 9:11blockade did not work. And before that,
  217. 9:14the air war did not work.
  218. 9:16Okay.
  219. 9:17Then what happens in early July is
  220. 9:22that the United States and Iran get
  221. 9:26involved in a tit-for-tat strategy.
  222. 9:30This starts on July 7th, and it lasts
  223. 9:32until about July 31st. And it basically
  224. 9:36involves the United States and Iran
  225. 9:39engaging in a limited air war where they
  226. 9:42bomb specific targets uh
  227. 9:46on each side. In other words, the United
  228. 9:49States bombs targets in Iran and the
  229. 9:51Iranians bomb targets in Kuwait,
  230. 9:55Saudi Arabia, and so forth and so on.
  231. 9:57And this lasts again from July 7th to
  232. 10:00July 31st.
  233. 10:02>> [snorts]
  234. 10:02>> Then the tit-for-tat campaign comes to
  235. 10:07an end.
  236. 10:09And what happens is the United States
  237. 10:13moves to the second blockade. The second
  238. 10:17blockade actually starts on July 14th,
  239. 10:21which is in the middle of the
  240. 10:23tit-for-tat campaign. So, there's a
  241. 10:25period there where you have the
  242. 10:26tit-for-tat campaign taking place and
  243. 10:29you have the second blockade. But as I
  244. 10:31said before, on July 31st, the
  245. 10:34tit-for-tat campaign comes to an end.
  246. 10:37The United States has basically had
  247. 10:40enough. So, all that's left is the
  248. 10:42blockade, the second blockade, and
  249. 10:45that's where we are today.
  250. 10:49Now,
  251. 10:50the question we have to ask ourselves is
  252. 10:53given that the memorandum of
  253. 10:54understanding has expired and there's no
  254. 10:57prospect of a new memorandum of
  255. 10:59understanding, and given that we've
  256. 11:01given up on tit-for-tat, given up on a
  257. 11:05major bombing campaign, given that
  258. 11:07there's not going to be a land option,
  259. 11:09the question is
  260. 11:11what will blockade do for the United
  261. 11:14States in terms of achieving its
  262. 11:16objectives?
  263. 11:18Now, we know that the first blockade
  264. 11:20didn't work. So, the question is what
  265. 11:22about the second blockade? Now, it's
  266. 11:24important to start by saying that at the
  267. 11:26end of last week, the Secretary of the
  268. 11:28Treasury, Scott Bessent, said that this
  269. 11:31week, starting today, we are going to
  270. 11:34inflict unprecedented
  271. 11:37economic hurt
  272. 11:39on uh
  273. 11:41the Iranian economy. So, in effect, what
  274. 11:44he was saying is that in addition to the
  275. 11:46blockade, and this naval blockade is
  276. 11:49designed to inflict economic hurt on
  277. 11:53the Iranian economy, we're going to do
  278. 11:55something special this week, and we're
  279. 11:58going to deliver unprecedented economic
  280. 12:01hurt.
  281. 12:02Now,
  282. 12:04let's evaluate how well this is all
  283. 12:06likely to work.
  284. 12:08First of all, it's hard to believe that
  285. 12:12there's more economic hurt that we can
  286. 12:15inflict on Iran. We've really maxed out
  287. 12:20at this point.
  288. 12:22What is the United States going to do to
  289. 12:24damage further the Iranian economy that
  290. 12:28it hasn't already done?
  291. 12:30Uh Bessen hasn't told us. He's made this
  292. 12:33vague claim, but he hasn't told us how
  293. 12:36this process works.
  294. 12:38I would argue that there's virtually
  295. 12:40nothing the United States can do
  296. 12:43to create unprecedented
  297. 12:46economic hurt.
  298. 12:49So, this brings us back to the question
  299. 12:51of the blockade.
  300. 12:53What is the likelihood that this
  301. 12:55blockade is going to produce a favorable
  302. 12:58outcome for the United States? In other
  303. 12:59words, what is the likelihood that this
  304. 13:01blockade is going to allow us to achieve
  305. 13:04our own goals and limit
  306. 13:07the number of goals that Iran has that
  307. 13:10it can achieve.
  308. 13:12The first point you want to keep in mind
  309. 13:14is that the first blockade failed.
  310. 13:17Uh
  311. 13:18and if the first blockade failed,
  312. 13:21why should we expect the second blockade
  313. 13:24to succeed?
  314. 13:26What's changed here? And by the way, you
  315. 13:28want to remember that the first
  316. 13:30blockade, as I said, lasted
  317. 13:32a little over 2 months. Went from April
  318. 13:3513th to June 17th. So, a little over 2
  319. 13:38months, and it didn't work. Again, we
  320. 13:40signed the memorandum of understanding,
  321. 13:42which is basically a surrender document.
  322. 13:45Well, the present blockade has gone on
  323. 13:48since July 14th. It's a little over 1
  324. 13:51month. So, we haven't even reached the
  325. 13:532-month period here. And you want to
  326. 13:55keep in mind, as I talk here, that
  327. 13:58blockades only work over a long period
  328. 14:02of time. Almost everybody agrees that
  329. 14:05blockades do not produce instant
  330. 14:07results. So, for this blockade to work,
  331. 14:10it's going to have to be in place for a
  332. 14:12long period of time.
  333. 14:14Uh
  334. 14:15we're not going to get instant results.
  335. 14:18Now, there are very good reasons to
  336. 14:21think that we, the United States, are in
  337. 14:25a worse position today in terms of
  338. 14:28implementing this blockade than we were
  339. 14:30when we started the first blockade on
  340. 14:34April 13th. Now, why is that the case?
  341. 14:37One reason is the state of the US Navy.
  342. 14:40It's quite clear that the US Navy is
  343. 14:43suffering in significant ways from the
  344. 14:46wear and tear of being deployed to the
  345. 14:50Gulf for a long period of time.
  346. 14:54And we see this with the case of the USS
  347. 14:56Abraham Lincoln. This is the large
  348. 14:58aircraft carrier, where there has been
  349. 15:01huge dissatisfaction
  350. 15:03among the crew members, uh because of
  351. 15:08the demands of this naval campaign
  352. 15:11against Iran, the United States has been
  353. 15:14forced to deploy ships like
  354. 15:19this carrier, the Lincoln, and
  355. 15:21destroyers and ships as well for
  356. 15:24extended periods of time in the area or
  357. 15:28in the waters around Iran. And those
  358. 15:33troops on these ships have not been
  359. 15:36getting proper food,
  360. 15:39uh and they have not uh
  361. 15:43been in very good living conditions, and
  362. 15:48all sorts of trouble has broken out on
  363. 15:51the Lincoln. There's evidence that some
  364. 15:54of the sailors were thinking about
  365. 15:56jumping off the side of the uh carrier.
  366. 16:02Uh there's evidence that fights had been
  367. 16:04breaking out and so forth and so on. So,
  368. 16:07actually what's happened is that the uh
  369. 16:11the Lincoln has been taken off station
  370. 16:13and it's being replaced by another
  371. 16:15carrier, by the USS George Washington.
  372. 16:18>> [snorts]
  373. 16:18>> Now, it's very important to emphasize
  374. 16:20that it's not only the Lincoln that is
  375. 16:23suffering from these problems.
  376. 16:24Destroyers and other ships that have
  377. 16:26been deployed for extended periods of
  378. 16:28time are also having all sorts of
  379. 16:31logistical problems.
  380. 16:34Uh so, my point here is that for
  381. 16:39purposes of implementing a protracted
  382. 16:43blockade, and blockades by definition
  383. 16:45are protracted, the US Navy is in
  384. 16:48terrible shape to accomplish that
  385. 16:51mission.
  386. 16:53There's just been so much wear and tear
  387. 16:55on the US Navy that it's not clear that
  388. 16:59it can keep in place a successful
  389. 17:02blockade for many more months. There's
  390. 17:05an additional additional
  391. 17:08issue at play here.
  392. 17:10And that is that uh
  393. 17:13the Navy at this point in time is small
  394. 17:16enough
  395. 17:17that it is
  396. 17:19only capable of focusing on one theater
  397. 17:23of operations at a time in a major way.
  398. 17:28And [snorts] what this means is that
  399. 17:30because we are focusing
  400. 17:32uh laser-like
  401. 17:35on the Middle East or on the Persian
  402. 17:36Gulf or on Iran,
  403. 17:38uh
  404. 17:40what we are doing is weakening ourselves
  405. 17:44in East Asia.
  406. 17:45And you want to remember that in East
  407. 17:47Asia, where the United States is
  408. 17:49interested in containing China, naval
  409. 17:53forces matter greatly. Naval and air
  410. 17:55forces matter much more than land forces
  411. 17:58in East Asia when you talk about
  412. 18:00containing China. But what's happening
  413. 18:03here is that the United States is being
  414. 18:05forced to pull forces out of East Asia
  415. 18:08and send them to the Persian Gulf. And
  416. 18:11this is true with regard to naval
  417. 18:13forces. As I said before, given the
  418. 18:16consequences of the logistical problems
  419. 18:18that the Abraham Lincoln faces, it's
  420. 18:21being taken off station. And it's being
  421. 18:24replaced, as I said, by the USS George
  422. 18:26Washington. The question you want to ask
  423. 18:28yourself is where is the George
  424. 18:30Washington coming from? And the fact is
  425. 18:33it's coming from East Asia. It's
  426. 18:35normally stationed in Japan. This means
  427. 18:39there's going to be no aircraft carrier
  428. 18:42in East Asia.
  429. 18:44This is not good from a strategic point
  430. 18:48of view when you think about containing
  431. 18:51China.
  432. 18:52So, not only is the wear and tear on the
  433. 18:56US Navy limiting its overall
  434. 19:00capabilities,
  435. 19:02the focus on Iran
  436. 19:05keeping a blockade on Iran is also
  437. 19:07weakening America's position in East
  438. 19:10Asia vis-a-vis its most important
  439. 19:13threat, which is China.
  440. 19:17There are additional problems with the
  441. 19:19blockade.
  442. 19:21One is that as long as we keep the
  443. 19:23blockade on, and the Iranians keep the
  444. 19:26blockade on, what we are doing is
  445. 19:29greatly limiting the amount of oil that
  446. 19:33comes out of the Persian Gulf
  447. 19:36because both sides are in effect
  448. 19:38blockading the Strait of Hormuz.
  449. 19:41This means that there's less oil
  450. 19:44to
  451. 19:45appear on
  452. 19:48global or in global markets.
  453. 19:50Furthermore, because there has been a
  454. 19:52huge conflict
  455. 19:54between the Houthis and the Saudis, and
  456. 19:57the Houthis have basically shut off
  457. 20:02the Bab-el-Mandeb Strait, which is where
  458. 20:04Saudi oil comes out of the Red Sea.
  459. 20:08Saudi oil is now not only coming out
  460. 20:13of
  461. 20:14the Persian Gulf through the Strait of
  462. 20:15Hormuz, it's not coming out of the Red
  463. 20:19Sea through Bab-el-Mandeb. And it is
  464. 20:22imperative to have lots of Saudi oil on
  465. 20:27or in global markets.
  466. 20:29But that's no longer the case. This is
  467. 20:31not to deny, of course, that some ships
  468. 20:33do get through
  469. 20:35either the Strait of Hormuz or the
  470. 20:38Bab-el-Mandeb Strait. Some Saudi ships
  471. 20:40do, but not many. So, the amount of
  472. 20:42Saudi oil that was coming out of the
  473. 20:46Gulf on February 27th has been greatly
  474. 20:49reduced.
  475. 20:51And this is a huge problem for the
  476. 20:54international economy.
  477. 20:56Uh
  478. 20:57So, there are all sorts of economic
  479. 21:00incentives
  480. 21:02uh to open the strait. Uh I might also
  481. 21:06note that if you look at the strategic
  482. 21:08petroleum reserve in the United States
  483. 21:11and the strategic petroleum reserve in
  484. 21:13other countries, it's quite clear that
  485. 21:16we have significantly drawn down those
  486. 21:19reserves uh, to uh,
  487. 21:23make up for the fact that so much oil is
  488. 21:25now not coming out of the Gulf. Uh, and
  489. 21:30the question is how long can we depend
  490. 21:33on taking oil out of those strategic
  491. 21:36petroleum reserves in places like the
  492. 21:38United States uh, to deal with this
  493. 21:41problem of um,
  494. 21:44of uh,
  495. 21:45uh, of missing oil coming out of the
  496. 21:49Persian Gulf.
  497. 21:50Now, another
  498. 21:53very important dimension to this is that
  499. 21:57uh, if you look at what's happened
  500. 21:59inside of Iran,
  501. 22:01uh, the hardliners are now in control.
  502. 22:05Uh, and uh, the hardliners are not
  503. 22:08interested in reaching any kind of
  504. 22:11accommodation with the United States.
  505. 22:13They are interested in driving a hard
  506. 22:15bargain. They interest They are
  507. 22:17interested in telling the United States
  508. 22:19that it has to meet
  509. 22:21all of Iran's demands, which I described
  510. 22:25before, before Iran will agree to open
  511. 22:30the Strait of Hormuz. And in addition to
  512. 22:34that, these hardliners who are in charge
  513. 22:39inside of Iran
  514. 22:40are making it perfectly clear that they
  515. 22:45want to initiate military
  516. 22:49action against the United States and its
  517. 22:52allies in the Persian Gulf. They believe
  518. 22:56that the best defense is a good offense.
  519. 22:59So, if you look at the hardliners who
  520. 23:01are now in control in Iran,
  521. 23:05they are
  522. 23:07bent on causing the United States more
  523. 23:10trouble than ever. They are interested
  524. 23:13in taking the initiative.
  525. 23:15They are interested in being proactive.
  526. 23:18So, the United States now faces a more
  527. 23:21dangerous adversary in Iran.
  528. 23:24In addition to the fact that the
  529. 23:26economic situation is deteriorating for
  530. 23:30the reasons I just described, and in
  531. 23:32addition to the fact that the US Navy is
  532. 23:36in
  533. 23:37bad shape
  534. 23:39for purposes of implementing a
  535. 23:42protracted
  536. 23:44naval blockade of Iran. So, the
  537. 23:47situation does not look good at all.
  538. 23:51Now, one might say,
  539. 23:53"Okay, you've convinced me that the
  540. 23:55blockade is not likely to work, but
  541. 23:58maybe what the United States can do here
  542. 24:00is a tit-for-tat
  543. 24:03strategy, or maybe the United States can
  544. 24:05go back
  545. 24:07to a major bombing campaign like we saw
  546. 24:09in the first 40 days. In other words, we
  547. 24:13do have an escalation option."
  548. 24:15But, this is not true. We don't have an
  549. 24:18escalation option. Uh
  550. 24:21In fact, we don't even want to go back
  551. 24:23to a tit-for-tat strategy, and there are
  552. 24:25basically three reasons for that.
  553. 24:28One is we have a significant shortage of
  554. 24:31munitions, and the last thing we want to
  555. 24:34do is get involved in a tit-for-tat
  556. 24:37campaign where we have to use up even
  557. 24:39more of those precious munitions.
  558. 24:42Furthermore, our Gulf allies have zero
  559. 24:46interest in seeing the war start back up
  560. 24:48again because they understand full well
  561. 24:51that they will be targeted. Uh the
  562. 24:53Iranians have made that clear, and of
  563. 24:55course in the past the Iranians have
  564. 24:57targeted our Gulf allies.
  565. 25:00So, our Gulf allies are saying, "No more
  566. 25:02escalation." And then finally, there's
  567. 25:04the economic consequences. At this point
  568. 25:07in time, President Trump cannot afford
  569. 25:10to restart the 40-day bombing campaign
  570. 25:14or even engage in a tit-for-tat
  571. 25:16campaign. He's got to open the strait.
  572. 25:18That's why Vice President Vance said our
  573. 25:20principal goal is to open the strait. Uh
  574. 25:24we have to open that strait for economic
  575. 25:26reasons. So, tit-for-tat is not even a
  576. 25:30viable option for the United States,
  577. 25:32much less starting the 40-day campaign.
  578. 25:35And to drive that point home, let me
  579. 25:38tell you a story that shows you uh how
  580. 25:41little interest we have even in
  581. 25:43escalating to a tit-for-tat campaign.
  582. 25:47As I said before, the tit-for-tat
  583. 25:49campaign started on July 7th, and it
  584. 25:51lasted until July 31st. Remember, we had
  585. 25:54first the strategic bombing campaign,
  586. 25:57then we had the first naval blockade,
  587. 25:59then we had the tit-for-tat campaign. It
  588. 26:01started on July 7th. Now, why did it
  589. 26:05start? How did the How did the
  590. 26:07tit-for-tat campaign begin?
  591. 26:10On July 6th,
  592. 26:13the Iranians attacked
  593. 26:16three
  594. 26:18cargo vessels
  595. 26:20that were trying to come out of the
  596. 26:22Strait of Hormuz
  597. 26:24through the Omani Channel. That was the
  598. 26:27channel that's close to Oman that the
  599. 26:30United States in effect helped control.
  600. 26:34The Iranians made it clear to us that
  601. 26:36that was unacceptable. No ships coming
  602. 26:39out of the Gulf could go through the
  603. 26:42Omani Channel, said the Iranians. Well,
  604. 26:46on July 6th, there were three ships
  605. 26:48coming through the Omani Channel in the
  606. 26:51Strait of Hormuz.
  607. 26:53And the Iranians opened fire on all
  608. 26:56three of those ships. This is July 6th.
  609. 27:00The next day, the United States started
  610. 27:03the tit-for-tat campaign by attacking
  611. 27:06targets inside of Iran. The Iranians, of
  612. 27:10course, retaliated. We retaliated, and
  613. 27:13so forth and so on. And this tit-for-tat
  614. 27:15campaign lasted from the 7th of July to
  615. 27:18the 31st of July. The key point that I
  616. 27:20want to make here is what started it was
  617. 27:23that the Iranians attacked cargo ships
  618. 27:26going through the Strait of Hormuz. And
  619. 27:29the United States said that is
  620. 27:30categorically unacceptable, and
  621. 27:32therefore we went to the tit-for-tat
  622. 27:34campaign.
  623. 27:35Well, if you look at what's happening
  624. 27:38today,
  625. 27:39the Iranians are attacking
  626. 27:43cargo ships in the Strait of Hormuz on
  627. 27:48an almost daily basis. They make no
  628. 27:51bones about it.
  629. 27:53And the question you want to ask
  630. 27:54yourself is, what is the United States
  631. 27:56doing? Is the United States retaliating?
  632. 28:00Is the United States shown any interest
  633. 28:02in going back to a tit-for-tat strategy?
  634. 28:04The answer is no.
  635. 28:06And the reason is that the United States
  636. 28:09has zero interest in escalating to a
  637. 28:13tit-for-tat strategy.
  638. 28:15So, what we have here is a very
  639. 28:17interesting situation if you think about
  640. 28:19it.
  641. 28:21If escalation does take place
  642. 28:24in the Gulf,
  643. 28:26it's not the United States that is
  644. 28:29likely to initiate
  645. 28:32that escalation. It is the Iranians who
  646. 28:36are likely to initiate
  647. 28:38that escalation because
  648. 28:42the leadership in Iran, very clearly
  649. 28:45now, is interested in playing hardball
  650. 28:48with the United States from a military
  651. 28:51perspective. As I said before, from an
  652. 28:53Iranian point of view, they believe that
  653. 28:56the best defense is a good offense. So,
  654. 28:59they are willing to escalate because
  655. 29:02they believe that the United States will
  656. 29:05not retaliate. Now, it is possible the
  657. 29:07United States will retaliate at some
  658. 29:10point, but that will not solve our
  659. 29:12problem.
  660. 29:14So, you see what's happened here
  661. 29:16is that over time
  662. 29:19the United States has failed to achieve
  663. 29:23any of its objectives, whether we're
  664. 29:25talking about the four big objectives
  665. 29:27that it started the war with or opening
  666. 29:30the straight
  667. 29:32or getting a nuclear deal, which are its
  668. 29:34two objectives today.
  669. 29:37And at the same time
  670. 29:39it's in a situation where it looks like
  671. 29:41it has little choice
  672. 29:44but to cave in to Iran's major demands
  673. 29:50because the United States has no
  674. 29:52strategy. It has no military option
  675. 29:57for achieving its goals and preventing
  676. 30:00Iran from gaining its goals. It's been
  677. 30:05forced into a situation where it has to
  678. 30:08rely on blockade. And as I said before,
  679. 30:11blockade didn't work the first time and
  680. 30:14there's no reason to think it's going to
  681. 30:16work this time.
  682. 30:18Because the situation for the United
  683. 30:20States in terms of implementing a
  684. 30:22blockade now is worse than it was
  685. 30:25between April 13th uh and June 17th.
  686. 30:30And if you think about it, what's
  687. 30:31happened here
  688. 30:33is that the Iranians have really turned
  689. 30:37the table
  690. 30:39tables
  691. 30:40in the sense that the Iranians
  692. 30:44are now
  693. 30:46the party in this conflict that is most
  694. 30:50likely to cause escalation.
  695. 30:53In the beginning, that obviously looked
  696. 30:56like the United States. It looked in the
  697. 30:58very beginning like the United States
  698. 31:00held all the cards.
  699. 31:03But as this conflict has worn on and as
  700. 31:07we've come to understand here on August
  701. 31:1017th,
  702. 31:12we have no military option.
  703. 31:15Escalation would be disastrous for us.
  704. 31:18And if anything,
  705. 31:20it's the Iranians who believe they have
  706. 31:23a military option and they believe they
  707. 31:27can escalate.
  708. 31:29All of this is to say that it's hard to
  709. 31:32see how the United States can
  710. 31:37achieve even a limited victory in this
  711. 31:40conflict with Iran. It looks to me here
  712. 31:45on August 17th like the United States
  713. 31:48has little choice but to surrender to
  714. 31:54virtually all of Iran's demands if it
  715. 31:57hopes to open the strait and avoid an
  716. 32:00economic catastrophe.
  717. 32:03That concludes my
  718. 32:06video for today.
  719. 32:07Thank you all for listening. And I look
  720. 32:11forward to the next time that we talk.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of Episode 4: The MOU Is Dead! Can a Blockade Save Us? by John Mearsheimer - Offensive Realism, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 4,307 words across 720 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.