Dr. Paul Kengor | The Dark Side of Marxism — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Point three in the Communist Manifesto
- 0:02calls for abolition of all right of
- 0:04inheritance. What hypocrisy. Markx and
- 0:06Engles got all their money through
- 0:08inheritance.
- 0:11Most students of most universities who
- 0:13take [music] a course on Marxism are
- 0:15going to get a promark perspective.
- 0:17People say, "Well, the Communist
- 0:18Manifesto is a pretty good book." I'm
- 0:20like, "Well, have you read it?" I think
- 0:21what's most commonly misunderstood about
- 0:23[music] Marxism is the idea that it's
- 0:25about sharing and helping your fellow
- 0:27man. I mean, it's not that at all. The
- 0:29word love is hardly mentioned at all in
- 0:31the communist manifesto. And when it is,
- 0:32it has nothing to do with loving your
- 0:34neighbor. People who take this course
- 0:36here. They're going to get the actual
- 0:38truth.
- 0:42Communism abolishes eternal [music]
- 0:43truths. It abolishes all religion and
- 0:46all morality. When you encounter an
- 0:48ideology that evil [music] and that
- 0:51destructive, it is the most colossal
- 0:53case of political carnage in history. I
- 0:56feel compelled to share [music] that
- 0:58with other people. This guy is no
- 0:59tinkerer. This is a guy who wants to
- 1:02take it all down. This is an ideology
- 1:05and a man [music] thinking of pure
- 1:06destruction.
- 1:09Hey everybody, welcome. Great to have
- 1:11you all here. So this series we're doing
- 1:13on Marx and Marxism, looking at the dark
- 1:16side of Karl Marx as as well as Marxism.
- 1:19Tell you a little bit about about
- 1:20myself, my background. So, I'm from
- 1:23western Pennsylvania, which is quite a
- 1:25distance from where we are in this
- 1:27studio right now. But I was born in born
- 1:29in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. So,
- 1:32December 1966. You could figure out my
- 1:34my age from there. Was actually raised
- 1:36in the town of Butler, Pennsylvania,
- 1:38which is now kind of infamous of all of
- 1:41all well, not infamous because the
- 1:43president president was shot there, but
- 1:45didn't die there mercifully. But I'll
- 1:47tell you, that's a weird thing. when
- 1:48when the high school that you graduated
- 1:50from in class of 1984, Butler High
- 1:52School, that was uh that was quite a
- 1:54shock to have that be something like
- 1:56that happen in your hometown. But I went
- 1:59to I went to school, University of
- 2:00Pittsburgh as an undergraduate. I
- 2:02actually was a premed major. I talked to
- 2:05Jordan Peterson about this when he
- 2:07interviewed me back in the summer of
- 2:082024. I worked for a a pioneering
- 2:12transplant surgeon named Dr. Dr. Thomas
- 2:15Starzel. So that was 1987 to 1991 and it
- 2:18it was during that time that I was
- 2:21premed a biochem bioysics major that the
- 2:24cold war was was was ending and it was
- 2:28the end of the Reagan presidency. Berlin
- 2:31wall came down in 1989, collapse of
- 2:34Soviet communism 1991. So I I was really
- 2:37taken by by those events and really got
- 2:40pulled into that and ended up writing
- 2:43for the student newspaper, became the
- 2:45editorial page editor for the student
- 2:46newspaper in those days back when they
- 2:49had print editions of newspapers. They
- 2:51don't have that many anymore, but we
- 2:52were a we were a daily campus newspaper.
- 2:55Well, at least daily Monday through
- 2:57Thursday. So every day I'm writing
- 2:59editorials and writing oped columns
- 3:01about the end of the Cold War. And I am
- 3:05all my premed studies working at
- 3:07Presbyterian University Hospital,
- 3:09Children's Hospital in Pittsburgh, I'm
- 3:11constantly just following the Reagan
- 3:14presidency and Gorbachev and John Paul
- 3:16II, Margaret Thatcher, Vaklav Havl,
- 3:19Lewissa, all of these events. And
- 3:21eventually I had to make a choice about
- 3:23which way I was going to take my career.
- 3:25So I decided after, and this was
- 3:28agonizing, this was a tough decision,
- 3:29right? I mean, you're kind of on your
- 3:30way to medical school. And I and I
- 3:33decided to end up studying international
- 3:36relations, foreign policy, Soviet
- 3:38history, Marxism, communism. So that
- 3:42ended up being my route instead. Went to
- 3:44graduate school in Washington DC,
- 3:46American University, School of
- 3:47International Service. And eventually I
- 3:50got I was hired by Grove City College,
- 3:53which is in Grove City, Pennsylvania.
- 3:55and that's amazingly only a half hour
- 3:57from my home in in Butler, Pennsylvania.
- 4:00And I've been teaching there since 1997.
- 4:03My first book other than my
- 4:06dissertation, which doesn't really
- 4:07count. No one reads a dissertation, but
- 4:09it was published, but dissertation was a
- 4:11book called God and Ronald Reagan, which
- 4:13came out in 2004.
- 4:15And that book and the one that followed
- 4:18which is the crusader Ronald Reagan and
- 4:20the fall of communism led to the Reagan
- 4:23movie starring Dennis Quaid that came
- 4:25out in August 2024. So that that movie
- 4:29is based on my book the crusader Ronald
- 4:31Reagan and the fall of communism. That
- 4:34led to a number of other books including
- 4:36a book I did a Pope and a President on
- 4:39Ronald Reagan John Paul II and the end
- 4:41of the cold war. I think I've done in
- 4:43total
- 4:45over 20 books and I uh they include the
- 4:50one that caught Jordan Peterson's eye,
- 4:52this one, The Devil and Carl Marx. And
- 4:54so that really this book and the
- 4:56conversation that I had with Jordan
- 4:59really inspired us to to to do this. And
- 5:02Jordan had asked me, he said um he said,
- 5:05"I'd like you to speak in my in my
- 5:06Jordan Peterson Academy." And I said,
- 5:08"Yeah, I'd love to. I'd love to." So I
- 5:10think at this point we're talking right
- 5:12now it's about a year and a half two
- 5:14years ago. So glad we glad we made it
- 5:17happen. I'm also I've got to put out
- 5:19this plug editor of the American
- 5:21Spectator which has been an a fantastic
- 5:25publication founded by RMTell Jr. on the
- 5:29campus of Indiana University in
- 5:31Bloomington in 1967.
- 5:34So, it is it's been around now almost
- 5:38almost 60 years. We're still in print.
- 5:41We print a couple we do a couple print
- 5:43editions per year, but we're mainly
- 5:45online. So, spectator.org is the is the
- 5:48is the website for that. All right. So,
- 5:51that's a little bit about my background.
- 5:53I could say a lot more, but I don't want
- 5:54to talk too much about myself. We want
- 5:57to talk about Karl Marx, Markx and
- 5:59Marxism. Altogether, we've got eight
- 6:02lectures in this series. I will
- 6:04eventually read from the text itself at
- 6:07one point the communist manifesto and
- 6:09it's not a very long book right
- 6:12everybody thinks I hear young people all
- 6:14the time that say oh the communist
- 6:16manifesto is a pretty good book if you
- 6:18just read it right I'm like well have
- 6:20you read it and it's very clear that
- 6:22they haven't and I'll tell them well
- 6:24read it because it's not going to take
- 6:26you a lot of time in fact it's not
- 6:29actually even that long because this has
- 6:32several preferences intro pros forward
- 6:35afterward. The text itself is about
- 6:3750ome pages. So, it's not it's not that
- 6:40long of a book.
- 6:42All right. So, I'll start with we're
- 6:44going to go chronologically through the
- 6:46series. So we'll start with Markx and
- 6:49where Marx was born, his upbringing, and
- 6:51then eventually when Marx meets Engles,
- 6:53then when the manifesto comes out,
- 6:55February 1848, and then we'll even go
- 6:58after that point through Bolevik,
- 6:59Russia, 1917 up through the end of the
- 7:02Cold War. One of the subjects I want to
- 7:04hit in this series that doesn't get
- 7:06talked about enough, but I spent a lot
- 7:08of time on it in this book, The Devil
- 7:09and Carl Marx, is the infiltration of
- 7:11churches.
- 7:13>> What's it called?
- 7:14>> Peterson Academy.
- 7:15>> Peterson Academy. Peterson Academy.
- 7:17>> It's called Peterson Academy.
- 7:18>> Peterson Academy. If you want an actual
- 7:20education
- 7:21>> with hand selected professors from top
- 7:24universities around the world,
- 7:26>> bringing the best professors together,
- 7:28making sure they're not censored in any
- 7:29way, giving them the audience and the
- 7:31remuneration and appreciation they
- 7:32deserve.
- 7:32>> And you were true to your word. You gave
- 7:34me absolute intellectual autonomy. I
- 7:36have had it through every course. We
- 7:37figure we can offer people a highquality
- 7:40university level education for under
- 7:42$2,000.
- 7:43>> Well, congratulations, Jordan. It's
- 7:44honestly brilliant. I can't wait to
- 7:45enroll myself. I'll be doing that
- 7:47straight after this.
- 7:49>> Fun your pre
- 7:54>> That's a a shocking really shocking
- 7:58thing that the that the communists did
- 8:00and people people aren't aware of it.
- 8:02They were we were aware of it in the day
- 8:04but people today don't don't talk about
- 8:06it much at all. All right. So to begin
- 8:08with the person of Karl Marx. So Markx
- 8:11was born May 5th, 1818. He was born in
- 8:16Trier, Germany. Now Trier is spelled
- 8:19almost like you'd pronounce it Trier. T
- 8:22R I E R. And remarkably, this was one of
- 8:26the most religious cities in all of
- 8:29Germany and and all of Europe. The great
- 8:33cathedral of Trier, which is, you know,
- 8:35Markx grew up really in the shadow of of
- 8:38that cathedral. what dates back to about
- 8:41the year 330. So I mean this goes back
- 8:451700 years. It's one of the oldest
- 8:47cathedrals in in Germany. Markx that
- 8:51cathedral is so old. It was founded in
- 8:54part built in part financed in part by
- 8:57Helena St. Helena who is the mother of
- 9:01none other than Constantine. Right?
- 9:03Constantine was the Roman emperor who
- 9:07brought freedom and protection to
- 9:10Christians in the Roman Empire after
- 9:12several centuries of persecution of
- 9:14Christians. Helena is the one who she so
- 9:18she obviously was a woman of means. She
- 9:20had money. She went to the Holy Land,
- 9:22made a fa a a famous pilgrimage to the
- 9:24Holy Land around the year 320 and she
- 9:27came back with several different relics
- 9:29which she believed were relics or told
- 9:32were were were relics. One of them was
- 9:34the Holy Cross, the cross itself which
- 9:38today is is in a cathedral in Spain. And
- 9:41there are parts of the Holy Cross,
- 9:43relics, you know, little pieces of it
- 9:45that are recognized by the Vatican and,
- 9:47you know, in different churches around
- 9:49the world. Some people have said, "Well,
- 9:51if you add up all the pieces, the cross
- 9:52will be as big as this room." I don't
- 9:54think that's quite true. I think that's
- 9:56people being cynical about it. But she
- 9:59brought back what she believed was was
- 10:01the original cross. She brought back the
- 10:04lance, the the lance that the that
- 10:07linus, the the Roman soldier at the foot
- 10:10of the cross stuck into the side of
- 10:12Jesus. That is in the Vatican today.
- 10:16She brought back the crown of thorns
- 10:19with which she was told and they believe
- 10:21is the crown of thorns and that is
- 10:24anyone know where that is today? It's in
- 10:27Notradam in Paris. In fact, when
- 10:29Notradam caught on fire a few years ago,
- 10:33a heroic priest ran in and you know
- 10:36grabbed the crown of thorns and you know
- 10:38put it up close and ran it through the
- 10:40flames to get it out of there and
- 10:42protect it. Now this relates to the
- 10:44cathedral and trer. She brought back the
- 10:46robe that that Jesus wore that the Roman
- 10:49soldiers cast lots for at the foot at
- 10:51the foot of the cross. And that robe is
- 10:54in the cathedral in Trier today.
- 10:57Different Christians will make
- 10:59pilgrimage there certain times of year
- 11:01when they venerate the holy robe. So
- 11:03it's a it is a it is a sacred relic. Now
- 11:08quite remarkably
- 11:10that that relic that robe did Karl Marx
- 11:13know about it? Oh yeah, of course.
- 11:15Everyone who grew up in Trier obviously
- 11:17knew knew about that. Markx in one of
- 11:20his devilish plays where called the
- 11:23player where he has this violinist who's
- 11:26sawing away with his violin and
- 11:28summoning up the powers of darkness.
- 11:30I'll read a quote from it in a minute.
- 11:33Markx not only did the not Markx was a
- 11:37playwright so not only wrote the script
- 11:38for the play but he also did the staging
- 11:40and production and also the costumes. He
- 11:43has his player his violinist as he's
- 11:46summoning up the powers of darkness
- 11:48wearing the holy robe that Jesus wore.
- 11:51So kind of mocking it. And in one case,
- 11:54Markx and his wife Jenny, Jenny is is
- 11:58making fun of these kind of like
- 12:00superstitious fools who come to town
- 12:03each year for this pilgrimage to to
- 12:06check out the Holy Robe. [snorts] I'll
- 12:08read from that poem right now. I I open
- 12:12the book with
- 12:14quotes from two different Mark's plays.
- 12:18And as Jordan Peterson noticed and
- 12:20really caught on to this,
- 12:23I mean, Jordan pointed out, Jordan said
- 12:26to me that when he was a professor and
- 12:28he would ask students to do writing, he
- 12:30he noticed that they would often do
- 12:32poetry because poetry really told them
- 12:36was really a way to express themselves
- 12:38and really showed a lot about the about
- 12:40the particular student. Well, it's
- 12:42fascinating that Markx wanted to be a
- 12:43poet. He fancied himself a poet. Markx
- 12:46more than anything else. I mean Markx
- 12:49was clearly not an economist. All right.
- 12:54This guy would have been a lousy
- 12:55economist. He was he was a philosopher
- 12:59really a kind of pmacist, right? I mean
- 13:02the communist manifesto is kind of a
- 13:04pmic kind of a diet tribe really but but
- 13:08poetry I mean poetry was was his thing.
- 13:11I'll read from Robert Payne who was one
- 13:15of the best biographers of Marx that's
- 13:18forgotten about. He did around late
- 13:201960s early 1970s
- 13:23two seinal volumes on Marx. Payne was a
- 13:27British professor man of letters. He was
- 13:31a reviewer of plays, poems, literature.
- 13:34He was no, you know, like hardline
- 13:36conservative or right-wing or anything
- 13:38like that. pretty pretty a-political
- 13:41and he pointed out he he did two
- 13:44different books 1968 marks a biography
- 13:48and the 1971 book the unknown Karl Marx
- 13:51and the second book was published by New
- 13:53York University Press the first book was
- 13:55published by Simon and Schustster so
- 13:57these are very reputable publishing
- 13:59houses
- 14:01he did a deep dive and went into Marxist
- 14:04poetry which a lot of people didn't even
- 14:08know about it was really discovered by
- 14:11one of the first Markx biographers a guy
- 14:13named Fron Maring way back the time when
- 14:16Marx's daughters were still alive and
- 14:19when Maring discovered [laughter]
- 14:21some of this poetry some of the quite
- 14:23literally demonic devilish poetry he
- 14:26advised you know you should probably
- 14:30keep this under wraps I don't know that
- 14:32you even want to get this published and
- 14:35it was a later Russian scholar Soviet
- 14:38scholar for the Marx Institute that
- 14:41found the material and and had the
- 14:43integrity to post it. And by the way, at
- 14:46that point, I mean, the Soviets are
- 14:48militant atheists. Lenin and Trosky had
- 14:51something called the League of the
- 14:53Militant godless. So it probably doesn't
- 14:55bother them at all if if Marx is writing
- 14:58this kind of devilish devilish poetry.
- 15:01But Payne, Professor Payne, picked up on
- 15:05this material, read it, and was really
- 15:07struck by it. So Payne wrote this. Markx
- 15:10had a special love for poetry. Markx was
- 15:12devoted to poetry. Poetry was in his
- 15:15blood, and he could no more think of
- 15:17living without poetry than living
- 15:20without his vision of a communist world.
- 15:23Markx most admired Gerta. Gerta is
- 15:27Gerta. Gera is People pronounce it a
- 15:29hundred different ways. Somebody
- 15:30watching this will probably say he's
- 15:31mispronouncing Gerta. G- oe t h e. And
- 15:34Gerta did the famous FA, the famous FA
- 15:38play epic. There's a FA one, FA 2. This
- 15:41really struck Jordan Peterson as well
- 15:43because Jordan has read this stuff and
- 15:45knows it very well.
- 15:48pain gear wrote fast
- 15:51and as pain pay states of marks
- 15:55marks had a retentive memory and could
- 15:57recite long passages of Gerta's fa with
- 16:01gusto with a special preference for the
- 16:04speeches of Mephostophles
- 16:07now Mephostophles is the devil the demon
- 16:10character in Gerus Foust Foust is the
- 16:12fast of the of the Fouian bargain so
- 16:15this is no small thing and marks had a
- 16:18favorite line. I think this is kind of
- 16:20fascinating,
- 16:22frightening, chilling, sick, disturbing,
- 16:26and it's one of the things that really
- 16:27got me into this whole issue of the
- 16:29devil and Karl Marx and struck Jord
- 16:31struck Jordan as well. If someone would
- 16:34ask you for a favorite line, a favorite
- 16:37quote, a favorite verse, I mean, I might
- 16:39quote a scripture verse. I might quote a
- 16:41line from a saint. I might say something
- 16:43like, "Be not afraid." Um, Ronald
- 16:45Reagan, one of my biographical subjects,
- 16:48would cite 2 Chronicles 7:14, maybe John
- 16:513:16. Actually, Reagan had a plaque on
- 16:53his desk in Sacramento that he also
- 16:56brought to the White House which said
- 16:58there's no limit to how much a man could
- 17:00do if he doesn't mind who gets the
- 17:02credit, right? So, kind of this, you
- 17:04know, nice thought. Well, Markx had an
- 17:07altogether different favorite phrase and
- 17:11it was a line from the Mephostophles
- 17:13character in FA and the line was
- 17:16everything that exists deserves to
- 17:19perish.
- 17:21Everything that exists deserves to
- 17:24perish. I mean that is something right?
- 17:28Everything that exists deserves to
- 17:30perish. And he's not just saying this is
- 17:33so typical of Marx which you'll see in
- 17:36the Communist Manifesto and his other
- 17:38writings. This guy is no tinkerer,
- 17:41right? People say, "Well, the Communist
- 17:42Manifesto is a pretty good book. Talks
- 17:44about loving your neighbor, helping the
- 17:46poor." We'll talk about this later. The
- 17:48word love is hardly mentioned at all in
- 17:50the Communist Manifesto. And when it is,
- 17:52it has nothing to do with loving your
- 17:53neighbor. And the word neighbor isn't
- 17:54there either. I mean it's filled with
- 17:56words like everything criticism
- 17:59abolition abolish over and over again.
- 18:02But so he doesn't just say yeah the bad
- 18:05things in society should cease to exist
- 18:07right this or that. This is so clear
- 18:10this is so common of Markx everything
- 18:13that exists deserves to perish. This is
- 18:15a guy who wants to take it all down
- 18:18destroy it root and branch and stand
- 18:21there. there. I mean, picture if you
- 18:22could, you know, Markx and some of his
- 18:24plays standing there in a village of
- 18:27ruins with flames all around him, you
- 18:29know, now we can begin again. You know,
- 18:31now we're ready. Now we're ready to go.
- 18:35So, he he also said in and I'll talk
- 18:39about this as well in the end in the end
- 18:41of the Communist Manifesto. The
- 18:43Communist Manifesto calls for the
- 18:45abolition of the present state of
- 18:47things. And I think the most telling
- 18:50line in the end of the manifesto, which
- 18:52I'll drill down down on a few lectures
- 18:54from now, it closes by calling for the
- 18:58forcible overthrow of all existing
- 19:01social conditions. Markx and Engle's
- 19:04Communist Manifesto, published February
- 19:061848, calls for the forcible overthrow
- 19:10of all existing social conditions. This
- 19:15guy isn't a tinkerer with tax rates.
- 19:18who's looking to redistribute a little
- 19:19wealth here to the poor. Right? This is
- 19:22a guy who wants to take it all down.
- 19:24Forcible overthrow of all existing
- 19:27social conditions. Everything that
- 19:29exists deserves to perish. To perish.
- 19:33Markx also knew by heart passages from
- 19:37Dante's Divine Comedy. Um, La Deavina
- 19:40comedia, right? And the divine comedy
- 19:44has three parts to it, right? What are
- 19:46the three parts? What's the bottom?
- 19:48Inferno, right? Hell, middle,
- 19:51purgatorio, purgatory, and then heaven
- 19:54paradiso.
- 19:56My colleague and good friend Robert
- 19:58Orlando has done a great book that came
- 20:02out in 2025, Carl, called Carl Marx, the
- 20:05divine tragedy.
- 20:07and and and Rob has a website that goes
- 20:10with the called markxinhell.com
- 20:13where where where Orlando imagines going
- 20:16to the different circles of hell with
- 20:18Carl Marx because Markx was really
- 20:20fixated on Dante's Divine Comedy. This
- 20:23is interesting. Dante's Divine Comedy.
- 20:26What what Dante wants to do is the
- 20:28pilgrim ascends, right? So you go down
- 20:32to the circles of hell and then you go
- 20:34into purgatory for this like purggation
- 20:36and your ultimate goal is heaven. But
- 20:38with Karl Marx it's just the opposite.
- 20:41You know he starts and Orlando does this
- 20:43with his book. He starts as this kind of
- 20:46idealist and then he ends up in hell in
- 20:50the end. In one of Marx's plays that I
- 20:52open up the book with from 1837.
- 20:55He said quote thus heaven I forfeited. I
- 21:00know it full well. My soul once true to
- 21:04God is chosen for hell. It's quite a
- 21:08statement. Thus, heaven I've forfeited.
- 21:10I know it full well. My soul once true
- 21:14to God is chosen for hell. Rob Orlando
- 21:18said it's it's curious. Dante's Divine
- 21:22Comedy. Of course, he talks about heaven
- 21:24all the time. His eyes are ultimately in
- 21:26heaven. Rob says, "But MarkX never
- 21:27writes about heaven.
- 21:30He does it. And actually the one time
- 21:32that he does in that 1837 play, right?
- 21:36He says, "Heaven, I've forfeited.
- 21:39I know it full well." And then he says,
- 21:40"My soul, once true to God, is chosen
- 21:42for hell." Markx himself, his soul was
- 21:46once true to God. He was he was raised
- 21:49in a religious home. [snorts] His I'll
- 21:52get I'll get back to this in a in a
- 21:53second, but he eventually chooses to
- 21:56move away from that. I don't know that
- 21:59we could say that his soul was chosen
- 22:01for hell, but Mark certainly chose from
- 22:04his own free will to reject this
- 22:07heavenly view that he had earlier and to
- 22:09reject God and go, let's just say, go in
- 22:11a different direction.
- 22:14Robert Payne
- 22:16also adds here that he said quote the
- 22:20young Marx was passionately devoted to
- 22:23poetry and he took himself very
- 22:25seriously as a poet. Poetry was the love
- 22:29of his life the safe refuge from all the
- 22:32turmoils of his revolutionary existence.
- 22:36the the the the one play that I
- 22:39mentioned earlier and I'll get to it
- 22:41again right now with the violinist
- 22:44that was called the player and it was
- 22:46published in 1841.
- 22:48He published it in the Berlin literary
- 22:51magazine Athenium in January 1841. Markx
- 22:55at this point is is 22 years old. So
- 22:57again born born May 5th 1818. So this
- 23:01point he's 22 years old. I' I've run
- 23:04into a couple of Marxist biographers.
- 23:06Most of the Marx biographers are
- 23:08sympathetic, so they try to defend the
- 23:09guy. Most of them ignore this devilish
- 23:12poetry like the plague. They want
- 23:14nothing to do with it. But if they
- 23:16mention it, they'll find a way to shrug
- 23:17it off, pretend like, you know, Marx is
- 23:20being playful or whatever. Or these are
- 23:23like youthful indiscretions. But when
- 23:25Markx is writing this at 1841, the 1840s
- 23:29are the peak of Marx's output. He did
- 23:32his opiate of the masses essay in the
- 23:341840s. He did the communist manifesto
- 23:391846 1847 published February 1848.
- 23:44So this was published the player 7 years
- 23:47before the publication of the communist
- 23:48manifesto fittingly published by the
- 23:51editors under the title Savage Songs
- 23:55which is really precisely what they
- 23:56canote kind of pure savagery.
- 23:59and the player. This un unnerving poem
- 24:03describes this violinist who like in a
- 24:06delirious frenzy is summoning up the
- 24:08powers of darkness with his furious
- 24:10strings.
- 24:13I'm thinking here of like Charlie Daniel
- 24:15song the devil and down to Georgia,
- 24:17right? Devil down to George Look for
- 24:18some soul steal, right?
- 24:20I don't think I don't think Daniels knew
- 24:22anything about this.
- 24:24But in the ballot, the violinist who
- 24:26seems like it's it seems to be
- 24:28autobiographical like it might be Markx
- 24:30himself. This is hard to say. It's
- 24:33always hard to know when a writer or a
- 24:35poet is writing if he's speaking about
- 24:37himself or or or not. Payne thinks it's
- 24:40autobiographical.
- 24:43There can only be one outcome here,
- 24:44right? He ultimately destroys himself.
- 24:47So when an onlooker asks the violinist
- 24:49why he's playing this way, right? This
- 24:51this like delirious frenzy and that
- 24:53onlooker is the love interest of of the
- 24:57player who pay and others think is
- 25:01Marx's future wife Jenny von Westfailen.
- 25:04So, a perturbed marks or perturbed
- 25:07player, whoever this is, says that he
- 25:09can't help himself and he will stab her
- 25:12with his blood dark sword before his
- 25:15high his violin and heart burst. All
- 25:17right, here's the quote. Here's Markx.
- 25:21The player strikes up his violin, his
- 25:24blonde hair falling down. He wears a
- 25:27sword at his side and a wide wrinkled
- 25:31gown. By the way, the gown is the holy
- 25:34robe of Christ.
- 25:37Oh player, this is a quote. Why playst
- 25:39thou so wild? Why the savage look in
- 25:42thine eyes? Why the leaping blood, the
- 25:45soaring waves? Why tearest thou thy bow
- 25:49to shreds?
- 25:52And he answers, "I play for the sake of
- 25:54the thundering sea crashing against the
- 25:56walls of the cliffs, that my eyes be
- 25:59blinded and my hearts burst and my soul
- 26:02resound in the depths of hell."
- 26:05Oh player, why terest thou thy heart to
- 26:07shreds in mockery? This art was given
- 26:10thee by a shining god to elevate the
- 26:13mind into the swelling music of the
- 26:16starry dance. So the player here is
- 26:19misusing this elegant art right the
- 26:21graceful sound of a violin. I mean
- 26:23what's more beautiful in orchestra right
- 26:25than a violin right Beethoven's violin
- 26:28conerto you know a Mozart orchestra
- 26:32coner concert
- 26:34or symphony
- 26:36so he uses it uh not to elevate the mind
- 26:39as God would want him to do but but just
- 26:41the opposite. Then Markx writes this.
- 26:46Look now, my blood dark sword shall stab
- 26:50unairringly within thy soul. God neither
- 26:54knows nor honors art. The hellish vapors
- 26:58rise and fill the brain till I go mad
- 27:02and my heart is utterly changed. See the
- 27:06sword, the prince of darkness sold it to
- 27:10me. For he beats the time and gives the
- 27:14signs. Ever more boldly I play the dance
- 27:18of death.
- 27:20I must play darkly. I must play lightly
- 27:24until my heart and my violin burst.
- 27:28Yeah, crazy. Ever more boldly I play the
- 27:32dance of death. In the book I the
- 27:34opening chapter I call the dance of
- 27:36death because the Marxist ideology ends
- 27:40up responsible for more deaths than any
- 27:42other ideology in history. Over 100
- 27:46million people dead according to the
- 27:48Harvard University press book the black
- 27:49book of communism in the in the 20th
- 27:51century in the 20th century 20th century
- 27:54alone. So he plays not for God right but
- 27:58and to uplift the mind but for but for
- 28:00the but for the dance of death. So
- 28:02surely the this again reminds of like FA
- 28:05the the f the Fouian bar the Foustian
- 28:07bargain. Robert Payne observes this
- 28:10quote Marx is here celebrating a satanic
- 28:14mystery for the player is clearly
- 28:16Lucifer or Mephostophles
- 28:18and what he is playing with such frenzy
- 28:20is the music which accompanies the end
- 28:22of the world unquote. That's that's
- 28:26Payne's inter interpretation of it.
- 28:30All right. Another Mark's play that is
- 28:33that is very disturbing and I would urge
- 28:37caution with this if you're doing any
- 28:40searching on this online is called olanm
- 28:45o u l a neolm
- 28:48o u l o u l a nem
- 28:52this is very unsettling and Robert Payne
- 28:56has this interpretation Richard
- 28:58Wormbbron who wrote the book toward
- 29:00tortured for Christ. The Romanian pastor
- 29:02who was tortured in communist cells in
- 29:05in Romania during the Cold War says
- 29:07this. Paul Johnson, the late British
- 29:09historian, said this. This play quite
- 29:12remarkably is is an anagram for Manuel
- 29:17or Emanuel or God. In fact, as Payne
- 29:21formulated it, quote, Manuel equals
- 29:24Emanuel equals God. Now, Wormbbrand was
- 29:27even blunder. He identified the anagram
- 29:30as a directly satanic anagram for the
- 29:32name Emanuel or or Emanuel which is the
- 29:35Hebrew biblical name for Jesus meaning
- 29:37God is with us. It's at the enunciation,
- 29:39right, that the angel Gabriel said says
- 29:42to Mary, um uh be uh be um hail full of
- 29:46grace, right? She said, 'What kind of
- 29:48greeting is this? Be not afraid, Mary,
- 29:50for God has found favor with you. You
- 29:52shall bear a child. His name shall be
- 29:54Emmanuel, meaning God is with us.
- 29:58So he's he's inverting this in this
- 30:01play, the sacred name. And Markx does a
- 30:03lot of this. He does a lot of using
- 30:05religious language which he knew because
- 30:07of where he lived and where he was
- 30:09brought up and the fact that he had been
- 30:10a Christian as a young man and he ends
- 30:12up inverting it and turning into into a
- 30:15dark way.
- 30:17Act one of them takes the audience
- 30:20straight into a dialogue between two of
- 30:22Marx's main characters, including the
- 30:24namesake Ulanm, who's described as a
- 30:27German traveler, and his trusty
- 30:29companion who's named Lucindo.
- 30:33L U C I N D O Lucindo. And the action
- 30:37takes place in a mountain town in Italy.
- 30:41Ulanm and Lucindo
- 30:43find no room in the inn,
- 30:46right? Maybe perhaps akin to Mary and
- 30:48Joseph finding no room in the inn to
- 30:50give birth to to to Emanuel.
- 30:54And yet and Lucindo are no Mary and
- 30:57Joseph, even as they are somewhat of a
- 30:59couple or almost, right? Both are male.
- 31:02And it's a it's a really weird thing.
- 31:06They stay with this house, an Italian
- 31:08man named Pertini.
- 31:10As Markx himself states in his play,
- 31:13Ulanm,
- 31:15the name rings forth like a death, rings
- 31:18forth until it dies away in a wretched
- 31:21crawl. And then he penned this this
- 31:24really disquing passage. Yet I have
- 31:27power within my youthful arms to clench
- 31:30and crush you with tempestuous force.
- 31:33While for us both the abyss yawns in
- 31:36darkness, you will sink down and I shall
- 31:39follow, laughing, whispering in your
- 31:41ears, descend, come with me, friend. So
- 31:46each each scene kind of insidious scene
- 31:50sort of craw crawls along like this. I I
- 31:52caution too, people watching this
- 31:55online, you're going to do it now, even
- 31:57though I'm going to warn you not to. If
- 31:59you look up if you Google Ulan, be
- 32:02careful because you'll get satanic
- 32:05imagery on on your on your computer.
- 32:08It's it's used. And in fact, the
- 32:10Wikipedia entry for Ulanm even refers to
- 32:14a play by a play by Marx by the young
- 32:17Marx.
- 32:18[snorts] Scene three is the is the most
- 32:21bitter of all of these. Ulanm is seated
- 32:23alone at a table writing with papers
- 32:25tossed all around him. That was what
- 32:27Markx did. I mean Markx was always in a
- 32:29library, always with papers always
- 32:30tossed around him. He suddenly springs
- 32:34up and stands with arms folded and
- 32:37declares. Now Payne and some others
- 32:39think again that this is
- 32:40autobiographical by Markx. I don't
- 32:43always know what Markx is thinking with
- 32:45this stuff. It's it's it's hard to say,
- 32:48but he springs up, stands with arms
- 32:50folded, and declares, "All lost.
- 32:55The hour is now expired, and time stands
- 32:58still. This pygmy universe collapses.
- 33:02Soon I shall clasp eternity and howl,
- 33:05humanity's giant curse into its ear.
- 33:09Eternity, it is eternal pain. death
- 33:12inconceivable, immeasurable, an evil
- 33:15artifice contrived to taunt us. So this
- 33:18is the climactic scene right here where
- 33:21the time comes for the death of Ulanm.
- 33:24And it's here that Markx, you know,
- 33:26quite astoundingly
- 33:28appears to have either the person or the
- 33:31subject or maybe even himself declare
- 33:34in the form of the creator, I shall howl
- 33:37gigantic curses at mankind.
- 33:41Paul Johnson's chapter on Karl Marx in
- 33:44his book the intellectuals is titled I
- 33:46shall howl gigantic curses at at
- 33:50mankind. I shall howl gigantic curses at
- 33:52mankind.
- 33:54Payne notes that sees himself as this
- 33:58agent of destruction
- 34:00as the judge who condemns and then acts
- 34:02as the executioner
- 34:05confident that he is in possession of
- 34:06the powers of God to annihilate the
- 34:09universe.
- 34:10And Payne says this, "Olanm was Marx as
- 34:15judge and executioner."
- 34:18Here again he goes to the line from FA
- 34:20Mephostophles. Everything that exists
- 34:23deser deserves to perish. Richard
- 34:26Wormbbron
- 34:27remarked that Ulanm may be the only
- 34:30drama he was aware of in which every
- 34:33character is fully aware of his or her
- 34:35own corruption and yet all flaunt and
- 34:38celebrate it with prideful conviction.
- 34:41All of the characters are irredeemably
- 34:43bad. There's usually right a
- 34:45protagonist. So there's a dark night of
- 34:48the soul. There's a moment there can be
- 34:50a happy ending. But not in this.
- 34:53And this is not done by the playwright
- 34:55with a noble purpose of revealing the
- 34:57dark to herald the light. There is no
- 34:59light. There is no black and white here.
- 35:02Just black. Wormbbrand wrote here all
- 35:05servants. Here all are servants of
- 35:08darkness. All are satanic, corrupt, and
- 35:12doomed.
- 35:13Yeah. So
- 35:16bad bad stuff. Bad stuff.
- 35:20All right. So picking up with with Karl
- 35:22Marx and his and his early life. So born
- 35:25May 5th, 1818
- 35:28and again in that shadow of of the great
- 35:31cathedral in in in Tr.
- 35:34He was his father was Heinrich. Heinrich
- 35:38was a very interesting man. The he was
- 35:41he was Jewish. The family Marx was was
- 35:44ethnically Jewish.
- 35:47His he came from a family that had many
- 35:50rabbis.
- 35:52A number of them were you know quite
- 35:54orthodox rabbis.
- 35:57His father however like an uncle and
- 35:59some others in his family converted to
- 36:01Christianity.
- 36:03And the father some biographers say that
- 36:06the father did this in response to the
- 36:08social pressures of the day. This was a
- 36:10place where Jews were persecuted. I
- 36:12don't know if I totally see it that way.
- 36:15I mean the father seemed legitimately
- 36:16interested in Christianity and seemed to
- 36:18have a pretty strong faith.
- 36:20Interestingly the father converted to
- 36:22Lutheranism
- 36:23which in the very Catholic trier was not
- 36:26the direction that most most people
- 36:27went. U but the father became Lutheran.
- 36:31The his wife Henrietta didn't wasn't
- 36:35fully on board with this and in fact the
- 36:38father wanted the kids to be baptized.
- 36:42She wasn't so sure about that. Markx,
- 36:45however, in fact, you can see this in
- 36:47the fact that Carl himself didn't get
- 36:49baptized until 1824.
- 36:52So, at that point, he's he's he's five
- 36:54or six years old. So, he wasn't baptized
- 36:56at birth, even though his father had
- 36:58been had been converted earlier.
- 37:02Markx would be eventually confirmed as
- 37:05well at the at the age of 15. The father
- 37:09the father urged the son always
- 37:12to be to to re to to
- 37:16embrace religion and understand the fact
- 37:19that that it was good for a person. And
- 37:23in fact, the the the quote the quote
- 37:25from the father
- 37:27he says to Carl that quote religion is a
- 37:29good support to morality and a simple
- 37:32faith in God. Sooner or later it's good
- 37:35for a man to have faith. It gives him
- 37:37something to believe in something other
- 37:40than himself.
- 37:42But Markx starts to slowly pull away
- 37:45from this. He's a fairly passionate
- 37:48Christian as a teenager, writes a writes
- 37:51a piece around the age of 15 or 16, an
- 37:54essay in an essay in high school on
- 37:57union with Christ, which actually shows
- 38:00that he seems to be a pretty pretty
- 38:02sincere Christian. But he starts to pull
- 38:05away from this in his late teens and as
- 38:09he becomes more restless, more troubled,
- 38:12and especially by the time that he got
- 38:14to college, he's going to have a full
- 38:17break when he when he gets to college.
- 38:20His father is watching this and is very
- 38:23very troubled by it.
- 38:26Heinrich the father wrote a letter to
- 38:28his son to Carl on March 2nd, 1837. This
- 38:34is quite a letter.
- 38:37Carl, at times my heart delights in
- 38:40thinking of you and your future because
- 38:43Carl is a very intelligent young man,
- 38:45right? Precocious, obviously is is
- 38:48blessed with a with a good mind, high
- 38:50level of intelligence.
- 38:52So at times [snorts] my heart delights
- 38:54in thinking of you and your future. And
- 38:56yet at times I cannot rid myself of
- 38:59ideas which arouse in me sad for
- 39:01boodings and fear when I am struck as if
- 39:04by lightning by the thought. Is your
- 39:08heart Carl in accord with your head?
- 39:12Your talents
- 39:13has it room for the earthly but gentler
- 39:16sentiments which in this veil of sorrow
- 39:20are so essentially consoling for a man
- 39:22of feeling. Again the importance of
- 39:24faith, right? Valley of sorrow, veil of
- 39:26tears, valley of tears.
- 39:29Then this line, from the dad to the son.
- 39:33And since that heart is obviously
- 39:35animated and governed by a demon,
- 39:39not granted to all men,
- 39:42is that demon heavenly or fouian?
- 39:47Some translators interpret the word
- 39:49demon in the initial line as ghost or
- 39:52spirit. Right? If it's governed by a
- 39:54spirit not granted to all men, is that
- 39:57spirit heavenly or foustian? And of
- 40:00course, Marx who wants to write nothing
- 40:02less than the Giras Foust of his age and
- 40:04wants to be a poet and quotes all the
- 40:07time Mephostophles
- 40:09father's on to something here.
- 40:12The father asked him, "Will you ever,
- 40:16and that is not the least painful doubt
- 40:18of my heart, will you ever be capable of
- 40:20truly human domestic happiness?
- 40:24Will, and this doubt has no less
- 40:26tortured me recently since I have come
- 40:28to love a certain person like my own
- 40:30child, will you ever be capable of
- 40:33imparting happiness to those immediately
- 40:36around you?"
- 40:37And that's quite a statement because
- 40:40Marx is not very good at imparting
- 40:42happiness to the people around him
- 40:45throughout throughout his life.
- 40:47He I mean he refuses to work. Both his
- 40:51wife and his and his mother express the
- 40:55wish that quote Carl would start earning
- 40:57some capital rather than just writing
- 40:59about it. The family is broke all the
- 41:02time. They get their money from Engles.
- 41:07Well, first initially the family gets
- 41:10money from from Marx's parents and then
- 41:14Heinrich eventually has to cut him off
- 41:17and then the mother after that, in fact,
- 41:20Markx did not go to his father's
- 41:21funeral.
- 41:23Some sympathetic biographers said,
- 41:25"Well, he couldn't make it. The weather
- 41:27was bad." Whatever. I don't totally
- 41:29know. Mark seemed to love his father. If
- 41:32this was out of I don't know, but Markx
- 41:34didn't attend didn't did not attend his
- 41:36father's funeral. He then goes and he
- 41:38sees his mother for the first time in
- 41:40quite a while. He writes a letter back
- 41:43to his wife Jenny saying basically bad
- 41:46news. I didn't get any more money from
- 41:48her. Uh however, some good news. I did
- 41:52get her to rip up the IUS. Right.
- 41:54Success, right? Success. And the mother
- 41:58at that point, tough love, right? Carl,
- 42:01I know you have all these children. I
- 42:03know that they're going hungry. I know
- 42:05it's cold at night. I mean, Mark's lost
- 42:09several children. I mean, some
- 42:11heartbreaking stories. In one case, this
- 42:13son Edgar who he just loved and adored.
- 42:16It's quite quite heartbreaking. I mean,
- 42:18that that Markx lost his child, this boy
- 42:20that they loved so much, Gido Guido,
- 42:22another child that they lost near near
- 42:25infancy. But the mother said, "I know
- 42:27this is a struggle, but we we can't give
- 42:29you any more money. You've got to work.
- 42:31You have to get your own job. You have
- 42:33to get your own job. So the family at
- 42:36that point, he and his wife Jenny, they
- 42:39go to Jenny's family. Jenny's family was
- 42:44pretty well off. They had money. So they
- 42:47started giving money to the Marxists
- 42:49because again, Carl refused to to work.
- 42:53Eventually the family says, "We have to
- 42:55cut you off. We can't do this. No,
- 42:57that's this is wrong. You have to get an
- 42:59income. we can't lend you any more
- 43:00money. Markx and Jenny start going after
- 43:04relatives for this. At one point, Jenny
- 43:06crosses the English Channel and even
- 43:08goes and it shows up wet in a rainstorm
- 43:11to like a relative's place, soaking wet,
- 43:14asking for money. Jenny is writing
- 43:16letters to Carl saying, "Carl, I'm in a
- 43:18terrible state. Everybody thinks I'm a
- 43:20liar. The the land lady wants to throw
- 43:23us out. The butcher is is this
- 43:25terrifying individual. We need money. I
- 43:27don't mean to ask you again and again,
- 43:29but we need money, Carl. We need money,
- 43:32right? Really, what Markx is creating
- 43:34with his Marxist system is the kind of
- 43:36economic system that would subsidize
- 43:39somebody like Marx. Well, he sat around
- 43:42and theorized and created an ideology
- 43:45and ideologized and sat in his study and
- 43:48didn't have to earn an income.
- 43:51Eventually, Jenny's family said, "Okay,
- 43:54we can't give you any more money.
- 43:57We will lend you Helen."
- 44:00Lenin was her nickname. Helen Deuth.
- 44:04Helen was the family nursemaid for the
- 44:08for Jenny's family. Grew up with Jenny.
- 44:11And so, at one point, the family says,
- 44:13"We will lend you Helen to help with the
- 44:17family at at at home." So Helen stays
- 44:21with Carl and and Jenny and the Marx
- 44:24family. And Marx of course doesn't pay
- 44:27her a dime. She's really Payne describes
- 44:30her as kind of an indentured servant
- 44:33because Markx is this champion of the
- 44:35working class and the proletariat and
- 44:37the working man and equal distribution
- 44:39of wealth. Won't pay her any money at
- 44:41all. By the way, Markx and Engles in
- 44:43their book, The Origin of the Family,
- 44:45which is published in 1884, a year after
- 44:48Markx died, posumously for Marks, Markx
- 44:50died in 1883. But Engles and Marks talk
- 44:53in there about turning child care into a
- 44:58a full-time state-run industry where you
- 45:01would have nannies at home that would
- 45:03take care of the children. And this is
- 45:05one of the things that radical leftists
- 45:08like about Marxism. women would be
- 45:10pushed out of the home into the farms
- 45:12and into the factories where they could
- 45:14work, right? So the the the raising of
- 45:16children would become a full-time state
- 45:19industry. So they they like that idea.
- 45:21They, you know, they they like that
- 45:23worldview. So Helen
- 45:26Helen Deuth
- 45:28is lent to the Marxists
- 45:30and Carl
- 45:32got her pregnant
- 45:34behind Jenny's back.
- 45:37We don't know exactly the circumstances.
- 45:41Payne says that it's not clear that the
- 45:44sex was consensual. I don't know how he
- 45:46would know that. I I I mean, we don't
- 45:49know. But a child was born.
- 45:53And at that point, Markx of course
- 45:56absolutely denied that the child was
- 45:58his. Everybody knew the child was his,
- 46:01including Jenny. Paul Johnson said
- 46:04Jenny's heart never recovered from this.
- 46:06She felt so betrayed by her husband o
- 46:09over over this.
- 46:11They
- 46:13knows that the child is Marxist. So
- 46:16Engles says you know I don't care about
- 46:19marriage.
- 46:20Uh I Marx by the way wasn't a big fan of
- 46:24it either. He wrote a letter to Engles
- 46:25at one point which said blessed is he
- 46:28who has no family. Kind of a curious
- 46:30take on the biatitudes. I think he's
- 46:32expressing at that point his misery of
- 46:34raising children. He even wrote a letter
- 46:36to Paul Leafar, his future son-in-law,
- 46:38saying, "If I had to do life all over
- 46:40again, I wouldn't get married."
- 46:42All right? And he and and he even says,
- 46:45"My wife's misery is unspeakable."
- 46:47Right? What she has what she has to go
- 46:50through all the time. So Engles did not
- 46:53believe in marriage. The Communists in
- 46:56the Communist Manifes Communist
- 46:57Manifesto talk about the abolition of
- 46:59the family. We'll we'll talk we'll talk
- 47:00about that later.
- 47:03Engles uh did not believe in marriage.
- 47:05Lived with a woman for a long time,
- 47:07which in those days didn't happen,
- 47:09right? If you lived together, you you
- 47:11were married. And the woman that he
- 47:12lived with wanted to to to marry her.
- 47:17But but he but he refused to. When she
- 47:19died, by the way, he was heartbroken at
- 47:23the loss. It was not expected.
- 47:26Markx wrote a letter to Ingles where in
- 47:28the first couple lines he acknowledged
- 47:30Engles's loss and then in like the next
- 47:3330 lines got to the more important point
- 47:35in Marx's mind of talking about money
- 47:38and Les exploded
- 47:40with an angry letter. Even my capitalist
- 47:44friends showed more sympathy than you
- 47:47did.
- 47:48Almost blew the relationship right there
- 47:50be between the two. So the boy is born
- 47:54and steps forward and says, 'Look, my
- 47:56reputation, I don't care about it. I'll
- 47:59accept paternity for the child. And they
- 48:03name the child Frederick, Friedrich,
- 48:05Freddy. And he he outlives all of the
- 48:10Mark's children, the children to to
- 48:13Jenny and Carl. Outlives Jenny, outlives
- 48:16Carl. And Markx never acknowledges
- 48:20existence. And of course, never gave him
- 48:23a dime. Never ever gave him a dime.
- 48:27Engel's relationship in all of this.
- 48:29He's not only a writing partner with
- 48:33Marx, but he's Marx's chief subsidizer.
- 48:37It's very ironic. We'll see this when we
- 48:39read the Communist Manifesto. Point
- 48:41three in the Communist Manifesto calls
- 48:43for abolition of all right of
- 48:45inheritance. What hypocrisy.
- 48:48Marks and Engles got all their money
- 48:50through inheritance. Markx got every bit
- 48:53of money he could from his father, his
- 48:54mother, from Jenny's parents. Ing's
- 48:57father was a wealthy industrialist.
- 49:00So after Markx couldn't get money from
- 49:02his and Jenny's family,
- 49:04Les became Marx's sugar daddy. That's
- 49:08where all the money came from. Markx and
- 49:11Markx and Jenny could not have survived
- 49:13literally without without the help that
- 49:15that that Engles provided.
- 49:19All right. [laughter]
- 49:21So, getting back to getting back to
- 49:23Heinrich, the father,
- 49:26Heinrich said, and here's the quote.
- 49:28I'll read it again. I said it maybe
- 49:29about 10 minutes ago.
- 49:32He advised Carl that quote, "A good,
- 49:34this is an exact quote. I butchered the
- 49:36quote a little bit earlier. A good
- 49:38support for morality is a simple faith
- 49:41in God."
- 49:43You know that I am the last person to be
- 49:45a fanatic. But sooner or later, a man
- 49:48has a real need of this faith. And there
- 49:52are moments in life when even the man
- 49:54who denies God is compelled against his
- 49:58will to pray to the Almighty.
- 50:01So that was that was his view to to the
- 50:05to the son.
- 50:07I should note here before I move on a a
- 50:09little bit a little bit further. So I
- 50:12and I want to make this clear to people
- 50:14watch watching this online.
- 50:17I don't say in my writings or in my book
- 50:20I mean even though it has the title the
- 50:22devil and Karl Marx I don't say that I
- 50:24think that Marx was possessed. I don't
- 50:27know any I mean that's to quote Barack
- 50:30Obama that's above my pay grade right
- 50:34I I have no idea whether whether
- 50:37something like that. The Richard
- 50:40Wormbbron, the Romanian pastor, he he
- 50:43went really far in describing certain
- 50:46things that Marxists did as satanic
- 50:48rituals. Talked, you know, black masses,
- 50:51seances, some I've never seen anything
- 50:54like that. All right. What what I and
- 50:56what I've seen is troubling enough,
- 50:59right? And and I would caution people,
- 51:01you know, don't go beyond what the
- 51:03evidence says, right? If you're going to
- 51:07criticize somebody, make strong charges,
- 51:09you you can't don't don't go don't go
- 51:11too far.
- 51:14But the but it's undeniable. You see
- 51:16over and over again Mark's family
- 51:19members and close friends referring to
- 51:21him with words like his father's
- 51:24governed by a demon. Right? His son once
- 51:28in one spot says refers to his dad as my
- 51:32dear devil. Maybe this is being playful.
- 51:34I don't know. But I my sons never refer
- 51:37to me as my dear devil. Maybe behind my
- 51:39back. I don't know. Engles and I'll talk
- 51:42about this when he and Les met, referred
- 51:44to Markx as the monster of 10,000
- 51:47devils.
- 51:50His wife referred to him as her wicked
- 51:52nave. My wife does not refer to me as
- 51:55her wicked nave. you know, with a
- 51:57striking number of inimates and
- 51:59associates who didn't hesitate to
- 52:01compare him to, you know, FA or
- 52:03Mephostophles.
- 52:05Um, Carl Heinen,
- 52:07one of one of his biographers
- 52:10or one of his friends. Heinesen wrote
- 52:12this.
- 52:15Carl Heinen, Heinen is Hi Nzn,
- 52:19was a friend of Markx. And he wrote
- 52:22about helping wa walk Mark's home after
- 52:26the two of them had consumed quote
- 52:28several bottles of wine unquote. That's
- 52:31a lot. By the way, my wife and I go out
- 52:34to dinner. You know, we split a bottle
- 52:36of wine. If I go a little further, maybe
- 52:38a third glass, several bottles, I don't
- 52:40know.
- 52:42But Hines recounted this.
- 52:45As soon as I was in the house with
- 52:47Markx, he shut the doors, hid the key,
- 52:51and jered comically at me that I was his
- 52:54prisoner.
- 52:55He asked me to follow him up into his
- 52:58study. Now Markx is obviously smashed
- 53:01drunk, right? Heinesen said that Mark
- 53:04seemed to forget that Heinen was there,
- 53:05but then he came around. He began acting
- 53:07very strangely.
- 53:09Heinesen wrote this. He Marx came over
- 53:12to me and he gave me to understand that
- 53:15he had me in his power
- 53:17and with a malice that recalled an imp
- 53:20rather than the intended devil, he began
- 53:22to attack me with threats and cuffs. I
- 53:25begged him to spare me this sort of
- 53:27thing because it went against the grain
- 53:29to pay him back in the same coin. When
- 53:32Markx did not stop, I gave him a serious
- 53:34warning that I would deal with him in a
- 53:36way that he would certainly feel. And
- 53:38when that too did no good, I saw myself
- 53:41compelled to dispatch him into the
- 53:42corner of the room.
- 53:44When he got up, I said that I found his
- 53:47personality boring, and I asked him to
- 53:49open the front door. Now it was his turn
- 53:52to be triumphant.
- 53:54Mark said to him, "Go home then, strong
- 53:57man." He mocked and added a most comical
- 54:00smirk. And then here's this phrase again
- 54:03from Heinensson. It was as though he was
- 54:05chanting the words from Foust. Foust
- 54:09again again.
- 54:11There is one imprisoned inside.qu.
- 54:15At least the sentiment was similar.
- 54:17Although his unsuccessful imitation of
- 54:19Mephostophles
- 54:20made the situation comic in the extreme.
- 54:24In the end, I warned him that if he
- 54:26would not open the door for me, then I
- 54:27would get it open myself and he would
- 54:28have to pay for the damage.
- 54:31Since Markx only answered with mocking
- 54:33sneers, I went down, tore the front door
- 54:36off its lock, and called him out to the
- 54:38street that he should shut the house up
- 54:40to prevent the entry of thieves.
- 54:43Dumb with amazement that I had escaped
- 54:45from his spell, he leaned out of the
- 54:47window and goggled at me with his small
- 54:49eyes like a wet goblin.
- 54:53So here again I mean words like imp
- 54:57intended devil fou mephistophles
- 55:01chanting the words from fast there is
- 55:04one prison imprisoned inside in his
- 55:07power mocking snears dumb with amazement
- 55:11that I had escaped from his spell
- 55:14eyes like a wet goblin
- 55:19pretty weird I've done biographies of a
- 55:22lot of people as diverse as Ronald
- 55:25Reagan, George W. Bush, Hillary Clinton,
- 55:28Pope John Paul II. I've never seen any
- 55:31description of any of them by anybody
- 55:34ever like that.
- 55:37All right, but back to the point. We got
- 55:38about five minutes to wrap up this this
- 55:40this first lecture. I want to make clear
- 55:43in the issue of you know demonic and you
- 55:46know how exactly
- 55:48how how I interpret this.
- 55:52So these phrases what you just heard
- 55:54from Carl Heines and what you heard from
- 55:57the father governed by a demon and
- 55:59everything there's just too many of
- 56:01these and it it it's hard to just kind
- 56:04of cast this off laugh it off. Yeah,
- 56:08some of his biographers, if they deal
- 56:10with this at all, they'll say that this
- 56:11is inest maybe or a weird playfulness by
- 56:15Mark and it's not entirely clear. All
- 56:18right. Um, but the frequency of all
- 56:21these observations is is is jarring and
- 56:24something that's kind of kind of hard to
- 56:26shrug off.
- 56:28Now that said, Robert Payne in his 1968
- 56:32book on Mars and Robert Payne again a
- 56:34British man of letters. This this book
- 56:37was published through Simon and
- 56:38Schustster.
- 56:40In his chapter on Markx called the
- 56:42demons,
- 56:44he writes this quote there were times
- 56:47when Mark seemed to be possessed by
- 56:50demons.
- 56:52He had the devil's view of the world and
- 56:55the devil's malign.
- 56:57sometimes he seemed to know that he was
- 57:00accomplishing works of evil," unquote.
- 57:03Now, it how evil. Personally, I have no
- 57:08proof that Karl Marx was a Satanist. I
- 57:11can't say that the man was possessed. I
- 57:13wouldn't dare hazard that kind of a
- 57:14charge. All right? I I I don't know
- 57:16that. And some will say, and Jordan
- 57:19Peterson really drilled down on this
- 57:21with me, it well by the end of his life,
- 57:25he was clearly a militant atheist. Why
- 57:28would an atheist be a Satanist? Right?
- 57:31Well, I'll talk about this in the lead
- 57:33for the next lecture. There are certain
- 57:37radicals of Marx's generation, Maily
- 57:40Bikunin, I could pick up with him. Even
- 57:42later, someone like Saulinsky, who in
- 57:44his book, Rules for Radicals, in the
- 57:46beginning says, um, lest we begin with
- 57:48at least an over-the-shoulder
- 57:50acknowledgement to that first of all
- 57:51rebels, right, who won himself his own
- 57:54kingdom, Lucifer. So, they identify with
- 57:57Satan as like this figure of rebellion.
- 58:00They might not even believe in the
- 58:01supernatural. They might not believe
- 58:03that there's an actual devil or that
- 58:04Satan exists, but they like Satan as
- 58:07this rebel, right? who you know who won
- 58:09for himself his his his own kingdom.
- 58:13So more likely, I think what some mean
- 58:15to say is that Marx was an atheist who
- 58:18in a way whether he was fully cognizant
- 58:20of it or not was doing evil or what some
- 58:23might even call the work of the devil
- 58:26and what communism led to with all the
- 58:28death that it led to. Right? And some
- 58:31might be uh but again you the these are
- 58:33things that I I certainly can't
- 58:36authenticate.
- 58:38I'll close again with the 1837 poem.
- 58:43Thus, heaven I've forfeited, I know it
- 58:46full well, said Markx. My soul once true
- 58:50to God is chosen for hell. And that's uh
- 58:54that's that's disturbing enough.
- 58:57>> The IUS that you spoke of.
- 58:59>> Yes. Um, since he refused to work, what
- 59:03exactly did he profer was going to be
- 59:06the way that he would ever pay anyone
- 59:07back? Was he to become famous or
- 59:10>> Right. Right. Yeah. I don't think he
- 59:12really ever expected to to to make much
- 59:15money. He was he was somebody who again,
- 59:17you know, simply did not want to earn
- 59:19capital. He marks envision there's a
- 59:22quote I use in the book from Aristotle
- 59:24which some have translated as um you
- 59:27know men seek uh you men seek
- 59:30revolutions for for um for for their own
- 59:33purposes right so they want a new
- 59:35revolutionary world according to what it
- 59:37is that they want from from their own
- 59:39personality I think Marx was trying to
- 59:41conceive or create a world where the
- 59:44system would take care of somebody like
- 59:46him and if you look at all the different
- 59:47communist dictators
- 59:49Lenin, Stalin, Maletang, Pulp Pot, Fidel
- 59:53Castro, these guys, these guys are taken
- 59:56care of by the masses. Right? So I I I
- 1:00:00often say that communism is for the
- 1:00:03masses, not the masters. Right? It's for
- 1:00:06the ruled, not the rulers. Right? The
- 1:00:09rulers have their own system. They live
- 1:00:11in a mansion. They live in their daca on
- 1:00:13the Black Sea. Castro, everybody in Cuba
- 1:00:17makes the same amount of money, but he
- 1:00:19dies worth $2 billion, right? So they,
- 1:00:22you know, they set themselves up
- 1:00:24completely differently. The rules that
- 1:00:25they make apply to everybody else. So in
- 1:00:28Carl's case, he's trying to put together
- 1:00:31a system that I think would would take
- 1:00:33care of somebody like him. Now, the
- 1:00:35reality is, and he says this in his in
- 1:00:38his 10-point plan in the Communist
- 1:00:40Manifesto, we'll talk about this a few
- 1:00:42lectures from now. One of his points is
- 1:00:44an equal obligation for all to work. So
- 1:00:49that's not an equal that's not like
- 1:00:51equal opportunity of work for everybody
- 1:00:54in the communist system. You had an
- 1:00:55obligation to work and if you didn't the
- 1:00:58Soviets they called you a work sherker
- 1:01:01and would quite literally goolog people
- 1:01:03who refused to work. Yiannis Bardosh in
- 1:01:05his book Man is wolf to man talks about
- 1:01:08being in the goolog and meeting a young
- 1:01:10girl who was in the goolog because she
- 1:01:12was 10 minutes late for work. He says 10
- 1:01:15minutes late for work. 10 minutes in the
- 1:01:18goolog, 10 minutes late to work. Right?
- 1:01:21But that's somebody who's failing in her
- 1:01:23obligation to work. They were in
- 1:01:27America,
- 1:01:28major cities, you see homeless people
- 1:01:30everywhere. You didn't see that in the
- 1:01:32Soviet Union, right? And it's not
- 1:01:34because well everybody has a job, right?
- 1:01:37No, I mean you didn't you didn't go
- 1:01:39homeless. You had an obligation to work
- 1:01:41as the book itself says. So with um with
- 1:01:45Karl Marx, there's so much hypocrisy
- 1:01:48in his life and ideology. And one of the
- 1:01:51things I like to really tell people is I
- 1:01:53think often times people think that I'm
- 1:01:55beating up on Markx personally in order
- 1:01:58to just go after him and take shots of
- 1:02:02No, I want people to see that the man's
- 1:02:04own life is a reflection of the ideology
- 1:02:08or even of the inconsistencies in the
- 1:02:10ideology. It's really important to
- 1:02:12understand the man to understand the
- 1:02:13ideology and the and the and the evils
- 1:02:16of the ideology. Um, I [snorts] guess my
- 1:02:19question centers around what were the
- 1:02:21economic or maybe cultural conditions
- 1:02:23that were existent when he was growing
- 1:02:25up that maybe helped shape his
- 1:02:27worldview.
- 1:02:28>> Yeah, the it's a good question. When he
- 1:02:30was growing up as compared to later,
- 1:02:32especially with the launching of the
- 1:02:33Communist League and the manifesto in
- 1:02:361848, the
- 1:02:39um Matt Frad who's who does pints with
- 1:02:42Aquinus, I remember he asked me this in
- 1:02:43a podcast. He said, "Can't you say
- 1:02:45anything good about Marxism at all? Was
- 1:02:47there anything that the communists got
- 1:02:49right?" And and I and I I said, "No, I I
- 1:02:52don't think so." And if I said, "Maybe
- 1:02:55they were right in and militating
- 1:02:58against the harsh conditions of the
- 1:03:01industrial revolution." But that's not
- 1:03:03unique to the communists. I mean, the
- 1:03:05churches were all complaining about
- 1:03:07that, too. In the United States, the
- 1:03:10turn of the century progressive movement
- 1:03:12pushed child labor laws. You know, my
- 1:03:15family that came to America, my dad's
- 1:03:18side Polish, my mother's side Italian,
- 1:03:21uh who worked in the coal mines, and you
- 1:03:23they you know, they had harsh working
- 1:03:25conditions, but it was also their choice
- 1:03:28to whether or not they wanted to work
- 1:03:30work there or not. But so other people
- 1:03:32were were right in in describing that.
- 1:03:34Markx alone didn't have that peg. you're
- 1:03:36going to read Charles Dickens,
- 1:03:38right? I I mean Dickens was Dickens
- 1:03:41father was a was in debtor's prison. So
- 1:03:44the and I would tell this to people as
- 1:03:46well today. So for people say well we
- 1:03:49should like Marx and Engles and
- 1:03:51communism even today because it was
- 1:03:53right about the conditions of the
- 1:03:55industrial revolution. Well look out
- 1:03:57your window.
- 1:03:58It ain't 1840s Germany anymore. Right?
- 1:04:02So that world that they described at
- 1:04:04that point in time, that's now gone.
- 1:04:06It's a totally different world. Which is
- 1:04:08why the Marxists today are applying
- 1:04:12Marxism not to economics and not the
- 1:04:15class, but to different areas, culture,
- 1:04:19gender, even sexuality, race. If you go
- 1:04:23to People's World, the website of um the
- 1:04:27website of people'sworld.org, org, which
- 1:04:29is the successor to the Daily Worker.
- 1:04:31They have a call there in the about
- 1:04:33section for cultural workers. They're
- 1:04:35not trying to get they're not trying to
- 1:04:38get coal miners from West Virginia.
- 1:04:40Those guys all voted for Trump. They're
- 1:04:42not trying to get steel workers. My
- 1:04:44relatives from Western Pennsylvania. Um,
- 1:04:47you know, those guys voted for Trump.
- 1:04:49You know, they're focused on the
- 1:04:51Starbucks worker, right? That's where
- 1:04:53you see them organizing with petitions.
- 1:04:55They're looking for people who could
- 1:04:56change the culture, who can apply
- 1:04:59communism in a totally different
- 1:05:01oppressor versus oppressed model based
- 1:05:03not on economics and proletariat
- 1:05:06bourgeoisi, but on male, female, black,
- 1:05:09white, or some other oppressed oppressor
- 1:05:12formulation. But I'm getting ahead of
- 1:05:13myself. I'll talk about that in depth
- 1:05:15later. Do we know what sort of
- 1:05:18relationship Markx and Engles had? if it
- 1:05:20was very close, maybe like Emanuel and
- 1:05:22Lucindo or more formal
- 1:05:26and if Engles's life was similar and
- 1:05:29maybe how they met.
- 1:05:31>> Yeah. Yeah. So, Engles was I'm going to
- 1:05:33hold my fire in Engles when I when I
- 1:05:35talk about him pro I think in the in the
- 1:05:38in the third lecture. But they I mean
- 1:05:40they did get along well. I mean Les
- 1:05:43spoke gave the eulogy at Marx's funeral.
- 1:05:46He gave the eulogy at Marx's wife's
- 1:05:49funeral. Jenny and really was one of the
- 1:05:52only people who was able to get along
- 1:05:54with them. Markx would eventually blow
- 1:05:56up with so many different people with uh
- 1:05:59with Heinen with with so many with
- 1:06:02Bikunan who I'm going to quote in the in
- 1:06:04the next lecture. They he he he was very
- 1:06:08very difficult to work with um and he
- 1:06:12was difficult to live with. In the next
- 1:06:14lecture as well, I'm going to talk about
- 1:06:17the the what it was like growing up in
- 1:06:20the Marx household because the man led
- 1:06:23this incredibly disord disordered life.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Dr. Paul Kengor | The Dark Side of Marxism by Peterson Academy, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 10,344 words across 1,538 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.