Elderly Couple Bought the Abandoned Mansion Nobody Wanted for $12 — Everyone Laughed Until… — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00At 74, Odell Sturgill signed one piece
- 0:02of paper for his son and lost the house
- 0:05he and Neva had lived in for 46 years.
- 0:07They were sleeping in a truck behind a
- 0:09church when he read a legal notice in
- 0:11the back of the county paper. A mansion
- 0:13at the top of the hill, condemned, tax
- 0:16delinquent. Opening bid $12. Nobody else
- 0:20raised a hand and the whole room laughed
- 0:22because along with that deed came a
- 0:24demolition order and 90 days to pay for
- 0:26it. Then Odell walked into the front
- 0:28hall, tipped his head back and did the
- 0:31one thing nobody in this town had done
- 0:33in 60 years. He looked up and what that
- 0:36house had been holding on to all that
- 0:38time was the exact thing somebody in it
- 0:40had spent a lifetime making sure nobody
- 0:42ever found. The sale was held in the
- 0:44basement of the county annex on the
- 0:46second Tuesday in October in a room with
- 0:49a low ceiling and a coffee urn that had
- 0:51not been cleaned since summer. 19 people
- 0:53sat in folding chairs. Most of them were
- 0:55there for a repossessed side-by-side and
- 0:58a lot on the flats that somebody wanted
- 0:59for storage building. Odell sat in the
- 1:02second row with his hands on his knees.
- 1:04He had shaved that morning in the mirror
- 1:06on the visor of the truck. The man from
- 1:08the treasurer's office worked through
- 1:09the list without any showmanship. He
- 1:11read each parcel off a clipboard, took
- 1:13bids, and wrote the winner's name in the
- 1:15margin. It went fast. A pickup, a
- 1:18camper, three lots, a house on the flats
- 1:21that went for 11,000. Then he turned a
- 1:23page and his voice changed. Parcel 417,
- 1:27he said. 12 and 6/10 acres. One
- 1:30structure, three stories, brick and
- 1:32sandstone, roughly 11,000 square feet.
- 1:35I'm supposed to read the following out
- 1:36loud. He held the clipboard closer.
- 1:39Structure was condemned under county
- 1:41code in 1968.
- 1:43Condemnation renewed most recently in
- 1:45March of this year. Property is sold as
- 1:48is, where is. Purchaser assumes all
- 1:50abatement liability including
- 1:52demolition. Somebody in the back laughed
- 1:54once, short, and then cut it off.
- 1:57Opening bid is $12, the man said. Which
- 2:00is what it cost us to run the notice in
- 2:01the paper." Nobody moved. A woman folded
- 2:04her program. The coffee urn ticked.
- 2:07Odell raised his hand. The man from the
- 2:09treasurer's office looked at him for a
- 2:11second longer than he had looked at
- 2:12anybody else that morning. "$12," he
- 2:14said, "do I hear 13?"
- 2:17He did not. He asked twice more, and
- 2:19then he set the clipboard down and said,
- 2:22"Sold. Parcel 417,
- 2:25$12."
- 2:26And the room came apart. It was not mean
- 2:29laughter, exactly. It was the noise a
- 2:31room makes when it decides somebody has
- 2:33just done something it will be repeating
- 2:34at supper. A man two rows behind him
- 2:37leaned forward and put a hand on the
- 2:39back of Odell's chair.
- 2:41"Congratulations, mister," he said, "you
- 2:44just bought a $140,000
- 2:46bill for $12."
- 2:48"I heard him read it," Odell said. "I
- 2:50don't think you did." Odell went up
- 2:52front and paid with seven ones and a
- 2:54five, counted out flat on the table.
- 2:57The clerk was young, and she took the
- 2:58money without any expression at all, and
- 3:00pushed a form across for his signature.
- 3:03"You want a receipt?" she said. "I want
- 3:05two." While she was stamping them, Odell
- 3:07looked back at the room. Everybody was
- 3:09talking to somebody. One man was not. He
- 3:12sat alone in the last row, an old man in
- 3:15a short-sleeved dress shirt so clean it
- 3:17looked new, with two pens clipped in the
- 3:19pocket. Nothing about the clerk or the
- 3:21clipboard had his attention. He was
- 3:23looking at Odell steadily, and he had a
- 3:26little spiral notebook open on his knee,
- 3:28and he was writing something in it. When
- 3:30Odell looked back a second time, the
- 3:32chair was empty. Neva was in the truck
- 3:35with the windows down, a soft-sided
- 3:37cooler on her lap. The masking tape on
- 3:39the lid said not food in black marker,
- 3:42because Odell had reached in there once
- 3:44in the dark looking for a sandwich.
- 3:46"Well," she said. He handed her one of
- 3:49the receipts. She read it twice. $12.
- 3:53$12.
- 3:55And the demolition.
- 3:56And the demolition.
- 3:58He got in and shut the door. "90 days
- 4:00from the letter, or the county does it
- 4:02and puts a lien on the ground. Neva
- 4:05folded the receipt into the pocket of
- 4:06her jacket, which was a men's jacket
- 4:09because it had been in the truck when
- 4:10the house went and hers had not. How
- 4:13much is the demolition? He said 140
- 4:16thousand.
- 4:18Thousand? She was quiet for a minute.
- 4:20Down the block a school bus went past
- 4:22with nobody in it. Odell put his hands
- 4:24on the wheel and did not start the
- 4:25engine because starting the engine
- 4:27burned gas and gas came out of the
- 4:29coffee can.
- 4:30I want to say something and then I don't
- 4:32want to talk about it again, Neva said.
- 4:34All right. We didn't buy a house, Odell.
- 4:37We bought 90 days. She snapped the
- 4:40cooler latch. That's all right. 90 days
- 4:43is more than we had at 8:00 this
- 4:44morning. 19 days before that they had
- 4:47been sleeping behind a church on the
- 4:49north end of town in a 1994 Ford
- 4:51half-ton with a camper shell Odell had
- 4:54bought used in 2001. The pastor knew. He
- 4:57had told them to park under the light
- 4:59and not by the dumpster. Before the
- 5:01church there had been Marla's basement
- 5:02in Columbus for 11 days.
- 5:05Their daughter had been decent about it,
- 5:06decent and she had already done the
- 5:08arithmetic before they got there. There
- 5:10was a couch that folded out. There was a
- 5:12half bath. She needed 400 a month and
- 5:15she needed them out of the house between
- 5:178:00 and 5:00 because she took calls for
- 5:18the dental office from the dining room
- 5:20and she would rather they did not have
- 5:22visitors because of the neighbors. She's
- 5:24not cruel, Neva had said in the car.
- 5:27Coming back? I never said cruel. You
- 5:30said something. I said 400, Odell had
- 5:33said. I said that's what she asked her
- 5:35mother and dad for and I'm going to sit
- 5:37with that a while. The house on 14th
- 5:40Street had sold at sheriff's sale in
- 5:41June for $162,000.
- 5:44They had lived in it for 46 years. Odell
- 5:47had hung every door in it and plastered
- 5:49the whole upstairs twice, once in 1982
- 5:52when the pipe let go and once in 2009
- 5:54because he was bored and Neva wanted the
- 5:56ceiling smooth instead of textured. He
- 5:59had put his name on his son's loan on a
- 6:00Thursday afternoon in the front room of
- 6:02that house at the drop-leaf table with a
- 6:05pen from the bank. "It's a formality,
- 6:07Dad." Jared had said.
- 6:09He was 48, and he owned an insurance
- 6:12agency, and he had explained it
- 6:13patiently three times, because Odell had
- 6:16asked three times.
- 6:18"The bank wants a personal guarantee on
- 6:20the file. Nobody ever actually calls
- 6:22one. In 20 years, I have never seen a
- 6:24bank call one. But if they did, then
- 6:27it'd be the same as if I'd signed it.
- 6:29And I'm signing it, too. Dad, look at
- 6:32me. I'm signing it, too." He had signed
- 6:35it, too. That part was true. It just had
- 6:38not mattered, because by the time the
- 6:39bank went looking, there was nothing of
- 6:41Jared's left to find. $241 had been in
- 6:45the coffee can that morning. $229 now.
- 6:49Odell started the truck. Quarry Hill
- 6:51Road ran a mile and a half of blacktop,
- 6:54and then gave up and went to gravel. The
- 6:56quarry itself had shut down in 1988.
- 6:58Sandstone. Odell's father had cut stone
- 7:01there for 9 years before he got into the
- 7:03plastering trade, and Odell had eaten
- 7:06his lunch on the tailgate up there as a
- 7:07boy while the crusher ran. The road
- 7:09climbed through second-growth timber,
- 7:12and then the trees stopped all at once,
- 7:14and there it was.
- 7:15Everybody in town called it the Duval
- 7:17place. Three stories of dark brick
- 7:19sitting on a sandstone foundation, with
- 7:22four sandstone columns holding up a
- 7:24porch that ran the whole front. 22
- 7:26windows across the face of it, and every
- 7:28one of them boarded with plywood gone
- 7:30silver from weather. Nailed through the
- 7:32casing of the front door was an Orange
- 7:34County placard, faded pink at the edges.
- 7:37"Condemned. Do not occupy. Unsafe
- 7:40structure." Nava got out of the truck
- 7:42and stood with a hand on the door. "How
- 7:44big is it?" she said. "11,000 ft." he
- 7:47said. "That's not a house." "It was
- 7:49somebody's house." Odell was looking at
- 7:52the roofline. He had been looking at the
- 7:54roofline since the trees stopped, and he
- 7:56had not said anything, and he did not
- 7:58say anything now for a while.
- 8:00The main roof was slate,
- 8:02purple-gray, laid in courses with maybe
- 8:04two dozen slates slipped or gone on the
- 8:06north slope, and a run of copper
- 8:08flashing hanging loose off the chimney.
- 8:11The rear third of the building was
- 8:12different. Somebody had thrown up an
- 8:14addition off the back, a two-story L and
- 8:17roofed it flat with tar and gravel.
- 8:19And that roof had let go completely. He
- 8:21could see the rafter tails from the yard
- 8:23black and open to the sky. "You're
- 8:25smiling." Neva said. "No, I'm not."
- 8:28"You are." Odell walked up the porch
- 8:30steps testing each one and put his
- 8:33shoulder against the front door. The
- 8:35county had put a hasp and padlock on it.
- 8:37That hasp came out of the wood with
- 8:39almost no argument, which told him
- 8:41something about the wood by the door and
- 8:42nothing at all about the house. The door
- 8:45swung in. A smell came out at them
- 8:47first. Cold plaster, mouse, old paper
- 8:52and under it something like a church
- 8:53basement. The front hall ran 40 ft to a
- 8:56staircase and the staircase turned twice
- 9:00and the floor was quarter-sawn oak
- 9:01buried under 60 years of grit and pigeon
- 9:04mess and fallen paper.
- 9:06Neva put her hand over her mouth. Odell
- 9:08walked to the middle of the hall. He
- 9:10stood there a second, then he tipped his
- 9:12head back and looked up. He stayed like
- 9:14that long enough that Neva said his
- 9:16name. "Odell."
- 9:18He did not answer.
- 9:19Instead, he reached into the inside
- 9:21pocket of his coat and brought out his
- 9:23father's trowel, an 11-in Marshall Town
- 9:26with the handle worn down on the left
- 9:27side and three initials filed into the
- 9:30wood with a triangle file. That trowel
- 9:32had lived in a coat pocket for 51 years
- 9:35because he had never once found a truck
- 9:37he trusted to keep it in.
- 9:39He reached up as high as he could and
- 9:41tapped the ceiling with the butt of the
- 9:42handle. Tap. Tap. He moved 4 ft and did
- 9:46it again. "What are you doing?" Neva
- 9:48said. "Listening." "To what?" "To
- 9:50whether it's hollow." He worked his way
- 9:52down the hall that way tapping and
- 9:54moving and tapping with his head back
- 9:56and his mouth open a little. Neva stood
- 9:58in the doorway and watched him and did
- 10:00not interrupt. At the foot of the stairs
- 10:02he stopped and let his arm down. "Come
- 10:04here." he said. "Stand right here. Now
- 10:07look up." The ceiling of the front hall
- 10:09was coffered, deep square panels, 32 of
- 10:12them, each one framed with a molded
- 10:15band. Where the ceiling met the wall,
- 10:17there was a cornice a foot and a half
- 10:18deep running three stages with a row of
- 10:21egg and dart under a row of dentals. In
- 10:24the center of the hall, over where a
- 10:25light had hung, there was a plaster
- 10:27medallion 4 ft across with an acanthus
- 10:30pattern coming out of it in six
- 10:31directions. It was filthy. It was also
- 10:34from one end of that hall to the other
- 10:37unbroken. "That's plaster," Nava said.
- 10:40"That's not plaster. That's run-in-place
- 10:42plaster." His voice had gone strange.
- 10:46"You see how the egg and dart doesn't
- 10:47repeat exactly? Look at it. Count six of
- 10:50them and look at the seventh."
- 10:52He pointed with the trowel. "That's
- 10:54because a man stood on a scaffold with a
- 10:56zinc template and a bucket of lime putty
- 10:58and ran that cornice by hand, one pass
- 11:01at a time, the whole length of this
- 11:03hall. Then he pressed every one of those
- 11:05eggs in with his thumb behind a mold."
- 11:07"How long would that take?" "Two men,
- 11:10six weeks." He lowered the trowel. "That
- 11:13ceiling was run by hand, Nava, every
- 11:16foot of it. There is not one man left
- 11:18alive in this county who can do that."
- 11:20He was quiet for a second. "Except me."
- 11:24Nava looked at the side of his face.
- 11:26"The county says this building is going
- 11:28to fall down." The county looked at the
- 11:30back. Odell turned and pointed down the
- 11:32hall toward the dark where the L
- 11:34started. "The back's gone, and the back
- 11:37deserved to go. Somebody stuck a flat
- 11:39tar roof on it in about 1946, and a flat
- 11:42roof is a 10-year roof no matter who
- 11:44lays it. Water's been coming into that
- 11:46third of the building since before I was
- 11:48born." He turned back. "But this part
- 11:50has slate on it. Slate lasts 150 years
- 11:54if nobody walks on it, and nobody's
- 11:56walked on it because nobody's been
- 11:58allowed in the yard since 1968."
- 12:01He tapped the wall beside him with two
- 12:02knuckles and it answered solid.
- 12:05"Everybody in this town has been
- 12:06standing at the bottom of the hill
- 12:07looking at that hole in the back. Not
- 12:10one of them came in here and looked up."
- 12:12They spent the rest of that day being
- 12:13practical because being practical was
- 12:16the only thing either of them had ever
- 12:17been good at when frightened. There was
- 12:19a hand pump at the corner of the house
- 12:21and it drew after 90 strokes a rope of
- 12:24orange water that ran clear in about 2
- 12:26minutes. Odell would not let her drink
- 12:29it until it was tested. There was a hose
- 12:31bib on the well house that worked. Two
- 12:34rooms on the ground floor were bone dry
- 12:36front to back and one of them had a
- 12:38fireplace that drew when he lit a page
- 12:40of the county paper in it. He set the
- 12:42camp stove on the hearth. Neva swept a
- 12:4412-ft square of the oak floor with a
- 12:47broom she found hanging on a nail and
- 12:49under 60 years of dirt the floor came up
- 12:51honey colored and tight, not a gap you
- 12:54could get a dime in. By 5:00 they had
- 12:56plastic sheeting stapled over four
- 12:58window openings and the truck backed up
- 13:00to the porch. At 6:00 they went up. The
- 13:03staircase was solid. The second floor
- 13:05was six bedrooms and a bathroom with a
- 13:07claw foot tub and a cast iron radiator
- 13:09lying on its side. It was a rich
- 13:11family's house and it looked like one.
- 13:14The third floor did not. The stairs to
- 13:16the third floor were narrower and
- 13:17steeper and came out into one long room
- 13:20that ran the entire width of the
- 13:22building, 60 ft of it, with dormer
- 13:25windows down both sides. Iron bed frames
- 13:27were stacked against the chimney breast
- 13:29in two piles, 10 or 11 of them, painted
- 13:32white a long time ago.
- 13:34Along the north wall, at a height of
- 13:36about 4 ft off the floor, somebody had
- 13:39screwed a board with 22 coat hooks on
- 13:41it, 4 ft. Odell looked at that a while.
- 13:45Neva, I see it. Those hooks are at a
- 13:48child's height. I see it, Odell.
- 13:52There was a chalkboard on the end wall,
- 13:543 ft by 5, and the ghost of writing on
- 13:56it that had been erased and rained on
- 13:58and erased again. The plaster walls were
- 14:00papered, a small blue diamond pattern,
- 14:03and the paper had let go in long curls
- 14:05near the ceiling where the damp had come
- 14:07around the chimney. Neva reached up and
- 14:09pulled one of the curls. It came away in
- 14:11a strip 2 ft long with a sound like
- 14:14tearing bread. She did not say anything.
- 14:17"What?" Odell said. "Bring the light
- 14:19over here." He brought the flashlight.
- 14:22Underneath the paper, the plaster was
- 14:23smooth and gray, and on the plaster, in
- 14:26pencil, in a child's careful capital
- 14:28letters, somebody had written, "Donny R.
- 14:31August 1953. I was here 9 days." Neva
- 14:36put her fingers on it and then took them
- 14:37off quick, like the wall was hot.
- 14:40Somebody wanted to be remembered bad
- 14:42enough to write it under the wallpaper,
- 14:43she said. Odell took the trowel out of
- 14:46his coat. He slid the edge of it up
- 14:48under the seam of the next strip,
- 14:49careful the way he had taken down a
- 14:51thousand square feet of bad plaster, and
- 14:54never once broken good plaster doing it.
- 14:56And he peeled. Two more names came out
- 14:58from under the paper, then a date, then
- 15:01four names in a row in an adult's hand,
- 15:03in ink, with numbers beside them.
- 15:06"Hold the light steady," he said. "It's
- 15:08steady." "Hold it higher."
- 15:11She held it higher and he peeled another
- 15:1218 inches, and there were seven more. By
- 15:15the time the batteries in the flashlight
- 15:17went brown and quit, they had cleared 6
- 15:20feet of that wall, and the names had not
- 15:22stopped. They came back up at first
- 15:24light with a broom, a putty knife, a
- 15:26spray bottle of well water, and a spiral
- 15:28notebook Neva had bought for 59 cents on
- 15:30the way out of Columbus. The dormer
- 15:33windows on the east side gave them 4
- 15:35hours of good light. Odell worked the
- 15:37seams and Neva worked the notebook, and
- 15:39neither of them stopped for lunch
- 15:41because neither of them thought of it.
- 15:42The paper came off in sheets where the
- 15:44damp had gotten to it, and in stubborn
- 15:46postage stamps where it had not. Under
- 15:48the paper, the plaster was in good
- 15:50shape, hard and smooth and gray, which
- 15:53told Odell that whoever hung that
- 15:54wallpaper had hung it over a wall they
- 15:56had no intention of ever repairing.
- 15:58They had covered something, not fixed
- 16:00it. "Read me the last one again," Neva
- 16:02said. "Loretta June 1951.
- 16:06That's all it says." "Loretta June,"
- 16:08Neva said, writing.
- 16:10By noon they had 41. By 3:00 they had
- 16:1398. They found a run of names in an
- 16:16adult's handwriting, in ink instead of
- 16:19pencil, 4 in high on the wall behind
- 16:21where the bed frames were stacked with a
- 16:24number written beside each.
- 16:26One. The numbers were not ages. They ran
- 16:29in sequence and the sequence climbed as
- 16:31the dates climbed. That's a list.
- 16:34Odell said.
- 16:35That's somebody's list. Whose?
- 16:38Whoever ran this place. He wiped his
- 16:41hands down the front of his coat.
- 16:43Kids don't number themselves. By dark on
- 16:45the second day, the notebook had 211
- 16:48names in it and they had cleared a
- 16:50little over half of one wall out of
- 16:51four. Neva sat on the top step of the
- 16:54third floor stairs with the notebook
- 16:56closed on her knees and did not get up
- 16:58when Odell said her name. I need to ask
- 17:00you a thing, she said. Ask it. What was
- 17:03this house? I don't know. You know it
- 17:05wasn't anybody's home. I know that. He
- 17:08sat down on the step below her which put
- 17:10his shoulder against her shin and he
- 17:12stayed there. The letter came on the
- 17:14fourth day. The truck that brought it up
- 17:16the hill was a county truck with a
- 17:17magnetic sign on the door and the man
- 17:20who got out of it was maybe 50 and
- 17:21carried a clipboard and a hard hat he
- 17:23did not put on. He stopped 10 ft from
- 17:26the porch which Odell noticed. You
- 17:28Sturgill. I am. You bought this. I did.
- 17:32The man looked at the plastic on the
- 17:34windows and the camp stove and the two
- 17:35lawn chairs and the extension cord
- 17:37running nowhere. You're living in it.
- 17:39We're standing in it. Mr., there's a
- 17:41placard on that door. There is, Odell
- 17:44said. It's dated 1968 and it's been
- 17:47renewed 11 times and I read every word
- 17:50of it before I raised my hand. The man
- 17:52came up two steps and handed over an
- 17:54envelope. Then you'll want to read this
- 17:55one, too. That's your abatement notice.
- 17:5890 days from the date on it which was
- 18:00Tuesday. Odell opened it standing there.
- 18:03Neva read it over his arm. The figure
- 18:05was $141,200.
- 18:08That was the county's estimate to take
- 18:10the building down, haul it, cap the
- 18:12well, and grade the lot. Underneath the
- 18:14figure was a paragraph in smaller type.
- 18:17Read the bottom part out loud, the
- 18:19inspector said and he did not say it
- 18:22unkindly. Nava read it. "Alternatively,
- 18:25the owner may submit a structural
- 18:26assessment prepared by a licensed
- 18:28professional engineer together with a
- 18:30phased schedule of remediation for
- 18:32review by the Board of Zoning Appeals."
- 18:34"That's the other door," the inspector
- 18:36said. "I'll tell you the truth because
- 18:38you're going to find it out anyway. In
- 18:4022 years with this department, I have
- 18:43never seen that paragraph work. Not
- 18:45once. Not on any building. And for
- 18:48certain not on this one." He put the
- 18:50hard hat under his arm. "The engineer
- 18:52alone is going to run you 3,000. How
- 18:55much of this building have you been
- 18:57inside?" Odell asked. "Excuse me. You,
- 19:01personally.
- 19:02How many rooms?"
- 19:04The inspector looked at the front hall
- 19:05through the open door, and Odell watched
- 19:08him look, and watched him not step
- 19:10toward it. "That's not how the file
- 19:11works," the man said. "The file says
- 19:14unsafe. I don't get to have an opinion
- 19:16about the file." He went down the steps.
- 19:19At the truck, he turned around. "For
- 19:21what it's worth, I hope you keep the
- 19:22columns. My wife's grandmother used to
- 19:24say they hauled those up from the quarry
- 19:26with a mule team."
- 19:28He drove off. Nava folded the letter
- 19:30along the crease it came with. "90
- 19:32days," she said. "86." Word got around
- 19:36town in about a day and a half, which
- 19:38for that town was slow. They went in for
- 19:40batteries and bread and a jug of
- 19:41vinegar, and a woman at the counter of
- 19:43the diner on the corner asked Nava
- 19:45straight out if it was true. And when
- 19:47Nava said it was, the woman said,
- 19:50"Honey, do you know what that place is?
- 19:53I know it's ours.
- 19:54There's people in this town won't drive
- 19:56up that road." "Why not?" The woman
- 19:58wiped the counter, and she wiped it a
- 20:00second time. "Because their mother told
- 20:02them not to." A stringer for the county
- 20:04paper came up the hill on Saturday, a
- 20:06young man with a camera and a phone, and
- 20:09stayed 40 minutes and took one
- 20:10photograph. He put Odell in the middle
- 20:12of the front hall with his head tipped
- 20:14back looking up at the medallion, and
- 20:16that photograph ran on page three under
- 20:18the headline $12.
- 20:20The story under it was 400 words and got
- 20:23two things wrong. Two days after it ran,
- 20:25a case of bottled water was sitting on
- 20:27the porch steps when they came out in
- 20:29the morning.
- 20:3024 half-liter bottles, shrink-wrapped,
- 20:33no note, no name. The same morning,
- 20:36folded under the wiper of the truck,
- 20:38there was a sheet of lined paper with
- 20:40two words on it in ballpoint pen,
- 20:42pressed so hard the paper had torn a
- 20:44little at the ends of the letters. Get
- 20:46out. Odell stood there holding it. Then
- 20:49he put it in his coat pocket with the
- 20:50trowel and did not mention it. And Neva,
- 20:52who had seen it from the porch, did not
- 20:54mention it either. And it sat between
- 20:56them all day like a third person. Odell
- 20:58went to the county recorder's office on
- 21:00the Monday because he wanted to see the
- 21:02file the inspector would not have an
- 21:04opinion about. The counter clerk was
- 21:06young, maybe 26 with her hair pulled
- 21:08back in a lanyard, and she was eating
- 21:10crackers out of a sleeve and looked glad
- 21:12of something to do.
- 21:14Her name was Dana. She drove a school
- 21:16bus at 6:00 in the morning and worked
- 21:17the counter from 8:30 until 4:30, and
- 21:20she had lived in that town her whole
- 21:21life. "Parcel 417,"
- 21:25Odell said. "The Duval place. You know
- 21:28it by number.
- 21:29Everybody in this office knows it by
- 21:31number." She went into the back and was
- 21:33gone 11 minutes, and came out carrying a
- 21:35file 4 in thick, and she set it down on
- 21:38the counter with both hands, and
- 21:39something in her face had changed. "It's
- 21:41a lot," she said. "I can read." "No, I
- 21:45mean" she opened it. "I mean it's a lot
- 21:48for a building nobody uses." They went
- 21:50through it together standing up for an
- 21:52hour and 10 minutes. Deeds. A quitclaim
- 21:56in 1963.
- 21:57A transfer to the county in 1971 for
- 22:00unpaid taxes. 11 separate condemnation
- 22:03renewals. 1968, 72, 77, 81, 85, 89, 94,
- 22:1199, 2004, 2010, 2017,
- 22:16and a 12th in March. Every one of them
- 22:18carried the same signature and the same
- 22:20place, and the signature did not change
- 22:23much over 57 years except to get
- 22:25smaller. Who's is that? Odell said. Dene
- 22:29looked at the door of the back office,
- 22:31then she looked at the counter, then she
- 22:33pulled a deposit slip out of a stack,
- 22:35turned it over and wrote three letters
- 22:37and a name on the back of it, and slid
- 22:39it under his hand without letting go of
- 22:40it. W. Prine. He was the auditor, she
- 22:44said quietly. 29 years. He's still on
- 22:47the board of zoning appeals. He comes in
- 22:50on Thursdays. Board of zoning appeals,
- 22:52Odell said. Yes, sir.
- 22:55The board that hears the engineers
- 22:56report. Yes, sir. She took her hand off
- 22:59the deposit slip. There's one more thing
- 23:02and then I'd rather you didn't say where
- 23:03you got it. Before 1968, that parcel's
- 23:06got a use classification on it in the
- 23:08county records. It's coded as an
- 23:10institutional use. Not residential. What
- 23:13institution? It doesn't say. That kind
- 23:16of file was in the courthouse basement.
- 23:19She stacked the papers square. The
- 23:21courthouse burned in 1968.
- 23:23Odell drove up the hill with the file
- 23:25copies on the seat beside him, and sat
- 23:27in the truck in the yard for a while
- 23:29without going in.
- 23:30When he did go in, Neva was at the card
- 23:33table with a notebook and a cup of tea,
- 23:35and he put the copies down and told her
- 23:37all of it, and then he said the thing
- 23:38that had been assembling itself in him
- 23:40the whole way up the road. They didn't
- 23:42condemn a building, he said.
- 23:44They condemned a witness. Weldon Prine
- 23:46came up the hill on a Wednesday at 10
- 23:49minutes after 9:00 in the morning in a
- 23:51Buick so clean it looked wet. He was 81
- 23:54and he moved carefully, but he did not
- 23:56use a cane, and he was wearing the same
- 23:58kind of short-sleeved dress shirt he had
- 24:00worn in the basement of the annex with
- 24:02two pens in the pocket. He stopped at
- 24:04the bottom of the porch steps and took
- 24:06his hat off, which was not a thing men
- 24:08did anymore.
- 24:09Mr. Sturgill, I know you, Odell said.
- 24:13You were at the sale. You were the one
- 24:15not laughing. I've never found much
- 24:17funny about this property.
- 24:19Neva came out and stood in the doorway
- 24:20with a dishtowel in her hand, and Weldon
- 24:23nodded to her and called her ma'am, and
- 24:25asked about the well, and said the water
- 24:27in this part of the county was hard, but
- 24:29it was good. Then he said, "I'd like to
- 24:31buy it from you." Odell did not answer.
- 24:34"$30,000," Welden said. "Cash today out
- 24:38of my own account, and I will assume the
- 24:40abatement and every dollar of it. You'll
- 24:42walk away this afternoon with $30,000
- 24:45and no lean and no letter and no 90
- 24:48days." He turned the hat around by the
- 24:50brim. "You paid $12 9 days ago. I don't
- 24:54believe a man alive would call that a
- 24:55bad week. Why? Because it's dangerous
- 24:59and it ought to come down." "That's not
- 25:01an answer to why you." Welden looked
- 25:03past him through the open door, down the
- 25:06front hall, and his eyes went up. Just
- 25:08for a second, up and then away.
- 25:11"My mother worked in this house," he
- 25:13said. "A long time ago. I don't like
- 25:16looking at it."
- 25:17"Then don't drive up here. $30,000, Mr.
- 25:20Sturgill." "I'll think on it."
- 25:23"Please do."
- 25:24Welden put the hat back on.
- 25:26"There's a thing I'd say to you as one
- 25:28old man to another, and then I'll go.
- 25:30That building has eaten every person who
- 25:32ever tried to hold on to it. Every
- 25:34single one. I'm not threatening you. I'm
- 25:37the only man in this county who's read
- 25:39the whole file, and I'm telling you it's
- 25:41true." He drove down the hill. Neva
- 25:43stood in the doorway with the towel and
- 25:45watched the Buick until it went into the
- 25:47trees. Then she said,
- 25:49"You're going to take it." "I didn't say
- 25:51that. You said you'd think on it. In 51
- 25:54years you have never once said you'd
- 25:56think on a thing you weren't already to
- 25:58doing." Odell sat down in the lawn
- 26:00chair. His hands had locked up that
- 26:02morning, both of them. They had been
- 26:04doing that for three winters now, and he
- 26:05had been hiding it since 6:00. "Neva,
- 26:08we've got $209."
- 26:11"I know what we've got."
- 26:13"$30,000 is a little house on the flats.
- 26:16It's a real one with a furnace."
- 26:18He was looking at the yard. "It's your
- 26:20insulin, and it's not a coffee can. It's
- 26:234 years of not being scared. And this
- 26:26This is a hole in the ground with a bill
- 26:28attached to it. And 81 days and one old
- 26:31man on the board that votes. There are
- 26:34211 children's names on the third floor
- 26:36of this building. They're dead, Odell
- 26:39said. Neiva's chin came up. Most of
- 26:42them, he said. You know they are, and
- 26:45I'm sorry, but I'm 74, and I can't fix a
- 26:48dead thing. He stood up out of the chair
- 26:50too fast and had to put a hand on the
- 26:52porch post. You've never once in your
- 26:54life had to bring home a dollar with
- 26:56your hands. You don't know what it costs
- 26:58to be the one who does. So, don't stand
- 27:00there and hand me the moral high ground
- 27:02like it's a plate of supper. He heard it
- 27:04as it left his mouth. He heard exactly
- 27:07how it sounded. Neiva did not raise her
- 27:09voice. She looked at him for about 4
- 27:11seconds, and then she went in the house
- 27:13and let the dish towel fall on the arm
- 27:15of the other lawn chair, and she did not
- 27:17speak to him again that day, or the next
- 27:19day, or until 11:00 the morning after
- 27:22that. That was how she had always done
- 27:24it.
- 27:25Odell would have taken shouting. On the
- 27:27second day of her silence, he drove into
- 27:29town and parked in the lot at the bank
- 27:30at 10:00 after 1:00 in the afternoon and
- 27:33sat there with the engine off. The deed
- 27:35was folded in his coat. He knew what
- 27:37Weldon's account was at, and he knew the
- 27:39man would come out and sign that
- 27:40afternoon if he called him. He sat in
- 27:43that lot for 40 minutes. Then he drove
- 27:45up the hill and told her he had gone to
- 27:46the hardware store, which was a lie, and
- 27:49she said, "Did you get the vinegar?" And
- 27:51he said, "They were out." And that was
- 27:53the whole conversation. On the third
- 27:55night, he could not sleep at all. Some
- 27:57men walk when they can't sleep. Odell
- 28:00looked at foundations. He had done it
- 28:01his whole working life, on jobs and off
- 28:04them, because a foundation is a thing
- 28:06that either tells you the truth or it
- 28:07doesn't, and either way it doesn't
- 28:09argue. At about 1:30 in the morning, he
- 28:11took the kerosene lantern down the
- 28:13outside cellar stairs at the back corner
- 28:15of the house, past the L where the roof
- 28:17was gone, and went in under the
- 28:19building.
- 28:20The cellar ran the full footprint.
- 28:22Sandstone block laid dry in courses 2 ft
- 28:25thick, and not one course of it out of
- 28:28line. He walked the whole perimeter with
- 28:30the lantern held low, and found three
- 28:32cracks, and every one of them was old,
- 28:35dry, and settled. And he put his thumb
- 28:37in each one, and it was the same thumb
- 28:39width top and bottom. "You're fine," he
- 28:42said out loud. "You're fine.
- 28:44You just needed somebody to come look at
- 28:46you."
- 28:47At the north end, there was a coal
- 28:48chute, a sheet iron hopper coming
- 28:50through the wall, and a heap of coal
- 28:52dust and clinker under it that had been
- 28:54there since the boiler died. Behind the
- 28:56hopper, back where the light did not
- 28:58reach unless you crouched, there was a
- 29:00shape that was not stone. Odell got down
- 29:02on his knees on the clinker and put the
- 29:04lantern on the floor and reached in.
- 29:06Steel, cold, flat, painted. He worked
- 29:10his fingers along it and found a corner,
- 29:13then an edge, then a drawer pull. It was
- 29:15a document cabinet, four drawers, 30 in
- 29:19wide, standing upright against the
- 29:20foundation wall. And somebody had built
- 29:23the coal hopper out from the wall in
- 29:24front of it, which meant somebody had
- 29:26put it there and then hidden it on
- 29:28purpose. The drawers would not move. He
- 29:30got the lantern up close and saw why.
- 29:33All four of them had been welded shut at
- 29:35the hinge side. Three fat, ugly beads of
- 29:38weld a piece laid down by a man in a
- 29:40hurry.
- 29:41Odell knelt there in the coal dust with
- 29:43his hands aching and looked at that
- 29:44cabinet for a long time. Then he went up
- 29:47the stairs, got a brick and a length of
- 29:49pipe out of the L, came back down, set
- 29:51the pipe against the top weld on the
- 29:53second drawer, and hit it 11 times. On
- 29:56the 11th, the weld cracked with a sound
- 29:58like a nail coming out of oak, and the
- 30:00drawer came off its track and slid 2 in.
- 30:03Inside, standing on end, were ledgers,
- 30:06nine of them, cloth-bound, gray, each
- 30:09one about the size of a hymnal, and the
- 30:11top edges of the pages were furred with
- 30:13damp, but the blocks were dry.
- 30:15Odell wiped his hand on his pants and
- 30:17opened the first one. The pages were
- 30:19ruled in two columns. Every line of both
- 30:22columns was full, front to back in the
- 30:24same small fast hand in ink, and not one
- 30:27word of it was English. It was loops and
- 30:29hooks and little curled marks, thousands
- 30:32of them running left to right in perfect
- 30:34lines, and Odell Sturgill sat down flat
- 30:37on the cold floor with a lantern beside
- 30:39him and could not read a single letter
- 30:40of it. He carried them up two at a time,
- 30:43nine trips of the outside stairs, and
- 30:45stacked them on the card table in the
- 30:47dry room, and then he stood there in his
- 30:49coal-black coat and waited for it to be
- 30:51morning. Neva got up at 20 after 4:00
- 30:54because she always did. She came in with
- 30:56her cooler under her arm, and she saw
- 30:57the stack, and she stopped. And Odell
- 31:00said nothing because for 2 and 1/2 days
- 31:03she had not been speaking to him, and he
- 31:04had decided he was not going to be the
- 31:06one to break it with talk. He opened the
- 31:08top one and turned it around and slid it
- 31:10across the table.
- 31:11Neva set the cooler down. She sat, and
- 31:14she pulled the lantern closer with one
- 31:16finger, and she looked at the first page
- 31:18for a long time.
- 31:19Then she said, "Get me a pencil."
- 31:22Neva, "Get me a pencil and get me the
- 31:24notebook and sit down and don't talk to
- 31:26me for a minute." He got the pencil. He
- 31:29got the notebook. Then he sat down on
- 31:31the far side of the table with his hands
- 31:33flat on his knees, and he did not talk.
- 31:35Neva put her finger under the first line
- 31:37of the left-hand column and moved it
- 31:38slowly across, and her lips moved, and
- 31:41she wrote three words on the notebook
- 31:43page.
- 31:44Then she moved her finger down and did
- 31:46it again.
- 31:47At 6:00 the window went gray.
- 31:49By 7:00 the light was good enough that
- 31:51she asked him to blow out the lantern
- 31:53because it was wasting oil. At 1/2 past
- 31:568:00 she straightened up and put her
- 31:57hand flat on the open page and looked at
- 31:59her husband for the first time in 2 and
- 32:011/2 days. "It's shorthand," she said.
- 32:04"It's Gregg. It's what?" "Gregg
- 32:06shorthand. It's not a code, and it's not
- 32:09a language. It's a system, and every
- 32:12stenographer in this country learned it,
- 32:14and it went out of style about the time
- 32:15you and I got married." She turned the
- 32:17ledger halfway back toward him. "This
- 32:19whole book is somebody's dictation
- 32:21written for their own eyes by somebody
- 32:23fast." Odell was looking at her hand on
- 32:26the page. "You can read that." "I could
- 32:28take it at 120 words a minute in 1969,
- 32:32and I could read it back cold 2 weeks
- 32:34later." "Neva Business College in
- 32:36Steubenville, 9 months. My daddy paid
- 32:40$40 a month for it and he complained
- 32:41about it every single month. She was
- 32:44still going down the page with her
- 32:45finger while she talked. Then I sat
- 32:47outside the office at the quarry for 11
- 32:49years and took dictation off three
- 32:51different superintendents. And I quit
- 32:53the week before Jared came and I have
- 32:55not opened a steno pad since the 11th of
- 32:58March, 1980.
- 33:00You never told me that.
- 33:02Neva looked up. Odell Sturgill. I told
- 33:06you the day I met you. I told you at the
- 33:08Elks in 1973 and you said, "Huh." And
- 33:11you asked me if I wanted a pop. She went
- 33:13back to the page. 51 years and you never
- 33:17once asked me what I did before you. He
- 33:19sat with that. "What does it say?" He
- 33:21said finally. "Give me till dinner."
- 33:24By dinner she had four pages of the
- 33:25notebook filled and she made him a cup
- 33:27of tea before she would read any of it,
- 33:30which was how he knew it was bad. "The
- 33:31front of the book," she said, "the
- 33:33flyleaf. It says, 'Receiving Home,
- 33:36County Children's Bureau. Volume one of
- 33:39nine.'"
- 33:40And then a name. I. Prine. Matron.
- 33:44Odell put the cup down without drinking
- 33:46out of it. "Say that again."
- 33:48"I. Prine. Matron." In a woman's hand.
- 33:52Neva turned the notebook around so he
- 33:53could see her block letters. "Odell,
- 33:56that man stood in our yard nine days ago
- 33:58and told us his mother worked in this
- 34:00house. He did. Well, she didn't work in
- 34:03it. She ran it. The ledgers were intake
- 34:06books and they were kept in two columns
- 34:08and it took Neva a day and a half of
- 34:09reading before she understood why.
- 34:12The left column was the county's
- 34:13version. Date received. Sex.
- 34:16Age.
- 34:18Condition on arrival. Circumstances
- 34:20disposition. Every line of it clean and
- 34:23short and official. The sort of thing a
- 34:25person writes when they know somebody
- 34:26upstairs is going to read it. The right
- 34:28column was what actually happened. "She
- 34:31wrote the form on the left," Neva said.
- 34:33"Then she came up here at night and
- 34:35wrote the truth on the right. In a hand
- 34:37nobody in that courthouse could read.
- 34:38And she did it 419
- 34:41times. 419.
- 34:44That's the last number in volume nine.
- 34:471946 through 1961.
- 34:50Neva shut the book carefully. The
- 34:52numbers on our wall upstairs, in the
- 34:54ink, in the grown handwriting, those are
- 34:57these. She wrote them on the plaster,
- 34:59and then somebody papered over her. Dana
- 35:02came up the hill on a Thursday after her
- 35:04shift, still in the lanyard, with a
- 35:06grocery bag of copy paper she had paid
- 35:08for herself. She read three pages of
- 35:10Neva's transcription standing in the
- 35:12front hall, and then she had to go
- 35:14outside and sit on the porch step. "My
- 35:16aunt wrote to the county in 1996," she
- 35:19said. "She was born in 1954,
- 35:22and she was placed out of here. And she
- 35:24wanted her mother's name, and she wrote
- 35:25three times over about four years."
- 35:28Dana had her elbows on her knees. "They
- 35:30sent her a form letter every time. Same
- 35:33letter. It says all records of the
- 35:35county children's bureau were destroyed
- 35:37by fire on the 19th of March, 1968, and
- 35:40no reconstruction of those records is
- 35:42possible."
- 35:43"Is that letter true?" Neva said. "The
- 35:45fire's true. There was a fire, and it
- 35:48took the basement." Danae looked up.
- 35:51"She died in 2011. She never knew her
- 35:53mother's first name, ma'am.
- 35:55Not the first name."
- 35:57Nobody said anything for a while. Out on
- 35:59the hill, the wind came up and went
- 36:01through the plywood on the second floor
- 36:02windows and made a sound like somebody
- 36:04breathing through their teeth. "What was
- 36:06her number?" Neva said. "I don't know if
- 36:09she had a number. Everybody had a
- 36:10number. That was the point of it." Neva
- 36:13stood up. "When was she born?" "April of
- 36:161954."
- 36:18"Come inside," Neva said. "Bring the
- 36:20paper." Curtis Odum came up on the
- 36:22Saturday in a two-tone truck with a
- 36:24toolbox in the bed, and he did not knock
- 36:26because he stopped at the bottom of the
- 36:28steps and took his cap off and stood
- 36:30there until somebody came out. He was
- 36:3279.
- 36:33He had worked 31 years for the county
- 36:35road department, mostly on a paver, and
- 36:38he was deaf in his left ear from it.
- 36:40"They tell me in town you found
- 36:41paperwork," he said. "Who's they?"
- 36:45Odell said. "A fellow I know at the
- 36:47Legion. He said the woman up here can
- 36:49read the old shorthand." Curtis turned
- 36:51the cap around in his hands. "Mr., I
- 36:54don't want to waste your time. I was
- 36:56raised over on the flats by people named
- 36:58Odum, and they were good to me and
- 36:59they're in the ground now, and they told
- 37:01me when I was 9 years old that I come
- 37:03out of this building. That's the whole
- 37:05of what I know. I'm 79 years old and
- 37:07that is every single thing I know about
- 37:09where I come from."
- 37:11Neva came out onto the porch with the
- 37:12notebook against her chest.
- 37:14"Do you know your birthday?"
- 37:16she said. "They gave me the 3rd of
- 37:18December. I don't think it's real."
- 37:20"What year?" "45. Then you'd be in
- 37:23volume one." Neva sat down in the lawn
- 37:26chair. "Mr. Odum, this is going to take
- 37:28me two or three days, and I want to tell
- 37:31you something first so you don't sit out
- 37:33here in the yard hoping. There are 419
- 37:36people in these books and some of the
- 37:38right-hand columns are three lines long
- 37:40and some of them are one word. Sometimes
- 37:42she didn't know either. "I've waited 79
- 37:45years," Curtis said. "Two or three days
- 37:48is nothing to me."
- 37:49It took her four.
- 37:51She found him on the Wednesday morning
- 37:53and she did not tell Odell first. She
- 37:55sat at the card table and copied it out
- 37:57twice, once in her own hand and once in
- 37:59careful printing on a clean sheet, and
- 38:02then she asked Odell to drive down and
- 38:03get the man. Curtis sat in the lawn
- 38:05chair on the porch with the sheet of
- 38:07paper on his knee and he could not read
- 38:09it because his glasses were in the truck
- 38:11and he would not go get them.
- 38:13"Read it to me," he said.
- 38:15Neva read it. "Intake 211,
- 38:19received the 4th of November, 1946.
- 38:22Male, 11 months, fair condition." She
- 38:26kept her voice level. "That's the left
- 38:28column, Mr. Odum. That's the form the
- 38:30county got. Under circumstances it says
- 38:33abandoned. Under parentage it says
- 38:36unknown." "Yes, ma'am.
- 38:38That's what they always said." Here's
- 38:40the right column. Neva put her finger on
- 38:43the page. "Mother present at intake,
- 38:46Delfia, age 20, not abandoned,
- 38:49surrendered on the instruction of the
- 38:51county agent who told her she could not
- 38:53be recorded as the mother without
- 38:55producing a marriage license, and that
- 38:57the entry would have to read abandoned.
- 38:59Curtis did not move. There's more. Go
- 39:02on. Mother returned the 6th of February,
- 39:05returned again the 2nd of June, returned
- 39:08the 9th of September.
- 39:09All of it 1947.
- 39:11Told each time the child had been placed
- 39:14out of county. Neva stopped. And then
- 39:16Ivetta Prine wrote four words of her own
- 39:19on the end of that line in the right
- 39:20column where nobody was ever going to
- 39:23read them. She wrote, "He had not been."
- 39:26Curtis Odum put both hands over his
- 39:28mouth. He sat like that for a while. His
- 39:31shoulders went, and then they stopped
- 39:33going, and he took his hands down and
- 39:35wiped his face with the flat of one of
- 39:37them, and looked out at the yard, at the
- 39:39gravel, and the truck and the hill going
- 39:41down into the trees. "Three times," he
- 39:44said. "Three times. 79 years I've been
- 39:48telling myself nobody came for me." His
- 39:50voice cracked open in the middle of it,
- 39:52and he let it. "Somebody came, somebody
- 39:54came three times. Yes, sir." "Ma'am,
- 39:57what was her whole name?" "Delfia." "And
- 40:00a last name I want to check twice before
- 40:02I hand it to you, because it's got a
- 40:04smudge on it, and I'm going to get it
- 40:05right." Neva folded the sheet and put it
- 40:08in his shirt pocket herself and buttoned
- 40:09the pocket. "But I'll tell you the one
- 40:11other thing I found already, and then
- 40:13you can go home and sit with it. She
- 40:15wasn't a girl who disappeared. She
- 40:17married in 1952, and she died in 1991 in
- 40:21a town about 40 miles east of here, and
- 40:23she had two more children, and one of
- 40:25them is a woman who is alive right now
- 40:27and 71 years old." Curtis put his hand
- 40:30flat over the buttoned pocket and held
- 40:32it there. "I've got a sister," he said.
- 40:35If you have made it this far into Odell
- 40:37and Neva's story, take a second and hit
- 40:39subscribe, because what happens next is
- 40:41the part I have been waiting to tell
- 40:42you. Curtis Odum told two people. Those
- 40:45two people told six. The next Saturday
- 40:48there were nine cars in the yard. Odell
- 40:51carried the card table out onto the
- 40:52porch and Neva sat behind it with volume
- 40:55one and volume two and a legal pad and
- 40:58she did what she had done at the quarry
- 41:00office for 11 years, which was take
- 41:02names and dates and put them in order
- 41:04and not get flustered. Some of them were
- 41:06the ones who had been in the building.
- 41:07Most of them were the children of the
- 41:09ones who had been in the building.
- 41:1060-year-old men holding a birth
- 41:12certificate that said a thing they had
- 41:13never believed. Neva told every one of
- 41:16them the same sentence before she opened
- 41:18a book. I might not find you. If I don't
- 41:20find you, it doesn't mean you weren't
- 41:22here. It means she couldn't write it
- 41:24down. She found six that day out of
- 41:26nine. The Saturday after there were 14
- 41:29cars and somebody had brought a folding
- 41:32table of their own and set it up beside
- 41:33hers without asking and there was a
- 41:35coffee urn on it and a woman from the
- 41:37diner on the corner had made two dozen
- 41:39sandwiches and would not take a dollar
- 41:42for them. Odell stood at the end of the
- 41:44porch and watched 14 strangers stand in
- 41:46a line up his front steps. Neva, he said
- 41:50when she came inside to change out the
- 41:51legal pad. What? Our own boy signed our
- 41:54house away with a pen he borrowed off
- 41:56the bank. He was looking out the window.
- 41:58These people never met us and they
- 42:00showed up with shovels. On the Monday a
- 42:02sheriff's deputy came up in a cruiser
- 42:04and posted a notice on the front door
- 42:06casing right below the orange placard
- 42:08and he was polite about it and would not
- 42:10look at either of them for more than a
- 42:11second at a time. The notice said that
- 42:13occupation of a structure condemned
- 42:15under county code was a misdemeanor of
- 42:17the fourth degree and that continued
- 42:19occupation after service of notice could
- 42:21result in citation and removal. You
- 42:23didn't write this, Odell said. No, sir.
- 42:27Who called it in? Sir, I just get handed
- 42:30the address. That's day 31, Neva said
- 42:33after the cruiser went down. 31 of 90.
- 42:37Odell stood in the yard with the notice
- 42:38in his hand and did not go in the house.
- 42:41He walked around to the back instead
- 42:43into the L where the roof was gone where
- 42:45the sky came down through the rafter
- 42:47tails and the rain had been coming in
- 42:49since before either of them was born and
- 42:51he stood in the wet and looked at the
- 42:52wall between the L and the main house.
- 42:55That wall was original, brick, three
- 42:57widths thick and dry. The building had a
- 43:00good coat on and one bad sleeve. He came
- 43:03back around front, got into the truck,
- 43:05drove to town and spent $41 of the 209
- 43:08on a 50-lb bag of hydrated lime, a bag
- 43:11of plaster of Paris, and a length of
- 43:1311-gauge zinc. Then he came home and
- 43:16made himself a running mold. He cut the
- 43:18profile out of the zinc with tin snips,
- 43:20filed it to a knife edge, nailed it to a
- 43:23wooden horse, and built himself a
- 43:24slipper and a nib out of scrap pine. And
- 43:27it took him 5 hours because he had not
- 43:29made one since 2004, and his hands were
- 43:32not what they were. He slaked lime in a
- 43:34mortar tub on the porch. A bench went up
- 43:36along the front hall wall, two sawhorses
- 43:39and a plank. He soaked burlap, mixed his
- 43:42gauging, and at 11:00 at night, with a
- 43:44work light hanging off a nail, he laid a
- 43:46bed of putty on the wall where the
- 43:48cornice had come away over the door to
- 43:49the dining room. Then he ran it. He
- 43:52pulled that mold along the plank in one
- 43:54long steady stroke, and came back and
- 43:56did it again, and again. And each pass
- 43:59took a little more and left a little
- 44:01more. And out of a lump of gray mud
- 44:03there came an egg, then a dart, then a
- 44:06straight molded band with a fillet on
- 44:07the bottom of it. 11 ft on the first
- 44:10night. Neva came out and stood in the
- 44:12doorway at half past 1:00 in the morning
- 44:15and watched him from behind, and he did
- 44:17not know she was there. Odell He turned
- 44:19around. There was lime in both eyebrows
- 44:22and up both forearms to the elbow.
- 44:24"It's a mess," he said. "The gauging's
- 44:27too fast. I'll have to cut that last 2
- 44:29ft out and run it again." "It matches,"
- 44:31Neva said. "It doesn't match yet."
- 44:34"Come to bed." He did not come to bed.
- 44:37He was still on the plank at half past
- 44:393:00 k, and he was on it again at 7:00.
- 44:42And by the end of that week, there was
- 44:4331 ft of new cornice in the front hall
- 44:46of that building, run by hand by a
- 44:4874-year-old man with a bag of lime and a
- 44:51piece of zinc, and no permit, and no
- 44:53plan and 38 days left. That was the
- 44:57Friday. On the Friday night at a quarter
- 45:00after 9:00, headlights came up the hill.
- 45:02They came slow, feeling for the gravel,
- 45:05and they stopped in the yard and it was
- 45:06a silver Nissan with Franklin County
- 45:08plates, and Marla got out of it with her
- 45:10phone already in her hand and a folder
- 45:12under her arm. "Mom," she said, "Dad,
- 45:16come out here both of you and sit down
- 45:18because Jared's on the phone and we are
- 45:20going to talk about this tonight." Marla
- 45:22put the phone face up on the card table
- 45:24and set it to speaker, and her brother's
- 45:26voice came out of it into the front hall
- 45:28of that house, sounding like a man in a
- 45:30car. "Dad, you there?"
- 45:33"I'm here." "Okay. So, Marla's got the
- 45:37paperwork with her. It's not a big deal
- 45:39and I want you to hear me out before you
- 45:41say anything. A blinker was ticking
- 45:43somewhere behind his voice. There's a
- 45:45place in Grove City that has a
- 45:47two-bedroom independent living, so it's
- 45:50not a nursing home. Nobody's saying
- 45:52nursing home. It's 2,200 a month and
- 45:54Marla and I are splitting it and all you
- 45:56have to do is sign the transfer on that
- 45:58deed so we can get the county off your
- 45:59back and then this whole thing goes
- 46:01away. Transfer it to who?
- 46:04To me. Just on paper. Dad, if there's a
- 46:07lien, it can't be on you, too. You're on
- 46:10Social Security. They'll garnish it.
- 46:12Odell looked at his daughter. Marla had
- 46:15the folder open on her knee with a pen
- 46:17already across the top of it, and she
- 46:19had on the face she used at work, the
- 46:21one for telling a man he needed a crown
- 46:23and it was not covered. "Marla," he
- 46:25said, "did you drive two and a half
- 46:27hours to hand me a pen? Dad, because the
- 46:30last pen somebody in this family handed
- 46:32me cost me a house. That is not fair,"
- 46:34Jared said from the table. "It's exactly
- 46:37fair," Neva said. It was the first thing
- 46:40she had said, and she said it without
- 46:42raising her voice at all. And the phone
- 46:44went quiet for four full seconds. "Mom,
- 46:47I'm going to hang up on you in a minute,
- 46:49Jared, and I want you to know before I
- 46:51do that it isn't because I'm mad." Neva
- 46:53folded her hands. "It's because your
- 46:55sister drove all this way she hasn't
- 46:58seen the building yet, and I'd rather
- 46:59she saw it than listen to you. Then she
- 47:02reached over and picked the phone up and
- 47:03ended the call and set it down face down
- 47:06on the table and looked at her daughter.
- 47:08"Come upstairs." Odell said. "Dad, I
- 47:11have to be at work at 8:00." "Then
- 47:13you'll be late. Come upstairs."
- 47:16He took the work light and ran the cord
- 47:17up two flights on extension after
- 47:19extension, and he put Marla in the
- 47:21middle of that long room on the third
- 47:22floor and turned the light so it raked
- 47:24across the north wall at an angle. They
- 47:26had cleared all four walls by then.
- 47:28Marla stood there in a good coat with
- 47:30her car keys still in her hand and
- 47:32looked at it, and she did not say
- 47:34anything for a long time, which for
- 47:36Marla was unusual.
- 47:38681 pencil names. Some of them 4 in tall
- 47:42in a child's capitals. Some of them
- 47:44small and careful and low down near the
- 47:46baseboard where a person would have had
- 47:48to lie on the floor to write. Dates from
- 47:501946 to 1961.
- 47:53Beside 109 of them, somebody had written
- 47:56a number in ink. "Read the one by the
- 47:58second window." Odell said. Marla walked
- 48:01over. She had to crouch. She read it out
- 48:04loud and her voice went funny in the
- 48:05middle of it. Ronnie and Dolores
- 48:07Kesterson, brother and sister. "Please
- 48:10do not separate us."
- 48:12"Spelled wrong." Odell said. "S E P E R
- 48:16A T E. She was 10." "How do you know she
- 48:20was 10?" "Because your mother found her
- 48:22downstairs in a book in shorthand." He
- 48:25put the light down on the floor. Intake
- 48:27304.
- 48:29She was 10 and her brother was six, and
- 48:31the county sent them to two different
- 48:33farms 11 days apart, and the woman who
- 48:35ran this house wrote it down in a
- 48:37language her bosses couldn't read
- 48:39because it was the only lie she could
- 48:41think of to tell in the direction of the
- 48:42truth. Marla sat down on the floor of
- 48:45the third story of that building in her
- 48:47good coat. "What is this place?" she
- 48:49said. "That," Odell said, "is the
- 48:51question." She did not go to work at
- 48:548:00. She called in at 6:30 and said she
- 48:56had a family situation, which was the
- 48:58first true thing she had told that
- 49:00office in a year. And she stayed the
- 49:02weekend, and then she took 3 days, and
- 49:04then she called the dentist she had
- 49:06worked for since she was 27, and asked
- 49:08for 6 weeks unpaid. And then Marla
- 49:11Sturgill did the thing that saved it,
- 49:13and it was not heroic, and nobody made a
- 49:16speech about it. She had run the front
- 49:18office of a four-chair dental practice
- 49:20for 19 years. She knew how to build a
- 49:22system for handling people who arrive
- 49:24frightened and want something you might
- 49:26not be able to give them. In 4 days, she
- 49:28had it. 419 index cards, one per intake,
- 49:33cross-indexed three ways, by number, by
- 49:36year, and by every name attached to that
- 49:38number. A one-page request form, a
- 49:41two-page release, because half these
- 49:43people were going to want to hand their
- 49:45transcription to a lawyer or a genealogy
- 49:47service, and Marla was not going to have
- 49:50this house sued. There was a sign-in
- 49:52sheet by the door, and a calendar with
- 49:54half-hour appointments. Four an hour,
- 49:57because she timed her mother, and her
- 49:58mother needed 12 minutes to read a line,
- 50:00and 8 minutes to sit with the person
- 50:02after. "You can't just have them stand
- 50:04in the yard, Mom," she said. "Somebody's
- 50:07going to have a heart attack in the
- 50:08yard. They've been standing in a yard
- 50:10for 70 years." "Then it's about time
- 50:12somebody gave them a chair." She bought
- 50:1414 folding chairs at a church sale for
- 50:17$2 apiece. At 2:00 in the morning on the
- 50:19fifth night, at the card table with the
- 50:21lantern between them, Marla said the
- 50:23other thing. "I need to tell you about
- 50:25the $400."
- 50:27"I don't want to hear about it," Odell
- 50:29said. "You're going to hear about it,
- 50:31because I've been carrying it around for
- 50:324 months, and I'd rather set it down."
- 50:35She had both hands around a cup. "I was
- 50:37two payments behind on the Rogue. They'd
- 50:39already called me twice at work, and
- 50:41Jared told me on the phone that you two
- 50:43had money put back, and I believed him,
- 50:46because it was easier than the other
- 50:47thing." She looked at the tabletop. "I
- 50:49didn't need $400 from you.
- 50:52I needed $400,
- 50:54and you were the two people in the world
- 50:56I wasn't scared to ask, and I asked you
- 50:58like a landlord instead of like your
- 50:59your
- 51:00And that's the part I can't get past.
- 51:03Neva reached over and put her hand on
- 51:05the back of her daughter's hand and left
- 51:06it there.
- 51:07"You could have said it plain," she
- 51:09said. "I know. Say it plain from here on
- 51:11out and we'll call the $400 square."
- 51:14Marla nodded. Then she picked up her
- 51:16phone and she turned it over and she
- 51:19scrolled a long time and she stopped.
- 51:21"There's one more thing and this one's
- 51:23worse. The email chain was from the
- 51:25second week of March. Jared had copied
- 51:28his sister on all of it and the reason
- 51:30he had copied her," Marla said, "was
- 51:33that he had wanted her to help him talk
- 51:35their parents into it and then in the
- 51:37end he had not needed her to." Odell
- 51:39read it on Marla's phone with his
- 51:41reading glasses pushed up his nose and
- 51:43Neva sitting beside him. In March the
- 51:45bank had agreed to restructure the note
- 51:47on the agency. Jared had asked them for
- 51:50two things as part of it. He asked them
- 51:52to release the boat, which was a 2018
- 51:55pontoon on Lake Norman, and he asked
- 51:57them to release a rental condominium in
- 51:59Myrtle Beach that his wife's name was
- 52:00also on. In exchange she had offered the
- 52:02bank the personal guarantee that was
- 52:04already sitting in the file and he had
- 52:06signed a substitution of collateral
- 52:08naming the property at 14th Street.
- 52:10It was four lines long. There was an
- 52:13attachment. Marla had opened the
- 52:15attachment in March and had not
- 52:16understood what she was looking at and
- 52:18in June when the sheriff sold her
- 52:20parents' house she had gone back and
- 52:22opened it again and had understood it
- 52:23perfectly.
- 52:25"He didn't lose it," Marla said. "In
- 52:27March he sat in a room and picked."
- 52:29Odell read the four lines twice. Then he
- 52:32handed the phone back to his daughter
- 52:34and he stood up and he put his coat on
- 52:37and he went out onto the porch and down
- 52:38the steps and around the side of the
- 52:40building to the mortar tub and he worked
- 52:42until 4:00 in the afternoon of the next
- 52:44day without saying one word to anybody
- 52:46about any of it. He ran 49 ft of cornice
- 52:49in that stretch. It is the best work he
- 52:51ever did in his life and he has never
- 52:53once been able to look at it. "What are
- 52:55you going to do?" Neva asked him that
- 52:57night. "Nothing."
- 52:59Odell "I'm not going to hate him," he
- 53:01said. "I haven't got the time and I
- 53:03haven't got the wind." He was looking at
- 53:05his hands. "And I'm not going to call
- 53:07him, either. If he wants to be in this
- 53:09family, he can drive here." Weldon
- 53:11Prynne came back on a Tuesday at day 62,
- 53:15and this time he did not take his hat
- 53:16off, and he did not ask about the well.
- 53:19He got out of the Buick and looked at
- 53:20the front of the house, and the plywood
- 53:22was off 11 of the windows, and there was
- 53:24glass in six of them, and there were 14
- 53:27folding chairs stacked on the porch
- 53:29under a tarp, and a hand-lettered sign
- 53:31leaning against the porch post that
- 53:33said, in Marla's handwriting, "Requests
- 53:36Saturday 9:00 to 3:00. Bring a birthday
- 53:38if you have one."
- 53:39He stood in the yard and read that sign
- 53:41for a while. "$90,000," he said. "No,
- 53:45Mr. Sturgill, I am 81 years old, and I
- 53:48have been in the same house on the same
- 53:50street since Eisenhower, and $90,000 is
- 53:53not a number I arrived at comfortably."
- 53:56"I believe you." "Then take it." "No."
- 53:59Weldon's jaw worked. "You will lose the
- 54:01hearing. I want you to understand that
- 54:04as a matter of arithmetic, and not as a
- 54:06threat. The board has five members.
- 54:09The county attorney will read the
- 54:10abatement estimate into the record, and
- 54:12he will read the code section, and the
- 54:14code section does not have any room in
- 54:15it for a coffee urn and a lot of sad
- 54:18paper." "You'd know," Odell said.
- 54:21"You wrote 11 of those renewals." "12."
- 54:24"12, then." "Why?" "Because the building
- 54:27is unsafe." "You've never been inside
- 54:30it." "I lived in it." Weldon said. The
- 54:33yard went quiet. He heard himself say
- 54:35it. Odell watched him hear it.
- 54:38"My mother worked in this house," Weldon
- 54:39said. "Slower. I told you that. She was
- 54:42the matron
- 54:44from 1946 until they shut it in 1961,
- 54:47and I was raised in the two rooms on the
- 54:49ground floor at the back, the ones under
- 54:51the part of the roof that's gone. So, do
- 54:53not stand in my county and tell me what
- 54:55I have and have not been inside of."
- 54:57Neva was in the doorway. She had been
- 54:59there for a while, and she had a ledger
- 55:01in the crook of her arm, volume one, and
- 55:04a folded sheet of paper on top of it.
- 55:07"Mr. Prime, she said, "Would you come up
- 55:09on the porch and sit down?" "I'd rather
- 55:11not." "I know. Come up anyway because I
- 55:14have been dreading this for 9 days and I
- 55:16would rather do it sitting down than
- 55:18shouting at across a yard." He came up.
- 55:20He sat in one of the $2 folding chairs
- 55:22with his hat on his knee and Nava sat
- 55:25across from him and opened volume one to
- 55:27a page she had marked with a strip of
- 55:29masking tape
- 55:30and she turned it around so it faced
- 55:32him. "You can't read it," she said. "I
- 55:34know that."
- 55:35"I'll read it." "I don't want it read."
- 55:38"I'm going to read it anyway and then
- 55:40you can do whatever you like with the
- 55:41rest of your life, but you're not going
- 55:43to sit on a board and vote to knock this
- 55:45building down without knowing what's in
- 55:46it." Nava put her finger on the line.
- 55:49"Intake 104, received the 19th of April,
- 55:521948.
- 55:54Male, 4 years, condition on arrival
- 55:57good, circumstances abandoned, parentage
- 56:00unknown, disposition retained." Weldon
- 56:04Prime did not move at all. "Right-hand
- 56:06column," Nava said. "It's four words,
- 56:09called Buddy. Keeps his shoes."
- 56:11Something happened in the old man's face
- 56:14and then it stopped happening and he sat
- 56:16very upright in the folding chair with
- 56:18his hands on the brim of his hat.
- 56:20"That's not evidence of anything," he
- 56:22said. "No, sir. It's four words in a
- 56:25book. There were 400 children through
- 56:27that house.
- 56:28419
- 56:30and your mother wrote down the
- 56:31disposition on every one of them and
- 56:33there is exactly one entry in nine
- 56:35volumes where the disposition is the
- 56:37word retained." Nava closed the book
- 56:39gently. "Mr. Prime, I was a
- 56:41stenographer.
- 56:43I don't guess at things. I count them."
- 56:45He sat there. "29 years I was the
- 56:48auditor of this county," he said at
- 56:50last. "Every record in that building
- 56:52went across my desk twice. Deeds,
- 56:54dockets, welfare rolls, the burned
- 56:57index, all of it." He turned the hat a
- 56:59quarter turn. "I never once pulled my
- 57:02own file, not one time in 29 years. A
- 57:05man doesn't go looking for a door he's
- 57:07scared is already open."
- 57:09"There's a second thing Nava said. I
- 57:11don't want it. You do. She unfolded the
- 57:14sheet of paper. It was small, a corner
- 57:17torn off a ledger page, brown along the
- 57:19tear, pressed dead flat. The backboard
- 57:22on volume one rattles. I thought it was
- 57:25a loose signature. It's this. It was
- 57:27folded and slid behind the marbled
- 57:29paper, and it has been there since 1948.
- 57:33She read it.
- 57:34Intake 104.
- 57:36Mother is my sister.
- 57:3819 years old, not married. Our father
- 57:41will not have her in the house, nor the
- 57:43child, neither. I have entered the
- 57:45mother as unknown, because that is what
- 57:46I was told to enter, and because it will
- 57:48protect her. And I'm going to keep the
- 57:51boy, and I am not going to tell him, and
- 57:53God forgive me for the second part of
- 57:55that. Welden Pryne put his hat on the
- 57:58porch floor beside his chair, which was
- 58:00the only thing he did. "She was my
- 58:02aunt," he said. "She was your mother's
- 58:04sister. She was the one who fed you."
- 58:07Nava folded the paper back along its old
- 58:09creases.
- 58:10"Mr. Pryne, I have read nine volumes of
- 58:13that woman's handwriting. She filed
- 58:15every false form the county handed her.
- 58:17She also came up three flights of stairs
- 58:19at night for 15 years to write down the
- 58:21truth in a language they couldn't read,
- 58:23and she let those children put their
- 58:25names on her wall, and then she papered
- 58:27over it herself so nobody would find it
- 58:29before somebody was ready to." Nava set
- 58:31the paper on top of the ledger. "I don't
- 58:33know what she was, but she wasn't
- 58:35nothing."
- 58:36Welden stood up. It took him a while.
- 58:39"The hearing is the 3rd of February at
- 58:4110:00," he said. "There are five of us
- 58:44on that board." He picked up his hat.
- 58:46"I'm not going to tell you what I'm
- 58:47going to do, because I don't know." Then
- 58:50he went down the steps and got in the
- 58:51clean Buick and drove down the hill. The
- 58:54engineer cost $3,200.
- 58:57They had 419 index cards and $38.
- 59:02On the Saturday without anybody
- 59:03organizing it, a coffee can went around
- 59:06the porch. It was a Maxwell House can
- 59:08with a plastic lid cut, and it came back
- 59:10to the card table at 10:00 after 2:00 in
- 59:12the afternoon with $3,180
- 59:15in it. And Curtis Odom put a personal
- 59:17check for 500 on top and told Nava if
- 59:20she tore it up, he would just write
- 59:21another one.
- 59:23The engineer came from two counties
- 59:24over, a woman in her 40s with a hard hat
- 59:27and a laser level and a $900 camera. She
- 59:30was there a day and a half. She put a
- 59:32crack monitor on all three foundation
- 59:34cracks and came back a week later and
- 59:36read them and they had not moved a
- 59:37thousandth of an inch. Her report was 14
- 59:40pages. Odell read it eight times. It
- 59:43said that the L at the rear was a total
- 59:45loss and should be demolished and that
- 59:47the main block, quote, exhibits no
- 59:50evidence of structural distress and that
- 59:52the slate roof on the main block was
- 59:54serviceable with spot repair and that in
- 59:56her professional opinion, the county's
- 59:58abatement order applied a single
- 1:00:00condition assessment to two structurally
- 1:00:02independent buildings. Two structurally
- 1:00:05independent buildings. Odell said that
- 1:00:07sentence out loud 11 times over four
- 1:00:10days. In the yard, in the truck, at the
- 1:00:13card table. The night before the
- 1:00:14hearing, he was still working. He was on
- 1:00:17the plank at 11:00 at night running the
- 1:00:19last four feet of the cornice over the
- 1:00:21dining room door. The four feet he had
- 1:00:23cut out in November because the gauging
- 1:00:25was too fast and he had never been
- 1:00:26satisfied with it. He finished it at 20
- 1:00:29past. The mold went down on the bench.
- 1:00:31He walked backward down the hall to the
- 1:00:33front door and turned around and looked
- 1:00:35up the length of it and the cornice went
- 1:00:37from one end of that hall to the other.
- 1:00:3929 feet of egg and dart and dental and
- 1:00:43you could not tell where 1911 stopped
- 1:00:45and where he started. Then he went out
- 1:00:47and washed the lime out of his hands at
- 1:00:49the hose bib, which took a long time
- 1:00:51because it always did and because his
- 1:00:53hands were split open across all eight
- 1:00:54knuckles and the lime got down in them.
- 1:00:56He was standing there with the water
- 1:00:58running over his wrists when headlights
- 1:01:00came up the hill. It was a rented car
- 1:01:02and Jared Sturgill got out of it in a
- 1:01:04quarter zip sweater and stood in the
- 1:01:05gravel with his hands at his sides.
- 1:01:07Odell shut the water off. Dad, you
- 1:01:10drove. Flew into Columbus and drove
- 1:01:13down. Jared looked up at the front of
- 1:01:15the building, all three stories of it,
- 1:01:18and the porch and the columns, and then
- 1:01:20back at his father, who was standing at
- 1:01:22the hose bib with his sleeves rolled and
- 1:01:24both hands raw. Marla sent me a picture
- 1:01:26of the ceiling. She shouldn't have.
- 1:01:29She's been sending me a picture every
- 1:01:30week since November. He came a few steps
- 1:01:33closer. I've got something in the car
- 1:01:35and I want to hand it to you before I
- 1:01:36lose my nerve. He went and got it. It
- 1:01:38was a cashier's check, folded once, and
- 1:01:41he held it out. $11,000.
- 1:01:45That's everything in the business
- 1:01:46account and the last of what the boat
- 1:01:47brought. He had clearly practiced the
- 1:01:49next part. I know it's not 162,
- 1:01:53but it's real money and it's the
- 1:01:54engineer and the permits and the first
- 1:01:56winter of heat. And Dad, I've been
- 1:01:58sitting with what I did since June, and
- 1:02:00if you don't take it, I don't know what
- 1:02:02to do with myself.
- 1:02:04Odell looked at the check a long time,
- 1:02:06then he pushed his son's hand back
- 1:02:08toward his son's chest.
- 1:02:10"Put it away, boy," he said. "You can't
- 1:02:12pay this off. You can only work it off."
- 1:02:15Jared stood there in the yard with
- 1:02:16$11,000 in his fist. "How?" "Hearings at
- 1:02:2010:00. Be in the back row and don't say
- 1:02:22anything because you're the last man on
- 1:02:24this hill anybody wants to hear from."
- 1:02:26Odell picked his coat up off the porch
- 1:02:28rail. "There's blankets in the truck. It
- 1:02:30gets down to 20."
- 1:02:32He slept in the rented car. In the
- 1:02:34morning, his mother brought him coffee
- 1:02:36out to it in a jar. The Board of Zoning
- 1:02:38Appeals met on the 3rd of February at
- 1:02:4010:00 in the morning in the second-floor
- 1:02:42meeting room of the county building,
- 1:02:44which held about 30 people. 41 came.
- 1:02:47They stood along the back wall and out
- 1:02:49into the hallway, and the fire marshal
- 1:02:51came up twice, looked at it, and went
- 1:02:53away both times without saying anything.
- 1:02:55The county attorney went first, and he
- 1:02:57was fair, and that was the frightening
- 1:02:59part. He read the abatement estimate
- 1:03:01into the record.
- 1:03:02$141,200.
- 1:03:05He read the code section and the 12
- 1:03:07renewals by date, and he noted that the
- 1:03:09property was occupied in violation of a
- 1:03:11posted order, that no citation had been
- 1:03:14issued, and that the department's
- 1:03:16position was that the order should be
- 1:03:17enforced as written. The county doesn't
- 1:03:19take pleasure in this, he said, but the
- 1:03:21standard isn't sentiment. The standard
- 1:03:24is the structure. Dana went second on
- 1:03:26her lunch break, which she had put in
- 1:03:28for 6 days in advance. She stood at the
- 1:03:30podium in her lanyard with the 4-in
- 1:03:32file, shaking so badly at the start that
- 1:03:34the chairman told her twice to take her
- 1:03:36time. She laid out the parcel history in
- 1:03:38order. Then came the 12 renewals and who
- 1:03:41signed them, the institutional use
- 1:03:43classification from before 1968 and the
- 1:03:46date of the courthouse fire.
- 1:03:48Last, she read the form letter the
- 1:03:50county had been mailing to record
- 1:03:51requests for 52 years. When she got to
- 1:03:54the line that said no reconstruction of
- 1:03:56those records is possible, she stopped
- 1:03:58and had to start it over. I mailed that
- 1:04:00letter myself, she said, 11 times in 4
- 1:04:03years at that counter in my own
- 1:04:06handwriting on the envelope. I'd like
- 1:04:08the record to show that the letter isn't
- 1:04:10true anymore. The engineer went third
- 1:04:12and she was in the room for 9 minutes.
- 1:04:14She had the crack monitors, the
- 1:04:16readings, and the slate survey, and she
- 1:04:18used the sentence Odell had been saying
- 1:04:20out loud in his yard for 4 days. The
- 1:04:23order treats this as one building, she
- 1:04:25said. It is two. The rear L is a 1946
- 1:04:29frame addition under a failed flat roof
- 1:04:31and it should come down tomorrow. The
- 1:04:33main block is load-bearing masonry on
- 1:04:35dry-laid sandstone with an original
- 1:04:37slate roof and it exhibits no structural
- 1:04:39distress of any kind. I've been doing
- 1:04:42this 19 years. If that building were in
- 1:04:44a city, it would be on a postcard. Marla
- 1:04:47went fourth with the schedule. She
- 1:04:48handed out 45 copies she had paid to
- 1:04:51have printed and she went through it
- 1:04:52line by line with no emotion in her
- 1:04:54voice at all because she had decided in
- 1:04:57the car that morning that the emotion in
- 1:04:58that room was going to have to come from
- 1:05:00somebody else. Demolition of the rear L,
- 1:05:0390 days funded. Slate repair and
- 1:05:05flashing, year one. Electrical service
- 1:05:08and one code compliant egress stair,
- 1:05:11year one. Sprinklers on the assembly
- 1:05:13floor, year two.
- 1:05:15Full occupancy, year three. That's "It's
- 1:05:18a wish list, she said. That's what a
- 1:05:20dental office looks like when you have
- 1:05:22to open Monday. You can hold us to every
- 1:05:24date on it."
- 1:05:25Curtis Odom went fifth. He spoke for 2
- 1:05:28minutes and he did not use the podium.
- 1:05:30He stood in the aisle with his cap in
- 1:05:32both hands and faced the five people at
- 1:05:34the table. "My name is Curtis Odom. I'm
- 1:05:3679 years old. I gave this county 31
- 1:05:40years on a paver and I was intake 211 in
- 1:05:43that building in 1946."
- 1:05:45He cleared his throat. "For 78 of my 79
- 1:05:48years, the government of this county
- 1:05:50told me my mother was unknown. Four
- 1:05:52months ago, a woman up on that hill read
- 1:05:54me her name out of a book and told me
- 1:05:56she come back for me three separate
- 1:05:58times and got turned away at that door
- 1:06:00by a man on this county's payroll.
- 1:06:02Nobody moved. Her name was Delphia," he
- 1:06:06said. "I'm going to say it out loud in
- 1:06:08this building because it has never once
- 1:06:10been said out loud in this building.
- 1:06:12Delphia." He turned the cap over. "You
- 1:06:15all vote how you want. I ain't a lawyer
- 1:06:18and I don't know about sprinklers."
- 1:06:20He looked at the table. "But that house
- 1:06:22is the only thing in this world that
- 1:06:23ever told me the truth about myself and
- 1:06:25I'd take it very hard if the same county
- 1:06:27that lied to me for 78 years knocked it
- 1:06:29down before it could finish talking." He
- 1:06:32sat down. The chairman called for board
- 1:06:34discussion and Weldon Prine put his hand
- 1:06:36up. "Mr. Chairman, before discussion,
- 1:06:39I'm going to recuse myself from the
- 1:06:40vote." "Noted." "Weldon, you don't have
- 1:06:43to state a reason." "I'm going to state
- 1:06:45one anyway and then I'd like to speak as
- 1:06:47a citizen from the floor. If the board
- 1:06:49will hear me." He got up out of his seat
- 1:06:51at the table and walked around the end
- 1:06:53of it, which took him some time, and
- 1:06:55stood on the floor with the rest of
- 1:06:56them. Then he took a folded sheet of
- 1:06:58paper out of his shirt pocket and put on
- 1:07:00his glasses. "I have signed 12 orders of
- 1:07:03condemnation against parcel 417.
- 1:07:06I signed the first one in 1968 when I
- 1:07:09was 25 years old and a clerk in the
- 1:07:11auditor's office and I signed the last
- 1:07:13one in March of last year.
- 1:07:15He held the paper up slightly. "I want
- 1:07:17the record to reflect that I never had a
- 1:07:19structural reason for any of them. Not
- 1:07:21one." The room went so quiet you could
- 1:07:24hear the radiator. This is a copy in a
- 1:07:26stenographer's hand of a page from an
- 1:07:29intake ledger kept in that building by
- 1:07:30the matron, Aveta Prine, who raised me
- 1:07:33and who I buried in 1979.
- 1:07:35He put his finger on the paper. Intake
- 1:07:37104, received the 19th of April 1948.
- 1:07:42Male, 4 years, circumstances abandoned,
- 1:07:45parentage unknown,
- 1:07:48disposition retained.
- 1:07:50He looked up over his glasses at the
- 1:07:51five chairs he had been sitting in for
- 1:07:5322 years.
- 1:07:55"That's me." He said.
- 1:07:57"I was one of them."
- 1:07:58There was one sound from the back of the
- 1:08:00room and then nothing. I have been the
- 1:08:02auditor of this county and a trustee of
- 1:08:04the library and my father's name is on
- 1:08:06the ball field and I have spent 57 years
- 1:08:09making sure nobody ever read four words
- 1:08:11in a book. Weldon folded the paper along
- 1:08:13its crease. The four words are, "Called
- 1:08:16Buddy keeps his shoes." That is
- 1:08:18everything the government of this county
- 1:08:20allowed to be written down about who I
- 1:08:22was and I had to be 81 years old and
- 1:08:24have a stranger read it to me on a
- 1:08:26porch. Every person in this room should
- 1:08:28understand that I did that to myself.
- 1:08:30Nobody did it to me but me. He took his
- 1:08:33glasses off.
- 1:08:34"Don't tear it down." He said. "There's
- 1:08:36418 more of us." At 11:50 the chairman
- 1:08:40called the question. The vote was four
- 1:08:42to nothing. The abatement order was
- 1:08:44vacated as to the main block, sustained
- 1:08:46as to the rear L, and the phase schedule
- 1:08:48was adopted as submitted with a
- 1:08:50three-year compliance window and
- 1:08:51quarterly review. Somebody in the
- 1:08:53hallway started clapping and got shushed
- 1:08:56by his own wife. Odell Sturgill never
- 1:08:58said one word at that hearing.
- 1:09:00He had his father's trowel in his coat
- 1:09:02pocket and he held onto it in there with
- 1:09:04his hand the whole 2 hours.
- 1:09:06And when it was over he went out and sat
- 1:09:08in the truck for a minute before Nava
- 1:09:10came out. Two years on from that
- 1:09:12morning, the building is not finished
- 1:09:14and anybody who tells you a house like
- 1:09:16that gets finished has never owned one.
- 1:09:18The L came down in April of the first
- 1:09:20year. The crew that took it did the work
- 1:09:22for the cost of the dumpsters and there
- 1:09:24is a graded footprint back there now
- 1:09:26with a new brick wall closing off the
- 1:09:28main block. That brick does not match.
- 1:09:30It will not match for 30 years. Odell
- 1:09:33says he can live with that. The front
- 1:09:35hall is done. Upstairs, there are seven
- 1:09:37rooms with plaster in them that came out
- 1:09:39of a tub on that porch. The third floor
- 1:09:41is the reason the buses come. That long
- 1:09:43room is not painted and it is not going
- 1:09:45to be. All four walls are behind glass
- 1:09:48now, floor-to-ceiling. 681 pencil names
- 1:09:52in children's handwriting with a brass
- 1:09:54rail 18 inches out so nobody can put a
- 1:09:56thumb on them. In one spot, the glass is
- 1:09:58jointed around a 2-ft square of the old
- 1:10:01blue diamond wallpaper they left up on
- 1:10:02purpose so people can see what it looked
- 1:10:05like when it was hidden. Neva finished
- 1:10:07the transcription in 22 months. 419
- 1:10:10intakes, both columns, written out
- 1:10:12longhand and then scanned with copies in
- 1:10:15a fireproof box in that house, at the
- 1:10:17state archive, and in a bank vault two
- 1:10:19counties over. Neva Sturgill does not
- 1:10:21believe in leaving one of anything. 206
- 1:10:25people have come up that hill and sat in
- 1:10:27a $2 folding chair and asked. 91 of them
- 1:10:30got an answer with a name in it. The
- 1:10:31rest got the number, the date, the age
- 1:10:34they arrived, how long they stayed, and
- 1:10:37in a lot of cases four or five words in
- 1:10:39a dead woman's private hand about what
- 1:10:41condition they were in on the day the
- 1:10:42county took them. Not everybody gets a
- 1:10:44mother. Neva tells every single one of
- 1:10:47them what she told the first 14, which
- 1:10:50is that if she cannot find them, it does
- 1:10:51not mean they were not here.
- 1:10:54Nine people have found a living brother
- 1:10:55or sister. The roof cost $68,000
- 1:10:59and it got paid for in one check. And
- 1:11:01there is no name on the paperwork
- 1:11:03because the man who wrote it made that a
- 1:11:04condition. He comes up on Thursdays. At
- 1:11:0783, he cannot do anything overhead, so
- 1:11:10he sits on an upturned bucket in the
- 1:11:12second floor hall and sands. And he is
- 1:11:14very good at it. And he does not talk
- 1:11:16much.
- 1:11:18He had a stone cut and set in the spring
- 1:11:19of the second year, 11 miles out on a
- 1:11:22grave that had carried a metal marker
- 1:11:24with a number and no name since 1959.
- 1:11:28The stone has her whole name on it and
- 1:11:30her dates and under that one line,
- 1:11:33"Mother of one son."
- 1:11:34"I've been Weldon Prynne for 83 years,"
- 1:11:37he told Nava when she asked if he had
- 1:11:39thought about changing it. "I'm not
- 1:11:40going to go be somebody else at this
- 1:11:42stage of things. I know it now and
- 1:11:44that's the part I didn't have. Somebody
- 1:11:46wanted me." Curtis Odum's sister came
- 1:11:49the second week of March in the first
- 1:11:51year. She was 71 and she brought a
- 1:11:54photograph. They sat in two folding
- 1:11:56chairs on that porch and looked at it a
- 1:11:57long time before either of them could
- 1:11:59say anything. A woman in her 30s in a
- 1:12:02coat standing in front of a fence
- 1:12:04squinting.
- 1:12:05"That's her," his sister said.
- 1:12:07"1958.
- 1:12:09She's 22 years older there than she was
- 1:12:11when she come up here after you." "Did
- 1:12:13she ever say anything?" Curtis said.
- 1:12:15"About me?" "Anytime. She never said one
- 1:12:18word to me my whole life." His sister
- 1:12:21put her hand flat on the arm of his
- 1:12:22chair, but she kept a bus schedule in
- 1:12:24her Bible. It was folded up in the book
- 1:12:26of Ruth and it was the route that comes
- 1:12:28out here and I have been wondering about
- 1:12:30that bus schedule for 34 years. Jared
- 1:12:33Sturgill has been mixing mud for 14
- 1:12:35months. He sold the agency for less than
- 1:12:37he owed on it and the condominium, too.
- 1:12:40He lives in the second room at the top
- 1:12:41of the stairs, gets up at 5:00 to slake
- 1:12:44lime and screens sand through a window
- 1:12:46screen his father made him build
- 1:12:48himself.
- 1:12:49There has never been a speech. Odell has
- 1:12:51not said he forgives him and Jared has
- 1:12:53stopped waiting on it. But on a Tuesday
- 1:12:55morning in October of the second year,
- 1:12:58Odell came around the corner of the
- 1:12:59porch carrying two hawks and two trowels
- 1:13:02instead of one and handed one of each to
- 1:13:04his son without breaking stride. "You're
- 1:13:06running the bottom 8 ft of the
- 1:13:08stairwell," he said. "Don't let me see
- 1:13:10you rush the second coat." That is all
- 1:13:12either of them has ever said about it
- 1:13:14out loud. Marla rents the yellow house
- 1:13:16at the bottom of the hill and runs the
- 1:13:18office four days a week. She took a 51%
- 1:13:21pay cut to do it and she has never once
- 1:13:24gone back. Nava is 74 now. She is still
- 1:13:27diabetic. She is still tired by 2:00 in
- 1:13:30the afternoon and the story does not fix
- 1:13:32that because stories do not fix that.
- 1:13:35Her insulin lives in a soft-sided cooler
- 1:13:37with a strip of masking tape on the lid
- 1:13:39that says "not food" and Odell still
- 1:13:42reaches for it in the dark about twice a
- 1:13:44year. The Orange County placard is
- 1:13:46screwed to the wall of the front hall 6
- 1:13:48ft inside the door at eye height and it
- 1:13:51is not framed. They call the whole thing
- 1:13:54the receiving home record. It is a
- 1:13:55non-profit corporation in the state of
- 1:13:57Ohio. The address on the letterhead is a
- 1:14:00hill road outside a town called Harnett
- 1:14:02and the telephone is a landline because
- 1:14:05Neva wanted a phone that rings in the
- 1:14:06house. On a Saturday morning in November
- 1:14:09of the second year, a boy of 19 came up
- 1:14:11the hill in a car with one hubcap. His
- 1:14:14instructor at the vocational school two
- 1:14:16counties over had heard there was an old
- 1:14:18man up here who could still run a
- 1:14:20cornice in place and would not be around
- 1:14:22forever. Odell put him on the bench in
- 1:14:24the second floor hall for 6 hours and
- 1:14:26let him ruin about $40 of lime. At the
- 1:14:29end of it the boy had 11 in of clean
- 1:14:31profile out of a 9-ft pole and he was
- 1:14:34ready to quit and did not say so.
- 1:14:36"That's 11 in," Odell said. "I got four
- 1:14:39my first day and my old man watched me
- 1:14:41do it and never said a word about that
- 1:14:43either." He reached into the inside
- 1:14:45pocket of his coat and took out the
- 1:14:4611-in Marshalltown with the handle worn
- 1:14:48down on the left and three initials
- 1:14:50filed into the wood. He put it in the
- 1:14:52boy's hand. "That was my father's," he
- 1:14:54said. "Keep it in your coat, not the
- 1:14:57truck. Trucks get sold." The boy did not
- 1:15:00know what to say, so he said nothing,
- 1:15:02which was the correct answer. Downstairs
- 1:15:05the last four requests of the day were
- 1:15:06still in their chairs. Neva sat at the
- 1:15:09table with volume six open on a stand
- 1:15:11Marla had bought her. Going down a page
- 1:15:13with one finger taking a woman's whole
- 1:15:15life apart and handing it back to her in
- 1:15:17order. Odell came down and stood in the
- 1:15:19front hall to wait on her. Half past
- 1:15:213:00 in the afternoon and the light was
- 1:15:23coming in through six windows that had
- 1:15:25glass in them now. The oak floor was
- 1:15:27swept. There were four folding chairs, a
- 1:15:30coffee urn and a stack of one-page forms
- 1:15:32on a card table that had cost nothing.
- 1:15:34He tipped his head back and looked up.
- 1:15:3729 ft of egg and dart and dental all the
- 1:15:40way down the hall and the medallion with
- 1:15:42the acanthus coming out of it in six
- 1:15:44directions and 32 coffered panels and he
- 1:15:47could not tell anymore which parts were
- 1:15:491911 and which parts were his. Nava came
- 1:15:52out with her hand on the small of her
- 1:15:53back. Two more and then I'm done, she
- 1:15:56said. Are you standing there admiring
- 1:15:58yourself again? I'm resting. You're
- 1:16:01admiring yourself. She stood beside him
- 1:16:03and looked up, too, because she always
- 1:16:05did when he did. That's a good ceiling,
- 1:16:07Odell. It's the best one in this county.
- 1:16:10It's the only one in this county.
- 1:16:12She put her arm through his. It's just a
- 1:16:14box, you know. That's all a house ever
- 1:16:17is. It doesn't mean one thing until
- 1:16:19somebody decides to be honest inside of
- 1:16:21it. He thought about that. $12, he said.
- 1:16:25$12, Nava said, and we're still paying
- 1:16:27on it. I know it. I wasn't complaining.
- 1:16:31Car came up the gravel outside, slow,
- 1:16:33feeling for the road. They all came up
- 1:16:35slow the first time. Nava let go of his
- 1:16:38arm and went to get another chair and
- 1:16:40Odell put his empty hands in his coat
- 1:16:42pockets and went to hold the door open
- 1:16:44for whoever it was.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Elderly Couple Bought the Abandoned Mansion Nobody Wanted for $12 — Everyone Laughed Until… by Hidden Legacy, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 15,024 words across 2,068 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.