Direito Penal Geral (Prof. Estefam) - Aula 2 — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Alright, let's move on to part two of
- 0:02our general criminal law tips. I'm
- 0:04going to talk about the concurrence of
- 0:05persons. I think the concurrence of
- 0:08persons and concurrence of crimes are
- 0:10definitely topics likely to be asked in
- 0:12the preliminary exam. How are these
- 0:17topics usually approached in
- 0:19preliminary exams? Concurrence of
- 0:22persons and concurrence of crimes? The
- 0:24questions usually refer to legal
- 0:27provisions. So let's get to it.
- 0:29Concurrence of persons involves three
- 0:31articles of the Penal Code: 29, 30, and
- 0:3331. I will break down article 29 here
- 0:39and talk about the others as well.
- 0:42Article 29 says: "Whoever, in any way,
- 0:45contributes to the crime, incurs the
- 0:47penalties provided for it, to the
- 0:49extent of their culpability." The main
- 0:53provision is what indicates that the
- 0:55Penal Code has adopted the monistic, or
- 0:58unitary, theory. The unitary theory, as
- 1:01you know, maintains that all
- 1:03participants, all those who contributed
- 1:05to the criminal offense, are liable for
- 1:07the same crime and subject to the same
- 1:09penalty, obviously, to the extent of
- 1:11their culpability. If one is a
- 1:14first-time offender, the sentence may
- 1:15be lower. If the other is a repeat
- 1:17offender, for them, the sentence will
- 1:18be increased by the aggravating factor
- 1:20of recidivism, which applies in the
- 1:22second phase. Anyway, they all answer
- 1:24for the same crime to the extent of
- 1:26their culpability. So, the rule is the
- 1:28monistic theory. These are the famous
- 1:30pluralistic exceptions to the monistic
- 1:33theory, cases where the legislator
- 1:35understands that people contributing to
- 1:37the same result, for certain criminal
- 1:39policy reasons, should be framed in
- 1:41different articles and, therefore,
- 1:44subject to different penalties.
- 1:46Abortion is a classic example. The
- 1:49pregnant woman who consents to the
- 1:51abortion is covered under article 124,
- 1:53and the doctor, or the third party who
- 1:55performs the abortion, under 126,
- 1:57because there is a much higher degree
- 1:59of blameworthiness for the third party
- 2:01than for the pregnant woman. So the
- 2:03legislator understood it would be
- 2:04better to classify them under different
- 2:06types of offenses. Corruption. The
- 2:09corrupt official is classified under
- 2:12article 317, passive corruption. The
- 2:15corrupting individual under 333, active
- 2:17corruption. The crime of facilitating
- 2:21smuggling or embezzlement. The
- 2:24facilitator, the public servant who
- 2:25facilitates the smuggling or
- 2:27embezzlement, is covered under 318. The
- 2:29perpetrator of the smuggling or
- 2:30embezzlement is classified under a
- 2:32specific criminal provision, right? The
- 2:34article on smuggling and embezzlement
- 2:36there. Eh, what was the article again?
- 2:39300 and, anyway, further along in the
- 2:42Penal Code, the number for smuggling
- 2:44and embezzlement slipped my mind,
- 2:46probably around 340 or so. I'll check
- 2:50and let you know later, but anyway,
- 2:52it's another classic example of a
- 2:54pluralist exception, the monist theory.
- 2:56And please excuse my momentary lapse in
- 2:59not recalling the legal provision.
- 3:03Still talking about Article 29, because
- 3:05what I told you was the head provision,
- 3:07but you have the first paragraph which
- 3:09brings up minor participation, which is
- 3:11a sentence reduction cause. If one of
- 3:15the participants provides minor
- 3:17participation, their sentence is
- 3:19reduced by 1/6 to 1/3. So, minor
- 3:22participation generates a sentence
- 3:25reduction of 1/6 to 1/3. Sentence
- 3:27reduction, cause for mitigation, third
- 3:29phase of sentencing. And the second
- 3:33paragraph of 29 deals with willfully
- 3:35distinct participation. If one of the
- 3:37participants intended to engage in a
- 3:39less serious crime, that sentence shall
- 3:41apply to them. To remember this, use
- 3:44the classic example. Two people agree
- 3:48to commit burglary at a residence at
- 3:50night, both assuming it is uninhabited,
- 3:53with no residents. And they agree that
- 3:57one will keep watch outside while the
- 3:59other goes inside to steal the
- 4:01belongings. They then separate and
- 4:03begin the execution of the crime. The
- 4:07subject who enters the property is
- 4:08suddenly surprised by a resident he
- 4:10didn't expect to be there, right?
- 4:12Remember? Both thought there were no
- 4:14residents at that time. And he ends up
- 4:17delivering a violent blow to the
- 4:18resident's head, causing them to die.
- 4:20And the guy outside has no idea what is
- 4:22happening. That's where the second
- 4:25paragraph comes in. It is the willfully
- 4:27distinct participation. One of the
- 4:30participants, the one outside, intended
- 4:31to participate in a less serious crime,
- 4:33a much less serious one. For him, it
- 4:35would have been aggravated theft,
- 4:37committed during the night, but never
- 4:39robbery-homicide, which is what the
- 4:41other accomplice committed. How is this
- 4:44resolved? By paragraph 2 of Article 29,
- 4:46to each their own or everyone in their
- 4:48own lane. The perpetrator of the
- 4:51robbery-homicide will be held
- 4:53accountable based on 157, paragraph 3.
- 4:56And the subject who stayed outside
- 4:58intended to participate in a less
- 5:00serious crime, the aggravated theft,
- 5:02right? There is a discussion about
- 5:04whether or not to apply a cause for
- 5:06increase, right? The issue of
- 5:08aggravated theft, is that true? But
- 5:10anyway, at the very least, he will be
- 5:12held liable for this theft crime,
- 5:14Article 155. Another thing that is also
- 5:18tested when talking about complicity is
- 5:21the requirements for establishing
- 5:23complicity. What are they? First,
- 5:29plurality of conduct, obviously, that
- 5:33is legally relevant. All subjects must
- 5:36engage in conduct that is legally
- 5:38relevant. Then, the causal relevance of
- 5:42these acts, that is, all must influence
- 5:49, even if minimally, but all must
- 5:54influence the outcome. Furthermore,
- 5:59number three, the subjective
- 6:01requirement, the unity or identity of
- 6:04purpose, right? It is the subjective
- 6:07link, the subjective bond. And finally,
- 6:12legal doctrine points to it as a
- 6:13requirement, but it is actually a
- 6:15consequence, right, the unity of the
- 6:16criminal offense. Everyone is liable
- 6:19for the same crime because, as we saw,
- 6:21the monistic or unitary theory was
- 6:24adopted, as shown above. Regarding the
- 6:27concurrence of crimes, I suggest
- 6:29reading articles 69 through 71. I will
- 6:31now speak on topic five about
- 6:32sentencing, and I will also recall a
- 6:34few things about the concurrence of
- 6:36crimes, okay? Let's go. Sentencing. The
- 6:40Penal Code, as we know very well,
- 6:42adopted the so-called three-phase
- 6:44system. This is found in article 68 of
- 6:48the Penal Code. It is clear that the
- 6:50legislator adopted the three-phase
- 6:52system there in 68, sole paragraph. So,
- 6:55how does the three-phase system work?
- 6:57Well, first, remember that before
- 6:59effectively starting the three-phase
- 7:02system—first, second, third phase,
- 7:04which I will specify better later—the
- 7:07judge must define the applicable
- 7:09secondary provision. They must analyze
- 7:12the elements and decide which is the
- 7:14correct penal type. Is it theft or
- 7:18embezzlement? Is it embezzlement or is
- 7:22it fraud? Is it theft or is it robbery?
- 7:25So, they will analyze the evidence. The
- 7:27elements are demonstrated, and then
- 7:28they define the secondary provision.
- 7:31Still within the penal type itself,
- 7:32even after having defined the type
- 7:34itself, it is necessary to check if
- 7:35there are any qualifiers that may alter
- 7:37the secondary provision, right? Is it
- 7:40simple theft or qualified theft? What
- 7:44is the qualifier? Today there are so
- 7:45many qualifiers there in 155, right?
- 7:47All the time the legislator changes
- 7:48things there, changing the secondary
- 7:50provision for theft, changing the
- 7:51secondary provision for robbery, right?
- 7:53As happened recently in the Penal Code,
- 7:55the alteration of the secondary
- 7:56provision of 157 of the Penal Code. But
- 7:59anyway, once the secondary provision is
- 8:02defined, that is when the sentencing
- 8:04properly begins. In the first phase,
- 8:07right, the first stage, the beginning
- 8:10of the sentencing, the judge will apply
- 8:13the base sentence. To apply the base
- 8:19sentence, the magistrate will rely on
- 8:21the judicial circumstances, on the
- 8:24analysis of the judicial circumstances
- 8:26found in article 59 of the Penal Code.
- 8:30Let me just put it here, to share with
- 8:32you. So, base sentence, judicial
- 8:34circumstances, where are they? Article
- 8:3759 of the PC. Culpability, background,
- 8:41social conduct, personality, motives,
- 8:43circumstances, consequences of the
- 8:45crime, victim's behavior, right? There
- 8:48are eight judicial circumstances.
- 8:51Having made the analysis, the base
- 8:53penalty is set. Next step, the judge
- 8:57will calculate the intermediate penalty
- 9:00. And what does the intermediate
- 9:03penalty depend on? On the presence of
- 9:06any aggravating and mitigating factors.
- 9:09The judge will verify which aggravating
- 9:11and mitigating factors apply to the
- 9:13case. An obvious reminder. The list of
- 9:16aggravating factors is, evidently,
- 9:18exhaustive. Any attempt to expand it
- 9:21without express legal provision would
- 9:23constitute analogy in malam partem.
- 9:26Whereas the list of mitigating factors
- 9:27is illustrative. And to consider it
- 9:30illustrative, I do not need the
- 9:31doctrinal resource of analogy in bonam
- 9:33partem. I don't need it because it is
- 9:35written in the law. It is written in
- 9:37the law that the list is illustrative.
- 9:39The mitigating factors are in articles
- 9:4165 and 66 of the Penal Code. But the
- 9:44mitigating factors in 65 and 66, and
- 9:47Article 66, which doctrine calls an
- 9:49innominate mitigating factor, clearly
- 9:51state: "The judge may also mitigate the
- 9:53penalty due to any other relevant
- 9:55circumstance, prior or subsequent to
- 9:58the crime, even if not provided for in
- 10:00the previous article, even if not
- 10:02provided for in 65." It is expressed
- 10:04that the penalty can be mitigated for
- 10:06any relevant circumstance prior or
- 10:09subsequent to the crime, even if not
- 10:12provided for by law. And doctrine calls
- 10:14this an innominate mitigating factor,
- 10:16right? So, if the examiner mentions it
- 10:18on the test, Professor Ponte,
- 10:19innominate mitigating factor, you know
- 10:21it's from 66. Well, let's go. Returning
- 10:25to the aggravating factors, an
- 10:26exhaustive list, obviously it cannot be
- 10:28expanded. Now, two points that are no
- 10:31longer, right, given so many novelties
- 10:33that were included in the Penal Code
- 10:35recently. These have ceased to be
- 10:38novelties in themselves, but it is
- 10:40relevant to remember, right, the roster
- 10:43of aggravating factors, the list of
- 10:44aggravating factors, it hadn't been
- 10:46modified for many years. Until July
- 10:512025, a year ago, the legislator
- 10:56included a new aggravating factor which
- 10:59consists of committing the act, the
- 11:01crime, on the premises of an
- 11:03educational institution. Furthermore,
- 11:10another law from the same date amended
- 11:14article 65, item I, and also 115 of the
- 11:18Penal Code, in the same terms, which
- 11:21deal with relative minority, we use
- 11:25this term, and senile majority
- 11:30mitigating factors, limiting the
- 11:31application of these figures. What is
- 11:35relative minority? Being the agent
- 11:37under 21 years of age at the time of
- 11:39the act. What is senile majority? Being
- 11:42the agent over 70 years of age by the
- 11:44date of the sentencing. These are
- 11:47mitigating factors. And also there,
- 11:50those same factors in article 115 of
- 11:52the Penal Code, remember? They reduce
- 11:55the statute of limitations by half. If
- 11:57the examiner asks questions about the
- 11:59statute of limitations, pay attention
- 12:02to this detail. Mentioned the agent's
- 12:05age. Why is it important to talk about
- 12:07the agent's age in a question about
- 12:09prescription? It is likely because
- 12:12there will be either relative minority
- 12:14or advanced age, reducing the
- 12:15prescription period by half. But what
- 12:19was the novelty? A caveat, an exception
- 12:25, or a restriction on these mitigating
- 12:28factors and also on the reducers of the
- 12:32prescription period was included in the
- 12:35Penal Code. For every defendant under
- 12:3921 at the time of the act or over 70 at
- 12:41sentencing, the mitigating factor
- 12:43applies and the prescription period is
- 12:44cut in half. Except in what case?
- 12:48Except if the crime involves sexual
- 12:53violence against women, except if it
- 12:58involves sexual violence against women.
- 13:01So, be careful here with the "sexual"
- 13:03issue, to avoid traps, it is not just
- 13:05any violence against women. Period.
- 13:08Except if it involves sexual violence
- 13:10against women. So, the violence must be
- 13:12of this nature for the reducer not to
- 13:15apply, okay? Very well. And the third
- 13:20and final phase of sentencing, what is
- 13:22the third and final phase? After
- 13:24applying the aggravating and mitigating
- 13:27factors, it is to analyze the presence
- 13:29of potential increase and decrease
- 13:32causes, the so-called "majorantes"(
- 13:34increase causes) or "minorantes"(
- 13:36reduction causes). What do I want to
- 13:41remind you of here about "majorantes"
- 13:43and "minorantes"? Remember the
- 13:45following, look. A point that is
- 13:50already well settled by jurisprudence
- 13:53is as follows: how should the judge
- 13:57proceed if more than one increase cause
- 14:00is applicable to the same specific case
- 14:04? And the legislator understands, right
- 14:08, more than one penalty increase cause,
- 14:09especially when they are increase
- 14:11causes from the special part of the
- 14:12code. And today there are so many
- 14:14crimes that have several increase
- 14:15causes. It may be that in the same
- 14:16specific case, more than one applies,
- 14:17right? And then the STJ defined the
- 14:20following: the judge should opt for the
- 14:28largest increase cause, right? Among
- 14:32those applicable, if there is one that
- 14:36increases by 2/3 and the other by half,
- 14:38then apply the largest increase of 2/3
- 14:41and the other, he opted for one and the
- 14:43other. So, the judge opts for the
- 14:46largest increase cause among those
- 14:48applicable and uses the others, the
- 14:53other one, right, or the others, right,
- 14:57let's say uses the other one or the
- 15:02others as an aggravating factor,
- 15:08provided it fits, right, in the list of
- 15:10aggravating factors, provided it falls
- 15:12under one of them. Remember that the
- 15:16Rol is exhaustive, or if it doesn't
- 15:19fall under it, or as an unfavorable
- 15:22judicial circumstance. And what do you
- 15:27call this additional aggravating factor
- 15:30that won't be used in the third phase
- 15:32because the judge must apply only the
- 15:34greatest one, leaving the other one
- 15:36over? To keep it from being left over,
- 15:39the judge uses it in the second phase,
- 15:40if it fits among the aggravating
- 15:41factors, or in the first, if it doesn't
- 15:43fit there, as an unfavorable judicial
- 15:44circumstance. The name given to this
- 15:48aggravating factor that ends up
- 15:49entering the second or first phase of
- 15:51sentencing is aggravating, excuse me,
- 15:53it’s a majorant. The name of this
- 15:58enhancement cause, sorry, the name of
- 16:00this enhancement, this majorant—not
- 16:02aggravating, for heaven's sake—this
- 16:05majorant, this enhancement cause. It's
- 16:08a majorant. Remember the name? No.
- 16:11Majorant. What? "Leftover,""
- 16:16supernumerary," or "excess" are the
- 16:19terms the STJ uses. Majorant, excess,
- 16:24leftover. Well, final sentencing tips.
- 16:30Remember Súmula 231? A Súmula from
- 16:33the 1990s, but which was confirmed by
- 16:35the STJ, by the third section of the
- 16:37STJ, by a narrow majority in 2025, 2000
- 16:40, or late 2024 or 2025, but recently,
- 16:42which is Súmula 231. According to it,
- 16:46the application of a mitigating factor
- 16:48cannot lead to a sentence reduction
- 16:50below the legal minimum. Remember, then
- 16:53, in sentencing, in the first and
- 16:55second phases, the judge is limited by
- 16:57the abstract limits; they cannot apply
- 16:59the sentence in the first two phases
- 17:02either below the minimum or above the
- 17:04maximum. You can only apply a sentence
- 17:07below the legal minimum or above the
- 17:09maximum in the third phase. STJ Súmula
- 17:14545, a Súmula that the STJ
- 17:16reformulated last year, changing its
- 17:19wording. This one, 545 and 630, both
- 17:24deal with the defendant's confession as
- 17:27a mitigating factor. It is written in
- 17:30Article 65 that the defendant's
- 17:31spontaneous confession is a
- 17:33circumstance that mitigates the
- 17:34sentence. And there are several
- 17:36discussions about which criteria the
- 17:37judge should use to apply this
- 17:38confession as a mitigating factor. Does
- 17:40it always apply? Must there be remorse?
- 17:42Must it have helped in clarifying the
- 17:44facts? Because the confession doesn't
- 17:46always help clarify the facts. There is
- 17:48so much evidence that the confession
- 17:50doesn't change anything regarding the
- 17:51clarification of the facts. So, Súmula
- 17:54545. The author's confession makes
- 17:57sentence mitigation possible,
- 17:58regardless of whether it was used to
- 18:00form the judge's conviction. This
- 18:02Súmula used to say the opposite, right
- 18:03? "When used in the formation of the
- 18:05conviction." So, the STJ changed it
- 18:07completely: regardless of whether it
- 18:09was used to form the judge's conviction
- 18:11. If they confessed, you have to apply
- 18:13the mitigating factor. And Súmula 630
- 18:16regulates the criteria for applying the
- 18:18mitigating factor of spontaneous
- 18:21confession in drug trafficking cases,
- 18:23especially those where the subject
- 18:26confesses, admits possession or
- 18:28ownership of the drugs, but denies
- 18:30trafficking. It wasn't mine, but it was
- 18:33for personal use, not for sale. Then
- 18:36the judge convicts the subject for
- 18:37trafficking because they were not
- 18:38convinced by the purpose the defendant
- 18:39claimed in their confession. It wasn't
- 18:41for personal use. The evidence showed
- 18:42it really was trafficking. But what
- 18:44then? Did he confess that the drugs
- 18:47were his or that they were in his
- 18:48possession? Can we reduce the sentence?
- 18:50So, what does the STJ understand after
- 18:52having reformulated Súmula 630? The
- 18:56application of the mitigating factor of
- 18:57spontaneous confession in trafficking,
- 18:59when the accused admits possession or
- 19:01ownership but denies trafficking,
- 19:03should occur at a lower proportion than
- 19:05what would be due in the case of a full
- 19:07confession. In other words, the judge
- 19:09mitigates, not by much, but mitigates a
- 19:11little, right? What would this lower
- 19:14proportion be, right? As a rule, the
- 19:16STJ says that a mitigating factor must
- 19:17cause a reduction of 1/6. So, a
- 19:20reduction smaller than 1/6, right? A
- 19:22fraction smaller than 1/6. Confession
- 19:25and recidivism are also subjects
- 19:27already well settled by the STJ, right?
- 19:31Actually, I don't even need to add this
- 19:32parenthetical here because it's already
- 19:33in the text itself, right? STJ theme,
- 19:36theme 585, very common, the defendant
- 19:39is a recidivist, right? Remember
- 19:43recidivism? The chance of a little
- 19:44question popping up is also high. Take
- 19:45a read of articles 63 and 64 of the
- 19:47Penal Code. 63 and 64 of the Penal Code
- 19:51. Recidivist. The one who commits a new
- 19:55crime after a final conviction for a
- 19:57previous crime, committed in Brazil or
- 19:59abroad. 64. Convictions for political
- 20:02or specific military crimes do not
- 20:04generate recidivism. The defendant is a
- 20:07recidivist and confessed. What prevails
- 20:10? Is recidivism more important, as an
- 20:14aggravating factor, or is the
- 20:16confession more important than
- 20:18recidivism, outweighing it, so I
- 20:20mitigate? "Look, recidivism and
- 20:23confession, which is very common, one
- 20:25offsets the other, it's a wash." So,
- 20:28neither aggravate nor mitigate. One
- 20:32offsets the other, it's a wash, except
- 20:34in cases where multi-recidivism occurs.
- 20:38So, the defendant has several final
- 20:40convictions for previous crimes. He is
- 20:44a multi-recidivist, so it will
- 20:45aggravate, okay? Súmula 636 says that
- 20:49to prove recidivism, the evidence must
- 20:51be documentary, right? But what
- 20:53document? A criminal record sheet is
- 20:55sufficient. Súmula 74. How is a
- 20:59defendant's minority proven for
- 21:02criminal purposes? For example, whether
- 21:05it's minority that leads to
- 21:07non-imputability and the application of
- 21:09the ECA, or the minority relative to
- 21:12the under-21 age group we mentioned
- 21:14earlier, only through valid
- 21:16documentation, only through valid
- 21:18documentation, birth certificate, ID
- 21:21card, etc. Precedent 44, it deals with
- 21:25the judicial circumstance of criminal
- 21:28records. What can generate a negative
- 21:30criminal record: police inquiries and
- 21:32ongoing criminal cases that do not
- 21:34result in recidivism, but can lead to a
- 21:36negative record. They cannot. It is
- 21:38written right there in Precedent 444.
- 21:41Regarding the four precedents on the
- 21:43initial sentencing regime, it is worth
- 21:46reading these precedents, okay? 269,
- 21:48440 of the STJ, 718, 719 of the Supreme
- 21:51Court. Precedent 659, which is a more
- 21:56recent STJ precedent on continuous
- 21:57crime, look: the increase fraction due
- 21:59to continuous crime must be set
- 22:01according to the number of offenses.
- 22:04Why? Continuous crime, as a rule, is
- 22:08there in article 71, it generates a
- 22:10penalty increase of 1/6 to 2/3. So, the
- 22:15judge has a generous range to define
- 22:18which fraction to apply in cases of
- 22:20continuous offense; what criteria
- 22:22should they use? The criterion is the
- 22:26number of crimes. How many crimes did
- 22:29the agent commit in continuous offense?
- 22:31Two. Then, apply the minimum increase.
- 22:34Three, a minimum increase, which is 1/6
- 22:37, right? Three crimes, 1/5. Four crimes
- 22:40, 1/4. And so it goes up: 1/3, half,
- 22:43and 2/3 for seven or more criminal
- 22:45offenses. All right? The last precedent
- 22:50I have noted here. A crime or
- 22:52misdemeanor against a woman in a
- 22:53domestic environment committed with
- 22:55grave threat or violence does not allow
- 22:57for substitution by an alternative
- 22:59penalty. There is no alternative
- 23:02penalty for a crime or misdemeanor
- 23:04committed against a woman in a domestic
- 23:06environment. Precedent 588. And now we
- 23:09will conclude by talking about the
- 23:12extinction of punishability. Obviously,
- 23:14this is a whole world, isn't it? No,
- 23:17logically, in the course, right? For
- 23:20example, we talk about statute of
- 23:22limitations. I teach statute of
- 23:24limitations in practically 3 hours of
- 23:27class, right? To be able to cover all
- 23:29the points, all the relevant points for
- 23:31the exam. So, of course, we are talking
- 23:34about a whole world here, but within
- 23:35our scope, final tips, obviously, right
- 23:37? I am speaking to people who are
- 23:40already preparing for the test and who
- 23:42here are looking to remember, right,
- 23:43those final tips that will not exhaust
- 23:45you on Saturday. Today is not a day to
- 23:48exhaust yourself, is it? Just this.
- 23:51That's it. After that, you rest. I hope
- 23:54you are watching this early in the
- 23:55morning, right? Because the team will
- 23:57release this very early in the morning
- 23:59for you all on the channel. So I hope
- 24:01you watch this in the morning so you
- 24:03have time to rest and do well on the
- 24:04exam Sunday afternoon. But let's go.
- 24:07Extinction of punishability, right?
- 24:09Extinctive causes. There is a list of
- 24:13extinctive causes in Article 107 of the
- 24:15Penal Code. This subject of extinction
- 24:17of punishability goes from 107 to 120
- 24:19of the Penal Code. And the code starts
- 24:21with a list in 107 that is not
- 24:23exhaustive, or rather, it is not
- 24:25taxative, right? Extinctive causes of
- 24:27punishability can only exist through
- 24:29express legal provision. Nevertheless,
- 24:32the list you see there in 107, death of
- 24:35the agent, amnesty, pardon, grace, a
- 24:38new law that decriminalizes conduct,
- 24:41which is abolitio criminis, eh
- 24:43renunciation, decadence, peremption,
- 24:46accepted pardon, etc., prescription is
- 24:49not an exhaustive list. There are
- 24:52others beyond those in the list, for
- 24:55example, eh, the reparation of damages
- 24:58in material crimes against the tax
- 25:01system. If the agent pays the tax and
- 25:03accessories, this extinguishes the
- 25:04punishability in material crimes
- 25:06against the tax order. Another thing
- 25:09that is important to remember is that
- 25:12there was a recent change in the Penal
- 25:15Code there in the article, a law that
- 25:17changed the same rule of the Penal Code
- 25:20, the CCP, and the JECRIM law that
- 25:22deals with the deadline for
- 25:24representation, filing of
- 25:26representation, or complaint. What is
- 25:32this alteration, eh, what is the
- 25:34content of this alteration? I will put
- 25:36it here for you. The Penal Code, the
- 25:40text of the Penal Code, how it was
- 25:41changed. Remember what the rule is
- 25:44regarding the deadline for the victim
- 25:46to offer the representation or file the
- 25:48complaint? It is a 6-month period
- 25:51counted from the knowledge of the
- 25:53criminal authorship, isn't it? Classic,
- 25:57right? 6 months counted from the
- 25:59knowledge of the criminal authorship.
- 26:01Well then, look now at what the Penal
- 26:04Code says after this modification. Let
- 26:08me find here for you where we are.
- 26:11Where is the change? Change that
- 26:20altered the Penal Code. Code of
- 26:23Criminal Procedure. Let me go here to
- 26:25the CPP to article 39. Where is it?
- 26:29Where is it? Where is it? I'm
- 26:48struggling here to find it, huh? Anyway
- 26:58, it's the change, you must know what
- 27:00I'm referring to, right? That, in cases
- 27:02involving domestic or family violence
- 27:05against women...Ah, I found it here, I
- 27:07found the rascal: 38, paragraph second
- 27:09of the Code of Criminal Procedure. Here
- 27:12, look, in crimes committed in the
- 27:16scope of domestic or family violence
- 27:19against women, the victim shall lose
- 27:21the right to a complaint or
- 27:23representation within a period of 12
- 27:25months and not 6 months, as is the rule
- 27:28of 38 caput. Of course, this rule does
- 27:31not have retroactive efficacy. That is
- 27:33a novatio legis in pejus, right? It is
- 27:36not retroactive; it only applies to
- 27:39facts occurring after Law 14.1538 of
- 27:422026 came into effect. This law went
- 27:46into effect on June 19, 2026, when it
- 27:49was published in the Official Gazette.
- 27:52So, do you remember this issue? This is
- 27:54a very recent change and, logically, it
- 27:55can be asked on exams. "Professor, can
- 27:57they ask about a change from June 2026
- 27:59if the notice has already been
- 28:01published?" Yes, because it amended the
- 28:03Criminal Procedure Code, which is on
- 28:04the syllabus, so it can be tested like
- 28:06that. Back to it, STJ Precedent 631,
- 28:12pardon. A pardon only extinguishes the
- 28:15primary effect of the conviction; it
- 28:17does not extinguish secondary, penal,
- 28:19or extra-penal effects. This precedent
- 28:21clarifies the light shed on the concept
- 28:24of a pardon, right? Which is that cause
- 28:27for the extinction of punishability
- 28:28that arises from a decree by the
- 28:29President of the Republic. A general
- 28:32rule, a general criterion regarding the
- 28:34extinction of punishability: what are
- 28:37the consequences that a cause for the
- 28:39extinction of punishability produces?
- 28:41And the answer is: it depends. If the
- 28:44extinction of punishability occurred
- 28:46before the final unappealable judgment,
- 28:48it prevents everything. There is no,
- 28:51there will be no penal or extra-penal
- 28:53effect of the conviction, neither
- 28:55primary nor secondary. Now, as in the
- 28:58case of a pardon, which is after the
- 29:00final judgment, if the extinction of
- 29:02punishability occurs after the final
- 29:03judgment, the rule—and the pardon
- 29:05falls under this rule—is that it only
- 29:07extinguishes the primary penal effect,
- 29:09which is the imposition of the sentence
- 29:11, but the defendant will not cease to
- 29:12be a recidivist, which is a secondary
- 29:14penal effect. The criminal conviction
- 29:17remains valid as an executive title in
- 29:19civil court, in the civil sphere, which
- 29:21is an extra-penal effect, and so on. It
- 29:24only kills the primary penal effect.
- 29:26Very well. Prescription, which is a
- 29:29delicate topic; you cannot forget,
- 29:31obviously, about non-prescriptible
- 29:32crimes, right? Non-prescriptibility is
- 29:35provided for in the Constitution,
- 29:38expressly in Article 5, clauses 42 and
- 29:4044. Racism is non-prescriptible, clause
- 29:4442, as is the action of armed groups,
- 29:47whether civil or military, against the
- 29:49constitutional order or the democratic
- 29:52regime. Clause 44. What are, within the
- 29:57Brazilian legal system, under Brazilian
- 29:59laws, the penal types, the crimes that
- 30:01fall under this idea of
- 30:03non-prescriptibility, that fit into the
- 30:05concept of racism and therefore do not
- 30:07prescribe, that fit into the concept of
- 30:09the action of armed groups, civil or
- 30:11military, against the constitutional
- 30:13order or democratic regime? So, let's
- 30:15go. Racism. First, the crimes under Law
- 30:207716 of '89, where racial injury was
- 30:25included. Racial injury is within Law
- 30:287716. Homophobia and transphobia, by
- 30:31force of the Supreme Court's decision
- 30:33in ADO 26, which was judged together
- 30:35with the writ of injunction as well,
- 30:37right? Because the Supreme Court
- 30:39equated homophobia and transphobia to
- 30:41racism and, therefore, subsumed them
- 30:43under Law 7716. And the conduct of
- 30:45discriminating against those carrying
- 30:46the HIV virus, which is in Law 12984,
- 30:51action by armed groups, civil or
- 30:52military, against the constitutional
- 30:54order, democratic regime, you can frame
- 30:56it under crimes against the Democratic
- 30:58Rule of Law that are in the part, in
- 30:59Title 12 of the Special Part. Now, it's
- 31:02not enough to be, right, as if that
- 31:04were little, but anyway, it's not
- 31:05enough to be a crime against the
- 31:07democratic rule of law, it must be
- 31:09practiced by a group, action of groups,
- 31:11and armed groups. Okay? What is good to
- 31:16remember to finish here the question of
- 31:18the extinction of punishability, since
- 31:20we are already running out of time once
- 31:22again. First, like, questions about
- 31:26initial terms and interruptive causes
- 31:28are the most common things there are.
- 31:32So, remember, remember the following, a
- 31:34premise here, right? There are two
- 31:37forms of prescription, two types of
- 31:38prescription, right? The prescription
- 31:41of the punitive claim, which occurs
- 31:43before the final judgment, and the
- 31:44prescription of the executive claim,
- 31:46which occurs after the final judgment.
- 31:48This is the first point. Second point,
- 31:51it is very common to have questions
- 31:53about the initial terms of prescription
- 31:56. Article 111 details several initial
- 32:01terms: the consummation, the last
- 32:03executive act in attempted crimes, the
- 32:06cessation of permanence in permanent
- 32:09crimes, and others. There in 117, in
- 32:14items one through four, the legislator
- 32:17includes the interruptive causes. There
- 32:20is a detail, one of the interruptive
- 32:21causes is there, right? Receipt of the
- 32:24complaint or accusation, indictment,
- 32:26appellate decision confirming the
- 32:28indictment, and the sentence or
- 32:30appellate decision that is appealable.
- 32:34About this issue, sentence or appellate
- 32:36conviction. If the defendant is
- 32:38convicted in the first degree, it
- 32:40interrupts the prescription. If he is
- 32:42acquitted in the first degree, there is
- 32:44no interruption, because the acquittal
- 32:45sentence is not an interruptive cause.
- 32:47But if he is acquitted in the first
- 32:48degree, the Public Prosecutor's Office
- 32:49appeals, and the court convicts. This
- 32:51is an appellate conviction. This
- 32:52appellate decision will interrupt. Easy
- 32:53. Now, what about the appellate
- 32:57decision that confirms the conviction?
- 32:59So, the defendant was convicted in the
- 33:01first instance, it interrupted. The
- 33:03defense appeals, but the court confirms
- 33:05, maintains the conviction. Does this
- 33:07confirming appellate decision also
- 33:08interrupt? Yes, according to the
- 33:10understanding fixed by the plenary of
- 33:12the Supreme Court in HC 176473. So, not
- 33:16only the convicting appellate decision,
- 33:18but the appellate decision that
- 33:20confirms the conviction is also an
- 33:21interruptive cause. Still, PPE,
- 33:26prescription of the executive claim, it
- 33:28has its own initial terms and its own
- 33:30interruptive causes. So, read sections
- 33:35112, 117, subsections 5 and 6. These
- 33:38are the specific causes for
- 33:39interrupting the PPE. In 112, remember
- 33:41there is a little rule there? The
- 33:43initial term is the final judgment for
- 33:46the prosecution. Jurisprudence has
- 33:49defined that, in fact, where it reads
- 33:51final judgment for the prosecution, it
- 33:53should be understood as final judgment
- 33:54for both parties. And this was an
- 33:58understanding set by the Supreme
- 34:00Federal Court, which modulated the
- 34:02effects of this decision and
- 34:04established that it has no retroactive
- 34:06application; it does not apply to cases
- 34:09prior to the ruling, but from that
- 34:11ruling, so back in 2020, here in 2026,
- 34:13one can already answer with confidence:
- 34:15the cause, the initial term for PPE is
- 34:18not the final judgment for the
- 34:20prosecution, because sometimes the
- 34:22prosecution did not appeal, but there
- 34:25is an appeal by the defense. So, it
- 34:27becomes final for the prosecution, but
- 34:28not for the defense. It is not the
- 34:30final judgment for both parties. Mainly
- 34:32because it is only with a final
- 34:33judgment for both parties that the
- 34:35sentence can be executed. So, it is
- 34:37only from the moment the sentence can
- 34:39be executed that the limitation period
- 34:41for the executive claim begins to run.
- 34:43Finally, I ask, does recidivism
- 34:45interfere with the calculation of the
- 34:47statute of limitations? Answer: it
- 34:50depends. Recidivism does not interfere
- 34:53with the calculation of the PPP. No, it
- 34:56does not. It is in STJ Precedent 220,
- 34:58but it does interfere with the
- 35:00calculation of the PPE in two ways. If
- 35:03the defendant was already a recidivist
- 35:05at the time of conviction, it increases
- 35:07the term by 1/3. Or even if, after the
- 35:11conviction becomes final, the defendant
- 35:13is a fugitive and, while a fugitive,
- 35:15commits a new crime, becoming a
- 35:16recidivist for the first time or again,
- 35:18whatever, this becoming a recidivist,
- 35:20this committing of a new crime,
- 35:22interrupts the statute of limitations.
- 35:25So, recidivism for PPE can function, if
- 35:28it is that prior recidivism, as a cause
- 35:30for increasing the limitation period,
- 35:33increasing the limitation term by 1/3,
- 35:35or subsequent future recidivism, if one
- 35:38is a fugitive and commits a new crime,
- 35:41it functions as a cause for
- 35:42interrupting the statute of limitations
- 35:45. So, remember that, okay? Recidivism
- 35:48interferes with PPE, but it does not
- 35:51interfere with PPP, alright? In the
- 35:54punishment of the custodial sentence,
- 35:56not for alternative sentences, it must
- 35:58be said, to conclude our presentation.
- 36:02Well, I tried, like the other
- 36:04professors here in our review week, a
- 36:07week that extended much more than 7
- 36:09days, I tried to bring everything that
- 36:12I found relevant for your final review.
- 36:16I truly hope you have the best possible
- 36:18exam this Sunday, that you make it to
- 36:21the written stage, that you manage to
- 36:23overcome this hurdle, and that we can
- 36:26continue together until you pass the
- 36:28São Paulo Public Prosecutor's Office
- 36:31exam so we can be colleagues there,
- 36:33right? God willing, a big hug. Good
- 36:37luck, stay positive.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Direito Penal Geral (Prof. Estefam) - Aula 2 by Cursos Foco Total | MP e Magistratura, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 5,375 words across 872 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.