Ep. 4 - The Hidden Patterns of Great Startup Ideas (NFX Masterclass) — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00The biggest waste in the startup
- 0:02ecosystem is great founders working on
- 0:04bad ideas. So here we go through the
- 0:06hidden pattern of great startup ideas so
- 0:08that you can set yourself up to be going
- 0:10in the right direction. Because if
- 0:12you're going fast, it doesn't matter if
- 0:13you're going in the wrong direction.
- 0:19One of the things I've learned is that
- 0:20most things don't work in the startup
- 0:23world. And so I'm here to save you. I'm
- 0:26here to save you years of time if I can.
- 0:29We run a uh program here at Stanford GSB
- 0:34called FAST. And last year we had 75
- 0:37teams from the Stanford community apply
- 0:40for $100,000 check, $250,000 check,
- 0:43uncapped convertible note, founder
- 0:45friendly, all that stuff. It was great.
- 0:48We gave out some money, got some great
- 0:50companies. Your classmates are super
- 0:53dynamic. You're just as talented as they
- 0:55are. However, out of the 75 companies,
- 0:5968 of the ideas were bad.
- 1:02They were We just knew they were bad.
- 1:05But you guys didn't know they were bad.
- 1:07And that's because I'm old and you're
- 1:09young. So, I've seen the patterns. I've
- 1:11seen what works. It's pretty clear. So,
- 1:14what you guys have is naive and talent
- 1:17and drive and smarts. You have
- 1:19everything you need, but most of you are
- 1:22starting off in the wrong direction. And
- 1:24so after we did this, what we what I
- 1:26said to Anna and to the NFX fellows,
- 1:29you've got six of them on campus here,
- 1:31is that we've got to get in earlier
- 1:34before they send in their applications
- 1:36in April. All right? Because they're
- 1:39just spending months working on bad
- 1:41ideas and it's the biggest waste in the
- 1:44startup in the VC ecosystem worldwide.
- 1:46Talented people like you working on bad
- 1:49ideas. It's a tragedy. All right. So,
- 1:52tonight is the beginning of our attempt
- 1:55to help keep this from happening more.
- 1:57All right, fair enough. That's what
- 1:58we're trying to do tonight. I want to
- 2:00share with you everything I know about
- 2:01where the good ideas come from so that
- 2:04you can navigate to hopefully a better
- 2:05idea. All right.
- 2:08How many people here are GSB?
- 2:12And how many people undergrad?
- 2:15>> And how many people other?
- 2:18Great. Good.
- 2:21Okay, so
- 2:24this is the way I look at the startup
- 2:25ideas landscape.
- 2:28On the far right, you've got the fertile
- 2:29soil. If you come to me with a team of
- 2:31two or three people and a good
- 2:33PowerPoint, a good idea, I'll be able to
- 2:36tell you you're in fertile soil. If you
- 2:37go hard at that for the next two years,
- 2:39you're going to end up selling your
- 2:40company for $10 million or more. Fertile
- 2:42soil.
- 2:44To the left of that is I'm not sure. And
- 2:46to the far left is the mediocre. And
- 2:48that's about 65% of the time I can tell
- 2:50you that that's just going to waste your
- 2:52life's energies, right? And in the
- 2:55middle, I'm like, I'm not sure. Airbnb,
- 2:57will someone sleep on an air bed in your
- 3:00extra room? I don't know. Turns out they
- 3:03won't, but I didn't know. It turned out
- 3:04to be a great company. Okay. So, my job
- 3:08is to move you from the left to the
- 3:10right if I can. And your job is then to
- 3:13go execute.
- 3:15Okay.
- 3:17So where do the next ideas come from?
- 3:18Right? So what are the frameworks? What
- 3:20are the patterns that we've seen that
- 3:23actually make good startup ideas? So I'm
- 3:25going to run through a bunch of patterns
- 3:27with you.
- 3:29I didn't number them or anything, but
- 3:30there's a whole bunch of them and you
- 3:32can take them and pull them in on the
- 3:33ideas you're thinking of or the
- 3:35industries you are interested in, that
- 3:36sort of thing. And at the end, I'm going
- 3:37to start saying a lot of controversial
- 3:39things. A lot of things counter to what
- 3:41you've been taught. A lot of things
- 3:43counter to what the conventional wisdom
- 3:46is about how you do this stuff. And some
- 3:49of it you won't like to hear. All right.
- 3:52Okay. So, the first pattern we've
- 3:53noticed is that great big companies Oh,
- 3:57let me let me back up. We're not here
- 4:00talking about making a little company.
- 4:01We're not talking about doing a
- 4:02McDonald's or a bakery. We're talking
- 4:05about doing big companies. We're doing
- 4:06world changing companies. That's what
- 4:07I'm here for. And hopefully that's what
- 4:09you're here for, too. If you're not,
- 4:10that's fine. You'll still get a lot out
- 4:11of the discussion.
- 4:14But what we're talking about here is how
- 4:15to make the big companies, the impactful
- 4:17companies, companies that move the
- 4:18world. All right?
- 4:20The companies that move the world have
- 4:22network effects generally. We've done a
- 4:24study and about 70 72% of all the value
- 4:27created in technology in the last 30
- 4:29years has come from companies with
- 4:31network effects at their core. You can
- 4:33build an enterprise SAS company and sell
- 4:34it for a billion dollars. It's really
- 4:37hard to build one and sell one for 10
- 4:39billion. Okay,
- 4:42still good businesses, but but most of
- 4:45the returns in tech, most of the impact
- 4:48is coming from businesses with network
- 4:50effects. We've discovered that there's
- 4:51at least 16 network effects. We've
- 4:53mapped them out. You can go to nfx.com
- 4:55and you can learn all about them. I'm
- 4:57not going to go into that in detail
- 4:58tonight, right? But there's a lot of
- 5:00stuff that we published. We haven't
- 5:02published a master class, three hours.
- 5:03You can listen to it to your heart's
- 5:05content. We lay out everything we've
- 5:06learned over the last 25 years studying
- 5:08network effects in more detail than
- 5:10anyone else in the world. All right, so
- 5:12network effects, that's why we call the
- 5:14firm NFX for network effects because
- 5:16it's so core to what makes great
- 5:18companies. So think about how you build
- 5:20your network effects into your company
- 5:22before you start it.
- 5:26Another thing we tell people is follow
- 5:29the three S's. Find something that's
- 5:32simple. You know, I heard a phrase years
- 5:35ago that was at Harvard Business School.
- 5:38The people who got A's worked for the
- 5:40people who got B's and the C's made all
- 5:43the money. The people who got C's make
- 5:45all the money. Why? Because the people
- 5:47who got C's would simplify stuff. And in
- 5:49in the end, business is simple. All
- 5:51right. Now, you guys have a
- 5:52disadvantage. You're all a little too
- 5:55smart for business,
- 5:58right? You want to complexify things.
- 5:59You complexified things in fourth grade,
- 6:018th grade, 12th grade, college. Now
- 6:03you're here. Why? Because you're too
- 6:05smart.
- 6:07And the university and the school system
- 6:08rewards the complexity, the longer
- 6:11essays, the more in-depth thinking.
- 6:14Whereas, in fact, business rewards
- 6:16simplicity.
- 6:18One of the things we've seen repeatedly
- 6:21is that with startups, they [ __ ] around
- 6:24with their four million that we give
- 6:25them and then they got $400,000 left in
- 6:27the bank. They say, "Fuck it." They get
- 6:31to their [ __ ] it moment and then they
- 6:34make the right decision. Why? Because
- 6:36they're simplifying. They're under
- 6:37pressure. Their backs are against the
- 6:38wall and they finally start thinking
- 6:40clearly. They stop complexifying.
- 6:43Okay? So, right now, I've got three or
- 6:45four companies in my portfolio. I'm
- 6:46allowing them to get to that 60-day left
- 6:48of I'm allowing it. I'm pushing it. And
- 6:51boy, are they learning fast. Boy, are
- 6:53they simplifying. They're getting to the
- 6:55point where they're actually going to
- 6:56make a business finally instead of
- 6:58messing around. All right, so you got to
- 7:00make things simple. Simplify as soon as
- 7:02you can. The second thing you've got to
- 7:04do is make something scalable. Okay, so
- 7:06again, we're not talking about bakeries
- 7:07and that sort of thing. We're talking
- 7:09about typically software, biology,
- 7:11technologies, but scale. We're all so
- 7:14lucky to have been born into this age,
- 7:16right? We're not manufacturing shoes in
- 7:171950,
- 7:19right?
- 7:21We're not farmers. We're doing things at
- 7:22scale. All right? So, think about
- 7:24something that scales up, particularly
- 7:26on the distribution side. And then think
- 7:28about things that are similar. Now,
- 7:29let's get into this for a second.
- 7:31Something that is similar. Something
- 7:32that is similar. Most of the talk about
- 7:36entrepreneurship is something brilliant
- 7:38and breakthrough. But if you look at the
- 7:40history of what creates big companies,
- 7:42the biggest companies, you know, were
- 7:44very, very similar to the companies that
- 7:46had just come before them a year, two or
- 7:48three or four before they started. They
- 7:50were similar to something that was
- 7:52already working. So think of the three
- 7:54S's, simple, scalable, and similar. All
- 7:57right? So what I say is copy a lot, but
- 8:00not all. So what does that mean?
- 8:03in more detail.
- 8:05You can imagine your idea could be
- 8:07totally new and everyone's gonna say,
- 8:09"Oh, dude, that's so cool. That's so
- 8:12exciting.
- 8:14You should totally do that."
- 8:17They'll say that to you, but they won't
- 8:18buy your product because they probably
- 8:20don't need your product because
- 8:20something totally new is unlikely to be
- 8:22something people need. This is just a
- 8:24fact. Okay?
- 8:27You're likely to fail. The other way you
- 8:29could go is to purely clone something
- 8:31pixel for pixel,
- 8:33violate their patents, whatever it is.
- 8:36And if you purely clone something,
- 8:38they're going to come after you legally.
- 8:40The community will say you're a jerk.
- 8:42Everyone will say, "Oh, there's nothing
- 8:43original there." And you'll sense this
- 8:45this degradation of support for you. So,
- 8:48you can't really just go and clone
- 8:50something. At least not in the United
- 8:51States. If you want to go clone
- 8:53something, do it in a different
- 8:54geography, that's fine. That's totally
- 8:56fine. That's actually a good model.
- 8:58But where you want to be typically is in
- 9:00this new energy area, okay? Where you're
- 9:04making two to three obvious changes.
- 9:08And I give you a bunch of examples,
- 9:09right? So we had this company Prosper.
- 9:12They were doing a loaning marketplace
- 9:15and two years later uh they were they
- 9:18were cloned essentially um and by
- 9:21Lending Club and Lending Club changed
- 9:23just two things. They bundled the loans
- 9:25and they actually talked to the FT the
- 9:27FCC before they excuse me the FTC before
- 9:30they launched their thing.
- 9:32And those two differences made all the
- 9:34difference. They soared up to about a $7
- 9:36billion valuation and Prosper was
- 9:37actually put out of business by the FTC.
- 9:40All right.
- 9:42Uh then later on Prosper came out and
- 9:44then copied what Lending Club had done
- 9:45and now both of them about the same
- 9:46size. Kind of interesting story but by
- 9:48changing those two things. Oh, it's
- 9:50totally different and then it worked.
- 9:51And you see the same thing with uh
- 9:53Google on info.
- 9:55You see the same thing with Airbnb on
- 9:57VBO. Just a couple changes to something
- 10:00that was very similar and no one
- 10:02thought, "Oh, it's just like VBO. Those
- 10:04guys are jerks." Everyone's like, "Oh,
- 10:05it's so different." Airbnb is its own
- 10:07thing, right? And so this Goldilock zone
- 10:10of this new energy is where a lot of the
- 10:13biggest companies you ever heard of. I
- 10:14mean, Facebook was just a copy of of
- 10:16Fster. It's the same blue. It's the same
- 10:18five features. In fact, there was about
- 10:20about a hundred social networks at that
- 10:22time before Facebook launched. It was
- 10:23very similar to what he knew was
- 10:24working, right? And that was the kernel.
- 10:27That was the beginning. And he grabbed
- 10:28the network effect. He grabbed the best
- 10:29team. And then he made what he did.
- 10:32Okay? So, this is where it usually comes
- 10:34from, not what you're taught.
- 10:38You're taught to talk to the customer
- 10:39and have them tell what they want. And
- 10:41that doesn't work. And I'm going to get
- 10:42into that later. And you're taught to
- 10:43come up with something brand new,
- 10:44something revolutionary. And that often
- 10:46doesn't work either. Okay. So look for
- 10:49this new energy.
- 10:52Another model to be aware of is this
- 10:54idea of the difference between market
- 10:56risk and execution risk. I didn't really
- 10:59understand this. My first four companies
- 11:01I was taking market risk and execution
- 11:03risk both times. I was an idiot. All
- 11:06right. Elon Musk tried it with X.com
- 11:09rolls into PayPal and after that said
- 11:10I'm never going to take market risk
- 11:12again because who knew if someone wanted
- 11:13to send money across trios because
- 11:15that's where he started massive market
- 11:18risk. So I'm not taking more market
- 11:20risk. I know people drive cars. I know
- 11:22people pay money to send things into
- 11:23space and I know people put solar panels
- 11:25on their on their houses. There's no
- 11:27market risk. I'm just going to take
- 11:28execution risk. Very smart.
- 11:31All right. And so first-time founders
- 11:34like I was, maybe like you are, we often
- 11:36take a lot of market risk and execution
- 11:38risk, but because we've never executed
- 11:40before, it's unlikely we're going to be
- 11:41very good at it. Second time founders
- 11:44who know they're good at execution
- 11:45because they messed up so many times and
- 11:47learned, they're smarter. They come in
- 11:50and they only take on execution risk
- 11:51because they know they're good at that.
- 11:53They can raise the money. They can hire
- 11:54the people. They know the right
- 11:56balances. They know how to move Bob
- 11:58weave, but they don't want to take
- 12:00market risk. It's just too much risk,
- 12:02just unlikely to work. All right, so
- 12:04understand the difference between those
- 12:06two things as you think about the
- 12:07businesses you're considering.
- 12:12Another way to look at risks is
- 12:13something that Rick Frisbee, the founder
- 12:15of Battery Ventures, told me when I
- 12:16worked there. I said to him, "Rick,
- 12:18we've got to invest internationally.
- 12:20That's where all the hot markets are.
- 12:21That's where we're going to get our big
- 12:22returns." He's like, "I don't think so."
- 12:23I said, "No, really. We have to do it."
- 12:25He's like, "All right." So another
- 12:27partner and I made two investments and
- 12:28within a year we had lost 100% of our
- 12:30money
- 12:32and he walks up to me about four months
- 12:33later in the hallway and he says I know
- 12:35what happened. I figured it out. He said
- 12:38when we invest in a US company we've got
- 12:41let's say eight big risks execution risk
- 12:44market risk legal product blah blah when
- 12:46we invest internationally
- 12:48we have a whole another set of risks. So
- 12:50systematically
- 12:52a venture portfolio with international
- 12:54investments is going to show lower
- 12:55returns than a domestic one with with uh
- 12:58with lower risks. I was like, "Wow,
- 13:00that's really insightful." Okay, I was
- 13:02wrong. You were right. I had to spend
- 13:04whatever it was $8 million to prove you
- 13:05right. There you go. And now I'm passing
- 13:07that on to you guys. Now, don't just
- 13:09think about as international.
- 13:11Think about everything like what if
- 13:13you've got regulation in your market.
- 13:15There are some markets with no
- 13:16regulation. What if you've got you've
- 13:17got to roll it out city by city? There
- 13:20are some markets where you don't have to
- 13:21roll it out city by city. What are all
- 13:22the risks you're taking on for your
- 13:24business to work?
- 13:26List them out and compare that to other
- 13:29ideas you're having. Not that risk is
- 13:32bad. We're in the business of taking
- 13:34risk and doing things that others won't
- 13:36do. But I'm just cautioning you to
- 13:39understand what your risks are and to
- 13:41map them out before you get going.
- 13:43Because what you'll see is that for
- 13:44instance in medical software,
- 13:47the amount of risk is so long, the
- 13:49barriers to your success so high, the
- 13:52track record of losing money in medical
- 13:54software so deep over the last 15 years
- 13:58that it's you really have to be certain
- 14:00you want to spend your life's energies
- 14:01for the next 10 years on this thing
- 14:03because I can tell you it's it's very
- 14:06thorny to get through that. There's so
- 14:08many risks, so many blockers. All right,
- 14:12another idea, red ocean versus blue
- 14:14ocean. Typically, people say, "Oh, well,
- 14:17what if Google does that? Oh, you've
- 14:19already got Sequoa already invested in a
- 14:21company in that space. That's a red
- 14:23ocean.
- 14:24You shouldn't go in there. It's
- 14:26dangerous. Too much competition." Well,
- 14:28try going into a blue ocean, guys, when
- 14:30no one's in there. That's pretty risky
- 14:33as well because you're taking on more
- 14:34market risk. So, what we've seen
- 14:36repeatedly is people who go into the red
- 14:38oceans end up doing better than the
- 14:40people who end up going into the blue
- 14:41oceans. In fact, I've got one company
- 14:43I'm working with right now and they they
- 14:45tried two blue oceans and now they've
- 14:48still got capital and so they're trying
- 14:49their third one. I'm like, "Guys, just
- 14:51go find a business that you admire and
- 14:54go find new energy around it. Start
- 14:57something very, very similar because you
- 14:59know someone's going to buy it. You know
- 15:00how to price it. You know the go to
- 15:02market because you can see what your
- 15:03competitor is doing. Get in business.
- 15:05Get some blood. Get some blood into the
- 15:07system and let the system, you know,
- 15:09work on on the blood because you don't
- 15:11have any blood right now. You're too far
- 15:12out in the blue ocean, right? Get in the
- 15:14red ocean, get some revenue, get some
- 15:17customers, and then learn what you need
- 15:18to do from here. Okay? So, that's what
- 15:21they're doing. And it's going much
- 15:22better now because then everyone in the
- 15:23organization can look at the revenues,
- 15:25they can look at the sales cycles, they
- 15:26they've got real numbers, and they're
- 15:28going to make a company. I don't know if
- 15:29it's going to be a billion dollar
- 15:30company, but it could be. At least
- 15:32they'll have a company, right? Another
- 15:35thing I'll just mention is we did do an
- 15:36accelerator with 75 companies and eight
- 15:38of them are already unicorns. So this
- 15:40methodology I'm teaching you it works.
- 15:43We've tried it out in the field. All
- 15:46right.
- 15:48So a lot of people ask me, okay, how do
- 15:49I know if the timing is right? Very good
- 15:52question. Generally, we don't know.
- 15:54Generally, none of us really know. But
- 15:56there are some signs that you can can
- 15:58look at and it's typically rapid
- 16:02technology platform shifts.
- 16:05It's distinct from a particular
- 16:07technology but platform shifts when
- 16:09something is suddenly newly possible.
- 16:13Okay? And I don't mean slow uh
- 16:17technology shifts. I mean rapid
- 16:18technology shifts like the one we've
- 16:20just gone through with generative tech
- 16:21over the last eight months. Right? So,
- 16:23we had all this generative tech for
- 16:25years. We've been investing it for
- 16:27years, but suddenly in the last eight
- 16:29months, the price of it dropped 100x.
- 16:32And it really does feel like a human
- 16:34being is writing that text. It does look
- 16:35like an artist is painting that picture.
- 16:37And it didn't two years ago, but now it
- 16:39does. Boom. So, there's an explosion.
- 16:42There's a Cambrian explosion that's
- 16:43going on right now around generative
- 16:44tech. That's a good example of a shift
- 16:46that takes place. and of course cell
- 16:48phones or um blockchain or certain types
- 16:51of of foundational technologies. When
- 16:53you see that, that's your key that there
- 16:56might be something newly possible.
- 16:58That's what you're looking for in terms
- 17:00of timing. Now, a lot of people come to
- 17:02us and say, "Oh, you know, Gen Z buys
- 17:05stuff differently. Gen Z, Gen Y feels
- 17:09differently about this." This is stuff
- 17:11that takes a decade to roll out, which
- 17:14means that all the competition can see
- 17:15it as well and take advantage of as
- 17:17well. You're not going to find really
- 17:20open opportunities when you're talking
- 17:21about cultural shifts.
- 17:23Okay,
- 17:25people mistake that this is what's
- 17:27changed. No, sometimes you can find
- 17:29regulatory shifts that took place a few
- 17:31years ago. regulation changed on how the
- 17:35government pays for dialysis
- 17:38because there was a new technology to do
- 17:39diialysis in the home. They changed the
- 17:41regulations after 10 years of lobbying
- 17:43and when that changed over the next
- 17:44three years there was an opening for new
- 17:46diialysis companies. Okay, those also
- 17:49can be good moments for why now or what
- 17:51the timing is. But had you tried to do
- 17:53it before, a lot of people come to us
- 17:55say, you know, they've got this
- 17:56legislation and it's going to be
- 17:57changing next year. Like nah, it's not.
- 18:00they're going to miss. They're going to
- 18:01push it to the next year and the next
- 18:02year and the next administration and
- 18:04it's going to come in four years. All
- 18:05right? So, don't try to anticipate these
- 18:07regulatory changes. The the opening for
- 18:09diialysis was still available four years
- 18:11after the law changed because no one had
- 18:13really absorbed it. So, with with
- 18:15regulation, don't try to, you know, get
- 18:17in front of it. Be be after it. Uh but
- 18:20with the technology shifts, you want to
- 18:21be right there. Um,
- 18:25and what I want to point out is that
- 18:26it's not also a technology shift that
- 18:28you've like some specific thing you
- 18:30found in your lab. A lot of people come
- 18:31to us and say,"I did this thing in the
- 18:33lab. I want to make a business out of
- 18:35it." And that rarely works. And the
- 18:37phrase that everyone has heard for 30
- 18:38years in the venture business is
- 18:40technology in search of a market. All
- 18:42right? And that's different from a
- 18:43platform shift. That's just a very
- 18:45specific thing you might have
- 18:46discovered. And those rarely turn in to
- 18:48something unless they are themselves
- 18:50platforms. And then you can have
- 18:52multiple at bats on that platform. So
- 18:54when we do our biotech investing, we're
- 18:56mostly only investing in things that are
- 18:57platforms. Okay? Because it might not
- 19:00work for the first six indications, but
- 19:01it might work for the next two. And
- 19:02there you have a real company. All
- 19:04right?
- 19:07Another thing in terms of timing that
- 19:09you're looking for is the market's
- 19:10growing quickly. So
- 19:13again, it's rapid new behaviors. You
- 19:15know, uh, home stays instead of hotels
- 19:18that became a thing really fast. There's
- 19:20a bunch of big companies including
- 19:21Airbnb that were built around that and
- 19:22continue to be built around that change
- 19:24in consumer behavior. Um,
- 19:27and a lot of people say, well, how big
- 19:28is your TAM? Well, the TAM isn't big
- 19:30today, but it's going to be big. You
- 19:32just have to see a fastmoving market,
- 19:34even if it's small right now. Doesn't
- 19:36have to be big TAM. So, don't always
- 19:38say, well, this tech this transactions
- 19:41that are taking place in this B2B
- 19:42marketplace, we're going to move those
- 19:44digitally. Ah, that we've tried that.
- 19:46That typically doesn't work. What you
- 19:48need to do is find new transactions that
- 19:50aren't taking place in a subsegment that
- 19:53could eventually take over more of the
- 19:55market and you want to attack there.
- 19:57Create new transactions,
- 19:59not just try to replace the old
- 20:01transaction because the TAM is so big.
- 20:03All right, so don't be deceived by only
- 20:05big TAMs. Here's another big one that
- 20:08took us a while to figure out. So years
- 20:10ago, we had a company called Wonderh
- 20:12Hill and we were building video games
- 20:14and the we built a bunch of them and the
- 20:20first few games we built didn't have
- 20:22enough users in terms of the number of
- 20:25potential customers and they weren't
- 20:27using it often enough. And then the
- 20:29average sales price, the amount we were
- 20:32making per day just wasn't enough to
- 20:34make a business. It was inside some sort
- 20:36of a boundary layer that prevented it
- 20:39from being a real business.
- 20:41Then we looked at this company that was
- 20:42being successful at the time called
- 20:44Farmville and they were making 4 cents a
- 20:45day from about 100 million people. They
- 20:49had a real business. They were
- 20:50advertising. They had a staff. They were
- 20:51growing. It was kind of cool. Everyone
- 20:53was talking about it. And we're like,
- 20:55well, could we build one of those? Well,
- 20:56we tried, but we didn't quite get there.
- 20:58We got to like 30 million. That wasn't
- 21:00enough.
- 21:02So then we built a game called Dragons
- 21:04of Atlantis,
- 21:05which was like another game called
- 21:07Kingdoms of Camelot. And we had 50,000
- 21:10users, but we were making almost four
- 21:11bucks a day. And so this became a real
- 21:14business. And we had a staff and it was
- 21:16going great and it was amazing, but it
- 21:19was outside that boundary layer. So as
- 21:21you think about your business, think
- 21:22about how many people could you actually
- 21:24go and get. You know, somebody came to
- 21:26me today with a generative tech company
- 21:28that's going to provide 3D modeling for
- 21:31game developers. Like, okay, that's
- 21:34good, but how many game developers are
- 21:36there? I mean, I know that's it's not
- 21:37less than 10,000. It might be 50,000.
- 21:39There's a lot of people, but is that
- 21:41really enough for you to build a really
- 21:43big company? Or does it become a 50
- 21:45to$100 million acquisition? Sure enough,
- 21:47all the 3D modeling companies of the
- 21:49last 10 years have all been bought
- 21:50between $50 and $100 million, which is
- 21:52great. You guys, if you want to start
- 21:53that, you can be in the games industry
- 21:55and you can make 10 million bucks, six
- 21:57million bucks. That's amazing. But
- 21:59that's not what I'm after. And hopefully
- 22:00that's not what you're after. You're
- 22:02after something bigger. Okay.
- 22:05Now, this game Mafia Wars was actually
- 22:07the game that drove Zingga because this
- 22:10thing had about 80 million users and was
- 22:12making about $2.70 a day per user. And
- 22:14they this drove them for two and a half
- 22:16years. So, if you ever want to build a
- 22:18video game, think of Mafia, Pirates,
- 22:20Mafia, Atlantis. These are the things
- 22:22that work. In fact, if you want to know
- 22:23what works in games, go to the Lego
- 22:25section of the toy store. See what's see
- 22:27what they have. They have pirates. They
- 22:29have Atlantis. They have Citybuilder.
- 22:31They have all the things that work on
- 22:32the video games. Anyway, it's another
- 22:33another pattern that you can put. So,
- 22:35the reason the Mafia Wars works is the
- 22:37area under the curve is so big. The area
- 22:38under your curve has to be big and you
- 22:39have to be outside that boundary layer.
- 22:41So, ASP versus size of market. Okay.
- 22:45Okay. Any questions so far? Anything?
- 22:47Anything? You guys are all very quiet.
- 22:49Good. Good. Okay. So, let's talk about
- 22:52your mindset. Those are things that are
- 22:55in the the world, math that's in the
- 22:58world that we've noticed drive
- 23:00successful big companies. Now, let's
- 23:01talk about how you think about stuff.
- 23:04Okay.
- 23:06People ask me, "When should I pivot?
- 23:08When should I when should I stick with
- 23:09it or when should I pivot?" Great
- 23:10question. Really hard to know. We don't
- 23:13we don't usually know either. But what's
- 23:15clear is that you can pivot and still
- 23:18build a deck of corn.
- 23:21Lots of people have done it and they do
- 23:24it because they have passionate beliefs
- 23:27loosely held where they really believe
- 23:29in the thing they're working on but then
- 23:31when they get data they let go easily
- 23:33and they move on and they teach their
- 23:36teams to feel the same way. Okay. And
- 23:39that's the that's the more hard part
- 23:41sometimes is teaching your team to
- 23:43loosely hold on because they're trying
- 23:45to do a good job for you. All right. So
- 23:47there's a lot of companies that have
- 23:48pivoted and become big, become
- 23:49important. Um, but you can't hold on too
- 23:52much and you should be open to pivots.
- 23:55Of my four companies, uh, we pivoted all
- 23:58but one of them and they were all
- 24:01successful. And two out of the four, we
- 24:03changed the name because once we found
- 24:05product market fit, we realized our name
- 24:06wasn't appropriate for the product
- 24:08market fit. So we changed the name. Do
- 24:10not be afraid of going all the way down
- 24:12to the base, the name of your company,
- 24:14and starting again. All right? Don't be
- 24:16afraid of that. It works.
- 24:18Right?
- 24:21Another mindset that comes up again and
- 24:23again is that when you get up in the
- 24:25morning because you've been successful
- 24:26in your lives because you've been told
- 24:28you're the best. You're at Stanford,
- 24:30right? You were the best in grammar
- 24:31school, you're best in high school,
- 24:32you're best in college, you're best
- 24:33here, right?
- 24:35You kind of feel like anything worthy of
- 24:37your efforts needs to be massive and
- 24:40need to do a giant thing. And so you're
- 24:42in love with the sports car. You get up
- 24:45in the morning and you tell people, "I'm
- 24:46building a sports car." And they say,
- 24:47"Dude, you're cool.
- 24:49You're really cool. I admire you. You're
- 24:51building that cool sports car, right?"
- 24:54But the fact is, you can't just build a
- 24:57sports car. It doesn't typically work
- 24:58that way.
- 25:00And you can't fall in love with that.
- 25:02You've got to be willing to build a
- 25:03skateboard and run on the skateboard and
- 25:04tell people, "I'm building the
- 25:05skateboard. I'm excited about this
- 25:07skateboard. This is the best
- 25:08skateboard." And they're going to be
- 25:10like,
- 25:12"That's not so cool." you know, I want
- 25:14to save I want to save the planet. I
- 25:16want to do climate tech, blah blah blah.
- 25:20And so, you have to be willing to build
- 25:22a skateboard and put your heart and soul
- 25:23into it at the moment you're building a
- 25:25skateboard because once you get the
- 25:26skateboard built, then you can move on
- 25:28up toward your sports car, right? So,
- 25:32college photo sharing, who thought that
- 25:33was a big idea?
- 25:35Very few people at the time, right?
- 25:38what you had for lunch in 140 characters
- 25:41or less. Was that a big idea? Renting an
- 25:44airbed, somebody's extra room, was that
- 25:46a big idea? Almost every company that
- 25:47you guys admire, other than like
- 25:49Snowflake, started as something really
- 25:51small. Okay?
- 25:54So, don't don't overindulge yourself
- 25:57with with your grandiose plans for how
- 26:00cool you're going to look to everybody
- 26:01because you're building the sports car.
- 26:02Does that make sense? Don't get ahead of
- 26:04yourself. Be a little bit humble.
- 26:08All right. Another mindset that we've
- 26:10seen uh be an indicator of where great
- 26:13ideas come from is whether it attracts
- 26:15commandos. There's a mindset between a
- 26:17commando who will take the hill and do
- 26:20whatever it takes and a soldier. You
- 26:22know, they put in those those white
- 26:24mobile homes, they put in some dirt
- 26:25roads, they put in one light by the
- 26:27floating bridge and things are kind of
- 26:28under control. Then you've got the
- 26:30police and their only job is to make
- 26:31sure nothing bad happens. Right? So if
- 26:35you are a police or a soldier, you are
- 26:37unlikely
- 26:39to be successful as a person who's
- 26:41starting a startup. Very unlikely.
- 26:45And one of the things that most VCs
- 26:46sniff for because of the track record of
- 26:49soldiers and sold uh and police to
- 26:51actually try these startups, we always
- 26:53sniff for these personality types
- 26:55because they're deadly. And if you have
- 26:57anyone on your team who's either a
- 26:59soldier or a police, you need to get
- 27:01them off your team. It's very very hard
- 27:03to change that mindset. People's fear
- 27:05levels are set at a certain place and
- 27:07it's very hard to change them. Okay. One
- 27:10of the reasons that Facebook was so good
- 27:13until you know whatever 2014 was because
- 27:15they just maintain the commando culture.
- 27:18Everybody there was still a commando up
- 27:19until about that time. And that's why
- 27:22they just kept winning and winning and
- 27:23winning. Okay? And even at scale they
- 27:25had 20,000 people and they were still
- 27:28commando culture. So don't tell me that
- 27:29you can't find eight commandos to go
- 27:32with you cuz you can.
- 27:36One of the reasons that as we'll discuss
- 27:38later,
- 27:40it's very hard for many ecosystems like
- 27:43Atlanta or Orlando or Cleveland to
- 27:46produce big tech companies is because
- 27:48there aren't a lot of commandos left
- 27:50there. They left. They moved. They
- 27:53didn't feel comfortable there. They went
- 27:54elsewhere.
- 27:56Right? You need the commando mindset to
- 27:58try to do something great, something
- 28:00fast, something on the edge, something
- 28:02that people poo poo,
- 28:04right? Because soldiers of police do not
- 28:06like to be poo pooed,
- 28:08particularly smart ones.
- 28:11All right,
- 28:12here's another mindset that we didn't
- 28:14see until later. There's a mindset of
- 28:16playing to win versus playing not to
- 28:18lose. I was a guy who played not to
- 28:20lose. That's why four out of my four did
- 28:21fine. But I never built a billion-dollar
- 28:24company. Pete Flint, my partner, did.
- 28:26Giggy did. Okay. But I never did because
- 28:28I was always playing not to lose. All
- 28:31right. We didn't realize we had this
- 28:32mindset until our third one. We're like,
- 28:34"Huh, this just keeps going well, but we
- 28:36keep selling for like 150 million.
- 28:38What's what's that all about?" It was
- 28:40because of this mindset. This mindset
- 28:43will hurt you. It'll keep you from doing
- 28:44something great. You have to figure out
- 28:46how to move into a space where you're
- 28:47playing to win, where you're willing to
- 28:48take that risk of of jamming and and
- 28:51really attacking something once you have
- 28:53got your product market fit. Once you
- 28:55once once you're ready to go, you got to
- 28:57go all in. Okay.
- 29:01Another thing is ambitious vision. Seems
- 29:04kind of trit to say that, but you'd be
- 29:06surprised at how few people have
- 29:08ambitious vision. If you have that
- 29:09mindset, that's that's contagious,
- 29:13right? That attracts the best people to
- 29:15you.
- 29:17That attracts the best capital to you.
- 29:18That attracts the best ideas. And people
- 29:20come and give you their best ideas
- 29:21because they see that you can take them
- 29:22and do something with them. So the
- 29:23ambitious vision, you need to surround
- 29:24yourself with people who are going to
- 29:26allow you to have that ambitious vision,
- 29:27egg you on. You know, another group of
- 29:29people who came to me and they had
- 29:31raised $6 million in Toronto and four
- 29:33four days a week they were being asked
- 29:35to go to breakfasts to give lectures to
- 29:36people at the Holiday Inn about how to
- 29:38do entrepreneurship. They were they were
- 29:39the kings of Toronto,
- 29:42you know, and if you're standing at a
- 29:43soccer game here in Palo Alto and you've
- 29:45raised 50, the dude next to you raised
- 29:46200 and you know, whatever. Like you're
- 29:48just like, whoa, okay, I got to keep
- 29:50going. Like this is when you're
- 29:51surrounded by big ambitious vision your
- 29:53ambition gets bigger. Another pattern
- 29:56that we see
- 30:00in the minds of the people who build the
- 30:02biggest companies is the ability and the
- 30:04desire to recruit the absolutely best
- 30:07talent. Now,
- 30:10uh I can tell you that
- 30:12uh like as I said again with Facebook,
- 30:16there were a hundred companies with the
- 30:17same five features,
- 30:19but he had a better team. We had a team.
- 30:22We had a 30 million person social
- 30:24network. When he launched, he had a
- 30:26team. The design was better. The pages
- 30:28loaded faster. They had real names. They
- 30:31just iterated faster. And we were very
- 30:33fast. We were among the best product
- 30:35designers in the world at the time. And
- 30:37these guys were at a different level.
- 30:40They started with a network effect. They
- 30:41hire the best and boom, Microsoft. They
- 30:44start with a network effect with their
- 30:45operating system. They got lucky. They
- 30:46didn't know what it was. They stumbled
- 30:47into it. They got the very best people.
- 30:50They're hiring processes.
- 30:52They they just hoovered up talent from
- 30:54all over the world and brought them up
- 30:55to Belleview and they crushed it. Same
- 30:58thing with Google. Okay? They copied
- 31:00Infosek. They had a better algorithm. It
- 31:02was about 10% better than the Alta Vista
- 31:04algorithm at the time. But what the
- 31:06story that they had a better search was
- 31:07is not true. Alta Vista was better about
- 31:11the same. They had better people. So 18
- 31:14months after they got their first
- 31:15funding, they were better. They weren't
- 31:17at the time that they started. Okay.
- 31:21So the idea of of identifying and hiring
- 31:25the best people who are better than you,
- 31:27that mentality
- 31:29has proven again and again to be the
- 31:31winning combination, particularly when
- 31:33most of the businesses that you're going
- 31:34to be doing are having new energy in a
- 31:36red ocean.
- 31:39You've got to have a better team.
- 31:41All right? And you guys are lucky
- 31:43because you're surrounded by the better
- 31:45people. It's unfair. Yes, life is
- 31:48unfair.
- 31:50Uh, and if you want to get a sense of
- 31:54how strong the power law is, go to
- 31:56YouTube and look up a video called these
- 31:59regular guys challenged an NBA player
- 32:00and instantly regretted it.
- 32:04And it's, I don't know, five or seven
- 32:05minutes and it really gives you a sense
- 32:07of how strong the power law is. And
- 32:09basically what happens is they find a
- 32:11guy who's 42 and when he was 27 to 30
- 32:14for three years he played in the NBA and
- 32:16he was 363rd out of 365 in terms of
- 32:20stats. He was the worst guy in the NBA
- 32:21for three years and now he's 12 years
- 32:25older, 30 pounds heavier. And they
- 32:28grabbed the best people out of the
- 32:29G-League, the best they grabbed a bunch
- 32:31of the best basketball players in every
- 32:33place else do one-on-one. And he killed
- 32:35him like 13 to nothing. 13 to nothing
- 32:38and 13 to3 or something. What 11 to
- 32:40three or something. He just absolutely
- 32:42kills him and and you you realize, wow,
- 32:46you know, he's the worst of this. He's
- 32:48like here on the power law and he's so
- 32:50much better than everybody else. And
- 32:51once you start to get a sense of this, I
- 32:54think you might become more committed to
- 32:56really recruiting and bringing in those
- 32:57very best people and working on yourself
- 33:00to make yourself one of these people.
- 33:02You don't want to stay in the G- League.
- 33:03you want to be in the NBA, you know, and
- 33:06you guys are near, you guys are close.
- 33:08It's going to take a lot of work on your
- 33:09part on yourselves, and that includes
- 33:12working on your authenticity,
- 33:14on your communication, on your
- 33:16willingness to say you're wrong, on your
- 33:18charisma to recruit people into your
- 33:20team, the energy to drag in all the
- 33:23nodes and bond them to your network,
- 33:24which is your company, right?
- 33:29So, it's going to take a lot of work on
- 33:30you to be at this part of the power law.
- 33:32Um, so that you're not Yahoo info and
- 33:34XI. If you met the Yahoo people, they're
- 33:36pretty good people. You know, we
- 33:38invested in the info people. They're
- 33:39pretty good people. Really, really
- 33:41talented, but nothing like the Google
- 33:44folks.
- 33:46All right, so that's your mindset. So,
- 33:47what are some of the other patterns?
- 33:50Okay, so let's think about centers of
- 33:51excellence. You guys happen to be in
- 33:53one. You probably were in some before
- 33:55this as well. Hopefully, you will be
- 33:57after this. Hopefully, you'll create
- 33:59those centers of excellence for others.
- 34:02Um, and of course we know about company
- 34:04mafias.
- 34:05We see a lot of great companies and
- 34:07founders come out of Facebook, PayPal,
- 34:09Stripe, Square, Salesforce, Peopleoft,
- 34:11and 8200.
- 34:14All right, patterns of geography. This
- 34:15is a controversial one no one likes to
- 34:17talk about. Maybe you guys will. If you
- 34:19want to read this article, your life is
- 34:20driven by network effects. It'll give
- 34:21you some sense of how the networks
- 34:23affect your outcome.
- 34:25Um,
- 34:26and if you want to read this article,
- 34:28where to build your startup, it gives
- 34:29you all the stats about where to build
- 34:31your startup. And to, uh, cut to the
- 34:33chase, it just turns out that the Bay
- 34:35Area is sort of seven times better than
- 34:37every other ecosystem. Minimum is seven
- 34:40times.
- 34:43There's lots of reasons for that. One is
- 34:45that
- 34:47you can hire a really good employee
- 34:49number 68.
- 34:51It's just really hard to do that in
- 34:52Atlanta. Another reason is that you get
- 34:55really good advice from people who have
- 34:56scars all over them because they've
- 34:58tried what you're doing and they've made
- 35:00a ton of mistakes and now they can warn
- 35:01you off of stuff and save you a week,
- 35:02save you a month. Hopefully I can save
- 35:04you a few years tonight.
- 35:08Uh, another wing is sharing KPIs. You
- 35:10know, I remember in two of my companies,
- 35:12we were kind of meandering along looking
- 35:14for our product market fit and we would
- 35:16just have a conversation with someone
- 35:18else and they would tell us a key
- 35:19performance indicator that made us
- 35:21change our business in this way and
- 35:23suddenly we got profitable or suddenly
- 35:25the business doubled or tripled because
- 35:27the way they were sending their emails
- 35:29allowed them to get 7% clickthrough
- 35:30rather than 2% and suddenly we had a
- 35:32business. these little details. The same
- 35:35thing is true for all creative
- 35:36industries like film down in LA.
- 35:41How you turn the Fresno this way so the
- 35:43light is on the face this way. Don't do
- 35:44it that way because that looks like TV.
- 35:46You want to look like a movie. You do
- 35:47there's all these little details that
- 35:49are required to get to the excellence
- 35:50level that's going to make you
- 35:51successful. And when you're in these
- 35:53ecosystems, that type of information
- 35:55flows to you. We're trying to make it
- 35:58work online. We're trying to make it
- 35:59work on Zoom, but it's not the same
- 36:01thing.
- 36:03So, as you're seeing what's happening
- 36:04is, you know, everybody's saying, "Back
- 36:07to the office, guys. Back to the office.
- 36:09Everybody, particularly in creative
- 36:11industries, particularly when it's
- 36:12competitive." All right? And that's
- 36:14going to continue for the next four
- 36:15years until everyone's, "Okay, I'm back
- 36:17to the office." Everyone's going to
- 36:18complain for the next two years, but if
- 36:19you want to do something great, you're
- 36:21going to need to be with each other.
- 36:22Okay? Um, all right. The methods for
- 36:26idea discover. Okay. Here's where we're
- 36:27going to get a little controversial.
- 36:30I want to see how many companies have
- 36:33actually come, great companies that we
- 36:34would admire, not little companies that
- 36:36we would admire that came from this
- 36:38process.
- 36:40And the fact is, guys,
- 36:42you know, they're making consulting fees
- 36:44by teaching this stuff to the US
- 36:46government or the big corporations. And
- 36:48I know I'm being harsh and everyone's
- 36:49going to get defensive and all this
- 36:51stuff, but I just need to tell you,
- 36:53don't don't go down this road if you can
- 36:56avoid it.
- 36:58look at some of the other ways we've
- 36:59talked about finding your idea. Okay.
- 37:04The other thing is that um so so why
- 37:07doesn't it work? It doesn't work for
- 37:09psychological reasons because customers
- 37:11don't actually see the future. You're
- 37:12the one who has to see the future.
- 37:13Right? On the far extreme you have Steve
- 37:15Jobs who says screw the customer. They
- 37:17don't know what they want. I'll tell
- 37:18them what they want. Talk to Braraw.
- 37:20They don't know what they want. We'll
- 37:21tell them what they want. We'll give
- 37:22them something amazing. That's the far
- 37:25extreme. I'm not advocating for that
- 37:26extreme because only very few people are
- 37:27that talented.
- 37:29But I am I am advocating for something
- 37:31closer to that on the spectrum than sort
- 37:33of going and interviewing customers and
- 37:34saying, "What do you want?" Right?
- 37:36Because you remember that story where if
- 37:38you went down to the docks in the 1800s
- 37:40and people were carrying bags of grain
- 37:42up the ramp into the boat and dumping it
- 37:44into the cargo hold and you say, "What
- 37:46do you want?" What would they tell you?
- 37:48I need better shoes.
- 37:50But no one would say, "Well, I need a
- 37:52piece of metal with a pulley on it to
- 37:54lift this thing up on a pallet and then
- 37:56swing it over and then drop it in." No
- 37:58one would have told you that. They would
- 37:59have wanted better shoes.
- 38:01Okay? So, you have to say, you know, I'm
- 38:02going to get a pulley and I'm going to
- 38:03get a bearing and do a different thing.
- 38:06We're going to do it differently. Well,
- 38:08that's going to put me out of a job.
- 38:09Well, yeah, put out a job, but now you
- 38:11don't have to carry the damn thing on
- 38:12your back. Now, you can go do some
- 38:14paperwork or become a banker or
- 38:15something, whatever.
- 38:18So the breakthroughs are also coming
- 38:19from the non-utilizers
- 38:22right and we see this again and again
- 38:23again don't go after the main
- 38:25transactions in BB marketplace go after
- 38:27the side ones the non-utilizers create
- 38:29new transactions so what what this leads
- 38:31us to is a very important point which is
- 38:34start with the transaction all right if
- 38:37you think to yourself I'm going to start
- 38:39a business around a particular
- 38:40transaction with a particular person
- 38:42that's the place to start I would submit
- 38:45to you that if you want to make real
- 38:47change in the world, you do something
- 38:49that I've seen in the last 20 years make
- 38:50the biggest difference I can imagine,
- 38:52which was these guys from Scotland, I
- 38:55believe, went and bought the used GSM
- 38:58mobile networks out of Europe, which
- 39:00were being replaced. They brought them
- 39:02to Africa and they set them up as purely
- 39:03for-profit businesses across Africa and
- 39:06suddenly everyone could do their own
- 39:08business and make their own decisions
- 39:10and live their lives. It transformed
- 39:13those economies in very positive ways.
- 39:16and was purely for profit and it laid a
- 39:19foundation for everything else to
- 39:21happen. So now everything can build on
- 39:23top of that.
- 39:25It doesn't look like a mission-driven
- 39:27thing, but boy did it make a positive
- 39:29social impact in the world. And now it's
- 39:32evolved into the fact that the you have
- 39:33to be a missionary founder.
- 39:37No, you have to be a speedy founder. You
- 39:38have to be a savage founder. You have to
- 39:40be a competitive founder. Okay? Then you
- 39:43can have your mission and then you can
- 39:44accomplish your missions once you've got
- 39:45a business that's going.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Ep. 4 - The Hidden Patterns of Great Startup Ideas (NFX Masterclass) by NFX, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 7,779 words across 1,158 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.