David Horowitz: Why socialism always ends up in tragedy — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00[Music]
- 0:02the second fundamental in addition to
- 0:05thinking that people are good and
- 0:06society is the problem government is the
- 0:09solution there future-oriented this is
- 0:14very very important and I don't think
- 0:15any conservative can understand this in
- 0:18their bones the way I do having having
- 0:23one spin-up leftist future-oriented a
- 0:28what I would say a normal way of looking
- 0:31at human affairs is to look at the past
- 0:35and see what worked what doesn't work
- 0:41how people have behaved for thousands of
- 0:43years
- 0:45and what the limits then that you can
- 0:49accomplish how much can you change
- 0:51things have people changed in 3,000
- 0:54years don't believe it how could we read
- 0:59The Iliad how could you read the Bible
- 1:01and relate to the people and if people
- 1:02have changed people haven't changed this
- 1:05is the same stories for 3,000 years you
- 1:08know the technology changes so there are
- 1:10aspects that changed but two fundamental
- 1:13people's Greed's their lusts Cain
- 1:16killing Abel I mean come on we see this
- 1:19among Republicans today I mean
- 1:25some people people don't change so
- 1:28consider it's now the conservative view
- 1:31I mean our country has moved polarized
- 1:34in this way and we now have a left which
- 1:37was significant left which we never had
- 1:39before but you know when the founders
- 1:43got together I mean I'm you know
- 1:46whatever their politics they all had had
- 1:48this common sense in framing a
- 1:52constitution we're gonna look at the
- 1:54past the history of monarchies the
- 1:57history of aristocracies the history of
- 1:59democracies and they thought that
- 2:01democracy is not you know they thought
- 2:03like Churchill it's it's the worst
- 2:05system except for all the others I mean
- 2:07and they were very fearful of a
- 2:09democracy because they saw that people
- 2:11are swept up in passions and if if the
- 2:15majority rules it's going to lord it
- 2:17over the terror the manat the minority
- 2:20tyrannize the minority and crush them
- 2:22that's why they put into checks and
- 2:24balances in the limits progressives
- 2:28don't look at the past if they did they
- 2:30would never have dreamed up Obamacare
- 2:32for crying out tears you know socialized
- 2:37medicine has failed for the last 70
- 2:40years central planning that's what the
- 2:43Soviet Union was about there are
- 2:46libraries of books about its failures
- 2:48and why it can't possibly work and yet
- 2:52they rammed through this centralized
- 2:55system and now it's you know it's coming
- 2:57back to them want them but how could an
- 3:00intelligent person as I say these are
- 3:03not stupid people but how can an
- 3:05intelligent person think that you can
- 3:08have a centrally planned health care
- 3:10system that works anyway progressives
- 3:17don't look at the past they look at the
- 3:20past to discard it that's why they all
- 3:22talk about a living Constitution it's
- 3:24it's an old document the Constitution
- 3:26well people don't change so yeah it
- 3:29needs you you know there are new
- 3:31technologies and there are all kinds of
- 3:33problems like that but the fun
- 3:36mental the fundamental core reality of
- 3:40human beings and their societies don't
- 3:42change that's why the Constitution even
- 3:45though was written a long time ago is
- 3:47still the wisest political the document
- 3:49ever written and you know we are
- 3:52abandoning it as we are at our peril
- 3:57where progressives look at is the future
- 4:01you know we look there's all these up
- 4:07all these children who aren't learning
- 4:09in school let's increase the hours of
- 4:14the bad schools we'll have these bad
- 4:17teachers teaching them longer and then
- 4:19they'll know we're spending billions of
- 4:22dollars on these early school programs
- 4:24that test after this shows don't work
- 4:27because it's obviously it's not just the
- 4:31schools but the future so they have they
- 4:36have a future where everybody is good
- 4:38we're gonna throw money at poor people
- 4:41and that's gonna make them just like
- 4:42middle-class people no it's not that's
- 4:46the problem it's not but their future in
- 4:51which there's perfect equal is equality
- 4:54there's no war there's no poverty is
- 4:57imaginary a difference between the past
- 5:00and the future the past you can make it
- 5:02mistakes in analyzing but it actually
- 5:06happened and there's actually records
- 5:09the future is a fantasy it's a delusion
- 5:14and it's the core belief of everybody on
- 5:19the left that there is this golden
- 5:23future if we can just get enough power
- 5:27and enough money to achieve it I can't I
- 5:31still have this vision of Nancy Pelosi
- 5:33on the day they got Obamacare through
- 5:36beaming and saying first we got was it
- 5:40Social Security and I think bankrupt and
- 5:44then we got Medicare bankrupt and now
- 5:48we're gonna
- 5:49drupal down on obamacare what could she
- 5:54have been thinking what she's thinking
- 5:57is that this is the cornerstone of the
- 5:59socialist future which is what she
- 6:01believes it that you know everything
- 6:04else fails because we didn't get enough
- 6:05money we couldn't extract enough money
- 6:08because of these evil Republicans who
- 6:11are anti taxation it's an imaginary
- 6:18future and that's what makes it so
- 6:20dangerous these people are pumped up
- 6:23their own they're intoxicated by their
- 6:26own self-righteousness and bringing
- 6:28about the wonderful world which all you
- 6:31and all Republicans and conservatives
- 6:33are determined to prevent from happening
- 6:35and that's the only obstacle to them we
- 6:41human beings are the root cause of all
- 6:45social problems and all government
- 6:48problems as well if human beings weren't
- 6:52so screwed up in their way yeah like
- 6:57rying it's not hard to lie is it so any
- 7:00so everybody sort of does it they're
- 7:02innocent
- 7:02I'm gonna do the fear that smooth things
- 7:04over with that one powers at stake and
- 7:08when you know wonderful goods are at
- 7:10stake the lies grow and they grow and
- 7:13they grow until you have a president who
- 7:15whatever the thirty six times to all the
- 7:18American people you can keep your health
- 7:20care we're not going to take your plan
- 7:22away lie knowing he was lying why did he
- 7:25lie because as we build a socialist
- 7:29future it's going to be so good we just
- 7:31have to get over this hump so any any
- 7:34libel well that serves that will be good
- 7:36the more the more beautiful the idea the
- 7:41nobler the cause the greater the crimes
- 7:44you are willing to commit if you could
- 7:48actually have a world where there was no
- 7:50war no poverty the on and on all these
- 7:54things eliminated what lie wouldn't you
- 7:56would you not tell and what crime would
- 7:58you not commit and that's why progress
- 8:01in power had killed a hundred million
- 8:05people in peacetime this is not just
- 8:08like Hitler did in war in peacetime
- 8:11progressives killed over a hundred
- 8:14million people across the Communist
- 8:16world Lenin did not come to power saying
- 8:19I'm gonna create gulags and put tens of
- 8:23million people in slave labor camps and
- 8:25slaughter others that's not what he said
- 8:28peace land bread he had a vision of the
- 8:31beautiful future that Marx had promised
- 8:35that's what he had a vision of and
- 8:37that's what caused him to be such an
- 8:40evil individual as he was the third
- 8:47thing I got a the third fundamental
- 8:52problem I think you need to watch in the
- 8:57left I'm you you can see the syndrome is
- 9:00this vision of the perfect future the
- 9:03land that never existed and never will
- 9:05but which you identify everything that
- 9:09you do is to get to that land every
- 9:13every sacrifice you make every misdeed
- 9:18that you excuse yourself in doing is
- 9:21justified by that future your allegiance
- 9:27to that future causes you to be
- 9:29alienated from your country and that
- 9:33uncertain Lowell T to country is endemic
- 9:37in the Democratic Party and I'm sorry to
- 9:42say Republicans let them get away with
- 9:44this all the time
- 9:52you
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of David Horowitz: Why socialism always ends up in tragedy by Simply explained, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 1,303 words across 191 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.