Droit constitutionnel : l'essentiel à savoir (L1 droit) — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00So, imagine you've learned your entire
- 0:02constitutional law course, or perhaps
- 0:05you're discovering constitutional law
- 0:07bit by bit. But what's important for
- 0:10you to understand right away, from the
- 0:12very start of this video, and I think
- 0:14it's vital to discuss, is how all these
- 0:17concepts are linked together. Because
- 0:20it's fundamental to understand, and
- 0:23we'll come back to this, that your
- 0:25constitutional law course is structured
- 0:27, organized, and also hierarchical. And
- 0:31what you need to understand is that
- 0:34there's a common thread in
- 0:35constitutional law, so the idea is to
- 0:38see how all these notions are connected
- 0:40. That's exactly what we'll cover in
- 0:43this video, because did you know there
- 0:45are links between the concept of the
- 0:48State, democracy, and the constitution?
- 0:51Well, there are connections between the
- 0:53constitution and the separation of
- 0:55powers. For example, I'm thinking of
- 0:57Article 16 of the Declaration of the
- 0:58Rights of Man, which makes that very
- 1:00link between the separation of powers
- 1:01and the constitution. In short, there
- 1:04are a whole host of notions, concepts,
- 1:06expressions, and legal terms you must
- 1:08master if you want to succeed and get a
- 1:11good grade in constitutional law. The
- 1:15idea for this video is to put all of
- 1:17that in order, recap what's important,
- 1:20and show that there is indeed a link
- 1:22throughout the whole subject. I should
- 1:26specify right now that this video
- 1:28focuses on the general theory of
- 1:30constitutional law, since in the first
- 1:33year of law school, the course is
- 1:35generally divided into two semesters or
- 1:37two parts. Usually, in the first
- 1:40semester, you study what's called the
- 1:42general theory of the State, or the
- 1:44general theory of constitutional law.
- 1:46It might not be called that at your
- 1:47university, but that's what is
- 1:49generally studied. For instance, you'll
- 1:51understand that you're studying the
- 1:52major principles: the constitution, the
- 1:54State, and the separation of powers.
- 1:56That is what is generally studied in
- 1:58the first semester of the first year of
- 2:00law. It's what you study in this course
- 2:03or in other degree programs. But
- 2:04primarily, as is very often the case,
- 2:06we start by studying this general
- 2:08theory. And generally, in the second
- 2:10semester, what will you be studying?
- 2:14You will study everything concerning
- 2:16the institutions of the Fifth Republic.
- 2:20Practically speaking, you are going to
- 2:21apply what you learned in the first
- 2:23semester to something concrete,
- 2:24specifically the institutions of the
- 2:25Fifth Republic. What exactly is an
- 2:28institution of the Fifth Republic?
- 2:29Everything concerning the parliament.
- 2:31For example, parliament is an
- 2:33institution, the government is an
- 2:34institution, and the President of the
- 2:36Republic is an institution. And
- 2:38generally, you study that in the second
- 2:39semester. So here, what we are going to
- 2:41look at in this video is really
- 2:43focusing on the general theory of the
- 2:44State. We will focus together on
- 2:47essential concepts, major principles,
- 2:49and key terms to know, and I will also
- 2:51share my advice as a professor on how
- 2:54to succeed and understand that,
- 2:55ultimately, the Constitutional Law
- 2:57course is organized and structured. But
- 3:00we will come back to all of that
- 3:02throughout the video. And speaking of
- 3:05this video, what is its purpose? What
- 3:07are the objectives assigned to this
- 3:09video? Initially, the idea is for you
- 3:12to know the definitions, mechanisms,
- 3:15and essential concepts that you need to
- 3:17master. Because very often, when you
- 3:20are in your first year of law—I'll
- 3:22take the classic first-year law example
- 3:24—you are flooded with all sorts of
- 3:26concepts and you don't really know what
- 3:28is important and what is a bit less so.
- 3:31The goal of this video is precisely to
- 3:33tell you and give you the essential
- 3:35principles and elements you need to
- 3:37know, and since that's the subject of
- 3:39first-semester Constitutional Law, by
- 3:41the end of this video, you will know
- 3:43the major principles to use to enrich
- 3:45your papers. In other words, there are
- 3:47principles expected in a Constitutional
- 3:49Law paper. So the idea will be to go
- 3:51over them. And finally, it is linked to
- 3:53the others; you will know what to
- 3:55include to pass your exams and, above
- 3:56all, to impress the grader. Preliminary
- 3:59remark: you can find the entire
- 4:00Constitutional Law course in my
- 4:02Constitutional Law study guide pack.
- 4:04Whoa, there's a big typo in "study
- 4:06guide." Plus, the coffee machine is
- 4:08doing its descaling cycle. We love that
- 4:10. As I was saying, as a preliminary
- 4:14remark, you can find the entire course
- 4:16in my Constitutional Law study guide
- 4:19pack. I’ll put the link in the
- 4:21description, and the idea is for you to
- 4:23have the entire course at your disposal
- 4:24. So, if you like my teaching style and
- 4:27how I explain things, these study
- 4:29guides will certainly be of great use
- 4:31to you. By the way, if any of you have
- 4:33already used the study sheets, don't
- 4:34hesitate to mention it in the comments.
- 4:35Let's get started. Okay, that spelling
- 4:37mistake is horrible, "pack" with an S,
- 4:38that really hurts. So, let's go. Let's
- 4:41go for the essentials of constitutional
- 4:43law. What are we going to see together
- 4:45in this video? What is the actual
- 4:47structure of the video? First, we will
- 4:50try to define what constitutional law
- 4:53is and distinguish between general
- 4:55theory and the institutions of the 5th
- 4:57Republic. What is constitutional law?
- 4:59The idea is to start off on the right
- 5:02foot. Then, the goal is also to
- 5:04understand the logic of a
- 5:05constitutional law course, as you will
- 5:07realize throughout your law studies.
- 5:10Professors 'courses are structured,
- 5:12hierarchical, and organized in a
- 5:14specific way that creates a certain
- 5:16logic, and you need to understand that
- 5:18constitutional law logic. Third part of
- 5:22the video: what we are going to look at
- 5:23together is what is concretely expected
- 5:25of you in constitutional law. I am
- 5:28thinking specifically here of advice
- 5:31you can apply and note down right now
- 5:34regarding constitutional law essays,
- 5:37because students very often write
- 5:40essays that are too descriptive,
- 5:42meaning it's just reciting the course
- 5:45material. The student knows their
- 5:49course well and wants to pack the essay
- 5:51with everything they know to show
- 5:53they've studied. Except, in reality,
- 5:55that's not really what is expected of
- 5:56you. What is expected is that your
- 5:59essays be demonstrative. Meaning you
- 6:02must demonstrate something. There is
- 6:04truly an effort of argumentation to
- 6:07pursue. You will have a research
- 6:09question, and to answer it, you will
- 6:10put forward a series of arguments,
- 6:12which is exactly what we expect from
- 6:14you. We will come back to that shortly.
- 6:16Next, in a fourth part, we will see the
- 6:1810 references to know perfectly to
- 6:19succeed in constitutional law.
- 6:21Spontaneously, I think for example of
- 6:23Jean-Jacques Rousseau and his book "The
- 6:25Social Contract," published in 1762. It
- 6:29is a reference, an essential concept to
- 6:32know perfectly, because not only do you
- 6:35study it in relation to sovereignty—
- 6:37which you bring up—but you also touch
- 6:40upon it through the constitution and
- 6:43the state. In short, you mention it in
- 6:45many different places. So it is
- 6:47imperative to know this reference well.
- 6:49And finally, I will share a tip with
- 6:52you that will help you pass your law
- 6:55exams. And it works almost every single
- 6:57time. So, first of all, what are we
- 6:59going to do? We are going to define
- 7:01constitutional law. What is
- 7:02constitutional law? Constitutional law
- 7:06is a branch of public law. Remember, in
- 7:10law, we distinguish between public law
- 7:12and private law. Private law concerns
- 7:15individuals, people, and specifically
- 7:17natural persons. And on the flip side,
- 7:19you have public law. Public law
- 7:22concerns the state and the
- 7:23administration. So, constitutional law
- 7:27is a branch of public law that studies
- 7:30the fundamental rules relating to the
- 7:32organization and exercise of political
- 7:35power. So, in constitutional law, you
- 7:39will study the fundamental rules
- 7:41regarding how politics is organized and
- 7:43exercised. All right? And speaking of
- 7:46political power, you will realize that
- 7:48the better you understand your
- 7:49constitutional law course, the better
- 7:51you will understand current events. And
- 7:55that is a total game changer when you
- 7:56realize that current events, what you
- 7:58learn in constitutional law, actually
- 8:00applies to reality. So, what exactly is
- 8:03constitutional law? What do we study in
- 8:06it? We study the state and its various
- 8:09forms. What is the state? We will get
- 8:12back to that. It is a political
- 8:14organization that serves to protect
- 8:16liberties, among other things. And so,
- 8:18regarding the state, you generally
- 8:20study the concept of the state itself.
- 8:23What is the state, how was it born,
- 8:26notably through the social contract,
- 8:29and you must master its three main
- 8:32forms: unitary state, federal state,
- 8:35and regional state. Next, you study the
- 8:38constitution, the supreme norm, and its
- 8:41protection through constitutional
- 8:42justice. We will come back to that, as
- 8:45well as sovereignty, democracy,
- 8:47political institutions, and how they
- 8:49relate to one another. For example, in
- 8:53the first semester, you study France,
- 8:55but not just France; you will also
- 8:57study the United Kingdom and its
- 8:58parliamentary system, specifically the
- 9:00importance of the Prime Minister and
- 9:02the much more subdued role of the
- 9:04monarch. And you will also study the
- 9:08separation and limitation of powers.
- 9:11There, you will encounter authors like
- 9:13John Locke or Montesquieu, and indeed,
- 9:16Montesquieu theorized the separation of
- 9:18powers, which we will return to. It is
- 9:22good to understand and know these great
- 9:23authors so you can do well on the day
- 9:25of your exam. And also, now this is
- 9:28more exceptional, it's not in all
- 9:29constitutional law courses, but it is
- 9:30related nonetheless. In general, what
- 9:33you also study are fundamental rights
- 9:34and freedoms. Because, regarding these
- 9:37fundamental rights and freedoms, very
- 9:39generally, you will understand that the
- 9:41constitution, and more broadly, the
- 9:43bloc of constitutionality, also aims to
- 9:46protect fundamental rights. And I am
- 9:48thinking in particular of the QPC. The
- 9:50QPC, it’s good to know what the QPC
- 9:52is, right, it’s an acronym. What is
- 9:55the QPC? It is the priority preliminary
- 9:58ruling on constitutionality, and it is
- 10:00a procedure that allows a litigant
- 10:01during a trial—that is, an individual
- 10:03involved in a lawsuit—to claim that
- 10:05such and such an article of law is
- 10:07contrary to the Constitution. Well,
- 10:09that serves to protect fundamental
- 10:11rights. And then finally, understanding
- 10:15the main idea is how to organize
- 10:17political power while framing its
- 10:18exercise to avoid what we call
- 10:20arbitrariness, meaning that political
- 10:22power acts without rules, without
- 10:23constraints. That is arbitrariness. It
- 10:26is an important concept to know and
- 10:28master, and even to bring up in your
- 10:29exam papers. Arbitrariness; when you
- 10:32say that constitutional law aims to
- 10:34limit arbitrariness, well, at least you
- 10:37show what the point of constitutional
- 10:39law is. OK, that is the definition of
- 10:43constitutional law. Now, what is the
- 10:47logic behind the constitutional law
- 10:49course? So, constitutional law is what
- 10:53you will study over two semesters, but
- 10:55here, what we are going to focus on is
- 10:58the general theory of the State.
- 11:01Meaning that you will have a fairly
- 11:03theoretical, fairly abstract, and
- 11:04fairly general approach, sometimes with
- 11:06concrete examples. But it is true that
- 11:09in the first semester, it is much more
- 11:10theory compared to the second semester,
- 11:12where we talk about concrete
- 11:13institutions, parliament, the
- 11:14government. And here, these are the
- 11:16major theories, the major notions, the
- 11:18major concepts of constitutional law
- 11:20that I am going to list for you and
- 11:21that you must absolutely know and
- 11:23understand. First notion to master well
- 11:25: the State; we will come back to that.
- 11:28Second notion to master: the
- 11:29constitution, and also the hierarchy of
- 11:31norms, since the two are linked. You
- 11:34know that with Kelsen, the constitution
- 11:36is placed at the top of the pyramid of
- 11:38norms. Next, you have sovereignty,
- 11:41which is also another important concept
- 11:43, and democracy. The separation of
- 11:46powers, and foreign and French
- 11:48political regimes. So, if you look at
- 11:51your constitutional law textbook,
- 11:54you'll see that you're essentially
- 11:56going over these major concepts again.
- 12:00And that's why it's important to
- 12:02understand there is a certain logic,
- 12:03since these are truly the fundamental
- 12:05principles of constitutional law. Okay?
- 12:09Now, let's try to dive a little deeper
- 12:12into the heart of the matter by
- 12:13discussing the different parts of a
- 12:15constitutional law course. Generally,
- 12:19in the first part, or an introduction,
- 12:21you will study the foundations of
- 12:23constitutional law. You will, in
- 12:25particular, find the definition of
- 12:27constitutional law. You will learn and
- 12:29understand that constitutional law and
- 12:32what is the distinction, what is the
- 12:34difference between public law and
- 12:36private law? And then you'll also
- 12:39discuss the hierarchy of norms, legal
- 12:42norms in particular, because
- 12:44constitutional law also uses this
- 12:46concept of a hierarchy of norms. Next,
- 12:51the second part—or the first part,
- 12:53depending on the introduction—is
- 12:55generally about the State. The State—
- 12:57what is the State? Understanding,
- 13:00through certain definitions, what the
- 13:02State actually is. What are the
- 13:04characteristics of the State? You know,
- 13:06the three fundamental characteristics:
- 13:09a territory, a population, and a
- 13:10sovereign power. Then, we will also
- 13:13talk about the concept of the rule of
- 13:15law. This is a concept you really must
- 13:17master, as you can use it very often in
- 13:19your papers, and it usually makes a
- 13:21great impression. What is the rule of
- 13:23law? It is the idea that citizens, of
- 13:26course, must respect the law, but those
- 13:28who govern must also respect the law.
- 13:31This means, for example, that when the
- 13:33Prime Minister adopts a decree, he must
- 13:35respect higher-ranking norms. He is
- 13:38subject to the rule of law. Yes, that
- 13:40is the concept of the rule of law. It
- 13:42helps protect freedoms. Meaning that if
- 13:45the governing official, the Prime
- 13:46Minister, has powers that are
- 13:48constrained, it protects individual
- 13:50freedom by avoiding arbitrary rule. As
- 13:53I said, it is this concept, this notion
- 13:56of arbitrariness, that comes up very
- 13:58often, where through the Constitution,
- 14:01we want to limit the arbitrary power of
- 14:04rulers found outside a constitutional
- 14:06regime. Anyway, for the rule of law,
- 14:09it's also important to understand the
- 14:12unitary state, what a unitary state is,
- 14:14the federal state, and the regional
- 14:16state, and to know two or three
- 14:18examples of unitary, federal, and
- 14:20regional states. A unitary state is
- 14:23France, right? Notably with
- 14:25centralization, decentralization,
- 14:28concentration, and deconcentration.
- 14:31What are the different concepts? What
- 14:33do they mean? That's a point to master
- 14:36well, and I take the time to explain it
- 14:38to you in my flashcard pack; I've put
- 14:39the link in the description. So, really
- 14:43knowing what a unitary state is,
- 14:44notably with this unity of the Republic
- 14:46, what a federal state is, and knowing
- 14:48the different federal states: the
- 14:50United States of course, but you also
- 14:52have Switzerland, you have Germany; in
- 14:54short, you have a whole bunch of
- 14:56examples of federal states, and then
- 14:58also the regional state. It's a bit of
- 15:01a mix of both; it's a hybrid regime
- 15:02between the unitary state and the
- 15:04federal state. And I'm thinking notably
- 15:07of the Italian regional state with its
- 15:09different regions, and then the
- 15:11autonomous communities of Spain, which
- 15:13also illustrate this concept of a
- 15:15regional state. And finally, there's a
- 15:18distinction to master well between
- 15:21centralization, decentralization,
- 15:23concentration, deconcentration, etc.
- 15:26Part 3, the constitution. There again,
- 15:28this is another big chunk of your
- 15:30constitutional law course, but it will
- 15:31really follow you, the constitution.
- 15:33You will study it in your 2nd year, 3rd
- 15:35year, even in your master's, and then
- 15:37for those taking the bar exam and other
- 15:39competitions, the concept and notion of
- 15:41the constitution come up very often. So
- 15:44, what you generally study regarding
- 15:47the Constitution is first this
- 15:49principle of constitutionalism. Agreed?
- 15:52What is constitutionalism? It is the
- 15:55act of limiting the governing power and
- 15:57protecting liberty, notably through a
- 15:59supreme rule: the constitution. You
- 16:03also generally study the notion of a
- 16:05constitution. You learn that it is the
- 16:07supreme legal act of a state that sets
- 16:10the rules for organizing political
- 16:13power and also protects fundamental
- 16:15rights. These are the two components of
- 16:17the constitution. In France, you know
- 16:20it, I hope. In any case, I urge you to
- 16:22know this date well. In France, the
- 16:24Constitution of the 5th Republic dates
- 16:26from October 4, 1958. That is a concept
- 16:29to master perfectly. Next, you have
- 16:32forms of constitution: a written
- 16:34constitution, as is the case for
- 16:35example in France with the '58
- 16:37Constitution or even the American
- 16:39Constitution of 1787. Conversely, you
- 16:43have the customary constitution, which
- 16:45leans more towards customs, traditions,
- 16:47and practices. And there, I am thinking
- 16:50notably of the British regime, which
- 16:52has a customary constitution; meaning
- 16:55the rules are not all mentioned in a
- 16:57single document. OK? Next, you also
- 17:01talk about what is called
- 17:03constitutional justice. Meaning, okay,
- 17:05it’s good to have a huge pyramid,
- 17:07it’s good to say that at the very top
- 17:08, there is the constitution. Now,
- 17:10it’s fine to say that, but concretely
- 17:13, in reality, it needs to be the case.
- 17:16Because it’s fine sometimes to invoke
- 17:19grand theories, but if, in practice,
- 17:21there is nothing to guarantee it, well,
- 17:23it’s useless to claim it. And so
- 17:26precisely, it is through the concept of
- 17:28constitutional justice. I don't know
- 17:31why I struggle with this "
- 17:32constitutional," I don't know how to
- 17:33pronounce it. Anyway, constitutional
- 17:36justice. well, you will learn that, for
- 17:40example, the law must respect the
- 17:42constitution and what mechanisms allow
- 17:44us to ensure that the law respects the
- 17:47constitution. This is what is known as
- 17:50the constitutional review of laws,
- 17:53right? Constitutional review of laws.
- 17:56Meaning you take the law passed by
- 17:58Parliament and the Constitutional
- 18:01Council will verify that this law
- 18:03respects the bloc and more generally
- 18:06the block of constitutionality. All
- 18:09right? So does the law respect the
- 18:11block of constitutionality? That is
- 18:13what is called the constitutional
- 18:15review of laws. And who is in charge of
- 18:17this control and verification, in your
- 18:18opinion? By the Constitutional Council,
- 18:22which is a new institution of the 5th
- 18:24Republic, since before '58, there was
- 18:27no concrete realization of
- 18:32constitutional justice. And so today,
- 18:35well, '58, the Constitutional Council
- 18:37is in charge of verifying that laws
- 18:39indeed respect the constitution. Next,
- 18:44you have this concept and what I just
- 18:45talked about, this concept, this notion
- 18:47of the block of constitutionality. What
- 18:50is it? The block of constitutionality
- 18:53is a whole set of rules, a set of
- 18:55principles and a set of texts that have
- 18:58constitutional value, that is, they
- 19:00have the highest value at the top of
- 19:02the pyramid of norms. And so, what is
- 19:04the consequence of this? It means that
- 19:07all lower norms, notably the law passed
- 19:09by parliament, the law must respect the
- 19:11block of constitutionality. And so this
- 19:13block of constitutionality, what is
- 19:15inside it? Well, obviously, there is
- 19:18the 1958 Constitution and its preamble.
- 19:22But you also learned, or you might
- 19:24learn, in 1971, a decision that you
- 19:26really need to know almost by heart for
- 19:28the exam, it’s the freedom of
- 19:30association decision where the
- 19:31Constitutional Council. So, what is
- 19:34this "freedom of association" decision?
- 19:37In a decision rendered in 1971, the
- 19:40Constitutional Council agreed to verify
- 19:43that a law respects the Constitution,
- 19:45specifically in relation to the 1958
- 19:48preamble. Right? And since the preamble
- 19:53includes various texts, such as the
- 19:55Declaration of the Rights of Man and
- 19:57the 1946 preamble, it follows that the
- 19:59Constitutional Council expanded its
- 20:01scope of review to what is now the bloc
- 20:03of constitutionality. It was with the
- 20:061971 decision that the desire to expand
- 20:09, let's say, the constitutional review
- 20:12of laws emerged. And it is since 1971
- 20:14that we have referred to the bloc of
- 20:16constitutionality. This means that when
- 20:19the Constitutional Council is tasked
- 20:20with verifying that a law respects the
- 20:22Constitution, it will obviously check
- 20:24that it complies with the 1958
- 20:25Constitution, but not only that. It
- 20:28will also check that the law respects
- 20:30the 1789 Declaration of the Rights of
- 20:32Man, the preamble to the 1946
- 20:35Constitution, the Charter for the
- 20:39Environment since 2005, and what we
- 20:41also call the PFRLR, meaning the
- 20:43fundamental principles recognized by
- 20:46the laws of the Republic. This is also
- 20:48a concept stemming from the 1971
- 20:49decision. So, you really need to master
- 20:52this notion of the bloc of
- 20:53constitutionality, as you will see it
- 20:55not only this year but in the following
- 20:56years as well, since it comes up very
- 20:58often. You must understand this
- 21:00mechanism for protecting fundamental
- 21:02rights. Okay? And finally, what you
- 21:06generally study in constitutional law
- 21:08is the constituent power, meaning the
- 21:10power related to the Constitution. And
- 21:13you know and learn, in particular, that
- 21:15there are two types of constituent
- 21:18power. The original constituent power
- 21:21and the derived constituent power. Okay
- 21:24? So, there is a distinction to be made
- 21:26between the two. The original
- 21:29constituent power is the drafting of
- 21:31the Constitution, and the derived
- 21:33constituent power is the revision or
- 21:35modification of the Constitution. So,
- 21:39it's really a big topic, constitutional
- 21:41law along with the Constitution. Then
- 21:44also, another important concept to
- 21:46master well is the concept of
- 21:47sovereignty. What is sovereignty? It is
- 21:50the supreme power of the State. Meaning
- 21:53that nothing is superior to the State.
- 21:55And you learn, in particular, that
- 21:57there are several distinctions
- 21:58regarding sovereignty. You have the
- 22:00distinction between internal
- 22:02sovereignty and external sovereignty.
- 22:04Internal sovereignty is within the
- 22:06country, on the territory of the
- 22:08Republic. In France, there is no
- 22:11institution superior to the State.
- 22:13Right? There are, for instance, no
- 22:15churches that would be superior to the
- 22:17State, since the State in France is
- 22:18sovereign. And then you also have this
- 22:20sovereignty which appears at the
- 22:22external level, that is to say at the
- 22:24international level, since States are
- 22:26placed on that plane on an equal
- 22:28footing. Now, there are today,
- 22:29nonetheless, some criticisms and some
- 22:31debates regarding this external
- 22:33sovereignty. Is France still sovereign
- 22:35at the international level when we
- 22:37think, in particular, of the importance
- 22:39of European Union law in France? So
- 22:42there are quite a few questions that
- 22:43arise regarding this subject of
- 22:45internal and external sovereignty. And
- 22:47then you also have a major, major
- 22:49distinction to master well between two
- 22:51forms of sovereignty. Ultimately, who
- 22:54holds sovereignty? You have, firstly,
- 22:58popular sovereignty, meaning that it is
- 23:00the people who hold sovereignty. And
- 23:03then on the other side, you have
- 23:04national sovereignty, where this time
- 23:06it is the nation. Concretely, generally
- 23:09speaking, what you must understand is
- 23:10that, first of all, people and nation
- 23:12are not the same thing. That, you
- 23:14really must master, and the distinction
- 23:16, you must master it well. Don't write
- 23:17just anything in your papers. So,
- 23:19popular sovereignty, national
- 23:21sovereignty. Popular sovereignty is a
- 23:23notion, a concept that was developed by
- 23:26—this is something to know,
- 23:27everything I say in the video must be
- 23:29mastered—Jean-Jacques Rousseau, the
- 23:31Genevan, a Swiss today, one might say.
- 23:35And Jean-Jacques Rousseau in his book,
- 23:36"The Social Contract," develops this
- 23:38concept of popular sovereignty by
- 23:40saying it is the people—that is to
- 23:42say, those who are in the State, the
- 23:43people who are part of the State—well
- 23:45, it is the people who have sovereignty
- 23:47. And so there are a whole host of
- 23:49consequences regarding the fact of
- 23:50saying that it is the people who have
- 23:52sovereignty. It really means thinking
- 23:53of it as a concrete notion. The people
- 23:54are the individuals who make up the
- 23:56country. And therefore, since it is the
- 23:58people—well, since it is the people,
- 24:00everyone holds a part of the
- 24:02sovereignty. That is why Rousseau, with
- 24:04his theory of popular sovereignty, will
- 24:07be keen to develop universal suffrage,
- 24:09since he considers that all the people
- 24:11have a share of the sovereignty. So
- 24:13that is truly sovereignty according to
- 24:15Rousseau, popular sovereignty. And then
- 24:17conversely, you have national
- 24:19sovereignty, which this time is no
- 24:20longer linked to Rousseau but to
- 24:22another great author to know in
- 24:23constitutional law, Abbé Sieyès. The
- 24:27source of this concept of national
- 24:29sovereignty is his very famous book "
- 24:31What Is the Third Estate?" from 1789,
- 24:34another reference to know, and this
- 24:37time he no longer bases it on the
- 24:39notion of the people, but on the notion
- 24:42of the nation. For him, it's the nation
- 24:45. It's the nation, it's something
- 24:46abstract, you see. The nation is
- 24:48something abstract. And so, since it's
- 24:50something abstract, to make it concrete
- 24:52, we need representatives. And that's
- 24:56why, very often, we'll have this idea
- 24:58of representative democracy, since the
- 25:00nation—meaning individuals linked by
- 25:02a whole set of values, a whole set of
- 25:04cultures, a whole set of languages, or
- 25:07even a common language, for example, a
- 25:09common culture, common values—well,
- 25:11for instance, that's what makes up the
- 25:13French nation. And since it's a very
- 25:17theoretical, very abstract notion, and
- 25:20we can't touch the French nation,
- 25:22Sieyès says that we need
- 25:23representatives to express the general
- 25:26will of the nation. Alright? And so it
- 25:30is through this concept of national
- 25:33sovereignty that we end up with
- 25:35representative democracy. Meaning there
- 25:38are representatives, and this national
- 25:41sovereignty, on the other hand, tends
- 25:44to justify restricted suffrage, notably
- 25:48census suffrage. I don't know if that
- 25:51rings a bell, but it's the suffrage
- 25:53that limits the right to vote to people
- 25:55who pay a specific tax based on a
- 25:57certain level of wealth. Anyway, I
- 25:59won't go into more detail than that,
- 26:01but popular sovereignty and national
- 26:02sovereignty, you need to have that
- 26:03straight. What is the difference
- 26:05between people and nation? What is the
- 26:07theory, and what are the consequences
- 26:09of Rousseau's theory and Sieyès's
- 26:11theory? All right? Part 5 as well, what
- 26:14you will study is democracy. Democracy,
- 26:16as you know, is power of the people, by
- 26:18the people, and for the people. This
- 26:20great quote by Abraham Lincoln, which
- 26:22is generally quite prominent. So what
- 26:25is democracy? First, that's what you
- 26:27will see. What is the difference
- 26:29between direct democracy, which is dear
- 26:32to Rousseau, where the people
- 26:34participate actively in decisions, and
- 26:36how does it differ from representative
- 26:38democracy, which this time is dear to
- 26:40Sieyès, with representatives who
- 26:42represent the nation. And then also,
- 26:46you have a system in between,
- 26:47semi-direct democracy, where you have
- 26:50within the nation, you have, you go
- 26:52into the state, mechanisms of
- 26:53sovereignty of representative democracy
- 26:56, since, well for example, there will
- 26:58be representatives, deputies, right,
- 27:00concretely in France, and then mixed
- 27:02with that, mixed with these elements of
- 27:05representative democracy. You are going
- 27:07to have elements of direct democracy
- 27:09and I am thinking in particular of the
- 27:11referendum. Do you know what a
- 27:13referendum is? The referendum is
- 27:15precisely a procedure that allows the
- 27:17people to participate directly in the
- 27:20voting or not of a law. All right? That
- 27:22is the referendum. It is truly a
- 27:24mechanism of direct democracy. We also
- 27:27very often talk to you about suffrage,
- 27:29right, suffrage which is an important
- 27:31notion since it is the right to vote in
- 27:33elections and you learn in particular
- 27:35that there are different
- 27:36classifications, different distinctions
- 27:38regarding suffrage. You have universal
- 27:40suffrage or restricted suffrage, all
- 27:43right? Universal suffrage, the right to
- 27:45vote belongs to everyone subject to a
- 27:48few rules, notably regarding age. In
- 27:50France, right, it is direct universal
- 27:52suffrage. That means that everyone can
- 27:55participate in the election, for
- 27:56example, of the President of the
- 27:57Republic. But there are still
- 27:59conditions of principle, notably with
- 28:01questions linked to age. So you must be
- 28:03, you must be 18 years old and
- 28:05conditions linked in particular to
- 28:07nationality, being French. So that is
- 28:09universal suffrage and also restricted
- 28:11suffrage. Conversely, restricted
- 28:13suffrage is where we grant the right to
- 28:16vote to certain people, notably to the
- 28:18wealthiest people with census suffrage.
- 28:21So that is the first distinction
- 28:22regarding suffrage. You have a second
- 28:24distinction, direct suffrage and
- 28:25indirect suffrage. Direct suffrage, you
- 28:28vote directly for the representatives,
- 28:30that is to say that, for example, for
- 28:32the election of the President of the
- 28:33Republic, well, you vote directly for
- 28:35the President of the Republic. And
- 28:38conversely, you have indirect suffrage
- 28:40where you will participate indirectly
- 28:43in the designation of the
- 28:45representative. And I am thinking in
- 28:48particular here of democracy, of the
- 28:50indirect suffrage of the American
- 28:52presidential election where, precisely,
- 28:55citizens will vote for a college of
- 28:57electors and these electors will then
- 28:59vote themselves for representatives.
- 29:03All right? So that is direct and
- 29:04indirect suffrage. In France, the
- 29:07example often given for indirect
- 29:09suffrage is the senatorial election,
- 29:12with the election of senators, where
- 29:15you ultimately participate indirectly
- 29:18in the designation of these members.
- 29:21Next, you have the different voting
- 29:23systems, so it’s important to first
- 29:24understand the various classifications.
- 29:26There are really two main distinctions
- 29:28you need to know. List-based voting
- 29:30versus single-member voting and
- 29:32two-member voting. For list-based, you
- 29:34vote for a list. Single-member, you
- 29:36vote for one name. Two-member, for two
- 29:39names. So, you really need to
- 29:41understand the purpose of these
- 29:42different voting systems. And then, you
- 29:46also have a major distinction between
- 29:48the majority principle and, conversely,
- 29:51proportional representation. My advice
- 29:55regarding voting systems is to make
- 29:57sure you understand how they work. But
- 29:59above all—and this is what I did in
- 30:01the study sheets because I think it’s
- 30:03the most important for an exam or a
- 30:04midterm—is to understand what these
- 30:06voting systems are for. What is the
- 30:08impact of choosing one voting system
- 30:10over another? For example, I'll take
- 30:12the typical case of proportional
- 30:13representation. Well, if an election
- 30:16uses proportional representation, it
- 30:18will particularly favor
- 30:19representativeness. Meaning that
- 30:23parties are better reflected in the
- 30:26results. Whereas if you use a majority
- 30:29principle instead, it will really favor
- 30:32the major parties. While proportional
- 30:37voting systems favor multiple parties,
- 30:40resulting in better representation for
- 30:43the voters. And finally, you have
- 30:46elements concerning political parties,
- 30:48which have constitutional recognition
- 30:51and are mentioned in the Constitution.
- 30:53I also recommend knowing the current
- 30:56major political parties to understand
- 30:59and even apply the course material in
- 31:01your essays. All right? Next, in
- 31:05constitutional law, we study the
- 31:07separation of powers. You will study
- 31:10what the separation of powers is,
- 31:12notably with the two essential authors,
- 31:14John Locke and Montesquieu, who
- 31:16theorized it. And the idea behind the
- 31:19separation of powers is to first state
- 31:20that the powers are separate.
- 31:22Legislative power, executive power, and
- 31:24judicial power, because as Montesquieu
- 31:26said, any man who has power is inclined
- 31:29to abuse it. So, distinguishing the
- 31:31powers is the first step. And then, and
- 31:33we really owe this to Montesquieu.
- 31:35These powers have means of action
- 31:37against each other, right? Meaning that
- 31:39, ultimately, the legislative branch
- 31:41has a means of acting on the executive.
- 31:44Parliament has a means of acting on the
- 31:46government, notably the motion of
- 31:47censure, which allows Parliament to
- 31:49bring down the government. All right?
- 31:51It's about understanding all these
- 31:53elements, the separation of powers, and
- 31:55realizing that not only are powers
- 31:57separated, but each branch has means of
- 32:00action. Obviously, depending on the
- 32:02state, you will have different
- 32:03applications of the separation of
- 32:05powers. The concept of the separation
- 32:08of powers in the United Kingdom is not
- 32:10the same as it is in the United States.
- 32:13It’s not exactly the same thing,
- 32:15because in the United States, you have
- 32:17a rigid separation of powers, meaning
- 32:19the powers are truly independent and
- 32:20there are very few means of action or
- 32:22oversight, though they do exist, it's
- 32:24the theory of checks and balances. And
- 32:28that is the rigid separation of powers,
- 32:31meaning the powers are strictly and
- 32:33independently separated. On the other
- 32:36hand, you have the flexible separation
- 32:38of powers, where this time the powers
- 32:39are separated but they have significant
- 32:41means of action over one another.
- 32:43Parliament can bring down the
- 32:45government with a motion of no
- 32:47confidence, for example, and conversely
- 32:49, the President of the Republic can
- 32:52dissolve parliament. So you see, there
- 32:54are means of action, which would truly
- 32:55be proper and dear to Montesquieu. And
- 32:57depending on the state, the separation
- 32:59of powers is not applied with the same
- 33:00intensity. And finally, what you also
- 33:04study in constitutional law are
- 33:06political regimes. Political regimes—
- 33:09the two major regimes you absolutely
- 33:11must master are the parliamentary
- 33:12system and the presidential system.
- 33:15Those are the two you really need to
- 33:16know. And what I also recommend is to
- 33:19know the major states politically: the
- 33:22United Kingdom, the United States,
- 33:24Germany, and then a few other foreign
- 33:27regimes for comparison. I am thinking,
- 33:29in particular, of Switzerland.
- 33:30Switzerland, which is a federal state
- 33:32but has a quite unique structure. And
- 33:34you also have Belgium. Belgium, also a
- 33:37federal structure, so it is a federal
- 33:39state but with a particular
- 33:40organization. So, knowing these
- 33:42different elements well is important in
- 33:43my view. And finally, know the French
- 33:46political regime, because even if you
- 33:48see it in the second semester, it’s
- 33:50good to understand how it actually
- 33:52works in France, so try to see, for
- 33:55example, what type of sovereignty is
- 33:57exercised in France. You will learn
- 33:59that it is both popular and national.
- 34:02What is the constitution? What are the
- 34:04constitutional rules? All of this
- 34:06should be mastered in my opinion, even
- 34:08if you don't cover it in class.
- 34:10Everything I've said, you need to
- 34:11master it. All right? So, I’m having
- 34:14a little drink because, believe it or
- 34:16not, I’ve been going for 35 minutes.
- 34:21Now, what is expected of you in
- 34:23constitutional law? Well, I told you at
- 34:26the start of the video, don't be
- 34:29descriptive; really step back. You have
- 34:33knowledge, but you just recite it in
- 34:36your paper. That is being too
- 34:38descriptive. Instead, you have the
- 34:41knowledge—the course, maybe my study
- 34:44sheets—and you will explain it in
- 34:46your own words, and above all, you will
- 34:49demonstrate. All right? It's not about
- 34:52recitation; it's about explanation and
- 34:54demonstration, okay? It's about proving
- 34:57and demonstrating something; you have
- 34:59the subject, the subject you'll be
- 35:00given, and you need to problematize it.
- 35:02You're going to create a problem
- 35:04statement. And based on that problem
- 35:06statement, you will answer yes or no.
- 35:09All right? And there, you must
- 35:10demonstrate it. Why yes, why no? Why
- 35:13yes, why but? Why no? Why but? All
- 35:16right? Knowledge, explanation,
- 35:19demonstration. Also, what you must
- 35:23avoid is using the wrong terms at the
- 35:25wrong time. In other words, using the
- 35:28right terms at the right time is what
- 35:29you need to do. For starters, don't
- 35:32confuse the people with the nation. We
- 35:36saw earlier Rousseau's popular
- 35:38sovereignty and Sieyès' national
- 35:41sovereignty. Okay. Another important
- 35:45distinction to know is the difference
- 35:47between a federal state and a
- 35:49confederation. A federal state is the
- 35:52United States; a confederation is used
- 35:54less and less. All right? And watch out
- 35:57, there's a little trap, I'm thinking
- 35:59of it because you might fall for it.
- 36:01Switzerland, in fact, the official name
- 36:03of the political system is the
- 36:05Confederation. It is a confederation,
- 36:07the Swiss Confederation. Except in
- 36:09reality, it's not a confederation at
- 36:11all; it's a federal state. So, there's
- 36:12this little trap you need to keep in
- 36:14mind. But knowing the difference
- 36:16between a federal state and a
- 36:18confederation well, that is also an
- 36:20important element. You also have the
- 36:23distinction between—I just saw I made
- 36:26a small typo—decentralization and
- 36:28deconcentration, understanding the real
- 36:31difference between the two.
- 36:34Understanding that in deconcentration,
- 36:36it's still the administration, it's
- 36:38still the State acting. Whereas in
- 36:41decentralization, it will be the local
- 36:42authorities, the department,
- 36:44municipality, or region. And also to
- 36:46understand that a parliamentary system
- 36:48is not necessarily a system with a
- 36:50parliament. Well, generally speaking,
- 36:52it is. But, how should I put it, a
- 36:55system with a parliament isn't
- 36:56necessarily a parliamentary system,
- 36:58because, for example, in the United
- 37:00States, there is a parliament, which we
- 37:02call Congress, with the House of
- 37:03Representatives and the Senate. It is a
- 37:06parliament. However, as you know, in
- 37:08the United States, it is a presidential
- 37:10system. So, be careful not to make that
- 37:12mistake. And, in particular, what is a
- 37:14parliamentary system recognized by?
- 37:16It's because there are reciprocal means
- 37:18of action between the different powers,
- 37:21the 10 references to know almost by
- 37:23heart at the very least. There are many
- 37:26others, and perhaps as we go through
- 37:28this list, some will come to mind, but
- 37:30you must master these. First, we have
- 37:33Locke with his Two Treatises of
- 37:35Government from 1690, notably his
- 37:37theory on the separation of powers. You
- 37:41have Montesquieu with The Spirit of the
- 37:42Laws, also concerning the separation of
- 37:44powers. You have Rousseau with The
- 37:46Social Contract in 1762, with his
- 37:48theory of popular sovereignty. Popular
- 37:51sovereignty. You have Sieyès,
- 37:54precisely with the work What Is the
- 37:57Third Estate? written in 1789. You also
- 38:02have Article 16 of the Declaration of
- 38:04the Rights of Man and of the Citizen,
- 38:05which is important regarding the
- 38:07separation of powers, as it states that
- 38:08any state without a separation of
- 38:10powers has no constitution. So, an
- 38:12article to know, and obviously also to
- 38:15understand a bit about the functioning
- 38:17of the American constitution, with the
- 38:191787 constitution of course, but also
- 38:22the various amendments added. This also
- 38:25concerns constitutional justice, with
- 38:28the 1803 Marbury v. Madison case by the
- 38:32Supreme Court, which established what
- 38:35we call judicial review of laws in
- 38:37America, and then France, and Europe
- 38:40more generally, would take some time to
- 38:43assimilate this concept. It would
- 38:47notably require Kelsen, who speaks
- 38:49about and imports this theory into
- 38:51France, leading to the fact that today
- 38:53in France, we also have the
- 38:54constitutional review of laws. But back
- 38:57then in 1803, so you see the American
- 38:59constitution is from 1787, and then in
- 39:021803, the American judges, the American
- 39:04Supreme Court, recognized its
- 39:05competence to perform what is called
- 39:07judicial review. This means, concretely
- 39:10, the control of constitutionality. You
- 39:13also have the concept of the German
- 39:16Basic Law. It is a concept that you
- 39:18will see throughout your constitutional
- 39:19law course. But the German Basic Law,
- 39:21what is it? It is the name given to the
- 39:24German constitution. That is to say, in
- 39:27France, our constitution is the
- 39:28constitution of October 4, 1958. It has
- 39:31no special name, whereas in Germany,
- 39:33this constitution has a specific name.
- 39:35It is what is called the German Basic
- 39:39Law, which was adopted after the 1939
- 39:42–1945 war. Next, you have, as I have
- 39:46already mentioned, the freedom of
- 39:48association decision. Precisely, the
- 39:51Constitutional Council recognizes its
- 39:52authority to protect fundamental rights
- 39:54. 1971, you have the two forms of
- 39:58review: prior review and post-review
- 40:00with the QPC, Article 61-1. In short,
- 40:04all these notions and many others must
- 40:06be known, but these are the ones I find
- 40:08essential to master. Now, we will end
- 40:12the video with a tip to get a passing
- 40:14grade every time; it works almost every
- 40:17time: using the major fundamental
- 40:19principles. In my pack, I list these
- 40:22different fundamental principles for
- 40:24you and I define them. But here, we
- 40:26will try to see why it can be useful to
- 40:28refer to fundamental principles.
- 40:31Because what you have to understand is
- 40:33that in a dissertation—what is
- 40:34expected of you, in a commentary too—
- 40:36is to take a step back, to say: "Okay,
- 40:38this concerns such an element of my
- 40:40course, but I will now look at what the
- 40:42interest is in relation to
- 40:43constitutional law as a whole." And so
- 40:45the idea is to tie yourself to
- 40:47fundamental principles, notably the
- 40:49principle of the rule of law. That is a
- 40:52principle that is well-received and
- 40:53works very well, very often. The rule
- 40:55of law, the hierarchy of norms, the
- 40:58principle of continuity,
- 40:59constitutionalism. The principle of
- 41:01constitutionalism, that is also good to
- 41:03put in your papers. Constitutional
- 41:05justice, there too, constitutional
- 41:08review, et cetera. Legalism, what is
- 41:11legalism? Well, you know, egocentrism
- 41:14is when one is at the center of
- 41:16everything. Well, legalism is when the
- 41:18law, the law is at the center of
- 41:20everything. And this concept was quite
- 41:24present at the beginning in 1958, but
- 41:27even before 1958, and with 1958, we
- 41:30were keen to regulate this legalism,
- 41:33notably with higher norms. The concept
- 41:36of arbitrariness, that is to say, we
- 41:38come to limit it; with arbitrariness,
- 41:40we want to limit arbitrariness, so how
- 41:42do we do it? Well, we are going to set
- 41:44rules so that, uh, so that the
- 41:46governing authorities respect the law.
- 41:49So there it is: rule of law, hierarchy
- 41:52of norms, constitutionalism,
- 41:54constitutional justice, arbitrariness,
- 41:57sovereignty, government by judges,
- 41:59general will, democracy, pluralism,
- 42:02majoritarian principle, democratic
- 42:04legitimacy, balance of powers, checks
- 42:07and balances, political accountability,
- 42:09parliamentarism, rationalized
- 42:11parliamentary system, everything. So,
- 42:15master all these concepts and whenever
- 42:18you have an essay, try to anchor
- 42:20yourself to these concepts, dig into
- 42:22this list and ask yourself if there is
- 42:25a concept here that might be relevant
- 42:28to your exam. All right? So that is
- 42:30truly a strategy that works every
- 42:31single time. Very often, if you manage
- 42:35to write great titles and headings
- 42:36using terms like rule of law,
- 42:38constitutional justice, or
- 42:40constitutionalism, the professor......
- 42:44will see that you have a comprehensive
- 42:46approach to constitutional law. Okay?
- 42:50So, that’s what we had to say
- 42:51regarding constitutional law. Let’s
- 42:53do a quick summary of what we’ve
- 42:54covered together. Constitutional law
- 42:57studies the organization, exercise, and
- 42:59limitation of power, notably through
- 43:01the constitution and the separation of
- 43:04powers. The state, the constitution,
- 43:06sovereignty, and democracy are truly
- 43:08the key foundations to master in this
- 43:09subject. The separation of powers,
- 43:12which is an essential concept, helps to
- 43:14clearly understand the organization of
- 43:16institutions and distinguish between
- 43:18the parliamentary and presidential
- 43:19systems. The constitution frames power
- 43:23and keeps it in check, notably through
- 43:27constitutional review. And finally, to
- 43:31succeed, don't just recite; define,
- 43:34distinguish, illustrate, and above all,
- 43:37demonstrate. All right? Now, if you
- 43:40want to save time in your
- 43:41constitutional law studies and you like
- 43:43this teaching style, click the link in
- 43:45the description to access my
- 43:46constitutional law study guides.
- 43:48Honestly, I put all my heart and soul
- 43:51into these guides. So I hope they will
- 43:53be useful to you. That’s it, see you
- 43:55very soon. Take care of yourselves. Bye
- 43:56!
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Droit constitutionnel : l'essentiel à savoir (L1 droit) by Jurixio - Les vidéos de droit, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 7,061 words across 1,154 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.