🌎🌱⚖️​Diplomado en medio ambiente, bioculturalidad y derechos humanos — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Ruis Cervantes, Deputy Director of
- 0:01Environmental Justice at the General
- 0:03Directorate of Human Rights and
- 0:05Pluricultural Justice. I describe
- 0:07myself as a person of thin build, with
- 0:09brown hair, brown-rimmed glasses. My
- 0:12pronoun is she/her, and I am wearing a
- 0:14red blouse. Today we begin with session
- 0:18six titled Mexican Legal Framework for
- 0:20the Protection of a Healthy Environment
- 0:22, which is part of module one,
- 0:24introduction and regulatory framework
- 0:26for environmental justice. The purpose
- 0:29of this session is to examine the
- 0:30constitutional, legal, and
- 0:32institutional bases of environmental
- 0:34protection in Mexico, as well as
- 0:36relevant criteria developed by the
- 0:38Supreme Court of Justice of the Nation.
- 0:40Before beginning, it is important to
- 0:42remember that the Zoom room has a
- 0:44maximum capacity of 3,000 people. Once
- 0:47this capacity is reached, the class
- 0:49signal will be sent to a YouTube
- 0:52broadcast that you can also view within
- 0:54the platform. Your attendance will be
- 0:57automatically recorded when you enter
- 0:59the Zoom session or the YouTube
- 1:01broadcast within the platform and
- 1:03remain on it throughout the session. We
- 1:06remind you that if for any reason you
- 1:08are unable to connect to the live
- 1:10session, you will be able to view the
- 1:12recording on the platform and prove
- 1:14your attendance as long as you complete
- 1:16the session within the following 7
- 1:18calendar days. After this period,
- 1:20attendance will no longer be counted.
- 1:23You may submit your comments and
- 1:24concerns in the Q&A section, which is
- 1:26located at the bottom of the Zoom
- 1:28window and is clearly marked with a
- 1:30question mark icon for your convenience
- 1:32. People following the broadcast on
- 1:35YouTube will be able to ask their
- 1:36questions through the link that appears
- 1:38on the platform. In both cases, your
- 1:41contributions will be reviewed in real
- 1:43time and an attempt will be made to
- 1:45answer as many as possible during the
- 1:47session. We invite you to ask clear and
- 1:50brief questions, indicating the
- 1:52specific point to which they refer, in
- 1:54order to facilitate their
- 1:56systematization and addressing by the
- 1:58speaker. For those who may require it,
- 2:01the option to enable automated
- 2:03subtitles is available for use directly
- 2:05within the Zoom meeting platform. You
- 2:07can enable them by clicking on the plus
- 2:10option or on the three dots in the
- 2:13lower right corner, then clicking on
- 2:15subtitles or CC caps. If you are
- 2:18following the YouTube broadcast, the
- 2:20subtitles are automatically activated.
- 2:23Without further ado, we welcome our
- 2:25speaker for today's session, Dr.
- 2:28Marisol Anglés Hernández, whom we
- 2:30thank for her willingness to contribute
- 2:33to this training space and from whom I
- 2:36would like to read a brief resume. She
- 2:39holds a PhD in Environmental Law from
- 2:41the University of Alicante, with
- 2:43unanimous distinction laude, a law
- 2:46degree from the UNAM Law School, and is
- 2:48a full-time researcher by competitive
- 2:50examination at the UNAM Institute of
- 2:52Legal Research. She is currently the
- 2:55coordinator of the UNAM postgraduate
- 2:57program in law, and is the author and
- 2:59co-author of publications on
- 3:01environmental law and energy law,
- 3:03comprehensive risk management,
- 3:05sustainable development, soils, and
- 3:07hazardous materials and waste. She has
- 3:09been a consultant for international
- 3:11organizations and national institutions
- 3:13. She is part of the following research
- 3:15groups at UNAM. Research seminar on
- 3:18knowledge society and cultural
- 3:20diversity. University seminar on
- 3:22society, environment and institutions,
- 3:24university seminar on
- 3:26socio-environmental risks and the
- 3:28university program of interdisciplinary
- 3:30studies on soil. Awarded by the
- 3:33Universidad Juárez Autónoma de
- 3:36Tabasco with the 2016 Milani National
- 3:38Award, as well as by the Legislative
- 3:41Assembly of Mexico City with the 2018
- 3:43Medal of Citizen Merit. She is the
- 3:46founder of the International Network on
- 3:48Climate Change, Energy and Human Rights
- 3:50and a member of the Ibero-American
- 3:52Network of Energy Law. The National
- 3:55System of Women Researchers recognizes
- 3:58her with level two. She co-directs the
- 4:00research line on energy, law and
- 4:02society of the UNAM Institute of Legal
- 4:05Research and the interdisciplinary
- 4:07diploma in energy law taught by the
- 4:09same institute. Without further ado, we
- 4:13give the floor to Dr. Marisola Anglés.
- 4:16Thank you very much.
- 4:18Thank you very much, dear Silvia. Good
- 4:20afternoon to everyone who is joining us
- 4:23in this space for taking the time to
- 4:28strengthen their knowledge about the
- 4:30topics covered in the diploma course.
- 4:33As you have already mentioned, I am
- 4:35Marisola Inglés, a 59-year-old woman
- 4:38with a ponytail, and I wear rectangular
- 4:40glasses with a transparent background
- 4:43and silver rim. I am wearing a green
- 4:46blouse and I am very happy because I
- 4:48just became a grandmother, so you can
- 4:50imagine how I feel today. Well, we are
- 4:53going to share this session with you,
- 4:56which aims to address the continuity of
- 4:59the topics you are looking at, with the
- 5:01specific objective of examining the
- 5:04constitutional, legal and institutional
- 5:07bases of environmental protection in
- 5:10our country, as well as the relevant
- 5:12criteria developed by the Supreme Court
- 5:15of Justice of the Nation. The agenda
- 5:19that we will cover is contained in
- 5:22three fundamental areas: first, as
- 5:24already mentioned, the constitutional
- 5:26basis of the right to a healthy
- 5:29environment, then the main
- 5:30environmental laws and institutions
- 5:33that protect the environment in Mexico.
- 5:36And these two topics will be, let's say
- 5:39, crossed by the different precedents
- 5:41and rulings of the Supreme Court of
- 5:43Justice of the Nation. Since this is
- 5:46not our first session. Uh, I would like
- 5:49you to raise your hand or write in the
- 5:52chat in a maximum of five words how you
- 5:55understand a healthy environment to be
- 5:58integrated. What is a healthy
- 6:00environment? What do you imagine there
- 6:04is there? How should it be? Let's give
- 6:10it a minute.
- 6:22If it helps us. Sil.
- 6:23Okay, here. Yeah. I can't see the hands
- 6:28, but I can see the answers here in the
- 6:31chat and they tell us that it is One
- 6:34Health. Care of flora and fauna. A
- 6:38dignified environment for life,
- 6:41coexistence between nature and
- 6:44individuals of all types, living well,
- 6:48free of pollutants,
- 6:51safe environments. Well, and it appears
- 6:53.
- 6:54Well, but then we are not sure that
- 6:57there is an idea, right? This, a fairly
- 7:00accurate one of what a healthy
- 7:02environment means. And indeed, we are
- 7:04talking about certain characteristics
- 7:07that the environment in which we live
- 7:10must have that allow us to develop with
- 7:13dignity, regardless of who we are or
- 7:16where we develop. But that also means
- 7:19that, and that is something that I
- 7:22would like you to internalize, because
- 7:24the diploma also talks about
- 7:26biocultural aspects, so that we can see
- 7:28that a healthy environment should not
- 7:31only be considered in terms of
- 7:33conditions that are not useful as a
- 7:35human species, but rather, I would
- 7:37define it as the support bases for
- 7:39planetary life. I believe that is what
- 7:42we have to continue building or in our
- 7:45imagination, but considering that we
- 7:48are not the only form of life on this
- 7:50planet. Well, as a first starting point
- 7:53, I would also like us to realize that
- 7:56when we talk about the constitutional
- 7:59basis of the right to a healthy
- 8:01environment, we have many
- 8:02constitutional precepts that interact
- 8:05with this environmental protection. For
- 8:09example, our first constitutional
- 8:11article recognizes human rights for all
- 8:14people, both those contained, as you
- 8:16have seen previously, in this
- 8:18Constitution of ours, but also in the
- 8:20international treaties to which the
- 8:23Mexican State is a party. This is very
- 8:26relevant because there are a series of
- 8:29environmental protections that derive
- 8:31precisely from international public law
- 8:33, from various treaties, agreements,
- 8:36and conventions that Mexico has signed
- 8:38and ratified. Article 25 of the
- 8:41Constitution is also relevant because,
- 8:44although it does not expressly speak of
- 8:47a healthy environment, it does state
- 8:49that the development of the State must
- 8:52be comprehensive and sustainable. And
- 8:55that must be our axis of action when
- 8:58defining different actions, authorizing
- 9:01projects, granting permits, always
- 9:03keeping as our axis of action that the
- 9:06governance of national development must
- 9:09be comprehensive and sustainable.
- 9:12Another aspect that is also important
- 9:15for us to be clear about is Article 26
- 9:18of the Constitution. Why? Because it
- 9:21tells us about the national planning
- 9:23system. This national planning system,
- 9:26which is outlined in the Planning Law,
- 9:28allows or should allow national
- 9:30development planning, which is
- 9:32integrated by this biennial instrument
- 9:35(sometimes five-yearly and sometimes
- 9:37four-yearly, but which the regulations
- 9:40establish should be every 6 years, with
- 9:42each change of federal government),
- 9:45since this National Development Plan
- 9:47gives rise to all the planning of the
- 9:50country, both at the sectoral and
- 9:52strategic level. Mexico. And so if we
- 9:55are clear about Article 25, which tells
- 9:58us that development must be governed by
- 10:01comprehensive and sustainable, then
- 10:03this should also permeate national
- 10:06development planning, in the sectoral
- 10:09plans for the environment, human
- 10:11settlements, water, energy, and
- 10:13everything. Then we have Article 27 of
- 10:17the Constitution, and this article
- 10:19tells us about the original ownership
- 10:21of the nation, as you well know, of
- 10:23lands, forests, water, and subsoil
- 10:25resources, but something that it tells
- 10:27us about and that is very important for
- 10:30our topic is the possibility of
- 10:32imposing modalities on private property
- 10:34. This, then, has a very close
- 10:36relationship, above all, with social
- 10:38property and agrarian property. It also
- 10:40allows the State, in addition to
- 10:43carrying out an expropriation under
- 10:45certain conditions established by law,
- 10:47the possibility of establishing
- 10:49protected natural areas under their
- 10:52various different characteristics, all
- 10:54without the property itself being
- 10:56affected, though the specific uses that
- 10:59can be given within the land are indeed
- 11:01limited by these regulations. Then,
- 11:04Article 73, section 29g, also of the
- 11:08Federal Constitution, determines the
- 11:11concurrence in environmental matters.
- 11:13And this precept is also very important
- 11:16to us because it makes us understand
- 11:19that the federation, the federal
- 11:21entities, and the municipalities must
- 11:24be involved in the preservation and
- 11:26protection of the environment. In other
- 11:29words, it is a transversal obligation
- 11:31at all levels of government. Article
- 11:35115 of the Constitution, specifically
- 11:37section 5c, focuses on the specific
- 11:39powers of the municipality that have a
- 11:42very close impact on various
- 11:44environmental issues, such as the
- 11:46issuance of building permits, the
- 11:48determination of land use, waste
- 11:51management, as well as the supply of
- 11:53water and basic sanitation services for
- 11:56the local population. these aspects are
- 11:59key to protecting the environment.
- 12:02Finally, Article 4 of the Constitution
- 12:05is the article that expressly
- 12:07concentrates or condenses the right to
- 12:11a healthy environment in our country
- 12:14for the development and well-being of
- 12:17all people. But it is not just phrased
- 12:21like this, let's say; it also imposes
- 12:24on the State the obligation to
- 12:26guarantee this right and also imposes
- 12:29on those who cause environmental damage
- 12:32or deterioration the responsibility to
- 12:35address this impact or damage. So, if
- 12:38you look closely, the regulatory
- 12:40framework associated with environmental
- 12:42protection, I mean, and I could expand
- 12:44on it, I could go to Article 133, but
- 12:46let's say the most basic one is this,
- 12:49but it is not in a single article, it
- 12:51is in several precepts. In that sense,
- 12:54I also want you to build in your
- 12:56imagination that the right to a healthy
- 12:59environment is not alone, it is
- 13:01constantly interacting with many other
- 13:04human rights. It is the equal of the
- 13:07right to health, the right to water,
- 13:11the right to food, the right to
- 13:14development and therefore the right to
- 13:17life. Therefore, it is not just any
- 13:20right, it is a very important right,
- 13:23right? Here I bring you the first
- 13:26precedent talking about concurrency,
- 13:28right? So, this first precedent tells
- 13:31us about the concurrent powers between
- 13:33states and municipalities and
- 13:35specifically refers to a form of action
- 13:38regarding the resolution of a
- 13:40regulatory instrument that is the
- 13:42ecological planning of the territory.
- 13:46And here, what I want to emphasize is
- 13:48that, although ecological planning has
- 13:51federal, state, and municipal planning
- 13:54due to this concurrence, which is
- 13:56already constitutional, when it came to
- 13:59implementation, some municipalities,
- 14:01within the framework of their municipal
- 14:04powers, said: "Well, we in the
- 14:06municipality are going to decide what
- 14:08to do in terms of ecological planning
- 14:11and also human settlements," because
- 14:14urban development is also a concurrent
- 14:17power. However, this resulted in a
- 14:20constitutional controversy in which it
- 14:23was resolved that when municipal urban
- 14:27development programs have ecological
- 14:33impact, whether federal or local...And
- 14:35here I would tell you, in parentheses,
- 14:38if you recall, that all national
- 14:40development must be comprehensive and
- 14:42sustainable. Well, although it seems
- 14:45that we have two instruments with the
- 14:47same normative hierarchy, both are
- 14:49municipal instruments, both have
- 14:51concurrent matters. Well, what the
- 14:54Court says is: municipal urban
- 14:56development programs must be consistent
- 15:00with federal and local ecological
- 15:03planning programs. It should not be
- 15:06overlooked that municipalities do not
- 15:09have exclusive and definitive powers in
- 15:12matters of urban settlements and
- 15:14environmental protection, since both
- 15:17are constitutionally concurrent. So,
- 15:20here the court resolves an initial
- 15:22dilemma, which was: which instrument
- 15:25should be privileged, if both are
- 15:28hierarchically equal? One tells me that
- 15:30I can carry out urban development and
- 15:32the other tells me that I cannot
- 15:34because it is an area of environmental
- 15:36protection. Here it is clear that the
- 15:39Court tells us that the environmental
- 15:42criterion of ecological planning must
- 15:44prevail in this concurrence. Well, in
- 15:48this evolution that we have had
- 15:50regarding the right to a healthy
- 15:53environment, it is important that you
- 15:56know the precedent of constitutional
- 15:58recognition that was initially given in
- 16:011999 in this fourth article,
- 16:03recognizing the right of all people to
- 16:06an adequate environment for development
- 16:09and well-being. Later, in 2012, this
- 16:12article was modified to change the
- 16:15qualification from adequate environment
- 16:18to healthy environment. And it is not a
- 16:22trivial decision, because the word "
- 16:24adequate" is a word with a very
- 16:27subjective content, because each person
- 16:30can say what they consider adequate
- 16:32according to their culture, according
- 16:35to their needs, according to many
- 16:38things. However, the term "healthy"
- 16:41already allows us to have a regulatory
- 16:44parameter to assess these conditions.
- 16:47And how do we assess these conditions?
- 16:49From a legal perspective, based on
- 16:52instruments called official Mexican
- 16:54standards. If you have heard of any
- 16:57standard of this type, for example, we
- 17:00have standards that establish maximum
- 17:03permissible limits for emissions into
- 17:05the atmosphere, maximum permissible
- 17:08limits for discharges into water. These
- 17:11limits are precisely a regulatory
- 17:13parameter that allow us to assess
- 17:16whether or not we are within what is
- 17:18considered healthy. Furthermore, in
- 17:222012, the State's obligation to
- 17:24guarantee this right was added, and
- 17:27liability for damage and deterioration
- 17:30of the environment was also imposed on
- 17:34those who cause it. Okay, here I would
- 17:39like to hear from you or have you write
- 17:42in the chat what other human rights you
- 17:45consider to be related to this right to
- 17:48a healthy environment based on what you
- 17:51are seeking to achieve with this
- 17:54training, with this diploma. Why were
- 17:57you interested? Because what do you
- 18:01think it connects with or will help you
- 18:03with? MarĂa Isabel de los RĂos raised
- 18:09her hand here. Let's
- 18:11see, MarĂa Isabel, we want to hear
- 18:12from you.
- 18:18If you can give her a voice, please. We
- 18:26can't
- 18:26hear her. And if not, let's see if we
- 18:32can give her a voice while I read this
- 18:35in the chat what they say.
- 18:37Yeah.
- 18:38It says, "Ah, there are many with the
- 18:42right to health, to territory, to life,
- 18:46to education, to a dignified life,
- 18:49again food, equality. That's what
- 18:54they've put in water." Thank you very
- 18:56much. Sure.
- 18:58What I wanted you to look at is that
- 19:00this right, in addition to the
- 19:02interactions that I already mentioned
- 19:04with respect to others, also has to do
- 19:06with the right to territory, with the
- 19:09right to community life, with the right
- 19:11to dignity, right? With the right of
- 19:14future generations. So, it is a right
- 19:17that carries with it very significant
- 19:19implications. And in that sense, well,
- 19:22here I have included some expressions
- 19:24that tell us about these rights that
- 19:27you have already mentioned, but that
- 19:30are also connected to procedural rights
- 19:32, that is to say: with the right of
- 19:35access to information, with the right
- 19:38of access to participation and, finally
- 19:40, with the right of access to justice,
- 19:43right? These three rights, which are
- 19:46very interconnected, are what allow us,
- 19:50as people who have the right to a
- 19:53healthy environment, to ensure its
- 19:56guarantee, right? To know how we are
- 19:59doing, to participate in
- 20:01decision-making processes and, where
- 20:04appropriate, to access justice through
- 20:07the different channels that we have for
- 20:09this.
- 20:11Hello. I think MarĂa Isabel can now
- 20:14speak.
- 20:14Ah, well, we're listening.
- 20:21Good afternoon. Can you hear me?
- 20:23Yes.
- 20:25Excuse me, teacher. No, I didn't want
- 20:28to participate with my voice, I was
- 20:31just reviewing the questions. I don't
- 20:33have any questions yet. Okay, don't
- 20:37worry. Well, later on, I hope you'll be
- 20:39encouraged to do so. Well, we're going
- 20:42to talk a little bit about the main
- 20:44entities that are in charge of
- 20:46environmental protection and in that
- 20:49sense, what is called the head of the
- 20:52sector or who heads the environmental
- 20:54sector at the federal level in our
- 20:57country is the Secretariat of the
- 20:59Environment and Natural Resources.
- 21:03Always remember that since it is a
- 21:05concurrent issue, all of this is
- 21:07brought down to the state level, to the
- 21:09level of all our federal entities and
- 21:11then to the municipal level. It does
- 21:13not remain at the federation or should
- 21:15not remain at the federation. And as
- 21:18this federal body, we have different
- 21:20entities as decentralized bodies: the
- 21:22National Water Commission, the Federal
- 21:24Attorney's Office for Environmental
- 21:26Protection, the Industrial Safety and
- 21:29Environmental Protection Agency for the
- 21:31Hydrocarbons Sector, which is the CEA,
- 21:33the National Commission for Natural
- 21:35Protected Areas, the Mexican Institute
- 21:38of Water Technology, and the National
- 21:40Institute of Ecology and Climate Change
- 21:42. These are the main ones. There are
- 21:45many others that we will see how they
- 21:47will emerge in an interconnected way
- 21:50throughout the presentation, but I also
- 21:52want you to see that it is huge. This
- 21:55is a tangle of the main environmental
- 21:59laws and their regulations, right? We
- 22:04see that in environmental matters we
- 22:06have the General Law on Ecological
- 22:08Balance and Environmental Protection,
- 22:10which as you know, general laws
- 22:12distribute powers among the three
- 22:14levels of government. That is why most
- 22:17of our environmental laws are called
- 22:20general in response to this
- 22:22constitutional concurrence. Well, we
- 22:26also have the General Law on
- 22:28Sustainable Forest Development, the
- 22:30National Water Law, the recently issued
- 22:33General Water Law, the General Law on
- 22:35Climate Change, the General Law on
- 22:38Wildlife, the CEA Law, the General Law
- 22:40for the Prevention and Comprehensive
- 22:43Management of Waste, the Law on Quality
- 22:45Infrastructure, which regulates all
- 22:48official Mexican standards, and the Law
- 22:51on Biosafety of Genetically Modified
- 22:53Organisms. And here, take a close look,
- 22:56open your eyes: everything is general,
- 22:59general, general, general, general,
- 23:01general, and then suddenly the Federal
- 23:03Law on Environmental Responsibility
- 23:05appears. Here we should have, in
- 23:09accordance with the constitutional
- 23:11mandate, a general law on environmental
- 23:14responsibility. So, we are in debt
- 23:17because what we have is a federal law.
- 23:20What does this mean? Well, it omitted
- 23:23to include in this same law the powers
- 23:26of federal entities and municipalities
- 23:29in matters of responsibility, and for
- 23:32me, that is a debt that we have.
- 23:35Finally, at the very bottom, the
- 23:37Federal Law of Administrative Procedure
- 23:40appears as a supplementary instrument,
- 23:43because practically all environmental
- 23:45regulations are governed by
- 23:47administrative law. Well, the first
- 23:51secretariat or institution in charge of
- 23:54environmental protection is the
- 23:56Secretariat of the Environment and
- 23:58Natural Resources. As I had already
- 24:01told you, its foundation or mandate is
- 24:04to promote the protection, restoration,
- 24:07conservation, preservation, as well as
- 24:10the sustainable use of ecosystems,
- 24:12natural resources, environmental goods
- 24:15and services, in order to guarantee the
- 24:18right to a healthy environment. Note
- 24:22here that sometimes when we read, we do
- 24:26not realize the semantic content of the
- 24:30words. What is the difference if I say
- 24:35environmental goods and if I say
- 24:39environmental services? Who can tell me
- 24:45? Who writes to me in the chat or
- 24:47raises their hand? I see raised hands.
- 24:54Let's see, JerĂłnimo RamĂrez is here.
- 24:58Tell us, JerĂłnimo.
- 25:04Yes, he is over there.
- 25:09JerĂłnimo, if you would like to
- 25:10activate your microphone, please. Okay.
- 25:12Yes, good afternoon, excuse me. Well,
- 25:16regarding environmental services, these
- 25:18would consist of the absorption of
- 25:21carbon that is performed by the natural
- 25:23environment through the existence of
- 25:26forest ecosystems; water resources,
- 25:32which would be the water cycle; and
- 25:35pollination by organisms, in this case,
- 25:41butterflies and insects. And regarding
- 25:44that other comment that I have
- 25:45forgotten at this moment, could you
- 25:47please help me with it?
- 25:48Yes, JerĂłnimo, thank you. If you see
- 25:51them as environmental goods,
- 25:53environmental goods would be ecosystems
- 25:56.
- 25:58Thank you very much. Yes, that's right.
- 26:00That's right, JerĂłnimo. Well, if you
- 26:02look at this explanation that Genorimo
- 26:05kindly provided for us, we realize that
- 26:08all this construction that we have
- 26:10about the environment is for the
- 26:12benefit of humans, right? This is also
- 26:16where we need to move forward: we don't
- 26:20just have to see them as services or
- 26:23goods, but as elements; environmental
- 26:26elements, elements of nature, because
- 26:30we always assign them this value based
- 26:33on what they provide us or based on
- 26:36what we can take advantage of, right?
- 26:40And that is something that, over time,
- 26:42we will see that perhaps we need to
- 26:45change, right? Now with the whole trend
- 26:47of moving towards the rights of nature.
- 26:50Well, exercising these actions in
- 26:53defense of a healthy environment is
- 26:55also an attribution of SEMARNAT, and
- 26:58also protecting human rights related to
- 27:01the environment in terms of applicable
- 27:03regulations. So, if you look at it this
- 27:06way, the first institution that has to
- 27:09rise up in environmental defense is
- 27:12this SEMARNAT. If we review the
- 27:16legislative instrument for SEMARNAT's
- 27:19actions, the basic instrument is this
- 27:21General Law on Ecological Balance and
- 27:24Environmental Protection. And if we
- 27:27were to open it up, just like a book,
- 27:29we could see that inside this law there
- 27:32are six separate titles. For example, I
- 27:36broke down the fourth title, which is
- 27:38related to environmental protection.
- 27:41See how it has a general chapter of
- 27:43general provisions; but it also has a
- 27:46chapter on the prevention and control
- 27:49of air pollution, the prevention and
- 27:52control of water and aquatic ecosystem
- 27:55pollution, soil pollution, and also all
- 27:58the regulations for highly risky
- 28:01activities, hazardous materials and
- 28:04waste, including nuclear energy, noise,
- 28:07vibrations, thermal energy, light, and
- 28:10visual pollution, among others. So, if
- 28:13you notice, the General Law on
- 28:15Ecological Balance, which is the Lejepa
- 28:18, also has very, very broad content
- 28:21that focuses on these federal powers,
- 28:24which in turn, remember, are also
- 28:26divided into federal entities. Each
- 28:29federal entity has its own state
- 28:31environmental legislation, which must
- 28:34also include the regulatory aspect in
- 28:36the municipalities. What does the
- 28:40Lejepa seek? This general law has many
- 28:44objectives. I tried to summarize them
- 28:46in these four points. First, it
- 28:49guarantees the right of every person to
- 28:51live in a healthy environment for their
- 28:53development and well-being, as well as
- 28:55their health. I want you to know that
- 28:57this law was issued in 1988. It was a
- 29:01law that recognized the right to a
- 29:03healthy environment 11 years before the
- 29:06Constitution. Then this law speaks of
- 29:09the sustainable use, preservation and
- 29:12restoration of soil, water and other
- 29:15natural resources in a way that is
- 29:17compatible with obtaining economic
- 29:20benefits, right? And the activities of
- 29:23society, but also visualizing the
- 29:25preservation of ecosystems. It is not
- 29:27just about using them, but also
- 29:29preserving them. And also note the word
- 29:32, it is not exploitation of resources,
- 29:35it is utilization. These words are also
- 29:38different and have different scopes.
- 29:41The law also seeks to prevent and
- 29:43control pollution, as already mentioned
- 29:46, of water, air, and soil, and to
- 29:48establish control and safety measures
- 29:50to ensure compliance with and
- 29:52application of the law itself, as well
- 29:54as all the provisions that derive from
- 29:57it. All the other laws that I mentioned
- 30:00at the beginning, wildlife, water,
- 30:03climate change, are laws that are
- 30:05related to this law and also to impose
- 30:08administrative and, as it says here,
- 30:10criminal sanctions that correspond,
- 30:13right? Well, the environmental policy
- 30:16instruments that allow us to carry out
- 30:20actions to protect the environment
- 30:23derive from this law. We have
- 30:26environmental planning, environmental
- 30:30regulation of human settlements,
- 30:33ecological land use planning,
- 30:35environmental impact assessment,
- 30:38official Mexican standards and, let's
- 30:42say roughly speaking, right? We also
- 30:45have environmental education as an
- 30:47environmental policy instrument,
- 30:49auditing and environmental
- 30:51self-regulation. But from this short
- 30:54list, if I were to ask you, where do
- 30:56you think we have the greatest impact
- 30:59on protecting the environment? as
- 31:02individuals, that is, as people who can
- 31:05get involved in a decision-making
- 31:08process. In which of these do you say,
- 31:10"I have participated here, I think we
- 31:12can have an impact." Who writes to me
- 31:15in the chat or raises their hand and
- 31:20says, "I'm always involved, Cristian
- 31:25Mirués is in charge, please accept the
- 31:30invitation so you can speak."
- 31:34Cristian.
- 31:34Yes.
- 31:35Well, a hug from La Paz, Bolivia.
- 31:38Hello, Cristian. How nice.
- 31:40Yes, look, to do a comparative study
- 31:44with Bolivia, we are a unitary system,
- 31:47you are federal, but nevertheless we
- 31:50have the issue of autonomies. So I was
- 31:53making a comparison between the powers
- 31:58and the central level of the State,
- 32:00which would be the laws, the general
- 32:02issue, the general laws, right? And the
- 32:06autonomous ones in the different sub,
- 32:09let's say state or subnational levels.
- 32:13We do not know that the issue of
- 32:15autonomies in Bolivia is a stage prior
- 32:18to federalism, right?,which is being
- 32:20discussed today. However, there are
- 32:23many similarities, as I can see,
- 32:26between the powers assigned to the
- 32:29central level of the State and that the
- 32:32law itself determines which level of
- 32:35government does what, so that everyone
- 32:39can, in a subsidiary way related to the
- 32:42citizen, meet the needs, especially of
- 32:45the level of government closest to the
- 32:49citizen, right? I know that and I
- 32:51completely agree with you, teacher, on
- 32:54the subject of the anthropocentric
- 32:57vision that is held, right? In vision,
- 33:00right? Everything is the human being
- 33:03and all of nature is at our service.
- 33:07But turning it around and being part of
- 33:10that nature and seeing it as a mother
- 33:14or sister or or being a small
- 33:17complement to that, is a vision that is
- 33:20, let's say, very much in line with
- 33:24current times, right? So I just wanted
- 33:27to make that comment, teacher, and
- 33:29congratulate you. And well, a hug from
- 33:33here, the cold, the peace.
- 33:36Thank you very much, Cristian. Well,
- 33:38indeed, as Cristian was saying, in
- 33:40practically all of these environmental
- 33:43policy instruments there are
- 33:45participatory mechanisms where we as
- 33:47individuals could get involved to seek
- 33:50environmental protection. It is also
- 33:53important that we have the EscasĂş
- 33:55agreement as a backdrop, which you will
- 33:57review very closely in other sessions.
- 33:59I just want you to see that these three
- 34:02rights of access that I mentioned are
- 34:04underpinned here: the right to
- 34:06information, participation, and justice
- 34:08, which are key to getting involved in
- 34:10this environmental decision-making
- 34:12process. And in this sense, I share
- 34:15with you this precedent that speaks of
- 34:17the right to citizen participation and
- 34:20access to environmental information as
- 34:23minimum obligations that the State must
- 34:25meet to guarantee its essential core in
- 34:28a decision-making process. And here
- 34:31what we have to look at, or I would
- 34:34like to emphasize, is that it is seen
- 34:37as an effective guarantee of the right
- 34:40to participation and access to
- 34:42information as a correlative duty of
- 34:45the State to ensure certain minimum
- 34:48obligations so that people can have
- 34:51effective participation, real
- 34:53decision-making. And this implies
- 34:56consultation, not necessarily the
- 34:59indigenous consultation regulated by
- 35:02article 169 of the ILO, public
- 35:04consultation, citizen consultation from
- 35:07the initial stages of the processes in
- 35:10which access to information is allowed
- 35:13in a timely, clear and understandable
- 35:15manner. And secondly, ensuring a real
- 35:19possibility of participation, not just
- 35:21a roll call or attendance, right? And
- 35:26thirdly, guaranteeing the participation
- 35:29of the different interests present in
- 35:32the territory through the appropriate
- 35:34means and this may even involve
- 35:36translation when needed into other
- 35:39languages. And finally, carrying out
- 35:42specific actions for groups in
- 35:44vulnerable situations or
- 35:46underrepresented. This also has to do
- 35:49even with places, accessibility and
- 35:51these types of issues that really allow
- 35:54people to arrive, get information,
- 35:56participate and I would go further,
- 35:59right? And that this participation is
- 36:02binding, that generates implications in
- 36:05decision-making. Well, another thing
- 36:08that is important for you to know is
- 36:11that this law was reformed in its
- 36:13article 180 to state that, in the case
- 36:15of works or activities that contravene
- 36:18the provisions of the same law,
- 36:20individuals and legal entities with an
- 36:22interest, and note this carefully, with
- 36:24a legitimate interest, will have the
- 36:27right to challenge administrative acts
- 36:30as long as they demonstrate in the
- 36:33procedure that said works or activities
- 36:36cause or may cause damage to the
- 36:38environment. This reform is the
- 36:42precedent for much subsequent work that
- 36:44has been done in the court to recognize
- 36:47legitimate interest. And then, finally,
- 36:50in its last paragraph, it tells us that
- 36:53for the purposes of this article,
- 36:55individuals or legal entities from the
- 36:57communities possibly affected by the
- 36:59works or activities that are being
- 37:01challenged will have a legitimate
- 37:03interest. Now, this was translated with
- 37:06what is known as the adjacent
- 37:08environment, but note that it comes
- 37:10from here, from the law itself. Well,
- 37:14what has the Court told us regarding
- 37:16this legitimate interest in filing an
- 37:18indirect amparo lawsuit in
- 37:20environmental matters held by
- 37:22beneficiaries of the environmental
- 37:24services provided by the ecosystem? It
- 37:27also has a very large anthropocentric
- 37:29burden here, but it is allowing the
- 37:32ability to prove, with the mere
- 37:34existence of a link between the person
- 37:37claiming to be the holder of a right
- 37:39and the environmental services provided
- 37:42by the ecosystem, right? I think that
- 37:45here we are or should be evolving so as
- 37:49not to only see it from a utilitarian
- 37:52perspective, but at least we are moving
- 37:55from having to prove a legal interest
- 37:58that implied a real, personal, direct
- 38:01impact to moving a little further,
- 38:04which is this legitimate interest. But
- 38:07above all, here there is, let's say, a
- 38:10close link between: I have to
- 38:12demonstrate that I benefit from the
- 38:15systems, from the environmental
- 38:17services provided by a certain
- 38:19ecosystem in order to prove my interest
- 38:22. Well, SEMARNAT, the federal Ministry
- 38:26of the Environment, is also empowered
- 38:29to monitor, promote, and stimulate, in
- 38:32coordination with state, federal, and
- 38:35municipal entities and authorities,
- 38:38compliance with all environmental
- 38:41regulations, as well as initiate
- 38:43inspection, monitoring, and sanction
- 38:46procedures that may be appropriate. And
- 38:49this mandate is what gives SEMARNAT,
- 38:52let's say, a partnership with the
- 38:54Federal Attorney General's Office for
- 38:57Environmental Protection, which is like
- 38:59its executive arm for this inspection,
- 39:02monitoring, and sanctioning. What do
- 39:07the internal regulations of SEMARNAT
- 39:09tell us about the powers and
- 39:11attributions of PROFEPA? Well,
- 39:13obviously, what I was telling you: that
- 39:16it is responsible for inspecting,
- 39:18monitoring and sanctioning, but also
- 39:20for receiving, addressing and
- 39:21investigating complaints, safeguarding
- 39:24the interests of the population and
- 39:26encouraging and fostering their
- 39:28participation in monitoring and
- 39:29complying with environmental provisions
- 39:32, providing advice on matters of
- 39:33environmental protection and defense
- 39:36and also assisting in solving problems
- 39:38caused by environmental emergencies and
- 39:40contingencies, right? It also becomes
- 39:43the entity responsible for reporting
- 39:46and filing complaints with the Federal
- 39:48Public Ministry when it identifies that
- 39:51we are facing the possible commission
- 39:53of federal environmental crimes.
- 39:58According to the Federal Law on
- 40:00Environmental Responsibility, we are no
- 40:02longer with LEGEPA, now we have changed
- 40:04the regulatory instrument, now it is
- 40:05the Federal Law on Environmental
- 40:07Responsibility. The profeEPA has a
- 40:10recognized right and legitimate
- 40:12interest to take action and legally
- 40:15demand environmental liability, repair
- 40:18and compensation for damages caused to
- 40:21the environment and the payment of
- 40:24economic sanctions. And also, in
- 40:27addition to recognizing this right, the
- 40:29federal law also recognizes SEMAR and
- 40:31ProfEPA, sorry, and also recognizes the
- 40:34right of individuals who live in
- 40:36communities adjacent to the damage
- 40:38caused to the environment. Just note
- 40:40that this law, in its first section,
- 40:43already speaks of actual damages; it
- 40:46does not speak of the possibility of
- 40:48causing damage, right? Rather, to those
- 40:51members of the community who have
- 40:53suffered damage. Therefore, in this
- 40:57situation, we would have to be more
- 41:00reactive than preventive. It also
- 41:03speaks of the possibility that private
- 41:06Mexican non-profit legal entities, that
- 41:08is, non-governmental organizations, can
- 41:11participate in these liability
- 41:13processes when they act on behalf of
- 41:16any of the adjacent communities, and of
- 41:19state attorneys general, always in
- 41:21coordination with the Federal Attorney
- 41:24General's Office for Environmental
- 41:27Protection. Well, I'll go back here.
- 41:33The administrative procedure that
- 41:36PROFEPA is also in charge of is this
- 41:38popular complaint. This procedure
- 41:41allows any person, social groups or
- 41:44organizations, without proving any
- 41:46interest, to report to the Attorney
- 41:49General's Office any act, omission or
- 41:52fact that they believe causes or may
- 41:55cause ecological imbalance or damage to
- 41:57the environment or natural resources.
- 42:01Notice how you don't wait for it to
- 42:03burn, but rather you as an individual
- 42:06intuit that the smoke you see may be
- 42:08harmful. You have the option of
- 42:11reporting it and the authorities will
- 42:14follow up to verify whether it is
- 42:16actually causing emissions or damage.
- 42:19Many times, as individuals, we are
- 42:22unaware of what a cloud we see means,
- 42:25it may even be steam depending on the
- 42:28time of day, the place, or the activity
- 42:31, but that is up to the authorities to
- 42:34review. We can also report anything
- 42:37that we believe violates the provisions
- 42:39governing environmental protection,
- 42:42preservation, and restoration of
- 42:44ecological balance. And when the
- 42:47Profepa is competent and the report is
- 42:50valid, it will grant the complainant a
- 42:52hearing so that they can follow up on
- 42:55this entire reporting procedure. So, if
- 42:59you notice, the popular complaint, I
- 43:02see it as if we are all given an
- 43:05environmental inspector's badge and we
- 43:08go about our daily lives and activities
- 43:11and anything we observe that may be
- 43:14environmental damage, we can report it.
- 43:18This same scheme that occurs at the
- 43:20federal level, as I say, is replicated
- 43:22at the state level and should also be
- 43:25replicated at the municipal level. And
- 43:29here I also share with you another
- 43:31criterion of the Court regarding this
- 43:33issue. It tells us that the
- 43:34precautionary principle of
- 43:36environmental law is very important in
- 43:38this area. Therefore, the Federal
- 43:40Attorney General's Office for
- 43:42Environmental Protection must apply it
- 43:44in the popular complaint procedure in
- 43:46the event that a risk of serious or
- 43:49irreversible damage is observed. This
- 43:52is very important because we were used
- 43:55to being guided by the principle of
- 43:57prevention in matters of environmental
- 44:00protection and here the court is giving
- 44:05a very important role to the
- 44:08precautionary principle. Someone raise
- 44:11your hand and quickly tell me the
- 44:13difference between precaution and
- 44:15prevention. Who can tell us? Let me see
- 44:24. Let's see, we have Lu, if you're
- 44:34around, Lu.
- 44:35Yes, yes, here I am. Yes, you can hear
- 44:36it. Yes, now.
- 44:37Yes. Uh, just, forgive me, I don't have
- 44:40the answer to that question, but I had
- 44:43something else, uh, a question about
- 44:46the subject of, uh, Profepa, about the
- 44:50complaints in ProfEPA. Should we leave
- 44:54it for the end or can I,
- 44:57as you wish, if you think it's time now
- 44:59? Well, since we're on the subject, I
- 45:04don't know, uh...well, my question is,
- 45:07uh, to know if, for example, here in
- 45:09Profepa, I've made complaints, I mean,
- 45:12here from Txcala, and they resolved, uh
- 45:14, several of my complaints by saying
- 45:17that they were incompetent. And they
- 45:20were complaints, uh, that I know I made
- 45:22about improvements that were being made
- 45:27in public spaces, in public spaces
- 45:30where they greatly reduced green spaces
- 45:33and started bringing in a lot of very
- 45:35large tree roots. Well, I do not know
- 45:39what the parameters are for resolving
- 45:42these types of complaints regarding
- 45:45incompetence,
- 45:46or if there is some other mechanism by
- 45:48which that resolution, which they made,
- 45:51could be reversed or set aside. Thank
- 45:54you, Lu. Well, look, it is important
- 45:56that we always have clear what the
- 45:59powers of the authorities or entities
- 46:02involved are so as not to get confused.
- 46:05Everything we are seeing from Profepa
- 46:08is federal in nature, so everything
- 46:11that involves urban issues, trees,
- 46:14communication routes within cities is
- 46:17state or even municipal jurisdiction.
- 46:20We would have to review your state's
- 46:23legislation to see, but practically
- 46:25urban matters are state jurisdiction.
- 46:28So, we would have to see why Profepa
- 46:33was not competent, but surely your
- 46:38state legislation makes it clear
- 46:39whether it is up to the state or the
- 46:41municipality, because it depends on the
- 46:43strength of the municipality. Sometimes
- 46:45, federal entities pass urban
- 46:48responsibilities to the municipality.
- 46:51If they are municipalities, let's say,
- 46:54with many economic and technological
- 46:56difficulties, then many times those
- 46:58powers are retained by the State, but
- 47:01it is in the law of your state where
- 47:03you will find out who is responsible
- 47:05for the complaint that you made. And
- 47:08just because you have filed it with the
- 47:10federal government, with PROFEPA and
- 47:12they have not resolved it or have
- 47:14declared themselves incompetent, does
- 47:16not mean that you cannot file it
- 47:18through the state, you can file it
- 47:20anyway. I don't know if I hope I have
- 47:24clarified it for you, and did anyone
- 47:25dare to tell me the difference between
- 47:27prevention and precaution? Or did they
- 47:29give me the runaround here?
- 47:31Uh, my hand is raised. MarĂa Sol.
- 47:35Let's
- 47:37see, it's your turn.
- 47:41Hello, good afternoon. Can you hear me?
- 47:43Yes.
- 47:45How are you? This is MarĂa Sol, I'm
- 47:46from Argentina. Well, what I understand
- 47:50is that the preventive principle
- 47:56attacks the source of the damage, even
- 48:00before it occurs. And the precautionary
- 48:05principle, as a difference, speaks of
- 48:09the fact that in the event of a danger
- 48:13of environmental damage, one must act
- 48:17invoking this principle even if there
- 48:21is no absolute scientific certainty,
- 48:25right? Regarding the issue of damage,
- 48:29so as not to postpone the solution.
- 48:32Well, that's it. Thank you.
- 48:34Thank you very much, Maria. Well, yes,
- 48:36perfect. As Maria said,
- 48:39when we talk about the precautionary
- 48:40principle, it's very easy, remember it.
- 48:42It has, oh, I lost it. There it has the
- 48:46small B. Prevent, prevention, avoid,
- 48:49evidence. Everything is written with a
- 48:52small B, it means that we have enough
- 48:54evidence and based on that sufficient
- 48:57evidence we take measures to avoid it
- 48:59and that's why we prevent. However,
- 49:02precaution, precautionary has a C and
- 49:05has to do with uncertainty. And in the
- 49:10face of this uncertainty, in any case,
- 49:12it is this uncertainty that gives us
- 49:15the possibility or forces us to take
- 49:17action, this, regarding the notion of
- 49:22certain activities to prevent damage
- 49:25from being committed; that then, the
- 49:28issue with environmental damage is that
- 49:31many times it is irreversible or its
- 49:34repair or remediation tends to be very
- 49:37costly, right? That is why we seek to
- 49:40prevent it from happening, from
- 49:42materializing. Well, Profepa is also
- 49:46authorized to file class actions. See,
- 49:50it has many caps, right? Uh, it is
- 49:53authorized to file class actions that
- 49:56are aimed more at protecting claims
- 49:59whose ownership corresponds to a group
- 50:02of people, as well as for the exercise
- 50:06of individual claims whose ownership
- 50:09corresponds to the members of a group
- 50:12of people. Now we are no longer in the
- 50:15General Law of Ecological Balance, we
- 50:17are no longer in the Federal Law of
- 50:19Environmental Protection, now we are in
- 50:21the Federal Code of Civil Procedures,
- 50:24right? So, look at all the rules and
- 50:26all the regulatory instruments that
- 50:29play or have an important role in
- 50:31environmental matters. Well, according
- 50:34to the Federal Code of Civil Procedure,
- 50:37class actions are classified into three
- 50:41categories: diffuse, strictly
- 50:43collective, and homogeneous individual.
- 50:47The ones that can be useful to us in
- 50:50environmental matters are diffuse
- 50:53actions that protect diffuse rights and
- 50:56interests with respect to undetermined
- 50:59groups; we don't know who they are. And
- 51:03so, the compensation for the damage
- 51:06does not necessarily require this link
- 51:08with the people, right? As we have been
- 51:11talking about the adjacent community
- 51:13and all this issue. And what the
- 51:16judgment seeks is the restitution of
- 51:18things or substitute compliance,
- 51:20because sometimes things cannot really
- 51:23be restored to the state they were in
- 51:25before the damage was caused. And the
- 51:29class action, strictly speaking, is
- 51:31oriented towards collective rights and
- 51:34interests, where it is possible to
- 51:37determine the affected group and the
- 51:40compensation is precisely intended for
- 51:43this group, although in the end it is
- 51:46individualized among the people who
- 51:49make up the group. Why is this category
- 51:53of class actions not so good for us?
- 51:56Because it is regulated. in a title
- 51:58that has to do with financial services,
- 52:01consumer protection and environmental
- 52:04protection. And it makes no sense that
- 52:07we put the protection of private,
- 52:10personal interests, such as consumption
- 52:13, against collective interests, such as
- 52:16the right to a healthy environment, in
- 52:19the same category. But I don't know
- 52:22what happened to the legislator who
- 52:24said, well, these are all good, these
- 52:26are all friends and we have to put them
- 52:28under the same rules, but it's not the
- 52:30best. Well, in this sense, regarding
- 52:33diffuse collective actions for
- 52:35environmental damage, we have a
- 52:37criterion from the First Chamber of the
- 52:40Court that determined that, in a
- 52:42diffuse collective action for
- 52:45environmental damage resulting from the
- 52:47construction of a real estate
- 52:49development, to prove legitimacy in the
- 52:52case, in the certification stage it was
- 52:55enough for the members of the community
- 52:58to state that they were inhabitants of
- 53:00the affected area or neighboring
- 53:02communities and to prove their address
- 53:04with a simple copy of a valid official
- 53:07identification, right? So, it says here
- 53:10, well, that was enough, but in reality
- 53:13a link to the area had to be proven,
- 53:15right? I had to say, well, here with my
- 53:18voter ID I can prove that I live in the
- 53:22area surrounding the place that is
- 53:24being impacted. Well, now we are going
- 53:28to change bodies. We already saw
- 53:30SEMARNAT, the Federal Attorney's Office
- 53:33, and now we are going to the National
- 53:35Water Commission. The National Water
- 53:38Commission is an administrative body
- 53:40that is also part of SEMARNAT. It also
- 53:44performs public law functions in
- 53:46matters of management of national
- 53:49waters and their inherent public assets
- 53:51and has technical, executive,
- 53:54administrative and budgetary autonomy,
- 53:56as well as management. What it seeks or
- 53:59or all its powers are regulated in
- 54:02various instruments, in the Organic Law
- 54:04of the Federal Public Administration,
- 54:07in the National Water Law, in the
- 54:09regulations of the National Water Law,
- 54:12in the internal regulations of SEMARNAT
- 54:15and now also in the General Water Law.
- 54:19Well, let's say that as a basic point,
- 54:22CONAGUA seeks to administer and
- 54:24safeguard national waters and their
- 54:27inherent public goods, manage and
- 54:29control the hydrological system, and
- 54:32promote and induce social development
- 54:35and the rights to water and sanitation.
- 54:40When we are speaking about water
- 54:43sanitation, it is not only a matter of
- 54:46the drainage system, is it? It involves
- 54:49improving water quality and reducing
- 54:51its contamination. When we increasingly
- 54:54hear, "water is running out," it is not
- 54:57that water is running out, because if
- 55:00we remember the water cycle, it is in
- 55:02this constant cycle. What we are
- 55:05reducing is the availability of water
- 55:08based on its conditions for human use
- 55:11and consumption. Why? Because we are
- 55:14not adequately treating the wastewater
- 55:17that we reincorporate into natural
- 55:19environments, right? Into bodies of
- 55:22water, rivers, lagoons, estuaries, and
- 55:25even the sea. So there is a connection,
- 55:29this right and this operation of
- 55:32CONagua implies a direct connection
- 55:34with an official Mexican standard. This
- 55:38official Mexican standard was recently
- 55:41updated to modify the classification of
- 55:45bodies receiving wastewater discharges,
- 55:49to strengthen the permissible limits of
- 55:52pollutants in these discharges, to
- 55:55decide their reception in the bodies
- 55:59that will assume them, to establish
- 56:02that wetlands and karst ecosystems
- 56:05require particular discharge conditions
- 56:08; they are sites much more vulnerable
- 56:11to contamination. Parameters of color
- 56:15and acute toxicity were also included,
- 56:18as well as a conformity assessment
- 56:20procedure and an obligation to have
- 56:23sampling ports at points close to the
- 56:26discharge. Regarding this entire
- 56:29official Mexican standard, many people
- 56:31who followed it realized just how
- 56:33complex the process of approval
- 56:34actually was. And why? Because when an
- 56:39industry, a factory or a municipality
- 56:42is discharging its wastewater without
- 56:46treatment, it is actually generating an
- 56:50environmental liability. an
- 56:53environmental liability that we are
- 56:56going to assume, well, first the
- 56:58ecosystems that are receiving this
- 57:00water without adequate treatment, then
- 57:03the species that inhabit these
- 57:05ecosystems, both plants and animals,
- 57:07and then us, right? At the end of the
- 57:10day. So, we have to deal with all this
- 57:13awareness, as you said at the beginning
- 57:16of your chat, with environmental
- 57:18education, with raising awareness that
- 57:21protecting the environment, the
- 57:24environment, protecting water should
- 57:27not be seen only as a cost issue, for
- 57:29example, for companies, for industry,
- 57:32but as an obligation, and it does not
- 57:35have to become an environmental
- 57:38liability. If you are receiving a
- 57:40lawful profit from the economic
- 57:43activity you receive, you have to
- 57:45include wastewater treatment in your
- 57:48costs. In this context, the obligation
- 57:52of water management to prevent and
- 57:54control pollution and the
- 57:56responsibility for environmental damage
- 57:58, which separates water management, the
- 58:00prevention and control of this
- 58:02pollution, and the responsibility for
- 58:04this damage, becomes relevant. Here we
- 58:08have that, in this topic of management,
- 58:13it is seen as a process based on
- 58:15principles, policies, resources,
- 58:18instruments, and norms that involve
- 58:21resources, rights, powers, and
- 58:23responsibilities from which the State
- 58:27must coordinate with water users, the
- 58:30different water users, and
- 58:32organizations in society and promote
- 58:35and implement sustainable development
- 58:38based on these strategies that are
- 58:41developed or defined to control and
- 58:43manage water and hydrological basins,
- 58:46regulate the exploitation and use of
- 58:49water, and preserve and achieve the
- 58:52sustainability of water resources. Well
- 58:56, here we see how CONAGUA takes on this
- 58:59important role in matters of pollution
- 59:01prevention and control. And the Law,
- 59:03here we are in the National Water Law,
- 59:06states that individuals or legal
- 59:08entities, including agencies,
- 59:11organizations, and entities of the
- 59:13three levels of government that exploit
- 59:16, use, or take advantage of national
- 59:18waters for any purpose or activity, are
- 59:21responsible for taking measures to
- 59:23prevent their contamination and
- 59:26reintegrate them in adequate conditions
- 59:28. This means providing treatment for
- 59:31that wastewater and, in doing so,
- 59:33maintaining the delicate balance of
- 59:35those vital ecosystems. The National
- 59:40Water Law itself tells us that it is up
- 59:44to PROFEPA. Now PROFEPA comes in, but
- 59:46we continue with water matters.
- 59:49Formulating complaints and sanctions in
- 59:51matters within its jurisdiction
- 59:53regarding water, national waters.
- 59:56Resolving administrative procedures and
- 59:58appeals in these matters. Imposing
- 1:00:01technical and corrective safety
- 1:00:03measures and promoting actions to
- 1:00:06repair or compensate for environmental
- 1:00:08damage to ecosystems associated with
- 1:00:11water. It also tells us that it is up
- 1:00:14to PROFEPA to request the cancellation
- 1:00:17of discharge permits. Note carefully,
- 1:00:19the cancellation of discharge permits
- 1:00:23when these discharges are causing
- 1:00:25damage to aquatic ecosystems. And then
- 1:00:30we move on to the area of
- 1:00:31responsibility for environmental damage
- 1:00:34within the scope of CONAGUA. Here the
- 1:00:37National Water Law itself tells us that
- 1:00:40it is up to CONAGUA to intervene to
- 1:00:43ensure that environmental damage is
- 1:00:46repaired, including damage that
- 1:00:48compromises vital ecosystem services,
- 1:00:51right? It also tells us that
- 1:00:55individuals and legal entities that
- 1:00:57discharge wastewater in violation of
- 1:01:00administrative or legal provisions and
- 1:01:02thereby cause contamination of
- 1:01:04receiving bodies must assume
- 1:01:06responsibility for repairing or
- 1:01:08compensating for the environmental
- 1:01:10damage. The problem in environmental
- 1:01:13terms is compensation. How do we assess
- 1:01:17environmental damage? How do we put
- 1:01:20numbers on it? As we say, this aquifer
- 1:01:22that is completely contaminated is
- 1:01:25compensated with this economic amount
- 1:01:28and that is the first problem, the
- 1:01:30assessment of environmental damage. The
- 1:01:33second problem, I don't know how it
- 1:01:36happens in our sister countries, but
- 1:01:38here the economic resources that are
- 1:01:41collected through all these
- 1:01:43environmental sanctions go to the
- 1:01:45federation, but they go to the general
- 1:01:48treasury, they do not go to a specific
- 1:01:51environmental area. So, although they
- 1:01:54are collected for environmental damage,
- 1:01:57they are not necessarily used to repair
- 1:02:00the environmental damage and that is a
- 1:02:03problem. That is why we are
- 1:02:05particularly interested in preventing
- 1:02:09it. CONagua, in support of river basin
- 1:02:12organizations, can intervene to
- 1:02:14implement the repair of damage to
- 1:02:17receiving bodies caused by extractions
- 1:02:19or discharges, right? Bodies of water
- 1:02:24can also be damaged not only by the
- 1:02:26untreated wastewater they receive, but
- 1:02:29also by over-extraction or
- 1:02:31over-exploitation of bodies of water.
- 1:02:36Here we have a very recent ruling,
- 1:02:39although it says 90, I mean 22, it is
- 1:02:42still under discussion. It is a ruling
- 1:02:45in which SEMARNAT, CONAGA, and the
- 1:02:48region's river basin agency are accused
- 1:02:52of omissions, as responsible for
- 1:02:55effective control of the extraction and
- 1:02:58exploitation, use or exploitation of
- 1:03:01surface and subsoil waters, to the
- 1:03:04serious detriment of the main aquifer
- 1:03:07of the lagoon region and the
- 1:03:10beneficiaries of its environmental
- 1:03:13services, as well as the possible
- 1:03:16analysis of the concessions that were
- 1:03:18granted due to an alleged deficit in
- 1:03:21the main aquifer. This ruling is very
- 1:03:24relevant because it involves a region
- 1:03:27of the country known as the lagoon
- 1:03:29region, which is a region located in
- 1:03:32the north of the country, where there
- 1:03:35is a very large and very strong dairy
- 1:03:38and livestock industry, right? So, all
- 1:03:42the concessions that CONAGA should have
- 1:03:45been granting to the concessionaires
- 1:03:48should have been based on the water
- 1:03:51availability agreements that they
- 1:03:53supported, since it was available for
- 1:03:56them. However, there was an excess in
- 1:04:00the granting of these concessions, a
- 1:04:03lack of wastewater treatment, a lack of
- 1:04:06follow-up by the State in its duty of
- 1:04:09surveillance, inspection and respective
- 1:04:12sanctions. And all of this together
- 1:04:15resulted in the availability of water
- 1:04:18from the main aquifer of this region
- 1:04:20being compromised. Now, when we look at
- 1:04:26who the authorities are, we see that
- 1:04:29they are all environmental authorities,
- 1:04:32but we also see that they are not
- 1:04:34acting in line with the obligations of
- 1:04:37due diligence. The State has the
- 1:04:40obligation to act diligently and not
- 1:04:43just to be at a window granting and
- 1:04:45granting and granting concessions. We
- 1:04:48do not have to monitor how the aquifer
- 1:04:51is behaving and how the concessionaires
- 1:04:54are behaving with respect to the
- 1:04:57respective concessions. And this did
- 1:05:00not happen that way. It is also
- 1:05:04important to note that here we have a
- 1:05:06ruling from the Court that addresses
- 1:05:08the exploitation of water, which
- 1:05:10implies the right to prior consultation
- 1:05:13of indigenous peoples and communities.
- 1:05:16The criterion tells us that the Mexican
- 1:05:19State must guarantee the right to prior
- 1:05:22, free, and informed consultation of
- 1:05:24indigenous peoples and communities
- 1:05:27before issuing any act that could
- 1:05:29affect the hydrological region from
- 1:05:31which they benefit. This is within the
- 1:05:37framework of Convention 169, taking
- 1:05:39into account the role that water plays,
- 1:05:42not only for the subsistence of these
- 1:05:44communities and peoples, but also as
- 1:05:47part of their cultural heritage and
- 1:05:49traditions. So, here we see how the
- 1:05:52Court begins to expressly incorporate
- 1:05:55these rights in relation to indigenous
- 1:05:58peoples and communities and, we could
- 1:06:01also say, Afro-Mexicans. Well, the
- 1:06:05General Water Law was recently issued
- 1:06:08because we were lagging behind. The
- 1:06:11National Water Law was never updated to
- 1:06:14recognize the human right to water and
- 1:06:17sanitation. The National Water Law
- 1:06:20dates from 1992 and we had a deficit in
- 1:06:23terms of recognizing rights. If I have
- 1:06:27been telling you that environmental
- 1:06:30matters are concurrent and that most of
- 1:06:33our environmental laws are therefore
- 1:06:35general, then what would have been
- 1:06:38appropriate would have been to have a
- 1:06:41general national water law that would
- 1:06:43regulate all issues associated with
- 1:06:46these goods, right? National waters and
- 1:06:49also the human right to water and
- 1:06:52sanitation. However, in this country
- 1:06:55anything can happen and we have two
- 1:06:58laws around the same environmental
- 1:07:02element, which is water. The National
- 1:07:06Water Law is still in force, which has
- 1:07:09this eminently administrative focus, on
- 1:07:11the use, management and administration
- 1:07:14of water as national goods and the
- 1:07:17inspection, surveillance and sanctions
- 1:07:19associated with these uses, concessions
- 1:07:22, permits and so on. And we also issued
- 1:07:25the General Water Law, which seeks to
- 1:07:28regulate the enjoyment of the human
- 1:07:31right to water and sanitation. Here it
- 1:07:35is interesting to see how the General
- 1:07:37Water Law tells us that the human right
- 1:07:40to water is linked to the respect,
- 1:07:42protection and guarantee of the human
- 1:07:44right to a healthy environment, as we
- 1:07:47saw at the beginning of this session,
- 1:07:49and the quality and environment as
- 1:07:51determinants of the population's health
- 1:07:54. So, if you notice, here it is
- 1:07:56interfering with the rights to water,
- 1:07:58the environment, and health. Then, the
- 1:08:02General Water Law itself involves not
- 1:08:05only SEMARNAT, but also another actor,
- 1:08:08which is the Ministry of Health. And it
- 1:08:12tells us that the Ministry of Health
- 1:08:14and its decentralized bodies, in
- 1:08:16coordination with the States—remember
- 1:08:19that this is a concurrent law—and
- 1:08:21Mexico City, will implement measures
- 1:08:23focused on the prevention, treatment
- 1:08:25and control of diseases associated with
- 1:08:27the lack of adequate services and water
- 1:08:30pollution. So, see how, once again,
- 1:08:33other actors are participating in this
- 1:08:37resource. Here we have another
- 1:08:40precedent that tells us about the right
- 1:08:42to a healthy environment and to public
- 1:08:44health, right? In this binomial, its
- 1:08:46guarantee cannot be conditioned by
- 1:08:49purely economic criteria. Here the
- 1:08:52Court tells us that the right to a
- 1:08:54healthy environment has both an
- 1:08:56objective and subjective dimension. And
- 1:08:59, from its objective perspective, it
- 1:09:02implies the existence of a regulatory
- 1:09:04and institutional system that
- 1:09:06guarantees the preservation and
- 1:09:08restoration of ecosystems; while, in
- 1:09:11the subjective dimension, which refers
- 1:09:13to individuals, it recognizes the right
- 1:09:16of every person to demand adequate
- 1:09:18environmental conditions for their
- 1:09:20development and well-being. But it also
- 1:09:23emphasizes how, based on this duality,
- 1:09:26the protection of the environment is
- 1:09:29not only a constitutional imperative,
- 1:09:32but also acquires an intrinsic value
- 1:09:35that transcends any cost-benefit
- 1:09:37analysis. Consequently, this implies
- 1:09:41that the authorities are
- 1:09:42constitutionally obligated to protect
- 1:09:44the right to a healthy environment and
- 1:09:47to health, without conditioning its
- 1:09:49effectiveness to possible economic
- 1:09:51repercussions, right? Which was always
- 1:09:54the State's excuse of not having enough
- 1:09:56resources, not enough budget. Well,
- 1:09:59here the Court says, well, let's see
- 1:10:01how you do it, right? Because that's
- 1:10:03not a good excuse. Well, here the
- 1:10:06National Water Law, the General Water
- 1:10:08Law, sorry, again links SEMARNAT with
- 1:10:11CONA Agua and tells us that both must
- 1:10:13coordinate to exercise the necessary
- 1:10:16powers to guarantee the effective
- 1:10:18enjoyment of the human right to water
- 1:10:21and sanitation. And look here what the
- 1:10:24law incorporates, with an approach
- 1:10:27based on human rights, gender
- 1:10:29perspective, interculturality,
- 1:10:31intersectionality, intergenerational
- 1:10:34equity, disability and also the best
- 1:10:37interests of children and adolescents.
- 1:10:40So it is a law built with a
- 1:10:44rights-based approach. Now, let's go
- 1:10:49back to SEMARNAT. SEMARNAT is obligated
- 1:10:53to share information, to make
- 1:10:56transparent information that has to do
- 1:11:00with protected natural areas, Mexican
- 1:11:04species at risk, waste generation type
- 1:11:10volume, entity year, the average annual
- 1:11:13availability of surface and groundwater
- 1:11:17by hydrological region. So, see how,
- 1:11:21once again, the issue of water comes
- 1:11:23into play, and there, the national
- 1:11:26inventory of municipal water
- 1:11:28purification and wastewater treatment
- 1:11:30plants is complemented, but also the
- 1:11:33list of contaminated areas by type of
- 1:11:35pollutant and location. It must also
- 1:11:39provide us with information on the
- 1:11:41types of forest vegetation, soils,
- 1:11:44conservation, protection and
- 1:11:46restoration areas, as well as changes
- 1:11:49in the dynamics of forest vegetation,
- 1:11:52sustainability criteria and indicators,
- 1:11:55deforestation, ecosystem degradation,
- 1:11:57statements and resolutions on
- 1:12:00environmental impact, statistical
- 1:12:02information on infractions and the
- 1:12:05citizen participation index. And all
- 1:12:08these obligations are framed in a new
- 1:12:10law that is none of the ones we have
- 1:12:13mentioned, which is now the General Law
- 1:12:16on Transparency and Access to Public
- 1:12:18Information of 2025. What I want you to
- 1:12:21see is that the environmental
- 1:12:23regulatory framework is not in one
- 1:12:26instrument, nor is it only in the
- 1:12:28instruments that by their name have to
- 1:12:31do with environmental issues. It
- 1:12:33permeates various instruments and
- 1:12:36government entities, which is why it is
- 1:12:39important to have a general map of
- 1:12:42interconnections. In terms of access to
- 1:12:46water information, we have two amparos
- 1:12:48here. The amparo under review 30726, in
- 1:12:51which it was assumed that people have
- 1:12:54the right to access information about
- 1:12:56the environment held by authorities,
- 1:12:59and it is the State's obligation to
- 1:13:02promote and raise awareness of citizen
- 1:13:04participation. It was also stated that
- 1:13:07the State must create institutional and
- 1:13:10legal tools that seek to include
- 1:13:12citizens in the control of public
- 1:13:15policy with environmental impact. The
- 1:13:19next amparo is a direct amparo under
- 1:13:22review, 3218217, which speaks to the
- 1:13:27recognition of access to water as a
- 1:13:30human right and the State's
- 1:13:32corresponding obligation to guarantee
- 1:13:34its compliance within the framework of
- 1:13:37diligence by the water authority in
- 1:13:40planning national water policy, based
- 1:13:42on real and timely information on the
- 1:13:45state of the nation's basins and
- 1:13:47aquifers. This is obviously very
- 1:13:50closely linked to the long-term
- 1:13:53sustainable development of watersheds,
- 1:13:56right? And it also has to do with
- 1:13:59ensuring that real availability is
- 1:14:01monitored, whether we are, as I was
- 1:14:03saying, simply granting concessions
- 1:14:06without interruption or without
- 1:14:08interruption. Well, we will now return
- 1:14:12to the ProfEPA and SEMARN, but with a
- 1:14:15new law, which is the Federal
- 1:14:17Environmental Liability Law. This law
- 1:14:21seeks to regulate this type of
- 1:14:23liability as a consequence of damage
- 1:14:26caused to the environment and, after
- 1:14:29that, of course, seek redress and
- 1:14:31compensation for this damage. Something
- 1:14:36important that we need to see is that
- 1:14:38this law is governed by the rules of
- 1:14:40civil law. And here, speaking of
- 1:14:43environmental damage within the
- 1:14:45framework of this law, we have a
- 1:14:47precedent that tells us about
- 1:14:49environmental damage, its
- 1:14:51characteristics, and its evidentiary
- 1:14:53standard. The Federal Environmental
- 1:14:56Liability Law, pay close attention to
- 1:14:58how it defines environmental damage. It
- 1:15:01states: "It is the adverse and
- 1:15:03measurable loss, change, deterioration,
- 1:15:05impairment, affectation or modification
- 1:15:08of habitats, ecosystems, elements and
- 1:15:11natural resources, their chemical,
- 1:15:13physical or biological conditions and
- 1:15:15the interaction relationships that
- 1:15:18occur between them, as well as the
- 1:15:20environmental services they provide."
- 1:15:23That is the regulatory definition of
- 1:15:25federal law. What does the court say?
- 1:15:29This definition must be interpreted in
- 1:15:32light of the EscasĂş agreement, as well
- 1:15:35as the principles of environmental law,
- 1:15:38especially precautionary and indubio
- 1:15:41pronatura. When studying the existence
- 1:15:44of environmental damage, it must be
- 1:15:47taken into account that it can be
- 1:15:50generated by one or several actions
- 1:15:53over time, so environmental damage can
- 1:15:56be continuous, permanent and
- 1:15:58progressive. Progressiveness means that
- 1:16:03the damage involves a series of
- 1:16:06successive acts that together cause
- 1:16:08greater damage than the sum of each of
- 1:16:12the individual damages. This ruling by
- 1:16:16the court is very important because if
- 1:16:18we only stick to the normative
- 1:16:20definition, which is in the first
- 1:16:23paragraph, it would seem that
- 1:16:25everything happens at one time and ends
- 1:16:27there. And what the court is telling
- 1:16:31you is that there cannot necessarily be
- 1:16:35a progressive, simultaneous process,
- 1:16:37right? And also, when we assess
- 1:16:40environmental impact, well, even there
- 1:16:43we see what is called environmental
- 1:16:46impact, right? Or environmental damage,
- 1:16:48synergistic environmental impact, and
- 1:16:51cumulative environmental impact, which
- 1:16:53are concepts that imply different
- 1:16:56effects. And in that sense, the same
- 1:17:00court tells us that in order to
- 1:17:02establish environmental damage, the
- 1:17:05judge must take into account that it is
- 1:17:09continuous, permanent, and progressive.
- 1:17:13And in that sense, it is neither
- 1:17:15adequate nor proportionate to require
- 1:17:17that concrete and fully measurable
- 1:17:20damage to the environment be
- 1:17:21convincingly demonstrated, as the
- 1:17:24normative provision states. On the
- 1:17:27contrary, it is enough that there is
- 1:17:29sufficient information to glimpse that
- 1:17:32we are talking about a possibility,
- 1:17:34right? In order to reasonably foresee
- 1:17:38the existence of an adverse effect
- 1:17:40generated to the environment by the
- 1:17:42conduct of the defendant. See the
- 1:17:44completely different approach of the
- 1:17:47Court to the approach of the legislator
- 1:17:49. Well, in this same federal law on
- 1:17:54environmental liability, regarding
- 1:17:57legitimacy, it tells us that
- 1:17:59individuals, inhabitants of the
- 1:18:01adjacent community have it, and see
- 1:18:03again how it speaks, to the damage
- 1:18:05caused to the environment. This precept
- 1:18:09of the first faction is preventive in
- 1:18:14nature. Who can tell me yes or no?
- 1:18:17Quickly, I can act if I am from the
- 1:18:24adjacent community, from the place
- 1:18:26where the damage occurred. Is that
- 1:18:28preventive?
- 1:18:31In the chat, the majority are saying
- 1:18:33yes.
- 1:18:35Okay.
- 1:18:35Because there are no handymen here now.
- 1:18:37Okay. Well, no. It is not preventive
- 1:18:41because it is referring to the damage
- 1:18:44caused, not to the damage that could
- 1:18:47possibly be caused. So, this law is not
- 1:18:52having a preventive nature, it is
- 1:18:55waiting for the damage to be consumed
- 1:18:58to allow me to act, to allow me to go
- 1:19:01to court. And so, here, for example, we
- 1:19:05see how under this logic of the law,
- 1:19:08the courts rule and it is not a
- 1:19:10preventive nature. The 2016 review
- 1:19:13amparo on the contamination of the
- 1:19:17rivers next to Yyac. In one of the
- 1:19:21paragraphs, the judge argues that the
- 1:19:25complainant only had a simple interest
- 1:19:29and did not prove a legitimate interest
- 1:19:33by not demonstrating specific damage to
- 1:19:37her or to Oaxacan society. If we stick
- 1:19:41with these views like the one this
- 1:19:44judge has, then there would never be
- 1:19:49prevention in environmental matters; we
- 1:19:52would only be reactive and would be
- 1:19:54responding only to completed damages.
- 1:20:01The preventive nature of environmental
- 1:20:04law would be blurred with these
- 1:20:06provisions. That is why this standard
- 1:20:10of the court is so important, which
- 1:20:13says, "No, you do not have to stick
- 1:20:16with this definition of measurable and
- 1:20:20that's it." No, no, because it is
- 1:20:24continuous and we must act only with
- 1:20:27the possibility that a negative effect
- 1:20:30exists or may exist. However, this law
- 1:20:33is still alive; it exists. That is why
- 1:20:36we must make them see it. Likewise, the
- 1:20:40Court has told us that in terms of
- 1:20:42environmental liability, Article 28 of
- 1:20:44this same Federal Environmental
- 1:20:46Liability Law violates the right to
- 1:20:48effective judicial protection. Why?
- 1:20:51Because it tells us that Mexican
- 1:20:54non-profit legal entities, that is,
- 1:20:57non-governmental organizations, must
- 1:20:59act on behalf of an inhabitant of the
- 1:21:02community adjacent to the damage; again
- 1:21:05, to the damage caused, that is, what
- 1:21:08happened, and prove that they were
- 1:21:11legally constituted at least 3 years
- 1:21:14before the lawsuit was filed. And what
- 1:21:17the Court says is: "This requirement of
- 1:21:20being constituted at least 3 years
- 1:21:22before violates the Constitution and
- 1:21:25violates the American Convention on
- 1:21:27Human Rights regarding the right to
- 1:21:30effective judicial protection," because
- 1:21:32it is imposing a requirement, well,
- 1:21:35that occurred to it, that the
- 1:21:37organizations had to have been
- 1:21:39constituted for at least 3 years, right
- 1:21:42? Which is not required with respect to
- 1:21:45collective and diffuse actions that we
- 1:21:47have already seen are regulated in the
- 1:21:50Federal Code of Civil Procedures. So
- 1:21:53what the Court says is, there is a
- 1:21:55symmetry, a greater requirement in this
- 1:21:57law and you would not have to place it,
- 1:22:00right? It is also important that we
- 1:22:02look at that. The Court also tells us
- 1:22:06that the prescription provided for in
- 1:22:08the same law that we are talking about,
- 1:22:10uh, article 29 of the Federal Law on
- 1:22:14Environmental Responsibility,
- 1:22:16establishes that the action prescribes
- 1:22:18in 12 years, take note carefully when,
- 1:22:21uh, counted from the day on which the
- 1:22:23damage to the environment and its
- 1:22:25effects occur. The legislator
- 1:22:29distinguishes that the prescription
- 1:22:31will begin from the moment in which the
- 1:22:33damages were caused and also refers to
- 1:22:35the effects, which allows us to
- 1:22:37interpret that the beginning of the
- 1:22:39term does not necessarily occur at a
- 1:22:41single moment when the damages are
- 1:22:43caused, but also when its effects occur
- 1:22:45. This situation allows us to conclude
- 1:22:48that the period for starting the
- 1:22:50calculation of the statute of
- 1:22:51limitations must begin not only from
- 1:22:53the moment the damages are caused, but
- 1:22:56also from the moment the effects are
- 1:22:58known, which is very different and can
- 1:23:00be years apart. Secondly, this
- 1:23:02interpretation takes into account the
- 1:23:05nature of the acts claimed in this type
- 1:23:07of action, which, due to their
- 1:23:09characteristics, cannot occur at a
- 1:23:11single moment, nor can they necessarily
- 1:23:14be known at the moment in which they
- 1:23:16occur, but rather this can happen when
- 1:23:18the effects occur. For example, if we
- 1:23:22have discharges to a certain body or to
- 1:23:25the ground that are causing
- 1:23:27contamination, as a result of which
- 1:23:29people are getting cancer, we will not
- 1:23:32know about it the day the damage
- 1:23:35occurred, we will know about it in 8
- 1:23:37years. So, this is very important and
- 1:23:40that is why the statute of limitations
- 1:23:42becomes very relevant in these contexts
- 1:23:49. Okay, another actor comes in here,
- 1:23:52which is the National Agency for
- 1:23:54Industrial Safety and Environmental
- 1:23:56Protection of the Hydrocarbons Sector,
- 1:23:58whose acronym, I don't know why, is ACA
- 1:24:00, but it is ACA. Well, this is the
- 1:24:04value chain that the ACEA regulates in
- 1:24:08Mexico: from exploration, extraction,
- 1:24:12transportation, refining, storage,
- 1:24:15distribution, and marketing, all the
- 1:24:19way to retail sales, until you arrive
- 1:24:23at the gas station to get your fuel
- 1:24:26supply. All of that is covered by ACA
- 1:24:30regulation. And in this context, in
- 1:24:34which of these stages do you imagine,
- 1:24:37visualize, or are you clear that
- 1:24:40socio-environmental damage or damage to
- 1:24:43the right to a healthy environment
- 1:24:46could occur? Who can tell me? I know
- 1:24:50something always happens at this stage,
- 1:24:52or it is common for it to occur.
- 1:24:55Erika raised her hand.
- 1:24:58Erika, tell us. Are you there, Erika?
- 1:25:08Hello, good afternoon.
- 1:25:12Hi,
- 1:25:13if I hear you, you
- 1:25:14hear me now. Hello, good afternoon.
- 1:25:17Each one of them, I believe, causes
- 1:25:20damage, but I especially believe that
- 1:25:24the commercialization and sale to the
- 1:25:28public, since people make use of them.
- 1:25:31So, I think that is the one that causes
- 1:25:35the most damage.
- 1:25:37Thank you very much, Erika. Well, yes,
- 1:25:40as she rightly said, well, I think all
- 1:25:42of them, well, yes, all of them, since
- 1:25:44we are in exploration because we change
- 1:25:46the use of the land, because we cut
- 1:25:48down the jungle, because we displace
- 1:25:50the forest, we remove what is there to
- 1:25:52access the hydrocarbon resources. This
- 1:25:55agency regulates the production and the
- 1:25:57entire hydrocarbon process. So, well,
- 1:26:01in any of them we have the possibility
- 1:26:04of causing socio-environmental damage.
- 1:26:08Well, the CA is also an agency that
- 1:26:10depends on the Secretariat of the
- 1:26:11Environment and Natural Resources. It
- 1:26:14also has technical and management
- 1:26:16autonomy. And what it seeks, according
- 1:26:20to the regulations themselves, is the
- 1:26:22protection of people, the environment,
- 1:26:25and hydrocarbon sector facilities based
- 1:26:28on industrial and operational safety,
- 1:26:30regulation of dismantling and
- 1:26:32abandonment activities, and
- 1:26:34comprehensive control of waste and
- 1:26:37polluting emissions. And here we see
- 1:26:40the CA, because we see that it issues
- 1:26:42regulations and standards in matters of
- 1:26:44industrial safety and environmental
- 1:26:46protection. It is responsible for
- 1:26:50defining public policy in matters of
- 1:26:52energy, but also environmental
- 1:26:54protection and natural resources in the
- 1:26:56hydrocarbon sector. It also regulates
- 1:26:59assignees, contractors, authorized
- 1:27:01parties, and permit holders regarding
- 1:27:03actions to prevent and repair damage to
- 1:27:06the environment or ecological balance.
- 1:27:10Specifically, what this agency is
- 1:27:12assigned is the regulation of
- 1:27:15environmental impact and risk,
- 1:27:17confinement and disposal of waste,
- 1:27:20forestry exploitation in tropical
- 1:27:22rainforests, and species that are
- 1:27:25difficult to regenerate. and works and
- 1:27:28activities in wetlands, mangroves,
- 1:27:30lagoons, rivers, lakes and estuaries
- 1:27:33and connected to the sea with
- 1:27:34coastlines and also in federal zones,
- 1:27:37that is, everywhere. It also regulates
- 1:27:40the emission of odors, gases or solid
- 1:27:43or liquid particles into the atmosphere
- 1:27:45and carries out proposals for the
- 1:27:48remediation of sites contaminated with
- 1:27:50hydrocarbons and the release of
- 1:27:52corresponding remediation programs; the
- 1:27:55regulation of special handling waste
- 1:27:57and waste management plans associated
- 1:27:59with, uh, the operation of the
- 1:28:01hydrocarbon sector; and the release
- 1:28:04into the environment of genetically
- 1:28:06modified organisms for the
- 1:28:08bioremediation of sites contaminated
- 1:28:10with hydrocarbons. So, here again, as
- 1:28:13it would seem, what do we have to do
- 1:28:15with environmental protection in terms
- 1:28:17of hydrocarbons? No, those are over
- 1:28:19there and it is not that they have a
- 1:28:21very close relationship with
- 1:28:23environmental protection. Here I put
- 1:28:27the legislation that is involved with
- 1:28:29the powers of the CA. We have already
- 1:28:32seen much of it, practically from the
- 1:28:35second to the last. We would need the
- 1:28:38CA law and the hydrocarbons sector law.
- 1:28:42The hydrocarbons sector law on
- 1:28:44industrial and operational safety
- 1:28:47states that assignees, contractors, and
- 1:28:50permit holders are responsible for
- 1:28:52damages and losses caused by
- 1:28:54hydrocarbon leaks and spills and other
- 1:28:57damages resulting from their activities
- 1:29:00. This links the CEA to the
- 1:29:03hydrocarbons sector law. Likewise, it
- 1:29:06tells us that these people are
- 1:29:08obligated to notify the Energy
- 1:29:11Secretariat and the CA itself and other
- 1:29:14competent authorities of any accident
- 1:29:17or contingency that, as a result of
- 1:29:20their operations, endangers life,
- 1:29:22health, public safety, the environment,
- 1:29:25the safety of the facilities, etc. If
- 1:29:28you recall, a couple of months ago, we
- 1:29:31had a problem with some oil spills in
- 1:29:34the Gulf of Mexico where the oil
- 1:29:36reached the beaches; But many species
- 1:29:38of biodiversity were also affected, and
- 1:29:40the fact that the hydrocarbons have
- 1:29:43reached the beaches also signifies a
- 1:29:45major impact for those individuals who
- 1:29:47are dedicated to fishing, those who
- 1:29:49work in the tourism sector, and for
- 1:29:52many other economic activities that are
- 1:29:54closely related to these specific sites
- 1:29:56. In turn, the electricity sector law
- 1:30:00also speaks of promoting the economic
- 1:30:03and environmental responsibility of the
- 1:30:06public, social, and private sectors,
- 1:30:09because now, as you know, in Mexico,
- 1:30:11not only the public sector, but also
- 1:30:14the private and social sectors
- 1:30:16participate in the electricity sector.
- 1:30:20So, what this new law tells us is that
- 1:30:22actions must be promoted in terms of
- 1:30:25energy justice, which involves
- 1:30:28environmental and social issues, the
- 1:30:30use of clean energy sources, and the
- 1:30:33energy transition, as well as seeking
- 1:30:36to reduce polluting emissions and
- 1:30:39promote decarbonization. Oh, I ate
- 1:30:41myself. Promote decarbonization.
- 1:30:47Returning now to the environmental
- 1:30:50sphere, the National Commission of
- 1:30:52Protected Natural Areas has among its
- 1:30:55mandates to promote and modify the
- 1:30:58recategorization of protected natural
- 1:31:00areas, direct the conservation and
- 1:31:03protection policy to protect
- 1:31:05biodiversity with the participation—
- 1:31:08this is very important in environmental
- 1:31:11matters—of the owners or legitimate
- 1:31:13holders of the properties where these
- 1:31:16protected natural areas are located. It
- 1:31:19also seeks to evaluate subsidy programs
- 1:31:22that promote the development of
- 1:31:24priority activities of general interest
- 1:31:27that seek these same objectives. But
- 1:31:30here it involves, and is very important
- 1:31:33for countries that have social property
- 1:31:36, it involves the ejidos, agrarian
- 1:31:38communities, indigenous peoples and
- 1:31:40communities, and Afro-Mexicans. So, the
- 1:31:43involvement of the National Commission
- 1:31:46of Protected Natural Areas is very
- 1:31:48important. On this small map, you will
- 1:31:51see some of the main protected natural
- 1:31:54areas under federal jurisdiction where
- 1:31:58they are located, but this federal
- 1:32:00jurisdiction also extends to the state
- 1:32:03and municipal levels. Therefore, there
- 1:32:06may be many other protected natural
- 1:32:08areas in the country, even if they are
- 1:32:11not under federal jurisdiction, but
- 1:32:13which have some category of protection.
- 1:32:16For example, if we look at these
- 1:32:18protected natural areas here, there are
- 1:32:22biosphere reserves, national parks,
- 1:32:24natural monuments, flora and fauna
- 1:32:27protection areas, natural resource
- 1:32:30protection areas and sanctuaries; but
- 1:32:33we also have, at state level, natural
- 1:32:36parks, nature reserves and, at
- 1:32:38municipal level, ecological
- 1:32:40preservation zones in population
- 1:32:43centers. So, the country is mapped and
- 1:32:46marked by a series of recognitions of
- 1:32:49these types of areas where, uh,
- 1:32:51ownership continues to belong to the
- 1:32:54people. In other words, the property
- 1:32:57itself is not affected, nor is the
- 1:32:59ownership of said property, but what is
- 1:33:01indeed affected is what people are
- 1:33:04permitted to do within these natural
- 1:33:06areas. For this purpose, a management
- 1:33:10program is established, which
- 1:33:12determines the classification of each
- 1:33:15of these areas to define the protection
- 1:33:18areas, the exploitation areas and the
- 1:33:21buffer areas, as well as the core areas
- 1:33:24. And based on this determination, what
- 1:33:28activities can be carried out within
- 1:33:31each of these categories and what
- 1:33:33activities are not allowed. But I also
- 1:33:37want you to look at this map here,
- 1:33:39right? And here you see the entire
- 1:33:43section on flora and fauna and natural
- 1:33:46attractions. And see how it connects
- 1:33:50with the same map of protected natural
- 1:33:52areas, but here it is playing a role
- 1:33:54with Afor, which is the same commission
- 1:33:57that we are looking at, with Fonatur.
- 1:34:00And Fonatour is a national tourism fund
- 1:34:03that is promoting tourism development.
- 1:34:06And see where the areas of interest for
- 1:34:10tourism development are mapped
- 1:34:13according to Fonatur. Well, many of
- 1:34:16these areas fall into protected natural
- 1:34:19areas and in many of these protected
- 1:34:21natural areas there are indigenous and
- 1:34:24Afro-Mexican towns and communities that
- 1:34:26should also be taken into account or
- 1:34:29given a voice and vote in deciding what
- 1:34:31to do. As I was saying, natural areas
- 1:34:36must have a management plan or program
- 1:34:39that must be developed jointly with
- 1:34:42SEMARNAP to define what will be done
- 1:34:44within this management program, as I
- 1:34:47was saying, depending on the core area,
- 1:34:51buffer area, and utilization area. And
- 1:34:55we are introducing a new environmental
- 1:34:58protection entity, the National
- 1:35:00Institute of Ecology and Climate Change
- 1:35:03. This institute also belongs to the
- 1:35:07Ministry of Environment and Natural
- 1:35:09Resources and its powers include
- 1:35:12national policy on biosafety,
- 1:35:14sustainable development, environmental
- 1:35:17protection, preservation and protection
- 1:35:20of ecological balance, conservation of
- 1:35:23ecosystems, and climate change. It has
- 1:35:26been established as the institute that
- 1:35:29provides technical and scientific
- 1:35:31information to SEMARN for the
- 1:35:33development of this policy. But
- 1:35:36fundamentally, INEC has focused on the
- 1:35:40first areas, which are climate change
- 1:35:43policy, emissions mitigation, and
- 1:35:45vulnerability and adaptation to climate
- 1:35:48change in the country. All of this
- 1:35:51within the framework of the United
- 1:35:54Nations Framework Convention on Climate
- 1:35:56Change and the Paris Agreement. When we
- 1:36:01think of climate change, it's not just
- 1:36:03about the heat, the rain, or the
- 1:36:06drought. No, it involves impacts on
- 1:36:09coastal areas in all kinds of ways:
- 1:36:12from the loss of coastlines, to forced
- 1:36:15displacement, to the loss of economic
- 1:36:18activities, to the ability to work, to
- 1:36:22armed conflicts, to the deterioration
- 1:36:25of access to drinking water, to water
- 1:36:28salinization. There is also a decrease
- 1:36:32in agricultural productivity, higher
- 1:36:35prices, food costs, increased poverty,
- 1:36:38an increase in the frequency and
- 1:36:41intensity of extreme events, the spread
- 1:36:44of diseases and, again, death, right?
- 1:36:47That is also climate change. Well, the
- 1:36:50National Institute of Ecology and
- 1:36:52Climate Change, within the framework of
- 1:36:55its policy on climate adaptation, has
- 1:36:57prepared this national atlas of
- 1:36:59vulnerability to climate change in
- 1:37:02Mexico. It is an atlas that is
- 1:37:04disaggregated by components of
- 1:37:06vulnerability, that is, social,
- 1:37:08economic, by types of vulnerability and
- 1:37:11also by categories. It is available
- 1:37:14online, you can Google it, you can go
- 1:37:16down to your municipality, you can go
- 1:37:18down to your state and realize the
- 1:37:20vulnerability. Now, realizing the
- 1:37:23vulnerability is not just, oh, yes, we
- 1:37:25are vulnerable, we already realized it.
- 1:37:29What the Court says in this regard is
- 1:37:31that based on these vulnerabilities and
- 1:37:34these instruments called risk atlases,
- 1:37:36they must be updated whenever there are
- 1:37:38significant changes in the conditions
- 1:37:40of the territory and the population.
- 1:37:43And why? The Court tells us: the risk
- 1:37:46atlas has an eminently preventive
- 1:37:49nature, since, as a comprehensive
- 1:37:51information system on disaster risk, it
- 1:37:54must be capable of including updated,
- 1:37:57inclusive information in real time;
- 1:38:00especially taking into account that
- 1:38:03hazards and threats are constantly
- 1:38:06changing due to various factors, both
- 1:38:09natural and human, including climate
- 1:38:11change, urban development, demographic
- 1:38:15changes, infrastructure and the
- 1:38:17development of megaprojects. The
- 1:38:20failure to update these types of
- 1:38:22instruments, risk atlases, prevents
- 1:38:24addressing the dynamic nature of risk;
- 1:38:27and that, in turn, restricts the
- 1:38:29authorities and the population from
- 1:38:31knowing the elements present in the
- 1:38:33territory in which they live, including
- 1:38:36the dangers, the conditions that make
- 1:38:38them vulnerable, and the measures
- 1:38:40necessary to mitigate or prevent
- 1:38:43disasters and address emergency
- 1:38:45situations, where appropriate, even to
- 1:38:47avoid the loss of life and property. So
- 1:38:50, if you notice, it is not trivial to
- 1:38:53have updated, accessible, and available
- 1:38:57risk atlases, not only for public
- 1:39:00decision-making, but also for society.
- 1:39:04And the Court also tells us that the
- 1:39:06right to a healthy environment, in its
- 1:39:09essential core, is a genuine human
- 1:39:11right that entails the right for every
- 1:39:14person, as part of a community, to
- 1:39:16demand effective protection of the
- 1:39:19environment in which they live, but
- 1:39:21also the correlative right to protect
- 1:39:24nature for the value it has in itself,
- 1:39:27right? This intrinsic value of
- 1:39:29environmental elements, which implies
- 1:39:32their essential core of protection,
- 1:39:35goes beyond the most immediate
- 1:39:37objectives of human beings, that is,
- 1:39:40moving from our anthropocentric vision
- 1:39:43to a more ecocentric perspective. In
- 1:39:46this sense, human rights are based on
- 1:39:49the idea of solidarity that entails an
- 1:39:52analysis of legitimate interests and
- 1:39:54not only subjective rights and freedoms
- 1:39:57. In this context, obligation prevails
- 1:40:01over law and we are faced with
- 1:40:04collective responsibilities rather than
- 1:40:07individual prerogatives. In this line,
- 1:40:11the environmental paradigm is based on
- 1:40:13an idea of complex interaction between
- 1:40:16human beings and nature that takes into
- 1:40:19account the present and future
- 1:40:21individual and collective effects of
- 1:40:24human action. If you notice, here we
- 1:40:27are already looking at a change, right?
- 1:40:29Conceptual, right? Even teleological.
- 1:40:35The Court also tells us that the right
- 1:40:37to a healthy environment must be
- 1:40:39resolved by the jurisdictional
- 1:40:41authorities of the various
- 1:40:43jurisdictions and matters in order to
- 1:40:45defend it in accordance with its
- 1:40:48guiding principles, as it is a
- 1:40:50cross-cutting right and the survival of
- 1:40:52all forms of life is at risk, not just
- 1:40:55ours, not just humans. Here the court
- 1:40:58states that the defense of the right to
- 1:41:01a healthy environment...To this end,
- 1:41:03the jurisdictional authorities of the
- 1:41:05various jurisdictions and matters must
- 1:41:07resolve in accordance with these
- 1:41:09guiding principles. And what are the
- 1:41:12guiding principles of the right to a
- 1:41:13healthy environment? The preventive,
- 1:41:17precautionary, indubio pronatura
- 1:41:20principles, right? All of these
- 1:41:22principles are what you will be working
- 1:41:26on throughout the diploma course. The
- 1:41:31Court also tells us that national
- 1:41:35courts are obliged, within their sphere
- 1:41:38of jurisdiction, to provide all
- 1:41:41necessary and pertinent measures to
- 1:41:43guarantee this right, and this must be
- 1:41:46carried out regardless of the subject
- 1:41:49matter of their specialization, that is
- 1:41:52, of the court. The subject matter does
- 1:41:54not matter, nor does the territorial
- 1:41:56jurisdiction. in accordance with the
- 1:41:59duties and responsibilities that each
- 1:42:01authority has in terms of the General
- 1:42:03Law on Ecological Balance. And this
- 1:42:05implies that the jurisdictional body is
- 1:42:07empowered to give notice to the
- 1:42:09authorities that do not have
- 1:42:10regulations favorable to the
- 1:42:12environment so that if they deem it
- 1:42:14necessary, they can consider it and
- 1:42:16address it. Well, here I left you other
- 1:42:19slides, this one, that also have more
- 1:42:21precedents on this right to a healthy
- 1:42:24human environment, but I don't know if
- 1:42:26you want us to stop, if you want us to
- 1:42:29talk a little bit or if I should
- 1:42:31continue telling you the slides. So,
- 1:42:33tell me, Sil, what do we do?
- 1:42:35Yes, well I was thinking, look, there
- 1:42:38are like several questions and maybe if
- 1:42:40you want I can do them in blocks.
- 1:42:42Yeah. And well, to answer people who
- 1:42:45have several doubts, precisely about
- 1:42:48the first topic which is about repair,
- 1:42:51here I put together some questions,
- 1:42:53well, that were related to the same
- 1:42:56thing; and what they say is that if,
- 1:42:59precisely, repair is the only way,
- 1:43:01right? Well, is the only way to do it
- 1:43:03through financial payment or is there
- 1:43:05another way, right?, to do this repair
- 1:43:08and how is this calculated or valued?
- 1:43:12Also in that same sense, which specific
- 1:43:15experts are actually authorized to make
- 1:43:17this assessment and how does this
- 1:43:22process function in practice? And they
- 1:43:24tell us that in Mexico City it says
- 1:43:26that there are regulations that apply
- 1:43:28to repair, which are in the area of
- 1:43:30trees and greenery
- 1:43:32and where a financial amount is
- 1:43:34established and if there is something
- 1:43:35similar at the federal level.
- 1:43:38Well, I think it is very important to
- 1:43:41clarify this issue. Uh, when we are in
- 1:43:44the area of repair, well, the damage
- 1:43:47has already been caused, right? We have
- 1:43:51to do something and yes, we have to do
- 1:43:53something. Unfortunately, this issue of
- 1:43:56financial valuation has always been a
- 1:43:58problem because it depends on who does
- 1:44:00the valuation. For example, if we talk
- 1:44:03about cutting down trees, well, we say,
- 1:44:06who values that cutting down? No, uh,
- 1:44:11the economic cost that a forestry
- 1:44:14engineer gives to those same trees will
- 1:44:18not be the same as that given by a
- 1:44:21biologist, right? Because their
- 1:44:24training and criteria are different. So
- 1:44:26here we are seeing how the same
- 1:44:28environmental element, which could be
- 1:44:30the forest mass, has different or can
- 1:44:32have different valuations depending on
- 1:44:35who the expert is who carries out that
- 1:44:37economic valuation. In that sense, it
- 1:44:41is in our environmental interests not
- 1:44:44to have an economic cost, not an
- 1:44:46economic payment, but rather a
- 1:44:48compensation and to say, well, if you
- 1:44:50cut down 25 trees of this species, then
- 1:44:53you plant 35 trees of this species
- 1:44:55because not all of them are going to
- 1:44:58grow, right? The problem also lies in
- 1:45:01where you plant them and who follows up
- 1:45:04on those specimens to ensure they grow
- 1:45:06properly. In Mexico City, for instance,
- 1:45:10you do have the payment that has been
- 1:45:13calculated for that. I don't know what
- 1:45:15the criteria are for establishing
- 1:45:17payments for urban trees, but they even
- 1:45:21tell you the species and where you have
- 1:45:24to take the number of these species and
- 1:45:28specimens to be planted. Let's say that
- 1:45:32the aim is for the repair to be
- 1:45:35environmental. At the end of it all, we
- 1:45:38really do not know how we should follow
- 1:45:40up on this as citizens. Surely the
- 1:45:42authorities will have a clearer idea of
- 1:45:44that critical path, right? But for
- 1:45:47example, I remember now that the Toluca
- 1:45:51train was built, and several trees had
- 1:45:56to be cut down in the Marquesa area,
- 1:45:57for example. And what is done to assess
- 1:46:00the value? Well, experts were called in
- 1:46:03and they are the ones who help with
- 1:46:06this assessment. But again, I come back
- 1:46:08to the same thing: who are accredited
- 1:46:10as experts? Well, there are forestry
- 1:46:12engineers, but there are also
- 1:46:13biologists, right? So, depending on
- 1:46:15your training, the assessment will be
- 1:46:17like this. I think that always has a
- 1:46:22special, complex nature. The issue of
- 1:46:26whether it always has to be economic,
- 1:46:28well, not necessarily, as was already
- 1:46:30said, in Mexico City there are other
- 1:46:32alternatives, others, uh, I understand
- 1:46:34that other federal entities also have
- 1:46:36other alternatives for compensation.
- 1:46:39The problem is the great environmental
- 1:46:42damage, right? Great environmental
- 1:46:44damage translates into economic costs
- 1:46:46and also into economic sanctions. If we
- 1:46:51look at the law, the nature of the laws
- 1:46:53tells us that we are not going down the
- 1:46:55right path. It is not possible that we
- 1:46:58have in the same category, as I was
- 1:47:00saying, of consumer protection and
- 1:47:03protection of financial services, the
- 1:47:05protection of the environment when the
- 1:47:07purposes are completely different. It
- 1:47:10is not possible that we have liability
- 1:47:12for environmental damage regulated in
- 1:47:14this federal law on environmental
- 1:47:16liability, which is something that, far
- 1:47:18from helping us, actually conflicts us,
- 1:47:20right? Because it is based on the
- 1:47:23consummation of the damage, it is not
- 1:47:26foreseeing or incentivizing prevention.
- 1:47:30And one could say, well, it is logical,
- 1:47:32it is the law of liability, right? Now
- 1:47:35you're going to hold me to blame. Okay.
- 1:47:37But then the measures should be much
- 1:47:40more open, as the Court has said, and
- 1:47:43not so restricted in terms of active
- 1:47:46legitimacy, in terms of prescriptions,
- 1:47:49in terms of repair mechanisms, right?
- 1:47:52There we should have a very wide range
- 1:47:55of possibilities for environmental
- 1:47:57repair, because the Federal Law on
- 1:47:59Environmental Responsibility, as I have
- 1:48:02already mentioned due to time
- 1:48:04constraints, speaks of a fund; but the
- 1:48:07fund is intended for litigation and,
- 1:48:09therefore, is not intended for the
- 1:48:12repair of environmental damages per se.
- 1:48:14So, I believe that we have great areas
- 1:48:18of opportunity in terms of directing or
- 1:48:21redirecting environmental repair in a
- 1:48:24substitute way, in equivalent places,
- 1:48:28but in environmental matters, not in
- 1:48:31monetary matters; because, at least in
- 1:48:34Mexico, the funds sometimes lack funds,
- 1:48:41you never find them, it is difficult to
- 1:48:45follow up on the funds and it is easier
- 1:48:49, well, for us to look for mechanisms
- 1:48:52that repair, or that try to carry out
- 1:48:56an incomplete restitution of the
- 1:48:59damages.
- 1:49:03Thank you, M. Another group of
- 1:49:05questions has to do precisely with
- 1:49:08companies that mention what mechanisms
- 1:49:11the law provides to ensure that
- 1:49:13companies comply with environmental
- 1:49:16protection standards and what sanctions
- 1:49:19they face in case of non-compliance.
- 1:49:22And this also asks, how pertinent would
- 1:49:25it be for the State to create a
- 1:49:27certification for socially and
- 1:49:29environmentally responsible companies
- 1:49:31and/or products? Okay. Well, regarding
- 1:49:36the responsibilities of companies, the
- 1:49:38General Law on Ecological Balance
- 1:49:41itself and all the laws on the subject
- 1:49:44have a section on infractions and
- 1:49:46sanctions. The way to follow up is
- 1:49:49through inspection, surveillance and
- 1:49:52sanction bodies that, as I was saying,
- 1:49:55at the federal level is Profepa; but
- 1:49:58also at the state level we have various
- 1:50:01different government actors who are
- 1:50:04responsible for following up. The
- 1:50:07problem is that they are usually
- 1:50:09insufficient, that is, the number of
- 1:50:12industries operating in the country at
- 1:50:15the federal or state level usually
- 1:50:17exceeds the inspection capacity of the
- 1:50:20authorities, right? So, that's why I
- 1:50:23believe that the awareness and
- 1:50:26education aspects are very important so
- 1:50:30that we don't have to be under the same
- 1:50:35umbrella, right? There, always being
- 1:50:38persecuted and sanctioned. Instead, I
- 1:50:40always say to business people, at the
- 1:50:43end of the day, business people are
- 1:50:46people who go out and breathe and have
- 1:50:49a family, children, a mother and their
- 1:50:52family, and they themselves breathe and
- 1:50:55eat. Aren't they just as exposed to
- 1:50:58environmental issues as anyone else?
- 1:51:01But sometimes we don't have that link
- 1:51:03and, therefore, this shared
- 1:51:05responsibility sufficiently established
- 1:51:07. I also often tell them that sadly,
- 1:51:11more and more people in our environment
- 1:51:14, people we know, have cancer,
- 1:51:17suffering from some type of cancer.
- 1:51:20It's not a coincidence, it's not a fad,
- 1:51:24it's a result of what we're breathing
- 1:51:28and eating. So, if we have to think
- 1:51:32that if I dedicate myself to
- 1:51:34agricultural production and I make
- 1:51:36intensive use of pesticides to have
- 1:51:38more production, then in the end that
- 1:51:40production will end up on people's
- 1:51:43plates, it will end up in their bodies,
- 1:51:45it will end up in their intestines and
- 1:51:48it will cause problems. So, I think we
- 1:51:53have to change our vision of wealth, of
- 1:51:57benefit, of well-being, right? Concepts
- 1:52:00like these have to be given a different
- 1:52:03meaning that is not just "I possess, I
- 1:52:05accumulate, I save, I have, I increase"
- 1:52:08, right? without any other type of
- 1:52:11value content that makes us relate
- 1:52:14differently to the environment, to
- 1:52:16ourselves as well. And regarding
- 1:52:20certification, well, at the federal
- 1:52:22level we have recognition from PROFEPA,
- 1:52:25and many, many recognitions from
- 1:52:27PROFEPA regarding, uh, clean companies,
- 1:52:30sustainable companies, sustainable
- 1:52:32tourism, sustainable municipalities; in
- 1:52:35other words, there are a series of
- 1:52:38certifications within the scope of
- 1:52:40PROFEPA, that is, at the federal level.
- 1:52:43There are also all the certifications
- 1:52:46that we know, like this one from the
- 1:52:48international sphere, but all of this
- 1:52:51falls under the voluntary zone, right?
- 1:52:54More than the mandatory zone. And
- 1:52:57unfortunately, today I think we are
- 1:53:01operating based on what I have to
- 1:53:04comply with. And what I have to comply
- 1:53:07with, I only half comply with, because
- 1:53:09what I have to comply with or could
- 1:53:11comply with voluntarily is even more
- 1:53:13complex. However, I do think it is
- 1:53:15important that these types of
- 1:53:17initiatives begin to take place because
- 1:53:20at the end of the day a domino effect
- 1:53:22will be generated, even if it is little
- 1:53:25by little. Some people with a certain
- 1:53:27awareness, but apart from that it is
- 1:53:29not just a certain awareness, it must
- 1:53:31also be said, it is a certain
- 1:53:33purchasing power, right? They begin to
- 1:53:35make these things different. Why do I
- 1:53:38say with a certain purchasing power?
- 1:53:40Because if I say let's consume organic
- 1:53:43tomatoes because they are
- 1:53:45pesticide-free and therefore I do not
- 1:53:47contaminate the soil or the water or
- 1:53:49anything, that organic tomato will cost
- 1:53:52three times more than tomatoes with
- 1:53:54pesticides. So, perhaps not all people,
- 1:53:58even if they have the awareness and the
- 1:54:01will, will have the purchasing power to
- 1:54:04consume these types of products. All
- 1:54:08organic products are more expensive.
- 1:54:13Therefore, our own realities as
- 1:54:15individual countries are what
- 1:54:17ultimately determine what we are
- 1:54:19actually able to access in these terms.
- 1:54:22But if we do not move it to the realm
- 1:54:25of voluntariness, of purchasing power,
- 1:54:27but rather to the state's obligation to
- 1:54:30demand, monitor, and comply, then I
- 1:54:32think a more significant change would
- 1:54:35have to take place.
- 1:54:40Thank you. Yes, I do. Well, time is
- 1:54:42almost up, but the last question has to
- 1:54:45do precisely with challenges. First,
- 1:54:49they asked for your opinion precisely
- 1:54:51in view of the lack of transversality
- 1:54:53and involvement of other institutions,
- 1:54:56right?, in the sectors of public
- 1:54:58policies and in these current issues
- 1:55:00such as the circular economy, emerging
- 1:55:03pollutants, climate change; if you
- 1:55:05consider that the LGEPA requires an
- 1:55:08update in order to properly respond to
- 1:55:10these specific problematics.
- 1:55:13Of course, all these observations are
- 1:55:15very important and they are challenges.
- 1:55:17It's clear that LEGEPA, as I told you,
- 1:55:21was in 1988, has undergone multiple
- 1:55:24reforms, but it does need a profound
- 1:55:27reengineering that is currently
- 1:55:29underway. LEGEPA is currently under
- 1:55:33review and obviously that will generate
- 1:55:36a domino effect, I understand, with
- 1:55:38respect to the other laws that are
- 1:55:40associated with it and the regulations
- 1:55:43derived from it. I also believe that, I
- 1:55:49don't know how to say it, reality is
- 1:55:52catching up with us and urging us to do
- 1:55:55things in a more coordinated manner.
- 1:55:59Recently, ECLAC shared a work on its
- 1:56:02website, a public work that I don't
- 1:56:06remember the name of, but if you search
- 1:56:09for it as ECLAC Top with double P T Opp
- 1:56:13. it talks about the evaluation of
- 1:56:16public policies from a cross-cutting
- 1:56:19perspective. And what I notice, at
- 1:56:21least in Mexico, is that there is no
- 1:56:23policy coherence. For example, let's
- 1:56:26look at the policy of the Energy
- 1:56:29Secretariat and it's more energy, more
- 1:56:33hydrocarbons, more fraquin, more diesel
- 1:56:36, more fuel oil, more combined cycle
- 1:56:39plants. You go to the environmental
- 1:56:43sector and fewer greenhouse gases. So
- 1:56:46you say, what is this? And then you go
- 1:56:50to the federal budget and there are no
- 1:56:52resources. So, if there are no
- 1:56:55resources available to execute a public
- 1:56:58policy, then it will be a dead public
- 1:57:01policy that will have no way of being
- 1:57:04executed. But also, if there is no
- 1:57:07coincidental vision among the State
- 1:57:10secretariats, that is, there is no
- 1:57:12state policy that articulates all the
- 1:57:15other policies, each policy has its
- 1:57:18mission, its vision, its vertical and
- 1:57:21straight line. And it seems that it
- 1:57:24does not intersect with everything else
- 1:57:27when we look at it operationally or at
- 1:57:29least I tried to show you how in real
- 1:57:32life everything is interacting. So, it
- 1:57:34is not possible that we do not
- 1:57:37recognize that climate policy versus
- 1:57:40economic policy versus tourism policy
- 1:57:43versus energy policy, versus
- 1:57:45agroecological policy, everything has
- 1:57:48interactions, right? Laagarpa, which is
- 1:57:53now Laer, well, introduced oil palm to
- 1:57:56this country with very important
- 1:57:58subsidies and many farmers in Tabasco,
- 1:58:02Veracruz, Chiapas and there are some
- 1:58:04here, no name, changed their plantain
- 1:58:08and papaya crops to oil palm, which was
- 1:58:11the boom. Now they do not know what to
- 1:58:14do with the oil palm. You drive along
- 1:58:16their roads and there are wheelbarrows
- 1:58:18there practically giving away the oil
- 1:58:21palm, they exhaust the soils because it
- 1:58:24is an introduced species. In other
- 1:58:27words, we have many public policy
- 1:58:30decisions that are short-term and that
- 1:58:33are not really articulated to a vision
- 1:58:36of a sustainable country in the medium
- 1:58:38and long term. So these are areas of
- 1:58:41opportunity. Well, thank you very much,
- 1:58:47Mariol, for this presentation, which
- 1:58:50was quite good, especially the overview
- 1:58:53of Mexican environmental legislation.
- 1:58:58As I said, we deeply appreciate your
- 1:59:01availability for being here and we
- 1:59:03remind you that each session involves,
- 1:59:05in addition to attending this class,
- 1:59:07dedicating an hour to study and
- 1:59:09independent work consisting of reading
- 1:59:12the sources of information indicated in
- 1:59:14the documents available on the platform
- 1:59:17. Thank you very much for joining us.
- 1:59:20We will meet next Tuesday, July 7, for
- 1:59:22session 7 entitled Guiding Principles
- 1:59:25for the Protection of the Environment.
- 1:59:28Have a nice afternoon,
- 1:59:30take good care of yourselves and have a
- 1:59:33lot of success in the diploma course.
- 1:59:37Thank you very much, Marisol.
- 1:59:39Thank you very much to the entire team
- 1:59:41as well. And yes, thank you very much.
- 1:59:43Well, we will be in touch.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of 🌎🌱⚖️​Diplomado en medio ambiente, bioculturalidad y derechos humanos by Casas de los Saberes JurĂdicos, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 15,701 words across 2,611 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.