Direito Penal Geral (Prof. Estefam) - Aula 1 — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Hello, my friends. Let's begin our
- 0:03review of criminal law, general part. I
- 0:06have prepared many topics and written
- 0:08material that will be made available to
- 0:10you, summarizing all of this. But I
- 0:13first want to point out that if I
- 0:15notice—and it is quite likely that
- 0:17this will happen—that my presentation
- 0:19will last more than 30 minutes, we will
- 0:21take a break to give you the chance to
- 0:23have two blocks, as if they were two
- 0:25classes. I think it becomes better and
- 0:29more productive. Also, I want to
- 0:31emphasize that the day before the exam
- 0:34is not a day to exhaust yourself
- 0:37mentally. So, just stick to these
- 0:39classes and get some rest. You have
- 0:42already done everything; if you have
- 0:44been following the weekly review, now
- 0:47is the time to prepare so that on the
- 0:4926th, on Sunday, you do your best. And
- 0:52God willing, you will do your best. You
- 0:55will continue studying and preparing
- 0:58for the next phases. The written phase
- 1:01is extremely challenging, isn't it? The
- 1:03written phase will take place on
- 1:05September 13th. God willing, you will
- 1:08have this problem to face and manage,
- 1:11which is preparation in seven weeks,
- 1:13the interval between July 26th and
- 1:16September 13th. But in these weeks, if
- 1:20you study in a focused, specific way
- 1:23with proper material, there is no doubt
- 1:25you will succeed in what is the true
- 1:27barrier in the São Paulo Public
- 1:29Prosecutor's Office exam: the written
- 1:32test. A good written test not only gets
- 1:35you to the oral exam but also enables
- 1:37your final approval in the competition.
- 1:40A good written exam is certainly the
- 1:42best business card a candidate can have
- 1:44when reaching the oral phase, because
- 1:46the examiner has the written test in
- 1:48hand, and then has the opportunity to
- 1:50identify: well, whoever wrote well,
- 1:51answered those questions correctly,
- 1:53handled that dissertation, and properly
- 1:55prepared that piece, demonstrating the
- 1:57typical language of the Public
- 1:59Prosecutor's Office, particularly in
- 2:01São Paulo, will certainly deserve a
- 2:03positive look from the examiners. God
- 2:05willing, this will happen to you. But
- 2:07now let's talk about our topic,
- 2:10Criminal Law, general part. Obviously,
- 2:13we have to make some selections here,
- 2:15and within those selections, I want to
- 2:18refer to the points we chose for this
- 2:20presentation. And the first one is the
- 2:22application of criminal law. So, let's
- 2:24go. The application of criminal law is
- 2:28the subject of articles 1 through 12 of
- 2:30the Penal Code. It is almost certain
- 2:35that at least one question on this
- 2:38topic will be asked. So let's get
- 2:42started. Article one of the Penal Code
- 2:45is very famous; it’s hard to imagine
- 2:47a specific question about it, because
- 2:49it would be, I think, too trivial.
- 2:51It’s possible the examiner, Dr. Ponte
- 2:53, could come up with a sophisticated
- 2:55question about it, but in principle, it
- 2:57deals with penal legality. There is no
- 2:59crime without a prior law defining it,
- 3:00nor a penalty without prior legal
- 3:02sanction. Article one of the Penal Code
- 3:04reproduces, in other words and with
- 3:06slightly different wording, what is
- 3:08stated in Article 5, item 39 of the
- 3:09Constitution. We are talking here about
- 3:12an entrenched clause. You see the same
- 3:14thing in Article 2 of the Penal Code,
- 3:16which is a detail of another principle
- 3:19in the Constitution, Article 5, item 40
- 3:21: the principle of retroactive benefit
- 3:23of penal law. Penal law shall not be
- 3:27retroactive, except to benefit the
- 3:29defendant. So, this is an introduction,
- 3:31these first two articles, legality and
- 3:34retroactive benefit. Well then, within
- 3:39the idea of retroactive benefit,
- 3:41Article 5, item 40 of the Constitution
- 3:45and Article 2 of the Penal Code, that
- 3:48is where we extract the criteria to
- 3:50resolve any conflict of penal laws over
- 3:54time. And given the profusion of new
- 3:58penal laws, it has been like this in
- 4:002025, and in 2026, let alone how many
- 4:02changes have already occurred in our
- 4:04Penal Code. When we talk about
- 4:07conflicts of penal laws over time, we
- 4:09must first start from two premises. For
- 4:13a new penal law to come into force and
- 4:16for a conflict of penal laws over time
- 4:19to arise, it is necessary for it to
- 4:21take effect. It may be in relation to
- 4:26its predecessor, which it repeals in
- 4:28whole or in part, either explicitly or
- 4:31in relation to whether it is more
- 4:33severe or beneficial to the agent. A
- 4:38more severe penal law, or*lex gravior*
- 4:40in Latin, will never be retroactive. It
- 4:44will only apply to facts occurring from
- 4:46the day it comes into force, whereas a
- 4:49beneficial law, or*lex mitior*, always
- 4:51has retroactive effect, even reaching
- 4:54matters of*res judicata*. I will place
- 4:57it here for you, so you can follow
- 4:59along with the material the
- 5:00corresponding excerpt. See? You see?
- 5:03Wait a second. Where is it? Conflict of
- 5:05penal laws over time. So, the new penal
- 5:10law has come into force; it can be
- 5:12beneficial, *lex mitior*, right? Or
- 5:16severe, *lex gravior*. The*lex mitior*,
- 5:23the beneficial penal law that has
- 5:24retroactive effect, acts retroactively,
- 5:26even reaching*res judicata*. It can
- 5:29occur in two ways, meaning there are
- 5:31essentially two types of beneficial law
- 5:33. *Abolitio criminis*, the new law that
- 5:35decriminalizes conduct; the act becomes
- 5:37penally atypical. And the*novatio legis
- 5:41*, which maintains the criminalization
- 5:44but grants some benefit, for example,
- 5:47reduces the sentence, authorizes parole
- 5:50in a shorter interval, increases, uh,
- 5:57the scope, the application of legal
- 5:59benefits. So, benefits that applied to
- 6:01few crimes now apply to many offenses.
- 6:05So this, in general, is what a*lex
- 6:08mitior*is, specifically a*novatio legis
- 6:11in mellius*. And a*lex gravior*can be
- 6:14—it never retroacts, it only applies
- 6:17to facts occurring from the day it
- 6:19enters into force. Or a*novatio legis
- 6:23incriminadora*, a new law that
- 6:25criminalizes conduct, or a new one that
- 6:28maintains criminalization, does not
- 6:30change what was a crime, but makes the
- 6:33penal consequences more severe,
- 6:35reducing the agent's sphere of liberty
- 6:37by increasing the sentence. Uh, is it
- 6:43not, making the sentence more severe,
- 6:45increasing the statutes of limitation,
- 6:47therefore, giving the State more time
- 6:49to exercise its right to punish. So,
- 6:53this would fit within this perspective
- 6:56of*novatio legis in pejus*. Do not
- 7:00confuse the conflict of penal laws in
- 7:04time with an apparent conflict of penal
- 7:09norms. There is a basic difference
- 7:13between them. Do you remember the
- 7:15apparent conflict of norms? It is the
- 7:17conflict resolved by the principles of
- 7:19specialty, subsidiarity, consumption,
- 7:21and alternativity. Oh, I will list them
- 7:24here, look. Remember the principles of
- 7:29specialty, subsidiarity, the principle
- 7:37of consumption and alternativity. What
- 7:43is the basic difference? So, let's
- 7:44revisit this point between the conflict
- 7:47of penal laws in time and the apparent
- 7:49conflict of norms. In the conflict of
- 7:53penal laws in time, there is a penal
- 7:55law in force that is succeeded by
- 7:57another that revokes it in whole or in
- 7:59part. In the apparent conflict of norms
- 8:04, two penal laws are in force at the
- 8:06same time. Both are fully in effect.
- 8:12One did not interfere with the other,
- 8:13it did not revoke the other. Both are
- 8:16in force at the same time and
- 8:18apparently apply to the same fact, and
- 8:21it is up to the interpreter to verify
- 8:24which of these—since they are all
- 8:26apparently in force at the same time—
- 8:29apply to the same fact. The interpreter
- 8:33must define which one should prevail,
- 8:35because we know: a single fact cannot
- 8:37be subsumed under two or more penal
- 8:39laws, because that would configure two
- 8:41or more penal types, particularly
- 8:43because that would configure*bis in
- 8:45idem*. Very well. The Public
- 8:50Prosecutor's Office of São Paulo in
- 8:52the first phase has several questions
- 8:53about which principles solve the
- 8:55apparent conflict of norms, right? So
- 8:57be careful not to confuse the topic of
- 8:59the conflict of penal laws in time,
- 9:02which includes*abolitio criminis*, *in
- 9:04mellius*, and*incriminadora in pejus*,
- 9:06with the apparent conflict of norms.
- 9:09One final detail, one last tip I wanted
- 9:11to remind you of is this. Regarding the
- 9:13topic of beneficial penal law, Lex
- 9:15Mitior, remember Supreme Court Súmula
- 9:2161: beneficial penal law applies
- 9:24retroactively, even reaching res
- 9:27judicata. Then a question arose. Years
- 9:30ago, the Supreme Court issued this
- 9:31Súmula. The doubt was, if there is
- 9:34already a final judgment and the case
- 9:36is in the sentence execution phase,
- 9:39which court is competent to apply the
- 9:41beneficial penal law? And the Supreme
- 9:44Court ruled: the criminal execution
- 9:46court itself. There is no need to file
- 9:48an action for annulment or anything
- 9:49like that. The execution court itself
- 9:50has the competence for it. And
- 9:54regarding the topic of harsher penal
- 9:57law, remember Supreme Court Súmula 711
- 10:00, which also covers a unique, relevant
- 10:03issue often tested: when there is a
- 10:06permanent crime—one whose
- 10:09consummation extends over time—or a
- 10:12continued crime, which is a form of
- 10:15concurrence of crimes (two or more
- 10:18crimes in continuous criminal activity)
- 10:21, and a new, harsher law arises during
- 10:25that duration, it applies to that fact.
- 10:29Imagine a permanent crime, let's take
- 10:31as an example kidnapping for extortion
- 10:34or drug trafficking in the form of "
- 10:37keeping in storage." So, kidnapping for
- 10:40extortion. While the victim is held
- 10:43under the agent's custody, let's use
- 10:46that term, right? Incarcerated,
- 10:49kidnapped, with their freedom of
- 10:52movement and ambulation deprived for
- 10:55days, weeks, perhaps even months, the
- 10:59consummation phase is extending over
- 11:02time. Drug trafficking. While the agent
- 11:06keeps the drugs stored for subsequent
- 11:08resale or sale, well, the fact is, it's
- 11:11drug trafficking, a conduct of a
- 11:13permanent nature, and they can keep
- 11:16these drugs for a long time. Suppose
- 11:20that during this interval, with the
- 11:22victim kidnapped or the drugs stored
- 11:23for later sale, a new law arises that
- 11:25increases the penalty for kidnapping
- 11:27for extortion or drug trafficking. Does
- 11:30it apply to this case? Yes. The Supreme
- 11:33Court codified this in Súmula 711.
- 11:36Important. So, if a new, harsher penal
- 11:39law arises during the duration of a
- 11:42permanent or continued crime, it
- 11:44applies to that permanent or continued
- 11:47crime, according to our Supreme Court,
- 11:50okay? So, remember that. Final tip on
- 11:54the application of penal law. Articles
- 12:004 and 6. This is mandatory. Article 4
- 12:05of the Penal Code deals with the time
- 12:08of the crime, and Article 6 with the
- 12:10place of the crime. So, let's put
- 12:13things in their proper place here.
- 12:17Article 4, time of the crime. The crime
- 12:22, says the Penal Code, is considered
- 12:24committed at the time of the conduct,
- 12:27of the action or omission, even if the
- 12:29result occurs at a different time.
- 12:34Therefore, if the agent carries out the
- 12:36conduct on one date, but the result or
- 12:39consummation only occurs on another,
- 12:41the time of the crime is determined
- 12:43based on the date of the conduct, the
- 12:45action or omission. So, if an agent,
- 12:49intending to kill someone, fires shots
- 12:52and hits the victim, but she is
- 12:54hospitalized and passes away months
- 12:57later, consummating the crime, when was
- 12:59that homicide committed? Back on the
- 13:03day of the conduct, the day of the
- 13:04shots, and not months later when the
- 13:06victim died, succumbing to her injuries
- 13:08. Professor, but what does that change?
- 13:11Oh, I know, it changes the statute of
- 13:13limitations calculation. No, no, no, no
- 13:15, no, no, no, no, no, no, that's not it
- 13:17. I'll tell you about the statute of
- 13:18limitations in a moment. This Article 4
- 13:21is decisive, for example, in defining
- 13:23the issue of criminal majority. If the
- 13:26subject was 17 years old when he fired
- 13:28the shots, even if he was 18 when the
- 13:30victim died in the hospital, the Penal
- 13:31Code does not apply, but the ECA (
- 13:33Statute of the Child and Adolescent)
- 13:34does, because he was 17. The moment of
- 13:36the conduct is what counts. Now,
- 13:39suppose he is already over 18, but he
- 13:41fires the shots, and the victim is
- 13:43hospitalized. And during the period the
- 13:46victim is hospitalized, a new law is
- 13:48passed increasing the penalty for
- 13:50homicide. Does it apply to this case?
- 13:54No, because it is a harsher penal law.
- 13:55A harsher penal law does not retroact,
- 13:57and for all purposes, the date of the
- 13:59event is considered the date of the
- 14:01conduct, the date of the shots.
- 14:03Therefore, since the law came later, it
- 14:05is a subsequent, harsher law, and it
- 14:07has no retroactive effect. So you see
- 14:10the importance of this Article 4 and
- 14:12the statute of limitations. Regarding
- 14:14the statute of limitations, there is a
- 14:15specific rule in the Penal Code.
- 14:18Regarding the initial term of the
- 14:20statute of limitations, the start of
- 14:22the counting of the limitation period,
- 14:24Article 111 of the code applies, which
- 14:26says that the statute of limitations is
- 14:29counted from the date of consummation.
- 14:31That is the rule in Article 111. So,
- 14:35this homicide was committed at the
- 14:37moment of the conduct, but the
- 14:38limitation period only begins to flow
- 14:40upon the death of the victim, because
- 14:42it is with the consummation that the
- 14:44counting of the limitation period
- 14:46begins, okay? Do not forget that. Now
- 14:50regarding the place of the crime,
- 14:51Article 4, time of the crime is done.
- 14:53Now Article 6, place of the crime.
- 14:57There is a lot of confusion here too.
- 14:58The examiner knows it and likes to set
- 15:00traps. Regarding the place of the crime
- 15:06, Article 6 of the Penal Code, the code
- 15:08adopted the mixed or ubiquity theory,
- 15:11because it says that the crime is
- 15:14considered committed both at the place
- 15:17of the conduct and the place of the
- 15:19result. Many people get confused
- 15:25because they think that, oh, regarding
- 15:28the place of the crime, the result
- 15:30theory was adopted, because then they
- 15:32confuse the place of the crime of
- 15:34Article 6 of the Penal Code with the
- 15:36territorial jurisdiction rule of the
- 15:38CPP. The CPP, there in Article 70, says
- 15:42that the competent forum is the place
- 15:44where the result occurred. But the
- 15:48Penal Code, when dealing with the place
- 15:50of the crime, is not concerned with
- 15:51defining a competent forum. That is not
- 15:54what Article 6 is for, get that in your
- 15:56mind. Article 6 was created, drafted,
- 15:59and included in the Penal Code to make
- 16:02things clear regarding crimes at a
- 16:04distance. So you have to link this
- 16:06Article 6 to this concept, crimes at a
- 16:08distance, those that reach the
- 16:10territory of two or more countries.
- 16:12That is what a crime at a distance is.
- 16:14And the crime starts in Brazil, the
- 16:15result is abroad. Or the opposite, the
- 16:17crime starts abroad and the result is
- 16:18here. So it was to define, regarding
- 16:22crimes at a distance, when Brazilian
- 16:26law applies. If the conduct started in
- 16:29Brazil, and the result occurred abroad,
- 16:31does Brazilian law apply? Yes. And if
- 16:36it is the opposite, the conduct started
- 16:37abroad, but the result occurred in
- 16:39Brazil, Brazilian law will also apply.
- 16:42Why? Because the mixed or ubiquity
- 16:44theory was adopted by the Penal Code.
- 16:47It doesn't matter if the conduct
- 16:48occurred here or if the result occurred
- 16:50here. In both cases, Brazilian criminal
- 16:53law will apply. So, remember the
- 16:56mnemonic? I'll share it with you here.
- 17:01Luta (Fight). Lugar (Place). This is to
- 17:05remember the theories, right? Place,
- 17:07ubiquity. Time, activity. Place of the
- 17:13crime, ubiquity theory. Lu, time of the
- 17:16crime, activity theory. Luta, place,
- 17:20ubiquity. Time, activity. Very well.
- 17:26Let's talk a little about the theory of
- 17:27crime, shall we? I think it is unlikely
- 17:30, although not impossible, that the
- 17:32São Paulo Public Prosecutor's Office
- 17:34will formulate questions of a more
- 17:36dogmatic nature. It is true that
- 17:40Professor Ponte is a deep connoisseur
- 17:43of criminal dogma, but in a preliminary
- 17:47exam, caution is recommended to avoid
- 17:50questions with too much dogmatic weight
- 17:54or basis. Why? Because when you speak
- 17:57of dogma, doctrine, there is always
- 17:59more than one school of thought. And
- 18:02you know that objective tests, like the
- 18:04preliminary exam for the São Paulo
- 18:06Public Prosecutor's Office, cannot be
- 18:08based on issues where there is
- 18:10doctrinal disagreement. So we think
- 18:13there is a trend, and at least the São
- 18:15Paulo Public Prosecutor's Office has
- 18:17been like this in recent years, of
- 18:19avoiding this type of bias. Now, there
- 18:23are some issues related to the theory
- 18:26of crime that are inevitable to be
- 18:28asked, that have a great chance of
- 18:30being asked, such as the principle of
- 18:32insignificance, which is already deeply
- 18:35rooted in our jurisprudence, isn't it?
- 18:39It started doctrinally here in Brazil
- 18:42quite timidly, back in the late 80s,
- 18:44early 90s, more fruitfully, and then it
- 18:47ended up being incorporated by the
- 18:49jurisprudence of the Supreme Federal
- 18:52Court. So yes, the principle of
- 18:54insignificance is applied.
- 18:56Insignificance, once recognized, leads
- 18:59to the lack of material typicality of
- 19:03the conduct. The act is formally
- 19:06typical, it fits the wording of the law
- 19:08, but it is materially atypical because
- 19:09the harm produced to the legal asset is
- 19:11so insignificant that the criminal
- 19:13relevance of the act is not justified.
- 19:17That is the consequence of the
- 19:18principle of insignificance, the
- 19:19material atypicality of the conduct,
- 19:21isn't it? Of course, I am talking about
- 19:23insignificance, not that story of
- 19:25improper trifles, which is a
- 19:26construction by part of the Brazilian
- 19:28doctrine based on Claus Roxin's
- 19:30functionalist conception. I think it is
- 19:33not an appropriate topic for the
- 19:34preliminary phase for the reasons I
- 19:36have already explained, but
- 19:37insignificance, or proper trifle, if
- 19:39you prefer, leads to the atypicality of
- 19:41the conduct, the material atypicality
- 19:42of the conduct. This is certain, this
- 19:44is unequivocal. Also, remember the
- 19:46vectors that the Supreme Federal Court
- 19:49has built throughout its jurisprudence.
- 19:53Four vectors that must be examined when
- 19:55the judge weighs and analyzes whether
- 19:58or not to apply the principle of
- 20:00insignificance. There is a little trick
- 20:03, which we created quite simply to help
- 20:05you remember, which is the acronym
- 20:07PR-O-L, right? These vectors of
- 20:10insignificance, according to the
- 20:12Supreme Federal Court, are also applied
- 20:15by the STJ and serve to weigh things,
- 20:17even to prevent the application of this
- 20:19principle from being trivialized. And
- 20:22what does PROL mean? The P is for
- 20:25perilousness, the R is for
- 20:28reproachability, the O is for
- 20:31offensiveness, and the L is for lesion
- 20:36or harm. The Supreme Court requires the
- 20:43absence of perilousness in the conduct
- 20:45of the act. The act cannot be
- 20:47characterized by perilousness. Reduced
- 20:50reproachability of the conduct, minimal
- 20:56offensiveness, and negligible harm or
- 21:03legal injury, right, or in a crime of
- 21:05danger, caused danger, right, not
- 21:07caused legal injury. But look here at
- 21:11the vectors, duly highlighted. P O,
- 21:17absence of danger, reduced
- 21:19reprovability, minimal offensiveness,
- 21:21and the negligible harm of the conduct.
- 21:26STJ precedents. These are the STJ ones
- 21:30regarding insignificance, right? Don't
- 21:31forget them. So the material will be at
- 21:35your disposal here, don't worry, you'll
- 21:37have access to it, okay? Therefore,
- 21:40nothing for you to worry about for now.
- 21:42Well, have a quick look at these
- 21:44precedents, we will make them available
- 21:46to you here. In the video description
- 21:50itself, the team will find a way—I
- 21:52technologically confess I don't know
- 21:54how—but they will find a way for you
- 21:57to access this material. Well, let's go
- 22:00. Talking about iter criminis, which is
- 22:02also another almost mandatory subject
- 22:04within the universe of the general part
- 22:06, right? We know very well that the
- 22:08iter criminis, the path of the crime,
- 22:11the itinerary of the crime, is composed
- 22:13of phases. There are four, do you
- 22:15remember them? Cogitation, preparation,
- 22:20execution, consummation. Exhaustion is
- 22:24not a phase of the iter criminis. The
- 22:26phases are cogitation, preparation,
- 22:29execution, and consummation. There are
- 22:32several important topics within this
- 22:35subject, but perhaps one of the most
- 22:37important and delicate is establishing
- 22:40the border, the dividing line between
- 22:42acts of preparation and acts of
- 22:44execution. Why? Because if the
- 22:48perpetrator stays within the
- 22:53preparation phase, as a rule, their
- 22:56conduct will be penally atypical.
- 23:00Preparatory acts are, as a rule, not
- 23:03punishable in Brazilian criminal law.
- 23:08Punishment only begins, as a rule, when
- 23:10there is an start of execution, because
- 23:13if there is an start of execution, even
- 23:15if the fact is not consummated due to
- 23:17circumstances beyond the agent's will,
- 23:19an attempt is recognized. Article 14,
- 23:23subsection 2 of the Penal Code. I mean,
- 23:26preparatory acts, as a rule, are not
- 23:28punishable, right? Do you know what the
- 23:31exception is? Preparatory acts will be
- 23:34punishable if the legislator chooses to
- 23:37criminalize them individually. There
- 23:40are several examples, right? The
- 23:42classic example, the crime of
- 23:43counterfeit currency in Article 289 of
- 23:45the Penal Code. The legislator
- 23:48criminalized autonomously, in Article
- 23:50291 of the Penal Code, the crime of
- 23:52equipment for counterfeiting currency.
- 23:56So they transformed what would merely
- 23:57be a preparatory act into an autonomous
- 23:59crime. So sometimes this happens, right
- 24:01, in the anti-terrorism law,
- 24:03preparatory acts for terrorism. Another
- 24:06example of criminalization of
- 24:08preparatory acts, but as a rule they
- 24:11are not punishable, they are penally
- 24:14atypical. Punishment presupposes a
- 24:17start of execution. It is necessary for
- 24:20the agent to enter the attempt phase,
- 24:22right? What are the requirements for an
- 24:23attempt? Beginning of execution,
- 24:25non-consummation, due to circumstances,
- 24:26by the way, regardless of the agent's
- 24:28intent and malice, right? Malice,
- 24:30direct or eventual malice. It is true
- 24:32that there is a controversy there about
- 24:34whether eventual malice is compatible
- 24:36or not with attempt, with good
- 24:37arguments from various, right, various
- 24:39schools of thought, those who agree,
- 24:41those who disagree, but the STJ has
- 24:42already admitted attempt with eventual
- 24:44malice. It has already recognized the
- 24:46compatibility of an attempted crime
- 24:48with eventual malice. But let's return
- 24:50to the central point. The central point
- 24:52I wanted to bring up, what is it? And
- 24:55this transition and this and this
- 24:57frontier, this dividing line that
- 24:59separates preparation and execution. I
- 25:03will go straight here to the answer you
- 25:06must uphold on the test. There are
- 25:08several theories, right? Here we have
- 25:09selected the three main ones. They are
- 25:12the formal objective, material
- 25:14objective, and individual objective
- 25:16theories. Now, which theory was adopted
- 25:20by the Brazilian Penal Code?
- 25:22Doctrinally, you will find several
- 25:24answers. Let's go to the one the STJ
- 25:26provides. The STJ adopts, and this
- 25:29became very clear, right, by a ruling
- 25:32of the Fifth Panel in April 2026, the
- 25:35tempered or mitigated formal objective
- 25:38theory. So, look here, look. Take a
- 25:41look. STJ, April 2026, Fifth Panel.
- 25:47Interlocutory appeal in special appeal
- 25:492255737, reported in the STJ's
- 25:54newsletter 887. This is an excerpt from
- 25:56the syllabus, it's a section of the
- 25:58syllabus, item four of the ruling's
- 26:00syllabus, that one up there. The
- 26:03jurisprudence of this court, although
- 26:06departing from the formal objective
- 26:08theory, which links the executive act
- 26:10to the beginning of the realization of
- 26:13the verb, adopts a tempered or
- 26:15mitigated conception, which
- 26:17distinguishes the start of the
- 26:19execution from the typical action. That
- 26:22is: when the agent enters the penal
- 26:24type, theft, did they really perform an
- 26:26act of subtraction, reduction of
- 26:27someone else's assets, right? removal
- 26:30of someone else's assets. So, there is
- 26:32a difference between the start of the
- 26:34execution of the typical action and the
- 26:36beginning of the execution of the crime
- 26:38. They are different things. No, the
- 26:41STJ does not treat them as synonyms.
- 26:42Therefore, tempered or mitigated formal
- 26:44objective theory. And the beginning of
- 26:47the execution of the crime, a situation
- 26:50covered by the exception rule of 142,
- 26:52which is the attempt, occurs when the
- 26:55crime, oh, can be considered attempted
- 26:57or a crime even before the start of the
- 27:00nuclear action when peripheral acts,
- 27:02analyzed in light of the agent's
- 27:04concrete plan, unequivocally
- 27:06demonstrate the beginning of the
- 27:08aggression to the legal interest,
- 27:10exposing it to a relevant and immediate
- 27:13risk. In this specific case, I think
- 27:15it's worth illustrating with this,
- 27:17right? And this interlocutory appeal,
- 27:19this special appeal here, what
- 27:20situation were they dealing with, right
- 27:22? So we can illustrate it. The agents
- 27:27were surprised by military police. It
- 27:30was very clear. The evidence in the
- 27:32case records was unequivocal: breaking
- 27:34a padlock to enter a business
- 27:36establishment and commit theft. They
- 27:39were caught just like that, breaking
- 27:40the padlock, a preparatory act or the
- 27:45start of execution, and therefore,
- 27:47attempted theft. And then the STJ said:
- 27:50"Look, in this case, even before the
- 27:51start of the core action, they hadn't
- 27:53taken anything yet, they hadn't seized
- 27:55anything." There was a peripheral act
- 27:58which, analyzed in light of the agent's
- 28:00concrete plan—that is, the subjects '
- 28:02intention—unequivocally showed that
- 28:04they had begun the aggression against
- 28:06the victim's legal interest, their
- 28:08property, exposing this legal interest
- 28:11to a relevant and immediate risk. And
- 28:13so the STJ recognized the attempt in
- 28:16this case. An attempt, which as a rule,
- 28:20let's talk now about the reflection on
- 28:21sentencing, this is quite simple, right
- 28:23? But it must be remembered, the
- 28:27attempt, says article 14, sole
- 28:29paragraph, will imply, when recognized,
- 28:32the application of the penalty for the
- 28:34consummated crime, reduced by 1/3 to
- 28:392/3. Therefore, the attempt from the
- 28:41perspective of the theory of penalty is
- 28:43a mandatory cause for reduction. Now,
- 28:47when does always, let me rephrase my
- 28:54question, is the 1/3 to 2/3 reduction
- 28:57always applied because of an attempt?
- 29:01The sole paragraph itself says so; the
- 29:03answer is not always, because the sole
- 29:06paragraph says: "Unless otherwise
- 29:08provided, the penalty for the attempted
- 29:10crime is that of the consummated one
- 29:12reduced by 1/3 to 2/3." And when the
- 29:16code says "unless otherwise provided,"
- 29:18what does it mean? It means the
- 29:22following: that in some crimes, which
- 29:25are called crimes of attempt or
- 29:27enterprise, the legislator expressly
- 29:30equates the attempt and the
- 29:32consummation for punishment purposes,
- 29:35as you find there in the Penal Code, in
- 29:38article 351 or 352, right? The exact
- 29:42number escaped me, but it is one of
- 29:44these two, 351 or 352. Escaping or
- 29:48attempting to escape by a prisoner or
- 29:50individual subject to security measures
- 29:53with the use of violence or grave
- 29:55threat. So it is the act of escaping or
- 29:57attempting to escape. The act of
- 30:01escaping, evading from a prison
- 30:02establishment or attempting to do so
- 30:04with the use of violence is already
- 30:06framed in the crime, already subsumed
- 30:07to the penal type, and already
- 30:09generates as a consequence the penalty
- 30:11provided in the secondary precept.
- 30:13Therefore, the reducer will not apply
- 30:15there. Now, the rule is that the
- 30:17reducer applies. When it comes to
- 30:19applying the rule, how is the 1/3 to
- 30:212/3 reduction determined? And based on
- 30:24what does the judge establish this
- 30:26benchmark? Based on what does the judge
- 30:28define the quantum of the reduction?
- 30:31Based on a peaceful, objective, and
- 30:33calm criterion. Don't answer anything
- 30:36else from the Penal Code, other than
- 30:37saying the following on the exam, right
- 30:39? Other than saying this: the quantum,
- 30:42the benchmark for the reduction, is
- 30:44defined by the proximity to
- 30:46consummation, meaning the closer to
- 30:48consummation, the smaller the benefit
- 30:51and, therefore, the smaller the penalty
- 30:53reduction, the smaller the reducer. 1/3
- 30:57. The further from consummation, the
- 31:01greater the reduction will be. Alright?
- 31:05So that's it, I see here on the clock
- 31:07that I’ve reached 30 minutes, went a
- 31:10little over. So let's go, so we don't
- 31:13drag it out, let's take a break. In
- 31:16block two, we will continue our review
- 31:19of the general part so you can ace the
- 31:21exam this Sunday the 26th. See you. M.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Direito Penal Geral (Prof. Estefam) - Aula 1 by Cursos Foco Total | MP e Magistratura, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 4,576 words across 721 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.