Enfant TDAH/TOP : pourquoi il s’oppose à tout — et comment réagir — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Three: be concise, because we see
- 0:02parents drowning and drowning in
- 0:04>> getting lost in the explanations,
- 0:05>> it turns into negotiation
- 0:07>> and it can even create a new crisis
- 0:08afterward. Opposition, I see it more as
- 0:11a form of psychic survival mechanism.
- 0:13Without my opposition, I wouldn't be
- 0:16here with you today. I certainly
- 0:18wouldn't be alive.
- 0:19>> It also reminds me that lies often start
- 0:22from inventing a reality, saying
- 0:24something about yourself that isn't true
- 0:27.
- 0:27Actually, I love provoking because I
- 0:29honestly find it exciting.
- 0:31>> Exhilarating.
- 0:32>> Exhilarating. It's a thrill. It's
- 0:33exciting to provoke. It’s that
- 0:35opposition saves your son, it saves your
- 0:38daughter. And if you don't understand
- 0:40that, then you're going to fight it. You
- 0:42see, it's a bit like "I reject others
- 0:44before they can reject me through my
- 0:45opposition." It's easier to say "Well no
- 0:48, I don't want to, Mom, Dad."
- 0:53Hello everyone and welcome to the Face-
- 0:55à-Face podcast, or video if you are
- 0:57watching.
- 0:59Uh, today we are going to talk a bit
- 1:01about opposition and the subject of
- 1:03opposition in children with ADHD, ASD,
- 1:06and therefore oppositional disorders. So
- 1:08the idea is that we can exchange a
- 1:09little bit about that. For those who
- 1:11don't know me, my name is Oscar Langlais
- 1:12. I am an international coach, so I have
- 1:15supported several thousand families on
- 1:17different continents and.
- 1:19Today, I have also written a book called
- 1:21"Face-à-Face with ADHD," in which I
- 1:23write down simple tips and advice to
- 1:25find more peace, notably with the "
- 1:27three small atypical steps" method.
- 1:29And so, I am the founder of the school "
- 1:31Un Simple Conseil," which is a school
- 1:34where we support parents every day to
- 1:36find more fulfillment and more serenity
- 1:38.
- 1:39And we are with Morgan today who is part
- 1:41of the support team, and we also have
- 1:43Chloé who works with us, who isn't here
- 1:46today, but we will perhaps have the
- 1:48opportunity to do a podcast or video
- 1:50with her.
- 1:51So the idea is that we can exchange a
- 1:53bit about this oppositional disorder,
- 1:55these oppositional behaviors, what is
- 1:58hidden behind them, and well, I will
- 2:00simply let you listen to Morgan to know
- 2:02who she is.
- 2:03So, Morgan, introduce yourself a bit,
- 2:05who you are, and how long have you been
- 2:07with us?
- 2:10>> Yes, so, I'm Morgan; I've been a coach
- 2:12with Oscar for a good year now, and in
- 2:15parallel, I'm also becoming a
- 2:17psychologist specializing in children,
- 2:20adolescents, and parenting.
- 2:23So, it's quite complementary to my coach
- 2:26training as well with Oscar. Hm. So, I
- 2:29have the chance to be able to work with
- 2:31Morgan for, well, as she said, a year
- 2:34now. It's a great collaboration, and the
- 2:36idea is for us to chat a bit about the
- 2:38families you've worked with and what we
- 2:40actually see within the school.
- 2:42First off, when it comes to opposition,
- 2:45what comes to mind, or at least what do
- 2:47you tell parents who come to complain
- 2:50about this opposition, saying, "He says
- 2:52no to everything, he never wants to do
- 2:55anything, he rejects me."
- 2:58You see, all these kinds of remarks we
- 3:00get in our school from the families we
- 3:02support.
- 3:03What would you say, then, to a parent
- 3:05who tells you that?
- 3:09Well, first of all, I think the first
- 3:11important point is to start by
- 3:13redefining what opposition actually is.
- 3:17What is oppositional defiant disorder?
- 3:20Because, first of all, there is an
- 3:22opposition that is normal during
- 3:24childhood and adolescence.
- 3:27It's normal, it's healthy; it's part of
- 3:29development to have this somewhat
- 3:31oppositional attitude.
- 3:33Where it becomes ODD, where it’s a
- 3:36disorder, is when the intensity is
- 3:38elevated compared to the norm.
- 3:42So, opposing at the core, it's
- 3:44interesting to ask ourselves why this
- 3:46opposition exists, and against whom?
- 3:48Because often the opposition—we might
- 3:51see this later—is frequently towards one
- 3:53person in particular: the mother, the
- 3:55father, or the grandmother. Exactly.
- 3:58Often, there is also this side of it, a
- 4:00bit of an attribution. Uh...
- 4:04>> So yeah, it's quite interesting what
- 4:05you're saying about the fact that
- 4:06opposition is normal in all children.
- 4:09>> Actually, that's why many parents talk
- 4:10about it to those around them: "He
- 4:12opposes me, he has meltdowns." Yes. Well
- 4:14, then...
- 4:14>> And they say, "Oh, but my child is ODD
- 4:16too."
- 4:17>> There's a bit of confusion around this,
- 4:19just like with ADHD, which is often
- 4:21something we hear: "Oh, my child can't
- 4:23focus for more than 5 minutes.""Well,
- 4:25then, they have ADHD."
- 4:26There are many parents who also
- 4:28self-diagnose. Uh, well, these are two
- 4:31different things.
- 4:33But, uh, Oppositional Defiant Disorder
- 4:35is a real diagnosis made by a doctor
- 4:37that requires specific care.
- 4:40Right, there is really that side of
- 4:43intensity that differs from a child who
- 4:45just needs to be oppositional to become
- 4:47autonomous, to be different from their
- 4:50parents, to make their own decisions.
- 4:53Yeah, we are really a notch above that
- 4:55here. So what is interesting, what
- 4:57Morgan says, is that obviously in
- 4:59diagnoses with oppositional disorders,
- 5:00it is the intensity of the crises.
- 5:03When I was little, I used to have
- 5:04meltdowns; I could tear the house apart
- 5:06because we weren't going to McDonald's
- 5:07that evening.
- 5:08I don't know, I'm making up a scene.
- 5:11So there is an intensity to the crises
- 5:13and a regularity, because an ODD child
- 5:14will oppose much more often.
- 5:17I don't have the multiplier, but
- 5:18compared to a non-ODD child, they can
- 5:21oppose 5, 10, 15, 20 times a day over
- 5:23small daily things, even things they
- 5:25enjoy.
- 5:26And it's important to make the
- 5:27distinction, already for the
- 5:29introduction of this podcast and this
- 5:30video.
- 5:31It's really about saying: "Well,
- 5:33actually, okay, there are children who
- 5:34are oppositional, all children are
- 5:36oppositional, but in that group, there
- 5:38will be a sub-trend, notably among ADHD
- 5:40, ASD, or ODD profiles, where the
- 5:41opposition is much more intense, much
- 5:43more violent, and much more recurrent."
- 5:45Repeating, repeating, repeating. So that
- 5:48is hyper important to understand this
- 5:50point already to grasp a bit of what is
- 5:51at play behind the opposition. And so we
- 5:54return to the basic question which was,
- 5:56uh...
- 5:56>> uh, yes. understanding already, uh, so
- 5:59oppositional defiant disorder, that too
- 6:02is an element...
- 6:03>> Yeah. Why do they provoke? Because they
- 6:05could just oppose and not get into that
- 6:07provocation.
- 6:08>> What do you notice with the families you
- 6:10see regarding this provocation? What
- 6:12does it actually bring them to provoke,
- 6:14to seek this out? They know exactly what
- 6:17to say to you, what to do to drive you
- 6:20crazy. I mean, I'm speaking for the
- 6:22parents listening to us.
- 6:24What I find interesting with this
- 6:25somewhat provocative aspect, uh, is the
- 6:28very act of provoking.
- 6:30It also allows for putting a form of
- 6:32distance between oneself and the other.
- 6:36It's a bit of a way to create a
- 6:37difference, to really mark something
- 6:39separate between oneself and the other,
- 6:41to say, "Well, I oppose you."
- 6:44It creates a bit of that aspect.
- 6:46We are different, you and I, we aren't
- 6:48the same people, we don't think alike,
- 6:49we don't have the same values.
- 6:51It creates this somewhat brutal
- 6:54separation.
- 6:55>> A polarity. Yeah.
- 6:56>> Yeah. A form of polarity, in a way. So
- 6:58that, right there, I find quite
- 6:59interesting.
- 7:01And regarding provocation, we often find
- 7:04almost a sense of threats.
- 7:08There can be that side of threatening,
- 7:11provoking with insults, being very
- 7:13violent with words.
- 7:17And I think that also increases internal
- 7:21stimulation.
- 7:22It creates a sort of dopamine excitement
- 7:24for the brain.
- 7:26>> Dopamine; there’s a piece of data that’s
- 7:29quite interesting, which is that 30%of
- 7:32people with ADHD have oppositional
- 7:34defiant disorder.
- 7:37So there is truly what we call a very
- 7:39high comorbidity.
- 7:4130%is quite, it’s quite significant.
- 7:44So there can be this side of
- 7:46self-stimulation when provoking others.
- 7:49It creates internal excitement.
- 7:52It can, you know, increase dopamine when
- 7:55it’s linked to ADHD.
- 7:58>> Yeah.
- 7:58>> There you go.
- 8:00I think there are quite a few underlying
- 8:02things like that which are also
- 8:04interesting to view as a frame of
- 8:06reference, you know.
- 8:08>> Yeah.
- 8:08So it really allows for rejecting others
- 8:11, getting that dopamine for individuals
- 8:13or children affected by ADHD, that
- 8:15stimulation of showing a differentiation
- 8:18.
- 8:19I’m speaking as a coach, but also as
- 8:21someone who has experienced it, because
- 8:23you know I am affected by the subject.
- 8:25Actually, I love provoking because I
- 8:28honestly find it thrilling.
- 8:29>> Exciting.
- 8:30>> Exciting. It’s a rush. It’s exciting to
- 8:32provoke.
- 8:34And we often have parents who will tell
- 8:35us, "Yes, the lies, he lies to me."
- 8:37"
- 8:37>> I caught him red-handed with the lie,
- 8:39he’s lying to me."
- 8:41There’s a bit of a, well, a side to
- 8:44lying.
- 8:45And for me, actually, I put lying in a
- 8:47form of, I group it with opposition. Why
- 8:50? Because, in fact, it’s a thrill to see
- 8:53how the person across from me will react
- 8:56if I distort reality.
- 8:58And that's something that's super
- 9:00interesting because there are a lot of
- 9:02parents who, who are like: "It's not
- 9:03normal, he's lying to me, I caught him
- 9:05red-handed, it's not normal for him to
- 9:07lie to me, he's a rude, poorly raised
- 9:09child, or he doesn't trust me, or
- 9:10whatever."
- 9:12But the lying that, for me, goes with
- 9:14defiance, it's really about seeing the
- 9:16other person's reaction, you know?
- 9:21>> How far will Mom, Dad, my brother, my
- 9:23sister flip out, and these are often
- 9:26lies about things that can provoke, you
- 9:28know?
- 9:30>> You see?
- 9:30>> Yeah, absolutely, in regards to that.
- 9:34For me, it always brings me back to that
- 9:36side of, like, a real release of
- 9:38excitement in that moment.
- 9:40And it brought something else to mind
- 9:43regarding lying, which is that there’s
- 9:45often this element of, well, it can be a
- 9:48lie, it can be, you know, a meltdown,
- 9:51something a bit exuberant, and so on.
- 9:54It also makes me think about how often
- 9:57lies come from inventing a reality,
- 9:59saying something about yourself that
- 10:01isn't true.
- 10:03And that brings me back to the fact that
- 10:06people with ADHD, people with
- 10:08oppositional disorders, often have low
- 10:10self-esteem.
- 10:12>> And the act of perhaps lying about
- 10:14yourself, lying about your reality, and
- 10:16so on, can also be a defense,
- 10:18>> a form of escapism. A form of escape,
- 10:20but also a defense to protect themselves
- 10:22, to protect their self-esteem.
- 10:25Often, you know, when they lie about
- 10:27their grades at school, they lie about
- 10:29problems they have, about their
- 10:31relationships, maybe things they’d like
- 10:33to have in life that they don’t, maybe
- 10:35things they can't manage regarding their
- 10:37emotions, maybe a lot of things.
- 10:40And I tell myself, there might also be a
- 10:41link with that side of low self-esteem.
- 10:43>> Yeah.
- 10:44They appropriate a form of success or a
- 10:46type of story that suits them better to
- 10:48fuel their image or their self-esteem at
- 10:51the same time, you know?
- 10:53Is that what you mean?
- 10:54>> Yeah. With the lies, with that side of
- 10:57things too, a bit—
- 11:00there are so many things coming to me at
- 11:02once, but it also makes me think of
- 11:04self-sabotage,
- 11:06>> the act of being provocative, of trying
- 11:08to damage the relationship, damage the
- 11:10bond.
- 11:11uh we sort of self-sabotage in a way,
- 11:14and once again, that is often linked to
- 11:16having a poor self-image.
- 11:19>> When we have a poor self-image, we will
- 11:21sabotage our relationships so that our
- 11:23belief—that nobody likes me, that I’m
- 11:25not interesting enough for others—
- 11:27actually becomes true in the end.
- 11:29>> Yeah. And that is super interesting. So
- 11:32, we quickly arrived at the conclusion
- 11:33of low self-esteem because of ADHD
- 11:35issues: you’re not doing enough, you’re
- 11:37doing too much, you don’t manage your
- 11:38emotions, you’re too impulsive. Anyway,
- 11:41I’m not going to make a whole list of
- 11:43the remarks I’ve taken to heart and that
- 11:46ADHD or ASD people receive. So, there’s
- 11:49this poor self-esteem that is really
- 11:50impacted.
- 11:52And what’s interesting to understand in
- 11:54this video, in this podcast, is that
- 11:56defiance today—I say it and I will say
- 11:58it again to all the families who trust
- 11:59us in our school—is a simple piece of
- 12:01advice.
- 12:04By the way, if you want to know more, I
- 12:05invite you to comment "ADHD" under this
- 12:07video or click the link in my bio to
- 12:08join us and see if you are eligible for
- 12:10coaching.
- 12:12It’s about understanding that, uh,
- 12:14defiance—I see it more as a form of
- 12:16psychic survival mechanism.
- 12:19Without my defiance, I wouldn't be here
- 12:22with you today.
- 12:24Uh, I certainly wouldn't be alive
- 12:26because I had a lot of dark thoughts,
- 12:28suicidal thoughts at the time, and
- 12:30defiance at some point allowed me to
- 12:32partially lie to myself.
- 12:35You see, I’m building on what you’re
- 12:37saying, about the reality of staying in
- 12:38denial because we were talking about
- 12:40that last time. Which also protected me
- 12:43.
- 12:45And, uh, and actually, that’s what
- 12:47parents or individuals who are around
- 12:49ADHD, ASD, or ODD children need to
- 12:51understand: that defiance is saving your
- 12:53son, it’s saving your daughter.
- 12:57And if you don’t understand that, you’re
- 12:59going to beat it, you’re going to try to
- 13:01fight this defiance, except you won’t
- 13:03win because for them, it’s their whole
- 13:05psychic life, it’s their entire mental
- 13:07health state that they are fighting for
- 13:09.
- 13:10So that is super important to understand
- 13:12.
- 13:13>> Yeah, that’s it, and in fact, it really
- 13:15is a defense mechanism at that moment.
- 13:18It’s that it’s useful in any case to
- 13:20your way of being, to your way of
- 13:22functioning.
- 13:23It's just that at some point, it was...
- 13:25it was your need too, you know, to have
- 13:28that opposition with others, to have
- 13:30distance from others, from your
- 13:31environment, and so on.
- 13:34Because, once again, opposition allows
- 13:37you to put distance, it provides a sense
- 13:39of protection, a sort of shield.
- 13:42So yeah, there really is this question
- 13:44of distance from others, and it's
- 13:45important to understand why these
- 13:47children or individuals put that
- 13:49distance there; it's because, uh, they
- 13:51create that distance since they
- 13:53themselves are distanced from others.
- 13:55You see, it's a bit like, "I'll reject
- 13:57others before they reject me" through my
- 13:59opposition.
- 14:00It's easier to say, "Well no, I don't
- 14:02want to, Mom, Dad, my friend,"
- 14:05>> uh, or whatever my relationships are,
- 14:07rather than getting rejected again.
- 14:10"So I create patterns that I know, where
- 14:12I myself
- 14:13>> of self-sabotage
- 14:14>> Yes. of self-sabotage where I myself
- 14:16will actually reject the person before
- 14:18they reject me.
- 14:19And what’s also interesting, uh, that
- 14:22comes to mind, is that unlike, for
- 14:24example, ADHD—ADHD is a
- 14:26neurodevelopmental disorder, uh, which
- 14:29is therefore biological, as well as
- 14:31environmental, social, and so on, uh,
- 14:34but which truly develops along with
- 14:36development.
- 14:38It’s really something that is
- 14:39neurological
- 14:41>> in the construction of the brain.
- 14:42>> In the construction of the brain.
- 14:44Whereas oppositional defiant disorder is
- 14:46a developmental disorder, not a
- 14:47neurodevelopmental one.
- 14:50So it is something that really develops
- 14:52based on the environment. There is a
- 14:54huge part of, of reaction, actually.
- 14:57Often, the, the opposition disorder—and
- 14:59that’s a piece of data that parents
- 15:01don’t always keep in mind—is that it was
- 15:03triggered, it was formed as a reaction
- 15:05by the child to their environment. uh,
- 15:07facing, uh, their standard of living,
- 15:09their society, and so on. It’s really
- 15:12something reactive.
- 15:13>> Yeah, that’s interesting what you’re
- 15:14saying, because once again, I’m talking
- 15:16—we’re just talking about observations
- 15:17from what we have in our coaching
- 15:19schools, and I’m speaking from my own
- 15:20experience. Uh, often, I wasn’t
- 15:22oppositional from the beginning. So,
- 15:24there was this intolerance to
- 15:26frustration that affects a lot of ADHD
- 15:28children, uh, or children with ASD as
- 15:30well.
- 15:31Uh, so there was this intolerance to
- 15:32frustration, but it wasn’t yet
- 15:33problematic. And as I grew up, from the
- 15:35moment I started middle school, there
- 15:37was more and more opposition and
- 15:39conflict with my parents, my siblings,
- 15:41and especially my teachers. For me, it
- 15:44spread to school. That’s also a question
- 15:46we could ask ourselves. Why does this
- 15:47opposition only manifest with certain
- 15:49people in the environment? We’ll answer
- 15:51that. So stay tuned.
- 15:54But from what I've observed, opposition
- 15:56often arises in a child's development
- 15:59around the pre-teen years.
- 16:02Uh, once again, that’s just an
- 16:03observation.
- 16:05For me, it was around 6th or 7th grade
- 16:07and, I don’t know, there must also be a
- 16:09hormone factor at play, as well as
- 16:11biological changes.
- 16:13>> Biological, where there is a form of,
- 16:16well, of power, in the sense that the
- 16:19child becomes a bit more self-controlled
- 16:22as they grow older, perhaps with more
- 16:26testosterone or estrogen.
- 16:28Which is a form of self-development that
- 16:30gives them confidence, and therefore
- 16:32more confidence to oppose.
- 16:34So, there you go, that was just
- 16:36something to add. It was just the fact
- 16:37that what I’m observing is really this
- 16:39opposition.
- 16:40In any case, with ODD, there are times
- 16:43in parenting where it intensifies,
- 16:45especially around 10, 11, or 12 years
- 16:47old, and it can increase with age if the
- 16:50environment doesn’t change or the
- 16:52parents’ approach doesn’t change, and it
- 16:54can reinforce itself.
- 16:57But it’s interesting to talk about ages
- 17:01because, precisely, 10, 11, 12 years old
- 17:04are ages where we are heading toward
- 17:08adolescence.
- 17:09At 10, you're in pre-adolescence; at 11
- 17:11, you're in pre-adolescence.
- 17:13Uh, adolescence is the moment when we
- 17:15are most focused on separating from the
- 17:18family, where we truly begin to gain
- 17:20autonomy and become an individual apart
- 17:22from our family.
- 17:24Which is different from childhood,
- 17:25because in childhood, we are always
- 17:27linked to our family; we are under our
- 17:30family's control.
- 17:32Uh, adolescence is really a time when we
- 17:34will oppose in order to separate.
- 17:37We will oppose to truly become
- 17:39independent from our parents, from our
- 17:41mother, from our father, and to be
- 17:43different from them.
- 17:46So at the same time, opposition can
- 17:49increase at that level.
- 17:51It’s that we can detect a diagnosis of
- 17:53ODD opposition.
- 17:55It can be done from age 6 when we see
- 17:57that the opposition is beyond the norm.
- 18:00But we often see, in general and in our
- 18:03coaching, that this opposition can
- 18:06really build up gradually with
- 18:08adolescence, where there is this
- 18:10question, you know, the image of the"
- 18:13teenage rebellion.
- 18:15"But, actually, what is the teenage
- 18:17rebellion?
- 18:18It's when you separate from your parents
- 18:20, get closer to your friends, and
- 18:23actually create your own identity.
- 18:26And so that can create strong opposition
- 18:28, particularly with ODD.
- 18:30Hm.
- 18:31>> So, there is also this developmental
- 18:33side, which is interesting to take into
- 18:36account. It's that, okay, there is the
- 18:38truly developmental aspect with
- 18:40Oppositional Defiant Disorder, why not
- 18:42ADHD, why not other conditions, but
- 18:44there is also the aspect to consider
- 18:46regarding adolescence or the phase they
- 18:48are currently in.
- 18:50So it's also interesting to be able to
- 18:52cross-reference; whether it's regarding
- 18:54their functioning or their development,
- 18:56it's always interesting to be able to
- 18:58bridge those things.
- 19:00>> Yeah. Uh, thanks for those
- 19:02clarifications, Morgan. For me, there
- 19:04are two things that are important that
- 19:05we will look at, or rather, that we are
- 19:06going to see right after this in the
- 19:07podcast.
- 19:09Don't hesitate, for those who need help
- 19:10, to really click on the link in this
- 19:12description or in the bio if you are
- 19:14listening to the podcast or watching the
- 19:15video.
- 19:18If you need help, if you feel concerned
- 19:20by the subject of a child with a form of
- 19:22child tyranny, a form of loss of control
- 19:24, helplessness, guilt, or a form of fear
- 19:27.
- 19:28If these are the feelings you have
- 19:30during this podcast, I really invite you
- 19:31to click and sign up for the online
- 19:33conference I’m organizing, the" Three
- 19:35Little Atypical Steps "method. So do it
- 19:37, we'll see you there, and we will give
- 19:39you keys to better understand and regain
- 19:41more security and peace. Because what is
- 19:43important to understand is that these
- 19:45patterns didn't happen overnight. This
- 19:47opposition didn't just appear overnight
- 19:49. There were really factors that
- 19:52amplified it. And that's what I often
- 19:54say to the families I support: we are
- 19:56not going to change or remove your son's
- 19:58or daughter's opposition.
- 20:01We are going to help you, as a parent,
- 20:02and that is the goal of our school and
- 20:04our program, to change your stance.
- 20:07Because you’ve been stuck for years and
- 20:10years in patterns of misunderstanding,
- 20:12communication issues, and
- 20:14misinterpretations, and that, in turn,
- 20:17creates hostile behavior from the child
- 20:19toward their parents, especially toward
- 20:22the most controlling and anxious ones.
- 20:26I want to go back to the environment.
- 20:29Why do some children, teens, or young
- 20:31adults oppose one parent in particular
- 20:33more than the other?
- 20:36>> Do you see that in your families?
- 20:37>> Yes.
- 20:39Well, often—and we shouldn't generalize
- 20:42—we see that you can have parents who
- 20:45are quite controlling, quite rigid about
- 20:48rules and structure, a bit" normative, "
- 20:51as we might call them.
- 20:55And often, that really creates a climate
- 20:59of war and opposition because things are
- 21:04very firm on both sides, and that
- 21:07creates an escalation of violence due to
- 21:11those two very rigid positions.
- 21:16So, there are often controlling parents
- 21:18, and that is something we find time and
- 21:19again.
- 21:22And above all, what I also see, which
- 21:24goes along with control, is anxious
- 21:26parents, because at the root of
- 21:27oppositional disorder, what’s important
- 21:30to understand is that there is a lot of
- 21:32anxiety, a deep, profound anxiety for
- 21:34these individuals.
- 21:36I’ve always been anxious since I was
- 21:37little. I still bite my nails today;
- 21:38it’s a challenge. But there is really an
- 21:41anxiety conflict in the child with ADHD
- 21:44, ASD, or ODD, and an anxiety conflict
- 21:47in the parent.
- 21:48So, is it a parent who is anxious
- 21:50because they have an anxious temperament
- 21:53, or is it a parent who was never
- 21:55diagnosed with ADHD, ASD, or
- 21:57oppositional behavior? Often, where we
- 22:00see it clash the most is in families
- 22:02where there’s a mirroring effect.
- 22:05>> Hmm.
- 22:05>> There’s anxiety on top of anxiety. So
- 22:07this anxiety creates distress for the
- 22:09child, the father, and the daughter, for
- 22:12example, if we take those two
- 22:14individuals.
- 22:15And so these anxieties, in fact, they
- 22:18invade each other.
- 22:20And so, at a certain point, there is
- 22:23opposition that comes in to clumsily set
- 22:26boundaries, to clumsily create distance
- 22:29, in what we might call this emotional
- 22:31confusion that can exist.
- 22:35So we might wonder what kind of advice
- 22:38or tips we could give to parents who are
- 22:40there struggling to maintain boundaries
- 22:43or to reduce opposition.
- 22:45What advice could we give them, or what
- 22:48are the things we work on during
- 22:50sessions?
- 22:51Typically, I see one, which is typically
- 22:53in moments of provocation, and that is
- 22:55to avoid giving negative attention.
- 22:59So, for the child who comes, uh, to push
- 23:01you to the limit, who tries to get a
- 23:02rise out of you on subjects that are
- 23:04sensitive for you, the key is not to
- 23:06react to it.
- 23:08The more you react to it, the more
- 23:09dopamine you're giving them. The more
- 23:11you give them dopamine, the more it
- 23:13justifies their behavior. Their
- 23:15provocation and their self-sabotage
- 23:17pattern.
- 23:19So the idea, once again, within reason
- 23:21because I know it’s not easy in every
- 23:22daily situation, is to avoid giving that
- 23:24attention.
- 23:26The more you feed into this negative
- 23:28attention, the more you fuel their
- 23:29opposition, the more you fuel their
- 23:31identity and their self-sabotage pattern
- 23:33.
- 23:34And the problem with doing that is that
- 23:36, in the long term, you're going to
- 23:38create a child who is going to be
- 23:40completely stuck in a form of polarity.
- 23:43And a polarity, actually, a
- 23:45non-conformist identity, except of
- 23:47course in cases where the child, a
- 23:49brother or sister, the siblings, or a
- 23:51parent are in danger, where you have to
- 23:53call the police or the fire department
- 23:55in an emergency.
- 23:58Did you have another piece of advice you
- 24:00could give regarding this opposition to
- 24:01a parent who is, well, facing these
- 24:03oppositional behaviors?
- 24:06What can also be interesting, and I know
- 24:08I really like everything related to, uh
- 24:10, communication.
- 24:12>> Uh, how to communicate, well, around
- 24:14these oppositional outbursts?
- 24:17Uh, for example, really just
- 24:18understanding, uh, a bit what the stages
- 24:20of the crisis are, what are, uh, the
- 24:22stages of opposition as well, at what
- 24:24moment we can more or less, shall we say
- 24:27, give attention or have a conversation
- 24:29, and at what moment we should, instead
- 24:31, have one posture or another.
- 24:33I find it quite interesting to know that
- 24:35as well.
- 24:36Uh, and at that moment, seeing what
- 24:39posture we can have after the crisis.
- 24:42Uh
- 24:43>> would you have an example of what
- 24:44posture we could take after the crisis?
- 24:46It's interesting what you're saying
- 24:47about how to communicate around a crisis
- 24:49, because often, what happens is there's
- 24:51a crisis and then we don't talk about it
- 24:52anymore, because it's a subject that
- 24:54makes people uncomfortable, creates
- 24:55tension, and creates frustration. So it
- 24:57kind of gets forgotten. It's really
- 24:59interesting what you say about this
- 25:00communication
- 25:01>> around the crisis.
- 25:03>> In what way? I mean, how how would you
- 25:05go about it yourself? What, well, what
- 25:06would you say to a family listening to
- 25:09us? You see, first of all, what's
- 25:11interesting is that when there is
- 25:13opposition, when there is a crisis, it
- 25:16does end up damaging the bond a little
- 25:18bit.
- 25:19So it's still a priority for families to
- 25:22maintain the bond as much as possible,
- 25:24which is often harmed by the opposition
- 25:26.
- 25:27So often what I try to work on with
- 25:30parents is really learning to come back
- 25:34afterward, after the crises, in moments
- 25:37where emotions have returned to a calmer
- 25:41state.
- 25:42Where we have a moment where we can
- 25:44actually communicate about what happened
- 25:45, put it into words, and try to make
- 25:47connections between the behavior and the
- 25:49emotions of the child or teenager.
- 25:51Really try to make sense of it, as much
- 25:54for them as for you.
- 25:56And also try to have a concrete area for
- 25:59improvement for next time, because once
- 26:02again, the idea is that with opposition
- 26:04, we aren't necessarily going to get rid
- 26:07of the crises. We aren't necessarily
- 26:10going to never have a disorder again—we
- 26:12aren't going to remove the ODD. So the
- 26:14idea is to learn how to deal with it.
- 26:17So how can we have a concrete area for
- 26:19improvement for the next crisis, for the
- 26:22next opposition, so that it's a bit
- 26:24better, so that it's less problematic,
- 26:26perhaps to learn how to manage the
- 26:29emotion, to identify the emotion, to
- 26:31identify the need?
- 26:33That would be hard to explain in a
- 26:35minute, but
- 26:37>> how, basically, can we find an area for
- 26:39improvement? How can we, at the same
- 26:41time, try to make sense of what happened
- 26:42?
- 26:43So what you're saying, Morgan, is really
- 26:45for parents to come back after the
- 26:46crisis. That's it. In order to verbalize
- 26:48and elaborate on the crisis, right?
- 26:51>> And to restore the bond.
- 26:52>> But what is a framework, just so that
- 26:54parents have a framework? What would be
- 26:56the appropriate setting? How much time—
- 26:58do we just show up randomly?
- 27:01We say we're talking about yesterday's
- 27:03outburst, how much time do we take with
- 27:04the child? What do we tell them? Do we
- 27:06bring up every single point? You see,
- 27:08that's really what we're interested in.
- 27:10It's all about one's posture. It would
- 27:12be hard to explain that. Exactly. So
- 27:13>> if you had two or three keys, you know,
- 27:16to give them on what is the right
- 27:18posture after an outburst? Well, after
- 27:21an outburst, first of all,
- 27:23>> wait long enough—it's not waiting 10
- 27:26minutes, not 5 minutes, it's perhaps
- 27:28waiting, well, 1, 2, or 3 hours, or even
- 27:31until the next day, so it has truly
- 27:33calmed down.
- 27:35>> Ask as well, because just as you aren't
- 27:37always available, well, your child or
- 27:39teen isn't always available either.
- 27:41There are times they're tired, times
- 27:43they have an appointment, or times
- 27:45they're doing homework.
- 27:47Just, well, there are maybe moments when
- 27:48they will be more available. Mentally
- 27:50and psychologically to truly be present
- 27:54in the conversation. So, first ask:" Is
- 27:56it okay with you if we talk a bit about
- 27:58what happened yesterday? "That's it,
- 28:00we're just laying the groundwork like
- 28:01that. Uh
- 28:03>> and in terms of quantity, because often
- 28:05>> in terms of quantity, we shouldn't be
- 28:06too long.
- 28:07The goal isn't to be, uh, to be stifling
- 28:11, it's not to have a one-hour discussion
- 28:14.
- 28:15The goal is for it to be concise.
- 28:17Already, the more concise it is, the
- 28:18more precise it is.
- 28:20Uh, the more you know where you're going
- 28:21, the more you know which battle you're
- 28:23choosing for the discussion, the clearer
- 28:25the message will be and, above all,
- 28:26heard, because the idea is that the
- 28:28whole message is heard.
- 28:29Uh, so the idea is to look back on what
- 28:32happened concretely. uh, well, state the
- 28:35observation you had of it.
- 28:37Uh, for example, I don't know, yesterday
- 28:39I noticed that, uh, when we were at the
- 28:42pool and you got upset with me, when you
- 28:44started insulting, hitting the wall, uh
- 28:46, slamming your fists on the table, well
- 28:48, there you go, uh, that is my
- 28:49observation.
- 28:51Then, afterwards, tell them:" Well,
- 28:53listen, next time, "and that's where we
- 28:55can introduce an area for improvement.
- 28:58Practically speaking, next time, if you
- 28:59feel this emotion, um, I don't know,
- 29:01maybe we could go somewhere else where
- 29:03there's less stimulation, maybe we could
- 29:05just go somewhere else, maybe we could
- 29:07talk, maybe you could give me a sign.
- 29:10Actually, also find your own way of
- 29:12communicating at that moment with your
- 29:14child or maybe just go and ask them
- 29:16about it. Well, what happened for you?
- 29:19What did you feel at that moment? How
- 29:20was it? What did you tell yourself? What
- 29:22did you see in your head? It's also
- 29:24about questioning them because maybe
- 29:25they don't know, they don't know what
- 29:27happened for them, they don't know what
- 29:28emotion they had, they might have just
- 29:30been a bit confused, a bit overwhelmed.
- 29:32Right, the idea is also to help them put
- 29:34words to what they experienced, to the
- 29:36emotions they had at that moment. So
- 29:38it’s clearer for them too.
- 29:40>> Yeah, that's really interesting what
- 29:41you're saying.
- 29:43And then, uh, to really be able to make
- 29:46it an area for improvement.
- 29:50That's really the idea, being able to
- 29:52find concrete solutions with your child
- 29:54, with your teen, and to see, really
- 29:55concretely, how we're going to come back
- 29:57better prepared the next time there's an
- 29:59outburst, the next time there's an
- 30:01emotion of anger or sadness.
- 30:04Right, it's also about having, uh,
- 30:06something concrete for next time.
- 30:08>> Hm. Okay. Well, that's super interesting
- 30:11what you're saying. So, if I recap a bit
- 30:13the advice you gave for the parents
- 30:15listening to us on this podcast or this
- 30:17video, it's, uh, well, let time pass
- 30:20after the crisis. That's super important
- 30:22, what you said. Uh, the act of coming,
- 30:25uh, to ask, that's so valuable.
- 30:29Who come into the room, want that
- 30:31discussion, and violate their private
- 30:33space a bit, you know.
- 30:36So ask the child, the teen, if they
- 30:37agree to have a discussion and respect
- 30:39it if they say no.
- 30:41If they say no, it's
- 30:43>> we come back later.
- 30:44>> We'll come back later. We
- 30:45>> don't give up, we just come back later.
- 30:47We give it another day. Maybe the
- 30:48emotions are still too raw at that
- 30:50moment.
- 30:51You wouldn't want to be forced to have a
- 30:53conversation if you didn't feel ready.
- 30:56So you also have to respect that for
- 30:57your teen, for your child, it might not
- 30:59necessarily be the right moment either.
- 31:01>> Be concise, because we see parents
- 31:03drowning and getting lost in
- 31:04explanations.
- 31:05>> Getting lost in explanations.
- 31:06>> It turns into a negotiation.
- 31:08>> And it falls back into a negotiation,
- 31:10and that can even recreate a crisis
- 31:12afterward. So be extremely concise. And
- 31:14for that, a little tip I can add on top
- 31:17of what Morgan told you is to put things
- 31:19in writing.
- 31:21It’s not just about letting your
- 31:24emotions out in the moment; it’s really
- 31:26about putting it in writing, which takes
- 31:29time, and giving a path for improvement
- 31:31.
- 31:32Meaning, okay, it's not just reproaches
- 31:34," you went to the pool, you spoke to me
- 31:36rudely, so you're going to be punished.
- 31:38"Right. OK. Is it just so he gets
- 31:41scolded again? If that's the case, it's
- 31:43useless.
- 31:44He already took it during the crisis; he
- 31:45already went through a difficult moment
- 31:47.
- 31:48So give him a path for improvement." The
- 31:50next time you want to insult me, what I
- 31:52invite you to do is run away. "You can—
- 31:55we're talking about younger children
- 31:57here, but of course, it adapts to the
- 31:58teen's age—but it's about giving an exit
- 32:00strategy, not just criticizing.
- 32:03So that’s what you said, and there was
- 32:04one last point where we pretty much
- 32:06covered what you...
- 32:07>> And then what can also be interesting,
- 32:10of course, if you feel up to it, if
- 32:12you're comfortable, is that you each
- 32:14have your own love languages.
- 32:17So the idea is to have a clear idea of
- 32:19what your love language is, but to end
- 32:21on something a bit positive to restore
- 32:23the bond.
- 32:25Once again, that is the priority.
- 32:27So maybe end with an encouraging word
- 32:30for him, end with a sweet word, an" I
- 32:32love you, "a hug, a kiss, just something
- 32:35that, let's say, also repairs things
- 32:38afterward without...
- 32:41>> Without...it's not—often parents tell me
- 32:44," Yes, but if I come back and give him
- 32:47a hug after what he did to me, it means
- 32:50I'm condoning it. "But no, it doesn't
- 32:52necessarily mean you're condoning it. It
- 32:54just means we've closed the chapter,
- 32:56we've talked, we've put words on what
- 32:59happened. And then, there you go. Uh,
- 33:02there's not necessarily any benefit for
- 33:04the child in making them understand that
- 33:06, uh, there...there could be a...a loss
- 33:08of love, because the child, as soon as
- 33:10there are moments like that of...of
- 33:12crisis, of violence, and so on, they
- 33:13think:" But will my father still love me
- 33:16after what I said to him? "" I lost my
- 33:18temper, I broke his car, I smashed my
- 33:21mother's vase. "Will she still love me,
- 33:24actually, after what I did, after what I
- 33:25said to her?
- 33:27So there is always that question, which
- 33:29can be, well, very guilt-inducing for
- 33:31the child.
- 33:33So the simple act of showing them that
- 33:36they haven't, let's say, lost your love
- 33:38, lost your bond, and so on, also helps
- 33:41them in their journey, in the
- 33:43self-esteem they have. There you go. So
- 33:45,
- 33:46>> in the rebuilding,
- 33:47>> in the rebuilding.
- 33:48after the crisis. So there you go, a
- 33:50little word.
- 33:52There, you know, if you're more
- 33:54comfortable with hugs, with words, with
- 33:56actions, and so on, the idea is to
- 33:58finish on something a bit positive to
- 34:00also reinforce behavior in a positive
- 34:02way, talking after the crisis, that it
- 34:04goes well, that it's not about
- 34:05reproaches, uh.
- 34:08>> Which doesn't which doesn't which
- 34:10doesn't forgive, but which actually
- 34:12encompasses the general situation to
- 34:14convey the area for improvement and, uh
- 34:17, the emotions that, as a parent, we
- 34:19experienced.
- 34:20Because that is also super important, we
- 34:22forgot to say it, but it's talking about
- 34:23one's emotions. It's I was angry, I am
- 34:26sad, you scared me.
- 34:29It's not you scared me, on the contrary
- 34:31, it's I felt fear.
- 34:33So it's really about talking about one's
- 34:35internal emotions and closing with that
- 34:37word of of reassurance, that word of
- 34:39Yeah.
- 34:41that that allows for bringing clarity to
- 34:42the emotional relationship with the
- 34:44child, even with the crises and even
- 34:46with the difficulties.
- 34:48I can guarantee that they blame
- 34:50themselves, even if they don't show it
- 34:52to you, they blame themselves and they
- 34:54are already hard enough on themselves
- 34:57for what they did.
- 34:59So I hope this podcast has been able to
- 35:01help you a bit to clarify these issues
- 35:03of opposition.
- 35:04Thank you Morgan for for coming over for
- 35:08this podcast.
- 35:09>> My pleasure.
- 35:10>> And we'll see you very soon then in
- 35:12another podcast.
- 35:14This was Oscar L'anglais from Un Simple
- 35:15Conseil with Morgan, from the support
- 35:17team.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Enfant TDAH/TOP : pourquoi il s’oppose à tout — et comment réagir by Oscar Langley, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 6,156 words across 1,011 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.