Discussing My Beliefs.. (Nihilism) — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00He would neither go towards the feeding
- 0:02grounds at the edge of the ice nor
- 0:05return to the colony.
- 0:08Shortly afterwards, we saw him heading
- 0:11straight towards the mountains, some 70
- 0:14km away.
- 0:17But why?
- 0:19Alrighty chat, today we're going to talk
- 0:21about the nihilistic penguin. So this is
- 0:23a case of a penguin that instead of
- 0:25staying safe with like all of the other
- 0:27nesting penguins or traveling to the
- 0:29ocean where it will presumably get food,
- 0:32it looks towards the mountains and takes
- 0:34off.
- 0:35And there's something like incredibly
- 0:37noble about this, right? So people watch
- 0:39this and they're sort of like, "Wow,
- 0:40this is like the triumph of the human
- 0:42spirit." I think a great example of epic
- 0:44meaning being epic failure is Into the
- 0:47Wild. So this is the story of someone
- 0:49who went into the wilderness and then
- 0:50basically starved to death. He started
- 0:52to eat something I think called potato
- 0:54berries, which are He was so hungry that
- 0:57he found these things that looked like
- 0:59potatoes, but are actually toxic when
- 1:01ingested in large quantities, and then
- 1:04he ends up sort of dying alone poisoning
- 1:06himself.
- 1:08And this is what we turn into movies.
- 1:10And if we want to understand why people
- 1:12are so into this, we got to understand
- 1:14the basic problem that human beings face
- 1:17in today's world. We no longer have the
- 1:20capacity for self-determination. So the
- 1:23world on a macroscopic level, there's
- 1:25inflation, there's war, there's the
- 1:27existential threat of AI. I recently
- 1:29talked to a buddy of mine who's a in a
- 1:31PhD or teaches in a PhD program, and she
- 1:35was telling me how hard it is for like
- 1:37new PhD graduates to find entry-level
- 1:39jobs because they're all being taken by
- 1:41AI. So we're like fundamentally like
- 1:43losing control. And it's not just the
- 1:45macroscopic forces. This is also a
- 1:47situation where I worked with so many
- 1:49people who can't even control
- 1:50themselves. Their day-to-day experience
- 1:52of life is there are so many things that
- 1:54I know would be good for me, that have a
- 1:57high probability of success. If I just
- 2:00did this, everything would be great.
- 2:03Simplest example of this is emailing my
- 2:05professor just to let them know, "Hey, I
- 2:07won't be able to turn in my paper on
- 2:09time. Can I have an extension?" It's
- 2:11like 30 seconds of work. And yet, even
- 2:14though there's so much stuff that we
- 2:16could do
- 2:17that would be good for us, we cannot
- 2:19bring ourselves to do it. Q dopamine
- 2:22addiction, social media addiction, video
- 2:24game addiction, porn porn addiction,
- 2:25take your pick. And so, what we see with
- 2:27this nihilistic penguin is exactly what
- 2:29we wish we could do. The penguin is
- 2:31faced with a situation where there is no
- 2:34chance of success, no chance of
- 2:36survival. And yet, it is able to muster
- 2:39up the energy to give everything that
- 2:42it's got for some impossible task. And
- 2:45this is the basic thing that I see in
- 2:47the majority of people today is like
- 2:49they just can't give life their effort,
- 2:52right? This idea of like, "Give me
- 2:54liberty or give me death." Going all in,
- 2:57giving everything you've got. This thing
- 2:58that we love as human beings. This This
- 3:02thing that we respect as human beings.
- 3:04Like, the ultimate respect that we give
- 3:06human beings are people who give it
- 3:08their all. And I can't even give it 25%.
- 3:11And when people watch this video, like
- 3:13the comments are like, "This penguin may
- 3:15not survive, but he'll certainly live."
- 3:17Ah, what nobility. And then, here's
- 3:19what's really scary about this is like
- 3:21when we look at this penguin, a lot of
- 3:23people will say like there's no purpose,
- 3:25there's no triumph of the human spirit
- 3:27or the penguin spirit. This is just like
- 3:28a biological error. Like, there's
- 3:30nothing going on here. That like the
- 3:32brain is malfunctioning. The penguin is
- 3:34running towards the mountains. It'll
- 3:35certainly die there. There's like no
- 3:37chance of survival. It's not accomplish
- 3:39anything. Like, this triumph of the
- 3:41penguin spirit is just a bug. And
- 3:43there's actually good like scientific
- 3:45evidence to support this, not just in
- 3:47penguins, but in humans as well. And
- 3:49then, we get to this really scary
- 3:50thought because here we are as human
- 3:52beings striving for meaning and striving
- 3:55for purpose. But there's a lot of
- 3:57biological evidence that this crap
- 3:59doesn't exist. When people hear about
- 4:01our coaching program, their first
- 4:02response is usually, "Why would I work
- 4:04with another human being when I can
- 4:06watch YouTube videos all on my own?"
- 4:09Working with a coach is about amplifying
- 4:11your time and effort. We're great at
- 4:13wanting things and even making some
- 4:15progress, but we usually struggle with
- 4:18follow-through or have some kind of
- 4:19setback. And that's exactly working with
- 4:21a coach can help. Coaches provide
- 4:23personalized support to help you set
- 4:25appropriate goals, make progress, and
- 4:27even work through setbacks. Just let us
- 4:29know what your goals are, what kind of
- 4:31support you're looking for, and we'll
- 4:33match you with the best coach for your
- 4:35unique needs. Check out the link in the
- 4:37description below to see if coaching is
- 4:38right for you. A really good example of
- 4:40this is more from the the field of
- 4:42psychology, but in something called
- 4:43terror management theory. So, here's
- 4:45basically what terror management theory
- 4:46says. So, as living organisms, we have
- 4:50one goal, which is survival. There's
- 4:52also one thing that is guaranteed when
- 4:54an organism becomes born in the world,
- 4:56which is that it is going to die. So,
- 4:57everything in our wiring is wired to
- 4:59survive, death is inevitable. Now, this
- 5:01is not a problem for most organisms. If
- 5:03I'm a bacteria, I have no sense of my
- 5:06mortality. If I'm a frog, if I'm a deer,
- 5:08if I'm a lion, we have really no
- 5:10evidence that primates or lions or any
- 5:12kinds of organisms are aware that they
- 5:15will die one day, except for humans.
- 5:18Because we as humans are different. We
- 5:20know that we're going to die, right? We
- 5:21have we've reached this cognitive
- 5:23plateau, which creates a problem because
- 5:26here we are wired to survive, but we
- 5:28have the knowledge of certain death. So,
- 5:30how does an organism fix this
- 5:33fundamentally irreconcilable thing? And
- 5:36that's where terror management theory
- 5:37comes in.
- 5:38What terror management theory says is
- 5:40that we're human beings, we all
- 5:43are afraid of death. So, organisms are
- 5:45wired for survival, and all organisms
- 5:48die.
- 5:49So, this is not a problem if you're like
- 5:50an amoeba. It's not a problem if you're
- 5:52a frog because frogs don't have a clear
- 5:54sense of their mortality. The problem is
- 5:56when you achieve a certain cognitive
- 5:58layer, a cognitive capability, you're
- 6:01wired for survival and you know you're
- 6:03going to die. So, how does our biology
- 6:07reconcile that we're wired to survive
- 6:10and we're definitely going to die. So,
- 6:11the main goal the main game we are
- 6:13trying to win, we will definitely lose.
- 6:16And that's where terror management
- 6:17theory basically says that the way that
- 6:19our we reconcile this fear of death is
- 6:22by like inventing
- 6:24some sense of like immortality. The
- 6:27sense of meaning and purpose and
- 6:29self-esteem and all of these like good
- 6:31things in life, all of these triumphs of
- 6:32the human spirit are basically
- 6:34biological copium to reconcile against
- 6:38this idea of death. We've evolved the
- 6:40delusion of purpose to keep the terror
- 6:44of our certain death, which is like runs
- 6:46contrary to our basic instincts of
- 6:48survival, at bay. And this is what I
- 6:50think is so scary about the nihilistic
- 6:51penguin is like all of us are sort of
- 6:53sitting in this situation where we wish
- 6:55we could be doing more. We want to live
- 6:57life more. We want to find purpose. We
- 6:58want to find meaning. But then on the
- 7:00flip side, there is so much evidence
- 7:02there's no proof of life after death.
- 7:04There's no proof of the existence of
- 7:06God. Maybe there is, you can leave a
- 7:07comment if you want. Right? We don't
- 7:09know if we're all like all we have proof
- 7:11of is that we're like sacks of meat with
- 7:13electrical activity in this particular
- 7:15skull that gives us a sense of purpose
- 7:18and meaning.
- 7:19And then we're kind of stuck because
- 7:20it's like, do I live life? Do I look for
- 7:24meaning? Do I look for purpose? Or is it
- 7:26all a scam? And this is what's so scary
- 7:28is that the thing that we strive for
- 7:31could be a biological delusion. So, how
- 7:34do we resolve this? What many people
- 7:35will say is like, like life is a journey
- 7:37and you have to like figure out for
- 7:38yourself. Which is like sort of a great
- 7:40answer, but honestly, it's a really
- 7:42crappy answer. It's It's sort of like a
- 7:43non-answer. There is no answer. You have
- 7:46to figure out for yourself. Like, you
- 7:47know, reminds me of the the
- 7:48hand-clapping meme when someone is
- 7:50drowning. Where it's like, okay, you
- 7:52have to figure it out yourself, but how
- 7:53do you figure it out? And this is where
- 7:54I don't have any profound guidance. I'm
- 7:56not like enlightened or divine or
- 7:58anything like that. The best that I can
- 8:00give you is sort of my take on this. So,
- 8:03my parents, you know, raised me in a
- 8:04religious kind of household, kind of
- 8:06culturally religious. I would go to
- 8:07temple and things like that, but I
- 8:08didn't really like believe this stuff. I
- 8:10remember going to a summer camp when I
- 8:12was like 14 years old that my mom really
- 8:14wanted me to go to for this religious
- 8:15organization. And I would people would
- 8:17say these things about God, and you
- 8:18know, this is what you should do and
- 8:19reincarnation. And I was like, where's
- 8:21your proof, bro? I started asking
- 8:23questions, and I didn't get any
- 8:24sufficient answers. And I was like,
- 8:25okay, like these people don't know what
- 8:27they're talking about. I was basically
- 8:28an atheist. And then I went to India,
- 8:30and I started studying meditation. And
- 8:32originally, the reason I studied
- 8:33meditation was not about spirituality.
- 8:34It was like, okay, I'm going to focus on
- 8:36the neuroscience. I'm going to focus on
- 8:37improving my physiology, gaining
- 8:39willpower. I wanted observable benefits
- 8:43in the real world through meditation.
- 8:45So, that's why I moved away from Reiki
- 8:47and started to move towards other kinds
- 8:49of meditation, which are scientifically
- 8:51valid, because I didn't believe any of
- 8:52this crap. And then as I started to
- 8:53meditate, I started to have these weird
- 8:55spiritual experiences. And I'll just
- 8:57share one with you that I don't know if
- 8:58I've talked about before, but the first
- 9:00time I got an interview for medical
- 9:02school, and I went home, and I
- 9:04meditated, and then I prayed, which is
- 9:06not something that I do usually. So, I
- 9:08prayed, and I was like, please,
- 9:10universe, God, whatever whatever the
- 9:12is out there, please let me get
- 9:15accepted to medical school. I've been
- 9:17trying really hard. I don't know if I
- 9:18it's going to work or not. My GPA sucks.
- 9:20Please, please, please, please, please
- 9:22let me get accepted to medical school.
- 9:23And then I had something called a
- 9:24knowing. So, this is something that I I
- 9:26don't talk about publicly, but I talk
- 9:28about with my patients sometimes, which
- 9:29is like, sometimes when you meditate,
- 9:31you know things. So, it's not a belief.
- 9:33It's not an understanding. It's not even
- 9:35an aha moment. The best word I can use
- 9:37to describe it is a knowing. Maybe
- 9:39you've experienced it and you kind of
- 9:40know what I'm talking about. If you
- 9:42haven't, it sounds like kooky, right?
- 9:43So, I just knew.
- 9:45Like, it's not like a voice. Like, I
- 9:47didn't hear something. I knew that I
- 9:49would not get accepted that year and I
- 9:50knew that it would take me 2 more years.
- 9:52And it was like I knew that I had to go
- 9:55through this and that it was like the
- 9:57price that I had to pay. But, it was
- 9:59also kind of reassuring because it was
- 10:01like I knew that things were going to
- 10:02work out in the end, but there would be
- 10:04a lot of pain that was necessary to get
- 10:07me to where I want to go. I was sitting
- 10:09there meditating and I had this profound
- 10:11experience of knowing. I started crying
- 10:13and I felt both loved and I felt a lot
- 10:16of pity towards myself. Since that
- 10:18moment, I've really appreciated this
- 10:20part in the Bible in the Garden of
- 10:21Gethsemane where Jesus says, "Please,
- 10:24Lord, let this cup pass from me to like
- 10:26somebody else. Like, I don't want to do
- 10:28do this. If there's any way that you can
- 10:29give me a pass, please let me know." And
- 10:31that's something that really resonates
- 10:32with me to this day. So, when you
- 10:34meditate and you do this kind of stuff,
- 10:36like weird stuff happens. And then I was
- 10:38in a then I had a problem because I was
- 10:40like, "What the hell is that?" Right? Is
- 10:42this a delusion? Is this some kind of
- 10:45psychological copium? Like, what's going
- 10:47on here? And this explains like why I
- 10:49read all of this stuff, right? So, I
- 10:50have this paper on terror management
- 10:52theory. I wrote a bunch of other papers
- 10:53about the nature of nihilism and human
- 10:55meaning and human existence and
- 10:56psychology and neuroscience and all this
- 10:58kind of crap because I'm looking for
- 10:59answers. So, I've read probably about
- 11:013,000 peer-reviewed publications since I
- 11:04started HealthyGamer looking for
- 11:06answers. And so, through a series of 20
- 11:09years of meditative experiences and
- 11:11getting married and having kids, I kind
- 11:13of found purpose, believed in dharma,
- 11:15believed in karma karma and all this
- 11:17stuff. And I was like, "Great. I figured
- 11:18it out." Now, here's the really scary
- 11:20thing. I'm sliding back towards atheism.
- 11:23And I got dragged into not theism, but
- 11:26the idea that there is more in this
- 11:29world than is materially visible. So, I
- 11:32had enough experiences and they kept
- 11:34happening once every like two or three
- 11:36years or so that was really profound.
- 11:38And when this happens to you for 20
- 11:39years and you get like hit with these
- 11:40things like you you get dragged into
- 11:43believing there is more. The really
- 11:44scary thing is over the last year or two
- 11:46I'm being dragged in the opposite
- 11:47direction. As I learn more about
- 11:50biology, as I learn more about
- 11:51neuroscience, as I learn more about
- 11:53psychology, about things like adaptive
- 11:55misbelief, I'm starting to really wonder
- 11:58whether all of the stuff that I learned
- 12:01is just delusions in my brain. That I've
- 12:04been evolved the biology of my system is
- 12:08designed to give me copium. Is designed
- 12:12to give me something called adaptive
- 12:14misbelief, which are things that are not
- 12:16true but are adaptive for for the
- 12:19organism. So, is all of the stuff that I
- 12:20experienced real or is it just the
- 12:23highest level of copium?
- 12:27I don't know. At the end of the day,
- 12:29it's incredibly fascinating, but I don't
- 12:31know.
- 12:32And I think this is where y'all have to
- 12:34tell us, right? So, do you think this is
- 12:36something noble? Do you think that
- 12:38there's some kind of atman or soul that
- 12:40has in hot inhabited the penguin? That
- 12:42the penguin is exploring the frontiers
- 12:45of its environment just like human
- 12:47beings did when they were like thousands
- 12:49of years ago? Or is it all just a
- 12:51biological malfunction?
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Discussing My Beliefs.. (Nihilism) by HealthyGamerGG, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 2,609 words across 380 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.