YouTube2Text

De DIOSAS a DECORADO: historia de las MUSAS — Transcript

by Pupina Plomer · 4,276 words · 668 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00What is a muse? Where did this term come
  2. 0:02from? Are all women the inspiration for
  3. 0:04artists? Hello, my lanteris. The term
  4. 0:06muse must sound familiar to us all,
  5. 0:08someone whose beauty, ability, and
  6. 0:11wisdom illuminate great artists.
  7. 0:14Wow, I'm interested in making this video
  8. 0:16not to explain the origin of the Greek
  9. 0:19muses in depth, but to understand how
  10. 0:21the term muse has changed over the
  11. 0:23centuries and how the woman's role went
  12. 0:25from inspiration to inspirer.
  13. 0:28Because when we talk about a muse, we
  14. 0:29are actually talking about two things:
  15. 0:31the capacity to have inspiration, that
  16. 0:32is, having something abstract that
  17. 0:34inspires you to make art or do something
  18. 0:35beautiful. And the muse as a person,
  19. 0:37which is basically that woman who
  20. 0:39inspires a man.
  21. 0:40I'll tell you that this video actually
  22. 0:42comes from a chat I had the other day
  23. 0:43with a friend that left me thinking, and
  24. 0:45I said, "Well, I'm going to start
  25. 0:47investigating a bit to bring the debate
  26. 0:48to you and hear what you think." The
  27. 0:50conversation started off completely
  28. 0:51unrelated.
  29. 0:52We were talking about how in cinema and
  30. 0:55movies we have completely normalized
  31. 0:57female nudity but not male.
  32. 0:59It's like it's common in all movies,
  33. 1:02whether they are artistic or comedies or
  34. 1:04dramas or whatever, to see women's
  35. 1:06breasts, to see naked women, but men's
  36. 1:09don't make us uncomfortable.
  37. 1:11It's like, "Ah, it's grotesque to see a
  38. 1:13naked man." That comes a little from the
  39. 1:15Western conception we have regarding the
  40. 1:17female body. First as something public,
  41. 1:20that is, something we all know.
  42. 1:22And, secondly, as something beautiful*
  43. 1:24per se*; that is, the woman's body is
  44. 1:26considered beautiful, however it is,
  45. 1:28obviously within the limits of the
  46. 1:30current hegemony, of course.
  47. 1:32But well, that idea of the Greek goddess
  48. 1:34, Greek nudity, the naked woman as
  49. 1:36something that inspires and as something
  50. 1:38worth seeing has always been linked.
  51. 1:41It was from that chat I had with my
  52. 1:43friend that I said: "Well, I'm going to
  53. 1:45start reading a bit to bring you a video
  54. 1:47talking about muses and how, throughout
  55. 1:49history, we have built that image of
  56. 1:51women as always a potential source of
  57. 1:53inspiration."
  58. 1:55We will also ask ourselves how a Greek
  59. 1:57religious category like the goddesses
  60. 1:59ended up creating a category that
  61. 2:01nowadays marks who creates and who
  62. 2:02inspires.
  63. 2:04And why that division historically
  64. 2:06always coincided with gender: the man
  65. 2:08creating, the woman inspiring.
  66. 2:13The etymological origin of the word "
  67. 2:15muse" isn't entirely clear—that is, the
  68. 2:17origin of the word in Greek—but we do
  69. 2:19know that the concept of the Muse began
  70. 2:21to be used in ancient Greece.
  71. 2:23First, a disclaimer: as a historian, I
  72. 2:25am not a specialist in ancient history.
  73. 2:28I have quite a few gaps when it comes to
  74. 2:29ancient history. I mean, I know about it
  75. 2:31because I earned my degree, but it’s not
  76. 2:33a period I feel comfortable in, so I’m
  77. 2:35going to speak in very general terms
  78. 2:37about this era to avoid any mistakes.
  79. 2:39You know I’m always sincere about these
  80. 2:41topics. It’s not a subject I navigate
  81. 2:43with much fluency. Of course, I read key
  82. 2:46texts to make this video, but there are
  83. 2:48details, fine points, that I’m going to
  84. 2:50gloss over so I don’t mess up.
  85. 2:53As I was saying, the concept of the Muse
  86. 2:55appeared in ancient Greece and
  87. 2:57originated from the poets 'feeling of
  88. 2:59dependence on a divine force.
  89. 3:01Basically, the muse was the
  90. 3:03personification of inspiration for
  91. 3:06writing poetry. That inspiration, of
  92. 3:08course, was divine in ancient Greece.
  93. 3:11It came from the gods, striking writers
  94. 3:14like a poetic ray of light that filled
  95. 3:16them with ideas, inspiration, and beauty
  96. 3:19to write beautiful texts.
  97. 3:22This was, of course, in a context where
  98. 3:24the Greeks believed that inspiration,
  99. 3:25capability, and the possibility of
  100. 3:27creating something beautiful could not
  101. 3:29be solely human; it had to have a
  102. 3:30footing in the gods.
  103. 3:32That is why Greek goddesses are always
  104. 3:34presented as muses of inspiration, as
  105. 3:36beautiful beings, as radiant beings.
  106. 3:39In the face of human ignorance—since
  107. 3:41humans were considered imperfect—the
  108. 3:43muses arrived as a form of omnipresent
  109. 3:46knowledge. They were capable of
  110. 3:48transferring all their knowledge to that
  111. 3:50imperfect human.
  112. 3:52And this can be seen, of course, in
  113. 3:54Greek literature, particularly in the
  114. 3:56archaic epics of the Iliad and the
  115. 3:58Odyssey.
  116. 4:00In these Homeric narratives, the
  117. 4:02goddesses sing, tell stories, and
  118. 4:04inspire, but they are not human; they
  119. 4:06are semi-goddesses, because human women
  120. 4:08—no, they aren't going to be muses
  121. 4:10because they are imperfect humans.
  122. 4:13Something very particular happens here,
  123. 4:15especially in the Homeric texts, which
  124. 4:17show how knowledge comes from a female
  125. 4:19figure, but it is the male voice that
  126. 4:21materializes it.
  127. 4:23What am I getting at with this? It is
  128. 4:25the perfect, ethereal goddesses who
  129. 4:27bring the inspiration, who carry the
  130. 4:29inspiration, but it is the man who grabs
  131. 4:31that inspiration and turns it into a
  132. 4:33poem.
  133. 4:34In other words, the knowledge comes from
  134. 4:35the feminine, but it comes out through a
  135. 4:37masculine voice. You see this a lot in
  136. 4:39Homeric texts. I’m actually reading a
  137. 4:42book I recommended the other day, I'll
  138. 4:43recommend it to you all right now. It’s
  139. 4:45this book called*Papyrus*by Irene
  140. 4:47Vallejo, about the invention of books in
  141. 4:49the ancient world. It has nothing to do
  142. 4:51with this video, but I just remembered
  143. 4:52it while writing the script. Well, it’s
  144. 4:54a book that talks about the origin of
  145. 4:57books in the ancient world. Anyway, it’s
  146. 4:59incredible. But in one part, she talks
  147. 5:01about Homer, you know, this Greek poet
  148. 5:04who we don’t know if he existed, or if
  149. 5:06it’s a group of writers, or someone
  150. 5:09posing as Homer. I mean, that doesn’t
  151. 5:11matter.
  152. 5:12But what she explains is that Homeric
  153. 5:15texts are very important because they
  154. 5:17bridge the oral tradition to the written
  155. 5:20tradition.
  156. 5:21She says that perhaps, it’s a hypothesis
  157. 5:24, all the Homeric tales included in the
  158. 5:27*Iliad*and the*Odyssey*might not be
  159. 5:29products of Homer’s imagination, but
  160. 5:31rather oral stories that were
  161. 5:33circulating where he lived, and he wrote
  162. 5:36them down; and by writing them down,
  163. 5:38they became his.
  164. 5:40Well, she says that in these archaic
  165. 5:42texts, meaning not just Homer’s but
  166. 5:45others too, we can see what Greek
  167. 5:47culture was like at the time.
  168. 5:49You can see what their traditions and
  169. 5:51customs were like, right? Their ways of
  170. 5:53life.
  171. 5:54And you can see how throughout the*
  172. 5:56Iliad*and the*Odyssey*there is a male
  173. 5:58preponderance, where men have the public
  174. 6:01voice and women are the sources of
  175. 6:03inspiration.
  176. 6:05So she says, "Well, it’s surely a
  177. 6:07reflection of how people lived back then
  178. 6:10, when women had no public voice."
  179. 6:12Anyway, that’s a side note, I’ll
  180. 6:13continue with the original script now,
  181. 6:15but it is a great book. I will cite it
  182. 6:17again at some point in this video.
  183. 6:19It’s a thick one, I mean, it’s 450 pages
  184. 6:22, but I swear it’s worth it.
  185. 6:24Also, I just remembered, it says
  186. 6:26something very interesting about how in
  187. 6:28the oral transmission of these tales and
  188. 6:30knowledge, memory is not just a record
  189. 6:32of the past, but also a way to create
  190. 6:34presents and futures.
  191. 6:37I mean, by collecting these stories from
  192. 6:39the past where we women are muses and do
  193. 6:41nothing but inspire, we build a present
  194. 6:43where we women are muses and do nothing
  195. 6:45but inspire.
  196. 6:47in the archaic texts of Homer or Hesiod
  197. 6:49, whom I didn't name, but well, another
  198. 6:51great Greek poet.
  199. 6:53The poet is like an active receiver of
  200. 6:55the inspiration given to him by women.
  201. 6:58This changes with Plato, who turns the
  202. 7:01matter around and suggests that in
  203. 7:03reality, the poet is a passive receiver
  204. 7:05of what the muses and the gods transmit
  205. 7:07to him. He will say that poets fall into
  206. 7:10a madness, a creative frenzy resulting
  207. 7:13from the inspiration provoked by the
  208. 7:16muses. It is not that the muses give
  209. 7:18them the poetry already made, but rather
  210. 7:19they inspire them to write poetry. It
  211. 7:21doesn't matter. Without getting into too
  212. 7:23much detail here, it must be clear that
  213. 7:25in ancient Greece the voice that knows
  214. 7:27is the female and divine voice, but the
  215. 7:29one that signs and gains prestige is
  216. 7:31always the male voice, which is the one
  217. 7:33that ends up writing. This idea is then
  218. 7:35installed in what will become Western
  219. 7:37culture.
  220. 7:38which of course is the one that
  221. 7:39continues to reproduce this logic of
  222. 7:41muses.
  223. 7:42In fact, this same thing can be seen not
  224. 7:44only in Greek literature, but also in
  225. 7:47Greek art, in how bodies, both male and
  226. 7:49female but fundamentally female, are
  227. 7:51always sources of inspiration, they are
  228. 7:53something to contemplate.
  229. 7:56But things change once the Roman world
  230. 7:58is established and new ideas appear.
  231. 8:03You know there is an idea circulating
  232. 8:05about these nine muses, which would be
  233. 8:08nine women who each represent an art.
  234. 8:11epic, history, astronomy, tragedy,
  235. 8:13comedy, dance, knowledge, etcetera.
  236. 8:16This idea consolidates during the Roman
  237. 8:18era.
  238. 8:19Here the muse ceases to be something
  239. 8:21religious, as it was in the Greek world
  240. 8:23, which had to do with the gods, and
  241. 8:25becomes a way to classify scholarly
  242. 8:27knowledge, that is, a kind of antecedent
  243. 8:29to what we call a canon.
  244. 8:30That is, there is a muse specifically
  245. 8:32for history, for art, for music, for
  246. 8:34theater.
  247. 8:36I just cited another fact from this
  248. 8:38fantastic book, which is that, well, she
  249. 8:41starts by talking a lot about the
  250. 8:43Library of Alexandria and how during the
  251. 8:45Egyptian Ptolemaic dynasty it began to
  252. 8:47consolidate as a space for knowledge,
  253. 8:49culture, wisdom, and so on.
  254. 8:53And it is from, it is from that era that
  255. 8:55the word museum appears, museum, I don't
  256. 8:58know how it would be pronounced in its
  257. 9:00original language, but they were spaces
  258. 9:02where the different muses were placed;
  259. 9:05that is, the representations of the
  260. 9:07different muses of art, literature,
  261. 9:09history, music, and so on, which were
  262. 9:11like study centers paid for by the kings
  263. 9:13, by the Ptolemaic dynasty in the
  264. 9:15Library of Alexandria, of course, as
  265. 9:18spaces to safeguard knowledge.
  266. 9:20Well, that is where the word museum
  267. 9:22supposedly comes from.
  268. 9:24As the centuries pass and we move past
  269. 9:26the 4th, 5th, and 6th centuries, the
  270. 9:28Middle Ages begin to consolidate, let's
  271. 9:30say, that historical period that goes
  272. 9:32from the 5th to the 15th century AD.
  273. 9:35The idea of the Muse changes as
  274. 9:38societies change. In the final years of
  275. 9:41the Roman Empire, let's say, of the
  276. 9:43Roman period, the Muse becomes something
  277. 9:45a little more earthly. She stops being
  278. 9:47that goddess who inspires and can be the
  279. 9:50lover, the girlfriend, the wife, the
  280. 9:52girl you like.
  281. 9:54And this idea begins to fade as the idea
  282. 9:56of Roman religiosity and the Roman
  283. 9:58religious world, let's say, also fades
  284. 10:00and the Christian Church begins to take
  285. 10:02hold; the idea of a Muse linked to a
  286. 10:04goddess begins to be abandoned and she
  287. 10:06is presented more as an earthly human
  288. 10:08whom you can desire and possess.
  289. 10:12As I said, a lover, a girlfriend, a wife
  290. 10:14, a girl you like, or the girl in front
  291. 10:17of you. But as this idea that the muse
  292. 10:19is something earthly is being created,
  293. 10:22an anti-muse idea also begins to take
  294. 10:24shape. What do I mean by this?
  295. 10:26As the Catholic Church separates the
  296. 10:29issue of Roman mythology from the
  297. 10:31European social imagination, it
  298. 10:33simultaneously installs the idea of
  299. 10:35modesty.
  300. 10:36Those muses were always very sexualized
  301. 10:38because it was assumed they were women
  302. 10:40one should desire.
  303. 10:42So, as this idea of modesty and decency
  304. 10:44that the Catholic Church begins to
  305. 10:46install in Europe starting fundamentally
  306. 10:48in the 5th century is formed, the muse
  307. 10:50also begins to be seen as something, I
  308. 10:53don't know if it's so good.
  309. 10:55For example, theaters where there were
  310. 10:57muses, theater muses who were women
  311. 10:59represented and sexualized, people start
  312. 11:01calling them the prostitutes of the
  313. 11:03theater.
  314. 11:04That, instead of prostitutes, the
  315. 11:05prostitutes go there. An idea that ends
  316. 11:07up consolidating over the centuries,
  317. 11:09right?
  318. 11:11I mean, we have the good muse, which is
  319. 11:13the woman who inspires you to write love
  320. 11:15and poetry and tell her she's the best,
  321. 11:17and the bad muse, the theatrical one,
  322. 11:19the one who dresses provocatively, a
  323. 11:20provocateur, a sinner, which also, of
  324. 11:22course, reflects the reality of women
  325. 11:24themselves.
  326. 11:26You have to be a woman for your family,
  327. 11:28have children, you shouldn't be a sinner
  328. 11:31running wild in the streets.
  329. 11:33An idea that began to take shape in
  330. 11:35Western society during the Middle Ages
  331. 11:36and that gained more and more strength
  332. 11:38over the following centuries.
  333. 11:40I've already spoken about this in a lot
  334. 11:42of videos regarding the construction of
  335. 11:44this desired-slash-desiring woman in
  336. 11:46conflict. So I’m not going to get into
  337. 11:48it.
  338. 11:49Let's just keep in mind that from now on
  339. 11:52the muse is an earthly woman, she is no
  340. 11:54longer a goddess, but she remains a muse
  341. 11:56; I mean, [ __ ] muse, puritanical muse
  342. 11:58, she continues to be an object that
  343. 12:00sparks imagination.
  344. 12:03It sparks knowledge in the man, but she
  345. 12:05is not the bearer of that knowledge. It
  346. 12:08remains the man finding inspiration in a
  347. 12:10woman. Of course, during the Renaissance
  348. 12:13it is exacerbated even further because
  349. 12:15it is during the Renaissance that
  350. 12:17certain aesthetic values typical of the
  351. 12:20Roman world return.
  352. 12:22Starting in the 15th century in Europe,
  353. 12:25as I tell you, they begin to recover
  354. 12:27aesthetic elements of white, of naked
  355. 12:30human figures. Michelangelo, let's say,
  356. 12:33all this, well, the Renaissance, in fact
  357. 12:35I have a video from a year ago, I think
  358. 12:38it's the fourth or fifth video I
  359. 12:39uploaded, about how the world became
  360. 12:41grayer and the false ideal of white, of
  361. 12:44Roman white, which you can go see, where
  362. 12:46I talk a bit about how that white idea
  363. 12:48we have of the Roman world is wrong
  364. 12:50because the Roman world was colorful, it
  365. 12:53just faded over time. But well, you can
  366. 12:55go see it, I'll leave it recommended at
  367. 12:56the end of this video, but I do want to
  368. 12:58recover this: that the idea of the Muse
  369. 13:00started making sense again.
  370. 13:01From an artistic standpoint, starting
  371. 13:03with the Renaissance, the idea of the
  372. 13:05Roman muse was recovered.
  373. 13:08This idea of the woman as solely a muse
  374. 13:11only begins to change from the 16th
  375. 13:14century on, maybe the 17th, when women
  376. 13:17begin to appear very slowly and
  377. 13:19sporadically in the world of literary or
  378. 13:23scientific production.
  379. 13:26I say very slowly because the women who
  380. 13:28start writing can be counted on the
  381. 13:29fingers of one hand, but they begin to
  382. 13:31turn things around a bit.
  383. 13:33And this is where I want to focus on a
  384. 13:35particular woman who brought the
  385. 13:37question of the muse into debate during
  386. 13:39the 17th century in a highly hostile
  387. 13:42context like the Church, and she is, of
  388. 13:44course, the immense Sor Juana Inés de la
  389. 13:46Cruz.
  390. 13:50The truth is that the life of Sor Juana
  391. 13:51Inés de la Cruz deserves its own
  392. 13:53separate video. In fact, I am planning
  393. 13:55to make a video about her. You can let
  394. 13:57me know in the comments if you want that
  395. 13:58video. You can also leave a like because
  396. 14:01she is a woman who deserves a full 3-
  397. 14:03hour video.
  398. 14:05Sor Juana Inés de la Cruz was a nun who
  399. 14:07lived during the second half of the 17th
  400. 14:09century in New Spain, that is, what is
  401. 14:11currently Mexico.
  402. 14:13And she is one of the most important
  403. 14:15Hispanic figures of the Baroque and
  404. 14:17Latin American literature, to the point
  405. 14:19that they came to call her the Tenth
  406. 14:21Muse.
  407. 14:23You saw that I mentioned this Greek
  408. 14:25issue of the nine muses, these nine
  409. 14:27women each representing a different art
  410. 14:29.
  411. 14:31Well, her writings were so recognized
  412. 14:33and so important and had such
  413. 14:36repercussions that she herself was
  414. 14:38called the Tenth Muse as a benchmark
  415. 14:41muse of knowledge and wisdom.
  416. 14:44She was not only very good at writing,
  417. 14:46but she was also a quite disruptive
  418. 14:48woman for the time, because she
  419. 14:50questioned the 17 th-century Church,
  420. 14:54she defended women, that is, as a
  421. 14:56concept, let's say, women in general,
  422. 14:59and left us a very interesting debate
  423. 15:01about the place of women in the world of
  424. 15:04inspiration or the muses.
  425. 15:07In her writings, she basically defended
  426. 15:09the right of women to question and learn
  427. 15:12.
  428. 15:13She said it was necessary for us women
  429. 15:15to have a voice in the face of the male
  430. 15:17voice, which seemed to be the only voice
  431. 15:19.
  432. 15:20We have the right to access information
  433. 15:22that allows us to question ourselves, to
  434. 15:24debate, to debate with men, proposing a
  435. 15:26scenario of equality that was
  436. 15:27unthinkable for any intellectual of the
  437. 15:2917th century.
  438. 15:32Her first book, in fact, "Poems of the
  439. 15:34Only American Poetess, Tenth Muse," has
  440. 15:36two key words in the title.
  441. 15:39First, "only," recognizing that it is
  442. 15:41truly exceptional for a woman to be
  443. 15:43capable of writing, not as if saying, "
  444. 15:46Oh, I am unique and peerless, no one
  445. 15:48will be able to copy me."
  446. 15:50But in the sense of "I am the only woman
  447. 15:52who managed to have this voice because
  448. 15:54the rest of the female voices are not
  449. 15:55being heard."
  450. 15:57And "American," making reference to her
  451. 15:59subalternity. The fact of being an
  452. 16:02American woman in a colony, in a context
  453. 16:06of colonialism.
  454. 16:08It's interesting to think how that
  455. 16:10category of muse, a Greco-Roman one,
  456. 16:12arrived in America as a sort of imported
  457. 16:15canon because, well, part of the
  458. 16:17colonization process meant thinking of
  459. 16:19women with the ability to speak as an
  460. 16:22exotic rarity, an exotic muse.
  461. 16:26It’s also interesting how the idea of
  462. 16:28the self-muse is presented here, because
  463. 16:30she is no longer a muse who inspires
  464. 16:32others, but a woman with a voice; she
  465. 16:34turns the category of muse on its head,
  466. 16:37as we saw that in the ancient world, the
  467. 16:39muse was the one who inspired men to
  468. 16:41create knowledge.
  469. 16:43Here, she is a Muse creating the
  470. 16:45knowledge herself. We can see the first
  471. 16:48break from that category of muse I
  472. 16:50mentioned, the one of the inspiring
  473. 16:52woman, as she is the only one with a
  474. 16:54voice—and I insist, the only one,
  475. 16:56exceptional, not because she was
  476. 16:57one-of-a-kind—though she was—but because
  477. 17:00women were not allowed to have a voice.
  478. 17:02She has a fantastic line, her most
  479. 17:04recognized one, which says, "Foolish men
  480. 17:07, who accuse women without reason,
  481. 17:09without seeing that you are the cause of
  482. 17:11that which you blame." If you want a
  483. 17:13video on Sor Juana Inés de la Cruz, you
  484. 17:15know what to do: leave a comment.
  485. 17:17But anyway, we arrive at the 17th to
  486. 17:19early 19th centuries, and gradually we
  487. 17:22begin to see more and more literary
  488. 17:25works produced by women.
  489. 17:30Of course, with Mary Shelley and
  490. 17:31Frankenstein, we see that women begin to
  491. 17:34occupy the place of the public voice
  492. 17:35rather than that of the muse.
  493. 17:38At the same time that men continue
  494. 17:40writing with the idea of the Muse,
  495. 17:42fundamentally in English and European
  496. 17:44literature, two visions begin to coexist
  497. 17:46: that of the muse and that of the
  498. 17:47genius.
  499. 17:49Something else also happens that begins
  500. 17:52to turn things around: characteristics
  501. 17:54that were previously associated with the
  502. 17:57feminine or the fragile begin to be seen
  503. 17:59as positive—like passion, imagination,
  504. 18:02sensitivity, and love—and are revalued,
  505. 18:04mainly during Romanticism, as traits of
  506. 18:07a genius; a genius who can be a man.
  507. 18:11So, with that genius man who possesses
  508. 18:13the characteristics of the female muse,
  509. 18:15men no longer need external muses
  510. 18:17because they carry their own muses
  511. 18:19within; they are sensitive men who can
  512. 18:21see those beautiful, muse-like
  513. 18:23capacities inside themselves.
  514. 18:25They no longer need an external muse;
  515. 18:27they are their own muse.
  516. 18:29And that is how, little by little, the
  517. 18:31idea of the muse, as that woman who
  518. 18:33inspires, begins to gradually disappear
  519. 18:35, especially within literature.
  520. 18:37In other types of art, perhaps the muse
  521. 18:39continues to exist as a more abstract
  522. 18:41concept, like this muse of theater or
  523. 18:43muse of music as a concept, and no
  524. 18:45longer that specific woman who inspires
  525. 18:47you.
  526. 18:49Also tied to a Renaissance idea, as an
  527. 18:51idea belonging to other eras, because
  528. 18:53during the 20th century we no longer see
  529. 18:55, except in some very specific literary
  530. 18:57matters, perhaps romantic or otherwise,
  531. 18:59that the idea of the muse is so present
  532. 19:02.
  533. 19:02A bit because now the genius has the
  534. 19:05muse inside, and a bit because we women
  535. 19:07stopped being muses to become
  536. 19:09protagonists of the stories being built
  537. 19:11, whether as writers, artists, and so on
  538. 19:14.
  539. 19:15Moving to the present, we will see that
  540. 19:17while in this, in artistic production,
  541. 19:19something has changed, where the idea of
  542. 19:21the Muse is no longer so present, in the
  543. 19:24way we continue to exhibit and represent
  544. 19:26art, the idea of the Muse remains just
  545. 19:28as it was in the Greco-Roman era.
  546. 19:34In cinema, there are plenty of films
  547. 19:36where there are female characters whose
  548. 19:39only purpose within the story is to make
  549. 19:41the male character grow.
  550. 19:45We have film productions where female
  551. 19:47characters only serve to build the
  552. 19:49male's story, to inspire, or to
  553. 19:51transform for the worse.
  554. 19:54In other words, although in hegemonic
  555. 19:56terms the idea of the Muse was
  556. 19:58dismantled as a concept, the idea of the
  557. 20:00woman as male inspiration remains
  558. 20:03present without the connotation of the
  559. 20:05Muse. I know I got tangled up here with
  560. 20:07what I'm trying to say, but well, I hope
  561. 20:09it's understood. Me again, making a
  562. 20:11video without much of a script.
  563. 20:13The last time I made a video just like
  564. 20:15that, it ended up being the most-watched
  565. 20:16video on the channel, which is the one
  566. 20:17about why we get married.
  567. 20:20I should have learned my lesson there,
  568. 20:21but the thing is, well, sometimes I come
  569. 20:23...I mean, this: I like making videos
  570. 20:25that are more general, with questions,
  571. 20:27with information to be discussed, to,
  572. 20:28well, this: generate back-and-forth, a
  573. 20:30conversation that always gets really
  574. 20:32interesting in the comments.
  575. 20:34But anyway, I wanted to make this video
  576. 20:36; I had this conversation pending that I
  577. 20:38mentioned at the beginning of the video
  578. 20:39with my friend, and I wanted to bring it
  579. 20:41here for debate with all of you to, well
  580. 20:42, this: hear what you think.
  581. 20:45So, this idea of the Muse has been
  582. 20:47falling apart; perhaps in strict terms,
  583. 20:48let's say, we don't see the word "Muse"
  584. 20:50as clearly anymore, but women still tend
  585. 20:52to be characters placed there only so
  586. 20:54that men can change—they wouldn't be
  587. 20:56like a Muse, but well, they would be
  588. 20:57female characters that don't serve the
  589. 20:59ends of their own story, but rather what
  590. 21:01a man wants to tell.
  591. 21:03This idea of the Muse, as I told you,
  592. 21:05remains intact in some spaces of
  593. 21:07artistic exhibition, such as museums.
  594. 21:11In 1989, quite some time ago, the
  595. 21:13Metropolitan Museum of New York had less
  596. 21:16than 5%of exhibited authors who were
  597. 21:19women, and more than 85%of works
  598. 21:22involving nudity featured female nudes.
  599. 21:26In other words, we have a reality very
  600. 21:28similar to the Greco-Roman world. Few
  601. 21:30women producing art, but many women
  602. 21:33being exhibited as art. This brings me
  603. 21:36back to the question I asked you at the
  604. 21:38beginning about how we naturalize female
  605. 21:40nudes, thinking a bit that it is the
  606. 21:42inspiration of the most beautiful beauty
  607. 21:44in the world, and how we have few women
  608. 21:46making art. This figure didn't change
  609. 21:48much.
  610. 21:49In the year 2011, 4%of the artists were
  611. 21:52women and 76%of the nudes were female.
  612. 21:56Because for the woman-as-art, you are
  613. 21:59always art.
  614. 22:01This leads me to think how, in the end,
  615. 22:03we continue to reproduce an idea where
  616. 22:05the place for women is still to be a
  617. 22:07muse and not a creator of knowledge;
  618. 22:09where the woman is inspiration and does
  619. 22:12not inspire; where the woman we see in
  620. 22:14the museum is a woman portrayed through
  621. 22:16a man's gaze.
  622. 22:18We can go to the museum, go ahead, do
  623. 22:20that exercise.
  624. 22:21When you go to an art museum, take the
  625. 22:23trouble to count how many male portraits
  626. 22:26there are and how many female portraits
  627. 22:28there are, and see how each one of them
  628. 22:30is represented.
  629. 22:32You will surely come across the
  630. 22:33coincidence that the majority of female
  631. 22:35portraits are sexualized or presented as
  632. 22:37something beautiful or something
  633. 22:39inspiring. And male portraits are male
  634. 22:42portraits or war portraits, of course. I
  635. 22:45leave you here with this doubt to think
  636. 22:47about: are you art, or are you
  637. 22:49inspiration?
  638. 22:50I'll tell you that every Wednesday at
  639. 22:522:00 PM Argentina time and 11:00 AM
  640. 22:54Mexico time, I'm doing live streams
  641. 22:56talking about different things.
  642. 22:59Last week I did one talking about a
  643. 23:01certain Austrian painter, and I left the
  644. 23:04recorded version only for members.
  645. 23:07I'll see how I do that because I want to
  646. 23:08give something to the channel members
  647. 23:10who so kindly become members. And I was
  648. 23:12thinking about this: that the live
  649. 23:13streams should be for everyone and the
  650. 23:14option to watch it recorded for members
  651. 23:16, or one for everyone, one for members.
  652. 23:18We'll see, because there are some that I
  653. 23:19might want everyone to be able to see.
  654. 23:22Most likely, the one next Wednesday will
  655. 23:23be open for everyone.
  656. 23:25But anyway, remember, you can set a
  657. 23:26reminder for Wednesday at 2 in the
  658. 23:28afternoon, Argentina time. If you are
  659. 23:29from another country, please calculate
  660. 23:31what time that is for you.
  661. 23:32If you are from Mexico, you already know
  662. 23:34I'll be there in January: January 22nd
  663. 23:36in Guadalajara, the 23rd in Mexico City
  664. 23:38, and February 3rd in Tulum.
  665. 23:40Let me know in the comments what you
  666. 23:41think about what I told you in this
  667. 23:43video, and I'll see you next week or on
  668. 23:45the live stream.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of De DIOSAS a DECORADO: historia de las MUSAS by Pupina Plomer, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 4,276 words across 668 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.