🌎🌱⚖️​Diplomado en medio ambiente, bioculturalidad y derechos humanos — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00and a length that reaches below the
- 0:02other. I am wearing gold-framed glasses
- 0:05, as well as a pale pink blouse with a
- 0:08red line, and my pronouns are she/her.
- 0:11Today we begin session 10 titled "
- 0:13International Legal Framework for the
- 0:15Protection of Biocultural Heritage,"
- 0:17which is part of module two, "
- 0:19Protection of Biocultural Heritage."
- 0:23This session aims to identify the
- 0:24international norms and standards
- 0:26applicable to the protection of
- 0:27biocultural heritage and the state
- 0:29obligations derived from them. Before
- 0:33we begin, it is important to remember
- 0:35that the Zoom room has a maximum
- 0:37capacity of 3,000 people. Once this is
- 0:40reached, the class signal will be a
- 0:42YouTube broadcast that you will also be
- 0:45able to view within the platform. Your
- 0:47attendance will be automatically
- 0:49registered upon entering the Zoom
- 0:51session or the YouTube broadcast within
- 0:53the platform and remaining in it
- 0:54throughout the session. We remind you
- 0:57that if for any reason you cannot
- 0:59connect to the live session, you may
- 1:01view the recording within the platform
- 1:03and verify your attendance, provided
- 1:05you complete the session within the
- 1:07following 7 calendar days. After this
- 1:10period, attendance can no longer be
- 1:12counted. You may submit your comments
- 1:16and concerns in the Q&A section located
- 1:19at the bottom of the Zoom window,
- 1:21marked with a question mark. Your
- 1:25contributions will be reviewed in real
- 1:27time, and we will try to answer as many
- 1:29as possible during the session. We
- 1:32invite you to formulate clear and brief
- 1:35questions, pointing to the specific
- 1:37point you are referring to, in order to
- 1:40facilitate their organization and
- 1:42addressing by the speaker. For all
- 1:46those who require it, the option to
- 1:48enable automated subtitles is available
- 1:50on the Zoom platform. You can enable
- 1:53them by clicking on the "More" option
- 1:56or the three dots in the bottom right
- 1:58corner, then clicking on "Subtitles" or
- 2:00"CC." If you are following the
- 2:04broadcast on YouTube, subtitles are
- 2:06activated automatically. Without
- 2:10further ado, we welcome our speaker for
- 2:12today's session, Licentiate YasmĂn
- 2:14Granados Torres, whom we thank for her
- 2:17willingness to contribute to this
- 2:19training space and whose brief
- 2:21curriculum vitae I will now read.
- 2:24Licentiate YasmĂn Granados Torres is a
- 2:27specialist in indigenous peoples '
- 2:28rights, biocultural rights,
- 2:30environmental governance, and
- 2:32rights-based conservation. With more
- 2:34than 10 years of experience in public
- 2:36policy design, institutional
- 2:38strengthening, and legal protection of
- 2:40biocultural heritage in Latin America.
- 2:44Her career has focused on promoting
- 2:46governance models that integrate
- 2:48biodiversity conservation, traditional
- 2:50knowledge, collective rights, and the
- 2:52participation of indigenous peoples and
- 2:55local communities in the management of
- 2:57their territories. She is currently a
- 3:01legal advisor for the Ocean Program of
- 3:03the Interamerican Association for
- 3:05Environmental Defense, AIDA, where she
- 3:07assists coastal communities and
- 3:09indigenous peoples in defending their
- 3:11rights against projects with impacts on
- 3:13marine and coastal ecosystems. She has
- 3:18worked directly with the PIBL peoples
- 3:20in Costa Rica, in Colombia, and the
- 3:22Kawésqar in Chile, promoting
- 3:24approaches that articulate human rights
- 3:26, environmental governance, and
- 3:28biodiversity conservation. Without
- 3:30further ado, we yield the floor to
- 3:33YasmĂn.
- 3:38Perfect, thank you very much. Good
- 3:40afternoon to everyone. I greet you from
- 3:42San José, Costa Rica. To start, well,
- 3:46my name is Yasmine Granados, I describe
- 3:49myself as a middle-aged person, I have
- 3:52brown skin, black hair. Today I am
- 3:56wearing a striped dress and I think
- 3:59that is it for the description. Um,
- 4:03perhaps to start, if you could share
- 4:06the text. Well, we are adapting to
- 4:10these technological tools to provide
- 4:12this training, although I cannot see
- 4:14you, I know you are there, that you
- 4:16have a lot of interest in learning and
- 4:18I also look forward to learning from
- 4:20you. A couple of introductory points
- 4:24that I would like to express to you. I
- 4:29am a lawyer by training, but I am a
- 4:31person from a coastal community, the
- 4:33community of Naldayure, which is
- 4:35originally a Chorotega indigenous town.
- 4:40And this connection with my community,
- 4:42with the territory, with the ancestral
- 4:44knowledge is also what has nourished me
- 4:46to carry out my work as a lawyer on
- 4:48issues regarding the rights of
- 4:50indigenous peoples and local
- 4:51communities. So, I want you to know
- 4:55that all knowledge is valid in this
- 4:57space and the idea is that we can have
- 5:00a little interaction and I can also
- 5:02learn from you. Before starting with
- 5:06the more theoretical content, I would
- 5:09like to know if anyone had the
- 5:11opportunity to read this poem I sent,
- 5:14which I think is a very beautiful poem
- 5:16and reflects a bit on what the content
- 5:19or reason for protecting the
- 5:21biocultural heritage of peoples is. If
- 5:26anyone had the opportunity to read it,
- 5:28perhaps you would like to share what
- 5:30your impression was, or what it made
- 5:32you feel, or what you were able to take
- 5:34away from this poem by Miguel
- 5:35LeĂłn-Portilla. If there is anyone who
- 5:38would like to share with us. Yes, I
- 5:56think the image of the document is way
- 5:58too big. Um, maybe if you close it. Uh,
- 6:02that's fine. That's fine. I think
- 6:04that's fine. If you didn't read it, you
- 6:06can read it later. Um, I don't know if
- 6:09anyone wants to comment on it. I don't
- 6:13think I can, I can't see them or
- 6:16Yes, for now, we don't have any
- 6:17comments on it, Doctor, regarding the
- 6:19poem.
- 6:20Well, we're starting off a bit shy, but
- 6:22it doesn't matter. When you have the
- 6:24chance to read it, uh, I hope you do.
- 6:28It's a very beautiful poem, and perhaps
- 6:30what I take from this poem by Miguel
- 6:33LeĂłn-Portilla is that the protection
- 6:35of biocultural rights or the protection
- 6:37of biocultural heritage through a tool
- 6:40like, like that of—ah, well, there is
- 6:42, there is—I will read them here and
- 6:44then I will give my...
- 6:47Of course,
- 6:48don't worry. Let's read Antonio's
- 6:51comment. Antonio says that the fact
- 6:53that a language dies is very profound,
- 6:55and the truth is the poem is, uh, it's
- 6:58very beautiful, it evokes, it evokes
- 7:00many feelings. Uh, Pierina says that
- 7:02when a language dies, the people lose
- 7:04their identity, and this, Isabel says
- 7:06that when a language dies, all the
- 7:08testimony of what it was dies. She also
- 7:13says that when we lose a language, we
- 7:15lose identity, tradition, and ancestral
- 7:17knowledge. Thank you very much for your
- 7:20opinions. This poem, I think, captures
- 7:23precisely this reality of the
- 7:26importance of protecting biocultural
- 7:28heritage. Biocultural heritage
- 7:31connected to language, to the tongue,
- 7:34as Miguel LeĂłn-Portilla explains, is a
- 7:36way of understanding the world; it is a
- 7:39way of understanding how we relate to
- 7:42the world, and for that reason, it has
- 7:44relevant importance for the existence
- 7:46not only of indigenous peoples, of
- 7:49communities, but also of all of
- 7:51humanity. The knowledge that
- 7:55communities and peoples maintain, which
- 7:57is reflected through their practices,
- 8:00their traditions, their artistic and
- 8:02cultural manifestations, uh, of
- 8:05language, of community structure, and
- 8:07it is an approach to that world. It is
- 8:12also important for us, those who
- 8:14dedicate themselves to law or who want
- 8:16to learn about law, how the law as a
- 8:18tool should approach communities, right
- 8:20? The law is a tool, it is a way of
- 8:24preserving different legal assets; and
- 8:30it is necessary for us to understand
- 8:32that we are not just protecting, uh,
- 8:35rights, or simply protecting people,
- 8:38simply communities, but an entire
- 8:40heritage, an entire collection, which,
- 8:43that belongs to its holders, to the
- 8:46communities, but which is also of
- 8:48relevance to humanity. So, I always
- 8:51invite you to reach that reflection,
- 8:54and also those who specifically
- 8:55dedicate themselves to these topics,
- 8:57how we approach biocultural heritage.
- 9:00Biocultural heritage is going to be
- 9:03different, uh, varying by country, by
- 9:08community, by culture. So, that
- 9:11approach has to be an approach that
- 9:13allows us to open up a bit, uh, our
- 9:15visions of what the world is like. And
- 9:19that the law, while it is a tool, is
- 9:21often a bit, uh, closed off to
- 9:23understanding these realities; and that
- 9:25is why we also need different kinds of
- 9:28knowledge, not just legal, but also
- 9:30local knowledge and also other sciences
- 9:32, other, other interdisciplinary
- 9:34approaches to understand them. So, that
- 9:38was a little bit of what I wanted to
- 9:40share with you about this poem, and we
- 9:42are going to continue with the, with
- 9:44the presentation. Now then, the
- 9:52international legal framework for the
- 9:54protection of, uh, biocultural heritage
- 9:57. In this lesson, on this occasion, we
- 10:01are going to work on three specific
- 10:03topics or learning objectives: what are
- 10:05the international norms that protect
- 10:07biocultural heritage. As a second point
- 10:11, what are the international standards
- 10:13on the protection of biocultural
- 10:15heritage? And third, what are the state
- 10:18obligations regarding the protection of
- 10:20biocultural heritage? To begin with,
- 10:25there is the question of what
- 10:27biocultural heritage is. How can
- 10:29biocultural heritage be defined? In
- 10:33literature, it is conceived as that
- 10:35interdependence between biological
- 10:37diversity and cultural diversity. It is
- 10:40also conceived as that series of
- 10:42traditional knowledge that integrates
- 10:45languages, practices, territories, and
- 10:47natural resources. It is also a concept
- 10:50developed from conservation,
- 10:52anthropology, and human rights.
- 10:56Biocultural heritage as a concept is,
- 10:59is a dynamic concept that can evolve,
- 11:02but it refers to all that accumulation
- 11:05of knowledge or this framework of, of
- 11:11this framework that involves culture
- 11:14and biodiversity. Before reaching the
- 11:19point of developing legal tools or
- 11:21interpreting the protection of
- 11:24biocultural heritage in a legal way, it
- 11:26is important that we have clarity on
- 11:29how nature is conserved or how ways to
- 11:32conserve nature have been created. In
- 11:37Latin America, for a long time, we had
- 11:39an environmental conservation scheme
- 11:42very focused on the standards developed
- 11:45by countries like the United States or,
- 11:47mostly, the global north, where
- 11:50environmental conservation had a vision
- 11:52of conserving natural resources just to
- 11:55conserve them, to keep them there. A
- 11:59kind of segregation, a conservation
- 12:02model that sought, uh, for people, for
- 12:05peoples to be, uh, external to the
- 12:07conservation of this natural heritage.
- 12:11And that is why, for example, this
- 12:13system of national parks is created.
- 12:15National parks, biological reserves,
- 12:18which are a very strict kind of
- 12:19protection, did not conceive at the
- 12:21beginning that people, that communities
- 12:24could also make use of those natural
- 12:26resources. What happens over time? As I
- 12:29was saying, the law doesn't evolve on
- 12:32its own; rather, the law responds to
- 12:34the demands of communities, indigenous
- 12:37peoples, and various groups. This is
- 12:40important, why? Because it is these
- 12:43same groups, such as indigenous peoples
- 12:45, coastal communities, and also
- 12:48land-based ones, that begin to demand
- 12:50international protection for
- 12:52biocultural heritage; not just to
- 12:55protect biological resources in
- 12:57themselves, but also because there is
- 13:00an integrated cultural heritage that
- 13:03requires formal recognition by
- 13:05international and national norms. So,
- 13:08it means that we must not only conserve
- 13:10natural resources but also the entire
- 13:12body of knowledge that is intertwined
- 13:14with them. Why? Because biocultural
- 13:17heritage has this synergy. If I only
- 13:20protect the resource, I may neglect the
- 13:22protection of the community, the
- 13:25protection of the language, the
- 13:27protection of knowledge, of the ways of
- 13:29using nature, of its transmission, and
- 13:32I create a fragmentation, a
- 13:34segmentation. So, know that these legal
- 13:38norms we are going to see are born from
- 13:40those demands made by these groups, and
- 13:42I am sure they will continue to push at
- 13:44the international and national levels
- 13:46so that their rights and the rights
- 13:48over their natural resources, their
- 13:50lands, and their collective property
- 13:52are recognized internationally. As I
- 13:58mentioned, the evolution of this, uh,
- 14:00of this concept has been developing
- 14:03over a long time, and its first legal
- 14:06recognitions came in the Convention on
- 14:09Biological Diversity in '92, in which
- 14:11Article 8 (j), a pioneering article for
- 14:14the topic of biocultural biodiversity,
- 14:17recognizes that traditional knowledge
- 14:20and practices of indigenous peoples
- 14:23must be protected. And communities,
- 14:27right? Also, in 2000, in 2010,
- 14:30recognition was given to traditional
- 14:32knowledge and access to genetic
- 14:34resources. This is important because a
- 14:38focus on human rights and environmental
- 14:40justice begins to be integrated here.
- 14:42What does this mean? That access to
- 14:45those genetic resources linked to it,
- 14:48to the access to biodiversity and the
- 14:51traditional knowledge held by
- 14:54communities and groups, must have
- 14:56specific protection. Why? Because for a
- 15:00long time, there have been, and
- 15:01continue to be, cases, for example, of
- 15:03biopiracy, which is the extraction not
- 15:05only of a biological resource but also
- 15:07of the associated knowledge. There have
- 15:11even been cases in Latin America where
- 15:13researchers or foreign companies have
- 15:15arrived to attempt to establish patents
- 15:18on certain knowledge and biological
- 15:20resources, and have even requested, in
- 15:23very extreme cases, that the community
- 15:25not use, for example, a certain plant
- 15:27or a certain piece of knowledge. So,
- 15:30that has no legal basis. Why? Because
- 15:33there is special legal protection for
- 15:35indigenous peoples regarding the
- 15:38management of those territories and all
- 15:40the biological and ancestral heritage
- 15:42linked to that knowledge. This human
- 15:47rights and environmental justice
- 15:49approach seeks to recognize and enforce
- 15:51the rights of indigenous communities
- 15:53and peoples to the autonomy of their
- 15:56territory, right? How are they used? In
- 15:59what way are they used? Right? For
- 16:01example, there are communities that
- 16:04have had to deal not only with this
- 16:06exploitation, this large-scale
- 16:08exploitation of natural resources by
- 16:11third parties, but also, if we review
- 16:14it, they have even been pressured by
- 16:16conservation models. So, what is the
- 16:20conclusion? It's not that it's good or
- 16:23bad, but rather that there continues to
- 16:26be pressure both from development
- 16:28projects and, even, from conservation
- 16:30projects that we could say have a
- 16:32slightly more laudable intention of
- 16:34preservation, but which have also
- 16:36affected the rights of indigenous
- 16:37peoples and have generated, for example
- 16:40, limitations on access to certain
- 16:42resources. Overlaps have been generated
- 16:45, for example, between protected areas
- 16:47and indigenous territories. There has
- 16:50also been the case, for example,
- 16:52specifically in Costa Rica: the
- 16:54creation of certain environmental
- 16:56criminal offenses, I don't know,
- 16:58related to hunting, where community
- 17:00members who were practicing subsistence
- 17:03hunting were at one point criminalized
- 17:05for this situation, which has had to be
- 17:08corrected over time by understanding
- 17:10that the communities, that the
- 17:12indigenous peoples residing on these
- 17:14lands, also have certain access or ways
- 17:18of using natural resources. So, this
- 17:20human rights approach allows us to
- 17:22recognize that we are not only
- 17:24protecting natural resources for their
- 17:27own sake, but also because we are
- 17:29protecting the communities and all
- 17:31their cultural heritage and their
- 17:33existence as communities. What are the
- 17:38international legal principles that are
- 17:41linked to the protection of biocultural
- 17:43heritage? Free determination. All those
- 17:47communities or indigenous peoples that
- 17:50are holders of this knowledge have the
- 17:52right to decide how to use it and also
- 17:55how to conserve it, right? This is very
- 17:58important and must be respected both by
- 18:00legislation and by the public policies
- 18:03that are developed. Also the principle
- 18:06of non-discrimination. As I was saying,
- 18:09for a long time, due to the same issue
- 18:11of structural discrimination, it was
- 18:13conceived that communities were not
- 18:15holders of biocultural heritage, but
- 18:17rather that it should be conserved as a
- 18:19common heritage; however, it must be
- 18:21recognized that indigenous peoples and
- 18:24traditional communities are the holders
- 18:26. There may be different concepts there
- 18:30, depending on your countries, that are
- 18:33linked to that—that have that
- 18:35distinct connection. And it is not that
- 18:39we recognize these as differentiated
- 18:41rights, but rather remember that we
- 18:43recognize that these collectives have a
- 18:45distinct connection. We can see it from
- 18:48the field of—from the legal field by
- 18:50recognizing the rights of indigenous
- 18:52peoples. But if we approach a community
- 18:56, if we work on a legal strategy with
- 18:58the community or any type of approach
- 19:00we may have, we know that people, as
- 19:03Miguel LeĂłn Portilla's poem says,
- 19:05consider biocultural heritage to be
- 19:07part of their worldview and their
- 19:09existence as a people. So, this
- 19:12recognition is important. Why? Because
- 19:16it is part of the rights of indigenous
- 19:19peoples. Intergenerational equity is
- 19:23also important because the protection
- 19:26of biocultural heritage does not only
- 19:28concern us or the specific bearers of
- 19:31this knowledge, but future generations
- 19:33as well, right? We do not know over
- 19:38time how this heritage may support and
- 19:40develop certain knowledge for the
- 19:42protection of future generations or
- 19:45humanity itself. Precaution and
- 19:49prevention always; any measure that is
- 19:52attempted to be taken, any policy, any
- 19:55project that will have a differentiated
- 19:58impact on how biocultural heritage is
- 20:01conserved or that will put at risk this
- 20:04knowledge linked to biodiversity, must
- 20:07be based on this principle: in the case
- 20:10of not having sufficient
- 20:12technical-scientific information, or if
- 20:17a reasonable doubt exists to question
- 20:20how to use biocultural heritage, a more
- 20:23cautious decision must always be taken,
- 20:26or any type of measure or project
- 20:28seeking such access must be stopped.
- 20:33Another very important one is
- 20:34environmental public participation.
- 20:37Biocultural heritage has this
- 20:39particularity that it depends on the
- 20:41interactions that people have, right?
- 20:45It is the holders themselves, the
- 20:47communities themselves, that give
- 20:49content to the right of biocultural
- 20:51heritage. Why? Because they are the
- 20:53ones who decide how to manage it within
- 20:55their communities. And communities, as
- 20:59holders of the lands or this concept of
- 21:02land that has been developed in
- 21:05inter-American and international
- 21:07jurisprudence, uphold that communities
- 21:10are the ones who must manage and
- 21:12determine what the conditions for
- 21:15participation are. Many times, in the
- 21:18processes of creating regulations, in
- 21:21the processes of creating public policy
- 21:23or of any kind, communities are not
- 21:25integrated or are not taken into
- 21:27account. Or, many times, these types of
- 21:31measures do not take into account the
- 21:33particularities of the community, do
- 21:35not take into account their rights to
- 21:38language, and manage natural resources
- 21:40without having real participation. It
- 21:43is also important regarding public
- 21:45participation that we must distinguish
- 21:47that participating is one thing, and
- 21:49influencing is another. If we are
- 21:53professionals or people involved in
- 21:55these processes, we must know that
- 21:58participation is not merely formal, not
- 22:01merely saying how things are managed,
- 22:03but that the titleholders, indigenous
- 22:06peoples, the communities, have that
- 22:08decision-making power over their
- 22:11biocultural heritage; that their
- 22:14decisions and their needs are heard and
- 22:17integrated into the decision-making for
- 22:20managing biocultural heritage. And a
- 22:24very important right is free, prior,
- 22:26and informed consent. Any type of
- 22:29access that has a link to biocultural
- 22:32heritage must respect this principle,
- 22:34not only consultation as a legal
- 22:36procedure, but also the right to
- 22:39consent. And that consent, as
- 22:42Convention 169 reiterates in its
- 22:44Article 6, must be free, prior, and
- 22:46informed. This also, these rights, as I
- 22:51tell you, try to alleviate the
- 22:53structural discrimination that
- 22:55communities and indigenous peoples have
- 22:58experienced for a long time as the main
- 23:01titleholders of the management of
- 23:03knowledge of biocultural heritage. To
- 23:09review a little bit about the main
- 23:11international conventions. As I was
- 23:14mentioning, it is not that these
- 23:17conventions establish an article or a
- 23:19specific norm that says protection of
- 23:22biocultural heritage, but that, from an
- 23:25interpretation both historical and the
- 23:27content that has been given in recent
- 23:30years to these rights, and mainly from
- 23:33jurisprudential developments, we can
- 23:37infer that in these articles there is a
- 23:40recognition of the defense of
- 23:42biocultural heritage. One of the main
- 23:45instruments is the Convention on
- 23:47Biological Diversity. As I tell you, if
- 23:50you went to the historical records of
- 23:53the discussion of this convention, it
- 23:56was a convention that was being pushed
- 23:58mainly by the conservation sector, by
- 24:01the academic sector, the scientific
- 24:03sector, but it also had significant
- 24:06representation and momentum from
- 24:08collectives and, mainly, indigenous
- 24:11peoples, where it was proposed that not
- 24:15only would they talk about the
- 24:17conservation of biodiversity or that
- 24:19diversity that nature provided, but
- 24:22that the rights of those bearer people
- 24:24had to be recognized. And knowledge, as
- 24:29you know, especially from communities,
- 24:32you might be able to protect a resource
- 24:35, I don't know, like a forest, or water
- 24:37, or the sea, but protecting the
- 24:39resource itself is more complex. Why?
- 24:44Because it requires knowing how that
- 24:48species is used, when it should be used
- 24:51, how, and what impact that plant or
- 24:55animal species will have. All this type
- 24:59of knowledge is based on traditional
- 25:02knowledge, even if that knowledge—and
- 25:04this is very important. And why,
- 25:07because it is also an international
- 25:09discussion. What that knowledge does,
- 25:13including some scientific processes
- 25:15that are now conceived in a different
- 25:18way, is what used to happen, where
- 25:20perhaps the protection of a species was
- 25:23carried out through some international
- 25:26agreement because science says we must
- 25:29protect, I don't know, so-called
- 25:31umbrella species, like a jaguar. But
- 25:36what happens when, or how was that
- 25:39conclusion reached? Many scientific
- 25:42research processes, not just many, I
- 25:44believe 100%of them, require the
- 25:47participation of the communities. So,
- 25:50what was not being made visible? That
- 25:52such recognition and protection of
- 25:54certain natural resources left the
- 25:55communities out. But the researcher
- 25:58often goes to the community, extracts
- 26:01the information, takes it away,
- 26:02publishes it, and that is what we now
- 26:04call or question—that scientific
- 26:06knowledge is not the only valid type of
- 26:09knowledge, but traditional knowledge is
- 26:11as well. And that is a very important
- 26:14struggle in terms of law. Why? Because
- 26:16it is a way to also recognize this
- 26:17framework of rights that indigenous
- 26:19peoples have. The Convention on
- 26:22Biological Diversity, specifically, has
- 26:25these articles referring to in situ
- 26:27conservation; and it also recognizes,
- 26:33specifically in 8J, the protection of
- 26:35traditional knowledge. And, basically,
- 26:38the interpretation it makes is that not
- 26:40only natural resources or the
- 26:42biological diversity of those resources
- 26:44must be protected, but all associated
- 26:46traditional knowledge as well. And who
- 26:49are its holders? That can vary
- 26:51depending on the context, but often it
- 26:53is the indigenous peoples or local
- 26:54communities who are the holders of that
- 26:56knowledge. And also this same
- 27:00convention, which is from '92, is a
- 27:01long-standing convention, it recognizes
- 27:04the participation of indigenous
- 27:05communities. This convention on
- 27:13biological diversity is implemented
- 27:16through protocols. Protocols are almost
- 27:19always about how a treaty is
- 27:20implemented for those who aren't
- 27:22lawyers and how it is developed. That
- 27:24protocol has been quite questioned in
- 27:26different countries. Why? Because it
- 27:29established how genetic resources
- 27:31associated with biodiversity would be
- 27:33accessed. Also, how to ensure the fair
- 27:37and equitable sharing of benefits and
- 27:39also the associated traditional
- 27:41knowledge. This is important because,
- 27:45often, what happened was that the state
- 27:47sought to access or grant access
- 27:50permits to researchers or third parties
- 27:53, I don't know, like pharmaceutical
- 27:55companies, to access not only the
- 27:58resource, or the material itself, but
- 28:00also the genetic resources and that
- 28:03knowledge. So, what was proposed at
- 28:06that time is that those access rights
- 28:09were not unrestricted, that they needed
- 28:12to involve the communities as holders
- 28:15of their rights. And obviously, in many
- 28:17states, for a long time, there was
- 28:19resistance to recognizing these rights.
- 28:22And it is here that indigenous
- 28:24communities, mainly those I am aware of
- 28:27, have used the constitutional path to
- 28:30defend their rights as holders of these
- 28:32resources and the territory. Also,
- 28:37another right proposed for accessing a
- 28:39community's genetic and biological
- 28:41resources is that there must be a fair
- 28:44and equitable sharing and participation
- 28:46in the benefits. What does this mean?
- 28:49For example, there were many states
- 28:51that received certain economic benefits
- 28:53or benefits of another nature that
- 28:54didn't reach the communities. So, if
- 28:56there is going to be some type of
- 28:59access to these biological or genetic
- 29:01resources, the community must also be a
- 29:04beneficiary of those benefits that are
- 29:06generated. And also how to protect the
- 29:09associated traditional knowledge. This
- 29:12is always very important. That these
- 29:15access processes had to respect the
- 29:17knowledge of the communities and not
- 29:20engage in, as I tell you, what is
- 29:22called biopiracy, which was mere
- 29:24extraction of knowledge, without
- 29:26recognition of the right and without
- 29:28any type of benefit for the community.
- 29:33Most countries have adopted this
- 29:35protocol, but some have not because,
- 29:37for example, there have been attempts
- 29:39to implement it without proper
- 29:40consultation with indigenous peoples,
- 29:42and that is why in some countries this
- 29:44has not been able to take legal hold.
- 29:50Another very important agreement for
- 29:52the protection of knowledge and
- 29:54biocultural heritage is ILO Convention
- 29:56169, which is the Convention concerning
- 29:58the rights of indigenous peoples. Why?
- 30:03Although this agreement is quite old, a
- 30:06rather dated agreement, one can make a
- 30:09broad legal interpretation of the
- 30:12rights it recognizes; for example,
- 30:14territorial rights, the right to land
- 30:17that Indigenous peoples and local
- 30:20communities have over their territory.
- 30:25And territory, as described by the
- 30:27Inter-American Court of Human Rights in
- 30:29its rulings—which I can also share
- 30:31with you—is a concept of territory or
- 30:33land as a broad concept. Why? Because
- 30:37it was often established as more of an,
- 30:39uh, territorial concept, but that is
- 30:41not the case; rather, the
- 30:43Inter-American Court, for example, in
- 30:45the jurisprudence—which is also a
- 30:47resource we use—interprets it as
- 30:49follows: this legal protection
- 30:50framework for land or the right to
- 30:52territory goes much further. It is not
- 30:56only about the natural resources
- 30:58present in these territories or lands,
- 31:00but all the knowledge that has been
- 31:02accumulated, the knowledge that is
- 31:04linked to them. So, for example, the
- 31:08Inter-American Court has determined in
- 31:11some rulings that certain development
- 31:14projects infringe upon, uh, not only
- 31:16the natural resources, but also the
- 31:19entire cultural heritage that involves
- 31:22the communities that are the holders of
- 31:24these rights. Prior consultation and
- 31:28consent, as we already mentioned, any
- 31:30type of access of any kind that a
- 31:32person, a collective, an organization,
- 31:34or a state wants to have within these
- 31:36communities requires these processes,
- 31:39and this is something very important
- 31:41for all of us who work on this issue
- 31:43and are involved. People often think
- 31:47this only applies to states or
- 31:49companies, but it is also important to
- 31:52know that any approach an individual of
- 31:54any kind might have with a community to
- 31:57work on these issues also requires
- 32:00consultation protocols and consent
- 32:02protocols. Why? Because this is part of
- 32:07respecting and breaking that structural
- 32:09discrimination where communities are
- 32:11not seen as their own titleholders. So,
- 32:14any approach I want to make, whether
- 32:16academic or artistic, must go through
- 32:19those principles. Therefore, any
- 32:21approach with the community requires it
- 32:23. And if there are people here from
- 32:27communities, you also have to know that
- 32:29anyone who approaches you with
- 32:31different projects or whatever it may
- 32:33be must respect the principles of
- 32:35consultation, the rights of prior
- 32:37consultation, and consent in some cases
- 32:40. Respect for their own institutions
- 32:44and also biocultural heritage,
- 32:46depending on the community or the
- 32:47Indigenous people, involves certain
- 32:49structures. So, what can I tell you? In
- 32:54Costa Rica, for example, within the
- 32:56Bribri indigenous people, the*awa*is
- 32:58the one who has, um, access to certain
- 33:01knowledge of traditional medicine. And
- 33:04we must respect the existence of this
- 33:06figure, that this figure must intervene
- 33:09in certain processes, and that is why
- 33:11we must interpret the territory
- 33:13whenever we approach it to, uh, comply
- 33:15with this right to be represented by
- 33:18their own institutions. Furthermore,
- 33:21Convention 169 also recognizes that the
- 33:23cultural survival of indigenous peoples
- 33:25and tribal communities depends on the
- 33:27protection of natural resources. So, as
- 33:31Miguel LeĂłn Portilla's poem said, it
- 33:33can go both ways, right? Conserving
- 33:36biodiversity is also conserving culture
- 33:39, and conserving culture is also
- 33:42conserving biodiversity. We also have
- 33:49the United Nations Declaration on the
- 33:51Rights of Indigenous Peoples. As I
- 33:53imagine you have seen in other courses,
- 33:56declarations are norms, uh, they are
- 33:58soft law norms or norms that states may
- 34:00or may not implement in some countries.
- 34:03For example, in Costa Rica, the
- 34:04declaration has binding legal force,
- 34:06just like a convention or a treaty. So,
- 34:09that is why it is important that we
- 34:11also know these standards. The
- 34:15Declaration came after Convention 169
- 34:18and reaffirms and reiterates that the
- 34:20holders of biocultural heritage, who
- 34:23are mainly local communities and
- 34:26indigenous peoples, have the right to
- 34:28self-determination; they have the right
- 34:31to control their territories and
- 34:34natural resources and, also, that there
- 34:37must be special protection for cultural
- 34:40heritage and traditional knowledge. I
- 34:44believe this 2008 declaration is quite
- 34:47relevant because, for the first time,
- 34:49this concept of heritage—a cultural
- 34:52and biological heritage associated with
- 34:54traditional knowledge—begins to be
- 34:57managed. There are also other
- 35:04international agreements that are
- 35:06recent, of recent date; for example,
- 35:08the EscazĂş Agreement, which also
- 35:10establishes a series of protections for
- 35:13the groups that are the holders of
- 35:15biocultural heritage, such as the issue
- 35:17of the right to access information, the
- 35:20right to public participation, the
- 35:22right to access justice, and the right
- 35:24to the protection of environmental
- 35:26defenders. That is important to mention
- 35:31because cultural heritage as a
- 35:33protected legal asset is not merely
- 35:35abstract; it is not just an asset that
- 35:37is protected, but there are a series of
- 35:40activities or tasks that the groups
- 35:42carry out that also require protection,
- 35:45right? People who dedicate themselves
- 35:48to the defense of the territory or its
- 35:51management, or who protect certain
- 35:53natural resources, are always exposed
- 35:56to being threatened, right? and to have
- 36:00, well, we have seen it across the
- 36:02length and breadth of Latin America,
- 36:04that people who dedicate themselves to
- 36:06the work of defending territory are
- 36:08criminalized and can even end up
- 36:10receiving not only threats, but also
- 36:12being murdered for their work in
- 36:13defense of the territory. So, as I tell
- 36:17you, this has been mutating over time.
- 36:20In the first instance, people only
- 36:22spoke of environmental defenders, but
- 36:24when we work more closely, we see that
- 36:26the defense is not only of the
- 36:28territory, not only of natural
- 36:30resources, but it is also a defense of
- 36:32biocultural heritage. And these
- 36:35processes are mainly led by indigenous
- 36:38peoples and local communities, which is
- 36:40not a defense merely for natural
- 36:43resources or for the territory, but
- 36:45they also protect their biocultural
- 36:47heritage. There are others, there are
- 36:56other treaties as well, other
- 36:58conventions mainly led by UNESCO, for
- 37:00example, the Convention on Material
- 37:03Heritage, there is the Man and the
- 37:05Biosphere program, and there are also
- 37:07certain conventions on traditional
- 37:10knowledge as living heritage. This is
- 37:15very important because UNESCO has
- 37:17recognized...it not only had a very
- 37:20rapid advance in the protection of
- 37:23material heritage, I don't know, like
- 37:26monuments, like I don't know, natural
- 37:29wonders, like certain more specific
- 37:32material issues. And since the 2000s,
- 37:37UNESCO also began to make that quite
- 37:39rapid recognition of intangible
- 37:42heritage, which is all that knowledge
- 37:45associated with resources, not only
- 37:48natural resources, but those
- 37:50manifestations. For example, in Costa
- 37:55Rica, the Boruca indigenous people have
- 37:59a very close link with the use of a
- 38:02mollusk on the coast. And what happens?
- 38:07That on this specific coast there is a
- 38:09national park, and by the national
- 38:12parks law in Costa Rica, you cannot
- 38:14take even a stone from an area that is
- 38:17a National Park. So, what happens? One
- 38:19was made. The community uses this
- 38:23mollusk to dye their, their, uh, what
- 38:25they use for their fabrics or for this
- 38:28whole phase of spinning, which is an
- 38:30artistic manifestation, very beautiful,
- 38:33the looms of the Boruca indigenous
- 38:35people; but which associates not only
- 38:37that artistic representation, let's say
- 38:40, or that cultural representation of a
- 38:42knowledge, but that it has an
- 38:44associated biological resource. In that
- 38:48particular case, the community has a
- 38:51specific permit to enter the National
- 38:53Park to have access to this mollusk. So
- 38:57, that is important because this
- 38:59knowledge, which is heritage, which is
- 39:01part of Costa Rica's tangible heritage,
- 39:04is not just a manifestation, but
- 39:06involves a whole body of associated
- 39:08knowledge, and that is where UNESCO has
- 39:10begun to intervene regarding that type
- 39:12of knowledge. For example, in Mexico,
- 39:16you know that traditional Mexican
- 39:18cuisine has been recognized by UNESCO
- 39:20as part of intangible heritage. Why?
- 39:24Because it is not the cuisine itself,
- 39:26but all the knowledge of the natural
- 39:29resources and the cultural heritage you
- 39:31have access to that is recognized. So,
- 39:35it is not just the practice or the use
- 39:37of the resource that is recognized, but
- 39:40also all the associated knowledge, and
- 39:42that forms part of the intangible
- 39:44heritage. The subject of living
- 39:48heritage has also been recognized,
- 39:50right? There are many types of such
- 39:53classifications, but they cover not
- 39:55only the manifestations but also the
- 39:57holders of that knowledge, right? They
- 40:01can be specific groups; in some
- 40:03communities, there are even specific
- 40:05individuals who possess that knowledge.
- 40:09For example, in my specific community,
- 40:11there has been recognition of a couple
- 40:14of people who are very long-lived. In
- 40:17Costa Rica, in the area where I am from
- 40:19, it is one of the longest-lived places
- 40:22on the planet, where these people are
- 40:24encouraged to pass on their knowledge,
- 40:26because the moment they are gone, that
- 40:28knowledge will also go with them. So it
- 40:32is important that new generations, that
- 40:34young people get involved in protecting
- 40:36heritage because it is a living
- 40:38heritage; it is a heritage, biocultural
- 40:40heritage is transmitted, transformed,
- 40:43and requires this intergenerational
- 40:45transmission. Before moving on to the
- 40:53section on international jurisprudence,
- 40:55which I would like us to go through
- 40:58more calmly, I would like to know if
- 41:00there are any questions or inquiries so
- 41:03we can have a little dialogue.
- 41:07Of course. I will share three questions
- 41:11with you, if that's all right.
- 41:13That is fine.
- 41:13This first, a first block of three
- 41:15questions. Well, MarĂa de los RĂos
- 41:19asks for your opinion regarding
- 41:21Monsanto's strategy of patenting life,
- 41:23that is, having rights over plant life
- 41:26and seeds, which has groups of farmers
- 41:28around the world planting seeds sold by
- 41:31Monsanto, seeds genetically modified to
- 41:34be sterile. Another person asks us, "
- 41:38The change in land use in the territory
- 41:41is one of the causes of the loss of
- 41:43biological and genetic heritage.""How
- 41:46should this heritage be protected from
- 41:48your perspective, and what will be left
- 41:50of these habitats for the next 30 years
- 41:51?" Thirdly, uh, the question is, does
- 41:55the Nagoya Protocol not apply?
- 41:57Therefore, would it be a fantasy, or
- 41:59what is your opinion? Yes, regarding
- 42:04the first question, uh, look, the legal
- 42:07protection of biocultural heritage is
- 42:10also part of a global resistance
- 42:13process, not just about protecting
- 42:16natural resources, but how cultural
- 42:19resources or the communities involved
- 42:22are protected. I couldn't speak to a
- 42:28particular case, but what happens is
- 42:31that those accesses or that type of
- 42:34technology or that type of genetic seed
- 42:36development and all of this has a very
- 42:39large implication for local knowledge
- 42:42because it transforms how natural
- 42:44resources are used a bit. I can give
- 42:48you an example from my community that I
- 42:51am sure is very similar to your
- 42:53contexts as well. In my community, we
- 42:56have a native seed, right? The moment a
- 43:00transgenic seed is introduced into
- 43:03practices or introduced into planting,
- 43:06uh, those are living organisms. So, as
- 43:10we say popularly, it can be eaten, it
- 43:13can be eaten, as we say in my town. And
- 43:17that means that this native seed can be
- 43:19displaced not only in terms of habitat,
- 43:22but in the species that consume them,
- 43:24in being species that don't adapt to
- 43:26the climates, that don't adapt to
- 43:29traditional use. And almost always the,
- 43:33no, almost always transgenic seeds have
- 43:35a link to the use of agrochemicals that
- 43:37can also generate a very radical change
- 43:40because, for example, in communities,
- 43:42at least in mine, that type of input is
- 43:44not used. So, I think the transgenic
- 43:48seed or transgenic products totally
- 43:51change the structure of knowledge,
- 43:54right? I am not a biologist, I am not
- 43:58an expert, I don't know what the
- 44:00specific impacts are, but I can speak
- 44:02from experience that this can greatly
- 44:05change the social fabric of the
- 44:07community. A community like mine, which
- 44:10is based on the exchange of seeds,
- 44:12which is based on respect for cycles,
- 44:14on letting the land rest: the
- 44:16introduction of transgenics has a
- 44:18change not only in the productive
- 44:20matrix, but also in how people relate
- 44:22to seeds, to plants, to the ecosystem
- 44:24in general. So, those are the types of
- 44:28effects. The second one, could you
- 44:31remind me, I
- 44:34Of course, uh, it has to do with land
- 44:36use in the territory as one of the
- 44:38causes of the loss of biological and
- 44:40genetic heritage. How should this
- 44:43heritage be protected from your
- 44:44perspective? And what will be left of
- 44:46these habitats for the next 30 years?
- 44:50Yes, well, that is a...that is always a
- 44:52question that each community must
- 44:54answer, because each community knows
- 44:56how to manage its own territory. And
- 45:00when regulations or policies come from
- 45:02outside to determine how the territory
- 45:05is used, then that is when strategies
- 45:07for the legal defense of the territory
- 45:10must be activated. In my view, there
- 45:13are different strategies. I often
- 45:16stress that it is important for people
- 45:18to get involved in processes, for
- 45:20example, in the formation of
- 45:22regulations. Why? Because when the law
- 45:25already exists and is about to be
- 45:27implemented to, I don't know, change
- 45:29land use for a certain activity, the
- 45:31impact is already much closer, right?
- 45:35So, there are certain strategies
- 45:37involving us in the discussion of
- 45:39legislation when it is going to be
- 45:41changed or those kinds of things, as I
- 45:44know there are certain groups that
- 45:46often warn about certain modifications
- 45:48that can affect land-use changes. Also
- 45:52issues of public policy. Often
- 45:55development models are not focused on
- 45:59protecting biocultural heritage; they
- 46:03are focused on maximizing land use, but
- 46:06what is important are the processes of
- 46:10community defense, right? Also, we
- 46:15shouldn't sound too tragic; there are
- 46:18processes where communities have
- 46:20managed to restore some ecosystems,
- 46:23right? Not just the soil, but many
- 46:26ecosystems. Costa Rica, or part of
- 46:28Costa Rica, is an example of that,
- 46:30right? Where it managed to reverse the
- 46:33serious impacts caused by the
- 46:34deforestation of the 80s, and currently
- 46:37many of those areas are secondary
- 46:39forests or have been recovered, but I
- 46:42think the answer there is that they are
- 46:44part of community processes. We can
- 46:47have certain regulations, the ones I
- 46:50already shared earlier, but if those
- 46:52regulations are not used by the holders
- 46:55of the biocultural heritage, then it is
- 46:57a regulation that can remain dead,
- 47:00right? So I think we need to think
- 47:02about creative strategies; the legal
- 47:04one is one, which is what we are
- 47:06looking at today, but we also have
- 47:07other strategies for community
- 47:09organization. I, now that I am...well,
- 47:13no, now that I work in this, whenever
- 47:15we develop a legal strategy, we work
- 47:17very closely with the community,
- 47:19because I feel that communities have
- 47:21much more clarity on how the territory
- 47:23must be managed and also how the
- 47:25territory must be defended, right? So,
- 47:29always start from, I don't know, if you
- 47:31are an attorney and you are going to
- 47:33approach this, you have to plan a
- 47:35strategy, but whatever the approach, I
- 47:37think it is very important right now
- 47:40that the groups themselves generate
- 47:42their own strategies for the defense of
- 47:44their biocultural heritage. And
- 47:48regarding the third part of the Nagoya
- 47:50Protocol, well, some countries have it,
- 47:53they have it integrated, right?,into
- 47:55their laws; others do not. But there
- 48:00have already been cases, I mean, there
- 48:02have been cases where access has been
- 48:04attempted without any benefit-sharing,
- 48:06without any, uh, access protocols. In
- 48:09practice, this does happen, right? So,
- 48:13the fact that the regulations do not
- 48:15exist, sometimes from a legal
- 48:17standpoint, it takes away a tool, a
- 48:19tool to be able to carry out these
- 48:21defense processes, but the most complex
- 48:23thing is that these things are
- 48:24happening, right? Access is taking
- 48:27place in different ways. Believe me,
- 48:30there are different ways in which they
- 48:32have approached it, and even if a
- 48:35country doesn't have it, all these
- 48:37legal regulations must be activated to
- 48:39carry out these defense processes. But
- 48:43it does happen, that is what I think is
- 48:45the main problem. But still, even
- 48:48though I personally find the protocol a
- 48:50bit outdated, we will see that
- 48:53jurisprudence, which is also a source
- 48:55of law, provides tools for us to carry
- 48:58out a process of legal protection, even
- 49:01if certain standards are not
- 49:03implemented by a country. That is a bit
- 49:09to answer those questions in this part
- 49:12of the talk, also, as I was telling you
- 49:15, well, this is a class focused on the
- 49:18legal protection of cultural heritage.
- 49:22We already looked a bit at
- 49:23international agreements, right? We
- 49:26have already worked with international
- 49:28agreements, we already pointed out the
- 49:30main ones, where the norms are, but it
- 49:33is also important to know the cases and
- 49:35how it has begun to be interpreted or
- 49:37integrated into international
- 49:39jurisprudence and inter-American
- 49:40jurisprudence. Why? Because it is the
- 49:44cases that can provide you with the
- 49:45parameters to understand how the
- 49:47regulations are used. For me, when you
- 49:50go to study a case, when a situation
- 49:53arises, you also have to—for me it is
- 49:55very enriching that you listen to other
- 49:58communities, that you learn from other
- 50:01cases. This matter of jurisprudence,
- 50:05for those who perhaps aren't lawyers,
- 50:08is how courts have addressed specific
- 50:10cases, how regulations have been
- 50:12applied, and that is the greatest, the
- 50:15greatest benefit of analyzing
- 50:17jurisprudence. As I was telling you,
- 50:22the Inter-American Court, which is this
- 50:25regional court that implements or
- 50:27ensures respect for the agreement, for
- 50:30the Convention on Human Rights, while
- 50:33it is a convention that began by being
- 50:36justiciable through certain rights,
- 50:38mainly civil rights, political rights
- 50:41due to the Latin American context in
- 50:44which the Inter-American Court was
- 50:46created, it has started to migrate from
- 50:50very, very, from very specific cases to
- 50:55, to migrate toward the protection of
- 50:58biocultural heritage. It’s not that
- 51:01the Court has stated there is
- 51:03protection for biocultural heritage,
- 51:04but rather it has made a series of
- 51:06interpretations that provide us with
- 51:08elements to mount a legal defense for
- 51:10the right to biocultural heritage. For
- 51:13example, as I mentioned, these specific
- 51:16cases, the Saramaka v. Suriname case,
- 51:20the Sarayaku v. Ecuador case, and a
- 51:23more recent case, which is the Lhaka
- 51:25Honhat v. Argentina case. In these
- 51:29specific cases, the communities came
- 51:31forward to make a series of claims.
- 51:35These claims would primarily have to do
- 51:37with Article 21 of the Convention,
- 51:39which involves the right to property
- 51:42and specifically the right to
- 51:43collective property. For a long time,
- 51:47the Court did not adjudicate cases on
- 51:49environmental issues, which is the
- 51:51closest to this topic we are working on
- 51:54, but focused more on the issue of the
- 51:56right to collective property for
- 51:58Indigenous peoples. But in this ruling,
- 52:01and we will see it in different
- 52:03advisory opinions, it has provided more
- 52:05elements to consider the issue of
- 52:06biocultural heritage protection. The
- 52:10Court, as I tell you, as I was
- 52:12mentioning, has made an interpretation,
- 52:15under the knowledge or under the
- 52:17interpretation of the right to
- 52:19collective property and the right to
- 52:22land; and in its jurisprudence, it has
- 52:24interpreted that this right to land or
- 52:27this right to territory is not a
- 52:29conventional right or is not a right,
- 52:32as we lawyers might speak of it, like
- 52:35the right to private property. For a
- 52:38long time, the concept of property or
- 52:41private property has had to do with
- 52:44possessing, right? With possessing. I
- 52:46am the owner or proprietor of something
- 52:48, I am the owner of the land, I am the
- 52:49owner of this forest. And it had a
- 52:52conception very much like that. But
- 52:55when the Inter-American Court begins to
- 52:57analyze these cases, or what the
- 52:58communities were stating, it is that
- 53:00this connection to the territory, and
- 53:03therefore to the right to property—
- 53:05consequently collective property—went
- 53:07further. It had a direct link to their
- 53:11cultural rights, to their cultural
- 53:13survival, to their right to language,
- 53:16and even to this whole body of rights,
- 53:18meaning that I am not only protecting
- 53:21the land or the physical space, but
- 53:23also protecting a worldview, a way of
- 53:26seeing the world, as LeĂłn Portilla
- 53:28told us, and all the associated
- 53:30knowledge. In these cases, the
- 53:34Inter-American Court has recognized
- 53:37that those impacts on property, those
- 53:39impacts on the land, had a link to the
- 53:41cultural rights of these communities.
- 53:44Why? Because, what was the argument
- 53:46often made by the states? That the use
- 53:49of that land or the use of that
- 53:51property was for a matter of, I don't
- 53:53know, development—well, the speeches
- 53:55we always hear: that it is a matter for
- 53:57the country's development, that it is a
- 53:59matter of economic benefits. But the
- 54:03Court makes an interpretation and says
- 54:05that land, in the specific case of
- 54:07indigenous peoples, does not have a
- 54:10merely mercantilist conception, but
- 54:12rather has a deeper connection; and
- 54:14that is why you cannot place, uh, the
- 54:17right to development above the right to
- 54:19the cultural survival of a particular
- 54:22indigenous community. Also in these, in
- 54:30these analyses, in the creation of new
- 54:33standards for the protection of
- 54:35biocultural rights, I imagine you have
- 54:38heard of some cases that have, well,
- 54:41that have been promoted by
- 54:43constitutional tribunals or some
- 54:46constitutional courts, uh, or what they
- 54:49are called in a similar way in other,
- 54:52in other latitudes, regarding the
- 54:55protection of ecosystems or the
- 54:58protection of biocultural heritage for
- 55:01its own existence. That is interesting
- 55:04because it has been a development, I
- 55:05imagine perhaps some have heard,
- 55:07regarding the rights of nature. So,
- 55:09people now discuss what the rights of
- 55:11nature are. Uh, those of the theory of
- 55:15the rights of nature, or what
- 55:17interpretations have been made, is that
- 55:20they protect, uh, the ecosystems or all
- 55:23this body of knowledge for its own sake
- 55:25. Almost always, when we conduct an
- 55:29analysis of the protection of heritage
- 55:32or the protection of natural resources,
- 55:34it was done with a link to what that
- 55:37natural resource gives to a, to a, uh,
- 55:40to a person or to a collective, which
- 55:42has to do with the, uh, anthropological
- 55:45vision of conservation. What does that
- 55:47mean? I protect the water because I
- 55:50need water to drink, because I need
- 55:53water for my right to life. But, in the
- 55:57interpretations, for example, from the
- 56:00Constitutional Court of Colombia, they
- 56:03speak of this river, the Atrato River,
- 56:05as an entity that can have, well, legal
- 56:08personality to be protected in itself,
- 56:10right? Not as something passive that is
- 56:14only protected because it has a
- 56:15connection or because it is a resource
- 56:17that provides something to a person or
- 56:19a collective. It also happened in New
- 56:22Zealand with an interpretation
- 56:23regarding another river. It has
- 56:26happened a lot with the issue of
- 56:28waterways. I don't know if you've heard
- 56:30. I think here in Costa Rica an attempt
- 56:33was made with the Térraba River, which
- 56:35was going to be affected by a dam, not
- 56:37only because of the link it had with
- 56:39the Térraba indigenous community, but
- 56:41as a legal entity in itself. I imagine
- 56:44it is very common in your countries to
- 56:47think of certain ecosystems as sacred
- 56:51sites, as sites that have a connection
- 56:54with people in a different way. So, the
- 56:59rights of nature sought to make that
- 57:01recognition and say that it was not
- 57:04necessary in the argument to make a
- 57:06connection with the benefits that those
- 57:08resources provided, but that protection
- 57:11must be provided in itself. And there
- 57:16is something very important here,
- 57:18because if one reviews a little how
- 57:20these standards are created, as you
- 57:22know, when an interpretation is made or
- 57:24a new standard is created, this does
- 57:26not come out of nowhere, but rather it
- 57:28is an entire context analysis. And in
- 57:32this, indigenous peoples have a lot of
- 57:35standing, right? Indigenous peoples are
- 57:40providing this guidance on the subject
- 57:43of indigenous worldview and
- 57:45conservation, not to conserve resources
- 57:49for themselves, but because of their
- 57:52connections, their existences. Recently
- 57:56something very interesting happened to
- 57:58me that I would like to share. We are
- 58:01working with an indigenous people in
- 58:03Colombia, with the Wayuu indigenous
- 58:05people, and speaking with a woman from
- 58:07the community, she told me that, I
- 58:09don't know, for example, I am a lawyer
- 58:11and I am dedicated to environmental
- 58:13conservation. And the person, when we
- 58:17were mapping environmentally fragile
- 58:20sites that were going to be affected by
- 58:23an offshore wind project with turbines
- 58:26in the sea. She told us that certain
- 58:30areas where seagrasses were located had
- 58:33to be protected, because that is where
- 58:35the, I don't remember if it's said
- 58:37correctly, but the Apolowi lived, which
- 58:40is like a deity of theirs. So it was
- 58:44about protecting the seagrasses or
- 58:46these marine zones, not because they
- 58:48needed to go there to fish or extract
- 58:50certain resources, but because there
- 58:52resided a very important figure in
- 58:54their worldview, in the worldview of
- 58:56the Wayuu people. And that would be
- 59:01important when we work with communities
- 59:03because we understand that the
- 59:05protection of resources is not per se
- 59:07only for the resource itself, but for
- 59:09everything it encompasses and for all
- 59:11the ecological and cultural importance
- 59:13it may have, not just because I'm going
- 59:15to fish there. So, for you to see how
- 59:19the law is evolving and also how we,
- 59:22those who in this group dedicate
- 59:24themselves to the law itself, have the
- 59:27opportunity to raise these arguments in
- 59:30different entities, both judicial and
- 59:33administrative, for the defense of
- 59:36these ecosystems, right? And I, now
- 59:39that I do this exercise, and you can do
- 59:42it in your communities where you
- 59:44identify certain ecosystems that have
- 59:46both a cultural and ideological
- 59:47importance due to their very existence,
- 59:50right? And we can see it in many
- 59:52communities, and if you think about it
- 59:54for a moment right now, you will know
- 59:56that my community protects certain
- 59:58resources because it has an importance
- 1:00:00not only ecological, not only because
- 1:00:02it gives me food, not only because it
- 1:00:03gives me water, not only because it
- 1:00:05gives me shelter, but for its
- 1:00:07protection in itself. Another case that
- 1:00:10is for me the most enriching thing as
- 1:00:12lawyers is working with the communities
- 1:00:14. Not long ago, and well, not long ago,
- 1:00:18a few years ago working with a
- 1:00:20community, the community pushed for a
- 1:00:23specific palm to be protected, a palm.
- 1:00:26The indigenous community [needed/valued
- 1:00:28] certain palms, because in Costa Rica
- 1:00:30it was very common during Holy Week to
- 1:00:32go and extract heart of palm, which is
- 1:00:34a palm, some specific palms. Well, it
- 1:00:36turns out that the most expensive heart
- 1:00:38of palm is from a palm that had a
- 1:00:40slightly reduced population, and the
- 1:00:42community proposed to the environmental
- 1:00:44authority that there be specific
- 1:00:45protection. Why? Because not only for
- 1:00:49the palm itself, but that palm is used
- 1:00:51for the construction of the Usure,
- 1:00:53which is their traditional conical
- 1:00:54house that has to do with a lot of
- 1:00:56their worldview, of their rituals. So,
- 1:00:59it was that link and it was that
- 1:01:02justification. And when you talk to the
- 1:01:04communities, or those of you who are
- 1:01:06from communities, you will be able to
- 1:01:07understand these reasonings. And those
- 1:01:10strictly dedicated to the law will know
- 1:01:13that these legal protections are also
- 1:01:15of a different nature, and it no longer
- 1:01:18serves as our sole argument to say we
- 1:01:20protect water because of this right to
- 1:01:23water, but rather these other
- 1:01:25connotations which are of great
- 1:01:27importance, and that is how we break
- 1:01:30down the protection of heritage.
- 1:01:33biocultural. What are the obligations
- 1:01:37of the states? And by state, we refer
- 1:01:40to all public institutions as well as
- 1:01:42private ones that are regulated. The
- 1:01:45recognition of collective rights, the
- 1:01:48protection of cultural heritage.
- 1:01:51Biocultural heritage does not only have
- 1:01:54an individual connotation, but
- 1:01:56primarily a collective one. That is why
- 1:02:01we speak of heritage, which is
- 1:02:02something joint, something shared. And
- 1:02:05the State must make that recognition.
- 1:02:08The State must also guarantee free,
- 1:02:10prior, and informed consultation and
- 1:02:13consent. As I was telling you, any type
- 1:02:16of project or measure that will have an
- 1:02:19impact on the protection of biocultural
- 1:02:21heritage must pass through these
- 1:02:23filters, right? Uh, states must protect
- 1:02:28territories, uh, not just to be
- 1:02:30exploited, but to be protected. And
- 1:02:34they must also prevent environmental
- 1:02:36damage. This is very important. As the
- 1:02:40person who asked the question said,
- 1:02:43when an ecosystem is already damaged or
- 1:02:45we see that there are very, very
- 1:02:48specific impacts, restoration is very
- 1:02:50complex. That is why environmental
- 1:02:55damage must always be prevented and, in
- 1:02:57case these damages exist, there must be
- 1:02:59comprehensive reparation to the holders
- 1:03:02of biocultural heritage if their rights
- 1:03:04are affected. And as we always think or
- 1:03:09ask ourselves, what happens if the
- 1:03:11State does not do it? Well, the State
- 1:03:16can be subjected to an inter-American
- 1:03:19jurisdiction. For example, the
- 1:03:21Inter-American Court can be the subject
- 1:03:24of a process of this nature, and we
- 1:03:26have seen it in recent years where the
- 1:03:28issue of protecting biological and
- 1:03:30cultural heritage has been brought much
- 1:03:32more often to the Inter-American
- 1:03:34Commission and the Court. In certain
- 1:03:37cases, then, states can also be seen
- 1:03:40and subjected to justice, and that is
- 1:03:43where we return to the right of access
- 1:03:45to justice for the holders of
- 1:03:48biocultural heritage to seek reparation
- 1:03:50. And also, what are the current
- 1:03:56challenges we have in the protection of
- 1:03:59biocultural heritage? Well, biocultural
- 1:04:02heritage is under different threats.
- 1:04:05very large, very complex threats. We
- 1:04:09have climate change, how climate change
- 1:04:12is affecting the entire body of
- 1:04:14knowledge, traditional knowledge. For
- 1:04:17example, those of us who are from
- 1:04:19communities or who work with
- 1:04:20communities, it's very easy for people
- 1:04:22to tell you that, for example, certain
- 1:04:24species that are part of, I don't know,
- 1:04:26artisanal fishing, are no longer there,
- 1:04:29they are no longer in a certain area.
- 1:04:32Or for example, many times communities
- 1:04:34express to me that their traditional
- 1:04:36areas where they fished or collected
- 1:04:37mollusks, since I work in coastal zones
- 1:04:39, are just not the same anymore. That
- 1:04:42changed the dynamics a lot. Or for
- 1:04:45example, communities that have
- 1:04:47artisanal practices or artisanal
- 1:04:49fishing practices, certain sites that
- 1:04:52are sacred where people gathered,
- 1:04:54performed their rituals, their
- 1:04:56community processes, right? They are no
- 1:05:00longer there. Or the corals are
- 1:05:03suffering acidification or it is also
- 1:05:06changing a lot, right? Recently, when I
- 1:05:10was talking to a community, they told
- 1:05:12me that, for example, certain species
- 1:05:14of little frogs that are important to
- 1:05:16them, something like that, they told me
- 1:05:18that because of the increase in
- 1:05:20temperature, they were no longer seen.
- 1:05:23So they said, "No, they are already
- 1:05:25gone." And people also express many
- 1:05:27things, right? About the damage we have
- 1:05:30done to the Earth, that now the Earth
- 1:05:33is also responding with these types of
- 1:05:36extreme weather events. We also have
- 1:05:39the phenomenon I was telling you about,
- 1:05:42like biopiracy. Uh, I don't know, in
- 1:05:46your countries, in Costa Rica, for
- 1:05:48example, it is common now to go to
- 1:05:51supermarkets and see them selling
- 1:05:53things. I know the feeling I have as
- 1:05:56part of a community that perhaps
- 1:05:58traditional knowledge is being
- 1:06:00commercialized without the
- 1:06:01authorization of the communities, right
- 1:06:03? Uh, the knowledge...look, my
- 1:06:08community is a community that has been,
- 1:06:10in recent years, uh, very, very, like
- 1:06:12very persecuted, I would say. It became
- 1:06:15very famous for being one of these
- 1:06:16well-known blue zones and now, uh, my
- 1:06:18mom was amazed recently when she came
- 1:06:21to the capital and went to a
- 1:06:22supermarket and it said ojoche flour
- 1:06:24and it cost a fortune. It's tasty.
- 1:06:26Those who have come know that it is
- 1:06:29very expensive, like $ 20 for some
- 1:06:31ojoche flour, and my mom said, but she
- 1:06:33was very surprised because she said
- 1:06:36that that seed which had such
- 1:06:38significance, now even had a name in
- 1:06:40English. Well, biopiracy is not only
- 1:06:43the extraction of knowledge, uh, or
- 1:06:44theft, but also so that you know there
- 1:06:46are subtle thefts, right? And those
- 1:06:50from communities know that they have to
- 1:06:52, as we say in Costa Rica, be very,
- 1:06:55very sharp, because biopiracy cannot
- 1:06:57happen, and it's not just big companies
- 1:07:00with pharmaceutical or other interests
- 1:07:02doing it, but I also think there are
- 1:07:04certain subtle thefts. And sometimes
- 1:07:08there are people who come to the
- 1:07:09community and start asking questions,
- 1:07:11and start conducting interviews,
- 1:07:12recording things, there are certain
- 1:07:14things. So, one must always be clear
- 1:07:16about how those approaches should be
- 1:07:18made. Uh, always refer it back to the
- 1:07:21community. Why? Because as I tell you,
- 1:07:23we are still victims of these
- 1:07:25structural discriminations where, if I
- 1:07:28go to an indigenous town, sometimes I
- 1:07:31may not consciously respect the
- 1:07:33community and I could steal their
- 1:07:35knowledge. Recently, well, Mexico has
- 1:07:38been a good case for analysis; you know
- 1:07:41, I don't know, there have been cases,
- 1:07:43for example, where they are stealing
- 1:07:45designs from indigenous communities and
- 1:07:47certain international designers, you
- 1:07:49know, then they take a weave and sell
- 1:07:51it on a handbag, things like that, and
- 1:07:53there have been actions of
- 1:07:54misappropriating intellectual property
- 1:07:57and intangible knowledge. So, you
- 1:07:59always have to keep an eye on biopiracy
- 1:08:02, because the communities are, as
- 1:08:04always, the least benefited. So, uh,
- 1:08:08and not just regarding material issues
- 1:08:10like the theft of certain, like, uh,
- 1:08:13things, but also of, uh...I don't know.
- 1:08:17If you go to a community in Peru, for
- 1:08:19example, some indigenous community
- 1:08:21might tell you that certain rituals are
- 1:08:23now being sold, being sold because this
- 1:08:25, I don't know, is...I don't know, this
- 1:08:27preventive medicine, things like that.
- 1:08:30So you always have to be careful about
- 1:08:31biopiracy. It is a challenge for the
- 1:08:34protection of biocultural heritage,
- 1:08:36because not only is it taken from the
- 1:08:38community, it can be carried off, it
- 1:08:40can be commercialized, but all the
- 1:08:42ancestral knowledge, all the linked
- 1:08:43knowledge is being lost. Now people, uh
- 1:08:46, I don't know, my mom used to say, "
- 1:08:48The joche isn't made like that, is it?"
- 1:08:50Now people are inventing that the joche
- 1:08:51has properties, I don't know what
- 1:08:52things. So, that is also biopiracy and
- 1:08:56it is also up to us to have protection
- 1:08:58strategies. Uh, mining and energy
- 1:09:02projects also in many Latin American
- 1:09:05countries are greatly affecting the
- 1:09:07issue of land access or territorial
- 1:09:10rights. As you know, these projects are
- 1:09:15expansive, they are very harmful to
- 1:09:17natural resources, and the communities
- 1:09:20that are victims of mining—worse yet,
- 1:09:23open-pit mining—find that the land is
- 1:09:26almost completely affected and it is
- 1:09:28very difficult to recover. Another
- 1:09:32challenge is a just energy transition.
- 1:09:35Often, there is an attempt to seek
- 1:09:37certain approaches or links with
- 1:09:39communities, or there is an exportation
- 1:09:42of concepts that are not built with the
- 1:09:44community and that the community does
- 1:09:47not embrace, and this can also lead to
- 1:09:49losses of knowledge or theft of
- 1:09:51knowledge. And there are also other
- 1:09:54things that are even more complex,
- 1:09:56which is the entire access to those
- 1:09:57genetic resources associated with
- 1:09:59biodiversity. Not only can there now be
- 1:10:03irregular or illegal access to a plant,
- 1:10:07an animal, or a piece of knowledge, but
- 1:10:10even the theft of digital information
- 1:10:13sequences, things that are even much
- 1:10:17more complex. What could be some
- 1:10:26applications in Latin America, or what
- 1:10:29are some alternatives, as we mentioned
- 1:10:31at the beginning, for both legal
- 1:10:34defense and other types of organization
- 1:10:37within the communities? Community-based
- 1:10:42conservation; these processes of
- 1:10:44protecting biocultural heritage do not
- 1:10:47have to be foreign to the communities,
- 1:10:49nor do they have to be exported models.
- 1:10:54I feel that when we try to export a
- 1:10:56conservation model—or not just a
- 1:10:58model, but a regulation—something
- 1:11:01that is foreign to the community, first
- 1:11:04of all, it is not respectful of their
- 1:11:06rights, but it also generates
- 1:11:08strategies that are not sustainable
- 1:11:11over time. So, I have seen cases where
- 1:11:14certain strategies for protecting
- 1:11:16cultural heritage come hand in hand
- 1:11:18with limitations and restrictions,
- 1:11:20rather than the sustainable use that
- 1:11:22the communities have practiced.
- 1:11:25Therefore, if we listen to the
- 1:11:27communities—not just as a matter of
- 1:11:29management, but if we truly respect
- 1:11:31their rights—they are the main ones
- 1:11:33to say how biocultural heritage should
- 1:11:36be managed and protected. There are
- 1:11:41also certain models that are more aimed
- 1:11:43at creating protected areas to
- 1:11:46safeguard certain resources or
- 1:11:48biocultural assets, but even this type
- 1:11:50of conservation cannot be a restriction
- 1:11:53on the rights of communities and
- 1:11:55indigenous peoples, right? In some
- 1:11:59countries, the issue of indigenous
- 1:12:01governance has been implemented, and
- 1:12:04great care has also been taken in
- 1:12:06implementing these models because,
- 1:12:08often, the communities themselves do
- 1:12:11not even know. The communities are the
- 1:12:13last to realize that their community is
- 1:12:15now a national park, a biosphere
- 1:12:17reserve, or a world heritage site. So,
- 1:12:20even though these conservation models
- 1:12:22have laudable goals, they can also
- 1:12:24generate a restriction on the access
- 1:12:26and rights of local and indigenous
- 1:12:28communities. And also recently, which I
- 1:12:34think is important to mention, a recent
- 1:12:36agreement, which is the BBNJ agreement,
- 1:12:39I don't know if you've heard of it,
- 1:12:41which concerns the protection of areas
- 1:12:43beyond national jurisdiction for high
- 1:12:46seas marine areas, which is like a
- 1:12:48common heritage because, well, because
- 1:12:51it's outside national jurisdictions. It
- 1:12:55is interesting what they propose, if
- 1:12:58you can check it out, because it also
- 1:13:00recognizes the integration and
- 1:13:02protection of traditional knowledge.
- 1:13:06Just to see how curious it is. Perhaps,
- 1:13:07those of us who are more...well, I am
- 1:13:09from the coast and I don't think I see
- 1:13:11it as, as different, but there are
- 1:13:13people from other parts of the world
- 1:13:15who perhaps cannot understand why there
- 1:13:17is a connection between indigenous
- 1:13:19peoples, I don't know, for example,
- 1:13:21from Chile with the high seas. And when
- 1:13:23you meet the people of Rapa Nui, when
- 1:13:26you meet the Kawésqar people, they are
- 1:13:28people who have established their
- 1:13:30worldview, their way of seeing the
- 1:13:32world, their cultural structure with
- 1:13:35the sea and the high seas area. So, the
- 1:13:37migratory flows of certain species are
- 1:13:40known to the people. So that is where
- 1:13:43we see that even in these
- 1:13:45fourth-generation environmental
- 1:13:47agreements, which are very recent, very
- 1:13:49novel, they have to integrate the issue
- 1:13:52of biocultural protection and also that
- 1:13:55marine governance has to be linked with
- 1:13:57the protection of coastal biocultural
- 1:14:00heritage. So, the issue of biocultural
- 1:14:03heritage is dynamic, it is complex, it
- 1:14:06has different variations, but its
- 1:14:08genesis is the same. The protection of
- 1:14:12these resources, not only in themselves
- 1:14:14, but in their connection with the
- 1:14:17holders of that knowledge. And to
- 1:14:22conclude, within the conclusions, right
- 1:14:25?,that biocultural heritage constitutes
- 1:14:28an object of transversal protection. As
- 1:14:33I told you, biocultural heritage is
- 1:14:36dynamic and I think that as we get
- 1:14:38closer to our communities wherever we
- 1:14:41are situated, we will understand it
- 1:14:44better. It varies by community, it
- 1:14:48varies by country, it varies by zone.
- 1:14:50Eh, so it requires that approach, right
- 1:14:53? And that protection must also respond
- 1:14:56to those differences, to those
- 1:14:57differences that exist. Also something
- 1:15:02very important, biocultural heritage,
- 1:15:04although it does not have a specific
- 1:15:07convention or treaty that protects it,
- 1:15:10we can indeed make this systematic
- 1:15:12analysis of the conventions we already
- 1:15:15mentioned and the jurisprudence, and
- 1:15:17human rights also give us a tool for
- 1:15:20the conservation of biocultural
- 1:15:22heritage. Why? Because if we protect
- 1:15:27the bearers, who in many cases—the
- 1:15:29majority of cases, I would dare say—
- 1:15:32are indigenous and local communities,
- 1:15:34if we protect the bearers, if we defend
- 1:15:37the people, the communities, the
- 1:15:39collectives, we are also defending
- 1:15:42biocultural heritage. So, I am clear in
- 1:15:46identifying that, for example, all the
- 1:15:49progress in the protection of
- 1:15:51indigenous peoples' human rights has
- 1:15:54had a direct impact on the conservation
- 1:15:56of biocultural heritage and how we
- 1:15:59achieve it. We also have, there is a
- 1:16:03trend—this is very important—of
- 1:16:05transitioning from those anthropogenic
- 1:16:08and ecocentric approaches, which meant
- 1:16:11something like protecting something
- 1:16:13because it serves human beings, versus
- 1:16:16protecting something just because. We
- 1:16:20are migrating to a biocultural approach
- 1:16:22, that is, to know and understand, uh,
- 1:16:25the protection of biocultural heritage
- 1:16:27as a whole; not to segregate it, not to
- 1:16:29isolate it into saying that I protect
- 1:16:32knowledge of plants, knowledge of
- 1:16:34animals, that I protect certain
- 1:16:36communities, no, but to see it as a
- 1:16:38whole and understand it as a whole,
- 1:16:40right? Which I think, for those who are
- 1:16:44legal practitioners, can be complex;
- 1:16:46because we are very used to things like
- 1:16:48the right to life, the right to water,
- 1:16:50or the right to housing, but
- 1:16:52biocultural heritage actually
- 1:16:53integrates many rights that have been
- 1:16:55recognized in both human rights
- 1:16:57regulations and environmental
- 1:16:59regulations. So, in this exercise, we
- 1:17:02have to learn to be creative in
- 1:17:04establishing our strategies for the
- 1:17:06protection of biocultural heritage. And
- 1:17:10well, this is a bit of the subject
- 1:17:12matter, what I wanted to share with you
- 1:17:14, uh, about the protection of
- 1:17:16biocultural heritage, and now I would
- 1:17:18like for us to interact during the
- 1:17:20remaining time, for you to ask your
- 1:17:22questions, and I am also open to
- 1:17:24hearing your comments.
- 1:17:27Thank you very much, Sandra. Indeed,
- 1:17:29throughout your presentation, uh, we
- 1:17:31have had several questions; some I have
- 1:17:33already shared with you at length. I am
- 1:17:36going to continue, if you like, with
- 1:17:38another block of three questions; you
- 1:17:40respond, and then we will proceed with
- 1:17:42another block. And also, if anyone
- 1:17:46wants to open their microphone, uh, and
- 1:17:48share, uh, their comment or question,
- 1:17:51well, please raise your hand or leave
- 1:17:53it in the comments or in the Q&A
- 1:17:55section, right? Right, uh, the first
- 1:17:59question in this first block, uh, is in
- 1:18:02relation to the international
- 1:18:04conventions that you mentioned in the
- 1:18:07first part of your presentation, and it
- 1:18:09is how the EscazĂş Agreement relates to
- 1:18:12them, to the ones you mentioned, uh, to
- 1:18:15the international conventions. Two, how
- 1:18:18to bridge the gap that exists regarding
- 1:18:20the genetic lack of knowledge of the
- 1:18:23vast majority of species in relation to
- 1:18:25traditional use. How could indigenous
- 1:18:29people argue ownership or use of
- 1:18:31certain organisms against large
- 1:18:33pharmaceutical companies? The third
- 1:18:36question in this block is, how can
- 1:18:38indigenous communities demand that the
- 1:18:41State protect their biocultural
- 1:18:43heritage? Perfect. Yes, let's talk a
- 1:18:56little bit. Well, regarding question
- 1:18:59one on how the EscazĂş Agreement is
- 1:19:01linked, it is very important that we
- 1:19:03remember and know, perhaps for those
- 1:19:06who are not dedicated to law, about the
- 1:19:08principle of interdependence. What is
- 1:19:12the principle of interdependence? This
- 1:19:16legal principle seeks to integrate
- 1:19:19legal regulations. So, what does this
- 1:19:23mean? The EscazĂş Agreement, also as an
- 1:19:26environmental agreement, must be
- 1:19:28integrated into the analysis, or it is
- 1:19:30integrated and complemented by the
- 1:19:33different treaties. For example, the
- 1:19:37EscazĂş Agreement is based on three
- 1:19:40main rights, which are access to
- 1:19:43information, access to participation,
- 1:19:47and access to justice. If you review,
- 1:19:51for example, the agreement, the
- 1:19:52Convention on Biological Diversity, it
- 1:19:55also establishes a right to
- 1:19:56participation. So, how does the EscazĂş
- 1:19:59Agreement serve me to generate a
- 1:20:01defense or a defense strategy for
- 1:20:04cultural heritage? It is an
- 1:20:06international agreement that recognizes
- 1:20:08, for example, my right to participate
- 1:20:10and to be involved in the protection of
- 1:20:13biocultural heritage. Because it can
- 1:20:16happen, or it happens in many cases,
- 1:20:18that decisions are made regarding the
- 1:20:20management of natural resources, or
- 1:20:23biological and cultural or biocultural
- 1:20:25resources, and communities are not
- 1:20:27involved. So, the EscazĂş Agreement is
- 1:20:30a tool, and it is a tool to protect
- 1:20:33these types of rights. And if those
- 1:20:36rights, for example in environmental
- 1:20:38matters, which we already recognized
- 1:20:41that in the CBD it says that agreements
- 1:20:43must be protected, eh, traditional
- 1:20:45knowledge must be protected; if there
- 1:20:48is a violation of those rights
- 1:20:50recognized by the CBD and which are
- 1:20:52subscribed to by the State, I also have
- 1:20:54the right to activate access to justice
- 1:20:57, I have the right to report. So, the
- 1:21:01EscazĂş Agreement is a convention, and
- 1:21:03if your country—whoever is asking the
- 1:21:05question—has signed it, it protects
- 1:21:07those procedural rights, those
- 1:21:09activation rights. The CBD, for example
- 1:21:12, the Convention on Biological
- 1:21:14Diversity, protects substantial rights,
- 1:21:17it protects the right to heritage, to
- 1:21:19knowledge, but the EscazĂş Agreement
- 1:21:21protects you more in how you act to
- 1:21:23protect biocultural heritage and gives
- 1:21:26you three rights to have information.
- 1:21:29If I know that in my community they are
- 1:21:31going to introduce, uh, I don’t know,
- 1:21:33some policy about transgenic seeds, I
- 1:21:35can go and ask what information
- 1:21:37supports that. If, for example, there
- 1:21:41is going to be a project, I don’t
- 1:21:43know, like granting a patent to a
- 1:21:45pharmaceutical company, I have the
- 1:21:47right to participate, I have the right
- 1:21:49to hear the hearings, I have the right
- 1:21:51to know what is happening, and if those
- 1:21:53rights are violated, or anything like
- 1:21:55that, as one always says, right? In
- 1:21:58good faith, one would hope that
- 1:22:00biocultural heritage is defended, which
- 1:22:03is why we are all gathered here. But if
- 1:22:06that doesn't happen, I also have the
- 1:22:08right to access justice, I have the
- 1:22:10right to go and file a complaint, I
- 1:22:11have the right to go and claim, uh, and
- 1:22:14defend the collective rights that
- 1:22:15protect our biocultural heritage. So,
- 1:22:18in conclusion, when we talk about the
- 1:22:20EscazĂş Agreement, when we talk about
- 1:22:23environmental and human rights
- 1:22:25agreements, the interpretation or what
- 1:22:27we seek is an interdependent analysis
- 1:22:29of the treaties; not to see them as
- 1:22:32isolated little things, but, when you
- 1:22:34conduct an analysis, uh, and you take
- 1:22:36those conventions, you find their
- 1:22:38meaning and how each one connects and
- 1:22:41how each one protects a range of rights
- 1:22:43that seeks to ensure we achieve the
- 1:22:45protection of our heritage. uh, natural
- 1:22:49and cultural as well, around there. Uh,
- 1:22:53the second one, yes, that is a complex
- 1:22:58question, isn't it? I don’t think I
- 1:23:01have the specific capacity to define
- 1:23:04the issue of loss of knowledge, that is
- 1:23:07, scientific knowledge. What I could
- 1:23:12say, or what one tries to defend from
- 1:23:15within the community, is that
- 1:23:18traditional knowledge should not be
- 1:23:20displaced by science. Why? Because also
- 1:23:25, and which type of science, I mean,
- 1:23:27there are certain scientific research
- 1:23:29processes that are exclusionary of
- 1:23:31traditional knowledge, right? That is
- 1:23:33what we don’t want. Also this type of
- 1:23:36seeking validation. Uh, for example, we
- 1:23:40recently had a discussion, which I tell
- 1:23:43you is a topic being debated, that
- 1:23:45posed exactly that; it asked that if
- 1:23:47the community hadn't defined, for
- 1:23:49example at a scientific level, if some
- 1:23:51species was in danger of extinction,
- 1:23:53how could they exercise those processes
- 1:23:55, or was it required that a scientist
- 1:23:57come to the community? Those
- 1:24:01discussions are on the table, but it
- 1:24:03depends on how you look at it. Working
- 1:24:07with these communities, I fully trust
- 1:24:09that they have the capacity, for
- 1:24:11example, to participate in treaty
- 1:24:13negotiation processes for the
- 1:24:15protection of their biocultural
- 1:24:17heritage. Meaning, they have the
- 1:24:21capacity and the knowledge to do so,
- 1:24:24and those information gaps can also
- 1:24:26begin to be, uh, filled. Perhaps one
- 1:24:31case I’ve been working on is that
- 1:24:33there is now a trend, mostly in South
- 1:24:35America, where the State wants to carry
- 1:24:38out a validation process for
- 1:24:39traditional knowledge; so, they send an
- 1:24:42anthropologist to the community to
- 1:24:44validate if it is truly traditional
- 1:24:46knowledge or not, right? So, there are
- 1:24:50also structures of discrimination there
- 1:24:52, uh, that we must fight against, right
- 1:24:55? I mean, it seemed a bit strange to me
- 1:24:58that it had to be one person who would
- 1:25:01give credibility to the fact that it
- 1:25:04exists. So, if we work from the
- 1:25:06communities’ point of view and defend
- 1:25:08their rights, we recognize that their
- 1:25:10knowledge is also valid and valuable.
- 1:25:14There is discussion, there is
- 1:25:15discussion about this topic, about
- 1:25:17information gaps, about science gaps.
- 1:25:20But also, as we discussed today, if
- 1:25:23there is a lack of knowledge, the
- 1:25:25precautionary principle must be applied
- 1:25:27, and if there is no certainty, then
- 1:25:29the projects or certain measures could
- 1:25:31not continue. But there is a debate on
- 1:25:35the issue of, uh, scientific gaps or
- 1:25:38scientific information, and also how to
- 1:25:40better integrate traditional knowledge
- 1:25:42into formal discussions, right? As I
- 1:25:46tell you, there are spaces for
- 1:25:48biocultural heritage protection, or
- 1:25:51rather, always biological heritage (and
- 1:25:54then they add "cultural" in Arial font
- 1:25:56underneath), where sometimes
- 1:25:58communities don’t participate and
- 1:26:01it’s just, I don’t know, scientists
- 1:26:04, and perhaps there is no real
- 1:26:06participation; but it is a topic being
- 1:26:09discussed. And the third point is how
- 1:26:13indigenous peoples can protect their
- 1:26:15biocultural heritage. Well, by
- 1:26:17activating all these mechanisms I
- 1:26:19mentioned. There are mechanisms not
- 1:26:23only for reporting, but for
- 1:26:25participating in public policy
- 1:26:27formation processes, being informed of
- 1:26:29what your local government or federal
- 1:26:32government is doing, what is happening,
- 1:26:34and demanding those rights. For example
- 1:26:38, even though I might infer that all
- 1:26:41communities know they have the right to
- 1:26:43participate, there are communities that
- 1:26:46don't know it, or don't know what
- 1:26:48rights they have or where they have to
- 1:26:51activate them, right? So, for example,
- 1:26:54regarding the right to participation,
- 1:26:57there are communities that still don't
- 1:26:59know it's their right to participate in
- 1:27:01policy-making processes or discussions
- 1:27:03of large-scale development projects. So
- 1:27:07, what communities can do is get
- 1:27:09informed, organize themselves primarily
- 1:27:12, and as I always tell them, stay alert
- 1:27:16. Uh, there are all sorts of processes
- 1:27:20that really help the community access
- 1:27:22certain things. For example, here in
- 1:27:25Costa Rica, communities have tried to
- 1:27:28protect some knowledge through
- 1:27:30intellectual property, which also makes
- 1:27:32one wonder, right? If only the formal
- 1:27:35part, if only formal recognition is
- 1:27:37valid, if a community has to put down
- 1:27:39on paper what the biocultural knowledge
- 1:27:42associated with a resource is in order
- 1:27:44to protect it via a patent, that is
- 1:27:46entering a logic and a dynamic that is
- 1:27:48honestly a bit foreign to the community
- 1:27:50. So, there are strategies. Uh, I could
- 1:27:54tell you not only about the legal side;
- 1:27:56I mean, the legal side in my community,
- 1:27:58for example, it has been activated when
- 1:28:01, I don't know, there was a case where
- 1:28:03there was like a theft of what was the
- 1:28:08knowledge of a traditional craft of the
- 1:28:10community. It was activated, public
- 1:28:14complaints were made that that craft
- 1:28:16was not from that other community, but
- 1:28:18from the Guaitil community. Complaints
- 1:28:22have been made, information has also
- 1:28:25been disseminated so that people are
- 1:28:27aware, so that they can verify if that,
- 1:28:29I don't know, if that craft is really
- 1:28:32from Guaitil or not. So those types of
- 1:28:36strategies, not just the legal ones, uh
- 1:28:38, and community support processes, I
- 1:28:41think the communities have most of the
- 1:28:44answers, right? Yes. In my community,
- 1:28:47the elders, for example, organize
- 1:28:48around the issue of seeds. So, many
- 1:28:51answers are not legal, even though this
- 1:28:53is a law class, but I believe that when
- 1:28:55you activate the law, you also have to
- 1:28:57accompany it with other types of
- 1:28:59protection strategies, and the lawyer
- 1:29:01should be the one who intervenes last.
- 1:29:04So, I'll leave those three answers
- 1:29:06there.
- 1:29:08Thank you very much. I am going to
- 1:29:10continue with a second block of
- 1:29:11questions. The first is, how can we
- 1:29:14move from a legal vision that protects
- 1:29:17biodiversity, territory, and culture
- 1:29:20separately? To an integral protection
- 1:29:23of biocultural heritage that recognizes
- 1:29:25that for many indigenous peoples and
- 1:29:27local communities, these are
- 1:29:29inseparable. Uh, secondly, it’s about
- 1:29:33how communities can protect
- 1:29:35biodiversity, especially those managed
- 1:29:38through ranches or energy parks
- 1:29:41operating within protected natural
- 1:29:43areas. Uh, someone asks us, noting that
- 1:29:48they believe bioculturality in Chile is
- 1:29:50not well-established in doctrinal
- 1:29:52discussions, much less at the level of
- 1:29:55jurisprudence. And given the comment
- 1:29:58you made during your presentation, they
- 1:30:00ask for your opinion on the
- 1:30:02opportunities and also the
- 1:30:03disadvantages or shortcomings that
- 1:30:05exist in Chile to bolster this subject
- 1:30:07and strengthen the protection of
- 1:30:09various indigenous and rural
- 1:30:11communities and their biodiversity. Mm.
- 1:30:17Yes, I will try to make a comment and
- 1:30:19see if we can cover them, if we can
- 1:30:22cover them all. Legal recognition. Uh,
- 1:30:27well look, that is a task for different
- 1:30:30actors that is being attempted in
- 1:30:32various countries. Uh. There has been
- 1:30:38advocacy for creating regulations at
- 1:30:41the legislative level so that it is
- 1:30:43recognized as a right, such as the
- 1:30:45right to the protection of biocultural
- 1:30:48heritage. Because if we review the
- 1:30:51regulations, I am sure you can still
- 1:30:54find it in your countries as, uh,
- 1:30:56fragmented or not yet established as a
- 1:30:58right per se. So, the strategies for
- 1:31:02that recognition, like everything in
- 1:31:04law, for a right to be recognized at a
- 1:31:06legislative level or through
- 1:31:08conventions or treaties, many things
- 1:31:10have to happen. So, what, what are the
- 1:31:14strategies being used in Latin America?
- 1:31:17Uh, well, at the international level
- 1:31:20where treaties are discussed, as I was
- 1:31:22telling you, this treaty that was just
- 1:31:25signed, the BBNJ agreement on the High
- 1:31:27Seas, had a very interesting
- 1:31:29negotiation process. Because, what is
- 1:31:33required at the international level at
- 1:31:35the UN, where these treaties or
- 1:31:36amendments to existing ones are
- 1:31:38discussed? I don’t know, if one
- 1:31:42wanted Article 8 (j) of the Convention
- 1:31:44on Biological Diversity to recognize
- 1:31:46biocultural heritage with all its
- 1:31:48details, well, that has to be pushed
- 1:31:50from this international forum, which is
- 1:31:52what is necessary. And one of the
- 1:31:56deficiencies that this system has been
- 1:31:58criticized for is: the real
- 1:32:00representation of communities, that it
- 1:32:02be the communities and indigenous
- 1:32:04peoples who participate, who go to
- 1:32:06these forums and represent their
- 1:32:08communities, who have a voice in those
- 1:32:11spaces; because, if they have a voice,
- 1:32:13they will be able to request that these
- 1:32:15concepts be integrated into the texts
- 1:32:18of amendments or the creation of new
- 1:32:20treaties at the national level. Well, a
- 1:32:24similar strategy is also used, pushing
- 1:32:27for regulatory changes, changes,
- 1:32:29legislative changes. In Costa Rica,
- 1:32:33there have been attempts, for example,
- 1:32:35to modify the biodiversity law to
- 1:32:37ensure there is recognition, uh, but it
- 1:32:39requires a strategy, uh, both legal and
- 1:32:42focused on advocacy before the
- 1:32:43authorities who establish legislative
- 1:32:46changes. And the other strategy, which
- 1:32:49I find the most, well, I think the most
- 1:32:52, uh, short-term that one tries to do,
- 1:32:54is that everything I shared with you,
- 1:32:56for those of us who are lawyers, all
- 1:32:58these analyses, all these regulations,
- 1:33:01these legal interpretations, be taken
- 1:33:03into concrete cases. In other words,
- 1:33:07that they be taken to constitutional
- 1:33:09courts or specific tribunals to demand
- 1:33:11the justiciability of those rights that
- 1:33:13already exist. And something very
- 1:33:15important, as we say, uh, well, not to
- 1:33:18educate the judge, but to provide
- 1:33:20elements to the judges, to those who
- 1:33:22decide cases, to those who can
- 1:33:24establish standards both at the
- 1:33:26national and inter-American level, uh
- 1:33:30regarding this, new trends. So, for
- 1:33:32example, in Latin America, it is very
- 1:33:35common for Constitutional Courts to
- 1:33:37have those research processes on how
- 1:33:39things have been resolved elsewhere.
- 1:33:43That is why, many times, we lawyers
- 1:33:44venture to say: "Well, in this case, I
- 1:33:46am going to include this legal analysis
- 1:33:48, uh, in accordance with this
- 1:33:50interpretation of the regulation, so
- 1:33:52that it becomes part of the
- 1:33:53jurisprudence and that jurisprudence
- 1:33:55can be implemented and create these
- 1:33:57standards." And that is how the law
- 1:34:00works a bit, right? But yes, regulatory
- 1:34:03changes tend to come at the end, it
- 1:34:05goes through many processes and many
- 1:34:08demands that collectives require, uh.
- 1:34:11So, uh, there can be many, many
- 1:34:14strategies. Uh, the last question had
- 1:34:18to do with Chile, if I am not mistaken.
- 1:34:23Well, the contexts are different; I
- 1:34:25mean, I think that if one goes, uh, to
- 1:34:27Mexico and talks with the people, with
- 1:34:29the communities, they are more familiar
- 1:34:32with the topic of biocultural heritage
- 1:34:34or the defense of biocultural rights,
- 1:34:36but there are countries that do not
- 1:34:38have it very integrated, neither in
- 1:34:40their legislation nor in their, nor in
- 1:34:42their, well, nor in their demands. So,
- 1:34:46we are, uh, at different stages. I
- 1:34:50think each country is implementing it
- 1:34:53differently. In Chile, for example,
- 1:34:56unlike Central America, perhaps they
- 1:34:59have a bit more regulatory progress in
- 1:35:01the recognition of coastal marine
- 1:35:04spaces for indigenous peoples, as there
- 1:35:06is a specific law called the ECPO, uh
- 1:35:09...which is also currently being, uh,
- 1:35:11quite questioned at the legislative
- 1:35:14level; they want to change it and
- 1:35:16almost strip it of the real content for
- 1:35:18which it was created. But for example,
- 1:35:24this law is a recognition of all marine
- 1:35:26biocultural knowledge, which is very
- 1:35:29interesting because in Latin America,
- 1:35:32the focus is often on terrestrial
- 1:35:34conservation, not so much on the marine
- 1:35:37. So, in that regard, you in Chile have
- 1:35:40been innovators. And from the
- 1:35:42experience I have had in recent years
- 1:35:45working with Kawésqar communities,
- 1:35:47there is a process that is not
- 1:35:49unrelated to the law, which is
- 1:35:51important to discuss, and that is the
- 1:35:54strengthening of community capacities,
- 1:35:57the strengthening of the capacity of
- 1:35:59local leaders, right? Not long ago, we
- 1:36:02had a meeting where many people from
- 1:36:04Latin America attended, from Mexico to
- 1:36:06Brazil. And one could see how the
- 1:36:08processes were a bit uneven. There are
- 1:36:11countries that are very advanced, or
- 1:36:13communities that are in very complex
- 1:36:15defense processes, and other
- 1:36:17communities that are starting to fight
- 1:36:19—well, not starting, but they are
- 1:36:21becoming more involved in legal
- 1:36:23strategies. But from the experience I
- 1:36:27have with the Kawésqar community, that
- 1:36:29process of cultural vindication is also
- 1:36:31valid for countries where perhaps the
- 1:36:33issue of Indigenous peoples 'rights has
- 1:36:36been very much affected for decades and
- 1:36:38decades. So, I think it is different,
- 1:36:41and from the experience I have working
- 1:36:44with different communities in different
- 1:36:46countries, sharing experiences is very
- 1:36:48valuable. So, never hesitate to
- 1:36:51participate in these spaces, for
- 1:36:52example, international ones, where you
- 1:36:54can exchange strategies, experiences,
- 1:36:56things that have worked, and things
- 1:36:58that haven't. And having those
- 1:37:01dialogues between communities seems
- 1:37:03very valuable at an international level
- 1:37:06, and also at a community level in your
- 1:37:08own countries, to integrate into those
- 1:37:11processes; but it really stems a lot
- 1:37:13from the drive that the communities
- 1:37:15have. So I think those are the answers
- 1:37:19for now.
- 1:37:23Thank you very much. Well, we are
- 1:37:26almost in the final part, so I am going
- 1:37:28to move on to another block of
- 1:37:30questions. How are customs, traditions,
- 1:37:34and traditional laws included in
- 1:37:36environmental regulations so that they
- 1:37:38become legally enforceable? A second
- 1:37:41question is, should a specific
- 1:37:43agreement be promoted for the
- 1:37:45protection of biocultural assets and
- 1:37:47rights? Although the subject is
- 1:37:49mentioned in major international and
- 1:37:51regional conventions, it would be
- 1:37:53important and valuable to promote a
- 1:37:55specific agreement. Also, on the other
- 1:37:59hand, they ask if you could help
- 1:38:01explain the process that is carried out
- 1:38:04for a case to be accepted by the
- 1:38:06Inter-American Court. Let's say, what
- 1:38:10makes a case admissible, what are the
- 1:38:13filters? For the moment, that would be
- 1:38:15all. Thank you. Yes. Uh, regarding the
- 1:38:20first question, how is it integrated?
- 1:38:22Well, I think that has to be a two-way
- 1:38:25effort between those who work in law
- 1:38:28and working with the communities. For
- 1:38:33example, it often even has to do with
- 1:38:36the issue of language, right? With care
- 1:38:40for things as specific as language,
- 1:38:43since many times laws, and specifically
- 1:38:46some regulations, use language that is,
- 1:38:49well, maybe not that it isn't valid,
- 1:38:52but perhaps it doesn't originate from
- 1:38:55the community. So, when that regulation
- 1:38:59is brought back or meant to be
- 1:39:01implemented, people don't recognize
- 1:39:02themselves in what is being protected
- 1:39:04there. So, what is a strategy? I
- 1:39:08believe that from the formation of the
- 1:39:11law, and not just the law, but any
- 1:39:14national or international regulation,
- 1:39:16it has to be socialized and it has to
- 1:39:19be consulted. You know that legislative
- 1:39:22measures that affect indigenous peoples
- 1:39:25must be consulted and must be built
- 1:39:27with the community. But what happens?
- 1:39:29That many times when regulations are
- 1:39:31created, people do not participate. So,
- 1:39:34it's a two-way street: the State must
- 1:39:36urge communities to participate, and
- 1:39:38secondly, communities should try to get
- 1:39:40involved and participate more in those
- 1:39:41processes. It can be tiring, it can be
- 1:39:45complex, and there may be some
- 1:39:46resistance from institutions for one to
- 1:39:48participate, but that is the only way
- 1:39:50for that recognition to be integrated;
- 1:39:52that is, from the formation of the law
- 1:39:55to the implementation of the
- 1:39:56regulations that already exist. And the
- 1:40:00other way to integrate it, as I was
- 1:40:02telling you, is through cases, it is
- 1:40:04trying to push for new legal arguments
- 1:40:06so that it is integrated into the
- 1:40:09jurisprudence of national and also
- 1:40:11international courts. That’s about it
- 1:40:15, that is the way to integrate it into
- 1:40:18the legal system and interpret what
- 1:40:20already exists and push for there to be
- 1:40:22specific recognition. Regarding the
- 1:40:26question you ask me about whether I
- 1:40:28would advocate for a specific agreement
- 1:40:30, I would say yes, because the
- 1:40:32agreements, the recognitions in the
- 1:40:34agreements that already exist are
- 1:40:36agreements that responded to other
- 1:40:38contexts or other realities. I think
- 1:40:42that if we discuss, for example, a
- 1:40:44multilateral agreement on the
- 1:40:45conservation of biocultural heritage,
- 1:40:47current discussions are different and
- 1:40:49the current challenges are different,
- 1:40:51right? So, I believe that, in my
- 1:40:54opinion, it is necessary, because even
- 1:40:56if one makes an interpretation, uh, in
- 1:40:59an interdependent manner of the
- 1:41:01treaties, we sometimes have to, those
- 1:41:04of us who work on legal strategies,
- 1:41:06sort of put together a puzzle. And
- 1:41:10sometimes that means that, for example,
- 1:41:12uh, the judge, or the...or when we make
- 1:41:15those interpretations, uh, they are
- 1:41:18rejected or are not analyzed in an...uh
- 1:41:20, in an interdependent way, or the
- 1:41:23person definitely says that this
- 1:41:25article is not linked to the...to a
- 1:41:27biocultural heritage issue, but just a
- 1:41:30biological one. So, yes, I think an
- 1:41:34international agreement specifically on
- 1:41:37biocultural issues would be necessary,
- 1:41:39as well as specific laws on biocultural
- 1:41:41matters, because, for now, in most
- 1:41:43countries—not in all—uh, almost
- 1:41:45always the same thing happens: an
- 1:41:47interpretation of some article of
- 1:41:49environmental or biodiversity laws that
- 1:41:51briefly recognizes the topic of
- 1:41:53traditional knowledge here and there.
- 1:41:57So, I believe there should be specific
- 1:41:58legal protection for the issue of
- 1:42:00cultural heritage and it should begin
- 1:42:02to be discussed. And regarding what the
- 1:42:06colleague asked, well, that would take
- 1:42:08up an entire class on how to access the
- 1:42:10Inter-American Court, but I can tell
- 1:42:11you that using the Inter-American
- 1:42:13system has different paths for a case
- 1:42:15to reach the court. It is a complex
- 1:42:19process, it is a long process. First,
- 1:42:22there must be a case admissibility
- 1:42:24process before the Inter-American
- 1:42:26Commission, which is like—the
- 1:42:27commission is like the filter for cases
- 1:42:30to reach the court. It must be
- 1:42:34submitted under some very specific
- 1:42:37rules. It is very complex. I can send
- 1:42:40you information so you can verify it,
- 1:42:42but it is the Inter-American Commission
- 1:42:44that determines the viability of a case
- 1:42:47going to the Court, which is, as I tell
- 1:42:49you, uh, long, tiring, expensive; it is
- 1:42:51not that easy to access the
- 1:42:53Inter-American Court. But what is more
- 1:42:56feasible for us who work on these
- 1:42:58topics is to use the standards, is to
- 1:43:01use the standards from the rulings, try
- 1:43:03to implement them; it is to start using
- 1:43:05the advisory opinions of the
- 1:43:07Inter-American Court and begin to
- 1:43:09implement them. Or also, uh, as I tell
- 1:43:13you, if you don't want to wait many
- 1:43:15years for your case to be reviewed,
- 1:43:17there are other instances within the
- 1:43:19Inter-American human rights system that
- 1:43:21we can access. For example, the
- 1:43:23rapporteurships, the rapporteurships on
- 1:43:25the rights of indigenous peoples, the
- 1:43:27rapporteurships on economic, social,
- 1:43:29and cultural issues. So, there are
- 1:43:32certain structures where we can take
- 1:43:34this matter. For example, the topic of
- 1:43:36biocultural heritage can be brought to
- 1:43:38these instances so that these dialogues
- 1:43:40can begin to open up within the system.
- 1:43:43So, there are different tools, and for
- 1:43:46the topic of how to understand the
- 1:43:48process, which is a very complex
- 1:43:50process to explain, I can send you some
- 1:43:53resource within the material I will
- 1:43:55give you so you can review it in your
- 1:43:57own time. And I will stop here for now.
- 1:44:03Thank you very much. Sandra, if you
- 1:44:06agree, let's go with the last two
- 1:44:08questions so we can wrap up now. Do you
- 1:44:12consider that a mechanism to protect
- 1:44:14traditional knowledge, or traditional
- 1:44:16knowledge associated with indigenous
- 1:44:18peoples and communities, such as
- 1:44:20creating catalogs of this knowledge
- 1:44:22where the holders of such knowledge are
- 1:44:24mentioned, is useful? And finally, can
- 1:44:28the landscape be protected from the
- 1:44:30leveling and paving done for industrial
- 1:44:32warehouses or large commercial
- 1:44:34businesses? The first one, that is a
- 1:44:40good question, there are different ways
- 1:44:43; I mean, first of all, I tell you that
- 1:44:46there was a time with a trend or, I
- 1:44:49would say, a race to systematize
- 1:44:52everything. Let's systematize these
- 1:44:55practices, let's systematize this,
- 1:44:57because if we don't systematize it,
- 1:44:59they are going to steal it. Or that
- 1:45:01could be one strategy. I tell you that
- 1:45:04it is very much up to the community's
- 1:45:06decision. There are communities that
- 1:45:10have "put on the jersey," as we say in
- 1:45:13Costa Rica, to systematize or compile
- 1:45:15their knowledge, but it doesn't work
- 1:45:18for all communities. There are
- 1:45:20communities that, for example, um that
- 1:45:25rely on oral tradition, so perhaps
- 1:45:28making a materialization of that
- 1:45:31knowledge is not the most ideal thing.
- 1:45:36And also, as a personal appreciation
- 1:45:39from what I have experienced, we don't
- 1:45:41have to start that race to legitimize
- 1:45:43the knowledge I have, right? Because I
- 1:45:47have experienced with certain
- 1:45:49communities that when you put that on
- 1:45:51paper, a lot is lost; you cannot
- 1:45:53systematize everything. So it is a tool
- 1:45:56, it has been used in communities, that
- 1:45:59is true, and systematizations have been
- 1:46:06done, for example, dictionaries have
- 1:46:09been made of traditional ecological
- 1:46:12knowledge. I have seen it. They have
- 1:46:14done systematizations of many things,
- 1:46:17but I think there is certain knowledge
- 1:46:20that doing it in those types of
- 1:46:23systematizations is not that easy. Or
- 1:46:26the community is also not...there is,
- 1:46:29for example, sometimes when an attempt
- 1:46:31is made to translate from an indigenous
- 1:46:33language to Spanish, a lot is lost,
- 1:46:36many things are lost. So, I think it is
- 1:46:39a community decision. I think it is a
- 1:46:42valid tool, it can be used, but no, not
- 1:46:44all communities want that type of
- 1:46:46approach. And also, if we do it as a
- 1:46:49way to create support, uh, as that type
- 1:46:52of objective, but not, it shouldn't
- 1:46:54stem from the need to validate through
- 1:46:57writing what already exists, right? or
- 1:47:00or that knowledge, because otherwise we
- 1:47:02fall into this same trap of thinking we
- 1:47:05need validation, and indigenous peoples
- 1:47:07and their worldviews do not need
- 1:47:09validation. And the other question,
- 1:47:11could you repeat it for me? I didn't
- 1:47:13quite understand it.
- 1:47:15Of course, don't worry.
- 1:47:20Can the landscape be protected from the
- 1:47:22leveling and paving done for industrial
- 1:47:24warehouses or large commercial
- 1:47:26buildings? Yes, it has been argued in
- 1:47:30some communities that the landscape is
- 1:47:32also part of well, of a cultural and
- 1:47:36ecological rootedness. There is an
- 1:47:40initiative called LALI, which is the
- 1:47:42Latin American Landscape Initiative,
- 1:47:44where in some communities the landscape
- 1:47:47can be part of their heritage, right?
- 1:47:50Uh, in Colombia I think there is
- 1:47:52progress in protecting certain
- 1:47:54landscapes. I forget the specific area,
- 1:47:58but there are initiatives; it has, it
- 1:48:01has been requested by some communities
- 1:48:03that the landscape also be protected,
- 1:48:06because when there are impacts, like
- 1:48:08the one our colleague mentions, when
- 1:48:11there are impacts from roads or these
- 1:48:13types of constructions, there is an
- 1:48:15impact on the landscape, but the
- 1:48:18landscape can be integrated into
- 1:48:20protection and, even UNESCO recognizes
- 1:48:22it as, uh, something that can be
- 1:48:25protected as part of intangible
- 1:48:27heritage. So, the landscape, yes, the
- 1:48:29landscape not just as an ecosystem
- 1:48:32service, which is what the landscape is
- 1:48:34, but as a biocultural link. We would
- 1:48:37have to explore if there are precedents
- 1:48:39, I don't recall any at a
- 1:48:41jurisprudential level, but I do know
- 1:48:44there are regional initiatives like the
- 1:48:46one I mentioned, the Latin American
- 1:48:49Landscape Initiative. So, just so you
- 1:48:53know, there is a sector that has pushed
- 1:48:55for its protection; I don't know of
- 1:48:58specific cases like court rulings, no,
- 1:49:01I don't know them, but there is
- 1:49:03definitely a group pushing to protect
- 1:49:06the landscape as part of the
- 1:49:08communities' heritage.
- 1:49:12Agreed. Thank you very much. Uh, we
- 1:49:16deeply appreciate the presentation by
- 1:49:18YasmĂn Granados and her time. Uh, and
- 1:49:21we would also like to take the
- 1:49:23opportunity for a few reminders. The
- 1:49:25first is that the exam corresponding to
- 1:49:28module one will be available until
- 1:49:30Friday, August 7, 2026, and we invite
- 1:49:33you all to complete it. On the other
- 1:49:36hand, we also remind you that each
- 1:49:38session involves, in addition to class
- 1:49:40attendance, dedicating one hour to
- 1:49:42independent study and work, consisting
- 1:49:45of reading the reference sources
- 1:49:46indicated in the documents available on
- 1:49:49the platform. Thank you very much for
- 1:49:52joining us, and we will meet again next
- 1:49:54Thursday, August 6, for session 11,
- 1:49:56titled The Mexican Legal Framework for
- 1:49:58the Protection of Biocultural Heritage.
- 1:50:00See you later.
- 1:50:04See you later. Take care. Best of luck
- 1:50:06with the course.
- 1:50:07Thank you. Thank you very much. Have a
- 1:51:13lovely afternoon, everyone. See you
- 1:51:15later. Bye.
- 1:51:22Thank you very much.
- 1:51:24Good afternoon. Thank you so much. We
- 1:51:27have concluded this afternoon's session
- 1:51:29.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of 🌎🌱⚖️​Diplomado en medio ambiente, bioculturalidad y derechos humanos by Casas de los Saberes JurĂdicos, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 15,690 words across 2,546 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.