Dr. Michael Boedts — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00There he is. There he is. We're so
- 0:03happy. Hi.
- 0:09We are so happy.
- 0:12Hi. [laughter]
- 0:14>> I couldn't find I couldn't find a Zoom
- 0:15invitation, so I was stupid looking in
- 0:18the middle. Hi. Hello.
- 0:20What I do with my cell phone, with my
- 0:22phone for the hour before the meeting is
- 0:26I have the Zoom link on uh Poppy because
- 0:30it happens to me every time. So before
- 0:33we start, Michael, we know how to
- 0:36pronounce your last name. It's Boots,
- 0:38right?
- 0:38>> Boots. Yes, that's it.
- 0:40>> So how do you pronounce is your first
- 0:42name Michael or Mikuel?
- 0:44>> Michael.
- 0:44>> Michael is fine. Michael is fine.
- 0:46>> Big crowd. I am so happy we have a big
- 0:49>> so many people.
- 0:50>> Welcome everyone. If you can uh get if
- 0:55you can be on your video uh if you
- 0:58cannot be on video we understand but
- 1:01more people that are on video it's a lot
- 1:03easier for a speaker to talk to live
- 1:06faces. So thank you very much. Uh
- 1:09everyone here knows our fearless leader
- 1:13Dr. Jim Henry, the guru of all tenitis,
- 1:17and our amazing host, David Trorgi, who
- 1:20just saved me. And uh I will introduce
- 1:25you to more people later, but I I am
- 1:28thrilled and delighted to have Dr.
- 1:30Michael Boots here. He is an otologist,
- 1:33an ENT specialist in Gent. Is that how
- 1:38you say it?
- 1:39>> Yeah, in Belgium.
- 1:41>> Belgium.
- 1:42>> And
- 1:43We This is why we had it on a special
- 1:46day. If you will keep yourself muted
- 1:49until we go to the questions and
- 1:51answers. Uh when we go to the questions
- 1:54and answers, please be mindful. We are
- 1:56recording this. I'll send the recording
- 1:58out tomorrow. It will end up on on uh
- 2:01YouTube. So, be mindful of anything you
- 2:04don't want that's out there. Uh, and
- 2:07after when we go to the Q&As's, if you
- 2:10have a question, if you can hit that
- 2:12little orange hand or wave or holler or
- 2:16if you can't handle uh please try to
- 2:20restrict the chat because it's really
- 2:22hard to monitor the chat and you'll see
- 2:24me with these looking the text is small.
- 2:27So, just one more thing I need to Jess
- 2:31did you want to ask something before we
- 2:33start?
- 2:35Let me know.
- 2:37>> No, there somebody has their hand up.
- 2:39>> Okay.
- 2:39>> Okay.
- 2:41>> Well, I'm going to read you our
- 2:43disclaimer.
- 2:45Our tinitis hyperacusis and other sound
- 2:47disorders groups are peer discussion
- 2:50groups focusing on updating and
- 2:53educating patients who live with sound
- 2:55hypersensitivity disorders which is
- 2:58mostly tinitis, tinitis, tonitis and
- 3:01hyperacusis. The information is intended
- 3:04for educational purposes aimed at
- 3:06advancing discussion groups members
- 3:08understanding of current research
- 3:12uh therapies and trends in the heel in
- 3:15the field. We don't uh we really don't
- 3:18endorse any specific product institution
- 3:21or researcher. This does not constitute
- 3:24medical advice. Uh it's for general
- 3:26information only. If you have any
- 3:28specific concerns, please go to your uh
- 3:32practitioner who I have to say as we all
- 3:35know will not know as much about tonitis
- 3:39and hyperacusis as you do with the
- 3:41exception of Dr. Boots. Uh so thank you
- 3:45so much. Do you want to share your
- 3:47screen or are you just going to talk?
- 3:49>> Well, I I made um uh I think I have 20
- 3:53to 30 minutes you told me. Yeah.
- 3:55>> Right. Fine. And I have a PowerPoint
- 3:58that I gave last week. It was a
- 4:01conference on Tinus TR
- 4:03>> and I I I have that PowerPoint, but it's
- 4:06rather um theoretical. So I hope it's
- 4:09okay. If you feel it's too theoretical,
- 4:11just tell me.
- 4:12>> Don't worry about it.
- 4:13>> We are thrilled to hear some real
- 4:15research.
- 4:17>> We don't always get to hear that and so
- 4:19we're thrilled. So if you will hit your
- 4:22share screen and uh we'll start unless
- 4:26you want to talk before that. That's
- 4:28>> no no it's fine. Uh if you feel it's too
- 4:30theoretical or if we say stop down a
- 4:33little bit just tell me and I stop and
- 4:35we talk during the presentation. Uh
- 4:38>> thank you. [clears throat]
- 4:39>> So uh
- 4:42here it is.
- 4:45>> Hit the little share screen button.
- 4:47There you go.
- 4:48>> Can you see it? Yep.
- 4:50>> Okay.
- 4:50>> Yeah.
- 4:54>> So,
- 4:56yes. So, we're treating tinitus and
- 4:57hyperacusis and it's all mixed up. Um it
- 5:00in the beginning it all looks mixed up
- 5:02and there are some similarities and some
- 5:06um
- 5:08things that are not similar. Uh so in
- 5:10tinitus we have continuous tinitus. We
- 5:12have a lot of patient patients with
- 5:14tinitus with fullness feeling, vertigo,
- 5:17hypercusis,
- 5:19uh pain, uh uh headaches, other
- 5:23complaints uh around the head. Then we
- 5:27have people with reactive tenitus which
- 5:29is very similar to hyperrais. Uh every
- 5:31time there's a sound they feel the tinus
- 5:33goes up and you have the immediate ones.
- 5:36So there's a sound and whoops the
- 5:39tinitus goes up and then you have the
- 5:40delayed many feel that when they go to a
- 5:43restaurant in the evening the tinitus is
- 5:45a little bit louder.
- 5:47So there's a difference between these
- 5:49immediate and these delayed forms and
- 5:51then you have tinitus disorder which
- 5:53means tinitus with uh concentration
- 5:55problems anxiety sleeplessness and so
- 5:58on. So there are different types of
- 6:00tinitus. Now hyperacusis as you all know
- 6:03because I I have the impression that
- 6:04most people with hyperacus are very very
- 6:06much uh know very much about it. Uh so
- 6:10you have loudness, anxiety, annoyance
- 6:12and pain hyperacusis typically. But
- 6:14there again you have people who tell me
- 6:16we notice that most of pain hyperacusis.
- 6:20Uh some people uh there's a sound and
- 6:22then whoops their pains come up comes up
- 6:25and then the sound stops and the pain
- 6:27stops while in others the sound comes up
- 6:30nothing happens but after 20 minutes of
- 6:33sound exposure slowly the pain comes up
- 6:36and then it lasts for hours weeks so two
- 6:40different types very strange then you
- 6:43have people have a a stable threshold
- 6:44and an unstable threshold people who
- 6:46tell me okay every time I'm exposed to a
- 6:49sound my loudness or pain or whatever
- 6:51comes up and it can last some time but
- 6:54then when it goes down I'm going back to
- 6:56the to the previous state nothing
- 6:59changes in the long term while in others
- 7:02every time there's a sound exposure they
- 7:04have their symptoms and then they notice
- 7:07that their threshold has come a little
- 7:09bit low so the problem has become a
- 7:12little bit worse and over time these
- 7:14people get worse and worse and worse
- 7:16with every exposure so again two
- 7:18different types
- 7:19And then also like in tinitus disorder
- 7:21you have sound hypersensitivity disorder
- 7:23which is hyp hyperacusis plus
- 7:27sleeplessness uh anxiety concentration
- 7:30problems and in the end loss of energy
- 7:33depression and so on and then you have
- 7:35all kinds of other complaints and this
- 7:37is with my background from ENT where I
- 7:40started with finitus that is the
- 7:43fullness feeling in the ear which I
- 7:44notice very very very often in
- 7:48And then uh vertigo uh pain, migraine,
- 7:54um nasal pain, uh burning mouth
- 7:57syndrome, all types of symptoms that go
- 8:00together with tinitus and or hyperus.
- 8:04Now um
- 8:07I come from tempanic membrane and tensor
- 8:11tmpony background which means that as an
- 8:13ENT I started out by uh working with the
- 8:17tempanic membrane. Um and uh what I
- 8:21found a long time ago was that if I
- 8:23applied a paper patch on the tempanic
- 8:24membrane that a lot of complaints were
- 8:27better. Very strange very very strange.
- 8:30So people with hyperacusis that said oh
- 8:32my hyperacusis is better or vertigo or
- 8:35pain fullness feeling very often tinitus
- 8:38sometimes. Um so I did it for many years
- 8:44for a long time I just tried by trial
- 8:46and error I applied cigarette papers on
- 8:47the tempanic membrane and um I found
- 8:51that it worked in many cases but then
- 8:53when I put it on the wrong location on
- 8:56the tempanic membrane people got worse.
- 8:59So I removed it and I put it on the
- 9:00right location and then say they said
- 9:02it's better. So there must be nerve
- 9:05endings and and receptor endings that
- 9:08measure the tension of the tempanic
- 9:10membrane and that respond to it when the
- 9:12tension of tempanic membrane is too
- 9:14high. They provoke problems. So um I
- 9:18read a lot of things. uh clock is the
- 9:20man who started everything with tensor
- 9:22temp tensor temp syndrome in the 70s but
- 9:25even older books 1920s 1930s 1910 uh the
- 9:30older ENTs who had a lot of interesting
- 9:33information and then there was work by
- 9:36Miriam Westcot who you know uh who
- 9:39developed the concept of acoustic shock
- 9:42and then Arnon Norina uh which I will
- 9:45talk about a bit later and then finally
- 9:47um Robangar also
- 9:49And so what we developed was an idea
- 9:51that uh this tensor tempony we started
- 9:54with tensor temp but now believe tens of
- 9:56vid palatini is also very important. So
- 9:58you have those two muscles tensor temp
- 10:00which increases the tension of the
- 10:02tempanic membrane. tens vid paralatini
- 10:05which is the brother uh of this muscle
- 10:08and increases well it very in a very
- 10:11difficult way closes the taken tube
- 10:13opens it up here and closes it in
- 10:15another part
- 10:17and we believe that these are at the
- 10:18center of a huge system that's related
- 10:21to attention and you have in this system
- 10:23you have inputs
- 10:25you have central throughput and then you
- 10:27have outputs and the general idea is
- 10:29that if a sound arrives in my ear these
- 10:34receptors will carry capture the sound
- 10:37they will send it to I believe this is
- 10:40the way it acts but I'm not sure but I
- 10:42think that's the way it works these
- 10:44receptors activate tens of tempt and
- 10:47maybe some other muscles these start to
- 10:49contract so there's nothing you can do
- 10:51about it whenever there's a sound these
- 10:53muscles will start to contract okay and
- 10:56then you choose to listen to that sound
- 10:58then they contract even more
- 11:01and The fact that these muscles contract
- 11:04sends signals to other locations to the
- 11:06output. So your skin will get a little
- 11:09bit more sensitive.
- 11:11Part of your uh smell, part of your
- 11:14taste, there's a trigeminal aspect on
- 11:16that. So the same nerve will be
- 11:18activated. Uh in animals, the whiskers
- 11:21will be activated, the ears will come
- 11:23up. Um the hairs will come up a little
- 11:26bit. Your muscles will start to
- 11:28contract. I believe that your uh
- 11:30vestibular system so your equilibrium
- 11:32will be activated so you're a bit more
- 11:35stable
- 11:37um and you can get local uh symptoms
- 11:39also. So the general idea is if a sound
- 11:43comes in then your whole your antenna
- 11:48will be activated. Uh the things that
- 11:51capture information from the outside
- 11:52world they will close off your inner
- 11:55sounds and make you open for external
- 11:58sounds. Not only hearing but everything.
- 12:03Um same if you get some electrical
- 12:05stimulation. This has been proven long
- 12:07time ago. Same if you contract certain
- 12:10muscles
- 12:11um and the whole system will be
- 12:14activated when you want to listen which
- 12:16means or because you want to have some
- 12:19listening effort uh some jobs you
- 12:22because your hearing is not so good so
- 12:24you're going to really to activate the
- 12:26system and you see what I do I'm I'm
- 12:28listening I'm contracting all those
- 12:30muscles
- 12:32uh or because of uh uh uh vigilance
- 12:35alertness
- 12:36so hyper vigilance which we all know is
- 12:40uh when you think the world is is not so
- 12:42safe, you try to get as much information
- 12:44and you're going to activate the system
- 12:46and it happens in all of us. Um and very
- 12:49strangely it's only when this period of
- 12:51stress is over very often that
- 12:53complaints develop because the stress is
- 12:56over but the system remains activated.
- 12:59So you have this acoustic stimuli uh you
- 13:02have this central stimuli hypervigilance
- 13:05listening effort. You have sensory
- 13:07stimula the nerve endings you have motor
- 13:10stimuli the the muscles the jaw and neck
- 13:11muscles and then you can have local
- 13:14stimula also for example a teeth
- 13:16problems or whatever. And the idea is
- 13:20that every time you activate it's called
- 13:23trigeminal cervical trigeminal is the
- 13:26face. It's mostly the lower part of the
- 13:29face and the ear. Cervical is the neck.
- 13:31So all these are inputs that activate
- 13:34the system and then you get this
- 13:36increase in uh sensory output. So so uh
- 13:41your your skin your muscles but also
- 13:44your hearing you can get your hearing
- 13:46will get a little bit sharper. It's not
- 13:48that your hearing gets better. It's not
- 13:51that you hear if you do tests before and
- 13:53after treatment for this it does not
- 13:56change in in quantity. It's about
- 13:58quality. It's the intrusiveness of the
- 14:01hearing. It's the sharpness. It's the
- 14:03emotional aspect of the hearing. It's
- 14:05all those things that are not really
- 14:06content but everything that's around it
- 14:08that gets yes sharper.
- 14:12Um okay. So this is the idea that we
- 14:14have and not all of this has been
- 14:16proven. Um there was a huge leap forward
- 14:20when Arnon Norina
- 14:22did his um results and actually he has
- 14:24proven part of it. Um part of it is
- 14:27still hypothesis. So uh clockov a long
- 14:30time ago ago described the tensotmpony
- 14:32syndrome and tensotmpony syndrome is
- 14:33actually all of these little bit of
- 14:35hyperacusis a little bit of tinitus a
- 14:38little bit of uh muffled hearing or uh
- 14:42dull hearing a little bit of fullness
- 14:44feeling or a lot of fullness feeling a
- 14:45little bit of headache little bit of
- 14:47vertigo. So a little bit of everything
- 14:49and actually that's not so difficult to
- 14:51cure if you see the clusters. So the the
- 14:54thing is you have to see those clusters
- 14:56of symptoms and many doctors uh if you
- 15:00if you don't know it you won't see it
- 15:02but once you see it you can't unsee it
- 15:05and so this all these uh complaints
- 15:08together help you know if this is a
- 15:09diagnosis so I I work with paper
- 15:11patching I work with um physotherapy
- 15:15botox uh a lot of things to calm down
- 15:17the system so what we actually do is
- 15:19decrease the inputs so the outputs
- 15:21decrease also
- 15:23Now
- 15:25when you have real tinitus or
- 15:26hyperacquisit this more than this um so
- 15:31you all know in tinitus everybody talks
- 15:33about neuroplastic changes and the
- 15:35typical example is in tinitus uh okay
- 15:38there's hearing loss so normally the
- 15:41input from the ear coming to the hearing
- 15:43pathways is disconnected they don't know
- 15:46what to do so they're going to couple to
- 15:48another input so from then on instead of
- 15:52hearing fibers coming in and going to
- 15:55the cortex, you'll have triinal cervical
- 15:58fibers of the listening system. So I
- 16:00call this the hearing pathway. I call
- 16:02this trigeminal cervical complex. I call
- 16:04this the listening system. Uh and from
- 16:07then on, every time you increase your
- 16:09input in your listening system, you get
- 16:11an increase in tinitus.
- 16:13So this is the classical example. But
- 16:14many people don't have uh don't have
- 16:17hearing loss. We see many people without
- 16:19any hearing loss.
- 16:21There's another type Weinberger is
- 16:24somebody who did a lot of research on
- 16:25that and he showed that you can have
- 16:27neuroplasticity
- 16:29without any hearing loss. You don't need
- 16:30hearing loss. What you need is
- 16:33conditioning, urgency and a trigger.
- 16:35What this means? Neuroplasticity means a
- 16:37brain changes. So when you're a student
- 16:40and you want to study and you want to
- 16:42study but you don't have any exam, it's
- 16:44very difficult to study. The system
- 16:45doesn't want to change. Costs energy.
- 16:48You don't want that. But if you study
- 16:50and you're having an exam the next day,
- 16:53it's very easy to study. Everything goes
- 16:55inside your memory is is is triggered.
- 16:58Why? Because there's an urgency. You
- 17:00have to. So the system says, okay, we'll
- 17:03change. Um also there's a conditioning.
- 17:06If you think well I missed my exam, it
- 17:09won't work. It's not going to to happen.
- 17:11Your neuroplasticity, you won't memorize
- 17:14anything. They think, okay, I have a
- 17:15chance of getting through. It's worth
- 17:17it. you get there and then you need a
- 17:20trigger. The exam is the trigger. Well,
- 17:22the same in tinitus and hyperrais mostly
- 17:25in tinitus is people tell me well I went
- 17:28to a party and oh, you know, the music
- 17:31was not that loud and I was a little bit
- 17:34afraid that something would happen and I
- 17:36came home and there was tinitus. So, you
- 17:37see there's this conditioning people
- 17:40thinking, "Oh, this sound will harm me."
- 17:43um and then they start to contract their
- 17:46muscles because they get hypervigilant.
- 17:49Uh there's an urgency and when I talk to
- 17:51these people always always always before
- 17:54it happened the last week before it
- 17:55happened there was a period of stress
- 17:57intense stress. So they had it's like a
- 17:59football player you know they have weeks
- 18:02and weeks and months and months of
- 18:03training and then they go on the field
- 18:04and they get a tick on their on their
- 18:07legs and they crawl they they fall all
- 18:10over. Not because they this was so
- 18:12heavy, but because their muscles had
- 18:14been contracting for months and months
- 18:16and months and then they just need some
- 18:17small stimulus to cramp. And this is the
- 18:21the the trigger. And the triggers can be
- 18:24a sound, it can be an emotional shock,
- 18:26it can be vaccination, it can be a
- 18:28medication, it can be uh oh whatever uh
- 18:31an infection, a car accident. We see
- 18:34many things and always the trigger seems
- 18:36so stupid. You all say why why the
- 18:39stupid trigger and you don't have to
- 18:40look at the trigger but you have to look
- 18:42at what's what came before the urgency
- 18:44and the conditioning. So people go to a
- 18:47doctor and he says oh so it's damage
- 18:49nothing is come it's for the rest of
- 18:51your life and you were stupid to to go
- 18:53there to the party and this is
- 18:55reinforcement of the conditioning and
- 18:57this makes it worse.
- 19:01Now uh if it goes on and on you get this
- 19:04uh this anxiety those um sleeping
- 19:08problems concentration loss this tinitus
- 19:10disorders. Now the most interesting
- 19:12thing I think for hyperacusis anyway is
- 19:15that Arno Norina a few years ago with
- 19:17Philip Fier from Quebec and Arno is from
- 19:20in France
- 19:22they have shown that in some patient
- 19:23with hyperacusis and variable tinitus
- 19:26the tensor tony contracts in an
- 19:29exaggerated way. So there was an um uh a
- 19:33device to measure the the pressure of
- 19:36the tempic membrane and you could see in
- 19:38some patients that when you gave a sound
- 19:40that this device warps this tensor
- 19:42tempony ex contracted in an exaggerated
- 19:46way which actually means that this
- 19:47neuroplasticity has not taken place in
- 19:51the hearing pathways but that there's a
- 19:52problem at the level of the tensor tony
- 19:55at the trigeminal nuclei at the
- 19:57listening system. Um and um when you use
- 20:02this device you see that the stensor
- 20:05contracts in an exaggerated exagger
- 20:08exaggerated way in some patients but not
- 20:11in other patients. In other patients you
- 20:12don't see anything at all. Very strange.
- 20:15So what happens in these patients is you
- 20:18get a simple stimulus but you get an
- 20:21exaggerated response there. You see when
- 20:24the stimulus comes in it goes to the
- 20:26brain stem and there it goes to the
- 20:29muscles TT TVP tensi
- 20:33and then it goes to the skin to the
- 20:35muscles and it goes to the hearing
- 20:37pathways and the brain but there
- 20:39something has happened instead of one
- 20:42relay you have two or three relays you
- 20:44have an exaggerated uh neuron going
- 20:47further on um and this from time from
- 20:51from then on every time there's is a a
- 20:53simple stupid stimulus, you get this
- 20:56much exaggerated response. Be it in
- 20:58hearing, be it in pain, be it in motor
- 21:01contraction, whatever.
- 21:05Um, and so you don't need any hearing
- 21:07loss for this. It's purely on another
- 21:09level. It's is it the listening path,
- 21:11listening system? Is it nuclei? It has
- 21:14nothing to do with the ear actually.
- 21:16Uh so you see a small stimulus and an
- 21:18exaggerated response. And if this goes
- 21:20on and on because your conditioning is
- 21:22there because people think something is
- 21:25horrible, this is going to get worse and
- 21:26worse and they they get afraid which I
- 21:29can understand and um they feel bad and
- 21:33their life is getting more and more
- 21:34difficult. You get this urgency and from
- 21:37then on then on every trigger will
- 21:39increase the problem and you get more
- 21:41and more central problems as anxiety,
- 21:44sleepless problems but also here um uh
- 21:48some of our patients have pain uh
- 21:51starting in the ear and then it goes to
- 21:52the jaw then it goes to the shoulder and
- 21:54then even to to the to the hands all
- 21:57over the body. So you see this
- 21:59increasing thing. So I think this is
- 22:02neuroplasticity
- 22:04going on and on and on. So this is um
- 22:08when I see people who tell me that the
- 22:11problem is getting worse and worse and
- 22:12worse, I think wow I see neuroplastic
- 22:15changes happening before my eyes, the
- 22:17first thing I have to do is stop this.
- 22:20So stop this ongoing neuroplasticity.
- 22:23Um and I think I have to work on this
- 22:26conditioning, on this urgency, and on
- 22:28the triggers. First and for all stop
- 22:30this if I see somebody who tells me yes
- 22:32I've been having hyperacusis for five
- 22:35years and every time it it it it remains
- 22:38stable I say okay this is a stable
- 22:40situation I don't have to work on that
- 22:43so
- 22:45you have
- 22:47neuroplasticity in the hearing pathways
- 22:49and in the listening system or the
- 22:51trigeminal system and uh these are
- 22:54different things and what I think I'm
- 22:57not sure yet what I think
- 22:59The people who tell me I have tinitus
- 23:01and it's louder when I come home after
- 23:04an evening in the restaurant or when I
- 23:06have some physical exercise or uh when
- 23:10I'm stressed. I think that's that's the
- 23:12left one. I think it's in the hearing
- 23:14pane. But when I see people who tell me
- 23:17it's an immediate response uh there's a
- 23:19sound and my tinitus goes up or my
- 23:21hyperacusis is there or I feel pain or I
- 23:24feel noises or anxiety. I think it's the
- 23:26right side. I think it's sensitization
- 23:29at the trigeminal level.
- 23:32Uh again, not much of this has been
- 23:34proven. These are all ideas, uh
- 23:36observations, clinical experience. Um
- 23:40but it seems logical to me. So as I told
- 23:44if I see someone who's going in the
- 23:47wrong direction, it's like he's skiing
- 23:48on a slope and falling and always
- 23:50falling, falling, falling. First thing I
- 23:51have to do is stop him falling up.
- 23:54Immobilize him. And I think we have to
- 23:56stop this. neuroplasticity going on and
- 23:59the next thing is then treat the input
- 24:00and actually treating the input is what
- 24:03everybody in the field is doing for
- 24:05tinitus for hyperacquis there decreasing
- 24:08the input if you decrease the acoustic
- 24:11stimuli it's uh of course it's logical
- 24:15um you want to decrease listening effort
- 24:17so you give people a hearing aid you
- 24:20want to decrease hypervigilance so you
- 24:22give uh psychological treatment you give
- 24:25medication
- 24:26uh mental coach all those things. You
- 24:30want to decrease motor input. So you
- 24:32send people to the physiotherapist
- 24:34and we do some local things also like
- 24:36this paper patching. So actually this is
- 24:39what is treatment of tinitus is actually
- 24:42decreasing and hyperus is decreasing the
- 24:44input. Now this works people say it's
- 24:48better. It's not gone but you know the
- 24:50fullness feeling is gone. Uh the pain is
- 24:53gone. The vertigo is gone. my tinus.
- 24:55Well, it's still there, but I can live
- 24:56with it. Uh, hyperacusis, okay, it's not
- 25:00as it used to be. It's still there, but
- 25:02okay, I can live with it. And they
- 25:04relapse, of course, because you don't do
- 25:06anything about the problem itself. You
- 25:08don't do anything about the the
- 25:09neuroplasticity that's taking place
- 25:11about the changes. So, you decrease the
- 25:14input, but then there's a period of
- 25:16stress and it comes up again.
- 25:20And this is new. Um, and I'm not even
- 25:24quite sure if we be able to do that. The
- 25:27idea is you stop the neuroplasticity
- 25:29taking place. You take away the input
- 25:32and then you should try to get the
- 25:35system learn in another direction. So
- 25:38induce another neuroplasticity but done
- 25:41in the right direction
- 25:43instead of the system going from uh
- 25:47relaxed to more and more alertness more
- 25:50and more hypervigilant more and more
- 25:53answering to any stimulus you get should
- 25:56get the system to learn that the world
- 25:59is safe and that these responses are not
- 26:01necessary and I'm not sure if we can get
- 26:03there at this moment it's very difficult
- 26:05at this moment mostly we stop after we
- 26:08decrease the input.
- 26:11So this is what we actually do in our
- 26:13clinic now is when we see somebody we
- 26:15try to evaluate is it still going on? Is
- 26:19there an unstable baseline? Is this
- 26:21person on a slope and slipping falling
- 26:23down or is he stable? And then we're
- 26:26going to look coitions at at the
- 26:29conditions. We are going to look is
- 26:31there an urgency? How stressed is he? Is
- 26:34there conditioning? Does he have ideas
- 26:35about danger sound being dangerous about
- 26:39uh this thing going to be for the rest
- 26:41of his life about impossible to do
- 26:44something and then facilitating
- 26:46conditions sleep loss inactivity? It's
- 26:48incredible how many people I see who
- 26:51tell me oh yes I had an problem at my
- 26:54knee I had surgery at my feet and I I
- 26:56stopped doing sports uh six months ago.
- 26:59It's incredible once you start asking
- 27:01it. so many people who do not practice
- 27:04sports anymore and I think it it's it's
- 27:07it looks a bit stupid but I think it has
- 27:09a huge impact. Uh doing sports does a
- 27:13lot to all those things.
- 27:17Uh some medication I think may increase
- 27:19or decrease neuroplasticity
- 27:21and of course yes we have to evaluate if
- 27:24there are any triggers. So the first
- 27:26trigger may have been for example I
- 27:29don't know a car accident or a
- 27:30vaccination but then people get aware of
- 27:34the stimulus that is sound and from then
- 27:37on uh sound becomes a trigger uh because
- 27:41of this idea that sound is dangerous and
- 27:43then it it becomes dangerous at the end.
- 27:47So and we treat these. So we give them
- 27:50counseling you know these are the
- 27:51classical things uh u uh psychological
- 27:56aiology counseling explaining them uh
- 27:59trying to get them their sleep better uh
- 28:02trying to get them to do some sports and
- 28:05eliminating all triggers.
- 28:07Uh and then the next thing is actually
- 28:09what what the present day therapy is
- 28:12about. It's decreasing inputs. Now in
- 28:15case of hyperacusis the trigger input is
- 28:18sound. That's clear. That's very clear
- 28:20but there are sounds all over and you
- 28:22cannot really eliminate that. So it's
- 28:25more interesting to look at the other
- 28:26inputs which are often covered. So uh
- 28:30listening effort can be one and we saw
- 28:32it very dramatically in one of of our
- 28:34pain hyperacquis patients who uh
- 28:37worsened whose condition worsened very
- 28:39much because of uh ongoing listening
- 28:43effort hours and hours without any loud
- 28:45sound. So it in some people it is
- 28:47important and others not at all. sound
- 28:49exposure, of course, hypervigilance, and
- 28:53we see people that go to a more um
- 28:57scanning, we call it scanning related,
- 28:59so anxiety for things that might happen.
- 29:02Very often in hyperacusis we notice that
- 29:04it's more a focusing behavior trying to
- 29:06get the world more uh safe because sound
- 29:10is dangerous and and and some people we
- 29:12see that they after some time they get
- 29:15to a more controlling way uh of of being
- 29:18in the world uh which actually is is of
- 29:22course good because they make their
- 29:24world safer. they avoid sounds. But I
- 29:27believe that this hypervigilance
- 29:30also uh activates the whole system and
- 29:33makes these muscles contract.
- 29:36Uh sensory inputs uh motor inputs. So
- 29:39this is physotherapy, Botox and so on.
- 29:42And then local. So this is actually what
- 29:44we at at the present time we can do and
- 29:46and what we can choose from and and and
- 29:48I believe that we have to do several
- 29:50things together. If you do one thing,
- 29:52nothing worse. But if you combine things
- 29:54then you get somewhere.
- 29:56Uh so what can you do? Input
- 29:58hypervigilance medication uh
- 30:01psychological therapy. Uh static
- 30:03ganglium bug sometimes makes people more
- 30:06relaxed but it doesn't last. Sound
- 30:08exposure bivvakine is is a local
- 30:10anesthetic but it doesn't last. It it
- 30:12lasts only a few hours. Physotherapy
- 30:15botox same. It lasts for three months.
- 30:18Uh and then surgery have the the silver
- 30:21surgery. Um then you can try to work on
- 30:24the TTTVP.
- 30:27Uh people ask me spin palatine ganglion
- 30:29here and there. You heard somebody
- 30:31here's somebody that was happy with that
- 30:33and I tried it a few times and sometimes
- 30:35was good sometimes not. So I it's in my
- 30:38opinion I I I don't find it incredible.
- 30:42Uh again you can work at the output. So
- 30:44the the nerve endings BP vacine nerve
- 30:46blocks botox and physotherapy.
- 30:49So these are the things we can work on
- 30:54and then the last step uh which is still
- 30:57a question mark I'm not sure but this is
- 31:00where we in our clinic are now going to
- 31:02so we
- 31:04try to evaluate is it neuroplasticity in
- 31:07the hearing pathway or in the trigeminal
- 31:09system so for hyperacusis it's I think
- 31:12mostly or always in the the trigeminal
- 31:15system and then evaluate the same thing
- 31:18how ready are people to get their
- 31:20neuroplasticity
- 31:22directed, activated but in a good
- 31:24direction and we do things we do biodal
- 31:27stimulation of tinitus we do electro
- 31:29stimulation of muscles we do a lot of
- 31:31things and we see that uh often people
- 31:34respond well and from time to time
- 31:36people respond in a wrong way their
- 31:38tinitus or the hyperacusis gets worse
- 31:41and I think what we're doing is we're
- 31:43inducing neuroplasticity in a system
- 31:45that's still geared in the wrong
- 31:46direction towards
- 31:48more
- 31:50uh alertness, vigilance. So I think it's
- 31:53very very important but again this is
- 31:55not scientific yet. This is first ideas,
- 31:58first thoughts and we're going to do it
- 32:00that way and then hopefully in a year
- 32:03we'll be able to show something. Uh I
- 32:05think we really want to gear the system
- 32:08in the right direction. So the urgency
- 32:10and the conditioning get expectation and
- 32:13motivation, hope. Um these are all nice
- 32:17terms but they're very important I
- 32:20think. um with counseling, with
- 32:23psychological treatment, with starting
- 32:25to doing physical activity, with
- 32:28medication if needed. And then uh people
- 32:31have to be able to sleep. Uh we're
- 32:35thinking of medication that helps
- 32:36inducing neuroplasticity. And this is
- 32:39where we want to go to to if you would
- 32:42be able to induce neuroplasticity in the
- 32:44right direction then there would be no
- 32:46relapse because then from then on you
- 32:49could stand stimuli without this
- 32:52increased response. So but this is is
- 32:54the future at this moment we are at the
- 32:58stage of
- 33:00decreasing the input.
- 33:05Um
- 33:06so
- 33:08uh what we do in the clinic and what we
- 33:12do as a research what we do in the
- 33:13clinic is mainly reducing the input.
- 33:17So um what we want to do is to try and
- 33:23personalize the treatment. So we want
- 33:24for every patient that we see to see
- 33:28which of the inputs that we know is
- 33:30responsible in this particular patient.
- 33:32So it appears that in some patients
- 33:34hyper vision in most patients anxiety,
- 33:37hypervigilance, focus uh are very
- 33:40important. From time to time there's
- 33:42somebody in who there's no psychological
- 33:44aspect at all. We see them but in most
- 33:47people we all humans and we all have
- 33:49this um listening for it mostly doesn't
- 33:52matter but in some people it is really
- 33:54very important. Sound exposure of course
- 33:56is for everybody very important. And
- 33:58then in some people we try
- 34:00[clears throat] trial therapies. I I
- 34:02often inject local anesthetics. Uh we do
- 34:05electro stimulation of the muscles and
- 34:07if people tell us well the day after the
- 34:10stimulation was 20% better okay we say
- 34:13these muscles we can treat them we go
- 34:14for it. Um and uh we try all these these
- 34:19things and it takes us a lot of time. It
- 34:21takes us a month, a month and a half for
- 34:23these trial therapies to see in this
- 34:26patient well it's mainly a motor problem
- 34:29or in this patient it's mainly uh an
- 34:32anxiety problem related to obsessive
- 34:35behavior whatever or in this patient it
- 34:37appears to be a local problem uh and and
- 34:40then we try to get some personalized
- 34:42treatments of these inputs but as I told
- 34:45you it works people are rather happy it
- 34:49doesn't disappear it gets
- 34:51But they relapse sooner or later and
- 34:52then we do the same therapy and it works
- 34:54again. This is where we are standing
- 34:57where we want to go to is this. So we we
- 35:00doing some research
- 35:02and these are the things I I um
- 35:06I gave a talk on on in this conference
- 35:08last week. Uh one was with burpy vakina.
- 35:11Whoopy vaccine is local anesthetic is is
- 35:13actually what what your dentist injects
- 35:16and uh so you get some anesthesia and
- 35:18after four five six hours it's gone. And
- 35:22uh we injected that in some people um
- 35:26a bit everywhere around the ear and the
- 35:28muscles and the sensory nerve endings
- 35:30all over. And we noticed that in quite
- 35:33some people their tinitus or
- 35:35hyperacquisa disappeared for a few
- 35:36hours. And uh what was interesting in
- 35:40people with continuous tinitus it did
- 35:42not work at all but people with variable
- 35:44tinitus it did work with pulsatile
- 35:47tinitus and with hyperacusis. So I have
- 35:50in my idea variable actu tinitus
- 35:54pulsatile tinitus are more related to
- 35:57hyperacusis than to continuous tinitus.
- 35:59I I I really see two things and I think
- 36:01that's the norina thing. I think that
- 36:04variable tinitus is more related to the
- 36:07trigeminal nuclei than to the hearing
- 36:08system because of these results. There
- 36:10was somebody else
- 36:13from Germany who did exactly the same
- 36:16but on another location more centrally
- 36:18located at the nerve base and who had
- 36:22very similar uh results. So there is
- 36:25something there but at this time uh it
- 36:29does work but it's only temporary. So
- 36:30now the idea is how can we make it more
- 36:33lasting?
- 36:36Um I had one patient in who the response
- 36:40lasted for a week. So I did in her uh
- 36:43week after week after week and after
- 36:45eight weeks it had gone but that's only
- 36:47one patient.
- 36:49Um and um I am trying Botox instead of
- 36:53bipakin because Botox also works on
- 36:56sensory nerve endings not only on on on
- 36:58muscles but this is just the beginning
- 37:00and I'm not sure if this will give
- 37:02something. Um but there may be something
- 37:06there. So this is working on the input
- 37:09on the sensory input or output
- 37:15actually more on the output if it's pain
- 37:19more on the input if it's loudness
- 37:21hyperacusis [clears throat] so this is
- 37:23something where I think we will work on
- 37:27further and we hope it may lead to
- 37:29something
- 37:31um then uh I have a little experience
- 37:34with surgery but not very
- 37:37I only started to doing the silverstein
- 37:39technique uh I think last year. Um and
- 37:45another surgery that I'm doing is um
- 37:48when I apply a tempanic a patch a paper
- 37:50patch on tipanic membrane and people are
- 37:53happy with the result. Um normally we
- 37:55try to look at the underlying things is
- 37:57what I explained the the other inputs.
- 38:00Um but sometimes we don't get very far
- 38:02and it we don't get further we don't
- 38:05succeed and people three or four times
- 38:08tell me that they're happy with their
- 38:09patch and they apply a permanent patch.
- 38:11So it's a small surgery and I've uh I
- 38:14increase the tension of the tempanic
- 38:16membrane by applying kind of a patch.
- 38:19Now um
- 38:21Silverstein has another idea. He
- 38:24increases the thickness of the round
- 38:26window and over time he started doing
- 38:28the oval window also and then he calls
- 38:31it the extended surgery. He now does a
- 38:34part of the tipanic membrane also which
- 38:36exactly which is exactly what we do with
- 38:39the with the patch. So these
- 38:42surgeries are coming together. Um
- 38:45um I think what Silverstein surgery does
- 38:50is applying a cushion. It's like uh
- 38:53hearing protection on the inside again
- 38:55the same as we see at Botox with other
- 38:58things. You decrease the input but you
- 39:00don't do anything about the problem
- 39:02itself. It's my idea. I I'm I have don't
- 39:05have huge experience. I only did it for
- 39:08the last year. I did not do many
- 39:09patients. Um but this uh is my first
- 39:13impression and I think it may be
- 39:15interesting in some people as it
- 39:17decreases the input.
- 39:19Um same with other treatments it's not a
- 39:22cure but okay it can be interesting. U
- 39:26at this moment I have but I did only a
- 39:29few case I have the impression is better
- 39:30for loudness hyperis than pain
- 39:32hypercusis.
- 39:34Um the tempanic patching uh I don't
- 39:38operate very often because I like to go
- 39:41to the to the underlying causes but uh
- 39:44same small surgery and um the nice thing
- 39:47is you don't have any hearing loss in in
- 39:49the service surgery I often have a
- 39:50slight hearing loss uh by applying a
- 39:53patch I don't have any hearing loss um
- 39:56yes in in selected cases it may be
- 39:58interesting so these are local things
- 40:00but again this I think what we need some
- 40:04objective measurement to measure what we
- 40:06do because we're always very reluctant
- 40:07to do surgery. If you don't know what's
- 40:09happening and and there may be placebo
- 40:11effect and so on and I I don't want to
- 40:14do it that much. Uh once we have a
- 40:17measurement method then I think we do
- 40:19much more of this. We know what we'll be
- 40:21doing and and and how it works and what
- 40:24results are and then I think this will
- 40:25be something in the future. Um, another
- 40:28thing we did was Botox for pain
- 40:30hyperuses. And so, yes, we started
- 40:34because people asked us to do that. Uh,
- 40:37because in the Norina paper, somebody
- 40:40was better after Botox injection and
- 40:43people asked us to prescribe chopramine
- 40:46also
- 40:47um because it helped in some patients.
- 40:50So we had some patients that we treated
- 40:52with combination of chromopramin or um
- 40:57similar uh vanlafaxine
- 41:00uh clonam
- 41:02um and uh and botox injections intensive
- 41:05viparatini and the TVP which is actually
- 41:08one of the main muscles involved and um
- 41:15one did not change very much. Um no
- 41:21one um has really it's it's there's a
- 41:24lot of psychology there so he needs
- 41:26further psychological treatment then two
- 41:28people did not change very much but one
- 41:31did not had have it in the TVP but in
- 41:33other muscles
- 41:35uh one did not have the medication so I
- 41:38have the impression that you need both
- 41:40and the medication and the botox and I
- 41:42think that the medication is more
- 41:43important than the botox at this moment
- 41:45but this is all very new and and and and
- 41:48our experience experience is very very
- 41:50limited. So maybe in in two years I'll
- 41:52tell something else. Uh but then there
- 41:55were uh four people who reacted very
- 41:58well. One of them has relapsed in a
- 42:00quite spectacular way and I hope she's
- 42:03going better again now. Um but we don't
- 42:07know exactly why.
- 42:10Um and then three are very very happy
- 42:12and these were people with pain
- 42:14hyperuses that had not come out of their
- 42:16house for months or years and who are
- 42:19now able to go to the restaurant uh to
- 42:22go to parties and they come back every 3
- 42:24months for their Botox.
- 42:27Um now again this is preliminary this
- 42:30your it's a very limited number of
- 42:32patients and maybe in two years we say
- 42:34okay now no now we thought it was this
- 42:36way but blah blah blah. Um
- 42:39I think this is decreasing the input and
- 42:43as I told before I think what we want to
- 42:46do right now is continue this uh Botox
- 42:49clomopamine or Botox vendelfac
- 42:52medication and combine it in a broad of
- 42:55treatment uh as in psychological perhaps
- 42:59after some time even exposure therapy
- 43:02um conditioning urgency you know all
- 43:05these things in order to perhaps and
- 43:08then maybe some electro stimulation.
- 43:10We're not sure yet in order to hopefully
- 43:12get a lasting result to something more
- 43:15than just the well just decrease the the
- 43:17input.
- 43:19So this is where it's standing now uh in
- 43:22our clinic what we're doing right now.
- 43:24You see some things we succeed we know
- 43:27some things but a lot is still uh
- 43:30unclear uncertain and future work. Um,
- 43:35well, that's it.
- 43:43I don't hear you.
- 43:59I'm not the only thing.
- 44:08Have you put on your microphone?
- 44:36So I hope it was not too theoretical
- 44:38well with this PowerPoint. I hope it was
- 44:40not too difficult. Um it's very
- 44:42difficult for me to know how to explain
- 44:44these things without becoming too
- 44:46theoretical. So I hope it was
- 44:48>> No, it was not. It was a beautiful,
- 44:51beautiful, fabulous overview.
- 44:53>> Okay. Thank you.
- 44:55One thing I want to say before we go on,
- 44:59uh, you cannot unmute unmute yourself
- 45:03this meeting. So, when you raise your
- 45:05hand and then I'll call on you and
- 45:07David, our host, will unmute you. But,
- 45:09I'll take the first comment because I
- 45:11can.
- 45:13>> First [clears throat] of all, I loved
- 45:15the way we could see you up close. I've
- 45:18not seen that on a PowerPoint before.
- 45:21So, we could watch you talk and not have
- 45:23to look in the little square. That was
- 45:25really beautiful. The other thing I want
- 45:27to mention is not all of us, but a lot
- 45:31of us swear that our tenitis has come on
- 45:35from stress. So many people that now not
- 45:39hyperacusis, but with tonitis, you can
- 45:42have it your whole life and then all of
- 45:43a sudden, bang. And so many people I
- 45:47have talked to including myself said
- 45:50just what you said was right after a
- 45:52period of stress and the way you said
- 45:56that the world is a scary place. Tinidis
- 45:59and hyper accuses are scary and no
- 46:02wonder we react like that. But before I
- 46:04go on, I want to tell you all that our
- 46:07uh our uh mindfulness guru David Veri is
- 46:12going to present at my meeting on
- 46:15Saturday. And if you don't have the the
- 46:18form, please email me because he's going
- 46:20to tell you how to habituate. So, thank
- 46:23you, Michael. That was just it wasn't
- 46:26too technical and it was beautiful. So,
- 46:28>> okay.
- 46:28>> Okay. I'm going to go to the to the
- 46:31questions now. I uh don't speak French,
- 46:33so if somebody wants to get in the chat
- 46:36and read the French questions.
- 46:38Okay, Bonnie. Bonnie has a question.
- 46:45>> You have to unmute her. I think
- 46:49>> David's going to send you a note that
- 46:51says, "Unmute yourself, Bonnie." Then
- 46:53you press on the unmute yourself.
- 46:59You want to go to John before Bonnie
- 47:01gets there? John, can you uh David, can
- 47:05you unmute John if he can talk?
- 47:08>> All right, there you go.
- 47:09>> Hi. Uh, can you hear me? It's John.
- 47:11>> Hi.
- 47:12>> Hey, guys. Hi, Dr. Votes. Thank you so
- 47:15much. You know, I've been following you
- 47:16uh for a long time. Uh wonderful
- 47:18presentation. Uh love the way you're
- 47:21thinking about it, not forcing
- 47:23conclusions where they aren't there. Um
- 47:26two two questions for you. one just
- 47:28curious if you could speak a little bit
- 47:30about whether you feel at all hindered
- 47:34by a lack of
- 47:38precise in in terms of hypercusis
- 47:40precise phenotyping subcategories
- 47:44you know kind of the best we have right
- 47:45now is this loudness and pain um you
- 47:49know you mentioned something like Miriam
- 47:50Wescott and acoustic shock I'm curious
- 47:53if if you from what you're seeing in
- 47:54your clinic do you feel you would
- 47:56benefit bit much more from you know
- 47:59better subdivisions and categories
- 48:02then my second question is just I'm
- 48:04curious you said the three with pain
- 48:05hyperacusis that did much better I'm
- 48:07curious if they also had
- 48:09>> can I think I'm unmuted
- 48:11>> right right I just emailed you back
- 48:15>> we'll get to you right after this you
- 48:17finally we'll get to you right after
- 48:19John speaks thanks yeah thanks
- 48:22>> if they also had loudness or hyperacusis
- 48:25um the first question. Yes, absolutely.
- 48:27Absolutely. So, um uh I have an uh
- 48:34I hope tomorrow it will be ready. We're
- 48:36going to start a database and we put all
- 48:38those things in and and not only the the
- 48:41phenotypes in terms of uh a geometry,
- 48:44but these less tangible things like uh
- 48:47motivation,
- 48:49hope, hopelessness, [sighs and gasps]
- 48:51uh it's it's a beginning. Um but I think
- 48:55if we if we put these things together
- 48:58after some months we'll get to know what
- 49:01is important and what is not. I want to
- 49:03go to all these human things actually.
- 49:08Um and and then the holy grail would be
- 49:11to have some objective measurement.
- 49:13We're still not there. Uh that would be
- 49:15wonderful but a database will be the
- 49:18second best thing I think. Um and these
- 49:22people had uh loudness hyperacusis. I'm
- 49:25not so sure it is possible. Um my
- 49:29patients with pain hyperuses very often
- 49:31have also these other things the
- 49:33reactive tinitus the loudness
- 49:34hyperacusis
- 49:36um these come together and and I think
- 49:39these are the other outputs uh which are
- 49:42activated also. Uh but uh in these
- 49:45patients if it was there it was not so
- 49:47important for them. the pain was really
- 49:51the most important thing. Um I have
- 49:54another patient who did not react but
- 49:56who was happy with the silverstein and
- 49:58who said after the surgery that his
- 49:59loudness was better but not his pain. Um
- 50:03yes very difficult to to tell something
- 50:05about it. It's very difficult.
- 50:09I these are similar. I think the
- 50:11mechanism in loudness and pain and and
- 50:13and even annoyance and anxiety hyperus I
- 50:17think the mechanism is the same but I
- 50:18think these are different pathways.
- 50:28>> Okay. Are we
- 50:29>> Thank you.
- 50:30>> Can we go on?
- 50:31>> All right. John, did you want to say
- 50:32some more?
- 50:34Uh God, I could talk to both for hours.
- 50:36I one follow-up question would be sounds
- 50:38like maybe your expectations for the
- 50:41tempanic device developed by Nania. Um
- 50:46it sounds like it's pretty variable and
- 50:47you're uncertain if it's really going to
- 50:49be objective and and diagnostic. Would
- 50:52you would you comment?
- 50:54>> I think it's it's a wonderful tool.
- 50:55That's a wonderful tool. Um there are a
- 50:58few problems in that um
- 51:01you have to make some sound and then uh
- 51:04which sound are you going to give
- 51:06because it's not only about DC bells uh
- 51:10some people you know that uh patients
- 51:13say no this particular sound or that
- 51:15sound no for me it's that sound oh no no
- 51:17no for me it's that other sound so uh
- 51:20you can give sound I just do ting ting
- 51:23ting and then you see this tensipony
- 51:25going up but how can to standardize it.
- 51:27It's very difficult and if you want to
- 51:30do clinical studies or make a diagnostic
- 51:33tool out of it, you have to standardize
- 51:35it.
- 51:37>> It's very difficult. And Norina and and
- 51:39Fer are doing they're really very um how
- 51:44to say they're very good at that. They
- 51:46really categorize sounds. They make
- 51:49tests to distinguish between several
- 51:51sounds, but there's such a huge variety
- 51:53and and sensitivity to sounds. It's more
- 51:56than than just about decibels.
- 52:00>> Thank you, Dr. Bose. I yield the I yield
- 52:02the floor.
- 52:04>> Thank you. Okay, just to remind you, um,
- 52:07when you raise your hand and David
- 52:10recognizes you, he will send you an a
- 52:13little note that says, "Please unmute
- 52:15yourself." Then you hit that little
- 52:17thing and you're m you're unmuted. So,
- 52:19Bonnie, hi Bonnie.
- 52:24Uh thank you so much for this
- 52:26presentation. It's very informative. Um
- 52:30so I have a pulsatile tinitus and
- 52:34earfulness and eardrum flutter that
- 52:38developed after a very aggressive uh ear
- 52:41cleaning to remove wax. M
- 52:44>> so my ENT
- 52:46uh has through testing diagnosed me with
- 52:50a patchulus ustation tube although maybe
- 52:54I think maybe I have TTS but but anyway
- 52:58I guess uh my next step in my treatment
- 53:01will be to put a patch in my ear. I just
- 53:04I just have it in in my right ear.
- 53:07>> Absolutely.
- 53:08>> Yes. So these are the local these are
- 53:10the local inputs.
- 53:13>> Yeah. So I wanted to ask whether you
- 53:17uh if you need to put the patch in a
- 53:20location on the tempanic uh membrane
- 53:24that you you cannot really see the whole
- 53:27membrane due to a narrow ear canal. So
- 53:30what do you do to address um if you want
- 53:33to put a patch in a particular location
- 53:36but you can't really see it?
- 53:38>> Oh, I can see it. We work with the
- 53:39microscope. Now these are interesting uh
- 53:44how to say these are interesting. This
- 53:47is the cluster of symptoms. [cough] So
- 53:50um your ENT is right and I think you are
- 53:52right also because I think petalist tube
- 53:55and TTS are two sides of one problem. Um
- 53:59the system your ear your middle ear is a
- 54:02resonance cavity and you can have some
- 54:05echoes coming up. All of us can have it
- 54:08our own voice, our own blood stream, our
- 54:11own steps. Um, but happily we're happy
- 54:15we have this system with TTVP that
- 54:18shield us from that. So the system
- 54:20filters all those body sounds unless it
- 54:23can't. So as long as it can and you can
- 54:26see that on the the device of Aronorina
- 54:29you see in many people you see uh heart
- 54:32rate and he says yes I I think it's hard
- 54:35I think is a muscle contracting to
- 54:38shield us from this heart sound. So if
- 54:42the system does not work anymore, you
- 54:44get into problems and a white uh ustaken
- 54:47tube is one of the problems that may
- 54:49cause uh echoes of your own voice,
- 54:52resonances of your own voice. So what
- 54:54does the body do? It it it contracts the
- 54:56tens of philip paralini in order to
- 54:59close this ustakian tube and
- 55:02it shields you a little bit from those
- 55:04resonances but you get fullness feeling
- 55:08you get fluttering you get tinus you get
- 55:10hyperus you get all those things because
- 55:11the system is designed to diminish
- 55:14internal sounds and to increase external
- 55:17sounds which is actually what happens in
- 55:19your case. So uh in some people TVP TT
- 55:23are contracting because of stress,
- 55:26anxiety, name it. But in people like you
- 55:30here, well it's always a mixture of of
- 55:32several things coming together. But here
- 55:35this open tube is a cause for TVP
- 55:38contraction. Now um in women it may be
- 55:42hormone uh a low hormone and it may be
- 55:45interesting to to try some hormone
- 55:47therapy. uh otherwise we put a patch. I
- 55:50always start with a patch and we see the
- 55:52whole tempanic memory is very simple for
- 55:54us because we work with a microscope and
- 55:56any ENT doctor can do it and I'll be
- 55:58very glad to to help your ENT doctor to
- 56:00send them some mail with explanation. Um
- 56:04uh the upper half of the tempanic
- 56:06membrane is is connected with the the
- 56:08neck muscles and the jaw muscles. The
- 56:10lower part is connected with these
- 56:12muscles. So by trying uh by by feeling
- 56:16the muscles I can in most cases know
- 56:19which location I have to do. It's
- 56:22connected with different nerves and so
- 56:23it's a very very beautiful system. Uh
- 56:27very special. Um so yes and sometimes
- 56:31it's not really clear. So I try one part
- 56:33and I tell people to come back the next
- 56:35day. If it's not a good result and then
- 56:37then I try the other part. But no it's
- 56:39very simple to do. Most ENTs are a bit
- 56:42reluctant because they think what
- 56:44strange thing is this never heard of it
- 56:46and uh and and and you know there are
- 56:50quite some patients uh with a lot of
- 56:53anxiety and and this makes physic
- 56:55physicians anxious also. Um they're
- 56:59afraid of trying unproven things on
- 57:02patients that may tell them it's worse
- 57:05and they don't feel secure. But if you
- 57:08can find an ENT that does tempanic
- 57:10patching, I'll be glad to help to to to
- 57:12give some explanation.
- 57:15>> Okay. Yeah, my my ENT he's he's willing
- 57:18to to do the patch. No, [laughter] no
- 57:21problem. But he just puts the patch
- 57:23whatever whatever location he can see.
- 57:27And I I had read your hypothesis about
- 57:31uh depending on whether it's dorsal or
- 57:35the the other location and I actually do
- 57:39have like a lot of like uh muscle
- 57:42tightness like with my trapezius and so
- 57:44forth and so I read that you would put
- 57:47the patch in a in a particular location
- 57:50but yeah my uh ENT just yeah he just
- 57:54puts the patch wherever he can see you
- 57:57know the the tempanic membrane because I
- 58:00have narrow ear canals. He can't see the
- 58:02whole tempanic membrane.
- 58:03>> Sometimes you can't see it. You cannot
- 58:05see the whole tempanic membrane.
- 58:06Sometimes it's difficult. Yes. Sometimes
- 58:09there's there's a bending in the ear
- 58:10canal and it's very difficult and then I
- 58:12just put it where I can. It happens.
- 58:15Yeah. Maybe it's that's the way in your
- 58:18case. Yeah.
- 58:21>> Okay.
- 58:21>> Okay. We'll go on.
- 58:23>> Thank you. That was that was so sweet of
- 58:26you to offer to share information. We
- 58:29don't always hear that from researchers
- 58:31and doctors. And thank you. Uh Sher,
- 58:33would you please uh either turn your
- 58:36video off or stop moving your hand in
- 58:38front of the camera? Sherry.
- 58:42Sherry, can you hear me? Okay, thank
- 58:44you. Okay, the next one on the list is
- 58:48Norman. David, can you unmute Norman?
- 58:50Norman, you're gonna get a little sign
- 58:52that says unmute yourself. Thanks.
- 58:58>> Unmute. There I am. Yes. Thank you very
- 59:00much, Dr. Boots, for taking the time to
- 59:03provide such an interesting information.
- 59:06I just want to clarify one thing. Did
- 59:08you say that um that hyperacusis, which
- 59:13I've got, uh can impact sleeping?
- 59:17Uh I I I'm having trouble sleeping also
- 59:21and I'm trying to work on that. So I'm
- 59:23trying to wonder whether they're
- 59:25related.
- 59:27>> Okay. Well, um
- 59:31I think it's about an uh attention
- 59:34system, an alertness system that's
- 59:36hyperactivated or hyper respponsive.
- 59:40But it has to do listening. You know,
- 59:42listening, we can listen in the dark. We
- 59:45can listen behind corners. we can listen
- 59:47in in in the mist. Uh listening is is
- 59:49like our radar. You know a marine ship
- 59:51with a radar and it helps us to detect
- 59:55dangers or opportunities.
- 59:57So listening is very much related to
- 1:00:00alertness, danger, anxiety, focusing
- 1:00:04behavior, uh all these that's
- 1:00:07biological. Our ears are connected to
- 1:00:09the inside. All the places that are
- 1:00:12connected related to attention. So
- 1:00:17the system is activated and at the end
- 1:00:19you don't know what was the chicken or
- 1:00:22was the egg. I don't know if you say
- 1:00:23that in English. You don't know what was
- 1:00:25the beginning, what was the result, what
- 1:00:27was the cause, what was the result.
- 1:00:28Everything influences everything. So I
- 1:00:30have patients many patients as you told
- 1:00:33also um who got tinitis or hyperis after
- 1:00:37period of stress
- 1:00:38>> figure something out.
- 1:00:39>> Um but I also have patients who said I
- 1:00:42was really chill. there was no problem
- 1:00:44in my life but since I got tinitis I
- 1:00:46feel that I'm getting more and more
- 1:00:47anxiety uh and sleeping problems so it
- 1:00:50can work in all directions the whole
- 1:00:52system gets more and more
- 1:00:53>> introduce those of you
- 1:00:58>> okay thank you very much
- 1:01:01>> okay who's next
- 1:01:05uh there's some things on the chat I
- 1:01:07can't read but if you uh put them in and
- 1:01:10want to ask they're all in French.
- 1:01:15Anybody? Oh, one thing I want to mention
- 1:01:18without fail is uh Oh, yeah. I didn't
- 1:01:22hear what you said, Dr. Boots. Did the
- 1:01:25Silverstein's uh surgery help you?
- 1:01:32>> Uh I haven't done many many surgeries. I
- 1:01:35I only started last year.
- 1:01:38Uh
- 1:01:40>> Oh, you haven't done Dr. Silverstein's
- 1:01:43uh
- 1:01:43>> yes I have done a few once a few once
- 1:01:45but not that many. I only do it I have
- 1:01:48been doing it for one year now. Uh I I
- 1:01:51did I don't know maybe six or seven
- 1:01:53patients and I my impression my first
- 1:01:56impression is that's like applying a
- 1:01:58cushion in the ear like applying a
- 1:02:01hearing protection inside the ear but
- 1:02:03same as our other methods I have the
- 1:02:05impression that it covers the problem.
- 1:02:08It diminishes the the symptoms, but I'm
- 1:02:10not sure that it cures the sensitization
- 1:02:12problem.
- 1:02:14>> Well, what I want to say is that he
- 1:02:16emailed me the other day and said uh
- 1:02:19he's got a new paper out and they've
- 1:02:22accepted it and he wants to come back
- 1:02:23and update us.
- 1:02:25>> So, we are trying to figure out when he
- 1:02:28can come back. It might have to be in
- 1:02:31January of next year because we're
- 1:02:34pretty much booked, but hopefully we'll
- 1:02:36get him. And I was just curious about
- 1:02:38that. Um, did you did you see the movie
- 1:02:43Tuner? We had a whole meeting on Tuner.
- 1:02:46Did that get to you?
- 1:02:48>> No.
- 1:02:49>> All right. It was a It was a a movie and
- 1:02:52it was a really great movie about a
- 1:02:55piano tuner that had hyperacusis and
- 1:02:58perfect pitch. And so some criminals get
- 1:03:01him to be a safe cracker. It was
- 1:03:04completely, you know, fake, but it it it
- 1:03:08brought hyperacusis into the world
- 1:03:12>> very recently. So, I just saw somebody
- 1:03:14else's hand up. Did I?
- 1:03:17>> No.
- 1:03:18>> Okay. Anybody else?
- 1:03:23>> Okay. What I want to do is I'd like uh
- 1:03:25to tell you that this particular meeting
- 1:03:29was a collaboration of myself and Jim
- 1:03:33Henry from Ears Gone Wrong and the board
- 1:03:36of directors of Hyperacusis Research and
- 1:03:40some of them are here tonight and I'd
- 1:03:42like you to just know who they are. One
- 1:03:45of them is John Wallace who's off video.
- 1:03:48Jim Henry,
- 1:03:50David Trareorgi,
- 1:03:52Ken D'vor, hi Ken, he's on camera.
- 1:03:56Kendore,
- 1:03:56>> hi.
- 1:03:57>> Who else we have here? Let me see down
- 1:04:00the list.
- 1:04:02Uh,
- 1:04:04oh, Steve was here before, but he left.
- 1:04:07Steve Baron, the president. Uh, I think
- 1:04:10I got everybody. What I want to tell you
- 1:04:12is that Hyperacusis research is an
- 1:04:16organization that raises money for
- 1:04:19research. There is no federal money.
- 1:04:21There is no anything NIH money or
- 1:04:24anything. They live by donations. And
- 1:04:27so, David, can you David, can you stick
- 1:04:30up the email in the chat if anybody
- 1:04:33wants to? is it's a m and uh another
- 1:04:36thing too if you've heard of you've
- 1:04:39heard of tinidis quest
- 1:04:42>> hyperacusis research has just
- 1:04:44coordinated with tinidis quest so
- 1:04:48we are hoping and hoping to cover
- 1:04:52everything
- 1:04:54did you maybe you didn't hear me well
- 1:04:56I'll send it out don't worry about that
- 1:04:59really really appreciate you Dr. boots.
- 1:05:02This was absolutely not too technical
- 1:05:06and we the more we my goal is to
- 1:05:11have everybody never walk out of a
- 1:05:15practitioner's office again sobbing when
- 1:05:18the practitioner says, "Sorry, nothing
- 1:05:20you can do for it. You'll have to learn
- 1:05:23to live with it." How many of us have
- 1:05:26walked out sobbing and that's not going
- 1:05:28to happen again? Okay, I think we have
- 1:05:30one more. Sherry, David, can you unmute?
- 1:05:34Sherry,
- 1:05:40>> there. There you go. No.
- 1:05:44>> Hi. Sorry. Uh, a few technical
- 1:05:46difficulties. Okay. So um would the
- 1:05:49patch and what type of patch is it work
- 1:05:50for pain hyperacusis which uh has a
- 1:05:53addendum of light sensitivity uh after
- 1:05:56years of being screamed at in a nursing
- 1:05:57home by the CNAs and residents and also
- 1:06:00most recently uh odor sensitivity
- 1:06:03primarily um uh marijuana and other
- 1:06:07street drugs not bleach which I did have
- 1:06:09and so forth. So um is there any patch
- 1:06:12or non-surgical solution that you could
- 1:06:14recommend or even an electronic
- 1:06:16simulation
- 1:06:18Uh the patch doesn't work for everybody
- 1:06:20and what it does in in patients with
- 1:06:22pain hyperact some it doesn't do
- 1:06:24anything and others it it decreases the
- 1:06:27pain with some 20%.
- 1:06:30But it's always temporary. You have to
- 1:06:33put it again and again. Um so I I often
- 1:06:36try it and and if it doesn't help well
- 1:06:39okay no harm done. Uh as for
- 1:06:43>> influence of marijuana I I don't know
- 1:06:46and that's not through my field
- 1:06:50>> can someone send me the patch
- 1:06:52information or or a copy of the chat and
- 1:06:54the end of the slides I was fascinated
- 1:06:56thank you so much sir
- 1:07:03>> who's unmuted there
- 1:07:09>> uh we I don't I'm not quite sure that we
- 1:07:13can make a copy of the chat, but I will
- 1:07:16be sending out the recording.
- 1:07:19So, you can watch it again. That
- 1:07:23I don't think I can get back to the chat
- 1:07:25with that. And uh
- 1:07:28All right, let's see if there's a new
- 1:07:30one. Okay, hyperacusis.org.
- 1:07:34Just the one word. Hyperacusearch.org.
- 1:07:38Wonderful organization. And I appreciate
- 1:07:41our collaboration.
- 1:07:43And uh anybody have a last word?
- 1:07:48Anybody have a last word? Dr. Boots, do
- 1:07:51you want the last word? Okay. Alice. Oh,
- 1:07:53wait. Oh, Alice. David, can you unmute
- 1:07:56Alice?
- 1:08:08just click the little thing that says
- 1:08:10unmute yourself.
- 1:08:13>> Um Alice doesn't have her hand up. If
- 1:08:15she can raise her hand.
- 1:08:21>> Okay, Alice.
- 1:08:25>> Okay. Alice wants to ask something.
- 1:08:27Don't Don't you, Alice? Okay. Yeah.
- 1:08:38David, can you unmute Alice? She She has
- 1:08:41her hand up now. Thank you, Bonnie. Glad
- 1:08:45you're here. Glad
- 1:08:47>> I'm not seeing her hand. I'll try to
- 1:08:49find her.
- 1:08:49>> Oh, she Oh, I see Alice. And she's go
- 1:08:52She's going like she's waving.
- 1:08:57>> No, she has to raise her hand and zoom.
- 1:08:59The yellow hand and zoom.
- 1:09:00>> Oh, can you hit the yellow the the
- 1:09:02little yellow hand, Alice?
- 1:09:05on the bottom on react.
- 1:09:09Look on react.
- 1:09:13Go click on react and hit that that um
- 1:09:19that yellow hand the wave cl. No, that's
- 1:09:21a clap, which is the one we want.
- 1:09:26I can't figure out which one we want.
- 1:09:31That's a wave.
- 1:09:34Which one is the hand, David? I see wave
- 1:09:37and clap. That's crazy.
- 1:09:40Maybe you can um It's It's a bar under
- 1:09:43the icons, right?
- 1:09:44>> Okay. You You should be able to hear me
- 1:09:46now. I can see.
- 1:09:47>> Oh, yay. Okay, there you go.
- 1:09:51>> I I am not sure. I feel it seems to me I
- 1:09:55do not have the neither hyper curses.
- 1:09:59Maybe something in the between.
- 1:10:02I get tired every if I go to restaurant
- 1:10:06any other any places I get tired in
- 1:10:08about 20 30 minutes and uh if I am even
- 1:10:14shorter time depends on the level of the
- 1:10:17noise. Uh this is caused by a serious
- 1:10:20brain injury
- 1:10:23which happened um about almost eight
- 1:10:26years ago. is just getting worse
- 1:10:29and I don't even know if there are any
- 1:10:32it is called by these symptoms this has
- 1:10:35a name or is there any treatment that's
- 1:10:38my question because I have not been able
- 1:10:41to figure out what to do about it I only
- 1:10:45use
- 1:10:46uh noise cancelling earbuds um and when
- 1:10:50I go anywhere then I can uh do not hear
- 1:10:54the noise to that
- 1:10:57It's from the company Bose company. I
- 1:11:00use this kind of noise cancelling but
- 1:11:03there is nothing I would know what I
- 1:11:05could do for myself.
- 1:11:07Yes, I I haven't heard it before being
- 1:11:10tired. I heard a lot of annoyance uh
- 1:11:12making somebody angry uh making somebody
- 1:11:15sad. I think it can do a lot of things
- 1:11:18uh depending on the output. So in your
- 1:11:20case it must be connected somewhere in
- 1:11:23your brain with an area that makes you
- 1:11:25tired. But I would
- 1:11:29you know when we hear something that we
- 1:11:31just try the same treatments and and and
- 1:11:33evaluation and we see what happens. I I
- 1:11:36would think maybe it would be similar to
- 1:11:38the to the annoyance hyperuse or pain
- 1:11:42hyperuse but on link to somebody else
- 1:11:45something else.
- 1:11:47Uh it was told me
- 1:11:50I when people start to have hearing aids
- 1:11:54usually with hearing aids you hear
- 1:11:56everything.
- 1:11:57>> Mhm.
- 1:11:58>> But the same is me. I can hear the bird.
- 1:12:02I can hear this kind of screaming. I can
- 1:12:05hear this. I can I hear all the noises.
- 1:12:08Not I would with the brain focus on
- 1:12:10certain certain talk. No I hear
- 1:12:14everything what is happening. I get
- 1:12:16tired.
- 1:12:18It It was told me I get tired because I
- 1:12:20hear everything. My hearing is going
- 1:12:23well. I hear well
- 1:12:25>> and I'm just protecting not to hear that
- 1:12:28much.
- 1:12:29>> Is there any is there a name to it or is
- 1:12:32just you don't know this at all?
- 1:12:34>> I don't know this at all.
- 1:12:36>> I do.
- 1:12:36>> I would like much I would very much like
- 1:12:39to to treat it and see what happens but
- 1:12:42I can't tell you now. Sorry. I know
- 1:12:44there's a name for it because I was
- 1:12:46involved in a hearing loss organization.
- 1:12:48It is called auditory fatigue.
- 1:12:54>> Auditory fatigue
- 1:12:55>> fatigue then you are
- 1:12:59trying
- 1:13:00to hear people's conversations and you
- 1:13:03can't hear them as well. It's exhausting
- 1:13:06and it's called auditory fatigue. Go
- 1:13:08ahead and look it up, but it's really
- 1:13:10common.
- 1:13:12uh a fatigue is something that everybody
- 1:13:15has after a few hours listening but so
- 1:13:19this is then an a very how to say
- 1:13:22immediate auditory fatigue after 20
- 1:13:25minutes this is impressive
- 1:13:31>> is there anywhere I could go I live uh I
- 1:13:35live in Chicago
- 1:13:37>> and is there a way to
- 1:13:40contact some organizations if they would
- 1:13:43somehow could help me.
- 1:13:46>> Uh the only ones I know in your
- 1:13:48neighborhood are Philip Fier and is but
- 1:13:51they're doing research. They're not
- 1:13:53doctors. They're doing research on all
- 1:13:55those strange uh symptoms and I think he
- 1:13:59will be very much interested in uh
- 1:14:01examining your hearing. Uh Laval
- 1:14:05University in Quebec, but they're not
- 1:14:07doctors. Uh, and as for doctors in the
- 1:14:10United States, I don't know.
- 1:14:12>> I can tell you,
- 1:14:15>> Alice.
- 1:14:16>> Yeah.
- 1:14:16>> Um, Jim Henry has a list of providers
- 1:14:22that he knows about in every si in he
- 1:14:26doesn't have every city, every state,
- 1:14:29but he's got them by state. So, you said
- 1:14:32you lived in Illinois, in Chicago.
- 1:14:35>> Why don't I get you the list? Do you um
- 1:14:39will you my email are you on my list
- 1:14:41serve?
- 1:14:42>> Yeah, I can I can email you.
- 1:14:44>> Okay, it's on the chat and I will get
- 1:14:47you the list at least for
- 1:14:50p practitioners that he knows about and
- 1:14:53has looked into. It is extremely hard to
- 1:14:57find anybody in any city you live in.
- 1:15:00But I I will get you that list. What is
- 1:15:02your last name, Alice?
- 1:15:05Uh, like forest without the s. For f
- 1:15:09like in Frank. O R E.
- 1:15:12>> Forest.
- 1:15:13>> Okay. Foret.
- 1:15:16>> Got it.
- 1:15:17>> Okay.
- 1:15:19Thank you.
- 1:15:20>> Thank you.
- 1:15:22>> Okay. Um, I think Floyd is next. Floyd.
- 1:15:25Our friend Floyd. David, can you send
- 1:15:27your little note to Floyd?
- 1:15:31Are you okay with this timing, Dr.
- 1:15:33Boots? Yes.
- 1:15:35>> Are you okay standing?
- 1:15:36>> I have to leave. I have to leave. I
- 1:15:37think in
- 1:15:39>> 1930 I should stop but it's okay.
- 1:15:42>> So tw 10 minutes maybe. Okay.
- 1:15:45>> We appreciate this so much and we love
- 1:15:48it when we don't want a guest to leave.
- 1:15:51>> Okay. Floyd.
- 1:15:52>> Yes. Hi. Can you hear me?
- 1:15:54>> Yeah.
- 1:15:55>> Yeah. I'm I'm sorry. I I missed the the
- 1:15:57beginning part of this meeting. Is there
- 1:16:00a way I could uh see it from the
- 1:16:02beginning? Is there a way you could send
- 1:16:04it to me?
- 1:16:06>> I'm sending it out tomorrow morning. I'm
- 1:16:08sending it out tomorrow.
- 1:16:09>> Okay, cool.
- 1:16:10>> We are recording it and so I will send
- 1:16:12it out to my list served tomorrow and
- 1:16:14you're on it.
- 1:16:15>> Okay, good to go. Thank you very much.
- 1:16:17Sorry about
- 1:16:23>> Oh, is that it? Okay.
- 1:16:24>> Yeah, that's it. Thank you.
- 1:16:25>> Okay. Uh Paul, I think Paul is in the
- 1:16:29other three speak spoken. I'm sorry, my
- 1:16:32brain is a little fried. Uh, Paul M,
- 1:16:35David, can you uh send your little note
- 1:16:37to Paul M.
- 1:16:39>> Hello. Can you hear me?
- 1:16:42>> Mhm.
- 1:16:42>> Yes.
- 1:16:43>> Oh, quick question. You talk about
- 1:16:46neuroplasticity. I've been dealing with
- 1:16:49tenitis for about 10 years now and I
- 1:16:52just started using lace AI for my
- 1:16:56hearing aids and it teaches you to
- 1:17:00listen u listen to people speaking with
- 1:17:05background noise and it's I don't know
- 1:17:07if you're familiar with it or uh heard
- 1:17:10of it at all but I was just curious
- 1:17:12about because I just started with it
- 1:17:14whether
- 1:17:16That's using neuroplasticity in the
- 1:17:20proper direction.
- 1:17:23>> Oh, the use of hearing aids. You mean
- 1:17:29um
- 1:17:31I I think neuroplasticity as I see it is
- 1:17:36in in in in this subject is towards more
- 1:17:41relaxed or more active state. active in
- 1:17:46the sense of more vigilant, more alert.
- 1:17:51So I think it's mostly the state of mind
- 1:17:56that if you feel that the world's okay,
- 1:17:58you're calm and relaxed and things
- 1:18:01happen then you will go in a direction
- 1:18:04of more relaxedness.
- 1:18:06If you feel the world is dangerous,
- 1:18:08chances are that any triggers
- 1:18:11may put you in a direction of more
- 1:18:14alertness, more vigilance. Uh again,
- 1:18:18this has not been proven. These are
- 1:18:19ideas and and these are things that I I
- 1:18:22think uh we want to to do research on.
- 1:18:27Um but
- 1:18:30that's all
- 1:18:32I think at this moment. I think there is
- 1:18:35about it. I have talked to someone with
- 1:18:38pain hyperactis, an Englishman who said
- 1:18:41that it um it cured from itself
- 1:18:45spontaneously and it had become better
- 1:18:47over months and I noticed that he had a
- 1:18:50very positive mindset.
- 1:18:54Um but okay, I'm not sure from one
- 1:18:56person if that's that important.
- 1:19:00Um
- 1:19:00>> great. Thank you. But it it it is it has
- 1:19:03not been proven all all these things
- 1:19:05that I say. But um I think there's
- 1:19:08something we might
- 1:19:10go for as it seems plausible from a
- 1:19:12biological point of view. Yeah.
- 1:19:17It's not not been proven. These are
- 1:19:19ideas. These are ideas.
- 1:19:23>> Great. Thank you.
- 1:19:24>> Okay. Uh we have not heard from Vicki
- 1:19:27yet. We've heard from other people.
- 1:19:29David, can you unmute Vicki? Hi Vicki,
- 1:19:32glad you're here.
- 1:19:40>> I just have a quick question for
- 1:19:42everyone and for the doctor. Thank you
- 1:19:43so much for a great presentation. Does
- 1:19:46anyone or you can tell me anything about
- 1:19:48the TMS is the transcranial stimulation?
- 1:19:54>> Uh I have no experience. I know that has
- 1:19:56been done for depression and and that it
- 1:19:57has some use. Um I know that um
- 1:20:04for hyperacus and tinitus as yet I have
- 1:20:06not really heard about spectacular
- 1:20:09results. So I assume at this moment no
- 1:20:12but I'm not really into that.
- 1:20:14>> Oh okay. because I have a an appointment
- 1:20:17next week coming up and I was wondering
- 1:20:19if anything on the chat here had it on
- 1:20:23because I do have tinitus and
- 1:20:25hyperaciosis and the sleeping problem
- 1:20:27that I have is horrible. I was doing
- 1:20:30clonipan and I'm trying to get off of
- 1:20:33clonosipan and the way that they were
- 1:20:36tippering off you know actually kicked
- 1:20:39the tinitus actually worse.
- 1:20:42M
- 1:20:43>> so
- 1:20:44you know I was in two migrams and then
- 1:20:47went down I I I assume too quickly to.5
- 1:20:53>> and it got my tinitus absolutely to the
- 1:20:57roof.
- 1:21:00So, so this tinitus and hyperacusis is
- 1:21:03part of a much larger thing with uh the
- 1:21:06whole brain um uh doing something in
- 1:21:11always in the sense of alertness,
- 1:21:13vigilance, attention and um all this
- 1:21:16medication works on that and we also use
- 1:21:20TDCS which is electrical stimulation not
- 1:21:23for the tinitus itself but to prepare
- 1:21:25patients for the therapy Because we feel
- 1:21:29that as long as they don't sleep, as
- 1:21:31they are hyper anxious, we cannot do
- 1:21:34anything. And even if I inject Botox,
- 1:21:37Botox is is less strong than the mind.
- 1:21:39As long as their mind is activating the
- 1:21:43system, as long as their mind is
- 1:21:45dictating these muscles to contract, I
- 1:21:47cannot do anything. So yes, we use TDCS.
- 1:21:51I know that TMS is used. Uh there are
- 1:21:54many things. Um and I think these can be
- 1:21:57interesting to prepare patients and then
- 1:22:00it's the physiotherapist who has to calm
- 1:22:03down their muscles and then we have
- 1:22:04those research things with with
- 1:22:07bivvakine botox and so on um which
- 1:22:10actually would hopefully cure the
- 1:22:14tinitus itself then in some cases
- 1:22:17>> preparation is very important sorry
- 1:22:19>> do you know anyone in Los Angeles that
- 1:22:21does botox because I can I don't know
- 1:22:24anyone Do anybody knows?
- 1:22:27>> I heard of someone who doing who was
- 1:22:29doing it. Um,
- 1:22:33>> no. Right, Trudy? You know everything.
- 1:22:35Truly,
- 1:22:38>> I should have a look. Somebody told me
- 1:22:40about someone doing Botox there.
- 1:22:43>> I'm not sure.
- 1:22:45>> Okay,
- 1:22:45>> I guess you'll have to call around.
- 1:22:48>> Thank you.
- 1:22:48>> We have time for one more question and
- 1:22:52that's going to be Joy. Hi Joy.
- 1:22:56That's gonna be the last question
- 1:22:57because we do have to let him leave.
- 1:23:00>> Okay.
- 1:23:00>> Unfortunately.
- 1:23:02>> Okay. Can you hear me?
- 1:23:05>> Yep.
- 1:23:06>> Yep. Okay. So, I this is um I'm
- 1:23:09wondering if you can tell me anything
- 1:23:11about a cure for autophany.
- 1:23:15>> Oh, yes. Uh autophagy is I I I find it a
- 1:23:20very interesting thing. Uh so the
- 1:23:22classical
- 1:23:24diagnosis of autophonyy is or or petus
- 1:23:27tube or uh turbo which means dehissance
- 1:23:32of superior single circular canal or
- 1:23:34which is very very rare incraanial
- 1:23:37hypertension. So your intracanal fluid
- 1:23:41has doesn't have the right tension but
- 1:23:43that's very rare. So actually what you
- 1:23:45do you do a CT scan to rule out the
- 1:23:47hissence and then you say okay it's a
- 1:23:49petalist tube. Now what I found is that
- 1:23:52this petal tube may have several causes.
- 1:23:56One of them is hormonal especially in
- 1:24:00women after the menopause and uh I see
- 1:24:04it very often in in women and uh another
- 1:24:08one is subconscious
- 1:24:11contracting of muscles. So again from
- 1:24:15psychological point of view people who
- 1:24:17really are stressed and contract these
- 1:24:20muscles and they without knowing it open
- 1:24:22their tube. So what I often do is just
- 1:24:25give them some 10 days of some relaxing
- 1:24:27medications and I've had people who were
- 1:24:29better with that. Um if that does not
- 1:24:33help if hormonal therapy does not work I
- 1:24:36put a patch on tempanic membrane. It
- 1:24:38helps sometimes. uh uh we put a grommet
- 1:24:42a tube in the ear. Sometimes it helps
- 1:24:44sometimes it wors then we remove it and
- 1:24:46if nothing nothing helps then then we
- 1:24:48operate it. We we inflate some filler in
- 1:24:50the ust tube which can be done um but
- 1:24:55the results only 60% of good results in
- 1:24:58in in my experience. Uh so I I I first I
- 1:25:02try some things. I I try some things
- 1:25:05psychological hormonal patching and then
- 1:25:08if nothing works uh physiootherapy even
- 1:25:11nothing works and I I do surgery.
- 1:25:14>> Oh thank you. And which which hormone is
- 1:25:18most effective?
- 1:25:20>> I think it's estrogen but I'm not so
- 1:25:22good in hormones. I sent people to the
- 1:25:24gynecologist or or uh or general
- 1:25:28practitioner. Um
- 1:25:31I think it's is too gel or something.
- 1:25:33Not sure.
- 1:25:34>> I can't find anybody who's even heard of
- 1:25:37autophony. They think I'm making it up.
- 1:25:39>> So, okay. Thank you. Thank you. I
- 1:25:42appreciate your help.
- 1:25:44>> Okay.
- 1:25:45>> I just had to look it up. I had to look
- 1:25:48it up, Joy. I didn't know what it was. I
- 1:25:51thought everybody hears everything in
- 1:25:52their body all the time. So anyway,
- 1:25:57thank you so much. We do have to let him
- 1:25:59go and I Dr. Boots, I appreciate you
- 1:26:02being here so much. You will get a
- 1:26:04recording tomorrow sometime. And uh you
- 1:26:08feel free to send it out to everybody.
- 1:26:10You're getting a lot of love.
- 1:26:13>> Thank you very much. It was very it was
- 1:26:14a pleasure. a lot of love here and we
- 1:26:16appreciate you so much and thank you so
- 1:26:20much for being here.
- 1:26:22>> Thank you
- 1:26:22>> and everybody thank you all for coming.
- 1:26:24We had a great group and more to come.
- 1:26:28There's always a lot more to come from
- 1:26:30us. We are not let we are going to
- 1:26:32educate you. So you know when you walk
- 1:26:35into a practitioner's office you pretty
- 1:26:38much know more than they do. So thank
- 1:26:41you everyone.
- 1:26:43Bye.
- 1:26:43>> Thank you.
- 1:26:45>> Thank you, Trudy.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Dr. Michael Boedts by HyperacusisResearch, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 13,099 words across 1,937 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.