đđ±âïžâDiplomado en medio ambiente, bioculturalidad y derechos humanos â Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00We welcome our speaker for today's
- 0:02session, Master Francisco Javier
- 0:05MartĂnez Esponda, whom we thank for
- 0:07his willingness to contribute to this
- 0:10training space and whose brief
- 0:12curriculum vitae I will now read. He
- 0:16holds a Master's degree in Tropical
- 0:18Ecology from the Universidad
- 0:19Veracruzana, a law degree from the
- 0:21Universidad Iberoamericana, and a
- 0:23higher diploma in climate change and
- 0:26just transitions from the Latin
- 0:27American Council of Social Sciences (
- 0:29CLACSO). Since 2005, he has been a
- 0:33defender of human rights and nature. He
- 0:36worked at the Mexican Center for
- 0:39Environmental Law (CEMDA) from 2013 to
- 0:412023, serving as Director of the Gulf
- 0:43of Mexico Regional Office and as
- 0:45Operations Director. Since 2023, he has
- 0:49been the founder and coordinator of
- 0:51Territorios Diversos para la Vida (
- 0:53Terravida). His lines of work include
- 0:56the autonomy and territories of
- 0:58indigenous peoples and similar
- 1:00communities, biocultural heritage, the
- 1:03multicultural management of water,
- 1:05native seeds and traditional food
- 1:07production systems, biocultural
- 1:09democracy, climate change, just energy
- 1:11transition, and ocean protection. He
- 1:16works in a multi-interdisciplinary
- 1:18manner with diverse peoples and
- 1:20communities, civil society
- 1:21organizations, and academia on the
- 1:23design and implementation of
- 1:25comprehensive strategies for the
- 1:26defense and protection of nature and
- 1:28the human rights of peoples and
- 1:30communities in Mexico. Without further
- 1:34ado, we yield the floor to Master
- 1:36Francisco Javier MartĂnez Esponda.
- 1:38Please, go ahead.
- 1:41Thank you very much, David. It is a
- 1:42pleasure to be with you. Thank you very
- 1:45much to the Supreme Court of Justice
- 1:47and the directorate for inviting me to
- 1:50reflect and share with you what has
- 1:52been done for so many years to defend
- 1:54what gives life, right? To defend what
- 1:57gives meaning. And what I propose and
- 2:00what I am going to share with you has
- 2:03to do with what we have built and lived
- 2:06, right? I mean, what you are going to
- 2:08see here is experience. It also has to
- 2:12do with a deep reflection on how we
- 2:17make the principle of pluriculturality
- 2:19and bioculturality enshrined in the
- 2:22second article of the Constitution a
- 2:24reality. It has to do with how we
- 2:26inhabit the institutions we have
- 2:29created and, therefore, how we can
- 2:32build long-term peace processes, right?
- 2:35So, that is a bit of the goal of my
- 2:37conversation and what you will be
- 2:39hearing. I would also love to hear the
- 2:43questions that may arise on this topic
- 2:45at the end, and I also take this
- 2:47opportunity to say that I am at your
- 2:49service for later conversations as well
- 2:51, right? I will allow myself to share a
- 2:57presentation that I have prepared in
- 3:00order to be able to exemplify and
- 3:02convey a couple of ideas. So, I am
- 3:06going to share, David. One second. It
- 3:22can be seen now, right?
- 3:23Yes. Sorry to interrupt you, it seems
- 3:26that in the comments they are pointing
- 3:29out that your camera cannot be seen, so
- 3:31I think it's just because mine is
- 3:33pinned, so I don't know if they can
- 3:35help us. Um, I think that now when you
- 3:40speak it will be visible.
- 3:42Now it is.
- 3:42Yes.
- 3:45Well, let's move forward with this then
- 3:47, right? Um, my goal is to be agile
- 3:51with my words. So, let's see how we do
- 3:54with this. So, I wanted to start with
- 3:58you with a transcendent reflection,
- 4:01also invoking an indigenous wise man,
- 4:04right?,who has inspired many
- 4:06conversations, which is how we look at
- 4:09and how we listen to the cases we know,
- 4:12right? As judges or as litigators. And
- 4:19this indigenous wise man, Davi Kopenawa
- 4:23, speaks from this reflection. He has a
- 4:28very beautiful metaphor about how many
- 4:30veils away we are from the other and
- 4:33how part of this exercise has to do
- 4:36with lifting these veils to be able to
- 4:38find them. That is the first reflection
- 4:41. The second one I wanted to share with
- 4:42you is this, right? He said that the
- 4:45problem is not in the voice of the
- 4:47subaltern, or the oppressed, but in the
- 4:49listening of the privileged subject.
- 4:51And that privileged subject in our case
- 4:54, well, has to do with the Federal
- 4:56Judiciary, right? And the Federal
- 4:59Judiciary from a dominant place and
- 5:02from a dominant paradigm like the
- 5:04modern Western one. So, uh, I know you
- 5:08spoke with Edard, I know Jorge
- 5:09FernĂĄndez was also sharing with you,
- 5:12and honoring and listening to that, I
- 5:14wanted to start with this image. This
- 5:17image is very powerful to me. This
- 5:19image is in the main square of the
- 5:21municipality of Papantla, Veracruz. It
- 5:24is the design and the dream of the
- 5:26Totonac people, right? But this is the
- 5:28origin, this is the core point. And
- 5:31here in this image for me, it has this
- 5:33reference to the explanation of "
- 5:35without corn there is no country," for
- 5:38example. I mean, here we are talking
- 5:41about the tangible and non-tangible
- 5:45things that give us identity, that make
- 5:49us who we are. And here I begin to drop
- 5:52a couple of ideas, right? The issue of
- 5:55bioculturality has to do deeply with
- 5:57human rights, as you will hear, but it
- 6:00has to do with who we are and what our
- 6:02relationship is with the territories we
- 6:05inhabit. And that, that question, for
- 6:09example, leads to this next one. This
- 6:14is the toponym of Tlaxcala. Um,
- 6:18Tlaxcala means in the Nahuatl language.
- 6:20place of good tortillas. And in this,
- 6:23in this glyph, in this coat of arms,
- 6:25you can see it, right? It is
- 6:26represented, isn't it? There are two
- 6:29hands making tortillas, but there is
- 6:32also the glyph, the sign that
- 6:34represents the altépetl. The altépetl
- 6:39was the ancient Mesoamerican state and
- 6:42is composed of two Nahuatl words: atl,
- 6:45water, and tepetl, hill. That is to say
- 6:49, the two elements necessary for a town
- 6:51to exist. Notice, notice how from the
- 6:53territory, right? And from the water,
- 6:55the sense of deity is born. There can
- 6:58be no town without water and without a
- 7:00hill. And so that is manifested here,
- 7:03and in the case of Tlaxcala, well, it
- 7:04is the altépetl of the place of good
- 7:06seeds or good tortillas, right? And so
- 7:10here comes a second idea on the subject
- 7:12of bioculturality, and it is a
- 7:14reflection from a very famous and
- 7:17renowned linguist, Luisa Maffi, who
- 7:19surely told you, and she has this
- 7:21powerful phrase about biocultural
- 7:23diversity as a process of coevolution,
- 7:26right? where these cultural, linguistic
- 7:30, ecological, and biological variables
- 7:33come together. So, here we are talking
- 7:37about processes rooted in the Earth,
- 7:41where there was a process of giving and
- 7:45receiving, right, between nature and
- 7:48the peoples who inhabited the different
- 7:52ecosystems. And now you are going to
- 7:56see a little bit more of this, well, of
- 7:58this magic, right? So, eh, let's go
- 8:01with this idea. Let me move on to the
- 8:03next one. Moving on now to this
- 8:08reflection and beginning to provide
- 8:10more elements for the conversation, the
- 8:13first thing I would like to tell you
- 8:16has to do with this idea of what
- 8:18biocultural heritage is and what
- 8:20territories are, right? We now have
- 8:24them in the Constitution and we have to
- 8:25put them into operation, right? We have
- 8:27to inhabit them. I was telling you.
- 8:32Excuse me. So, I would like to leave
- 8:36some ideas and reflections, right?
- 8:39Because biocultural heritage, eh,
- 8:41colleagues, does not necessarily have
- 8:46to be touched; it is also intangible.
- 8:48So, it is important to me that we have
- 8:51that idea, because it has often
- 8:52happened to us with other, with other
- 8:54adjudicators, that if it cannot be
- 8:56touched, it is not biocultural heritage
- 8:59, and that is not the case. So, eh,
- 9:03from the office, from "diverse
- 9:04territories for life," we have been
- 9:06contributing to this discussion and we
- 9:08have been saying, right? That it refers
- 9:12to reciprocal relationships between
- 9:14nature and peoples. We have been
- 9:17pointing out that this leads to this
- 9:18configuration of territories that we
- 9:20are going to talk about now, right? And
- 9:23therefore, biocultural heritage refers
- 9:27to practices and knowledge, it refers
- 9:30to, um, biological resources managed as
- 9:34well, right? So, we are talking about
- 9:37water management, we are talking about
- 9:39woodlands, we are talking about lands,
- 9:42we are talking about agroecosystems
- 9:44like the milpa, like the chinampas, or
- 9:46like the metepantle, for example, right
- 9:48? Like seeds, but also like languages.
- 9:56Uh, Luisa Maffi has this beautiful
- 9:59reflection where she talks about how
- 10:02every time a plant or an animal goes
- 10:05extinct, a word goes extinct and a way
- 10:08of relating to each other goes extinct,
- 10:11that is to say, a piece of knowledge
- 10:14goes extinct. So, notice the triple
- 10:17tragedy that extinction implies, and
- 10:20that also refers, therefore, to the
- 10:22existence of these biocultural
- 10:23heritages, right? Um, VĂctor Toledo
- 10:31teaches in one of his books, for
- 10:33example, about the subject of corn, and
- 10:36he makes this reflection that in Mexico
- 10:39there are 66 indigenous peoples and we
- 10:42have 66 races of corn. So, for example,
- 10:47that has led us to have corn varieties
- 10:50that have been cared for, cultivated,
- 10:52developed by particular peoples,
- 10:55because corn also has to do with
- 10:57specific tastes. It is not the same to
- 11:00be a person from the central highlands
- 11:02of Mexico as it is to be a person on
- 11:05the coastal plain of the Gulf of Mexico
- 11:07. Usually, for example, we say that the
- 11:10best corn in the central highlands
- 11:12would be blue corn. But if you go to
- 11:15the Totonacs, they will tell you, "No,
- 11:17blue corn is used for sour atoles, it
- 11:19is not used, it is a drink for the heat
- 11:20, to cool down." So, look, we have
- 11:24these particular adaptations, these,
- 11:26these, um, adaptations to the ecosystem
- 11:31, right? In Tabasco, for example,
- 11:33indigenous peoples were able to develop
- 11:35native corn varieties that, from sowing
- 11:37to harvest, take 60 days, right?
- 11:40Because of the flooding. In contrast,
- 11:43in the central highlands, we are
- 11:44talking about corn varieties that are
- 11:47much larger, but that have a longer
- 11:49duration in terms of cultivation, right
- 11:51? 9 months. So, notice how, how we have
- 11:57a spirituality, how we have knowledge,
- 11:59and how we have an intervened territory
- 12:01. And now we move to this concept that
- 12:04is also in the Constitution and that
- 12:06has also been widely developed by the
- 12:08Inter-American Court of Human Rights,
- 12:10which is an absolutely transcendental
- 12:12issue. In other words, when we read
- 12:15about the subject of bioculturality, we
- 12:17have to go through the territory and we
- 12:18have to read them in light of the
- 12:20principle of bioculturality, right? So,
- 12:23using this metaphor from feminists
- 12:25about putting on our glasses to read
- 12:27problems, we must use the lens of
- 12:29bioculturality here, and thus,
- 12:31territories are physical and symbolic
- 12:33spaces, right? What is touched and what
- 12:36is not touched. We are talking about
- 12:39knowledge, we are talking about
- 12:41spiritualities, we are talking about
- 12:43ways of relating to and understanding
- 12:45the world. It is about being, right?
- 12:49About being and existing. And I
- 12:52particularly want to refer here to
- 12:54these two elements that for me are
- 12:57absolutely essential to understand what
- 13:00territory is, what the issue of habitat
- 13:03is, the habitus, well, the way it is
- 13:06occupied, the way a space is inhabited.
- 13:11Eh, and the other is the usus, right?
- 13:14How we use it, because it may be that
- 13:17we inhabit one territory and have
- 13:20another space that we use, for example,
- 13:23the case of the Nayari people who make
- 13:26the migration to Wirikuta, right? They
- 13:30live in Nayarit or Jalisco and from
- 13:32time to time they make this pilgrimage
- 13:34to San Luis PotosĂ, to Wirikuta, where
- 13:37the gods created the world. So it is
- 13:40clear that they use that territory,
- 13:43right? So these elements become key
- 13:48when hearing an amparo trial, when it
- 13:52comes to having to rule on these
- 13:55matters, right? So, these are elements
- 14:00that I put on the table that allow us
- 14:03to identify and help us understand the
- 14:06issue we are facing, right? And well,
- 14:14this leads to the following, which is a
- 14:18reflection by a Colombian
- 14:20anthropologist, Arturo Escobar, whom I
- 14:23invite you to read. He has a fabulous
- 14:26book called "Sentipensar con la tierra"
- 14:28(Feeling-thinking with the earth),
- 14:30which is a profound reflection on what
- 14:36other peoples have contributed and what
- 14:38they have taught about how to care for
- 14:41nature and, therefore, how to care for
- 14:43the peoples. Also, I take this moment
- 14:47to invite you to reflect on another
- 14:50book that I also find fundamental to
- 14:52understand bioculturality, which is the
- 14:55book "Epistemologies of the South." It
- 14:59is a book by Boaventura de Sousa Santos
- 15:01. And that book is fabulous because,
- 15:04among other things, it tells us about
- 15:06the epistemic blindness we have had,
- 15:11right? I mean, modernity has made it
- 15:15seem that our only criterion of truth
- 15:17is science, but that science has
- 15:19excluded other forms of knowledge, it
- 15:22has excluded other wisdoms, and that
- 15:24science approaches reality in a partial
- 15:27way, right? it is also a limited,
- 15:31partial, and incomplete knowledge. So,
- 15:36you, as members of the judiciary, will
- 15:39face complex problems, and to address
- 15:42them, a dialogue of knowledge is
- 15:45required, and that dialogue can only
- 15:49happen if we use what has been
- 15:51relegated; and that is part of
- 15:54indigenous knowledge or traditional
- 15:57knowledge, and that has started to gain
- 16:00ground, right? I will give you a couple
- 16:03of examples of that right now. I am now
- 16:07starting to include the IPBES or IPSS,
- 16:09which have already brought it to the
- 16:11table, or even now the advisory opinion
- 16:1432/25 from the Inter-American Court of
- 16:19Human Rights, right? But well, having
- 16:21said all that and returning to to
- 16:24Escobar, he states that territories are
- 16:33the place where the life projects of
- 16:36peoples are embodied. So, notice, here
- 16:41there is already a direct connection to
- 16:44the right to life in its life project
- 16:47component. And so he states, it is that
- 16:52there is established there a a way of
- 16:58being and existing in the world is
- 16:59materialized, right? When we observe
- 17:03the territory and can see how the
- 17:04people in question manage it, that
- 17:07shows that there is a life project, and
- 17:09that life project has elements related
- 17:11to self-sustenance, for example, and
- 17:13well-being. And so, in the Mesoamerican
- 17:17case, things like milpas or chinampas
- 17:19come in, the metepantles I told you
- 17:21about, the way we produce food, but
- 17:23other things also come in, like
- 17:25traditional medicine or the very
- 17:27spirituality, right? For example, let's
- 17:29think about the Voladores de Papantla
- 17:31and what they signify. There is also
- 17:33the issue of organization. This is the
- 17:36issue of their own normative systems
- 17:38and their own authorities, right?
- 17:41Whether we have assemblies here, or
- 17:43councils here, and the issue of
- 17:46mayordomĂas, and we can reach larger
- 17:48cases like indigenous municipalities,
- 17:51right?,which are these transformations
- 17:54we have been seeing. Or in the case of
- 17:58TOSEPAN, for example, we have also seen
- 18:00the case of cooperatives, right? the
- 18:02Tosepan Titataniske cooperative there
- 18:04in the northern sierra of Puebla, or
- 18:07the case of communal lands there in the
- 18:09Sierra de JuĂĄrez in Oaxaca, and so
- 18:11many other examples, right? Um, that
- 18:15also refers to a knowledge and a
- 18:18multi-activity. This refers to
- 18:20biocultural landscapes, right? As I was
- 18:23telling you, in this approach and this
- 18:25way of reaching out to the peoples,
- 18:28well, the peoples have thought about
- 18:30and managed the territory in different
- 18:33ways. So, in the case of the Mayan
- 18:35jungle in Yucatan, waterâand it is
- 18:38always waterâis what makes these
- 18:40things evident. So, in the Yucatan
- 18:43peninsula, water management involves
- 18:46managing cenotes, managing chaltunes,
- 18:49and managing artenejas, right? Which
- 18:52are very sophisticated elements for the
- 18:55storage and management of water that,
- 18:57to an untrained eye, go unnoticed,
- 19:02right? In Mexico City, this is also
- 19:05visible, isn't it? If one goes to Milpa
- 19:08Alta, TlĂĄhuac, or Xochimilco, well, we
- 19:11will see the chinampas and we will also
- 19:13see the forest, right? And the
- 19:16management that is practiced there. And
- 19:19that, therefore, also refers to the
- 19:20sustainability of the habitat, right?
- 19:23And here comes another very important
- 19:25premise, which is the indigenous
- 19:29peoples, the Afro-Mexican people, and
- 19:32comparable communities, such as peasant
- 19:35communities, have higher degrees of
- 19:38sustainability than urban society, than
- 19:41modern Western society. And as
- 19:45Boaventura de Sousa Santos says, if one
- 19:47wants to conserve nature, well, what
- 19:49one needs to do is use indigenous
- 19:51knowledge. So, notice the magnitude of
- 19:55that statement. Um, the next point is
- 20:02that, therefore, the territory is also
- 20:04a sociopolitical project because it is
- 20:06a commitment to life, right? It is a
- 20:09medium-and long-term commitment. I was
- 20:12telling you about the Tosepan
- 20:14cooperative, which I'm sure was
- 20:15mentioned to you, with the life plan
- 20:17they made and their dream for the next
- 20:1940 years. Well, there you have a
- 20:22sociopolitical project that has to do
- 20:24with this, that has to do primarily
- 20:25with having oneâs own vision of the
- 20:27future. And the Tosepan Titataniske
- 20:32cooperative brings in the honey and
- 20:34pepper cooperative, the construction
- 20:37cooperative, the medicine cooperative,
- 20:40the ecotourism cooperative, and so on;
- 20:43the savings cooperative, by the way, is
- 20:46one of the largest, right? 42,000
- 20:50members. So, notice how the territory
- 20:55enables so many things and these
- 20:57options. And here we begin. I want to
- 21:01highlight this element. There is an
- 21:04appropriation and social control of the
- 21:07territory. This is key. I was telling
- 21:11you about the habitus and the customs.
- 21:14And the issue and many of the conflicts
- 21:17we see in our country and in the world
- 21:20have to do with a dispute over control
- 21:23of the territory and the dispute and
- 21:25control of traditionally managed
- 21:27natural resources, such as corn. You
- 21:31may have heard of the collective action
- 21:33for corn and heard of the campaign "
- 21:35Without corn there is no country, and
- 21:37without beans neither," right? Or the
- 21:40campaign and the litigation that the
- 21:42Mayan communities carried out to defend
- 21:44their bees and thereby defend the
- 21:45jungle. So all of this speaks to the
- 21:49issue of control, and that is a very
- 21:51important element as well in the
- 21:53reading you make of the cases submitted
- 21:56for your consideration. And on this,
- 22:07the Inter-American Court has been
- 22:10reflecting a lot. There are many very
- 22:14good judgments. Here I brought you one,
- 22:16which is Sarayaku versus Ecuador. The
- 22:19one I like best is Saramaka. Um, but to
- 22:25demonstrate this issue, it seems very
- 22:27clear to me, right? That the court says
- 22:31, right? The right to use and enjoy the
- 22:35territory would lack meaning in the
- 22:37context of indigenous and tribal
- 22:38peoples if said right were not
- 22:40connected to the protection of the
- 22:41natural resources found in the
- 22:43territory. Therefore, the protection of
- 22:48the territories of indigenous and
- 22:49tribal peoples also derives from the
- 22:51need to guarantee the security and
- 22:53permanence of the control and use of
- 22:55these resources. So, look, that is, in
- 23:02my experience, the dispute in 90%of the
- 23:06matters, right? In our office, the
- 23:10cases that usually come to us have to
- 23:12do with someone else's appropriation of
- 23:15a natural resource traditionally
- 23:17managed by a community. Usually, one of
- 23:20the resources that most rouses the
- 23:23people is the issue of water. And of
- 23:27course, that makes sense in a context
- 23:28of climate change and unplanned urban
- 23:34growth, right? In the office, we also
- 23:39have this metaphor of the water
- 23:40paradigm in our country; sadly, it is
- 23:42the appropriation of our neighbor's
- 23:43water. We do not know how to live from
- 23:47the water of our basins, and that makes
- 23:49nature and the people live saddened, as
- 23:51a dear friend of mine, Dr. Luisa Paré,
- 23:53says. Um, so this leads me to this
- 24:01formula and this thesis that Guillermo
- 24:05Bonfil formulated on cultural control,
- 24:09right? This has been around for a long
- 24:12time, and we have argued it a lot. So,
- 24:14notice that what we have discussed up
- 24:17to this moment shows that cultural
- 24:19diversity in association with
- 24:21biological diversity has originated
- 24:24what we have called the biocultural
- 24:26paradigm and biocultural heritage. What
- 24:29we were just talking about, cultural
- 24:33control in association with biocultural
- 24:36heritage, speaks to and is expressed in
- 24:40human rights, and we will give a couple
- 24:43of examples now, right? Um, so this is
- 24:48the materialization of that. So, what
- 24:53these photographs refer to and what you
- 24:57are seeing is a community water supply
- 25:01system. So, in this photograph, we have
- 25:05several images that reflect different
- 25:06things, expressions of the same right
- 25:08in this case, or several rights, right?
- 25:11But particularly right now, we can talk
- 25:14about the human right to water. So,
- 25:17notice, first on this side, on the left
- 25:20side, you can see this waterfall above.
- 25:24Up here is where the spring originates,
- 25:25and you can see the crosses. Those
- 25:27crosses indicate that we are in a
- 25:29sacred site. Um, the Day of the Holy
- 25:35Cross, May 3rd, for many of the peoples
- 25:38of this country, is the day of water.
- 25:41It is the day where there is a ritual
- 25:43associated with water. It is a day
- 25:45where they go to clean the water or the
- 25:48wells, so it is, therefore, a day of
- 25:51celebration. I love to tell about what
- 25:54I have learned from the Maegual people.
- 25:57The Maéwal people, for example, in the
- 26:00Nahuat language, have two words for
- 26:02springs: one is*apamej*and the other is
- 26:05*ayeles*. *Apamej*is a spring
- 26:09intervened upon to satisfy human needs.
- 26:13*Ayeles*is a spring left to nature. So,
- 26:17notice the sophistication of the
- 26:19language, and what you just heard here
- 26:22is biocultural heritage embodied, right
- 26:25? So here you have the sacred site, and
- 26:29on the other hand, in this first image,
- 26:32you have the basin built at the spring,
- 26:36here you have the water box, and here
- 26:40you have the pipe used to distribute
- 26:43water to the town. So, notice, what you
- 26:47are seeing here first is the right to
- 26:50autonomy, and you are seeing the right
- 26:53to one's own authorities materialized,
- 26:56because the communities constitute
- 26:58water committees that manage, without
- 27:01any municipal or state intervention,
- 27:04the issue of meeting the vital minimum,
- 27:07right? But you are also seeing the
- 27:10issue of cultural identity, because you
- 27:13are seeing the issue of the sacredness
- 27:18of the divine, but you are also seeing
- 27:20the issue of the right to water, which
- 27:22has to do with access, which has to do
- 27:24with participation, etcetera, right? So
- 27:27, here we could cite various documents
- 27:29such as General Comment 15 and others,
- 27:34right? And here, well, here you can see
- 27:41an assembly for the defense of land and
- 27:45life projects. It is an assembly of the
- 27:49Mawual, Tutunaku, and Mestizo people
- 27:52there in the northern mountains of
- 27:54Puebla. It is an authority that was
- 27:56established and is the supreme
- 27:58authority, and from which many
- 27:59decisions are made, right? I will try
- 28:02to tell you a little bit more, uh, but
- 28:05it is important for me to tell you that
- 28:09to echo our Constitution, right? And
- 28:13thinking about the fourth and fifth
- 28:15paragraphs of the second article of the
- 28:17Constitution, thinking, well, one about
- 28:19the issue of territory that is there,
- 28:21right? The peoples, well, where do they
- 28:24settle? Where do they live? Where,
- 28:26where do these dreams happen? Where do
- 28:28life and death occur? Well, in the
- 28:31territory, right? And it is, and it is
- 28:34established by our own authorities.
- 28:38That is to say, we have the authorities
- 28:40of the Mexican State, uh, 19 th-century
- 28:42, we could say, and we have the own
- 28:44authorities of the peoples, right? And
- 28:48here they are making decisions and
- 28:49under the protection of the second
- 28:51article of the Constitution. And here
- 28:56then I was thinking about section A of
- 29:00the second article of the Constitution
- 29:03as a kind of the powers granted to the
- 29:09own authorities of the peoples, right?
- 29:13And that has to do, therefore, with a
- 29:15new paradigm, right? Something that has
- 29:18also been fought for since the
- 29:20Zapatista uprising in '94, and if not
- 29:21since before, as they say in the
- 29:23villages. Uh, I also recommend this
- 29:26book by Arturo Barman, "Venimos a
- 29:28contradecir," right? Since colonial
- 29:30times. Well then, here we have what, in
- 29:33my opinion, also serves to illuminate
- 29:36the cases that do not reach us,
- 29:39thinking that here we can find many of
- 29:42the powers exercised by the own
- 29:45authorities of the peoples, right?
- 29:48Particularly, well, here we have been
- 29:52talking about access to the territory.
- 29:56We have been, oh, sorry, we have been
- 29:58talking about bioculturality, right? We
- 30:02have been talking about access to
- 30:04natural resources. So, here let us
- 30:06think if we see a reading that allows,
- 30:09I mean, a reading of this second
- 30:12article of the Constitution, that
- 30:14section A, that allows us to give life
- 30:17to legal solutions that allow us to
- 30:20resolve in depth the issues that reach
- 30:23us in a way that protects peoples and
- 30:26communities. Um, thinking also about
- 30:30what I just told you and as the former
- 30:32United Nations Special Rapporteur on
- 30:34human rights and the environment said,
- 30:37the best way to conserve nature is with
- 30:39indigenous peoples. If they are not in
- 30:42the formula, this is not going to
- 30:43happen, right? Now we are also
- 30:50undergoing a very important shift in
- 30:55how we understand nature. We have
- 31:01usually understood nature as one, and
- 31:04this chart is from the IPCC, it is a it
- 31:10is a reflection on how we view nature.
- 31:13It is an evolution from nature seen as
- 31:17a resource, which would have to do with
- 31:20this purple light of how one views
- 31:22nature, and therefore only sees it, or
- 31:26only sees it as a resource, right? And
- 31:30the translation of this would be like
- 31:32living off nature, right? Living at the
- 31:35expense of, but there are other, more
- 31:40respectful, more careful visions of
- 31:42nature. So, there is a vision that is
- 31:45still anthropocentric, but it is
- 31:47starting to shift, which is living in
- 31:50nature. There is another one, which is
- 31:54living with nature, and here we change
- 31:56the paradigm toward something more
- 31:59ecocentric or biocentric, and there is
- 32:01one more, which is living as nature.
- 32:04And this is very much the paradigm of
- 32:06peoples and communities, right? When
- 32:08they tell us that the water is alive,
- 32:10when they tell us the mountain is alive
- 32:11, when nature is alive, and we have
- 32:13also already seen these important
- 32:15changes, right? The Constitution of
- 32:17Oaxaca already recognizes nature, and
- 32:18many other federal entities are on that
- 32:20same path. So, doing this, the
- 32:24recognition of the rights of nature in
- 32:27light of biocultural rights, as the
- 32:29Colombian Court, the Colombian
- 32:31Constitutional Court said, makes
- 32:34perfect sense, because it is from this
- 32:37vision that these rights of nature have
- 32:39originated, and it is a new window to
- 32:42transform paradigms of law that we have
- 32:45had and that require a new
- 32:47interpretation and require new, more
- 32:51ways to be able to procure the justice
- 32:54we need. Well, so, in what rights do we
- 33:09see biocultural heritage? In what
- 33:11rights do we see this paradigm? Well,
- 33:14we see it in a lot of rights, right?
- 33:16And well, I was just putting as an
- 33:18example here those we usually work with
- 33:20and that I understand Jorge told you
- 33:22about; but there is the right to life,
- 33:25and I already told you here,
- 33:26particularly Teresa, in its modality of
- 33:29life project, because that allows us to
- 33:31understand a lot. And in Colombia, and
- 33:34now in Mexico, the subject of life
- 33:37plans has been attempted, right? So you
- 33:41can search for life plans on the
- 33:43internet and you will see a lot. And
- 33:46this originated from the Afro-Colombian
- 33:50peoples as a way to also explain to
- 33:53people not native to the territory what
- 33:56the vision of the territory was, how
- 33:59one lived and how one dies in that
- 34:02space. There is the issue of cultural
- 34:08identity, and this point, I personally
- 34:12love this point. In one of our cases,
- 34:16for example, an expert report regarding
- 34:19a mining issue was able to explain in
- 34:22no uncertain terms that, when the
- 34:25Mexican State granted the concessions
- 34:31to a private party without having
- 34:34guaranteed consent to that people, it
- 34:36disrupted the pact that those people
- 34:39have with the divine, and that caused
- 34:42the people unsufferable anguish, right?
- 34:47So, just look, look at what a state act
- 34:51can become from this epistemic
- 34:54blindness regarding identity. A wise
- 34:59friend, a defender of the land and the
- 35:02territory here in the state of Veracruz
- 35:05. Just to go back to what I was telling
- 35:10you earlier about the anguish, when we
- 35:12were granted the precautionary measure
- 35:15that paralyzed several mining
- 35:17concessions, he told us, "Since that
- 35:20happened, I can sleep peacefully." I
- 35:23mean, just look at the power you can
- 35:25have as judges making these decisions,
- 35:27right? Being able to sleep peacefully.
- 35:31I find it endearing, and I believe the
- 35:33judicial function has these
- 35:34possibilities to transform people's
- 35:36lives. The issue of a healthy
- 35:40environment, right? One cannot live
- 35:43without a healthy environment. To
- 35:46exercise every human right, we require
- 35:48living in a healthy environment. And
- 35:50what happens when this has been taken
- 35:53from us? I invite you here to also do a
- 35:57reading, for example, from the paradigm
- 36:01or the epistemic reflection of
- 36:04sacrifice zones. I don't know if you've
- 36:08heard that concept, but it is very
- 36:10clarifying. And that concept comes from
- 36:13the fight for civil and political
- 36:15rights in the United States. It is a
- 36:19concept that served, for example, to
- 36:21explain that in the United States,
- 36:24usually or almost always, all the
- 36:26garbage dumps were next to African
- 36:28American communities, never next to
- 36:31white communities. So, with that
- 36:35concept, they were able to demonstrate
- 36:37that the legislation and its operation
- 36:40allowed vulnerable communities, in this
- 36:42case the African American community, to
- 36:45always be the ones to bear the sick and
- 36:47the dead. And that can be taken to many
- 36:52other places. We have been bringing
- 36:55this reflection, for example, to
- 36:57various territories in Veracruz and
- 36:59Tabasco regarding the hydrocarbon
- 37:01industry. Because living with Pemex as
- 37:05a neighbor is very complicated. We have
- 37:10also spoken about and work a lot from
- 37:12the perspective of the right to water,
- 37:13right? The right to water is, as I was
- 37:16telling you, one of the great catalysts
- 37:19for peoples to exercise their right to
- 37:22access justice. And water, in these
- 37:26interpretations made by General Comment
- 37:2915 of the CESCR committee, is just
- 37:31fabulous, isn't it? It speaks of
- 37:34participation rights, it speaks of
- 37:36recognizing their own authorities, it
- 37:38speaks of how the water resources of
- 37:39the people cannot be compromised. So it
- 37:43gives a lot of viability to the
- 37:45argumentative side, thinking that the
- 37:47law is an argued truth and clay to be
- 37:50molded. uh participation in
- 37:54decision-making. Biocultural heritage
- 37:57therefore allows us to understand the
- 37:59right to autonomy from other places and
- 38:02allows, therefore, to advance in the
- 38:04matter of own authorities. As I was
- 38:07telling you, water committees are
- 38:09perhaps the best example of this, but
- 38:11there are many others, right? In the
- 38:13case of the Macehual people there in
- 38:15the Sierra Norte de Puebla, well, they
- 38:17constituted, via their assembly, a new
- 38:20authority and that authority was the
- 38:22Altepetajani committee, right? And that
- 38:24committee was formed for the defense of
- 38:26the territory, right? So, based on the
- 38:29right to participate, something new is
- 38:31constituted, right? There is the issue
- 38:35of the right to health. And here, for
- 38:39example, in the case of Tabasco with
- 38:42the issue of the hydrocarbon industry,
- 38:45uh, some communities told us: "You see,
- 38:49the flares, these structures that are
- 38:52burning gas and usually work at night,
- 38:56well, they have taken the night away
- 38:59from us, right?". We cannot rest, we
- 39:02don't have darkness. What does it mean
- 39:06to live without darkness for rest? How
- 39:09does that affect our health? And the
- 39:13issue of territories and traditionally
- 39:16managed natural resources. Here we talk
- 39:18about, we started with the issue of
- 39:20corn and I bring it up again. It seems
- 39:22to me that the issue of corn is one of
- 39:23these great examples to explain this,
- 39:25right? Corn is a resource that was
- 39:27invented, developed in coevolution
- 39:30between nature and Mesoamerican peoples
- 39:33. It was a process of 350 generations
- 39:35of grandmothers and grandfathers,
- 39:36according to what Ecar has told me. Um,
- 39:39and it is a process. Therefore,
- 39:43therefore, who should make the
- 39:46decisions about corn? The Mexican State
- 39:50or the peoples? When we have left it to
- 39:54the state, the transgenic contamination
- 39:58of 2001 happened, for example, or there
- 40:01are these pressures for the
- 40:03commercialization of transgenic corn,
- 40:07which eventually this fight led to the
- 40:10incorporation of corn into the
- 40:12Constitution, right? But notice, we had
- 40:16to fight for all of that so it would
- 40:18make it into the Constitution, because
- 40:21it hadn't been recognized that the best
- 40:23way to care for that corn was by
- 40:26leaving it in the hands of the people
- 40:28who created it and who safeguard it to
- 40:31this day, right? So, there is also the
- 40:33issue of guardianship there. Well, I'm
- 40:37going to continue. So, well, where do
- 40:42we find all of this, right? And this is
- 40:46just a non-exhaustive list of
- 40:48instruments with which you can buildâ
- 40:50this is the clay you can work with to
- 40:52construct these arguments. I personally
- 40:57really like ILO Convention 169, right?
- 41:01Articles 13 and 15 seem sensational to
- 41:04me for the purposes of protecting
- 41:07rights and peoples, and particularly
- 41:11biocultural heritage. It seems to me
- 41:15that the EscazĂș Agreement now also
- 41:17gives you, as justice operators, a ton
- 41:20of tools to be able to do this in
- 41:22Article 8. So, it's a bit like inviting
- 41:27you to say, well, here are these tools;
- 41:30none of them were thought of for
- 41:32biocultural heritage, or they name it
- 41:35without saying it, and now you will
- 41:38have the task of being able to name it,
- 41:41right? So, uh, well, here is this list.
- 41:45Perhaps, uh, you could take a look and
- 41:49get a feel for it. Right now, I think,
- 41:53at least since last year, we are in an
- 41:55era where advisory opinions have given
- 41:57us a great deal to move the frontier of
- 41:59the rights we want to defend. So, the
- 42:04Inter-American Court's Advisory Opinion
- 42:06OC-23/17, and as I told you, number 32
- 42:09from last year on environmental issues,
- 42:12are brilliant, or the La Oroya case
- 42:14also, uh, seems exceptional to me. So
- 42:19now there is a lot to weave together to
- 42:22make these arguments, which allow us to
- 42:24fulfill the mandate of the first
- 42:27article of the Constitution to better
- 42:29protect and guarantee human rights,
- 42:32right? Hm. So, we close the first part
- 42:40there and are going to move to a second
- 42:44part. And this has to do with the
- 42:48jurisdictional side; it has to do with
- 42:51how how we make the Amparo Law, how we
- 42:57make the Constitution serve to protect
- 43:00this biocultural heritage, and above
- 43:03all, to protect rights, right? so
- 43:07people can continue being who they are
- 43:09and, above all, that they can flourish,
- 43:12right? Um, so I propose these two
- 43:20questions to you. What is the role of
- 43:24the judge in cases where this paradigm
- 43:27is present, and what are the possible
- 43:30tools to use? No, because here we have
- 43:34heard a lot that the that the
- 43:38Constitution or the Amparo Law doesn't
- 43:40give much room for maneuver, and we do
- 43:43not agree with that. We believe that
- 43:47there is indeed a path forward, and
- 43:50what is needed is the creativity to
- 43:53create law and to ensure that our
- 43:55institutions and norms can achieve the
- 43:58ends for which they were designed,
- 44:01right? So, what you are seeing here,
- 44:07this image, I like it because what you
- 44:08can see here is the overlap between two
- 44:14visions. Here you are seeing two rivers
- 44:18in the Filobobos basin, where the
- 44:21communities and towns have their own
- 44:24community water supply systems. So,
- 44:28here you can see the little dots
- 44:31referring to these springs. Here you
- 44:35can see the green lines are the piping
- 44:37that they themselves built, that they
- 44:39manage, that they care for, and that
- 44:41they use to serve their communities,
- 44:43right? In this case, there are 510
- 44:46families in this community, 250 in this
- 44:48other community, for example. They
- 44:52therefore have a very sophisticated
- 44:55management of the territory, and yet
- 44:58the Mexican state, not knowing that
- 45:00this was a peasant territory, managed
- 45:03and cared for, fell into this blindness
- 45:06âbecause our responsible authorities
- 45:09also usually claim they are just
- 45:12operating within the law, right?
- 45:15Coincidentally, they almost never cite
- 45:17the Constitution in these arguments, do
- 45:20they? And concessions were granted,
- 45:25first water concessions to an energy
- 45:28generation company, and then they
- 45:31obtained environmental impact
- 45:34authorizations for the uh, or the use
- 45:39of this water, right? Without the
- 45:42participation of the affected
- 45:45communities, right? And that has led to
- 45:49a litigation that has been going on for
- 45:53more than 11 years now. Uh, but notice
- 45:56what matters here, which is how these
- 45:57two stories intersect, right? On one
- 45:59hand, we have this situation where it
- 46:01is a biocultural territory, a territory
- 46:03where there are deep roots, where there
- 46:05has been a development of authorities,
- 46:07where there is a way of managing and
- 46:09using it, and on the other hand, the
- 46:11invasion. Someone came in to displace
- 46:14this*habitus*and this*usus*. Therefore,
- 46:17there is a dispute for control, as we
- 46:19were saying a moment ago. So, what do
- 46:22we do in these circumstances? How do we
- 46:25act as judges? How do we build
- 46:29plausible legal solutions to complex
- 46:33problems, right? So, the first thing I
- 46:43would like to do is invite you to
- 46:45resonate with this provocation made by
- 46:47the now-defunct First Chamber of the
- 46:50Supreme Court of Justice in the Laguna
- 46:52del Carpintero*amparo*case. The need
- 46:58for judges in these types of cases to
- 47:01be able to perform their role in a
- 47:04different way, not in the traditional
- 47:07way, because the traditional way means
- 47:10closing the door. But, on the other
- 47:15hand, if we echo the highest standard
- 47:19of protection for the rights at stake,
- 47:22in this case the environment and
- 47:24biocultural heritage; other solutions
- 47:27are possible, plausible solutions,
- 47:29solutions that protect rights. So, the
- 47:33former First Chamber told us, right?
- 47:39The justiciability of the human right
- 47:41to the environment cannot be developed
- 47:44based on classic or traditional models
- 47:46of justice, as in most cases these
- 47:48prove insufficient or unsuitable for
- 47:50such a purpose, because, of course, it
- 47:56is the dimensions of the problem, right
- 47:58? the consequences involved, I mean, a
- 48:04bad court decision can result in the
- 48:06migration of an entire town, for
- 48:09example, right? The disappearance of
- 48:12forests, anyway, we can talk a little
- 48:15more about that. And the Inter-American
- 48:18Court in its advisory opinion 32 refers
- 48:21to this, which I also think is a gem,
- 48:24right? it says, "In the context of the
- 48:28climate crisis, and I underscore this,
- 48:30we are in a context of contingency and
- 48:32the climate crisis is also a crisis of
- 48:35rights, right? Uh, it implies in turn
- 48:39the crisis of biocultural heritage and
- 48:42rights. Judges are obligated to conduct
- 48:44their actions based on the pro-active
- 48:45principle. We need to have an active
- 48:48role, as the Supreme Court said. That
- 48:51is, here comes the quote from the
- 48:52Inter-American Court. Judicial bodies
- 48:55must interpret and apply the relevant
- 48:58norms in a way that effectively
- 48:59guarantees access to substantive
- 49:01justice for those who require it in the
- 49:04context of the emergency. So, for me
- 49:08this means that the judge goes from
- 49:13being a, well, often going beyond just
- 49:19a mere observer or moderator, they
- 49:24become more of a kind of orchestra
- 49:27conductor, right? because they start to
- 49:30have more specific interventions in
- 49:32such a way that their actions allow for
- 49:34gathering elements to better provide
- 49:36for justice, and that is what we are
- 49:38looking for. So, the court, sorry, I'm
- 49:49going to go back one line and here I
- 49:52will refer to something I learned from
- 49:55the Constitutional Court of Ecuador. it
- 49:58was in a concurrent vote by Judge
- 50:00Ramiro Ăvila Santa MarĂa, which I
- 50:02found absolutely fabulous and which
- 50:04comes with this resonance and which
- 50:06says, well, and there is the ruling,
- 50:08right? It is also an important ruling.
- 50:11But he said," To better provide for
- 50:14justice we need to use different tools,
- 50:18tools that are within reach, and those
- 50:21tools are teleological interpretation.
- 50:26That means that the norm can fulfill
- 50:28the purpose for which it was created,
- 50:30right? And that has to do with, well,
- 50:33guaranteeing access to justice if we
- 50:36are talking about the Amparo Law, for
- 50:38example. And that has to do with rights
- 50:41based on principles, right? What he
- 50:44says is that all the principles, for
- 50:46example, general principles of law, the
- 50:48principles of bioculturality we are
- 50:50talking about here, well, what they
- 50:52lack is materialization. They are often
- 50:55contained in the norm, but they lack
- 50:57their application, their applicability.
- 51:01So, he says, "The judge must learn to
- 51:03make these principles operative." And
- 51:07right now, well, I'm going to give you
- 51:08a couple of examples of this, right? Um
- 51:11, the third thing Judge Ăvila Santa
- 51:15MarĂa talks about is the issue of
- 51:18legal forms as a guarantee of rights.
- 51:22And so here he is referring again to
- 51:25how we are inhabiting institutions. And
- 51:28so here there is an important
- 51:30reflection, right?,on the commitments
- 51:33to access to justice. And he also
- 51:38speaks, and I like this one a lot,
- 51:41about the perspective from which law is
- 51:44made and applied, and he named it the
- 51:47law of the oppressed. And that means
- 51:51the justice operator is obligated, in
- 51:53order to understand these problems, to
- 51:56put themselves in the place of the one
- 51:58asking for justice, the one who has
- 52:01been harmed, the one who has been
- 52:03exposed to an unacceptable risk. So,
- 52:08that also makes for a much more human
- 52:12law, right? He speaks of an embodied
- 52:16law; he therefore also speaks to the
- 52:18appeal that the judge must be able to
- 52:19feel. And that, that means, for example
- 52:28, we just experienced that with the
- 52:30issue of judicial inspections. And here
- 52:33there is a transcendent reflection. Who
- 52:36is the judicial official who usually
- 52:38goes to judicial inspections? How does
- 52:42that judicial official transmit what
- 52:44they perceived during an inspection? So
- 52:47, often, for example, that translation
- 52:50is lost there. If this person lacks
- 52:52that sensitivity, it may be that it has
- 52:54been lost. So, I leave you with these
- 52:58reflections from Judge Ăvila Santa
- 53:00MarĂa, thinking that this might give
- 53:02you some tools, right? Now, from what I
- 53:07have studied, from what I have seen,
- 53:10there are also other principles. And
- 53:14these other principles, some have
- 53:17already been used by the Federal
- 53:19Judiciary and the Supreme Court, and
- 53:21others are on the way, and the paradigm
- 53:23of bioculturality compels us. So, the
- 53:27first is the precautionary principle,
- 53:29the in dubio pro natura, which I don't
- 53:32think we need to dwell on. This is
- 53:36explored law. Well, the second one is
- 53:39bioculturality, and bioculturality
- 53:42means putting on glasses to search for,
- 53:45scrutinize, and find this inextricable
- 53:49link between the biodiversity of a
- 53:52territory and the people in question,
- 53:55and to understand the process of
- 53:57coevolution, the process of prosperity,
- 54:01and the flourishing of the people. Um,
- 54:06and that involves how we look and how
- 54:10we listen, as I said at the beginning
- 54:13with this quote from Davi Kopenawa,
- 54:17right? So, the principle of
- 54:20pluriculturality can also be a
- 54:21watershed in the administration of
- 54:23justice. The second, the third is the
- 54:28principle of the adjacent environment,
- 54:30which is this concept also already
- 54:32developed by the court. And it seems to
- 54:35me that here too, and that is a part of
- 54:38my argument, there is a way with the
- 54:40lenses of bioculturality to be able to
- 54:42see the territory, because the adjacent
- 54:44environment speaks of the habitus and
- 54:46the usus that we saw at the beginning
- 54:49of this conversation. So, if the
- 54:53legitimate interest comes from the
- 54:55adjacent environment due to a matter of
- 54:58habitus or usus, then we are talking
- 55:01about a biocultural issue and it allows
- 55:04the territory to be materialized. So,
- 55:09there is also the invitation to be able
- 55:13to continue evolving this concept or
- 55:16principle that is already, uh, well,
- 55:21that is already on the table in our
- 55:22amparo proceedings, right? As a tool.
- 55:26The theme of the dialogue of knowledge
- 55:28as a fourth principle. The theme of the
- 55:31dialogue of knowledge, colleagues, is
- 55:33absolutely transcendent. I was telling
- 55:35you, modern Western knowledge is not
- 55:38enough. It is clear that by the
- 55:42principle of Iura novit curia, the
- 55:44judge must know the law, right? But
- 55:48will the judge, the magistrate know
- 55:50about bioculturality, will they know
- 55:53the nuances that are sought or
- 55:56pertinent to the case? My experience is
- 56:00that they do not. And so this requires
- 56:03thinking of novel situations of how to
- 56:06provide themselves with information to
- 56:09better rule. It is clear, for example,
- 56:14that here expert opinions become a key
- 56:18tool, judicial inspections become a key
- 56:21tool, and testimonies become a key tool
- 56:25. However, I still think that those
- 56:29three possibilities that are in the
- 56:32Amparo Law are not enough. I am
- 56:36increasingly convinced that, for
- 56:38example, an ad hoc committee is
- 56:40required to advise the judge because
- 56:45many times the justice operator is not
- 56:48blind to these issues and, unless they
- 56:52operate strictly with the precautionary
- 56:55principle, uh, they are often left in
- 56:58the open, right? So, If you'd like,
- 57:05maybe during the Q&A session I can tell
- 57:08you a bit more about this committee
- 57:11idea, but it's clear that judges are
- 57:15often alone and could really benefit
- 57:18from advisory support, right? Um, the
- 57:23fifth principle is the maximization of
- 57:25autonomy. The Court has already stated
- 57:28this; it's the idea that, in order to
- 57:31pursue the autonomy of peoples,
- 57:33whenever possible, they should opt for
- 57:39that interpretation of the law which
- 57:42allows the people's own authority to
- 57:45develop and flourish. That is key. Key
- 57:50for bioculturality, key for nature. The
- 57:55sixth is the rights of nature. This has
- 57:58to do with daring to recognize entire
- 58:00biomes as subjects of rights, and the
- 58:03peoples who care for them as their
- 58:05guardians and therefore as their
- 58:07defenders. And sixth, culturally
- 58:10appropriate reparation for damages.
- 58:14This principle is absolutely
- 58:17transcendental because, often, rulings
- 58:21solve very little. They often hinder,
- 58:25but above all, they are not framed in
- 58:29an intercultural way and, therefore,
- 58:32many times the solutions proposed by
- 58:35the federal judiciary are not adequate
- 58:39for the cultural identity that exists
- 58:42in this country, which therefore enjoys
- 58:45the same rights, right? And we can list
- 58:49many examples here. I think, for
- 58:53instance, of the Mayan honey case that
- 58:55Jorge told you about; there is a huge
- 58:57reflection there on what the Court
- 58:59resolved in 2016. Um, and finally,
- 59:05echoing the former First Chamber in the
- 59:08Laguna Carpintero Amparo case, it
- 59:10stated that there are other very
- 59:13important tools for interpreting
- 59:15bioculturality cases, and one is the
- 59:18preliminary assessment regarding the
- 59:20existence of risk or harm. I haven't
- 59:25seen anyone do this. The Court has
- 59:29already stated this. This would be very
- 59:32useful for taking both precautionary
- 59:34and substantive measures. The second
- 59:38has to do with the reversal of the
- 59:40burden of proof, meaning the person in
- 59:43the best position should prove it, or
- 59:45the dynamic burden of proof, where the
- 59:47judge determines who should provide the
- 59:49evidence, which is included in the
- 59:51EscazĂș Agreement. And lastly, the duty
- 59:54to gather the necessary means of
- 59:56evidence to rule more effectively. This
- 1:00:00has to do with the proactive stance we
- 1:00:02mentioned, where perhaps the judge
- 1:00:04determines they need to carry out
- 1:00:07expert assessments, right? This
- 1:00:11happened to us in the case of the
- 1:00:13Sierra Norte of Puebla with the Maeguat
- 1:00:16people, where the court decided on its
- 1:00:18own initiative to order expert reports
- 1:00:21in anthropology, environmental impact,
- 1:00:23and topography and surveying, I believe
- 1:00:28that was the third one. So, notice,
- 1:00:31many times we have to have this active
- 1:00:34role that I was telling you about in
- 1:00:37order to seek and build viable
- 1:00:39solutions to the problems we face,
- 1:00:42right? And here are a couple of
- 1:00:49examples, they are little-known
- 1:00:52examples, but I think they are
- 1:00:54absolutely significant because they
- 1:00:57were precursors to several of the
- 1:00:59Court's rulings, which resolved
- 1:01:02important matters. Both are from the
- 1:01:05seventh circuit here in Veracruz. So,
- 1:01:09notice, the first one has to do with a
- 1:01:132015 resolution and this court was one
- 1:01:16of the very first to dare to speak
- 1:01:19about the precautionary principle. It
- 1:01:23is the second collegiate court in
- 1:01:24administrative matters of the state of
- 1:01:26Veracruz. And in this precautionary
- 1:01:30measure, this court said: for the
- 1:01:32granting of the precautionary measure,
- 1:01:34it said, in the conditions, under those
- 1:01:36conditions, in the present matter, the
- 1:01:38principle that governs environmental
- 1:01:40matters called*in dubio pro natura*or
- 1:01:42prevention will be applied, which
- 1:01:44consists of the fact that if there is a
- 1:01:46danger or threat of serious or imminent
- 1:01:48damage to elements of biodiversity, the
- 1:01:52absence of scientific certainty or the
- 1:01:54imminence of damage in any degree is no
- 1:01:56reason not to adopt measures to protect
- 1:01:58the collective good. Or in other words,
- 1:02:02the fact that there are no conclusive
- 1:02:03scientific elements to open the
- 1:02:05decision to paralyze or stop the
- 1:02:07administrative action that generates
- 1:02:08such risk is not an obstacle to
- 1:02:10dictating the necessary measures for
- 1:02:12the conservation of the environment,
- 1:02:14which, by itself, invalidates the
- 1:02:15district judge's statement. Therefore,
- 1:02:19it is necessary to establish actions
- 1:02:21that prevent an ecological and social
- 1:02:24catastrophe from happening. That is the
- 1:02:27biocultural issue derived from the
- 1:02:29irreparable damage to the springs of
- 1:02:30the indigenous communities. That was
- 1:02:33the first case, right? And this
- 1:02:35decision was very applauded at the time
- 1:02:38. I remember the Supreme Court's
- 1:02:41communication emphasizing this decision
- 1:02:43. And then there is this other decision
- 1:02:49by the 18th district judge in the state
- 1:02:52of Veracruz in indirect amparo 687/28,
- 1:02:59where that judge said the following,
- 1:03:03right? He said with the implementation
- 1:03:05of the decree, it'sâah, let me give
- 1:03:07you that context. This amparo
- 1:03:11questioned the decrees of in 2018, the
- 1:03:18then president Enrique Peña Nieto saw
- 1:03:23fit to lift the ban in several of the,
- 1:03:26or several of the, ban decrees that
- 1:03:28existed in multiple basins of the
- 1:03:30country. It was said to be a novel
- 1:03:35measure because this decision
- 1:03:37guaranteed an ecological flow for the
- 1:03:40river, about 35%or so, if I recall
- 1:03:43correctly, and the rest could be
- 1:03:45conceded. Just imagine that, right? The
- 1:03:48ban decree meant that none of the water
- 1:03:50could be taken. So, a river with 100%of
- 1:03:54its flow is not the same as a river
- 1:03:56with 35%of its flow. The river is not
- 1:03:59the same. So, when the judge had to
- 1:04:02make the decision, he said the
- 1:04:04following, right? He said: "With the
- 1:04:09implementation of the decree, the
- 1:04:11communities of the plaintiffs run the
- 1:04:14risk of their rights to enjoy the vital
- 1:04:16minimum of water they require being
- 1:04:18affected, and that the region where
- 1:04:21they live not be the object, in an
- 1:04:23arbitrary manner, of excessive water
- 1:04:25use; because, of course, they are going
- 1:04:28to come for, water concessions will be
- 1:04:30requested from CONAGUA and control of
- 1:04:33the river territory will be affected."
- 1:04:36The way the people live will be
- 1:04:38affected, someone else will be
- 1:04:39disputing it, and the river will no
- 1:04:41longer be the same, right? And the
- 1:04:44judge says even more, since the
- 1:04:46elimination of bans in almost 300
- 1:04:48hydrological basins in the country,
- 1:04:50which is equivalent to 50%of the
- 1:04:51country's lakes and rivers, means there
- 1:04:54will be no obstacles to water
- 1:04:55extraction in those basins. So, that
- 1:04:59decision was fabulous because it also
- 1:05:03gave viability to the ruling, right?
- 1:05:06The ruling did have the useful effect
- 1:05:08that amparo rulings must have according
- 1:05:10to our Constitution and the amparo law
- 1:05:12itself. Because had the concession not
- 1:05:17been issued, I mean, the suspension,
- 1:05:20concessions would have been granted for
- 1:05:22this basin and therefore the issue of
- 1:05:25access to justice would have been very
- 1:05:28different and the lawsuit would have
- 1:05:30been much longer. So, look, in my
- 1:05:35opinion, these are rulings that speak
- 1:05:37of bioculturality without
- 1:05:38bioculturality being explicitly stated,
- 1:05:41right? At no point in these resolutions
- 1:05:44was it named, but it is certainly
- 1:05:45present. And now let's move on to a
- 1:05:51third moment. And the third moment has
- 1:05:54to do with the substantive decisions.
- 1:05:58It has to do with how we make how we
- 1:06:04make these adjective rules, how we make
- 1:06:08rights viable, how we manage to make
- 1:06:12the law fulfill the purpose for which
- 1:06:16it is intended, right? So, I am going
- 1:06:21to share with you here, also very
- 1:06:24briefly, a couple of reflections also
- 1:06:28based on the from the path traveled,
- 1:06:32right? So, the first thing I would like
- 1:06:42to recommend to you as judges or those
- 1:06:45who participate in building legal
- 1:06:48solutions for cases through
- 1:06:50jurisdiction, has to do with proposing
- 1:06:54a problem set, right? So, that problem
- 1:07:00set, I believe based on what I have
- 1:07:03learned, could contain some of these
- 1:07:06questions. The first is, what is the
- 1:07:10biocultural heritage at risk? In other
- 1:07:12words, what is what is at stake? As I
- 1:07:15told you, it could be the springs, it
- 1:07:16could be the forest, it could be the
- 1:07:18language, it could be, uh such a
- 1:07:22practice, I mean, it could be many
- 1:07:23things, right? And therefore, what are
- 1:07:26the fundamental rights at stake? What
- 1:07:30what is this this biocultural heritage?
- 1:07:33How does it translate into the language
- 1:07:35of rights? And, therefore, what is the
- 1:07:37risk? And also what is the violence
- 1:07:42that this thing we are talking about
- 1:07:46entails. And I will refer to that in a
- 1:07:47moment, right? Because whenever we talk
- 1:07:49about concepts of violation and
- 1:07:51grievances, what we are talking about
- 1:07:53is violence, colleagues. And that has
- 1:07:56been widely studied, and it is also
- 1:07:58important to determine it because once
- 1:08:00you manage to determine it, there are
- 1:08:03approaches and tools to do so, right?
- 1:08:07The second question I would ask is what
- 1:08:09is the relationship between the
- 1:08:11complainant and that biocultural
- 1:08:13heritage, the habitus and the usus I
- 1:08:15told you about, how it is inhabited,
- 1:08:17how it is used, so that you can unravel
- 1:08:19it. So, here I told you that many times
- 1:08:23by following the path of the water, the
- 1:08:25territory reveals itself, right? I
- 1:08:29already told you about the case of the
- 1:08:31Maya people in the YucatĂĄn Peninsula
- 1:08:33and how they manage the different
- 1:08:36elements of the territory, but that
- 1:08:38repeats itself in other places. In the
- 1:08:43northern highlands of Puebla, the
- 1:08:45Maseual people, for example, leave the
- 1:08:47forest at the very top of the basin.
- 1:08:50They say it is the place of the thunder
- 1:08:51. And the place of the thunder is not
- 1:08:52only the place of the forest; it is the
- 1:08:54place of water collection. And then in
- 1:08:57the transition between the upper and
- 1:08:59middle basin, they have the achicuales.
- 1:09:02The achicuales are small cisterns where
- 1:09:03they collect water, but also in this
- 1:09:05area are the springs and the caves. And
- 1:09:08I already told you that the springs and
- 1:09:10the caves are sacred sites, right?
- 1:09:12Because they are thresholds of
- 1:09:14transition and connection with the
- 1:09:15divine. So, notice how the territory is
- 1:09:19here and therefore allows for an
- 1:09:21interpretation, right? Second or third
- 1:09:26issue, what should the role of the
- 1:09:29judge be in the case? I told you that
- 1:09:33rather than being a simple moderator or
- 1:09:35facilitator, they are like the
- 1:09:36orchestra conductor. So, what can this
- 1:09:40judge do to bring in the violins or the
- 1:09:43wind instruments, following this
- 1:09:46metaphor, because we need to build this
- 1:09:50concert. The fourth is, what should be
- 1:09:55the standard required of the plaintiff,
- 1:09:58right? And there is also extensive
- 1:10:00reflection on this, starting with what
- 1:10:02I told you about the EscazĂș Agreement
- 1:10:04and the reversal of the burden of proof
- 1:10:06, dynamic proof. So, what is also clear
- 1:10:10here, due to the nature of the risks
- 1:10:13and damages, is that we are in a place
- 1:10:17where the requirements are very
- 1:10:20different from, for example, civil
- 1:10:23cases. So, that is also something that
- 1:10:27must be determined. A fifth question
- 1:10:30would be, what affirmative measures can
- 1:10:32be decreed to safeguard the rights and
- 1:10:34assets at stake? which we already
- 1:10:38mentioned here, right? Beyond the
- 1:10:39precautionary measure. As the process
- 1:10:45moves forward, other questions will
- 1:10:46arise. What should a judgment look like
- 1:10:48? A judgment that repairs the damage in
- 1:10:53a culturally appropriate and
- 1:10:55ecologically sustainable way, right?
- 1:10:58Relevant. Well then, here are a couple
- 1:11:02of questions with which to interrogate
- 1:11:07the problem presented to you and see
- 1:11:09what answers the matter gives you in
- 1:11:12light of the amparo lawsuit, right?
- 1:11:15often they will require other
- 1:11:17information. And here is, as I told you
- 1:11:23, the issue of violence, right?
- 1:11:26Johannes Galtung, who was a great peace
- 1:11:29theorist, said that to understand peace
- 1:11:32, one must understand violence. And he
- 1:11:36spoke of cultural violence, saying, "
- 1:11:38Cultural violence has three facets,
- 1:11:39physical violence, and I don't need to
- 1:11:41go much into that. Sadly, our country
- 1:11:45is affected by that." But let's talk
- 1:11:48about structural violence and symbolic
- 1:11:50violence. Much of the legislation is
- 1:11:55built solely from the modern Western
- 1:11:59paradigm. it is not imbued with the
- 1:12:03values of pluriculturalism. So, for
- 1:12:08example, in the case I'm telling you
- 1:12:10about in the Northern Sierra of Puebla,
- 1:12:12the matter reached the Supreme Court;
- 1:12:15and the Supreme Court, in a sad ruling
- 1:12:17by the now-defunct Second Chamber of
- 1:12:19the Supreme Court, resolved that the
- 1:12:21Mining Law did not conflict with the
- 1:12:23rights of Indigenous peoples, except in
- 1:12:26rare instances, and therefore, there
- 1:12:28was no matter to study, whereas the
- 1:12:32Constitutional Court of Colombia and
- 1:12:34the Constitutional Court of Ecuador
- 1:12:36struck down the mining laws of those
- 1:12:38countries because they did not consult
- 1:12:40Indigenous peoples, because those legal
- 1:12:43systems were not imbued with the value
- 1:12:45of pluriculturalism. Just think about
- 1:12:47that, right? So, when you encounter
- 1:12:50these issues, you have to subject them
- 1:12:52to an examination of what values this
- 1:12:55legislation responds to. This
- 1:12:58legislation only serves to commodify
- 1:13:00nature and biocultural heritage. What
- 1:13:04is the role of the peoples '
- 1:13:06participation? What place do their
- 1:13:08legitimate custodians and guardians
- 1:13:10play? And the third, well, is symbolic
- 1:13:15violence, and this has to do with the
- 1:13:18misappropriation of symbols, and that,
- 1:13:21well, has many nuances and is a bit
- 1:13:24more sophisticated, right? In this
- 1:13:27country, we have seen several examples
- 1:13:30that maybe it isn't worth getting into
- 1:13:33fully right now. If you want, we can
- 1:13:36discuss it another time. Hm. So, here
- 1:13:41also comes this reflection: what should
- 1:13:43the Mexican State look like in light of
- 1:13:45the second article of the Constitution?
- 1:13:48Well, it is a pluricultural state, and
- 1:13:50that implies particular characteristics
- 1:13:52, right? Characteristics that recognize
- 1:13:57their own authorities and normative
- 1:13:59systems, that recognize the right to
- 1:14:01territory and the right of peoples to
- 1:14:03make decisions in that territory, the
- 1:14:05recognition of participating in the
- 1:14:07construction of legislation, public
- 1:14:08policy, and the administrative acts of
- 1:14:11the authorities, and above all, the
- 1:14:13issue of access to justice. And these
- 1:14:16are issues that are, well, like
- 1:14:17everything, under construction, right?
- 1:14:19This, this never, this never ends. This
- 1:14:23is always a path where, when you reach
- 1:14:26a certain point, the next frontier
- 1:14:28appears, and thatâs how we go. Hm.
- 1:14:34Here, I would also like to say we have
- 1:14:36been talking about state institutions,
- 1:14:37we have talked about their own
- 1:14:39institutions, and the next frontier is
- 1:14:40called mixed institutions. This, this
- 1:14:44possibility of creating institutions
- 1:14:46between the traditional authorities of
- 1:14:49the State and the authorities of the
- 1:14:51peoples themselves. We still haven't
- 1:14:54seen this in this country. Uh, just as
- 1:14:56we began to perhaps outline it, for
- 1:14:59example, in the case of the Central
- 1:15:01Valleys of Oaxaca, when they finally
- 1:15:03recognized to the Zapotec water
- 1:15:07committees as water authorities, but
- 1:15:09they remain their own unique
- 1:15:10authorities. No, no, not necessarily
- 1:15:14mixed, as I will explain below. So,
- 1:15:19look, I was telling you that I was
- 1:15:21about to start sharing these stories,
- 1:15:24right? Uh, if you want to learn about
- 1:15:28biocultural rights, I think the
- 1:15:30reference point is the ruling on the
- 1:15:32Atrato River by the Constitutional
- 1:15:35Court of Colombia, it's marked right
- 1:15:37there, isn't it? STC 622 2016, well,
- 1:15:442016 is a ruling that studied the issue
- 1:15:47of bioculturality a lot, and because of
- 1:15:50what the judge understood from this
- 1:15:53recognition, and this court did a lot
- 1:15:57to understand, it did a lot to stand
- 1:16:00from the place of the oppressed, from
- 1:16:03the law of the oppressed, it stated
- 1:16:09that that there existedâmind youâ
- 1:16:15the third resolution determined that
- 1:16:17there was a serious violation of the
- 1:16:20fundamental rights to life, health,
- 1:16:22water, food security, a healthy
- 1:16:25environment, culture, and the territory
- 1:16:28of the ethnic communities inhabiting
- 1:16:30the Atrato River basin and its
- 1:16:32tributaries. When you can, search for
- 1:16:37the Atrato River and you will see that
- 1:16:38it is immense. And so, look, the scale
- 1:16:43of the contingency is recognized, and
- 1:16:45furthermore, it is stated that the
- 1:16:48authorities of the Colombian State are
- 1:16:51responsible for the violation of
- 1:16:53biocultural rights. And then comes one
- 1:16:57of the court's proposals for a
- 1:16:59culturally appropriate solution, and it
- 1:17:01is this. The Atrato River and its basin
- 1:17:06and tributaries are recognized as an
- 1:17:09entity subject to rights to protection,
- 1:17:12conservation, maintenance, and
- 1:17:15restoration, overseen by the State and
- 1:17:18the ethnic communities. Note the
- 1:17:22novelty here, what is different. There
- 1:17:28are two issues. The first is the
- 1:17:31recognition of this body, of this water
- 1:17:35body as a subject of rights. And the
- 1:17:39second novelty is who the guardian of
- 1:17:41that river is, who remains in charge of
- 1:17:44that river. And so here, the court's
- 1:17:47answer was the state and the riverside
- 1:17:50communities, right? Those who live the
- 1:17:53river again as biocultural heritage,
- 1:17:56the communities as its holders, as its
- 1:17:59guardians by habit. And this just
- 1:18:04happens to be a solution, right? And
- 1:18:06that is why I told you they are
- 1:18:07creating a mixed authority. We also saw
- 1:18:09this in New Zealand with the
- 1:18:11construction and protection of the
- 1:18:14Whanganui River, which is also a
- 1:18:16beautiful story that I invite you to
- 1:18:19take a look at, right? It is the
- 1:18:22longest litigation in the history of
- 1:18:24New Zealand, which ended with the
- 1:18:27creation of legislation; legislation
- 1:18:29that recognizes the river and
- 1:18:31establishes this new authority, uh,
- 1:18:34which therefore allows us to think
- 1:18:36about a very different protection
- 1:18:38scheme, considering that the river is
- 1:18:41an articulating axis of the lives of
- 1:18:44the people who live there, right? Now,
- 1:18:50allow me to move on to the Mexican case
- 1:18:53, and I will tell you that I found this
- 1:18:56resolution by the Third Collegiate
- 1:18:59Court in Administrative Matters in the
- 1:19:02state of Puebla to be a breath of fresh
- 1:19:05air. It is the amparo review 149/19.
- 1:19:13This is the case I was telling you
- 1:19:14about regarding the mining concessions.
- 1:19:18Uh, here the district court had
- 1:19:20initially granted the amparo and
- 1:19:22protection of the federal justice
- 1:19:24system so that a consultation would be
- 1:19:31held, and we were very disappointed
- 1:19:33with that because we have all seen how
- 1:19:36consultations end up. Uh, and this
- 1:19:40court raised the standard because it
- 1:19:41said, "Well, a consultation will have
- 1:19:43to be held, but it will be a
- 1:19:44consultation for consent." But the part
- 1:19:48I am interested in sharing with you is
- 1:19:49the interpretation it made. And notice
- 1:19:52what this court said. Uh, it is
- 1:19:55absolutely a breath of fresh air,
- 1:19:58especially in this, in this possibility
- 1:20:00of how the Constitution is read. So,
- 1:20:04notice what it said. In the particular
- 1:20:08case, the authorities of the Ministry
- 1:20:10of Economy, during the process of
- 1:20:12issuing the mining concession titles
- 1:20:15over the properties called Atescaco,
- 1:20:17Atescaco 2, and Mauelquila, should have
- 1:20:20provided for a consultation procedure
- 1:20:22with the indigenous community, the
- 1:20:25current complainant, that would meet
- 1:20:27all the requirements indicated in ILO
- 1:20:30Convention 169; since the extraction
- 1:20:32activities of minerals from the subsoil
- 1:20:34, which are the subject of the
- 1:20:38concession titles, are assets that
- 1:20:40share a dual regime. Here it comes,
- 1:20:42right? That is, on one hand, ownership
- 1:20:46belongs to the Mexican State; however,
- 1:20:49the convention itself recognizes as
- 1:20:51part of the rights of indigenous
- 1:20:53communities the participation in their
- 1:20:55use, administration, and conservation.
- 1:21:00So, if you go look for that resolution,
- 1:21:02you will see that it says a bit more.
- 1:21:05Because what it is saying is how
- 1:21:06Article 27 of the Constitution is read,
- 1:21:08specifically the part regarding the
- 1:21:09subsoil. You have just seen, uh, and we
- 1:21:13saw what the committee, uh, that
- 1:21:15President Shabound constituted for the
- 1:21:17fracking issue, what it said about the
- 1:21:20consequences of fracking and how it
- 1:21:22could be done. But notice, that
- 1:21:26committee is providing an opinion on
- 1:21:29how fracking is to be done. And here
- 1:21:33come these questions. Well, whether
- 1:21:35there will be fracking or not in this
- 1:21:38country should be decided alongside the
- 1:21:40people who inhabit these territories,
- 1:21:42because these are the people who would
- 1:21:44have to deal with, and once again, bear
- 1:21:47the burden of the deaths, the sickness,
- 1:21:49and the deprivation of control over
- 1:21:51their lands. And therefore, this
- 1:21:54interpretation of the dual regime is
- 1:21:57absolutely transcendental, isn't it? I
- 1:22:00mean, it allows, on one hand, it
- 1:22:02reaffirms the State's domain, but it
- 1:22:04says: "You must exercise this domain in
- 1:22:05a collaboration scheme with the
- 1:22:07Indigenous people in question," and
- 1:22:09that allows, once again, for the
- 1:22:10protection of biocultural heritage; it
- 1:22:12allows for the protection of human
- 1:22:14rights such as cultural identity, water
- 1:22:16, and many others, right? The, the
- 1:22:19topic, I was telling you just now about
- 1:22:21the Totacos, uh, itâs a, itâs a
- 1:22:25tragedy because fracking has been
- 1:22:27happening there since '97, and this
- 1:22:29tragedy implies that their water has
- 1:22:31been contaminated and used without them
- 1:22:33ever being informed, without them
- 1:22:35having participated in the
- 1:22:37decision-making process, which in this
- 1:22:39case required consent, because you
- 1:22:41can't live in the water, you can't live
- 1:22:43without water there. And for those who
- 1:22:47are in the tropics, they know even more
- 1:22:48about the importance of water due to
- 1:22:50the heat, right? So, here I share with
- 1:22:53you these two gems. Um, and here there
- 1:23:00is a call to action. On one side we
- 1:23:03have Xochimilco, on the other side we
- 1:23:05have the cenotes, the YucatĂĄn
- 1:23:06Peninsula as parts of this territory,
- 1:23:08right? The, the process of co-evolution
- 1:23:12led to these places existing and being
- 1:23:15maintained. Today there are other
- 1:23:17rulings that I suggest you take a look
- 1:23:19at, like the Kichwa peopleâs case
- 1:23:21from the Inter-American Court, or this
- 1:23:23one from the Central Valleys of Oaxaca.
- 1:23:28The one from the Central Valleys of
- 1:23:30Oaxaca seems brilliant to me because of
- 1:23:32what we were talking about, regarding
- 1:23:34the order to create and issue communal
- 1:23:37water titles in favor of the water
- 1:23:39committees of the traditional Zapotec
- 1:23:41authorities. That figure was not in the
- 1:23:45National Waters Law, and here the
- 1:23:47justice operator showed a lot of
- 1:23:50creativity, right? And they constructed
- 1:23:53a legal solution for a complicated and
- 1:23:56complex problem, right? This is the La
- 1:24:00Antigua River basin, which I mentioned
- 1:24:02a moment ago. This basin has been
- 1:24:04defended, first against dams, then it
- 1:24:07was defended against companies that
- 1:24:10wanted to take the water, and now it is
- 1:24:13being defended against the lack of
- 1:24:16sanitation provided by the
- 1:24:18municipalities, right? Or what the
- 1:24:20local governments don't do. And this is
- 1:24:22a body that also, according to the
- 1:24:24peoples who inhabit it, well, it is a
- 1:24:27sacred body, right? Uh, well, to wrap
- 1:24:31things up, meet the hour and a half of
- 1:24:33talk, and be able to move on to
- 1:24:35questions, I want to close with this,
- 1:24:37perhaps with this reflection, right?
- 1:24:40Where does bioculturality begin? And
- 1:24:44the answer I have found when I have
- 1:24:46walked the paths and roads of this
- 1:24:48country, and from the people, is that
- 1:24:50it is in the individuals, it is in the
- 1:24:52communities. And when someone tells me,
- 1:24:56"I love the La Antigua River." They are
- 1:24:59telling me, as I showed you in the IPCC
- 1:25:02diagram, "I am with the river. We
- 1:25:06cannot exist without nature, comrades."
- 1:25:10So, the bioculturality paradigm, I
- 1:25:13believe, is a gift that the Indigenous,
- 1:25:16Afro-Mexican, and equivalent
- 1:25:18communities have given us. Uh, and now
- 1:25:22it is up to us to see how we are going
- 1:25:24to honor it, right? And this honoring
- 1:25:28has to do with building law and
- 1:25:30providing plausible solutions. As I was
- 1:25:34telling you, I know many of you have
- 1:25:38little time to read, so thinking that
- 1:25:41you shouldn't have to read, I share a
- 1:25:45couple of videos that are available
- 1:25:48here. The first is a report we made on
- 1:25:53the destruction of biocultural heritage
- 1:25:55. It was made with various
- 1:25:57organizations and several Indigenous
- 1:25:59peoples. It is a report that was
- 1:26:02presented before the Inter-American
- 1:26:04Commission on Human Rights in 2013, and
- 1:26:06the report is online, and the video is
- 1:26:08online. I truly recommend that you
- 1:26:10watch it. Uh, if you want to see the
- 1:26:14case of biocultural heritage applied to
- 1:26:16agriculture, I recommend this
- 1:26:17documentary made by Radio and
- 1:26:19Television of the Universidad
- 1:26:20Veracruzana called Tri Lotli. It's
- 1:26:23episode 15. At the Mexican Center for
- 1:26:27Environmental Law, a few years ago, we
- 1:26:29made this pair of documentaries called
- 1:26:31AT, which is the reflection and vision
- 1:26:34of the Maseual people regarding water,
- 1:26:36or the one on Mandinga, which is an
- 1:26:38Afro-Mexican community and their
- 1:26:40relationship with the sea. And this one
- 1:26:44, which is tougher, is the Totonac
- 1:26:47vision of the hydrocarbon problem,
- 1:26:49which is the song of the mountain. Take
- 1:26:55a look, they will give you many ideas,
- 1:26:57right? Told from the very voice of the
- 1:27:00people. This has no intermediaries,
- 1:27:03meaning it's not some theorist telling
- 1:27:06it, but it's the people explaining
- 1:27:09heartfeltly how these other paradigms
- 1:27:11are lived, right? And well, I finish
- 1:27:16here. Uh, it has been a privilege and
- 1:27:19an honor to be able to share my words
- 1:27:20with you and to have you listen to me.
- 1:27:29And I hand the voice back so we can
- 1:27:30chat for a little while. Thank you very
- 1:27:33much.
- 1:27:37Thank you so much for the, uh, talk,
- 1:27:39for the lecture. It has been truly
- 1:27:42illustrative, especially for learning
- 1:27:44about biocultural heritage, and I think
- 1:27:46the materials you shared with us will
- 1:27:48also help us quite a bit, including the
- 1:27:50rulings, right? And above all, that you
- 1:27:53have been pointing out or giving us
- 1:27:55these, uh, notes on where to start,
- 1:27:57right? Because sometimes when one
- 1:27:59starts a topic, they don't know where
- 1:28:00to begin. So, if you think it's okay,
- 1:28:04we will move on to the Q&A section. Ah,
- 1:28:08we have received many questions, and if
- 1:28:10you like, let's go in blocks of three
- 1:28:13questions so we have time to, well,
- 1:28:15capture them well and be able to answer
- 1:28:17them, and we will see how far we get
- 1:28:19with these questions. Uh, the first
- 1:28:24question asks, or rather, we are asked,
- 1:28:26what does the term "symbolic spaces
- 1:28:28appropriated by peoples" refer to? That
- 1:28:33is the first question. Uh, the second
- 1:28:37one says, "I understand that people who
- 1:28:39inhabit territories with a particular
- 1:28:42conception of biocultural heritage
- 1:28:44framed in tradition, such as the
- 1:28:46Mennonites, are considered comparable
- 1:28:48communities. But I would like to know
- 1:28:52if Italian immigrants in Chipilo,
- 1:28:55Puebla, and Guanajuato, Mexico, and
- 1:28:57organized people from Woods are also,
- 1:29:00how or who validates them? Are they
- 1:29:03also the result of a self-ascription
- 1:29:05process? And the third question asks,"
- 1:29:09How deep-rooted is the customary law of
- 1:29:12indigenous peoples in Western societies
- 1:29:15like ours? "
- 1:29:20David, a favor, could you repeat the
- 1:29:22third one? I didn't understand the
- 1:29:23third one.
- 1:29:25Yes." How deep-rooted is the customary
- 1:29:29law of indigenous peoples in Western
- 1:29:32societies like ours? "
- 1:29:44Uh, thank you very much for the
- 1:29:46questions. I will share some
- 1:29:48reflections on them, acknowledging that
- 1:29:51what I say is also an incomplete answer
- 1:29:54; we will have to keep building them
- 1:29:57and giving them more content. The first
- 1:30:01question is the topic of symbolic
- 1:30:04spaces, right? And symbolic spaces are
- 1:30:07very varied. For example, with
- 1:30:11Amazonian peoples, they paint their
- 1:30:14bodies, and when they paint their
- 1:30:16bodies, they are representing the
- 1:30:18territory. They are saying," The
- 1:30:21territory is the body. "And we have
- 1:30:24also seen that with feminists, right?
- 1:30:27Starting with, the territory begins
- 1:30:29with the body. What are the cares we
- 1:30:31take for the body? Now, symbolic spaces
- 1:30:35are manifold, but sacred sites are
- 1:30:38those that allow, or are the easiest,
- 1:30:41to recognize. So, for example, with the
- 1:30:46Nayaris and the Wirraricas in Nayarit,
- 1:30:49at the San Pedro River, you may have
- 1:30:52heard of the CFE hydroelectric project,
- 1:30:55the dam there. Um, and which would mean
- 1:31:00, for instance, the disappearance
- 1:31:03through flooding of the Muchaena, a
- 1:31:05sacred site. So, one of the paths we
- 1:31:11have found to make this biocultural
- 1:31:14heritage or these territories visible
- 1:31:18has had to do with the exercise of
- 1:31:22community mapping, maps where what the
- 1:31:26executive branch usually does not see
- 1:31:30is made visible, right? So those those
- 1:31:34those maps become absolutely
- 1:31:36transcendent, because those maps not
- 1:31:38only have the political boundaries or
- 1:31:40the relief contours, but they have much
- 1:31:42more information. They refer to
- 1:31:45community and public spaces, they refer
- 1:31:48to the places upon which the peoples
- 1:31:50depend and, above all, they construct
- 1:31:53or make visible a managed biocultural
- 1:31:55landscape, right? And all of those are
- 1:32:00symbols of the territory. So I think my
- 1:32:03answer there has to do with being able
- 1:32:08to identify what is in the territory,
- 1:32:12and that is why I told you how one
- 1:32:14looks at it. Uh, regarding the second
- 1:32:18question, the topic of self-ascription,
- 1:32:20uh you referred to self-ascription,
- 1:32:24right?,of indigenous peoples, right?
- 1:32:26What I heard was the Mennonite
- 1:32:28communities or the topic of Italians or
- 1:32:31French who arrived here. Um, it is a
- 1:32:35very interesting reflection. Uh, the
- 1:32:39path I know and that we have seen has
- 1:32:42to do with differences. uh, well, much
- 1:32:46larger epistemic and ontological ones,
- 1:32:48right? Well, in the end, a person of
- 1:32:51French origin or a person of Italian
- 1:32:54origin, uh, belongs to the Western
- 1:32:57world. That does not mean that within
- 1:32:59the Western world there are no
- 1:33:00indigenous peoples, right? There is the
- 1:33:02famous case of the Roma people. Um, so
- 1:33:06it seems to me that when we deal with
- 1:33:09this issue, we must indeed apply the
- 1:33:12topic of self-ascription and we should
- 1:33:15also apply the topic of the uses and
- 1:33:17habits of the territory, because that
- 1:33:20is where the difference lies. So I can
- 1:33:25attest, because I happened to be a
- 1:33:27trial lawyer, in the case of the Mayan
- 1:33:30honey, the Mayan communities, that the
- 1:33:32Mennonite community in the Yucatan
- 1:33:35Peninsula does not have the deep roots
- 1:33:37of the Mayan community. So, we often
- 1:33:41hear, for example, the testimony of how
- 1:33:44in one night, with two bulldozers and a
- 1:33:47chain, the jungle was torn down and how
- 1:33:50the community didn't know they were
- 1:33:52destroying not only the jungle but the
- 1:33:55Maya community water management system
- 1:33:58created centuries ago, right? This,
- 1:34:02this that I was telling you about the"
- 1:34:03sartenejas "of the" chatutunes. "So, it
- 1:34:06seems to me that this issue of
- 1:34:08self-ascription must also be read
- 1:34:10through the lens of habitus and customs
- 1:34:12. And above all, these other tools that
- 1:34:16I was telling you about as well, right?
- 1:34:18These principles of bioculturality.
- 1:34:20What is the biocultural heritage of the
- 1:34:21Mennonite people settled on the
- 1:34:23YucatĂĄn Peninsula, for example? Does
- 1:34:26that biocultural heritage exist? Is its
- 1:34:28control at risk, or what is the nature
- 1:34:31of the dispute? Um, and I'll finish
- 1:34:35this question with a very interesting
- 1:34:37case I learned about in BrasĂlia. In
- 1:34:43BrasĂlia, the capital of Brazil, I had
- 1:34:45the chance to visit an ancestral
- 1:34:47territory, but this ancestral territory
- 1:34:50was newânew in the sense of its
- 1:34:52occupationâbecause this people had
- 1:34:55been displaced, and because they had
- 1:34:57been displaced, they had to settle on
- 1:35:00the periphery of the city due to
- 1:35:02insecurity and other circumstances. And
- 1:35:07it was very interesting how this
- 1:35:10habitus and these customs had been
- 1:35:13relocated and transferred to this new
- 1:35:17space. The community was reproducing
- 1:35:19itself, right? And here I recommend
- 1:35:21that you read MartĂnez Luna on"
- 1:35:23comunalidad "(communality). The same
- 1:35:25thing happens, for example, with
- 1:35:28Oaxacan migrants in New York or with
- 1:35:30communities from the state of Puebla in
- 1:35:33Chicago and other places. There are
- 1:35:37very interesting studies where they
- 1:35:39rent the entire building, and in that
- 1:35:41building, their own normative systems
- 1:35:43and their own local authorities are
- 1:35:45reproduced, right? So, the community is
- 1:35:49reconstituted in a new location. And
- 1:35:55the last one, David, you mentioned it
- 1:35:58was the topic of local systems in
- 1:36:00Western societies. I think this
- 1:36:05question is interesting because here in
- 1:36:08our region, in Latin America, is where
- 1:36:10this reinvention of the State came from
- 1:36:13, based on the paradigm of
- 1:36:14plurinationality. Uh, and there is the
- 1:36:18paradigmatic case of Bolivia and
- 1:36:21Ecuador, where we don't have dominant
- 1:36:24minority societies like the urban and
- 1:36:28mestizo societies, and where we have a
- 1:36:31large portion of the indigenous
- 1:36:34population that has these other systems
- 1:36:37. And therefore, the very interesting
- 1:36:41reflection here is legal pluralism and
- 1:36:44how we maximize autonomy, right? And
- 1:36:47there isâI really like this ruling
- 1:36:50from the Court of Suchilquitongo, if I
- 1:36:52remember correctlyâthat whenever
- 1:36:55possible, we should bet on the autonomy
- 1:36:58of the peoples, because that will
- 1:37:00generate a plausible and adequate
- 1:37:02solution to the problem. So, um, on
- 1:37:06this matter, I would also recommend
- 1:37:08that the person who asked the question
- 1:37:11read this book by Boaventura de Sousa
- 1:37:13Santos called*The Refounding of the
- 1:37:16State*, which comes from this
- 1:37:18reflection on this paradigm that has
- 1:37:20now, uh, become interwoven into our
- 1:37:23constitutions and where much has been
- 1:37:25woven, right? Also, the '91
- 1:37:28Constitution of Colombia and the
- 1:37:30interpretation given by its courts is
- 1:37:32quite interesting. So I think there is
- 1:37:35an important commitment to legal
- 1:37:38pluralism there. Ready, David.
- 1:37:41Perfect, thank you very much. And well,
- 1:37:44next there are two somewhat, uh, broad
- 1:37:46questions, so I am going to read two so
- 1:37:49that we can capture their essence and
- 1:37:52then we will move on, if we have time,
- 1:37:54to another two. The first question asks
- 1:37:58," Should the legal defense of
- 1:38:00biocultural heritage be limited to
- 1:38:02reactive mechanisms like litigation, or
- 1:38:05are there preventive paths within the
- 1:38:07law? Specifically, how can applied
- 1:38:11research guide institutions in creating
- 1:38:14strategies for the sustainable use and
- 1:38:17protection of various artisanal and/or
- 1:38:20traditional products and territories?
- 1:38:26The second question, uh, asks us, "
- 1:38:29Wouldn't defending nature through
- 1:38:31biocultural rights make the defense of
- 1:38:34nature anthropocentric? What difference
- 1:38:39would there be compared to defense
- 1:38:41through other mechanisms like the
- 1:38:42recognition of ecosystem services?
- 1:38:49David, I heard you a bit poorly. Can
- 1:38:52you repeat the second one, please? Of
- 1:38:55course. Wouldn't defending nature
- 1:38:59through biocultural rights make the
- 1:39:02defense of nature anthropocentric? What
- 1:39:07difference would there be compared to
- 1:39:09defense through other mechanisms like
- 1:39:10the recognition of ecosystem services?
- 1:39:18Thank you very much for the questions,
- 1:39:20I find them quite interesting. So, the
- 1:39:23first one about the topic of whether
- 1:39:24there are other strategies besides just
- 1:39:26litigation to protect biocultural
- 1:39:28rights and rights of nature. The answer
- 1:39:30is yes, there are. Uh, and many things
- 1:39:33have been built, right? I was telling
- 1:39:36you a little while ago about the topic,
- 1:39:40for example, of life plans, right? Of,
- 1:39:44of the peoples who, I mean, I was
- 1:39:46telling you about this reflection from
- 1:39:48Colombia and how that has intertwined
- 1:39:50in other places. Also thinking about
- 1:39:54that, for example, peoples have made
- 1:39:56use of creating their own consultation
- 1:39:59protocols, right? And I invite you to
- 1:40:02look at this page from a Brazilian
- 1:40:04organization that is called exactly the
- 1:40:06Consultation Protocol Observatory. And
- 1:40:11we have seen other countless efforts
- 1:40:13for the prevention and protection of
- 1:40:16biocultural heritage. I think a lot
- 1:40:19about the maps we just discussed a
- 1:40:21moment ago, these community maps to
- 1:40:23show what is there and how the
- 1:40:25territory is cared for. I think about
- 1:40:29the experience of cooperatives, right?
- 1:40:33Cooperatives have been one of the great
- 1:40:35instruments that Indigenous peoples
- 1:40:37have found to protect their
- 1:40:38organizations and protect their
- 1:40:40biocultural heritage. And so, I think
- 1:40:45of the example of Oaxaca with communal
- 1:40:49property, for instance, which is a very
- 1:40:52cherished experience, and I think there
- 1:40:56are many others. It seems to me, and I
- 1:41:01have witnessed, for example, that the
- 1:41:05need to protect biocultural heritage
- 1:41:08has led to the creation of new
- 1:41:11indigenous authorities based on
- 1:41:14reflection of where they are and what
- 1:41:18is currently required, right? And that,
- 1:41:22for example, is super inspiring because
- 1:41:24it also calls upon the creativity of
- 1:41:27the peoples, and appeals to previous
- 1:41:29experiences and revitalization, right?
- 1:41:32In other words, functions that they had
- 1:41:34and that perhaps were lost are
- 1:41:35revitalized and rethought, and they
- 1:41:37seek to create new solutions from there
- 1:41:39. So, that has also come up in many
- 1:41:43ways. I think, just now while I was on
- 1:41:47this, I remembered that at the time
- 1:41:49there was the issue, for example, of
- 1:41:52GMO-free zones, with the corn issue; it
- 1:41:54didn't go well for me on that topic,
- 1:41:57but with corn, I remember PichĂĄtaro.
- 1:42:00And this legal circumstance, for
- 1:42:02example, led to thinking of schemes not
- 1:42:07based on Western law. And so, for
- 1:42:10example, the peoples started a seed
- 1:42:13protection strategy through community
- 1:42:16seed banks that function on a
- 1:42:18reciprocal basis, for example, right? I
- 1:42:22lend to you and then you lend to me. Or
- 1:42:24seed fairs, right? Seed fairs are one
- 1:42:27of the great bets on making use of
- 1:42:30their own normative systems, such as
- 1:42:32the free exchange of seeds, something
- 1:42:34that the agribusiness industry does not
- 1:42:37like, nor do breeder's rights and those
- 1:42:39kinds of things. So yes, there are a
- 1:42:44lot of strategies that have not
- 1:42:46necessarily been litigious, or that
- 1:42:49perhaps later turned into litigation,
- 1:42:52which were built from the creativity
- 1:42:55and cultural relevance of each people,
- 1:42:58thinking about the need that was to be
- 1:43:01addressed. And the other, the question
- 1:43:07was: whether this defense of the of
- 1:43:13nature through biocultural rights
- 1:43:15wasn't, or rather didn't remain, uh,
- 1:43:17anthropocentric, and whether that might
- 1:43:20have to do with, for example, what I
- 1:43:22understood as payment for, uh,
- 1:43:24hydrological systems, right?
- 1:43:28environmental services. Well, I don't
- 1:43:30think so. I think the logic under which
- 1:43:34they are built is different, and that's
- 1:43:37why the dialogue of knowledge becomes
- 1:43:41so important, because if that isn't
- 1:43:44made possible, it just continues to be
- 1:43:47a construction from a single place. And
- 1:43:51when we open the door to these other
- 1:43:54forms, uh, well, other things come
- 1:43:57along. For example, I think of I think
- 1:44:06that when the La Antigua River was
- 1:44:08defended, when it was defended, it was
- 1:44:10made clear that there is a spiritual
- 1:44:12relationship with the people, right?
- 1:44:15The same thing I was telling you about
- 1:44:19the mining company; if that spiritual
- 1:44:23relationship is broken, the people die,
- 1:44:26right? That translates, for example,
- 1:44:30into migration, it translates into
- 1:44:32losses. So, this is on a different
- 1:44:35level, right? It's on a biocultural
- 1:44:38level. Payment for hydrological
- 1:44:40services or payment for environmental
- 1:44:43services is very much based on the
- 1:44:45Western logic of monetary compensation,
- 1:44:48right? And the people don't necessarily
- 1:44:50require that. I, for example, think of
- 1:44:54the case of CEDICAM and JesĂșs LeĂłn
- 1:44:58Santos, who is Mixtec. This JesĂșs
- 1:45:03LeĂłn Santos received the Goldman Prize
- 1:45:05many years ago. Which is the equivalent
- 1:45:11of a Nobel Prize in environmental
- 1:45:14matters, and they received that award
- 1:45:17because of the work they had done to
- 1:45:20combat erosion in the Mixteca region,
- 1:45:23in the upper Mixteca, based on their
- 1:45:27own indigenous normative systems. And
- 1:45:31they built it without compensation,
- 1:45:33that is, based on mutual aid, on
- 1:45:35communal work, sorry. Apart from that,
- 1:45:39based on communal work, they built
- 1:45:412,000 km of trenches to capture water.
- 1:45:452,000 km of trenches, friends, that's
- 1:45:47from Mexico City to Cancun without
- 1:45:49being paid. The logic of compensation
- 1:45:54wasn't there. In the logic of
- 1:45:56bioculturality, and this is also very
- 1:45:59important for us to keep in mind, it is
- 1:46:03governed by other values, as I was
- 1:46:05telling you here. So, the values that
- 1:46:09are usually put on the table have to do
- 1:46:12with experience and service. So, one
- 1:46:17ascends in the social position of the
- 1:46:20town or community according to how one
- 1:46:23serves and how one acquires experience.
- 1:46:27So, they are, well, they are different
- 1:46:29values, right? So, the ontology is
- 1:46:32definitely different. Well, Iâll
- 1:46:35leave that comment there.
- 1:46:38Very well, thank you very much. And we
- 1:46:39will continue with two more questions.
- 1:46:43The first one says," Given the
- 1:46:45multicultural nature of our nation, is
- 1:46:48it possible to consider requiring
- 1:46:50judges to visit these territories in
- 1:46:53person to see the impacts of the
- 1:46:55reported situation firsthand? "The idea
- 1:46:59of committees within the judiciary
- 1:47:01would be like a type of specialized
- 1:47:03jury. And the second one asks," To what
- 1:47:07extent can an environmental policy be
- 1:47:10considered a true human rights policy
- 1:47:12if it protects biodiversity, but does
- 1:47:15not protect the rights of the
- 1:47:17communities that have historically
- 1:47:19cared for and inhabited those
- 1:47:21territories? "
- 1:47:29David, Iâm very sorry to say that it
- 1:47:31cut out on me again. Can you repeat
- 1:47:33that? I hope thatâs not happening
- 1:47:35with my signal, but I lost you
- 1:47:37completely.
- 1:47:38I think itâs mine, but Iâll repeat
- 1:47:40the second question, right? Or all of
- 1:47:42them?
- 1:47:43No, particularly the first, and if you
- 1:47:45could repeat the second one as well, I
- 1:47:46would appreciate it. Sure. The first
- 1:47:51one says," Given the multicultural
- 1:47:53nature of our nation, is it possible to
- 1:47:56consider requiring judges to visit
- 1:47:59these territories in person to see the
- 1:48:02impacts of the reported situation
- 1:48:04firsthand? "The committees within the
- 1:48:08judiciary would be like a type of
- 1:48:11specialized jury. And repeat the second
- 1:48:18one for me. You were saying that an
- 1:48:20environmental policy...
- 1:48:23Sure. Yes. To what extent can an
- 1:48:25environmental policy be considered a
- 1:48:28true human rights policy? If it
- 1:48:31protects biodiversity, but fails to
- 1:48:33protect the rights of the communities
- 1:48:35that have historically cared for and
- 1:48:36inhabited their territories.
- 1:48:42Thank you very much. Great questions.
- 1:48:45The one about the advisory committee
- 1:48:48and, well, for me, from what Iâve
- 1:48:50learned as a litigating attorney,
- 1:48:53itâs very difficult. Usually, with
- 1:48:58judicial inspections, what tends to
- 1:49:00happen to me is: the court or district
- 1:49:03judge requests assistance from a local
- 1:49:06court; the local court sends its clerk,
- 1:49:09and that clerk performs the inspection,
- 1:49:12files the report, and sends it back.
- 1:49:17The translation is that the judge
- 1:49:19remains somewhat blind because they
- 1:49:21didn't stand on the territory, they
- 1:49:23didn't understand, they didn't feel it;
- 1:49:25thereâs a difference between what we
- 1:49:27understand intellectually and actually
- 1:49:30standing on the land and having a
- 1:49:32sensory experience, right? And that is
- 1:49:36often what these inspections are for.
- 1:49:39The challenge for many litigators has
- 1:49:42to do with how we can get judges to be
- 1:49:44out in the territories. I think that
- 1:49:47shouldn't be difficult. I mean, I think
- 1:49:49, how many biocultural cases does a
- 1:49:51district court have? The truth is, not
- 1:49:54that many. Um, and if there is a desire
- 1:49:58to be able to understand, it seems to
- 1:50:01me there are ways to build paths so
- 1:50:03that this can happen. And the issue of
- 1:50:07the advisory committee, right? The only
- 1:50:09thing the advisory committee has to do
- 1:50:12is provide information and, above all,
- 1:50:14translation for the judge. I will
- 1:50:17explain: we are in a process of
- 1:50:20sentence execution. In this sentence
- 1:50:24execution, it is a complex technical
- 1:50:26environmental issue, and every time the
- 1:50:31responsible authority submits its
- 1:50:33compliance reports, the court says," Ah
- 1:50:35, thank you very much. I'll give you
- 1:50:40another 20 days and I reserve my ruling
- 1:50:43until the end, "right? Until I have to
- 1:50:47determine whether the sentence is
- 1:50:48complied with or not. And we have told
- 1:50:53them," Hey, you have to rule now. They
- 1:51:00are pulling the wool over your eyes, as
- 1:51:02we say in good Mexican, because what
- 1:51:04you are not realizing is that they are
- 1:51:07destroying the natural heritage that
- 1:51:09the sentence says to protect. And the
- 1:51:13more you delay this, when you have to
- 1:51:17rule on it, there will be nothing left
- 1:51:19to rule on because it will be destroyed
- 1:51:21. You need advice, and the court's
- 1:51:26response has been no. No way until I
- 1:51:30issue my ruling. So, this court is
- 1:51:34still stuck in the logic of the
- 1:51:37traditional vision of justice delivery.
- 1:51:43And that, in environmental or
- 1:51:45biocultural matters, is obsolete,
- 1:51:47because what it will do is disrupt what
- 1:51:50we were saying about the purpose of the
- 1:51:53law, right? I mean, what it will do is
- 1:51:56make this sentence have a useless
- 1:51:58effect, and the uselessness of a
- 1:52:00sentence translates into the
- 1:52:02discrediting of the judiciary and,
- 1:52:04therefore, the loss of legitimacy of
- 1:52:06the judicial power. So, here comes the
- 1:52:11issue of how we make these paradigm
- 1:52:14shifts, right? And therefore, therefore
- 1:52:17, if the Constitution is our compass
- 1:52:19and our navigation map, and
- 1:52:21bioculturality is already inscribed
- 1:52:23here like DNA, then let's use it, right
- 1:52:26? Let's inhabit it to make better
- 1:52:28decisions. Well, regarding the topic of
- 1:52:33public policy for biocultural
- 1:52:36protection, I think, and in one of the
- 1:52:39readings I shared with you, there is a
- 1:52:43reflection on how we build a
- 1:52:45biocultural democracy, because for a
- 1:52:49public policy to be biocultural, it
- 1:52:52needs to be built from the origin with
- 1:52:56the people, and that, that
- 1:52:59horizontality, we haven't developed yet
- 1:53:02, have we? Sadly. So, what we have is a
- 1:53:07public policy that continues to be
- 1:53:09built from a single vision. We, I
- 1:53:13remember very well when in the last
- 1:53:16administration the "Sembrando Vida"
- 1:53:19program was published on CONAMER, and
- 1:53:22look, "Sembrando Vida" does have many
- 1:53:25elements of the American vision. We
- 1:53:29told them, "Allow us to consult, allow
- 1:53:33us to participate on our own terms with
- 1:53:36the appropriate timeframes." And if I
- 1:53:39recall correctly, the program was in
- 1:53:41CONAMER for 5 days, or at most 10 days
- 1:53:44for consultation. It was very little
- 1:53:48time, and that takes away its relevance
- 1:53:50, it takes away the opportunity to be
- 1:53:53built in biocultural terms, and
- 1:53:55therefore, to actually follow this
- 1:53:57logic. So, if we bet on bioculturality,
- 1:54:01because surely Car told you this, right
- 1:54:04? But in Mexico, there is no virgin,
- 1:54:06pristine ecosystem that hasn't been
- 1:54:08intervened in; rather, all ecosystems
- 1:54:11in this country have been managed since
- 1:54:13we have had Mesoamerican peoples and
- 1:54:16the travelers, right? A-and then here
- 1:54:23comes the change of mindset, right, of
- 1:54:25genetics. The question is, how do we
- 1:54:28build legislation and policy that is
- 1:54:30bioculturally appropriate? And that
- 1:54:33involves incorporating their voice in a
- 1:54:36meaningful way into the construction of
- 1:54:38these decisions, and that is where we
- 1:54:40are, right? I mean, that, I mean, we
- 1:54:45are starting to glimpse this abyss and
- 1:54:47now we will have to build the bridge to
- 1:54:49cross it. Very good, David. Thank you.
- 1:54:55Perfect, thank you very much, and well,
- 1:54:57we are already running out of time. So,
- 1:55:00we thank you again for the presentation
- 1:55:02. I think it has been a presentation
- 1:55:06from which we have learned a lot,
- 1:55:07especially from these tools and key
- 1:55:09points you leave us, above all, to
- 1:55:11access a deeper knowledge. The readings
- 1:55:13, of course, that you have suggested
- 1:55:15and that can be found on the platform.
- 1:55:18Also, I think they are a very relevant
- 1:55:21resource, and well, again, to reiterate
- 1:55:23our gratitude for the presentation. And
- 1:55:28we remind those listening to us that
- 1:55:31each session implies, in addition to
- 1:55:33attending this class, dedicating one
- 1:55:35hour to autonomous study and work,
- 1:55:38consisting of reading the reference
- 1:55:40sources indicated in the documents
- 1:55:42available on the platform. Likewise,
- 1:55:46the exam corresponding to module 1 will
- 1:55:49be available until Friday, August 14,
- 1:55:522026. Thank you very much for joining
- 1:55:55us. We will meet next Thursday, August
- 1:55:5813, for session 13 titled Scientific
- 1:56:00knowledge and community wisdom in
- 1:56:02environmental protection. See you later
- 1:56:05. Thank you very much,
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of đđ±âïžâDiplomado en medio ambiente, bioculturalidad y derechos humanos by Casas de los Saberes JurĂdicos, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 15,397 words across 2,394 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator â no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.