El Mito de las Caidas Libres explicado por Ingeniero Aeroespacial — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00A few weeks ago I uploaded a video
- 0:01explaining that a person does not fall
- 0:03at the same speed as two people
- 0:04together, like when you skydive in
- 0:06tandem. Thousands of people literally
- 0:08jumped at my throat saying that I had
- 0:10no idea about physics. Let me ask you a
- 0:12question at this point. Here I am with
- 0:13two water bottles, one empty and one
- 0:16full. Do you think they will fall at
- 0:17the same time or that the full one will
- 0:19fall first? Surprisingly, both answers
- 0:21are incorrect and I will explain why.
- 0:25On Earth, all objects with mass support
- 0:27the force of our own weight. This force
- 0:30is generated by the acceleration of
- 0:32gravity and we all know that this value
- 0:34is more or less 9.81 m/sund² on the
- 0:36Earth's surface. This means that if we
- 0:39drop an object, it will not fall at a
- 0:41constant speed, it will accelerate more
- 0:43and more, that is, its speed will
- 0:45increase. In this animation we simulate
- 0:47an altitude of 60 m from the highest
- 0:49line to the lowest line. The
- 0:51intermediate lines delimit a distance
- 0:53of 20 m between each one. If we drop a
- 0:55ball, this is what would happen. Notice
- 0:57that it takes much less time to travel
- 0:59the last 20 m than to travel the first
- 1:0220. This is because the object is going
- 1:04much faster at the end. As a curiosity,
- 1:06I'm also going to show a ball falling
- 1:08on Mars and a ball falling on the Moon
- 1:10so that you can see the difference
- 1:12compared to Earth. Aristotle said about
- 1:142,300 years ago that an object that is
- 1:16heavier than another would fall faster.
- 1:18Since he was one of the greatest
- 1:20thinkers of the time, people didn't
- 1:21doubt it. I suppose that since a
- 1:23heavier object generates more downward
- 1:25force, when you hold them in your hand,
- 1:27it made sense to think that the one
- 1:28that generated more force would fall
- 1:30faster. This idea was respected until
- 1:32Galileo arrived in the 10th century and
- 1:34disproved it, saying that the mass of
- 1:36the objects didn't matter at all. They
- 1:38would all fall with the same
- 1:40acceleration, that of gravity. There
- 1:42are stories about him climbing the
- 1:43Leaning Tower of Pisa and dropping two
- 1:45objects of different masses at the same
- 1:47time to show that they would take the
- 1:48same amount of time to reach the ground
- 1:50. According to the story, this
- 1:51experiment worked, although there are
- 1:53doubts about whether it actually
- 1:54happened, but what is clear is that
- 1:56whether it was because of this
- 1:57experiment or others, Galileo made his
- 1:59point. But before we continue, let me
- 2:00make you think about how it is possible
- 2:02for two objects to fall at the same
- 2:04time if one weighs more than the other.
- 2:05The downward force is greater.
- 2:07Shouldn't the acceleration also be
- 2:09greater? No, because it should be. The
- 2:11force is greater, but the mass is also
- 2:13greater, so it will have more inertia
- 2:15and therefore it will take longer to
- 2:17accelerate. That is why in the end they
- 2:19take the same amount of time to reach
- 2:20the ground. But the thing is, there is
- 2:22a problem. This theory of Galileo that
- 2:24I just told you about is not actually
- 2:26correct because in the world we live in
- 2:27there is friction with the air and that
- 2:29changes everything radically. I
- 2:31remember in high school I used to think
- 2:33that frictional forces wouldn't really
- 2:35change the physics of bodies that much,
- 2:37but the reality is that they do. Here
- 2:39we have a feather and a ball. We know
- 2:41from our own experience that the ball
- 2:43will fall first, yes, but it turns out
- 2:45that this experiment was being carried
- 2:47out in a vacuum chamber, so they could
- 2:49then remove all the air from the room.
- 2:52In this way they would eliminate the
- 2:53friction with the air and look what
- 2:55happens. Both objects in these
- 2:59circumstances fall exactly at the same
- 3:01time, governed by a motion of constant
- 3:04acceleration. As Galileo said,
- 3:06regardless of mass, both objects fall
- 3:08at the same time, but that is only true
- 3:10in vacuum conditions. For example, this
- 3:12experiment was also carried out on the
- 3:15Moon by the astronauts of the Apollo X
- 3:17mission, dropping a hammer and a
- 3:19feather at the same time. Since there
- 3:21is no atmosphere on the Moon, they did
- 3:22indeed fall at the same time. The
- 3:24friction force of a body with the air
- 3:26is determined by this formula, where we
- 3:28see the density of the air, the speed
- 3:30at which the object is moving, the
- 3:32cross-sectional area and the
- 3:33coefficient of resistance. The density
- 3:36of the air appears in the formula
- 3:37because the denser it is, the more air
- 3:39the moving object will be hitting. As a
- 3:42curiosity, for example, a missile
- 3:43launched at sea level has about half
- 3:45the range of that same missile if it
- 3:47were launched from an altitude of 10 km
- 3:49, because the density at sea level is
- 3:51much greater and therefore slows the
- 3:53missile down much more. We can also see
- 3:55in the equation that the speed appears.
- 3:57This is because the faster the body is
- 3:59moving, the more air mass it will
- 4:01affect per second. When you are driving
- 4:03fast, the amount of air that hits you
- 4:04if you stick your hand out the window
- 4:06is greater than if you are driving
- 4:07slowly. But be careful, because the
- 4:09speed is squared, so it is actually the
- 4:11most important factor in this equation.
- 4:14The cross-sectional area appears in the
- 4:16equation because it introduces the
- 4:17dimensions of the object that is moving
- 4:19. Obviously, a car is not the same as a
- 4:21truck. Finally, we have the drag
- 4:24coefficient, which represents how
- 4:26aerodynamic a body is. For example, an
- 4:29airplane that is designed to be very
- 4:31aerodynamic has a drag coefficient of
- 4:33approximately 0.03. A parachute, which
- 4:36is the opposite, since it is designed
- 4:38to generate a lot of drag, has a
- 4:40coefficient of 1.75. In a falling
- 4:44motion on Earth, we have the force of
- 4:46the weight moving downwards and we also
- 4:48have the force of friction opposing the
- 4:50weight. If you recall, the sum of
- 4:52forces is equal to mass times
- 4:53acceleration. In a world where there
- 4:55was no air, the acceleration of the
- 4:57fall would be the same as the
- 4:58acceleration of gravity. But the moment
- 5:01we introduce the influence of air, this
- 5:02is no longer the case. Now the
- 5:04acceleration will be determined by how
- 5:06much greater the weight is than the
- 5:09drag force. If the drag, for example,
- 5:11is very small, the acceleration will be
- 5:13almost like in a pure free fall.
- 5:14However, if the drag is very large,
- 5:16there will be very little acceleration.
- 5:18This is important because, if you
- 5:20notice, the weight is always constant
- 5:22in a free fall, but the resistance does
- 5:24not depend on the speed, which means
- 5:26that in the first moments of the
- 5:28movement the resistance will be very
- 5:30small because the speed will also be
- 5:32small. As a consequence of this, at the
- 5:34beginning of any fall, the movement
- 5:36will be very similar to the behavior in
- 5:38a free fall without friction, but as
- 5:40the seconds go by, the speed of the
- 5:43object increases, causing the
- 5:44resistance to also increase and the
- 5:46acceleration becomes less and less,
- 5:48until there comes a moment when the
- 5:50speed is so great that the resistance
- 5:52is equal to the weight. This speed is
- 5:55known as terminal velocity and
- 5:56represents the maximum speed at which
- 5:58an object falls subject to the force of
- 6:00its weight in an environment in which
- 6:02there is an atmosphere that slows it
- 6:04down. In a parachute jump, it takes you
- 6:07approximately 5 seconds to reach
- 6:09terminal velocity, so after those 5
- 6:11seconds you will not accelerate any
- 6:13more, you will fall very quickly, but
- 6:15the speed will be constant. Now I will
- 6:17repeat the initial question. Two
- 6:19bottles, one empty and one full. Which
- 6:22one reaches the ground first? The
- 6:23correct answer is it depends. Since
- 6:25they are two identical bodies that are
- 6:27being thrown at the same time, in the
- 6:29same place, they will generate the same
- 6:31friction. However, their weight is not
- 6:33the same, so when solving for the sum
- 6:35of forces, we will obtain a greater
- 6:37acceleration for the case of the full
- 6:39bottle, so its speed will be greater
- 6:41and therefore it will reach the ground
- 6:42first. But if we throw them from a
- 6:44small height, they will not have time
- 6:46to accelerate much and therefore the
- 6:48friction will be negligible in both
- 6:49cases and they will behave almost as if
- 6:51they were in free fall. both. That is
- 6:53why, from this very low height, they
- 6:55fall at the same time. However, if we
- 6:57increase the height a lot, the bodies
- 6:59will accelerate enough for friction to
- 7:02act. And since the weight of the empty
- 7:04bottle is very small, as soon as the
- 7:05aerodynamic resistance increases a
- 7:07little, it will slow down a lot, so it
- 7:08can be clearly seen in the videos that
- 7:10the one with water reaches the ground
- 7:12first. A few weeks ago I published a
- 7:14survey on my Instagram account where I
- 7:16asked exactly this question. If I were
- 7:17to drop two balls of different masses
- 7:19but the same shape, which one would
- 7:21fall first? There were three possible
- 7:23answers. Will the one with more mass
- 7:25fall first at the same time or will it
- 7:27depend on the altitude? We have already
- 7:28seen that the correct answer will
- 7:30actually be the third one, because if I
- 7:32drop them from a small height, they
- 7:33will both fall practically as if they
- 7:35were in a vacuum, that is, at the same
- 7:37time. But if the height were
- 7:38considerable, the resistance would
- 7:40increase a lot in the ball with less
- 7:42mass and, therefore, it would slow it
- 7:44down, causing the ball with more mass
- 7:45to fall first. In the survey, the
- 7:47option that got the most votes was that
- 7:49both balls would fall at the same time.
- 7:51I am convinced that most people who
- 7:53voted for that option did so because
- 7:54they believed that the problem assumed
- 7:56being in a vacuum. We will talk about
- 7:58that later, but the terminal velocity
- 7:59of an object does not depend solely on
- 8:01mass. The shape of the object must also
- 8:03be taken into account, since the
- 8:05cross-sectional area in the equation
- 8:06and the coefficient of friction depend
- 8:08on it. The clearest example to
- 8:10understand this is a person jumping out
- 8:12of an airplane with a parachute. At
- 8:14first, since the person is carrying it
- 8:16inside their backpack, the
- 8:17cross-sectional area and the
- 8:18coefficient of friction are determined
- 8:20by the person's body. However, when the
- 8:22parachute deploys, although the mass
- 8:24remains the same, since the friction
- 8:26suddenly increases enormously due to
- 8:28the parachute, a huge upward force is
- 8:30generated that slows down the person
- 8:32who is falling. So, let's get to the
- 8:34question that led me to make this video
- 8:36. If we compare a one-person jump into
- 8:38the void with a two-person jump tied
- 8:40together, the mass of the two people
- 8:41will be double. However, their
- 8:43cross-sectional area and the
- 8:44coefficient of drag will be practically
- 8:46the same. So, when the individual
- 8:48person has reached their terminal
- 8:49velocity, the two people in tandem will
- 8:51still continue to accelerate more,
- 8:53because the friction will still not be
- 8:54the same as the weight. And this is why
- 8:57both people will fall faster, their
- 8:59terminal velocity will be higher. And
- 9:01if it weren't for the addition of a
- 9:03small parachute known as a Droke to
- 9:05increase drag, two people wouldn't fall
- 9:07at the same speed as one. And in case
- 9:09anyone has any doubts, I jumped tandem
- 9:11with an instructor and with the small
- 9:13parachute deployed we fell at the same
- 9:15speed as the person who was right in
- 9:17front of me filming me. If we hadn't
- 9:19deployed that small parachute, we would
- 9:22have fallen faster. So yes, in cases
- 9:24where there's friction, mass does
- 9:26matter in free fall, but so does
- 9:28cross-sectional area and the
- 9:30coefficient of friction. Because of
- 9:32normalizing free fall in a vacuum,
- 9:33there are people who believe that this
- 9:35is the reality. That's why when I
- 9:37released my video and said that two
- 9:39people fall at a different speed than
- 9:41one person, we could see in the
- 9:43comments people who were disrespectful,
- 9:45arrogant, but also wrong. The serious
- 9:47thing is that if you watch this video
- 9:48and start looking at the comments,
- 9:50you'll think that the person who made
- 9:52the video, in this case me, was wrong,
- 9:53because everyone in the comments said
- 9:55that the video was wrong. And I don't
- 9:57know about you, but I really find it
- 9:59quite worrying. On October 9, 2012,
- 10:01Felix Bardner became one of the most
- 10:04famous people in the world by jumping
- 10:06from almost 40,000 m. To give you an
- 10:09idea, commercial airplanes fly at
- 10:11around 10,000 to 11,000 m, more or less
- 10:13. So he jumped from almost four times
- 10:16that height. The incredible thing is
- 10:18that during his jump, Felix became the
- 10:20first person in the world to exceed the
- 10:22speed of sound with his own body and in
- 10:25a free fall. But how is this possible?
- 10:27Well, most normal parachute jumps are
- 10:30made from around 4,000 m in height.
- 10:32Being so low in the atmosphere, the air
- 10:35density is very high and therefore the
- 10:37drag is also high, making the terminal
- 10:40velocity relatively low, between 200
- 10:42and 400 km/h, depending on how you
- 10:44position your body. But at 40,000 m the
- 10:47air density is 300 times less than at
- 10:50sea level. So by jumping from there,
- 10:52Felix was able to accelerate a lot
- 10:54until he exceeded the speed of sound,
- 10:56but as he descended, the density
- 10:58increased and therefore the drag slowed
- 11:00him down more and more. So, if we
- 11:02compare a free fall between two exactly
- 11:05identical objects, that weigh exactly
- 11:07the same, but one is dropped from the
- 11:09Empire State Building and the other
- 11:11from 30,000 m, they will not take the
- 11:13same time to fall 200 m. Again, this is
- 11:16due to air resistance. A few months ago
- 11:19I was invited by Madrid Fly to fly in
- 11:20the wind tunnel, an incredible
- 11:22experience because they taught me more
- 11:24or less how to move in a free fall.
- 11:26This tunnel consists of a vertical duct
- 11:28in which the air rises at a tremendous
- 11:30speed to make you stand still. This
- 11:32happens because the air rises at the
- 11:34terminal velocity of your body and,
- 11:36thanks to this, I was able to feel the
- 11:38magic of aerodynamic forces, because a
- 11:40simple variation of looking down or up
- 11:43with my face changed my cross section
- 11:45by a few square centimeters, causing my
- 11:47body to rise or fall, because that
- 11:49gesture changed my terminal velocity.
- 11:51That's how fine that balance is. And of
- 11:54course I was able to stretch out one
- 11:56arm, which allowed me to turn 360
- 11:57degrees abruptly. Incredible. One
- 12:00interesting thing is that the person
- 12:02helping me can stand on the net because
- 12:04their terminal velocity when standing
- 12:06and having a smaller cross section is
- 12:08much higher, which means that the air
- 12:11is not moving fast enough to keep them
- 12:13flying. However, a person who is lying
- 12:15down is going at the terminal velocity
- 12:17of the air and that's why they can
- 12:18remain suspended. Here is an example
- 12:20from an expert so you can see the crazy
- 12:22things you can do if you know how to
- 12:24manipulate aerodynamic forces 100%. All
- 12:26of this would be completely impossible
- 12:29in a vacuum. Another important point is
- 12:31people who believe that when you throw
- 12:32an object upwards, it will then fall at
- 12:34the same speed that you threw it. This
- 12:36is what they teach us in high school.
- 12:38Well, that's in a vacuum. On Earth,
- 12:40where there is an atmosphere, the
- 12:42arrival velocity is most likely the
- 12:43terminal velocity. And that's why, if
- 12:45you shoot in the air, the speed at
- 12:46which the bullet reaches the ground
- 12:48will not be the same as the speed at
- 12:50which the bullet left the gun. There
- 12:52are many other interesting experiments,
- 12:54such as if you put a sheet of paper
- 12:55right on top of a book and let it fall,
- 12:57the sheet will fall at the same speed
- 12:59as the book, because in this case it is
- 13:01removing all the friction force from
- 13:03the sheet, which, since it weighs so
- 13:04little and has a large cross-sectional
- 13:06area, has a very low terminal velocity
- 13:08and that's why a sheet of paper falls
- 13:10very slowly by itself. But as we
- 13:12explained in this video, if we did this
- 13:14same experiment in a vacuum, both would
- 13:16fall at the same time. I hope this
- 13:17helps you understand everything about
- 13:19free fall. If you have any questions,
- 13:21leave them in the comments and remember
- 13:23that you have my book The Thinking Like
- 13:24an Aerospace Engineer Handbook that is
- 13:26really kicking ass so you can learn
- 13:27everything in a practical way. Thank
- 13:29you very much and I'll see you in the
- 13:30next video.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of El Mito de las Caidas Libres explicado por Ingeniero Aeroespacial by Sergio Hidalgo, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 2,867 words across 415 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.