David Horowitz - The Flaws Of Humanity Doom Socialism & Communism To Failure — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:02well up next author David Horowitz
- 0:04speaks about the history of the
- 0:06Communist Party and his views on
- 0:08socialism conservatism and liberalism
- 0:10this was part of a conference hosted by
- 0:12the Grove City College Centre for vision
- 0:14and values he's interviewed by the
- 0:16center's director and he'll take
- 0:18questions from the audience this is
- 0:19about an hour ten minutes
- 0:25everybody welcome and ladies and
- 0:28gentlemen David Horowitz
- 0:34[Applause]
- 0:37we've been we've been trying to get you
- 0:39here for years I mean we have we've
- 0:41become we've been trying to get it we've
- 0:43been trying to get in here for the
- 0:44longest time so it is it's so good to
- 0:47have you here and we have we have a
- 0:50little over an hour and so we're gonna
- 0:52have a conversation and then we're gonna
- 0:54take questions from the audience as well
- 0:56and when I say that I've read all your
- 0:59books I mean I literally have although
- 1:01this isn't all of them but this is
- 1:03probably a quarter fifth maybe and
- 1:07destructive generation was the first one
- 1:10I read this was with Peter Collier
- 1:11and this was second thoughts about the
- 1:1460s I think this was the big one the one
- 1:16where you first really came out right
- 1:18from the from the from the left left the
- 1:20left and then this book is he didn't ask
- 1:25me to do this I promise you
- 1:27radical son is great this is so good
- 1:30this is I think like the Whittaker
- 1:32Chambers witness of this generation in
- 1:35fact I believe National Review or one of
- 1:38the publication's Weekly Standard even
- 1:39said something like that at the time
- 1:41Weekly Standard and he's done of late a
- 1:44number of different books the black book
- 1:48of the American left and I've got volume
- 1:511 volume 2 and there's been at least
- 1:54three maybe four or six six okay there
- 1:57you go so I got a quarter I'm a third of
- 2:00them right right I can't keep up with
- 2:02them I seriously can't keep up one but
- 2:05so there's there's so much here and I
- 2:07went up in in my office and tried to
- 2:09sort out questions and I eventually just
- 2:11said forget it
- 2:11I'm just going to sit here and and try
- 2:13to have a conversation and and try to
- 2:15ask him some things about the left the
- 2:17old left the new laughs the current left
- 2:19today's left and but but I think we'll
- 2:22start first a little bit with with your
- 2:24background if that's okay I don't know
- 2:26how much of that you're willing to go
- 2:28into well obviously a lot you've been
- 2:30talking about
- 2:32but tell us all right so tell us about
- 2:35this is this is a conference on
- 2:37communism socialism since 1917 and your
- 2:42family lived a lot of this right herons
- 2:45were card-carrying members the American
- 2:49Communist Party which means that they
- 2:51were part of a vast international
- 2:55conspiracy that was organized from
- 2:58Moscow my parents I don't think ever
- 3:02broke a law I don't think my mother ever
- 3:04got a speeding ticket they were school
- 3:07teachers but they hid an East German
- 3:10Communist in the basement that the
- 3:13United States wanted deported I think he
- 3:16eventually was deported they had secret
- 3:20party names for the day when the party
- 3:24would go underground and the armed
- 3:26revolution would begin although unlike
- 3:30my comrades in the left in the sixties I
- 3:34don't think my parents ever went to a
- 3:36firing range although some of our family
- 3:39friends did disappear in 1949 and turned
- 3:48up in the sea in the Sierras in
- 3:50California and they were they were
- 3:53supposed to be the leadership there was
- 3:55fascism was coming to America when a
- 3:59hold on an ethics a firing range in the
- 4:0160s so are you talk like a moon maiden
- 4:05and people they had you know military
- 4:08you know training I mean they they were
- 4:11literally training for an armed
- 4:13revolution yes yes Tommy and the founder
- 4:16of SDS recently have some maiden called
- 4:20for liberated zones in American cities
- 4:24modeled on the liberated zone so-called
- 4:27of the Communists in Vietnam it was a
- 4:31whole chapter of a book II wrote called
- 4:33the trial which he then suppressed when
- 4:35he was joining the Democratic Party when
- 4:38he joined the Democratic Party yet
- 4:40then you didn't ever give up the idea
- 4:42I'm sorry maybe you guys could turn this
- 4:46up a little
- 4:48yeah Haven had written a chapter of a
- 4:50book called the trial calling for armed
- 4:55revolution in America and I went Clinton
- 5:00was it you know Hayden became a state
- 5:03legislator in California and Clinton
- 5:05gave him the medal of freedom richly
- 5:08undeserved and so he's not joking he
- 5:13suppressed that chapter of his book not
- 5:15because he ever gave up the idea the one
- 5:19thing about the left is that they lie
- 5:21and there's it's very important to
- 5:25understand that they lie because they
- 5:27know that if they told the truth about
- 5:30what they actually believed in what they
- 5:33wanted they would either be rejected or
- 5:38worse well on that point so and you have
- 5:43to convey have to conceal what they
- 5:45really believe is always concealing its
- 5:47agendas so to bring that back to the
- 5:49early days of Communist Party USA well
- 5:51you know that I mean the Obama who comes
- 5:55from the same background I did he was
- 5:57raised by communists the difference
- 5:58between us is that he never left the
- 6:01left the communists left his all book
- 6:06called you lie about Obama it's like 300
- 6:10pages I think jack has the world it
- 6:12footnoted of all Obama's obvious lies I
- 6:16mean everybody knows some of them you
- 6:18know you you can keep your doctor if you
- 6:22like them period you can keep your plan
- 6:25if you like it period
- 6:27but there's so many others and the the
- 6:34manual of the left their guide is Saul
- 6:37Alinsky's rules for radicals which is
- 6:40still a bestseller and it's the
- 6:43recommended reading of the National
- 6:44Education Association which is the
- 6:47largest I think the largest union in
- 6:49America teachers union that's the whole
- 6:53agenda of the alinsky book he was the
- 6:57one thing I could say about the sixties
- 6:59left which was a communist left one
- 7:04redeeming virtue was that we said what
- 7:07we wanted we know we want a revolution
- 7:08and we want it now up against the wall
- 7:13this is a stick up I don't know the
- 7:16slogans were used but they they
- 7:19telegraphed what we believed in and
- 7:22elinsky in his book says the the led the
- 7:27new left was right that the system needs
- 7:29to be burned down that's that's that's
- 7:32the way he looked at America he was
- 7:35never an active member of the party but
- 7:37he was say communists did you know did
- 7:41you meet no I despised him well because
- 7:45I was a new leftist well I believe we
- 7:47should be open I mean maybe that's why
- 7:49I'm no longer a leftist and III didn't
- 7:55believe in lying although I I had very
- 7:58uncomfortable moments when I told the
- 8:01truth I remember being on it television
- 8:03show for my first book came out in 1962
- 8:07about the Berkeley demonstrations and I
- 8:11was going on and on and then and it was
- 8:14on the KPIX news and at the end of the
- 8:18little segment he said are you a
- 8:20socialist and I well I believe in
- 8:23decentralized this and that and I was
- 8:26just caught and dead because I you know
- 8:31I would have been smarter to lie as I
- 8:35say that's probably I didn't like that
- 8:37uncomfortable feeling but those are the
- 8:42good old days when America was not and
- 8:47when the American culture wasn't
- 8:48dominated by these people which it is
- 8:52today that what what makes what makes a
- 8:57communist a communist is it's a couple
- 9:00of things one is this
- 9:02first of all communism socialism and the
- 9:06social justice movement progressivism
- 9:08they're all modeled on Christianity the
- 9:14they look on the world as a fallen place
- 9:17although they would never use that
- 9:20that's words that way it's a place of
- 9:24injustice and oppression and like
- 9:28Christians they believe there's going to
- 9:30be a Redemption
- 9:32unlike Christians they don't believe the
- 9:35redemption is coming through a divinity
- 9:37they believe in themselves as the
- 9:40divinity
- 9:40they are the social Redeemers and this
- 9:43is what makes even well-meaning people
- 9:45like my parents dangerous if you believe
- 9:50that you can achieve the work of God and
- 9:56you can bring about a heaven on earth
- 9:59which is what they believe that's what
- 10:01social justice is what crime would you
- 10:05not commit what law would you not tell
- 10:09or what crime would you not if you
- 10:12incapable of committing the crimes
- 10:14support and so very well-meaning people
- 10:18quote my parents never refer to
- 10:20themselves as Communists I never heard
- 10:22them use that word in connection with
- 10:24themselves or their friends Tom sells
- 10:28progressives progressives every
- 10:30progressive believes this and look at
- 10:34the crimes that they they're comfortable
- 10:36with even you know as we sit here today
- 10:38I mean all the Hollywood progressives
- 10:41that support these monsters in Venezuela
- 10:44are destroying destroying the country
- 10:47there everybody on the Left a Steven
- 10:52Spielberg probably a very we were
- 10:54discussing him before said that the five
- 10:56hours he spent with Fidel Castro who was
- 10:59a sadistic monster
- 11:00but the greatest five hours of his life
- 11:04and that's because
- 11:06what I when I came out of the left
- 11:10people would ask me how how can you hate
- 11:13America how could you how could you why
- 11:15would you want a revolution in America
- 11:18if you and that's because these are
- 11:21people without the ideology people who
- 11:26are looking at other countries if you
- 11:27look at the world this is the best place
- 11:30to be this is the greatest society on
- 11:32earth how do we know that well it's got
- 11:35all the people who want to come here
- 11:36legally illegally risk their lives to
- 11:40get into America you don't see that
- 11:42there's nobody you know swimming across
- 11:47shark-infested waters to get to Cuba
- 11:51very obvious so how could you well it's
- 11:56easy to hate it's not easy to in America
- 11:59or even to think badly of America if you
- 12:01look at the way human societies have
- 12:03been through the 5,000 years of recorded
- 12:07history that we have however if you have
- 12:11this vision of a heaven on earth that
- 12:14can be achieved if you just get rid of
- 12:17the oppressors if you just want to you
- 12:21know take over the means of production
- 12:24Institute's social justice outlawed the
- 12:30pronouns he and she whatever it is if
- 12:34you would if you compare it to this
- 12:37vision of the future well of course it's
- 12:39warranty and the reason that America is
- 12:42wanting is this because it's like every
- 12:44society it's a reflection of who we are
- 12:47and then since we're i that christian
- 12:52college i mean this this is what the
- 12:55first 18 chapters of genesis are about
- 12:59that the root cause of social problems
- 13:02is us I mean we were given a paradise we
- 13:09treated as a you know if you're not
- 13:11religious treated as a parable we were
- 13:14given paradise much better than
- 13:17socialism or so
- 13:19justice by the way because there was no
- 13:20death no pain no suffering you have to
- 13:26work as a proof fell from the trees but
- 13:32in order to enjoy this
- 13:35you had to forego the knowledge of good
- 13:39and evil and really the knowledge of
- 13:41evil and human beings are prone to evil
- 13:46where the corruption is within us once
- 13:50you understand that you're a
- 13:51conservative that's it it's pretty basic
- 13:56what comes it comes down to your
- 13:58understanding of human nature yes the
- 14:01other thing that people always ask me
- 14:03you know was were you being financed but
- 14:07and this is the new left now because it
- 14:09was actually Moscow Gold which was a big
- 14:12thing in the 50s when we all scoffed at
- 14:16it the Moscow was financing American
- 14:21Communist Party it's me me now no but
- 14:24they would ask me getting you know who
- 14:26was financing you radicals sort wanted
- 14:29to burn down America and the answer was
- 14:34you are I mean then we getting
- 14:36government money and and what have you
- 14:39and then they would ask me well what
- 14:42about the Communist Party and actually
- 14:44by then the Communist Party was
- 14:46destroyed by the revelations of the
- 14:49Khrushchev report that is I remember the
- 14:54the right-wingers whom we hated like
- 14:56William F Buckley would say that Stalin
- 14:59had murdered seven million people and
- 15:02the actual number is something like 40
- 15:04million and then in 1956 Nikita
- 15:10Khrushchev was then the head of the
- 15:13Soviet Union gained a secret speech
- 15:16which was smuggled out by the Israeli
- 15:18Mossad on the crimes of Stalin and for
- 15:23Khrushchev the crimes of Stalin were
- 15:25that he killed so many communists just
- 15:27true he killed more communist and all
- 15:30the capitalists
- 15:31put together but this destroyed my
- 15:36parents world that demoralized them my
- 15:38parents never really politically acted
- 15:41after that so they would say well what
- 15:46about the Communist Party
- 15:47well the Communist Party was I mean
- 15:51there still is a communist party but
- 15:53it's not very important it's not about a
- 15:58party it's about an idea it's it's about
- 16:02this mission to change the world the
- 16:07omission to to make everybody equal to
- 16:10redistribute income now to redistribute
- 16:12genders well which sister come to the
- 16:19conclusion in my view today I don't see
- 16:21any difference between difference
- 16:24between the current agendas and
- 16:28attitudes of the Democratic Party and
- 16:31the Communist world I grew up in the
- 16:34communist movement that I grew up in
- 16:37Bernie Sanders is the Democratic Party
- 16:41today Bernie Sanders would have been the
- 16:45nominee if the crooked Clintons hadn't
- 16:47fixed the primaries with the help of
- 16:50debbie Wasserman Schultz and Donna
- 16:52Brazile Bernie Sanders is a lifelong a
- 16:56lifelong supporter of communist claw
- 16:58causes and this mentality is is what I
- 17:02call brain-dead Marxist and we all the
- 17:05evil in the world comes from the 1% who
- 17:09oppressed the 99% how stupid is that and
- 17:15particularly since there were always one
- 17:17percenters like Soros and steyr the
- 17:20Democratic Party I mean I've written I
- 17:22run old book about this the Democratic
- 17:26Party is the party of wealth money if if
- 17:32if the old left or the old communists
- 17:34left if the Redeemer class was the
- 17:36proletariat then for the new left who's
- 17:39the Redeemer class are they always
- 17:41looking for wannabe looking well
- 17:42this is the other thing just to carry
- 17:47this analysis a little further they the
- 17:53only Marxist texts that communists and
- 17:57certainly my generation read I mean I
- 18:01deviants like me read a lot more but
- 18:03with the Communist Manifesto and the
- 18:07Communist Manifesto really got two ideas
- 18:11when is the opening sentence the history
- 18:15of all hitherto existing societies is
- 18:19the history of class struggles war
- 18:21social war which is a ridiculous comment
- 18:26I mean the history is not the history of
- 18:28class struggles and then the second idea
- 18:34of the manifesto is don't forget that
- 18:38Marx was writing after the great
- 18:42capitalists revolutions of the
- 18:44industrial revolutions of the 18th
- 18:46century and the creation of flowering I
- 18:51should say of market societies and
- 18:53political democracies so in the
- 18:56manifesto the next lines
- 18:58I said describe the history of these
- 19:01class struggles it was you know
- 19:03patrician and plebeian slave master and
- 19:08slave aristocrat of feudal lord and
- 19:14peasant and then he came to capitalist
- 19:18societies democracies and he said and
- 19:21it's identical here only it's simplified
- 19:24as the bourgeoisie and the proletariat
- 19:27the one-percent and and my today it's
- 19:30called the 1% and the 99% well if you
- 19:35believe that society that is an
- 19:39oppressive system everything can be
- 19:42understood in terms of a dominant class
- 19:44or a dominant race or a dominant sex and
- 19:49everybody that they oppress
- 19:53and that's the way you see the world
- 19:55then you're a communist and that's the
- 19:57way the Democratic Party sees the world
- 20:00is called identity politics in the in
- 20:04Marxism and March says this in the
- 20:06opening of capital he says I'm not
- 20:09interested in particular capitalists I'm
- 20:12interested in the capitalist as a class
- 20:15they I they had and that's because of
- 20:18course Marx was always supported by a
- 20:23capitalist named Frederick angles they
- 20:25released the money of English but that's
- 20:28the mentality and then when it came to
- 20:30the Bolsheviks I have a passage in one
- 20:35of one of my writings I think it's not a
- 20:40destructive generation but um by an
- 20:44official of the Czech at which was the
- 20:46secret police in the time of Lenin
- 20:48saying that we when we eliminate people
- 20:54we're not looking to see their it
- 20:56whether they're guilty or not we're
- 20:59looking to see what their class position
- 21:02is and so if you were a Kulak you could
- 21:07get eight years in the gulag just by the
- 21:11fact that you own half an acre of land
- 21:14because that's what be a Kulak so
- 21:20condemning people for their identity
- 21:26that's the mentality that eventually
- 21:29leads to the gulags america's built on
- 21:32the opposite idea that you don't judge
- 21:35people by their origins or by things
- 21:37they can't change that we in a word if
- 21:41we are a nation of immigrants who were
- 21:44fleeing religious persecution
- 21:46so the idea this country could only have
- 21:50been for I don't even know if I'm in a
- 21:52Protestant college but only by
- 21:54Protestants because the Protestant idea
- 21:57was that no human agency should mediate
- 22:01between an individual and his or her God
- 22:05and that it for the Protestants of
- 22:07course it was the Catholic Church but of
- 22:09course the government is another human
- 22:11institution so the founders of this
- 22:14country wrote in to our birth
- 22:16certificate the idea that we're all
- 22:19equal in the eyes of our Creator and our
- 22:22Creator has endowed us with certain
- 22:25rights that government cannot take away
- 22:28because government doesn't give us life
- 22:30liberty and the pursuit of happiness
- 22:34that's the American idea that means our
- 22:38fundamental value is individual freedom
- 22:40and individual accountability people are
- 22:44to be judged on their merits and this is
- 22:47obviously The Huffington Post just ran
- 22:50an article by a white white white men
- 22:53should be denied the vote that's pure
- 22:57racism but I the National Book Award was
- 23:03won last year by a racist named Donaghy
- 23:06Z Coates
- 23:07it was the son of a black panther and
- 23:10who's I I've called him the most
- 23:13pampered racist in America
- 23:15Susie it means a very young man he kind
- 23:18of $600,000 genius award from the
- 23:21MacArthur Foundation he never he didn't
- 23:25graduate college but MIT gave him a
- 23:28lectureship he's an editor at The
- 23:31Atlantic Monthly and he won the National
- 23:33Book Award and in this book the the
- 23:35central incident of the book is the
- 23:40killing of his friend by a policeman in
- 23:45Montgomery County Maryland which is a
- 23:49sanctuary County I believe and very
- 23:53liberal in them so his friend was killed
- 23:56the police officer said that the friend
- 23:59knew this tiny AZ Coates friend tried to
- 24:02run him over with his vehicle the
- 24:06problem is that the police officer is
- 24:08black as his friend so how does Coates
- 24:12deal with that he says well he was
- 24:14thinking white
- 24:16this is just racism people are saying
- 24:20that America's white supremacists
- 24:23they should need to see a psychiatrist
- 24:28this is certifiable but you get you can
- 24:33see you know very respected so I hate
- 24:38using the word liberal liberals using
- 24:41that the phrase white supremacy you
- 24:45don't like the word liberal you you
- 24:47always drive agent well because they're
- 24:49not liberal about anything about except
- 24:51hard drugs sex spending other people's
- 24:54money coddling criminals and
- 24:56sympathizing with our enemies but you
- 25:00say there's a big difference between
- 25:02liberals and leftists right you'd like
- 25:05to like to use the term left I'm a
- 25:07liberal
- 25:08your're conservatives or liberals we
- 25:12believe in two sides to a conversation
- 25:14we don't obstruct speeches we don't try
- 25:17to shut down campuses you know what when
- 25:21our opponents talk we enjoy that
- 25:25dialogue because you know we think I
- 25:28mean if you think you're right why
- 25:30wouldn't you want to engage that's the
- 25:33other side yeah but that it's not
- 25:36they're not thinking of us as people
- 25:40they see themselves as the army of the
- 25:42Saints bringing about a new world so
- 25:45they see us as the party of the devil
- 25:47this just happened next week I'm
- 25:49scheduled to speak in South Dakota and
- 25:52as it happens keith Ellison and the
- 25:56Democrats are going to be here not keith
- 25:58Ellison as you probably know spent
- 26:00eleven years as a spokesperson for that
- 26:05raving anti-semitic anti-american racist
- 26:08Luis barragán which is who keith Ellison
- 26:11obviously is and is now the deputy
- 26:16chairman of the Democratic National
- 26:19Committee and was almost chairman very
- 26:22very close what 13 votes misses by we
- 26:25were an endorsed by Bernie say
- 26:27there's another racist so we happen to
- 26:33be of my event for the South Dakota
- 26:36Republicans it's a big convention
- 26:38centers in the same building and they
- 26:40objected because I was going to speak
- 26:42now what is it they don't want to be in
- 26:45the same building with David Horowitz Oh
- 26:47what is that about that's that's about I
- 26:50should be a nun person that I should not
- 26:52exist that that is an attack on my
- 26:57humanity is what it really is and it's
- 27:00sad to say that this is this is what the
- 27:03Democratic Party has become and for me
- 27:07the most disgraceful episode of recent
- 27:11months was the so-called confirmation
- 27:15hearing of Senator Jeffery sessions jeff
- 27:19sessions has been a friend of mine for
- 27:2120 years I would say he's one of the
- 27:24half dozen most decent human beings in
- 27:27the United States Senate when he was
- 27:28there he's a champion of civil rights
- 27:31it was the Attorney General in the deep
- 27:34south state Alabama prosecuted the Ku
- 27:37Klux Klan desegregated the schools and
- 27:40yet Democrat after Democrat beginning
- 27:44with Chuck Schumer called him a racist
- 27:46and repeated it and Elizabeth Warren got
- 27:51shut up for for doing it by because she
- 27:54violated Senate rules on them this is
- 27:57disgrace these people know Jeff Sessions
- 28:00ain't no he's not a racist now I mean
- 28:04it's very distressing what's happened in
- 28:06this country but I think it's very
- 28:09important for conservatives
- 28:10conservatives are very well-meaning
- 28:13people very decent I say this is
- 28:19somebody who came out of the radical
- 28:21left so I can appreciate this and very
- 28:24well mannered to well-mannered
- 28:26so they're willing to give the benefit
- 28:29of the doubt and not think the worst of
- 28:32people I try to think the best of them
- 28:33and in the political war
- 28:36you can't do that but what I like about
- 28:40Donald Trump there is no other
- 28:43Republican I can think of not one who on
- 28:46national TV in front of 50 million
- 28:48people would look Hillary Clinton in the
- 28:50eye and say you're a liar and a crook
- 28:53which which is both you know you you
- 29:02have your masthead for front page
- 29:04magazine calm if it's still there
- 29:07there's a quote it said inside every
- 29:09liberal is a totalitarian screaming to
- 29:11get out yeah I think that's one of my
- 29:17desk contributions to this why is that
- 29:21the case this is saying did you say
- 29:25liberal yes I changed it to progressive
- 29:28did you change it okay well there you go
- 29:31that's right you know some progresses
- 29:33the same thing right right and that's
- 29:35not because they're liberal it's because
- 29:36they control the universities the
- 29:38schools the newspapers they dominate the
- 29:42media so they get to define terms right
- 29:46we don't we have to live with them it's
- 29:49not control but I alive so absolutely
- 29:52so um the reason that inside every
- 29:56progressive is a totalitarian screaming
- 29:59to get out is because they think they
- 30:02can change the world
- 30:03fundamentally what is it that Obama said
- 30:07America's we're five days away from
- 30:10fundamentally changing the United States
- 30:13of America by which they mean not just
- 30:16changing the policies of America but
- 30:21changing the people in it and then the
- 30:23whole leftist agenda then but I I mean I
- 30:28think the appropriate word for the
- 30:30Democratic Party and for progressives is
- 30:32neo communist we have neo we understand
- 30:35the old fascist neoconservative there
- 30:38neo communists they have the same
- 30:39mentality and this mentality is that
- 30:44although for 5000 years people
- 30:48continuous warfare for 5000 years we can
- 30:52have a world at peace if we just
- 30:54disarmed the United States basically
- 30:57they wouldn't say that but that's what
- 31:00they mean that you know 5,000 years of
- 31:06well first of all people are unequal and
- 31:09everybody knows that I mean be five
- 31:12years old you understand that did these
- 31:15talents intelligence strength beauty
- 31:20we're not handled handed out equally in
- 31:23the beginning I mean it's very obvious
- 31:25so the idea that you can transform the
- 31:28world and change people it's a very
- 31:32dangerous idea when you think about it
- 31:35what salutary force you well I will use
- 31:38the government since they see themselves
- 31:40as social Redeemers and the instrument
- 31:44of the redemption is a government a
- 31:47state so they will force you well for
- 31:51example there's a disagreed religion
- 31:53they see religion as obscure and distant
- 31:57oppressive the opium of the people is
- 32:00what Marx called it so when they come to
- 32:06power they want to stamp out religion
- 32:08well now I mean they've been pretty
- 32:11effective with Christmas and things like
- 32:12that where the Bolsheviks burned a
- 32:17hundred thousand churches when they came
- 32:20to bed so the first things they did yeah
- 32:22so they that's why it's so dangerous
- 32:26yeah I mean the religion has been part
- 32:31of the human story as long as there's
- 32:35been a human story so this gets back to
- 32:37the literal fundamental transformation
- 32:39of you that's right so that's why yes
- 32:42inside every progressives totalitarian
- 32:45because it's free your own good why did
- 32:47they lie about Obamacare they would be
- 32:51familiar with John John Gruber's video
- 32:55where he
- 32:57we you know we've structured it so that
- 33:00we would fool the CBO and it wouldn't be
- 33:04called the tax we have we concealed the
- 33:07fact that it was redistribution of
- 33:09wealth from young healthy people to
- 33:11older sicker people I know on and on we
- 33:17had to lie for your own good
- 33:21that's where they lie to you we're gonna
- 33:23tell you you can keep your doctor
- 33:24because if we told you you can't keep
- 33:26your doctor you wouldn't vote for this
- 33:29and yet it's gonna be trust us for your
- 33:33good so they and that's where their
- 33:36arrogance comes from same thing why are
- 33:39you always interrupting see them on
- 33:41television they can't let the
- 33:43conservative finish the sentence they
- 33:47have to interrupt you they can't let you
- 33:49speak at a university when when I I mean
- 33:55I don't you see what's happening there
- 33:56and culture it happened to me I have the
- 33:58myeloma innopolis this is a big trend in
- 34:01the universities to just shut to what
- 34:04happened to Charles Maurey what happened
- 34:06to Heather McDonald has never happened
- 34:09that you had Pomona no I did have to be
- 34:12listen Heather McDonald spoke at the
- 34:18five colleges she spoke at Claremont
- 34:20McKenna and another one is a Pomona and
- 34:23the students at Pomona came out with an
- 34:25editorial which said free speech is what
- 34:32white supremists
- 34:33use to silence marginalized and minority
- 34:37people yeah but there's a war on
- 34:42free speech in America on the First
- 34:44Amendment the First Amendment is the
- 34:47First Amendment for a reason it's the
- 34:49most fundamental right that we have
- 34:51because if you can't aren't free to
- 34:53speak your mind
- 34:57you can't defend any of your other
- 34:59rights it's all over so that the left's
- 35:02war on free speech now there are a
- 35:04handful of liberals actual liberals and
- 35:08so I should
- 35:09and one Kirsten powers has written a
- 35:11book called the silencing the lefts war
- 35:15I think that's the subtitle lots more on
- 35:19free speech something like that
- 35:21kudos to Kirsten powers Alan darshan
- 35:26which would be another yeah but they're
- 35:28few and far between but what would you
- 35:30keep going back to I think recently of
- 35:34Angela Davis speaking at the Women's
- 35:36March he sighs and a National Book Award
- 35:40this week Angela Davis here's a woman at
- 35:43political hack of the worst lowest right
- 35:47revered throughout the university system
- 35:50right right one it's got the lenin prize
- 35:54a Lenin from weight but from the German
- 35:57police state right right right from
- 35:59Stassi she abetted the murders of
- 36:03several people in Marin County just a
- 36:08vile person this year the National Book
- 36:12Award was won by it some another black
- 36:15leftist to author the whole last section
- 36:19of the book is a him to Angela Davis to
- 36:22tell you what kind of book fetes it's
- 36:24another racist tract but she ran for
- 36:28Qasim right literate too she ran for
- 36:29president vice president in the
- 36:31Communist Party USA take it twice but
- 36:34but her speech of the others she I think
- 36:38she supported I can't remember which
- 36:41factions she supported the cool in
- 36:43Russia find that communist trying to
- 36:45retake but at her talk at the women's
- 36:49March and I think this is what you keep
- 36:50you keep hitting on she identified a
- 36:53whole bunch of new victim groups I mean
- 36:56she mentioned immigrants Muslims LGBTQ
- 37:00it's like they're always looking for the
- 37:02new proletariat to identify will new
- 37:05oppress I Got News for you that de
- 37:07Blasio is just in New York as officially
- 37:10listed thirty-one gender
- 37:13right right that's true that's true you
- 37:17go to the website that you have if
- 37:18you're an employee in the city of New
- 37:20York there are 31 gender options to
- 37:22choose from by a facebook list I think
- 37:2470 protected why she's right right
- 37:27what's true but but that's part of it is
- 37:31it's more of a cultural Marxist well the
- 37:32women's March let's not forget that
- 37:34Linda Sarsour was a Hamas terrorist
- 37:38supporter and advocate of Sharia law
- 37:42which would take away women's rights
- 37:47sanctioned the murder of gays was the
- 37:51co-chair woman of the woman's march yeah
- 37:55and Roz Mia Odell was another organizer
- 37:58who is a convicted murderer she blew up
- 38:02a supermarket and in any way Israel or
- 38:09and how many people how many women well
- 38:13no but the leadership does that's right
- 38:16that's right so the sort of the marchers
- 38:19the margins just it's always a social
- 38:21and I quote this SDS statement often the
- 38:25issue is never the issue the issue is
- 38:27always the revolution these people are
- 38:30not about practical matters that they're
- 38:35not concerned with actual making a
- 38:38society work a society of people who
- 38:41have unequal talents who are
- 38:45self-centered we're all born very
- 38:48self-centered as you wouldn't know if
- 38:50you leave to 18 month olds in the same
- 38:55room with a pile of toys and shut the
- 38:58door you know there will be screams
- 39:00coming from there shortly
- 39:02I mean people were very egocentric we
- 39:06see the world just that way we don't see
- 39:09this way it all has to be learned
- 39:12so they'll seize whatever issue they can
- 39:14to advance the revolution but yeah
- 39:16they're not thinking of a society
- 39:19they're thinking of this fantasy future
- 39:22which will never exist
- 39:25with the path to which is strewn with
- 39:28100 million corpses in the last century
- 39:33the greatest mass murderers in human
- 39:35history
- 39:36I've been progressives can you tell can
- 39:39you tell us what I was I once said the
- 39:45equivalent of that in Berkeley when I
- 39:47was just leaving the left and you can
- 39:51imagine what the whole audience rose up
- 39:58I was gonna say but that went over
- 40:02really well but could tell us related to
- 40:06this then what's a Democratic Socialist
- 40:08a contradiction in terms
- 40:14maybe that is a term that's in vogue now
- 40:17but I guess bernie is socialism is theft
- 40:20that's all it is it's just taking from
- 40:25people mainly who've earned it and
- 40:28giving it to people who are your friends
- 40:30that's what socialism is I mean Lenin
- 40:34called himself a Democratic Socialist
- 40:36right Lenin called himself a Democratic
- 40:39Socialist rue to mark who's I called
- 40:41himself no they called himself a social
- 40:43democrat yeah a social never get the
- 40:45tell us the difference all right sue so
- 40:50in a nutshell what's the difference
- 40:51between the new left and the old left is
- 40:54you you were the new mid-level there was
- 40:56a yes when we began we were different we
- 41:03were willing to entertain new ideas we
- 41:07believed in you know dialogue with with
- 41:12other people we didn't like the fact
- 41:16that communists concealed their agendas
- 41:18that was a good thing about them left by
- 41:21the end of the 60s the new left was
- 41:23identical to the Communists left who was
- 41:26supporting all of worst regimes in the
- 41:28world it hated America look
- 41:34you just have to not be deceived by
- 41:36left-wing wordplay then there's never
- 41:42been a significant anti-war movement in
- 41:45America it's always an anti-american
- 41:46movement you know one of the my exit
- 41:51from the left came and a period when the
- 41:55United States was forced to withdraw
- 41:57from Vietnam by the domestic left and
- 42:02basically surrender betray our
- 42:05Vietnamese allies and surrender the
- 42:08country to the Communists the Communists
- 42:12proceeded to slaughter two and a half
- 42:15million peasants in Indochina
- 42:19there wasn't one protest not one now
- 42:23this is really key to your leaving the
- 42:25left wasn't it this is just an
- 42:27anti-american movement the the movement
- 42:31to save Saddam Hussein called itself and
- 42:35anti-war movement too but it was just an
- 42:38anti-american movement and that's where
- 42:40the Democratic Party really veered to
- 42:42the left the Democratic Party sabotage
- 42:45the Iraq war they voted for it they sent
- 42:49young people to die and within three
- 42:52months of the war Wars inception they
- 42:57turned against them were calling it an
- 42:59illegal and moral and unnecessary war
- 43:01and why did they do that they did that
- 43:04because there was a Democratic
- 43:06presidential primary in the spring of
- 43:082000 when tin in 2003 we went in in
- 43:15March and at that time and anti-war and
- 43:21on an anti-war anti-american so-called
- 43:24anti-war activist named Howard Dean was
- 43:28winning the Democratic nomination it was
- 43:31running away with it I think that forty
- 43:33five percent of the vote and Kerry and
- 43:36John Edwards switched 180 degrees and
- 43:40been supporters of the war I had voted
- 43:43to authorize it
- 43:44and to become president they betrayed
- 43:49all those young people that we had sent
- 43:51into Iraq and I it's to his credit that
- 43:55every woman know who I think is a
- 43:57liberal Joe Lieberman gay but basically
- 44:01sacrifices presidential ambitions rather
- 44:04than betray his country the way they did
- 44:07now a lot of you guys in the 60s talking
- 44:10about the old Democratic Party the new
- 44:12democratic party and I don't want to
- 44:14clue you with this group but SDS Marc
- 44:18Rudd Tom Hayden then there's a split
- 44:20into the Weather Underground Bill Ayers
- 44:22Bernardine Dohrn I mean they hated like
- 44:25the JFK Democrat probably Bobby we did I
- 44:28did they were they by yeah I so how does
- 44:32I voted for Jack Kennedy that was my
- 44:35last the last time I voted no then was
- 44:42one embarrassing vote in 1980 we all
- 44:48guess who that was for then I voted for
- 44:50Reagan well my luck I was not paying any
- 44:54attention I was at the time to politics
- 44:57well and what did your friends say when
- 44:58on the old left when you when you and
- 45:01and Peter Collier right Kay that now see
- 45:04you relieved on the left and this was
- 45:06always by the way that was on the 700
- 45:08club right that you did the the
- 45:10interview of all things right no no I
- 45:13was on the 700 right with Pat Robertson
- 45:15yes huh well it was with Pat Robertson
- 45:17which must have really made your full
- 45:19friends go bonkers i mean roger McGuinn
- 45:23of McGuinn and McGrane right right that
- 45:25was fun
- 45:26whatever ah Jim McGuinn sing Oh somebody
- 45:29I don't know somebody knows that I want
- 45:32your solo like Aaron Berger that names
- 45:34it the revolution songs no no no no no
- 45:38no no gonna do that one no it's better
- 45:40but but but so so what what did your
- 45:43friends think when you know these were
- 45:45all former hippies who were benign the
- 45:48hippies were benign who had become
- 45:51Christians okay that was I was I enjoyed
- 45:55that
- 45:56anyway we got very distracted yeah so so
- 46:01the the SDS Weather Underground Mark
- 46:04Rutte Bill Ayers that crew it's to
- 46:06everything that was to see that there's
- 46:08that's the sunset that's it
- 46:10that's that mark broad yeah we we aided
- 46:13the Democrats um because we saw them as
- 46:16co-opting people this why we hated Saul
- 46:20Alinsky because Olinsky said you you
- 46:24can't make you can't burn the system
- 46:27down without you have to get power and
- 46:30if you tell people that you want to burn
- 46:32the system down they're not gonna vote
- 46:35for you they're not going to give you
- 46:36the power they're gonna reject you and
- 46:39so it's stupid what you're doing what
- 46:41you need to do is join the Democratic
- 46:43Party I could you know this is in the
- 46:44book you can see it you know get funded
- 46:48by the Democrats pretended but we come
- 46:50all this boring from within and we hated
- 46:53it
- 46:54and as I say it's the only thing I can
- 46:57think of what I did in the sixties then
- 46:58that I'm fond of but it's what Tom made
- 47:02it's what Tom Hayden Hayden did hayden
- 47:04went right into the dye couldn't believe
- 47:06it they went into the Democratic Party
- 47:08they first he organized a riot at the
- 47:10Democratic convention in 68 and then
- 47:14they took over the party and then and I
- 47:16you know we had seen it as a party of
- 47:20the ruling class I mean that's sure
- 47:22diluted we were but whatever yeah but
- 47:27what tell us about Bill Ayers and
- 47:29Bernardine Dohrn and they despised
- 47:32did he lead and when he was it when I
- 47:34was a leftist because he would say hey
- 47:39rich snot-nosed arrogant stupid
- 47:43individual and violent when he was
- 47:46elected vice president of SDS and 68 in
- 47:51his acceptance speech he boasted he
- 47:54hadn't read a book in a year as a
- 47:57college student and you know I I felt it
- 48:03was our responsibility as I took
- 48:05revolution very seriously
- 48:06if we're gonna upend the whole system we
- 48:11needed to know you had to you can't and
- 48:15that's probably why I'm no longer a
- 48:18leftist there are they're completely
- 48:20irresponsible when it comes to things
- 48:22like that they don't care if they lie
- 48:24they don't care how many people good
- 48:29just this immigration thing they don't
- 48:32care about that Kate Steinle they don't
- 48:34care about the victims illegal criminals
- 48:38who come here who are probably mainly
- 48:40Hispanic I don't know why the Republican
- 48:42Party is it mentioning this they don't
- 48:45care about the victims of the Michael
- 48:47Brown thugs and the Freddie gray thugs
- 48:50who are mainly black because they have
- 48:54this agenda and the agenda is the
- 48:56transformation of the world you have to
- 48:59you after the religious analogy is it's
- 49:03if you think that you can be the agent
- 49:08of the redemption of the world again
- 49:12think of what crime would you not commit
- 49:14or support and what law would you not
- 49:16tell and then if there's a natural
- 49:20affinity that leftists have for one of
- 49:25these Islamist fanatics they think I
- 49:30mean they're doing God's work they're
- 49:32doing it in the name of God and
- 49:33redeeming the world and making it a holy
- 49:35place by purging it of infidels so you
- 49:39know singular leftist thinks he's he's
- 49:42doing good
- 49:43see this is what the Democratic Party in
- 49:45South Dakota just tried to do to me is
- 49:47to purge me from the building the hell
- 49:49is that about
- 49:52by the way we could take some questions
- 49:55if anybody is okay a lot of hands and
- 49:59microphones anybody we have the time is
- 50:04flying and we probably have about
- 50:07fifteen or twenty minutes
- 50:09so wherever you want to go first miss
- 50:13grace go ahead whoever you want to over
- 50:16there okay good Sara Chad got a
- 50:27questionable
- 50:31[Music]
- 50:35that I thought was profound and very
- 50:37helpful and that is why does the left in
- 50:41this country make common cause with the
- 50:43radical islamists yeah oh what a whole
- 50:46book about this called unholy alliance
- 50:49first of all this well first of all
- 50:56because they they both share a view of
- 50:58who the Great Satan is which is us and
- 51:02that's that's that's the most basic bond
- 51:06and by us what do you mean by us by the
- 51:08United States like our roots we're the
- 51:11most successful country in the world
- 51:13that's why they look kind of
- 51:14judeo-christian based American Founding
- 51:16America the way it was based on certain
- 51:18yeah that's probably even too
- 51:20intellectual for most of them but in a
- 51:25way I mean they don't think they know
- 51:27what they want to tear down but what's
- 51:29the goalpost what's the it's all about
- 51:33abstractions the end goal is to create
- 51:36the new world and the way they excuse
- 51:39the crimes of whether it's Islamists or
- 51:44communists or what that is to say the
- 51:47devil made them do it why why is Castro
- 51:51a sadistic monster time the number of
- 51:56people is jail the percentage what I
- 51:58think it would be 30 million in the
- 52:01United States comparable population it's
- 52:06because he had to because of the United
- 52:08States why the Palestinians blow up
- 52:10little children any Jewish child is a
- 52:13target for them why is that well it's
- 52:17because of the evil Israelis that then
- 52:19they're desperate people the
- 52:20Palestinians they have no recourse of
- 52:22course they do
- 52:23people even if they were oppressed which
- 52:26they're not people been oppressed for
- 52:29thousands of years without strapping
- 52:32bombs on their own children telling them
- 52:34to blow up other children because
- 52:37they're Jewish and if they're lucky
- 52:39enough to be male they'll go to heaven
- 52:42and get
- 52:4372 virgins I mean how sick is that and
- 52:47so why would a modern leftist be simply
- 52:51because they think the same way I mean
- 52:54odd and that's it it's said there
- 52:56they're fun they're fighting phantoms I
- 52:59mean I was just attacked at Berkeley by
- 53:01the head of the the United Auto Workers
- 53:03has organized the teaching assistants at
- 53:07Berkeley so there are 16,000 of them so
- 53:10the administration listens to them and
- 53:13their steward who was a music major send
- 53:18an email around saying David Horowitz
- 53:21should be denied a platform at Berkeley
- 53:25because he is a promoter of racial
- 53:29purity and white nationalism I have
- 53:32three black granddaughters and one
- 53:34Filipino I marched in my first civil
- 53:37rights march in 1948 before this woman's
- 53:40mother was born I have a public record
- 53:43of supporting civil rights that
- 53:46stretches over a half a century I don't
- 53:50exist
- 53:51I'm a category right that's all I am
- 53:54senator Blumenthal the liar from
- 53:58Connecticut who lied about his Vietnam
- 54:01record attacked Jeff Sessions in the
- 54:04confirmation hearing because I gave him
- 54:06an award and the quote from me that he
- 54:11used to show when a racist I use you
- 54:14against sessions yes he said David you
- 54:17received a word from David hearth David
- 54:20Horowitz said too many black people are
- 54:23in jail because black people commit too
- 54:26many crimes which is just the truth
- 54:31and how do we know it's the truth how do
- 54:34we know it's not a racist criminal
- 54:36justice system that doesn't we know it
- 54:38because the FBI has a victim's annual
- 54:44victims of crime report so they
- 54:47interview the victims see the 95 percent
- 54:50of the victims of black criminals are
- 54:52black so you have to imagine that these
- 54:55black victims if they get raped say oh
- 54:58it was a black person when it was really
- 55:01a white person come on
- 55:03but that facts don't mean anything today
- 55:06whether question goes it could be
- 55:09because they're not thinking of the
- 55:10facts the particulars individual
- 55:13accountability they're thinking of the
- 55:15vision of the world transform where
- 55:19everybody there's no inequality and
- 55:23there's no poverty and there's you know
- 55:29right inside the White House is someone
- 56:02who understands it the way we're talking
- 56:04Steve bad there are some people on the
- 56:06way I'd also understand it um I've
- 56:09written the whole book called big agenda
- 56:12president Trump's plan to save America
- 56:14and my advice is you fight fire with
- 56:17fire
- 56:18as I said conservatives are too nice
- 56:20they're too deferential
- 56:22when it comes to these people they
- 56:25wouldn't look Hillary Clinton the eye
- 56:26and say you're a crook and a liar she is
- 56:29both a chapter of my book is called the
- 56:35Achilles this is just one example that
- 56:37Kelly's heel of the Democrat
- 56:38party which is the stranglehold the
- 56:40Democrats have on the inner cities every
- 56:43killing field in America Chicago Detroit
- 56:46st. Louis Ferguson Baltimore 100%
- 56:50controlled by the Democratic Party and
- 56:52has been for fifty to a hundred years
- 56:55every injustice in the inner city every
- 56:58oppression the schools that year in a
- 57:01year out do not teach these kids where
- 57:04forty percent dropout and forty percent
- 57:06who graduate a functionally illiterate
- 57:09100% controlled by the Democratic Party
- 57:11run is a jobs program for adults and a
- 57:15slush fund for the Democratic Party the
- 57:18gun control laws that prevent
- 57:20law-abiding citizens in these high crime
- 57:23areas from defending themselves the
- 57:25catch and release policies which led
- 57:27Wayne Wade's cousin a beautiful mother
- 57:31of four children was murdered by two
- 57:33felons who should never have been out on
- 57:35the streets except that the Democrats
- 57:38have a lock on Chicago and Republicans
- 57:41are too polite to mention this ever
- 57:45[Applause]
- 57:49and and and and you get called the
- 57:54racist of course other questions the
- 58:10quote you were looking for from the
- 58:11editorial that was attacking Heather
- 58:13McDonald see it's even worse than you
- 58:14said it was it's a the idea that the
- 58:16truth is an entity for which we must
- 58:18strive in matters that endanger our
- 58:20ability to exist in open spaces and is
- 58:22an attempt to silence the silence of
- 58:23press people the truth that searching
- 58:25for the truth is it is an attempt to
- 58:27silence the press people yes truth the
- 58:30left has been conducting this is not
- 58:33obviously a recent development this has
- 58:35been going on for 30 or 40 years the
- 58:38left has conducted a systematic war
- 58:40against standards truth being won the
- 58:43scholarship our universities faculties
- 58:47are filled with morons and I mean that
- 58:51literally well people who had
- 58:58semi-literate are not illiterate the New
- 59:01York City just ended was it literacy
- 59:07testing the tests for teaching so
- 59:10they're inflicting on on kids and it's
- 59:12look it's not going to be you know
- 59:16people with monies kids it's going to be
- 59:18the people who can't afford anything but
- 59:20the public schools and they're
- 59:22inflicting illiterate teachers on these
- 59:25kids and Campbell Brown has got a
- 59:29crusade going she's a this is another
- 59:31liberal she's in in the Kirsten powers
- 59:34book against the tenure system in the
- 59:38schools if you are hired after two years
- 59:43you have a lifetime job it can't get rid
- 59:45of you this is this is another form of
- 59:49progressive races I've written actually
- 59:51one of these books is called progressive
- 59:53racism progressive racism it's just
- 59:56racist that's all it is is it
- 59:58and and the collusion of the Maxine
- 1:00:02Waters she said I Menace this woman to
- 1:00:05black people she when I was in I
- 1:00:09actually did in the eighties I did gang
- 1:00:13stories in Compton in South Central I
- 1:00:16would ask the residents their mothers of
- 1:00:20murdered children what's your complaint
- 1:00:22about the police where are they
- 1:00:24that's the complaint there are not IIIi
- 1:00:28forgotten the statistics but they're
- 1:00:30astounding how few police there are
- 1:00:32because the LA area is a huge
- 1:00:35geographical area and Maxine for what is
- 1:00:39of course is always at war with the
- 1:00:41police
- 1:00:41she doesn't represent those people
- 1:00:47you're talking about there's a quote
- 1:00:49from radical son you were in Berkeley
- 1:00:52with max Lerner and yes what yeah
- 1:00:56Michael Lerner he asked you if you did
- 1:00:58drugs he told him no and he was have you
- 1:01:01ever dropped acid and I said no no he
- 1:01:04said you can't understand socialism
- 1:01:06until you do that could be a bumper
- 1:01:18sticker
- 1:01:29do you have an explanation for why there
- 1:01:33are so many American Jews or at least
- 1:01:35leaders in the Jewish community who are
- 1:01:38Democrats insurance religion the
- 1:01:40Democratic Party no this is saying about
- 1:01:45Reform Judaism which is the most deressa
- 1:01:48nated it's of the is Reform Judaism
- 1:01:52conservative and Orthodox they say
- 1:01:56Reform Judaism is the Democratic Party
- 1:01:58with holidays and it's because it's a
- 1:02:05religion the less religious you are you
- 1:02:08actually are the more the Democratic
- 1:02:13Party is a substitute for it you listen
- 1:02:15to them the other Redeemers everything
- 1:02:20that comes out of their mouths is a
- 1:02:22moral indictment they all sound like
- 1:02:24Hellfire and damnation preachers
- 1:02:26condemning here's another condemning
- 1:02:31people like us people who oppose them in
- 1:02:34the second debate Trump turned to the
- 1:02:38television audience and he said you have
- 1:02:42to understand Hillary has tremendous
- 1:02:44hatred in her heart and then what he was
- 1:02:48referring to was the basket of
- 1:02:50deplorable in which he puts all of us
- 1:02:53and what is what's in that basket racist
- 1:02:56she named them racist sexist homophobic
- 1:02:58Slama folks xenophobes there's not a
- 1:03:01person in this room who has been in an
- 1:03:04argument about say even policy with the
- 1:03:07so-called liberal who hasn't been called
- 1:03:10a racist a sexist or homophobic long
- 1:03:12before the Democratic Party is a party
- 1:03:14of hate didn't you say they were beyond
- 1:03:16redemption or something like that was
- 1:03:18that the phrase and the deplorable right
- 1:03:20irredeemable irredeemable the plural and
- 1:03:23they redeem about deficit well yeah
- 1:03:25that's religious statements right right
- 1:03:27and Republicans never is moral
- 1:03:30indictments they talk like accountants
- 1:03:38but they are afraid to do what you're
- 1:03:40doing to mix it up like you know the
- 1:03:42worst thing about Obamacare is I mean
- 1:03:45the bad that it raises cause it's bad
- 1:03:48you know all the things that Republicans
- 1:03:51do say but it's an assault on individual
- 1:03:55freedom you can't choose your doctor you
- 1:03:57can't choose your plan you can't manage
- 1:04:00your own healthcare the government is
- 1:04:03going to tell you what you can do
- 1:04:05horrifying I I'm I think I I think Rand
- 1:04:09Paul once said that it's the only one
- 1:04:12that I can that came across my radar
- 1:04:14screen hmm other questions by the way
- 1:04:19what she's walking there you made a
- 1:04:20comment in one of these books about the
- 1:04:23the battles you have with truth with
- 1:04:24liberals and and AIDS debates in the
- 1:04:281980s right the press let's go left
- 1:04:32killed half a million gay people in this
- 1:04:35country young gay people and they did it
- 1:04:38by denying by making politically
- 1:04:43incorrect that is banning government
- 1:04:48information or information about how
- 1:04:50aids was cost it's sexually transmitted
- 1:04:56it's made mainly through anal sex
- 1:04:59all these things were politically
- 1:05:01forbidden to toss that I was yeah you
- 1:05:07couldn't talk about it and you you're
- 1:05:09anti-fascist you couldn't close with
- 1:05:13when there was a heterosexual herpes
- 1:05:15epidemic actually they closed all these
- 1:05:19whatever they call Plato's retreat I
- 1:05:22don't know there were these sex clubs
- 1:05:25yeah and the government shut him down
- 1:05:29but while the AIDS epidemic was raging
- 1:05:31you had all these gay bath houses and
- 1:05:34government the Democrats it was a
- 1:05:37Democrat because the epidemics were the
- 1:05:41cities and the cities are controlled by
- 1:05:43the Democrats terrible but you try to
- 1:05:46address this and you were you were just
- 1:05:47vilified farmers fortunately
- 1:05:51this guy was gay and he said I gave a
- 1:05:54talk
- 1:05:55all right debated I know I I had I had
- 1:05:59gay allies trying to wear actually it
- 1:06:01was a nurse but she she got cold feet
- 1:06:03and this didn't want to show up for the
- 1:06:05debate and I'm it was about 200 people
- 1:06:11and they got as the it started very
- 1:06:16quietly and then it built and people got
- 1:06:24one more exercise finally one guy said
- 1:06:28to me said I feel like I have to attack
- 1:06:33you so I felt somewhat safe and then it
- 1:06:38was and then there was a actually was
- 1:06:43the first gay police officer in San
- 1:06:49Francisco
- 1:06:50Larry little John was I think was very
- 1:06:53little John and anyway he he came up to
- 1:06:56me and he said don't stop saying what
- 1:06:58you're saying it's absolutely true and
- 1:07:00then he carried on an initiative in San
- 1:07:03Francisco to try to shut the bathhouses
- 1:07:05which was thwarted more questions can we
- 1:07:20pin him down on that she was defeated
- 1:07:28[Applause]
- 1:07:30that's pretty good
- 1:07:35to me Naruto down to one really the
- 1:07:38greatest problem is is the what I call a
- 1:07:42relative passivity of conservatives
- 1:07:44conservatives don't a large number don't
- 1:07:49understand the bath well Paul Ryan does
- 1:07:52not understand the war I mean I think
- 1:07:55he's probably is he's a very bright guy
- 1:07:57and you know as a wonk he's terrific but
- 1:08:01he doesn't understand the political war
- 1:08:03that's taking place when Donald Trump in
- 1:08:06the second presidential debate brought
- 1:08:08Bill Clinton's accusers to the debate
- 1:08:10with him that's what you're talking
- 1:08:18about that's a that's fighting in your
- 1:08:19face you know or when they I forget what
- 1:08:24they were they were attacking him when
- 1:08:26it when he brought up these fact that
- 1:08:28they were spying it turns out that about
- 1:08:30with spying they were spying on Dennis
- 1:08:33Kucinich using it I mean what is more
- 1:08:36threatening to a democracy then you use
- 1:08:39the intelligence services to spy on your
- 1:08:42political opponents that's the end of
- 1:08:44democracy Obama is a traitor
- 1:08:48he's a betrayed this country betrayed us
- 1:08:50to Iran and he's betrayed us
- 1:08:52domestically he's a menace I think we
- 1:08:56have one or two questions probably
- 1:08:58that's it let's go for the first one
- 1:09:02Josh first thank you for being here
- 1:09:05today my question regarded the Democrat
- 1:09:07Party and the metamorphosizing of the
- 1:09:10Democratic Party now with Bernie Sanders
- 1:09:12and the socialist agenda that's becoming
- 1:09:15more and more evident within the
- 1:09:16Democratic Party but specifically
- 1:09:19referring to the slaughter fields of
- 1:09:21Chicago and these inner cities what can
- 1:09:24be done to reach out to these
- 1:09:25communities mainly the black communities
- 1:09:27and the Latino communities that are very
- 1:09:31religious have a lot of conservative
- 1:09:34principles that we agree with but at the
- 1:09:35same time it's just like they don't see
- 1:09:37the light and they're look let's get a
- 1:09:41I actually persuaded the Trump team to
- 1:09:45put forward a hundred thirty billion
- 1:09:48dollar voucher program let's bow ties
- 1:09:50the whole educational system every black
- 1:09:53church could be a school well it is a
- 1:10:05problem but the Democrats will oppose it
- 1:10:07and make them conservative yeah how
- 1:10:13about a brad to 2p last question and
- 1:10:16we'll have to end it with this Senator
- 1:10:23Joe McCarthy could have been the end of
- 1:10:26the American left but obviously it
- 1:10:28didn't work out that way how do you look
- 1:10:29back on the McCarthy period why your
- 1:10:31thoughts got an expert I know I don't
- 1:10:34know it's Ronnie here yeah Ron radio is
- 1:10:37Ron here well he's not here he's gonna
- 1:10:40be here tomorrow right yes speaking on
- 1:10:42the rosalie should ask him that question
- 1:10:44I think that first of all let me say
- 1:10:47what the Democrats have done to the
- 1:10:50Trump administration is the hundred
- 1:10:54times worse than anything McCarthy was
- 1:10:56ever accused of because all of
- 1:10:58McCarthy's targets were actually members
- 1:11:01of this communist conspiracy the problem
- 1:11:04with McCarthy is that he exaggerated
- 1:11:06things he was very undisciplined like
- 1:11:11Owen Lattimore
- 1:11:13I think you should talk to Ray - ray -
- 1:11:17will tell you but he just exaggerated
- 1:11:20what they did some of them were not
- 1:11:21really that important and he made them
- 1:11:24into chief Soviet agents and and gave
- 1:11:28fodder to the left and they destroyed
- 1:11:31him you know we know what the left looks
- 1:11:33at the McCarthy and let me just say it's
- 1:11:36unfair the playing field is very unfair
- 1:11:39but so conservatives have to be much
- 1:11:42more disciplined yeah then leftist still
- 1:11:45left us get away well when I first came
- 1:11:48out of the left
- 1:11:50and and I wrote you know about my
- 1:11:54leaving the left
- 1:11:55I met with Norman Podhoretz and what he
- 1:11:58said to me is this he said David and you
- 1:12:01were a leftist you got away with
- 1:12:03everything now they're not gonna let you
- 1:12:06get away with anything
- 1:12:07so that true that's so true
- 1:12:10we gotta be perfect this is real it
- 1:12:12really true you think what a mistake
- 1:12:13well we can't be rude so we're gonna
- 1:12:15make wrestling's right right to no one
- 1:12:17to be reckless well we have to stop
- 1:12:21we're at the end of the time but all I
- 1:12:24can say is thank you very much
- 1:12:27[Applause]
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of David Horowitz - The Flaws Of Humanity Doom Socialism & Communism To Failure by Conservative Conscience, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 9,600 words across 1,396 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.