YouTube2Text

Cuando las MUJERES defienden su propia OPRESIÓN | Las Serena Joy de la VIDA REAL — Transcript

by SuFrida · 4,407 words · 686 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00a Christian woman who has a very
  2. 0:01healthy connection with my husband. I
  3. 0:03vote the same way he does. So, honestly
  4. 0:05, I would be okay with giving up my
  5. 0:07right to vote because I know that he
  6. 0:09would represent me well. He was voting
  7. 0:12on behalf of our household. I would be
  8. 0:13fine with that. Do you think your
  9. 0:14daughter should have the right to vote?
  10. 0:16I'd be okay if she didn't because I
  11. 0:17also know she's going to marry a
  12. 0:19biblical man that they would also be in
  13. 0:21line. I would as well give up my vote
  14. 0:23if got rid of like things like abortion
  15. 0:24. I feel like with my mindset, I would
  16. 0:27want to put my vote in, but the
  17. 0:28majority of women are liberal and I
  18. 0:30think getting rid of that would
  19. 0:32actually help women. What's your take
  20. 0:35away from women? I am not in favor of
  21. 0:47women voting, man. The privilege comes,
  22. 0:52but not the responsibility; for me, the
  23. 0:55fact that they increasingly make
  24. 0:57couples compete even in voting, man, is
  25. 1:00one more reason why you ruin it. Why
  26. 1:02would—wouldn't it make more sense to
  27. 1:04you, if you want to start there, for
  28. 1:06there to be one vote per household? So
  29. 1:10why shouldn't women vote? So here's
  30. 1:13what I'll say is that if somebody asked
  31. 1:15me if the government was like—if we
  32. 1:17could have a more conservative country
  33. 1:19if all women gave up their vote—I
  34. 1:21would gladly give up my right to vote
  35. 1:23to have a more conservative country.
  36. 1:28Serena Joy is one of the main
  37. 1:29characters in*The Handmaid's Tale*and
  38. 1:31probably one of the most complex in the
  39. 1:33entire story, as through her, the
  40. 1:34series shows us how a woman, from a
  41. 1:36position of privilege, can participate
  42. 1:38in the oppression of others, believing
  43. 1:40that as long as she supports those who
  44. 1:41hold power, she will be safe. However,
  45. 1:45Serena discovers too late that systems
  46. 1:47that strip people of human rights
  47. 1:49rarely stop there. And the thing is,
  48. 1:53when we stop defending our freedoms and
  49. 1:54cede them to those who promise to
  50. 1:56protect us, sooner or later we also end
  51. 1:58up losing the ability to decide over
  52. 2:00our own lives. And when that happens,
  53. 2:02there is no longer any support network
  54. 2:04left to hold us up. Neither those who
  55. 2:06were victims of our actions have any
  56. 2:08reason to defend us, nor do those who
  57. 2:10concentrate power feel any loyalty
  58. 2:11toward us. But perhaps the most
  59. 2:14unsettling thing about Serena Joy is
  60. 2:15that she isn't as fictional a character
  61. 2:17as we'd like to believe; rather, her
  62. 2:19way of thinking, her speeches, and the
  63. 2:21way she justifies the loss of rights
  64. 2:22for other women have too many parallels
  65. 2:24in real life. Because, just as it
  66. 2:27happens in the series, those ideas
  67. 2:29don't exist in a vacuum, but are found
  68. 2:31in people willing to support and spread
  69. 2:33them. And that is precisely where I
  70. 2:35would like to mention Erika Kirk. You
  71. 2:38have probably heard her name everywhere
  72. 2:40in recent weeks, since in June of this
  73. 2:43year she led the Turning Point USA
  74. 2:45Women's Leadership Summit, an event
  75. 2:47attended by more than 2,000 women that
  76. 2:49brought together some of the most
  77. 2:51influential voices in American
  78. 2:52conservatism. And one of the things
  79. 2:56that drew the most attention, aside
  80. 2:58from the considerable number of
  81. 2:59attendees, was the proposal called "
  82. 3:01household voting," which defends the
  83. 3:03idea that each family should cast a
  84. 3:05single vote. Presented by the head of
  85. 3:08the household, who would traditionally
  86. 3:09be the father or the husband. The fact
  87. 3:12is that, apparently, many people today
  88. 3:14take many rights for granted. They seem
  89. 3:17so commonplace to us that we often
  90. 3:19forget that, for a large part of
  91. 3:21history, women simply couldn't do many
  92. 3:24things, like voting. For example, the
  93. 3:27suffragette movement began to gain
  94. 3:29momentum during the 19th century,
  95. 3:30driven by women who demanded to be
  96. 3:32recognized as citizens with the same
  97. 3:34political rights as men. And it wasn't
  98. 3:37until the 20th century that most
  99. 3:38countries began to approve women's
  100. 3:40suffrage. In Mexico, for example, women
  101. 3:43didn't gain the right to vote and run
  102. 3:46for office until 1953, which is to say,
  103. 3:49just over 70 years ago. And what was
  104. 3:51the argument to prevent it? Well, many
  105. 3:54maintained that women didn't have the
  106. 3:56intellectual capacity, the rationality,
  107. 3:58or sufficient interest to participate
  108. 4:00in politics. It was said that they were
  109. 4:04too emotional to make important
  110. 4:05decisions or that their natural role
  111. 4:07was within the home. But there was
  112. 4:11another argument that is especially
  113. 4:13interesting because it bears a
  114. 4:15significant resemblance to the rhetoric
  115. 4:17being spread today, as many politicians
  116. 4:19claimed there was no point in granting
  117. 4:22women the right to vote, because in the
  118. 4:24end, they would vote exactly the same
  119. 4:26as their husbands or their fathers. So,
  120. 4:29under that logic, the male vote already
  121. 4:32represented the entire family, so
  122. 4:35allowing women to vote was seen as
  123. 4:37unnecessary. Does that sound familiar?
  124. 4:40That is why, in this video, we are
  125. 4:42going to analyze the character of
  126. 4:43Serena Joy, compare her with different
  127. 4:45female figures of contemporary
  128. 4:47conservatism, and understand why her
  129. 4:48way of thinking continues to have such
  130. 4:50an impact today. But we are also going
  131. 4:53to talk about one of the discourses
  132. 4:55that has gained the most momentum in
  133. 4:57recent years, which is the ideal of the
  134. 4:59traditional wife or the famous "trad
  135. 5:01wives." Because although many content
  136. 5:03creators present it as a simple and
  137. 5:06desirable alternative for all women,
  138. 5:08the reality is much more complex. And
  139. 5:11well, as I said in my previous video
  140. 5:13where I talk more in-depth about*The
  141. 5:15Handmaid's Tale*—which, if you
  142. 5:16haven't seen it, go watch it—Margaret
  143. 5:18Atwood, the author of this story, did
  144. 5:20not predict the future when she wrote
  145. 5:22it; rather, what she did was base it on
  146. 5:24history to write every law, punishment,
  147. 5:25and control mechanism in Gilead. And
  148. 5:29the same thing happened with the
  149. 5:31character of Serena Joy, since Margaret
  150. 5:33took elements from various figures of
  151. 5:35American conservatism to build the
  152. 5:37character, but the main inspiration was
  153. 5:39Phyllis Schlafly, one of the most
  154. 5:41influential women of the American right
  155. 5:43during the 60s and 70s. Phyllis was a
  156. 5:48mother of six, a lawyer, writer,
  157. 5:49lecturer, and an extraordinarily
  158. 5:51skilled political strategist who
  159. 5:53traveled all over the United States
  160. 5:55giving lectures, published books,
  161. 5:57appeared constantly in the media, and
  162. 6:00managed to mobilize thousands of women
  163. 6:02to defend a deeply traditional vision
  164. 6:04of the family. In other words, she
  165. 6:08built a public career thanks to the
  166. 6:09fact that she could work, travel, write
  167. 6:11, engage in politics, and exercise
  168. 6:13national leadership. So it was like,
  169. 6:17while she was enjoying all those
  170. 6:19freedoms, she was also convincing other
  171. 6:22women that their ideal place was in the
  172. 6:24home and that feminism represented a
  173. 6:27threat to the family. In fact, her
  174. 6:31greatest battle was against the Equal
  175. 6:33Rights Amendment, known as the ERA, a
  176. 6:35constitutional reform that sought to
  177. 6:38guarantee that men and women had equal
  178. 6:40rights under the law in the United
  179. 6:42States. And while figures like Gloria
  180. 6:46Steinem defended the approval of this
  181. 6:49amendment, Phyllis led one of the most
  182. 6:51successful conservative campaigns of
  183. 6:53the 20th century to prevent it from
  184. 6:55being passed, since, according to her,
  185. 6:57that legal equality would end up
  186. 6:59harming women, as they could lose
  187. 7:01certain privileges like being
  188. 7:03financially supported by their husbands
  189. 7:05, remaining exempt from mandatory
  190. 7:07military service, or retaining certain
  191. 7:09legal protections based on their gender
  192. 7:12. And well, in the end, this amendment
  193. 7:15never achieved the number of states
  194. 7:17necessary to be incorporated into the
  195. 7:19U.S. Constitution, so Phyllis achieved
  196. 7:21her goal, and to this day, it remains
  197. 7:23that way. However, her story took a
  198. 7:26quite ironic turn because, after
  199. 7:28dedicating decades of her life to
  200. 7:30strengthening the conservative movement
  201. 7:33, Phyllis hoped to occupy an important
  202. 7:35role within the new political power she
  203. 7:37had helped build. For example, Ronald
  204. 7:41Reagan never gave her the position she
  205. 7:43expected within his government; even
  206. 7:45though she had been key to mobilizing
  207. 7:47the conservative right, she did not
  208. 7:49receive the level of government
  209. 7:51influence she expected, and on more
  210. 7:53than one occasion, she was sidelined by
  211. 7:55the same male leaders whose rise she
  212. 7:57had promoted. And that is precisely
  213. 8:01what happens with Serena Joy, since
  214. 8:02before the creation of Gilead, Serena
  215. 8:05was a writer, speaker, and a very
  216. 8:06influential public figure. She traveled
  217. 8:09the country giving speeches about the
  218. 8:11importance of women returning to the
  219. 8:13home, accepting their biological
  220. 8:15destiny, and being submissive to their
  221. 8:18husbands. She defended a traditional
  222. 8:21family model and maintained that
  223. 8:22feminism had led women away from their
  224. 8:24true purpose. But again, the hypocrisy
  225. 8:28was that she herself did not live that
  226. 8:30way. She was not locked in her house
  227. 8:33being a traditional wife; instead, she
  228. 8:35was writing books, appearing on
  229. 8:36television, participating in political
  230. 8:38debates, and traveling across the
  231. 8:40country to spread her message. So, just
  232. 8:44like Phyllis Schlafly, Serena occupied
  233. 8:46an enormous public space, while at the
  234. 8:48same time arguing that this space was
  235. 8:51not an appropriate place for other
  236. 8:53women. And in this part, I would like
  237. 8:56to clarify that from this point on, I
  238. 8:58am going to base this primarily on the
  239. 8:59Serena Joy from the series because this
  240. 9:01character is developed better there
  241. 9:02than in the book. The thing is, during
  242. 9:05the first few seasons, Serena was
  243. 9:07presented as a deeply cruel character.
  244. 9:10She manipulated those around her,
  245. 9:11exerted both physical and psychological
  246. 9:14violence against the handmaids, and was
  247. 9:16willing to do whatever it took to get
  248. 9:18that child she longed for so much.
  249. 9:21However, as the story progresses,
  250. 9:23Serena begins to experience the
  251. 9:24consequences of this system firsthand.
  252. 9:28For example, one of the most disturbing
  253. 9:30moments in the series are the
  254. 9:32ceremonies, those rituals in which the
  255. 9:34commanders rape the handmaids with the
  256. 9:36forced consent of their wives to try to
  257. 9:38conceive a child. Serena, as a wife,
  258. 9:42participated in those ceremonies and
  259. 9:44forced June to endure them. But the
  260. 9:48series makes it very clear to us that,
  261. 9:50not even for the wives, this experience
  262. 9:52was free of pain or humiliation,
  263. 9:54because they literally live in a system
  264. 9:57where their husbands have relations—
  265. 9:59well, rather, they rape other women in
  266. 10:01front of them. Therefore, what they
  267. 10:06feel is not taken into account either,
  268. 10:08as for Gilead, only their vision of
  269. 10:10what a woman should be or what she must
  270. 10:12endure to become a mother is valid. And
  271. 10:17that is exactly where one of the
  272. 10:18greatest ironies of this character
  273. 10:20appears, since Serena helped build a
  274. 10:22regime that objectifies women, only to
  275. 10:25discover too late that she was one of
  276. 10:27those women too. Because as Gilead
  277. 10:30consolidates, Serena begins to realize
  278. 10:32that the rules apply to her as well.
  279. 10:35And now I am going to give some
  280. 10:37spoilers that, in my opinion, are not
  281. 10:39that important. I mention this because
  282. 10:41if you haven't seen the series and want
  283. 10:43to watch it later, I don't think this
  284. 10:44will ruin your experience. But if you
  285. 10:46really don't want to know anything, I
  286. 10:49recommend you skip to this minute. But
  287. 10:52well, having said that, one of the
  288. 10:53first reality checks for Serena comes
  289. 10:55after an attack in which her husband,
  290. 10:57Commander Fred Waterford, is seriously
  291. 10:59wounded. While he remains hospitalized,
  292. 11:03Serena tries to temporarily take charge
  293. 11:04of some political and administrative
  294. 11:06matters. She drafts documents,
  295. 11:09organizes meetings, and makes decisions
  296. 11:11that even benefit her own husband.
  297. 11:14However, when Fred recovers, far from
  298. 11:16thanking her for her help, he beats her
  299. 11:18brutally for having assumed a role that
  300. 11:20, according to Gilead's rules,
  301. 11:22corresponds exclusively to men. That is
  302. 11:26to say, not even when women use their
  303. 11:28abilities to help the regime can they
  304. 11:31be thanked for it, because the role
  305. 11:33they themselves defended relegated them
  306. 11:36to that. But perhaps the moment that
  307. 11:39best summarizes Serena's tragedy occurs
  308. 11:41shortly after, in one of the most
  309. 11:43shocking scenes in the series, where
  310. 11:44she proposes that girls be allowed to
  311. 11:46learn to read the Bible, and to defend
  312. 11:48her stance, she takes one and reads a
  313. 11:50passage before the Council of
  314. 11:52Commanders. And thinking she would be
  315. 11:55spared any punishment for being a
  316. 11:57commander's wife, the exact opposite
  317. 11:59happens, as she receives an immediate
  318. 12:01punishment, which was having a finger
  319. 12:03amputated. Because yes, in Gilead, if a
  320. 12:06woman was discovered reading or writing
  321. 12:08, that was her punishment. And moments
  322. 12:12like these make it clear to us that in
  323. 12:14Gilead, when a punishment was given,
  324. 12:15there was no distinction between the
  325. 12:17women who were always oppressed and the
  326. 12:19women who helped build the regime.
  327. 12:23However, an even harder blow for Serena
  328. 12:25comes when she finally achieves what
  329. 12:27she had always wanted. And it is that
  330. 12:30for years, Serena treated June as if
  331. 12:32she were merely a means to get a baby.
  332. 12:35He humiliated her, punished her,
  333. 12:36mistreated her, and wanted to separate
  334. 12:38her from her daughter from the moment
  335. 12:40she was born. But when Serena becomes
  336. 12:43pregnant later on, she ends up
  337. 12:45experiencing a different version of
  338. 12:47that same violence, because her
  339. 12:48pregnancy no longer belongs to her and
  340. 12:51other people with more power than her
  341. 12:53begin to decide for her, control her
  342. 12:55future, and treat her as if she were
  343. 12:57merely a vessel for a child. That is to
  344. 13:00say, they started treating her as if
  345. 13:02she were a handmaid. So, the woman who
  346. 13:05once believed she controlled the system
  347. 13:07ends up being controlled by it. But
  348. 13:10despite the lessons we see from
  349. 13:12characters like Phyllis in real life or
  350. 13:14Serena Joy in fiction, today we
  351. 13:16continue to see these types of figures
  352. 13:18who propagate these discourses. One of
  353. 13:22the most talked-about today, evidently,
  354. 13:24is Erika Kirk, who is a businesswoman,
  355. 13:26podcaster, and a public figure of the
  356. 13:28American right who began to gain
  357. 13:30notoriety after participating in beauty
  358. 13:32pageants and later developed religious
  359. 13:34projects on digital platforms. And
  360. 13:38after marrying conservative political
  361. 13:39activist Charlie Kirk, she began to
  362. 13:41accompany him in debates and
  363. 13:42conferences at various universities in
  364. 13:44the United States. But after Charlie's
  365. 13:47assassination in 2025, Erika was named
  366. 13:50executive director of Turning Point USA
  367. 13:52, one of the most influential
  368. 13:54conservative organizations in the
  369. 13:56country, which was led by Charlie, but
  370. 13:59once he passed, the position went to
  371. 14:01Erika. So, the same question arises
  372. 14:04again. Why the hell are you telling
  373. 14:07women to stay at home when you aren't
  374. 14:09in yours? That said, I think the
  375. 14:12pattern of these types of figures is
  376. 14:15very obvious, like Phyllis, Serena, and
  377. 14:17Erika, who are women speaking from a
  378. 14:19position of privilege because they have
  379. 14:22political influence, economic
  380. 14:23independence, huge platforms, and
  381. 14:26access to public spaces that previous
  382. 14:28generations of women had to conquer;
  383. 14:30but, at the same time, they use those
  384. 14:32very spaces to convince other women
  385. 14:35that they should aspire to a more
  386. 14:37traditional model of life. where their
  387. 14:40main function is to become wives and
  388. 14:43mothers. But precisely because they
  389. 14:45speak from their privilege, they do not
  390. 14:47consider the reality of other women and
  391. 14:49they think that since they haven't had
  392. 14:51the need to exercise certain rights,
  393. 14:53they assume it's the same for everyone.
  394. 14:56But, just because you haven't lived
  395. 14:57through something doesn't mean you
  396. 14:59can't have empathy. I don't think you
  397. 15:01have to go through a pregnancy, forced
  398. 15:03marriage, abuse, domestic violence,
  399. 15:05economic dependence, or workplace
  400. 15:07discrimination to inform yourself and
  401. 15:09empathize with the women who have lived
  402. 15:11through all that. And so, with that
  403. 15:15said, I’d like to touch on the "trad
  404. 15:17wife" or traditional wife movement,
  405. 15:19which can be defined as when a woman
  406. 15:21chooses to live under a classic family
  407. 15:23model, where the man works outside and
  408. 15:25earns money, while she stays home to
  409. 15:27look after the children and do the
  410. 15:29housework. This movement is
  411. 15:33characterized by using an aesthetic
  412. 15:34inspired by the 50s and 60s, where
  413. 15:36everything looks vintage, colorful, and
  414. 15:38clean. And this phenomenon has become
  415. 15:41popular on platforms like TikTok and
  416. 15:43Instagram, where various content
  417. 15:45creators call themselves traditional
  418. 15:47wives while showing their daily
  419. 15:48routines. And maybe at first glance
  420. 15:51this might seem harmless, but what
  421. 15:53generates debate is that those who
  422. 15:55practice this lifestyle say they do it
  423. 15:58because it’s a free decision to get
  424. 16:00rid of the stress of the working world
  425. 16:02and value the family and the home more.
  426. 16:05But other people criticize the trend
  427. 16:08because it puts women back in a
  428. 16:10position of dependency and revives old
  429. 16:12ideas about gender roles. And well, at
  430. 16:15least I believe there is nothing wrong
  431. 16:17with a woman wanting to dedicate
  432. 16:19herself to the home, start a family, or
  433. 16:21be a full-time mother. If that decision
  434. 16:24is free, it’s free. Of course, if
  435. 16:28someone has that dream for their life,
  436. 16:30well, it deserves the same respect as
  437. 16:32other projects. But the problem begins
  438. 16:36when that lifestyle stops being
  439. 16:38presented as an option and starts being
  440. 16:40sold as the only correct path for women
  441. 16:42, because we know that reality is much
  442. 16:45more complex. Currently, millions of
  443. 16:48families depend on two incomes to be
  444. 16:50able to pay for housing, cover their
  445. 16:52expenses, or simply make it to the end
  446. 16:54of the month. Wages have lost
  447. 16:57purchasing power, the cost of living
  448. 16:59has increased, and more and more people
  449. 17:01are delaying motherhood or deciding not
  450. 17:03to have children because they simply
  451. 17:05cannot afford it. That’s why I find
  452. 17:08it very problematic to romanticize the
  453. 17:10traditional wife model as if it were a
  454. 17:12possibility that all women could have.
  455. 17:16Besides, another problem is that social
  456. 17:18media usually shows a very aesthetic
  457. 17:20version of this lifestyle. Impeccable
  458. 17:23houses, pretty floral dresses,
  459. 17:25fresh-baked bread, and an apparently
  460. 17:27perfect family. But history and
  461. 17:31statistics tell us something totally
  462. 17:33different, since for centuries millions
  463. 17:35of women lived under that traditional
  464. 17:37model and many lived through domestic
  465. 17:40and sexual violence, economic
  466. 17:41dependency, infidelity, forced
  467. 17:43marriages, and pregnancies they could
  468. 17:46never choose. That’s why I find it so
  469. 17:49stupid when there are people who say
  470. 17:51that women back then didn’t complain.
  471. 17:54It’s like, come on, it’s not that
  472. 17:56women back then complained less or were
  473. 17:59happier; the reality is that many
  474. 18:01couldn't divorce, open a bank account
  475. 18:03without a man's permission, have a job
  476. 18:06that allowed them independence, or
  477. 18:08report different types of abuse;
  478. 18:10because, even in many countries, [rape]
  479. 18:13within marriage wasn't even legally
  480. 18:15recognized as a crime, since it was
  481. 18:17assumed that a husband had rights over
  482. 18:20his wife’s body. So, how the hell are
  483. 18:23you going to complain if practically
  484. 18:25the entire system is designed so that
  485. 18:26you have nowhere to go? And that’s
  486. 18:30not to mention that many girls didn’t
  487. 18:32even have the chance to choose the path
  488. 18:34of their lives, as from a very young
  489. 18:36age they were forced to marry, dropped
  490. 18:38out of school after an early pregnancy,
  491. 18:40or were handed over by their own
  492. 18:41families to much older men. And I want
  493. 18:45to share that when I was a girl and
  494. 18:48heard people like my aunts or
  495. 18:49grandmothers say things like "the girls
  496. 18:52were stolen," I genuinely believed it
  497. 18:54was just an expression. I thought it
  498. 18:58was like when someone jokingly says, "
  499. 18:59Oh, I'm going to steal them." But they
  500. 19:02never actually did it. However, when I
  501. 19:04grew up, I understood that it wasn't a
  502. 19:06metaphor. I mean, in many places, there
  503. 19:10were literally men who kidnapped a
  504. 19:12young woman or a girl to take her away
  505. 19:14to live with them and force her to
  506. 19:16become their wife and have many
  507. 19:18children. And in other cases, there was
  508. 19:22family or community pressure so that
  509. 19:25once a young woman spent a night with a
  510. 19:27man, marriage was considered mandatory.
  511. 19:31And the thing is, look, there was no
  512. 19:33real consent; instead, there was
  513. 19:34coercion, fear, and enormous social
  514. 19:36pressure. And the darkest part is that
  515. 19:39forced marriages of girls and women
  516. 19:41still happen today. Maybe not in the
  517. 19:43numbers they used to, but it remains a
  518. 19:46problem. That’s why I find it so
  519. 19:49dangerous to romanticize the past as if
  520. 19:51all women lived happily as traditional
  521. 19:53wives. Because, again, history is full
  522. 19:57of women who couldn't choose, but who
  523. 19:59for a long time convinced themselves
  524. 20:01that it was what they wanted so it
  525. 20:03would be easier to endure. But then,
  526. 20:06knowing this, why do younger
  527. 20:08generations idealize that lifestyle so
  528. 20:11much? Well, I think there are several
  529. 20:13reasons. The first is what I was
  530. 20:15already telling you: the image social
  531. 20:17media sells us, showing us a completely
  532. 20:20aspirational version of a "tradwife's"
  533. 20:22life. A nice house, vintage dresses,
  534. 20:25financial stability, a wonderful
  535. 20:27husband, and a routine that looks like
  536. 20:29it was taken straight out of a movie.
  537. 20:32But guys, remember that many of these
  538. 20:34content creators have a very high
  539. 20:36economic status. They generate income
  540. 20:39thanks to social media itself or have
  541. 20:41teams working for them. In other words,
  542. 20:43that life is also a product they are
  543. 20:45selling. Also, another idea I think is
  544. 20:49being sold a lot and seems dangerous is
  545. 20:51the idea of being a kept wife, because
  546. 20:53it minimizes or eliminates the idea
  547. 20:56that depending on someone financially
  548. 20:58always entails risks. But remember that
  549. 21:02nothing guarantees the future of a
  550. 21:04relationship, as there could be a
  551. 21:05divorce, an illness, an economic crisis
  552. 21:07, a layoff, or even the death of that
  553. 21:09partner. And well, when your entire
  554. 21:12stability depends exclusively on
  555. 21:14someone else, your ability to make
  556. 21:16decisions also becomes much more
  557. 21:18limited, and in the case of
  558. 21:19experiencing any type of violence, it
  559. 21:22is harder to get out of it. That’s
  560. 21:24why I believe financial independence is
  561. 21:26not just a question of money, but also
  562. 21:28a way to have greater autonomy over
  563. 21:30your life in case of an emergency. But
  564. 21:33I think there is a deeper reason why
  565. 21:35these discourses are connecting so much
  566. 21:38with young people. And it’s that our
  567. 21:40generation is facing a crisis where
  568. 21:42there are low wages, increasingly
  569. 21:44expensive rents, precarious jobs, and
  570. 21:46enormous uncertainty for the future.
  571. 21:49Nowadays, buying a house seems
  572. 21:51impossible for many people. Having
  573. 21:54children is increasingly expensive, and
  574. 21:56the idea of reaching financial
  575. 21:57stability feels much further away than
  576. 21:59it did a few decades ago. That’s why,
  577. 22:02in that context, it is understandable
  578. 22:05that some think returning to
  579. 22:07traditional values will magically solve
  580. 22:09those problems. Since it used to be
  581. 22:13more common for there to be only one
  582. 22:14breadwinner in the family, some people
  583. 22:16assume that going back to that model
  584. 22:18will also bring back the stability of
  585. 22:20that era. But no, guys, history has
  586. 22:23shown us that things don't work that
  587. 22:25way. In fact, that pattern has repeated
  588. 22:29itself over and over, where every time
  589. 22:31a society undergoes profound changes or
  590. 22:33expands rights for certain groups, an
  591. 22:35opposition appears that promises that
  592. 22:38the solution consists of returning to
  593. 22:40the past. For example, it happened when
  594. 22:43women began to join the labor market en
  595. 22:46masse, when they won the right to vote.
  596. 22:50It occurred during the different waves
  597. 22:52of feminism and happened again after
  598. 22:54World War II, when millions of women
  599. 22:56were pressured to leave the jobs they
  600. 22:58had held during the war and return to
  601. 23:00the home. Actually, I have a video
  602. 23:04where I explain this better, so go
  603. 23:06watch it if you haven't, but yes, in
  604. 23:08short, nostalgia and idealization can
  605. 23:10be dangerous. And I really ask myself,
  606. 23:14why are there people who want to take
  607. 23:16away the rights of others? Just because
  608. 23:19they decide not to exercise those
  609. 23:21rights themselves. I mean, if you don't
  610. 23:24want to work, want to stay home, get
  611. 23:26married young, and have children,
  612. 23:28that's cool. But you cannot turn your
  613. 23:32choice into an obligation for everyone
  614. 23:34else, because rights don't function as
  615. 23:37an imposition, but rather as a
  616. 23:38possibility for those who need them.
  617. 23:42And I think with all that said, we can
  618. 23:44talk about one of the most important
  619. 23:47lessons left by the character of Serena
  620. 23:49Joy: just because you kiss up to people
  621. 23:51in power doesn't mean those people will
  622. 23:53always support you. Because Serena
  623. 23:56thought that by supporting the men who
  624. 23:58built Gilead, she would always be the
  625. 24:00exception. She believed that the
  626. 24:02restrictions would be for other women,
  627. 24:05the feminists, the gender traitors, the
  628. 24:07rebels, those who didn't share her
  629. 24:10worldview, but she discovered too late
  630. 24:12that systems that start by taking away
  631. 24:15rights from others rarely stop there.
  632. 24:18And I think this doesn't just happen
  633. 24:19with women. Throughout history, we have
  634. 24:22seen how vulnerable groups align
  635. 24:23themselves with their oppressors. For
  636. 24:26example, there are people in the LGBT
  637. 24:29community who support homophobic
  638. 24:31rhetoric, racialized people who back
  639. 24:33movements that reproduce racial
  640. 24:35prejudices, or low-income people who
  641. 24:38defend billionaires, believing their
  642. 24:40interests are the same as their own. In
  643. 24:44all cases, the same idea is repeated:
  644. 24:46the belief that if you show enough
  645. 24:48loyalty to the group in power, that
  646. 24:50group will treat you differently. But
  647. 24:54history shows that this almost never
  648. 24:56happens, because those who build
  649. 24:58systems based on exclusion don't
  650. 25:00usually make exceptions out of
  651. 25:02gratitude; instead, when those systems
  652. 25:04need to point to a new enemy, the
  653. 25:06people who once felt protected can also
  654. 25:08become the next target. That is why
  655. 25:11defending the rights of others is also
  656. 25:13a way of defending one's own. And not
  657. 25:16because we are all going to live the
  658. 25:18same experiences, but because we never
  659. 25:20know when we will need those freedoms
  660. 25:22we take for granted today. So, get
  661. 25:26informed, develop critical thinking,
  662. 25:28fight, and don't let the bastards grind
  663. 25:31you down. But anyway, babies, that’s
  664. 25:34it for today’s video. Let’s say
  665. 25:35this was the continuation of the
  666. 25:37previous video. I hope you liked it.
  667. 25:39You know I really like reading your
  668. 25:41opinions. Also, like the video so
  669. 25:43YouTube recommends it and subscribe if
  670. 25:44you want to keep seeing content like
  671. 25:46this. I also remind you that you can
  672. 25:48now become channel members for a cost
  673. 25:50of D per month or 19 Mexican pesos, and
  674. 25:52I'll take this chance to show those who
  675. 25:53are members so far. Honestly, thank you
  676. 25:55very much for all your support for the
  677. 25:57channel, I really appreciate it a lot,
  678. 25:58and if you can't or don't want to be
  679. 26:00members, there's no problem, you
  680. 26:01already support me enough by watching
  681. 26:02my videos, liking, commenting, and
  682. 26:04subscribing. To finish up, I'll leave
  683. 26:05my socials here in case you want to
  684. 26:07follow me, and well, I'll see you in
  685. 26:08another video. Bye. Nolitas de
  686. 26:13bastardos Carbor dorum. Yeah.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of Cuando las MUJERES defienden su propia OPRESIÓN | Las Serena Joy de la VIDA REAL by SuFrida, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 4,407 words across 686 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.