Des excommunications nulles et non avenues - Abbé F-M. Chautard - 05/07/2026 — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:04In the name of the Father, Son, Spirit.
- 0:06Amen. My dear brothers, Saints Peter
- 0:09and Paul are being solitary today. This
- 0:13is a very great feast that reminds us
- 0:15of the immense gift given by God to
- 0:18these giants of holiness, but also of
- 0:20the incomparable benefit of the papacy.
- 0:23A papacy instituted by God to confirm
- 0:26souls in the faith of Jesus Christ, to
- 0:29shepherd these souls in Jesus Christ,
- 0:32that is, to lead them to heaven by
- 0:35giving them the true faith, the true
- 0:38sacraments, good laws, and good pastors
- 0:41. Unfortunately, for several decades
- 0:44the Church has been experiencing a
- 0:46crisis of authority which, instead of
- 0:49using its supreme power to shepherd
- 0:52souls, uses its iron rod to strike down
- 0:54the little sheep who ask for the bread
- 0:57of doctrine, the water of the
- 0:59sacraments, and the wine of the Holy
- 1:02Mass. So have we received the wrath of
- 1:05Rome through this excommunication? You
- 1:10will have noted that this condemnation
- 1:13goes far beyond the scope of the July
- 1:151st consecrations. It is the Fraternity
- 1:19of Saint Idis that is certainly
- 1:21included in this condemnation, along
- 1:24with its faithful and its friendly
- 1:26communities. And this is based on the
- 1:30rejection of Vatican I and the Mass of
- 1:33Paul VI. Indeed, in the Roman document
- 1:37intended for the reconciliation of the
- 1:40priests and faithful of the Fraternity
- 1:43of Saint Pidis, the first requirement
- 1:46is the acceptance of Vatican I and this
- 1:49new Micel. It should be noted that if
- 1:53acceptance of Vatican I is requested,
- 1:55it is not because of the traditional
- 1:57passages that pose no difficulty, but
- 2:00rather because of the innovative texts
- 2:02that break with the tradition of the
- 2:04Church. By mentioning these two points,
- 2:08the Vatican reveals the true motives
- 2:11behind this condemnation of the
- 2:13consecrations and the Fraternity of
- 2:16Saint Bidis. It is not so much that it
- 2:19consecrated 100 papal mandates against
- 2:22the will of the Pope. No, that's not
- 2:25really what's behind this condemnation.
- 2:29It is the rejection of this disastrous
- 2:33Vatican I and the resulting liturgy.
- 2:37They want us to accept this revolution
- 2:40in the Church. What bothers Rome? Rome,
- 2:44with its neo-Protestant and
- 2:46neo-Dernerist tendencies, as Monsignor
- 2:48de Fèvre said, is that these new
- 2:51bishops are going to preach against
- 2:53Vatican I and the new Mass. These new
- 2:56bishops are going to ordain priests who
- 2:59will also preach against these modern
- 3:02errors and priests who will celebrate
- 3:06not the liturgy of Vatican I but the
- 3:10traditional Mass. What bothers this man
- 3:14of neo-Dernerist tendencies is that
- 3:17these new bishops are going to confirm
- 3:19in the anti-liberal Catholic faith the
- 3:22faithful who will come to receive the
- 3:24Holy Spirit from their hands. Those are
- 3:28the real reasons for the condemnation.
- 3:30Oh, nothing really new. But this
- 3:33constitutes a weighty argument brought
- 3:36by Rome to justify these sacraments,
- 3:39that is to say, the state of necessity.
- 3:43We have not ceased to say since
- 3:46February 2 that the faithful could not
- 3:49receive an integral faith and the
- 3:51sacraments, in short, the entire
- 3:54Catholic life with its fullness in
- 3:57their parish or diocese and that it was
- 4:00therefore necessary through these
- 4:03consecrations to maintain the perennial
- 4:06transmission of all of its spiritual
- 4:09goods. And Rome confirms this point of
- 4:12view by requiring priests and faithful
- 4:16to accept Vatican I and the new Mass.
- 4:20Yes, the real reason for the refusal of
- 4:22the consecrations and the
- 4:23excommunication is written in black and
- 4:25white. It is this rejection of these
- 4:28novelties that caused this
- 4:30unprecedented Church crisis. Also, let
- 4:33us measure how false and unjust the
- 4:37foundations of this excommunication are
- 4:41and consequently how unjust, void and
- 4:45invalid these excommunications are.
- 4:49This excommunication is then
- 4:51canonically null and void. For several
- 4:56reasons, I will cite one given by the
- 5:00canonical code, the new one, which is
- 5:05canon 1323, is not punishable by any
- 5:09penalty. A person who has violated a
- 5:15law or a precept, there is a number 4,
- 5:19has acted out of necessity unless the
- 5:22act is intrinsically evil. And a little
- 5:28further on, still in this same canon,
- 5:30in paragraph 7, it is added that a
- 5:33person who believed that one of the
- 5:35circumstances provided for in numbers 4
- 5:38and 5, that is, necessity, had arisen,
- 5:41is not punishable by any penalty. Now,
- 5:45if it is clear that we have apparently
- 5:48violated an ecclesiastical law, this
- 5:50act of consecration is obviously not
- 5:53evil in itself. A consecration is in
- 5:55itself a good thing and we were moved
- 5:59by necessity. And as we have just
- 6:02recalled, even if we are not convinced
- 6:06of the objectivity of this case of
- 6:09necessity, we can only observe that our
- 6:13intention is motivated by this
- 6:16perception of a necessity. And
- 6:20therefore, we are exempt from this
- 6:21penalty. Let us not be afraid, my dear
- 6:23brothers. This excommunication is,
- 6:27moreover, particularly iniquitous and
- 6:31scandalous. Why? Remember, a few months
- 6:37ago, the fraternity reacted vigorously
- 6:40when the Roman document Populifideis
- 6:43fidelis appeared, which questioned the
- 6:46universal mediation of the Virgin Mary.
- 6:50This document was all the more shocking
- 6:53because it tended to distance the
- 6:55faithful from the Virgin Mary, thus
- 6:58depriving them of a spiritual help that
- 7:01is particularly necessary in the desert
- 7:04in which souls find themselves. Well,
- 7:08there is something equivalent today.
- 7:11For what is the intention of this
- 7:14condemnation? To clearly turn souls
- 7:18away from the Fraternity of Saint
- 7:21Pilice where they can find the honest
- 7:24profession of faith. The sacraments in
- 7:27their canonical form, the fraternity
- 7:30for countless souls is an ark of
- 7:32salvation, a life raft, if I may say so
- 7:35. In other words, this document aims to
- 7:39distance souls from the true Mass, from
- 7:42true doctrine, from the true sacraments
- 7:45. Is it the right spirit? Dear brothers
- 7:47, who could be at the origin of such a
- 7:49measure that distances souls from God?
- 7:56In this regard, let us note on the one
- 7:59hand that the ecclesiastical
- 8:02communities are also forbidden, like
- 8:05everyone else, from celebrating the
- 8:09sacraments in the traditional form. And
- 8:13on the other hand, let us remember that
- 8:16while the Fraternity of Saint Pilis is
- 8:19present in 77 countries throughout the
- 8:21world, in all latitudes, these
- 8:24ecclesiastical communities are present
- 8:27in about forty countries with a much
- 8:29smaller presence. This means that for
- 8:33tens of thousands of souls, from dozens
- 8:36of countries, if they can no longer go
- 8:38to the fraternity, they will become
- 8:41impetuous. They will no longer have
- 8:43access to the good Mass, the true
- 8:45sacrament, or the true doctrine. And
- 8:48that is why this Roman document aims to
- 8:51suffocate souls, to euthanize them
- 8:53spiritually, for want of nourishing
- 8:56them. And that is why we say that this
- 9:00excommunication is scandalous. And we
- 9:04add that this excommunication is unjust
- 9:08for three new reasons related to the
- 9:11good of communism. First, because by
- 9:17depriving souls of its spiritual goods
- 9:20and by delivering the faithful at the
- 9:23same time to adulterated sacraments, a
- 9:26deviant doctrine, a bad Mass. This
- 9:30condemnation, as we have just said,
- 9:32deprives souls of necessary spiritual
- 9:34goods. By making this condemnation, he
- 9:40opposes this major and supreme law of
- 9:43the salvation of souls. Salusanimarum
- 9:48supreme. The supreme law is the
- 9:50salvation of souls. The Church is made
- 9:52for the good of souls. And the powers
- 9:56of condemnation of the men of the
- 9:58church are given to them not to destroy
- 10:02goods, but to give goods, to edify. How
- 10:06? How then can we not be saddened by
- 10:11this condemnation, not for ourselves
- 10:15but for the church and for men? It is a
- 10:20new offense against the church of God,
- 10:23which is done to it by its own members,
- 10:26and these are souls that will be
- 10:28confused, disoriented and therefore
- 10:31deprived of the sacraments. Secondly,
- 10:35with regard to communal good, because
- 10:37this condemnation based on adherence to
- 10:40Vatican II and the new Mass is a new
- 10:43anathema brought to the tradition of
- 10:45the church through what it has
- 10:47transmitted. We no longer want this
- 10:49traditional doctrine. We no longer want
- 10:51Christ the king. We no longer want this
- 10:53claim of the church as sole salvation.
- 10:56No, we are making an apology for false
- 10:59religions, religious freedom and so on.
- 11:03Thirdly, because when a superior uses
- 11:06double standards, he is sinning against
- 11:10that part of justice called legal
- 11:13justice, which aims at the common good
- 11:16of the whole of society, which
- 11:19precisely demands a general consistency
- 11:22of punishments. For example, if a
- 11:25sovereign systematically turns a blind
- 11:30eye to all crimes of bloodshed and,
- 11:32conversely, is inflexible when it comes
- 11:35to crimes of theft, he is sinning
- 11:37against the common good. You see the
- 11:40feeling of revolt that animates us when
- 11:43we sometimes see an intrnational side,
- 11:46breaches of the highway code and then
- 11:49laxity towards a certain number of
- 11:52crimes in our country. It is clear that
- 11:55this offends the common good. There is
- 11:58an injustice precisely because of this
- 11:59disproportion. Well, that is why it is
- 12:03inconsistent and unjust for the Church
- 12:06authorities to condemn those accused of
- 12:10schism-nous on the one hand and, on the
- 12:13other, to receive with all the honors
- 12:17and thus promote those who are heretics
- 12:20, schismatics or have a scandalous
- 12:24moral life. By receiving with all due
- 12:27respect Mrs. Mulali, who will be called
- 12:30this Bishop of Canterbury at the head
- 12:33of a pseudo-church that separated from
- 12:35Rome several centuries ago; by
- 12:37receiving with great cordiality the
- 12:40representatives of the LGBT movements;
- 12:43by not sanctioning Cardinal Radcliff,
- 12:45who has just praised an unnatural union
- 12:48during a Mass, while condemning us, the
- 12:53Pope is creating a new disorder, a new
- 12:56injustice towards the common good, that
- 12:59is to say, towards the entire Catholic
- 13:02community. And this condemnation, by
- 13:06treating doctrinal and moral deviations
- 13:09well and by treating defenders of
- 13:11tradition badly, is likely to blind the
- 13:14faithful Catholics who are not very
- 13:16well-educated. This condemnation
- 13:20therefore contains within itself a
- 13:23profound inconsistency, indeed, and God
- 13:26alone searches the minds and hearts, an
- 13:29attitude, I do not say an intention,
- 13:32once again, God alone judges, but a
- 13:35pharisaical attitude. We no longer
- 13:37speak of serious sins today. We no
- 13:40longer condemn, we no longer
- 13:41excommunicate. And then, we remember
- 13:44that there are serious sins, that there
- 13:47are excommunications, that there are
- 13:49chisms, as if we had been exhumed from
- 13:51the dust. These documents, as if today
- 13:54there were two sins, being attached to
- 13:57tradition and sins against the planet.
- 14:03When we speak of chism, let us remember
- 14:06that chism consists of not wanting to
- 14:10act as part of the Catholic Church vis-
- 14:14à-vis the authority, vis-à-vis the
- 14:17members. I am saying as part of the
- 14:21Catholic Church, not the conciliar,
- 14:25synodal, ecological, multi-colored
- 14:28Church. So yes, the chism. Where are
- 14:32those who no longer want to act like
- 14:34the entire Catholic Church and the
- 14:36Catholics who preceded them? Where is
- 14:39the rupture? Where is the division? Who
- 14:42refuses to be part of this Mass of all
- 14:44time, to profess the faith of all time,
- 14:46to celebrate the Mass of our ancestors,
- 14:48to receive the sacraments as our
- 14:50ancestors received them? Who, on the
- 14:53contrary, wants to remain with the
- 14:55whole Church in time and space? So let
- 14:59the faithful rest assured, if they are
- 15:03frightened or worried, we will continue
- 15:06, thanks to God, to preach the true
- 15:10doctrine to them, to celebrate the true
- 15:13Mass, to give them valid and fruitful
- 15:17sacraments. Let them rest assured, an
- 15:21unjust law is not a law and an unjust
- 15:23punishment is not valid. When an
- 15:30authority strikes so hard, it is
- 15:35because it considers itself powerful
- 15:38enough to crush its adversary or it is
- 15:40perhaps because it is afraid of what it
- 15:43perceives as a great danger against
- 15:46which it has little resilience. And
- 15:50that may be it. This great harshness is
- 15:53perhaps only the sign of great fear in
- 15:56the face of a great good that this
- 15:59authority perceives. Let us conclude
- 16:03these few words by quoting Saint Peter
- 16:06again, whom we honor today. It is
- 16:10better to obey God than men. This is
- 16:13the teaching of the first pope before
- 16:15the supreme religious authorities of
- 16:16the old covenant. We keep our word and
- 16:19we also let ourselves be carried away
- 16:22by these few words given by the Acts of
- 16:25the Apostles. When Saint Peter and Paul
- 16:27had preached the name of Jesus Christ,
- 16:30they were arrested by the religious
- 16:32authorities. They were forbidden to
- 16:34preach, but they continued. They were
- 16:36flogged. What do the Acts tell us then?
- 16:43Two gifts went joyfully before the Holy
- 16:47Edrin because they had been judged
- 16:50worthy to suffer clean waters for the
- 16:53name of Jesus. So, my dear brothers, if
- 16:58we are legitimately indignant at the
- 17:01injustice, the iniquity of this
- 17:04condemnation, if we are legitimately
- 17:09saddened by this camouflage against
- 17:12Tradition and therefore against the
- 17:15Church herself, we have no bitterness
- 17:18in our hearts, and even a joy in
- 17:21suffering for the Church, through the
- 17:24men of the Church, like Saint Anas,
- 17:27Saint John of Arc or even more recently
- 17:30Monsignor le Fèvre. And as our
- 17:34Superior General invites us, we pray to
- 17:37the Virgin Mary, strong as an army
- 17:40drawn up in battle array, the mediatrix
- 17:44of all grace, the faithful Virgin, that
- 17:47she may hasten the return of Rome to
- 17:50its tradition. Amen, in the name of the
- 17:54Father, Son, Holy Spirit. Amen.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Des excommunications nulles et non avenues - Abbé F-M. Chautard - 05/07/2026 by Eglise Saint-Nicolas-du-Chardonnet, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 2,238 words across 345 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.