Edward Thorp · Math genius who beat the dealer and the market — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Chat With Traders episode 109.
- 0:05This is your key to the minds of
- 0:08trading's elite performers, those who
- 0:10profit in relentless markets. Here on
- 0:13the Chat With Traders podcast, you'll
- 0:15hear about the skill sets and tactics
- 0:17that lead winning traders to win, so you
- 0:20can level up and become a better trader.
- 0:23Here's your host, Aaron Fifield.
- 0:31This episode is brought to you by
- 0:33tradestation.com,
- 0:35a top online broker used by many
- 0:38professional traders, including past
- 0:40guests of Chat With Traders, and myself,
- 0:43too, for what it's worth. Trade
- 0:45Station's platform and market monitoring
- 0:47tools are excellent, commissions are
- 0:49fair, support is never far away, and all
- 0:52round, just a really great broker to be
- 0:54with. To learn more about Trade Station,
- 0:57please visit tradestation.com.
- 1:01Support for this episode also comes from
- 1:03squarespace.com.
- 1:05Squarespace is quite possibly the
- 1:08easiest way for you to build your own
- 1:10website, whether that's a professional
- 1:12blog, an online store, or a website for
- 1:15your brick-and-mortar business. So, make
- 1:18your next move at squarespace.com.
- 1:21Start a free trial today and use the
- 1:23coupon code traders to get 10% off your
- 1:27first purchase.
- 1:29Well, guys, I'm not sure how to best say
- 1:32this, but my guest here on Chat With
- 1:34Traders episode 109 is kind of a big
- 1:39deal. Not only in the world of financial
- 1:42markets, but he's also a household name
- 1:45amongst the gambling scene. The
- 1:47gentleman's name is Edward Thorp, the
- 1:50man who beat the dealer and later beat
- 1:53the market. Let me explain. It was the
- 1:56late '50s, early '60s, when Ed, a math
- 2:00genius and professor at MIT, took on the
- 2:04challenge of discovering a way to get an
- 2:06edge playing gambling games such as
- 2:09blackjack, roulette, and even baccarat.
- 2:13Long story short, Ed won, and he's now
- 2:16considered the father of card counting.
- 2:19From there, the next obvious move for Ed
- 2:22was to take on financial markets, which
- 2:24he also did with a great degree of
- 2:26success. Ed's first hedge fund,
- 2:29Princeton-Newport Partners, achieved an
- 2:32annualized return of 19.1%
- 2:35before fees over a 19-year period with
- 2:39227
- 2:41out of 230 months being profitable. The
- 2:45worst monthly loss being less than 1%.
- 2:49And his second fund, Ridgeline Partners,
- 2:52averaged 21% annually over a 10-year
- 2:56period. Now, I must say, full credit to
- 2:58Jack Schwager for these stats, as I
- 3:01pinched them out of Hedge Fund Market
- 3:03Wizards. Now, throughout the interview,
- 3:05we mostly discuss the interesting path
- 3:07Ed has taken through life, but also his
- 3:10thoughts on having an edge and money
- 3:12management. I really wish I did have
- 3:15more time with Ed, as there were so many
- 3:17more questions I would like to ask him,
- 3:19but we did speak for about an hour, and
- 3:21I'm extremely grateful for the
- 3:23opportunity. One last thing, I would
- 3:25like you to make note, Ed has a new book
- 3:28which has just been released, and it's
- 3:30titled A Man for All Markets. It's
- 3:32available now on Amazon, so if you go to
- 3:35chatwithtraders.com/thorp,
- 3:38t h o r p, that will take you directly
- 3:42to A Man for All Markets on Amazon.
- 3:45Anyway, I hope you find this episode
- 3:47interesting. I'm Aaron Fifield. Please
- 3:50welcome my guest, the legendary Edward
- 3:53Thorp.
- 3:56I'm on it pretty much every day, so I'm
- 3:58quite familiar with with how it all
- 4:00works, but um man, thank you very much
- 4:02for taking the time to speak with me.
- 4:04It's it's quite the honor.
- 4:06Oh, thanks. Ed, I I've begun reading
- 4:09your book, and I got quite a kick out of
- 4:11hearing that your very first job was
- 4:13actually the same as my very first job.
- 4:17We were both paper boys. Oh, yes.
- 4:21I thought that was that was very cool to
- 4:23read about. And one of the other
- 4:25similarities, to some degree, which I
- 4:28also thought was quite interesting, is
- 4:30that you ran an independent radio
- 4:32station. Yes. What sort of things were
- 4:35you broadcasting? How long did you keep
- 4:37that up for?
- 4:39Well, I got my ham radio operator
- 4:41license when I was
- 4:43just turning 13.
- 4:45And I was on 2 m voice, and also I did a
- 4:50little bit of code, and so I used to
- 4:51play chess with people in my part of the
- 4:53country, and just
- 4:55chat with people up and down the state.
- 4:57At that time, 2 m was
- 5:00very short range with the equipment
- 5:03people had and the techniques they had.
- 5:06So, you could only go about maybe 100,
- 5:07120 mi.
- 5:09And then I I was qualified to go on all
- 5:13the other bands and use code and talk
- 5:15around the world, but I
- 5:17mainly just had fun talking on 2 m.
- 5:20Okay, okay. So, it wasn't really a radio
- 5:22station as such, like we think about a
- 5:25radio station today.
- 5:27Well, it was it was a a ham radio
- 5:28station, is what it was,
- 5:30transmitter and receiver, but it wasn't
- 5:32a radio station in the sense of having
- 5:34any any commercial or
- 5:37public outreach.
- 5:38Got it, got it. Okay. What sparked your
- 5:41interest in that sort of thing? How did
- 5:42you Like you were very young. I think
- 5:44you actually said in your book you were
- 5:45maybe the youngest person in the class
- 5:47going for your radio license. What
- 5:51sparked your interest? Well,
- 5:53I got fascinated by all things science
- 5:55when I was about 10 or 11, and so I just
- 6:00explored on my own, and electronics, as
- 6:03they were in that in that day, vacuum
- 6:05tube electronics, caught my interest.
- 6:08So, I decided to learn about it, and
- 6:11when I did, I realized that there was
- 6:12this whole world I could potentially
- 6:14talk to
- 6:15if I got a ham radio license, so that
- 6:18was something I pursued.
- 6:19Well, tell us a little bit about your
- 6:21childhood.
- 6:22You know, set the scene for us here.
- 6:24What was your childhood like? I know
- 6:26you're born in I think it was 1932,
- 6:29which was right when the Great
- 6:30Depression was beginning. What was your
- 6:32childhood like during that phase?
- 6:35Well, actually I was born in August '32,
- 6:38and the Dow Jones hit its all-time low
- 6:41in the crash in July of '32. So,
- 6:45it was it was all up from there, but it
- 6:46was a long a long haul for people to dig
- 6:48themselves out of. And I remember when I
- 6:51was five or six, I was selling Kool-Aid
- 6:55to WPA workers in the street. I would
- 6:57buy a
- 6:595-cent pack of Kool-Aid and make six
- 7:03glasses out of it, and sell them all for
- 7:05a penny a glass. And they were very
- 7:06happy to see me because they were
- 7:08working out in the heat for very little
- 7:10pay, and very hot and tired in the
- 7:13summer.
- 7:14So, I I realized I could turn 5 cents
- 7:16into 6 cents
- 7:18over and over with a fair amount of
- 7:19work.
- 7:20What was the drive to start working and
- 7:22start trying to earn some money? Like
- 7:24you were very interesting, you know, as
- 7:27as a young child. You were very kind of
- 7:30experimental,
- 7:31even quite the prankster in some ways.
- 7:34Like where did this sort of come from?
- 7:36You were quite different from most kids
- 7:38at that age.
- 7:39You know, I'm not sure. I I think that a
- 7:42lot of it was I was
- 7:45an early very early reader, and I got
- 7:48into books a lot, and I found out that I
- 7:51learned so much stuff that there wasn't
- 7:54a whole lot of
- 7:55commonality
- 7:57I had with other kids, except except
- 7:58playing, going out playing games in the
- 8:00afternoon, and that sort of thing, but
- 8:02the things I wanted to think about and
- 8:03talk about, nobody else seemed to be
- 8:06thinking and talking about except
- 8:07adults.
- 8:09So, where did that Where did that thirst
- 8:11for knowledge come from?
- 8:14Well, I think partly it was my father.
- 8:18When I was
- 8:19not quite three, I hadn't talked yet,
- 8:21and then one day I started talking in
- 8:24basically complete sentences, which
- 8:26seemed to amaze everybody, so my father
- 8:28then said, "Let's I wonder how much he
- 8:30can learn." So, he started to teach me
- 8:32things, and I was very happy about that,
- 8:34so I I learned to read, I learned to
- 8:36count, I learned to do arithmetic
- 8:38operations, you know,
- 8:39add, subtract, multiply, divide,
- 8:41and that seemed to come very easily, and
- 8:44then I began to read more and more
- 8:45advanced books.
- 8:47So, by the time I was seven, I was
- 8:48reading basic high school level books
- 8:51very comfortably. And what do you think
- 8:53it was about, particularly math and
- 8:56science, that was so interesting to you?
- 8:59Math and science, I I didn't I didn't
- 9:01Math I liked, I just enjoyed numbers.
- 9:04They seemed very interesting, and they
- 9:05had rules.
- 9:07It was fun to learn what those rules
- 9:08were. Science came a little bit later.
- 9:11I think I started with a mineral set
- 9:13when I was about 10, and then learned
- 9:15the Mohs scale of hardness they had, a
- 9:18number of examples. Of course, they
- 9:19didn't have
- 9:21the top one, diamond, which has a
- 9:22hardness of 10, but they had everything
- 9:24up to nine in there.
- 9:26And so, that was pretty interesting to
- 9:28me. And then a little little time went
- 9:30by, and I began to poke around with
- 9:34chemicals. I learned how to make
- 9:35gunpowder out of an encyclopedia,
- 9:37and
- 9:39that's kind of crossed my caught my
- 9:40interest. I made bombs and rockets and
- 9:43so forth.
- 9:44And
- 9:45from there, just one thing led to
- 9:47another, and so when I got a paper route
- 9:49at
- 9:50age 11, I started putting part of my
- 9:51money into science equipment.
- 9:54Okay, now, as a as a 10-11 year old
- 9:57playing around with gunpowder, did that
- 9:59land you in any sort of trouble?
- 10:02Well, things were different in those
- 10:04days. You know, there wasn't any kind of
- 10:06regulation.
- 10:08And the corner druggist
- 10:10was very happy to sell me lots of things
- 10:14that would terrify parents now.
- 10:17At a nice markup. Things like
- 10:19concentrated sulfuric acid and
- 10:21concentrated nitric acid, ether. I
- 10:24actually thought about knocking myself
- 10:26out with ether to see what it was like,
- 10:28but I decided it wasn't a good idea
- 10:29because
- 10:30I wouldn't be able to tell whether I had
- 10:33gone too far or not. So, I decided to
- 10:35forget about the ether.
- 10:37That that was probably smart move. That
- 10:39sounds quite dangerous.
- 10:41So, Ed, what did you do after finishing
- 10:44school? What was the next move for you
- 10:46from that point? You mean after
- 10:48finishing high school? Yes. Well,
- 10:50everybody was poor in those days and we
- 10:52went through the depression and
- 10:55World War II, but I managed to save
- 10:57money
- 10:58for an education, at least for part of
- 11:00an education
- 11:01by delivering newspapers and doing other
- 11:04odd jobs.
- 11:05So, I went off to the University of
- 11:07California to study chemistry.
- 11:10And
- 11:11as time passed, I realized I was more
- 11:13interested in physics, so I changed to
- 11:15physics.
- 11:16And then finally
- 11:17when I got
- 11:19halfway through my doctorate in physics,
- 11:20I'd done all the work except the last
- 11:22part of my thesis,
- 11:23I realized I had to learn a lot more
- 11:24mathematics to finish.
- 11:26So, I went to the math department to
- 11:28take the courses and when I got there, I
- 11:30found out that
- 11:31I would be able to get a math PhD sooner
- 11:34than finishing my physics PhD. UCLA was
- 11:37notorious then for keeping people around
- 11:39for 10 years in graduate school before
- 11:42they got out. So, I in 2 and 1/2 years I
- 11:45was out in math
- 11:46and it was a good decision.
- 11:48Okay, and from that point you went on to
- 11:51become a professor actually teaching
- 11:53math. Is that correct?
- 11:55Yeah, I got a position as a C.L.E. Moore
- 11:58instructor at MIT. That was my first
- 12:00position.
- 12:01That's a kind of an honorary
- 12:02sought-after position. They have
- 12:04competition all over the country to get
- 12:06that job and they
- 12:08appoint anywhere from one or two to six
- 12:11depending on the year and how much space
- 12:13and money they have.
- 12:14So, that was a great experience.
- 12:16So, I spent 2 years in Cambridge
- 12:18teaching at MIT and my then my wife
- 12:20said, "No, we can't stand these winters
- 12:22anymore." At least she couldn't. Tiny
- 12:24baby and all. So, we got a really good
- 12:27relocation to New Mexico State who had
- 12:29just gotten a whole lot of National
- 12:31Science Foundation money.
- 12:33So, I went there and I had my pick of
- 12:34graduate courses, 6 hours a week, pick
- 12:37of top graduate students who they were
- 12:39paying to come in.
- 12:40And so, after 4 years of that,
- 12:43I learned a lot of math
- 12:45and went on to UC Irvine when it opened
- 12:48up out in Southern California.
- 12:51And actually live not far from there
- 12:52now.
- 12:54And just to put this in perspective for
- 12:56us, where do you kind of sit on the
- 12:58spectrum? Like your understanding of
- 13:01math and that field is very advanced. I
- 13:04believe you competed in like numerous
- 13:07competitions, maybe more so in your
- 13:08earlier days, but like where did you
- 13:10stack up in those competitions?
- 13:13Well, when I was in high school,
- 13:15I needed to enter competitions to get
- 13:18scholarships and earn money, so
- 13:21I took the
- 13:23All Southern California chemistry
- 13:25contest which had one or two top
- 13:27students from each high school
- 13:28and I came in fourth in that and then I
- 13:31took the physics contest the next year
- 13:32and I came in first in that.
- 13:35And then I was a finalist
- 13:37for the National Science Talent Search.
- 13:40There were 40 winners out of 11,000
- 13:43contestants all over the country. So, I
- 13:45went to Washington, D.C. and got some
- 13:47money for going there and then I got
- 13:49scholar a scholarship from uh
- 13:52UC Berkeley which continued as a uh
- 13:55scholarship when I went to UCLA. So,
- 13:57piecing all these together
- 13:59went a long way toward helping me uh get
- 14:01through a college that I couldn't
- 14:02otherwise afford.
- 14:04Just
- 14:05skipping forward a few years now, how
- 14:07did a mathematics professor become
- 14:10curious about blackjack?
- 14:12Well, when I was a kid growing up in
- 14:14high school,
- 14:16I was left on my own a lot. My parents
- 14:18were working in defense or in that case
- 14:21war industries
- 14:22and they had my mother had the
- 14:26uh swing shift,
- 14:27uh 4:00 p.m. to midnight and my father
- 14:29had the graveyard shift, midnight to
- 14:318:00 a.m. at another
- 14:33uh industry.
- 14:35And so, I and my brother kind of took
- 14:38care of ourselves
- 14:39and grew up grew up uh
- 14:42without any particular supervision. Now,
- 14:44that was uh good and bad. It was bad
- 14:47because I didn't have the opportunities
- 14:49that kids with more money and uh who
- 14:52went to a better high school would have,
- 14:54but it also taught me to think
- 14:56on my own about things. And so, when I
- 14:58came across situations later in life,
- 15:01I often looked at them for a fresh
- 15:03viewpoint. Um
- 15:06For example, um
- 15:08when I was
- 15:09finishing my PhD at UCLA,
- 15:13I
- 15:14uh was going to go to Las Vegas to have
- 15:17a nice vacation with my wife over with
- 15:18the Christmas holidays.
- 15:21And I learned before I went that there
- 15:23was a way to play blackjack
- 15:26published in a statistics journal that
- 15:27would give you
- 15:29not quite an edge, but it you come
- 15:31pretty close.
- 15:33Your disadvantage only was less than 1%.
- 15:37So, I said, "Well,
- 15:38I don't know anything about gambling,
- 15:40but I'll risk $10 to see what happens."
- 15:44And I was also interested in going there
- 15:46for a second reason which was that I had
- 15:47figured out
- 15:49in the physics part of my career
- 15:51that roulette wheels might be
- 15:54predictable. And I had good reason to
- 15:55think that they almost surely were
- 15:57predictable if you could measure
- 15:59the position and velocity of the
- 16:02spinning rotor
- 16:03and the position and velocity of the
- 16:05spinning ball,
- 16:06uh you could predict with enough
- 16:08accuracy,
- 16:10not perfect accuracy, but enough
- 16:11accuracy to actually get an edge on the
- 16:13casino. So, one of the reasons I wanted
- 16:15to go to Vegas besides the cheap
- 16:17vacation and have fun playing blackjack
- 16:19as just as an experience was to look at
- 16:21roulette wheels and see whether they
- 16:24were like I thought they were from just
- 16:27pictures and hearsay and so on.
- 16:30And the reasoning.
- 16:32And sure enough they were.
- 16:34And I had set I set out to beat
- 16:38roulette with a by building a hidden
- 16:40computer, wearable computer on person's
- 16:43body.
- 16:44But when I played blackjack, I also
- 16:46stumbled across the knowledge that the
- 16:49people playing didn't know what they
- 16:50were doing and the people running the
- 16:51game didn't know what they were doing.
- 16:54And there were some obvious things that
- 16:55they were missing and I said, "I can
- 16:57beat this game, too."
- 16:58So, I set out to basically beat both of
- 17:00them at that point. And that was a
- 17:02distraction from an academic career and
- 17:04from mathematics,
- 17:06but I'm not enough of a distraction to
- 17:08take me out of the academic world, just
- 17:10enough to be stimulating and give me
- 17:12something one more great thing to do.
- 17:15Now, that first trip to Las Vegas, how
- 17:18did you go playing blackjack and
- 17:20roulette?
- 17:22Well,
- 17:23you mean where did I go to observe them
- 17:25or Did you do well? Like did you make
- 17:27money that on that first trip? Oh,
- 17:29that's a good question. Yes. Well, I had
- 17:3110 silver dollars that I was willing to
- 17:33risk and that was it. So, I played for
- 17:35about 40 minutes and I lost 8 and 1/2 of
- 17:38my 10 silver dollars, but everybody else
- 17:40at the table was smashed.
- 17:42And
- 17:43at first I thought I was
- 17:45some sort of screwball with my little
- 17:47strategy card
- 17:48which I checked and I was also playing
- 17:50rather slowly because I wasn't used to
- 17:52all this. It was all new.
- 17:54And then after about 20 minutes, there
- 17:56was a remarkable hand that I I drew. I
- 17:59drew a seven-card 21 following the
- 18:02instructions on the card which I I had
- 18:05no intention of drawing a seven-card 21.
- 18:07It was just that the instructions led to
- 18:09this, led to me sacrificing a pretty
- 18:12good hand
- 18:14and and continuing to draw cards until I
- 18:17ended up with an unbeatable hand. And
- 18:19so, at that point, the people watching
- 18:21me were kind of electrified at what had
- 18:23happened.
- 18:25And they thought that I did this on
- 18:26purpose which is not true.
- 18:29And so, I realized from their reactions
- 18:32that they didn't have a clue.
- 18:35That that led me to go back and think
- 18:37about the game and I very quickly
- 18:39reasoned out in principle how to beat
- 18:42it.
- 18:43And then and then the work began.
- 18:45Okay, so walk us through that process.
- 18:47How long did you spend trying to work
- 18:50out and come up with a formula for
- 18:52beating the casinos at blackjack?
- 18:55Well, I spent
- 18:56a substantial amount of time during the
- 18:59spring of and summer of 1959
- 19:02trying to do it by hand.
- 19:04And I realized as I made relatively
- 19:06little progress that the computation was
- 19:09so enormous
- 19:10that I was never going to finish in my
- 19:11lifetime
- 19:13or
- 19:13actually 100 lifetimes.
- 19:16At that point, I learned that MIT had an
- 19:19IBM 704 computer and as a staff member,
- 19:22I could use it.
- 19:23So, I taught myself of a programming,
- 19:26something called Fortran II
- 19:28and
- 19:30entered
- 19:31left groups of punch cards
- 19:34at a bin every 2 or 3 days to to check
- 19:38parts of the program that I was writing,
- 19:40uh
- 19:41subroutines. And they would come back
- 19:43sometimes with errors which I had to fix
- 19:45and sometimes they would run perfectly.
- 19:48When I finally built all my subroutines
- 19:49and put put together,
- 19:51this was probably
- 19:53uh early
- 19:551960.
- 19:57So, I continued to
- 19:59turn stuff out from the computer through
- 20:02a large part of 1960.
- 20:04And then I got all the information I
- 20:05needed and I saw I could beat the game.
- 20:08And I I saw how to do it in multiple
- 20:11ways.
- 20:12So, I would say that I spent
- 20:14overall about
- 20:18oh, maybe half or 2/3 time for
- 20:22a year and a half.
- 20:24And once you'd come up with this formula
- 20:26or these various formulas for beating uh
- 20:30the casino at Blackjack,
- 20:32correct me if I'm wrong, but you
- 20:33actually went public with that formula
- 20:35or your strategy. What was your thought
- 20:37process in actually going public with
- 20:39that? Did you have any doubts about
- 20:40doing that?
- 20:42Well, to me it was a math problem and
- 20:44people thought that you could not beat
- 20:46casino games.
- 20:48And there was a lot of evidence to that
- 20:50effect.
- 20:51There were theorems in fact that had
- 20:53been proven uh as probability developed
- 20:56over several previous centuries.
- 20:58They proved uh
- 21:00uh theorems which said that most of the
- 21:03standard gambling games could not be
- 21:05beaten
- 21:06uh no matter how you varied your bet
- 21:07your bets, uh you would lose at a rate
- 21:10that was predictable.
- 21:13But uh
- 21:14Blackjack didn't quite fit the
- 21:16assumptions that they'd used to draw
- 21:18that conclusion
- 21:20which I observed later
- 21:22uh when I began to learn more about
- 21:24probability itself and the history of
- 21:27the attempts to beat gambling games.
- 21:29And what was different about Blackjack
- 21:31was
- 21:32that
- 21:33as you deal through the cards,
- 21:35uh they don't reshuffle after every
- 21:37hand.
- 21:38So,
- 21:39the composition of the deck tends to
- 21:41change as play continues.
- 21:44And with the change in composition of
- 21:46the deck, the odds of uh for and against
- 21:49the player and the way he should play
- 21:51his hands, those things shift also.
- 21:55And so,
- 21:56what I saw very early when I thought
- 21:59about the game was that the shifts would
- 22:01undoubtedly be large enough to give me a
- 22:03substantial edge
- 22:05during a fairly large part of the time
- 22:08that I was playing.
- 22:09And so, then the next step was obvious.
- 22:11If you can
- 22:12tell when you have an edge, you bet big
- 22:15when you have the edge and you bet
- 22:16little or leave when you don't have an
- 22:18edge.
- 22:19So, you win most of you win a majority
- 22:21of the big hands and you lose a majority
- 22:24of the little hands
- 22:25and overall, you come out uh pretty well
- 22:28ahead. I could compute how rapidly I
- 22:30could make my bankroll grow.
- 22:33So, what happened after you went public
- 22:35with this formula uh this way of beating
- 22:38the casinos at Blackjack? Did that
- 22:40attract the attention of
- 22:42quite a few people?
- 22:44Well, I gave a talk at the American Math
- 22:46Society thinking this would be really
- 22:48interesting mathematics.
- 22:50And so, when I sent in my talk, the
- 22:53abstract committee thought this is
- 22:55another crank
- 22:56who
- 22:58uh is sending in uh more garbage. He's
- 23:01claiming he can do something that we've
- 23:03already proven is impossible.
- 23:05And the mathematics committees that uh
- 23:08screen abstracts for meetings get a lot
- 23:10of this stuff.
- 23:12There are quite a few famous math
- 23:13problems that
- 23:15uh
- 23:17Well, there are quite a few famous
- 23:18things in mathematics where it was
- 23:20eventually proven that you couldn't do
- 23:22it. Uh one of them is
- 23:25trisecting an arbitrary angle with
- 23:27compass and straightedge alone.
- 23:30It took uh from the time the Greeks
- 23:32tried to do it and couldn't, it took
- 23:34almost 2,000 years before somebody came
- 23:37up with a mathematical proof showing in
- 23:39fact that it was not possible. There
- 23:41were some angles that were not
- 23:43trisectable.
- 23:45And so, with the gambling games,
- 23:48over the uh 17th, 18th, and 19th
- 23:50centuries,
- 23:51they developed a a rather tight proof
- 23:54that nearly all of them were not
- 23:56beatable.
- 23:57So, anyhow, I said this is going to be
- 23:58interesting mathematics. The abstract
- 24:00committee said
- 24:01uh
- 24:02this is some other wingnut who's sending
- 24:04in this stuff.
- 24:05And just by chance,
- 24:07one of the members of the committee was
- 24:09somebody
- 24:10from UCLA who knew me when I was there
- 24:12and he was an eminent number theorist
- 24:14and he said, "No, no. If this guy says
- 24:16he can do it, he probably can."
- 24:18So, the abstract survived
- 24:21and was published in the
- 24:24uh little notices that they had before
- 24:25the meeting and then the papers got wind
- 24:27of it.
- 24:28And after that, it went kind of viral on
- 24:30the uh print media. And then I got a
- 24:32flood of people who wanted to either
- 24:36know the secret so they could get rich,
- 24:38know the secret because they were in
- 24:40dire straits and needed the money, or
- 24:42who wanted to bankroll me and go out and
- 24:45share the money.
- 24:46And that's how you met uh the infamous
- 24:48Manny Kimmel. I'd love to hear the story
- 24:51about how you actually met him and um
- 24:53for those who don't know,
- 24:55describe a little bit about this
- 24:57character. Like who was he?
- 24:59Well,
- 25:00many people
- 25:02came to my talk
- 25:03and afterwards, there was a lot of
- 25:06publicity uh in both print and on
- 25:08television. And then I began to get
- 25:11people offering to bankroll me. And one
- 25:14very persistent guy
- 25:16uh kept calling
- 25:17and uh finally I said, "You know,
- 25:20uh the casinos are scoffing at me.
- 25:22They're saying this is all garbage.
- 25:23They're saying they'll send a cab for me
- 25:25and if I don't do anything, people are
- 25:27going to say, 'Well, this guy is just a
- 25:29blowhard who claimed to do something but
- 25:31couldn't back it up.'"
- 25:34And I felt it was obligatory for me to
- 25:37show that what I'd done was actually
- 25:39correct and worked.
- 25:42So, I finally decided to listen to Manny
- 25:45Kimmel who drove up from New York.
- 25:48And
- 25:50so, we talked for a while and
- 25:52he got very excited. Turned out all I
- 25:55didn't know all this at the time, but
- 25:56not only was he a wealthy businessman
- 25:59who owned 64 parking lots in New York
- 26:01City among other things,
- 26:03but many years later, I discovered from
- 26:07um Connie Bruck who wrote a biography of
- 26:10uh Steven Ross called Master of the
- 26:12Game, I discovered that Manny Kimmel had
- 26:16been associated with mobster number two,
- 26:18a guy named Longy Zwillman.
- 26:20That is up. He was the mobster king in
- 26:23New Jersey in the '30s.
- 26:25So, he probably made his original money
- 26:27from bootlegging, prostitution, and so
- 26:29on.
- 26:31Be that as it may,
- 26:32he actually was an important businessman
- 26:35at that time as well as a knowledgeable
- 26:38gambler. He wasn't an educated man. He
- 26:40probably never got past uh 7th or 8th
- 26:43grade.
- 26:44Uh but
- 26:46he'd been around the casinos. He'd been
- 26:47a big better in Cuba before
- 26:49it got shut down in uh '59, '60.
- 26:52So, anyhow, I showed him what I could do
- 26:56and we had some practice sessions in
- 26:58in New York
- 27:00where he
- 27:01verified that uh I won pretty steadily
- 27:04against
- 27:06his uh dealing.
- 27:08So, anyhow, we went out to Las Vegas and
- 27:11we brought a $10,000 bankroll. He wanted
- 27:13to bring a lot more, but I figured that
- 27:15I wanted to play with something that was
- 27:17small for him in case things went wrong.
- 27:20And we did a little better than double
- 27:22our bankroll in the uh
- 27:25well, 20 hours of serious play and about
- 27:2720 hours of uh getting used to it play.
- 27:32So,
- 27:34a $11,000 win on a $10,000 bankroll
- 27:36doesn't sound like a whole lot, but
- 27:38it's a little more than you'd think
- 27:40because money in that day
- 27:43uh adjusted for inflation was about
- 27:45eight times what it is now. So, think of
- 27:47it as an $80 bankroll and maybe a uh
- 27:50$90,000 win.
- 27:52Yeah, I mean that's that's a significant
- 27:54amount, especially in such a short time
- 27:56frame. Yeah. It's very impressive.
- 27:59Uh and how long did your relationship
- 28:00last with Manny for?
- 28:03Well, I wasn't I was more interested in
- 28:05being an academic than a gambler. So,
- 28:07what I decided was I wasn't going to
- 28:09spend a lot of time doing this. I might
- 28:11go occasionally if I needed uh money for
- 28:13something,
- 28:14but uh it was
- 28:16kind of an avocation.
- 28:19But uh casinos continued to scoff and I
- 28:22decided to uh write a book about it and
- 28:25see how they fared when thousands or
- 28:29tens of thousands of players came out to
- 28:30the casinos and started counting cards.
- 28:33And of course, uh the book became a New
- 28:35York Times bestseller
- 28:37and tens of thousands of players did
- 28:40show up and some of them were good card
- 28:42counters.
- 28:42So, the casinos eventually panicked and
- 28:45they on April Fool's Day, 1964, they
- 28:48announced from the Nevada Casino Resort
- 28:51Association, there came an announcement
- 28:53that they were changing the rules of
- 28:54Blackjack. They were taking away some of
- 28:56the choices people had involving
- 28:58doubling down, pair splitting, and so
- 29:00forth.
- 29:01And I was asked what was going to happen
- 29:04and I said, "Well,
- 29:06what's going to happen is
- 29:07the ordinary players from whom they make
- 29:09all their money are going to be very
- 29:12irritated by this and they're going to
- 29:13lose a lot of business.
- 29:15So, they're going to have to uh give in
- 29:17and change back, which is what
- 29:19happened."
- 29:20And so, the tactic then was to do a
- 29:23mixture of things. Uh in those days,
- 29:25there was a lot of cheating. I don't
- 29:26think as much now.
- 29:28And
- 29:29at least not in the uh
- 29:32casinos that are run by the big
- 29:33corporations.
- 29:36And they also uh would shuffle up.
- 29:39They'd bar players. They had a a
- 29:41blacklist of people when they identified
- 29:43them and so forth. So, this kind of
- 29:45battle between players and casinos
- 29:48uh really heated up and the good players
- 29:50got very clever at disguising themselves
- 29:54and inventing extra new techniques for
- 29:56winning more money
- 29:57and so forth and so this this battle
- 30:00goes on. There are good players out
- 30:02there now who still make their living.
- 30:04They get together every January at the
- 30:06Blackjack Ball and kind of celebrate
- 30:08the Blackjack life.
- 30:11So this is very interesting. So during
- 30:13this time you you'd kind of worked out a
- 30:15way to well you not kind of you had
- 30:17worked out a way to beat the casinos at
- 30:19their own game yet you didn't want to
- 30:22really pursue it
- 30:24too much. You really wanted to stay
- 30:26doing your academic work. Why was that?
- 30:30Well I never had a focus on trying to
- 30:32make a lot of money.
- 30:34It wasn't important to me. I basically
- 30:36just wanted to learn things
- 30:39be around people that I liked. Um
- 30:42especially smart people who knew a lot
- 30:44and I figured the academic world was the
- 30:46place to be for that kind of experience.
- 30:48But I also had this
- 30:50element of
- 30:52uh
- 30:53not doing things the way everybody else
- 30:55does and trying new things
- 30:57and having a certain amount of
- 31:00adventurousness as well probably from my
- 31:03childhood the way I grew up um
- 31:05making nitroglycerin shooting off
- 31:07rockets and so forth.
- 31:12Team just a short break here to mention
- 31:14our sponsor of this episode Trade
- 31:17Station. Trade Station are a trusted
- 31:20online broker that've been in this
- 31:21business for a really long time and
- 31:23still continue to win awards for their
- 31:26services and trading technology.
- 31:29The upside of being a Trade Station
- 31:30customer include platform availability
- 31:33on web mobile and desktop various
- 31:36real-time market monitoring tools access
- 31:39to many markets and products low trading
- 31:42costs support for advanced order types
- 31:44and trade management etc. And for those
- 31:47who lean more towards quant trading
- 31:50Trade Station give you the ability to
- 31:52create custom indicators back test and
- 31:55rigorously analyze strategies against a
- 31:57huge historical database and you've also
- 32:00got the option to completely automate
- 32:02your strategy too. For more info on all
- 32:05the above and so much more just visit
- 32:08tradestation.com
- 32:10and open an account to get started. Also
- 32:13backing this week's episode is
- 32:15squarespace.com.
- 32:17You know I remember back to when I was
- 32:19around 17 years old. I actually paid
- 32:22someone almost $2,000 to create a
- 32:25website for a graphic design company I
- 32:27started. But nowadays we have companies
- 32:30like Squarespace where you can very
- 32:32easily do it yourself. Creating a
- 32:35website with Squarespace is simple it's
- 32:38intuitive and you have many many
- 32:40templates to choose from which all look
- 32:42very slick. So whether you want to start
- 32:45a personal blog to write about your
- 32:46trading actually now I have a few
- 32:48traders who do this using Squarespace or
- 32:51if you need a site for your business or
- 32:53even to sell things online make your
- 32:56next move with Squarespace. Start your
- 32:59free trial today at squarespace.com
- 33:02and enter the coupon code traders to get
- 33:0510% off your first purchase.
- 33:09So tell us a little bit about the other
- 33:11games that you were able to beat the
- 33:13casinos at. So we we spoke about
- 33:15Blackjack there quite extensively.
- 33:18You also mentioned roulette earlier as
- 33:20well as something that had piqued your
- 33:22interest. How did you go with roulette?
- 33:24Well roulette actually is the first
- 33:26thing I thought about in my life that
- 33:28was a beatable casino game. It was way
- 33:29back when I was in high school
- 33:31and studying physics.
- 33:34And what I realized was that the
- 33:36roulette ball orbited kind of like a
- 33:39planet
- 33:40and the spinning rotor
- 33:43uh didn't really make any difference. It
- 33:44just changed the relative rate in which
- 33:47the ball orbited around whatever pocket
- 33:49it was going to end up in.
- 33:52So I thought of it mainly as a lot like
- 33:55a
- 33:56a lot like a system
- 33:58that is so predictable the emotion of
- 34:00the planets around the sun. And I know
- 34:02there's friction and there are a lot of
- 34:04other elements like little deliberate
- 34:07vein deflectors that are set in the
- 34:10side of the stator which which the ball
- 34:13hits on the way down
- 34:16uh to make randomness. So there are
- 34:19little things that make randomness in it
- 34:21that still seem predictable. And then
- 34:23time passed and then when I was after I
- 34:25got my master's in physics I was having
- 34:27a chat with people one afternoon
- 34:30and they were claiming that you couldn't
- 34:32beat any casino game and I said well I
- 34:34think you can beat roulette.
- 34:36I argued that you could beat roulette
- 34:39and
- 34:40the argument was fairly
- 34:42heated.
- 34:44So I decided that I would prove it.
- 34:46So I and a couple of other people set
- 34:47out to do it
- 34:49and the other people dropped away very
- 34:51quickly.
- 34:52I continued.
- 34:54And then when I was at MIT
- 34:56and I had worked on my Blackjack ideas I
- 34:59wanted to publish them quickly because
- 35:02one of the things that happens
- 35:04especially
- 35:05in the gambling world and sometimes in
- 35:08mathematics
- 35:09people steal your ideas and claim that
- 35:11those ideas are theirs.
- 35:15So in order to get quick publication
- 35:17the
- 35:18place to go was the proceedings of the
- 35:20National Academy of Sciences. They took
- 35:23short papers so you couldn't put most of
- 35:25what you knew in the paper but you could
- 35:27at least make an announcement that you'd
- 35:29done something and describe it briefly.
- 35:32But you had to have a member of the
- 35:34National Academy
- 35:35uh send the paper in for you and
- 35:38basically sponsor you. And the only one
- 35:40in mathematics at MIT was the one named
- 35:42Claude Shannon.
- 35:44He was famous because he invented
- 35:47something called information theory
- 35:48which is the basis of of modern
- 35:50computing and modern communications. We
- 35:53wouldn't be talking you're probably if I
- 35:55hadn't been for him.
- 35:57So Claude Shannon
- 35:59um I looked him up.
- 36:02Uh they told me that I would maybe get 5
- 36:03minutes if I was lucky.
- 36:05And he didn't really spend time with
- 36:07people unless he got really interested.
- 36:09So we went through my
- 36:11uh proposed paper for the National
- 36:13Academy and he liked it and said looks
- 36:15like you solved all the main problems in
- 36:17this area and have all the big ideas so
- 36:19I'll send the paper in. Then he said
- 36:21well what else are you working on? So I
- 36:23told him about
- 36:25uh attempting to build a computer a
- 36:27wearable computer to beat roulette.
- 36:30And so he got very excited because as it
- 36:32turns out he was one of the most famous
- 36:34gadgeteers of all time. Built lots of
- 36:37different devices just playing machines
- 36:41maze solving robots
- 36:43um I could go on for quite a while here.
- 36:45So he got excited and wanted to work on
- 36:47this too so we decided to team up. We
- 36:49spent the next 9 months
- 36:51um we bought a full-size roulette wheel
- 36:53set it up in his basement
- 36:55and used some equipment from the MIT
- 36:58labs to make really accurate
- 37:00measurements.
- 37:01And then we figured out how to build a
- 37:03small computer which is now at the MIT
- 37:06Museum incidentally
- 37:08uh that you could hide on your body.
- 37:10And
- 37:11one person would sit in with the
- 37:13computer and use their big toes to tap
- 37:15switches
- 37:17uh for inputs as the roulette ball and
- 37:19the
- 37:20spinning rotor in the middle went around
- 37:23and then the computer would tell you
- 37:26where to bet on the wheel.
- 37:27And the other person which was me was
- 37:29sitting at the roulette table
- 37:31uh not even
- 37:33able to see the ball sitting at the far
- 37:35end on purpose.
- 37:37And I when I hear heard the instructions
- 37:39from the computer then I put money down
- 37:41on
- 37:42a few neighboring pockets.
- 37:45For example uh 0 13 23 36 is the little
- 37:49group that uh hangs together on the
- 37:51wheel.
- 37:53So
- 37:55um we divide we we bet on four or five
- 37:57numbers that were neighboring.
- 37:59And a pile of dollars would blow up into
- 38:01a whole lot of dollars very quickly
- 38:03because we had it turned out a 44% edge
- 38:08which is
- 38:10really huge. I mean you almost never
- 38:12come across anything like that.
- 38:15But the equipment was fairly crude. We
- 38:18had little wires that ran up
- 38:21from the radio receiver hidden on my
- 38:23body up into my ear canal where there
- 38:25was a tiny loudspeaker and that's where
- 38:28I heard the instructions to where to
- 38:29bet. And those wires were very fragile
- 38:32the size of a human hair they would
- 38:33break quite easily. Copper just almost
- 38:36falls apart when it's that size. We had
- 38:38steel wires and they were still still
- 38:40too fragile. So I'd have to go back and
- 38:42get
- 38:43rewired periodically.
- 38:45And then I thought about it. I said you
- 38:47know
- 38:48if they forbid us to bet after the ball
- 38:51is spun
- 38:52then we can't predict. We need to use
- 38:54the motion of the ball to make the
- 38:56prediction.
- 38:57And characteristically they let you bet
- 38:59until almost the end because they want
- 39:02to get people as much time as possible
- 39:04and they want also to have more spins in
- 39:07a given hour.
- 39:09Um anyhow so I thought about it. I said
- 39:11this is this is not going to go unless
- 39:13we're really clever. We spent a lot of
- 39:15time disguising ourselves and a lot of
- 39:18time
- 39:19I guess misdirecting the casino so they
- 39:22think we're other than the kind of
- 39:24people we really are.
- 39:26Uh Blackjack players got good at this.
- 39:29There'd be a big player betting huge
- 39:31amounts of money and wandering around
- 39:32from table to table with
- 39:35uh
- 39:36a beautiful companion
- 39:38on his or her arm.
- 39:41And that was a pretty good disguise for
- 39:43a while. Pretty good misdirection.
- 39:45Anyway, I didn't want to spend my life
- 39:46doing that sort of thing.
- 39:48So I said, you know, this is this is
- 39:50fun. It worked. It's a good idea.
- 39:53Other people, by the way, took it and
- 39:55made lots of money.
- 39:57And but
- 39:59I'd rather continue with my academic
- 40:00life.
- 40:02So I decided to do that until I got
- 40:05deflected one more time into the world
- 40:08of uh
- 40:09real money and real action.
- 40:12So just before we get into your trading
- 40:15your trading venture,
- 40:17I've got to ask, like you mentioned a
- 40:19little earlier that you know, you knew
- 40:21of people who had been blacklisted from
- 40:22casinos and that sort of thing. Did you
- 40:24have any run-ins with casino owners and
- 40:27security during that time? I I imagine,
- 40:30you know, you probably had a target on
- 40:32your back to some extent, like I've seen
- 40:35what they do to card counters in the
- 40:36movie Casino and it's not pretty. Well,
- 40:39the movie Casino was written about 10
- 40:41years after I played.
- 40:43And the book in the movie
- 40:45and things were worse when I played than
- 40:48they were in the movie Casino to give
- 40:49you a way
- 40:51the way things were going. So the '50s
- 40:53were terrible.
- 40:54People like Bugsy Siegel got shot up.
- 40:57The El Rancho Vegas got burned down in a
- 41:00dispute and so forth. In the '60s people
- 41:03were getting beat up.
- 41:07One person was almost murdered that I
- 41:09know about. Another person was murdered.
- 41:12And then
- 41:13uh
- 41:14in the '70s
- 41:16it was like the movie Casino. And in the
- 41:19'80s it was better because the
- 41:20corporations were coming in
- 41:22and people were going legit. They
- 41:25realized there were certain benefits to
- 41:27going in that direction.
- 41:29Life in some ways was better than
- 41:31mob life.
- 41:33So yes, there was a lot of risk and I
- 41:36didn't realize that initially.
- 41:38But as time passed, I it began to become
- 41:41clear to me. One of the episodes in the
- 41:43book is about another thing that I
- 41:45discovered how to beat the side bets
- 41:47when they were there
- 41:49in
- 41:50a a game called baccarat.
- 41:52The game that James Bond originally
- 41:55plays in Casino Royale, the first
- 41:58version of the movie.
- 42:00And it's uh
- 42:02one of the highest or the highest stake
- 42:04game in the world.
- 42:07People were betting uh
- 42:10just routinely to the $10,000 a hand.
- 42:14And the side bets we could bet five to
- 42:17100. And I figured out a way to beat
- 42:19them systematically. And so we came and
- 42:21did that night after night after night
- 42:24until finally they drugged my drinks and
- 42:28barred us from playing anymore.
- 42:30And on the way home
- 42:32a strange thing happened to the car I
- 42:34was driving.
- 42:35The accelerator locked to the floor
- 42:38when I was coming downhill in Arizona
- 42:40and nothing I could do with the brake
- 42:44seemed to be able to stop it. So I
- 42:45finally
- 42:46got to 80 miles an hour, I put on the
- 42:48handbrake
- 42:50the foot brake
- 42:52put it in a low gear
- 42:54turned the engine off and used the drag
- 42:57of the motor. Also, I was finally able
- 42:59to bring it to a stop.
- 43:01And then somebody came by and looked at
- 43:03the car and said, "I've never seen
- 43:05anything like
- 43:06what's going on here with the connection
- 43:09to the accelerator pedal."
- 43:12So the person was able to fix it
- 43:15but
- 43:16their opinion was that it had been
- 43:18tampered with. This is somebody who knew
- 43:19mechanics that I did not.
- 43:21And then we resumed our trip home
- 43:23somewhat chastened. So if they got
- 43:26serious
- 43:27Yeah, that's really heavy. And in your
- 43:30interview with Jack Schwager for his
- 43:32book Hedge Fund Market Wizards,
- 43:35you mentioned that you later discovered
- 43:37that some of the casino owners were
- 43:39actually plotting to take you out.
- 43:41What's the story there?
- 43:42When they changed the rules in
- 43:43blackjack, there was a big discussion
- 43:46which only came out publicly about 30
- 43:49years later when one of the one of the
- 43:50people there wrote it up and published
- 43:52it in one of the Las Vegas newspapers.
- 43:55There was a big discussion about how to
- 43:57deal
- 43:58with me and the card counters.
- 44:01And so one of the proposals was to break
- 44:03knees or worse.
- 44:05And
- 44:07people explained that that wouldn't be a
- 44:08good idea. They needed to tone it down
- 44:11and do something else. So they changed
- 44:12the rules instead.
- 44:14But there was there was quite a mix of
- 44:16people at this meeting. This was the
- 44:18Nevada casino
- 44:20the Nevada Resort Hotel Association
- 44:22meeting where they decided to change the
- 44:23rules.
- 44:25So that was a good decision. Changing
- 44:26the rules was a good decision on their
- 44:27part. It wasn't effective but it was
- 44:29better than
- 44:31what they might have come up with.
- 44:33So tell us about how you got into
- 44:36financial markets. How did that come
- 44:37about?
- 44:38Well, I'd made some money gambling
- 44:42and from book sales
- 44:44and I started to invest it.
- 44:46And I didn't do very well.
- 44:49And when I don't do very well
- 44:51I sit down and decide whether I should
- 44:53be doing whatever it is at all or
- 44:55whether I'm going to
- 44:57change and do it very well.
- 45:00So I decided that I would learn what I
- 45:02could about investing. I spent the
- 45:04summer of 1964
- 45:06all summer just reading books on
- 45:07investment.
- 45:09And
- 45:10then I decided to do the same thing
- 45:11again in the summer of 1965. And at the
- 45:13very beginning of the summer
- 45:16I happened to come across
- 45:17a little pamphlet on think something
- 45:19called a warrant which is like
- 45:23a call option.
- 45:25Only it's
- 45:26issued by a company. And in those days
- 45:28it wasn't on an exchange. It was traded
- 45:30over the counter.
- 45:33And so it was a real pain to try to
- 45:34trade these things because you had to
- 45:36deal with people that were really greedy
- 45:38and had huge bid-ask spreads.
- 45:40In any case
- 45:42I saw almost immediately that you could
- 45:45mathematize
- 45:46most of the uncertainty in how a warrant
- 45:48behaves.
- 45:50The main thing that affected it was the
- 45:52price of the underlying stock.
- 45:55So then I saw that X that if I were to
- 45:58hedge short a warrant and buy the stock
- 46:01or the other way around, I could get rid
- 46:03of the stock risk.
- 46:05So what did that leave? That left
- 46:07mispricing risk.
- 46:10Well, it's no longer risk if I can tell
- 46:12whether the warrant is
- 46:14relatively overpriced or relatively
- 46:16underpriced. If it's relatively
- 46:17overpriced
- 46:19I can sell it short and buy the stock
- 46:21get rid of the stock risk
- 46:23because the warrant and the stock tend
- 46:24to move together.
- 46:26If the warrant is relatively
- 46:27underpriced, if it's cheap, I can buy
- 46:29the warrant short the stock against it
- 46:31and get rid of most of the risk.
- 46:33And if the stock moves around, changes
- 46:35its price, I can change the mix of the
- 46:37warrant against the stock.
- 46:40So I realized that this was something
- 46:43that I could almost certainly solve
- 46:45mathematically.
- 46:47And so I set out to do that.
- 46:49And I happened to be
- 46:51moving to the new UC Irvine campus
- 46:54when it opened in the fall of 1965.
- 46:57And I was telling somebody there about
- 46:58this idea.
- 47:00And they said, "Wait a minute, we've got
- 47:01somebody else coming in who
- 47:04is doing the same thing."
- 47:06And it turned to be an economist named
- 47:08Sheen Kassouf.
- 47:10So we realized that we were doing the
- 47:11same sort of thing. Only he had been
- 47:13doing it for real with real money for
- 47:16two or three years and he'd written a
- 47:18thesis about trying to price warrants.
- 47:20So I said, "Well
- 47:21if we put our two heads together, we can
- 47:23do better yet."
- 47:25So we started meeting and I brought a
- 47:27lot of math to the table
- 47:29and
- 47:31we evolved
- 47:34our analysis of warrants and warrant
- 47:36hedging. And we wrote a book called Beat
- 47:37the Market.
- 47:40That book
- 47:41uh inspired quite a few people. I was
- 47:44having lunch with
- 47:45Nobel Prize winner Harry Markowitz
- 47:48a week or so ago and he was telling me
- 47:49that he spent three years co-managing an
- 47:52operation
- 47:54an investment operation in New York
- 47:56because he read Beat the Market. He
- 47:58wanted wanted to follow up on those same
- 48:00ideas and do that sort of thing.
- 48:02And then he decided that he'd rather be
- 48:04an academic than get deflected off into
- 48:07the marketplace and
- 48:09financial trading and so on.
- 48:12And then
- 48:13uh
- 48:15two academics, Fisher Black and Myron
- 48:17Scholes, were aware of Beat the Market.
- 48:20And that got them to thinking about
- 48:22the fact that you could make the hedge
- 48:24riskless in principle if you adjusted it
- 48:27like in very small increments.
- 48:30So if you could do that
- 48:32then you could figure out
- 48:35uh
- 48:36what the right discount
- 48:38was for the stock and for the warrant,
- 48:41two uncertain payoffs.
- 48:43And you could figure out what the right
- 48:44price was for the warrant. So they went
- 48:46ahead and did that.
- 48:48I had
- 48:49I coincidentally, sometime before they
- 48:51did that
- 48:52guessed that
- 48:55uh because the warrant hedge is
- 48:57essentially riskless
- 48:59that we might as well look at it from
- 49:02the standpoint of a person who is risk
- 49:04neutral. If we did that then we get the
- 49:07Black-Scholes formula. So
- 49:10when I got their paper in 1973
- 49:14a paper which said uh yes, we
- 49:16uh were inspired in part by your idea in
- 49:19Beat the Market. When I got that paper,
- 49:21I already had the formula. I'd already
- 49:22been using it for four years.
- 49:25Cuz I had uh
- 49:26I figured out with plausible reasoning
- 49:29what the formula must be.
- 49:32And
- 49:33uh sure enough
- 49:35But I checked what I had with different
- 49:37notation against what they had, they
- 49:39were the same.
- 49:41So, their paper came about the same time
- 49:43as the Chicago Board Options Exchange
- 49:45opened.
- 49:46And it was
- 49:48one of the reasons that exchange opened
- 49:49is because
- 49:51they had shown that you could price
- 49:53warrants with the formula for it. And so
- 49:56that made
- 49:57the warrants somehow, well, options I
- 49:59should say, more legitimate than this
- 50:02the by appointment only kind of trading
- 50:04that existed before.
- 50:07You know, you've come from playing the
- 50:08games in the casinos, you've come into
- 50:10financial markets now.
- 50:13Was it easier for you to find an edge
- 50:16like you've just described here? Was it
- 50:18easier for you to find that edge in
- 50:20financial markets than it was to find an
- 50:23edge uh playing games at the casino?
- 50:26Um
- 50:28I don't know.
- 50:30Uh if it was easier or harder.
- 50:32Probably about the same.
- 50:33Right. And as I bring up edge, this is a
- 50:36question I'm really keen to ask you and
- 50:38I've asked it a few times on the
- 50:40podcast, but I'm
- 50:41uh particularly interested to hear how
- 50:43you describe this.
- 50:45How would you describe an edge? Like
- 50:47when we talk about an edge, what exactly
- 50:49does that mean?
- 50:51Well, the way I see it,
- 50:54if you're
- 50:55playing a gambling game,
- 50:57uh that's the easy The gambling game is
- 50:59the easiest. And by the way, uh
- 51:01understanding gambling games like
- 51:03blackjack and some of the others is
- 51:07one of the best possible training
- 51:10grounds for
- 51:11uh getting into the investment world.
- 51:13You learn how to manage money. You learn
- 51:15how to compute odds.
- 51:17You learn how to uh reason what uh what
- 51:20to do when you have an advantage. So,
- 51:23what do I mean by an advantage or an
- 51:24edge?
- 51:26In a gambling game,
- 51:27it's
- 51:29an advantage or edge over your opponent,
- 51:31meaning that if you were to continue to
- 51:34play the game for a long period of time
- 51:35against your opponent,
- 51:37you would
- 51:38in the end win money
- 51:40at what might be a fairly predictable
- 51:43rate.
- 51:44For instance, uh playing blackjack,
- 51:46if
- 51:49I have a 2% edge
- 51:52half the time
- 51:53and the casino has a 2% edge half the
- 51:55time, it looks like I don't have any
- 51:58advantage.
- 51:59But if I bet considerably more when I
- 52:02have a 2% edge and considerably less
- 52:04when they have a 2% edge,
- 52:06then in the long run,
- 52:09I'll tend to win
- 52:102% of my big bets. I'll tend to make 2%
- 52:13of the amount of my big bets. I'll tend
- 52:16to lose 2% of the amount of my little
- 52:18bets.
- 52:19So, actually my advantage is the
- 52:21difference between those two numbers.
- 52:24In a gambling game, you can often, but
- 52:26not always,
- 52:27calculate what your advantage or edge
- 52:30is. Now, mathematicians call this edge
- 52:32the mathematical expectation.
- 52:35And it's typically
- 52:37uh what you would win in the long run or
- 52:39in a specific situation, either uh if
- 52:42that situation repeated many times, what
- 52:45you would win divided by uh how much you
- 52:47put up.
- 52:49I call what you put the total that you
- 52:50put up the action. So, if I make
- 52:52a thousand
- 52:54$100 bets, that's $100,000 worth of
- 52:57action.
- 52:58If I have a 2% edge, I expect to make 2%
- 53:01of $100,000, plus or minus
- 53:06So, that Those are gambling games. Now,
- 53:08in the
- 53:09securities markets, it's harder cuz you
- 53:11don't You're not able to calculate
- 53:13precisely what the payoffs are and what
- 53:16their probabilities are.
- 53:18You might know what the payoffs are, but
- 53:20you may not know the probabilities.
- 53:21You're unlikely to know both.
- 53:25Uh for instance, if I were to
- 53:28buy a cheap
- 53:31option, cheap call option,
- 53:33I know the stock is going to be
- 53:34somewhere or other in the future and
- 53:36it'll follow some
- 53:38prob some likely distribution that I can
- 53:41hypothesize that's fairly close to
- 53:42what's going to happen. But I don't know
- 53:44exactly what's going to happen. This
- 53:46distribution is just an estimate based
- 53:48on past experience.
- 53:50And the distribution might turn out to
- 53:52be somewhat different than
- 53:54what I forecast.
- 53:57Uh if I do it many times,
- 53:59what I do in the securities markets is I
- 54:01try to think through how good or how bad
- 54:04some uh something might be compared with
- 54:07my
- 54:09most probable estimate.
- 54:11And if it looks
- 54:13if even the bad situation looks good,
- 54:15then I know I've got something worth uh
- 54:18uh playing on.
- 54:19And now you've brought up managing your
- 54:22bankroll, you know, money management.
- 54:25Well,
- 54:27that is the thing where gambling is a
- 54:30master teacher.
- 54:32Because
- 54:33when the odds are computable,
- 54:36like in blackjack,
- 54:38there's a solution, a mathematical
- 54:40solution to
- 54:42how much to bet on any any given
- 54:45situation. And that
- 54:47if you're only betting in favorable
- 54:49situations,
- 54:50then the solution is that you bet an
- 54:54amount,
- 54:55roughly speaking,
- 54:57equal to
- 54:59your expected
- 55:01edge or advantage
- 55:03divided by the amount of uncertainty
- 55:05that there is in the bet, the standard
- 55:06deviation of it. That's a rough estimate
- 55:09of what you bet.
- 55:10There's an exact estimate
- 55:12um which you can compute using
- 55:15logarithms and probability theory and so
- 55:18on for all these situations. And
- 55:20I and two other guys have co-edited and
- 55:23written part of a book called uh The
- 55:25Kelly Criterion.
- 55:27So, it's a treatise
- 55:29on how to apply this Kelly criterion
- 55:33in
- 55:34well, almost any situation you can think
- 55:36of.
- 55:37And what the Kelly criterion does is if
- 55:40you apply it,
- 55:41it maximizes
- 55:44the expected growth you're going to get
- 55:46in your bankroll.
- 55:48So, a guy using this
- 55:50is likely after a period of time to have
- 55:52more money than somebody who just does
- 55:54something significantly different.
- 55:57So, anyhow, blackjack's a perfect
- 55:59training ground for that because you get
- 56:01a lot of bets. And so you get into the
- 56:03long run very quickly. I mean, playing
- 56:05100 hands an hour
- 56:06in a $100, you play you play 10,000
- 56:09hands.
- 56:10So, what I'll do is I'll link to uh the
- 56:12Kelly Criterion book that you mentioned
- 56:14there, which you co-authored. I'll link
- 56:16to that in the show notes. So, if anyone
- 56:17listening wants to find out more about
- 56:19that, um but just what we're we're what
- 56:22just what as you bring this up, would
- 56:23you mind just explaining what is Kelly
- 56:26Criterion just a little more? Just um
- 56:29probably um in simple terms if possible.
- 56:31Sure. Okay. Suppose that
- 56:35I have an infinitely rich adversary
- 56:37and
- 56:39one of the Koch brothers, maybe.
- 56:41And they say, "Look, uh bring your
- 56:43bankroll. We're going to flip a coin.
- 56:45This coin is in your favor by
- 56:482%.
- 56:50Bet as much or little as you want. You
- 56:52lose your money, you're gone."
- 56:54How much should I bet?
- 56:56Well, the Kelly criterion, if you go
- 56:58through the calculations, says
- 57:00with a coin toss, it's different for
- 57:02other things, bet 2% of your bankroll.
- 57:06And so, at first, when your bankroll is
- 57:09small, if you bet 2% of your bankroll
- 57:12and your edge is 2% of that,
- 57:14you're basically
- 57:16expanding your bankroll by four basis
- 57:18points on average per bet. Not much.
- 57:22But as your bankroll grows, uh the
- 57:25expansion gets faster and faster and
- 57:26faster.
- 57:28Okay, so why is this intuitively
- 57:30sensible? Well, suppose instead of
- 57:33betting 2% of your bankroll,
- 57:36you decided to bet as little as you
- 57:37could,
- 57:38a dollar, let's say.
- 57:40Well, betting a dollar all day long with
- 57:42a 2% edge, you're not going to make a
- 57:43whole lot of money.
- 57:45Suppose instead you decided to go for
- 57:47what mathematicians call maximum
- 57:50expected return.
- 57:51Well, you bet the whole bankroll.
- 57:55Your expected win is 2%
- 57:58of your bankroll on that one flip, way
- 58:01more than 2% of 2% of your bankroll.
- 58:05However,
- 58:06you're not going to win all the time if
- 58:08you keep betting your whole bankroll.
- 58:09Eventually, you're going to lose and
- 58:11then you'll end up with nothing.
- 58:12So, the guy who bets his whole bankroll,
- 58:14if you have a whole lot of people doing
- 58:16that,
- 58:17one guy may end up with a gigantic
- 58:19amount of money,
- 58:21but all the other guys will be wiped
- 58:22out. And the one guy will be wiped out,
- 58:24too, if he keeps going.
- 58:26So, the upshot is that it's too risky to
- 58:29bet your whole bankroll, even though
- 58:31if many, many people were all doing it
- 58:33at once, the group would win more money
- 58:35that way.
- 58:38So, anyhow, the Kelly criterion is a
- 58:39compromise between timid betting, where
- 58:42you make very little, and way
- 58:45overaggressive betting, where you're
- 58:47almost sure to be wiped out.
- 58:49And it turns out you can show
- 58:51mathematically that it's the optimal
- 58:53compromise for somebody who's going to
- 58:55play for a long time.
- 58:58Now, critics say, "Yeah, but, you know,
- 59:00it's Not everybody wants to play for a
- 59:02long time."
- 59:03The answer is, "Well, then you may not
- 59:05want to use the Kelly criterion. Use
- 59:06something else. Use whatever it is that
- 59:08you think is optimal for your
- 59:09situation." It's just a recipe for
- 59:12people who are going to make a lot of
- 59:13bets over a lifetime. Early on, that was
- 59:16my situation, so that's what I've done.
- 59:20Yeah. Uh yeah, like I said, what I'll do
- 59:22is I'll link to uh the book you
- 59:24mentioned about Kelly Criterion in the
- 59:26show notes. And I might also dig up I
- 59:28know there's a couple of articles that
- 59:29flesh out the actual formula for um this
- 59:33way of of managing money. So, I'll
- 59:35include links to those in the show notes
- 59:37at chatwithtraders.com.
- 59:38While we, uh, sort of on the subject of
- 59:41edge here, I guess this is sort of just
- 59:43general advice, um, and suggestions for
- 59:46some newer traders,
- 59:48how would you encourage newer traders to
- 59:50think about gaining an edge over the
- 59:53market, like putting the odds in their
- 59:55favor?
- 59:56Well,
- 59:57there are two parts to making money as
- 1:00:00far as I can see it. One is finding a
- 1:00:01good situation where you have an edge,
- 1:00:04and the other is managing your money.
- 1:00:06And Kelly criterion and things like it
- 1:00:08take care of managing your money.
- 1:00:10But,
- 1:00:11harder
- 1:00:13harder than using the Kelly criterion
- 1:00:14and figuring out how much to bet is
- 1:00:17finding the advantage situation in the
- 1:00:19first place. And,
- 1:00:21um,
- 1:00:22that changes from time to time and from,
- 1:00:25uh,
- 1:00:26ability to ability. People have
- 1:00:28different different knacks for doing
- 1:00:29things. There are
- 1:00:31guys like Warren who've spent their
- 1:00:32whole life picking stocks and keeping
- 1:00:35track of companies and knowing balance
- 1:00:36sheets in their head
- 1:00:38and
- 1:00:39looking for, uh, bargains when they
- 1:00:41occasionally come by.
- 1:00:43Uh, there are people who
- 1:00:45at the other end who are high-frequency
- 1:00:47traders. They have computer algorithms
- 1:00:49and they're wired into the exchanges and
- 1:00:51they have they get to look at orders
- 1:00:52before other people. Uh,
- 1:00:54that's a different game entirely. So,
- 1:00:57there's so many different games. So,
- 1:00:58what you have to do is
- 1:01:00go find one that works and that suits
- 1:01:03you. But, I can't really tell you
- 1:01:05uh, which games
- 1:01:07would work for you.
- 1:01:09Uh, or even, um, very many of the games
- 1:01:12that are out there.
- 1:01:13Yeah. Now, that's a that's a really fair
- 1:01:15comment. Putting, you know, trading and
- 1:01:17gambling aside, I'd like to ask you just
- 1:01:20this one last question. You know,
- 1:01:22someone who has made a great fortune and
- 1:01:24done very well in life, how do you
- 1:01:27encourage others to think about money,
- 1:01:29wealth, and success?
- 1:01:32I think that
- 1:01:34if your pursuit is money
- 1:01:37or your pursuit is success,
- 1:01:39uh, you're looking at things the wrong
- 1:01:40way.
- 1:01:42I think people should be doing what they
- 1:01:44enjoy and what they love.
- 1:01:46And hopefully things that something
- 1:01:48they're good at. And if they do that, I
- 1:01:51think they're very likely to get money
- 1:01:53and success along the way.
- 1:01:55Uh,
- 1:01:57uh, a lady I know wrote a book called Do
- 1:01:59What You Love and the Money Will Follow.
- 1:02:01I think that's, uh, not far off.
- 1:02:05And speaking of books, you've just
- 1:02:06released your latest book, A Man for All
- 1:02:09Markets. You know, as we've mentioned,
- 1:02:11you've written a number of books in the
- 1:02:13past. How is this one different and what
- 1:02:15can readers expect from also reading
- 1:02:17this?
- 1:02:18Well, A Man for All Markets, uh, which
- 1:02:20will be coming out, uh, January 24th,
- 1:02:22actually, in the US and probably about
- 1:02:25the same time in the UK,
- 1:02:27uh, a little bit later in China,
- 1:02:30Korea, Japan, and
- 1:02:32uh,
- 1:02:33I think Germany, too.
- 1:02:34It is
- 1:02:36a memoir.
- 1:02:38It's also the story of, uh,
- 1:02:41how I got started in life,
- 1:02:44how I got into things like
- 1:02:46blackjack,
- 1:02:48roulette,
- 1:02:50and the stock market,
- 1:02:52and then what I learned along the way,
- 1:02:54uh, different profit centers that I
- 1:02:57found, uh,
- 1:02:58hedge fund, uh,
- 1:03:00statistical arbitrage,
- 1:03:02advice to people about investing, what
- 1:03:05to do if you don't know anything,
- 1:03:07you can still beat 90% of investors, uh,
- 1:03:09without doing any work,
- 1:03:11uh, what to do if you want to try to do
- 1:03:14better than that, what's going to take,
- 1:03:16and then some general thoughts about
- 1:03:19what is really important in life.
- 1:03:21And I find that a lot of people
- 1:03:24don't don't get it. Um,
- 1:03:27one person I know
- 1:03:28who's a billionaire,
- 1:03:31uh, is getting divorced because
- 1:03:34he just
- 1:03:35won't stop working. Uh, he's got a
- 1:03:37wonderful wife. They've got along for,
- 1:03:40uh,
- 1:03:41several decades,
- 1:03:42but I think she finally said, "Gee, I'm
- 1:03:45growing old
- 1:03:46and it's
- 1:03:47it's time to enjoy all this money we've
- 1:03:49made."
- 1:03:51But,
- 1:03:52people just get hooked and they won't
- 1:03:53stop.
- 1:03:54And I I would say if you can never have
- 1:03:57enough, then I can't I can't give you
- 1:04:00any advice because you're just going to
- 1:04:02be driven to pile up more and more and
- 1:04:04more.
- 1:04:05And at the end, you'll end up saying,
- 1:04:08"What was it all for?"
- 1:04:10And you won't have an answer.
- 1:04:12I say enjoy the people that you love and
- 1:04:15the people that are worth being with
- 1:04:18and don't spend all your time just
- 1:04:20trying to pile up wealth.
- 1:04:22Sound advice, very sound advice. Um, and
- 1:04:24guys listening, if you want to grab a
- 1:04:27copy of Ed's book and just take a close
- 1:04:30a look at it, uh,
- 1:04:31chatwithtraders.com/tharp,
- 1:04:34t h a r p, will take you directly to A
- 1:04:38Man for All Markets on Amazon. So,
- 1:04:42uh, Ed, I just want to say what an honor
- 1:04:44this has been. I'm very grateful for
- 1:04:45your time. Thank you.
- 1:04:47Pleasure meeting you and talking with
- 1:04:48you.
- 1:04:50You've reached the end of this episode
- 1:04:52of Chat With Traders. But, rest assured,
- 1:04:55there are more episodes loaded with real
- 1:04:57market insight and zero hype on the way
- 1:05:00soon. So, to stay updated with each
- 1:05:03great new release, subscribe to the
- 1:05:05podcast in iTunes. And we'd love it if
- 1:05:07you'd leave a rating and review. We'll
- 1:05:09catch you next time on Chat With
- 1:05:11Traders.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Edward Thorp · Math genius who beat the dealer and the market by Chat With Traders, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 10,637 words across 1,799 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.