Eduardo Giannetti fala de ajuste fiscal no governo Lula, reforma e juros | UOL Entrevista — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:04Hello, you are now watching another UOL
- 0:07Interview.
- 0:08President Lula's reelection has opened
- 0:10up room for a discussion on the economic
- 0:12direction for the next term.
- 0:15The negative reception of the runoff
- 0:17results in the financial market has
- 0:19reignited the debate over the need for
- 0:21fiscal adjustment in the next government
- 0:24.
- 0:25To talk about this subject, I am here
- 0:27with economist Eduardo Giannetti and UOL
- 0:29Economy columnist Patrícia Cruz.
- 0:33Thank you, Giannetti, thank you,
- 0:34Patrícia, for being here with us.
- 0:37Giannetti, the market reacted very
- 0:39negatively to the second-round results.
- 0:43How do you assess this reaction and the
- 0:45strong pressure for a fiscal adjustment
- 0:48today?
- 0:49>> The financial market's negative reaction
- 0:52doesn't surprise me in the slightest.
- 0:56And I must say that it tends to be an
- 0:59excessive reaction.
- 1:03Just look at what happened back in 2002
- 1:06, when Lula almost won the presidential
- 1:08election in the first round.
- 1:14The stock market fell about 20%, a
- 1:17little more than that, the real melted
- 1:19down, and the markets were extremely
- 1:22volatile in a context of double-digit
- 1:24inflation.
- 1:27And then, when Lula confirmed his
- 1:29victory in the runoff, the stock market
- 1:31fell a bit more, though not as much as
- 1:33it had right after the first round.
- 1:37And yet, look at this: Lula increased
- 1:40the primary surplus relative to what had
- 1:43been practiced by Fernando Henrique,
- 1:46maintained the Central Bank's
- 1:49independence, kept the inflation
- 1:52targeting system,
- 1:56he managed to bring inflation back to
- 1:59the center of the target over time,
- 2:04Brazil earned investment grade,
- 2:08and Brazilian assets appreciated
- 2:11significantly, recovering with great
- 2:14advantage everything they had lost in
- 2:17that immediate post-election period.
- 2:22The financial market overreacts. It is
- 2:27So it doesn't surprise me at all.
- 2:30>> Regarding the pressure that has existed
- 2:33since he was reelected, it has been the
- 2:36market pushing for this, asking for a
- 2:39name for the Ministry of Finance soon.
- 2:43What is your assessment regarding?
- 2:47>> Brazil has a date with fiscal adjustment
- 2:50.
- 2:51We are in a delicate situation.
- 2:55The Brazilian public debt will not grow
- 2:57over the next 4 years at the same pace
- 2:59it did from the pandemic until now, and
- 3:01we will have to do something to address
- 3:03this problem.
- 3:07If we do nothing to address this problem
- 3:10—and I would say right at the beginning
- 3:13of President Lula's new term—if we lose
- 3:16this window that won't happen again, the
- 3:19unavoidable meeting will force itself
- 3:21upon us.
- 3:24Like any situation of economic imbalance
- 3:27, if it is not corrected, reality will
- 3:30force itself upon us.
- 3:33It's more or less like your health.
- 3:35You can fool yourself about a problem
- 3:37for a while by taking a painkiller,
- 3:39kicking the can down the road,
- 3:40pretending to do something, but the
- 3:42problem gets worse until the point where
- 3:44there's no way around it.
- 3:48And then the cost is much higher than it
- 3:50needed to be.
- 3:52I think it is fundamental to understand
- 3:54that there is no contradiction between
- 3:57fiscal adjustment and social policy.
- 4:01Effective social policy has a
- 4:03precondition: the government must be in
- 4:06a position to fund it.
- 4:10That is what happened in Lula's first
- 4:12term. It was thanks to the courageous
- 4:15adjustment made early in the term, in
- 4:17Lula 1, that space was opened up by
- 4:19lowering interest rates, mainly, to be
- 4:21able to carry out the social policies
- 4:23for which Lula was elected.
- 4:27And that is what he has a mandate for.
- 4:30Now, one must accept a bit of sacrifice
- 4:32at the start to reap the benefits
- 4:34further down the road.
- 4:37If that sacrifice at the start isn't
- 4:39accepted to reap the benefits later, it
- 4:42will compromise the term and make the
- 4:44social policy that Brazil needs—and for
- 4:47which Lula was legitimately elected by
- 4:49the majority of Brazilians—unfeasible.
- 4:53>> Janete, you mentioned President Lula's
- 4:57first term, and we've been hearing many
- 5:01parallels about the possibility, or the
- 5:05need, for the president to repeat the
- 5:09successes he had in his first term.
- 5:15The world has changed, Brazil has
- 5:18changed; what parallels do you see
- 5:21between that moment in the Brazilian
- 5:23economy and now, and what from that
- 5:26positive experience can Brazil repeat
- 5:29today?
- 5:31>> Patrick, I believe the situation Lula
- 5:35inherited in 2003 was more delicate than
- 5:38it is today.
- 5:43We needed to practice a fiscal surplus
- 5:45on the order of 4%of GDP at that time.
- 5:50Brazil had turned to the IMF to meet
- 5:51external commitments; we didn't have
- 5:53foreign exchange reserves.
- 5:55Inflation was running in double digits.
- 5:57>> Sorry, Lula 1.
- 5:58>> I remember it was almost a...sorry?
- 6:01>> That was Lula 1.
- 6:03>> Lula 1.
- 6:04>> It's just that you said Lula
- 6:05>> three, so I got confused.
- 6:07>> Ah, no, excuse me, I misspoke. Lula 1.
- 6:09>> Easier now, the situation is easier
- 6:12compared to Lula 1.
- 6:14>> I think the situation Lula took over in
- 6:162001—sorry, 2003—was more delicate.
- 6:20>> Three.
- 6:21>> Yes, I said 2003, that he took office in
- 6:232003, than the situation now.
- 6:25It was double-digit inflation, the real
- 6:28was at, if I remember correctly, six
- 6:30reais to the dollar; it was something
- 6:32very aggressive for that time.
- 6:35And yet, the situation was reversed.
- 6:38And look, the opinion among economists
- 6:39was almost unanimous that he wouldn't
- 6:41achieve that result.
- 6:44And he did.
- 6:47What we need now is not something from
- 6:49another world.
- 6:51We are currently at a primary deficit
- 6:53hovering between half a percent and one
- 6:55percent of GDP.
- 6:57We need a primary surplus to put public
- 7:00debt on a stable trajectory over time,
- 7:03on the order of one and a half to two
- 7:06percent of GDP.
- 7:09We are talking about a delta of two to
- 7:10two and a half percent of GDP for a
- 7:12fiscal turnaround.
- 7:14It can be done. It is not something that
- 7:16is far beyond the government's capacity
- 7:18to achieve.
- 7:20However, it requires boldness, courage,
- 7:22and determination to act at the
- 7:24beginning of the term.
- 7:28Because this whole game is half action
- 7:31and half managing expectations.
- 7:36If the government doesn't win the battle
- 7:37of expectations at the start of its term
- 7:39, what will we witness?
- 7:41Probably a sharp
- 7:44devaluation of the real,
- 7:47an acceleration of inflation because of
- 7:49that, with the Central Bank having to
- 7:51raise interest rates to curb inflation.
- 7:54And then we lose control of inflation
- 7:57and public debt.
- 7:59Then we enter a spiral and a situation
- 8:01that will quickly become unsustainable,
- 8:03and a crisis will impose itself.
- 8:07We don't need to go down that path.
- 8:11We have a very concrete chance to act,
- 8:14win the expectations game, and from
- 8:17there be able to reduce interest rates
- 8:20sustainably, creating room for social
- 8:22policies without committing any
- 8:25electoral fraud.
- 8:28That is what Lula was elected for.
- 8:30>> You mentioned this 2%to 2.5%of GDP
- 8:33fiscal adjustment, which is feasible; in
- 8:36your assessment, where would this
- 8:39adjustment come from?
- 8:42Where would it come from? Is the
- 8:44adjustment about reductions and cuts?
- 8:47Beyond, obviously, a search for
- 8:50increased tax revenue, where would the
- 8:53focus of this search for cost reduction
- 8:57be?
- 9:00>> Well, I think we have to look very
- 9:03carefully at so-called tax expenditures
- 9:06, this whole plethora of special
- 9:08taxation and exemption regimes.
- 9:13We must decouple social benefits
- 9:18from real gains in the minimum wage.
- 9:21It makes no sense to index social
- 9:24benefits to the real increase of the
- 9:27minimum wage.
- 9:30Social benefits must be corrected for
- 9:31inflation, without a doubt, to maintain
- 9:33their purchasing power.
- 9:36Now, there is no logic in transferring
- 9:38the economy’s productivity gains to
- 9:40social benefits. That is a question of
- 9:43who you are working for.
- 9:45Only then can the minimum wage have a
- 9:47real gain.
- 9:49But transferring this automatically, as
- 9:51is done today, at a very high cost to
- 9:53the entire social safety net,
- 9:55practically all of it, really does not
- 9:57have any logic; it makes no economic
- 9:59sense.
- 10:02I think we need to deconstitutionalize
- 10:04many public expenditures and reduce the
- 10:06proportion of mandatory spending, which
- 10:08today accounts for 91, 92%of the budget
- 10:11.
- 10:14We have to discuss with Congress the
- 10:16allocation of amendments, their lack of
- 10:19transparency, their lack of criteria in
- 10:21allocation, and social security.
- 10:26Brazilian social security today consumes
- 10:2912.7%of GDP if you include the INSS and
- 10:31public servants at all three levels of
- 10:34government.
- 10:36It is a number completely
- 10:37disproportionate to our demographic
- 10:39reality.
- 10:42So, the Brazilian fiscal problem, I
- 10:44think, boils down fundamentally to two
- 10:45numbers that are highly discrepant.
- 10:49One is social security spending, as I
- 10:51said, 12.7%of GDP, and the other is
- 10:53interest payments on public debt, which
- 10:55are currently running around 9%of GDP.
- 10:59So you already have practically 22%of
- 11:02GDP spent on interest and social
- 11:04security, out of a total gross tax
- 11:07burden of 33-34%of GDP.
- 11:10Now, to sustainably reduce interest
- 11:12rates, you will have to make a fiscal
- 11:15effort on the front end.
- 11:17I think we need to courageously rethink
- 11:20things there.
- 11:22Regarding deconstitutionalization, I see
- 11:25a need to end this mandatory floor for
- 11:28spending on education and health.
- 11:32We have already learned in Brazil that
- 11:34spending more, throwing money at the
- 11:35sector, does not improve delivery, does
- 11:37not improve the results obtained.
- 11:40The Brazilian population is no longer
- 11:42growing as it did in the past; on the
- 11:44contrary, the average number of children
- 11:46per woman has fallen abruptly, and fewer
- 11:49people are entering school.
- 11:51It makes no sense to keep education
- 11:54spending rigid and growing vegetatively
- 11:57.
- 11:58>> Mr. Ernani, you mentioned the need to
- 12:00make this adjustment right at the
- 12:01beginning to, you know, create a shock
- 12:03of credibility.
- 12:06How have you been interpreting the
- 12:08political signals or the statements from
- 12:11both the president and those close to
- 12:14him regarding the political will to do
- 12:16this?
- 12:18How have you seen these signs?
- 12:22>> I believe that within the government
- 12:23there are people aware and alert to the
- 12:25need for this credible action.
- 12:30And of the necessary size right at the
- 12:33start.
- 12:36I think excessive gradualism here will
- 12:39compromise the battle for expectations.
- 12:43We run a serious risk of heading down
- 12:45that path of exchange rate devaluation
- 12:47and having to raise interest rates, and
- 12:48so on.
- 12:51Now, I think there are people in the
- 12:53government who also don't see it that
- 12:56way, who think there's time, that they
- 12:58can drag it out a bit longer, that they
- 13:01can do it slowly over time, and that the
- 13:04financial market will willingly accept
- 13:07this path.
- 13:10It's not about pleasing the financial
- 13:12market, it's about taking this game of
- 13:14expectations seriously.
- 13:16The economy is a kind of meteorology
- 13:18where the weather forecast affects the
- 13:19weather itself.
- 13:22If people start to see a storm forming
- 13:25on the horizon, they act accordingly
- 13:27right away, and the storm comes.
- 13:32If people see that the weather is going
- 13:34to improve, that everything is being
- 13:35adjusted, they act accordingly, and the
- 13:37weather improves.
- 13:40The real appreciates, this eases
- 13:42inflationary pressure, space opens up
- 13:44for the Central Bank to cut interest
- 13:46rates, because the fiscal effort is
- 13:48being made, and then you free up
- 13:50resources for the core objective, which
- 13:53is social policy.
- 13:55I think the government is divided.
- 13:57>> Sorry.
- 13:58>> Uh, do you want to finish? I think it
- 14:00stayed, uh...
- 14:01>> No, just to say that I understand the
- 14:03government is divided and Lula, as is
- 14:05his nature, will listen to both sides
- 14:07and will arbitrate.
- 14:08>> Geni, you have been pointing out
- 14:10imbalances, right?
- 14:12These imbalances, for example, the high
- 14:15tax burden in Brazil, the enormous
- 14:18limitation of the budget, when you argue
- 14:21that creating fiscal rules doesn't solve
- 14:25Brazil's problems if the country doesn't
- 14:28tackle the root of the problem.
- 14:32In your assessment, what is the root?
- 14:35>> No, the root of the problem is that
- 14:37public spending has been growing for
- 14:39many years at an unsustainable pace.
- 14:42In Brazil, the money is already spent
- 14:45before it is collected.
- 14:47Public spending is already determined
- 14:49beforehand.
- 14:51What the government collects, the
- 14:52government has become an administrator
- 14:54of cash, of transfers.
- 14:56The budget, in fact, the budget that the
- 14:59government actually determines the
- 15:00purpose for is minimal and is getting
- 15:03smaller and smaller, and has shrunk even
- 15:05further with the growth in the size of
- 15:07the budget controlled by Congress.
- 15:11So we will have to face this situation.
- 15:15It's good to have fiscal rules, but
- 15:17there must be substantive actions right
- 15:19at the start of the government, during
- 15:21the so-called honeymoon, when the new
- 15:23government's political capital is still
- 15:25intact and Congress is less able to
- 15:27offer resistance; I think one must know
- 15:29how to use this moment very well.
- 15:34What happens in these first few months
- 15:36of the term will be decisive for the
- 15:38entire term and will signal whether or
- 15:40not the government will be able to
- 15:42implement the social policies for which
- 15:45it was elected.
- 15:48>> Mr. Nats, you recently stated that the
- 15:50last few years of Lula 3 were not,
- 15:53quote-unquote, a disaster.
- 15:55How do you evaluate the government as a
- 15:58whole, and based on this Lula 3, what
- 16:00would you expect for a Lula 4?
- 16:03>> Well, Lula 3 began with very strong
- 16:06fiscal expansionism, which was that
- 16:09transition amendment.
- 16:13Then came an effort at regulation, the
- 16:16third in a short period of time in
- 16:18Brazil—first was the Fiscal
- 16:21Responsibility Law, then the spending
- 16:24cap, and in the Lula 3 government, the
- 16:27new fiscal framework was created to try
- 16:30to build a favorable expectation
- 16:32regarding fiscal adjustment.
- 16:37Over time, it became clear that the
- 16:39government's commitment to this new
- 16:42framework was very doubtful because they
- 16:46kept creating many exceptions, opening
- 16:49many loopholes; a series of expenses
- 16:52went off the books, and the new fiscal
- 16:55framework ended up being demoralized, I
- 16:58would say.
- 16:59But look, Brazil has tried to create
- 17:01this regulation on three occasions and
- 17:03has failed.
- 17:05So, I think now is a very special chance
- 17:08because we cannot repeat what Lula 3 was
- 17:12.
- 17:15We cannot in any way step on the gas at
- 17:17the start and then try to precariously
- 17:22manage some kind of control.
- 17:26I was reminded the other day of a very
- 17:29beautiful, very precious metaphor by the
- 17:31Austrian economist Schumpeter, when he
- 17:34says the following: it is precisely
- 17:37because a car has brakes that it can
- 17:39reach higher speeds.
- 17:44It is because the car possesses this
- 17:46braking mechanism that it allows it to
- 17:49develop greater speed over time.
- 17:53So, you have to brake a little at the
- 17:56beginning, you have to do the necessary
- 17:58adjustments—not as an end in itself,
- 18:00just to please the financial market, but
- 18:02to win the game of expectations and
- 18:04create legitimate, sustained space to
- 18:06implement social policies.
- 18:10>> Chinetti, we just got the results of the
- 18:14midterm elections in the United States,
- 18:18with a fairly strong victory for the
- 18:21Democratic Party, defeating Donald
- 18:25Trump's Republicans.
- 18:28What impacts do you think this might
- 18:30have on the Brazilian economy in the
- 18:33immediate term?
- 18:35Would the revocation of tariffs, for
- 18:37example, be a possibility?
- 18:40>> I think it provides relief, possibly
- 18:42relieving the geopolitics of the
- 18:44continent.
- 18:46Trump will have less freedom of action
- 18:49to be able to take aggressive unilateral
- 18:52measures in relation to the Latin
- 18:54American continent.
- 18:58I think that for those who value
- 19:00democracy and for those who value the
- 19:03balance of power, having a Congress—
- 19:05both the House and the Senate—capable of
- 19:08imposing limits on Donald Trump's
- 19:10imperial power is very welcome.
- 19:14Looking at the broader landscape,
- 19:17Patrick, I see Brazil potentially
- 19:19becoming a major beneficiary of the end
- 19:21of the long hyper-globalization cycle we
- 19:24are living through today.
- 19:28Brazil completely lost its footing
- 19:30during the period of hyper-globalization
- 19:32.
- 19:33The contrast with South Korea here is
- 19:36stark. South Korea bet on integration,
- 19:39increasing its GDP exportability,
- 19:41participating in global value chains,
- 19:44and became a high-income country.
- 19:48Brazil, on the contrary, when
- 19:50hyper-globalization began back in the
- 19:52early 1980s, doubled down on a closed
- 19:54economy and import substitution.
- 19:58We experienced tremendous macroeconomic
- 20:01instability and spent decades completely
- 20:03on the sidelines, with stagnant
- 20:05productivity.
- 20:08Now that hyper-globalization is ending,
- 20:11due to our geopolitical situation, our
- 20:13endowment of natural resources—fresh
- 20:16water, ores, critical minerals, rare
- 20:19earths, arable land, renewable energy,
- 20:21biofuels—I could list an immense number
- 20:24of factors.
- 20:26We are very well positioned to recover
- 20:29the dynamism we lost during
- 20:31hyper-globalization.
- 20:34The world covets what Brazil has and
- 20:36needs Brazil, just as Brazil needs the
- 20:38world.
- 20:39Now, we must get our house in order and
- 20:42tidy up internally to actually regain
- 20:45this dynamism and capture, for our
- 20:48benefit, the favorable winds that the
- 20:51end of hyper-globalization represents
- 20:53for us.
- 20:56>> Following this geopolitical line, Brazil
- 20:59has historically defended
- 21:01multilateralism, and that has been
- 21:03called into question, especially during
- 21:06the terms of President Donald Trump,
- 21:09right?
- 21:11Do you believe that this return to the
- 21:14multilateralism discussion, where
- 21:17countries have equivalent power in
- 21:20international negotiations, could regain
- 21:23strength with the shift in power in the
- 21:26U.S. Congress?
- 21:29>> I don't see that as a realistic prospect
- 21:31in the short term.
- 21:34However, Brazil’s position in defending
- 21:36multilateralism is correct.
- 21:38And I think we also need to work hard on
- 21:41our regional trade and our trade with
- 21:43countries of the Global South.
- 21:48The Brazilian reaction to American
- 21:50protectionism was extremely constructive
- 21:52.
- 21:55We managed to improve our trade balance
- 21:58performance, and our exports by finding
- 22:00new markets when American markets closed
- 22:03to us.
- 22:06It was healthy for Brazil to be
- 22:08stimulated not to become complacent.
- 22:12I think we have plenty of room to grow
- 22:16in international trade.
- 22:20Foreign investors view Brazil with much
- 22:22more optimism and a better outlook today
- 22:24than Brazilians themselves do.
- 22:29Because they look at this troubled world
- 22:31, at this very complex situation in so
- 22:34many regions of the globe, and Brazil,
- 22:36with all its resources and its vibrant
- 22:38entrepreneurial culture, is a country
- 22:40that still has much to achieve.
- 22:44We represent 3%of the global GDP.
- 22:47Our exports, including agribusiness, are
- 22:51on the order of 1%of world exports.
- 22:54We are still one of the most closed
- 22:56countries in the world.
- 22:59If we learn to sell a larger proportion
- 23:01of what we produce to the world, adding
- 23:04value internally, industrializing our
- 23:06comparative advantages, and, at the same
- 23:08time, if we buy from the world a larger
- 23:11proportion of what we consume, our
- 23:13economy will return to growing as it did
- 23:15in a time of greater dynamism that
- 23:17preceded hyper-globalization.
- 23:20>> Janete, Patrick spoke here about the
- 23:22American Congress, I would like to talk
- 23:24now about the Brazilian Congress.
- 23:27The new composition of Congress, what is
- 23:29your assessment regarding it, how do you
- 23:31see this new composition working on
- 23:33economic agendas?
- 23:37>> It is not a congress favorable, in
- 23:39principle, to the executive, right?
- 23:45But I think that at the beginning of the
- 23:48term it will still be less capable of
- 23:51offering resistance, and if the
- 23:53government in the middle has a good
- 23:56start, I think it can improve its
- 23:59representation and its capacity for
- 24:01leadership among Brazilian
- 24:03representatives in Congress quite a bit
- 24:06.
- 24:08>> You are still talking about other powers
- 24:11besides the executive; before the
- 24:13elections, there was a great tension
- 24:16between all the powers.
- 24:19Do you think that, what is your
- 24:21assessment now? Do you think it should
- 24:23de-escalate? What is the expectation?
- 24:27>> I believe that the issue of the Vorcaro
- 24:30scandal regarding the Supreme Federal
- 24:34Court will still demand discoveries, new
- 24:37discoveries will still happen, and, in
- 24:40fact, we cannot passively watch what
- 24:43happened as if
- 24:48as if the Supreme Court were above the
- 24:51law.
- 24:52I hope, as a Brazilian citizen, that
- 24:55after everything that has already
- 24:58appeared, appropriate measures will be
- 25:01taken so that those who, in fact,
- 25:04disappointed and frustrated expectations
- 25:08of integrity in the responsibility
- 25:11assumed as a Supreme Federal Court
- 25:13justice, so that this is addressed.
- 25:18>> But do you see the possibility, with
- 25:21possible new discoveries, responses from
- 25:24one power to another, could this be a
- 25:27major crisis?
- 25:31Democratic, not just economic, not just
- 25:34for
- 25:34>> active.
- 25:35It is a prerogative, it is a
- 25:37constitutional prerogative of the
- 25:39National Congress to impeach a Supreme
- 25:42Court justice.
- 25:44I think that if what happened does not
- 25:47justify it, I have difficulty imagining
- 25:49what could justify an initiative by the
- 25:52Senate in that direction.
- 25:55>> Seneti, in recent days we've seen a lot
- 25:58of buzz surrounding an article by
- 26:00economist André Lara Resende, in which
- 26:03he argues, among other things, that the
- 26:06fiscal problem lies in debt servicing,
- 26:08and everything else is secondary.
- 26:13Some interpreted the text as a proposal
- 26:15for, quote-unquote, interest rate caps.
- 26:20Lara Resende classified this statement
- 26:22as a distortion in bad faith, even in a
- 26:25column by our dear colleague Zé Paulo
- 26:28Kupfer here at UOL.
- 26:32But, controversy aside, some economists
- 26:35saw André Lara Resende's article as a
- 26:37call, an invitation for the country and
- 26:40for economists to rethink their
- 26:42diagnoses, rather than just suggesting
- 26:45effective actions to combat economic
- 26:47problems—to rethink the diagnoses of the
- 26:50country's fiscal issues.
- 26:54In your assessment, do you think we
- 26:56still need to advance in improving these
- 26:59diagnoses, or have we already overcome
- 27:01that stage?
- 27:03>> Patrick, I read André Lara Resende's
- 27:05article with great interest.
- 27:07I consider
- 27:10it very welcome and healthy,
- 27:15the stimulus
- 27:18that he proposes for us to critically
- 27:21debate our mental models and the
- 27:24dominant macroeconomic theory.
- 27:29I think this proposal to rethink, to
- 27:32question, and to evaluate is very
- 27:35healthy, it’s very welcome, and we need
- 27:38to dig deep into this.
- 27:42I share André's concern about the impact
- 27:46of interest rates on the dynamics of
- 27:49public debt.
- 27:53In fact, the 9%interest that Brazil pays
- 27:57on the current stock of public debt is
- 28:00exactly what most compromises Brazil's
- 28:03fiscal balance.
- 28:08I believe this diagnosis is correct.
- 28:12What I do not accept as an argument or
- 28:16proposal
- 28:20in André Lara Resende's formulation is
- 28:22the idea that the government can commit
- 28:24to a target for reducing primary
- 28:26interest rates.
- 28:30You cannot have, at the same time,
- 28:34a Central Bank's independence, an
- 28:36inflation target, and an interest rate
- 28:38target.
- 28:40That is unfeasible.
- 28:42We have to accept that
- 28:47reducing interest rates is essential to
- 28:49put Brazil's public accounts and public
- 28:52debt on a balanced trajectory over time
- 28:55.
- 28:57But this will not happen through wishful
- 29:00thinking.
- 29:01It is necessary to build and open space
- 29:03to be able to reduce interest rates, and
- 29:06this comes from the Central Bank in a
- 29:08consistent and sustained manner over
- 29:10time.
- 29:14I know he isn't proposing anything like
- 29:17what Dilma Rousseff did in her
- 29:19administration, but I saw what happened
- 29:22when Tombini, the Central Bank president
- 29:25, tried to lower interest rates
- 29:27willfully at a time when the opposite
- 29:30was needed: raising rates.
- 29:33It was a signaling error.
- 29:38So I think we need to look very
- 29:40carefully, and, in fact, this type of
- 29:43proposal as it's being put on the table
- 29:46creates a lot of noise and generates a
- 29:49lot of uncertainty regarding the
- 29:52financial market's own reaction.
- 30:00When a doctor prescribes medicine, they
- 30:03don't need to take the patient's beliefs
- 30:06into account.
- 30:11The doctor prescribes an analgesic, an
- 30:14anesthetic; it will work regardless of
- 30:17what the patient believes.
- 30:22The patient can believe in witchcraft,
- 30:24in voodoo, or whatever they want, the
- 30:26anesthetic will still work.
- 30:29In economics, it's not like that,
- 30:31because there isn't a patient on the
- 30:33other side.
- 30:35There are economic agents who will
- 30:38interpret what is being done and will
- 30:41react to their interpretation of those
- 30:44actions.
- 30:48So every economic policy measure must
- 30:49take that into account; it's not like
- 30:51pressing a button.
- 30:53I press the button and what I want
- 30:54happens.
- 30:56I am going to do something that will be
- 30:59read, interpreted, and will produce
- 31:01behaviors that I am often not even
- 31:03capable of anticipating.
- 31:08And measures that are far
- 31:13from convention, it's not that they are
- 31:16necessarily wrong—they might be correct
- 31:19—but if they don't account for how those
- 31:21who believe in the convention will react
- 31:24, they become disastrous.
- 31:28And that is what I really worry about.
- 31:31>> Do you see any option between the theory
- 31:33—between what André Lara Resende is
- 31:36proposing—and traditional monetary
- 31:39theory?
- 31:40>> He is questioning the foundations of the
- 31:42theory of money and the theory of
- 31:44interest.
- 31:45He is arguing, for example, that
- 31:47lowering interest rates will reduce
- 31:49inflation.
- 31:51I have great doubts about finding
- 31:52empirical evidence for that correlation
- 31:54.
- 31:56But it is a welcome discussion; it is
- 31:58healthy.
- 32:00We must have the detachment to rethink
- 32:02mental models and to question
- 32:04conventional theory.
- 32:09Now, when proposing something, one
- 32:11cannot fail to take into account the
- 32:14effect it will likely produce in the
- 32:17minds of those who might react by
- 32:20selling the real to buy dollars, selling
- 32:23stocks, speculating, and so on.
- 32:29An excellent policy can be disastrous if
- 32:32it is poorly read and misinterpreted by
- 32:34economic agents.
- 32:38A policy that isn't so good can produce
- 32:40interesting results if it is embraced by
- 32:43economic agents and produces favorable
- 32:46responses.
- 32:48So, we are in a very dangerous and very
- 32:51delicate territory here.
- 32:53You have to be careful with high-risk
- 32:55piloting.
- 32:56>> Beyond the internal elements or factors
- 32:59regarding fiscal issues in Brazil, we
- 33:02also have the international scenario,
- 33:05which many economists believe isn't very
- 33:08favorable for lowering interest rates in
- 33:11Brazil.
- 33:13Interest rates in the United States are
- 33:15relatively high compared to the
- 33:17historical average.
- 33:19And Brazil needs to maintain high rates
- 33:24here in the economy to attract capital.
- 33:30So, it's an element that makes cutting
- 33:32interest rates even more difficult.
- 33:35Do you see any possibilities or a path
- 33:38for interest rate cuts when comparing
- 33:41them with American rates?
- 33:44Is there room for a reduction in the
- 33:47medium-term horizon?
- 33:50>> That effect does exist, Patrick.
- 33:53In fact, inflation abroad and higher
- 33:55rates out there do restrict the room for
- 33:58cutting rates here to some extent.
- 34:01I don't see it as a first-order factor
- 34:03at the moment.
- 34:06I believe the Central Bank of Brazil
- 34:08missed the mark back then, pushing
- 34:10interest rates to a level much higher
- 34:13than was technically necessary.
- 34:17I believe they were late to start the
- 34:20rate-cutting process and were caught off
- 34:23guard this year by the worsening
- 34:25international geopolitics, the war, and
- 34:28rising energy prices, which made the
- 34:30previously planned rate cuts unfeasible
- 34:33this year.
- 34:36If we don't have any other shock as
- 34:39severe as the war was this year, I don't
- 34:41think the external scenario of
- 34:43international monetary policy will be a
- 34:45restrictive factor.
- 34:48Now, the room to cut interest rates in
- 34:50Brazil depends on the credibility of the
- 34:53proposal and the execution of the
- 34:54financial adjustment at the beginning of
- 34:57the next Lula administration.
- 34:59>> Senator, last question.
- 35:02So far, the strongest name that has
- 35:03emerged to occupy the Ministry of
- 35:05Finance is Rafael Fonteles.
- 35:07How do you evaluate this name?
- 35:09>> I will not discuss names, Luciana. I
- 35:11don't find it elegant, I don't find it
- 35:12correct.
- 35:14I will limit myself to saying that the
- 35:17credibility of the Finance Minister, and
- 35:20not just his,
- 35:22but his ability to assemble a good
- 35:24technical team—much like the excellent
- 35:27technical team Palocci assembled when he
- 35:30took over the Finance Ministry back in
- 35:33Lula's first term—is fundamental both
- 35:36for designing the paths and solutions
- 35:38for fiscal adjustment and for the
- 35:41credibility and improved expectations it
- 35:44will inspire in these nervous financial
- 35:47market agents.
- 35:51So, the ability of a Finance Minister to
- 35:53gather a top-tier technical team, and
- 35:56serious, competent people—people who
- 35:59command respect from those who control
- 36:01the money in this country—is, I think,
- 36:04fundamental.
- 36:07I would look not only at the name of the
- 36:09Minister, but also at their capacity and
- 36:12discernment in choosing key figures for
- 36:14the second tier of leadership.
- 36:17>> Zanetti, thank you very much for your
- 36:19time. Thank you, Patrick.
- 36:21Thank you to everyone who watched
- 36:23another O Interview. Until next time.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Eduardo Giannetti fala de ajuste fiscal no governo Lula, reforma e juros | UOL Entrevista by UOL, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 4,622 words across 816 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.