Dirichlet Function: The King of Calculus Counter-Examples — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:02can you find a function that is defined
- 0:04everywhere but you cannot draw it can
- 0:07you find a function that is defined
- 0:08everywhere but discontinuous
- 0:11everywhere can the sum of two
- 0:13discontinuous functions be
- 0:16continuous and can you find a function
- 0:18that is periodic but does not have the
- 0:21smallest period the first four questions
- 0:24are pretty tricky but the fifth one is
- 0:26very concrete and straightforward so
- 0:29let's solve the fifth one first the
- 0:31inner limit is cosine K factorial X to
- 0:35the^ of 2 J When J goes to Infinity
- 0:39because cosine is no greater than one so
- 0:41when it is one we get one but as long as
- 0:45it is smaller than one no matter how
- 0:47small the difference is we get zero in
- 0:50order for the limit to be one cosine
- 0:52expression must be either positive one
- 0:55or negative one therefore K factorial X
- 0:58must be an integer now when K goes to
- 1:01Infinity K factorial X is an integer
- 1:04when and only when X is a rational
- 1:07number this fact is also used in the
- 1:10proof of the irrationality of e you will
- 1:13be surprised how easy it is to prove
- 1:15that e is irrational check out this
- 1:18video here back to our question so this
- 1:21expression is one when X is rational but
- 1:24zero when X is irrational because all
- 1:28real numbers are either rational or
- 1:30irrational so this is a well-defined
- 1:32function over all real numbers this
- 1:35function has a name the Der function
- 1:38invented by German mathematician dly it
- 1:41is literally impossible to draw this
- 1:43function even the tipe of your Peno is
- 1:46made of a single carbon item the graph
- 1:49on the right is often used to represent
- 1:51the D function because really there
- 1:54isn't a better
- 1:56one so the Der function is the answer to
- 1:59our last question and the Der function
- 2:02is a function that cannot be drawn
- 2:04precisely according to its definition
- 2:06moving on to our second question as you
- 2:09may guess the answer is still the derly
- 2:12function without knowing the disly
- 2:14function it is really hard to imagine a
- 2:17function that is defined everywhere but
- 2:19the discontinuous everywhere the dis
- 2:22function is really the king of counter
- 2:24examples and the Godzilla of anti-
- 2:27intuition recall that a function is
- 2:30continuous at a point C when the value
- 2:33of FC equals the limit of the function
- 2:36when X goes to C applying this on the
- 2:39Der function we see that the limiting
- 2:41process will depend on whether C is a
- 2:44rational number or irrational number so
- 2:46let's focus on the case that c is
- 2:48rational first so C is p/ q and DC is 1
- 2:53I can construct this series it's clearly
- 2:56approaching p/ Q which is C but it's all
- 2:59always irrational because e is
- 3:02irrational therefore this limiting
- 3:05process will always e to zero thus FX is
- 3:09not continuous at any rational Point C
- 3:12how about irrational points let's say C
- 3:15is pi so D Pi is zero and I can just
- 3:18pick the first end digits of pi and they
- 3:21are all rational so I can constract the
- 3:24limiting process that's always one and
- 3:27it's never equal to the actual value of
- 3:29d Pi so here we go the second question's
- 3:32answer is disly function defined
- 3:35everywhere but the discontinuous
- 3:37everywhere now you know the drill can
- 3:39you think about the answer for the third
- 3:56question did you get it if one fun fun
- 4:00is a deral function another function is
- 4:02a negative of deral function when you
- 4:04add them together you get a zero which
- 4:07is a continuous function how about the
- 4:10product we can Define GX as zero when X
- 4:14is rational and One X is irrational both
- 4:17FX and GX are discontinuous but when
- 4:20multiplying together we get zero a
- 4:23constant therefore
- 4:25continuous let's do something even
- 4:27fancier can a function be continuous at
- 4:30only given values here's a hint this
- 4:33function is only discontinuous at one
- 4:37and E so again 15 seconds let's
- 4:56go how about this function when X is
- 5:00irrational it is zero when X is rational
- 5:03it is a polinomial x -1 * x - e and this
- 5:08function is only continuous at 1 and
- 5:12E fub1 is exactly zero and the limit of
- 5:17FX when X goes to one has two possible
- 5:20Expressions when X is rational FX
- 5:23approaches zero as a polinomial when X
- 5:26is irrational FX is already zero
- 5:29therefore the value at one is exactly
- 5:32the same as the limit when X goes to one
- 5:36and the exact same argument works for
- 5:38the x equals e case you can extend this
- 5:41trick to construct functions that are
- 5:43only continuous for example at integers
- 5:46which is
- 5:47crazy anyway the answer to the third
- 5:50question is still the disly function how
- 5:53about the fourth one is dly function
- 5:56periodic the answer is yes for example
- 5:59example one is a period of the Der
- 6:02function whether X is rational or
- 6:05irrational DX + 1 is always DX but think
- 6:10about that
- 6:110.01 is also a period of diary function
- 6:16in fact arbitrarily small rational
- 6:18number is a period of the derish
- 6:20function so the derish function is a
- 6:23periodic function but there is no
- 6:26smallest period that is
- 6:30crazy how about irrational numbers let's
- 6:33say x is an irrational number then the
- 6:36CU of X which is the smallest integer
- 6:39that is greater than or equal to X is an
- 6:42integer therefore a rational number so
- 6:45dcx is
- 6:47one however as the construction you see
- 6:50here cux - x is another irrational
- 6:53number therefore dcx - x is zero we can
- 6:58conclude that any irrational number is
- 7:01not a period of the derly function and
- 7:04this concludes our investigation to the
- 7:07five questions we had at the beginning I
- 7:10can't express how amazed when I first
- 7:12learned the disly function it's like the
- 7:15experience you read War and Peace for
- 7:17the first time or beat Diablo for the
- 7:19first time and if this is the first time
- 7:22you learn about the dis function I hope
- 7:25I successfully passed the joy of
- 7:27mathematics to you
- 7:39[Music]
- 7:58[Music]
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Dirichlet Function: The King of Calculus Counter-Examples by Ron & Math, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 1,030 words across 148 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.