YouTube2Text

Daniel Libeskind's 17 words of architectural inspiration — Transcript

by TED · 3,334 words · 411 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:12I'll start with my favorite muse, Emily Dickinson,
  2. 0:15who said that wonder is not knowledge, neither is it ignorance.
  3. 0:19It's something which is suspended
  4. 0:21between what we believe we can be,
  5. 0:23and a tradition we may have forgotten.
  6. 0:25And I think, when I listen to these incredible people here,
  7. 0:28I've been so inspired -- so many incredible ideas, so many visions.
  8. 0:32And yet, when I look at the environment outside,
  9. 0:36you see how resistant architecture is to change.
  10. 0:38You see how resistant it is to those very ideas.
  11. 0:41We can think them out. We can create incredible things.
  12. 0:44And yet, at the end,
  13. 0:46it's so hard to change a wall.
  14. 0:48We applaud the well-mannered box.
  15. 0:51But to create a space that never existed is what interests me;
  16. 0:54to create something that has never been,
  17. 0:57a space that we have never entered except in our minds and our spirits.
  18. 1:00And I think that's really what architecture is based on.
  19. 1:03Architecture is not based on concrete
  20. 1:05and steel and the elements of the soil.
  21. 1:07It's based on wonder.
  22. 1:09And that wonder is really what has created the greatest cities,
  23. 1:12the greatest spaces that we have had.
  24. 1:14And I think that is indeed what architecture is. It is a story.
  25. 1:18By the way, it is a story that is told through
  26. 1:21its hard materials.
  27. 1:23But it is a story of effort and struggle
  28. 1:25against improbabilities.
  29. 1:27If you think of the great buildings, of the cathedrals, of the temples,
  30. 1:29of the pyramids, of pagodas,
  31. 1:31of cities in India and beyond,
  32. 1:34you think of how incredible this is that that was realized
  33. 1:37not by some abstract idea, but by people.
  34. 1:40So, anything that has been made can be unmade.
  35. 1:42Anything that has been made can be made better.
  36. 1:45There it is: the things that I really believe
  37. 1:47are of important architecture.
  38. 1:49These are the dimensions that I like to work with.
  39. 1:51It's something very personal.
  40. 1:53It's not, perhaps, the dimensions appreciated by art critics
  41. 1:55or architecture critics or city planners.
  42. 1:57But I think these are the necessary oxygen
  43. 2:00for us to live in buildings, to live in cities,
  44. 2:02to connect ourselves in a social space.
  45. 2:05And I therefore believe that optimism is what drives architecture forward.
  46. 2:08It's the only profession where you have to believe in the future.
  47. 2:12You can be a general, a politician, an economist who is depressed,
  48. 2:16a musician in a minor key, a painter in dark colors.
  49. 2:19But architecture is that complete ecstasy that the future can be better.
  50. 2:24And it is that belief that I think drives society.
  51. 2:27And today we have a kind of evangelical pessimism all around us.
  52. 2:30And yet it is in times like this
  53. 2:32that I think architecture can thrive with big ideas,
  54. 2:35ideas that are not small. Think of the great cities.
  55. 2:38Think of the Empire State Building, the Rockefeller Center.
  56. 2:40They were built in times that were
  57. 2:42not really the best of times in a certain way.
  58. 2:44And yet that energy and power of architecture
  59. 2:48has driven an entire social and political space that these buildings occupy.
  60. 2:53So again, I am a believer in the expressive.
  61. 2:55I have never been a fan of the neutral.
  62. 2:58I don't like neutrality in life, in anything.
  63. 3:00I think expression.
  64. 3:02And it's like espresso coffee, you know, you take the essence of the coffee.
  65. 3:04That's what expression is.
  66. 3:06It's been missing in much of the architecture,
  67. 3:08because we think architecture is the realm of the neutered,
  68. 3:12the realm of the kind of a state that has no opinion,
  69. 3:16that has no value.
  70. 3:18And yet, I believe it is the expression --
  71. 3:20expression of the city, expression of our own space --
  72. 3:23that gives meaning to architecture.
  73. 3:25And, of course, expressive spaces are not mute.
  74. 3:28Expressive spaces are not spaces
  75. 3:30that simply confirm what we already know.
  76. 3:32Expressive spaces may disturb us.
  77. 3:34And I think that's also part of life.
  78. 3:36Life is not just an anesthetic to make us smile,
  79. 3:39but to reach out across the abyss of history,
  80. 3:42to places we have never been,
  81. 3:44and would have perhaps been, had we not been so lucky.
  82. 3:47So again, radical versus conservative.
  83. 3:50Radical, what does it mean? It's something which is rooted,
  84. 3:53and something which is rooted deep in a tradition.
  85. 3:55And I think that is what architecture is, it's radical.
  86. 3:58It's not just a conservation in formaldehyde
  87. 4:00of dead forms.
  88. 4:02It is actually a living connection
  89. 4:04to the cosmic event that we are part of,
  90. 4:07and a story that is certainly ongoing.
  91. 4:09It's not something that has a good ending or a bad ending.
  92. 4:12It's actually a story in which our acts themselves
  93. 4:15are pushing the story in a particular way.
  94. 4:17So again I am a believer in the radical architecture.
  95. 4:20You know the Soviet architecture of that building
  96. 4:22is the conservation.
  97. 4:24It's like the old Las Vegas used to be.
  98. 4:26It's about conserving emotions, conserving the traditions
  99. 4:29that have obstructed the mind in moving forward
  100. 4:31and of course what is radical is to confront them.
  101. 4:34And I think our architecture is a confrontation
  102. 4:36with our own senses.
  103. 4:38Therefore I believe it should not be cool.
  104. 4:40There is a lot of appreciation for the kind of cool architecture.
  105. 4:44I've always been an opponent of it. I think emotion is needed.
  106. 4:47Life without emotion would really not be life.
  107. 4:50Even the mind is emotional.
  108. 4:52There is no reason which does not take a position
  109. 4:54in the ethical sphere, in the philosophical mystery of what we are.
  110. 4:58So I think emotion is a dimension
  111. 5:01that is important to introduce into city space, into city life.
  112. 5:05And of course, we are all about the struggle of emotions.
  113. 5:08And I think that is what makes the world a wondrous place.
  114. 5:11And of course, the confrontation of the cool, the unemotional with emotion,
  115. 5:15is a conversation that I think
  116. 5:17cities themselves have fostered.
  117. 5:19I think that is the progress of cities.
  118. 5:21It's not only the forms of cities,
  119. 5:23but the fact that they incarnate emotions,
  120. 5:25not just of those who build them,
  121. 5:27but of those who live there as well.
  122. 5:29Inexplicable versus understood. You know, too often we want to understand everything.
  123. 5:32But architecture is not the language of words.
  124. 5:35It's a language. But it is not a language that can be reduced
  125. 5:39to a series of programmatic notes that we can verbally write.
  126. 5:42Too many buildings that you see outside that are so banal
  127. 5:44tell you a story, but the story is very short,
  128. 5:47which says, "We have no story to tell you."
  129. 5:49(Laughter)
  130. 5:50So the important thing actually,
  131. 5:52is to introduce the actual architectural dimensions,
  132. 5:55which might be totally inexplicable in words,
  133. 5:58because they operate in proportions,
  134. 6:01in materials, in light.
  135. 6:03They connect themselves into various sources,
  136. 6:06into a kind of complex vector matrix
  137. 6:08that isn't really frontal
  138. 6:11but is really embedded in the lives,
  139. 6:13and in the history of a city, and of a people.
  140. 6:16So again, the notion that a building should just be explicit
  141. 6:19I think is a false notion,
  142. 6:21which has reduced architecture into banality.
  143. 6:23Hand versus the computer.
  144. 6:25Of course, what would we be without computers?
  145. 6:27Our whole practice depends on computing.
  146. 6:29But the computer should not just be the glove of the hand;
  147. 6:33the hand should really be the driver of the computing power.
  148. 6:37Because I believe that the hand
  149. 6:39in all its primitive, in all its physiological obscurity,
  150. 6:44has a source, though the source is unknown,
  151. 6:47though we don't have to be mystical about it.
  152. 6:49We realize that the hand has been given us
  153. 6:52by forces that are beyond our own autonomy.
  154. 6:55And I think when I draw drawings
  155. 6:58which may imitate the computer, but are not computer drawings --
  156. 7:01drawings that can come from sources
  157. 7:03that are completely not known, not normal, not seen,
  158. 7:07yet the hand -- and that's what I really, to all of you who are working --
  159. 7:11how can we make the computer respond to our hand
  160. 7:15rather than the hand responding to the computer.
  161. 7:18I think that's part of what the complexity of architecture is.
  162. 7:22Because certainly we have gotten used to the propaganda
  163. 7:26that the simple is the good. But I don't believe it.
  164. 7:28Listening to all of you, the complexity of thought,
  165. 7:31the complexity of layers of meaning is overwhelming.
  166. 7:34And I think we shouldn't shy away in architecture,
  167. 7:37You know, brain surgery, atomic theory,
  168. 7:40genetics, economics
  169. 7:43are complex complex fields.
  170. 7:45There is no reason that architecture should shy away
  171. 7:47and present this illusory world of the simple.
  172. 7:50It is complex. Space is complex.
  173. 7:52Space is something that folds out of itself into completely new worlds.
  174. 7:56And as wondrous as it is,
  175. 7:58it cannot be reduced to a kind of simplification
  176. 8:01that we have often come to be admired.
  177. 8:03And yet, our lives are complex.
  178. 8:05Our emotions are complex.
  179. 8:07Our intellectual desires are complex.
  180. 8:09So I do believe that architecture as I see it
  181. 8:12needs to mirror that complexity in every single space that we have,
  182. 8:16in every intimacy that we possess.
  183. 8:18Of course that means that architecture is political.
  184. 8:21The political is not an enemy of architecture.
  185. 8:23The politeama is the city. It's all of us together.
  186. 8:26And I've always believed that the act of architecture,
  187. 8:28even a private house, when somebody else will see it, is a political act,
  188. 8:32because it will be visible to others.
  189. 8:34And we live in a world which is connecting us more and more.
  190. 8:36So again, the evasion of that sphere,
  191. 8:40which has been so endemic to that sort of pure architecture,
  192. 8:43the autonomous architecture that is just an abstract object
  193. 8:45has never appealed to me.
  194. 8:47And I do believe that this interaction
  195. 8:50with the history, with history that is often very difficult,
  196. 8:54to grapple with it, to create
  197. 8:56a position that is beyond our normal expectations and to create a critique.
  198. 9:02Because architecture is also the asking of questions.
  199. 9:04It's not only the giving of answers.
  200. 9:06It's also, just like life, the asking of questions.
  201. 9:09Therefore it is important that it be real.
  202. 9:11You know we can simulate almost anything.
  203. 9:13But the one thing that can be ever simulated
  204. 9:15is the human heart, the human soul.
  205. 9:18And architecture is so closely intertwined with it
  206. 9:20because we are born somewhere and we die somewhere.
  207. 9:23So the reality of architecture is visceral. It's not intellectual.
  208. 9:27It's not something that comes to us from books and theories.
  209. 9:30It's the real that we touch -- the door, the window,
  210. 9:34the threshold, the bed --
  211. 9:36such prosaic objects. And yet,
  212. 9:38I try, in every building, to take that virtual world,
  213. 9:40which is so enigmatic and so rich,
  214. 9:43and create something in the real world.
  215. 9:45Create a space for an office,
  216. 9:47a space of sustainability
  217. 9:49that really works between that virtuality
  218. 9:52and yet can be realized as something real.
  219. 9:54Unexpected versus habitual.
  220. 9:56What is a habit? It's just a shackle for ourselves.
  221. 9:59It's a self-induced poison.
  222. 10:01So the unexpected is always unexpected.
  223. 10:03You know, it's true, the cathedrals, as unexpected,
  224. 10:06will always be unexpected.
  225. 10:08You know Frank Gehry's buildings, they will continue to be unexpected in the future.
  226. 10:11So not the habitual architecture that instills in us
  227. 10:14the false sort of stability,
  228. 10:16but an architecture that is full of tension,
  229. 10:19an architecture that goes beyond itself
  230. 10:22to reach a human soul and a human heart,
  231. 10:24and that breaks out of the shackles of habits.
  232. 10:27And of course habits are enforced by architecture.
  233. 10:30When we see the same kind of architecture
  234. 10:32we become immured in that world of those angles,
  235. 10:35of those lights, of those materials.
  236. 10:37We think the world really looks like our buildings.
  237. 10:40And yet our buildings are pretty much limited by the techniques and wonders
  238. 10:44that have been part of them.
  239. 10:46So again, the unexpected which is also the raw.
  240. 10:49And I often think of the raw and the refined.
  241. 10:51What is raw? The raw, I would say
  242. 10:53is the naked experience, untouched by luxury,
  243. 10:56untouched by expensive materials,
  244. 10:58untouched by the kind of refinement
  245. 11:00that we associate with high culture.
  246. 11:03So the rawness, I think, in space,
  247. 11:06the fact that sustainability can actually, in the future
  248. 11:09translate into a raw space,
  249. 11:11a space that isn't decorated,
  250. 11:13a space that is not mannered in any source,
  251. 11:16but a space that might be cool in terms of its temperature,
  252. 11:20might be refractive to our desires.
  253. 11:23A space that doesn't always follow us
  254. 11:26like a dog that has been trained to follow us,
  255. 11:29but moves ahead into directions of demonstrating
  256. 11:32other possibilities, other experiences,
  257. 11:34that have never been part of the vocabulary of architecture.
  258. 11:39And of course that juxtaposition is of great interest to me
  259. 11:42because it creates a kind of a spark of new energy.
  260. 11:46And so I do like something which is pointed, not blunt,
  261. 11:49something which is focused on reality,
  262. 11:52something that has the power, through its leverage,
  263. 11:55to transform even a very small space.
  264. 11:57So architecture maybe is not so big, like science,
  265. 12:00but through its focal point
  266. 12:03it can leverage in an Archimedian way
  267. 12:05what we think the world is really about.
  268. 12:07And often it takes just a building
  269. 12:09to change our experience of what could be done, what has been done,
  270. 12:13how the world has remained both in between stability and instability.
  271. 12:18And of course buildings have their shapes.
  272. 12:21Those shapes are difficult to change.
  273. 12:23And yet, I do believe that in every social space,
  274. 12:25in every public space,
  275. 12:27there is a desire to communicate more
  276. 12:29than just that blunt thought, that blunt technique,
  277. 12:33but something that pinpoints, and can point in various directions
  278. 12:37forward, backward, sideways and around.
  279. 12:40So that is indeed what is memory.
  280. 12:43So I believe that my main interest is to memory.
  281. 12:47Without memory we would be amnesiacs.
  282. 12:49We would not know which way we were going,
  283. 12:51and why we are going where we're going.
  284. 12:53So I've been never interested in the forgettable reuse,
  285. 12:58rehashing of the same things over and over again,
  286. 13:01which, of course, get accolades of critics.
  287. 13:03Critics like the performance to be repeated again and again the same way.
  288. 13:07But I rather play something
  289. 13:09completely unheard of,
  290. 13:11and even with flaws,
  291. 13:13than repeat the same thing over and over which has been hollowed
  292. 13:15by its meaninglessness.
  293. 13:17So again, memory is the city, memory is the world.
  294. 13:20Without the memory there would be no story to tell.
  295. 13:22There would be nowhere to turn.
  296. 13:24The memorable, I think, is really our world, what we think the world is.
  297. 13:28And it's not only our memory,
  298. 13:30but those who remember us,
  299. 13:33which means that architecture is not mute.
  300. 13:35It's an art of communication.
  301. 13:37It tells a story. The story can reach into obscure desires.
  302. 13:41It can reach into sources that are not explicitly available.
  303. 13:44It can reach into millennia
  304. 13:47that have been buried,
  305. 13:49and return them in a just and unexpected equity.
  306. 13:53So again, I think the notion that
  307. 13:55the best architecture is silent has never appealed to me.
  308. 13:59Silence maybe is good for a cemetery but not for a city.
  309. 14:02Cities should be full of vibrations, full of sound, full of music.
  310. 14:05And that indeed is the architectural mission
  311. 14:07that I believe is important,
  312. 14:09is to create spaces that are vibrant,
  313. 14:11that are pluralistic,
  314. 14:13that can transform the most prosaic activities,
  315. 14:16and raise them to a completely different expectation.
  316. 14:18Create a shopping center, a swimming place
  317. 14:20that is more like a museum than like entertainment.
  318. 14:23And these are our dreams.
  319. 14:25And of course risk. I think architecture should be risky.
  320. 14:29You know it costs a lot of money and so on, but yes,
  321. 14:31it should not play it safe.
  322. 14:33It should not play it safe, because if it plays it safe
  323. 14:36it's not moving us in a direction that we want to be.
  324. 14:40And I think, of course,
  325. 14:42risk is what underlies the world.
  326. 14:44World without risk would not be worth living.
  327. 14:47So yes, I do believe that the risk we take in every building.
  328. 14:51Risks to create spaces that have never been cantilevered to that extent.
  329. 14:55Risks of spaces that have never been
  330. 14:57so dizzying,
  331. 15:00as they should be, for a pioneering city.
  332. 15:03Risks that really move architecture
  333. 15:06even with all its flaws, into a space which is much better
  334. 15:09that the ever again repeated
  335. 15:11hollowness of a ready-made thing.
  336. 15:14And of course that is finally what I believe architecture to be.
  337. 15:17It's about space. It's not about fashion.
  338. 15:19It's not about decoration.
  339. 15:21It's about creating with minimal means
  340. 15:23something which can not be repeated,
  341. 15:26cannot be simulated in any other sphere.
  342. 15:28And there of course is the space that we need to breathe,
  343. 15:32is the space we need to dream.
  344. 15:34These are the spaces that are
  345. 15:36not just luxurious spaces for some of us,
  346. 15:39but are important for everybody in this world.
  347. 15:41So again, it's not about the changing fashions, changing theories.
  348. 15:45It's about carving out a space for trees.
  349. 15:48It's carving out a space where nature can enter
  350. 15:50the domestic world of a city.
  351. 15:52A space where something which has never seen a light of day
  352. 15:56can enter into the inner workings of a density.
  353. 16:00And I think that is really the nature of architecture.
  354. 16:04Now I am a believer in democracy.
  355. 16:06I don't like beautiful buildings
  356. 16:08built for totalitarian regimes.
  357. 16:10Where people cannot speak, cannot vote, cannot do anything.
  358. 16:12We too often admire those buildings. We think they are beautiful.
  359. 16:15And yet when I think of the poverty of society
  360. 16:17which doesn't give freedom to its people,
  361. 16:19I don't admire those buildings.
  362. 16:21So democracy, as difficult as it is, I believe in it.
  363. 16:23And of course, at Ground Zero what else?
  364. 16:26It's such a complex project.
  365. 16:28It's emotional. There is so many interests.
  366. 16:30It's political. There is so many parties to this project.
  367. 16:34There is so many interests. There's money. There's political power.
  368. 16:36There are emotions of the victims.
  369. 16:38And yet, in all its messiness, in all its difficulties,
  370. 16:42I would not have liked somebody to say,
  371. 16:44"This is the tabula rasa, mister architect -- do whatever you want."
  372. 16:47I think nothing good will come out of that.
  373. 16:49I think architecture is about consensus.
  374. 16:51And it is about the dirty word "compromise." Compromise is not bad.
  375. 16:55Compromise, if it's artistic,
  376. 16:57if it is able to cope with its strategies --
  377. 17:00and there is my first sketch and the last rendering --
  378. 17:02it's not that far away.
  379. 17:04And yet, compromise, consensus,
  380. 17:06that is what I believe in.
  381. 17:08And Ground Zero, despite all its difficulties, it's moving forward.
  382. 17:11It's difficult. 2011, 2013. Freedom Tower, the memorial.
  383. 17:16And that is where I end.
  384. 17:18I was inspired when I came here as an immigrant
  385. 17:20on a ship like millions of others,
  386. 17:22looking at America from that point of view.
  387. 17:25This is America. This is liberty.
  388. 17:27This is what we dream about. Its individuality,
  389. 17:29demonstrated in the skyline. It's resilience.
  390. 17:32And finally, it's the freedom that America represents,
  391. 17:34not just to me, as an immigrant, but to everyone in the world. Thank you.
  392. 17:38(Applause)
  393. 17:43Chris Anderson: I've got a question.
  394. 17:45So have you come to peace
  395. 17:47with the process that happened at Ground Zero
  396. 17:50and the loss of the original, incredible design that you came up with?
  397. 17:53Daniel Libeskind: Look. We have to cure ourselves
  398. 17:57of the notion that we are authoritarian,
  399. 17:59that we can determine everything that happens.
  400. 18:01We have to rely on others, and shape the process in the best way possible.
  401. 18:05I came from the Bronx. I was taught not to be a loser,
  402. 18:08not to be somebody who just gives up in a fight.
  403. 18:10You have to fight for what you believe. You don't always win
  404. 18:12everything you want to win. But you can steer the process.
  405. 18:15And I believe that what will be built at Ground Zero
  406. 18:18will be meaningful, will be inspiring,
  407. 18:21will tell other generations of the sacrifices,
  408. 18:23of the meaning of this event.
  409. 18:25Not just for New York, but for the world.
  410. 18:27Chris Anderson: Thank you so much, Daniel Libeskind.
  411. 18:29(Applause)

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of Daniel Libeskind's 17 words of architectural inspiration by TED, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 3,334 words across 411 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.