DISBARRED Lawyer Demands Attorney Fees... Judge's Decision SHOCKS Everyone — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:01Okay. All right. We're going on the
- 0:03record now in Riemann versus Johnston
- 0:07file number 2319394.
- 0:10The record should reflect that Mr. Couch
- 0:12is present today by video
- 0:15on behalf of Johnston. Mr. Riemann is
- 0:16present by Zoom video on his own behalf.
- 0:20This is the date and time set for
- 0:21hearing Mr. Couch
- 0:24on your motion
- 0:25in limine
- 0:27regarding trespass damages. I did have a
- 0:30chance to review your motion and brief.
- 0:34Mr. Riemann, I did get your response
- 0:36and brief. I had a chance to review that
- 0:38as well.
- 0:39Mr. Couch, is there anything that you
- 0:41wanted to say by way of oral argument
- 0:42today?
- 0:44>> Your Honor, based on my past appearances
- 0:46in this court, I know how prepared you
- 0:49are and I'll I'll stand on the arguments
- 0:51presented in our motion and
- 0:55you know, stand available for any
- 0:57further questions that the court might
- 0:59have, but I think it's a relatively
- 1:01simple, straightforward issue that we
- 1:03set forth in our motion.
- 1:07>> All right, thank you. Mr. Riemann,
- 1:08anything that you wanted to say today in
- 1:10terms of argument?
- 1:12>> Just briefly, Your Honor. Thank you and
- 1:14good afternoon. Along the same
- 1:16vein as Mr. Couch, I understand the
- 1:19court had an opportunity to receive our
- 1:21and and consider our brief and
- 1:22materials.
- 1:24Judge, I would just note as I said in my
- 1:27brief in response, Mr. Couch makes a
- 1:29good argument but for the fact that the
- 1:31court has allowed the damage to the
- 1:34driveway
- 1:36claim to proceed
- 1:38based on what the court found to be a
- 1:40factual issue based on the conflicting
- 1:43proofs.
- 1:44>> [clears throat]
- 1:45>> There hasn't been any case offered by
- 1:47Mr. Couch or
- 1:49any cited by the most recent Court of
- 1:52Appeals published case on this issue
- 1:54that ever ruled that in the event that
- 1:58you prove all the or you allege all the
- 2:00elements of a trespass nuisance, which
- 2:02are
- 2:03a condition, in this case that would be
- 2:06the altered driveway,
- 2:08a inva- excuse me, a [clears throat]
- 2:11physical intrusion, in this case that
- 2:12would be the
- 2:14allegations that Mr. Johnston came onto
- 2:16plaintiff's property with a tractor and
- 2:18made the changes,
- 2:19and then the third element is causation
- 2:21or control by the defendant, and again
- 2:23that's alleged that the defendant was
- 2:25the person who came onto plaintiff's
- 2:27property with a tractor making the
- 2:28changes.
- 2:29There's never been a case that is cited
- 2:32either by the defense or in the most
- 2:35recent published decision of Mack that
- 2:37ever said what that ever said when you
- 2:39allege those three elements, you cannot
- 2:42have non-economic damages.
- 2:45And that is
- 2:46as I cited in my brief, in my complaint,
- 2:48very clearly stated, I allege those
- 2:51elements, I allege non-economic damages,
- 2:53and I state because of the changes to my
- 2:56driveway made by Mr. Johnston,
- 2:58allegedly,
- 3:00I don't have the same use and enjoyment
- 3:02of my property.
- 3:04And if we wanted to get into specific
- 3:06facts, there's been discovered evidence
- 3:09in the form of affidavits from witnesses
- 3:11saying that they were not able to enter
- 3:14plaintiff's driveway because of the
- 3:15changes. They would get stuck at the
- 3:17top. Even with a four-wheel drive
- 3:19vehicle, they could not enter the
- 3:20driveway. That affects the use and
- 3:22enjoyment of the property, and
- 3:24specifically the driveway. And just just
- 3:26so, you know, the the slope issue
- 3:30is that you can only now enter the
- 3:32property
- 3:33from the direction of the low point, and
- 3:36that is now to the south. When Mr.
- 3:41Johnston made the changes, you could
- 3:42only enter from the north, and that's a
- 3:43direction that plaintiff doesn't come
- 3:45from, and that it it caused significant
- 3:47problems. So, the elements of trespass
- 3:50nuisance were alleged, that it the the
- 3:53cases are clear that non-economic
- 3:55damages are allowed for loss of undue
- 3:58loss or diminution of enjoyment of the
- 4:00property are allowed for those cases and
- 4:04we'd ask the court on that basis to deny
- 4:07the defendant's motion.
- 4:09>> Okay.
- 4:10>> Thank you,
- 4:11your honor.
- 4:12Anything in response?
- 4:13>> Yeah, very briefly, your honor. Um the
- 4:16as we argued in our motion, the
- 4:17plaintiff's nuisance claims have all
- 4:19been dismissed. Mr. Riemann continues to
- 4:22attempt to resuscitate dismissed claims
- 4:25to support the remaining claim of
- 4:28straightforward trespass that that is
- 4:30set to go to trial in late November.
- 4:33Um
- 4:34so for the reasons set forth in our
- 4:35motion, your honor, we would ask that
- 4:37the court enter an order limiting his
- 4:39damages to economic damages and not
- 4:41non-economic
- 4:43damages in this case.
- 4:47>> All right, thank you. Um
- 4:49again, I did have a chance to review the
- 4:51briefs. I did read
- 4:53the Matt case very carefully, which also
- 4:57refers in large part to the Price case,
- 5:00which the court of
- 5:02Um also had a chance to review.
- 5:04First of all, just in terms of the
- 5:06motion itself, it's a motion in limine.
- 5:08It's a motion dealing with what kind of
- 5:10evidence will or won't be allowed.
- 5:12>> Before you decide who's right or wrong,
- 5:14remember this.
- 5:15Court cases are rarely as simple as they
- 5:18first appear. The smallest legal detail
- 5:20can completely change the outcome, and
- 5:23sometimes the person who seems to be
- 5:24winning ends up walking away
- 5:26disappointed. That's exactly why
- 5:28watching only a few minutes never tells
- 5:30the whole story. Stay with us because
- 5:33what happens later may completely change
- 5:36the way you look at this case. As the
- 5:38arguments continue, you'll notice how
- 5:40strategy often matters just as much as
- 5:43the facts themselves. If you enjoy real
- 5:45courtroom proceedings with no
- 5:47unnecessary drama. Make sure you
- 5:48subscribe to Court Watch USA and turn on
- 5:51notifications. And while you're
- 5:53watching, let us know in the comments,
- 5:56do you think courtroom success depends
- 5:57more on the law or on how well someone
- 6:00presents their argument?
- 6:02>> to be presented at the trial,
- 6:05um whether or not to admit or exclude
- 6:07evidence is a matter that's within the
- 6:09discretion of the court. [clears throat]
- 6:10So, the court is act- acting within the
- 6:11exercise of its discretion
- 6:14in ruling on the motion.
- 6:16Um looking at the Mack case, um which
- 6:20again, as I indicated,
- 6:22is
- 6:23largely follows the principle uh set
- 6:26forth in the Price case, even though
- 6:27those cases were obviously
- 6:29uh different in terms of their factual
- 6:31basis and the claims that the courts
- 6:32were looking at.
- 6:34Um but the court finds that each of
- 6:36those holdings and the underlying
- 6:38principle is applicable in this case.
- 6:41And in my view, after reading Mack, uh
- 6:45the the thrust of that opinion is in
- 6:47property damage cases,
- 6:50um where there's property's been uh
- 6:53damaged or destroyed,
- 6:55um [clears throat]
- 6:57the uh measure of damages is generally
- 6:59the cost of replacement or the repair of
- 7:01the property.
- 7:03And under the holding in Mack and Price,
- 7:08uh that generally excludes non-economic
- 7:11damages by implication. And as the Mack
- 7:14court discussed in in great detail in
- 7:17analyzing the Price holding,
- 7:20uh there's a number of reasons for that.
- 7:22Um number one, the idea be- behind
- 7:25property damage cases, whether it's
- 7:27based on negligence or trespass, is to
- 7:30make the plaintiff whole.
- 7:32Um
- 7:34and so, that's one part of it, uh
- 7:37because uh people
- 7:39perceive damage to property in different
- 7:43ways.
- 7:44Um the
- 7:47stress or emotional harm
- 7:49that may be experienced by one plaintiff
- 7:51could be completely different than the
- 7:53other than that experienced by a
- 7:55different plaintiff.
- 7:57And where the injury or the damage is
- 8:00similar,
- 8:01um by excluding non-economic damages,
- 8:05courts can um
- 8:08can bring about similar results as
- 8:11opposed to wildly different results
- 8:13based on the subjective feelings of each
- 8:15individual plaintiff um with regard to
- 8:17damage to property.
- 8:19So, excluding non-economic damages
- 8:22results in more consistent verdicts for
- 8:24the similar types of injuries.
- 8:27Um
- 8:28as the Mack court also indicated,
- 8:31because that case involved a business,
- 8:33uh it can provide
- 8:35uh some continuity and some expectation
- 8:38on part of business owners in that case,
- 8:40but I think in this case it would apply
- 8:42to adjoining property owners.
- 8:44Um as to the scope of liability and a
- 8:47reasonable level of certainty as to the
- 8:49scope of liability
- 8:51um when there is an intrusion and that
- 8:54uh relatively minor intrusion can't
- 8:56result in
- 8:58um
- 8:59excessively high verdicts based on the
- 9:02subjective
- 9:04uh effect of
- 9:06the intrusion on the plaintiff.
- 9:09And um as the court indicated,
- 9:12uh economic damages are much more
- 9:13readily ascertainable, they're much
- 9:16[clears throat] more easily
- 9:16quantifiable, and in terms of making a
- 9:19plaintiff whole for an intrusion,
- 9:22um it's more important more appropriate
- 9:24than the non-economic damages.
- 9:27And even though uh the Price case was
- 9:30one that involved negligence, in that
- 9:33case it involved a trespass,
- 9:35um and the Mack court held that that the
- 9:39that principle announced in Price
- 9:41applies to trespass cases because again
- 9:44the goal is the the same to make a
- 9:46plaintiff whole for damages to property
- 9:48that are caused by a trespass.
- 9:51Um, and
- 9:53and so
- 9:55in that case Mac found that
- 9:58non-economic damages were not
- 10:00appropriate
- 10:01um, because the claim was one for
- 10:03trespass. The court did and Mr. Rieman
- 10:06did raise this in his brief. The court
- 10:09did acknowledge that uh, there is some
- 10:11divergence in terms of the specific
- 10:13[clears throat] claims that are pled and
- 10:15that there have been holdings that
- 10:16trespass nuisance claims can be the
- 10:18basis of
- 10:20uh, non-economic damages.
- 10:23Um, but there's a difference between
- 10:24trespass claims and trespass nuisance
- 10:27claims and certainly the Mac court
- 10:29recognized that and drew a distinction.
- 10:32And other courts have as well.
- 10:36And that's because uh, while trespass
- 10:40and trespass nuisance do contain some
- 10:42overlapping concepts
- 10:45um, they are different and separate
- 10:47claims. Um,
- 10:48>> One thing that separates experienced
- 10:50courtroom observers from casual viewers
- 10:52is patience. The most important moment
- 10:55in a hearing often comes long after the
- 10:57opening arguments. Judges don't simply
- 10:59react to a motion. They carefully
- 11:01analyze legal standards, prior
- 11:03decisions, and every word presented
- 11:06before making a ruling. That's why this
- 11:08case becomes more interesting the longer
- 11:10you watch. If you've made it this far,
- 11:12don't leave now because the next phase
- 11:15could answer questions that many viewers
- 11:17usually miss. If you enjoy watching real
- 11:19legal strategy unfold, subscribe to
- 11:22CourtWatch USA for more courtroom
- 11:24content every week. Also tell us below,
- 11:27have you ever changed your opinion about
- 11:29a case after hearing the judge explain
- 11:31the reasoning?
- 11:32>> Elements of trespass include a
- 11:34possessory interest on the part of the
- 11:36plaintiff, an invasion into that
- 11:37possessory interest by the defendant, an
- 11:41intent to trespass, in other words, not
- 11:43necessarily an intent to harm, but an
- 11:45intent to do an act that caused the
- 11:47trespass, and an actual intrusion or
- 11:50invasion onto that property caused by
- 11:52that act.
- 11:54That's different and distinguishable
- 11:56from a trespass [clears throat] nuisance
- 11:58claim. The thrust of
- 12:00the thrust of nuisance claims deals with
- 12:03the reasonable use and enjoyment of
- 12:05property.
- 12:06So, they're not interchangeable. They
- 12:08aren't the same claims, and I think
- 12:11that's why
- 12:12cases like Mack
- 12:14draw a distinction.
- 12:16As again, that case
- 12:18involved strictly a claim for trespass,
- 12:20and Mack acknowledged that in other
- 12:22cases where the claims were for trespass
- 12:25nuisance,
- 12:26um
- 12:27that you can not economic damages could
- 12:29be available.
- 12:31And in this case, I agree with Mr.
- 12:33Couch, the court dismissed all of
- 12:35plaintiff's claims involving nuisance,
- 12:38and so, what's remaining in count three
- 12:41of
- 12:43plaintiff's complaint is trespass.
- 12:45And that's how it's pled. My reading of
- 12:47that count is as a trespass, and I think
- 12:50that's backed up again by the court's
- 12:52dismissal by summary disposition of
- 12:54[clears throat] the nuisance claims, and
- 12:57so, I don't think
- 12:59that plaintiff can get around the Mack
- 13:01holding by styling or arguing that his
- 13:05count three for trespass is actually a
- 13:07count for trespass nuisance because it's
- 13:10not.
- 13:11So,
- 13:12based on the holding in Mack, the court
- 13:14finds that
- 13:15for a trespass claim such as the one we
- 13:17have here,
- 13:20that remains, that non-economic damages
- 13:23are not available.
- 13:25So, the court will grant the motion in
- 13:27limine. As also part of the motion,
- 13:31um Mr. Couch requested that the court
- 13:36transfer jurisdiction of this case to
- 13:37the the district court under MCR 2.227
- 13:41B1B.
- 13:42Um I reviewed that court rule and the
- 13:44case law interpreting it,
- 13:47and in my view that that court rule that
- 13:49that court rule and and the change of
- 13:52jurisdiction
- 13:53is based on pleadings. So, in other
- 13:55words, if if plaintiff's complaint had
- 13:58only pled claims of an amount that had
- 14:02only legally
- 14:03um
- 14:05be within the jurisdictional limit of
- 14:07the district court, then I think
- 14:08transfer would be appropriate. But in
- 14:10this case, it's not what happened. The
- 14:12plaintiff pled claims that were within
- 14:15the jurisdiction of the circuit court
- 14:17because uh those some of those claims
- 14:20and some aspects of those claims were
- 14:22dismissed on summary disposition, it
- 14:24certainly could bring it within the
- 14:25jurisdiction of the district court, but
- 14:27that's not a reason later on uh change
- 14:31or transfer venue or jurisdiction to the
- 14:33district court.
- 14:35So, um I find that that court rule would
- 14:37not justify change in this case. So, the
- 14:40court is is granting the motion in
- 14:42limine to preclude evidence of
- 14:44non-economic damages, uh is denying the
- 14:46motion to transfer jurisdiction to the
- 14:48district court.
- 14:49>> Thank you, Your Honor.
- 14:51>> And Mr. Couch, I would just ask that you
- 14:54uh prepare an order and submit that
- 14:56under the 7-day rule reflecting the
- 14:57ruling of the court today for the
- 14:59reasons stated in the record.
- 15:01>> I will. Thank you, Your Honor.
- 15:03>> All right.
- 15:04Um
- 15:04that's all we have for today. I know
- 15:06we're going to be back on the record
- 15:07again on Thursday, I believe. Uh so, um
- 15:11I will see the parties in a couple days.
- 15:13Um all parties are free to disconnect on
- 15:14this call.
- 15:16>> Thank you.
- 15:16>> Thank you, Judge.
- 15:18>> Thank you.
- 15:20>> [clears throat]
- 15:20>> Okay.
- 15:21>> All right. Uh we'll go and record in
- 15:24Riemann versus Johnston, file number
- 15:262319394.
- 15:30Um we have Mr. Riemann present by Zoom
- 15:32video
- 15:34um on his own behalf. Uh we have Ms.
- 15:36Stewart here on behalf of
- 15:39uh the plaintiffs, I'm sorry, the
- 15:41counter plaintiffs,
- 15:43uh Mr. and Ms. Johnston.
- 15:45>> This is where many courtroom cases
- 15:47become truly unpredictable. Most people
- 15:50expect the biggest surprise to happen
- 15:52early, but experienced courtroom viewers
- 15:54know that the most important moments
- 15:56often come later. Every legal dispute
- 15:58has layers, and sometimes the smallest
- 16:01detail can completely reshape the
- 16:03outcome. That's why staying until the
- 16:05end gives you the full picture instead
- 16:07of only part of the story. If you're
- 16:09enjoying this real courtroom coverage,
- 16:11subscribe to CourtWatch USA, and turn on
- 16:14notifications so you never miss our
- 16:16latest courtroom cases and legal
- 16:18updates. We upload authentic court
- 16:20content every week. And here's today's
- 16:23question. If you were sitting in the
- 16:25judge's chair, what would matter most to
- 16:27you? Fairness, evidence, or credibility?
- 16:31Let us know in the comments below.
- 16:33>> Um and I I just want to make sure I
- 16:36think we all would get this, but Ms.
- 16:39Stewart, I'm not sure that you've um
- 16:41you've made any uh appearances on the
- 16:44record, although you obviously filed an
- 16:45appearance on behalf of your clients,
- 16:47but I want to make sure that the
- 16:48record's clear as to the attorney
- 16:50relationships here. So, you're you're
- 16:52representing the Johnstons in their
- 16:55counter complaint. Is that correct?
- 16:58>> That is correct, Your Honor.
- 17:00>> Okay. And Mr. Couch, you were you're
- 17:02only representative for purposes of
- 17:03defending the claims brought by Mr.
- 17:06Riemann. Is that correct?
- 17:08>> That is correct, Your Honor. Thank you.
- 17:10>> Okay. So, this motion
- 17:13um Ms. Stewart uh was filed by you, uh
- 17:16and this is a motion to dismiss uh those
- 17:18counterclaims.
- 17:20Um I did have a chance to review your
- 17:22motion and uh the supporting documents.
- 17:25Mr. Reeman, I did get your objection to
- 17:27that. I had a chance to review that. Uh
- 17:29so, Ms. Stewart, um uh anything by way
- 17:32of oral argument in support of your
- 17:33position here today?
- 17:36>> Thank you, Your Honor. I was not um I
- 17:38did not receive any copy of any response
- 17:40filed by Mr. Reeman. I just want to
- 17:41bring that to the court's attention.
- 17:43Um
- 17:44I I was not aware that any response is
- 17:47was provided, so I don't know any of the
- 17:48contents of that. Um with that With that
- 17:51said, Your Honor, my clients have
- 17:53counterclaims against Mr. Reeman.
- 17:55Uh we're seeking in our motion a
- 17:57voluntary dismissal of those
- 17:59counterclaims. Um the primary focus of
- 18:02this case as far as the court is aware,
- 18:05uh including the motion practice, has
- 18:07been focused on defending against the
- 18:10121-count complaint filed by Mr. Reeman
- 18:13against the Johnstons. There's been very
- 18:15little discovery, if any, Your Honor,
- 18:18conducted with regard to the
- 18:19counterclaims specifically. Um my
- 18:23clients sought a voluntary dismissal
- 18:25from Mr. Reeman. Um and the response
- 18:27from Mr. Reeman was that
- 18:29uh my clients needed to agree to what
- 18:33was referred to as a partial settlement
- 18:34agreement that would have necessitated
- 18:36my clients waive any claim for attorney
- 18:39fees arising out of claims beyond the
- 18:41scope of the counterclaims, which my
- 18:43clients were not agreeable to. That
- 18:46would have affected the operative claims
- 18:47that Mr. Reeman filed against that has
- 18:49been filed against the Johnstons that
- 18:51Mr. Couch is defending against.
- 18:54Um
- 18:55ultimately, Your Honor, after careful
- 18:57consideration, um my clients made a
- 19:00decision that the escalating costs of
- 19:02litigation outweighed the potential
- 19:04benefits
- 19:05um of continuing to pursue these claims.
- 19:08Um It was going to impose It will
- 19:10impose, Your Honor, a financial hardship
- 19:12on my clients. The decision on my
- 19:14client's part to seek a voluntary
- 19:17dismissal was made in good faith to
- 19:18conserve their resources, and I think
- 19:20it's in alignment with the court's
- 19:23interest in promoting an efficient
- 19:25resolution of claims. Um
- 19:28I bring
- 19:31The court rules provide that a voluntary
- 19:34dismissal
- 19:35um
- 19:36is is in general a dismissal without
- 19:39prejudice. But the court as this court
- 19:41is well aware has the discretion to set
- 19:43any other terms and conditions that the
- 19:45court deems just and proper.
- 19:48Um and in this case, Your Honor, we're
- 19:49asking for a dismissal with prejudice
- 19:52with one exception, and that is the
- 19:54abuse of process claim in this case. We
- 19:57are only preserving that claim, Your
- 20:00Honor, for the reason that there has
- 20:01been recent threats already made to my
- 20:04clients concerning a fence
- 20:06that was recently installed um by the
- 20:09Johnsons. There was a threat of of a
- 20:12future litigation against the Johnsons
- 20:14by Mr. Riemann, and that is the only
- 20:16reason, Your Honor, we are asking the
- 20:17court to
- 20:19uh dismiss the abuse of process claim uh
- 20:22without prejudice. All remaining claims,
- 20:25all other counterclaims, Your Honor,
- 20:27we're actually seeking a dismissal um
- 20:29with prejudice, which is the reason that
- 20:32um I think it's appropriate in this case
- 20:33given the fact that there's been little
- 20:35discovery,
- 20:36um given the fact that uh we're seeking
- 20:38a dismissal with prejudice. My clients
- 20:41have reached this decision in good faith
- 20:43um and for good reason.
- 20:44Uh we think it's appropriate that the
- 20:46court enter a voluntary dismissal
- 20:48um as requested without the imposition
- 20:51of any costs.
- 20:52Um
- 20:54And
- 20:58I think that's all I have, Your Honor.
- 21:02>> All right, thank you. Uh Mr. Riemann,
- 21:04your response?
- 21:06>> Yes, uh Your Honor, thank you. I I'm
- 21:08sorry. I I thought I lost you, and I I
- 21:11must say that I'm having some logistical
- 21:13technical issues. So, if I lose you, uh
- 21:16please bear with me. Um
- 21:18I will be uh logging back in on the
- 21:20computer, but um
- 21:23Your Honor, as to not uh providing a
- 21:25copy of my response to Ms. Stewart, I
- 21:28I'm a couple of minutes away from my
- 21:30computer, and when I get there, I'll be
- 21:31able to confirm, but I I as a form of
- 21:34habit, I know I always sent her a copy,
- 21:37and I I feel like I remember um putting
- 21:39her and Marielle in,
- 21:41uh because sometimes I just communicate
- 21:43with Mr. Couch and uh his his
- 21:46assistant, but I I really think I I sent
- 21:49that email to her. Uh I know I intended
- 21:52to, so if if she hasn't received it, I
- 21:54apologize, uh and I'll try to confirm
- 21:56that I I did send it. But, uh
- 22:00essentially, Your Honor, um
- 22:03my [clears throat] issue is that the
- 22:05complaint itself is not a legally viable
- 22:08claim. It's uh against me. It they make,
- 22:12you know, mean accusations against a
- 22:14bunch of people,
- 22:15uh other adults that they claim
- 22:17misbehaved in my absence. That's that's
- 22:20the gravamen of the complaint, and
- 22:22before it was filed, because uh you
- 22:25know, they're talking about threats of
- 22:26uh
- 22:27suits, of course, any future action
- 22:29wouldn't be covered by the statute of
- 22:31limitations anyway. Um so, I don't know
- 22:33what
- 22:34uh sense there is in making the
- 22:37uh abuse of process claims um
- 22:40without prejudice, because
- 22:42if they're worried about a future
- 22:43lawsuit, which you know, I I
- 22:45I've taken up with Mr. Couch uh seeking
- 22:48his uh stipulation based on new actions
- 22:51over the last 6 to 8 weeks and and
- 22:54ongoing
- 22:55uh with a new fence and some new uh
- 22:57changes to the uh
- 23:01to the [clears throat]
- 23:02properties uh that affect uh both
- 23:04flooding and uh
- 23:08it violates the zoning and you know,
- 23:09blatantly uh and
- 23:11obviously intentionally. But as to the
- 23:15uh
- 23:15threats
- 23:17um
- 23:18I'm sorry. I am getting to my computer
- 23:20now.
- 23:21Um
- 23:22Oh, the reason I uh I have asked for the
- 23:26court to award costs in this case is
- 23:29when I received the counter complaint, I
- 23:31contacted uh Ms. Stewart and Ms. Lehman
- 23:33who was also, I believe, on the initial
- 23:36appearances
- 23:37and uh noted that
- 23:40this court had ruled in a similar uh
- 23:43claim
- 23:44involving Little Bear Lake subdivision
- 23:46property owners that the claims against
- 23:49the owners, rather than the adult
- 23:51offenders,
- 23:53uh was not proper. And I provided uh the
- 23:56this court's ruling on those nuisance
- 23:58cases.
- 23:59And uh they proceeded with to file it
- 24:01anyway. And then uh in January of 2024,
- 24:06I uh sent an email to Ms. Stewart and
- 24:09said, "Hey, I don't know if you got this
- 24:10information. It's not a valid claim.
- 24:12Please dismiss so that we don't incur
- 24:14costs."
- 24:16That was ignored. And then throughout
- 24:18this process, Judge, I tried to do
- 24:20discovery on this. I I noticed her
- 24:24properly for her clients to appear at
- 24:26depositions four times. They never
- 24:29appeared. They never objected. They
- 24:30never tried to
- 24:32cancel the notice or take offense to it.
- 24:33They just chose not to appear.
- 24:37So, I I'm on all those occasions,
- 24:40I prepared with counsel the questions to
- 24:43defend against the counter claim.
- 24:45And
- 24:47uh
- 24:49they just didn't appear. At my
- 24:50deposition, the same. I prepared with
- 24:52counsel
- 24:53uh to respond to questions that I
- 24:55expected would be asked of me on the
- 24:56counter complaint.
- 24:58And Ms. Stewart didn't even show up. Um
- 25:01So
- 25:02probably six or seven times I've sent an
- 25:05email before I was having legal a
- 25:07consultations on the council on the
- 25:09counter claim and asked Ms. Stewart to
- 25:12dismiss the case.
- 25:13On each occasion I was ignored.
- 25:16More recently, we did have discussions.
- 25:19Um she she's not referencing our most
- 25:21recent discussion when she just spoke
- 25:23with you.
- 25:24But
- 25:25a discussion we had before the June uh
- 25:28hearing on summary disposition.
- 25:30And at that time I said, "Fine, but I
- 25:34don't want you coming back claiming
- 25:35attorney fees that I owe your attorney
- 25:37fees or costs." So that settlement
- 25:40agreement that she's speaking of was
- 25:42simply I asked for a statement that each
- 25:45party will be responsible for their own
- 25:47costs and attorney fees.
- 25:49That was a a no go with her. So
- 25:52we didn't have any more discussions
- 25:53until
- 25:54after the hearing and I think I attached
- 25:56Ms. Stewart's email to me on that
- 25:58occasion and she said, "Fine, we're not
- 26:00dismissing."
- 26:01That's the last I've heard.
- 26:03Um and now she filed a motion
- 26:06even the court rule says she's supposed
- 26:08to seek concurrence in the relief
- 26:10sought, which she didn't do. Uh but it's
- 26:14just it's been a very big inconvenience.
- 26:16I've incurred thousands of dollars. Even
- 26:18they're saying
- 26:20uh that they can no longer afford to go
- 26:22forward because of what they're spending
- 26:24on attorney fees. And Ms. Stewart just
- 26:26to go, she hasn't really even done
- 26:27anything.
- 26:29Uh so I've had to prepare to defend.
- 26:30It's just been a farce and a game right
- 26:33from the start. It's not a legitimate
- 26:35lawsuit against me.
- 26:36And so they should be responsible at
- 26:40least for part of my uh attorney fees
- 26:42and costs. And I would ask the court to
- 26:45um
- 26:46enter
- 26:47a an order of costs and attorney fees
- 26:49in the amount of 1,500, approximately
- 26:51half of my out-of-pocket.
- 26:57>> All right.
- 26:58Mr. Riemann,
- 27:00I mean, you've never had an attorney
- 27:02make an appearance on your behalf.
- 27:05So, how can I award you
- 27:06>> That's correct.
- 27:09Well,
- 27:10attorney fees
- 27:11Attorney fees are not only incurred when
- 27:14an attorney appears on a case. When you
- 27:16get advice, and I I am having counsel of
- 27:18course for trial, your honor, and I have
- 27:20been preparing with counsel.
- 27:23And was doing so on this case, and I
- 27:25will have an appearance of an attorney
- 27:27as we prepare for, you know, get closer
- 27:28to trial.
- 27:32I could provide the attorneys
- 27:34billing and affidavit or something if
- 27:36the court just wanted to confirm
- 27:38the billing, but I don't I don't think
- 27:40the fact that they haven't filed an
- 27:41appearance on the case
- 27:43makes it an illegitimate legal expense.
- 27:47>> Well, the case law that I reviewed
- 27:49indicates that for the court to award
- 27:51attorney fees, there has to be an actual
- 27:53attorney-client relationship where the
- 27:55attorney has made an appearance in the
- 27:57case.
- 27:58So,
- 27:59>> I'm not I'm not aware of that, your
- 28:01honor.
- 28:01>> Well, I can appreciate that you're not
- 28:03aware of it. I I don't know whether
- 28:05you're aware of it or not. You're not
- 28:06giving me any authority. You're telling
- 28:08you think that that doesn't matter.
- 28:12>> Well, I'm saying I was not aware of it.
- 28:15>> [laughter]
- 28:15>> So, if the case law is
- 28:17that yes, the case law is that there
- 28:18needs to be an attorney-client
- 28:20relationship, I have an attorney-client
- 28:22relationship on which I consulted
- 28:24wisely.
- 28:25And uh
- 28:27if it says that the test for having an
- 28:28appearance before can be then I then I
- 28:30then I guess I'm out on that. But I the
- 28:32court rule does say the court can issue
- 28:35the terms that
- 28:36leaves are just. And if the court court
- 28:39believes that I shouldn't have
- 28:40had to respond to this lawsuit with, you
- 28:43know, attorney consultations, then I
- 28:45think it's within the court's
- 28:46discretion.
- 28:47>> Okay. All right. [clears throat] Thank
- 28:48you. Um Um
- 28:50Ms. Stewart, uh to your motion, uh I'll
- 28:52give you the last word. Anything you
- 28:53wanted to say in response?
- 28:56>> Well, Your Honor, I
- 28:58I
- 28:59I don't as an officer of this court, I
- 29:02heard Mr. Reiman represent that there's
- 29:04been six or seven discussions about
- 29:05dismissal of the counterclaim.
- 29:07Um I don't remember any of those. I
- 29:10don't without an opportunity
- 29:13cuz I'm hearing that right now on the
- 29:14record, Your Honor, to go back and
- 29:16review whether there may have been one
- 29:17email or not. I just can't say, but I
- 29:20can say with certainty that um
- 29:23I I'm confident as an officer of this
- 29:25court that if Mr. Reiman and I had had
- 29:26six or seven discussions ever about the
- 29:28counterclaims, that I would recall that,
- 29:29and I do not. Um additionally, there was
- 29:32a reference to having discussions
- 29:34earlier about the merits of the
- 29:36counterclaim based on prior rulings of
- 29:38the court that Mr. Reiman says he has
- 29:39with me before they were filed, and then
- 29:41they were filed thereafter. I was not
- 29:43even in the case at that time, Your
- 29:44Honor.
- 29:45So, those discussions
- 29:47um would have had to have hap- happened
- 29:49with other counsel, not with me.
- 29:51Um
- 29:51with that said, I I I I
- 29:53I completely disagree that there's
- 29:55um any frivolity whatsoever with regard
- 29:58to the counterclaims.
- 30:00Um
- 30:01Those claims uh
- 30:03are are
- 30:05I believe as as counsel would have been
- 30:06meritorious claims, Your Honor, but
- 30:08ultimately,
- 30:09um there's a financial hardship here um
- 30:12that would to pursue these cases through
- 30:14trial would cost my clients so much
- 30:16money, and that's the reason why we're
- 30:18seeking a dismissal with prejudice. Um
- 30:21or I'm sorry, without prejudice only as
- 30:23to the abusive process claim, Your
- 30:24Honor.
- 30:25Um
- 30:29>> All right. Okay. Thank you. Um
- 30:32I did review the uh court rule 2.504
- 30:35governing uh dismissals. I think both
- 30:38sides have accurately cited the the rule
- 30:41and uh the basis in this case, which is
- 30:43the court can grant dismissal on terms
- 30:47which the court deems to be just and
- 30:49proper. Generally, unless the order
- 30:51provides otherwise, those dismissals are
- 30:54without prejudice.
- 30:55Um in this case, I don't find whether
- 30:58the the merits of the counterclaim
- 31:00really have anything to do with it. I
- 31:01mean, of course, the the the
- 31:03counterclaimants, the Johnsons, are
- 31:05going to take the position that uh
- 31:07there is merit to it. And of course, Mr.
- 31:09Riemann I would expect would take the
- 31:11position he's taking, which is that they
- 31:13don't have merit. Um the court's never
- 31:15made any determinations one way or the
- 31:17other because
- 31:18the counterclaims certainly haven't been
- 31:20litigated by the counterclaimants in
- 31:23this case.
- 31:24Uh they haven't brought any motions that
- 31:26Mr. Riemann's been required to defend
- 31:28regarding the counterclaims.
- 31:30Uh and Mr. Riemann hasn't taken any
- 31:32actions. He hasn't brought any motions
- 31:34to dismiss the counterclaims.
- 31:36Um Mr. Riemann's statements that uh Miss
- 31:40Stewart did not appear for depositions
- 31:43uh reinforces the notion that there
- 31:45hasn't been uh really any litigation of
- 31:48the counterclaims.
- 31:50Uh and that, as I think both parties
- 31:53would have to acknowledge, the the
- 31:55litigation so far has all dealt with Mr.
- 31:59Riemann's claims against the Johnsons.
- 32:01So,
- 32:03um
- 32:05Uh the court finds that there hasn't
- 32:07really been anything that would cause uh
- 32:10really up till now either side to incur
- 32:13costs [clears throat] or fees with
- 32:14regard to the counterclaim.
- 32:16Um
- 32:18I don't think Mr. Riemann has any basis
- 32:21as a pro per uh party here to seek
- 32:24attorney fees when he hasn't had an
- 32:26attorney make any appearances on his
- 32:28behalf.
- 32:30Um and I'm not [clears throat] aware of
- 32:31any case law or authority otherwise that
- 32:34would allow the court to award attorney
- 32:36fees to a proper
- 32:39uh litigant. So,
- 32:41I don't find that any attorney fees
- 32:43would be appropriate either in this
- 32:46case.
- 32:47Um, and again,
- 32:49um, the court finds that, you know,
- 32:52there could be any number of reasons why
- 32:54a plaintiff or counter plaintiff would
- 32:56want to dismiss claims.
- 32:58Uh, it doesn't necessarily mean that it
- 32:59doesn't have merit. Um, they could have
- 33:03perfectly reasonable decision
- 33:06as a strategic decision in consultation
- 33:08with counsel that, uh,
- 33:10given the potential expenditures that
- 33:12the, even if they win, the possible
- 33:14relief wouldn't outweigh, uh, the
- 33:16expense of going through litigation. So,
- 33:19again, I don't find that the merits one
- 33:21way or the other have much to do with
- 33:22the court's decision on a motion for
- 33:24dismissal. So,
- 33:26uh, for those reasons, the court will
- 33:28grant the motion. Uh, the court does not
- 33:30find a basis to award, uh, the costs or
- 33:33attorney fees,
- 33:35uh, in this case, and, uh, the court
- 33:38will grant the dismissal as requested
- 33:40by,
- 33:41uh, Ms. Stewart with, uh, with
- 33:43prejudice, with the exception of the
- 33:46abuse of process claim. Ms. Stewart,
- 33:48I'll ask that you prepare an order,
- 33:50uh, reflecting the ruling of the court
- 33:52and submit that under the 7-day rule.
- 33:56And
- 33:56>> Yes. Yes, Ronald.
- 33:58>> That is all for this hearing today, and
- 34:01all parties are free to disconnect at
- 34:02this time.
- 34:03>> Your Honor, Judge, could I just confirm
- 34:05about, uh, providing notice of this
- 34:06hearing, um, to counsel? I have filed
- 34:09it.
- 34:10>> Okay. Sure.
- 34:12>> I would just, uh, thank you, Judge. I
- 34:14didn't want to interrupt you either, but
- 34:15I just wanted to make sure I make a
- 34:16record of this. On Friday, August 29th
- 34:19at 4:55, I sent the court's, um,
- 34:24Judge's copy to Ms. O'Rourke, her email,
- 34:27and on that tagged was, um, Mr.
- 34:30Cowlishaw and his assistant, as well as
- 34:32Merial Lehman, and Ms. Stewart.
- 34:34And I've used the same
- 34:35>> What makes courtroom videos so
- 34:37fascinating isn't just the final ruling.
- 34:40It's understanding how the legal system
- 34:42reaches that decision. Every hearing
- 34:44reminds us that facts, preparation,
- 34:47procedure, and the rule of law all work
- 34:49together in the pursuit of justice.
- 34:51Thank you for watching all the way to
- 34:53the end. If you enjoyed today's case,
- 34:56please subscribe to CourtWatch USA, turn
- 34:58on notifications, and never miss another
- 35:01courtroom story. Your support helps us
- 35:03continue bringing you authentic legal
- 35:05proceedings from real courtrooms. If you
- 35:07found this case interesting, give the
- 35:09video a like, share it with someone who
- 35:11enjoys courtroom content, and leave your
- 35:13opinion in the comments. We read as many
- 35:16comments as we can, and we'd love to
- 35:18hear your perspective. Thanks for
- 35:20watching, and we'll see you in the next
- 35:22case here on CourtWatch USA.
- 35:24>> same uh email address
- 35:26that I corresponded with her recently.
- 35:28But that and that that would be the same
- 35:30email address that
- 35:32the attached exhibit was uh was
- 35:35communicated with. And all those other I
- 35:37said approximately five or six There
- 35:39were email conversations with Ms.
- 35:40Stewart that she didn't reply to. Uh
- 35:43maybe that may maybe for some reason my
- 35:45my emails are going to her junk.
- 35:47I know we've had we've had some
- 35:48communication through email.
- 35:53>> Okay. Um thank you for making that
- 35:55record, and um
- 35:58all parties are free to disconnect this
- 36:00time.
- 36:01That also concludes
- 36:03>> the Zoom docket. The court will be in
- 36:04recess until 9:00 a.m. tomorrow.
- 36:06>> Thank you, Your Honor.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of DISBARRED Lawyer Demands Attorney Fees... Judge's Decision SHOCKS Everyone by Court Watch USA, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 5,727 words across 997 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.