Финал войны: победители и побеждённые | История Второй мировой (English subtitles) — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Unless we conclude our WW2 saga without any political takeaways,
- 0:04our entire docuseries will be relegated to a pointless watch.
- 0:07If we assume that this war didn’t change the world
- 0:09or lead to the renewal of its fundamental principles,
- 0:13its history will come down to a long-winded tale
- 0:16of a bunch of people slaughtering a great many others.
- 0:20True, the death toll was record-high.
- 0:22Yet the death count and the scope of devastation alone
- 0:25isn’t something that makes this war stand out.
- 0:28This fact just bears testimony to the technological spurt of the era.
- 0:31Humanity came up with machine guns, rapid-firing guns,
- 0:34warplanes, and massive air-dropped munitions,
- 0:36which combined for the wide-ranging manslaughter
- 0:40of truly unthinkable proportions.
- 0:44Stats and advanced new weaponry aside,
- 0:47it might come across as a war like many others.
- 0:51There was nothing the world wouldn’t have seen before.
- 0:54The systematic genocide of civilians,
- 0:57ethnic and religious cleansing campaigns,
- 1:01mass displacement, atrocities, and torture—there
- 1:06was nothing new about any of that.
- 1:08The only thing that could set this war apart would be
- 1:13the political outcome reshaping the fabric of the world.
- 1:17First and foremost, wars of aggression, which used to be
- 1:22rationally justifiable pursuits with a clear endgame,
- 1:29were rendered pointless.
- 1:33Wars used to expand the countries’ land mass, spawning more resources.
- 1:37Wars used to connote trophies and more power over people.
- 1:41Wars used to be a vehicle for natural selection.
- 1:44Unless you were capturing somebody else’s land,
- 1:46you’d soon fall prey to somebody else’s expansion.
- 1:50Wars used to be a natural extension of foreign policy.
- 1:55In fact, the entire foreign policy and international relations
- 1:59centered around wars. That included alliances, coalitions,
- 2:02ultimatums, and the exploitation of the newly added provinces.
- 2:07But WW2 stripped armed aggression of its rationale.
- 2:13War became so deadly, devastating, and detrimental
- 2:17to the belligerents’ economic capabilities,
- 2:21it could no longer be thought of as a military arm of politics.
- 2:27It was just evil. A war of aggression became a crime.
- 2:34WW2 didn’t really benefit anyone.
- 2:37It didn’t bring them something that they could’ve used to
- 2:40their advantage and that would’ve justified the warfare.
- 2:45Europe was lying in ruins. The entire cities, factories,
- 2:49and pieces of critical infrastructure were unusable.
- 2:52It required years and decades’ worth of investment
- 2:57so that it could just be rebuilt.
- 3:02The Soviet Union vastly expanded its territory
- 3:05and took over half of Europe in colonial fashion.
- 3:10Yet the only benefit it reaped
- 3:12was the notion of power and political clout.
- 3:17The idea of war having changed forever is aptly illustrated
- 3:20by the subsequent major armed conflicts
- 3:24involving the world’s leading nations.
- 3:27The Vietnam War resulted in a bitter thrashing of the U.S.
- 3:30Years of hostilities didn’t yield anything close to victory.
- 3:36For the U.S. military, it devolved into a quagmire
- 3:39with a mounting casualty count.
- 3:42George W. Bush’s war in Iraq emerged impressively victorious.
- 3:45The Iraqi military crumbled in a matter of weeks.
- 3:48The invasion was launched on Mar. 20, 2003.
- 3:51On Apr. 9, the Americans captured Baghdad.
- 3:53The kinetic phase cost the entire U.S.-led coalition just 172 lives.
- 3:59Assessed through the lens of the prevalent pre-WW2 notions,
- 4:02the Iraq War was a glorious chapter in U.S. military history.
- 4:07But politically speaking, the loss in the Vietnam War
- 4:11and the victory in Iraq made no difference.
- 4:14Nobody knew how that W could be converted.
- 4:17The occupation of Iraq cost the Americans
- 4:201,000s of lives lost and 100s of billions of dollars wasted.
- 4:26In a post-WW2 world, defeat is no different from victory.
- 4:30Fighting a war is tantamount to a defeat.
- 4:33The Soviet–Afghan War, the Vietnam War, the Iraq War,
- 4:38and the ongoing Russo– Ukrainian war are strikingly
- 4:42different in terms of scale, casualties, progress, and gains.
- 4:46But the results are strikingly similar.
- 4:49A squandered federal budget, a tarnished reputation
- 4:53in the global arena, and prolonged political crisis.
- 4:55We won’t go down the rabbit hole by engaging in the conversation
- 4:57on whether the Afghan campaign was deleterious to the USSR.
- 4:59But it certainly didn’t help its faltering economy, either.
- 5:03The assertion that WW2 marked the end of an era
- 5:06can be proved by the fact that it’s the last war to date
- 5:11to have resulted in victory.
- 5:14It was an undisputed victory achieved by those
- 5:19who are still considered to be the good guys.
- 5:23This is also the last military victory that’s still being
- 5:27celebrated annually by the winning nations.
- 5:39The dates, the ceremonies, and the sentiment may vary, but barring the political fringe,
- 5:44the defeat of the Nazis and their allies is almost
- 5:50universally viewed as a great achievement.
- 5:56As for the subsequent major conflicts, people
- 5:58aren’t proud of them. The dominant sentiment is that of relief.
- 6:02Formal victory or loss is immaterial.
- 6:05People are thankful that those conflicts ended.
- 6:10!Post-Battle Scenery!
- 6:25Sept. 2, 1945. 9 A.M. The Japanese delegation
- 6:29is climbing aboard the USS Missouri.
- 6:33It’s led by foreign minister Mamoru Shigemitsu clad in
- 6:39an all-black ensemble mourning the deceased Japanese citizens.
- 6:41He’s heartbroken as he’s about to formally concede the defeat.
- 6:45Minutes later, he’ll sign the Japanese Instrument of Surrender,
- 6:49marking the end of WW2.
- 6:56It officially lasted six years and one day.
- 6:59WW2 entangled 62 countries out of a total of 74.
- 7:05The hostilities spanned three continents and four oceans.
- 7:10The war was fought in the air and under water.
- 7:12It was the first time nuclear weapons were used in combat.
- 7:16The belligerents mobilized more than 110 million personnel,
- 7:20which was almost 5% of the world’s population as of 1939.
- 7:25Almost no one was spared by that disaster.
- 7:30The final death tally is still unconfirmed. The count will go on forever.
- 7:35The death toll is estimated between 55 and 85 million.
- 7:41The Soviet Union saw one in seven citizens killed.
- 7:44Poland lost around 25% of its population.
- 7:47Many cities were wiped off the map, villages burned to the ground,
- 7:51and factories razed. Arable lands were turned into minefields.
- 7:56Trenches, barbed wire fences, refugees,
- 7:59children separated from their parents, poverty, famine,
- 8:03and the endless moonscapes were all part of the post-WW2 scenery.
- 8:07Here’s how Keith Richards, a legendary guitarist for the Rolling Stones,
- 8:10described a post-war life in the U.K.
- 8:14“Rationing lasted until 1954, so World War Two
- 8:20went on for people of my generation for another
- 8:25nine years after it finished everywhere else.
- 8:29I remember when I first went to school, for months and months
- 8:32you got a bottle of concentrated orange juice—that was
- 8:34the only time you saw it—against the scurvy.
- 8:39Used to come in medicine bottles in England;
- 8:41you’d get them from the school medical services.”
- 8:45The Soviet Union plunged into famine.
- 8:48The lack of equipment and workers was compounded by drought.
- 8:50People were trying to survive by eating scraps.
- 8:56There’s no official count of the hunger victims.
- 8:59Historians suggest that at least
- 9:01100s of 1,000s of people succumbed to it.
- 9:04In the winter of 1946/47, Germany was afflicted with starvation, too.
- 9:09Some even coined a pun on the national anthem’s lyric.
- 9:12“Deutschland, Deutschland ohne alles!”
- 9:14(lit. Germany, Germany without anything)
- 9:16The original line was: “Deutschland, Deutschland über alles!✠” (lit. above everything).
- 9:21Most city dwellers were consuming a sub-1,000-calorie diet.
- 9:26They staged labor strikes and protest rallies
- 9:29like the one that took place in Hamburg on May 9, 1947.
- 9:32The poster reads: “One can’t work on 800 calories.”
- 9:39Asia was affected as badly as Europe.
- 9:44China saw a staggering 20 to 35 million people dead.
- 9:50Even Japan’s surrender failed to bring peace to China.
- 9:54The liberation effort targeting the Japanese occupiers descended into a civil war
- 9:58fought between the U.S.-backed Chiang Kai-shek army
- 10:03and the Soviet-supported communists.
- 10:06The three-year war led to the formation of mainland China
- 10:11run by the Communist Party and the independent democratic Taiwan.
- 10:16The two spent decades vying for the right to be called China.
- 10:19Up until 1971, Taiwan represented China in the U.N.
- 10:22It was internationally recognized as China.
- 10:25Mainland China, by contrast,
- 10:27was regarded as the abode of the communist separatists.
- 10:30Japan’s Hiroshima and Nagasaki were flattened in the atomic bombings.
- 10:34Other large cities were bulldozed in the air strikes.
- 10:38Tokyo was almost wiped off the map.
- 10:41Japan lost a substantial portion of its manufacturing industry.
- 10:44The U.S. Navy’s blockade of the Japanese islands
- 10:48led to food shortages, exacerbated by the heavily
- 10:51strained crops of rice, a staple food product in Japan.
- 10:56The locals were saved from starvation
- 10:58by the U.S. food supplies that started in 1946.
- 11:02!Tehran, Yalta & Potsdam!
- 11:03It was in the fall of 1943 that the Allies began mulling a post-war future.
- 11:09The Red Army blew out the German forces at the Battle of Kursk.
- 11:12Smolensk and Kyiv were liberated.
- 11:15The Allies defeated the Germans in Africa and landed in Italy.
- 11:20Benito Mussolini’s fascist regime fell.
- 11:24The Americans were victorious in the Battle of Midway
- 11:27and the Guadalcanal campaign.
- 11:30The winning streak set the stage for the first of the Big Three conferences.
- 11:36The Tehran event featured the leaders of the anti-German coalition:
- 11:39Franklin D. Roosevelt, Winston Churchill, and Joseph Stalin.
- 11:43They mostly focused on military strategy, specifically, the opening of the second front in Europe.
- 11:48But it was at that conference that they began sharing
- 11:52their vision of the post- war world order.
- 11:55The second meeting took place in Yalta in 1945.
- 11:58It wasn’t about who was going to win. It was about when.
- 12:02Nazi Germany was almost on the ropes.
- 12:05The Red Army was closing in on Berlin from the east.
- 12:09The British and American forces were about to cross the Rhine in the west.
- 12:14The Big Three almost unanimously agreed
- 12:16on Germany’s post-war future as they decided
- 12:19to divide it into four military occupation zones controlled
- 12:23by the Soviets, the Americans, the British, and the French.
- 12:27By that time, France had already been liberated. It joined the future winners,
- 12:32even though Charles de Gaulle wasn’t invited over to Yalta.
- 12:36Poland was a much more complicated issue.
- 12:39The war started with Germany invading Poland.
- 12:43Britain and France got involved to protect their ally.
- 12:48But now Poland was occupied by the Soviet troops.
- 12:51Its eastern regions were annexed to the USSR
- 12:55under the secret additional protocol of the Molotov–Ribbentrop Pact.
- 13:00Vyacheslav Molotov, the co- signatory of the agreement,
- 13:03had joined Stalin for the winners conference in Yalta.
- 13:06The Allies had to negotiate a deal.
- 13:09In the end, they recognized Poland’s former eastern provinces
- 13:16as part of the USSR, although Białystok was returned to Poland.
- 13:22Lviv, Eastern Galicia, Brest, and Vilnius were acknowledged as the constituent parts
- 13:26of Ukraine, Byelorussia, and Lithuania under the Soviet Union.
- 13:32The resulting Soviet–Polish border nearly matched the Curzon Line
- 13:38proposed shortly after WW1.
- 13:42To make up for the territorial losses,
- 13:44Poland’s western border was moved further westward.
- 13:48Many former German cities were incorporated into Poland.
- 13:53Those included Silesia and Wrocław (former Breslau)
- 14:00and Pomerelia, a crucial former Prussian province hugging the southern Baltic coast.
- 14:06Poland also got the former Free City of Danzig, renamed Gdańsk.
- 14:13The next summit featuring the three leaders took place in July 1945 after WW2 had ended in Europe.
- 14:18It was a full-fledged winners conference.
- 14:25Support the release of part two of my book on WW2.
- 17:01The Allies were tasked with picking up a location.
- 17:06Berlin was heavily damaged by the war,
- 17:08with no fitting intact structures capable of hosting a conference.
- 17:11Yet convening far away from the fallen capital city of Germany
- 17:15would be an odd call for the victors.
- 17:18They ended up choosing this country manor,
- 17:21Cecilienhof Palace in Potsdam.
- 17:25A Berlin suburb, the place was only
- 17:28a 20-kilometer tank ride away from the Reichstag.
- 17:32Potsdam was a storied location.
- 17:34For several centuries, the city served
- 17:38as the country residence of the Prussian kings.
- 17:42That’s why, in March 1933, the Nazis,
- 17:45who had only just come to power, chose to hold
- 17:48their grand ceremonial event here, in Potsdam.
- 17:51The ceremony culminated in the symbolic handshake between
- 17:54the newly appointed Reich Chancellor Adolf Hitler
- 17:56and the elderly Reich President Paul von Hindenburg.
- 18:00According to the ceremony's architect, Joseph Goebbels, the handshake
- 18:04was meant to symbolize the link between Prussian history and National Socialism.
- 18:09It turns out that Potsdam was the birthplace of the Third Reich.
- 18:13And it was here, too, that the victorious Allied powers were to lay it to rest.
- 18:18Cecilienhof was built in the mid-1910s by Germany's
- 18:23last Kaiser, Wilhelm II, for his heir—Wilhelm Jr.
- 18:27Shortly after the palace was completed, Germany lost WW1,
- 18:31a revolution broke out, and the ruling dynasty was deposed.
- 18:37But Wilhelm Jr.—the former Crown Prince—resided here
- 18:39until almost the very end of WW2.
- 18:43The palace emerged from the fighting unscathed
- 18:45and was perfectly suited to host the conference.
- 18:48Potsdam had been occupied by Soviet forces, so responsibility
- 18:53for organizing the conference fell to the Soviet side.
- 18:57The preparations had to be completed on an extremely tight deadline.
- 18:59The decision to hold the meeting was reached in late May,
- 19:03and the conference kicked off on Jul. 17.
- 19:06In the span of just six weeks, the NKVD officers in charge
- 19:09of the preparations completely renovated the palace,
- 19:12brought in furniture from Moscow—including the round table
- 19:15used for the negotiations—set up new flower beds,
- 19:18planted trees in the garden outside the building,
- 19:22prepared villas to accommodate the delegations,
- 19:24and cleared the entire surrounding area of landmines.
- 19:27In addition, some 800 km (500 mi) of railway track
- 19:31stretching from the Soviet border all the way to Potsdam
- 19:33had to be regauged to fit the broader Soviet standard.
- 19:37Stalin would famously avoid air travel
- 19:39(with the sole exception of a round-trip wartime flight between Baku and Tehran),
- 19:43so he journeyed to the Potsdam Conference on board a special train.
- 19:48Or rather, three trains.
- 19:50The train carrying the Soviet dictator was preceded
- 19:53and followed by trains loaded with security personnel.
- 19:57An additional 17,000 NKVD troops were deployed to guard the railway line along the entire route.
- 20:02Stalin arrived in Berlin on Jul. 16,
- 20:05whereas his counterparts had turned up the day before.
- 20:07Incidentally, speaking of the participants,
- 20:09a glance at the newsreels and photos from Potsdam reveals
- 20:12perhaps the most striking difference between
- 20:16this conference and those at Tehran and Yalta:
- 20:18the Big Three—Stalin, Roosevelt, and Churchill—saw a major reshuffle.
- 20:24U.S. President Franklin D. Roosevelt had died in April 1945.
- 20:28He was succeeded by VP Harry S. Truman,
- 20:32who led the American delegation at Potsdam.
- 20:36As for the British delegation, mid-conference,
- 20:39PM Winston Churchill was replaced by Clement Attlee.
- 20:45The reason was simple. Old Winston—the national hero
- 20:48who had led Britain to victory in the war—had lost
- 20:51the general election.
- 20:52The votes were counted up in late July, with the conference still in full swing,
- 20:56and Churchill had to surrender his seat at the negotiating table
- 21:00to the newly minted prime minister.
- 21:03The conference attendees recollected that the news had come as a shocker to Stalin,
- 21:07who could scarcely comprehend how such a thing was even possible.
- 21:11But that’s how democracy works.
- 21:13Your track record, however stellar, doesn’t guarantee you the continued support of the voting public.
- 21:19At the Potsdam Conference, the Allies
- 21:22reaffirmed the decisions they’d already reached at Yalta.
- 21:25Germany was divided into four occupation zones:
- 21:27the Soviet zone in the east, the British zone in the north, the American zone in the south,
- 21:32and the smallest of them all—the French zone—in the west.
- 21:35The same division pattern was true for Berlin,
- 21:39making for a convoluted configuration.
- 21:41While deep into the Soviet-occupied zone,
- 21:44the city was still divided among the four Allied powers.
- 21:47To govern occupied Germany, the Allies established a special body:
- 21:51the Allied Control Council, with representatives from the Soviet Union, the U.S., Britain, and France.
- 21:55The Council continued its operations—at least formally—until 1990.
- 22:01The political requirements imposed on Germany boiled down to the "Four Ds":
- 22:05democratization, demilitarization, de-Nazification, and decartelization,
- 22:10that is, the dismantling of the industrial monopolies that had propped up the Nazi regime.
- 22:16Naturally, Germany was stripped of all the territorial gains it’d made
- 22:19under the Nazis, including the Saar, Austria, and the Sudetenland.
- 22:23The Saar became a French protectorate.
- 22:25Austria regained its status as an independent state.
- 22:27The Sudetenland was restored to Czechoslovakia.
- 22:29Königsberg, however—the former capital of East Prussia—was
- 22:33added to the Soviet Union and soon renamed Kaliningrad.
- 22:37The Potsdam Conference concluded on Aug. 2, 1945.
- 22:41Its decisions weren’t regarded as set in stone once and for all.
- 22:44The expectation was that a comprehensive peace conference would later be convened
- 22:48to determine Germany's long-term future and the final status of its territories,
- 22:52including those that’d been transferred to other countries.
- 22:54But that conference never materialized.
- 22:59Before long, the former Allies had squared off in the Cold War.
- 23:05In fact, the first chill was already palpable here
- 23:10in Potsdam in the summer of 1945.
- 23:12Just one day before the conference opened,
- 23:13the U.S. successfully tested an atomic bomb.
- 23:17The nuclear arms race had teed off.
- 23:24Germany wouldn’t be reunified for a long time.
- 23:27What had been intended as a temporary solution
- 23:30gradually grew into permanent statehood.
- 23:32In 1947, the U.S. and the U.K. merged their occupation zones to create the Bizone.
- 23:37In 1948, the French zone joined them, forming the Trizone,
- 23:42which would later become the Federal Republic of Germany (West Germany).
- 23:47The Soviet occupation zone, meanwhile, evolved into East Germany, or the German Democratic Republic.
- 23:51The entire postwar international order—with its division of spheres of influence
- 23:56between the Western and socialist blocs—proved remarkably durable.
- 24:00It came to be known as the Yalta, or Yalta–Potsdam, system.
- 24:05To be sure, each of the powers at these conferences pursued its own national interests.
- 24:09But they also shared a common objective:
- 24:11to prevent another world war—one that, in the nuclear age,
- 24:13might well have been humanity's last. And succeed they did.
- 24:18And that set Europe on course for decades-long peace.
- 24:21!Nuremberg Trials!
- 24:24There’s a paradoxical flip side to the wave of nationalism
- 24:27that swept Europe at the turn of the 20th century.
- 24:32Every form of nationalism seems to go hand in hand with ressentiment.
- 24:36No one has yet managed to concoct a narrative of national superiority
- 24:40without first invoking some national trauma, humiliation,
- 24:43or grievance against neighboring peoples.
- 24:46In a sense, Europe was the perfect breeding ground.
- 24:49Its borders resulted from countless wars, conquests, partitions,
- 24:54territorial rejigs, secessions, unions, and the often
- 24:58highly questionable settlements imposed by the victors
- 25:01on the vanquished after yet another conflict.
- 25:04It was difficult to find a place that wouldn’t have been disputed.
- 25:08Countries had ethnic enclaves in neighboring states,
- 25:11and, at some point in the recent past,
- 25:14many of them lost territory—almost invariably
- 25:18in circumstances its citizens viewed as profoundly unjust.
- 25:23Such narratives could easily fuel war.
- 25:27Our ancestral land, the argument goes, belongs to someone else.
- 25:31Our people are being governed by a foreign state,
- 25:35where they are oppressed and persecuted.
- 25:37We were once a great nation, stretching all over the place,
- 25:41and now we’ve been reduced to an insignificant dot on the map.
- 25:44The idea of compensating for national humiliation
- 25:47through territorial conquest, of restoring historical justice
- 25:52by redrawing borders and reunifying divided peoples
- 25:56not only captivated the masses in many European countries
- 26:01ahead of WW2 but also won sympathies abroad.
- 26:07When Hitler annexed Austria and demanded
- 26:10the Sudetenland from Czechoslovakia,
- 26:13was this regarded as an act of aggression?
- 26:15The prevailing consensus at the time was that
- 26:18it was merely a question of where the border
- 26:21between Germans and Germans should be officially marked.
- 26:24The people of the Sudetenland, Austria, and Germany shared
- 26:27the language and the cultural heritage.
- 26:29Their unification within a single state could,
- 26:32therefore, come across as an act of restoring historical justice.
- 26:37Hitler, the argument went, wasn’t going
- 26:38after somebody else's land—he was simply reuniting his own people.
- 26:42One of the central lessons of WW2 was the recognition
- 26:47that the pursuit of historical justice and revenge
- 26:50for past grievances was a process that was
- 26:52all too easy to embark on but almost impossible to stop.
- 26:55Once borders begin to shift—and once it’s encouraged,
- 26:59recognized, and legitimized—an emboldened aggressor pushes farther,
- 27:04and others soon set out to follow suit.
- 27:09The postwar consensus, which endured until 2014,
- 27:12rested on a different principle.
- 27:15Countries may go through a lot of things.
- 27:17They may break apart, unite, form alliances, or become rivals.
- 27:22But they mustn’t wage wars of aggression, alter borders by force,
- 27:26or seek to grab the land from their neighbors—no matter what higher
- 27:28conception of historical justice might be invoked to justify it.
- 27:33!Investigator Agency!
- 27:37On Nov. 20, 1945, the trial of the major Nazi war criminals
- 27:42commenced in the Palace of Justice in Nuremberg.
- 27:46Hitler, Goebbels, and Himmler had already taken their own lives,
- 27:50but others remained to be held accountable.
- 27:53One by one, under armed guard, the defendants
- 27:56were escorted into the courtroom—22 men in all.
- 28:00Why were they put on trial instead of being executed right away?
- 28:03That was explained by the chief U.S. prosecutor, Robert H. Jackson,
- 28:06in his opening statement.
- 28:50To ensure that the proceedings gained public outreach, journalists, photographers, and artists
- 28:55were invited for a total of 240 seats.
- 28:59The Soviet Union sent some of its most prominent
- 29:03journalists to Nuremberg, including Ilya Ehrenburg
- 29:06and Boris Polevoy, who reported extensively on the trial.
- 29:09The Nazi leaders were to be judged by a tribunal of prosecution
- 29:14teams from the Soviet Union, the U.S., the U.K., and France.
- 29:17The principal charges were these: conspiracy to wage aggressive war,
- 29:23crimes against peace, war crimes, and crimes against humanity.
- 29:29These were entirely new concepts in international law.
- 29:32They were formulated by Allied jurists specifically
- 29:35to encompass the unprecedented crimes committed by the Nazi regime.
- 29:40Trials of this kind are inevitably faced with a question:
- 29:42To what extent do the victors have the right to judge the vanquished?
- 29:46After all, the victorious powers had also killed civilians,
- 29:49destroyed cities, and violated the conventions of war.
- 29:52Why, then, were only the defeated sitting in the dock?
- 29:55Some of the victors themselves were acutely aware of this moral dilemma.
- 29:59Gen. Curtis LeMay, the American commander
- 30:01who led the bombing campaign against Japanese cities—including
- 30:05the annihilation of Hiroshima and Nagasaki—would later acknowledge:
- 30:09“If we had lost the war, we all
- 30:12would have been prosecuted as war criminals.”
- 30:15For that very reason, the defense went beyond denying the defendants' guilt.
- 30:20They focused on accusing the Allies of applying double standards.
- 30:24The argument was that the victors had simply written the rules after the fact
- 30:27and were now prosecuting the defeated for actions
- 30:29that they themselves had committed with comparable brutality.
- 30:32The prosecution, however, offered a fundamental rebuttal.
- 30:35True, war is almost inevitably accompanied by crimes committed on both sides.
- 30:39But it’s crucial to distinguish between one-off violations
- 30:43of the conventions of war and a deliberate state policy built
- 30:47around aggressive wars of conquest, the Holocaust,
- 30:50the establishment of a vast concentration camp system,
- 30:54and the systematic extermination of millions of people
- 30:58who posed no threat to Germany.
- 31:02The defendants included the most powerful figures of the Nazi regime.
- 31:06The principal defendant was Hermann Göring—founder of the Gestapo,
- 31:10Hitler's former designated successor, commander-in-chief of the Luftwaffe, and President of the Reichstag.
- 31:17Also in the dock were Joachim von Ribbentrop, the foreign minister;
- 31:22Field Marshal Wilhelm Keitel, Chief of the High Command of the Armed Forces;
- 31:26Alfred Rosenberg, the chief ideologue of Nazi antisemitism
- 31:29and Minister for the Occupied Eastern Territories;
- 31:32along with many others who’d helped set up the Nazi regime,
- 31:35masterminded its crimes, or carried them out—including
- 31:37military leaders, government officials, and SS officers.
- 31:43Despite the gravity of the charges, many of the defendants appeared surprisingly
- 31:46calm early into the trials. Some even looked bored.
- 31:50Vsevolod Vishnevsky, a Pravda contributor, expressed outrage that Keitel
- 31:54sat through the proceedings, casually munching on a chocolate bar.
- 31:58Boris Polevoy later recalled that Hitler's highest-ranked henchman,
- 32:02Rudolf Hess, spent his time reading detective novels.
- 32:05Others remembered Göring’s smirks and laughter,
- 32:08as well as the conversations and glances he exchanged with his fellow defendants.
- 32:13There’s an explanation for this seemingly surprising scene.
- 32:15The Nazi leaders were already positioned
- 32:17the best way they could realistically have hoped for.
- 32:19They could’ve easily been executed long before the trial even began.
- 32:23The fact that they weren’t mostly owed to Stalin.
- 32:25The idea of putting the leadership of the Third Reich on trial
- 32:28first emerged in Moscow in the spring of 1942,
- 32:31as the Red Army began liberating Soviet territory from Nazi occupation
- 32:34and unveiled the full scale of the atrocities committed
- 32:37by the Germans: mass murder, widespread destruction, systematic r_pe, and countless other crimes.
- 32:41The Soviet leadership promised that those responsible would face justice under the law.
- 32:44The Allies wanted much the same outcome—but without a trial.
- 32:47Both the British and the Americans proposed executing
- 32:50the Nazi leadership by virtue of their anticipated victory, without any judicial proceedings.
- 32:54According to the British ambassador, Sir Archibald Kerr,
- 32:58the Führer ought to have been hanged by a joint decision of Stalin, FDR, and Churchill.
- 33:03Stalin's response was: "We'll certainly get them hanged—but not until after a trial."
- 33:08It’s easy to see why the Western Allies favored summary executions.
- 33:11In their view, a trial could be a toss-up.
- 33:14It was about contesting the truth, with an outcome that wasn’t predetermined.
- 33:18Putting the Nazi leadership on trial carried real risks.
- 33:24In the end, however, the Soviet position prevailed.
- 33:27The Allies concluded that if executed without trial,
- 33:30the Nazi leaders would be martyred.
- 33:32A public trial, by contrast, would command greater respect
- 33:34and place the victors on higher moral ground than the defeated.
- 33:38During the London Conference in the summer of 1945,
- 33:40the Allies drafted the Charter of the International Military Tribunal
- 33:44and agreed on the list of defendants.
- 33:49As preparations got underway, however, it became clear
- 33:52that the trial would be nothing like what Stalin had envisioned.
- 33:56He had expected something resembling the Moscow show trials
- 34:00of the 1930s, a scripted and choreographed spectacle.
- 34:04The charges would be read, the defendants would confess,
- 34:08and the sentence would be carried out.
- 34:14No wonder the Soviet legal team was instructed by Andrei Vyshinsky,
- 34:18the chief prosecutor of the Moscow Trials.
- 34:21The Soviet delegation was led by Judge Iona Nikitchenko
- 34:25and Chief Prosecutor Roman Rudenko, both veterans of Stalin's political purges.
- 34:32Rudenko had overseen 1,000s of death sentences handed down without due process,
- 34:36while Nikitchenko had reportedly approved executions by telegram,
- 34:39often without even reviewing the defendants' case files.
- 34:42Those were the men entrusted with representing Soviet justice.
- 34:44The Soviet authorities hadn’t anticipated that the Western Allies
- 34:47would allow the defendants to challenge the prosecution,
- 34:51deliver witness testimony, and, perhaps most astonishingly,
- 34:54level accusations of their own.
- 34:57Nikitchenko proposed granting the prosecution
- 34:59veto power over defense witnesses,
- 35:02but the proposal was rejected.
- 35:04He also suggested limiting the proceedings
- 35:07to the presentation of the indictment and documentary evidence.
- 35:10That proposal, too, failed.
- 35:12At a dinner with the Allied delegations in Nuremberg,
- 35:16Vyshinsky even offered a toast to the defendants:
- 35:18“May they quickly leave the courtroom and arrive at the cemetery.”
- 35:21The Western judges raised their glasses before the toast had been translated.
- 35:24Afterward, they were horrified to find out
- 35:26that they’d unwittingly drunk to the defendants' execution
- 35:29before the trial had even properly begun.
- 35:32The Americans, British, and French had a fundamentally different concept of justice.
- 35:37To them, a criminal trial was an adversarial legal process.
- 35:39The defendants had defense counsel, were permitted to call witnesses,
- 35:42and were guaranteed the opportunity to speak in their own defense.
- 35:45They’d be able to make full use of those rights.
- 35:48Many of the accused shouldn’t have thought that they were doomed.
- 35:51On day one of the trial, Otto Stahmer, Hermann Göring's defense attorney,
- 35:56challenged the tribunal's legitimacy.
- 35:58First, he argued that the victors couldn’t be impartial judges.
- 36:03Second, he contended that the tribunal was applying the law retroactively,
- 36:06since launching and waging an "unjust war" hadn’t been defined as a criminal offense
- 36:11under any international agreement in force in 1939.
- 36:15This notion would become central to the defense strategy throughout the proceedings.
- 36:18Besides, some defendants denied any involvement in the crimes altogether,
- 36:23while others insisted that they’d merely been following orders.
- 36:29The defense also pointed out that the countries
- 36:31conducting the trial were hardly models of peaceful conduct themselves.
- 36:35In 1939, the Soviet Union had invaded Finland,
- 36:39while the Red Army occupied eastern Poland and the Baltic states.
- 36:44The devastating bombings of Dresden, Hamburg, Tokyo,
- 36:48and other cities had killed 10s of 1000s of civilians,
- 36:52and the atomic bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki claimed tens of thousands more.
- 37:00These, too, were arguments the defense would mount at the Nuremberg Trials.
- 37:05The prosecution, however, countered that Germany
- 37:08had undertaken a binding international obligation in 1928
- 37:12not to resort to war as an instrument of national policy.
- 37:14Moreover, the Nazi regime had systematically violated
- 37:18the Hague and Geneva Conventions.
- 37:23German leaders knew perfectly well
- 37:24that murdering POWs and civilians was prohibited.
- 37:27It was at Nuremberg that jurists first introduced
- 37:31the legal concept of crimes against humanity.
- 37:34That was one of the tribunal's most controversial aspects,
- 37:37its apparent breach of the fundamental
- 37:40legal principle of “nulla poena sine lege.”
- 37:43If conduct can be declared criminal only after the fact, critics argued,
- 37:49then the very purpose of a judicial process is undermined.
- 37:53Virtually every modern legal system since the French Revolution
- 37:58has embraced the principle that criminal laws
- 38:02cannot operate retroactively.
- 38:05An act is punishable only if it was already defined
- 38:08as a crime at the time it was committed.
- 38:12Thus, the criticism of the tribunal wasn’t limited
- 38:14to the fact that the victors were judging the defeated.
- 38:17It also extended to the claim that the victors
- 38:19were inventing new charges after the fact
- 38:22and prosecuting civilian and military leaders for merely doing their job.
- 38:27Aware of this obvious challenge, the tribunal grounded
- 38:31its reasoning in the much older tradition of natural law.
- 38:36Although the term itself wasn’t invoked during the proceedings,
- 38:41the concept of crimes against humanity rested on precisely this idea.
- 38:45The Russian translation of the term is vague.
- 38:47The phrase “crimes against humanity" carries an important ambiguity.
- 38:53The expression can mean both crimes against
- 38:56the principle of humaneness and crimes against humankind.
- 39:01In English and French, the same wording
- 39:04naturally conveys both meanings.
- 39:08The underlying idea is that certain acts are inherently criminal,
- 39:11whether or not they’ve been formally codified.
- 39:14Above all, this includes the systematic mass extermination of people
- 39:18simply because of who they are,
- 39:20as well as the launching and waging of aggressive war.
- 39:23Far from violating the laws of individual states, these acts defy
- 39:28the fundamental principles upon which human civilization rests.
- 39:31Those principles stand above both national sovereignty and domestic legislation.
- 39:35The entire postwar concept of human rights
- 39:38would be predicated upon this premise.
- 39:41The same principles would later be invoked in the prosecution
- 39:43of war criminals from the former Yugoslavia and Rwanda.
- 39:45They also underpinned the international sanctions
- 39:48and diplomatic isolation imposed on South Africa's apartheid regime
- 39:53that ultimately contributed to its collapse.
- 39:57Even so, the prosecution at Nuremberg faced a formidable task.
- 40:01It wasn’t enough to demonstrate that the Third Reich had committed crimes.
- 40:05It also had to prove the personal guilt of each individual defendant,
- 40:08none of whom had any intention of ending up on the gallows.
- 40:12Every one of the accused began the trial with the same plea: “Not guilty.”
- 40:26They repeated it over and over again.
- 40:29Starting the war? We were attacked!
- 40:32The Soviet Union was about to attack us,
- 40:35so we were forced to strike pre-emptively.
- 40:38War crimes? Things happen in war.
- 40:41I was merely carrying out orders, just as any officer in the Allied armies was.
- 40:45Isn't that how your military works as well?
- 40:48The Holocaust? I knew nothing about it.
- 40:50And whatever I did know was simply the law of the land—I didn’t legislate it.
- 40:55The Soviet side realized far too late what kind of trial it was about to face.
- 40:59It began piecing together the evidence only two months
- 41:02before the proceedings began, working against the clock.
- 41:051,000s of documents had to be translated into German, French, and English,
- 41:09while documents submitted by the other delegations
- 41:12had to be translated into Russian.
- 41:14Just four days before the trial opened, Andrei Vyshinsky admitted that
- 41:18the Soviet prosecution hadn’t even drafted its opening statement
- 41:22and would need several more weeks to prepare it.
- 41:26Preparing for the trial was especially difficult for the Soviet delegation
- 41:31because nothing like that existed in the Soviet justice system.
- 41:35In Soviet courts—particularly in political cases—the defendant
- 41:40was almost never expected to contest the prosecution on equal footing.
- 41:44Defense witnesses, cross- examinations, and attempts
- 41:47to challenge the prosecution's evidence either had no
- 41:50meaningful effect on the outcome or were simply absent altogether.
- 41:55The purpose of the court was to rubber-stamp the ruling the Party leadership
- 41:59had already decided upon, not to seek the truth.
- 42:03In short, despite their extensive experience, Soviet prosecutors
- 42:06had virtually no experience preparing for a proper adversarial trial.
- 42:10They needed more time than they had.
- 42:12So, the Soviet delegation resorted to a simple expedient
- 42:16as they informed the Allies in Nuremberg that Roman Rudenko
- 42:19had suddenly come down with malaria.
- 42:23The ruse failed.
- 42:25The Allied judges realized they were being played and insisted
- 42:28that the trial commence on schedule, on Nov. 20.
- 42:31As Robert Jackson delivered his opening statement,
- 42:33the chief Soviet prosecutor, Roman Rudenko, was nowhere
- 42:36to be seen, diligently playing the part of a sick man.
- 42:39He wouldn’t show up in Nuremberg until several days later.
- 42:43Because the proceedings turned into a genuinely adversarial trial,
- 42:46some of the testimony that surfaced wasn’t to Stalin’s liking.
- 42:50Countering the charge of conspiring to launch a war of aggression,
- 42:54Joachim von Ribbentrop readily spoke about the secret protocol
- 42:56to the Molotov–Ribbentrop Pact of 1939,
- 42:58under which Hitler and Stalin divided Poland and carved up spheres of influence in Europe.
- 43:03The governments involved already knew about the protocol.
- 43:06The wider public did not.
- 43:09The very next day, newspapers were buzzing
- 43:12about the Soviet Union and Nazi Germany having secretly agreed to partition Poland.
- 43:15Shortly afterward, the defense and the American prosecutor
- 43:18Thomas Dodd leaked the text to the St. Louis Post-Dispatch.
- 43:25From that point on, outside of the Soviet Union,
- 43:28the secret protocol was an open secret, really.
- 43:32To say the least, it cast doubt on Moscow’s moral authority
- 43:35to prosecute the Nazi leaders for conspiracy to wage aggressive war.
- 43:38The defense argued that such accusations were hypocritical.
- 43:41Indeed, some of the defendants went even further, claiming that the pact
- 43:44had made the conquest of Poland possible in the first place.
- 43:46Put bluntly, they argued that without Stalin’s agreement,
- 43:49Hitler might never have dared to start the war.
- 43:53The morning after the publication of the secret protocol, Nikolai Zorya,
- 43:58the Soviet prosecutor responsible for presenting the case against Ribbentrop,
- 44:01was found dead in his hotel room.
- 44:04The Soviet delegation announced that he’d accidentally shot himself
- 44:08while cleaning his handgun. Virtually no one bought into it.
- 44:13“Up to this day, I’m convinced that
- 44:16while he may not have been murdered,
- 44:18he had no options to take his own life.
- 44:22Zorya was all too familiar with the Soviet punitive system
- 44:25he’d been a part of for many years.
- 44:27He realized that any mistake made on the world stage
- 44:32would inevitably carry tough punishment.
- 44:37Another major setback came when the Soviet prosecutors attempted
- 44:41to pin the Katyn massacre on the Germans.
- 44:46Suspecting that the Germans weren’t, in fact, responsible,
- 44:48the American, British, and French prosecutors
- 44:50had urged that the charge be omitted from the indictment.
- 44:53Stalin and Andrei Vyshinsky, however, insisted on including it.
- 44:56They believed that, amid the long list of Nazi crimes
- 44:58committed in Poland, the allegation would simply pass unnoticed
- 45:01and ultimately be incorporated into the tribunal's final judgment.
- 45:03The Allied powers would then endorse the Soviet claim
- 45:05that the Germans had murdered the Poles.
- 45:07Things went sideways.
- 45:09The Soviet prosecution presented fabricated evidence,
- 45:13while the defense called witnesses:
- 45:16officers from a German signals regiment that had been stationed near the Katyn Forest.
- 45:21They testified that in 1943, they were the ones who discovered the mass graves.
- 45:24According to their testimony, they’d never been ordered to execute Polish prisoners,
- 45:27while local residents had spoken of the killings having taken place in 1940,
- 45:30when the area was still under Soviet, not German, control.
- 45:33They also noted that their regiment had been dispersed
- 45:36across several locations at the time and couldn’t physically
- 45:40have scrambled to carry out the execution of 1,000s of people.
- 45:43The witnesses' testimony was sufficient to cast
- 45:46serious doubt on the Soviet case.
- 45:49In the end, the chief prosecutors decided to drop the Katyn charges
- 45:53from the tribunal's final judgment.
- 45:57But it wasn’t only the Soviet prosecutors who struggled in the courtroom.
- 46:00During cross-examination, Hermann Göring repeatedly
- 46:02made Robert Jackson appear unprepared and ineffective.
- 46:04When the American prosecutor asked why Germany
- 46:08had kept its military mobilization plans secret,
- 46:10Göring replied that he couldn’t recall the U.S.
- 46:13ever publishing its own mobilization plans, either.
- 46:16It wasn’t Jackson's first awkward exchange, and eventually
- 46:19he lost his composure, complaining to the judges
- 46:21about Göring's contemptuous attitude toward the tribunal.
- 46:25The court was forced to adjourn the session.
- 46:29Göring proved to be one of the tribunal's most defiant defendants.
- 46:32When he surrendered to the Americans, he’d initially believed that,
- 46:35as the former Reichsmarschall and commander-in-chief of the Luftwaffe,
- 46:38he’d be negotiating an armistice.
- 46:41It soon became clear, however, that he’d instead stand trial.
- 46:43So, Göring resolved to defend himself vigorously.
- 46:47He was trying his hardest to misrepresent the tribunal
- 46:49as a politically biased kangaroo court.
- 46:51He protested that he was being accused of waging aggressive war
- 46:54by the U.S., a country that, as he pointed out, had itself conquered half of Mexico.
- 46:57Like the other defendants, Göring denied virtually everything:
- 47:01any responsibility for the Nuremberg Race Laws, political assassinations,
- 47:04concentration camps, or the atrocities committed by the Nazi regime.
- 47:07He insisted that he’d merely carried out the Führer's orders as a loyal soldier
- 47:10and claimed that he had no knowledge of the Holocaust.
- 47:14“Our state was led by the Führer.
- 47:17We were to obey the orders issued by our head of state.
- 47:23We weren’t a criminal gang that’d assault people
- 47:25in the dark of the night.”
- 47:28During his interrogations by the Soviet investigators,
- 47:30Göring claimed that he’d always opposed a war with Russia.
- 47:32When he learned of Hitler's plans to invade the Soviet Union, he said,
- 47:35he’d been "horrified" and had tried to talk Hitler out of it.
- 47:38When that line of argument failed to impress,
- 47:39Göring told Rudenko that the Soviets themselves had deported more than
- 47:42one and a half million Poles and Ukrainians beyond the Urals.
- 47:45Later that same evening, he boasted to the American forensic psychologist
- 47:49about how skillfully he’d baited the Soviet prosecutor, adding with satisfaction:
- 47:51"I'll bet the old man Joseph will give him hell for that!"
- 47:55Hitler's former second-in-command also worked hard to cultivate
- 47:58a favorable impression among both the Allied observers and the public.
- 48:00Göring appeared in court wearing a gray tunic with gold buttons and polished military boots,
- 48:05making himself stand out from the other defendants.
- 48:07By then, he’d also had to wean himself off morphine and paracodeine.
- 48:12He’d slimmed down and looked noticeably healthier.
- 48:14Whenever photographers approached, he smiled and posed for their cameras.
- 48:17During questioning, he projected confidence and even charisma.
- 48:22None of this, however, would save him.
- 48:24The prosecution presented damning evidence proving Göring's responsibility
- 48:28for preparing Germany's war of aggression and for the persecution of the Jews.
- 48:32He’d been instrumental in creating the Gestapo,
- 48:34had proclaimed and enforced the Nuremberg Race Laws,
- 48:36had directed the systematic plunder of Jewish property,
- 48:39and had been Hitler's designated successor.
- 48:41The evidence linking him to the atrocities was overwhelming.
- 48:46At one point, the Reichsmarschall realized where the trial was headed.
- 48:49Unwilling to listen to the mounting evidence
- 48:51that’d underpin the devastating verdict,
- 48:54he simply removed his headphones, shutting out the translation.
- 48:58The tribunal was profoundly shaken by documentary footage
- 49:00filmed by the American and British forces
- 49:01at Dachau, Buchenwald, and Bergen-Belsen.
- 49:05The images were harrowing: piles of dead and emaciated prisoners too weak even to stand.
- 49:10Some of the defendants, too, appeared visibly disturbed
- 49:12as a spotlight illuminated their faces in the dimly light courtroom.
- 49:16Göring closed his eyes, Keitel turned away from the screen,
- 49:19and Rosenberg was seen trembling.
- 49:21Then came the documents that tied individual defendants to specific crimes.
- 49:24Göring had ordered the plunder of territories.
- 49:26Keitel had authorized the execution of POWs.
- 49:28Sauckel had organized the deportation of millions for forced labor.
- 49:31Albert Speer—Hitler's personal architect
- 49:34and Reich Minister for Armaments and War Production—adopted
- 49:37a very different defense strategy.
- 49:39Presenting himself as a repentant idealist who’d been deceived, he acknowledged
- 49:42the collective responsibility of the Nazi leadership for the crimes of the Third Reich.
- 49:47Speer had overseen Germany's wartime armaments industry,
- 49:49which relied on the forced labor of some seven million POWs,
- 49:52concentration camp inmates, and Ostarbeiter (forced laborers from Eastern Europe).
- 49:56100s of 1,000s died under appalling working conditions,
- 49:59making a death sentence appear all but inevitable.
- 50:03Yet Speer managed to combine an acknowledgment of collective guilt
- 50:07with an effort to downplay his own personal responsibility.
- 50:09He distanced himself from the other defendants, declared
- 50:12that he regarded Hitler as a criminal,
- 50:14and insisted that he’d known nothing about the Holocaust.
- 50:16For everything else, he said, he was deeply remorseful.
- 50:18At times, however, Speer seemed to overdramatize it.
- 50:20He claimed that toward the end of the war, he’d intended to assassinate Hitler
- 50:23by releasing poison gas into the Führer's bunker through its air intake—but
- 50:26that he couldn’t find a ladder tall enough to reach it.
- 50:28The other defendants sneered at the story.
- 50:33Meanwhile, the Soviet delegation learned from its earlier mistakes
- 50:35and soon found a more effective way to present its case.
- 50:39It screened its own documentary on the Nazi concentration camps,
- 50:41directed by Roman Karmen, which contained even more graphic
- 50:45and disturbing footage than the tape presented by the Americans.
- 50:49An even greater surprise awaited the defendants when
- 50:52Field Marshal Friedrich Paulus appeared as a witness.
- 50:55He was captured by the Red Army at Stalingrad in January 1943
- 50:59along with the remnants of Germany’s Sixth Army.
- 51:04He directly refuted the defense’s claim that Germany
- 51:06had launched a pre-emptive war against the Soviet Union.
- 51:09Paulus detailed his own role in preparing Operation Barbarossa,
- 51:13intended as a war of conquest and a way of colonizing Soviet territory.
- 51:17His testimony was widely reported in the Western media.
- 51:20Moscow swung the momentum their way and offset the damage
- 51:22caused by the earlier disclosure of the secret protocol to the Molotov–Ribbentrop Pact.
- 51:27The outcome of the trial would come as a surprise to the entire world.
- 51:31Contrary to what the Soviet delegation had wanted,
- 51:34the Nuremberg Trials didn’t sentence all of the defendants to death.
- 51:37In fact, three of them were acquitted,
- 51:39including the former economic minister, Hjalmar Schacht.
- 51:43Ahead of WW2, Hjalmar Schacht sent Hitler a letter warning that
- 51:47Germany's financial system couldn’t sustain a major war.
- 51:50When Hitler ignored his advice, Schacht resigned as president of the Reichsbank,
- 51:54retaining only the ceremonial job as minister without portfolio.
- 51:57In 1943, he left the government altogether.
- 52:00A year later, he was arrested on suspicion of involvement in the plot to assassinate Hitler.
- 52:05By the end of the war, Schacht was being held in a concentration camp.
- 52:08The judges concluded that Schacht should be acquitted.
- 52:12Merely involvement in Germany's rearmament of the 1930s, they ruled,
- 52:17didn’t prove his personal intent to wage aggressive war,
- 52:20and the prosecution had failed to produce evidence to that effect.
- 52:22The tribunal also acquitted the former diplomat Franz von Papen
- 52:26and Hans Fritzsche, an official with the Ministry of Propaganda.
- 52:29All of the judges, except Iona Nikitchenko,
- 52:31agreed that although Fritzsche had made anti-semitic statements,
- 52:35he hadn’t incited the murder of Jews.
- 52:38Seven other defendants received prison sentences ranging from ten years to life imprisonment.
- 52:43It was important to demonstrate— above all to the German public—
- 52:45that the proceedings weren’t a show trial and that
- 52:47individual defendants bore different degrees of responsibility.
- 52:50Albert Speer also succeeded in avoiding the death penalty.
- 52:54First, the prosecution failed to prove his personal involvement in the Holocaust.
- 52:58Second, his admissions of collective responsibility
- 53:01amplified his credibility before the court.
- 53:03Speer's strategy had worked.
- 53:05Even the forensic psychologist Gustave Gilbert
- 53:08came to believe that his remorse was genuine,
- 53:10while the American judge Francis Biddle described him
- 53:12as “the most human and decent” of all the defendants.
- 53:16Speer was sentenced to 20 years’ imprisonment.
- 53:19The tribunal sentenced 12 defendants to death by hanging.
- 53:24Among them were Hermann Göring,
- 53:26convicted on all counts of the indictment;
- 53:30Wilhelm Keitel, who insisted that he’d merely obeyed orders;
- 53:35Gen. Ernst Kaltenbrunner, an SS officer
- 53:38and one of the principal masterminds behind the Holocaust;
- 53:41and Julius Streicher, the publisher of Der Stürmer,
- 53:43whose relentless anti-semitic propaganda dehumanized Jews
- 53:46and openly called for their extermination.
- 53:49Another defendant, Martin Bormann, was sentenced to death in absentia.
- 53:58The executions were scheduled for just after midnight on Oct. 16, 1946.
- 54:02Reporters gathered around the gallows,
- 54:05which had been erected inside the gymnasium.
- 54:08Only three days earlier, American guards had been playing basketball there.
- 54:12Now the same hall would be used as a site for executing 11 convicts.
- 54:16A commotion erupted outside.
- 54:18Some called Göring's name, but none of the reporters understood what was going on.
- 54:24An hour behind schedule, the guards finally escorted
- 54:26the first convict, Joachim von Ribbentrop, to the gallows.
- 54:31The executions took about an hour and a half.
- 54:34One after another, Master Sergeant John C. Woods of the U.S. Army
- 54:37hanged ten convicts.
- 54:40Only then did the reporters learn why the proceedings had been delayed.
- 54:44Several hours earlier, Hermann Göring had swallowed a capsule
- 54:47of cyanide in his cell, choosing s__cide over execution.
- 54:51Whoever handed him the poison has never been conclusively identified.
- 54:56The Allies placed Göring's body in a coffin beside the gallows.
- 55:01Two days later, the bodies were cremated in Munich.
- 55:03Their ashes were scattered to prevent the graves from becoming places of pilgrimage.
- 55:11The Nuremberg Trials lasted 316 days.
- 55:16Over the course of 403 hearings, court clerks
- 55:18produced some 16,000 pages of transcripts.
- 55:21The judges combed through 1,000s of documents submitted by both the prosecution
- 55:25and the defense and heard testimony from 100s of witnesses.
- 55:26In the end, 19 defendants were convicted.
- 55:29Of course, that alone could never fully restore justice.
- 55:33After all, 100s of 1,000s of people were implicated.
- 55:35But, as Roman Rudenko observed, the tribunal was judging not only the individual defendants
- 55:40but also the organizations they’d created,
- 55:42as well as the inhumane ideologies and doctrines they’d promoted.
- 55:46That was the tribunal’s greatest significance.
- 55:48By presenting the public with the overwhelming evidence of the Third Reich's crimes,
- 55:53the proceedings became the first step in Germany's de-Nazification.
- 55:56It also created the framework for subsequent international tribunals,
- 55:59including those established for the former Yugoslavia and Rwanda.
- 56:04The Nuremberg Trials revolutionized international law
- 56:07by establishing aggressive war itself as a criminal act.
- 56:11For the first time, international justice recognized that not only murder but also
- 56:15the deliberate incitement of hatred and the dehumanization of victims could all entail criminal responsibility.
- 56:18This precedent became one of the cornerstones of modern international criminal law.
- 56:23Starting in 1946, one of its fundamental principles has been
- 56:26that launching a war of aggression is a crime,
- 56:29and so is carrying out criminal orders,
- 56:32inciting, aiding, or abetting atrocities.
- 56:37Albert Speer, whose life the tribunal spared, was released after
- 56:40serving his 20-year sentence. He lived for many years thereafter,
- 56:44publishing memoirs and giving numerous interviews in which
- 56:48he cultivated the image of a "good and remorseful Nazi,"
- 56:50an architect who’d been seduced by the evil genius.
- 57:20In 1981, he died a prosperous and lionized man
- 57:23as he suffered a stroke while on a date with a mistress.
- 57:28It wasn’t until years later that historians uncovered documentary evidence showing that
- 57:32Speer had deceived the world.
- 57:33He’d seen the plans for Auschwitz,
- 57:35had participated in the design of its crematoria,
- 57:38and had been involved in the plundering of Jewish property in Berlin.
- 57:40Incidentally, the Nuremberg Trials weren’t the only major postwar tribunal for war criminals.
- 57:45Equally well known is the Tokyo Trial,
- 57:47which prosecuted the military leaders and senior officials of the Japanese Empire.
- 57:51Seven of the 29 defendants were sentenced to death by hanging.
- 57:58In Nuremberg itself, a whole series of the Subsequent
- 58:00Nuremberg Trials was held between 1946 and 1949.
- 58:03They tried German physicians and judges.
- 58:06Those convicted included executives of the Krupp industrial conglomerate,
- 58:09which had supplied battle tanks to the German war effort,
- 58:11members of the Einsatzgruppen mobile killing units, and many others.
- 58:13!De-Nazification!
- 58:16These trials were only one element
- 58:18of the much broader campaign to de-Nazify Germany.
- 58:22After their victory, the Allies naturally outlawed
- 58:24the National Socialist German Workers' Party
- 58:26along with organizations such as the SS and the Gestapo.
- 58:28They repealed Nazi legislation and scrapped Nazi propaganda
- 58:31from the airwaves, newspapers, and school curricula.
- 58:34Eradicating Hitler's ideology from the minds
- 58:36of ordinary Germans, however, proved to be a mammoth task.
- 58:40By the end of the war, 8.5 million Germans had been members of the Nazi Party.
- 58:44Tens of millions more were linked to affiliated organizations.
- 58:48Some had served in the SS, others in the League of German Girls.
- 58:52Few of them felt any genuine remorse.
- 58:57The first challenge, therefore, was to determine the degree
- 59:00of responsibility of everyone who’d collaborated with the Nazi regime.
- 59:03To that end, the Allies established several categories of culpability.
- 59:06The responsibility of each individual was to be assessed
- 59:09by 100s of specially established panels, review boards, and committees.
- 59:14To facilitate the process, detailed questionnaires were created,
- 59:18which every adult German was required to fill out.
- 59:22The British questionnaire had 133 questions,
- 59:25with 131 questions posed by the American version.
- 59:28Each questionnaire had to be endorsed by people who personally knew the applicant.
- 59:32Although de-Nazification got off to a solid start,
- 59:35it gradually became mired in bureaucracy.
- 59:38The sheer scale was staggering.
- 59:40The British and the Americans collected 25 million questionnaires,
- 59:43far more than could realistically be processed one by one.
- 59:46There were simply too many former Nazi Party members
- 59:49to investigate individually.
- 59:55Meanwhile, former Nazis often cooperated with one another,
- 59:57providing favorable testimony on each other's behalf
- 59:59and helping one another dodge the sanctions.
- 1:00:02Amid the resulting administrative chaos, a black market even emerged
- 1:00:05for certificates attesting to a person's successful passage through the de-Nazification process.
- 1:00:08Besides, if everyone who’d collaborated with the Nazi regime
- 1:00:11were permanently barred from public employment,
- 1:00:13there’d be too few qualified people left to keep the country functioning.
- 1:00:16In the French occupation zone, e.g.,
- 1:00:18three-quarters of all German teachers were initially dismissed.
- 1:00:22Before long, however, they got rehired because
- 1:00:24there were simply no qualified replacements.
- 1:00:27The same problem arose throughout civil service.
- 1:00:30As a result, the occupying authorities frequently
- 1:00:32designated certain individuals as "useful Germans"
- 1:00:34and chose to overlook aspects of their Nazi past.
- 1:00:37This practice was followed by the American, British, French, and Soviet administrations alike.
- 1:00:42Thus SS Sturmbannführer Wernher von Braun went on
- 1:00:46to become the chief architect of the U.S. lunar program.
- 1:00:49Before his Saturn rockets carried astronauts into space,
- 1:00:51his V-2 ballistic missiles had been raining down on London.
- 1:00:55Likewise, Günther Quandt, an industrialist, member of the Nazi Party,
- 1:00:58former husband of Magda Goebbels, and a businessman who made
- 1:01:01extensive use of forced labor—was granted amnesty
- 1:01:04and classified merely as a "follower" of the Nazi regime
- 1:01:07because the British decided to take advantage of his expertise.
- 1:01:09The Soviet Union likewise made extensive use of what
- 1:01:11it called "trophy Germans"—German experts brought to the USSR.
- 1:01:15They enjoyed living conditions that most Soviet citizens could scarcely imagine.
- 1:01:19For example, physicist Gustav Hertz, winner of the 1925 Nobel Prize in Physics,
- 1:01:23lived on the former Romanov grand dukes’ estate at Sukhumi.
- 1:01:28Together with other German scientists,
- 1:01:30he helped lay the foundations of the Soviet nuclear program.
- 1:01:34Some of these specialists received the Soviet Union’s highest honors.
- 1:01:36Peter Adolf Thiessen, a former Nazi Party member,
- 1:01:40became a recipient of the Stalin Prize and the Order of Lenin.
- 1:01:44Meanwhile, the rocket-design team led by Helmut Gröttrup
- 1:01:48was given an entire island on Lake Seliger.
- 1:01:50They were permitted to bring furniture, carpets, paintings, and even their personal libraries from Germany.
- 1:01:56By the early 1950s, de-Nazification had been scrapped.
- 1:01:59100s of 1,000s of people were found guilty and punished.
- 1:02:02Most Germans, however, returned to ordinary life,
- 1:02:05resuming careers in the manufacturing industry,
- 1:02:07commerce, education, government, the armed forces, and the police.
- 1:02:12The process went so far that in 1966, Kurt Georg Kiesinger,
- 1:02:16a former member of the Nazi Party,
- 1:02:18became the third Chancellor of West Germany.
- 1:02:22Two decades after the war, around 1,800 former Nazis
- 1:02:24held senior positions in the Federal Republic,
- 1:02:29including 15 ministers and deputy ministers,
- 1:02:32100 generals and admirals, and 300 senior military officers.
- 1:02:36West Germany's first chancellor, Konrad Adenauer, summed up
- 1:02:39the dilemma with a famous remark: "I don't have any other Germans."
- 1:02:43Importantly, as an attempt to re-educate the German people,
- 1:02:47de-Nazification ultimately fell short of its ambitions.
- 1:02:49The reasons weren’t limited to the inconsistencies
- 1:02:52and double standards of the occupying powers.
- 1:02:55In the early years, many efforts were undertaken in good faith.
- 1:02:58The Americans, for instance, enlisted the renowned Swiss
- 1:03:01psychiatrist and psychologist Carl Gustav Jung,
- 1:03:04who concluded that virtually the entire German nation
- 1:03:06was mentally ill and required treatment.
- 1:03:09Jung endorsed the practice of compelling German civilians to visit
- 1:03:12former Nazi concentration camps and recommended expanding it.
- 1:03:16Germans were also forced to exhume mass graves with their bare hands.
- 1:03:21These measures, however, produced none of the desired effects.
- 1:03:24Some participants later suffered severe mental breakdowns
- 1:03:27or even took their own lives.
- 1:03:30Others emerged with growing resentment—toward both
- 1:03:32the occupying Allies and the victims of Nazism themselves.
- 1:03:37Rather than feeling remorse, many coped
- 1:03:40by repressing traumatic memories altogether.
- 1:03:44In the end, Germans had to confront their country's past
- 1:03:48and rebuild a moral framework that’d collapsed during the Nazi era.
- 1:03:52Accepting that one had been—even unwillingly—a participant in
- 1:03:55or accomplice to terrible crimes was extraordinarily difficult.
- 1:03:58Unsurprisingly, many denied any personal responsibility for decades.
- 1:04:04For a long time, Germans regarded the participants
- 1:04:07in the failed 1944 plot against Hitler as traitors.
- 1:04:11Likewise, many viewed Wehrmacht deserters with suspicion and contempt.
- 1:04:16When Chancellor Willy Brandt knelt before the memorial
- 1:04:20to the victims of the Warsaw Ghetto Uprising in 1970,
- 1:04:24nearly half of West Germans considered the gesture excessive.
- 1:04:29Only the generation that had grown up after Hitler's fall
- 1:04:32was able to examine Germany's past without
- 1:04:35the same burden of personal involvement or illusion.
- 1:04:39In 1985, West German President Richard von Weizsäcker
- 1:04:43became the first head of state to describe May 8—the day
- 1:04:46of Germany's surrender—as Germany's day of liberation
- 1:04:48from the dictatorship of National Socialism.
- 1:04:50In Italy, by contrast, the process of defascistization was considerably more lenient.
- 1:04:53After all, the Italians themselves had overthrown Benito Mussolini in 1943,
- 1:04:57after which the country joined the Allies.
- 1:05:00Moreover, Italy had experienced virtually no Holocaust before the German occupation:
- 1:05:03Italian Jews began to be deported to Nazi death camps
- 1:05:05only after Germany occupied northern Italy later that same year.
- 1:05:11Italian officials were nevertheless screened
- 1:05:14for collaboration with the fascist regime.
- 1:05:18The scrutiny was simply far less extensive than in Germany.
- 1:05:21About 140,000 people underwent investigation,
- 1:05:2313,000 were formally prosecuted,
- 1:05:26and only around 2,000 ultimately lost their jobs.
- 1:05:30What about Japan, though?
- 1:05:32The postwar reforms were supervised by the American occupation authorities.
- 1:05:35Japan's armed forces were dissolved, and what little
- 1:05:37remained of its military industry after the bombing campaign was dismantled.
- 1:05:42The onset of the Cold War and the rise of Communist China,
- 1:05:46however, put de-Nazification on hold.
- 1:05:48Japan became the U.S.’s principal strategic ally in Asia,
- 1:05:52and the occupation authorities reversed course.
- 1:05:54The Japanese Communist Party was suppressed,
- 1:05:55many left-wing politicians were imprisoned, and, conversely,
- 1:05:58numerous wartime figures convicted of war crimes were released.
- 1:06:05In 1955, those sentenced to life imprisonment
- 1:06:08at the Tokyo Trial who had survived were freed from prison.
- 1:06:15Some even returned to prominent public life.
- 1:06:21Okinori Kaya, for example, had served as Japan’s finance minister
- 1:06:25during the war and was appointed justice minister in the 1960s.
- 1:06:28Despite these developments, however, revanchist sentiment
- 1:06:31never dominated the political landscape in postwar Japan.
- 1:06:33The devastation of the war had left too deep an impression
- 1:06:37for most Japanese to wish to redo it.
- 1:06:39Militarism came to be associated not with national greatness
- 1:06:43but with the country's total destruction.
- 1:06:48Instead, Japan redirected its national ambitions
- 1:06:50from military expansion to economic expansion.
- 1:06:53The global success of companies such as Sony and Toyota
- 1:06:55proved to be a far more effective antidote to revanchism.
- 1:06:58!The Morgenthau Plan!
- 1:07:01But let’s get back to postwar Germany.
- 1:07:03Identifying former Nazis and putting them on trial was only part of the challenge.
- 1:07:06Another question loomed just as large:
- 1:07:08What price should the vanquished German people pay for Hitler's crimes?
- 1:07:12“There are two schools of thought—those
- 1:07:14who would be altruistic in regard to the Germans, hoping that
- 1:07:18by loving kindness to make them Christian again—and those
- 1:07:23who would adopt a much tougher attitude.
- 1:07:28Most decidedly I belong to the latter school.”
- 1:07:34When Franklin D. Roosevelt wrote these words—nearly a year before the war
- 1:07:36was over—the prevailing view among many
- 1:07:39Allied policy-makers was that Germany's economy should be dismantled,
- 1:07:42forcing the German population to struggle merely to survive.
- 1:07:46This thinking found its expression in the Morgenthau Plan, drafted by U.S.
- 1:07:50Secretary of the Treasury Henry Morgenthau Jr.
- 1:07:52He hailed from a family of German Jews:
- 1:07:55his father had been born in Mannheim
- 1:07:58before moving to the U.S. as a teenager.
- 1:08:02Here’s how it went. First, the Allies' objective should be
- 1:08:06the complete demilitarization of Germany immediately after victory.
- 1:08:10This included the total disarmament of both the German military and civilian population,
- 1:08:14the removal or scrapping of military equipment,
- 1:08:17and the dismantling of Germany's entire armaments industry,
- 1:08:20as well as other major industries that underpinned its military power.
- 1:08:25Second, Germany should be broken up
- 1:08:26into several independent states,
- 1:08:30with portions of its territory transferred to Poland and France.
- 1:08:35Third, the plan targeted the Ruhr, Germany's most
- 1:08:38heavily industrialized region in the west and southwest.
- 1:08:43It was regarded as the heart of German industrial strength
- 1:08:45and the engine of its war-making capacity.
- 1:08:49Under the proposal, every industrial asset in the Ruhr was to be
- 1:08:52dismantled or destroyed, its machinery removed,
- 1:08:56and its workforce forcibly displaced.
- 1:09:01The Ruhr itself would become an international territory administered by the U.N.
- 1:09:08According to Secretary of State Cordell Hull,
- 1:09:11who opposed the Morgenthau Plan, its implementation would’ve
- 1:09:14condemned at least 40% of Germany's population—roughly
- 1:09:1825 mln people—to death by starvation.
- 1:09:21In September 1944, FDR and Winston Churchill met at the Second Quebec Conference.
- 1:09:25Ahead of that meeting, Morgenthau drafted a memorandum entitled
- 1:09:29"Program to Prevent Germany from Starting a World War III."
- 1:09:34The conference culminated in Roosevelt and Churchill
- 1:09:37signing a memorandum agreeing that they were prepared
- 1:09:40to see Germany transformed into a predominantly agricultural country.
- 1:09:45but Morgenthau reportedly persuaded him by offering
- 1:09:47Churchill had initially opposed the proposal, American financial aid.
- 1:09:51Without U.S. loans, Britain faced the prospect of bankruptcy.
- 1:09:55Within days, details of the plan were leaked to the American press.
- 1:09:59It’s difficult to imagine a greater gift to Nazi propaganda.
- 1:10:02Goebbels scarcely had to embellish the story.
- 1:10:05The Jew Morgenthau wants to turn Germany
- 1:10:08into one vast potato field! Roosevelt and Churchill, he claimed,
- 1:10:12had endorsed a Jewish plan to exterminate the German people.
- 1:10:15The Nazi propaganda machine exploited the issue relentlessly.
- 1:10:19In December 1944, American intelligence reported to FDR:
- 1:10:25“The Morgenthau plan gave Dr. Goebbels the best possible chance.
- 1:10:29He was able to prove to his countrymen, in black and white,
- 1:10:33that the enemy planned the enslavement of Germany <...>
- 1:10:36The conviction that Germany had nothing to expect from defeat
- 1:10:41but oppression and exploitation still prevails, and that accounts
- 1:10:45for the fact that the Germans continue to fight.”
- 1:10:48Nevertheless, Roosevelt embraced the idea of dismantling Germany's
- 1:10:51industrial capacity all the way until his death in April 1945.
- 1:10:56His successor, Harry S. Truman, initially maintained the same policy.
- 1:11:00In May 1945, immediately after the end of the war in Europe,
- 1:11:03Truman approved Directive JCS 1067, which instructed
- 1:11:07the American occupation authorities not to take any steps aimed
- 1:11:11at restoring or strengthening the German economy.
- 1:11:16“You will take all practicable economic and police measures to assure
- 1:11:22that German resources are fully utilized and consumption held
- 1:11:24to the minimum in order that imports may be strictly limited
- 1:11:28and that surpluses may be made available for the occupying forces.”
- 1:11:32The directive prohibited the production of iron and steel,
- 1:11:35automobiles, and heavy industrial machinery.
- 1:11:38In the early years of the occupation, JCS 1067 served
- 1:11:40as the principal guide for the administration of the American occupation zone.
- 1:11:45Its implementation was closely supervised by officials from the U.S. Treasury Department,
- 1:11:49who became known as the "Morgenthau Boys."
- 1:11:53Their policies further aggravated the already desperate conditions in war-ravaged Germany,
- 1:11:57pushing many people to the brink of starvation and survival.
- 1:12:00The mass closure of industrial enterprises
- 1:12:03caused catastrophic unemployment.
- 1:12:08A typical illustration was the Blohm & Voss shipyard in Hamburg.
- 1:12:12Although the yard had been heavily bombarded and damaged during the war, its owners
- 1:12:16sought to resume operations by producing civilian goods.
- 1:12:20Instead, they were imprisoned.
- 1:12:22Thousands of Hamburg residents
- 1:12:25who might’ve found work there were left penniless.
- 1:12:29Economic policy in the Soviet occupation zone differed little in its immediate goals.
- 1:12:33Factories were nationalized. Industrial equipment
- 1:12:36was dismantled and shipped to the Soviet Union.
- 1:12:40The Soviets sent trainfuls of food, clothing, footwear,
- 1:12:45carpets—and 60,000 grand pianos.
- 1:12:50The German population, meanwhile, received only
- 1:12:52the portion of their own remaining supplies that the Soviet occupation authorities
- 1:12:56chose to distribute through the ration-card system.
- 1:12:59As a result, living standards in East Germany were just
- 1:13:01as catastrophically low as they were in the west.
- 1:13:04By 1947, it had become clear that things couldn’t continue that way.
- 1:13:09Executing the Morgenthau Plan
- 1:13:11in full would simply lead to mass starvation.
- 1:13:15Moreover, the policy of collective punishment and
- 1:13:18the creation of an impoverished, embittered Germany
- 1:13:21in the heart of Europe wouldn’t prevent another world war.
- 1:13:24If anything, it could only raise the odds.
- 1:13:27!The Marshall Plan!
- 1:13:31In March 1946, Winston Churchill delivered
- 1:13:36the historic speech in Fulton, Missouri,
- 1:13:39that’s thought to have marked the beginning of the Cold War.
- 1:13:44A year later, President Harry Truman presented his new doctrine to Congress.
- 1:13:48The U.S. would support its allies in a bid to contain
- 1:13:51the spread of communist regimes. It ushered in a new era.
- 1:13:56The former Allies of WW2 had now become rivals.
- 1:14:00Around the same time, George C. Marshall became
- 1:14:05U.S. Secretary of State.
- 1:14:06A career military officer, one of America’s most distinguished commanders,
- 1:14:09and a war hero, Marshall had coordinated the Allied strategy in the Pacific
- 1:14:13and had been named Time magazine’s Man of the Year for 1943.
- 1:14:18The mission assigned to the State Department
- 1:14:21reflected the new strategic reality.
- 1:14:23Its task was to counter the Soviet threat—not by
- 1:14:26military means but through economic policy
- 1:14:28in accordance with the Truman Doctrine.
- 1:14:32The first half of 1947 proved extraordinarily difficult
- 1:14:35for the whole of Europe, not just Germany.
- 1:14:38In the spring, France pleaded with the U.S.
- 1:14:41to supply emergency grain shipments.
- 1:14:43Shortly afterward, Italy also requested assistance.
- 1:14:46Britain, meanwhile, still required American financial aid
- 1:14:49as it struggled to balance its postwar economy.
- 1:14:52Against this backdrop, Marshall developed his proposal.
- 1:14:56The U.S., he argued, should do everything in its power to help stabilize
- 1:15:00According to Marshall, the policy didn’t target any country or doctrine.
- 1:15:05political stability, there could be no lasting peace.
- 1:15:18The U.S. would bankroll the relief effort
- 1:15:21for the countries devastated by the war by helping rebuild
- 1:15:23their cities, railroads, and industrial infrastructure.
- 1:15:26Marshall insisted that Germany
- 1:15:29must also be included in the program.
- 1:15:32At the time, the very idea of helping the German economy recover
- 1:15:36rather than extracting everything possible from it seemed deeply counterintuitive.
- 1:15:40Yet the Secretary of State was convinced that Europe could never achieve lasting
- 1:15:45stability and prosperity without a stable and productive Germany.
- 1:15:49In April 1948, the Marshall Plan was formally approved
- 1:15:53by Congress and signed into law by President Truman.
- 1:15:59Through the Marshall Plan, the United States
- 1:16:01was also addressing its own economic challenges.
- 1:16:04During the 1930s, the American economy had been a complete shambles.
- 1:16:08The fiscal and regulatory measures introduced
- 1:16:12by the FDR administration to combat the Great Depression
- 1:16:16had only made things worse.
- 1:16:18At the height of the Depression in 1933,
- 1:16:21official unemployment reached nearly 25%:
- 1:16:25roughly one in four working-age Americans was out of work.
- 1:16:29By 1940, the last full year before the U.S. entered WW2,
- 1:16:33unemployment had fallen to 14.5%.
- 1:16:35Although substantially lower than the 1933 peak,
- 1:16:38it was still extraordinarily high.
- 1:16:41In the first half of the 1930s, the US experienced net emigration.
- 1:16:45Between 1932 and 1935, around 123,000 people arrived to settle permanently,
- 1:16:50while nearly 262,000 left the country.
- 1:16:53And this was despite the fact that the US was still attracting
- 1:16:56tens of thousands of newcomers every year.
- 1:16:59The influx of refugees from Nazi Germany, which might have
- 1:17:03reversed the trend, did not begin until the second half of the decade.
- 1:17:06Then everything changed for the U.S.
- 1:17:09The war itself became a triumph of what economists later called "military Keynesianism."
- 1:17:12Unemployment fell well below its natural rate.
- 1:17:16By 1944, the U.S. unemployment rate had dropped to just 1.2%.
- 1:17:20America had gone from being a country
- 1:17:21with too few jobs to one with too few available workers.
- 1:17:25But it is important to understand what the wartime American economy actually consisted of.
- 1:17:28Government spending was overwhelmingly directed toward the defense sector.
- 1:17:34Millions of people were employed building ships
- 1:17:37that would later sink in battles against Japan,
- 1:17:40and manufacturing tanks for the Allies that would eventually
- 1:17:42burn at the Battle of Kursk—all financed by the U.S. government.
- 1:17:47In other words, much of the economy
- 1:17:49was devoted to non- productive wartime output.
- 1:17:54This wartime economic structure threatened to plunge
- 1:17:56the U.S. back into a slowdown once the fighting ended.
- 1:17:59Suddenly, there was no longer a need for so many tanks
- 1:18:02or such enormous industrial capacity.
- 1:18:03Millions of workers employed in defense industries
- 1:18:06faced the prospect of unemployment.
- 1:18:09Indeed, 1946 ended with a severe recession.
- 1:18:14U.S. GDP contracted by 11.5%, one of the sharpest declines
- 1:18:18in the nation's history—comparable to the lowest point of the Great Depression.
- 1:18:21At the same time, however, America's industrial capacity remained intact.
- 1:18:26Instead of lying idle, it could now be repurposed.
- 1:18:29Yet the U.S. faced not only economic challenges but political ones as well.
- 1:18:33Communist ideas enjoyed enormous prestige in postwar Europe.
- 1:18:36They had to be countered.
- 1:18:37The Red Army had liberated much of the continent,
- 1:18:41while the collapse of the far right inevitably strengthened the appeal of the hard left.
- 1:18:47The Marshall Plan, therefore, came with a number
- 1:18:52of significant political and economic conditions.
- 1:18:57Participating countries were expected to restore private ownership,
- 1:19:00reverse the wartime nationalization of the industries,
- 1:19:04embrace open-market economics, and provide the U.S.
- 1:19:06with detailed accounting of how the aid was spent.
- 1:19:09They were also required to join the emerging international monetary system
- 1:19:11and establish an official exchange rate between their currencies and the U.S. dollar.
- 1:19:14Most importantly, communist parties were expected to be excluded from the government.
- 1:19:18It was obvious that the Soviet Union would never accept such terms.
- 1:19:22Nevertheless, both the USSR and the countries of Eastern Europe were invited to participate.
- 1:19:26The Soviet government slammed the proposal.
- 1:19:29Soviet Foreign Minister Vyacheslav Molotov declared:
- 1:19:34“The Marshall Plan is nothing more than
- 1:19:37a malicious American scheme to buy Europe with dollars.”
- 1:19:44Under Soviet pressure, the countries of Eastern Europe
- 1:19:46also declined to participate.
- 1:19:49Finland likewise stayed out, unwilling to jeopardize
- 1:19:53its relationship with the Soviet Union.
- 1:19:55The nations of Western Europe, however, accepted the offer.
- 1:19:58Over the next three years, they received approximately $13B
- 1:20:00in American aid—equivalent to roughly $170B in today's money.
- 1:20:03The largest shares went to Britain, France, Italy, and West Germany.
- 1:20:07Historians continue to debate whether the Marshall Plan
- 1:20:11truly rescued Europe or merely accelerated an economic recovery that would’ve ensued anyway.
- 1:20:15Whatever the answer, the 1950s gave rise to two famous phenomena:
- 1:20:18the "German economic miracle" (Wirtschaftswunder) and the "Italian economic miracle."
- 1:20:22Within just a few years, the impoverished, half-starved populations of West Germany
- 1:20:26and Italy—many of whom had recently been homeless—were transformed into a middle class.
- 1:20:32In cities where, only a short while earlier, the water supply and sewer systems had barely functioned,
- 1:20:35public transportation had ground to a halt, and there’d been not enough coal to heat homes,
- 1:20:38a new consumer society began to emerge.
- 1:20:41!The Cold War!
- 1:20:43The Marshall Plan envisioned not only financial assistance
- 1:20:47for Europe but also its economic integration.
- 1:20:50It didn’t take long for that vision to begin taking shape.
- 1:20:53Exactly five years after Germany's surrender, on May 9, 1950,
- 1:20:58French Foreign Minister Robert Schuman proposed
- 1:21:02to the government of West Germany the creation
- 1:21:05of a Franco-German Coal and Steel Community,
- 1:21:09open to other European countries as well.
- 1:21:11West German Chancellor Konrad Adenauer accepted the proposal.
- 1:21:15Almost a year later, on Apr. 18, 1951, the Treaty of Paris
- 1:21:19established the European Coal and Steel Community (ECSC).
- 1:21:24Its founding members were France, West Germany, Italy,
- 1:21:27Belgium, the Netherlands, and Luxembourg.
- 1:21:30In later years, Denmark, Ireland, the U.K.,
- 1:21:33Austria, Sweden, and Finland would join them.
- 1:21:36Many of these countries had fought one another in WW2.
- 1:21:40Now they were choosing to unite so that they’d never again wage war.
- 1:21:46In 1957, the Treaties of Rome created
- 1:21:49the European Economic Community (EEC).
- 1:21:52In 1992, the European Union was born.
- 1:21:56To understand how profoundly WW2 transformed people's thinking,
- 1:22:00it’s worth recalling the ideas that prevailed after WW1—a conflict that,
- 1:22:04at least in much of the former Soviet historical narrative, has been largely overshadowed.
- 1:22:08Pre-revolutionary history is often treated as though it belonged to a distant age.
- 1:22:12Yet WW1 profoundly reshaped global consciousness,
- 1:22:16especially in Europe.
- 1:22:19For centuries, European states had fought one another almost continuously.
- 1:22:22There was scarcely a time when no wars were being fought
- 1:22:28somewhere on the continent.
- 1:22:30The First World War was a war of an entirely different kind.
- 1:22:34For the first time, Europe’s major powers mobilized virtually
- 1:22:36all their resources—their economies, industries,
- 1:22:40and populations—to ensure their survival. It was total war,
- 1:22:46with the very existence of states as sovereign entities at stake.
- 1:22:52The natural consequence of such a war was
- 1:22:54the triumph of ideas centered on national sovereignty:
- 1:22:57protecting one's borders, one's domestic market,
- 1:23:00one's industries, and one's national identity.
- 1:23:05The U.S. experienced a similar shift.
- 1:23:07Although they championed the creation of the League of Nations, the U.S. ultimately never joined it.
- 1:23:11In the aftermath of WW1, political currents gained strength
- 1:23:16that’d eventually evolve into the "America First" movement.
- 1:23:21Like, we are Americans. Our parents did not cross an ocean
- 1:23:25and build a new nation from scratch for nothing.
- 1:23:28They fled Europe because it’d always been
- 1:23:32a cursed continent—if not war, then genocide;
- 1:23:35if not genocide, then pogroms; if not pogroms, then revolutions.
- 1:23:38They cleared forests, settled wilderness,
- 1:23:41and fought Native American tribes precisely
- 1:23:44so they didn’t have to live there
- 1:23:47or be entangled in Europe's endless conflicts.
- 1:23:51Yet in WW1, we became involved in Europe's quarrels
- 1:23:55and lost more than 100,000 Americans in someone else's war.
- 1:23:59We must never allow that to happen again.
- 1:24:01Even if Europeans destroy one another entirely, that’s exactly why
- 1:24:04our ancestors left: to ensure that it wouldn’t be us who were being killed.
- 1:24:09This sentiment would resurface in the years that followed.
- 1:24:11During WW2, the American public strongly opposed any U.S. involvement.
- 1:24:16Importantly, the interwar period wasn’t only an era of rising nationalism
- 1:24:20but also an age of isolationism throughout the civilized world.
- 1:24:24International trade became more restrictive than ever.
- 1:24:27Countries imposed extremely high tariffs on foreign goods.
- 1:24:31Everyone sought to protect their own industries, produce
- 1:24:33as much as possible domestically, and shield both
- 1:24:37their economies and their markets from outside influence.
- 1:24:40The catastrophic consequences of WW2 made one thing unmistakably clear:
- 1:24:44deep interdependence and integration among nations
- 1:24:46posed no threat to their cherished sovereignty.
- 1:24:49On the contrary, they were the best protection—and
- 1:24:52perhaps the only reliable safeguard—against future wars.
- 1:24:54The European Coal and Steel Community was established precisely
- 1:24:56to bind Europe's industrial production together as tightly as possible.
- 1:25:00The idea was to ensure that no country could produce
- 1:25:02battle tanks, artillery shells, or even ammunition entirely on its own.
- 1:25:05If every nation depended on the others, none could wage war against them.
- 1:25:09And this was only one of the war’s many lasting takeaways.
- 1:25:13Another major one was the dramatic reduction of barriers to international trade.
- 1:25:18This gave rise to the globalized world we know today—the one
- 1:25:24that filled our closets with affordable clothing, brought us smartphones and the internet,
- 1:25:29and made international travel commonplace.
- 1:25:31That world emerged from the conviction
- 1:25:34that trade does more than create prosperity.
- 1:25:36It also helps prevent war.
- 1:25:39Dependence on one's neighbors isn’t a vulnerability.
- 1:25:41It’s what makes fighting them far less likely.
- 1:25:43At the height of the tariff wars in the late 1930s,
- 1:25:47just before the outbreak of WW2, international trade
- 1:25:50accounted for only about 14% of global GDP.
- 1:25:53During the war, that share dipped even further.
- 1:25:57Yet by 1960—just 15 years after the war—international trade
- 1:26:02was already generating roughly a quarter of the world's GDP.
- 1:26:06By 2000, it exceeded half of global GDP.
- 1:26:12The entire postwar era was marked by rapidly
- 1:26:15accelerating global economic integration.
- 1:26:18Technological progress undoubtedly played a major role, but innovation,
- 1:26:21from the shipping container to the global internet, followed,
- 1:26:25rather than caused, the world's growing interconnectedness.
- 1:26:28They were products of globalization, made possible because countries
- 1:26:31had become increasingly dependent on one another,
- 1:26:34not the reason globalization happened in the first place.
- 1:26:37Alongside the economic European Coal and Steel Community,
- 1:26:40a military alliance was also established.
- 1:26:42NATO, the North Atlantic Treaty Organization.
- 1:26:46Its 12 founding members included the U.S., the U.K., and France.
- 1:26:51In 1955, West Germany joined in.
- 1:26:54Just ten years after signing its instrument of surrender,
- 1:26:57Germany's former enemies had become its allies within the same military alliance.
- 1:27:00In response to these Western European institutions of integration,
- 1:27:04the Soviet Union created its own organizations
- 1:27:06within its sphere of influence in Eastern Europe.
- 1:27:09The question of establishing that sphere of influence
- 1:27:11had already been discussed at the Tehran and Yalta conferences.
- 1:27:14For the Western Allies, it was crucial
- 1:27:16to secure Soviet participation in the war against Japan,
- 1:27:19and they were willing to make concessions to achieve that goal—including
- 1:27:22recognizing Soviet dominance over Eastern European countries,
- 1:27:25many of which were already occupied by the Red Army.
- 1:27:30For Moscow, meanwhile, creating a belt of satellite states
- 1:27:36along its western frontier was essential as a buffer against any future major
- 1:27:40European war—whether defensive or offensive.
- 1:27:44In his memoirs, Winston Churchill described how,
- 1:27:46during negotiations with Joseph Stalin in Moscow in October 1944,
- 1:27:50they divided spheres of influence on a simple sheet of paper:
- 1:27:54Romania—90% to Russia, 10% to the others;
- 1:27:58Greece—90% to Britain, 10% to Russia;
- 1:28:02Yugoslavia—50%–50%; and so on.
- 1:28:04Churchill later recalled asking,
- 1:28:06"Might it not seem rather cynical if it appeared
- 1:28:08that we had disposed of these issues, so vital to millions of people,
- 1:28:13in such an offhand manner?" He suggested burning the paper.
- 1:28:17Stalin, however, asked that it be kept.
- 1:28:20It still exists today and is preserved in the British archives.
- 1:28:25By the end of the decade, the socialist bloc in Eastern Europe had taken its final shape.
- 1:28:31The Soviet Union, Albania, Bulgaria, Hungary, Poland, Romania, and Czechoslovakia
- 1:28:36were united within the Council for Mutual Economic Assistance (Comecon).
- 1:28:40East Germany joined the organization the following year.
- 1:28:44In 1955, in response to the creation of NATO, the Warsaw Pact
- 1:28:48was set up as the military alliance of the Eastern Bloc.
- 1:28:50East Germany was among its members.
- 1:28:52Three European countries, however, remained outside both blocs:
- 1:28:56Yugoslavia, Austria, and Finland—each for its own reasons.
- 1:28:58Yugoslav dictatorial leader Josip Broz Tito broke with Stalin
- 1:29:03as early as 1948 and refused to follow Moscow's lead.
- 1:29:07Yugoslavia remained a socialist state but never joined the Warsaw Pact,
- 1:29:11later becoming one of the leading members of the Non-Aligned Movement.
- 1:29:16Austria, meanwhile, remained divided
- 1:29:19into Soviet, American, British, and French occupation zones
- 1:29:22for an entire decade after the war, much like Germany.
- 1:29:25In 1955, however, the occupying powers agreed to withdraw their troops
- 1:29:30in exchange for Austria's commitment to permanent neutrality.
- 1:29:35Austria never joined NATO, and even its accession
- 1:29:38to the European Union in 1995 was preceded by extensive domestic debate
- 1:29:42and a membership process that lasted nearly five years.
- 1:29:46After its painful war with the Soviet Union,
- 1:29:48Finland lost part of its territory but preserved its independence.
- 1:29:51It remained a liberal democracy while carefully avoiding
- 1:29:54any foreign policy decisions that might provoke Moscow,
- 1:29:59including joining NATO.
- 1:30:02Finland wouldn’t become a member of the alliance until 2023,
- 1:30:06following Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine.
- 1:30:09This approach to foreign policy—adjusting a smaller country's actions to accommodate
- 1:30:12the wishes of a much more powerful neighboring state—would later
- 1:30:14come to be known as "Finlandization."
- 1:30:17After the war, the world was divided into two opposing blocs:
- 1:30:20the Western, capitalist bloc and the Eastern, socialist bloc.
- 1:30:24On several occasions, they came perilously close to the brink of war.
- 1:30:26In 1961, Soviet and American battle tanks
- 1:30:29faced each other in Berlin at point-blank range.
- 1:30:31But neither side would open fire.
- 1:30:33A year later saw the Cuban Missile Crisis,
- 1:30:35when the world came within a hair's breadth of nuclear war.
- 1:30:41Yet each time they approached the threshold of a WW3,
- 1:30:44leaders on both sides—Western and Soviet alike—pulled back. A paradox emerged.
- 1:30:50At the height of the Cold War, despite the intense confrontation between
- 1:30:54two rival ideological systems, the world was in many ways
- 1:30:59a safer place than it’d been during the first half of the 20th century.
- 1:31:03The bleakest way to view the nuclear age is neither
- 1:31:07political, nor economic, nor even humanitarian.
- 1:31:11It’s evolutionary.
- 1:31:14In the span of just 10,000 years of building civilization,
- 1:31:17our species created a technology capable
- 1:31:21of bringing about its own extinction.
- 1:31:23Not only did we create it, we placed it in the hands of a small number of individuals
- 1:31:26who are accountable to almost no one and constrained
- 1:31:29by little other than fear for their own survival.
- 1:31:32Humanity has taken comfort in the idea of nuclear deterrence.
- 1:31:36During the Cold War, both superpowers—the U.S.
- 1:31:39and the Soviet Union—quickly developed the means to guarantee each other's destruction.
- 1:31:44Under this view, we owe our long peace to that balance of terror:
- 1:31:47the great powers could no longer wage war against one another
- 1:31:50without risking the destruction of the entire planet.
- 1:31:55In reality, however, we can’t say with certainty whether nukes
- 1:31:59have saved humanity or merely postponed its destruction.
- 1:32:02The reason is simple. They’ve been around for only a very short time.
- 1:32:06The entire history of nuclear weapons—from their first and,
- 1:32:09so far, only wartime use by the U.S. against Japan
- 1:32:12to the present day—has unfolded within the lifetime of a single generation.
- 1:32:15For that reason, we’d be misguided to attribute
- 1:32:18extraordinary deterrent powers to this technology.
- 1:32:20It’s equally misguided to claim that nuclear war is impossible
- 1:32:26simply because it hadn’t occurred during the past 80 years.
- 1:32:29What WW2 did make unmistakably clear is this.
- 1:32:32Humanity now possesses the ability to wage wars
- 1:32:34with consequences catastrophic enough to threaten its own survival.
- 1:32:37!Sole Winners!
- 1:32:41The only major WW2 belligerent that truly emerged victorious was the U.S.
- 1:32:47It was the war that transformed America into a superpower
- 1:32:50and the world’s leading economic center.
- 1:32:53The reason was simple. The U.S. was the only major industrialized nation
- 1:32:57whose economy and infrastructure remained largely intact.
- 1:33:00The industrial capacity that, under other circumstances,
- 1:33:04might’ve been reduced to rubble was instead perfectly
- 1:33:07positioned to supply a Europe lying in ruins.
- 1:33:11From 1945 through the 1960s,
- 1:33:15even considering postwar fluctuations, the U.S. economy
- 1:33:18more than doubled in nominal terms.
- 1:33:21Adjusted for inflation, it grew by a factor of 1.5.
- 1:33:23This wasn’t only because American industry
- 1:33:26supplied much of the world's demand.
- 1:33:27The American labor market also attracted the most energetic
- 1:33:32and ambitious people—those willing to work hard, take risks,
- 1:33:35and leave a devastated Europe behind in search of a new life.
- 1:33:40Its industrial dominance, combined with access to stellar human capital,
- 1:33:44made the U.S. the world's economic hegemon,
- 1:33:47while the U.S. dollar became the world's only truly
- 1:33:50global reserve currency for the next half century.
- 1:33:53This is one of the most instructive lessons of WW2.
- 1:33:58The conflict ultimately elevated to global dominance the country
- 1:34:03that chose to invest in territories rather than conquer them.
- 1:34:07That outcome ran completely counter to the logic of virtually every previous war.
- 1:34:11Before WW2, one didn’t even need
- 1:34:13to study history in detail to determine who’d won.
- 1:34:16It was enough to compare a political map
- 1:34:18from before the war with one from after it.
- 1:34:20Whichever country had expanded its territory was the victor.
- 1:34:23The Soviet Union acquired more territory than any other party to the war.
- 1:34:26It retained the lands it’d gained during its brief alliance with Nazi Germany—including
- 1:34:30eastern Poland, with its fertile farmland and favorable climate,
- 1:34:34and the Baltic states. But it also received
- 1:34:37the northern part of East Prussia,
- 1:34:38today's Kaliningrad Region, complete with its infrastructure.
- 1:34:44The Soviet Union also stripped the defeated Germany of virtually everything it could.
- 1:34:48Soldiers carried away jewelry, clothing, furniture, and artworks by the sack.
- 1:34:53Officers shipped them by the crate—marshals by the trainload.
- 1:34:56They transferred the entire factories.
- 1:34:59They also transported the personnel for forced labor.
- 1:35:01Entire streets—and sometimes entire neighborhoods—were built
- 1:35:04by German POWs. Yet unlike the U.S.,
- 1:35:08the Soviet Union failed to convert its victory into lasting economic prosperity.
- 1:35:14The result was striking. The country that acquired none of its enemies' cities,
- 1:35:18factories, mines, or territory became the world's leading power
- 1:35:21in the 20th century and the only true global superpower of the 21st century.
- 1:35:25The country that annexed land, seized cities, industries, and people,
- 1:35:29and established colonial-style control over half of Europe
- 1:35:32didn’t survive even five decades after its victory.
- 1:35:36Many of the soldiers who captured Berlin would live to witness
- 1:35:39both the collapse of their own empire and the reunification of Germany.
- 1:35:42WW2 started out as a classic war of aggression—a struggle
- 1:35:45to expand living space, measured literally in square kilometers.
- 1:35:50It was fought for access to ports, coal and oil deposits,
- 1:35:53fertile farmland, factories, and people
- 1:35:57who could be forced to work at gunpoint.
- 1:36:00Yet its outcome marked the end of that era.
- 1:36:03It turned out that acquiring intellectual capital was far more
- 1:36:09valuable than seizing machine tools, pianos, or territory.
- 1:36:15Everything you conquer must also be maintained.
- 1:36:17Colonies no longer generate wealth for the metropole.
- 1:36:19Instead, the metropole has to pay to sustain them.
- 1:36:22Even then, every so often, you still have to send
- 1:36:25battle tanks to Leipzig, Budapest, or Prague.
- 1:36:28The people there may end up living better than you
- 1:36:31at your expense—and still resent your rule.
- 1:36:34The U.S. didn’t become extraordinarily wealthy because it deprived the vanquished
- 1:36:38of their resources, as victors had done throughout history,
- 1:36:41but because it invested enormous fortunes in rebuilding them.
- 1:36:45Instead of ending up with dead enemies or miserable slaves,
- 1:36:48it gained living—and soon
- 1:36:50very prosperous—customers for American goods.
- 1:36:53WW2 began as a struggle to expand living space.
- 1:36:56It ended with the Marshall Plan,
- 1:36:58under whichthe victor bankrolled the reconstruction of the defeated
- 1:37:01in a bid to turn them into customers.
- 1:37:03This forever changed what global influence meant.
- 1:37:07America's global dominance, established in the aftermath of the war,
- 1:37:11permanently changed the very notion of international clout.
- 1:37:14In many ways, the U.S. became an empire without colonies.
- 1:37:18It was nowhere, yet everywhere.
- 1:37:21It turned out that if you planted your flag somewhere
- 1:37:24and colored another region of the map with your country’s paint scheme,
- 1:37:27you also assumed responsibility for the locals.
- 1:37:30You had to provide healthcare and education, support them in childhood and old age,
- 1:37:34build their roads, bridges, power plants, and public utilities,
- 1:37:36and pay for their police and firefighters.
- 1:37:38And despite all of that, many would still resent you as an occupying power.
- 1:37:41By contrast, if people chose to buy your products,
- 1:37:43watch your movies, read your books, and listen to your music,
- 1:37:48they would bolster your economy
- 1:37:51voluntarily—without coercion or supervision.
- 1:37:54But they’d also begin eating your burgers, dressing like you,
- 1:37:58and adopting your values and way of life.
- 1:38:01They’d pick up your language and increasingly
- 1:38:03look to your country in both foreign and domestic policy.
- 1:38:06The most talented, energetic, educated, and entrepreneurial people
- 1:38:10would choose to move to your country to work, build businesses, and pursue careers.
- 1:38:13You didn’t have to raise them, educate them, or pay for their healthcare.
- 1:38:16They arrived with the already mature human capital already
- 1:38:20at no cost to you. They weren’t slaves or POWs.
- 1:38:25You didn’t need prison walls or wardens armed with whips.
- 1:38:29A mortgage, a car loan, and the aspiration
- 1:38:31to live the American dream proved more effective
- 1:38:34than coercion and more durable than barbed wire.
- 1:38:37Their labor generated economic growth and profit.
- 1:38:42Expanding your Lebensraum militarily has become an obsolete strategy.
- 1:38:45Wherever there’s a McDonald's, wherever people drive Fords—or
- 1:38:50assemble them locally—eat cereal for breakfast,
- 1:38:54wear blue denims, and, above all, keep their savings in U.S. dollars,
- 1:38:58that place has effectively become part of your sphere of influence.
- 1:39:01For them, your country's voice would carry more weight
- 1:39:04than the orders of any military occupation authority ever could.
- 1:39:06The postwar world
- 1:39:08was no longer dominated by the greatest conqueror.
- 1:39:11Instead, it was led by the world's largest employer, seller, customer,
- 1:39:15investor, and destination for investment.
- 1:39:19It no longer needed to install political commissars in foreign classrooms.
- 1:39:22Hollywood would shape hearts and minds across the globe—and people
- 1:39:25would willingly pay for the privilege.
- 1:39:27They would pay in their own currencies, which would then be converted into dollars.
- 1:39:32The postwar global order didn’t emerge simply because humanity
- 1:39:36was so horrified by the war that it collectively resolved never to attempt it again.
- 1:39:40We can see for ourselves how easily people can devolve back into barbarism.
- 1:39:49Even in the developed world, people haven’t forgotten
- 1:39:51how to kill, torture, or reduce cities to rubble.
- 1:39:54As recent history suggests, turning an ordinary person into a willing perpetrator of atrocities
- 1:39:57has become no more difficult than it was some 80 years ago.
- 1:40:00The ongoing Russia–Ukraine war is a stark reminder of this reality.
- 1:40:05It forces us to acknowledge that the much-touted
- 1:40:08moral progress of humanity was certainly
- 1:40:11greatly overestimated. It may even be illusory.
- 1:40:15What truly changed, however, was something else.
- 1:40:16War itself lost much of its practical rationale.
- 1:40:19The very purpose of war began to fade away.
- 1:40:22Just as hunting ceased to be humanity's primary means of obtaining food,
- 1:40:25war ceased to be an effective means of acquiring valuable resources.
- 1:40:29!Time Heals!
- 1:40:30On Sept. 2, 1945, when Mamoru Shigemitsu signed
- 1:40:34the Japanese Instrument of Surrender, there were surely many skeptics
- 1:40:39who believed the peace would be short-lived.
- 1:40:41They expected the defeated Axis powers to seek revenge against their conquerors.
- 1:40:46In 15 or 20 years, they thought, new Führers
- 1:40:49would once again lead another generation
- 1:40:52of young men—raised in poverty and humiliation—into a new "holy war."
- 1:40:57This view was entirely understandable.
- 1:40:59The whole course of previous history seemed to support it.
- 1:41:03As far back as 15 centuries earlier, the Roman writer Flavius Vegetius
- 1:41:08had famously declared: “Si vis pacem, para bellum.”
- 1:41:11If you want peace, prepare for war.
- 1:41:14But in the Roman era, throughout the Middle Ages,
- 1:41:17and even into the 19th century, war, however devastating,
- 1:41:22didn’t jeopardize the very existence of humanity.
- 1:41:26Two armies clashed on the battlefield, one prevailed, the other was defeated,
- 1:41:29and afterward, the rulers sat down to negotiate a peace treaty.
- 1:41:32The new age changed everything. At the Battle of Borodino in 1812,
- 1:41:37the Russians and the French together lost up to 80,000 men,
- 1:41:41making it the bloodiest battle of that campaign.
- 1:41:44A typical battle of WW2, by contrast, claimed
- 1:41:46100s of 1,000s—and sometimes millions—of lives on each side.
- 1:41:51And there were dozens of such battles over the course of six years.
- 1:41:56Nor was WW2 confined to the battlefield.
- 1:41:58With the advent of nuclear weapons, the destruction of entire cities
- 1:42:01and all their inhabitants became a matter of minutes.
- 1:42:07Humanity had reached the brink— beyond which lay only emptiness.
- 1:42:09Beyond that point, ideology, political calculations,
- 1:42:12and old grievances would matter no more.
- 1:42:14For beyond that line, there’s no life.
- 1:42:18!Afterword!
- 1:42:20This docuseries has proven to be a Herculean task.
- 1:42:23More than once, it felt as though we’d taken on something far beyond our means:
- 1:42:27dozens of cities—from Moscow and Kyiv to New York and Tokyo—five full years of production,
- 1:42:33countless people involved, archival records, historical footage,
- 1:42:36computer graphics, and animated maps.
- 1:42:39We wanted to align it with the ethos of the finest docuseries from television's golden age.
- 1:42:44It turned out to be far longer, more difficult, and more expensive
- 1:42:48than we’d ever imagined. We gave it everything we had,
- 1:42:51and I hope the result speaks for itself.
- 1:42:53If I could pick just one idea for viewers to take away
- 1:42:58from this long series, it would be this.
- 1:43:03The real winner of WW2 wasn’t the country that captured Berlin,
- 1:43:06nor the one that achieved the greatest military victories on the battlefield.
- 1:43:10The winner was the country that offered the world
- 1:43:13the most compelling way of life. The one whose culture
- 1:43:17became pervasive and dominant— not by imposing it on others,
- 1:43:19but because people embraced it willingly.
- 1:43:21The one whose economy became a global hub.
- 1:43:24The one that lent money to everyone—and in time cashed in on the rest of the world.
- 1:43:30People are far more eager to learn the language
- 1:43:32of an employer thanthat of an occupier.
- 1:43:34Victory belongs to the one to whom people willingly bring
- 1:43:38their money, their labor, and their attention—to the country
- 1:43:43whose vehicles they want to drive, whose jeans they want to wear,
- 1:43:46whose music they want to listen to, and whose movies they want to watch.
- 1:43:50After WW2, starting a war in order to gain something from it became
- 1:43:55the most foolish, the most irrational idea imaginable.
- 1:44:01Today, any war is bound to turn into a defeat the moment it breaks out.
- 1:44:06In the end, it was the intelligent—not the strongest—who won.
- 1:44:09And that’s equally true for those who fought and those who didn’t;
- 1:44:15for those who ended up among the victors and for those
- 1:44:18who were steamrolled, whose countries were leveled.
- 1:44:21Since WW2, the world hasn’t been shaped by firepower but by brainpower.
- 1:44:25The world that was built and conquered by force is gone forever.
- 1:44:29The most aggressive and heavily armed states become pariahs;
- 1:44:33the most intelligent, secure, and prosperous ones define the way the rest of us live.
- 1:44:38The ability to defeat others by force—a skill that, throughout human history,
- 1:44:44was immensely valuable for both individuals and nations—can now
- 1:44:47send an individual to prison and drive an entire state into shambles.
- 1:44:52The only path to success is to be useful to others:
- 1:44:56to possess unique skills as an individual
- 1:44:59and to build a country where those skills can flourish.
- 1:45:04In the end, it’s not the strongest who prevail. It’s the smartest.
- 1:45:07And the countries that succeed are the ones where the smart are allowed to succeed.
- 1:45:12See you tomorrow!
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Финал войны: победители и побеждённые | История Второй мировой (English subtitles) by Максим Кац, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 15,229 words across 1,722 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.