YouTube2Text

El VOTO FEMENINO, las SUFRAGISTAS y la lucha por DERECHOS POLÍTICOS en Argentina — Transcript

by Pupina Plomer · 4,867 words · 753 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00I think I started this YouTube channel
  2. 0:01to talk about what I'm going to talk
  3. 0:03about in this video. September 23rd in
  4. 0:05Argentina commemorates the day of
  5. 0:06women's political rights, precisely
  6. 0:08because it was on September 23rd, 1947,
  7. 0:11that the female vote was decreed. But
  8. 0:14the truth is that the fight for the
  9. 0:15female vote is not exclusive to the 40s
  10. 0:17; in our country, it can be dated, it
  11. 0:19can be traced back to the end of the
  12. 0:2119th century. In other words, the saga
  13. 0:23of women's political rights is quite a
  14. 0:25bit broader than people think. First,
  15. 0:27we have to understand that the process
  16. 0:29of the politicization of women was, in
  17. 0:31fact, very long. By the late 19th
  18. 0:33century, the debate about women
  19. 0:35practically didn't exist. We were
  20. 0:38considered inferior by nature; I mean,
  21. 0:40science supported that inferiority and
  22. 0:42it seemed that we only deserved to
  23. 0:44occupy the private sphere, that is, the
  24. 0:46domestic, the daily, the one inside our
  25. 0:49homes, except for very few exceptions
  26. 0:51that were seen more as exceptional, as
  27. 0:53strange. Like, for example, we talked
  28. 0:55in another video about Juana Manso, who
  29. 0:58in 1869 dared to speak in public in
  30. 1:00front of men, but they killed her. In
  31. 1:02fact, the very same Sarmiento said that
  32. 1:04he was a very respected man. Juan Manso
  33. 1:07was a very respected man. But well, we
  34. 1:09know that these cases of women who
  35. 1:11managed to break the norm are
  36. 1:13exceptional; the general rule was that
  37. 1:15women were considered inferior in
  38. 1:16biological terms and therefore did not
  39. 1:18deserve political or civil rights. If
  40. 1:21we base ourselves on our country's
  41. 1:23first civil code, which was drafted by
  42. 1:25Vélez Sarsfield in 1869, we will see
  43. 1:28that it is based on what were called
  44. 1:30Napoleonic laws, within which female
  45. 1:32subordination was the norm. They were
  46. 1:35not considered subjects of law. In fact
  47. 1:36, they were almost like minors; they
  48. 1:38could not manage their assets, they had
  49. 1:40to ask their husband for authorization
  50. 1:42for anything they wanted to do. They
  51. 1:44did not have parental authority over
  52. 1:46their children and were always under
  53. 1:47the legal guardianship of their
  54. 1:48husbands. Basically, married women.
  55. 1:50Single women had a little more freedom,
  56. 1:52but a single woman was rare at the end
  57. 1:53of the 19th century. The point is that
  58. 1:56in that context, feminism and the
  59. 1:57feminisms that began to emerge fought
  60. 1:59mainly for three issues: to be
  61. 2:01considered equally intelligent and have
  62. 2:03access to education, legal equality,
  63. 2:05and political equality—that is, being
  64. 2:07able to vote like men. But our country
  65. 2:09was not the only place where feminisms
  66. 2:11existed. In fact, the first great
  67. 2:13feminist movement of the era occurred
  68. 2:15in England, known as the English
  69. 2:17suffragettes, who at the beginning of
  70. 2:19the 20th century organized and were
  71. 2:21basically the "knuckle-dusters" of the
  72. 2:23vote. Why do I say the "knuckle-dusters
  73. 2:25" of the vote? Because the English
  74. 2:27women who organized for the vote were
  75. 2:29truly extreme and radical. Something
  76. 2:31never before seen in history.
  77. 2:33Knife-wielding women, I mean, when I
  78. 2:34say "knuckle-dusters," it’s real.
  79. 2:36It’s well-known, there are many memes
  80. 2:38, in fact, about how English women took
  81. 2:40to the streets. There is the very
  82. 2:41famous case of Emily Davison, who
  83. 2:43stepped onto a racetrack where the
  84. 2:45King’s horse was running to raise
  85. 2:46visibility for the suffragette struggle
  86. 2:48, and well, she was struck and killed
  87. 2:50by the horse in 1913. These women, who
  88. 2:53had no fear whatsoever, were thrown
  89. 2:55into prison and beaten. When they were
  90. 2:57thrown in jail, they went on hunger
  91. 2:59strikes; I mean, they were very
  92. 3:00organized. The point is that with that
  93. 3:02example from the English suffragettes,
  94. 3:04the rest of the Western world had a
  95. 3:06kind of beacon. The thing is, here in
  96. 3:09Argentina, the suffragette movement
  97. 3:11wasn't that radical. Argentine
  98. 3:13suffragists didn't take such an extreme
  99. 3:15stance as the English women; instead,
  100. 3:17they went more through institutional
  101. 3:18and legal channels, as we will see
  102. 3:20below. Because yes, if I didn't say it
  103. 3:23at the beginning, the goal of this
  104. 3:25video is to track the entire struggle
  105. 3:27of the early 20 th-century suffragists
  106. 3:29to understand how we arrived at women's
  107. 3:31suffrage in 1947; to understand that it
  108. 3:33wasn't an isolated event mid-century,
  109. 3:35but rather the result of a demand and a
  110. 3:37struggle that was super diverse, super
  111. 3:38varied, and, of course, super silenced.
  112. 3:41Let's return to Argentina, early 20th
  113. 3:43century, we are in the year 1900. Just
  114. 3:47a few women were very incipiently
  115. 3:49entering academic spaces like medical
  116. 3:51school and spaces for political
  117. 3:52discussion. Women were starting to
  118. 3:55occupy public debate, but very
  119. 3:57incipiently, very slowly. Let’s not
  120. 3:59think it was full of women. These women
  121. 4:00, who are known as the Argentine
  122. 4:02suffragists, began to organize into
  123. 4:04groups and proposed different ways to
  124. 4:06end the unequal world in which they
  125. 4:08lived. The most relevant event at the
  126. 4:11beginning of the century was the first
  127. 4:13international women's congress held in
  128. 4:16the world in the year 1910, hosted in
  129. 4:18Buenos Aires, where different feminist
  130. 4:20women's groups gathered to debate. Many
  131. 4:24of the suffragists, these women who
  132. 4:25fought for women's suffrage, were also
  133. 4:27doctors. This is not a minor detail
  134. 4:30because you will see there is a
  135. 4:31continuity there. The point is that
  136. 4:33these women gathered in Buenos Aires
  137. 4:34for the world's first international
  138. 4:36congress—I'll keep insisting because
  139. 4:38Argentina has been a world champion
  140. 4:39since forever—to debate different
  141. 4:41issues. For example, their director,
  142. 4:43Cecilia Grierson, who was actually the
  143. 4:44first female doctor in Argentina, I
  144. 4:46mean, Cecilia was an absolute legend.
  145. 4:49Cecilia presided over this congress,
  146. 4:51which had the backing of Clara Zetkin
  147. 4:53and Rosa Luxemburg, two world-renowned
  148. 4:55feminists. But what did they talk about
  149. 4:57? What were they debating at that first
  150. 4:58international congress? For one thing,
  151. 5:00they demanded that women be educated in
  152. 5:02history with a gender perspective to be
  153. 5:04recognized as a political subject over
  154. 5:06100 years ago. Furthermore, they asked
  155. 5:08that women receive sexual education. I
  156. 5:09mean, do you realize this was over 100
  157. 5:11years ago? But beyond all this, they
  158. 5:13debated the vote. Although there was no
  159. 5:16unanimous decision on what to do about
  160. 5:18the female vote, because some women
  161. 5:21refused—they didn't refuse the vote
  162. 5:23itself, but rather that women be
  163. 5:25equated to a masculine condition and
  164. 5:27that no specific figure be created for
  165. 5:29women. For example, anarchist women
  166. 5:31were not in favor of the female vote;
  167. 5:33they were feminists and everything else
  168. 5:34, but they weren't in favor of the
  169. 5:36female vote because they weren't in
  170. 5:37favor of the State. They said that if
  171. 5:39one were seeking equality, the system
  172. 5:41itself had to be dismantled, rather
  173. 5:43than granting a right to a woman who,
  174. 5:45at the end of the day, remained
  175. 5:46subjected to an unequal, patriarchal
  176. 5:48system—just so you keep in mind that
  177. 5:50the debate wasn't so unified. However,
  178. 5:52there were many feminists who were in
  179. 5:54favor of the female vote. One of these
  180. 5:56young women who was at the first
  181. 5:58international women's congress was
  182. 6:00Julieta Lanteri. My favorite woman in
  183. 6:02history. Julieta Lanteri was a woman
  184. 6:04who was a doctor, like many of the
  185. 6:06suffragists. She was, I think that when
  186. 6:09she was born, when she saw the light of
  187. 6:11this world for the first time, she said
  188. 6:13, "I'm here to break things." Because
  189. 6:17Julieta truly did things that no other
  190. 6:19woman had done at the time and that
  191. 6:21were crucial for the formation of a
  192. 6:23suffragist movement. What did Julieta
  193. 6:25do? You might be wondering. In the year
  194. 6:281911, Julieta Lanteri became the first
  195. 6:31woman to vote in Argentina and in Latin
  196. 6:34America. Remember that at the beginning
  197. 6:36of the video, I mentioned that the
  198. 6:37Argentine vote dates from 1947. You are
  199. 6:40going to tell me, how did Julieta
  200. 6:42Lanteri vote in 1911 if women's
  201. 6:43suffrage didn't even exist? I created
  202. 6:46this YouTube channel to talk about
  203. 6:47Julieta Lanteri in depth. The year was
  204. 6:501911. Women's suffrage did not exist,
  205. 6:52not even by a long shot, but in the
  206. 6:54city of Buenos Aires, the electoral law
  207. 6:56was modified. What did this electoral
  208. 6:58law say? This law stated that those
  209. 7:00people who could vote had to be
  210. 7:02citizens. Nowhere did it say, "Men vote
  211. 7:04, women do not vote." Women were not
  212. 7:06excluded from that electoral law
  213. 7:07because they were not even considered
  214. 7:09capable of wanting to vote. In that
  215. 7:11context, my dearest Julieta Lanteri, a
  216. 7:13suffragist and a very well-informed
  217. 7:15woman, found this legal loophole and
  218. 7:18said, "It doesn't say anywhere here
  219. 7:20that women cannot vote." In that
  220. 7:22context, what Julieta Lanteri did was
  221. 7:24become an Argentine citizen. She was
  222. 7:26Italian by birth. When she studied
  223. 7:29medicine, she had to start the process
  224. 7:31to become an Argentine citizen in order
  225. 7:33to work at the university. But when she
  226. 7:35found this legal loophole in the Buenos
  227. 7:37Aires electoral law, she sped up the
  228. 7:38process and said, "I am a citizen." The
  229. 7:40law only stated that to vote, one had
  230. 7:43to meet two conditions: be a citizen
  231. 7:45and be on the electoral roll. Julieta
  232. 7:47was already a citizen; she had achieved
  233. 7:49citizenship. All that was left was to
  234. 7:51register on the electoral roll. It’s
  235. 7:53not that it was so easy; she didn't
  236. 7:54just go to the electoral office and say
  237. 7:55, "Hi, sign me up." And they didn't
  238. 7:56just let her vote right there. She had
  239. 7:58to initiate a series of claims and
  240. 8:00prove that she was mentally sound, that
  241. 8:02she had a job, that she paid taxes, and
  242. 8:04other things that, of course, no man
  243. 8:05was required to do. And finally, they
  244. 8:07let her register. That is how, in 1911,
  245. 8:10she became the first woman to vote in
  246. 8:12Argentina and in Latin America. There
  247. 8:15are only records of her voting in those
  248. 8:17elections; no other woman voted, but
  249. 8:19the important thing here is that she
  250. 8:21found a legal loophole to trick the
  251. 8:23system. It was all very nice; Julieta
  252. 8:25voted, and it was in all the newspapers
  253. 8:27of the time. Let’s keep in mind that
  254. 8:29at that time, the electoral law was
  255. 8:31different from the current one. I
  256. 8:34repeat, people voted voluntarily, they
  257. 8:36only voted if they had registered, and
  258. 8:38well, the vote was public and so on. It
  259. 8:42wouldn't last; the following year, in
  260. 8:441912, one year after Julieta voted, the
  261. 8:46Sáenz Peña Law was created, which
  262. 8:48established secret, mandatory, and
  263. 8:50universal voting. Why do I say
  264. 8:52universal in quotation marks? Because
  265. 8:54now it would be considered universal,
  266. 8:55contemplating that men were the only
  267. 8:57ones capable of voting; in other words,
  268. 8:59it was masculine. They called it
  269. 9:01universal, because women were not even
  270. 9:02considered in the possibility of a "
  271. 9:04universe." This law wasn't created
  272. 9:06because Julieta had voted the year
  273. 9:07before, right? They didn't say, "Oh, a
  274. 9:09woman found a loophole in the system,"
  275. 9:11but rather it had to do with the fact
  276. 9:13that the previous system was very
  277. 9:14corrupt and involved issues within the
  278. 9:16oligarchy and so on, but well, that's
  279. 9:18for another video. So, by 1912, Julieta
  280. 9:20can no longer vote. Because now the
  281. 9:23requirement wouldn't be being
  282. 9:25registered, but having an enrollment
  283. 9:27booklet. The enrollment booklet is a
  284. 9:29document that was given to men, uh,
  285. 9:31until not many years ago, when they did
  286. 9:33mandatory military service. Guess what
  287. 9:36Julieta Lanteri did. I'll let you think
  288. 9:37for a bit. Uh, she wanted to do
  289. 9:39mandatory military service. She
  290. 9:41insisted that they let her sign up to
  291. 9:43do military service to get the
  292. 9:44enrollment booklet. She was like, she
  293. 9:47said, "I'll do push-ups, I'll scrub the
  294. 9:49floor with a toothbrush, I'll dance,
  295. 9:51I'll run, everything, just let me." But
  296. 9:54well, of course they didn't let her. So
  297. 9:55she, Julieta, won't be able to vote
  298. 9:58because voting is now strictly
  299. 9:59established for men. But she, an
  300. 10:02absolute queen, said, "Okay, no problem
  301. 10:04, they won't let me vote, it doesn't
  302. 10:06matter, I already voted." So she says,
  303. 10:08"If I can't vote, I'm going to be a
  304. 10:10candidate for deputy, legislator,
  305. 10:12councilwoman." And she was one of the
  306. 10:14first women candidates. She ran
  307. 10:16numerous times during the 20s in
  308. 10:18different elections. On one occasion
  309. 10:20she got something like 1,000 votes,
  310. 10:22that is, 1,000 men voted for her. Even
  311. 10:25in the hypothetical case that in a
  312. 10:27parallel world she had gotten all the
  313. 10:28votes, she couldn't assume the office
  314. 10:30because women couldn't hold public
  315. 10:32office. What I want you to take from
  316. 10:34the life of Julieta Lanteri is that
  317. 10:36there were many obstacles for women,
  318. 10:38but there were also many women willing
  319. 10:40to be bold and break those obstacles.
  320. 10:42Besides all this, Julieta created the
  321. 10:44National Feminist Party. Well, she
  322. 10:46participated in the International
  323. 10:48Women's Congress, participated in the
  324. 10:50drafting of, uh, women's suffrage bills
  325. 10:53, well, she voted, I mean, she ran in
  326. 10:55elections. She had a very active
  327. 10:57militancy within the suffragist
  328. 10:59movement, which somewhat explains what
  329. 11:01happened to her. In February 1932,
  330. 11:04Julieta Lanteri is hit by a car on the
  331. 11:06street in 1932, at a time when vehicles
  332. 11:09didn't go very fast. The case was filed
  333. 11:13as a traffic accident, but the truth is
  334. 11:15it's an open secret that it was an
  335. 11:17attack, because the people driving that
  336. 11:19vehicle were members of the Patriotic
  337. 11:21League, a conservative group that had
  338. 11:23Julieta in their crosshairs. And,
  339. 11:26although it was explained at the time,
  340. 11:28it was known to have been an attack,
  341. 11:30but of course it remained unpunished
  342. 11:32like so many other femicides throughout
  343. 11:34history. Anyway, Julieta's story ends
  344. 11:36very tragically, but it serves as an
  345. 11:38example to see the mark that feminists
  346. 11:39had at the time and how they had that
  347. 11:41difference I told you about with the
  348. 11:43English suffragettes, who were more
  349. 11:45aggressive and combative; here, they
  350. 11:47went more through institutional
  351. 11:48channels. But wait, because Julieta
  352. 11:50Lanteri wasn't the only woman who voted
  353. 11:52before female suffrage in the province
  354. 11:53of San Juan. Thanks to the reforms made
  355. 11:56by the Cantoni brothers in 1928, women
  356. 11:59in San Juan were able to have a
  357. 12:01democratic suffrage experience for the
  358. 12:03first time at the provincial level. In
  359. 12:06this province, there was a modification
  360. 12:08of the provincial law by the Cantoni
  361. 12:10brothers themselves, who were governors
  362. 12:12on different occasions, which allowed
  363. 12:14women to vote. In fact, this law not
  364. 12:18only allowed women to vote, but the
  365. 12:20province of San Juan had its first
  366. 12:22female deputy in 1934, the, of course,
  367. 12:24forgotten Emar Acosta. But well, that
  368. 12:27democratic experience, that possibility
  369. 12:29for the women of San Juan to vote was
  370. 12:31unique in history. Afterward, they
  371. 12:33weren't able to vote again; it was an
  372. 12:34exceptional act because the law was
  373. 12:36later modified. But notice how we
  374. 12:38already have two experiences prior to
  375. 12:39female suffrage. Julieta Lanteri on one
  376. 12:42hand, the women of San Juan on the
  377. 12:44other, and I'm of course missing the
  378. 12:46dozens, and why not hundreds, of female
  379. 12:48suffrage bills that were presented
  380. 12:50during the 1920s. The first was
  381. 12:53presented by deputy Rogelio Rodríguez
  382. 12:55Araya in 1919, that is, 1919, the first
  383. 12:58female suffrage bill. This was a
  384. 13:02radical deputy who, with the help of
  385. 13:04different suffragists like Julieta
  386. 13:05Lanteri, Cecilia Grierson, Alicia
  387. 13:07Moreau de Justo, and Elvira Rawson,
  388. 13:09drafted a bill that even had the
  389. 13:11support of the church. To give you an
  390. 13:14idea, even the Church supported female
  391. 13:17suffrage in 1919. The church did not
  392. 13:19fear that women would abandon their
  393. 13:21role as mothers if they were allowed to
  394. 13:23vote. So, it sort of endorsed this, and
  395. 13:26the truth is that it's quite atypical
  396. 13:27for the church, especially in the 20th
  397. 13:29century, to support these types of
  398. 13:30measures. But well, notice how there
  399. 13:32were already several sectors of the
  400. 13:34population, except for the most
  401. 13:36conservative ones, that were looking
  402. 13:37favorably upon the possibility of women
  403. 13:39being able to vote. The 20s decade
  404. 13:41moves forward, and different women's
  405. 13:44suffrage bills are presented. Some even
  406. 13:46manage to get semi-sanction in the
  407. 13:47House of Representatives, but when they
  408. 13:49reach the Senate, they get shelved.
  409. 13:51Other bills are presented, such as the
  410. 13:53divorce law bill, alongside the women's
  411. 13:55suffrage bill. Of course, we know that
  412. 13:57it was also shelved for a couple of
  413. 14:00decades, until the year 1926 arrives
  414. 14:02and the first reform of the Civil Code
  415. 14:05is made. This Civil Code reform brought
  416. 14:08some improvements for women. It wasn't
  417. 14:10exactly "we want them alive, crazy, and
  418. 14:12free," but there was indeed an
  419. 14:14improvement in the legal status of
  420. 14:16women. On one hand, they were given
  421. 14:17full civil capacity, which remained
  422. 14:19subordinate to their husband, but at
  423. 14:21least they had civil capacity. They
  424. 14:23were allowed to sign contracts, manage
  425. 14:25inheritances, and manage assets, but of
  426. 14:27course, parental authority remained
  427. 14:29with the father. We weren't advancing
  428. 14:32all that much, but it did imply a step
  429. 14:34forward in the successive little steps
  430. 14:36that women would take in their conquest
  431. 14:38of rights, which stemmed somewhat from
  432. 14:40this persistence that the suffragists
  433. 14:42had in the streets, in the media, in
  434. 14:44the House, in the Senate, and in other
  435. 14:46places. And you might ask yourselves, "
  436. 14:48What about the rest of the continent,
  437. 14:49what was happening there?" Look, by the
  438. 14:51year 1932, Uruguay, Cuba, and Brazil
  439. 14:54already had women's suffrage. Uruguay,
  440. 14:57in fact, even had divorce. And it was
  441. 14:59in that year, 1932, when the
  442. 15:00semi-sanction of the women's suffrage
  443. 15:02law that I mentioned was achieved. And
  444. 15:04unfortunately, it was also the year
  445. 15:06that Julieta Lanteri died. A detail
  446. 15:08there so you can place yourselves on
  447. 15:09the timeline I am putting together,
  448. 15:11perhaps a bit disorganized, but well,
  449. 15:13time passes and we reach the 40s. In
  450. 15:16the 30s, we know that the political
  451. 15:18situation was a bit more chaotic and
  452. 15:21there was no progress regarding women's
  453. 15:23rights until something changes in the
  454. 15:2540s. First, the international context
  455. 15:28changes. Of course, we are in the
  456. 15:30postwar period. The world is changing
  457. 15:33its paradigm. Many refugees from the
  458. 15:35Spanish Civil War are arriving, which
  459. 15:37is no small detail because many
  460. 15:38feminist figures come with them. And
  461. 15:40the actors concerned about women's
  462. 15:42suffrage begin to increase more and
  463. 15:43more. Socialist women, radical women,
  464. 15:46even liberal Catholic women are in
  465. 15:48favor of women's suffrage. And it was
  466. 15:51in that decade that a new political
  467. 15:53force appeared, one that would provide
  468. 15:54the final push for women's suffrage. Of
  469. 15:57course, I am talking about Peronism. In
  470. 15:59the 1946 elections, when Juan Domingo
  471. 16:01Perón ran for the first time, there
  472. 16:03was a rumor that if this man, if this
  473. 16:05politician reached power, he would
  474. 16:07enact women's suffrage. Which is
  475. 16:10exactly what happened, and on September
  476. 16:1323, 1947, Law 13.010, the women's
  477. 16:15suffrage law, was enacted. But I got
  478. 16:19ahead of myself; I think we need to
  479. 16:21explain a few things about how Peronism
  480. 16:23condensed this suffragist struggle to
  481. 16:25finally pass the vote and why
  482. 16:27suffragist women were not happy about
  483. 16:29it at all. Let’s start by saying that
  484. 16:32Eva Perón’s role in the enactment of
  485. 16:34this law is indisputable, although we
  486. 16:36know from her own words that she was
  487. 16:38quite distant from what was understood
  488. 16:40as feminism at that time. Mind you, we
  489. 16:42shouldn't be anachronistic; feminism in
  490. 16:44the mid-20th century is not the same as
  491. 16:46it is today. In her book, "My Mission
  492. 16:48in Life," Eva Perón has some very
  493. 16:50harsh things to say about feminism,
  494. 16:52which stemmed partly from what people
  495. 16:54thought within the patriarchal
  496. 16:55structures of that era. She even uses
  497. 16:57epithets like "ugly" or "hateful," as
  498. 16:59some still say today, which was
  499. 17:01basically what people said about
  500. 17:02suffragists back then. If we read her
  501. 17:05with a gender perspective, she has
  502. 17:07points of contact with feminism; while
  503. 17:09not with the stereotypical
  504. 17:11understanding of feminism at the time,
  505. 17:13she does have ideological parallels
  506. 17:15with what we understand today as
  507. 17:17feminism and women's rights. Because
  508. 17:19basically, although the women's
  509. 17:21suffrage law was passed under her
  510. 17:23husband Juan Domingo Perón's
  511. 17:24government, she was one of the main
  512. 17:26driving forces behind it, to the point
  513. 17:28that when it was enacted, Perón took
  514. 17:30it and handed it directly to her. But
  515. 17:32of course, the suffragist feminists of
  516. 17:34that time were very angry about this
  517. 17:36law, especially the socialists. Alicia
  518. 17:39Moreau de Justo, a very important
  519. 17:40suffragist, had terrible things to say
  520. 17:43about this law, basically saying she
  521. 17:45didn't even want to vote under it. Why?
  522. 17:48Because the socialists, for one thing,
  523. 17:49were angry at Peronism for partisan and
  524. 17:51ideological reasons. Alicia Moreau was
  525. 17:54one of those most angered by the
  526. 17:56passing of women's suffrage by Peronism
  527. 17:58, because what she was feeling
  528. 18:00represented what all the suffragists
  529. 18:02were going through, especially the
  530. 18:04socialists; on one hand, they felt that
  531. 18:06Peronism had appropriated a struggle
  532. 18:08they had been carrying out for a long
  533. 18:10time and had left them out, and, of
  534. 18:12course, they were against Peronism as
  535. 18:14an ideology and as a political party.
  536. 18:16Now, if you ask me what I think about
  537. 18:18all this, the truth is that it is
  538. 18:20indisputable that Peronism created the
  539. 18:22space and the conditions to pass
  540. 18:24women's suffrage. I don't know if any
  541. 18:26other type of government would have
  542. 18:27taken such a measure. It's incorrect to
  543. 18:29think about it that way because, well,
  544. 18:31one cannot assume what might have
  545. 18:33happened, but I do believe that the
  546. 18:34political will was generated and that
  547. 18:36was key to passing a law like this. Of
  548. 18:39course, socialism and Peronism had no
  549. 18:41points in common due to partisan,
  550. 18:43ideological, political, and other
  551. 18:45issues. So, it is understandable how
  552. 18:47the socialist women reacted, having
  553. 18:48been fighting for the vote for 40 years
  554. 18:50, when they saw that the law was
  555. 18:52finally passed by a government that was
  556. 18:54their opponent. But the truth is that
  557. 18:55this would have been impossible if the
  558. 18:57political will to do it had not existed
  559. 18:58. A significant point is that in
  560. 19:00addition to passing women's suffrage,
  561. 19:02space was also created to welcome women
  562. 19:04into politics. We know that Eva Perón,
  563. 19:07of course, was a super important figure
  564. 19:09in politics, but it is important to
  565. 19:12recognize, for example, that in 1951,
  566. 19:1430%of Congress began to be made up of
  567. 19:16women. I mean, there was a 30%female
  568. 19:18participation. That is a lot. Of course
  569. 19:21, after the 1955 military coup, when
  570. 19:24Perón was overthrown and a military
  571. 19:26dictatorship began—one of so many
  572. 19:28dictatorships we had during the 20th
  573. 19:31century—this female representation
  574. 19:33disappeared. Why? Because, naturally,
  575. 19:36the military—and who is more
  576. 19:37conservative than the military—did
  577. 19:39not even consider the possibility of
  578. 19:41women occupying a place within the
  579. 19:42military structure itself. In the
  580. 19:45democracies that followed, which we
  581. 19:47know were not democracies as we
  582. 19:48understand them today, because some
  583. 19:50were intervened by the military, others
  584. 19:52had bans, and others had fraud. In
  585. 19:55those democratic elections, women did
  586. 19:58vote because the vote had been
  587. 19:59institutionalized as women's suffrage,
  588. 20:02but that 30%participation we saw in
  589. 20:041951 would not be repeated until the
  590. 20:06end of the 20th century. Still, even
  591. 20:09though they were excluded from those
  592. 20:11spaces and that female participation
  593. 20:13practically disappeared, there were
  594. 20:15some exceptional individual cases of a
  595. 20:17few women who managed to occupy spaces
  596. 20:19at certain junctures. One of them was
  597. 20:22Clotilde Sabatini, daughter of the
  598. 20:24governor of Córdoba, Amadeo Sabatini,
  599. 20:26a radical woman who, during the
  600. 20:27Frondizi administration, held a very
  601. 20:29important position that was almost like
  602. 20:32Minister of Education. She was
  603. 20:33president of the National Congress of
  604. 20:36Education because, in addition to being
  605. 20:38a radical politician, she was a
  606. 20:40renowned pedagogue, teacher, scholar,
  607. 20:42and intellectual. We know that her life
  608. 20:45, unfortunately, ended in a very tragic
  609. 20:48way when, after having married Jorge
  610. 20:50Baron Biza, a very renowned poet in the
  611. 20:53city of Córdoba, she suffered an
  612. 20:55attempted femicide by this poet, who
  613. 20:58threw acid in her face and, after being
  614. 21:00left with all the wounds from this, she
  615. 21:03decided to take her own life. This,
  616. 21:07honestly, deserves a separate video
  617. 21:09because Jorge Baron Biza, a renowned
  618. 21:11poet as I told you from the aristocracy
  619. 21:13here in Córdoba, is recognized as the
  620. 21:15last romantic here in Córdoba, because
  621. 21:17he built a very large monument for his
  622. 21:19previous wife on a road that connects
  623. 21:21Córdoba with Alta Gracia, which is the
  624. 21:23wing of Myriam Stefford. And everyone
  625. 21:26says, "How romantic!" For his first
  626. 21:28wife, who died in a plane crash, he
  627. 21:30built a monument shaped like an
  628. 21:31airplane wing because he was a romantic
  629. 21:33. Well, his second wife he tried to...
  630. 21:36well, I got a bit side-tracked, but
  631. 21:38these things really interest me. I
  632. 21:41wanted to highlight the participation
  633. 21:43of Clotilde Sabatini because those
  634. 21:45suffragettes we saw at the beginning of
  635. 21:46the 20th century, by the second half of
  636. 21:48the 20th century, many had already
  637. 21:50passed away. From the 50s to the 90s,
  638. 21:54the truth is there was practically no
  639. 21:57progress, although in 1968 there was a
  640. 21:59new reform that granted more equality
  641. 22:02and freedom to women. Basically, women
  642. 22:06were legally equalized to men. This
  643. 22:08isn't exactly utopian, we can't think
  644. 22:10of it as something that advanced,
  645. 22:12because what was done was precisely to
  646. 22:14equalize women to men. A specific legal
  647. 22:16status for women was not created that
  648. 22:18contemplated our specificity as women,
  649. 22:20but rather we were equated with men.
  650. 22:23But well, from that moment on, civil
  651. 22:25capacity was, let's say, full for women
  652. 22:27. And finally, the last milestone of
  653. 22:31the 20th century arrived in 1991 with
  654. 22:34the famous female quota law, which
  655. 22:36established a 30%floor for women in the
  656. 22:39different chambers. Which unfortunately
  657. 22:43, we know that 30%often became a
  658. 22:45ceiling, because once that 30%quota was
  659. 22:47reached, it was like: "Done, we hit 30%
  660. 22:49, let's not call any more women." And
  661. 22:51well, the story of the 21st century is
  662. 22:53different because we know there were
  663. 22:54rights won and so on, but I don't want
  664. 22:56to get into that because I want to
  665. 22:57stick to the 20th century. In any case,
  666. 22:59I'll make a later video about the 21st
  667. 23:01century. The idea with this video was
  668. 23:04precisely to take a journey through the
  669. 23:06fight for the conquest of women's civil
  670. 23:08, legal, and political rights
  671. 23:10throughout the 20th century to
  672. 23:12understand that it is not something
  673. 23:14that is condensed solely into the
  674. 23:16approval of the female vote in '47, but
  675. 23:18is the product of a, of a collective
  676. 23:20struggle without which it would have
  677. 23:22been impossible to win this right. Why
  678. 23:24do I want to emphasize the collective
  679. 23:26aspect? Because, although I mentioned
  680. 23:29individual cases today like Julieta
  681. 23:30Lanteri or Alicia Moreau de Justo,
  682. 23:32which Tini used, these women were part
  683. 23:34of a collective of suffragette women
  684. 23:36who, at the same time, are a group that
  685. 23:38I’m not sure represents the entire
  686. 23:40population, because the majority of
  687. 23:41suffragettes were white women from
  688. 23:43middle or wealthy sectors,
  689. 23:44university-educated, studious, an
  690. 23:46intellectual elite among women; but,
  691. 23:48despite being an intellectual elite,
  692. 23:50they dedicated their lives to fighting
  693. 23:52so that the rest of the women, who
  694. 23:54could not be in that privileged group,
  695. 23:56would have the same rights as them. So
  696. 23:59well, on Women's Political Rights Day,
  697. 24:01it's good to look at the full picture,
  698. 24:03to have a more complete reflection on
  699. 24:05how this fight, the truth is, was not
  700. 24:07simple, was not handed to us, and was
  701. 24:09precisely the product of women
  702. 24:10deploying different strategies to reach
  703. 24:12an equality that, well, of course, we
  704. 24:14know was not reached. To close, I would
  705. 24:17like to recover a quote from the great
  706. 24:19Alicia Moreau. If you allow me, I will
  707. 24:22read it. She said, "Remember that true
  708. 24:24rights must be conquered, that it is
  709. 24:26necessary to overcome the routine-bound
  710. 24:28retrogrades, the fearful of the new,
  711. 24:30the lovers of the past, that it is
  712. 24:32necessary to overcome the fear of
  713. 24:34politicians who view with suspicion
  714. 24:36that unknown contained in the female
  715. 24:38vote." She was an absolute legend, and
  716. 24:39well, if you made it this far, of
  717. 24:41course, I’m going to ask you what all
  718. 24:42YouTubers ask, like, subscribe, and so
  719. 24:44on. Something very crazy is happening
  720. 24:45to me. This is my third video on
  721. 24:46YouTube. And in the previous video, a
  722. 24:48lot of people, in the previous videos,
  723. 24:50a lot of people told me like, "Wow, you
  724. 24:52speak so fluently, I didn't know you,
  725. 24:54it can't be your first video." Well,
  726. 24:55they are my first videos on these
  727. 24:57platforms. I have been working as a
  728. 24:59social media educator for years. You
  729. 25:01can follow me on Instagram where I
  730. 25:03upload many short videos there, on
  731. 25:05TikTok, eh, you can find me everywhere,
  732. 25:07now on YouTube for a short time. And
  733. 25:09well, on my broadcast channel on
  734. 25:11Instagram we decided that this
  735. 25:12community has to be called Las Lanteris
  736. 25:14, los Lanteris, my Lanteris, because
  737. 25:16Julieta Lanteri is my animal spirit,
  738. 25:18she is the woman who sparked my passion
  739. 25:20for communicating women's history. So
  740. 25:22well, you already know this code. Now
  741. 25:24you will be my lanteris, the lanteris,
  742. 25:26the lanteris. It will be the new
  743. 25:27greeting for this channel, I guess,
  744. 25:29something like hello my lanteris. And
  745. 25:31if you made it here, of course, you can
  746. 25:33leave me in the comments if you are in
  747. 25:35favor of me calling you the lanteris
  748. 25:37from now on. Thanks for watching this
  749. 25:40far. You can stay with a recommended
  750. 25:42video from the three videos I have on
  751. 25:43this channel and if you are watching
  752. 25:44this from the future, maybe you will
  753. 25:46have many more videos. Bye.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of El VOTO FEMENINO, las SUFRAGISTAS y la lucha por DERECHOS POLÍTICOS en Argentina by Pupina Plomer, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 4,867 words across 753 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.