DESTROYING Communism (Dr. Paul Kengor) | Ep. 381 — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00all right we are live we are live with
- 0:02Dr Paul kangor pleasure yeah great to be
- 0:05with you Matt thanks yeah terrific for
- 0:07those uh great Studio thank you you like
- 0:09it yeah I do yeah 800 children all
- 0:12around us yeah that's right that's right
- 0:13that's right it makes it released yeah
- 0:15about 800. that's about right uh for
- 0:18those who aren't familiar with you who
- 0:19are you what do you do well oh man so I
- 0:24don't know how much of the life story do
- 0:25you want but I I was born uh December
- 0:281966 in Pittsburgh so it was born at
- 0:32McGee Hospital in Pittsburgh which is on
- 0:34the campus of the University of
- 0:36Pittsburgh which is ironic because I
- 0:38ended up going to school there as an
- 0:39undergrad and I was um went to Butler
- 0:43High School Butler High School Butler
- 0:44Pennsylvania and that was um so that's
- 0:47the alma mater of people as diverse as
- 0:50uh Rick Santorum uh Terry Hanratty the
- 0:53Notre Dame quarterback Steelers
- 0:55quarterback who was uh there for the
- 0:57Immaculate Reception of Franco Harris
- 1:00saying that reference you know you don't
- 1:02know the Immaculate Reception the
- 1:03American Football is it yeah yeah that's
- 1:05that's exactly right by the way as a as
- 1:08a giant uh American football fan I got
- 1:10to admit to college football is really
- 1:12stupid I mean what does it have to do
- 1:14with football I mean what do you you
- 1:15kick during an American football but but
- 1:18football because Chicago like tackle I
- 1:19wonder what the history of that is I
- 1:21don't know it's it's it's really
- 1:23ridiculous and you know I I bleed black
- 1:25and gold as a Steelers fan but um you
- 1:27don't know what the Immaculate Reception
- 1:29is no I barely know what this deal is uh
- 1:30so all right so we have two hours right
- 1:33all right but get the communism tour
- 1:36but the 50th Anniversary December 23rd
- 1:391972 of this epic game between the the
- 1:42Steelers and the Oakland Raiders they
- 1:44had like almost 30 Hall of Famers
- 1:45between the two teams I mean that's just
- 1:47an amazing thing and there's there's
- 1:48like 30 seconds left on the clock maybe
- 1:50less than that fourth and ten I think
- 1:53Terry Bradshaw the Steelers quarterback
- 1:54just throws a desperate pass down the
- 1:56field aiming for a guy named Frenchy
- 1:59Fuqua and it hits Fuqua in the back and
- 2:02bounces in the air and Franco Harris
- 2:05reaches down and picks it up before it
- 2:07falls on the ground runs it in for a
- 2:09touchdown Steelers win and they gave it
- 2:12the name the Immaculate Reception we're
- 2:14gonna have to watch this on YouTube and
- 2:16by the way as I'm saying this and people
- 2:17are listening
- 2:19um Franco Harris just died he was 72
- 2:22years old when was yesterday you know
- 2:24it's funny you say that because this
- 2:25morning I turned the radio on
- 2:27accidentally and I heard Immaculate
- 2:29Reception yeah yeah well it's an
- 2:31absolutely stunning thing because he was
- 2:33as far as we know he was in he was in
- 2:34great shape and and so the Steelers are
- 2:38playing the Raiders on Christmas Eve
- 2:39December 24th and the NFL Network set
- 2:42all his NFL set up all of this the
- 2:45entire country was going to watch the
- 2:47celebration of the 50th anniversary of
- 2:48the Immaculate Reception it's known as
- 2:50the most famous play in the history of
- 2:51NFL football and Franco Harris was going
- 2:54to be there and they were going to
- 2:55retire his jersey they've only retired
- 2:57one or two jerseys the Steelers despite
- 2:59all these great players and he died he
- 3:02died he died yesterday a complete shock
- 3:05I wrote a piece on it for crisis
- 3:06magazine and and I think they're going
- 3:08to be posting it on the 23rd but um but
- 3:12anyway so that's part of Steelers
- 3:14football lore and where do you teach now
- 3:16and what do you do so I teach at Grove
- 3:18City College in Grove City Pennsylvania
- 3:20which is alma mater of Scott Hahn
- 3:24and Scott was uh when Scott was at Grove
- 3:27City he was chasing around Catholics
- 3:29with torches running them running them
- 3:31off campus and Scott ended up of course
- 3:34being the most probably the most famous
- 3:36Converse I would say in the
- 3:37English-speaking World he's probably
- 3:38converted
- 3:40almost as many people as jump all the
- 3:42SEC yeah no really true and in fact his
- 3:45book Rome sweet home which if you go
- 3:47back and read through it you'll see oh
- 3:49yeah wow Grove City College it's all
- 3:51through there so he talks all about
- 3:52growth so that's where he met Kimberly
- 3:54as well his wife
- 3:56so I met him in the early 2000s I got to
- 4:01Grove City College in 1997. this was
- 4:04really my first full-time teaching job
- 4:06out of college and Scott
- 4:09um yeah it's kind of interesting so my
- 4:12colleague Michael Coulter who's also a
- 4:13convert and teaches at Grove City
- 4:15College
- 4:16uh pulled me aside one day and said hey
- 4:18I got this call from Scott Hahn who who
- 4:21was stuck in an airport and he found
- 4:22your book God and Ronald Reagan and he
- 4:25and he read in the back that read my bio
- 4:27that I taught at Grove City College and
- 4:29Scott and kind of typical Hans speak
- 4:31said you can see a lot about Ken Gore in
- 4:34the bio the in the words of this book
- 4:36right what does that mean but I but I
- 4:39think he was referring to a lot of the
- 4:41Catholic references the relationship
- 4:43between Reagan and John Paul II Reagan
- 4:45and Mother Teresa Reagan's family had
- 4:48all these Catholic influences his father
- 4:50was Catholic his only sibling his
- 4:52brother was a daily communicant so are
- 4:54you a convict I'm a convert yeah well I
- 4:56mean technically I'm a revert but I was
- 4:59raised in the church in the Dark Ages
- 5:02when was that the 1970s the 70s Robbie
- 5:06George asked me one time that he he said
- 5:08Paul tell me tell me your story your
- 5:10your con convert no you're a revert and
- 5:13I said yeah I said well you know I was
- 5:15raised in the church Church in the 70s
- 5:17and he said oh the Dark Ages you know
- 5:19you don't need to say anything else you
- 5:21don't need to say anything else but yeah
- 5:23so I was um I fell away from the church
- 5:26in the 80s when I went to college
- 5:28University of Pittsburgh I was a pre-med
- 5:31major at the University of Pittsburgh so
- 5:33I went there I worked for the organ
- 5:35transplant team from 1987 to 91. it was
- 5:41pioneered organ transplantation was
- 5:43pioneered by my boss Dr Thomas starzel
- 5:45there's a great documentary on on him
- 5:48which just came out about three years
- 5:50ago called um well why can't I think of
- 5:52the name of it right now Neil could
- 5:54probably find it the documentary and Dr
- 5:57Thomas starzel
- 5:58and it is a burden of genius that's what
- 6:01it's called
- 6:02so we did 90 of the world's organ
- 6:04transplants at the University of
- 6:06Pittsburgh in the late 90s and I was
- 6:09agnostic almost atheist at that point
- 6:12and I was planning on going to medical
- 6:14school it was the late 80s and I got
- 6:16very very interested in the end of the
- 6:18Cold War I started writing for the
- 6:21student newspaper which was called the
- 6:22pit news that's where I met my wife she
- 6:24was a copy editor I was the editorial
- 6:26page editor published four days a week
- 6:28Monday through Thursday print edition I
- 6:31I was a campus conservative that all the
- 6:33Liberals attacked and called names you
- 6:35know already calling me every name of
- 6:37the book before I even wrote like my
- 6:38second column I mean at that point I
- 6:40already been called a fascist a Nazi and
- 6:42you know just go you know go on down the
- 6:44line for writing an article on Reagan
- 6:46arming the contras in Nicaragua or
- 6:48something but but I was
- 6:51so I got interested in the end of the
- 6:53Cold War Ronald Reagan Pope John Paul II
- 6:55Margaret Thatcher
- 6:57lekwaldessa vaklav Havel solidarity
- 6:59movement Mikhail Gorbachev and I got I
- 7:02got pulled in my senior year between
- 7:04majoring in biochem biophysics which was
- 7:07my major and taking a bunch of courses
- 7:09on political science and I thought boy
- 7:12what do I really want to do with my life
- 7:14you know which direction do I want to go
- 7:16in what what do what do I want to do and
- 7:19interestingly I used to walk home to my
- 7:21apartment on North Craig Street
- 7:23in Oakland right next to Chief's Bar you
- 7:25know where Chiefs is okay
- 7:27I thought you would
- 7:29you haven't been here long enough yet
- 7:31that's right but right next to right
- 7:34next to Chief's uh bar and I would stop
- 7:36at Saint Paul's Cathedral in Oakland and
- 7:39go inside and just sort of beg God I'd
- 7:43say you know if you're really there if
- 7:44you really exist tell me what am I
- 7:46supposed to do with my life what do you
- 7:48want me to do with my life
- 7:50please tell me you went into a pub to
- 7:53ask this question well no I wouldn't I
- 7:55went into St Paul's Cathedral yeah okay
- 7:57I missed that yeah and then you went to
- 7:59the gym no no so the pub the pub the pub
- 8:03was right next to my apartment okay but
- 8:05but but I would go I would stop at St
- 8:07Paul's Cathedral on the way on the way
- 8:09home from class or from work when I
- 8:11worked at the Oregon transplant team
- 8:13because I worked there almost full time
- 8:14while I was in school and I would just
- 8:16beg God what am I supposed to do with my
- 8:18life what if you exist what am I
- 8:19supposed to do so it's a really
- 8:21agonizing decision but I ended up
- 8:23graduating with a degree in political
- 8:25science intending to finish my degree in
- 8:27biochem biophysics
- 8:29transplant team hired me full time out
- 8:32of school I did that for about a year
- 8:34and then I went to college graduate
- 8:36school at American University in
- 8:38Washington the School of International
- 8:40Service focusing on foreign policy
- 8:42National Security and really focusing on
- 8:45the issue of the end of the Cold War
- 8:47communism Russia Russia China Eastern
- 8:51Europe and it was there for a few years
- 8:54worked for a number of think tanks and
- 8:56other organizations my wife and I we got
- 8:58married when we were when we were in DC
- 9:00and then I came back to we both came
- 9:03back to the University of Pittsburgh to
- 9:05apply for graduate school because DC
- 9:07it's a great place to work but if if
- 9:10you're in that field but it's not a
- 9:11place to raise kids it's kind of a rat
- 9:14race so we both decided we're going to
- 9:17apply back to our alma mater she applied
- 9:19to the master's program in exercise
- 9:21physiology I applied to the master or
- 9:24the PHD program and we both got in so we
- 9:27both came back and got our graduate
- 9:30degrees there and then I got hired at
- 9:31Grove City College in 1997. so I my
- 9:35conversion
- 9:37I mean my wife took a gamble she married
- 9:39me when I was really not a Christian
- 9:42and she didn't understand that how how I
- 9:45how I couldn't believe in God I remember
- 9:47tearful conversations with her right
- 9:49where she just said I just don't see how
- 9:51you can't believe and I would give
- 9:53agnostic atheistic arguments but I
- 9:56eventually threw frankly Evangelical
- 9:59Christians found my way to the faith uh
- 10:03kind of it was one of the more prominent
- 10:05ones well
- 10:07it's a good question I mean I read a
- 10:09whole bunch of them and I mean all the
- 10:11popular ones of the day I listened to
- 10:14kind of Evangelical talk radio RC Sproul
- 10:17who was an influence on Scott Hahn D
- 10:20James Kennedy of Coral Ridge ministries
- 10:22of course C.S Lewis right and I read all
- 10:26of them and that kind of kind of
- 10:27reasoned my way into the Christian faith
- 10:29and then slowly so I joined the
- 10:32Presbyterian Church Presbyterian Church
- 10:35USA PC USA that's considered the
- 10:38mainline denomination of Presbyterians
- 10:40but they called the Presbyterians the
- 10:42split peas because they're always
- 10:44splitting and PC USA recently split
- 10:47again in fact there in Grove City my
- 10:50church Tower Church was PC USA Scott
- 10:53Hall know all of this and then across
- 10:55the street was East Main church that was
- 10:58PC USA Presbyterian Church USA they're
- 11:01both now outside of PC USA they're both
- 11:03in the new denomination is that why you
- 11:06were she was she was Presbyterian and by
- 11:08the way those two PC USA splintered up
- 11:11over kind of theological liberalism you
- 11:14know issues like marriage coordination
- 11:16kind of all the usual all the usual
- 11:19issues so I was there in a Presbyterian
- 11:23church for a while from
- 11:25probably
- 11:271995 97 until 2005 when I came into the
- 11:33church and John Paul II was a major
- 11:35influence on that so I I could talk a
- 11:39lot more about
- 11:41why I became Catholic if you want well
- 11:43very good well I I want to talk I want
- 11:45to get to the the topic at hand
- 11:47communism so this past week I read The
- 11:49Communist Manifesto oh congratulations
- 11:51that's wonderful isn't it yeah uh well
- 11:54it's definitely more of a rah-rah poetic
- 11:57book than it is uh philosophically
- 12:00precise book isn't it it's it's
- 12:02polemical I mean really I've I've heard
- 12:05people
- 12:06say how would you best describe Marx
- 12:08because Marx is clearly not an economist
- 12:10I mean that's for sure okay in fact what
- 12:13did he study because he's said to be an
- 12:15economist well and it's interesting too
- 12:17you'll see this just getting ahead of
- 12:19that a little bit at the universities
- 12:20today when you hear of marxist
- 12:24professors like Carnegie Mellon
- 12:25University in Pittsburgh they they had a
- 12:29200th anniversary celebration of the
- 12:31birth of Marx in 2018. that was put on
- 12:34by The English Department right it's
- 12:37it's always like the critical theory
- 12:39Department critical theory books folks
- 12:42it's not the economist it's not the
- 12:43political scientist it's not the
- 12:45historians all right I mean though
- 12:46colleges I mean you will at a lot of
- 12:48colleges have that econ Professor with a
- 12:50bust of marks yeah in the office but
- 12:52it's usually people in education English
- 12:57departments like that but if you read
- 12:59The Communist Manifesto I mean clearly
- 13:01he knows squat about about economics I
- 13:05mean it is more
- 13:07frankly it's kind of a diatribe but it's
- 13:10but he's very polemical it's more
- 13:14philosophical
- 13:15Mark's fancied himself a poet Marx
- 13:18wanted to be nothing less than right
- 13:20that wanted to be the guerreta of his
- 13:22age right the Faust of his age and
- 13:24that's where he he kind of dabbled with
- 13:27some of his satanic poetry that's quite
- 13:30chilling when when did communism become
- 13:33a word when was that like did a was it
- 13:36angles and Mark it's a great question
- 13:38it's a great question it was 1840s
- 13:41Richard pipes who was the long-time
- 13:44Harvard professor emeritus of Russian
- 13:47history he died in I think 2018 and I
- 13:52knew him very well but he he's so good
- 13:54on this subject his in fact his short
- 13:56book communism a history is something I
- 13:59strongly recommend people say to me
- 14:01often is there just like 100 or 200 Page
- 14:03book and he and he describes their
- 14:05communism as an ideal a program and a
- 14:08regime okay which is a really good way
- 14:10to put it but he said that that the word
- 14:13communism was coined in Paris at some
- 14:16point in the 1840s which seems to be
- 14:18true probably Marx and Ingles met in
- 14:21Paris probably around 1844.
- 14:24so at that point communism exists okay
- 14:27and they form something called the
- 14:29Communist League which is made up of 40
- 14:32to 50 basically
- 14:35um you know progressives white European
- 14:38males right and the guys you're not
- 14:40supposed to like but but Marx's Marx's
- 14:43wife was the only female in the group
- 14:45but it was the Communist League
- 14:48wasn't a party yet and they decided we
- 14:51need a sort of programmatic statement of
- 14:54what the Communists believe so they
- 14:56created they tasked to Marx and Ingles
- 14:59they were paid by that League correct
- 15:01yeah I know they were paid or not
- 15:03yeah so but but they uh but they
- 15:06probably were paid they were paid to
- 15:07revise it I think well well Marx was
- 15:10obsessed with money which is really the
- 15:12irony of this I mean I want to just back
- 15:14up a sec before we get into this because
- 15:15it said that those who were unaware of
- 15:16History are doomed to repeat it and I
- 15:18think sometimes we can be so familiar
- 15:20with the position it's the insanity of
- 15:22it can be so apparent to us that
- 15:25um maybe we're kind of leaving people
- 15:26behind a little there's bound to be
- 15:28people who are watching right now going
- 15:29I don't even know what this thing is
- 15:31where it came from why anyone would find
- 15:34it appealing right so maybe before we
- 15:36get a little bit more complicated can
- 15:37you just give us a overview well so so
- 15:40they well let me finish this first so
- 15:42they so they went to Marx and Ingles and
- 15:43said we need a kind of uh what we
- 15:46believe statement so they came up with
- 15:48now first they called it there's a
- 15:51letter from Ingles to Marx where Mark
- 15:53says Engel says to Marx give a little
- 15:55more thought to our communist confession
- 15:57of Faith wow that's what they call it
- 15:59can you pause me that yeah
- 16:01the Communist confession of Faith he
- 16:04said I think we should drop the
- 16:05catechetical form and just call it the
- 16:07manifesto okay The Communist Manifesto
- 16:10so they end up with this book that
- 16:12becomes the Communist Manifesto which is
- 16:14published in 1848. now this is a
- 16:16Catholic show in 1846 Pope Pius IX
- 16:21issued the encyclical Quee pluribus
- 16:23condemning communism that's two years
- 16:26before the manifesto was even published
- 16:27so communism existed before the
- 16:30manifesto was published in 1848.
- 16:33so that yeah that in itself shows shows
- 16:36that the idea had already been around in
- 16:38fact the opening words of the manifesto
- 16:40are that A specter is haunting Europe
- 16:43the Specter of Communism it says all the
- 16:47old powers of Europe Pope and czar
- 16:50meternik German radicals others are
- 16:53Allied together into a holy Alliance
- 16:56through exorced size the Specter that's
- 16:59hope yeah so so they describe it in this
- 17:02kind of Specter demonic exercise
- 17:05exorcism language so literal first words
- 17:08of the manifesto I just want to read
- 17:09this one law and to get to our point
- 17:10about it being a diatribe more than
- 17:12something philosophically precise I mean
- 17:14it's quite poetic it talks about the
- 17:15bourgeoisie they have drowned the most
- 17:18Heavenly ecstasies of religious ferva of
- 17:20chivalrous enthusiasm of philistine
- 17:22sentimentalism and the icy water of
- 17:24egotistical calculation yeah it makes
- 17:27you feel really smart when you said it
- 17:28was he had a poison patent he was an
- 17:30angry man and he could really
- 17:33um he could he could he could write I
- 17:35mean he's a polymerist he's an arguer
- 17:37right that's that's what he was good at
- 17:40doing if you want a kind of vitriolic
- 17:42hatchet man to to make your to make your
- 17:44case that was Mark so what is communism
- 17:46and say it in a way that a communist
- 17:48listening would go yeah I agree okay
- 17:50here's the easiest way to say it that
- 17:52people can't argue with all right
- 17:55um let's say Marx and Ingles gave us a
- 17:57definition they gave us four words they
- 18:00say in this book they say the entire
- 18:02communist Theory program may be summed
- 18:04up in a single sentence abolition of
- 18:07private property okay so I mean that
- 18:10that's it in a nutshell now once you
- 18:12actually read the book and and you hear
- 18:15all the time I get this from young
- 18:16people at college campuses around the
- 18:18country that oh communism is a pretty
- 18:21good idea if you just read it if you
- 18:22just read the book and have you read it
- 18:25yeah wow you know I have kind of looked
- 18:28around a little bit but I haven't but if
- 18:30you if you read it they're talking not
- 18:32just about abolition of private property
- 18:34they say that that's what it is there's
- 18:36the word abolition of all religion all
- 18:38morality all Eternal truths uh quote
- 18:41abolition of the family exclamation mark
- 18:43even the most radical flare up at this
- 18:46Infamous proposal of the Communists
- 18:47that's verbatim from they talk about
- 18:50abolishing money capital states uh you
- 18:53know entire societies and then tell me
- 18:55why is this attractive to someone even
- 18:58if they haven't read it that's okay
- 18:59whatever the bad idea of Communism why
- 19:03is that appealing to to people today I
- 19:06think it's utterly inexplicable how it
- 19:08could be a attractive now in the 1840s I
- 19:12think maybe the only thing you could say
- 19:14in defense of it what is that Marx and
- 19:17Ingles got right just how bad some of
- 19:21the effects were of the Industrial
- 19:22Revolution okay right some of the abuses
- 19:25of workers in the industrial revolution
- 19:27But but so did all kinds of people
- 19:31I need you to steal me because push back
- 19:35too because
- 19:36um not that I like communism but yeah
- 19:38you do bull crap
- 19:40uh the so the abolition of this that
- 19:45private property that's just anarchism
- 19:47right yeah these people anarchists or is
- 19:49there actual because when I hear about
- 19:50communism it's usually more like what is
- 19:53it creating as a you know if we all like
- 19:56you know pool our funds and stuff like
- 19:59that right yeah I mean people think it's
- 20:00just about like redistribution of the
- 20:02wealth and in fact if you look at some
- 20:04Modern polls of younger people where
- 20:07they ask them hey what do you think of
- 20:08Communism right and they'll say well I
- 20:10kind of like it right like 40 they'll
- 20:13say Well define what you think communism
- 20:15is and they'll say it's some polls
- 20:17literally say exactly this right from
- 20:19from younger people oh it's about people
- 20:21being kind to one another right it's
- 20:24about sharing sharing it's about free
- 20:26stuff but but on the abolition point
- 20:29these are these are bullet points on
- 20:31page 383 of my book The Devil and Karl
- 20:33Marx marks in the manifesto say the
- 20:36communism represents quote the most
- 20:38radical rupture in traditional relations
- 20:41now right there think about that
- 20:42communist what is communism well says
- 20:45Marx it represents the most radical
- 20:47rupture in traditional relations so they
- 20:50knew how radical it was also said
- 20:52because because until this time he's
- 20:55essentially saying we're just
- 20:56rearranging furniture on the Titanic
- 20:58because capitalism poisons everything
- 20:59well he says more than that in the
- 21:01manifesto he and he he and Ingles right
- 21:03the communism quote seeks to abolish the
- 21:07present state of things right I mean
- 21:10seeks to abolish the present state of
- 21:12things
- 21:13right yeah no here's the here's the
- 21:16kicker here's the money line if you're
- 21:18part pardon the expression the close of
- 21:21the manifesto everybody remembers the
- 21:22phrase workers of the World Unite we
- 21:25have a world to win but the final
- 21:27paragraph where it says those things
- 21:29also says this
- 21:31the Communists openly declare that their
- 21:34ends can be attained only by the
- 21:37forcible overthrow of all existing
- 21:41social conditions all right so people
- 21:44that think that this is just about
- 21:46sharing the wealth and being kind enough
- 21:48they're saying in their book they're
- 21:50calling for the forcible overthrow of
- 21:54all existing social conditions these
- 21:57guys aren't tinkerers they're not just
- 21:59talking about cutting taxes or
- 22:01increasing tax rates or a few
- 22:03regulations or National Health Care
- 22:05right forcible overthrow of all existing
- 22:07and these guys do this all the time
- 22:11but wouldn't they say whereas the
- 22:14capitalist says people are
- 22:16self-interested by nature and therefore
- 22:18that's why capitalism is the way things
- 22:20ought to be wouldn't they say no it's
- 22:22the other way around capitalism has made
- 22:24us self-interested and made us selfish
- 22:27and cruel so we have to overthrow
- 22:29everything in order that something you
- 22:31can result in in order to start entirely
- 22:34Anew and really Marx that's where that's
- 22:38where Marx was in fact he had when Marx
- 22:41was asked if he had a favorite line and
- 22:44people who knew Marx was asked if he had
- 22:45a favorite line I mean you or I might
- 22:47cite a scripture verse or a quote from a
- 22:51saint to where I'll say yeah John Paul
- 22:52II Be not Afraid Mark said yes Garrett
- 22:56is Faust the Mephistopheles character
- 22:59now the Mephistopheles character is the
- 23:01demon devil character and Faust and the
- 23:04line was everything that exists deserves
- 23:07to perish
- 23:09everything that exists deserves to
- 23:12perish one of the biographers of of
- 23:15Mark's uh Payne says you know picture
- 23:18marks and you can see this in his poetry
- 23:20kind of standing there in the in the
- 23:22smoldering ruins the Embers right
- 23:25everything on fire everything raised
- 23:28r-a-z-e-d everything level and then
- 23:31saying now we can begin right everything
- 23:33that exists deserves to perish forcible
- 23:38overthrow of all existing social
- 23:39conditions yeah that's that's a
- 23:41philosophy and it also I mean the main
- 23:44idea for those who haven't read it is
- 23:45this idea that there's this antagonism
- 23:47between two major classes the oppressor
- 23:50and the oppressed this is written to the
- 23:52oppressed right he seems to be assuming
- 23:53that the oppressors Are Holy evil and
- 23:56the oppressed a good just kind
- 23:57empathetic right and that even though
- 23:59they're going to have to take the place
- 24:01of the bourgeoisie they won't keep it
- 24:03for long and they'll eliminate all the
- 24:06systems that have caused this antagonism
- 24:07which just seems so insane
- 24:10yeah and and he had um and the irony of
- 24:13that is that Mark said it had a very
- 24:15negative view of people in fact he he
- 24:18referred he referred to what he called
- 24:21the lumpin proletariat and and Marx's
- 24:25Charming definition was this alongside
- 24:28ruined an adventurous offshoots of the
- 24:30bourgeoisie were vagabonds discharged
- 24:34soldiers discharged jailbirds escaped
- 24:36Galley slaves swindlers Mount backs
- 24:39lazarone pickpockets tricksters gamblers
- 24:42pimps brothel Keepers Porters Literati
- 24:46organ Grinders rag Pickers knife
- 24:48Grinders Tinkers Beggars and I'm not
- 24:50even talking here about his views of
- 24:52blacks this is when came from he's
- 24:54saying that's the what he called the
- 24:56lumpin what does that mean lumpin well
- 24:58it's it's it kind of translates into
- 25:01kind of rag Vagabond well he he uses all
- 25:04kinds of he applies at a really broad
- 25:07way but you see there his his kind a
- 25:10very demeaning view of the Common Man
- 25:12and this is a criticism of Marx that
- 25:14you'll hear even from some people who
- 25:16aren't as anti-marks as I am he never
- 25:19visited the factory floor I mean Marx
- 25:21wrote all this stuff from you know like
- 25:23a library in in Britain or from or from
- 25:27his apartment as he rested on his
- 25:29carbuncles he has a famous phrase to
- 25:32Ingles that at least maybe the
- 25:34bourgeoisie will remember my carbuncles
- 25:36you know he had these these violent
- 25:39outbursts of Rage because he was
- 25:42infected but by these boils on his
- 25:45backside on his penis and you know the
- 25:49doctors came in ought to try to figure
- 25:51out what's he suffering from no one else
- 25:54in the family seems to be picking this
- 25:55up but main reason was probably the Marx
- 25:58never bathed he refused to take a bath
- 26:00why he was a he was a really dirty guy
- 26:04and he um his his wife this really
- 26:08depressed his wife and his mother his
- 26:11parents cut him off my wife would be
- 26:13pretty depressed right parents cut him
- 26:15off and so at that point he got all of
- 26:17his money from Ingles and ingles's
- 26:19Family's inheritance the irony here too
- 26:22we'll talk he wants to abolition he
- 26:23wants to abolish all right of
- 26:24inheritance Marx completely lives from
- 26:26inheritance so how in this case isn't
- 26:28Engels the the bourgeoisie and he right
- 26:31how do you a quick question how do you
- 26:33even make that distinction is it is it
- 26:35those who uh are paying a wage for
- 26:39somebody else's uh time and and work and
- 26:42and creativity are those the the
- 26:45bourgeoisie like the the owners of
- 26:47factories yeah how did he make the
- 26:48decision well that's a good point
- 26:49because this binary kind of you're in
- 26:52the proletariat of the bourgeoisie is
- 26:54just an incredible simplification it's
- 26:57kind of like modern critical race
- 26:59theorists
- 27:02right and and whichever you are defines
- 27:05you and put you in a box as if you think
- 27:08a certain way and act a certain way so
- 27:10he's really just you can totally see
- 27:13this in BLM I mean that last line about
- 27:15the overthrowing of the current
- 27:16structure and to bring about some Dream
- 27:19doll of utopian equality I mean if you
- 27:22were just to read that line and say
- 27:23where does this apply in the United
- 27:24States over the last 10 years well
- 27:25obviously BLM we can get to that yeah
- 27:27and that's the Marxist framework now the
- 27:29Marxist framework was Martin Malia who
- 27:32was a professor at University of
- 27:34California Berkeley and actually uh
- 27:36wrote the best preface to The Communist
- 27:38Manifesto this is in the penguin
- 27:41Classics version and and Malia it was
- 27:44probably more like a moderate Democrat
- 27:45sort of I don't know he was very
- 27:47conservative but he really understood
- 27:49Marx very well he said for Marx the
- 27:51proletariat is both the victim class and
- 27:54the Redeemer class all right by the
- 27:57stripes of the proletariat shall we be
- 27:59here that's that's what I got from right
- 28:01yeah and there's kind of like a Via del
- 28:03crochet way of the Cross right that the
- 28:05proletariat was was going through but
- 28:08and Lenin said this all the others have
- 28:11said it all the marxists through the
- 28:131960s said it the proletariat's
- 28:15Consciousness had to be raised they had
- 28:17to be taught that they were the
- 28:19suffering class they had to be informed
- 28:22of this yeah Mark Rudd one of the
- 28:24founders of the Weather Underground said
- 28:26he used to frustrate us we would go into
- 28:28we would go into the working class areas
- 28:30of Chicago and New York and Pittsburgh
- 28:32to the Italian kids the Polish kids us
- 28:36kids from Colombia right Bill Ayers Mark
- 28:39Rudd Bernardine Doran and we were trying
- 28:41to tell them how repressed they were you
- 28:43know they're all like Italian and polish
- 28:45Catholics and they're saying Get out of
- 28:47here you commies and they'd beat us up
- 28:48right you know the greasers didn't want
- 28:50anything to do with us so the the
- 28:52educated Elite or standing there saying
- 28:54do you not understand how oppressed you
- 28:57are right and and of course they want
- 28:59nothing to do with Communism but but the
- 29:01proletariat needs to understand that
- 29:03it's the victim class which will serve
- 29:05as the Redeemer class so they will Usher
- 29:07in the revolution now the Marxist
- 29:09framework ever Hereafter for all modern
- 29:12day marxists including marxistent
- 29:14culture is to always look for that new
- 29:16victim class so the victim class
- 29:19according to gender marxists might be
- 29:21women
- 29:22the the victim class for critical race
- 29:26theorists the Marxist base CRT Advocates
- 29:29would be blacks right and so blacks have
- 29:32to be informed that they are repressed
- 29:34even if you're talking to someone like
- 29:36Oprah Winfrey right or somebody or or uh
- 29:40you know an NBA player an NBA player is
- 29:42like why does I don't feel repressed at
- 29:43all I vote Republican I want lower tax
- 29:45cuts and like no oh you you are
- 29:48repressed because of the color of your
- 29:50skin and that guy over there who might
- 29:52be white and might be homeless he's your
- 29:55repressor right whether you realize it
- 29:57or not which is again the absurdity and
- 30:00the incredible simplification that these
- 30:03guys engage in which is something that
- 30:05um Catholicism and Christianity doesn't
- 30:07do right I mean we are all individuals
- 30:10made in the Imago day the image of God
- 30:12you know we were not born into groups
- 30:14this hammers everyone into groups why a
- 30:16t Walker who was a close friend of
- 30:18Martin Luther King Jr said a critical
- 30:21race Theory came after King who was shot
- 30:24in April 1968 but he would have
- 30:27absolutely rejected any sort of uh not
- 30:30any sort of theory that put people into
- 30:33categories or groups and Define them
- 30:35that way because King said you were
- 30:37judged by the content of your character
- 30:38not the color of your skin so you don't
- 30:41Define people that way but that's what
- 30:44these guys did and they were willing to
- 30:46launch revolutions and abolish and clean
- 30:48out entire Societies in order to get
- 30:51there
- 30:52well
- 30:54so I mean if it weren't for Marks and
- 30:56angles other people would have been
- 30:58writing on this I suppose but uh I don't
- 31:00I don't
- 31:02well
- 31:04okay to some extent yeah I mean there's
- 31:06a category
- 31:07my friend Dan Flynn uh one of my fellow
- 31:10columnists at the American spectator if
- 31:12I can give a plug for the American
- 31:13spectator I'm the editor of American
- 31:15spectator we'll put a link in the
- 31:17description.org but Dan uh Dan Flynn did
- 31:20a book called um intellectual morons and
- 31:24his argument was that um how ideology
- 31:26can make you stupid how it can force
- 31:29people who are otherwise very
- 31:30intelligent to go for these really bad
- 31:34ideas because ideology kind of pushes
- 31:36them in there but he talks about the
- 31:39Yankee utopians in America from the
- 31:421820s to 1840s were all sorts of
- 31:44socialists who preceded Marx who were
- 31:48engaging in this there was a guy
- 31:49um Welsh British Scottish Robert Owen
- 31:53was his name
- 31:54and he founded a what people have called
- 31:57a communist colony in New Harmony
- 31:59Indiana in 1826 and this is a crazy
- 32:02thing Neil you could look it up and post
- 32:04it maybe and this is the kind of thing
- 32:06we ought to be learning in our schools
- 32:07Robert oh and a New Harmony Indiana on
- 32:11July 4th
- 32:131826.
- 32:14so it's the 50th anniversary of the
- 32:17Declaration of Independence I got to ask
- 32:19you I don't mean to embarrass you as a
- 32:20non-american do you know who died in
- 32:22America on July 4th 1826 no Thomas
- 32:25Jefferson and John Adams which is
- 32:28amazing because Jefferson wrote the
- 32:29Declaration and Adam has chosen to write
- 32:31the Declaration Adams was 90 years old
- 32:34Jefferson was 83. this was going to be
- 32:36America's Jubilee the whole country is
- 32:38watching right are they going to make it
- 32:39to July 4th they made it and the whole
- 32:42country was celebrating but as that's
- 32:43going on Robert Owen this this British
- 32:46socialist
- 32:47stands there at his ideological colony
- 32:50which is a great phrase of Pope Francis
- 32:52and in New Harmony Indiana and he
- 32:54declares what he calls his Declaration
- 32:56of mental Independence
- 32:59where he declares war and what he calls
- 33:01the three-headed Hydra
- 33:03okay of property religion and marriage
- 33:08so right there he's going after exactly
- 33:12what Marx and all the Communists are
- 33:15going to go after so would there have
- 33:17been others who would have come along
- 33:18and uh yeah probably I guess but the
- 33:22conditions were such that what mocks and
- 33:24angles did lit a Spock and it did and I
- 33:27would say this to Marxist today who say
- 33:30well you know there's something we could
- 33:31learn from this book right I mean he got
- 33:33right the factory conditions in the
- 33:351840s well okay but I got news for you
- 33:38dude look out your window right this is
- 33:412022 all right and you're not looking
- 33:44out your window at 1848 Britain France
- 33:48and Germany this was written for an era
- 33:51that does not exist and is completely
- 33:55gone which is why today Mark says that
- 33:58you see today aren't talking about
- 34:01classical Marxism they're not talking
- 34:03about abolishing private property Bernie
- 34:05Sanders doesn't talk about that right
- 34:07they're talking about they're borrowing
- 34:09other elements of it to call for maybe
- 34:12nationalization of Health Care maybe
- 34:15something to do with unions but most of
- 34:17today's marxists are applying it at a
- 34:19cultural gender and even racial area if
- 34:23you go to people's World which is the
- 34:25successor publication to the Daily
- 34:27worker they say we are looking for
- 34:29culture workers not Factory workers not
- 34:33coal miners from West Virginia not steel
- 34:36workers from Steubenville in Pittsburgh
- 34:38right they're looking for culture
- 34:40workers they're looking to fight for
- 34:43lgbtq they're looking to fight to
- 34:46redefine marriage so today's Marxist
- 34:49really very few of them have anything to
- 34:51do with what these guys were thinking
- 34:53about in the 1840s Marx couldn't have
- 34:55conceived of same-sex marriage or
- 34:58transgenderism
- 34:59but today's Marxist that's that's where
- 35:01they are yeah it would seem to me that
- 35:04as someone say on a University campus
- 35:06who gets a whiff of socialism would say
- 35:08look there's incredible inequality in
- 35:10the world there are very rich people
- 35:11there are very poor people this seems
- 35:13unfair socialism is about making it fair
- 35:16and they might even say look even when
- 35:19you read the book of Acts it isn't it
- 35:21funny how it's always the atheists Who
- 35:22quote the Bible before the Christian
- 35:24whenever they're trying to make an
- 35:25unchristian Doctrine all the Believers
- 35:28were together and had everything in
- 35:30common they sold property and
- 35:32possessions to give to anyone who had
- 35:34need right and they would say gee that
- 35:36sounds a lot like socialism how could
- 35:38this how could this be a problem let's
- 35:40just implement this on a nationwide
- 35:42level and call it a Christian Nation
- 35:44what's the problem with that three
- 35:45problems with that one is Christian with
- 35:47Marx which Marx rejected I love it three
- 35:49problems like you haven't been out yeah
- 35:51right it believes in God which Marx
- 35:54rejected he was an atheist it talks
- 35:56about selling your possessions how can
- 35:58you sell your possessions if you don't
- 36:00have private property to begin with very
- 36:01good these people are voluntarily on
- 36:04their own for the purposes of the church
- 36:05the good of Christianity very
- 36:08voluntarily giving of themselves and
- 36:10being willing to share their property
- 36:12communism is a state-run regime by Fiat
- 36:16and the power of the state by gun and
- 36:18Gulag forcibly taking money and
- 36:21possessions from everybody regardless of
- 36:23whether or not they want to do it and in
- 36:25the name of materialistic atheism of all
- 36:27things so it's got nothing to do with
- 36:29that so you get all the time these kind
- 36:31of you know soft-headed Silly religious
- 36:34life Christians will say wow The
- 36:36Communist Manifesto talks about sharing
- 36:38and so does the bible it's just like the
- 36:41Bible you know no I mean just because
- 36:43there's one or two elements of
- 36:46commonality in something doesn't mean no
- 36:48they rejected the by Mark said said
- 36:51Christianity preaches cowardice it
- 36:54preaches sacrifice it preaches
- 36:57humiliation he said of Judaism the
- 37:00Israelite faith is repulsive to me
- 37:03communism begins where atheism begins
- 37:06where was that quote from which one
- 37:08communism begins where atheism communism
- 37:10begins where atheism begins it was it's
- 37:12a quote that that's originally written
- 37:14in French in fact Fulton Sheen uses that
- 37:17in communism in the conscience of the
- 37:19West Fulton Sheen's 1948 book who said
- 37:22that uh like Christianity or religion is
- 37:25like necrophilia that was Lenin yeah and
- 37:28so what was the context of that what did
- 37:30he mean by yeah Lennon said there is
- 37:32nothing more abominable than religion
- 37:34all worship of a Divinity is a
- 37:37necrophilia he said religion is a kind
- 37:40of medieval mildew a spiritual booze it
- 37:44is the opiate of the masses
- 37:46Lennon said that but Lenin quoting marks
- 37:49Lenin said like Mark said it's the
- 37:50opiate of the masses and if you look at
- 37:52Marx's actual opiate of the masses essay
- 37:56he says in there religion is the sigh of
- 37:59the oppressed creature the heart of a
- 38:01heartless world the soul of soulless
- 38:03conditions it is the Opium of the people
- 38:06so sometimes you'll hear people on our
- 38:09side say well I can see what Marx meant
- 38:11I mean religion and opium of the people
- 38:13yeah it's kind of like a drug like a
- 38:15crutch you know you know as Christians
- 38:17we believe it's a proper one a real one
- 38:19right it's not like a placebo so I see
- 38:22what he's getting but if you read the
- 38:23whole context right no religion is the
- 38:26sigh of the oppressed creature the heart
- 38:28of a heartless world the soul of
- 38:30soulless conditions it is the opiate of
- 38:32the masses and he says in in that in
- 38:35that essay as well and this is kind of
- 38:37profound I'll give Mark's credit on this
- 38:40one Mark said the criticism of religion
- 38:43is the beginning of all criticism
- 38:46and what does that mean so if you want
- 38:49to really begin all criticism and
- 38:51criticize everything else you got to do
- 38:53it from the root and this is it yeah
- 38:54because it's exactly right you've got to
- 38:56go after God which is why they were
- 38:58hell-bent on going after religion the
- 39:01only word that Marx uses more than
- 39:03criticism is abolition and those words
- 39:06are all through that opiate of the
- 39:08masses essay so he got that right you
- 39:11know they knew that if you wanted to
- 39:13burn down the village and start all over
- 39:15you had to take out take out God because
- 39:17this this is first and foremost a
- 39:21Manifesto or an attack on human nature
- 39:23Pope Benedict the 16th John Paul II
- 39:27popes all the way back to Pope Pius IX
- 39:30said especially Benedict and jp2 they
- 39:34said where Marxism really failed isn't
- 39:37even so much philosophical isn't so much
- 39:40economic it's anthropological they fail
- 39:43to understand human nature such as if if
- 39:46if your beginning point is
- 39:48that the entire communist program may be
- 39:51summed up in a single sentence abolition
- 39:52or private property
- 39:54I mean think about that what what does
- 39:58that mean you're in a classroom where
- 40:00some German guy is writing this on the
- 40:01board uh Professor can you stop for a
- 40:04second
- 40:05abolition of private property quick
- 40:08question
- 40:09what does that mean right
- 40:13the Ten Commandments you know Thou shalt
- 40:15not steal implies the right to own
- 40:17property natural law talks about private
- 40:19property from the cave to the courthouse
- 40:21the judeo-christian tradition you have
- 40:24the right to property if you're going to
- 40:26try to abolish all private property I
- 40:29can tell you right now I mean a
- 40:31five-year-old walking in here with one
- 40:33of those little propeller hats and all
- 40:35lollipop because you know tell you
- 40:36they're going to have to kill 100
- 40:37million people if they want to abolish
- 40:39private property I mean you're going to
- 40:41have a war on your hands so bad starting
- 40:45point right there in the Republic when
- 40:49they try to figure out what Justice is
- 40:51they talk about seeing at a I think on a
- 40:54larger level I want to do something
- 40:56similar here with maybe rather than
- 40:58thinking of the state what would
- 40:59communism look like if we had a little
- 41:01commune so I suppose there's some zombie
- 41:05apocalypse and every everybody in here
- 41:06we find a little group of houses and
- 41:11we're trying to figure out how we can
- 41:12live peaceably together I'm wondering
- 41:14like what does communism look like in
- 41:16that point like do we all have to agree
- 41:18yes I think we won't all agree so
- 41:20someone's going to have to tell us that
- 41:21we're all going to agree that all of
- 41:23this is going to be owned collectively
- 41:25right but and even then a commune is not
- 41:28actually communism because your commune
- 41:31is probably something you're joining
- 41:32voluntarily right you might have
- 41:34marriage and family in there you might
- 41:36have religion in there you might have
- 41:38religious people in there you don't have
- 41:40all these various things that Marx wants
- 41:42to abolish but on the level of entire
- 41:44societies and States I'm agreeing with
- 41:46you because what I'm saying is even in
- 41:48that situation you're going to have
- 41:49somebody from the top down imposing
- 41:51those beliefs on you that they won't be
- 41:52religion that they won't be marriage
- 41:54presumably that they won't be
- 41:56yeah yeah one one of the and you can see
- 41:59how horrific that would be in that small
- 42:00setting and then you just have to apply
- 42:01that to a nation of the world one of the
- 42:04early Yankee utopians John Humphrey
- 42:06Noyes who was kicked out of New England
- 42:08by the Puritans he's like the only one
- 42:11who was religious he called himself a
- 42:13Bible communist all right which shows
- 42:15the danger of all this he ended up
- 42:17forming the Oneida colony in Oneida New
- 42:19York they make famous um silverware in
- 42:22fact one of the only reasons that that
- 42:23utopian Colony didn't go bankrupt is he
- 42:26actually had something to sell but but
- 42:28he was he was redefining marriage they
- 42:31were doing group marriages they were
- 42:33doing Collective marriages and they had
- 42:36younger girls being forced to marry
- 42:38older men which the younger girls didn't
- 42:40like but but right away they're they're
- 42:43trying to reinvent marriage so he's
- 42:46applying his communism on a sort of
- 42:48cultural level and again all of this is
- 42:52really disastrous when when you break
- 42:54out of traditional relations right he
- 42:57called it the most radical rupture in
- 42:58traditional relations once you start
- 43:00tinkering with and taking down these
- 43:03ideas that have been the bulwark of
- 43:05human beings for thousands of years it
- 43:08gets ugly it gets messy now one of the
- 43:11things he says in the manifesto is that
- 43:13yeah we want to do away with marriage it
- 43:15seems that he says that but he says but
- 43:17look at how y'all engage look at how the
- 43:19Bourgeois they engage in marriage you
- 43:21basically prostitute each other in any
- 43:23way and treat each other like Capital
- 43:25right sleep with each other's wives what
- 43:28was his point in saying that was it just
- 43:29that yes we're trying to do away with
- 43:31marriage but you've done away with
- 43:32marriage too or what yeah he he does he
- 43:35does a lot of that and in fact on um on
- 43:38on property which I I'll answer that too
- 43:41but it's kind of um it illustrates the
- 43:44point the point really well uh yeah so
- 43:48he he even says in the property issue
- 43:51he says the theory of the Communists may
- 43:52be summed up in a single sentence
- 43:54abolition of private property and you
- 43:56think to yourself he doesn't really want
- 43:57to abolish private property that's what
- 43:59he says this you are horrified and are
- 44:01intending to do away with private
- 44:03property yes and you're thinking yeah
- 44:04and you're thinking at that point yeah
- 44:06you're thinking yeah we are and you
- 44:07don't really mean that right and he says
- 44:09precisely so that is just what we intend
- 44:11and then he doubles down on it he says
- 44:13it again and then he goes into one of
- 44:15his diatribes but the property is
- 44:16already owned by both that's right and
- 44:18well some of these things first of all
- 44:21it's a vast exaggeration all right vast
- 44:24exaggeration all right
- 44:25um you know all kinds of people at
- 44:27private property and and you find too
- 44:29that a lot of the poor which I had been
- 44:31at one point in my life I didn't have
- 44:33any money at one point when I was in
- 44:34graduate school in the 1990s yeah most
- 44:36people including those the greasers in
- 44:39Pittsburgh and and Cleveland and Chicago
- 44:42so greasers was like a term for
- 44:451950s kind of working class kids you
- 44:49know the the sons of Steel Workers and
- 44:51so forth gotcha um but they all they all
- 44:55want private property and they all want
- 44:56to Aspire to make a buck you know they
- 44:59they don't want to demand you know that
- 45:01the rich guy down the street give them
- 45:03all their money I mean why would you go
- 45:05to school and better yourself and borrow
- 45:07money and you know most people actually
- 45:10want to work their way up and a lot
- 45:12these guys assume that whatever the
- 45:15proletariat and the poor are are like
- 45:18stuck there forever
- 45:19it kind of it's sort of a helpless view
- 45:22of pathetic lump and proletariat
- 45:25Humanity if we don't come in to help
- 45:27these slack jawed rabble right they're
- 45:30just going to be walking around you know
- 45:31drooling all over themselves right so
- 45:34most people in fact want freedom most
- 45:37people want private property uh the the
- 45:40idea that a group of individuals could
- 45:42come along and say literally to hell
- 45:44with that we're gonna burn it all down
- 45:46because this person has more money than
- 45:49that person or whatever about so what's
- 45:50this or you already believe that they
- 45:52already have that you already treat your
- 45:53lives like prostitutes anyway
- 45:55um okay then we should abolish marriage
- 45:57great right because of whatever is
- 45:59happening with however some of the
- 46:01bourgeoisie wives are treated by the way
- 46:04Mark's there is talking about his wife
- 46:07who behind her back is back yeah behind
- 46:11his wife's back he bedded the housemaid
- 46:15lynching
- 46:16who was who was who was lent to Marx's
- 46:19family by Marx's wife Jenny's mom uh
- 46:24Jenny grew up with this girl named
- 46:25lynchin
- 46:26maybe you could find a photo of Lynch
- 46:28and put it up there and uh how do you
- 46:30spell it
- 46:31l-e-n-c-h-e-n lynching so so Jenny grows
- 46:35up with lynching the Marx family is so
- 46:39broke
- 46:40Jenny and Marx's wife both expressed the
- 46:43wish that quote Carl would start earning
- 46:45some Capital rather than just writing
- 46:46about it
- 46:47so the family has given them as much
- 46:50money as they possibly can because Marx
- 46:52won't earn any money this book is
- 46:54written for someone like Marx who could
- 46:56have the state give him all of his money
- 46:57all right
- 46:58so he's not earning any money and the
- 47:00family can't in good conscience no one
- 47:02could give him any more money because he
- 47:04just squanders it he drinks a bottle of
- 47:06booze whatever he does with it so the
- 47:09family says okay we'll lend them
- 47:10luncheon so they lend him luncheon the
- 47:13family nurse maid she becomes the Marx
- 47:16family's nurse made and Marx
- 47:19had sex with her doesn't bathe who
- 47:22doesn't bathe right got her pregnant one
- 47:25of the Mark's biographers pain thinks
- 47:27that it wasn't consensual but I don't
- 47:28know how he could know that
- 47:30she got pregnant
- 47:32she had a child
- 47:34Marx denied that the child was his
- 47:36everyone knew that the child was Marx's
- 47:39including Marx's wife Jenny this really
- 47:41crushed Jenny Ingalls being Marx's sugar
- 47:46daddy and kind of sap who doesn't
- 47:48believe in marriage and who lives with
- 47:50women and refuses to marry any of the
- 47:53women that he lives with and these poor
- 47:55women who all want Ingalls to marry them
- 47:57to make you know to make honest women
- 47:59out of them so Ingles says
- 48:01all right I know it's Carl's kitten I
- 48:03know it's Carl's kid
- 48:05I will accept paternity for the child
- 48:08and we will name him Friedrich
- 48:10and the kid became known as Freddy
- 48:12Marx refused to ever acknowledge the
- 48:15existence of the kid refused to ever pay
- 48:18a child a penny of child support and
- 48:20Marx also refused to ever pay luncheon
- 48:23any money
- 48:24so she never got any money this champion
- 48:26of the proletariat never paid any money
- 48:29to luncheon at all
- 48:31typical of kind of Mark's family values
- 48:34Ingles and Marx wrote in the origins of
- 48:36the family that in their ideal Society
- 48:39housekeeping would become a
- 48:41government-run industry a nationalized
- 48:43affair and all children would
- 48:45immediately be put into government
- 48:47Collective schools one of the first
- 48:49things that Bolsheviks did in the Soviet
- 48:51Union was abolished all private schools
- 48:53all home schooling and all religious
- 48:55education and put everyone in the giant
- 48:58secular Collective schools point 10 in
- 49:01The Communist Manifesto calls for free
- 49:03education for all children in public
- 49:04schools
- 49:05Marx made fun of what he called the
- 49:09hallowed correlation between parent and
- 49:11child he said that's a bunch of
- 49:13Bourgeois claptrap
- 49:15um but see after he says free
- 49:17educational children Public Schools he
- 49:18says abolition of children's Factory
- 49:19labor in its present form so that could
- 49:22be seen as children are being sent to
- 49:24these factories we need to educate them
- 49:26yeah sure
- 49:27yeah I I think so and and in America
- 49:32right um any progressives watching the
- 49:35Progressive Movement in the early 1900s
- 49:37one of the things that they did best was
- 49:39eliminate um child labor and had
- 49:42regulations Woodrow Wilson who was an
- 49:45intensely anti-communist Progressive so
- 49:48the point is you can fix child child
- 49:51abuse and labor without becoming a
- 49:53communist right you know you don't have
- 49:56to abolish the family all Eternal truth
- 49:57morality all states all societies of
- 49:59private property and everything else to
- 50:01take care of that issue so again so
- 50:03remarks to get that right but yeah I
- 50:06have some some more uh Devil's Advocate
- 50:07to play yeah sure marks loved would love
- 50:10that okay so it seems that
- 50:13the these as this being presented today
- 50:15let me start in a different way okay so
- 50:17basically when I think of the Communist
- 50:19Manifesto what's interesting to me is
- 50:21not Marx as a person and and it was life
- 50:25and his philosophy because it seems to
- 50:27me it's not really even a philosophical
- 50:28book what's interesting to me is how did
- 50:30this uh Manifesto spread the way it did
- 50:34what appealed to the heart of the reader
- 50:36um why is the human heart such that this
- 50:39is such an appealing ideal and then my
- 50:42other question I guess would be it seems
- 50:44like
- 50:45in the conversation so far communism is
- 50:48being presented as this great abolition
- 50:50of private property which we've already
- 50:53talked about is kind of like you have to
- 50:55have a government you have to have some
- 50:56kind of system you can't really have no
- 50:58such thing as property maybe it's public
- 50:59property but if if that's what communism
- 51:03is then kind of what are we criticizing
- 51:05here is that what people who call
- 51:06themselves Communists want they want no
- 51:08more private property do they want no
- 51:09system of government do they want
- 51:11everyone to be pushed into some
- 51:13warehouse and taught States rules until
- 51:15they're 18 and then like like what what
- 51:18do what a communist one of the things
- 51:20that Lennon wrote and so really becomes
- 51:22Marxism leninism when it's first
- 51:24implemented but Lenin said now don't
- 51:27think that we talk about abolition of
- 51:28private property and public property and
- 51:30common ownership of means of production
- 51:31this actually means that people are
- 51:33going to own all this stuff right you
- 51:35know the the state is obviously is
- 51:37obviously going to run it I mean that's
- 51:39the way that it's going to work uh
- 51:41Lennon wrote a famous essay called what
- 51:43is to be done which is a great question
- 51:45yeah what do you do once you abolish all
- 51:48the private property and if you're not
- 51:50going to have a state or the state
- 51:52Withers away and ceases to exist who's
- 51:56going to redistribute all the stuff this
- 51:58doesn't just like magically happen right
- 52:01who's going to be in charge and Lennon
- 52:05step four said well of course what this
- 52:08means is you're going to need a Vanguard
- 52:09you're going to need a kind of educated
- 52:11Elite Class or group neither raise the
- 52:14consciousness of the proletariat and
- 52:16everybody else but in order to have the
- 52:18power to do all of this and you're all
- 52:20you're also going to need because there
- 52:21are these dialectical stages in the
- 52:23revolution you need somebody to call the
- 52:26shots at a certain point and say okay
- 52:28okay okay okay we've now left serfdom
- 52:31and we've now left feudalism and we've
- 52:33now left capitalism we're now in
- 52:36socialism we're now on our final
- 52:37transitionary step to Communism here we
- 52:41are now and now we do this you're going
- 52:43to need people to make those decisions
- 52:46and call those shots but if you read
- 52:48marks there's just this kind of magic
- 52:50withering away it's all it's it's really
- 52:54like it's really almost religious the
- 52:56way these things happen here this is one
- 52:59of my favorite quotes from Marx that I
- 53:01think says it all
- 53:03in communist Society where nobody has
- 53:07one exclusive sphere of activity
- 53:09but each one can become accomplished in
- 53:11any branch he wishes now listen to this
- 53:14very carefully all right
- 53:16Society regulates the general production
- 53:18got it okay Society regulates the
- 53:21general production okay okay and thus
- 53:24okay is all you need what happens after
- 53:26Society regulates General production
- 53:30and thus makes it possible for me to do
- 53:33one thing today and another tomorrow to
- 53:35hunt in the morning fish in the
- 53:37afternoon rear cattle in the evening
- 53:40criticize after dinner just as I have a
- 53:43mind without ever becoming hotter
- 53:45fishermen herdsmen or critic to do all
- 53:49that to be a hunter a fisherman a farmer
- 53:52rear calorie all you need is for society
- 53:54to regulate General production
- 53:57and that that's the key to Utopia so if
- 54:00we could just have this Elite group of
- 54:02managers
- 54:03right that could do this everything will
- 54:06be all right you will have the New
- 54:07Jerusalem there's a stunning statement
- 54:09from Margaret Sanger it's like parents
- 54:12taking care of children it's like we'll
- 54:14we'll take care of everything and you
- 54:16son and daughter will be free to do the
- 54:18things that you wish to do but you have
- 54:20to trust us right we're allowed to
- 54:21impose certain things upon you and
- 54:23disappear whoever the thus may be and
- 54:25then however they come into being
- 54:27however they come into power
- 54:29um Margaret Sanger made a trip to
- 54:31Bolshevik Russia in 1934 she wrote about
- 54:33it in her birth control review and it's
- 54:37called birth control in Soviet Russia
- 54:39and she was stunned at the number of
- 54:42abortions that were taking place in
- 54:44Moscow she couldn't believe it she was
- 54:45actually horrified by it wow and and
- 54:48yeah and she said
- 54:50um however of all the Communist
- 54:53officials that that I spoke to they say
- 54:56that once a fully functioning
- 54:58communistic Society Society is in place
- 55:01neither abortion nor birth control will
- 55:05be necessary
- 55:06so all you need is the fully functioning
- 55:09communist Society in place and then you
- 55:11won't even need abortion one birth
- 55:13control hypothetical
- 55:17[Music]
- 55:19angels
- 55:20write these like perfect almost ednick
- 55:24managers Guardians yeah yeah they will
- 55:28because they're using the etiology of
- 55:30communism
- 55:31will make everything good it's like
- 55:34Benedict said it's like they they would
- 55:36usher in the New Jerusalem and Pope
- 55:40Benedict said Marx what Marx really got
- 55:43wrong is he thinks that if you solve the
- 55:45economic problem all other problems will
- 55:48be solved but the mistake that he made
- 55:50is as Jesus said to Satan man does not
- 55:54live by bread alone you know Augustine
- 55:56said there's a god-shaped vacuum in each
- 55:58of us there's not a dollar-shaped vacuum
- 56:00in each of us Marx and Ingles believe if
- 56:03we could just solve the capital problem
- 56:05or wait a second the private property
- 56:07problem or no no
- 56:09family marriage all Eternal truths all
- 56:11traditional relations all Society
- 56:12whether all those problems right we
- 56:14could just solve all of that right then
- 56:17we will have the New Jerusalem I think I
- 56:19can answer you a first question which is
- 56:21why is this so appealing to people I
- 56:23think it's because it locates the evil
- 56:25of the world to some other group of
- 56:27people than me so if I if I am so
- 56:30disappointed with my life and I feel
- 56:33frustrated because I haven't been able
- 56:34to actualize what I want and then you
- 56:36come along and say it's not your fault
- 56:38it's their fault yeah all of a sudden I
- 56:41have this community of people to Rally
- 56:43with to and then to inflict pain on the
- 56:46evil that's you're the victim and
- 56:48they're the bad guys yeah I said how
- 56:50could you not see how that's appealing
- 56:52so it Fosters Envy yeah it Fosters
- 56:54resentment and he's appealing yeah
- 56:56that's right it's it's based on voice
- 56:58viciousness yeah there's there there's
- 57:00no virtue in there and the first
- 57:02question you had asked too about why
- 57:04would it appeal to people I I don't
- 57:06think it ever really has and and the the
- 57:09I mean there are not democratically
- 57:11elected communist regimes
- 57:13I mean the Bolsheviks took over in
- 57:16October 1917 only because the Czar had
- 57:19abdicated and the provisional government
- 57:21collapsed read Richard pipes the the
- 57:25Russian Revolution people were shocked
- 57:27that the Bolsheviks took over and then
- 57:30by force you know through the Soviet
- 57:32commentary they tried they tried taking
- 57:34over countries and and of all the
- 57:37countries that became Communists I mean
- 57:38none of them stood for for Democratic
- 57:41elections Cuba under Fidel Castro and
- 57:43Raul Castro they've never stood for
- 57:46elected leadership I mean Castro
- 57:49promised in January 1959 came United
- 57:51States April 17 1959 told Meet the Press
- 57:54and and Congress and all these other
- 57:56groups we are for democracy we are for
- 57:58free and fair elections they've never
- 58:00held free elections because they know
- 58:02that people wouldn't elect them and by
- 58:04the way knowing that if if they knew
- 58:07that people would elect them they would
- 58:08stand for elections and then get elected
- 58:10and then that would help them they could
- 58:11end the Embargo and all sorts of things
- 58:13but these are all totalitarian
- 58:16dictatorial regimes Pol Pot Castro the
- 58:20Kims in North Korea Mao uh all the
- 58:23countries behind the Iron Curtain so
- 58:26that should tell people something too
- 58:27name me the communist regime
- 58:31that's not a dictatorship right you
- 58:33could you could when you look at the
- 58:35ideas that are in here you say to
- 58:36yourself you're only going to be able to
- 58:38abolish private property and do these
- 58:40other things through a dictatorship
- 58:42through a period position of full it's
- 58:43Common Sense yeah yeah unless everybody
- 58:45just decides to give it up and that's
- 58:47the difference between a monastery right
- 58:48like in a monastery you willingly give
- 58:51away your property right and choose to
- 58:53submit to an elder and to share things
- 58:55in common and and it's and it's and it's
- 58:57based on religion you you all you also
- 58:59have freedom of religion
- 59:01that's right that's right how important
- 59:04was the thought of Hegel in that of Marx
- 59:07because he he was a contemporary blogs
- 59:09he lived prior to him I've heard that
- 59:11the hegelian dialect somehow influenced
- 59:13him I'm also seeing though that he's a
- 59:15contemporary of Darwin
- 59:17and Nietzsche and there seems to be a
- 59:20common strand of thought throughout
- 59:21these characters and I wonder if you
- 59:22agree and if you could explicate that
- 59:25yeah wow there's um they they love
- 59:28Darwin in fact Ingles at Marx's funeral
- 59:32in 1883
- 59:34quoted Darwin in his eulogy and he said
- 59:38that Marx has done for the social
- 59:40sciences right what what Darwin did for
- 59:43the Natural Sciences so he's applied
- 59:46this evolutionary idea using hegel's
- 59:49idea of the dialectic which is really
- 59:51just kind of a fancy way of saying that
- 59:55history over time would would go through
- 59:58these Progressive stages kind of one
- 1:00:00after another each happening on a higher
- 1:00:03plane that eventually evolves into this
- 1:00:05kind of Final Destination for Hegel it
- 1:00:08was this ideational dialectic for Marx
- 1:00:11it was this materialistic dialectic
- 1:00:13based on based on economics but uh so so
- 1:00:17Ingle said the glory of Marx is that he
- 1:00:20has he's they call the Scientific
- 1:00:22Socialism or scientific communism to try
- 1:00:25to put this veneer of science to what
- 1:00:28Marx was doing so history is not
- 1:00:30progressing through this kind of series
- 1:00:33of stages and the idea that Chris
- 1:00:34Christian idea that all eventually leads
- 1:00:37to the second coming of Christ but
- 1:00:39instead this atheistic materialist
- 1:00:42dialectic that goes on stage over stage
- 1:00:44over over time and so Marx quoted Darwin
- 1:00:49or English called Darwin and Marx's
- 1:00:50funeral Ingalls quoted Darwin and Marx's
- 1:00:53wife Jenny's funeral
- 1:00:55and gives us really depressing eulogy
- 1:00:58about here's you know here live the
- 1:01:02vivacious Jenny right so full of life
- 1:01:05and there he is kind of brooding over
- 1:01:07her coffin right and now she becomes I
- 1:01:11don't know what do you say Matt worm
- 1:01:13food right you know how wonderful how
- 1:01:16how uplifting that is but but they but
- 1:01:18they all they were they were all
- 1:01:21darwinists Trotsky who was the cohort of
- 1:01:24Vladimir London the Bolshevik Revolution
- 1:01:28said the idea of evolution and
- 1:01:30determinism took possession of me
- 1:01:32completely
- 1:01:34Darwin stood for me like a mighty
- 1:01:36doorkeeper at the entrance of the Temple
- 1:01:39of the universe
- 1:01:40I was Intoxicated by his thought
- 1:01:43and here's
- 1:01:46here's Marx himself in his 1844 essay
- 1:01:50private property and communism
- 1:01:52Natural Science will in time incorporate
- 1:01:55into itself the science of man just as
- 1:01:58the science of man will incorporate into
- 1:02:00itself Natural Science there will be one
- 1:02:03science so he saw what he was doing as
- 1:02:07scientific fully rational
- 1:02:09but in a way
- 1:02:11this is this is more religious than a
- 1:02:14lot of religions you know Ronald Reagan
- 1:02:15used to say communism that religion of
- 1:02:17theirs Raymond Aaron called it Marxism
- 1:02:21the Opium of the intellectuals but but
- 1:02:24this idea that
- 1:02:26um Arthur Kessler and darkness at noon
- 1:02:28and The God That Failed he was he was he
- 1:02:30was an ex-communist
- 1:02:31and and he said you got to understand
- 1:02:33for the for the converts to Communism
- 1:02:36it's like all the pieces of the universe
- 1:02:39suddenly fall into place and you know
- 1:02:41there is no leaving the faith right
- 1:02:44um there's this Rapture is joy that
- 1:02:46you've solved all the riddles of the
- 1:02:48Universe I don't know anybody could feel
- 1:02:50that way about communism but but but a
- 1:02:52lot of these people these atheistic
- 1:02:54adherents did and yet at the same time
- 1:02:56the irony is they've made fun of
- 1:02:58religious people and called them idiots
- 1:02:59and morons but they're just as religious
- 1:03:02as your Catholic grandmother work in her
- 1:03:04Rosary yeah right I mean these guys are
- 1:03:07really they put all their faith in this
- 1:03:09kind of Earthly Utopia
- 1:03:11I here are the Devils by Dostoevsky
- 1:03:13there's a great deal of talk of
- 1:03:15Communism there right oh yeah and he's
- 1:03:17almost uh I mean right on par they were
- 1:03:20born a few years apart between him and
- 1:03:23Marx so was the was this revolution
- 1:03:25taking place in Russia while he's
- 1:03:27writing the Devils sparked by Marx well
- 1:03:30yeah I mean there's a lot going on in
- 1:03:31Russia throughout the 1800s
- 1:03:33there's like 1880 well let's see so Marx
- 1:03:36was born in 1818. he was born in 1821
- 1:03:40yeah yeah right and what did ostevsky
- 1:03:42die 1881 okay yeah yeah so he so in
- 1:03:47Marx's 1883 right that's right and and
- 1:03:49the manifesto was published in 1848
- 1:03:51Ingles I think died 1895. so all of this
- 1:03:54is going on at the time and again the
- 1:03:56church right I mean the Catholic church
- 1:03:58is issuing statement after statement
- 1:04:01um Pope bias III pluribus in 1846 did
- 1:04:05several other encyclicals
- 1:04:07um and then Leo the 13th in 1878 yeah
- 1:04:10and on to 1905 three a whole bunch of
- 1:04:13statements as well but the highest
- 1:04:15intent listed it in his Syllabus of
- 1:04:16Errors uh yeah they you know they they
- 1:04:19referred to Communism as as pestilential
- 1:04:22pests uh they're just the strong the
- 1:04:25strongest language the 1937 Pius the
- 1:04:2811th encyclical Divinity redemptorus
- 1:04:30called communism a satanic Scourge
- 1:04:33orchestrated by the sons of Darkness
- 1:04:37and and said the communism was demonic
- 1:04:39which pope was it maybe Leah the 13th
- 1:04:41who said you cannot be a Catholic and a
- 1:04:43socialist that was um that that was Pope
- 1:04:46Pius uh
- 1:04:48popius the 11th and Quadra Jason moano
- 1:04:511931. one cannot be at the same time a
- 1:04:54socialist and a Catholic yeah the two
- 1:04:57are incompatible
- 1:04:58okay now I think what bothers people
- 1:05:01when we go after communism is they think
- 1:05:03that we're necessarily extolling
- 1:05:05capitalism in all of its forms right and
- 1:05:08celebrating all of its outcomes exactly
- 1:05:10now John Paul II in sentessimus anus
- 1:05:14yeah which which was done on the 100th
- 1:05:17anniversary of um of um Leo the 13th
- 1:05:20novarum right because that's what that
- 1:05:22means 100 years since uh henceforth and
- 1:05:25Quadra JC Moana was 40 years after Ram
- 1:05:28Navarre I want to quote so those three
- 1:05:30are all connected I want to quote
- 1:05:31paragraph 42 because the the first thing
- 1:05:34is often kind of cited by those who
- 1:05:36would Champion capitalism he says can it
- 1:05:38perhaps be said that after the failure
- 1:05:40of Communism capitalism is the
- 1:05:42Victoria's social system and that
- 1:05:44capitalism should be the goal of the
- 1:05:45countries now making efforts to rebuild
- 1:05:47their economy and Society if by
- 1:05:49capitalism is meant an economic system
- 1:05:51which recognizes the fundamental and
- 1:05:52positive role of business the market
- 1:05:54private property and the resulting
- 1:05:55responsibility for the means of
- 1:05:56production as well as free human
- 1:05:57creativity the economic sector then the
- 1:06:00answer is certainly in the affirmative
- 1:06:01even though it would perhaps be more
- 1:06:03appropriate to speak of a business
- 1:06:04economy market economy or simply free
- 1:06:07economy this one short quote because
- 1:06:09then he says this but if by capitalism
- 1:06:12is meant a system in which freedom in
- 1:06:14the economic sector is not circumscribed
- 1:06:16within a strong jurisial judicial
- 1:06:20framework which places it at the service
- 1:06:22of human freedom in its totality and
- 1:06:23sees it as a particular aspect of that
- 1:06:25freedom the core of which is ethical and
- 1:06:28religious then the reply is certainly
- 1:06:30negative
- 1:06:31so maybe help those who are listening
- 1:06:34who have questions maybe not even full
- 1:06:36out critiques there's questions about
- 1:06:38capitalism yeah but yeah yeah it's a
- 1:06:41beautiful statement and I'm so glad you
- 1:06:43brought this up because for anyone who
- 1:06:46everyone says well you're a capitalist
- 1:06:48I'm not a capitalist I mean I've heard
- 1:06:50people say that Marx invented the term
- 1:06:52capitalism I I don't know if I don't
- 1:06:54think I don't know I don't know for sure
- 1:06:56but the idea that you and I might be
- 1:07:00capitalists what do we like worship
- 1:07:02Capital uh I don't I don't care about
- 1:07:04capital I mean what is going to happen
- 1:07:06what is capital money
- 1:07:08I think it might refer to in his sense
- 1:07:12as
- 1:07:14um maybe the means of production maybe
- 1:07:16factories Farms things that are owned
- 1:07:19currency perhaps right I don't know you
- 1:07:22have to really drill down on what more
- 1:07:23actually Das Ka Patel right I mean he he
- 1:07:26talks about it but but the thing is I
- 1:07:29tell people all the time I'm not a
- 1:07:31capital list I mean I I'm just kind of a
- 1:07:33general free marketer I believe in
- 1:07:36private property and you know and and
- 1:07:40freedom to engage in Commerce right a
- 1:07:43free exchange of ideas currency the
- 1:07:45right to start a business lower
- 1:07:47regulations lower taxes uh and I and I'm
- 1:07:51not against the state doing some things
- 1:07:54to you know help the poor Social
- 1:07:57Security
- 1:07:58um you know workers comp
- 1:08:02welfare even right but limited to a
- 1:08:05certain amount of time you know maybe
- 1:08:06like two years or so I'm not against
- 1:08:08those things but so they they often set
- 1:08:11up a caricature right and call it
- 1:08:13capitalism and and you know and and kind
- 1:08:16of contrast their communism to that but
- 1:08:19I I don't know anybody
- 1:08:21really even including my Wall Street
- 1:08:24friends who call themselves capitalists
- 1:08:26right they're going to General free
- 1:08:28marketers so I think that in itself is a
- 1:08:32straw man that they've they've gotten
- 1:08:33away with they've tried to take I think
- 1:08:36what most of us would consider ourselves
- 1:08:38free marketers and accuse us of
- 1:08:40following this ISM no they're the ism
- 1:08:43people they're doing communism they're
- 1:08:45doing Marxism leninism but but given
- 1:08:47that modern day Communists wouldn't
- 1:08:50ascribe to much of what Mark said aren't
- 1:08:53we straw Manning them by focusing so
- 1:08:55much on Marx instead of dealing with
- 1:08:56what they believe today well I yeah I
- 1:08:59know I mean we could deal with their
- 1:09:00arguments and their points and their
- 1:09:02beliefs on separate issues and in fact
- 1:09:04all right to sort of bring this forward
- 1:09:06to today
- 1:09:07today Communist Party USA which was
- 1:09:10founded in Chicago September 1919 which
- 1:09:13at its peak had about 60 000 members in
- 1:09:17the 1930s there's debates on this fifty
- 1:09:19thousand to a hundred thousand but
- 1:09:21there's an FBI report from 1948 which
- 1:09:23really did a deep dive and said about 60
- 1:09:26000 Communists in the United States by
- 1:09:28the way I said thirty thousand of them
- 1:09:29lived in New York City alone one of them
- 1:09:31was Bella Dodd we could talk about later
- 1:09:34but but so they're about 60 000
- 1:09:36Communists today Communist Party USA has
- 1:09:39about 5 000 members that's it out of 300
- 1:09:43million people in this country 5 000
- 1:09:45members but where the action is is the
- 1:09:48group called The Democratic socialists
- 1:09:50of America the DSA and they have
- 1:09:53according to their most recent
- 1:09:54convention report 94 512 comrades
- 1:09:59as they call them and if you go to the
- 1:10:01website of the democratic socialists of
- 1:10:03America doing it they call themselves
- 1:10:06quote the largest socialist organization
- 1:10:08in the United States unquote they have
- 1:10:11not changed that that's been up there on
- 1:10:12the on the lead website for 10 years now
- 1:10:16by the way the DSA was founded by a
- 1:10:18Catholic Michael Harrington in the 1980s
- 1:10:21and today if you follow the DSA they're
- 1:10:24very secular if not they're they don't
- 1:10:28say that they're atheistic but they're
- 1:10:30not Catholic for sure I mean they're not
- 1:10:32religious coming out of the the DSA is
- 1:10:35Alexandria ocasio-cortez AOC
- 1:10:38Corey Bush ilhan Omar uh Rashida Talib
- 1:10:43the most far left members of Congress or
- 1:10:46DSA members who have now been running
- 1:10:49for office as Democrats but so they're
- 1:10:51crafting what they call Democratic
- 1:10:53socialism which is but the best possible
- 1:10:57spin on that before you how would she
- 1:10:59how would she they Define it at their
- 1:11:02website all right and and if you I don't
- 1:11:05know if you have it handy well I'm here
- 1:11:08let's see about us yeah about what is
- 1:11:11democratic socialism all right all right
- 1:11:13here I'll stop every few sentences and
- 1:11:15you can say what you think capitalism is
- 1:11:17a system designed by the owning class to
- 1:11:20exploit the rest of us for their own
- 1:11:22profit okay now stop right there all
- 1:11:24right so is that us are we America a
- 1:11:29capitalist system where what the owning
- 1:11:32system yeah who is the owning class well
- 1:11:34the owning class in America all these
- 1:11:37people oh yeah believe me it's AOC I
- 1:11:39mean those people they have they have
- 1:11:42money Bernie Sanders has money Bernie
- 1:11:44Sanders has you know homes I mean a lot
- 1:11:48of the owning class in America today is
- 1:11:52um you know teachers and people who have
- 1:11:54pensions and their pensions are based on
- 1:11:56what they own through what's invested in
- 1:11:58Walsh street it's so simplistic isn't it
- 1:12:00it's so it it is
- 1:12:02like the rest of us now if you're
- 1:12:05reading that you're like yeah that's me
- 1:12:06I'm the rest of us right right
- 1:12:08definitely not one of those dirty
- 1:12:10capitalists yeah I don't feel whoever
- 1:12:12those dirty guys are
- 1:12:14um would would it be Elon Musk Buffett I
- 1:12:18I I I don't feel any antagonism toward
- 1:12:21those guys at all
- 1:12:23they have a literal gazillion more
- 1:12:26dollars than me great I don't care I'm
- 1:12:28not upset about it are you well we're
- 1:12:30not upset about it but we're not you
- 1:12:32know we're not uh in any way destitute
- 1:12:34neither of the people writing this but I
- 1:12:36mean maybe maybe it might be a little
- 1:12:37more on their computers if I had no
- 1:12:39money and felt I had no uh options I
- 1:12:42might then look at people who had uh
- 1:12:44which I think shows how divisive these
- 1:12:47people are because they go to that guy
- 1:12:49and say you know this isn't your fault
- 1:12:52this is the fault of these this
- 1:12:54capitalist scum right the owning class
- 1:12:58you got a great voice when you said
- 1:13:00capital is scum I think I would like you
- 1:13:02to do a bedtime story when you read The
- 1:13:04Communist Manifesto and we put it on
- 1:13:06Halloween right right yeah these
- 1:13:08capitalists reptiles all right let's see
- 1:13:11we must replace it with Democratic
- 1:13:13socialism a system where Ordinary People
- 1:13:16yeah yeah wait that's not me I'm not
- 1:13:18ordinary no uh have a real voice in our
- 1:13:22workplaces neighborhoods and Society
- 1:13:23that's you know what does that mean
- 1:13:25what is that I suppose I want to see I'm
- 1:13:28a business guy right I don't own a
- 1:13:29business but I have more of a business
- 1:13:30mind
- 1:13:31what do you mean by that
- 1:13:38look like yeah well then go ahead who's
- 1:13:42it speaking to is it speaking to people
- 1:13:43who feel that they have no power in
- 1:13:45their local area but the one thing I
- 1:13:48want to help that is top-down government
- 1:13:51dictatorship like that's the opposite of
- 1:13:53subsidy and what's the voice what what's
- 1:13:56the voice and not just a voice a real
- 1:13:58voice a real voice so basically maybe
- 1:14:00what they're saying is
- 1:14:02these big bureaucracies and I I maybe I
- 1:14:05can relate to this like pretend you have
- 1:14:06a voice right yeah we really value your
- 1:14:08feedback no you don't yeah at all I
- 1:14:10would say the bigger the government and
- 1:14:11the more government control the more you
- 1:14:13feel like you don't have a voice yeah I
- 1:14:15think that's right I mean the more
- 1:14:17freedom you have and the more right to
- 1:14:18own private property
- 1:14:21um in a sense than the more
- 1:14:22responsibility you have over the thing
- 1:14:24that you earn right right rather than
- 1:14:26having a managerial class that
- 1:14:28redistributes it we believe there are
- 1:14:30many avenues that feed into the
- 1:14:32Democratic road to socialism our vision
- 1:14:35pushes further than historic social
- 1:14:37democracy and leaves behind
- 1:14:38authoritarian visions of socialism in
- 1:14:40the Dustbin of History okay what does
- 1:14:42that mean there well but Dustbin of
- 1:14:44history is Lennon's famous free but yeah
- 1:14:46authoritarian you're going to need
- 1:14:48authoritarian control to do socialism to
- 1:14:51you because they're saying you don't
- 1:14:52yeah that's the way it is I mean it says
- 1:14:56we're not it's going to leave behind the
- 1:14:57authoritarian visions of socialism so is
- 1:14:59that a critique of socialism there is
- 1:15:00that what that is I think I think
- 1:15:02thought up by Marx and they are they are
- 1:15:05um they're they're criticizing their how
- 1:15:07they want to frame up our vision pushes
- 1:15:10further than historic social democracy
- 1:15:12and leaves behind authoritarian visions
- 1:15:14of socialism in the Dustbin of History
- 1:15:15we want a democracy that creates space
- 1:15:18for us all to flourish not just survive
- 1:15:22and answers the fundamental question of
- 1:15:24our lives with the input of all okay I
- 1:15:27don't know if I want everybody answering
- 1:15:30the fundamental question of my life and
- 1:15:32even then a lot of that those are just
- 1:15:34sort of those are just sort of fluffy
- 1:15:36words yeah they're General platitudes
- 1:15:37that's kind of General language that
- 1:15:40love is love I want to know what does
- 1:15:43that mean what okay so you know I want
- 1:15:45to know what tax rates do you want to do
- 1:15:48that
- 1:15:49give me we have a progressive income tax
- 1:15:52in the United States and the upper rate
- 1:15:54is around 39 percent what would you like
- 1:15:58that to be to do that let's see and I
- 1:16:01bet they say oh like 80 to 90 percent
- 1:16:03and okay give it yeah give us some
- 1:16:06specifics because I don't know I'm not
- 1:16:08Bernie Sanders isn't really in the
- 1:16:09Limelight anymore but would he be the
- 1:16:11kind of poster child for this he would
- 1:16:12yeah so how did he kind of respond to
- 1:16:14those very specific questions about how
- 1:16:16much do you want to tax us to get this
- 1:16:17accomplished well in Bernie Sanders
- 1:16:20people don't get this I mean Bernie
- 1:16:21Sanders ran for president on the debt
- 1:16:23for the Democrats in 2016 and 2020 but
- 1:16:25he's always been an independent in the
- 1:16:27Senate
- 1:16:28um you know Bernie's a lifetime
- 1:16:29socialist in 1980 and 1984. 1980 when
- 1:16:33Americans are choosing between Ronald
- 1:16:35Reagan and Jimmy Carter Bernie Sanders
- 1:16:38party which he was a formal presidential
- 1:16:40elector to was a trotskyist Socialist
- 1:16:43Workers Party the swp I don't think
- 1:16:46Bernie ever actually joined the swp
- 1:16:48we've tried to figure that out but
- 1:16:50um but he spoke for them and was a
- 1:16:51formal presidential elector for he was a
- 1:16:53supporter so you know he's he's very
- 1:16:55he's very much a socialist by the way if
- 1:16:58I could give you a quote here please I
- 1:16:59don't know if this is totally off
- 1:17:01subject but but Mussolini all right
- 1:17:04let's do it and and and you Mussolini
- 1:17:07who's referred to as a right-wing
- 1:17:09fascist I just want to before you read
- 1:17:11the quote real quickly those who are
- 1:17:13watching right now thanks for being here
- 1:17:14we've almost got 300 000 subscribers
- 1:17:16right now we don't when we hit that I
- 1:17:18will finally be happy
- 1:17:21so if you could click that that would
- 1:17:23help that that subscribe button also if
- 1:17:25you are a local supporter go ask a
- 1:17:27question for Dr kangor because we're
- 1:17:28going to get to some questions soon so
- 1:17:30uh the only way to ask your questions is
- 1:17:32either to send in a super chat or to go
- 1:17:33over to locals and uh and post your
- 1:17:36question there sorry yes well yeah yeah
- 1:17:39uh Mussolini and Hitler are both often
- 1:17:41called far right but they were both
- 1:17:42socialists and and in fact in fact
- 1:17:45Hitler the party Nazi met National
- 1:17:48Socialist German Workers Party all right
- 1:17:52that doesn't sound like you know Ronald
- 1:17:55Reagan or Ludwig van nizas or Milton
- 1:17:57Friedman all right National Socialist
- 1:17:59German Workers Party and by the way did
- 1:18:02he oppose the Communists oh yeah yeah
- 1:18:05you know but you you can get you get
- 1:18:07socialists and calm you you get
- 1:18:09um the the the Bolsheviks come out of a
- 1:18:121903 meeting of the Russian Social
- 1:18:15Democratic labor party and they split
- 1:18:18into the Bolsheviks and the mensheviks
- 1:18:19so the Bolsheviks called the themselves
- 1:18:22a majority and they call the mensheviks
- 1:18:24the minority but they came out of the
- 1:18:25Russian Social Democratic labor party so
- 1:18:27you will get you get these people in a
- 1:18:29room together they'll go they'll go at
- 1:18:31each other's throats over a little tiny
- 1:18:34different different issues that they
- 1:18:35disagree with but but Mussolini who's
- 1:18:37also considered by you know people
- 1:18:39historically on the left and everything
- 1:18:41as a right winger he was a Marxist and
- 1:18:44he referred to Marx as quote the father
- 1:18:46and teacher and the Magnificent
- 1:18:48philosopher of working class violence
- 1:18:51so he was a Marxist and look at this
- 1:18:54quote that will really confuse everybody
- 1:18:57Mussolini fascism is for Liberty
- 1:19:00it is for the only kind of Liberty that
- 1:19:03is serious the liberty of the state
- 1:19:06because for the fascists all is
- 1:19:09comprised in the state and nothing
- 1:19:11spiritual or human exists much less much
- 1:19:15less has any value outside the state so
- 1:19:19so this is how they can just just you
- 1:19:22know destroy these words these fascism
- 1:19:25is for Liberty right fascism
- 1:19:28for the liberty of the state exactly
- 1:19:30freedom is something that's exactly
- 1:19:32right so they use the state and the
- 1:19:34power of the state for their Marxist or
- 1:19:37socialistic means and so
- 1:19:40um I would warn the people at the
- 1:19:42Democratic socialists of America right
- 1:19:44you may say that you're against
- 1:19:45authoritarianism and I commend you for
- 1:19:48that but but the more that you want your
- 1:19:50state to do in order for this group of
- 1:19:53oppressed right to be assuaged from from
- 1:19:56these attackers from these capitalists
- 1:19:58you're going to have to give power to
- 1:20:00the state and in order to take down a
- 1:20:03few pegs these owning class this owning
- 1:20:05class you're gonna have have to take
- 1:20:07away some of their property which
- 1:20:09probably means their Capital which
- 1:20:10probably means taxing their income which
- 1:20:14means taking redistributing by the Fiat
- 1:20:17of the state to do that and so it that's
- 1:20:21why I ask what do you mean by that I I
- 1:20:24want to see it put the paper how you're
- 1:20:27going to do that don't just give me this
- 1:20:29Gobbledy because one thing that
- 1:20:31struck me as a Layman reading the
- 1:20:32Communist Manifesto was okay so you've
- 1:20:34got the proletariat who are much more
- 1:20:37numerous than the bourgeoisie we are
- 1:20:39going to take the private property of
- 1:20:41the bourgeoisie and somehow inherit it
- 1:20:44for a time but if there's a lot more of
- 1:20:46the proletariat in the bourgeoisie
- 1:20:47you're not all fitting into their
- 1:20:49private property so who's kind of
- 1:20:51agreeing to live in the nice places
- 1:20:52while the others choose not to right and
- 1:20:55the point is the practical application
- 1:20:56isn't there and especially tearing down
- 1:20:58something yeah that's attractive let's
- 1:21:00blow this thing up yeah in fact how do
- 1:21:02you build it so you're using these
- 1:21:04definitions I would say in America today
- 1:21:06there's more bourgeoisie than
- 1:21:08proletariat especially if you're
- 1:21:09defining bourgeoisie as like the owning
- 1:21:11class that these people are doing yeah I
- 1:21:13I I mean far more people in America are
- 1:21:15owners and private property owners yeah
- 1:21:17Neil is my proletariat yeah right he's
- 1:21:19your he's your your weight slate unless
- 1:21:21he hires somebody but but Neil owns
- 1:21:24stuff damn right and as soon as you
- 1:21:27couldn't do that as soon as he becomes a
- 1:21:28homeowner is he a bad guy is he part of
- 1:21:30the owning class yeah they would be yes
- 1:21:32exactly if he was to rent anything right
- 1:21:34so so in America today the bourgeoisie
- 1:21:38so defined and these these crazy
- 1:21:40categories might be a lot bigger than
- 1:21:43the proletariat there's not that many
- 1:21:45people even that that are there that are
- 1:21:48working in the steel I I drove across
- 1:21:49the bridge coming the Allegheny coming
- 1:21:52here today right those old steel mills
- 1:21:54they're shut down now yeah you know a
- 1:21:57lot of them are working at home on their
- 1:22:00computers and their laptops and homes
- 1:22:01that they own here's the thanks to
- 1:22:03capitalism Here's the final line from
- 1:22:05the DSA um
- 1:22:07we want a democracy powered by everyday
- 1:22:10people and again that's got to be me
- 1:22:13well I'm definitely yeah that sounds
- 1:22:15great yeah the capitalist class tells us
- 1:22:18we are powerless but together we can
- 1:22:19take back control yeah
- 1:22:22well do they know uh that Lennon was a
- 1:22:25big supporter of democracy
- 1:22:28and Ingles was a big supporter of
- 1:22:31democracy in fact let me uh give you
- 1:22:34Lennon's definition
- 1:22:36Lennon said democracy means equality
- 1:22:41he said say that again democracy means
- 1:22:44equality okay the Bella Dodd who was um
- 1:22:47a member of Commerce part of USA said oh
- 1:22:50yeah democracy they always talk about
- 1:22:52that meaning Communists she said when
- 1:22:54the Communist talk of democracy when the
- 1:22:57Socialists talk of democracy they mean
- 1:22:59economic democracy see we hear that and
- 1:23:02we think oh yeah founding fathers man
- 1:23:05Jefferson a freedom of speech freedom of
- 1:23:08press Bill of Rights right but Lenin
- 1:23:11said yeah I support democracy democracy
- 1:23:13means equality democracy is of enormous
- 1:23:16importance to the working class in its
- 1:23:19struggle against the capitalists for its
- 1:23:22emancipation but democracy is only one
- 1:23:25of the stages on the road from feudalism
- 1:23:27to capitalism and from capitalism to
- 1:23:30Communism and Ingles said said this
- 1:23:33democracy would be wholly valueless to
- 1:23:36the proletariat get this
- 1:23:38if it were not immediately used as a
- 1:23:41means for putting through measures
- 1:23:43directed against private property
- 1:23:46so they wanted to use democracy in order
- 1:23:49to go against private property that's
- 1:23:52that's how they sought and he even
- 1:23:54talked about America Ingalls did in
- 1:23:57America where a democratic Constitution
- 1:23:59has already been established the
- 1:24:01Communists must make common cause with
- 1:24:03the party which will turn this
- 1:24:05constitution against the bourgeoisie
- 1:24:08and use it in the interest of the
- 1:24:10proletariat so democracy and even like
- 1:24:13our constitution our tools to be
- 1:24:15exploited so American Communists would
- 1:24:18sit there before the house committee on
- 1:24:20American activities and and they'd be
- 1:24:23asked are you now or have you ever been
- 1:24:24a member of the Communist Party what
- 1:24:25would they do they'd cite the
- 1:24:27Constitution they did invoke the Fifth
- 1:24:29Amendment the ready and
- 1:24:30self-incrimination which made
- 1:24:32anti-communist Furious because they knew
- 1:24:34these guys were literally sworn to the
- 1:24:36Soviet Union and if they ever took over
- 1:24:38the United States the first thing they
- 1:24:39were going to put through the shredder
- 1:24:40was the U.S Constitution so they used
- 1:24:43these things as a temporary means in
- 1:24:45order to do what they want to do with
- 1:24:47their larger project
- 1:24:50do us a favor and quickly Define the
- 1:24:53difference or Define communism socialism
- 1:24:55and Marxism and then if it's okay I want
- 1:24:57to go through the 10 outcomes of
- 1:25:00Communism as outlined in the manifesto
- 1:25:03and just give and have you offer a brief
- 1:25:05reply to each 10 points but yeah these
- 1:25:08distinctions between communism socialism
- 1:25:10and Marxism yeah I'm glad I brought my
- 1:25:12computer with me so I gave you this
- 1:25:14stuff verbatim I usually do it off the
- 1:25:15top of my head no it's helpful thank you
- 1:25:17so the book the definition on this comes
- 1:25:20from Lennon a book he did in 1917 called
- 1:25:23the state and Revolution and he issued
- 1:25:26in September 1917 never finished it
- 1:25:29completely it's a long tone but uh the
- 1:25:33running the the running the the the
- 1:25:36violent State got in the way of
- 1:25:37finishing the book but he gives a
- 1:25:40definition there okay and and here it is
- 1:25:43all right this is right from the horse's
- 1:25:44mouth this is Lenin and this brings us
- 1:25:47to the question of the scientific
- 1:25:49distinction between between socialism
- 1:25:51and communism all right all right
- 1:25:53everybody's like okay good here it is
- 1:25:54here it is from Lenin what is usually
- 1:25:57called socialism was termed by Marx the
- 1:26:00first or lower phase of communist
- 1:26:02Society
- 1:26:03and so far of the means of production
- 1:26:05becomes common property the word
- 1:26:08communism is also applicable here
- 1:26:10providing that we do not forget that
- 1:26:12this is not complete communism so Marx
- 1:26:14and Lenin are both saying that socialism
- 1:26:16is the first or lower phase of communist
- 1:26:19Society
- 1:26:20so the dialectic of History you'd go
- 1:26:23from slavery to feudalism to capitalism
- 1:26:26to socialism to Communism so socialism
- 1:26:29is the final transitionary step to
- 1:26:31Communism Marion Smith of the victims of
- 1:26:33Communism Memorial Foundation used to
- 1:26:35say as the Christian aspires to heaven
- 1:26:38the Socialist aspires to Communism which
- 1:26:41is a good definition because it's like a
- 1:26:44religion to them now here's where it
- 1:26:45gets a little messy today's socialists
- 1:26:49really they'll say well
- 1:26:52I don't want communism I'm a Democratic
- 1:26:56Socialist and then they'll kind of
- 1:26:58redefine it but in in terms of Marx's
- 1:27:01leninist Theory socialism leads to
- 1:27:03Communism we're now in a if if you type
- 1:27:06in Google communism
- 1:27:09Merriam-Webster will say common
- 1:27:10ownership of the means of production the
- 1:27:12Lisa said that forever
- 1:27:14until about a year or two now they've
- 1:27:16got all they're playing with it man I
- 1:27:18mean the different definitions but we're
- 1:27:20now in a society where people are
- 1:27:22redefining marriage they're redefining
- 1:27:25their gender
- 1:27:26I mean there's oval you know Google is
- 1:27:29over 70 different definitions of gender
- 1:27:32so leave it to these folks today to come
- 1:27:35up with their own new definitions of
- 1:27:36socialism it's just kind of a train
- 1:27:39wreck in trying to Define anything today
- 1:27:41but according to Marx's Elena's Theory
- 1:27:43socialism is the final trans
- 1:27:44transitionary step to Communism
- 1:27:48all right let's go through these 10 uh
- 1:27:50outcomes of Communism as laid down in
- 1:27:52the manifesto and if it's if you're able
- 1:27:55let's try try to give up it's the
- 1:27:5610-point plan the 10 the 10 goals the 10
- 1:27:58goals so let's if you can try to give a
- 1:28:00brief response to each otherwise this
- 1:28:02would take far too long but the first
- 1:28:04goal of Communism is outlined is the
- 1:28:06abolition of property in land an
- 1:28:09application of all rents of land to
- 1:28:11public purpose yeah yeah well there you
- 1:28:14go but it but but it starts off the
- 1:28:16first of the 10 points right abolition
- 1:28:19of property in land yeah application of
- 1:28:22all rents of land the public it kind of
- 1:28:24speaks for itself wow yeah like double
- 1:28:27down tripling down quite discipling down
- 1:28:28an abolition of property what might that
- 1:28:30look like if that happened right now I
- 1:28:32don't know my house anymore you don't
- 1:28:34own your house anymore yeah so
- 1:28:36presumably no one can take your house
- 1:28:39from you except the state yeah so the
- 1:28:42state really it's not like yeah we all
- 1:28:43learn everything that's right imagine
- 1:28:45doing that and it's not that no one owns
- 1:28:47anything is that the state owns
- 1:28:49everything right this is what Lennon
- 1:28:50said it doesn't actually mean that the
- 1:28:51people commonly own the stuff I mean
- 1:28:54it's like you've got to be stupid to
- 1:28:57think that but if you tried to do that
- 1:28:59today that is it's impossible which
- 1:29:03which is why my point is you know I'm
- 1:29:05sorry I I know this sounds insulting and
- 1:29:07demeaning but
- 1:29:08you I don't know how anybody today could
- 1:29:11be a communist I I you've got to look at
- 1:29:14this and say this is not possible to be
- 1:29:16period to be fair I think a lot of
- 1:29:18Communists today would say that of that
- 1:29:20first point wouldn't you say like ioc's
- 1:29:22nuts but I read them and I watch them
- 1:29:26online and they will argue for this and
- 1:29:28that and kind of it's just a non-starter
- 1:29:31yeah you don't scratch that you can
- 1:29:33maybe try this in 1848 but in America
- 1:29:36today forget it which which again is why
- 1:29:38a lot of modern Communists are doing
- 1:29:40gender Marxism new victim class uh
- 1:29:43critical race Theory I I mean today this
- 1:29:46is just pure sophistry all right let's
- 1:29:47get rid of that one yeah give the
- 1:29:49benefit of the doubt yeah this is one of
- 1:29:51my all-time favorites but like two I can
- 1:29:53see why uh socialists today would push
- 1:29:56for this a heavy Progressive and
- 1:29:58graduated income tax all right so just
- 1:30:00look yeah uh it would be nice if people
- 1:30:02were all living in a way where they all
- 1:30:05had opportunity they all had houses and
- 1:30:07cars and
- 1:30:09um the you know it's it seems unfair
- 1:30:11that certain people should have yachts
- 1:30:13and private jets and other people have
- 1:30:15have to eke out a living working at
- 1:30:17Kroger and renting that's unfair so if
- 1:30:19we had something like this then we could
- 1:30:22distribute the world what would we do
- 1:30:23now that's what's fascinating about this
- 1:30:25I remember the first time that I learned
- 1:30:27that I was reading an old Reagan speech
- 1:30:29and he said you know our our Progressive
- 1:30:32graduate income tax right out of the
- 1:30:33Communist Manifesto and I said I I just
- 1:30:36hyperbole by Reagan right because I
- 1:30:38never actually read The Communist
- 1:30:40Manifesto even though I majored in
- 1:30:41political science and went to graduate
- 1:30:43school and all this other stuff what is
- 1:30:45it like people who go to law school and
- 1:30:46don't read the Constitution which
- 1:30:48happens all the time it's totally true I
- 1:30:50believe you it's so maybe it's
- 1:30:51self-explanatory but for those at home
- 1:30:53Progressive or graduated income tax what
- 1:30:55does that mean we got in America a um
- 1:30:58and progressives today speak like this
- 1:31:00is etched on the Liberty Bell in 1776.
- 1:31:03we got our Progressive graduated income
- 1:31:05tax in America in 1913. it required
- 1:31:08amending the constant institution with
- 1:31:09the 16th Amendment to make it possible
- 1:31:11so we now have a permanent federal tax
- 1:31:14on income and it's graduated or
- 1:31:16Progressive which means if you make like
- 1:31:19let's say zero to twenty thousand
- 1:31:20dollars a year you'd pay zero percent
- 1:31:22income tax 20 to 40 10 40 to 60 15 gets
- 1:31:27higher and higher and higher I think the
- 1:31:29top rate is 36 percent or 39.6
- 1:31:33when when Ronald Reagan was an actor in
- 1:31:35California the top rate was 94 percent
- 1:31:3994 wow I know look it up people won't
- 1:31:42believe it the FDR actually wanted
- 1:31:46during World War II and this is in Bert
- 1:31:48fulsome's book Burton and East Burton
- 1:31:50and Anita folsom's book FDR goes to war
- 1:31:52FDR actually wanted a 99 federal income
- 1:31:56tax on income over a hundred thousand
- 1:31:59dollars wow and people can look it up
- 1:32:01this is on video people are going to
- 1:32:03check it he wanted 99 on income over a
- 1:32:06hundred thousand dollars so once you get
- 1:32:08over that next over a hundred thousand
- 1:32:10dollars yeah 99
- 1:32:12000 goes to the federal government just
- 1:32:15for the income tax that's a side from
- 1:32:18any state income tax sales tax property
- 1:32:21taxes
- 1:32:23um inheritance tax all that stuff mocks
- 1:32:25knew this about America he would have
- 1:32:28been happy with this yeah he probably
- 1:32:29would have and uh by the way that top
- 1:32:32rate was moved down to 70 percent by JFK
- 1:32:35and then Reagan took it eventually down
- 1:32:38to 28 percent when Reagan was finished
- 1:32:41in 1989 when when Reagan came in there
- 1:32:44were 16 tax brackets so you'd be taxed
- 1:32:47at that level that level that level all
- 1:32:49the way 16 of them when Reagan left
- 1:32:51there were two rates 28 and 15. and some
- 1:32:55people in America have pushed for just a
- 1:32:56flat tax of like 20 15 but since Reagan
- 1:33:01left it's now gone up again and I think
- 1:33:03it's like 36 or 30. just to clarify too
- 1:33:05yeah it's because I have them all pulled
- 1:33:07up now basically looking at this it
- 1:33:09seems like what has happened is not that
- 1:33:12there is one top wealth bracket that's
- 1:33:14like this is you know arguably a
- 1:33:17it's basically the top wealth bracket
- 1:33:20has basically been cut off so not
- 1:33:21necessarily that these people that used
- 1:33:23to be paying
- 1:33:25um 70 have now only have to pay 39 it's
- 1:33:28that that bracket has been cut off so
- 1:33:30they're now clumped in with the group
- 1:33:32behind them and you can argue about that
- 1:33:33a little bit with inflation and stuff
- 1:33:34but like
- 1:33:36yeah the top bracket that's the 70 is
- 1:33:39for two hundred thousand dollars and
- 1:33:40that's in 1974 200 000 and today's money
- 1:33:44is like over a million dollars yeah
- 1:33:46there's no bracket like that today the
- 1:33:48highest bracket today is right
- 1:33:50head of household
- 1:33:52and for people who say
- 1:33:54um six hundred thousand dollars for
- 1:33:55people who say well the poor pay more in
- 1:33:58taxes than the rich no just look at that
- 1:34:00chart if if you're if you're under like
- 1:34:0325
- 1:34:04000 you're in the bottom tax bracket you
- 1:34:07might pay like you know 10 right it's
- 1:34:11compared to the wealthier people pay
- 1:34:12like 36 39 so you do pay higher at a
- 1:34:16higher level what would you like to see
- 1:34:18happen if you could uh I I like to see a
- 1:34:20flat tax and and and then again you the
- 1:34:24the people who think emotionally about
- 1:34:26the stuff well that wouldn't be fair
- 1:34:28then the poor would pay the same
- 1:34:29percentage as the rich
- 1:34:31yeah they pay the same percentage it's
- 1:34:3420 but if you make 2 million a year okay
- 1:34:37you pay a lot more than if you make 2
- 1:34:41000 a year yeah no no do math I'm gonna
- 1:34:44push back a little bit here's the
- 1:34:46calculator this is Neil's last show
- 1:34:48before he goes to so this is where he
- 1:34:50comes out as a full-on coming right well
- 1:34:53I will say this is a little bit less I
- 1:34:55am I do kind of to me it seems strange
- 1:34:57that there is no higher tax bracket
- 1:34:58above 600 000 it just stops that is
- 1:35:01strange okay but I will I will say this
- 1:35:02this is I've written down a few things
- 1:35:04that are like the actual concrete things
- 1:35:05that I think of people thinking when
- 1:35:07they say they're Communists or
- 1:35:08socialists or whatever Yep this is one
- 1:35:09of them as they say well there does seem
- 1:35:12to be a way which
- 1:35:14people can exploit workers right you can
- 1:35:17have a system where you exploit workers
- 1:35:18you can put in a Walmart and put all the
- 1:35:21small businesses out of business and
- 1:35:23then raise the prices and you're in
- 1:35:25control there's money going to
- 1:35:27corporations rather than local people
- 1:35:28this is about like distributism that
- 1:35:30kind of thing are you sure so it seems
- 1:35:32to me that uh the argument isn't that
- 1:35:35rich people should pay more money
- 1:35:37because they're rich and we want them to
- 1:35:39pay more money the idea is that the way
- 1:35:41to get that rich seems to be about
- 1:35:43using the work of people and
- 1:35:47this is kind of a counter balance of
- 1:35:49that yeah yeah well and you can um I
- 1:35:52think these are all legitimate
- 1:35:53conversations and debates right in a
- 1:35:56functioning free market Society about
- 1:35:59about what would be the best tax
- 1:36:01brackets and so forth I I think um I I
- 1:36:05detest the property tax because you
- 1:36:08could have you know some little lady who
- 1:36:12lives in
- 1:36:13um you know we're in this area going
- 1:36:15closer to Pittsburgh like Fox Chapel
- 1:36:17Upper St Claire who's now 80 years old
- 1:36:19doesn't work and who lives on Social
- 1:36:21Security and maybe whatever money she
- 1:36:22inherited and her husband's dead and she
- 1:36:24might have to pay thirty thousand
- 1:36:27dollars a year in property taxes twenty
- 1:36:29five hundred dollars a month just in
- 1:36:31property taxes and I what I don't like
- 1:36:34about two is it assumes that the county
- 1:36:36or the state owns the property
- 1:36:40who's she paying it to they don't own
- 1:36:42that property she bought it her husband
- 1:36:44bought it so I would say I I hate they
- 1:36:49come up with another form of Taxi do a
- 1:36:51higher sales tax if you want to but I
- 1:36:54don't I don't like that one the other
- 1:36:55one I had to test and it's 0.3 right
- 1:36:59um is the inheritance tax before we get
- 1:37:01to that it sounds like you're saying
- 1:37:02that you can have legitimate questions
- 1:37:04about the way things are yeah the one
- 1:37:06solution that won't work is communism so
- 1:37:08come up with something else right and
- 1:37:10that could be a spectrum of different
- 1:37:12opinions and options yeah but it's not
- 1:37:14the state and one of the worst ideas in
- 1:37:16history is abolition of private property
- 1:37:18that's Madness you're gonna have you're
- 1:37:20gonna have 100 million dead on your
- 1:37:22hands if you do that and have right
- 1:37:24that's exactly right I would just say it
- 1:37:26seems like what I see a lot is things
- 1:37:28like bigger tax brackets and stuff like
- 1:37:30that people do call that kind of thing
- 1:37:33communism and they say that's communism
- 1:37:35communism is bad because it's about the
- 1:37:37abolition of property but it seems like
- 1:37:39there does need to be a distinction yeah
- 1:37:40the Marxist communism that's in the
- 1:37:42manifesto I think is
- 1:37:45criticizing that is different from
- 1:37:47criticizing today's ideas yeah 100. and
- 1:37:51by the way they have complete
- 1:37:52redistribution of wealth and common
- 1:37:54ownership of the means of production and
- 1:37:56abolition of private property
- 1:37:58what kind of tax rates are you going to
- 1:38:01need to have complete leveling of all
- 1:38:04this stuff I mean you think that's true
- 1:38:06are we attacking a straw man here by
- 1:38:08even looking to mocks as if he is the um
- 1:38:12Expositor of the Communist Doctrine I
- 1:38:14mean there's been a lot of development
- 1:38:15in darwinian theory if we were to sit
- 1:38:18here today and try to critique it and
- 1:38:20just critique what Darwin wrote that
- 1:38:22seems like that would be yeah yeah we're
- 1:38:24falling into that here well and there's
- 1:38:25Marxism leninism there's maoism there's
- 1:38:28there's these different variations or
- 1:38:30strains you have to pick something but
- 1:38:31but here we are in 2022 and in July 2019
- 1:38:35America magazine which is the American
- 1:38:38Catholic Jesuit magazine published an
- 1:38:40article called the Catholic case for
- 1:38:42Communists what did you think of it I
- 1:38:44just I was floored I was on baby
- 1:38:45education in New Jersey and I got an
- 1:38:48email from Tom the producer of Drew
- 1:38:50Mariani show on relevant radio and said
- 1:38:52I know you're on vacation but you could
- 1:38:54you come on and talk about the same
- 1:38:56thing I couldn't believe it yeah and and
- 1:38:58that would have been
- 1:39:00that would have under the 1949 people
- 1:39:03decree against communism under Pious the
- 1:39:0512th they would have been literally
- 1:39:06excommunicated for that
- 1:39:09and then I think they did a follow-up
- 1:39:10piece why we wrote an article defending
- 1:39:12yeah yeah in fact there was an editor I
- 1:39:14know from the editor father Malone I
- 1:39:16think on why we published a piece called
- 1:39:18the Catholic case and people I know you
- 1:39:20got blowback right you got to do that
- 1:39:21yeah and and the picture that goes with
- 1:39:23it is um Evo Morales the tin horn
- 1:39:28crackpot of Bolivia handing a communist
- 1:39:32crucifix
- 1:39:33to Pope Francis and Francis is smiling
- 1:39:37it's a communist crucifix and by the way
- 1:39:41Francis said in December 2013 the
- 1:39:45Marxist ideology is wrong so he has
- 1:39:47rejected it but but he he I collect this
- 1:39:51stuff he hasn't said a word more and
- 1:39:53he's he's not a Marxist but he's
- 1:39:55definitely not strong on it he's not
- 1:39:58strongly at least yeah fair enough fair
- 1:40:01enough would okay I don't want to put
- 1:40:03you on the spot yeah
- 1:40:05who claims himself or thinks of
- 1:40:08themselves as a Catholic communist
- 1:40:09watching right now and they're like bye
- 1:40:11darn it I'm gonna come on and I'll
- 1:40:13debate this guy yeah the other churches
- 1:40:15said you can't be a Catholic but what
- 1:40:16would you be would you be open to a
- 1:40:18debate if someone you know I I I'm not
- 1:40:21afraid to debate anybody but that would
- 1:40:23be like saying to me
- 1:40:25um if if you if you have a like an
- 1:40:28American Nazi on you want to debate with
- 1:40:30him no I'm not doing it so I I I just I
- 1:40:33any it's just it is so beyond the pale
- 1:40:38of reason that it's just sophistry and
- 1:40:41it's just but what if the what if
- 1:40:43they're a Democratic Socialist oh sure
- 1:40:45okay would you debate so I could
- 1:40:46probably do that yeah yeah I mean again
- 1:40:48you'd have to you have to consider who
- 1:40:49this person is
- 1:40:51debating so yeah but someone who's a um
- 1:40:54a Catholic communist it's just
- 1:41:01I'd have a hard time being charitable I
- 1:41:04wouldn't want to sound insulting either
- 1:41:05you can sound insulting yeah well the
- 1:41:07nice thing about debates is you get
- 1:41:09equal time to be insulting the other
- 1:41:11thing about debates is people people
- 1:41:12really do want more light than heat
- 1:41:14people like heat in the moment yeah but
- 1:41:16they're really trying to understand
- 1:41:16these issues right so now I I ask them
- 1:41:19it's hard to debate somebody who just
- 1:41:20like
- 1:41:21everything you believe is wrong I'd be
- 1:41:24like I like like I I could I'm a
- 1:41:27registered Republican and I could easily
- 1:41:28debate a Democrat and we'd find all
- 1:41:31kinds of things to agree on okay but a
- 1:41:33Catholic communist it's an oxymoron and
- 1:41:36the church has said you can't even be a
- 1:41:39Catholic socialist I mean the you know
- 1:41:41the church calls your communism a
- 1:41:43satanic Scourge demonic from the pit of
- 1:41:47Hell I I just I don't know do you
- 1:41:50actually think to say to be a Catholic
- 1:41:52communist is like saying a Catholic Nazi
- 1:41:54or would you not go that far
- 1:41:57um oh I don't have to think I think I
- 1:41:59should have to think all that through
- 1:42:00yeah fair enough and I know that those
- 1:42:02who would hold socialism today don't do
- 1:42:04everything marks yeah no let me say so
- 1:42:06someone doesn't clip that I get in
- 1:42:07trouble yeah you can't be a Catholic and
- 1:42:09a Nazi either right no of course but are
- 1:42:11you saying that the two are on par like
- 1:42:12they're as contradictory no I I mean no
- 1:42:15they're not important Nazis and
- 1:42:17Communists are very different it's one
- 1:42:18of the reasons they went after each
- 1:42:19other
- 1:42:20um Ronald Reagan used to say between the
- 1:42:22fascists and Communists there's not like
- 1:42:23a dime's worth of difference between
- 1:42:24them because they're both about the
- 1:42:26power of the state but actually are they
- 1:42:27both as oxymoronic whether they're they
- 1:42:31are very different so um you know a Nazi
- 1:42:33Nazism Fascism and uh they're they're
- 1:42:36definitely all different but they do all
- 1:42:38involve the power of the state yeah you
- 1:42:41know and and the intrusive power of the
- 1:42:43state and authoritarian control of the
- 1:42:45state I was sure they're both really bad
- 1:42:47speaking of Nazism I was shocked to see
- 1:42:49what Marx had to say about Jews correct
- 1:42:51me if I've got this yeah but something
- 1:42:52to the effect of once the Jews are
- 1:42:55emancipated from the world the world
- 1:42:57will finally be emancipated from the
- 1:42:58Jews or something to that it's horrible
- 1:43:00it's horrible and the stuff he said
- 1:43:02about blacks yeah I mean they not right
- 1:43:05yeah marks and Ingles you if you're
- 1:43:07reading through letters between them in
- 1:43:09German you come across the word n-i-g-g
- 1:43:13yep they they don't they don't use the
- 1:43:15German word for black or negro yeah they
- 1:43:18use the American English racial epithet
- 1:43:21yeah Marx uses the n-word throughout his
- 1:43:24writings he he referred to
- 1:43:27um uh one person Ferdinand LaSalle as
- 1:43:30the Jewish N word and he referred to his
- 1:43:33own son-in-law Paul the farg who was
- 1:43:36partly Cuban so picture this Marx and
- 1:43:38Ingles these two evolutionary atheists
- 1:43:40sitting around chortling as they try to
- 1:43:43figure out how much quote-unquote n-word
- 1:43:46blood Paul has Paul's married to it's
- 1:43:49his son-in-law and they're and they're
- 1:43:51like I think um they're talking about
- 1:43:53his cranial formation talking about out
- 1:43:56hybrid descended from the Negro race and
- 1:43:59from Egypt one-eighth inward blood 1
- 1:44:0212th inward blood Ingalls wrote a letter
- 1:44:04to um to to Paul's wife
- 1:44:07saying that um oh I see he's running for
- 1:44:10office in this District in Paris that
- 1:44:12contains a zoo well that he'd be a
- 1:44:14perfect place for that given that give
- 1:44:17as a zookeeper he given that he is uh as
- 1:44:20an n-word one step closer to the Animal
- 1:44:23Kingdom and apes than the rest of us
- 1:44:24they were evolutionary atheists Marx and
- 1:44:27Ingalls believed that black people were
- 1:44:29lower on The evolutionary scale than
- 1:44:31white people and Marx called Paul who
- 1:44:34was partly Cuban uh negrilo or the
- 1:44:38gorilla the gorilla that's what he
- 1:44:40called his own son-in-law Paul committed
- 1:44:43suicide in a suicide pact with Marx's
- 1:44:45daughter Marx had two daughters who
- 1:44:48committed suicide and suicide pacts with
- 1:44:50her husbands that's a messed up father
- 1:44:53well he might be a messed up father for
- 1:44:56the things that he said but obviously
- 1:44:58there are good Fathers his children
- 1:44:59commit suicide as well yeah oh yeah yeah
- 1:45:01but you think that it was his influence
- 1:45:03absolutely Yeah Yeah well yeah he was he
- 1:45:06was um well there's there are to be fair
- 1:45:09there are some marks of Scholars that
- 1:45:10think that Marx was actually a doting
- 1:45:11father so but um two of his daughters
- 1:45:15committed suicide and suicide pact I
- 1:45:18mean I can see somebody kind of leveling
- 1:45:20the charge of ad hominem at you like who
- 1:45:22cares yeah sure he was a horrible person
- 1:45:23congratulations but
- 1:45:25um I think it what you're saying is
- 1:45:27actually important if we're going to be
- 1:45:29erecting statues of the man and then
- 1:45:30refusing to tear them down right if
- 1:45:32they're gonna if they're gonna cancel
- 1:45:34um you know George Washington or whoever
- 1:45:36for they said I mean you could cancel
- 1:45:37marks man just for the use of the of the
- 1:45:40n-word alone and by the way I need to
- 1:45:42say this is a key point but the private
- 1:45:44life of Marx is very much his writings
- 1:45:48and what he believed publicly and about
- 1:45:49the state are totally an extension of
- 1:45:52his private life in so many ways so so
- 1:45:55in his case the private life does offer
- 1:45:58lessons for the kind of society that he
- 1:46:00wanted so it's relevant in his case
- 1:46:02there is no duplicity in him it's just
- 1:46:04that what's in him is is what there
- 1:46:07you go all right
- 1:46:09um all right let's keep going abolition
- 1:46:12of All rights of inheritance yeah right
- 1:46:14so communism takes over and then uh no
- 1:46:16one's inheriting anything that's
- 1:46:18unbelievable and for people that um any
- 1:46:21Millennial who considers himself or
- 1:46:23herself a Marxist or likes communism
- 1:46:28abolition of all right of inheritance
- 1:46:30you want what by the way what does that
- 1:46:32mean that means the money you would get
- 1:46:35from your parents one would assume that
- 1:46:38this is what that means would be taken
- 1:46:40by the state yeah confiscated
- 1:46:43confiscated by said because you because
- 1:46:45we've abolished your right of
- 1:46:46inheritance so all that money that your
- 1:46:49parents saved all right that you you
- 1:46:51you're a trust fund whoever whatever you
- 1:46:53do now you have to be a rich kid just
- 1:46:55just whatever Americans
- 1:46:57most people's parents own homes yeah
- 1:47:00when the people when the parents died
- 1:47:02you're gonna inherit some of their money
- 1:47:03why should the state get all of that
- 1:47:06money they talk about greed that's great
- 1:47:09that's government greed they come in
- 1:47:11they're already taking your your
- 1:47:12property and graduated progressive
- 1:47:15income income tax now whatever you have
- 1:47:17left the inheritance you want to leave
- 1:47:18to your kid they're going to take all of
- 1:47:20that and imagine and imagine a system in
- 1:47:24which you had no right of inheritance
- 1:47:26where all of that money went to Uncle
- 1:47:28Sam or the federal state uh what's this
- 1:47:32thing going to do with all that money
- 1:47:33build pyramids
- 1:47:36why do they even need that much money to
- 1:47:38build giant concrete brutalist
- 1:47:40architecture
- 1:47:42gonna do with all of it and of course
- 1:47:44the grandest hypocrisy of all
- 1:47:47is that Marx and Ingalls the guys
- 1:47:49writing this book
- 1:47:51got all of their money from inheritance
- 1:47:55and these guys want to abolish it no
- 1:47:57they want to abolish it for you not for
- 1:48:01them I I heard Ben Shapiro once say for
- 1:48:03those who want the state to be more
- 1:48:05involved in your lives have you been to
- 1:48:07the DMV do you enjoy going to the post
- 1:48:10office yeah well another lesson here too
- 1:48:14is that all of these Marxist dictators
- 1:48:16in an uptaking power they're the
- 1:48:19greediest people in the world they never
- 1:48:20give up power look at the Kims in North
- 1:48:22Korea they live like kings well the
- 1:48:25entire rest of the country is broke look
- 1:48:27at Fidel Castro when he died Castro was
- 1:48:30worth two billion dollars he was one of
- 1:48:31the top 10 wealthiest
- 1:48:33rulers in the world according to Forbes
- 1:48:35Magazine every single year you want
- 1:48:37equal equal distribution of wealth go to
- 1:48:40a place like Cuba and North Korea ninety
- 1:48:42percent of the people are equally poor
- 1:48:44and then there's a 10 percent of party
- 1:48:47apparat checks who own all the property
- 1:48:49have all the money and at the very top
- 1:48:51of the pyramid there there's Fidel and
- 1:48:53Raul
- 1:48:54right and it's like that was Stalin it's
- 1:48:56like that with Mal it's like it's like
- 1:48:58that with all of these communist
- 1:49:00dictators so the big dirty secret here
- 1:49:02is really this is communism for you not
- 1:49:06for them it's through the ruled not the
- 1:49:08rulers Compass number four confiscation
- 1:49:11of the proper before we move on from
- 1:49:12that there's a big
- 1:49:14um what would I say like meme kind of
- 1:49:16going around right now based around an
- 1:49:18article that was like
- 1:49:19uh focusing on the idea of nepotism
- 1:49:21babies so it's like people who are
- 1:49:23parent or kids of of rich or famous
- 1:49:27parents and how they essentially putting
- 1:49:32forward a bunch of celebrities and
- 1:49:33saying well these people actually had
- 1:49:35rich or and or famous parents and I
- 1:49:38guess the idea is that you would lose
- 1:49:39some respect for them or that some of
- 1:49:41them would be talented and the other
- 1:49:43ones kind of just are positioned in that
- 1:49:45place
- 1:49:46um unjustly because they have had this
- 1:49:48Advantage how do you think that connects
- 1:49:51to this conversation well I would I
- 1:49:53would add there that their parents made
- 1:49:56that money and they've earned it legally
- 1:49:58and and their children have a right to
- 1:50:01be useless right right yeah and people
- 1:50:05can be useless with or without money
- 1:50:06yeah and it's and it's it's unfortunate
- 1:50:08the parents shouldn't do that but
- 1:50:11um should the state then come in and
- 1:50:13play the role of it
- 1:50:14what's your Solution that's the thing he
- 1:50:17keeps coming back so so we would need
- 1:50:19some sort of a morality Bureau to come
- 1:50:23in in Washington and decide which of
- 1:50:26these cases are just and which are
- 1:50:28unjust and then how much of that money
- 1:50:30presumably Google would need to be taken
- 1:50:33they deserve to be from these kids the
- 1:50:35son of a rich parent and then given to
- 1:50:37who right
- 1:50:39so so what what's the solution to that
- 1:50:41that's the question you're going to keep
- 1:50:42coming back to it's like it's very easy
- 1:50:44to point out awful things in the world
- 1:50:46right but if your solution is abolished
- 1:50:48private property and have the government
- 1:50:50take care of everything yeah I mean
- 1:50:51they're brats and that sucks but what do
- 1:50:53you do yeah and again people with no
- 1:50:56money can be awful too yeah and by the
- 1:50:58way I don't envy him I don't wake up in
- 1:51:00the middle of the night I can't believe
- 1:51:01they're just I can't go back to sleep
- 1:51:05right where's my Manifesto
- 1:51:08um
- 1:51:09[Music]
- 1:51:11oh I see centralization of credit in the
- 1:51:15hands oh hang on confiscation of
- 1:51:16property of O M okay let's try to do the
- 1:51:19next really quick because this is going
- 1:51:21to take us eight more hours if we don't
- 1:51:23number five okay centralization of
- 1:51:26credit in the hands of the state by
- 1:51:27means of National Bank with state
- 1:51:29capital and the exclusive Monopoly and
- 1:51:31an exclusive novel right what does that
- 1:51:33mean a national bank with state capital
- 1:51:34and exclusive that's what that means on
- 1:51:37all credit do you know and do and do do
- 1:51:40the young people that are out there that
- 1:51:42are looking for loans for their car or
- 1:51:44their house or whatever want a banking
- 1:51:47system like that of course you don't
- 1:51:50try getting a license plate renewed yeah
- 1:51:52you have to do that first why do you
- 1:51:54want that no one wants that all right so
- 1:51:56this it's a really a pretty good book if
- 1:51:58you just read it no it's not read it you
- 1:52:00not know what you're talking about
- 1:52:01number six centralization of the means
- 1:52:03of communication and transport in the
- 1:52:05hands of the state that's a great one
- 1:52:06Greyhound buses is terrific right so
- 1:52:09that's not run by the state so
- 1:52:10centralization of communication
- 1:52:13and transport yeah what is that actually
- 1:52:15has it Communication in those days would
- 1:52:18have been newspapers newspapers and then
- 1:52:20phone companies phone companies
- 1:52:22newspapers Google Twitter put email uh
- 1:52:27radio TV everything if you can maybe try
- 1:52:31to do this in 1848 today
- 1:52:33and and transport what was transport in
- 1:52:361848 did they even have railroads yet
- 1:52:38the Transcontinental was built what like
- 1:52:401860 some so so I guess there was some
- 1:52:43rail at that time now there's cars and
- 1:52:45buses and planes and ship you can't do
- 1:52:49this today
- 1:52:50do you want this today
- 1:52:52insane number seven extension of
- 1:52:56factories and instruments of production
- 1:52:58owned by the state the bringing into
- 1:53:00cultivation of wastelands and the
- 1:53:03Improvement of the soil generally in
- 1:53:06accordance with a common plan yeah a
- 1:53:08common plan what does that mean foreign
- 1:53:21because I'm watching the clock you got
- 1:53:23to hit number nine because this one is
- 1:53:25stunning and people please listen
- 1:53:27carefully combination of Agriculture
- 1:53:30with manufacturing Industries gradual
- 1:53:33abolition of the distinction between
- 1:53:36Town and Country by a more
- 1:53:38what's that word equitable distribution
- 1:53:40it doesn't say Equitable but does it
- 1:53:42yeah it does well here on I'll get a
- 1:53:43spelling error here sorry equitable
- 1:53:45distribution of the population of the
- 1:53:46country so gr think about what this
- 1:53:48means the gradual abolition of all the
- 1:53:52distinction between Town and Country
- 1:53:54think about it right the gradual
- 1:53:57abolition of the distinction between in
- 1:53:59Town and Country what do you mean by
- 1:54:03that how are you going to abolish the
- 1:54:06distinction between a town and a country
- 1:54:09well
- 1:54:10by a more equitable distribution of the
- 1:54:14population over the country they didn't
- 1:54:16want to just redistribute your property
- 1:54:18they wanted to be distribute you so so
- 1:54:20the the beginning of the movie The
- 1:54:23Killing Fields when they're emptying all
- 1:54:24those people out of the capital of
- 1:54:25Cambodia and sending them out into the
- 1:54:27countryside and people saying well I'll
- 1:54:29tell you that's not in my Communist
- 1:54:30Manifesto that's dictatorship I can't
- 1:54:32believe they're doing something Marx
- 1:54:33would have never supported anything
- 1:54:34they're moving yeah they are they're
- 1:54:36moving everybody more equitably out into
- 1:54:39the countryside they're gradually
- 1:54:40abolishing the distinction between Town
- 1:54:42and Country
- 1:54:43all all the all the liberals who live in
- 1:54:46New York and San Francisco okay Missouri
- 1:54:48for you yeah but yeah exactly we're
- 1:54:50going to put you out with with no
- 1:54:52offense
- 1:54:53yeah we're going to push out with with
- 1:54:55uh the Trump Mega hay seeds out in the
- 1:54:57Hicks okay you're going to be forcibly
- 1:54:59going to live out there because we need
- 1:55:01a more equitable distribution of the
- 1:55:03population across the country if that's
- 1:55:05not totalitarian or authoritarian I
- 1:55:08don't know what is what's the point of
- 1:55:09that and you're gonna have have to do
- 1:55:11what the Bolsheviks did put them on box
- 1:55:14cars
- 1:55:16and and send them off
- 1:55:19why uh why why would they want that I
- 1:55:22don't know man I don't know well you
- 1:55:24should know I mean this is your thing I
- 1:55:26I all right you want my real I mean
- 1:55:30there's gonna be a reason they might
- 1:55:31made this as well I think that the that
- 1:55:33the answer to the this and the fact that
- 1:55:37it could have ever gotten any supporters
- 1:55:38and still have people today I think it's
- 1:55:40mainly ignorance and people who lack
- 1:55:42common sense but there's no logical or
- 1:55:45rational reason for it I think it's only
- 1:55:47a supernatural reason it does not make
- 1:55:51logical rational sense that these ideas
- 1:55:54could have ever had any appeal and still
- 1:55:57could and that they could be implemented
- 1:55:59and the fact that they were implemented
- 1:56:01by people that killed over 100 million
- 1:56:02people with these ideas I think says it
- 1:56:06all wouldn't it be possible I agree with
- 1:56:07my church I think that this is okay but
- 1:56:10wouldn't I mean I'm trying to get inside
- 1:56:12the head and figure out why you might
- 1:56:13want to distribute the population across
- 1:56:15the country wouldn't it be to take
- 1:56:16advantage of the resources of that
- 1:56:18country so you're not just in isolated
- 1:56:20pockets with a minimal amount of
- 1:56:22resources or at least a limited amount
- 1:56:23wouldn't if if you spread the population
- 1:56:25throughout the country presumably you
- 1:56:27could
- 1:56:27you could become more wealthy I I well
- 1:56:30you don't want to become wealthy yes
- 1:56:32right
- 1:56:34no yeah you're destroying commitment but
- 1:56:36they wouldn't but they would say that no
- 1:56:37I'm with you
- 1:56:41if the goal is to destroy old traditions
- 1:56:43they can't hear you that's what I'm
- 1:56:44saying
- 1:56:45uh
- 1:56:48yeah
- 1:56:51that's good okay you said can you repeat
- 1:56:53that you read it yeah so she said you
- 1:56:55you can't just dismantle the community
- 1:56:57or the family you got to dismantle the
- 1:56:59community it's like Mars everything that
- 1:57:02is just deserves to perish he's standing
- 1:57:04in the middle of the burning field the
- 1:57:06burning city right everything in flames
- 1:57:08and saying now we can begin Anew it's
- 1:57:11like you've got to take everything down
- 1:57:12they call it the most radical rupture in
- 1:57:15traditional relations okay final one and
- 1:57:17then we can be done with these ten
- 1:57:18points and we can all take a drink of
- 1:57:19whiskey free education well we've done
- 1:57:21that
- 1:57:22free education for all children in
- 1:57:24public schools yeah it actually says
- 1:57:26that people are shocked when they see
- 1:57:28that but it actually says free education
- 1:57:30for all children in public schools so
- 1:57:33they wanted and the Bolsheviks
- 1:57:35immediately did this they they stopped
- 1:57:37home education they stopped religious
- 1:57:39education they took all schools away
- 1:57:41from the Russian Orthodox Church they
- 1:57:43did this in Cuba they did this they did
- 1:57:45this in all the different countries
- 1:57:46where communism was taken North Korea
- 1:57:48Pyongyang was once called the Jerusalem
- 1:57:50of the East it was a very religious City
- 1:57:53they take everybody and they put them in
- 1:57:55public schools Collective schools no
- 1:57:57teaching of God no teaching of religion
- 1:57:59and to do the full indoctrination and by
- 1:58:02the way what does it say at the
- 1:58:03beginning of the ten points from Marx
- 1:58:04and Ingalls so people are thinking don't
- 1:58:06they realize that you this would require
- 1:58:08despotism actually yeah
- 1:58:12of course in the beginning this cannot
- 1:58:15be affected except by means of despotic
- 1:58:18inroads yes there's a Marx biographer
- 1:58:20who says it is absurd to blame marks for
- 1:58:22the gulags and the despotism what are
- 1:58:25you talking about Mark said that you
- 1:58:27can't even do this unless you have
- 1:58:29despotic inroads Marx knew this would
- 1:58:31require despotism I I mean you you've
- 1:58:34got to live in a complete fantasy land
- 1:58:36to think that you could take away
- 1:58:37people's private property inheritance
- 1:58:39and all this other stuff without
- 1:58:40despotism of course it requires
- 1:58:42despotism do you think today then having
- 1:58:45looked at these 10 things that that the
- 1:58:47common
- 1:58:49I don't know why we keep picking on
- 1:58:50University students but the common
- 1:58:51University students student who would
- 1:58:53say he's a socialist
- 1:58:55looks out at an unfair world and would
- 1:58:57like to see it more fair I think that
- 1:58:59that typical student who let's say might
- 1:59:02say positive things about communism and
- 1:59:04appall doesn't know any of this yeah I
- 1:59:06think that's probably in fact I spoke at
- 1:59:08a
- 1:59:09but the head the heavy Progressive or
- 1:59:12gradual income tax is really the only
- 1:59:13one of the only things that they would
- 1:59:15support yeah yeah I think that's right
- 1:59:17in fact the Democratic party supports
- 1:59:19that I mean they had uh they had the
- 1:59:21upper rate of 70 percent although
- 1:59:24um the Democrats in August 13 1981 and
- 1:59:27also 1986 supported both the Reagan tax
- 1:59:29cuts Joe Biden included so so yeah the
- 1:59:33Senate Democrats all voted for
- 1:59:36um the the Democratic House of
- 1:59:37Representatives overwhelmingly passed
- 1:59:39Reagan's 1981 tax cut and uh the Bill
- 1:59:42Clinton brought up the 39.6 there are
- 1:59:45people like Bernie and others who would
- 1:59:46take it up a lot higher in fact I I
- 1:59:49always say ask somebody like AOC or
- 1:59:52ilhan Omar or Jerry Naylor one of these
- 1:59:54people in your perfect world what would
- 1:59:56be the upper income tax rate I think
- 1:59:58that's a great question to ask people
- 1:59:59because it forces them to give a
- 2:00:01practical answer on a specific point the
- 2:00:04other thing too is this distinction
- 2:00:05between like equity and equality so if
- 2:00:07we take 100 people and put them in a
- 2:00:09Village because we're spreading them
- 2:00:11throughout the country and we give them
- 2:00:13all a hundred thousand dollars we give
- 2:00:14them all equal resources right the idea
- 2:00:16that everyone's going to live an equally
- 2:00:18decent life is insane some people are
- 2:00:22going to be sick some people are going
- 2:00:23to be vicious some people are going to
- 2:00:25be more industrious yeah and if you have
- 2:00:27an actual free market economy
- 2:00:30um some people are going to grow that
- 2:00:31hundred thousand and end up having a lot
- 2:00:34more than everybody else because
- 2:00:36everybody everybody's not made the same
- 2:00:39with the same talents right with the
- 2:00:41same with the same ambition Ronald
- 2:00:44Reagan used to say that that he believed
- 2:00:45that the best thing that a free market
- 2:00:47Society could do and that America could
- 2:00:49do could do is give everybody
- 2:00:52um the Equal Opportunity everybody has a
- 2:00:54chance to start at the starting line
- 2:00:55right right no one's prohibited from
- 2:00:58starting at the starting line but after
- 2:00:59that where you go depends on your own
- 2:01:03initiative and everything else and I'm
- 2:01:04not saying in a callous way well and as
- 2:01:07for those who don't do well in around on
- 2:01:10the street yeah fine right let the wood
- 2:01:13Scrooge say let them uh decrease the
- 2:01:16Surplus population or whatever I'm
- 2:01:18saying help those people that's where
- 2:01:20the church comes in and frankly too
- 2:01:22that's where the state can help that's a
- 2:01:24legitimate role for the state okay
- 2:01:26all right let's take a break and then we
- 2:01:28come back we are going to put you in a
- 2:01:30hot seat with all of these questions
- 2:01:32from our local supporters so if you're
- 2:01:34watching right now Matt frad.locals.com
- 2:01:36feel free to put in a question under the
- 2:01:39questions on communism posts that we put
- 2:01:40up recently and we'll get back to that
- 2:01:42soon hey if you want to uh pray better
- 2:01:45and you're not great at praying right
- 2:01:47now you might need the Fantastic number
- 2:01:50one downloaded Catholic app in existence
- 2:01:53hello hello.com Matt go check them out
- 2:01:58over there click the link in the
- 2:01:59description below because if you sign up
- 2:02:01over there you'll actually get three
- 2:02:03you'll get hello for three months free
- 2:02:05you'll have access to their entire app
- 2:02:07their sleep stories their novenas their
- 2:02:09daily gospels their everything Matt on
- 2:02:12an unrelated note do you I was trying to
- 2:02:14find somewhere that I could you know
- 2:02:15hear Jonathan Rooney
- 2:02:17yes exactly Jonathan remember that I
- 2:02:20could do that hallow.com yep yep Jason
- 2:02:23Everett can read a night story to you
- 2:02:24Bobby Angela does stuff for the
- 2:02:28management yeah father Mike Schmitz it
- 2:02:29really is a fantastic app like here's
- 2:02:32the thing though Matt I don't like uh I
- 2:02:35don't want to put all this money into it
- 2:02:37if I don't know if it's great you're
- 2:02:39very good at throwing up softballs so if
- 2:02:42you download the app right now I think
- 2:02:43you can like use a couple of features
- 2:02:45but not many so you can pay for it and
- 2:02:47it's a reasonable price a month but if
- 2:02:49you go to hello.com Matt again click the
- 2:02:52link in the description below that does
- 2:02:53two things number one it lets them know
- 2:02:55that I sent you making them like me more
- 2:02:57and I like being liked by them second
- 2:03:00and more importantly for you you'll get
- 2:03:02a three month free trial so you can try
- 2:03:05it for what's that 90 days and you can
- 2:03:07decide whether or not you like it and if
- 2:03:09you don't cancel by the end of that
- 2:03:10three month free trial and you won't pay
- 2:03:13a cent but I use it my wife is it's
- 2:03:15really great I think a really great use
- 2:03:16case for it too just something that I
- 2:03:18was impressed that it had was uh like
- 2:03:20morning prayer yeah I think that's
- 2:03:22really good because it's hard to like
- 2:03:23read the through the book yeah pieces
- 2:03:25and things so I think that's yeah way
- 2:03:27more
- 2:03:29cheesy next thing I want to talk about
- 2:03:31is Exodus 90 Exodus 90 is an aesthetical
- 2:03:35program for men where you and a bunch of
- 2:03:37fellas get together in a confraternity
- 2:03:40as it were in a small group and for 90
- 2:03:43days really live the spiritual Life Like
- 2:03:46A Champion I mean you're praying for an
- 2:03:48hour every day you're not eating in
- 2:03:49between meals you're not drinking
- 2:03:51alcohol you're only taking cold showers
- 2:03:53it's a very grueling 90 days but it's
- 2:03:55certainly worth it they did independent
- 2:03:57research on people who completed Exodus
- 2:04:0090 and what they found is that most
- 2:04:02people were using their phones and
- 2:04:05computers far less than when they
- 2:04:07started they had better marriages they
- 2:04:09had better prayer lives it's really
- 2:04:11terrific and they're starting soon in
- 2:04:15January so Now's the Time to Begin
- 2:04:17thinking about it so go to exodus90.com
- 2:04:21Matt and they've also got a fantastic
- 2:04:24app and you can learn more about it over
- 2:04:25there Exodus 90.com Matt finally I want
- 2:04:29to let you guys know about parlor and
- 2:04:31the fact that I'm over there go to
- 2:04:32parlor Dot com slash we're on my Matt
- 2:04:36frad if you want the link is in the
- 2:04:37description below I'm always posting the
- 2:04:39latest videos that we put up over here
- 2:04:41over there and that's a great way to
- 2:04:42stay in touch with all the work of pints
- 2:04:44with Aquinas it's nonsensorial
- 2:04:47um you know they're not gonna Shadow ban
- 2:04:49you or any stuff like that so parlor.com
- 2:04:51Matt frad thanks so much
- 2:04:55okay we're back and we're back have you
- 2:04:57done a long interview like this before
- 2:04:59um not this long and and no and we were
- 2:05:03just we were just talking to Jenny one
- 2:05:04of the people here and and um I I don't
- 2:05:08want to put this in uh misrepresent her
- 2:05:11words but at least got me to thinking
- 2:05:12this and maybe this is her view as well
- 2:05:14but uh I I think most people who think
- 2:05:18that their communism is good who haven't
- 2:05:19really read it are just ignorant and
- 2:05:22don't know but this does have an appeal
- 2:05:25to certain very selfish and evil people
- 2:05:28who like Lenin and Stalin who can see in
- 2:05:31this a way to control people and
- 2:05:33resources and make themselves super
- 2:05:35powerful and now I'm now please
- 2:05:37understand me I'm just saying for
- 2:05:39somebody out there who's a Marxist today
- 2:05:40kind of intellectual I'm not saying that
- 2:05:42you're evil but but I'm just saying this
- 2:05:43has an appeal to certain people like
- 2:05:45that because they look at this and say
- 2:05:47wow if I really want to control things
- 2:05:49if I really want to control property
- 2:05:51this is for me right
- 2:05:54but one thing I think I've that's
- 2:05:56bothering me a little bit in this
- 2:05:57interview right is that like I've thrown
- 2:05:59out the term capitalism and you've sort
- 2:06:00of said well you're not a capitalist and
- 2:06:02you know people on Wall Street who
- 2:06:03aren't really capitalists and so you're
- 2:06:04unwilling to sort of identify with that
- 2:06:06title fair enough and that's okay I mean
- 2:06:08you can Define yourself however you want
- 2:06:10to and yet whenever we're talking about
- 2:06:12socialists in any sense it sounds like
- 2:06:14we want to like throw the manifesto at
- 2:06:16them and say well this must be what you
- 2:06:18believe yeah no I don't want to do that
- 2:06:19in fact like I said
- 2:06:21um a lot of modern socialists are kind
- 2:06:24of busily redefining socialism in a way
- 2:06:26that they feel better defined surely
- 2:06:28you'd be in favor of that well I I I I I
- 2:06:31don't like messing with definitions to
- 2:06:33the point where you can no longer Define
- 2:06:34things that's a big problem I would tell
- 2:06:36that person in fact I see this a lot all
- 2:06:39the time to people
- 2:06:41um no what you really support is social
- 2:06:43democracy right more like what they have
- 2:06:46in maybe Belgium or France and I will
- 2:06:50kind of plead with them I'll say you're
- 2:06:52not a Democratic Socialist you're more
- 2:06:54like a Social Democrat and they'll say
- 2:06:55What's the difference they say well let
- 2:06:57me try to explain so I'm gonna play I
- 2:06:59teach political science right and so
- 2:07:01these words have meaning and so if
- 2:07:04people start going on Google and these
- 2:07:06faceless 20-something Millennials who
- 2:07:08are like redefining words like cultural
- 2:07:10Marxism as anti-semitic conspiracy
- 2:07:13theory a lot of them don't know what
- 2:07:14they're talking about so it they you
- 2:07:16can't Tinker with definitions and then
- 2:07:18the definitions no longer have any
- 2:07:20meaning you can't soften them up and
- 2:07:22whitewash them and dress them up and put
- 2:07:23a pretty pink bow on them and make them
- 2:07:26into something that they're not okay
- 2:07:27fair enough so and but then your problem
- 2:07:29with the term capitalism is is it sounds
- 2:07:32like that what you're saying is the
- 2:07:34reason you're unwilling to accept that
- 2:07:36title is that it was it was maybe maybe
- 2:07:38how did they Define it if you type in
- 2:07:40well if you go to Google right now and
- 2:07:42type in capitalist definition I'll do
- 2:07:44just that it it does look like
- 2:07:47well I don't know who came up with the
- 2:07:48term but right that's the problem we
- 2:07:50don't I see yeah so all right fair
- 2:07:53enough capitalism an economic and
- 2:07:55political system in which a country's
- 2:07:57trade and Industry are controlled by
- 2:07:59private owners for profit well CA really
- 2:08:02don't know of any country that really
- 2:08:04fits that I mean oh really I don't I
- 2:08:07don't
- 2:08:08yeah what would that even be I mean if
- 2:08:10you look at the heritage foundation's
- 2:08:12great index of economic freedom the
- 2:08:14freest country in the world is Hong Kong
- 2:08:15economically economically Singapore is
- 2:08:18second New Zealand I think is third
- 2:08:20Australia's top ten
- 2:08:22um America is now out of the top 20.
- 2:08:25uh so I don't know if that really
- 2:08:27defines
- 2:08:29any anybody today yeah all right look we
- 2:08:33don't have much time and so we've got a
- 2:08:35lot of questions from our local
- 2:08:36supporters so would it be okay if we
- 2:08:38tried to think of this as the lightning
- 2:08:39round yeah go through it as quickly as
- 2:08:41we can Jeff says I listened to most of
- 2:08:42your book The Devil and Karl Marx we'll
- 2:08:44put a link in the description below if
- 2:08:45people want to get it he says I had to
- 2:08:47stop listening I really enjoy history
- 2:08:49and know a lot of bad things to do with
- 2:08:51Communism in Russia I struggled with
- 2:08:53your book with all the dark things they
- 2:08:55did to priests and nuns I'm glad you
- 2:08:57wrote the book did you struggle
- 2:08:59researching for that book well yeah is
- 2:09:02Jeff is that his name Jeff if you pick a
- 2:09:04back up and read the afterword and you
- 2:09:07could see the how I express my Agony
- 2:09:09about having to research this and and
- 2:09:12it's it's dark and depressing it really
- 2:09:14is and and I can tell you quite
- 2:09:16literally at the end of the day after
- 2:09:18writing this stuff I had to get away
- 2:09:20from it and you know read a book about
- 2:09:22baseball or football right or
- 2:09:25um and actually what I usually do at
- 2:09:26night is I read books biographies of
- 2:09:28saints Padre Pio right now so I need a
- 2:09:31break from because it's so dark and I
- 2:09:34mean for people who don't know what he's
- 2:09:36talking about imagine opening a book
- 2:09:37with this this is Karl Marx poem The
- 2:09:40Pale Maiden 1837.
- 2:09:42thus Heaven I forfeited I Know It full
- 2:09:45well my soul once true to God is chosen
- 2:09:49for hell
- 2:09:50or this one the player 1841 by Marx look
- 2:09:55now my blood Dark Sword shall stab
- 2:09:58unerringly within thy Soul the hellish
- 2:10:01Vapors rise and fill the brain till I go
- 2:10:05mad and my heart is utterly changed see
- 2:10:08the sword the Prince of Darkness sold it
- 2:10:10to me for he beats the time and gives
- 2:10:13the signs ever more boldly I play the
- 2:10:16dance of death
- 2:10:18Karl Marx so uh his favorite line was
- 2:10:22Mephistopheles everything that exists
- 2:10:24deserves to perish and if you read this
- 2:10:26section of the book on infiltration of
- 2:10:28churches and he's probably talking about
- 2:10:30the prison of potesti in Romania oh man
- 2:10:35where they took priests tied them to
- 2:10:38crosses the Communists did laid them on
- 2:10:40the floor had prisoners come by urinate
- 2:10:44on them defecate on them make the priest
- 2:10:46consecrate the Eucharist and the form of
- 2:10:49feces shove it in mouths
- 2:10:52unbelievable stuff Richard wormbrand
- 2:10:56from Romania saying that while the
- 2:10:57Communists were torturing him saying
- 2:11:00something like one of his tortures said
- 2:11:02I've lived all of my life for this
- 2:11:04moment to express all my evil in my
- 2:11:06heart against you and one of them
- 2:11:09chanting I am the devil I am the devil
- 2:11:11as he's whipping him I mean it's it's
- 2:11:13it's it's awful yeah called Mary
- 2:11:16um the the the the of Christ and
- 2:11:19Christ the the great idiot crucified on
- 2:11:23and on and on uh Richard wormbran the
- 2:11:26Pastor said there is nothing even the
- 2:11:28worst descriptions of Dante's Inferno
- 2:11:30cannot compare to the hellaciousness of
- 2:11:33the way you're treated in communist
- 2:11:35prison camps I could truly say that this
- 2:11:37was of the devil this is what the Tower
- 2:11:39of Babel gets you hmm doesn't get to get
- 2:11:42you to heaven we can try to build to
- 2:11:44order Utopia speaking of Utopia have you
- 2:11:46read some Thomas Moore's book on Utopia
- 2:11:48I I have and it's it so it's very
- 2:11:51different 1516 and sometimes it's often
- 2:11:53cited as one of the earlier examples of
- 2:11:56Communism but in Thomas Moore's book
- 2:12:00um religion for example is not a bad
- 2:12:02thing in fact priests are part of a like
- 2:12:04kindly highly respected revered class so
- 2:12:07in a way you can't call that in any way
- 2:12:09a communist and look at Thomas More
- 2:12:10Thomas More was a great
- 2:12:12um son of the church who went to his
- 2:12:14death defending the Christians against
- 2:12:16the Catholic church so in no way is
- 2:12:18Thomas Moore's Utopia in any way like
- 2:12:21Karl Marx or or the or the Communist
- 2:12:24Marxist and Lynn on his vision Kyle
- 2:12:26wiffington says what are your thoughts
- 2:12:27on distributism yeah it's it's
- 2:12:30Chesterton was a big advocate of it and
- 2:12:33yeah Bell Rock I I could see I think
- 2:12:36they were drawn to a given where they
- 2:12:38were at the times in Britain the Fabian
- 2:12:40Society was is rising up at that time
- 2:12:42the Fabian Society believed in evolution
- 2:12:45rather than Revolution by the way the
- 2:12:47coat of arms for the Fabian Society is a
- 2:12:50wolf in sheep's clothing
- 2:12:52look it up imagine that H.G Wells George
- 2:12:55Bernard Shaw all those guys so I think
- 2:12:58they were maybe looking for something in
- 2:12:59England at the time the labor parties
- 2:13:01Manifesto of 1918 called for common
- 2:13:04ownership of the means of production but
- 2:13:06I think distributism I don't like it and
- 2:13:09I think certainly today it wouldn't I
- 2:13:11can't imagine it being implemented in
- 2:13:13America today H.G wells's time traveler
- 2:13:16seems to be inspired by a hatred of what
- 2:13:19might be thought of as capitalism yeah
- 2:13:21yeah and and Wells was um
- 2:13:23Wells also made some awful comments
- 2:13:28yeah comments about Lenin and Stalin
- 2:13:31which were horrible oh horribly positive
- 2:13:34oh okay yeah yeah yeah George Bernard
- 2:13:37Shaw same thing really embarrassing I
- 2:13:40wrote a book on that called dupes I lay
- 2:13:42all that out of my book dupes okay
- 2:13:44Michael vielma says what are your
- 2:13:46thoughts on investing in the stock
- 2:13:47markets of 401ks there are certain
- 2:13:50Catholics that say you shouldn't be
- 2:13:51participating in that what are your
- 2:13:52thoughts well I wouldn't say that I mean
- 2:13:54there's nothing wrong with a free market
- 2:13:56system where you can invest your money I
- 2:13:58mean it's a risk like like everything
- 2:14:00else but what if these uh but you're
- 2:14:02free too and you're free not to so it's
- 2:14:03a free exchange of ideas free Commerce
- 2:14:05freedom freedom freedom private property
- 2:14:07I mean how interested should we be in
- 2:14:09what these things are contributing to
- 2:14:11financially yeah yeah well that's you
- 2:14:13know that's a concern too uh I mean and
- 2:14:15you consider all those different things
- 2:14:17when you invest your money
- 2:14:19conductor kangor speak to Marx's
- 2:14:22obsession with destroying sexual ethics
- 2:14:23and their influence on the sexual
- 2:14:24Revolution oh yeah I could go on and on
- 2:14:27about that
- 2:14:28but that's I mean
- 2:14:31one of the crowning statements on that
- 2:14:32was Kate millets 1968 book sexual
- 2:14:35politics which was her dissertation of
- 2:14:37Columbia University she was a Frankfurt
- 2:14:40School cultural sexual Marxist
- 2:14:43she was and I haven't even talked about
- 2:14:45the Frankfurt School but that's Herbert
- 2:14:46Marcus Wilhelm Reich who was one of the
- 2:14:51kind of predecessors to the Frankfurt
- 2:14:52School in Germany who was a Freudian
- 2:14:55Marxist so imagine taking it you got to
- 2:14:57be really the worst philosopher of the
- 2:14:5919th century Marx and the nuttiest guy
- 2:15:02of the 20th century Freud and thinking
- 2:15:04we should fuse these together into a
- 2:15:06common field of Freudian Marxism so
- 2:15:09Wilhelm Reich wrote the book and coined
- 2:15:12the term the sexual Revolution and if
- 2:15:14you read reich's actual Memoirs it is it
- 2:15:18is stunning the sexual stuff is
- 2:15:21unbelievable he's five years old you
- 2:15:24know fantasizing about yeah
- 2:15:28doesn't matter oh it's stimulating the
- 2:15:30farm animals fantasizing about jumping
- 2:15:33in bed with his mother and his mother's
- 2:15:35lover and not Wilhelm Reich was a sexual
- 2:15:38freak yeah and that guy wrote the book
- 2:15:41the sexual Revolution and see we don't
- 2:15:43people criticize me oh you're like you
- 2:15:45said
- 2:15:46um someone might say you're attacking
- 2:15:48Marx's personal life in order to
- 2:15:50integrate his ideas in so many of these
- 2:15:52cases and Reich is a great example the
- 2:15:54personal life explains the ideas and
- 2:15:57you've got to go into the personal life
- 2:15:59to really get a feel for where they're
- 2:16:01coming from yeah that makes sense Daniel
- 2:16:03James has a good question what's
- 2:16:05interesting about Daniel is that he was
- 2:16:06arrested for antifa activities and then
- 2:16:09had a conversion to Christ wow wow he
- 2:16:12said he started listening to plants with
- 2:16:14Aquinas since started to learn how to
- 2:16:15pray the rosary anyway wow so Daniel
- 2:16:17says Dr kengo with a recent passing of
- 2:16:19the Beloved Queen Elizabeth II what are
- 2:16:21your thoughts on monarchy as a political
- 2:16:23system I've heard that some Catholics
- 2:16:24prefer monarchy as a form of government
- 2:16:26I was gonna say with the recent passing
- 2:16:28of Franco Harris to bring us back to the
- 2:16:30beginning of our conversation on the
- 2:16:31Immaculate Reception right it would be a
- 2:16:33great place to close
- 2:16:35um sure we could yeah
- 2:16:38you know I don't think so it goes on
- 2:16:40Monday no I'm not a monarchist I mean I
- 2:16:42I I think that the system of the
- 2:16:44American Founders created as a as
- 2:16:46originally envisioned and if you stick
- 2:16:48to it
- 2:16:49um is is you know about the best system
- 2:16:52that's been created you know Winston
- 2:16:54Churchill famously said democracy is not
- 2:16:56perfect but it's better than all the
- 2:16:57other systems I would say that about
- 2:16:59free market systems as well too I'm not
- 2:17:01saying that free markets are are the
- 2:17:03solution to everything it's not going to
- 2:17:05bring you to to Utopia it's not a
- 2:17:06Panacea but it's certainly better than
- 2:17:09uh closed economies and closed markets
- 2:17:11and non-democracies any uh super chats
- 2:17:14or questions in there with bringing up
- 2:17:16um we have a tone here but
- 2:17:19there were some some of them have
- 2:17:21already been addressed let's see
- 2:17:24let me ask this while you're looking for
- 2:17:26one this comes from T-Bone or T-bone
- 2:17:28could you please ask Dr King Pickens
- 2:17:31yeah speaking of capitalists yeah could
- 2:17:34you please ask Dr kangor to shed light
- 2:17:35on the commonly held belief that the
- 2:17:37Scandinavian countries are so are a
- 2:17:39socialist Paradise we should model
- 2:17:40ourselves after that's a great question
- 2:17:42and and do some Googling on this there
- 2:17:45there are a bunch of really good
- 2:17:47articles on how the Scandinavian
- 2:17:49countries they're not socialists in fact
- 2:17:52if you look in the Heritage foundations
- 2:17:54index of economic freedom go to the
- 2:17:57Scandinavian countries some of them are
- 2:17:59ranked more free economically than the
- 2:18:00United States there's a really good
- 2:18:03prageru video as well that one of my
- 2:18:05students sent me not not that long ago
- 2:18:07from somebody one of the Scandinavian
- 2:18:09countries uh just because a country
- 2:18:11might have government managed health
- 2:18:14care or maybe generous pensions or high
- 2:18:18regulations it doesn't make them
- 2:18:20socialist and this is what Bernie and
- 2:18:22AOC Bernie Sanders is horrible about
- 2:18:24this he'll tell people all the time well
- 2:18:26look at the Netherlands it's a social
- 2:18:28it's not a socialist country Venezuela
- 2:18:31is a social
- 2:18:32that's socialism just because again
- 2:18:34those countries are more social
- 2:18:36democracies and the state does some
- 2:18:38things it does other things but some of
- 2:18:41them have lower tax rates than we do so
- 2:18:43it's much more complicated than that
- 2:18:46Patrick Turner says many people use
- 2:18:48Jesus feeding the people with the fish
- 2:18:50and bread as an example of socialism how
- 2:18:52can this be easily refuted was Jesus is
- 2:18:54a social Jesus was not a socialist for
- 2:18:57one thing Jesus wasn't against religion
- 2:18:58he didn't call it the opiate of the
- 2:19:00masses and uh in fact if you want to
- 2:19:03start working through The Parables of
- 2:19:04Jesus right look at some of them the
- 2:19:08um the the tenants right the uh the the
- 2:19:11the vineyard owner who who also Pays His
- 2:19:16People what he wants depending on
- 2:19:18whether they came earlier in the day or
- 2:19:19later in the day
- 2:19:21um and and by the way defends the
- 2:19:24ownership rights of the vineyard owner
- 2:19:27right he's allowed to have a Vineyard I
- 2:19:30mean Jesus is not against private
- 2:19:32property
- 2:19:33um no you know you know Jesus is not
- 2:19:36Karl Marx
- 2:19:37and then somebody responded after under
- 2:19:40this person's question said socialists
- 2:19:42can't multiply the fish and bread
- 2:19:43miraculously right that's exactly right
- 2:19:45yeah Ronald Reagan said socialism Works
- 2:19:48only in heaven where they don't need it
- 2:19:49and in hell where they already have it
- 2:19:52we've addressed this but Gina asked why
- 2:19:54are so many Christians under the
- 2:19:56impression that communism has any
- 2:19:57similarities to Christianity where are
- 2:19:59the common errors in that line of
- 2:20:00thinking and how do we refute them yeah
- 2:20:02they'll have this incredibly simplistic
- 2:20:04approach of looking at certain things in
- 2:20:07scripture the New Testament that talk
- 2:20:09about sharing or sharing wealth and say
- 2:20:11hey Marx does that too well so what that
- 2:20:15that's I I I I I I mean Hitler loved
- 2:20:18puppies right Hitler was a vegetarian
- 2:20:22right
- 2:20:24you don't take a couple things here and
- 2:20:27a couple things there and say so thus
- 2:20:30this must be a good ideology no that's
- 2:20:34that's that is sophistry it's incredibly
- 2:20:37simple holistic and by the let me just
- 2:20:39say extraordinarily intellectually lazy
- 2:20:42yeah
- 2:20:45um is feminism rooted in Marxism
- 2:20:47communism asks Heath farachy no I don't
- 2:20:50think so no they uh there have been a
- 2:20:53number of prominent feminist marxists in
- 2:20:56in fact the most famous is
- 2:20:59um Angela Davis who was a student of
- 2:21:01Herbert marcusa the guru of the 1960s
- 2:21:04new left and one of the most prominent
- 2:21:05members of the Frankfurt School and look
- 2:21:07her up she is she wrote the forward to
- 2:21:10the Patrice collars the founder of blm's
- 2:21:13Memoirs and Patrice Collins said of
- 2:21:16herself and uh and Alicia Garza two of
- 2:21:19the founders of BLM she said we are
- 2:21:21trained marxists we are we are very
- 2:21:23steeped in uh in in Marxism and Marxist
- 2:21:26ideologies but you don't think that
- 2:21:28feminism in any way has been influenced
- 2:21:30by communist thought well uh seems to me
- 2:21:32obviously well I mean Kate Millett who
- 2:21:34wrote sexual politics which was her
- 2:21:38sister Mallory by the way is a very
- 2:21:40devout Catholic read Mallory's article
- 2:21:42about Kate Millett at front page
- 2:21:44magazine.com but Kate was a sexual
- 2:21:48Marxist and a feminist so she was fusing
- 2:21:51the two and also Betty Betty Friedan was
- 2:21:55a communist
- 2:21:56feminist talking points right again you
- 2:21:59have like the bourgeoisie the man in his
- 2:22:02capitalist system monogamy you know and
- 2:22:04then you've got the oppressed the woman
- 2:22:06who has to have abortion has to have
- 2:22:08access to contraception in order to free
- 2:22:10herself from the shackles of her I mean
- 2:22:13the commonality is they're both kind of
- 2:22:15I think destructive left-wing ideologies
- 2:22:17but but if you look to sort of you know
- 2:22:20what are the tenements of tenets of
- 2:22:22feminism and line them up against you
- 2:22:24know like a 10-point plan I see fair
- 2:22:26enough yeah you're using words correctly
- 2:22:28right right yeah I thought this made I
- 2:22:30insist on these categories I thought
- 2:22:31this meme was hilarious it's it's a red
- 2:22:34book and it says well that didn't work
- 2:22:37yeah an abbreviated history of Communism
- 2:22:39nice nice yeah except that's almost two
- 2:22:42Cavalier it didn't not just work it was
- 2:22:45very destructive and killed a lot of
- 2:22:46people wrecked a lot of lives
- 2:22:50I lived through communism says Ania and
- 2:22:53my parents were active in underground it
- 2:22:55is scary to see how it it cripples back
- 2:22:59in the U.S with so many people clapping
- 2:23:01amen I've had I've had Parents email me
- 2:23:06and I've done talk shows on the subject
- 2:23:08of Communism where I'll get a call from
- 2:23:10a distraught mom who's crying and saying
- 2:23:13I came to this country after the Berlin
- 2:23:16Wall fell to escape communism and I sent
- 2:23:19my daughter to this you know prominent
- 2:23:22Elite college and she is a communist she
- 2:23:26is a communist how can this happen in
- 2:23:28America yeah
- 2:23:31final question rootberg says could you
- 2:23:33name one place in the Bible that
- 2:23:36promises that a free market will in
- 2:23:38general lead to human flourishing and
- 2:23:40has the magisterium taught that human
- 2:23:41interactions within a free market
- 2:23:43economy will somehow tend towards
- 2:23:45Prosperity is are you identifying the in
- 2:23:50visible hand with the hand of God no
- 2:23:53that is where does this Great Trust of
- 2:23:56his come from what is his theological
- 2:23:58basis for your belief in free markets
- 2:24:00well I would say read rarum novarum uh
- 2:24:03read quadrajc Milano uh check the says
- 2:24:07those those encyclicals that yeah very
- 2:24:10much describes me but I actually very
- 2:24:13much am in sync with the church on these
- 2:24:15things but for example the Bible defends
- 2:24:19private property it says Thou shalt not
- 2:24:21steal this this book says is a good way
- 2:24:23to wrap up but the entire communist
- 2:24:25Theory or program may be summed up in a
- 2:24:27single sentence abolition of private
- 2:24:28property theft yeah that's right that is
- 2:24:30that that is State Fiat to abolish and
- 2:24:33take away your private property the
- 2:24:35Bible doesn't support that I mean you
- 2:24:37know now the Bible encourages to do
- 2:24:40charitable good things with your wealth
- 2:24:43and even share it with with the needy
- 2:24:45but you know but it's no it's not a
- 2:24:47Manifesto on free markets but it's
- 2:24:50um it certainly ain't this
- 2:24:52as we wrap up well how do we how do we
- 2:24:54want to wrap up is there is there a
- 2:24:55single book that you would that you're
- 2:24:57most proud of that you would Point
- 2:24:58people to to get a fuller understanding
- 2:25:00of Communism and how to refute it well I
- 2:25:02I mentioned communism history by Richard
- 2:25:04pipes that's really good when you meet
- 2:25:06in my own books any any good I like what
- 2:25:08you said about that book that's not too
- 2:25:09long you don't have to invest your whole
- 2:25:11life into understanding what you would
- 2:25:12consider to be and I would consider to
- 2:25:13be such an idiot yeah and I did a book
- 2:25:15called um the devil and Karl Marx so I
- 2:25:17did um Politically Incorrect uh guide to
- 2:25:20Communism
- 2:25:21and I did a book called a pope and a
- 2:25:23president on Ronald Reagan and John Paul
- 2:25:25II and the end of the Cold War which
- 2:25:26talks about Fatima and a whole bunch of
- 2:25:28other things and I said to you too maybe
- 2:25:30Neil could post him if he hasn't already
- 2:25:32but a couple of Articles one I did I'll
- 2:25:34send them to you on on marks on
- 2:25:37Christianity Judaism and evolution race
- 2:25:41and that kind of sums up some of his
- 2:25:44really outrageous beliefs on religion
- 2:25:46Judaism and race
- 2:25:48and I also did a a piece for the
- 2:25:51American spectator called why not cancel
- 2:25:53Karl Marx and for the record I don't
- 2:25:56support canceling anyone but when you
- 2:26:00look at what this guy has said and done
- 2:26:01you wonder why people on the left
- 2:26:04haven't canceled this guy and the reason
- 2:26:05is because he's one of their guys he's
- 2:26:08on the left but but Marx's background is
- 2:26:11is really outrageous and you have a
- 2:26:13recent book you just put out yeah the
- 2:26:15devil and Bella died tell us about that
- 2:26:17which came out through tan books so
- 2:26:18Bella Dodd was a master organizer for
- 2:26:22the Communist Party in the 1930s and
- 2:26:241940s in New York put a thousand to 1500
- 2:26:27teachers in the New York State teachers
- 2:26:29union and then
- 2:26:32according to what she told Alice Von
- 2:26:34Hildebrand and others and we spent a lot
- 2:26:36of time on this help place quote over a
- 2:26:39thousand communist men unquote in
- 2:26:41Catholic seminaries and we go through
- 2:26:43that claim the documentation for it is
- 2:26:46it possible everything I was very very
- 2:26:48very carefully and a very hopefully a
- 2:26:50very thought uh very thoughtful the
- 2:26:52claim that the Catholic church was
- 2:26:53infiltrated by the Communists isn't just
- 2:26:55some cocoa no that's right she was part
- 2:26:58of it and then she left the party in
- 2:26:591948 the party accused her in a press
- 2:27:03release of being anti-negro anti-semitic
- 2:27:06anti-puerto Rican pro-fascist pro-nazi
- 2:27:09the same thing they always do it's page
- 2:27:10one of their playbook right because
- 2:27:12they've been doing this for a hundred
- 2:27:13years and she was eventually brought
- 2:27:15back into the Catholic faith by Bishop
- 2:27:17Fulton Sheen in a wonderful conversion
- 2:27:20story so in her in her case the devil
- 2:27:22and Karl Marx Marx remained infatuated
- 2:27:25with the devil throughout his life and
- 2:27:26remaining sounds like this new book's a
- 2:27:28little more hopeful yeah in her case she
- 2:27:29described breaking away from communism
- 2:27:31is breaking away from the seduction of
- 2:27:33the devil and led a life of redemption
- 2:27:36and reparation and spent the rest of her
- 2:27:37life as a courageous witness warning the
- 2:27:40world and the church not to embrace
- 2:27:43communism but to reject it I would think
- 2:27:45too as a friend people watching this
- 2:27:47they probably have many loved ones who
- 2:27:49are interested in Socialism or may spout
- 2:27:52some certain lines like that a simple
- 2:27:54kind of Socratic method of questioning
- 2:27:56could be helpful like what do you mean
- 2:27:58yeah have you read the book right was
- 2:28:00the single thing that Marx or Engel said
- 2:28:03that you found most compelling why well
- 2:28:05and I would say when they're in classes
- 2:28:07with a professor who's maybe not giving
- 2:28:10them enough information or even if the
- 2:28:12professor does give information and says
- 2:28:15something like abolition of private
- 2:28:17property just put your hand up in a
- 2:28:19non-confrontational way say
- 2:28:20what do they mean by that Professor what
- 2:28:23would that look like and how how would
- 2:28:26this excellent idea be implemented yeah
- 2:28:27right how would this be carried out and
- 2:28:29without it not in a mean way right to
- 2:28:32just say but Professor I don't know you
- 2:28:34support this what would that look like
- 2:28:36how much of it would just start you know
- 2:28:38taking the lid off start asking
- 2:28:40questions and let it let it fall apart
- 2:28:43through its own you know obvious
- 2:28:45self-contradictions an inherent
- 2:28:47fallacies well Dr Kango this has been
- 2:28:50fantastic I've learned a lot and uh it's
- 2:28:52been great with you but wait till you
- 2:28:55find out I made it all up he's actually
- 2:28:56a communist infiltrated
- 2:28:59just put straight in this a little bit
- 2:29:01the Communist cross the pope actually
- 2:29:03said this is not okay and yeah I know
- 2:29:07and by the way and you said the opposite
- 2:29:09well well no in the what's unfortunate
- 2:29:11about the picture at American Magazine
- 2:29:13is francis's smiling that was your point
- 2:29:15yeah not that he didn't yeah and and and
- 2:29:18and Francis has said the Marxist
- 2:29:20ideology is wrong so I he has he has not
- 2:29:24been good on communism he's not a
- 2:29:26Marxist he's not pro-communist he's not
- 2:29:28very anti-communist he's been bad on
- 2:29:30China he's been bad ones yeah well
- 2:29:32what's funny is there's also a photo of
- 2:29:34him looking pretty pissed off about it I
- 2:29:36know look but not a yeah that's right
- 2:29:38which one is that well but that's not
- 2:29:40the one at America right how many people
- 2:29:42did you see them
- 2:29:45the one in America oh I see
- 2:29:48time but he looked happy and I know I
- 2:29:50think he's I could confirm it before we
- 2:29:52leave so I can apologize if I'm wrong
- 2:29:55but I think he's smiling I'm gonna find
- 2:29:57it I've got it I'm opening it are you
- 2:29:59smiling yep right I know
- 2:30:02shame on them and it could be and they
- 2:30:04could that could have been a moment
- 2:30:05where he's smiling like puzzle like what
- 2:30:07the you know
- 2:30:11it does look a little goofy when you
- 2:30:12look at it that someone would think it's
- 2:30:14okay to make that yeah exactly a
- 2:30:16communist crucifix right by the stripes
- 2:30:20of Marx we are he looks about as goofy
- 2:30:22as that we won't comment on what that is
- 2:30:24but yeah
- 2:30:26glory to Jesus Christ thank you for
- 2:30:28being with us hey thanks so much loved
- 2:30:29it yeah pleasure yeah thanks yeah
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of DESTROYING Communism (Dr. Paul Kengor) | Ep. 381 by Matt Fradd, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 27,049 words across 3,913 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.