Depression Medications Tier List: Psychiatrists Rank Antidepressants for MDD — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Psychopharm podcast. This
- 0:01podcast is for education and
- 0:02entertainment. It certainly is not
- 0:03medical or psychiatric advice,
- 0:05diagnosis, or treatment. Listening does
- 0:06not create a doctor-patient relationship
- 0:07with me or Dr. Foo. If you're a patient,
- 0:09certainly don't change your treatment
- 0:09plan because of something you hear in
- 0:10the show. If you're a clinician, do not
- 0:11use this podcast as a clinical reference
- 0:13or substitute for your own training,
- 0:14judgment, thinking, and up-to-date
- 0:15sources. Opinions are our own and don't
- 0:16necessarily reflect any employer or
- 0:18affiliated organization and may even be
- 0:19detached from reality.
- 0:21Good morning, Dr. Malzburg.
- 0:23So, today we will
- 0:26we're making a tier list for
- 0:27medications. I think that you'll find
- 0:30it's going to be hard to see me
- 0:32violating my usual rules. And my usual
- 0:34rules are that
- 0:38I I'll never pick medications that will
- 0:40cause weight gain or appetite increase
- 0:43if I can help it. And I try to minimize
- 0:46uh side effects. That's kind of rule
- 0:48one. And then rule two is most
- 0:50efficacious. So, that tends to be how I
- 0:53go. Uh I feel like a lot of
- 0:55psychiatrists out there go in the
- 0:57opposite direction. I think a lot of
- 0:59people go for most efficacious first and
- 1:01then don't worry so much about the side
- 1:03effects. But, um you know, everyone's
- 1:04[clears throat] a little different.
- 1:06My only issue is like mirtazapine, I'm
- 1:08going to that's going to be a high tier
- 1:10on my list and that causes a lot of
- 1:11weight gain. So, it's like the patient
- 1:13population matters.
- 1:15It does, but that's what I mean, all
- 1:17arounders. I don't use much mirtazapine
- 1:19despite its great efficacy.
- 1:21All right. Well, I'm going to use your
- 1:24your list as what goes in the screen and
- 1:26then I'll just yell at you when I
- 1:28disagree.
- 1:29Okay, that sounds fine.
- 1:31All right. So, So, what diagnostic class
- 1:34are we starting with in terms of picking
- 1:36medications? We're doing depression. So,
- 1:39major depressive disorder.
- 1:41Okay. Do we mean true recurrent
- 1:44biological type major depressive
- 1:46disorder, the cousin to bipolar
- 1:47disorder, or do we mean um
- 1:50dime store depression from personality
- 1:53and stressors that happens to meet major
- 1:55depressive episode criteria? All the
- 1:57above. I want All of the above. Oh, boy.
- 2:01Okay.
- 2:03Yeah, understandably you want a very
- 2:05specific
- 2:06set of rules in what we're doing and I
- 2:08want
- 2:10nothing.
- 2:11>> [laughter]
- 2:11>> We just grade the medications.
- 2:13>> Okay.
- 2:14Well, obviously it's going to be
- 2:15Adderall because that's going to get you
- 2:16the most return visits. No, that that
- 2:18that's a joke. Do not put Adderall.
- 2:19Let's put Adderall into F or No, not
- 2:22even question mark. Adderall immediately
- 2:24goes into F tier.
- 2:25Uh why are we going to do that first?
- 2:26Because too many psychiatrists will
- 2:28essentially
- 2:30uh ignore anxiety and depressive
- 2:32disorders and call it
- 2:33neurodevelopmental. Uh
- 2:36maybe not too many psychiatrists though
- 2:38I definitely see psychiatrists doing it,
- 2:40but just a lot of clinicians out there.
- 2:42I think for run-of-the-mill
- 2:45meets criteria major depressive episode,
- 2:48you got to go with sertraline.
- 2:50Sertraline is
- 2:51your normal
- 2:52>> why Adderall's in the F class first? To
- 2:54me it's not obvious.
- 2:55>> just did. It's not obvious though.
- 2:57>> That's not enough? Okay okay, go ahead.
- 2:58There's I mean I think there's a lot of
- 3:00people will report that they feel better
- 3:03on Adderall and we also know that
- 3:06methylphenidate is commonly used for
- 3:09geriatric depression. So, we can't write
- 3:11off stimulants just with one sweeping
- 3:13blow.
- 3:14But maybe we can come back to it.
- 3:16>> but I will explain more. That's Those
- 3:17are some good points. Uh first of all,
- 3:20uh it's not a very good antidepressant.
- 3:22Uh what you feel on a stim uh on meth or
- 3:26cocaine or uh speed, which is what
- 3:29Adderall is, uh is a intoxicant effect.
- 3:33That is the euphoria and energy burst
- 3:35and you will build tolerance to that.
- 3:37Proper psychiatric treatment of a major
- 3:39depressive disorder is not something
- 3:42that you build tolerance to. Now, there
- 3:44is something called tachyphylaxis on the
- 3:46order of years of exposure to a
- 3:48medication where a medication becomes
- 3:50apparently less effective, but it's not
- 3:52a long-term solution. Freud tried to use
- 3:54it, cocaine, to treat a bunch of stuff.
- 3:57You can read his cocaine papers, and
- 3:59everyone concluded it didn't work. It's
- 4:00like every few years people try to treat
- 4:02everything under the sun in psychiatry
- 4:04with a stimulant because it feels great
- 4:06and people love it. It's not a solution.
- 4:08It's a drug. Uh now, for the geriatric
- 4:11class, um there is an exception that
- 4:13should be made for geriatric depression
- 4:15or geriatric uh neurocognitive disorders
- 4:19that come with apathy. Okay, apathy.
- 4:23This is sort of a unique thing, not
- 4:25exactly negative symptoms, but uh apathy
- 4:29can happen in older age uh people, and a
- 4:33little stimulant treatment can be
- 4:34helpful for that. But that that's very
- 4:36niche use and not
- 4:38run-of-the-mill major depressive
- 4:39disorder.
- 4:40Yeah, I'm I'm glad you brought this
- 4:41stuff up cuz
- 4:43what I do see is I see a lot of
- 4:45Now, you see all the time patients are
- 4:47treated for ADHD to the exclusion to all
- 4:50of all the other diagnoses. And the
- 4:52thing is, as you mentioned, people feel
- 4:54good on the medication. So often times
- 4:56they'll say like, "Oh, it actually
- 4:57really helps my depression." Because the
- 4:59first few times you take it, boom, you
- 5:01you feel great. It's it's a very
- 5:03rewarding drug. The important thing is
- 5:05it doesn't treat depression in the long
- 5:07term. And what I've seen with so many
- 5:09patients who have uh ADHD plus
- 5:12depression is you're
- 5:15you're not treating the depression, and
- 5:17you'll see irritability creep up, you'll
- 5:19see some added symptoms creep up, you'll
- 5:21see all these other things, and then the
- 5:23ADHD isn't getting treated because
- 5:26you're
- 5:27the person isn't addressing the
- 5:29underlying depression. So yes, it does
- 5:31work. In my opinion, it does {quote}
- 5:32{unquote} work the day the first day you
- 5:34take it.
- 5:35>> Symptomatically. But it does it is it is
- 5:37a very ineffective antidepressant.
- 5:40That's right. And uh if you've ever even
- 5:42just been treating what seems to be
- 5:45plain ADHD executive dysfunction, and
- 5:47there's a sense that the stimulant stops
- 5:50working in some sense or needs a higher
- 5:52dose after initially working for a few
- 5:55weeks. That's not the medication
- 5:56treatment effect. That's the drug
- 5:58effect. So, do not fall for that trap.
- 6:01Okay, folks. It's important one. So,
- 6:03does that mean can we should we put
- 6:05methylphenidate as D or F?
- 6:07F because we're talking about
- 6:09depression. Okay.
- 6:13Um
- 6:14Is it
- 6:15>> frozen? It looks Oh, there you go. We're
- 6:16going to snap it into place.
- 6:18I think we should stop you know, running
- 6:20our ideology and talk about actual
- 6:22depression of treatment of depression
- 6:24though and again, got to go with my boy
- 6:27sertraline. Oh.
- 6:29>> Zoloft.
- 6:30>> Boom. Boom. Sertraline. Sertraline as
- 6:31they like to call it due to the
- 6:32diarrhea.
- 6:34Um it is a great medication. First of
- 6:37all, you can titrate it on multiple
- 6:40steps. Okay, eight steps to the FDA
- 6:42maximum. Pretty useful. Uh secondly,
- 6:46just works. Works pretty great. Third,
- 6:49does not have much in the way of med-med
- 6:52interactions. Arguably at a higher dose
- 6:55may inhibit 2D6 according to some people
- 6:58or maybe in older adults, but basically
- 7:00clinically not a problem. No significant
- 7:03QTc prolongation. Uh yes, does have more
- 7:07GI side effects maybe, but those tend to
- 7:09dissipate at each dose after you know,
- 7:12up to a week or so. Um effective.
- 7:16Well tolerated. Great first line
- 7:18medication. Absolutely S tier. I 100%
- 7:21agree. It is almost always the
- 7:23medication I reach for first.
- 7:26Um I feel like I used to reach for
- 7:27Lexapro more. Like it was almost a 50/50
- 7:30split. And for some reason
- 7:33I I mean maybe there is a reason. I
- 7:34actually tended early on to reach for
- 7:36Lexapro for boys more and Zoloft for
- 7:38girls more. I wonder if that had had
- 7:40something to do with the fact that
- 7:42uh I we're supposed to use the name
- 7:44sertraline. I wonder if sertraline has
- 7:46the most I think the best safety in in
- 7:49pregnancy and breastfeeding. And I
- 7:51wonder if somehow that just seeped into
- 7:53my brain. That wasn't something I was
- 7:54doing intentionally. I think it was one
- 7:56of those like when I look back it's like
- 7:57oh I tend to to reach for escitalopram
- 8:00more often for men.
- 8:01Um now I tend to reach for sertraline
- 8:03first line uh
- 8:05pretty much for all patients. Now why do
- 8:07I reach for sertraline in front of
- 8:09escitalopram? So
- 8:12the main thing is you do see more
- 8:16um
- 8:16because of the the way these drugs are
- 8:19metabolized, sertraline has a bunch
- 8:22different sip sips that metabolize it.
- 8:25For patients that have uh
- 8:27ultra slow or ultra fast metabolization
- 8:30of whatever escitalopram's metabolized
- 8:32by, you will get patients who have
- 8:35really bad response to escitalopram more
- 8:37often than with sertraline.
- 8:41Yeah, I would say in my experience you
- 8:43do see a little bit more uh poor
- 8:45tolerance to Lexapro just a hair.
- 8:47Uh Lexapro used to be in my S tier. I
- 8:49used to reach for it first uh but that
- 8:52was earlier in the career and across
- 8:54increasing clinical experience. Again,
- 8:56still a great medication, probably my
- 8:57number two, but I wouldn't put it in the
- 8:59S tier. I would put it into A tier. And
- 9:02uh you know, it only has four titration
- 9:05uh steps unfortunately
- 9:07uh which I don't like. I like to have
- 9:09more steps. I think that works
- 9:11psychologically and physiologically for
- 9:13more people who are uh treatment naive.
- 9:16Um you've got to consider the
- 9:18possibility of QTc prolongation above 20
- 9:21mg because it hasn't been tested though
- 9:23it probably is unlikely.
- 9:25Um
- 9:26the FDA label kind of handcuffs you in
- 9:28the elderly population saying you can't
- 9:29go above 10 mg because you're being
- 9:31ultra careful about QTc prolongation,
- 9:34but uh similar to sertraline,
- 9:35efficacious uh relatively well tolerated
- 9:38compared to some of the other ones, and
- 9:40a few med-med interactions. So, uh
- 9:43pretty good med.
- 9:44Yeah, I used to in terms of I I guess
- 9:46we'll try to do a little bit of
- 9:47didactics in in in here. Escitalopram is
- 9:50the quote-unquote purest SSRI. I used to
- 9:53think that meant that it's going to have
- 9:54the least side effects or um just like
- 9:57the the the most direct effect. I I find
- 10:00that sertraline has less side effects
- 10:02overall, and sertraline's a little bit
- 10:03better tolerated. Even though it is the
- 10:06quote-unquote most pure
- 10:08uh SSRI, um you know, I've had patients
- 10:10who tolerate citalopram better than
- 10:12escitalopram, which goes against what
- 10:15we're taught. Um
- 10:17the
- 10:18You mentioned the doses on sertraline.
- 10:20My one complaint is There's no 150 mg
- 10:23pill.
- 10:24There's a capsule, actually.
- 10:27Really? I
- 10:28must not be able to get it covered.
- 10:30>> don't know if it's available everywhere,
- 10:31actually, cuz sometimes
- 10:32>> that I have to have on two pills,
- 10:34which is more inconvenient than
- 10:37um
- 10:38I I I feel like we got to
- 10:39>> got the option. You got the option. And
- 10:41then what I like about doing the step
- 10:43from 100 to 150 is that you can say,
- 10:45"Listen, uh if this doesn't work out for
- 10:47you, take the 100 and half of the 50."
- 10:50Giving the patients real control, and
- 10:53then also, of course, if you have real
- 10:54control, then you have the sense of
- 10:55control, uh I think can help uh a little
- 10:58bit of anxiety when it comes to med
- 10:59titration. Yeah.
- 11:02Um but yeah, we are in agreement. I have
- 11:03I have escitalopram at A tier. I would
- 11:06have been fine if you put it in S tier.
- 11:08I would not have have fought you.
- 11:11Now now now speaking of uh what you
- 11:13mentioned in terms of pure purity versus
- 11:16dirty,
- 11:18uh I think I agree, purity is very
- 11:20overrated
- 11:22um both in real life and in medications.
- 11:25And I would say that I love a dirty
- 11:27drug, okay? I love medications that can
- 11:30do multiple things at once. You get it
- 11:31all in one pill. Now, this is a problem
- 11:34when the dirtiness, uh, that means
- 11:36hitting multiple different types of
- 11:37receptors and having activity at
- 11:38multiple different types of receptors,
- 11:40it's a problem if that comes with weight
- 11:41gain and appetite increase because
- 11:43nobody likes that and it's bad for you
- 11:45physically. But, uh, for the rest of
- 11:47them who don't necessarily do that and
- 11:49have a little bit more, uh, multiple
- 11:50action, good meds. I like those.
- 11:53Yeah, and theoretically we should be
- 11:54using cuz I've seen people use the word
- 11:56dirty because it causes a lot of side
- 11:58effects. Dirty should mean if it's a
- 12:00bunch of different other receptors. I
- 12:01almost feel like is a better
- 12:02word, but, um,
- 12:05>> [laughter]
- 12:05>> Well, I mean, I I I I thought there was
- 12:07going to be a implication of that
- 12:09without staying stating it outright, Dr.
- 12:11Malzberg. We don't have to get all
- 12:13zoomer about that, speaking at YouTube.
- 12:15>> [laughter]
- 12:16>> All right, our next one is going to be
- 12:18fluoxetine, Prozac.
- 12:20What? I thought I was making this.
- 12:22You're You're playing it up there.
- 12:24>> No, I'm not putting it anywhere. I'm
- 12:25just holding it.
- 12:25>> No, that's okay. I I want to do a bit
- 12:27here. So, if you can put the Prozac down
- 12:29for a second. All right. I actually
- 12:30would have done that with you if I
- 12:31wasn't about to do a bit. All right,
- 12:33let's
- 12:33>> But, for major depressive disorder, I'm
- 12:35going to do a bit here and this is
- 12:36controversial, but I want to put lithium
- 12:38in S class.
- 12:40Okay, put it up there, but there's a
- 12:42caveat. Oh, great bit, Dr. Drew.
- 12:46>> It's because, uh, lithium is all the way
- 12:48at the bottom there under the Xanax.
- 12:51As it always is in real life.
- 12:52Wait. Oh.
- 12:54Yeah, there you go. Boom.
- 12:57Why? Well, if we narrowly define major
- 13:00depressive disorder as simply the state
- 13:03of depression that somebody is in and
- 13:05then we take the population of people
- 13:07who have recurrent major depressive
- 13:09episodes, uh, that require medication
- 13:12treatments and don't respond to, uh,
- 13:14psychotherapy treatments or lifestyle
- 13:16changes,
- 13:17um, as we go down and narrow the
- 13:20population of people that have
- 13:21experienced that, uh, over time, you are
- 13:24going to see more and more of those
- 13:25people who may have a bipolar depression
- 13:28that the underlying cause is a bipolar
- 13:30disorder, not a unipolar depression. And
- 13:33on top of that, we have to remember that
- 13:34there are varieties of major depression.
- 13:37Again, not from personality, not from
- 13:39trauma, not from stress, but any more
- 13:42biological major depressive episodes can
- 13:45be agitated depressions where you have
- 13:47severe
- 13:48insomnias,
- 13:50you have just psychomotor agitation. Are
- 13:53these bipolar disorders? Uh no, not by
- 13:56our modern definitions, but do they
- 13:58respond
- 13:59to mood stabilization? They may. And it
- 14:02can explain why the antipsychotic
- 14:04augmentation is so effective in the
- 14:07studies. In my opinion, that may be an
- 14:09artifact of our poor differentiation of
- 14:13people who have a physiology, let's call
- 14:15it a psychophysiology, closer to a
- 14:17bipolar disorder, yet never actually
- 14:19qualify for a bipolar disorder. And yes,
- 14:22there are a couple little studies
- 14:23showing efficacy of lithium as an
- 14:25augmentation agent in unipolar
- 14:27depression. So, I'm putting it up there
- 14:30more as a position statement than a true
- 14:33this is a first-line medication for
- 14:35depression.
- 14:36And that's I wanted to do position
- 14:38statements. That's why I wanted to make
- 14:40it feel space. Um I am supporting your S
- 14:44class of lithium. And again, not for
- 14:47first line. But uh we we talked about
- 14:50this. Nassir Ghaemi is a huge proponent.
- 14:52He he's
- 14:54He's a proponent of
- 14:56of the
- 14:58uh manic depressive illness being any
- 15:00sort of recurrent mood disorder
- 15:01independent of polarity and feels that
- 15:04lithium is first line for any patients
- 15:06who fit that. And he's a big proponent
- 15:08of arguing that lithium should be used
- 15:10significantly earlier. And he he puts it
- 15:13He thinks it should be used for any
- 15:14patients with temperament issues.
- 15:16Um
- 15:17one thing that's important that people
- 15:19need to I I people providers should get
- 15:21better at Is using low-dose lithium. So,
- 15:24Yes. there's a good um YouTube channel
- 15:26called Psych Education. It's Dr. Jim
- 15:28Phelps. He He has a few videos that kind
- 15:30of walk through thinking through using
- 15:32low-dose lithium. Now,
- 15:35the the thing is like it's just convent-
- 15:37it's not just convention, but with
- 15:39low-dose lithium we don't need to be
- 15:41monitoring all labs. Uh we don't need to
- 15:43have the same lab monitoring schedule
- 15:45that we have with with higher-dose
- 15:47lithium. We wouldn't expect the same
- 15:49level of kidney dysfunction, the same
- 15:51level of all the other problems with
- 15:53lithium. Um
- 15:54and
- 15:56I do agree that so many providers are
- 15:58scared of lithium. We should do it We
- 16:00need to do uh
- 16:01a lithium episode. I've had so many
- 16:03people that say like they're scared to
- 16:04use it. And I feel like if we just did
- 16:06one good episode on using it, I think we
- 16:09would change
- 16:10two people's practicing habits.
- 16:12>> [laughter]
- 16:13>> I hope so. Uh but as you know, I'm
- 16:15always like uh oh, you know, can we
- 16:17really make an episode out of that? Just
- 16:18like today when you mention this as a
- 16:20topic, I was like, this isn't going to
- 16:21make an episode. We have to cover every
- 16:23single diagnostic class ever. Uh but now
- 16:25it's obvious to me that you're right.
- 16:27So, uh we'll keep that in mind.
- 16:29All right. Let's Let's uh
- 16:31So, you did your bit. I I don't know if
- 16:33I would call it a bit. I didn't I didn't
- 16:36I don't know.
- 16:37I would call it a bit. But uh yeah,
- 16:39Prozac totally, man. I absolutely agree.
- 16:41That's the next one that we're going to
- 16:42put up.
- 16:44For me, that's A class.
- 16:47So,
- 16:49I'll let you go and then I'll explain
- 16:51why I have it in B class.
- 16:53Oh, B class for you, man. Okay, Prozac's
- 16:57awesome.
- 16:58Okay. Is it the best tolerated? No.
- 17:01But um it's kind of like Haldol.
- 17:04All right. It's so old that the FDA max
- 17:07is really high. So, you have a really
- 17:09high upper cap in terms of level of uh
- 17:11drug activity when you need it.
- 17:13Secondly, uh that also means that the
- 17:16starter dose, the low doses, even 10 mg
- 17:18can be completely efficacious
- 17:21for people who are medication naive or
- 17:23have relatively lower disease burden.
- 17:26Okay? Great med. Another good thing
- 17:28about Prozac, just like Abilify, if your
- 17:30patient tends to miss doses, skip doses,
- 17:33great medication. You can just give a
- 17:35higher dose and they skip a few doses a
- 17:37week.
- 17:38Long half-life, still gives you
- 17:39effective serum level. I believe they
- 17:42even had FDA approved a once-a-week
- 17:44version of Prozac at one point,
- 17:46fluoxetine that is. Called something
- 17:49else where you only have to take, I
- 17:50think it was like 80 mg once a week or
- 17:52something, which would be equivalent to
- 17:53a
- 17:54um
- 17:56you know,
- 17:5620 mg daily dose or something like that.
- 17:58I don't recommend you do this, by the
- 18:00way.
- 18:00These are strategies that you can use
- 18:03for patients with
- 18:04limited adherence despite counseling.
- 18:07Downsides, why it's not S-tier, well
- 18:12maybe a little bit more sexual side
- 18:14effects possibly.
- 18:16Maybe a little bit more activating or
- 18:18agitating in some.
- 18:20And
- 18:21plenty of medication medication side
- 18:24effects, med-med, not side effects,
- 18:26med-med interactions a little bit more
- 18:27common with Prozac.
- 18:30Yeah.
- 18:32Um
- 18:32I guess in terms of a few comments, the
- 18:35reason why I put it in B class is
- 18:37strictly has nothing to do with the
- 18:38medication itself.
- 18:40For some reason with with sertraline and
- 18:41escitalopram, like I know exactly how to
- 18:44think about the dosing
- 18:46in terms of like when I'm at halfway FDA
- 18:48max, when I'm thinking starting dose.
- 18:51For some reason fluoxetine always gets
- 18:53me a little bit nervous. And I don't
- 18:55know if it's cuz there's like capsules
- 18:56and tablets and
- 18:58uh I don't know, for some reason I get I
- 19:01get anxious about using fluoxetine
- 19:05just because I think I've used it
- 19:06slightly less than than sertraline and
- 19:09escitalopram. Now, [snorts] I guess if a
- 19:10few other comments I think you're right
- 19:12to feel that way. Go on. Yeah, and I
- 19:14don't know if it's just in my head. Um
- 19:18but the
- 19:19>> Um I would say that that's actually from
- 19:22the fact that it's the oldest one. And
- 19:24therefore like Haldol the FDA max is
- 19:27higher.
- 19:28Um
- 19:29fluoxetine I think it is easier to go
- 19:31too high to where you tip the scales for
- 19:35risk over benefit where there's more
- 19:37side effects than benefit. And people
- 19:39just think that FDA maximums are
- 19:42equivalent. They are not equivalent. Um
- 19:45do not assume that the max of FDA
- 19:47approval on one medication is equivalent
- 19:49to another.
- 19:50Uh fluoxetine is basically the Haldol of
- 19:53SSRIs.
- 19:55Now, the other comments with regards to
- 19:57what you're saying, I do think of it as
- 19:59being
- 20:00population-based slightly less efficacy
- 20:02compared to sertraline or escitalopram.
- 20:04I may maybe it's the Cipriani study. It
- 20:06just comes up a little bit less
- 20:08effective than escitalopram and
- 20:11sertraline.
- 20:13Um there are are there are more
- 20:15drug-drug interactions. So, any sort of
- 20:17patient uh that I'm I'm worried about
- 20:19drug-drug interactions, I'm going to be
- 20:20a little bit more wary about. Um
- 20:23I do really like the extended half-life.
- 20:26It is great for patients that you expect
- 20:28to miss a few doses.
- 20:30Um
- 20:32Now,
- 20:35people a lot of people categorize
- 20:37fluoxetine as the most weight neutral. I
- 20:40think there was some study that like in
- 20:41a short short very short term there
- 20:43might have been like some even weight
- 20:45loss.
- 20:46I don't see a significant difference. I
- 20:48don't think it's anything that um will
- 20:51make me actually think that there will
- 20:53be a big difference if I switch someone
- 20:54from
- 20:55one of the medications to fluoxetine. Um
- 20:58clinically I haven't seen a big
- 20:59difference.
- 21:01I'm trying to think if there's any other
- 21:02comments that I have
- 21:04with regards to fluoxetine. It is known
- 21:06to be a little bit more activating.
- 21:08Um
- 21:09I don't typically see it much worse
- 21:11though than than escitalopram.
- 21:15Yeah, that's that's my my reflections.
- 21:17>> Yeah, you know, when it comes to weight
- 21:18gain, I personally try to disregard
- 21:23the hard numbers found in population
- 21:25studies because the population studies
- 21:27can't differentiate uh between weight
- 21:30gain as a direct metabolic cause of a
- 21:32medication and weight gain as a
- 21:35consequence of treatment. What do I mean
- 21:37by this? Uh if you sedate a person or if
- 21:40you treat their anxious depression that
- 21:42lowers your appetite, then their
- 21:44appetite will come back. And if that
- 21:46person uh does not already have healthy
- 21:48eating habits and they happen to be in
- 21:50the United States like our patients,
- 21:53uh then they're probably going to gain
- 21:54weight. Right? That's different than a
- 21:56medication that we know to directly
- 21:59stimulate the appetite uh through some
- 22:02known mechanism or that even induces a
- 22:05uh drug-created metabolic syndrome like,
- 22:08for example, Seroquel. Right? So I I I
- 22:12don't consider any of the SSRIs except
- 22:17for Paxil a direct weight gain-causing
- 22:20medication. Can they apparently cause a
- 22:23more
- 22:24uh drug-driven weight gain in some
- 22:26patients? Yeah. Yeah, you see that
- 22:28occasionally. But you can kind of tell
- 22:31from actually checking in with the
- 22:32patient about their eating habits at
- 22:34baseline and their eating habits after
- 22:37the medication. Now, if we were being
- 22:40just straightforward about this, I think
- 22:43the next one um that we would rank would
- 22:47probably be Paxil. But before that, I
- 22:50want to add more into the F tier. Okay?
- 22:53Uh I want to add We have Dexedrine down
- 22:56there for some reason. Let's just put
- 22:57that right next to the Adderall. And I'm
- 23:00also going to go ahead and put in any
- 23:02benzos. So, Ativan, Xanax, uh both of
- 23:05those go into F tier as well.
- 23:08Uh where else do we What else is on this
- 23:10list here? Okay, that's all the ones
- 23:12that we have there. Uh we might as well
- 23:14put
- 23:14>> see dextroamphetamine. Oh, there we are.
- 23:16Right there, right there.
- 23:18Okay.
- 23:20Okay. We'll hold off on the rest for
- 23:22now, I think. We put all the benzos
- 23:24there, right?
- 23:25>> Why are you putting the benzos in F
- 23:26tier?
- 23:28Um again, similar to the stimulants,
- 23:30they are symptomatic treatments that
- 23:33create habits, uh build tolerance, and
- 23:36stop working. They're not fundamental
- 23:39uh treatments of the underlying
- 23:40condition, so much as they are that
- 23:42they're drugs that help people feel
- 23:44better temporarily, you know? Um really
- 23:46not too different than a prescribed
- 23:48version of a street drug in my mind.
- 23:50Okay, controversial, I know. I know back
- 23:52in the day, especially for the world
- 23:54well population, a lot of people would
- 23:56give a couple weeks of benzos uh with
- 23:58the first start of the SSRI. Okay, I
- 24:01think if you need to do that, you may be
- 24:04using SSRIs too early, okay? If a
- 24:07patient is going to react with that
- 24:09level of anxiety to an SSRI, and they
- 24:14are not so psychomotor
- 24:17uh
- 24:18you know, slowed and majorly depressed,
- 24:21why aren't we just giving them a talk
- 24:24therapy and behavioral activation
- 24:25instead? The effect size is the same.
- 24:28Why subject them to the SSRI? There's
- 24:30really no point to do that, right? No
- 24:32need for the medication um unless the
- 24:34patient is motivated, willing, feels
- 24:36good about it,
- 24:37uh or it's like a medical necessity. And
- 24:40anyway, I do prefer to stabilize the
- 24:42sleep using other agents anyway.
- 24:45I So, I agree with putting in the F
- 24:46class. I will again defend it a little
- 24:49bit. There are a lot of patients that
- 24:52I'm not acute stress reaction is not
- 24:54what I'm trying to say. When patients
- 24:55have very high stress, and I see an
- 24:57agitated type depression, um it it I've
- 25:01seen it be incredibly helpful,
- 25:02especially patients that have
- 25:04really really really bad insomnia. I'm
- 25:06not talking about chronic insomnia. I'm
- 25:08talking about patients who
- 25:10I I I'm thinking of a lot of patients
- 25:11who have like a ton of stress at work,
- 25:13um have some some major crisis or death
- 25:16in the family, and the
- 25:19benzodiazepines can help as a short-term
- 25:221-week prescription to get over that
- 25:26crisis, which is partially depression.
- 25:28Now, I agree I don't think of it as
- 25:31it is symptomatic treatment. You can use
- 25:33other sleepers.
- 25:35Um I do find the benzodiazepines are
- 25:39the most likely to have
- 25:42not a lot of problems when
- 25:44not in the long term. I'm talking about
- 25:45like
- 25:47trazodone, sometimes I'll have patients
- 25:48who have a paradoxical reaction with the
- 25:50metabolite.
- 25:51Um
- 25:52Other medications, sometimes they don't
- 25:54work as well or they work a little bit.
- 25:55The benzos will knock people out. So, I
- 25:58do keep it in my after year, but I don't
- 26:00think it's a completely useless
- 26:01medication even in
- 26:04short-term depression, although I'm not
- 26:05thinking of it as treating the
- 26:06depression so much as much as
- 26:08uh things going along with the
- 26:10depression. In essence, it's keeping
- 26:11them functional
- 26:13while
- 26:15under a lot of stress.
- 26:17Yeah, it's not ineffective. It's that
- 26:21it's not effective for what we're trying
- 26:23to do. That That's my philosophy. Yeah.
- 26:25Um I think that what you're referring to
- 26:28can just as easily be accomplished by
- 26:30high-dose hydroxyzine, low-dose
- 26:32trazodone,
- 26:34uh gabapentin at higher doses,
- 26:37uh
- 26:38you know,
- 26:40mirtazapine if you have to, Seroquel
- 26:42over benzodiazepine any day. There
- 26:44There's a lot of choices, I think. If
- 26:46we're going to do a short-term hypnotic,
- 26:49I would reach for Seroquel every time
- 26:50over a benzodiazepine. Don't get into it
- 26:52is what I say. We're doing We're doing a
- 26:54tier list for insomnia, so we'll we'll
- 26:55get there.
- 26:56>> of
- 26:58What's that? I said we're doing We're
- 26:59going to do a tier list for insomnia.
- 27:01So, we We'll We'll get into the more
- 27:03details in that one.
- 27:04>> Yeah.
- 27:05Yeah. Um yeah, it's not as if benzos are
- 27:08without adverse effects. It's just that
- 27:10so often people love the
- 27:13uh drug effects so much um
- 27:15understandably. They work great. You
- 27:17feel great. Um
- 27:19we ignore the adverse effects, but
- 27:20people are just as likely to have
- 27:22adverse effects on these medications. I
- 27:24just stay away from them.
- 27:25All right.
- 27:26Let's move on to our next one. I think
- 27:29we got the Paxil. Paxil.
- 27:33>> [gasps]
- 27:34>> Oh boy. You know, it's a very hard one
- 27:36for me to place. It's got to be either B
- 27:39or C and
- 27:42uh I have to fight against my bias. I
- 27:44think it is a B class medication
- 27:46ultimately with a big caveat. I would
- 27:48give it B- if
- 27:49I can.
- 27:51Because uh it's quite effective.
- 27:53Okay.
- 27:54Uh there's a reason why it's been FDA
- 27:57approved specifically for so many
- 27:59neurotic conditions.
- 28:01Uh
- 28:02it's great in terms of its efficacy. It
- 28:05works quickly, you know, and you it's a
- 28:08sleeper on top of being an
- 28:10antidepressant class medication. You get
- 28:12a lot of bang for your buck there on one
- 28:14tablet, easy to dose. Uh there's
- 28:16long-acting form and short-acting form.
- 28:19Uh a lot of good options. But, weight
- 28:21gain, weight gain, weight gain.
- 28:23Anticholinergic effects, dry mouth, dry
- 28:26eyes, constipation.
- 28:28Um what else with Paxil that's a
- 28:30problem? Well, it's a very short
- 28:32half-life. So, if somebody is not very
- 28:34med adherent, then it's likely to cause
- 28:37uh a little sense of withdrawal in some
- 28:40people. So, it's uncomfortable.
- 28:42Uh I've been I was taught that, "Hey,
- 28:45this is something you should consider
- 28:46for patients with poor med They'll
- 28:47notice the withdrawal and remember to
- 28:49take medication. I feel like that's very
- 28:51outdated. Set alarm on the phone, use a
- 28:52pill organizer. I think that's a
- 28:54ridiculous notion. So, um despite its
- 28:57efficacy, I cannot rank this one highly.
- 28:59I certainly never use it first line and
- 29:01I hardly ever prescribe it, uh as you
- 29:03know, because of the weight gain.
- 29:05Uh first off, that's hysterical. The
- 29:07idea of using it for patients who are
- 29:08non-adherent because it's so punishing
- 29:10when you miss it.
- 29:11>> [laughter]
- 29:12>> Yeah, it's ridiculous.
- 29:14Just a small plug to leave a review if
- 29:17you can. Leaving a review will help
- 29:18other clinicians find our show and will
- 29:21let us keep making it. If you're on
- 29:23Apple Podcasts, open the show page,
- 29:25scroll to ratings and review. If you
- 29:27like us, tap five stars. If you're not
- 29:30sure of what to put for the review, just
- 29:31say "Hi Dr. Foo." And if you're on
- 29:34Reddit or YouTube, leave a comment. Dr.
- 29:36Foo reads absolutely every single one.
- 29:39Let's get back to the show.
- 29:41As I just got a dog, so there's you
- 29:43know, the the new movement is all
- 29:44positive reinforcement and that is not
- 29:47using positive reinforcement in in your
- 29:49line of reasoning for medications. So,
- 29:52paroxetine, cuz we got to make sure we
- 29:53use
- 29:54>> Don't tell me they're gentle parenting
- 29:55dogs now, too.
- 29:57There's a lot of people who refuse to
- 29:58use any sort of uh balanced training.
- 30:00But, paroxetine
- 30:02they're called SSRIs, selective
- 30:04serotonin reuptake inhibitors. They are
- 30:05not all selective. So, paroxetine hits
- 30:08is an is antimuscarinic and that helps
- 30:10me to organize all the information that
- 30:12you kind of just mentioned. So, it is
- 30:14sedating. Um it does have bad withdrawal
- 30:16because we know any antimuscarinic
- 30:18medication is going to have bad
- 30:19withdrawal. Short half-life. Um
- 30:22now, bad for pregnancy and
- 30:26uh what's the other bad one? Bad for
- 30:27weight gain. Most of that you can
- 30:29categorize as antimuscarinic. I'm not
- 30:31saying that that is the you know, reason
- 30:33why, but
- 30:34that does help me categorize a lot of
- 30:36the problems with Paxil.
- 30:37Now, as you mentioned, the
- 30:38antimuscarinic also probably has some
- 30:41effects with regards to helpfulness in
- 30:43some anxiety disorders. And that's why
- 30:45you said neurotic conditions, but
- 30:46anxiety
- 30:48Yeah, for for people who Mhm. Mhm. don't
- 30:50don't know what that means. The it has a
- 30:52lot of FDA indications for
- 30:53>> that's why it got an approval for PTSD,
- 30:55right? Cuz the PTSD treatment for
- 30:58diagnosable PTSD early on, majority of
- 31:00what you're really what you really
- 31:02should be doing is sleep stabilization.
- 31:05And Paxil will hit both your sleep
- 31:06stabilization and the treatment of the
- 31:09severity of core PTSD symptoms. So,
- 31:12great med for that, but I'd rather skip
- 31:14the weight gain and just give a sleeper
- 31:16with Zoloft, which is what I usually do.
- 31:18Yeah. I I would probably put it in C.
- 31:21Now, it's funny, I think we're balancing
- 31:22like right now a lot of people just
- 31:24simply don't use Paxil. So, I think it's
- 31:26higher ranked than that. But then anyone
- 31:28who's using Paxil first line, you got to
- 31:30knock it down. I probably would put it
- 31:31in C, but I'm fine with B.
- 31:32>> Yeah. You know what? Let's put it in C.
- 31:34You've convinced me. Okay, it was on the
- 31:36edge. Put it in C.
- 31:38You know, bad Paxil. Don't give it so
- 31:40much weight gain. We can use other
- 31:42things.
- 31:44All right. What's our I think
- 31:47round out the SSRIs, but I'll let you
- 31:49keep us going.
- 31:51Should we
- 31:53Well, let's briefly put Celexa in. It's
- 31:55basically Lexapro, but that makes you
- 31:58more sleepy and it causes you
- 32:00more QTc prolongation. I never use it
- 32:04because of that because there's just so
- 32:05many other choices, but I can see why an
- 32:07older psychiatrist might use it. It has
- 32:10to be in B class. It's again just
- 32:12Lexapro, but it makes you more sleepy
- 32:14and it prolongs your heart rhythm. So,
- 32:17it's not a bad medication by any means.
- 32:19It's just got some downsides and in my
- 32:21opinion, there's hardly a reason not to
- 32:23use a different medication.
- 32:25All right, I'll I'll I'll let me go off
- 32:26my soapbox on this one. So, little
- 32:28didactics.
- 32:29Citalopram is both an enantiomer of
- 32:32escitalopram. So, that's why it's named
- 32:34escitalopram cuz cuz the S enantiomer.
- 32:36So, theoretically, the R-enantiomer has
- 32:39a little bit of antihistaminergic
- 32:41activity, and that's why it's probably a
- 32:43little bit more sedating. Now, I have
- 32:45seen on the Reddits people being like,
- 32:47"Oh, uh a nurse practitioner." Now, I
- 32:49hate I I do I strongly dislike the NP
- 32:52hate on Reddit, and I try I try my best
- 32:54to defend the NPs. The
- 32:56they'll say like, "The nurse
- 32:57practitioner switched them from
- 32:58escitalopram to citalopram. What a
- 33:00moron." And
- 33:02what I'll say to that is
- 33:04often times these medication like
- 33:06reactions patients have to medications
- 33:08isn't what we would expect based on what
- 33:10we know pharmacologically. So, I don't
- 33:13see patients respond to citalopram as if
- 33:16it's escitalopram with a little bit of
- 33:17sedation. I've seen patients get
- 33:19opposite responses and opposite side
- 33:22effects. I've seen patients who have not
- 33:25been able to tolerate escitalopram and
- 33:27then tolerate citalopram perfectly fine.
- 33:29So,
- 33:31now
- 33:32I don't think it makes sense to go from
- 33:33escitalopram to citalopram
- 33:36for for most of the time. But, if
- 33:38someone does have a good response to
- 33:39citalopram, I don't say like that's not
- 33:41possible because they something, you
- 33:43know,
- 33:44we don't know how these medications work
- 33:45exactly and how patients respond to them
- 33:48is cannot be deduced from what we
- 33:50understand pharmacologically.
- 33:52So, that's that's my soapbox.
- 33:54Yeah, it can be defended exactly as you
- 33:57have. I simply never do it because
- 33:59there's just too many options out there,
- 34:01you know,
- 34:02uh if you take every permutation
- 34:05of hypnotic anxiolytic sleep support
- 34:08medication plus primary serotonin-based
- 34:11anxiety-depression medication,
- 34:14never have to reach for the same
- 34:15medication twice, you know,
- 34:18uh if it's been a few years
- 34:20and I want to do a trial again and
- 34:22they're super against escitalopram and
- 34:25there's some reason why I want to use
- 34:26it. I really can't imagine the
- 34:27situation. I might do it. But, um
- 34:30basically, if I'm on my third or fourth
- 34:34medication and this isn't some kind of a
- 34:36super zebra patient, like someone with
- 34:39autism spectrum disorder, borderline
- 34:41personality disorder, uh psychotic
- 34:43features, and like three
- 34:45hospitalizations where it's like clearly
- 34:48both a social, psychological, and a
- 34:52biological thing and I'm doing all kinds
- 34:54of weird stuff. Uh, if you're treating
- 34:57major depression and you're on your
- 34:58third medication in a row with no
- 35:00remission, reconsider your diagnosis.
- 35:02Yeah, absolutely.
- 35:04Um, one last comment about citalopram, I
- 35:06feel like uh
- 35:0840 mg is the max dose except it's 20 mg
- 35:13is the max dose for I think elderly
- 35:15patients. I think patients over 60,
- 35:17uh patients who are poor to C19
- 35:21metabolizers.
- 35:22Um
- 35:25Yeah, max dose is 20 mg.
- 35:27There might be another other population,
- 35:29but I can't think of it off
- 35:30top of my head.
- 35:33We have
- 35:35not yet exhausted the rest of the SSRIs,
- 35:38so let's do Luvox, the sigma
- 35:42the sigma of the SSRIs. Technically, it
- 35:46has sigma receptor activity. Um, where
- 35:49do we
- 35:50put Luvox?
- 35:52>> Yeah, sigma grindset antidepressant. I
- 35:54don't know.
- 35:55I don't know.
- 35:57I think we should keep it in a question
- 35:58mark. It's just simply such a backline
- 36:01choice uh that you pretty much only use
- 36:04in patients to have OCD
- 36:06uh that I don't think we can fairly
- 36:08grade it. The sigma they use it
- 36:12>> uh SSRI that goes its own way, isn't it?
- 36:14I've had some patients get a little
- 36:15sedated on it.
- 36:17It's not too hard to titrate. The main
- 36:19reason why I don't use it more
- 36:21is because I think there's random
- 36:23insurance denials and it's just um
- 36:26again, too many men-men drug
- 36:27interactions. There's no particularly
- 36:29good reason to use it over the other
- 36:31ones. I haven't seen that sigma thing
- 36:33actually play out in better clinical
- 36:35response for a major depression. So, uh,
- 36:38very niche pick, you know? But, maybe
- 36:40it's a sleeper hit that we're just not
- 36:41using enough. Hard for me to say.
- 36:43Yeah, the men-men interactions, it
- 36:45inhibits, um, especially sip 182, and
- 36:49then basically all of them, 2C9, 2C19,
- 36:51sip 3A4.
- 36:53Um,
- 36:54I think it was studied a little bit for
- 36:56like COVID because of the sigma enigma.
- 36:59Um,
- 37:01Yeah, apparently there was a signal that
- 37:04it reduced COVID mortality, I think.
- 37:08But, Who knows? Who knows?
- 37:10All right.
- 37:11What do we got next?
- 37:13Well, we surely are now in the realm of
- 37:15the SNRIs. Boom. And, uh, I think we
- 37:19should start with good old Effexor,
- 37:21venlafaxine.
- 37:23Okay, um,
- 37:25Jeez.
- 37:27Ah. Almost forgot to put it in B.
- 37:29>> B and A class for me.
- 37:31Between B and A class. Let's put it in
- 37:33B.
- 37:34Oh, definitely B class for me.
- 37:35Definitely B for me. Venlafaxine, mhm.
- 37:38And, why?
- 37:39Well, you know, um, it works.
- 37:43I have to admit it works, and you know,
- 37:44you're going to see all kinds of, uh,
- 37:46psychopharmacologists crying,
- 37:48uh, you guys are pretending this is a
- 37:51SNRI. There's no norepinephrine activity
- 37:54until at least 150. Some studies do not
- 37:57show a blood pressure response when used
- 37:59with so-and-so medication. In the
- 38:01studies, there's no norepinephrine
- 38:02activity. Well,
- 38:04there may not be,
- 38:06but belief is strong,
- 38:08and
- 38:09I just tend to see more response on this
- 38:13compared to some other medications for
- 38:15some reason. I can't explain it.
- 38:17Uh,
- 38:18seems to be pretty well tolerated,
- 38:19actually. The only downside is the awful
- 38:21withdrawal syndrome. I'd probably put it
- 38:23in A class and I'd probably use it a lot
- 38:25more often. I might even put it in S
- 38:27class if it weren't for that terrible
- 38:30withdrawal syndrome.
- 38:32Famously the worst withdrawal syndrome
- 38:34out of all the antidepressants. I've
- 38:35even seen an elderly person get
- 38:38medically hospitalized once because of
- 38:40the withdrawal from venlafaxine.
- 38:43So you know, it works well but just be
- 38:46careful. You you want to you know, taper
- 38:48it slowly.
- 38:50It's also a little annoying I feel like
- 38:53because I want I'm fine with it
- 38:56titrating up but I also feel like I wish
- 38:59it came in smaller increments for
- 39:01titrating down. But
- 39:03if you have to come off of it you're
- 39:04just going to accept some brain zaps and
- 39:06whatnot.
- 39:08Yeah, I I think I have less of less warm
- 39:11feelings for for venlafaxine.
- 39:13Um
- 39:15Yeah, the the withdrawal is famous.
- 39:17You'll hear lots of horror stories.
- 39:19That's it. I've actually had relative
- 39:21success. The the patients that I've
- 39:23tapered off I had no no major hiccups.
- 39:26Um but I'm not minimizing it. I've also
- 39:28seen horror cases. I've seen patients in
- 39:31the emergency room crying
- 39:33just feeling like absolutely horrendous
- 39:35as a result of of venlafaxine
- 39:37withdrawal. So I'm not It seems very hit
- 39:38and miss.
- 39:39>> saying I'm not minimizing and saying
- 39:41it's not real but for the average
- 39:43patient before they have a complicated
- 39:45withdrawal I don't kick and scream. I
- 39:47tell them to probably be careful about
- 39:50what they read online. Um
- 39:52Now I don't like venlafaxine because
- 39:55it's improvement over SSRIs is
- 39:57relatively small.
- 39:58So it's not like it's this big hit
- 40:00medication.
- 40:02There it can raise blood pressure.
- 40:05It Yep. can raise heart rate.
- 40:07So there are more side effects. There's
- 40:09more problems. Now
- 40:11in Europe there's a warning for overdose
- 40:15uh,
- 40:16because of its cardiac effects in
- 40:18overdose. I think
- 40:20um,
- 40:21I feel like that's something in the US
- 40:22that we don't pay as much attention to,
- 40:23that there are cardiac problems as a
- 40:25result in terms of arrhythmia risk with
- 40:27these medications.
- 40:28Um,
- 40:29Yeah. So, I tend to avoid it with anyone
- 40:31with any sort
- 40:32>> not as much as the TCAs. I mean, it's
- 40:33real, but it's just not as much as the
- 40:35TCAs. That's all. Yeah. Um, so, I think
- 40:38of it as like very marginal improvement
- 40:40over the SSRIs.
- 40:42Um,
- 40:42a lot of side effects, a lot of
- 40:43problems. Now, I don't think it's a
- 40:45useless medication. I will use it, but
- 40:48I I don't think you jump the gun. I
- 40:50don't think there's ever a patient that
- 40:52I'll use it first line unless I'm using
- 40:54the two birds one stone, like migraine
- 40:56or something very specific that makes me
- 40:58feel like it would work. But,
- 41:00in general, I'm doing first line
- 41:02sertraline, SSRIs. Um, I don't typically
- 41:05start with venlafaxine.
- 41:08Yeah, I don't go for the SNRIs unless,
- 41:11as you say, they have a migraine
- 41:12disorder, a diagnosed fibromyalgia.
- 41:16Um,
- 41:17I don't believe in it, by the way, for
- 41:19apparent ADHD. If you really think
- 41:21there's a diagnosable ADHD, you should
- 41:23probably be using at least atomoxetine,
- 41:25Strattera.
- 41:27Uh, but, you know,
- 41:29it's useful.
- 41:31I'm warm to it because I've been burned
- 41:34enough from receiving for some reason, I
- 41:37don't know why this is. Maybe you can
- 41:39shed some light on this. In the
- 41:40community here, for some reason, there's
- 41:43a lot of people doing venlafaxine
- 41:46And no, it's not a cross-taper. Okay,
- 41:48they love to do venlafaxine plus Zoloft,
- 41:51SNRI plus SSRI.
- 41:52>> Ooh. I totally disagree with it. Uh, but
- 41:55then I've been burned by trying to pull
- 41:57off the Effexor first and seeing
- 41:59worsening and then putting them onto
- 42:00Effexor monotherapy and maxing it out
- 42:02and seeing significant improvement. So,
- 42:05uh, you know, I've warmed to it a little
- 42:06bit. Um, the combo that is a little, you
- 42:10know, famous is the California rocket
- 42:12fuel as as coined by Stephen Stahl,
- 42:14which is mirtazapine and venlafaxine.
- 42:17Venlafaxine,
- 42:18anyone who's using an SSRI and SNRI,
- 42:20stop it.
- 42:21>> [laughter]
- 42:22>> Stop it. Yeah, pick one, please. Pick
- 42:25one. That's that's bad.
- 42:26>> Um you know, we might as well throw
- 42:28Cymbalta on here. I think it's C class.
- 42:31Uh you know, there's nothing terribly
- 42:32wrong with Cymbalta. It's on the first
- 42:34one. It's just the first one there.
- 42:37It's again C class. C class.
- 42:40I I
- 42:42I don't have I have venlafaxine Oh, you
- 42:43want to put it up in B class?
- 42:45>> I think of it as I think venlafaxine's
- 42:46probably a little bit more effective and
- 42:47then duloxetine has probably little
- 42:50special indications with regards to
- 42:51pain. Um
- 42:55Well, again, the duloxetine runs into
- 42:57the same problem as the venlafaxine.
- 42:58It's unclear how much of a
- 43:00norepinephrine reuptake inhibitor
- 43:01actually is.
- 43:02>> It's more balanced marketed that way.
- 43:04Yes, we believe it.
- 43:05What's that?
- 43:06>> It's more balanced than venlafaxine.
- 43:08Supposedly, but I believe when they
- 43:10actually go and then study the amount of
- 43:13norepinephrine reuptake inhibition using
- 43:16that method where they measure the blood
- 43:18pressure after giving I already forgot
- 43:20the name of the other chemical.
- 43:23Uh but it may not be very potent at all
- 43:25as far as that goes. The only true SNRI
- 43:29on the market
- 43:30may be
- 43:32um levomilnacipran
- 43:35Wow, it's I can't remember the brand
- 43:36name right now, but it's uh milnacipran.
- 43:39Savella
- 43:41Savella. Um I'm going to go off of my
- 43:43very limited experience with Savella,
- 43:45which I've been able to get approved for
- 43:47patients who have an existing diagnosis
- 43:48of fibromyalgia and who I'm treating for
- 43:50depression because I obviously can't use
- 43:52Fetzima. My patients are low income, so
- 43:54no one gets Fetzima. I would put this
- 43:57one
- 43:59maybe in A class.
- 44:00>> Whoa. Maybe. Maybe, maybe. Yeah.
- 44:04Um
- 44:05actually fulfilling the promise
- 44:08of the SNRI, you know,
- 44:11um
- 44:13and
- 44:14yeah, lots of good titration steps that
- 44:17you can use. Do we also have uh
- 44:19desvenlafaxine lying around here? Yes,
- 44:21we do. There's Pristiq.
- 44:23Um
- 44:24this is again theoretical and so I'm
- 44:26going to let you move these around if
- 44:28you've got more experience with them
- 44:29than me. I can't use it very much, again
- 44:31too expensive, uh but I'd put it up in A
- 44:33class. Better tolerated, less uh
- 44:36withdrawal I've heard than the
- 44:38venlafaxine for some reason, but who
- 44:40knows? I'm shooting in the dark here.
- 44:42Just that it's some some fact so it is
- 44:45not it isn't generic. Um whether it's on
- 44:48formulary is a different question.
- 44:50Desvenlafaxine
- 44:52um
- 44:53theoretically is
- 44:55uh
- 44:59has less drug-drug interactions than
- 45:01venlafaxine. Um I haven't noticed
- 45:03significant difference in terms of
- 45:04efficacy with the the two medications.
- 45:07I would put it at at probably probably a
- 45:09B class.
- 45:10>> hit and miss level for the SNRIs. I feel
- 45:13like it's uh some people it's like no
- 45:15better and then for some people suddenly
- 45:17it works. It's very hard to say. Could
- 45:19be completely random and based on the
- 45:23uh what's happening in their lives. I
- 45:24can't rule that out, but you know, when
- 45:26you're doing med management you just
- 45:27kind of have to work along a certain
- 45:30set of things.
- 45:32All right. Um
- 45:35What have we got next?
- 45:38You know, we probably should have done
- 45:39the atypicals. Oh, yeah, clonidine goes
- 45:42up there. We probably should have done
- 45:43the atypicals before we did the SNRIs
- 45:46because personally I would consider
- 45:48atypicals before the uh SNRIs. I don't
- 45:51mean atypical antipsychotics. I mean the
- 45:54uh you know, non-traditional
- 45:56antidepressants, Wellbutrin and Remeron.
- 45:58Okay, uh despite my hatred of weight
- 46:01gain, I must put Remeron in A class.
- 46:05Okay, if it was not for the weight gain
- 46:08and in many patients, especially Asian
- 46:10patients,
- 46:11who are more sensitive to antihistamine
- 46:13effects, significant sedation. Oh man,
- 46:16it works so good. Works so good. It's
- 46:18almost S class. Great med. Mirtazapine.
- 46:21I Let's put it at the front of the list.
- 46:23>> Yeah, I have it I have it on on Right
- 46:24after Lexapro.
- 46:25>> I have it in probably the S class. Now,
- 46:28in my opinion, oh
- 46:30Oh, for some reason. There we go. In my
- 46:31opinion, first-line medications for
- 46:33antidepressants, I'm thinking of
- 46:35escitalopram, sertraline, mirtazapine,
- 46:38bupropion. I I think those are all
- 46:40reasonable first choices depending on
- 46:42patient profile.
- 46:43Um I very very very rarely deviate from
- 46:46those four. Now, mirtazapine, weight
- 46:49gain. So, for patients that need to gain
- 46:52weight, great medication. It is
- 46:54incredibly sedating. Incredibly
- 46:56incredibly incredibly sedating. Warn
- 46:58your patients that they will feel like a
- 46:59zombie. Now, why do I think it's
- 47:01important to warn patients? Because I
- 47:03tell them the first three or four days
- 47:05you're going to feel like a zombie.
- 47:06Usually what I see with patients is it
- 47:07gets better. And as they adapt, the that
- 47:11zombie hollow like can't do anything
- 47:13feeling is better by day four. And
- 47:15usually it gets better every single day.
- 47:17And there's Think of the first period as
- 47:19kind of getting
- 47:20past the the hump. Another important
- 47:23thing, some people say at the higher
- 47:25doses it's not sedating or it's
- 47:27activating at the higher doses.
- 47:29The better way to put it in my opinion
- 47:31is it's not going from zero to seven and
- 47:35a half
- 47:36is not as sedating as going from 15 to
- 47:4030. So,
- 47:42to me the important thing to teach is
- 47:43it's Did you mean the opposite? It's
- 47:45more sedating to go from zero to seven
- 47:47and a half than it is to go from 15 to
- 47:4830.
- 47:49>> Correct. Correct. And that like it Going
- 47:51from 50 to 30 is more sedating, but it's
- 47:53significantly less of a jump
- 47:56than going from zero to 7.5. In fact,
- 47:59zero Yeah, the most sedating jump is
- 48:01zero to 2.5. So, so for patients who are
- 48:04on super low dose and they're on, you
- 48:06know, I'm on I'm on 7.5. What do you
- 48:08mean I need to get to 30 mg? They'd be
- 48:10like, are you nuts? I'm going to be a
- 48:11zombie.
- 48:12You have to teach that I don't say, oh,
- 48:14it's activating and you'll have more
- 48:16energy, but the jump isn't as big of a
- 48:19jump from the beginning stages.
- 48:22Yeah, uh
- 48:23that's the old tradition, right? I don't
- 48:25believe in it. I I don't think it stops
- 48:27being sedating or increasing sedation at
- 48:30any dose, as you say. Uh it is less of a
- 48:32serious issue for most patients once you
- 48:35get into the 30 range, uh but I've had
- 48:38patients that I just can't tolerate that
- 48:40change anyway. Yeah. So, it really
- 48:42depends. And again, Asians more
- 48:44sensitive to antihistamine effects, so
- 48:46just be aware of that sedation.
- 48:48Um
- 48:50great med, by the way, forgot to mention
- 48:52if you're afraid of GI side effects and
- 48:54sexual side effects, okay? Uh and
- 48:57actually gets you probably some
- 48:59norepinephrine action through a unique
- 49:00mechanism uh versus SNRIs, which on
- 49:04paper are named that but may not get you
- 49:06much norepinephrine action. Also, um
- 49:10has a pathetic but still statistically
- 49:12significant reduction in some
- 49:14populations for meth use disorder. You
- 49:17can get like three less meth days in the
- 49:19month. Pretty good, huh?
- 49:21Yeah, that that the the reason why I
- 49:22bring it up is there's like this paper
- 49:24of like, we don't have a drug to treat
- 49:26meth as if like this is going to uh
- 49:28to- totally change the landscape of meth
- 49:30use.
- 49:31Um yeah, it it helped a little bit. Uh
- 49:34well, it doesn't stop everyone here from
- 49:35throwing it on every single uh person
- 49:39who is incarcerated that has a meth use
- 49:41disorder and wants to sleep because the
- 49:42dorm is noisy.
- 49:43A lot of that going around around here.
- 49:45I imagine.
- 49:46Um so, yeah, great medication, very
- 49:48sedating, uh does increase weight,
- 49:51does help with GI side effects. So, it's
- 49:53a poor man's Zofran.
- 49:56Mhm.
- 49:57Okay.
- 49:58Uh Wellbutrin, great man.
- 50:00Uh hit and miss tolerability.
- 50:03Uh love to throw this on on almost
- 50:04everyone who doesn't respond to just one
- 50:07medication. Uh
- 50:09A class, certainly A class as well. Uh
- 50:12great medication, can give you a pep in
- 50:14your step. Uh beware of using it in
- 50:17patients who have a lot of baseline
- 50:18anxiety. Uh even if this is a medication
- 50:21that seems to treat anxiety in the long
- 50:23term, if the patient can tolerate it, uh
- 50:25the initial burst or worsening anxiety
- 50:27may be intolerable. Uh this is also a
- 50:30medication that you can use with or
- 50:32without depression if people are having
- 50:33problems reaching orgasm. There's been
- 50:35several studies showing that this helps
- 50:37you reach orgasm faster. So, you can use
- 50:39this for anyone with an orgasmic
- 50:41disorder. Um little weight uh loss and
- 50:46appetite decrease, which a lot of people
- 50:47like. Um people use it off-label for
- 50:50ADHD. Never seen it work for that, but
- 50:52why not? Go ahead and throw it on.
- 50:55Um
- 50:56watch out for the sleep problems. And
- 50:58lots of nice little formats, you can
- 51:00play around with it. You want to only
- 51:01have them exposed to it uh in the
- 51:03daytime for some reason, sure, use the
- 51:05SR uh once a day. But, do not play with
- 51:08the dosing if you're using it as
- 51:09monotherapy. If you're using it as
- 51:11monotherapy, you should probably just
- 51:12use the XL types. Absolutely. I think
- 51:15this is a spectacular medication. Um
- 51:17doesn't have very sought out by patients
- 51:20cuz it doesn't have the typical problems
- 51:22that we see with there's, you know, not
- 51:23weight gain, there's not sexual
- 51:24problems, uh there's not sedation. It's
- 51:26a you know, we think of it as a a mild
- 51:28stimulant. Now, my warning to providers
- 51:32is a lot of times people use bupropion
- 51:35for anyone who says they don't want
- 51:36weight gain for any sort of disorder.
- 51:39To me,
- 51:41as a clinician, you should be learning
- 51:43patients that respond well to SSRIs
- 51:46versus patients who will respond well to
- 51:47bupropion. There are patients with
- 51:49depression that I say like
- 51:51I'm telling you that Zoloft will be a
- 51:53much more effective medication for you.
- 51:55Um I I think
- 51:59as you mentioned with anxiety, yes, it
- 52:01does help anxiety for some patients, but
- 52:04it does worsen anxiety for a lot of
- 52:06other patients. And you see I feel like
- 52:10we see pendulum swing so far as if
- 52:12people are answering the question of
- 52:13like either yes, it's bad for anxiety or
- 52:15no, it's it's not bad for anxiety. And
- 52:17there's there's nuance here. So
- 52:20uh
- 52:21I I feel like in med school I learned
- 52:23like never use it for anyone with
- 52:24anxiety. And now I see all over LinkedIn
- 52:26of like why are you not using it in your
- 52:28anxiety patients? What's wrong with you?
- 52:30Um
- 52:31you know, the
- 52:33for for patients who have that very
- 52:35strong anxiety, I I do see it worsen
- 52:38long term. And oftentimes what I'll see
- 52:40is they'll get a little benefit in the
- 52:41beginning as their depression gets
- 52:43treated, but then 4 months, 6 months
- 52:45down the line, I do see a little bit
- 52:47increase in irritability, a little bit
- 52:48of less little more insomnia. There are
- 52:51problems. So there are patients that
- 52:53come wanting a medication that doesn't
- 52:55have problems and I provide the psychoed
- 52:57that like, yes, it would be ideal that
- 52:58we could have an SSRI that doesn't have
- 53:00problems, but that said, I don't think
- 53:01we use an incorrect medication for you
- 53:03be just because it doesn't have the
- 53:04problems you don't want to have.
- 53:06Um
- 53:07yeah. Yeah, you know, the anxiety
- 53:09increase can be substantial. Don't just
- 53:11throw it around because the database
- 53:14shows that the people who tolerate it
- 53:15improve their anxiety. I have had
- 53:17patients with severe anxiety uh
- 53:20actually end up having a major
- 53:21catastrophe at work because of how bad
- 53:24the anxiety was when they started it. Uh
- 53:26for a medication like Wellbutrin in the
- 53:28anxious patient, if we are going to
- 53:29trial it, I recommend they try it for
- 53:31the first time on a weekend or something
- 53:32or they when they have nothing to do.
- 53:33Yeah.
- 53:34Awesome.
- 53:36Um let's see. Also it is a 2D6
- 53:38inhibitor.
- 53:40Um
- 53:41make sure you get your your blood
- 53:42pressure and heart rate.
- 53:43>> 2D6 inhibitor and thus can be used to
- 53:45increase effective dose of your Abilify
- 53:48Maintena and Aristada,
- 53:50which maxes out at a 15 to 20 mg daily
- 53:53dose. This is not medical advice
- 53:55that may increase
- 53:57possible side effects
- 53:58and is technically off-label strategy.
- 54:01>> Yeah. And we also have a validity which
- 54:03I don't think I didn't I used a
- 54:07template that already existed. This one
- 54:08doesn't have a validity.
- 54:10Yeah, this is a weird template. Where
- 54:12are my TCAs? Where are my MAOIs? And
- 54:15yeah.
- 54:16I I had it on my template, but I like
- 54:19this one cuz it had colors.
- 54:21And it was already pre-made and I
- 54:22couldn't pick update it. Yeah. And why
- 54:24are there so many antipsychotics?
- 54:27To make it fun. It's weird. It's a it's
- 54:30a weird template.
- 54:31Let's do trazodone.
- 54:33I think I have to put poor old trazodone
- 54:37into
- 54:39C class
- 54:40C class because we're rating it for
- 54:42major depressive disorder. We're not
- 54:44rating it for trauma disorder or
- 54:47insomnia.
- 54:49It's just not tolerated enough by most
- 54:52people
- 54:54you know at a
- 54:56high dose, a dose that you would need
- 54:57for the antidepressant effect and I
- 55:00don't think when I have had it at that
- 55:03high for people that it's that
- 55:05efficacious for depression primarily.
- 55:07Quite efficacious for sleep, not
- 55:09necessarily all that efficacious for
- 55:11depression, but that again is probably a
- 55:13bias because I only get it up that high
- 55:15in very rare individuals who happen to
- 55:18need this severe polypharmacy type
- 55:21treatment and
- 55:23you know also somehow don't have a QTC
- 55:25problem at a higher dose of trazodone.
- 55:28Now
- 55:29I guess a little some teaching points.
- 55:31Low-dose trazodone is not a small
- 55:34antidepressant. So it is one of those
- 55:35medications that you need to get it to
- 55:36the higher doses. The mechanism is
- 55:39through
- 55:41serotonin reuptake the same as the SSRIs
- 55:43except it's not selective.
- 55:45Um
- 55:47I haven't seen it be a home run. I
- 55:50typically, as you say, will have low
- 55:52dose trazodone and then an SSRI. Um
- 55:55I I agree with the D class
- 55:57recommendation.
- 56:00Um one thing to add, um
- 56:02trazodone has an active metabolite
- 56:04called m-chlorophenylpiperazine and that
- 56:06can cause agitation in some people. So,
- 56:08don't be surprised if even that low dose
- 56:09trazodone or especially that low dose
- 56:11trazodone, some patients report a
- 56:13paradoxical effect on their sleep or
- 56:15their mood. Uh not everyone likes that.
- 56:18It's apparently a designer drug Now that
- 56:20people don't like and can can cause
- 56:22dysphoria.
- 56:22>> Important teaching point here. So, it's
- 56:25tough because
- 56:26what what I do with that information is
- 56:28be careful about how you talk to
- 56:30patients cuz you're using it for
- 56:31insomnia which has a lot to do with
- 56:33anxiety. And by telling them that they
- 56:35might have a paradoxical awful reaction
- 56:37and not sleep that night, you're going
- 56:38to worsen their anxiety using that
- 56:39medication. The flip side is if someone
- 56:42comes and says, "I slept terribly on my
- 56:44trazodone." you have to believe them.
- 56:45And it doesn't mean you don't provide
- 56:46psychoed, but just be wary about how you
- 56:48provide that psychoed.
- 56:51Yeah, I pretty much say, "Hey, this
- 56:52works great for a lot of people and for
- 56:54some people it doesn't work at all and
- 56:55might even make the sleep worse. Uh we
- 56:57don't know. Why don't you just try it
- 56:59out and see if you like it. If you like
- 57:00it, keep taking it. If you don't like
- 57:01it, don't keep taking it." Uh that can
- 57:03be helpful, but I think your population
- 57:05is more neurotic than mine. Believe all
- 57:07insomniacs.
- 57:09All right.
- 57:10Okay, um we're low on time. Let's go a
- 57:12bit quickly. I'm not going to put any of
- 57:14the antipsychotics on this list uh
- 57:17except for Abilify.
- 57:18No, no, no, don't even put them on the
- 57:19list. I don't even want them on the
- 57:20list. Get them off. Get them off.
- 57:22Terrible. Uh they shouldn't be on this
- 57:24list. Uh that's for a different day. But
- 57:26actually, I'm sorry, we're going to put
- 57:27Abilify, low dose Abilify in S tier. Oh,
- 57:31man, that's controversial. S tier, get
- 57:33it up there. But, it has to be
- 57:36under under 5 mg. Um
- 57:40the data and the clinical experience
- 57:42shows that this is a very good
- 57:44augmenting agent. Works great. Uh
- 57:47probably has a unique effect. Uh that's
- 57:49probably true also then the
- 57:50brexpiprazole and maybe of raylar, not
- 57:53clear, a little early to say.
- 57:55Uh but, you know, the dopamine partial
- 57:58agonists uh seem to be pretty good as an
- 58:00add-on. But, um
- 58:02while we're briefly putting it in S
- 58:04tier, let's put it down in A. Thank you
- 58:05very much. You read my mind.
- 58:07>> I refuse to let you get away with
- 58:08putting it in S tier. You are not going
- 58:10to be at You read my mind. I wanted to
- 58:11emphasize how efficacious it is, but
- 58:13even at low doses, the risk of tardive
- 58:15dyskinesia is there. And especially in
- 58:18patients without schizophrenias, okay?
- 58:20The risk of tardive dyskinesia is
- 58:21higher.
- 58:25Um
- 58:26Now, let's see if we can do. So, uh one
- 58:28helpful thing
- 58:30uh tdscreen.ai is a cool free AI to help
- 58:35um screen your patients for tardive
- 58:37dyskinesia.
- 58:38I didn't know this exists. I don't know.
- 58:41Until I can read the research on this,
- 58:43you should know how to do an AIMS.
- 58:44>> See the research.
- 58:45>> Okay. Read the AIMS. Read the AIMS. Read
- 58:48the uh you know, directions and actually
- 58:51do an AIMS and you can do a modified
- 58:53version of the AIMS over video if you
- 58:54have assistance from a family member or
- 58:56nurse. Um okay. Spravato as a nasal
- 59:00Yeah, man. I'm not letting you lead to
- 59:02an increase of antipsychotic use for for
- 59:05I don't think it can get any higher.
- 59:08Do not dose Abilify above 5 mg if what
- 59:11you are trying to do is trying to treat
- 59:13major depressive disorder without
- 59:14psychotic features. Do not do it. Just
- 59:16don't do it. It's not worth it.
- 59:19So, yes. Please please be wary be
- 59:22mindful when you use it. Don't throw it
- 59:23out. Uh
- 59:25I I think there's so many important
- 59:26caveats. Make sure you have the right
- 59:27diagnosis. Make sure you're not ignoring
- 59:29other things. Please don't use more
- 59:30antipsychotics unless you feel very
- 59:32confident with what you're dealing with.
- 59:34Okay.
- 59:35You know, there's going to be a lot of
- 59:36lay people who are going to skip to the
- 59:37end of this video, so let's put put it
- 59:39down in the question mark section.
- 59:40Abilify.
- 59:41>> go from S tier to A tier to question
- 59:42mark.
- 59:44Yeah, I think that's indicative of how
- 59:46we want to think about it.
- 59:47>> Okay.
- 59:48And in the same way, let's go ahead and
- 59:50put Seroquel in the question mark. Well,
- 59:53I agree with the skip, but I think you
- 59:55should put it in
- 59:57Oh, no. No. Come on. Good old Seroquel.
- 59:59I'm just thinking I'm just thinking I
- 1:00:00would I didn't I didn't have it in in
- 1:00:02particular. I think I should be going
- 1:00:03like this. I would not put it anywhere
- 1:00:07just because it's augmentation agent.
- 1:00:08So, it goes in the question mark, but as
- 1:00:10augmentation agent is pretty dang good.
- 1:00:12I would give it a B. It works great in
- 1:00:14anyone who doesn't care about weight
- 1:00:16gain appetite increase, but definitely
- 1:00:17causes a ton of weight gain appetite
- 1:00:19increase. It's got lower risk of tardive
- 1:00:21dyskinesia than other ones and it's
- 1:00:23pretty dang well tolerated. So well
- 1:00:25tolerated, it's hard to get patients off
- 1:00:26of it sometimes once they're stabilized
- 1:00:28because they're like, "Oh man, this
- 1:00:29helped me so much." And then they're
- 1:00:31asleep while destabilized when you pull
- 1:00:32it off at least temporarily. So, use
- 1:00:34with caution Seroquel.
- 1:00:36Um
- 1:00:38Yeah, and I hate I don't want to have
- 1:00:39the high-risk medications be up top
- 1:00:41where they have people be prescribing
- 1:00:43lithium and antipsychotics. Make sure
- 1:00:44you have the right diagnosis, people. Um
- 1:00:47Treatment-resistant depression is where
- 1:00:48personality disorders go to hide.
- 1:00:50Let's carry on.
- 1:00:51Yeah.
- 1:00:52Oh, lithium.
- 1:00:54Actually, I'm not as worried about if
- 1:00:56you're sticking to 300 to 450 as long as
- 1:00:58you're there.
- 1:00:59That does. Yeah. Okay. Vortioxetine.
- 1:01:02It's okay.
- 1:01:04It's all right. You know, you know that
- 1:01:06meme maybe on YouTube where if that guy
- 1:01:08eating that I think it's like a burger
- 1:01:09or something, he's like, "It's all
- 1:01:11right." That's Trintellix. So, I think
- 1:01:13it belongs in B tier.
- 1:01:14>> it's B. I've used more than a couple
- 1:01:16times.
- 1:01:17Where did you go?
- 1:01:18Okay. It didn't really pan out in terms
- 1:01:20of the promises, right? Like helping
- 1:01:21with cognition or is just the one where
- 1:01:23they claim there was um some improvement
- 1:01:25in sexual side effects. I think there
- 1:01:27might be a little bit of signal for
- 1:01:28that. Or is that another one?
- 1:01:30>> and vortioxetine have the signal for
- 1:01:32sexual side effects. Vortioxetine has
- 1:01:34the maybe cognitive effects question
- 1:01:36mark.
- 1:01:38Oh yeah, when they wanted to call it
- 1:01:39Brintellix but there was always like
- 1:01:41some kind of onset already called that.
- 1:01:42Anyway,
- 1:01:43I would put vortioxetine and vilazodone
- 1:01:47on the same tier B. This is expensive,
- 1:01:50it's not particularly more effective
- 1:01:51than others. If you're having someone
- 1:01:53who has a hard time tolerating
- 1:01:54medications, they might be able to
- 1:01:56tolerate it better than the other ones.
- 1:01:57It's worth a try.
- 1:01:59Is it something you reach for first?
- 1:02:01Absolutely not. Is it something that you
- 1:02:03avoid? No. It's called solid B tier.
- 1:02:05>> Yeah, I so I've used a little bit more
- 1:02:06of the vilazodone. Um, you know, I don't
- 1:02:09think I'm not going to be using it first
- 1:02:11line. I have It did help a little bit
- 1:02:12with the sexual side effects. So I had a
- 1:02:13bunch of guys that
- 1:02:15it helped a little bit. It wasn't
- 1:02:17foolproof. It wasn't like they had no
- 1:02:18sexual side effects.
- 1:02:20Um, but it did help a little bit. So I
- 1:02:22do like it as a medication. And I will
- 1:02:24it is I feel like some of these
- 1:02:25medications I'll just never get to.
- 1:02:27Vilazodone I do get to.
- 1:02:29Um.
- 1:02:30Yeah.
- 1:02:31How about esketamine? Whoa. Everyone
- 1:02:34loves their ketamine today.
- 1:02:37This is a C tier class medication for
- 1:02:38me. Yeah. This is a C or a D. Maybe D.
- 1:02:43We're going to upset the people.
- 1:02:45Putting in D.
- 1:02:46It's in D. Why is it in D? It's in D for
- 1:02:49me and I won't budge from that. Why? Uh,
- 1:02:52works great in a select amount of
- 1:02:53people. Can be life saving in a select
- 1:02:55amount of people but unfortunately
- 1:02:57probably has opened up the field to more
- 1:03:00peddling of drugs instead of treatment.
- 1:03:03And also only a 7-day treatment effect
- 1:03:06and I don't think that a lot of these
- 1:03:09clinics giving out Spravato are doing
- 1:03:11the work that they should be in actually
- 1:03:13getting patients into therapy and
- 1:03:15lifestyle changes which is how Spravato
- 1:03:17is going to work. It is a short-term
- 1:03:19treatment that helps you lift out of
- 1:03:21depression and then you have to do
- 1:03:22hardcore lifestyle changes and
- 1:03:25psychotherapy on top of that. It's not
- 1:03:27like one of the other medications in the
- 1:03:29S or the A tier where you can basically
- 1:03:31get someone mostly out of remission even
- 1:03:33if they do zero work and you know, have
- 1:03:36them live their life long term with
- 1:03:37minimal side effects. Spravato a bit of
- 1:03:40a problematic medication. I'm glad it
- 1:03:42was discovered. I'm glad it's being used
- 1:03:44sometimes responsibly but lot of
- 1:03:47caveats.
- 1:03:47>> lots of thoughts that I'm not going to
- 1:03:48go into here. I'm going to say something
- 1:03:50which I shouldn't say cuz it's not going
- 1:03:52to be heard correctly by the people who
- 1:03:53I want to hear it. But to me an
- 1:03:55archetypal risk is and I'm basing this
- 1:03:58off of the few things I've read. This is
- 1:04:00not a political but this is nothing.
- 1:04:02Elon Musk to me is an archetypal hit
- 1:04:04story of the risks that I see with Mhm.
- 1:04:07esketamine. And what I mean by that is
- 1:04:10that there's so many patients now who
- 1:04:12are seeking it out to use it in a sense
- 1:04:15to ignore other problems. And they're
- 1:04:17using it essentially as a drug as in
- 1:04:19they're they're making lifestyle choices
- 1:04:21that are
- 1:04:23leading to that almost bound to lead to
- 1:04:25stress levels that are not manageable.
- 1:04:27And then they're trying to compensate
- 1:04:29with a drug to keep them going. And
- 1:04:31that's what I see with a lot of patients
- 1:04:32who are seeking out a lot of the
- 1:04:33controlled substances is uh
- 1:04:36and that's not all patients. I've seen
- 1:04:38it spectacular treatment. I love that
- 1:04:39it's short-acting
- 1:04:41short
- 1:04:42I like I love that it works right away.
- 1:04:44There's a lot of patients that it helps
- 1:04:45a ton but
- 1:04:47so many patients are now seeking it out
- 1:04:49instead of looking at the other problems
- 1:04:50in their lives. And
- 1:04:53I have a lot more to say that I'm not
- 1:04:53going to right now but yeah, I agree
- 1:04:55with the CD.
- 1:04:59I wish there was buspirone here.
- 1:05:02And I know it's not an approved
- 1:05:03medication for depression.
- 1:05:05But I do think that the a zip arounds
- 1:05:08cuz there's a new one too which I don't
- 1:05:10see a point in using when we have brown.
- 1:05:12I hope you can edit this in, but I would
- 1:05:14put buspirone into the B class.
- 1:05:17Buspirone class.
- 1:05:18>> Because it's just so low risk
- 1:05:20and relatively well tolerated and it is
- 1:05:24pretty efficacious for anxiety, trauma,
- 1:05:26and irritability, which often can come
- 1:05:29hand in hand in your major depression
- 1:05:30patients.
- 1:05:31It works for augmentation.
- 1:05:34Just don't under dose it. Start at 15,
- 1:05:37but be ready to go down if the patient
- 1:05:40is more sensitive to it and don't be
- 1:05:42afraid to take it to the max. Buspirone,
- 1:05:43buspirone, buspirone, buspirone.
- 1:05:45>> Also
- 1:05:46Big fan of it these days.
- 1:05:47>> Um I've also seen Isn't there that small
- 1:05:48study that it helped with the sexual
- 1:05:50side effects of the SSRIs?
- 1:05:53Yes, I also use it along with bupropion
- 1:05:55to help with sexual side effects and
- 1:05:57yeah, it seems to have some efficacy for
- 1:05:59that. So if someone needs to stay on
- 1:06:01something and they're having too much
- 1:06:02anorgasmia,
- 1:06:03reach for the buspirone or the
- 1:06:05bupropion. Not a bad idea.
- 1:06:07>> lamictal.
- 1:06:10I'm not going to put it up there. It's
- 1:06:12too niche. I would use it for people
- 1:06:14with obviously mixed depression or
- 1:06:16bipolar features. I would consider it
- 1:06:18for OCD. Do not put it up there. Stop
- 1:06:20it. Stop it.
- 1:06:22>> [laughter]
- 1:06:23>> And then for some reason they put
- 1:06:24lamictal XR for some reason. Why do you
- 1:06:26do XR? I don't need it. Just use
- 1:06:28regular.
- 1:06:29>> It's got enough risk that I don't want
- 1:06:31it being given more often
- 1:06:34unless you're real pro and you know what
- 1:06:36you're doing. And stop it. Where do you
- 1:06:38want to put it? I will not sign off on
- 1:06:40this if you leave it up there. It should
- 1:06:42stay at the bottom. It is not mainstream
- 1:06:44treatment.
- 1:06:45Um Yeah.
- 1:06:48Now it's interesting. I think there's
- 1:06:49there's more to say about that. I think
- 1:06:52um
- 1:06:53it does have some evidence for
- 1:06:55depression. I think of it as Now some
- 1:06:57people like to use it
- 1:06:59I kind of I was rallying against the
- 1:07:02bupropion cuz it's like people are
- 1:07:03saying like oh it just If someone
- 1:07:05doesn't want side effects, then I use a
- 1:07:06medication that doesn't have side
- 1:07:07effects, but you don't use something
- 1:07:08that's not indicated just because the
- 1:07:10side effect profile matches the side
- 1:07:11effect profile that you want. Um, I do
- 1:07:14for patients with emotional
- 1:07:15dysregulation and
- 1:07:19uh, reporting depression, I do see it
- 1:07:21helpful. I don't see it helpful in MDD
- 1:07:22proper.
- 1:07:25Yeah, it's it's too hit and miss. The
- 1:07:28risk is too high. Uh, and it's too easy
- 1:07:32for it to be basically a placebo because
- 1:07:36it doesn't really have so many side
- 1:07:38effects. I think it's an S-tier med for
- 1:07:40bipolar, but we should not put it in the
- 1:07:43MDD columns. That's all I'm going to say
- 1:07:45about it.
- 1:07:46Um,
- 1:07:48where would you put your TCAs? I would
- 1:07:50put doxepin in C.
- 1:07:52Uh, I'll put amitriptyline in D.
- 1:07:54>> Doxepin is used as a sleep aid
- 1:07:56for sleep, not for depression.
- 1:07:58Oh, you can use it for both.
- 1:07:59>> Yeah.
- 1:07:59And then, um, probably clomipramine
- 1:08:03is like
- 1:08:05B
- 1:08:06and, uh, what's that other one? I don't
- 1:08:09use them enough.
- 1:08:10>> Clomipramine?
- 1:08:11No one uses them. No point in doing a
- 1:08:12tier list. Um,
- 1:08:14I wish we did I've I've had the MAOIs.
- 1:08:16>> But, consider them. Consider them if you
- 1:08:17have true, uh, treatment-resistant
- 1:08:19depression, not just we're calling
- 1:08:21something that's trauma and personality
- 1:08:23depression. Uh, please consider your
- 1:08:25TCAs and your MAOIs if you know what
- 1:08:29you're doing.
- 1:08:29>> the phenelzine and selegiline patch in A
- 1:08:32or B tier, probably.
- 1:08:35Yeah, they're pretty good.
- 1:08:35>> Yeah. Okay, that's all the time I got.
- 1:08:38Uh, I hope people like this one. Uh,
- 1:08:40it's very click-baity, very internet,
- 1:08:43um, but hopefully it also has some
- 1:08:44useful information for people to at
- 1:08:46least make your own tier list, you know,
- 1:08:48because the tier list I use for
- 1:08:50medication should really be tailored to
- 1:08:52your patient population. Patient
- 1:08:53populations are different and, uh, your
- 1:08:55diagnostic pool is going to be different
- 1:08:57and so your treatment response is going
- 1:08:59to be different, too.
- 1:08:59>> Awesome. Great ending point. I will see
- 1:09:01you next time, Dr. Phil.
- 1:09:04All right. See you.
- 1:09:05Thanks for listening. If you want to
- 1:09:07support the show, check out my very
- 1:09:09practical antidepressant course. If you
- 1:09:12want to check that out, go to
- 1:09:14psychopharm.farm.
- 1:09:17If you prefer to read, you can go to
- 1:09:19amazon.com.
- 1:09:21You can search my name, Gregory, g r e g
- 1:09:24o r y, Malzburg, m a l z b e r g.
- 1:09:28And the book is Psychopharm's Guide to
- 1:09:30Treating Depression.
- 1:09:31>> [music]
- 1:09:31>> It's a nice, easy, readable, practical
- 1:09:34guide to medications for depression.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Depression Medications Tier List: Psychiatrists Rank Antidepressants for MDD by Psychofarm, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 12,342 words across 2,033 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.