EL PENSAMIENTO POLITICO EN ROMA — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:01This is Theory of Power. Political
- 0:04thought in Rome as opposed to Greece.
- 0:07Rome. Literature and political
- 0:10philosophy were scarce. Very few
- 0:13thinkers developed systems of political
- 0:15ideas as grand and profound as the
- 0:18constructions of Plato or Aristotle,
- 0:21for example. Instead, what was valid in
- 0:23Rome were its public institutions and
- 0:26legal system, the principles of which
- 0:28survived the destruction of the Roman
- 0:31Empire throughout the Middle Ages, up
- 0:33to the present day. The Romans have
- 0:36been characterized as more practical
- 0:38people. The Greeks were more
- 0:39theoretical. That is why many of Rome's
- 0:42political institutions are based on the
- 0:45political institutions of Greece. That
- 0:48is what we will see today in Theory of
- 0:51Power. Power and freedom, the
- 1:04principles and human desires that have
- 1:07marked history and will mark the future
- 1:10of humanity. Join us as we try to
- 1:14understand why humanity seeks power so
- 1:18much and permanently pursues freedom.
- 1:23We will see. Rome, the city-state. Rome
- 1:36was originally a city-state similar to
- 1:38the Greek cities, made up of several
- 1:41tribes living in a relatively small
- 1:43area. Its form of government was
- 1:46monarchical. There was a king assisted
- 1:49by a senate of Senex, which means elder
- 1:52, composed first of 200 and later of
- 1:55300 pater familias who were founders of
- 1:58the city or their descendants, and an
- 2:01assembly made up of the comitia curiata
- 2:03. The patricians, who were descendants
- 2:06of the founders of Rome and who owned
- 2:09the lands in common, were divided into
- 2:11families, and by grouping them together
- 2:14they formed a Jens, and a dozen Jens
- 2:16formed a cia. There were 30 curiae in
- 2:19Rome that formed these comitia and
- 2:21their main responsibility was to elect
- 2:24the king. Institutions of the Republic.
- 2:27The Republic was established in the
- 2:30year 510 BC. This means that the system
- 2:33of government, which had previously
- 2:35been monarchical, changed due to
- 2:37political decisions, political revolts,
- 2:40and even revolutions that led to the
- 2:42existence of a new form of government.
- 2:44The Republic was established with the
- 2:46deposition of the seventh king,
- 2:48Tarquinius the Proud, who had committed
- 2:50many abuses and outrages against the
- 2:52patricians. The latter took power, but
- 2:54the plebeians fought tenaciously for a
- 2:56period of 12 years against the
- 2:58patricians until they achieved
- 3:00recognition of their civil rights and
- 3:02the granting of some political rights.
- 3:05To prevent political contradictions
- 3:07from acquiring the character of
- 3:09sacrilege for either side in the
- 3:11conflict, a distinction and separation
- 3:13of religious power from secular or
- 3:15temporal power was decreed. The king
- 3:17was replaced by two consuls elected
- 3:20annually from among the patricians by
- 3:22the comite curiata. The praetors, the
- 3:25sensors, and the aediles collaborated
- 3:27with the consuls in their tasks as
- 3:29governors. Upon completion of their
- 3:31annual term, the consuls had to account
- 3:33for their management, during which
- 3:35their authority was limited. Only in
- 3:38times of war could it be unlimited, but
- 3:40later, for times of internal upheaval
- 3:42or external war, an exceptional and
- 3:44temporary magistracy called the
- 3:46dictatorship was legally established.
- 3:49Contradictions in Slave Society. Rome,
- 3:52from its founding in 753 BC as a
- 3:55city-state, was organized through a
- 3:58slave society. The subsistence of free
- 4:01citizens, whether patricians or
- 4:03plebelli, was always based on the work
- 4:05of slaves, whose situation in Rome was
- 4:07even harder than in Greece. At first,
- 4:10only barbarians, because they were
- 4:12considered inferior to the Romans, were
- 4:14subjected to slavery. But later even
- 4:16free Romans who could not pay their
- 4:19debts were enslaved. Of course, slaves
- 4:21were never happy with their situation.
- 4:25There were many attempts at rebellion
- 4:27to free themselves from slavery.
- 4:29Beginning of the expansion in Greece,
- 4:32until the advent of Philip and
- 4:33Alexander of Macedon and, despite
- 4:36internal struggles, the excessive
- 4:38growth of the city-states did not occur
- 4:40; and, moreover, the colonies founded
- 4:42in distant territories barely
- 4:44maintained their unity with the mother
- 4:46city, invariably becoming independent
- 4:49after a short time. Rome, in its
- 4:52beginnings, from the foundation,
- 4:54remained a small urban community; but,
- 4:57from the 1st century BC and under a
- 4:59republican system, driven by the
- 5:02internal contradictions between
- 5:04patricians and plebelli, and free men
- 5:06and slaves, it adopted a policy of
- 5:09force and conquest with foreign peoples
- 5:12and neighbors, until in the 3rd century
- 5:14it became a large, extended slave state
- 5:18covering the Mediterranean basin. These
- 5:22conquests allowed a double objective.
- 5:25The lands of the rich patricians and
- 5:27plebelli increased, and some poor
- 5:29plebelli also obtained some land. On
- 5:31the other hand, the number of slaves to
- 5:34work those lands increased with the
- 5:36barbarian prisoners, as did the
- 5:38lucrative artisan production for the
- 5:41masters of those slaves. The changes
- 5:43that surpassed the very essence of the
- 5:46primitive urban community that was Rome
- 5:48also gave rise to notable changes in
- 5:50legal and political conceptions, and
- 5:52even greater ones in practical
- 5:54institutions. Civil wars and
- 5:56dictatorships became very frequent, as
- 5:58a prelude to new changes of magnitude
- 6:00in the political existence of the
- 6:02problem of the individual and humanity.
- 6:05Since the transformation of the state,
- 6:07man, escaping from the narrowness of
- 6:08the polis, had to begin learning to
- 6:10live only for himself, on the one hand,
- 6:12and to live together with the other men
- 6:14of the world, on the other. From this
- 6:17situation arose a series of
- 6:19philosophies of ethical consolidation,
- 6:21mainly based on forms of religion that
- 6:23proclaimed the immortality of the
- 6:25individual and the existence of a god
- 6:28or several gods who died to redeem men.
- 6:30Religion thus assumed an increasingly
- 6:33greater role in human interests, and
- 6:35the importance of religious
- 6:37institutions grew. This circumstance
- 6:39led to the advent of Christianity and
- 6:42the formation of the church by the year
- 6:45325 AD. The universal city. Alexander
- 6:48the Great, in order to consolidate his
- 6:50empire, was the one who provided the
- 6:52first elements of the universal city as
- 6:54a sign of the definitive expiration of
- 6:55the city-state. Alexander and his
- 6:57successors could maintain an empire
- 6:59only under the scepter of absolute
- 7:02monarchy. But on the other hand, the
- 7:05Romans found that they could generate
- 7:07the criterion of a universal city or a
- 7:10universal state through conquest, but
- 7:13not through absolute conquest. The
- 7:15Roman conquest had a fundamental
- 7:17characteristic, which was the
- 7:19possibility of respecting the
- 7:21institutions, religion, society, and
- 7:23customs of the people they were going
- 7:25to conquer. In that sense, Rome gained
- 7:28more than a conquered, an ally, but
- 7:31formed part of the universal city. The
- 7:34state in Rome. Rome, the state does not
- 7:36absorb the individual as in the
- 7:38Platonic or Aristotelian conception, it
- 7:40distinguishes him first and then
- 7:41respects him. But this also occurs as
- 7:43in Greece only with the free man
- 7:45citizen. It does not apply to the slave
- 7:48, who is not a person, but a thing and
- 7:51a beast. The state has its rights and
- 7:53duties different from those of the
- 7:54citizen. Both, State and Citizen, are
- 7:56legal persons. The first has to
- 7:58exercise its authority within
- 8:00pre-established legal norms and the
- 8:02second enjoys rights and prerogatives
- 8:04before the government and the other
- 8:06citizens of the State. Positive law. In
- 8:09Rome, law did not arise from a system
- 8:10of philosophical or political ideas as
- 8:12in Greece. The Romans learned and
- 8:14benefited much from the Greeks and
- 8:16especially from the Stoics. Their
- 8:18practice, especially when they began
- 8:20their expansion over neighboring
- 8:22peoples, was that of divide et impera,
- 8:24divide and conquer. However, this Roman
- 8:26practicality perfected some of the
- 8:28political and legal ideas of Greece,
- 8:30whose validity translated into the
- 8:32imposition of certain principles, among
- 8:34which the concept of positive law soon
- 8:36stood out, which is based on the
- 8:38separation of ethics and politics. That
- 8:40is, a written law that is established
- 8:43as clear rules so that society can
- 8:45comply with and enforce all the norms
- 8:47of social coexistence. Thus the theory
- 8:50of the pact was born. For the Romans,
- 8:52the State was an institution of a
- 8:54natural nature. But it did not need
- 8:56further justification. The Romans
- 8:58accepted the original authority of the
- 9:00people through a contract between
- 9:01rulers and the governed to become the
- 9:03patrimony of the rulers. In other words
- 9:05, it was a true delegation of powers
- 9:07from the people to the rulers. But once
- 9:10the magistrates were constituted, they
- 9:11had full authority and the people could
- 9:13not strip them of the powers that had
- 9:15been ceded to them. In this way, the
- 9:17people did not have the right to resist
- 9:19or rebel against the public authorities
- 9:21. The pact was consolidated and must be
- 9:23respected. The empire. The Roman
- 9:26colonies dependent on the metropolis
- 9:28maintained their dependence and,
- 9:29together with the absorption of
- 9:31neighboring Italian peoples, produced
- 9:33the transfer of the city-state to the
- 9:35universal state. In this sense, a new
- 9:37situation was configured: an empire, an
- 9:39empire capable of administering the
- 9:41entire known world and the entire
- 9:43civilized world, from Europe, Africa,
- 9:46and the Middle East. Many of the
- 9:48peoples that were part of the Roman
- 9:51Empire not only applied the norms of
- 9:53peaceful coexistence and the
- 9:55distribution of the rules of law, but
- 9:57also became the transmitters of Roman
- 10:00civilization, which of course had Greek
- 10:02civilization as its inheritance. The
- 10:07imperial autocracy. During the course
- 10:09of the 1st and 2nd centuries of the
- 10:11Christian era, the Roman Empire
- 10:12transformed into a world power. During
- 10:15this period there was a notable
- 10:16development of the communication routes
- 10:18of universal trade, as well as an
- 10:19increase in the production of goods for
- 10:21exchange. The old cities grew and many
- 10:24new ones emerged, spreading Roman
- 10:26culture to the most distant regions of
- 10:28the known world. This expansion,
- 10:31however, caused an economic crisis in
- 10:33the Roman Empire that had a decisive
- 10:35influence on the social distribution of
- 10:37the population. In the imperial
- 10:38territory, a distinction was
- 10:40established between three classes made
- 10:42up of a complex variety of national men
- 10:44. The upper class was made up of
- 10:46landowners, merchants, and usurers, not
- 10:48all of whom had a noble rank, but were
- 10:51joined by an infinite number of
- 10:53freedmen or former slaves. The second
- 10:55class was made up of poor free men, who
- 10:57in Rome were already called
- 10:58proletarians. Finally, there was the
- 11:00enormous mass of slaves who were housed
- 11:02throughout the extensive territory of
- 11:04the empire. The universality of Roman
- 11:07law. During the Republic, the
- 11:09administration of justice in civil
- 11:11matters was exercised by an official
- 11:13called the Praetor, who, developing his
- 11:15faculty to formulate his own legal
- 11:16interpellation, produced the definition
- 11:18of new principles and, since the
- 11:20praetors, when taking charge of the
- 11:22administration, issued edicts, they
- 11:24indicated in advance the general
- 11:25principles that governed their actions.
- 11:28Extensions of the doctrine of Roman law
- 11:30were established. Later, in the 1st
- 11:32century AD, as a result of the empire
- 11:34and cosmopolitanism, the peregrine
- 11:36praetor was established to administer
- 11:38justice in the affairs of foreigners
- 11:41incorporated into the empire. And since
- 11:43it was not possible to apply the rules
- 11:45of a foreign law, these peregrine
- 11:47praetors made a selection of legal
- 11:49principles common to Rome and the
- 11:51neighboring peoples they governed, thus
- 11:53beginning to form the Ius Gentium,
- 11:55which we know today as international
- 11:57law. The law of peoples of nations that
- 11:59was considered a faithful
- 12:01interpretation of reason and was
- 12:03finally identified with natural law or
- 12:05jus natural. The Roman thinkers Cicero
- 12:09and Ulpian. An early critique of the
- 12:13political concepts regarding the
- 12:14government of Rome during the time of
- 12:17the Republic was developed by a Greek,
- 12:19Polyvius of Megalopolis, leader of the
- 12:21Akean League and opponent of Rome when
- 12:23Greece fell under its domination. After
- 12:26Alexander was taken hostage and taken
- 12:29to Rome. He lived there for many years
- 12:32and studied the Roman Political
- 12:34Constitution. He wrote a universal
- 12:36history and another of Rome, both of
- 12:38which deal with the problems of the
- 12:40State during the development of the
- 12:42Romanian Republics. Bolivia accepts
- 12:44Plato's theory of the cyclical movement
- 12:46of forms of government, which pass from
- 12:48one to another until a cycle is
- 12:50concluded and then the forms that have
- 12:52already passed are repeated again. In
- 12:54this sense, he accepts the three forms
- 12:56of government that Aristotle considers
- 12:58pure and their respective degenerations
- 13:00. He states that monarchy, which is the
- 13:02moral and just beginning, becomes
- 13:04tyranny when the king becomes arbitrary
- 13:06and unjust. Conspiracies ensue
- 13:09involving the most select men among the
- 13:11citizens, who depose the tyrant and
- 13:14inaugurate the government of the
- 13:16aristocracy, which in turn generates an
- 13:18oligarchy that oppresses the people,
- 13:21provoking a new popular revolution
- 13:23against the oppressors and the advent
- 13:25of democracy which, in turn, after a
- 13:28period of normality, degenerates into
- 13:30demagogy and the government of the mob
- 13:33to give rise to a new revolution in
- 13:35which a bold and brave man takes over
- 13:37the government, thus restarting the
- 13:39cycle of this form of government in its
- 13:42consequent degenerations and
- 13:44revolutions. Cicero, for his part,
- 13:46proposes natural law. After the death
- 13:49of Polivia, a period of crisis ensued
- 13:51in Rome in which the deep division
- 13:53between the noble and opulent
- 13:54patricians, entrenched in the Senate,
- 13:56and the impoverished people taking
- 13:58refuge in the assemblies deepened.
- 14:00Meanwhile, on the other hand, the
- 14:02masses of slavery were agitating in
- 14:04demand for liberation. All these
- 14:06antagonisms led to civil wars and
- 14:08dictatorship. In these circumstances,
- 14:11Cicero, a fiery orator, emerged. In his
- 14:14youth he had sympathized with the
- 14:15Democratic Party, but later switched to
- 14:17the party of the Octimates, the rich
- 14:19and better off. He wrote several works,
- 14:23the main ones on political matters
- 14:25being the Republic, the Republic or the
- 14:27Legibus or Laws, in which he tried to
- 14:30follow Plato's expository form and even
- 14:32in his literary style in the form of
- 14:34dialogues. But in reality, Cicero did
- 14:37not show originality, but rather
- 14:38expressed his conservative tendency by
- 14:41trying to restore the aristocratic
- 14:43republican institutions that existed
- 14:45before the popular reforms of the
- 14:47tribune Tiberius Gracchus. Cicero, in
- 14:50defense of the Roman slave-owning
- 14:52aristocracy, took from Polyvius the
- 14:54theory of revolutionary cycles and the
- 14:55principle of the mixed form of
- 14:57government, but Polyvius 'empirical
- 14:59conclusions corresponded to the period
- 15:01of the fullness of the Roman
- 15:02city-states. Cicero's shortcoming was
- 15:05that he sought to reaffirm such
- 15:06theories at a time when political
- 15:08upheavals and social and economic
- 15:10contradictions were leading to the
- 15:13emergence of an imperial state. Thus,
- 15:15Cicero's work in this regard was
- 15:17limited to praising the theory of the
- 15:20cycle of degenerations and revolutions
- 15:22of the mixed form of government. Ulpian
- 15:25and the Jurisconsults. During the
- 15:27period of culmination and after the
- 15:29decline of the Roman Empire, the
- 15:31institution of the Jurisconsults
- 15:33acquired great prestige and they
- 15:35received legal advice from individuals,
- 15:37public figures, and emperors. Augustus
- 15:40ordered that the interpretation of the
- 15:42Jurisconsults had to be taken into
- 15:44account by the judges in litigation.
- 15:46The work of the Jurisconsults was
- 15:48limited to clarifying the principles
- 15:50and norms of Roman law that sanctioned
- 15:52the existing institutions. For this
- 15:54reason, in general, the Jurisconsults
- 15:57were exponents of many of the most
- 16:00important principles of Roman law. Many
- 16:03of the most notable, such as Caius,
- 16:05maintained that the division of society
- 16:07into slaves and free men was natural
- 16:10and that the former were mere things,
- 16:12as was the distinction between poor and
- 16:14rich. However, Ulpian, in expounding
- 16:17his opinion on natural law, maintained
- 16:19that its mandates provided that all men
- 16:22are born free. Jurists did not have
- 16:24uniform opinions. A great historical
- 16:27division among them was that which
- 16:28grouped the Savenians with the
- 16:30Procleellans. The Savenians
- 16:32distinguished the legitimacy of the
- 16:33empire, while the Procleellans leaned
- 16:35towards the Republic. Therefore, the
- 16:37former were conservatives and the
- 16:39latter were progressives, proclaiming
- 16:41the permanence of social and economic
- 16:43inequalities. Ulpian defined justice as
- 16:45consisting of living honestly, not
- 16:47causing harm to one's neighbor, and
- 16:49giving each person what is due. This
- 16:52formula prevented any revolutionary
- 16:54changes in society. The Roman jurists
- 16:57are Ulpian, Papineanus, Paulus Gallus
- 16:59and Modestinus, and they were the
- 17:01creators of the natural law of the IUS
- 17:03Gentium and the IUS Civil. Let us
- 17:05remember then that Roman political
- 17:08thought is still valid today in the
- 17:10forms, in the basic structures of
- 17:13states, of governments. The structure
- 17:15of the State is basically oriented on
- 17:17the basis of the structure of the Roman
- 17:20states, especially from the time of the
- 17:22Republic. Well, that was the video for
- 17:25today. If you found it interesting,
- 17:26don't forget to like it. Likewise,
- 17:28subscribe to the channel and activate
- 17:30the bell to be able to receive our
- 17:32notifications. Leave us your comment so
- 17:34that we can have an ongoing debate on
- 17:36this topic and in that sense we will
- 17:38soon have a new video here on Theory of
- 17:40Power.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of EL PENSAMIENTO POLITICO EN ROMA by Dr Ronald Hurtado Paravicini - Profesor de Derecho, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 2,774 words across 462 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.