Desmontando mentiras ecologistas sobre la energía nuclear — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00The topic of this blog was chosen by
- 0:02the guys from Patreon. Many thanks to
- 0:05all of them for choosing this topic and
- 0:06many others, as they encourage me to
- 0:08research and learn about a lot of
- 0:10interesting things like this, and in
- 0:11the process, you also benefit because
- 0:13we all learn a little more about how
- 0:15the world works. If you want to suggest
- 0:17topics for future blogs of this type,
- 0:19you can become a patron on my Patreon;
- 0:20the link is in the description. And
- 0:22before starting the video, I want to
- 0:23make it clear that I am not an expert
- 0:25on any of the topics I am going to
- 0:26cover. You only need to visit my
- 0:28channel to realize that. But don't be
- 0:30discouraged, because that doesn't mean
- 0:31there is no rigor in the video. I have
- 0:34spent the last four months researching,
- 0:36reading documents and studies, and even
- 0:38asking people who work in or have
- 0:39studied the subject we are going to
- 0:41cover in this video to document myself
- 0:43properly. That said, let's begin. Today
- 0:47we are going to talk about nuclear
- 0:48energy and its relationship with
- 0:49environmentalists. Nuclear energy is
- 0:51currently the most hated form of energy
- 0:53. 62%of the world's population is in
- 0:56favor of banning it. Environmentalists
- 0:59constantly fight against nuclear energy
- 1:01, trying to shut down power plants at
- 1:03all costs because they consider it an
- 1:05extremely dangerous, polluting, and
- 1:07above all, radioactive energy. They say
- 1:11that plants contaminate river and ocean
- 1:13water; that poor maintenance could make
- 1:15them explode, killing everyone as if
- 1:17they were nuclear bombs; that they
- 1:18serve as a cover for making nuclear
- 1:20weapons; that they cause cancer; that
- 1:22they kill animals; that they cause
- 1:24strange mutations; and that if you live
- 1:26nearby, you will start glowing green
- 1:27like Mr. Burns. Nothing could be
- 1:30further from the truth. The hatred for
- 1:32nuclear energy comes from a veil of
- 1:35ignorance that surrounds everything
- 1:37related to it, because they really
- 1:39don't know how it works. Because, what
- 1:41do they know? That if you take a little
- 1:42device and put it near something and it
- 1:44starts making noise, "What is it, poop?
- 1:46" You shouldn't touch it. How does it
- 1:48go? They don't really know how it works
- 1:50. They only know what they've heard
- 1:52from other people, what they've seen in
- 1:53video games, or on TV. They have a
- 1:55media-driven opinion about nuclear
- 1:57energy. They base all their actions on
- 1:59what they believe it is, and not on
- 2:01what it actually is. And this is a very
- 2:04big problem because they are
- 2:05conditioning the environment, human
- 2:06development, and electricity costs with
- 2:08those beliefs, which are groundless
- 2:10beliefs. Because, what would you think
- 2:13if I told you that nuclear energy is
- 2:15the safest, the cleanest, and the
- 2:16cheapest that exists? Would you believe
- 2:19me? I don’t think so, right? Well,
- 2:21only one of those three is false; I bet
- 2:23you don’t know which one it is. Place
- 2:25your bets, ladies and gentlemen.
- 2:26Let’s spin the wheel. Which one do
- 2:28you think is going to be the false one?
- 2:29I’m sure you’ve bet your money that
- 2:31it’s not clean or that it’s not
- 2:32safe. Well no, nuclear energy is not
- 2:35the cheapest; it isn't particularly
- 2:37expensive, but it certainly isn't the
- 2:39cheapest. And the fact is that,
- 2:41contrary to popular belief, nuclear
- 2:42energy—including the Chernobyl and
- 2:44Fukushima disasters—is the safest and
- 2:46cleanest energy in existence. Nuclear
- 2:48energy is more than one and a half
- 2:50times safer than wind energy and nearly
- 2:52five times safer than solar, the safest
- 2:54energies in the world. The fact is that
- 2:56nuclear energy is the one that causes
- 2:58the fewest deaths in all stages of its
- 2:59life cycle. Fewer deaths in the mining
- 3:02of materials and fuels. Fewer deaths in
- 3:04the construction of facilities. Fewer
- 3:05deaths in the operation of facilities.
- 3:07Fewer deaths in the replacement and
- 3:09dismantling of damaged equipment. Fewer
- 3:11deaths in the demolition of obsolete
- 3:13infrastructure and fewer deaths caused
- 3:15to citizens, whether by accidents or
- 3:17pollution, which is another of its
- 3:18advantages. Nuclear energy is very
- 3:22low-polluting. In fact, most studies
- 3:24consider it the cleanest energy that
- 3:25exists, and for that reason, they are
- 3:27calling for it to be recognized as
- 3:28green. To determine how much an energy
- 3:32source pollutes, one must look at
- 3:34greenhouse gas emissions and the liquid
- 3:36and solid waste it produces throughout
- 3:38its entire life cycle: during material
- 3:40extraction, power plant construction,
- 3:43fuel transport, the machinery that
- 3:45operates it, and the plant's own
- 3:46emissions. With all this in mind, we
- 3:50find that nuclear energy, depending on
- 3:52the country of course, ranges from
- 3:54being the least polluting to being just
- 3:55as polluting as wind energy, the second
- 3:57cleanest energy in the world. Studies
- 4:01conducted in Denmark, which are among
- 4:03the most detailed studies I could find,
- 4:05by the way, discovered that
- 4:06hydroelectric power is the least
- 4:08polluting, followed closely by nuclear
- 4:10and then wind. In the United States,
- 4:13the conclusion was reached that nuclear
- 4:15energy pollutes the same as wind energy
- 4:17, and both less than solar. And in the
- 4:19United Kingdom, wind energy is the
- 4:21cleanest, slightly less polluting on
- 4:23average than nuclear, although nuclear
- 4:25has a lower minimum pollution level
- 4:26than wind. Global statistics conclude
- 4:30that nuclear energy is as clean as wind
- 4:32energy. Although the most detailed
- 4:35studies that exist separate wind energy
- 4:37into two subcategories: onshore wind
- 4:39energy and offshore wind energy. When
- 4:42wind energy is divided into these two
- 4:43separate categories, offshore wind
- 4:45energy becomes the least polluting on a
- 4:47global scale. It is also the second
- 4:49most expensive, it should be noted;
- 4:51offshore becomes the least polluting,
- 4:53followed by nuclear, and then followed
- 4:55by onshore wind. In other words, wind
- 4:57energy is sandwiching nuclear energy in
- 4:59terms of pollution. But there is a
- 5:01problem with these statistics, which is
- 5:03that there are also other very
- 5:04important factors regarding pollution
- 5:06that these statistics do not take into
- 5:08account. The space occupied, the impact
- 5:11on fauna and flora, the capacity at
- 5:13which they produce electricity, the
- 5:15batteries, and the operating time. One
- 5:18of the biggest concerns for
- 5:19environmentalists is the conservation
- 5:21of the environment, altering it as
- 5:22little as possible and protecting the
- 5:24species that inhabit it. Basically, not
- 5:26cutting down all the forests, filling
- 5:28the oceans with trash, and shooting all
- 5:30the species, something like that. The
- 5:33irony of the matter is that renewables
- 5:34are the ones that require the most
- 5:36space and, therefore, are the ones that
- 5:38have to modify the land the most. They
- 5:40are the ones that have to cut down
- 5:42forests, excavate or fill land, and
- 5:43relocate species the most. The most
- 5:45obvious one is hydroelectric power. A
- 5:47gigantic barrier is built that creates
- 5:48an artificial lake, flooding an entire
- 5:50area and destroying the ecosystem. If
- 5:53we look at the comparison, we can see
- 5:55that the most intrusive are renewables.
- 5:58And this is a problem, because if we do
- 6:00not use energy sources that take up
- 6:02less space and require less fuel, we
- 6:03will not be able to free up large areas
- 6:05of land, allowing those altered
- 6:07ecosystems to restore themselves,
- 6:09forest mass to regrow, and species to
- 6:11repopulate the area. In ancient times
- 6:14and today, in poor countries, energy
- 6:16methods like wood or manure are still
- 6:19used. These energy sources are the most
- 6:21inefficient and polluting that exist,
- 6:23more than coal, whether due to CO2
- 6:25emissions or the large amount of land
- 6:27they require. That is why we have moved
- 6:29to denser energy sources like coal, and
- 6:31subsequently to natural gas, which
- 6:33pollutes half as much as coal, and
- 6:35finally to nuclear, which is incredibly
- 6:37dense and low-polluting. But now we
- 6:39find ourselves making the jump to
- 6:40renewables. And renewable energies,
- 6:43even though they don't depend on all
- 6:45that biomass or biofuels, require much
- 6:47more space—more than traditional
- 6:49methods like logging forests for timber
- 6:51, farming, or grazing—which is why
- 6:53they are wiping out forest mass and the
- 6:55species that inhabit it. And this could
- 6:59be solved with nuclear energy, a
- 7:00preferable energy source compared to
- 7:02other fossil fuels. It is very
- 7:04low-polluting, requires a very small
- 7:05amount of fuel, and takes up very
- 7:07little space. Another problem with
- 7:10renewable energy is animal deaths.
- 7:13Defenders of fossil fuels argue that
- 7:14renewable energies indirectly kill more
- 7:16birds than fossil fuels do. That is to
- 7:20say, wind turbines and solar mirrors
- 7:22kill more birds than cooling towers,
- 7:24coal chimneys, and incinerator exhausts
- 7:25. And although wind turbines might swat
- 7:30them down and solar mirrors might set
- 7:32them on fire like Japanese warplanes,
- 7:34fossil fuels indirectly end the lives
- 7:36of many more birds through pollution
- 7:38than renewables do throughout their
- 7:39entire life cycle. Although it is true
- 7:43that renewables are posing a serious
- 7:45problem for migratory and raptor
- 7:47species, and not just for birds, but
- 7:49also for bats. These energy sources are
- 7:52responsible for between 6 and 18
- 7:54million deaths annually here in Spain.
- 7:57And in the United States, wind turbines
- 7:59kill 20 million hoary bats annually.
- 8:02Yes, that’s what they are called.
- 8:03I’m not making it up, I swear. Here,
- 8:05environmentalists argue that those bird
- 8:07numbers aren't as serious as they seem,
- 8:09since domestic cats hunt an infinite
- 8:11number of birds more than wind turbines
- 8:13do. And it's true, domestic cats are
- 8:15the greatest killers in history after
- 8:17us. Of course, cats are responsible for
- 8:20killing 3.7 billion birds a year. They
- 8:24are the most invasive species that
- 8:25exists after us, of course. And this
- 8:27puts thousands of species at risk. So,
- 8:29instead of banning nuclear energy, how
- 8:32about we ban cats? Nobody wants to ban
- 8:36a cute kitty. They are very cute and
- 8:39stupid. They keep us entertained. Let
- 8:43them keep killing. The problem with
- 8:46this argument is that the birds being
- 8:47hunted are little birds like Tweety.
- 8:50They are sparrows, robins, starlings,
- 8:53warblers, turtledoves, pigeons, things
- 8:55like that. And renewables don't kill
- 8:58those birds. Renewables are dangerous
- 9:00for endangered birds, like the Spanish
- 9:02imperial eagle or the bustard. And cats
- 9:05don't hunt imperial eagles; imperial
- 9:07eagles hunt cats. And since we can't
- 9:10resist interfering with nature and
- 9:12can't allow any species to go extinct,
- 9:15we have to emphasize them because those
- 9:17endangered birds are more important
- 9:19than the rest. But these birds and
- 9:22those being severely affected by fossil
- 9:25fuels could be saved if we used nuclear
- 9:28energy, as it could supply the need for
- 9:30fossil fuels, reducing emissions and
- 9:32mortality, for workers and citizens
- 9:35alike, and also for the birds. Besides
- 9:38the fact that we would need to build
- 9:40fewer renewable parks, polluting less
- 9:42and interfering less with nature, which
- 9:43, after all, is what environmentalists
- 9:45want. Animal mortality statistics are
- 9:48very hard to find for some reason. The
- 9:51most complete study I have found
- 9:53specifies only bird deaths. The study
- 9:56indicates that avian deaths caused by
- 9:58wind energy are twice as low as those
- 10:00from nuclear energy and 35 times lower
- 10:02than those from fossil fuels.
- 10:04Unfortunately, there is no data on
- 10:06solar or hydroelectric energy, but it
- 10:08is estimated that solar energy causes
- 10:09three times fewer avian deaths than
- 10:11wind energy. Despite these data, if we
- 10:13read the fine print, we can see that
- 10:15for nuclear energy, the study includes
- 10:17uranium mines, so a third of the values
- 10:19are not from nuclear power plants, but
- 10:21from their mines. And for fossil fuels,
- 10:24it includes the damage caused to the
- 10:26terrain by large mines and acid rain
- 10:27produced by pollution. The problem with
- 10:30these metrics is that they unfairly
- 10:32inflate avian deaths for nuclear and
- 10:33fossil energy. In the case of fossil
- 10:36fuels, whether or not you take acid
- 10:38rain into account won't change much how
- 10:40harmful they are to the environment.
- 10:42But in the case of nuclear, the nuclear
- 10:44plant barely kills any birds, if it
- 10:47even kills any at all. Because, how
- 10:50does a nuclear plant kill a bird?
- 10:52Unless a bird crashes into a window and
- 10:54dies, just like with any other building
- 10:55on the face of the earth. Hm, seems a
- 10:58bit difficult, don't you think? Another
- 11:00way to die would be if the bird flew
- 11:02into the middle of the cooling tower
- 11:04while it is cooling and got roasted
- 11:05somehow. Nuclear power plants really
- 11:08don't kill birds. What nuclear energy
- 11:11affects most is the marine life found
- 11:13near the pipes that draw in or expel
- 11:15water from the reactor. And the nuclear
- 11:18reactor only takes in cold water and
- 11:20expels it hot, that's all. And it
- 11:22doesn't expel water at 1000 degrees, it
- 11:24expels slightly warm water, but that's
- 11:25it. It doesn’t dump harmful
- 11:27substances into the water, nor does it
- 11:29make fish glow green or anything like
- 11:31that. Birds are a minor concern for
- 11:33nuclear power plants. However, a third
- 11:36of these statistics regarding nuclear
- 11:39energy comes from mines. And okay, yes,
- 11:41uranium mines can wipe out surrounding
- 11:43animal life, and in fact, they do. They
- 11:46contaminate nearby water sources, and
- 11:47machinery emissions and altering the
- 11:49soil to extract the material also take
- 11:51their toll. Though here is where the
- 11:53plot twist comes in. Renewable energy
- 11:56sources also have to obtain the
- 11:58materials to be built. Or do you think
- 12:01they descend from the sky in a beam of
- 12:02light and land gracefully on the ground
- 12:04as if they were the quintessence of
- 12:05engineering? Those materials have to be
- 12:09dug out of mines, and those mines also
- 12:11pollute. They’re called mines for a
- 12:13reason, because they mine/contaminate.
- 12:14Did you see what I did there? However,
- 12:16those mines are not being taken into
- 12:18account in these statistics. And why is
- 12:20that? Why aren't they taken into
- 12:22account? Because materials like
- 12:25concrete, lithium, and plastic have a
- 12:27large number of applications. If you
- 12:30mine calcium, you can use it to make
- 12:32alloys, chemicals, plastics, cosmetics,
- 12:35drugs, and concrete. And that concrete
- 12:37can be used for all types of
- 12:38construction, such as power plants. If
- 12:41you extract oil, you can use it as fuel
- 12:43for cars, ships, planes, to make
- 12:45plastic, or to burn it in a generator
- 12:47to get electricity. Lithium, the same
- 12:51thing; cells, batteries, drugs, alloys,
- 12:53but what about uranium—what is
- 12:55uranium extracted for? Well, it is
- 12:58extracted for nuclear power plants and
- 13:02armor or ammunition for tanks, oh,
- 13:05bombs; it doesn't have many uses, and
- 13:09since its main use is nuclear energy,
- 13:12the pollution goes to nuclear energy.
- 13:16Since the materials and resources used
- 13:18for other energy sources are used in a
- 13:20great number of sectors, it isn't
- 13:22logical to attribute bird deaths from
- 13:24those mines entirely to energy. But
- 13:26since we don't know exactly how much of
- 13:28those materials goes where and for what
- 13:31, the statistics ignore that pollution.
- 13:34The problem with other energy sources
- 13:36is that the mining of the materials
- 13:37they require is more polluting than
- 13:39that of uranium. They alter the
- 13:42ecosystem more, emit more greenhouse
- 13:44gases, kill more animals, and most
- 13:46importantly, they have to dig up a much
- 13:48larger quantity, and it is ignored. And
- 13:51for this reason and others we will see
- 13:54later on, renewable energies appear
- 13:56greener than nuclear in certain
- 13:57statistics. Uranium is a very dense
- 14:00energy source, meaning it has a lot of
- 14:03energy per unit of mass. 1 kg of
- 14:05uranium in a reactor produces 45 GW per
- 14:08day. Meanwhile, a 1.5 square meter
- 14:11solar panel, which is roughly the
- 14:14average, produces 0.001 GW per day. To
- 14:17produce the same electricity as 1 kg of
- 14:19uranium, we would need 45,000 solar
- 14:22panels. And for that, we need to mine
- 14:25huge quantities of silicon, nickel,
- 14:27lithium, cadmium, gallium, and other
- 14:29materials used to build these solar
- 14:31panels. Materials that are very
- 14:34polluting to extract, more polluting
- 14:36than uranium. Each 1.5 square meter
- 14:38solar panel weighs around 20 kg. That
- 14:41is 900 tons of solar panels. Just the
- 14:44solar panels, nothing else. 900 tons of
- 14:46silicon, nickel, lithium, cadmium,
- 14:49gallium. Plus, we then have to add the
- 14:52additional weight of the steel,
- 14:54supports, and concrete to anchor the
- 14:56panels, in addition to the fact that
- 14:58this structure will occupy a total
- 15:00space of 6.75 hectares. Have you seen
- 15:03the movie Blade Runner, the new one,
- 15:04the 2049 one? In the movie's intro, you
- 15:08see an expanse of solar farms that
- 15:10stretches as far as the eye can see,
- 15:12well, that movie is not wrong at all.
- 15:15The world would look something like
- 15:17that if we decided to become 100%
- 15:18renewable with current technology. In
- 15:222017, the planet consumed 162.5
- 15:25trillion Wh. To produce that using
- 15:29solar panels, we would need more than
- 15:316.7 billion of them, and those solar
- 15:34panels would cover an area of 10
- 15:36billion square meters. Basically, we
- 15:39would have to turn the entirety of
- 15:40Jamaica into a solar panel, which
- 15:41doesn't seem so bad because Jamaica
- 15:43isn't very big, but ask Jamaica for
- 15:45permission and see if they give it to
- 15:46you. We can do that, or we can build
- 15:501,350 nuclear power plants. They take
- 15:53up less space, pollute less, are
- 15:55cheaper, are safer, and are more
- 15:57durable. Because we have to take into
- 15:59account that the lifespan of a solar
- 16:01panel is 25 years and its battery is 10
- 16:03years, while nuclear power plants have
- 16:05an average lifespan of 40 years.
- 16:08Although the reason nuclear power
- 16:09plants stop operating is not because
- 16:11they break down or no longer work—
- 16:12which sometimes happens, I'm not saying
- 16:14it doesn't—but it really happens
- 16:16because governments shut them down,
- 16:17whether through seizure, by not
- 16:19allowing them to renew their licenses,
- 16:21or because they yield to public and
- 16:22environmentalist pressure, even when
- 16:24they are still perfectly functional and
- 16:26their service life could continue.
- 16:28Anyway, even if it were true that
- 16:30nuclear power plant reactors had
- 16:31reached the end of their service life,
- 16:33they can always be refurbished or
- 16:35replaced with new ones, making the
- 16:37nuclear plant operational for another
- 16:3920 or 40 years. And this is good
- 16:41because a plant that lasts a long time
- 16:43does not generate waste. A reactor
- 16:45thrown away every 60 years is very
- 16:47little waste. And for Masriry, one of
- 16:49the most infamous qualities of nuclear
- 16:51energy is that it leaves a huge amount
- 16:53of waste. But did you know that solar
- 16:55panels produce 300 times more waste?
- 16:58Toxic waste than nuclear plants—not
- 17:00just waste in itself, which they also
- 17:02produce more of, but it is also more
- 17:04toxic than that of nuclear plants. The
- 17:07real problem with nuclear waste, which
- 17:10is not as toxic and is not produced in
- 17:12the quantity they claim, is that it is
- 17:14radioactive, and this scares people a
- 17:16lot, which is another of nuclear
- 17:17energy's advantages. Waste from this
- 17:20type of energy is buried, while other
- 17:22energies dump their waste into the
- 17:24atmosphere and then we breathe it in,
- 17:26or they just leave it lying in
- 17:28landfills. Another lie often repeated
- 17:31by environmentalists is that nuclear
- 17:33energy is on its last legs, that it is
- 17:35coming to an end, and that people have
- 17:37finally realized it is bad and we must
- 17:39close the nuclear reactors.
- 17:41Unfortunately for the environmentalists
- 17:43, that is not the case. Not only is it
- 17:46neither dangerous nor polluting, but it
- 17:48is not dying either. At this very
- 17:50moment, more reactors are being built
- 17:52than are being closed. Between now and
- 17:542040, the construction of 289 reactors
- 17:57is planned, compared to the closure of
- 17:59154. Do the math. They also say that
- 18:04nuclear plants take a very long time to
- 18:06build, even decades, so it is not worth
- 18:08it for the short time they will serve,
- 18:09which is a lie. First, it is worth it;
- 18:13we have already seen before the number
- 18:14of solar panels we would need otherwise
- 18:16. And second, nuclear plants do not
- 18:18take decades to build; they take on
- 18:20average between 40 and 50 months, which
- 18:22is 3 to 4 years. And that is without
- 18:25even having talked about capacity or
- 18:26batteries yet. One of the most
- 18:28essential differences between renewable
- 18:30and fossil energies, besides the fact
- 18:31that they pollute much less, is that
- 18:33they do not operate all the time and
- 18:35cannot regulate the capacity at which
- 18:36they produce electricity. Capacity is
- 18:39the measure that compares the amount of
- 18:41energy being obtained with the maximum
- 18:43amount of energy that can be obtained.
- 18:46In other words, if I have a power plant
- 18:49whose maximum capacity is 100 MWh and
- 18:51that plant is currently generating 50
- 18:53MWh, it is operating at 50%capacity
- 18:55because it is producing half the energy
- 18:57it is capable of generating. Fossil
- 19:01fuels can increase or reduce their
- 19:03output by burning more or less fuel to
- 19:05adapt to electricity demand. If more
- 19:07electricity is needed in a given month,
- 19:09more fuel is burned to meet that demand
- 19:11. If less electricity is needed in a
- 19:13month, less fuel is burned and it is
- 19:14saved. But renewables cannot do that.
- 19:17The production capacity of renewables
- 19:19is at the mercy of the environment. If
- 19:21the wind blows hard, the sun shines
- 19:23bright, or it pours rain, they will
- 19:25produce plenty of energy. But if there
- 19:27is no wind, it gets cloudy, or there is
- 19:29a drought, they will produce little or
- 19:31nothing at all. If it turns out there
- 19:34is a high demand for electricity one
- 19:35day, renewables cannot increase
- 19:37capacity to meet that demand, and if
- 19:39another day there is no electricity
- 19:40demand, renewables cannot decrease
- 19:42their capacity. So that electricity is
- 19:45either stored or lost. But fossil fuels
- 19:49and nuclear energy certainly can. If
- 19:51there is a lack of energy, more uranium
- 19:53is used or more coal is put into the
- 19:54boiler. Is there a surplus? You take it
- 19:56out. It is as simple as that. And
- 19:58renewables cannot do that. That is why
- 20:01renewables are called complementary or
- 20:03intermittent sources, because they are
- 20:05not reliable or constant enough to be
- 20:07considered primary sources. To solve
- 20:11this problem, we can use batteries,
- 20:13storing the surplus energy in batteries
- 20:15to subsequently use that energy when
- 20:18production is low. The problem with
- 20:20batteries is that, first of all, they
- 20:22do not have enough capacity to store
- 20:24the amount of energy required to cover
- 20:27an entire demand. In the United States,
- 20:29which is the country with the second
- 20:31most renewables after China. Yes, China
- 20:33. China
- 20:34is the country with the most renewables
- 20:36. It is somewhat ironic that the most
- 20:39polluting country in the world is the
- 20:40one with the most renewable energy. And
- 20:43the United States is the second most
- 20:45polluting in the world and
- 20:46coincidentally has the second most
- 20:48renewables. And the coincidences
- 20:50continue. India is the third most
- 20:52polluting in the world and ranks fifth
- 20:54in renewables. Russia is fourth and
- 20:57ranks seventh in renewables. Japan is
- 20:59fifth and ranks eighth in renewables.
- 21:02The reason Japan became the
- 21:04fifth-largest polluter in the world is
- 21:06because the vast majority of its
- 21:07reactors were shut down after the
- 21:09Fukushima scare, which is perfectly
- 21:11understandable; but those reactors have
- 21:13not been restarted, and as a result,
- 21:15pollution has soared to historic highs,
- 21:17because all that electrical demand that
- 21:19is no longer being met by nuclear
- 21:21energy has to be supplied somehow, and
- 21:23it is supplied with coal, oil, natural
- 21:25gas, and renewables. And when
- 21:27renewables aren't producing electricity
- 21:29, they have to be backed up by more
- 21:31coal, oil, and natural gas. And then we
- 21:34ask ourselves, why do things happen the
- 21:36way they do? Well, Japan is the
- 21:38fifth-largest polluter in the world.
- 21:40And in Europe, we have Germany, the
- 21:41sixth-largest polluter in the world and
- 21:43the biggest polluter in Europe. And it
- 21:45has the sixth-most renewables in the
- 21:47world. Coincidence? I don't think so.
- 21:50In the state of California, the state
- 21:52with the highest battery storage
- 21:54capacity in the United States, they
- 21:56only have 23 minutes of battery power,
- 21:58including every type of battery: from
- 22:00the batteries at the power plants
- 22:02themselves to car batteries, laptops,
- 22:04even pocket batteries, the double-As
- 22:06and triple-As you put in remote
- 22:08controls and all those things. And with
- 22:10all of those combined, they only have
- 22:1223 minutes of battery power. To be able
- 22:15to depend on these renewables, we need
- 22:17better and larger batteries. Second,
- 22:20batteries take up space and they
- 22:22pollute. Most of the batteries we have
- 22:25are lead-acid and molten salt. More
- 22:27molten salt than lead-acid. These
- 22:29batteries are extremely corrosive, they
- 22:31don't have a very long lifespan, and it
- 22:33is neither recommended nor possible to
- 22:35discharge them completely. Of course,
- 22:38very few statistics that deal with
- 22:40emissions from different energy sources
- 22:42take into account the solid and liquid
- 22:44waste and greenhouse gases produced by
- 22:45batteries, especially the solid and
- 22:47liquid ones. By this, I don't mean that
- 22:50renewables are more polluting than
- 22:51fossil fuels, mind you, because they
- 22:53clearly are not. But we must also take
- 22:56these factors into account; factors
- 22:57almost exclusive to renewable energies
- 22:59that must be considered when drawing
- 23:01conclusions about the pollution emitted
- 23:03by these sources, especially when
- 23:05nuclear energy is being scrutinized
- 23:07under a microscope, while renewables
- 23:09are being given an impressive blind eye
- 23:11. But hey, not everything is bad for
- 23:13renewable energy. Obviously, throughout
- 23:16this last decade, these old batteries
- 23:18have started to be replaced by new
- 23:19lithium-ion ones. Lithium-ion batteries
- 23:23have the advantage of storing more
- 23:24energy, they can be fully recharged or
- 23:26discharged without shortening their
- 23:27lifespan, and they aren't as dangerous,
- 23:29as they are less corrosive. The fact is
- 23:32that lithium batteries require much
- 23:33less maintenance than lead-acid ones.
- 23:36They have more than three times the
- 23:38specific energy, more than triple the
- 23:40energy density, 50%more specific power,
- 23:42and higher charge and discharge
- 23:44efficiency. They lose much less charge
- 23:47over time and have a longer service
- 23:49life. Joy, well that's great, isn't it?
- 23:52Well, if they really are that good, why
- 23:53don't we switch to those batteries once
- 23:55and for all? Why do we keep using
- 23:57lead-acid and molten salt ones? Let's
- 24:00switch already, right? The problem with
- 24:02these batteries is that they are
- 24:04somewhat expensive. Lithium batteries
- 24:07are five times more expensive per unit
- 24:09of capacity, and as a result,
- 24:10electricity ends up being slightly more
- 24:12expensive. It is worth noting that this
- 24:16year they are developing new lithium
- 24:18batteries capable of providing energy
- 24:21in a price range between $ 150 to $ 200
- 24:23per kWh, which will likely be ready by
- 24:262020 or 2022, give or take. When that
- 24:29day comes, there will be no reason to
- 24:31choose acid batteries over lithium ones
- 24:32, but for now, the batteries we have
- 24:34pollute less in exchange for being more
- 24:36expensive. And that is the third point:
- 24:39the price. Environmentalists are
- 24:41willing to pay more for electricity in
- 24:43exchange for polluting less. And that's
- 24:45fine, as long as you have the money to
- 24:47pay for that price increase and, of
- 24:49course, as long as you want to. For
- 24:52first-world countries, this isn't such
- 24:54a serious problem, quote-unquote,
- 24:56because I can pay the increase, but I'm
- 24:58not thrilled about having gone from
- 24:59paying € 40 to € 65 a month because
- 25:01of renewables, especially when they
- 25:03were supposed to be there to reduce
- 25:05pollution, and what they’ve done is
- 25:07not only increase pollution but also
- 25:09the price. So, thank you very much,
- 25:12environmentalists. But what about poor
- 25:14countries? The underdeveloped, the
- 25:16non-industrialized ones. Those
- 25:18countries cannot afford the luxury of
- 25:19installing such expensive energy
- 25:21sources. Those countries continue to
- 25:23use coal and oil, not because they
- 25:24don't give a damn about the environment
- 25:26—they might, I'm not saying they
- 25:28don't—but they use them because they
- 25:29are a faster and cheaper energy source.
- 25:33But environmentalists argue that we
- 25:34have to deal with it, that we must make
- 25:36the sacrifice of paying more to pollute
- 25:38less and wait for the day when
- 25:39renewables are cheap and profitable.
- 25:42Hold on in there, come on, it's okay,
- 25:44just hang in until it arrives. But that
- 25:47sacrifice isn't necessary; there's no
- 25:50need to wait because right now, we have
- 25:53an energy production method that is
- 25:56cheaper and pollutes less than
- 25:58renewables: nuclear energy. Not only
- 26:03that, it's also safer, works all the
- 26:05time, generates more power in less time
- 26:07, and can adapt to the grid's needs,
- 26:09yet environmentalists don't want it.
- 26:13Nuclear energy would not only meet the
- 26:15goals of environmentalists—preserving
- 26:17the environment and reducing pollution
- 26:19—but it would also provide a source
- 26:21of green, cheap energy for poor
- 26:22countries that want to join the fight
- 26:24against climate change, because
- 26:26renewables are quite expensive;
- 26:27especially solar, which is by far the
- 26:29most expensive. Over the last few years
- 26:33, the cost of wind energy has dropped
- 26:35considerably, reaching parity with or
- 26:37even falling below nuclear. Although
- 26:41many websites tell us that renewables,
- 26:43especially solar—which is the most
- 26:45expensive—are cheaper than any other
- 26:47type of energy, that they are the
- 26:49panacea of life, the energy
- 26:51quintessence, if you will. Well, if
- 26:53that were true, if they were really
- 26:55that cheap, don't you think we would
- 26:57have already rushed to switch to those
- 26:59energies? We aren't that foolish, right
- 27:01? If they are cheaper, cleaner, and
- 27:04safer, why are we here wasting time
- 27:06with coal? Environmentalists believe
- 27:10the reason we haven't managed to make
- 27:12this transition to renewables is that
- 27:13the government is against it, that the
- 27:15government doesn't want to, but the
- 27:16government has been subsidizing these
- 27:18energies for a long time, at least here
- 27:20in Spain. In fact, the huge rise in
- 27:22electricity prices in Spain was due to
- 27:24Zapatero's renewable bubble, which
- 27:26resulted in losses of 740 million euros
- 27:28. And it is estimated that the losses
- 27:30could amount to as much as 8.1 billion
- 27:32euros. And today, politicians like
- 27:34Sánchez or Errejón continue to
- 27:36support renewables. Take a look at what
- 27:39Más País said in its Green Agreement
- 27:41for Spain. We propose an ecological and
- 27:44feminist reform of national accounting
- 27:46based on two key points. First, we will
- 27:49displace GDP from the center of gravity
- 27:51of economic action. Second, also
- 27:54through a parliamentary commission, we
- 27:56will introduce a biophysical accounting
- 27:59system parallel to monetary accounting
- 28:01that allows us to locate and intervene
- 28:04in processes of environmental damage
- 28:06externalization, metabolic tensions,
- 28:08and hidden psychological burdens that
- 28:11do not fit within the narrowed economic
- 28:13rationality of the price system. Damn,
- 28:17this looks like Pokémon, doesn't it?
- 28:20You found a hidden eco-backpack.
- 28:23Squirtle can't learn HM07. Well, blow
- 28:27me down, blow me down, blow me down. If
- 28:31this isn't some hippie nonsense. This
- 28:33is clearly a coded, flute-playing
- 28:35environmentalist mating call. Merkel
- 28:39subsidized renewables, so did Obama,
- 28:41Zapatero, Sánchez. And they do it,
- 28:43right? Because they care about the
- 28:44environment. No, sir. Mr. Falconetti
- 28:47doesn't give a damn about polluting to
- 28:49go to The Killers 'concert. They do it
- 28:51because they want your vote, and if
- 28:52pushing renewables sells votes, even if
- 28:54it hikes up electricity prices and
- 28:56pollutes more, they're going to do it.
- 28:57Because, what does it matter? What does
- 28:59it matter? They don't care. They don't
- 29:01care about the environment; they care
- 29:03about your vote. Another reason you
- 29:07think we aren't transitioning is
- 29:08because oil companies inject tons of
- 29:10money to buy off bureaucrats and
- 29:12brainwash us with propaganda so we keep
- 29:13supporting them and yada yada yada. Let
- 29:17me tell you a secret, my dear viewer.
- 29:20There is no one more interested in
- 29:21renewables on this planet than oil
- 29:23companies. The more renewables there
- 29:25are, the less competition they have.
- 29:28And since renewables don't produce all
- 29:30the time, they have to meet the demand
- 29:32with oil because we don't want nuclear,
- 29:34right? And who sells the oil? That's
- 29:37right. It’s just like drug
- 29:39traffickers and arms smugglers. They
- 29:41are the first ones interested in
- 29:43keeping drugs and weapons illegal. That
- 29:46way, you're forced to buy what they
- 29:47offer, from no one but them, at
- 29:49whatever price they feel like. The
- 29:51reason we don't switch entirely to
- 29:53renewables is because all these
- 29:55statistics don't take into account
- 29:56other factors like batteries. Here is a
- 29:59chart that does take batteries into
- 30:01account. See how the price of
- 30:02renewables skyrockets when the cost and
- 30:04maintenance of batteries are included.
- 30:09Another reason this happens is because
- 30:11the government subsidizes these
- 30:12energies by paying for part of the
- 30:14construction and part of the electric
- 30:16bill, in addition to placing fees and
- 30:18other taxes on fossil fuels and nuclear
- 30:20energy to discourage their use, which
- 30:22apparently doesn't work. If we look at
- 30:26the cost of energy, some renewables,
- 30:28even with the discount, are still more
- 30:31expensive than nuclear. This is why we
- 30:34don't finish the transition to
- 30:35renewable energies. Because of that and
- 30:37because they don't work all the time.
- 30:40As we said before, renewable energies
- 30:42cannot regulate their capacity, except
- 30:44for hydroelectric. But beyond that,
- 30:46renewable energies cannot choose when
- 30:48to operate and when not to. The
- 30:50windmill will only spin when there is
- 30:52wind. If there is no wind, it doesn't
- 30:53spin. If it gets cloudy, rains, if
- 30:56it’s nighttime, or if it’s winter,
- 30:58the panel will get very little energy.
- 31:01And this is the real problem with
- 31:02renewables: they are intermittent
- 31:04energy sources. Solar and wind energy
- 31:07only operate between 10 and 30%of the
- 31:09time. This means that for the remaining
- 31:12time when these energies are not
- 31:13working, that lack of energy production
- 31:15must be covered by generating
- 31:17electricity through another method. And
- 31:19since nuclear energy is so hated and
- 31:21nobody wants it, it is supplemented
- 31:23with other energies. Which energies?
- 31:25Coal, natural gas, and oil. Highly
- 31:28polluting energies. So, because
- 31:31renewables don't work all the time,
- 31:33pollution increases to make up for that
- 31:35energy deficit. And this is exactly
- 31:38what has happened in Germany and Japan;
- 31:40by closing nuclear plants and
- 31:42increasing renewables, that demand is
- 31:44met by burning fossil fuels that
- 31:46increase pollution. Let's look at
- 31:49Europe. Let's compare France with
- 31:51Germany, the most nuclear country in
- 31:52Europe and the world, with the most
- 31:54renewable country in Europe and the
- 31:56sixth in the world. France gets 72%of
- 31:59its energy from nuclear power plants,
- 32:01while Germany gets 13%. France gets 18%
- 32:05of its energy from renewables, while
- 32:07Germany gets 47%. In the last 10 years,
- 32:11France closed one nuclear reactor, one
- 32:13in 2010, while Germany closed 10: 8 in
- 32:162011 in response to Fukushima, one in
- 32:182015, and another in 2017. The result
- 32:22of these decisions was that France
- 32:24reduced pollution by 15%, while Germany
- 32:26reduced it by 2%. And not only that,
- 32:29the German electricity bill rose to
- 32:327.23 €/kWh, while in France it was
- 32:345.16. Furthermore, France became the
- 32:37fourth least polluting country in
- 32:39Europe, while Germany is the most
- 32:41polluting in Europe and the sixth in
- 32:42the world. Coincidence? I don't think
- 32:45so. It is as simple as this, gentlemen.
- 32:48The evidence is on the table, the cards
- 32:50are face up. Clearly, nuclear energy is
- 32:53safer, cheaper, more efficient, and
- 32:56greener. When has there been a nuclear
- 32:58catastrophe in France? And it is the
- 33:00most nuclear country. When has there
- 33:02been one in Sweden, Hungary, Spain,
- 33:03Switzerland, the United Kingdom,
- 33:05Slovakia, or Korea? What’s more, how
- 33:08many nuclear catastrophes do you know
- 33:09of? How many? Probably Chernobyl and
- 33:12Fukushima, nothing more. The well-read
- 33:15might know about Three Mile Island, and
- 33:17the absolute soccer superstars might
- 33:19know about Kyshtym. But that’s it.
- 33:22There really isn't much more to it.
- 33:25There have only been 10 cases in the
- 33:27entire history of nuclear energy where
- 33:29radiation escaped from the reactor, and
- 33:31only two are serious: Chernobyl and
- 33:33Fukushima. The fear of nuclear energy
- 33:36comes from, well, not knowing how it
- 33:38works, and that's normal; we are all
- 33:41afraid of or cautious about the unknown
- 33:43. But to lose that fear, you have to
- 33:46venture out and understand what scares
- 33:47you so you can grasp it and stop being
- 33:49afraid, or just to know if you need to
- 33:51run for your life before everything
- 33:52blows up. So let’s explain how a
- 33:55nuclear power plant works, specifically
- 33:56a reactor, which is where the magic
- 33:58happens. There are quite a few reactor
- 34:01models, but the most common are the
- 34:03pressurized water reactor, the boiling
- 34:05water reactor, and the pressurized
- 34:07heavy water reactor. We are going to
- 34:10look at how the pressurized water
- 34:11reactor works, as it is the most common
- 34:12. The reactor is divided into three
- 34:14circuits. The first circuit where
- 34:16uranium is fissioned, the second
- 34:18circuit where electricity is generated,
- 34:20and the third circuit that cools the
- 34:22second circuit. The first circuit
- 34:25begins in the reactor. The reactor
- 34:27contains uranium and water, and that
- 34:28water heats up thanks to the fission of
- 34:30the uranium. Fission, which shouldn't
- 34:32be confused with fusion—they are
- 34:34different things. Fission is the
- 34:36nuclear reaction that causes an atom to
- 34:38split into two or more new atoms. To
- 34:41differentiate them easily, fission is
- 34:44division and fusion is union. That’s
- 34:47a good way to remember it, since it
- 34:48rhymes. Fission, division; fusion,
- 34:50union. And the reason uranium is chosen
- 34:53is that it's the only visible natural
- 34:54element, although not all uranium.
- 34:56Watch out, you can't just take the rock
- 34:58, throw it in the reactor, and presto,
- 35:00energy. No, no, you can't do that. We
- 35:03need a specific isotope. Natural
- 35:05uranium is mainly composed of three
- 35:07isotopes. Uranium-234, uranium-235, and
- 35:11uranium-238. The one we are interested
- 35:15in is uranium-235, as it is the only
- 35:17naturally fissile isotope. In other
- 35:19words, uranium is not only the only
- 35:21fissile element, but only one isotope
- 35:23of that single fissile element—only
- 35:25one of those isotopes—is fissile as
- 35:27well. When a uranium-235 isotope
- 35:30receives a neutron, it fissions and
- 35:32splits into two atoms, while also
- 35:34releasing two or three neutrons. These
- 35:37neutrons will collide with other
- 35:39uranium-235 isotopes, which in turn
- 35:41will split and collide with others, and
- 35:43so on until everything has fissioned.
- 35:46That is a nuclear reaction. But as we
- 35:48have seen before, uranium-235 is quite
- 35:50scarce. Generally, the concentration of
- 35:53uranium in uranium ore ranges between
- 35:560.05%and 0.5%. And of that small
- 35:59portion, only uranium-235, which is
- 36:01what we are interested in, accounts for
- 36:030.72%. That is to say, from 1 kg of
- 36:08uranium ore we get 5 g of uranium, and
- 36:11of those 5 g of uranium, only 36 mg are
- 36:14uranium-235. In other words, get ready
- 36:17to wear out your diamond pickaxe mining
- 36:18uranium. Well, they're going to add
- 36:20something now that's going to be better
- 36:21, right? They were going to update the
- 36:22game, they were going to add...uh,
- 36:25netherite, that's it, you're going to
- 36:27wear out your Netherite pickaxe. Well,
- 36:29what does it matter? you're going to
- 36:30wear out your pickaxe. Back to the
- 36:33subject, since uranium has such a low
- 36:35concentration of the uranium-235
- 36:36isotope, to be used in a reactor we
- 36:38have to increase its concentration. To
- 36:41do this, the uranium is enriched,
- 36:43meaning more uranium-235 is
- 36:45artificially added to the uranium until
- 36:48it reaches 5%of its total mass. This
- 36:51enriched uranium is compacted into tiny
- 36:53cylinders. That cylinder, which is
- 36:56called a pellet, is the nuclear fuel.
- 36:58And those pellets are subsequently
- 37:00stacked in a battery to be inserted
- 37:02into zirconium tubes. The reason
- 37:05zirconium is used is because it is a
- 37:07metal very resistant to heat and
- 37:09corrosion, and it allows neutrons to
- 37:11pass freely through the material. Once
- 37:14those tubes are filled and assembled,
- 37:16they are called fuel rods. Those rods
- 37:19are grouped together with other rods
- 37:21into a larger group. That group is
- 37:23called an assembly, and those
- 37:24assemblies are the final product that
- 37:26is introduced into the reactor. When
- 37:29all the fuel assemblies are introduced
- 37:31into the reactor, it is filled with
- 37:33water and turned on, emitting a very
- 37:35cool blue glow, honestly. I bet you
- 37:38didn't know radiation was blue; I bet
- 37:40you thought it was green. Man, you've
- 37:42watched too much The Simpsons, haven't
- 37:43you? The uranium-235 in the fuel will
- 37:46begin to fission, releasing neutrons
- 37:48that will collide with more uranium-235
- 37:50, and so on, creating a chain reaction.
- 37:53This activity, this agitation in the
- 37:55water, will cause the water to heat up
- 37:57to about 300ºC, and thanks to a
- 37:59pressurizer that increases the circuit
- 38:01pressure, the water is prevented from
- 38:04evaporating. This water will be moved
- 38:06through the circuit by a pump that will
- 38:08bring the water to the steam
- 38:10generator's radiator. The radiator will
- 38:13heat the water in the second circuit
- 38:15until it boils, and that steam will
- 38:17pass through a duct that will spin a
- 38:19turbine. And this turbine, which is
- 38:22connected to a part in a generator,
- 38:23will cause electricity to be produced
- 38:25as it spins. Afterward, that same steam
- 38:28will reach the condenser where it will
- 38:30cool down and condense. That is where
- 38:33the condenser gets its name, and it
- 38:35condenses thanks to a third circuit
- 38:37that, with the help of a pump, brings
- 38:39in cold water from a cooling tower, the
- 38:41sea, a lake, a river, or whatever,
- 38:43cooling the water vapor until it
- 38:44condenses. And the water from the third
- 38:48circuit that has been heated will be
- 38:50returned to the cooling tower or
- 38:51expelled into the sea, river, or
- 38:53whatever, and the water from the
- 38:54condenser will be moved again by a
- 38:56water pump to the steam generator,
- 38:58completing the cycle. Very well,
- 39:01everything is correct. But, what about
- 39:03the radiation? Doesn't it escape from
- 39:05the reactor and cause people to die or
- 39:06the water to become toxic or something
- 39:07like that? No, no, man. The reactor is
- 39:11shielded and prevents almost all
- 39:12radiation from escaping. The radiation
- 39:15right next to the wall of a fully
- 39:17operational reactor is barely higher
- 39:19than natural radiation. In any case,
- 39:21the radiation emitted by the reactor is
- 39:23generally alpha. This type of radiation
- 39:26is stopped by a few centimeters of air.
- 39:28It is also unable to pass through
- 39:30clothing or skin, so don't worry. Okay,
- 39:33but can't the reaction get out of
- 39:35control without adult supervision? Yes,
- 39:38obviously it can get out of control. To
- 39:41keep the reaction under control,
- 39:43reactors insert or withdraw control
- 39:45rods between spaces reserved in the
- 39:48fuel elements. These rods are normally
- 39:51made of boron or cadmium, and the
- 39:53reason they are made of that material
- 39:54is because they are capable of catching
- 39:56loose neutrons. That is to say, they
- 39:59are used like a fishing net. If there
- 40:01is too much activity, if the reaction
- 40:03is stronger than it should be, these
- 40:04rods are inserted and they fish for the
- 40:06neutrons, trapping them and preventing
- 40:08them from colliding with more uranium-
- 40:09235, slowing down the reaction. If the
- 40:12reaction is too low, is very little,
- 40:14they are withdrawn to allow more
- 40:16neutrons to collide with uranium-235,
- 40:18increasing the reaction. Okay, okay,
- 40:20but what about the radioactive water
- 40:21they dump into the sea? They don't dump
- 40:23radioactive water into the sea.
- 40:24Radioactive water is never dumped into
- 40:26the sea or into any natural water
- 40:27source, ever. The water in contact with
- 40:29the uranium is in a separate circuit
- 40:31and is never discharged into the sea.
- 40:34Besides that, all circuits are properly
- 40:36isolated to minimize contamination
- 40:38outside the uranium circuit, and the
- 40:40reactor and cooling circuits never meet
- 40:42, preventing the sea water and reactor
- 40:44water from mixing and becoming
- 40:46contaminated in any way. The water used
- 40:49for cooling either evaporates in the
- 40:52cooling towers or is discharged into
- 40:54the sea, and that water is the same
- 40:56that entered, exactly the same, only
- 40:58warmer, nothing else, absolutely
- 40:59nothing else. And the reactor water,
- 41:02the kind that is radioactive or may
- 41:04contain traces of radioactive materials
- 41:06, is quickly and effectively
- 41:08decontaminated after use. Later on, we
- 41:10will delve deeper into nuclear waste
- 41:12and its treatment, which I believe is
- 41:14the part that concerns everyone the
- 41:15most. But now let's talk about
- 41:18radiation. First, we have to clarify
- 41:20what radioactive, radioactivity, and
- 41:22radiation are. Radioactive is something
- 41:24that emits radiation. Everything,
- 41:28absolutely everything, is radioactive,
- 41:30from the hairs in your nose to the red
- 41:32ink in your bank account. But not
- 41:34everything is equally radioactive. Some
- 41:36things are more radioactive and others
- 41:38are less radioactive. That is what we
- 41:41use radioactivity for. Radioactivity
- 41:43itself is the capacity to emit
- 41:45radiation, nothing more. That is its
- 41:48definition, the capacity to emit
- 41:49radiation, but it is also used to
- 41:51measure the intensity of the radiation.
- 41:53Depending on the amount of radiation an
- 41:55object emits over a period of time, it
- 41:57can be classified as a high, medium, or
- 42:00low radioactivity material. And finally
- 42:02, radiation is the propagation of waves
- 42:05or a set of particles emitted by a
- 42:07radioactive material. In other words,
- 42:10radioactive means it emits radiation.
- 42:12Radioactivity is the intensity,
- 42:14although it can also be used as the
- 42:16capacity to emit. And radiation is the
- 42:19propagation. And radiation can be of
- 42:21several types. It can be
- 42:23electromagnetic like a microwave,
- 42:26corpuscular like photons, gravitational
- 42:28like that of your obesity, or acoustic,
- 42:36like music. The music you listen to is
- 42:39a type of radiation; that doesn't mean
- 42:41the guitar is radioactive—which it is
- 42:42, it is, because everything, absolutely
- 42:44everything, is radioactive—but it's
- 42:46not radioactive enough for playing it
- 42:47to give you cancer. Well, it depends a
- 42:50bit on the song. There are some songs
- 42:51that are a bit carcinogenic, but there
- 42:54shouldn't be any danger. Radiation can
- 42:56be divided into two types: ionizing
- 42:58radiation and non-ionizing radiation.
- 43:01Ionizing radiation, as the name
- 43:03suggests, ionizes. You've surely heard
- 43:05this about some hairdryer or some fan
- 43:07or something like that. It has the
- 43:09capacity to ionize or something of the
- 43:10sort. What ionization does is ionize
- 43:14atoms; that is, the radiation's energy
- 43:16strips away or adds electrons, altering
- 43:18their charge and making them more
- 43:20positive or more negative. That is
- 43:24ionization: changing the charge of an
- 43:25atom. This radiation, if it penetrates
- 43:28the body, is capable of damaging
- 43:30genetic material, the DNA of our cells,
- 43:31by ionizing it, which is why it is
- 43:33dangerous. While non-ionizing radiation
- 43:36is not ionizing. I think this was
- 43:38obvious, no need to say it. The source
- 43:40of ionizing radiation we are usually
- 43:42exposed to is ultraviolet light, well
- 43:43known for coming from the sun. It is
- 43:46useful for both getting a tan and for
- 43:48finding blood at a crime scene. I mean,
- 43:51there are people who like to do little
- 43:53things to a person once they kill them.
- 43:56Those things happen. As you may already
- 43:59know, being exposed to the sun for a
- 44:01long time causes burns, in addition to
- 44:02potentially causing skin cancer. And
- 44:04that is because ultraviolet light is
- 44:06both ionizing and non-ionizing.
- 44:09Ultraviolet light is divided into three
- 44:11groups: UVA rays, UVB rays, and UVC
- 44:14rays. UVA rays are not ionizing
- 44:17radiation, but UVB and UVC rays are.
- 44:21UVA rays make up 95%of the ultraviolet
- 44:23radiation that reaches us from the sun.
- 44:26This radiation is not ionizing, but it
- 44:29produces burns after a period of
- 44:31exposure. It's as if you were cooking
- 44:34on low heat, slowly but surely. Well
- 44:36done. This type of radiation, even
- 44:39though it cannot damage DNA, can lead
- 44:41to skin cancer, such as melanomas. UVB
- 44:44rays are indeed ionizing. These make up
- 44:475%of the radiation that reaches us from
- 44:49the sun and are the main culprits
- 44:51behind skin cancer. And despite being
- 44:53less dangerous than any other type of
- 44:55ionizing radiation, it is the one that
- 44:57causes the most deaths, more than
- 44:59X-rays and radiation from nuclear
- 45:00reactors and their waste. And that is
- 45:02because we are exposed to it all day
- 45:04long, literally, because if there is no
- 45:06sun, there is no day. Remember that the
- 45:08dose makes the poison, meaning that
- 45:10going out in public without clothes—I
- 45:12don't know why you'd want to do that,
- 45:14but anyway—going out in summer
- 45:15without clothes poses a higher cancer
- 45:17risk than living inside a nuclear power
- 45:19plant. And UVC rays are completely
- 45:22stopped by the ozone layer. The one
- 45:24that was being destroyed a few decades
- 45:26ago and we were all going to die or
- 45:27something like that. What happened to
- 45:29it? It wasn't being destroyed. Well,
- 45:31anyway. Thanks to that layer, UVC rays
- 45:33don't reach the Earth's surface, and
- 45:35although they aren't as dangerous to
- 45:37the skin as UVB, they are more harmful
- 45:38to your eyesight. In fact, welders are
- 45:41sources of those rays. You already know
- 45:43you can't look at them without a mask.
- 45:45They leave you blind, although I have
- 45:46actually done it and looked at welders
- 45:48without a mask because I'm that foolish
- 45:49. But anyway, let's move on to the real
- 45:52ionizing kind. Alpha particles,
- 45:55produced mostly by natural decay and
- 45:57nuclear reactors, also only travel a
- 45:59few centimeters through the air before
- 46:01stopping and cannot penetrate skin,
- 46:03clothing, or paper; so it's harmless,
- 46:05unless you eat what is emitting that
- 46:07radiation, in which case you should
- 46:09start writing your will. If radioactive
- 46:13material enters the body through wounds
- 46:15, ingestion, or inhalation, depending
- 46:17on how large the dose is, you might
- 46:19experience radiation poisoning.
- 46:21Radiation poisoning is characterized by
- 46:23nausea, vomiting, diarrhea, and loss of
- 46:25appetite. It can damage DNA
- 46:27irreversibly and, in the worst-case
- 46:30scenario, you die. Although with alpha
- 46:33radiation, unless it's a very large
- 46:35dose, you won't suffer the symptoms of
- 46:37radiation poisoning. You'll just
- 46:39develop cancer. Just nothing serious.
- 46:44Curiously, alpha radiation damages DNA
- 46:46about 20 times more than beta, but it
- 46:48cannot penetrate the skin. So as long
- 46:51as it doesn't get into a wound, you
- 46:52don't breathe it in, or you don't eat
- 46:54it, nothing will happen. The most
- 46:56common natural source of alpha
- 46:58radiation we are exposed to is radon
- 46:59gas. Radon is produced naturally by the
- 47:03decay of uranium. If your house is on
- 47:05land that contains uranium, no matter
- 47:07how deep it is, the gas will seep to
- 47:09the surface and be trapped in rooms,
- 47:12usually in basements or garages, since
- 47:14radon gas is heavier than air. And if
- 47:16you breathe it continuously, your risk
- 47:18of cancer will increase. It can also
- 47:20filter into aquifers and come out mixed
- 47:22with tap water, as it is soluble. And
- 47:24this is why radon is the second leading
- 47:26cause of lung cancer in the world. I
- 47:28bet you don't know what number one is:
- 47:30smoking. To no one's surprise, smoking
- 47:32is bad. Go figure. It's so bad that
- 47:35it's more radioactive than radon. It's
- 47:37so bad that it's worse than plutonium.
- 47:40Tobacco contains lead and polonium.
- 47:42Polonium is even worse than plutonium,
- 47:44and you're putting it into your lungs
- 47:46daily. It's not for nothing that
- 47:47tobacco is the number one cause of lung
- 47:49cancer. You are putting radioactive
- 47:51material in yourself by choice,
- 47:52material that is more radioactive than
- 47:54some nuclear waste. If we compare it to
- 47:57radon, a small part of the radon you
- 47:59breathe stays in your lungs, but nearly
- 48:0150%of the lead and polonium you inhale
- 48:03when smoking stays inside them. The
- 48:07most durable radon isotope is radon-222
- 48:09, which has a half-life of 3 days,
- 48:11while lead-210 has a half-life of 22
- 48:13years. The half-life, also known as the
- 48:17decay period, which I'm sure you
- 48:19recognize from the game, is the time it
- 48:21takes for half of the atoms in an
- 48:23element to decay. The reason this
- 48:27measurement is used is because the
- 48:28first half of the atoms decays the
- 48:30fastest. In other words, it doesn't all
- 48:32decay at once, just like that overnight
- 48:34. Decay is a gradual process, and the
- 48:37more that has decayed, the slower the
- 48:39remainder decays. And not content with
- 48:43that, polonium-210 decays into lead-206
- 48:46, a stable lead isotope, meaning it
- 48:48doesn't decay any further. And lead-210
- 48:51decays into bismuth-210, which after 5
- 48:54days decays into polonium-210, and this
- 48:57polonium-210 into lead-206. And this
- 49:00lead-206 stays in your lungs forever,
- 49:02and lead is toxic. So, think about what
- 49:05you're doing every time you smoke a
- 49:07cigarette. And I'm not doing this so
- 49:09you quit smoking—I already know
- 49:10you're not going to quit—but so that
- 49:12you know. Because I don't want you to
- 49:14die. I want you alive because I value
- 49:16you, and I especially need you to watch
- 49:18my videos because dead people don't
- 49:20watch videos. Let's move on to the next
- 49:22particle. The beta particle. The beta
- 49:24particle is also produced by natural
- 49:26decay and to a lesser extent by nuclear
- 49:29waste. This radiation is stopped by the
- 49:32air after a few meters and is capable
- 49:34of penetrating a few millimeters of
- 49:35skin; therefore, if you are going to
- 49:37work near a radioactive source of this
- 49:39type, it is recommended to wear some
- 49:40protection over it: a sheet of aluminum
- 49:42foil, plexiglass, or even water is more
- 49:44than enough. This radiation, like all
- 49:48ionizing radiation, damages DNA,
- 49:50although 20 times less than alpha, as
- 49:52we saw before, so its harmful
- 49:53properties are more controllable and it
- 49:55can be used to eliminate cancer in
- 49:57radiation therapies. That radiation can
- 50:00be focused on the point where the
- 50:02cancer is and, through the radiation,
- 50:04destroy the DNA of the cancer cells.
- 50:08X-rays, which are used by doctors to
- 50:09see bone fractures or if you have a
- 50:11screw loose, are also produced by the
- 50:13sun, although they are stopped by the
- 50:15atmosphere, just like UV rays. X-rays
- 50:18travel several meters through the air
- 50:21and require a minimum of 1 mm of lead
- 50:23to be stopped. They are more harmful to
- 50:26health than alpha and beta radiation,
- 50:28but practically if it weren't for the
- 50:29doctor, we wouldn't be exposed to any
- 50:31significant or dangerous source of
- 50:33X-rays throughout our lives. It should
- 50:36be noted that X-rays are classified as
- 50:38carcinogenic. Several consecutive head
- 50:41X-rays can be quite dangerous, from
- 50:43hair loss to cancer. Although the
- 50:46enormous benefits that these X-rays
- 50:48provide compensate for the possible
- 50:50side effects, it's better to risk dying
- 50:52a little, I guess. And finally, gamma
- 50:56rays. This radiation usually comes
- 50:58mainly from nuclear waste resulting
- 51:00from nuclear fission. This radiation is
- 51:02the most dangerous of all. It travels
- 51:04quite a few meters and passes through
- 51:05our body completely, and therefore
- 51:07affects it in its entirety. Depending
- 51:09on the radioactivity, several materials
- 51:11are used to stop it, generally half a
- 51:13meter of lead or 2 meters of concrete.
- 51:16These are the famous nuclear wastes
- 51:18that are buried at I don't know what
- 51:19depth and in the middle of nowhere. It
- 51:22should be noted that all types of
- 51:24ionizing radiation will produce similar
- 51:26damage. There is no water-type,
- 51:28fire-type, or plant-type radiation.
- 51:30What determines the damage you will
- 51:32suffer is where that radiation hit you,
- 51:34how much, and how deep it penetrated.
- 51:36Remember that the dose is what makes
- 51:37the poison. It doesn't matter so much
- 51:39which type of radiation, but where and
- 51:40how much your body absorbs. And this is
- 51:42what we are going to see now. Radiation
- 51:45has many ways of being measured:
- 51:46becquerels, curies, rems, grays, but
- 51:48the one we are interested in is
- 51:50sieverts. The sievert measures the
- 51:53amount of ionizing radiation absorbed
- 51:55by the body, sort of like calories, but
- 51:58for ionizing radiation; the larger the
- 52:00dose, the more dangerous it will be. A
- 52:03dose is an abnormal radiation exposure
- 52:05in a short amount of time, generally
- 52:08less than an hour. Let's look at a
- 52:10chart to get an idea of how much is
- 52:12dangerous. From 0.05 to one sievert, we
- 52:15have a low risk of cancer, anemia, and
- 52:17headaches, with no mortal risk. From
- 52:21one to two sieverts, we have a cancer
- 52:23risk, nausea, loss of appetite, and
- 52:25fatigue, in addition to the previous
- 52:27ones. And we have a 10%chance of dying
- 52:29within a month. From two to four
- 52:32sieverts, we have a cancer guarantee,
- 52:34vomiting, sterility, leukopenia, hair
- 52:37loss, and all of the above, plus a 35%
- 52:39chance of dying within a month. From
- 52:43four to six sieverts, we have internal
- 52:45hemorrhaging, infections, diarrhea, and
- 52:46the previous symptoms. And on top of
- 52:49that, a 50%chance of kicking the bucket
- 52:51within a month. From 6 to 10, we have
- 52:53all of the above, plus destruction of
- 52:55gastric tissue and bone marrow
- 52:57destruction, in addition to a
- 52:58guaranteed death in less than two weeks
- 53:00. From 10 to 50, we have hypotension,
- 53:03intense diarrhea, delirium and
- 53:05hallucinations, water loss, and coma,
- 53:07plus a 100%guarantee of death in less
- 53:09than a week. And from 50 sieverts on,
- 53:13we have all of the above, plus tremors,
- 53:16convulsions, ataxia, death, just plain
- 53:18death, 100%guaranteed death at any
- 53:21moment. If you survive, we'll give you
- 53:23your money back. So, now that we know
- 53:25what radiation does, let's look at the
- 53:28radiation produced by a nuclear reactor
- 53:30. If you live for a year near a nuclear
- 53:33power plant, let's say less than 1 km
- 53:36away, the radiation increase is one
- 53:38microsievert per year. One microsievert
- 53:41, that means you receive 0.000001
- 53:47sieverts a year. The Earth's natural
- 53:51radiation is 0.3 microsieverts per hour
- 53:53. In other words, by living 3 hours in
- 53:56your bedroom, you have already received
- 53:57the same radiation as if you lived next
- 53:59to a nuclear power plant for an entire
- 54:01year. Even being next to a fully
- 54:03operational nuclear reactor, you are
- 54:05still not in danger. A reactor only
- 54:08increases radiation by 0.1
- 54:09microsieverts per hour. But that is
- 54:12nothing compared to a plane, because if
- 54:14you have traveled on a plane during the
- 54:16day, the radiation multiplies by 10,
- 54:18rising above 3 microsieverts per hour.
- 54:22In Fukushima, areas with more than two
- 54:24microsieverts per hour are considered
- 54:26uninhabitable. Meanwhile, our friends
- 54:29the pilots spend their lives at three
- 54:31microsieverts per hour, and there are
- 54:32even worse cases. On the International
- 54:36Space Station, astronauts are exposed
- 54:38to 20 microsieverts per hour, and the
- 54:41average stay for astronauts is 6 months
- 54:43. In other words, during those 6 months
- 54:46, they receive 60 times the natural
- 54:48radiation. Meanwhile, down here on
- 54:50Earth, we have these paranoid
- 54:52environmentalists closing nuclear power
- 54:54plants because they receive one
- 54:56microsievert per year. There are also
- 54:59radioactive foods, more radioactive
- 55:00than a nuclear power plant. Potatoes,
- 55:03beans, avocados, beer. Eating a banana
- 55:07involves a dose of 0.1 microsieverts.
- 55:1010 bananas is the same radiation as
- 55:11living near a nuclear power plant for a
- 55:13whole year. A 100g serving of Brazil
- 55:16nuts, which, by the way, are delicious.
- 55:19100g of Brazil nuts equals 10
- 55:21microsieverts, which is 1000 bananas or
- 55:23100 years of a nuclear plant, or better
- 55:25yet, one hour of exposure in the
- 55:27immediate vicinity of the Fukushima
- 55:30plant on the day of the accident. A
- 55:33cigarette equals 0.1 microsieverts, the
- 55:35same as a banana, but as we saw before,
- 55:3750%of the radioactive material in the
- 55:39cigarette stays in the lungs. That
- 55:42means that with every cigarette you
- 55:43smoke, you are constantly increasing
- 55:45your radiation. The average amount of
- 55:47tobacco smoked per day is 20 cigarettes
- 55:49, which is outrageous, but hey, you do
- 55:51what you want. That equals two
- 55:53microsieverts per day. That is to say,
- 55:5620 cigarettes is the same as spending
- 55:58two days in front of a fully
- 56:00operational nuclear reactor. But as I
- 56:02said before, it is cumulative. After
- 56:04smoking for a year, your lungs are
- 56:06subjected to so much daily radiation
- 56:08that it's the same as getting a chest
- 56:10X-ray every day. Imagine what it will
- 56:13be like after 10 or 20 years. Smoking
- 56:16for two years is just as radioactive as
- 56:18the famous Chernobyl excavator. The one
- 56:20they say if you touch it, you die.
- 56:22That's a lie; you can touch it, nothing
- 56:24happens. But yes, it is very, very
- 56:26radioactive. It's 40 microsieverts per
- 56:28hour, so start doing the math to see
- 56:30how much time you have left to live.
- 56:33You studied math in school for a reason
- 56:35, so go ahead. Okay, but what about
- 56:38nuclear accidents? Even if power plants
- 56:40are very safe, if an accident occurs,
- 56:42everyone nearby dies and the area
- 56:43becomes uninhabitable for centuries. Mm
- 56:46, no. As we saw before, nuclear energy,
- 56:51including the disasters of Chernobyl
- 56:53and Fukushima, plus all the others that
- 56:55have occurred, remains the safest
- 56:56energy in the world. No civilian has
- 56:59died from radiation due to a nuclear
- 57:00accident. By civilian, I mean those who
- 57:03are not plant workers or emergency
- 57:05services personnel. regular, everyday
- 57:07people who live near the site and have
- 57:09nothing to do with it. It is true that
- 57:12there have been civilians who died from
- 57:13radiation, specifically six in the last
- 57:15100 years, but none of them were from a
- 57:17nuclear accident or a nuclear plant.
- 57:19Other statistics claim that 5,000
- 57:21people around the world who were
- 57:23exposed to radiation from those
- 57:25accidents ended up dying 20 to 40 years
- 57:28later from cancers that were possibly,
- 57:30it is not known for sure, but possibly
- 57:33aggravated by radiation. That is to say
- 57:35, the cancers are not really caused by
- 57:37radiation—surely some might be, I'm
- 57:39not saying otherwise—but they were
- 57:41actually aggravated by the radiation,
- 57:43and they died 20 or 40 years after the
- 57:45incidents. Of all nuclear accidents, 28
- 57:48people died from radiation in Chernobyl
- 57:50, and one died in Fukushima. It is also
- 57:53worth noting that two people died at
- 57:55the Tokaimura reprocessing plant and
- 57:56one at Three Mile Island. These
- 57:59facilities, although they are not
- 58:01nuclear power plants, are related to
- 58:03obtaining nuclear energy, fuel
- 58:04processing, reprocessing, and fuel
- 58:06recycling, so I believe they should
- 58:08also be taken into account. In other
- 58:11words, a total of 32 people have died
- 58:12from ARS. Not many, right? Especially
- 58:15when you compare it to other forms of
- 58:17energy. Furthermore, forget about the
- 58:18radioactive aspect. Take all nuclear
- 58:20energy accidents together. All of them,
- 58:22absolutely all of them, even those that
- 58:24have nothing to do with radiation. I
- 58:26don't know, someone has a beam fall on
- 58:28them, someone sticks a fork in an
- 58:30outlet, things like that, and nuclear
- 58:32energy is still safer than any other.
- 58:35The problem is that no one understands
- 58:37how radiation works. Everyone thinks
- 58:39that if you are exposed to it, you are
- 58:40going to disintegrate, and that is not
- 58:41really the case. And the truth is that
- 58:44nuclear disasters are nothing compared
- 58:46to natural sources. I want to remind
- 58:49you that the criterion in Fukushima,
- 58:50the standard Japan uses to label an
- 58:52area uninhabitable, is that radiation
- 58:54is higher than 20 millisieverts per
- 58:55year or 2 microsieverts per hour, or 20
- 58:57bananas per hour. We could, we could
- 59:01turn that into an international
- 59:02standard, huh? Bananas per hour. A
- 59:04staggering 34 bananas per hour. Whoa,
- 59:06there's a lot of radiation here. But
- 59:09back to the topic, along the Brazilian
- 59:11coast, from Rio de Janeiro to Salvador
- 59:13de Bahia, the sea sand is mixed with
- 59:15radioactive elements like monazite,
- 59:17thorium, and uranium, making its
- 59:19beaches radioactive, specifically
- 59:21Guarapari beach, the most radioactive
- 59:23beach in the world. Keep in mind that
- 59:26the most radioactive town in Fukushima
- 59:28currently is Shimonogami, and it has 6
- 59:30microsieverts per hour. The beaches on
- 59:33Brazil's coast average 20 microsieverts
- 59:35per hour, though in some spots it can
- 59:38reach over 100 microsieverts per hour,
- 59:40but there's even more. Ramsar, a city
- 59:43in Iran built near some radioactive hot
- 59:45springs, is the most radioactive
- 59:47inhabited city in the world. It is even
- 59:49more radioactive than Chernobyl. In
- 59:51Chernobyl, the most radioactive point
- 59:53of reactor 4 that you are allowed to go
- 59:55to is about 10 microsieverts per hour.
- 59:57Meanwhile, our friends in Ramsar are at
- 59:5914 microsieverts per hour. In some
- 1:00:02homes, like this one here, the most
- 1:00:04radioactive in the world, it reaches
- 1:00:05over 140 microsieverts. Now, where is
- 1:00:08NATO evacuating this place? This is
- 1:00:11much more lethal than Chernobyl. This
- 1:00:13is horrifying. It's fatal to one's
- 1:00:16health. Yet, they live there and nobody
- 1:00:19cares. So, don't get so scared of
- 1:00:23radiation from nuclear disasters.
- 1:00:25Radiation is not that big of a deal.
- 1:00:27You in your little house, on the other
- 1:00:29side of the ocean, you won't even
- 1:00:30notice. The very people living within a
- 1:00:3220 km radius don't even notice, let
- 1:00:34alone are affected. And even if you
- 1:00:35live in the most affected area, you
- 1:00:37aren't going to die. Otherwise, they
- 1:00:39wouldn't let you do tourism in
- 1:00:40Chernobyl, and that's even though
- 1:00:41Chernobyl is five times more
- 1:00:42radioactive than the uninhabitable zone
- 1:00:44of Fukushima. Mind you, I'm not saying
- 1:00:46you should roll around in plutonium
- 1:00:47like little pigs, eh? But get the idea
- 1:00:50that it's not this tall tale so often
- 1:00:52told that if you live near a nuclear
- 1:00:54plant, you're going to mutate into a
- 1:00:56werewolf and die of cancer, AIDS, and
- 1:00:58reggaeton in two days. Some
- 1:01:02environmentalists say that's a lie,
- 1:01:04that accidents and nuclear plants
- 1:01:06directly cause animal species living
- 1:01:08nearby to mutate, transforming into
- 1:01:10weird creatures like three-eyed fish or
- 1:01:12earless rabbits and mutant daisies. The
- 1:01:16famous three-eyed fish dates back to
- 1:01:182002, when an environmental group
- 1:01:20called Ecologists in Action announced
- 1:01:22they found a three-eyed fish in the
- 1:01:23Ebro river near the Garoña nuclear
- 1:01:25power plant. Shortly after, this
- 1:01:27environmental group confessed they had
- 1:01:29made it up, but they defended that it
- 1:01:32was necessary to raise awareness among
- 1:01:34the population about the dangers of
- 1:01:36nuclear energy. Those dangers that also
- 1:01:39seem to be made up. It seems these
- 1:01:41environmentalists watched a lot of The
- 1:01:42Simpsons. And Japan also went into a
- 1:01:44panic. After what happened in Fukushima
- 1:01:46, people became paranoid and blamed
- 1:01:48radiation for anything out of the
- 1:01:49ordinary. Your back hurts. Fukushima.
- 1:01:53The neighbor's dog barks at you.
- 1:01:54Fukushima. They charge you a 3%
- 1:01:56commission at the bank. Fukushima. It's
- 1:01:59Fukushima's fault. This rabbit born
- 1:02:01without ears was also attributed to
- 1:02:03Fukushima. It is true that it is
- 1:02:05unusual for a rabbit, but one must keep
- 1:02:07in mind that rabbits are sometimes born
- 1:02:09without ears. Just as other animals are
- 1:02:12sometimes born with two heads, one leg
- 1:02:14less, an extra leg, or other types of
- 1:02:17malformations. Anyway, if we look
- 1:02:19closely, this rabbit shows signs of
- 1:02:21albinism. It is very white, so that
- 1:02:23could be the case. Several scientists
- 1:02:26and biologists have ruled out radiation
- 1:02:28as the cause of this mutation, and some
- 1:02:30have even claimed it is impossible for
- 1:02:32radiation to cause this type of damage.
- 1:02:35The same happens with the next case. On
- 1:02:38Twitter, shortly after the disaster, a
- 1:02:40user posted photos of a mutant daisy
- 1:02:42and people got scared. After a while, a
- 1:02:45biologist replied to this user stating
- 1:02:47that this type of mutation is quite
- 1:02:49common in more than 20,000 species of
- 1:02:51daisies spread throughout the world,
- 1:02:53and that radiation has nothing to do
- 1:02:54with it. Well, well, but even so, a
- 1:02:57nuclear power plant can be used to make
- 1:02:59bombs. As we saw before, the uranium in
- 1:03:02the fuel is enriched to 5%. To make a
- 1:03:04bomb, the ideal would be to enrich it
- 1:03:06to more than 80%. But uranium is not as
- 1:03:09good an explosive as, for example,
- 1:03:11plutonium. Plutonium is indeed good as
- 1:03:13an explosive, which is why nuclear
- 1:03:14bombs are made of plutonium and not
- 1:03:15uranium. The most famous uranium bomb
- 1:03:18is Little Boy, the Hiroshima bomb. This
- 1:03:20bomb had 64 kg of uranium enriched to
- 1:03:2280%. That is, of the 100%of uranium, 80
- 1:03:26%was uranium-235. Meanwhile, in a
- 1:03:29reactor, the most radioactive thing it
- 1:03:31has is the fuel. The fuel consists of
- 1:03:33uranium rods enriched to 5%that weigh
- 1:03:35about 100 kg. These rods are grouped
- 1:03:39into elements of 200 rods generally,
- 1:03:41and each reactor has about 150 on
- 1:03:43average. That means that if the reactor
- 1:03:46were operating at 100%capacity and the
- 1:03:48fuel were loaded and completely new, we
- 1:03:51would have a total of 15,000 kg of 5%
- 1:03:53enriched uranium. Let's say you want to
- 1:03:56blow the place up just for kicks. To
- 1:03:58create an explosion similar to the
- 1:03:59Little Boy, you have to add up 50 kg of
- 1:04:01uranium-235. At 50 kg of uranium-235
- 1:04:04per rod, you need to move 10 rods
- 1:04:07weighing 100 kg each. So I hope you're
- 1:04:10strong. After that, you have to find a
- 1:04:12way to extract the uranium-235 from the
- 1:04:15rod and gather it until you reach 80%
- 1:04:16enrichment. And then you have to find a
- 1:04:20way to detonate them, and not just any
- 1:04:21way—all at once, without anyone
- 1:04:23seeing you, and without it blowing up
- 1:04:24in your face. It's a bit complicated,
- 1:04:28but it's worth noting that among all
- 1:04:30the fission waste, one of them is
- 1:04:32plutonium, and plutonium is indeed
- 1:04:35usable for nuclear bombs; however, the
- 1:04:37plutonium used isn't just any plutonium
- 1:04:39, it's a specific isotope. And to
- 1:04:42manage to separate that isotope from
- 1:04:43all the plutonium, it must undergo an
- 1:04:45isotopic separation process. But before
- 1:04:48we can do that, we need to separate
- 1:04:49that plutonium from the rest of the
- 1:04:51waste because it's all mixed together.
- 1:04:53So to get that plutonium from the waste
- 1:04:55, we need to distill it first. And that
- 1:04:58process is a real pain, it's tedious,
- 1:05:00it's long, and it's expensive. The fact
- 1:05:03is, there are much better ways to
- 1:05:05obtain plutonium for bombs. A nuclear
- 1:05:07power plant is not the most efficient
- 1:05:09way to obtain plutonium for that
- 1:05:11purpose, but technically it is possible
- 1:05:13to make a nuclear bomb with a plant,
- 1:05:14though no one is going to do it. But
- 1:05:18anyway, making bombs with nuclear waste
- 1:05:20from a plant is indeed possible, and
- 1:05:22that is what we are going to look at
- 1:05:24now. Nuclear waste. Nuclear energy is
- 1:05:27one of the energy sources that recycles
- 1:05:29the most. Between 25%and 30%of spent
- 1:05:32fuel is reprocessed for reuse. The rest
- 1:05:35of the waste, depending on its
- 1:05:37radioactivity, will be recycled,
- 1:05:39disposed of, or buried. The waste from
- 1:05:41a nuclear plant can be classified into
- 1:05:43declassifiable waste, which is a bit
- 1:05:45contradictory to what I just said.
- 1:05:47Declassifiable, low-level,
- 1:05:49intermediate-level, and high-level
- 1:05:51radioactive waste. Declassifiable waste
- 1:05:54is conventional waste material that is
- 1:05:56neither dangerous, toxic, nor
- 1:05:58radioactive. Like leftover food, paper,
- 1:06:01office supplies, tissues with snot,
- 1:06:03things like that. Low-level waste is
- 1:06:07material exposed to radiation or
- 1:06:09radioactive material that has a
- 1:06:11half-life of less than 30 years and a
- 1:06:13radioactivity level below 20 mSv. Tools
- 1:06:17, suits, gloves, filters, or used
- 1:06:20machinery parts. These types of waste
- 1:06:24are not exclusive to nuclear energy.
- 1:06:26Some non-nuclear industries also
- 1:06:27produce this waste, such as hospitals.
- 1:06:3030%of hospital waste must be buried due
- 1:06:32to its radioactivity. 30%. Note this
- 1:06:36fact: this waste is usually buried,
- 1:06:38although in some cases the weakest is
- 1:06:40burned or left in the open air until it
- 1:06:42loses its radioactivity and is
- 1:06:44subsequently disposed of conventionally
- 1:06:46. Medium-level waste is that whose
- 1:06:49half-life is greater than 30 years and
- 1:06:51whose radioactivity is less than 20 mSv
- 1:06:53/h. These undergo the same treatment as
- 1:06:57low-level ones, but they are
- 1:06:59prioritized over the low-priority ones.
- 1:07:01And finally, high-level waste, nuclear
- 1:07:04fuel, all those that are over 30 years
- 1:07:06and 20 mSv/h. These are the ones that
- 1:07:10are buried in those deep, shielded
- 1:07:11cemeteries. The famous nuclear waste
- 1:07:13that is buried in the depths of Helm's
- 1:07:15Deep. Those are the high-level ones. It
- 1:07:19is worth noting that of all radioactive
- 1:07:22waste, 95%is low-level, 5%is
- 1:07:24medium-level, and less than 0.01%is
- 1:07:27high-level. And the thing is, nuclear
- 1:07:32waste is so scarce that nuclear power
- 1:07:34plants around the world, throughout
- 1:07:37history, have produced almost 24
- 1:07:39million cubic meters of low-level waste
- 1:07:41, about 550,000 m³ of medium-level
- 1:07:44waste, and 22,000 of high-level waste,
- 1:07:46which seems like a lot, but it isn't.
- 1:07:50Especially when you compare it to other
- 1:07:52sources. Most people think that of all
- 1:07:55the radiation on the planet, the vast
- 1:07:57majority is caused by nuclear power
- 1:07:59plants. But nuclear power plants are
- 1:08:01the artificial sources that contribute
- 1:08:03the least radioactivity. More than 80%
- 1:08:06of radiation is natural. And of
- 1:08:08artificial radiation, the biggest
- 1:08:10polluter is not nuclear energy, which
- 1:08:12is the least polluting of all. The most
- 1:08:14polluting are hospitals. Hospitals
- 1:08:17produce 200 times more low-level waste
- 1:08:20than a nuclear plant. 30 times more
- 1:08:23medium-level waste than a nuclear plant
- 1:08:25, but they do not produce high-level
- 1:08:27waste, or at least not in a significant
- 1:08:29enough way for statistics to take it
- 1:08:31into account. And furthermore, of the
- 1:08:35low and medium-level waste, only 4
- 1:08:38million, which is 16%, are buried. The
- 1:08:41rest are lying around radiating
- 1:08:43everything, waiting for you to walk
- 1:08:45near them. Don't panic. But as we saw
- 1:08:52before, radiation is not that dangerous
- 1:08:54. The radiation drops off within a few
- 1:08:56meters, and if the vast majority is
- 1:08:58alpha, it’s not that big of a problem
- 1:08:59. And I repeat, I’m not saying you
- 1:09:02should roll around in plutonium like
- 1:09:03pigs, but get a realistic picture of
- 1:09:05what it can be. The most dangerous ones
- 1:09:08, the ones you should fear, are the
- 1:09:10high-level waste products. These emit a
- 1:09:12large amount of ionizing radiation and
- 1:09:14heat up to high temperatures. That is
- 1:09:16why they must be buried, cooled, and
- 1:09:18shielded. Most people think this is the
- 1:09:21most common nuclear waste, but it
- 1:09:23isn’t. It accounts for 0.01%.
- 1:09:26That’s why they don’t want nuclear
- 1:09:27power plants nearby. But all the
- 1:09:30high-level nuclear waste produced in
- 1:09:32the entire history of nuclear energy
- 1:09:34occupies only 22,000 m³, which seems
- 1:09:36like a lot, but it’s just the same
- 1:09:38space occupied by a soccer field 3
- 1:09:40meters high. Nothing more. Nothing more
- 1:09:45. This is the great advantage of
- 1:09:47nuclear energy; unlike other energy
- 1:09:49sources, some of its waste is buried,
- 1:09:51which is much better than dumping it
- 1:09:53into the atmosphere, which we then
- 1:09:54breathe, or just leaving it lying
- 1:09:56around. And for this simple reason,
- 1:09:58nuclear energy is the most ecological
- 1:10:00because it produces the least amount of
- 1:10:02waste. It is a good, safe, fast,
- 1:10:05efficient, and green energy that,
- 1:10:07because of environmentalists—who,
- 1:10:09ironically, while wanting to save the
- 1:10:11environment, are closing the doors to
- 1:10:13the energy that does exactly everything
- 1:10:16they would want from an energy source.
- 1:10:19And although it may not be the perfect
- 1:10:21energy, it is worth using until we find
- 1:10:23better technologies than the obsolete
- 1:10:25ones, because nuclear energy is a good
- 1:10:27method for producing energy in a
- 1:10:28non-polluting way, for taking care of
- 1:10:30the environment, and for covering the
- 1:10:32needs of the power grid without
- 1:10:33spending a fortune. Perhaps in the
- 1:10:37future, renewables will be efficient
- 1:10:38enough. Who knows? They might be
- 1:10:41durable and cheap and be able to
- 1:10:43replace nuclear, but until that day, we
- 1:10:45cannot blow up this energy, which is
- 1:10:47the safest and least polluting in the
- 1:10:49world, while we turn a blind eye to
- 1:10:51coal and oil, which could perfectly
- 1:10:52well be replaced by nuclear. But in the
- 1:10:56future, new nuclear technologies might
- 1:10:58be more efficient, cheaper, and even
- 1:11:00less polluting. Currently, the
- 1:11:03third-generation reactors we have use
- 1:11:05only 5%of the energy in uranium. That
- 1:11:08is why it remains radioactive for so
- 1:11:10many years. With the new
- 1:11:12fourth-generation reactors that will be
- 1:11:14commercialized in this decade of the
- 1:11:152020s, we will be able to harness up to
- 1:11:1895%of the uranium's energy, reducing
- 1:11:19the radioactivity of the waste to a
- 1:11:21maximum of 300 years. We cannot throw
- 1:11:24this technology in the trash. We could
- 1:11:27also use breeder reactors to take
- 1:11:28advantage of that nuclear waste and get
- 1:11:30energy in return. These reactors
- 1:11:32produce more fuel than they need, which
- 1:11:35is why they are called breeders,
- 1:11:37because they breed fuel. What these
- 1:11:40reactors do is like a normal reactor,
- 1:11:42they obtain energy through fission, but
- 1:11:44they also transform uranium-238 and
- 1:11:46thorium-232, non-fissile elements, into
- 1:11:48fissile elements that can later be used
- 1:11:51as nuclear fuel, either in the reactor
- 1:11:53itself or for others. With this
- 1:11:56technology, we could reduce nuclear
- 1:11:58waste production by 100 times, as well
- 1:12:00as reduce the need to mine uranium.
- 1:12:02Although this technology is quite
- 1:12:04expensive, and since uranium and
- 1:12:05nuclear waste disposal are not such a
- 1:12:07serious problem and are cheap, it is
- 1:12:09not used. We could also use thorium.
- 1:12:13Thorium is a radioactive element that
- 1:12:14is more abundant than uranium, so it
- 1:12:16would be cheaper to obtain. It is 200
- 1:12:18times more efficient than uranium,
- 1:12:19leaves 10 times less waste, and cannot
- 1:12:21be used to produce bombs, as it does
- 1:12:23not produce plutonium. This technology
- 1:12:25was already tested in Germany in the
- 1:12:2780s, but unfortunately it was abandoned
- 1:12:29because it has no military applications
- 1:12:31, and now, even though there is a
- 1:12:32desire to develop it, it cannot get
- 1:12:34enough funding to take off. Look how
- 1:12:37sad that is. Look how sad it is that
- 1:12:39because we can't use it to kill each
- 1:12:41other, we don't want it. Maybe one day
- 1:12:44we will discover how to use fusion, but
- 1:12:46for now, nuclear energy is a good
- 1:12:47option that should not be discarded. It
- 1:12:50is unfairly hated, being very safe and
- 1:12:52beneficial for the environment. If
- 1:12:55environmentalists want to reduce
- 1:12:57pollution, they have to move away from
- 1:12:59coal, natural gas, and oil and use a
- 1:13:00cleaner, more efficient energy that can
- 1:13:03replace them. And that energy is
- 1:13:05nuclear energy. But they don't want
- 1:13:07nuclear energy. So they say, "No,
- 1:13:09renewables work fine." Install
- 1:13:11renewables and they don't produce
- 1:13:13enough. And since they don't want
- 1:13:14nuclear, those energy needs have to be
- 1:13:16met with coal, gas, and oil. But we
- 1:13:18don't want coal, gas, and oil. Well, we
- 1:13:20can replace those energies that were
- 1:13:22going to supplement renewables with
- 1:13:24nuclear energy, which is less polluting
- 1:13:26, but we don't want nuclear because
- 1:13:28nuclear is dangerous and radioactive
- 1:13:30and lethal. So, more renewables. And
- 1:13:32the more renewables, the more coal, gas
- 1:13:34, and oil, because they don't want
- 1:13:35nuclear. But we don't want coal, gas,
- 1:13:38and oil. Well, we will have to replace
- 1:13:39them with something, and we can only
- 1:13:40replace them with nuclear. But we don't
- 1:13:42want nuclear. So, how do we produce
- 1:13:46energy? With hamsters? Ladies and
- 1:13:50gentlemen, nuclear energy is an
- 1:13:51excellent option. We should use it to
- 1:13:54reduce pollution and fight climate
- 1:13:56change, lower electricity prices,
- 1:13:58improve air quality and consequently
- 1:14:00people's health, and also increase
- 1:14:02worker safety. If environmentalists
- 1:14:06really, truly want to help the
- 1:14:07environment, they should stop
- 1:14:09protesting and go to the beach, because
- 1:14:10just by picking up one can, they’ve
- 1:14:12probably already done more than most of
- 1:14:14them. But beyond that, if they truly
- 1:14:17want to help the environment, they
- 1:14:19should educate themselves on what they
- 1:14:21are preaching. And if they are informed
- 1:14:24, they should be rigorous and
- 1:14:26determined enough to be willing to
- 1:14:28change their position if evidence is
- 1:14:30presented, because the environmentalist
- 1:14:32stance on nuclear energy is either
- 1:14:34ignorance or malice. Thank you very
- 1:14:40much to my patrons for their patience
- 1:14:41and to all of you for making it to this
- 1:14:42part of the video. It took me 4 months
- 1:14:44to make this video, which is insane,
- 1:14:46but you know I’m juggling multiple
- 1:14:47jobs, so I have to make videos in the
- 1:14:49spare time of my spare time of my spare
- 1:14:51time. And in the case of this video,
- 1:14:53since it’s a secondary project, it
- 1:14:55was in the spare time of all that spare
- 1:14:56time, though there are no excuses, 4
- 1:14:58months is enough, it had to be released
- 1:15:00at once. But I think I’m going to
- 1:15:02stop making these types of videos.
- 1:15:03First, because it doesn’t fit the
- 1:15:04theme of my channel, even though I love
- 1:15:06making these types of videos, I don’t
- 1:15:08think it really fits the channel's
- 1:15:09theme. And second, they take an insane
- 1:15:11amount of time, they take too much. So
- 1:15:14I’m going to switch to semi-serious
- 1:15:16videos that are a bit easier to make,
- 1:15:18that I can do in less than a week, and
- 1:15:20that don’t require intensive research
- 1:15:22on a topic completely unknown to me,
- 1:15:24because otherwise this happens—it
- 1:15:26takes 4 months for one video. And I
- 1:15:28would like to invest that time into
- 1:15:30making more videos that are more
- 1:15:31interesting for the people who watch
- 1:15:33this channel and also into the
- 1:15:34development of my video game, which has
- 1:15:36been stalled since then. Anyway, I’m
- 1:15:38not very satisfied with the final
- 1:15:40product. I’m a bit of a perfectionist
- 1:15:42and I don’t like the audio; I don’t
- 1:15:43like my voice, I don’t like the
- 1:15:45intonation I use, I don’t like how
- 1:15:46abrasive my voice sounds when I’m
- 1:15:48reading for a video. When I try to
- 1:15:50speak well into a microphone, my voice
- 1:15:52changes; I try to get the microphone to
- 1:15:54pick up my voice better and I end up
- 1:15:55with a very abrasive tone, I raise the
- 1:15:57pitch when I shouldn't, I make bad
- 1:15:58connections, and I want to work on that
- 1:16:00aspect too, but I don't know, it
- 1:16:01doesn't work, no, I just can't manage
- 1:16:03it and I'm never satisfied with my
- 1:16:05voice; I don't like my audio, I don't
- 1:16:06like my vocalization, and in fact, I've
- 1:16:08done several sessions. I have done five
- 1:16:11sessions of 4 hours each, and in the
- 1:16:13last 20 minutes, you can probably tell
- 1:16:14that I sound like a smoker because my
- 1:16:16voice is being destroyed. I've been
- 1:16:18talking non-stop for 4 hours straight
- 1:16:20and it's completely shredded. And even
- 1:16:21then, I still had to make small
- 1:16:22corrections afterwards. I made cuts, I
- 1:16:24took things out, I inserted audio later
- 1:16:27and later, and I still went back to add
- 1:16:29more audio. Some time later, after
- 1:16:31rendering and producing the video, I
- 1:16:32decided to add even more audio. So, I
- 1:16:34am not satisfied with my voice. I don't
- 1:16:37like it. I don't like how I vocalize,
- 1:16:39so these videos work me to death, they
- 1:16:41destroy my voice, I don't agree with
- 1:16:43the final product, I think it doesn't
- 1:16:44fit the channel's audience, so I don't
- 1:16:46know what I'm going to do. But anyway,
- 1:16:48the video is finished; it took me 4
- 1:16:50months. I hope it was worth it. I hope
- 1:16:52you liked it, which is what counts
- 1:16:54after all. And well, we'll see what I
- 1:16:57bring next time. Best regards and until
- 1:16:59next time. M.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Desmontando mentiras ecologistas sobre la energía nuclear by DarthThunder, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 13,634 words across 2,118 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.