CREMA 101: Does Crema Matter? — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00good morning oh hey can I order a double
- 0:04espresso Absolutely I'll make one right
- 0:06now for you
- 0:17here you go thanks
- 0:25Crema for ants the crema must be at
- 0:28least three times as much
- 0:32foreign
- 0:37[Music]
- 0:53I think this will be the one what's up
- 0:56everyone today we're talking all about
- 0:58Crema Crema for so long has been the
- 1:01signifier of quality in an espresso shot
- 1:04so whether or not a barista is competent
- 1:06whether or not the grind setting is
- 1:07dialed in or whether or not the pressure
- 1:09of specific pressure or temperature was
- 1:11hit Crema in and of itself was what
- 1:14people use in order to understand or
- 1:16assume that a coffee shot was of quality
- 1:18is that relevant today well I did a lot
- 1:22of Deep dive research I actually used
- 1:24quite a few books and academic papers in
- 1:26order to ascertain some information
- 1:27about Crema both Crema formation Crema
- 1:30stabilization sensory aspects of it and
- 1:33surprisingly there's not that much out
- 1:35there Illy did some research both in a
- 1:38book and in a paper which I'll have
- 1:39everything linked Below in the caption
- 1:41on top of that there's a nice article in
- 1:44the craft and science of coffee which I
- 1:45have the book link below as well but
- 1:48outside of these few articles which are
- 1:50kind of repetitive as far as the
- 1:51information that is shared between them
- 1:53there's not much out there on on this so
- 1:56what I want to do today is I just want
- 1:57to take a look at how Crema is formed
- 1:59what we know about the stabilization and
- 2:01formation of Crema how it tastes and
- 2:04then just have an under a kind of a
- 2:06speculation as to what Crema does today
- 2:08what is its place in today's Coffee
- 2:10Culture is it necessary is it one of
- 2:13these signifiers or qualifiers of
- 2:14quality or is it something that we can
- 2:16kind of just toss to the side is Crema
- 2:19important is it really as big of a deal
- 2:21as it's been said to be for over 100
- 2:23years or is it time for a new
- 2:25understanding of Crema so let's jump
- 2:27straight into it so essentially all
- 2:29Crema is is it's an Italian word for
- 2:32espresso foam so it's the foam on top of
- 2:34your espresso scene right here espresso
- 2:37is an incredibly complex beverage more
- 2:39so than any other iteration of coffee
- 2:40preparation what you have is essentially
- 2:43three things going on this is very much
- 2:45boiled down but you have an
- 2:46emulsification of oils now all the oil
- 2:49and espresso about 90 percent of it is
- 2:51sub 10 microns in diameter the bubble of
- 2:54oil the emulsified bubble of oil then
- 2:57you have suspension of solids so of
- 2:59course you have cell wall fragments in
- 3:00different fines that get through
- 3:01typically these bits are two defined
- 3:03microns but they can obviously be bigger
- 3:05than that and then finally we have an
- 3:07effervescence of gases so in order to
- 3:10demonstrate this complexity this
- 3:12tripartite complexity of the solids the
- 3:15gases and the emulsified oils I have my
- 3:19glass of water right here now first what
- 3:21I'm going to do is I'm going to take
- 3:22some oil and essentially we're going to
- 3:24assume that this is the sugars the acids
- 3:26the proteins that are already in the
- 3:28aqueous solution and we're going to add
- 3:30these three things that really separate
- 3:31espresso so we're going to take some oil
- 3:33it's just some olive oil we're going to
- 3:35dump it in there and you're going to see
- 3:36how they kind of blob up right now what
- 3:39I'm going to do is I'm going to emulsify
- 3:40them essentially I'm going to make them
- 3:42into tiny little bubbles throughout the
- 3:44solution just like whenever water is
- 3:47going through the espresso Puck at high
- 3:49pressure it's able to get some of the
- 3:51those oils and it's able to disperse
- 3:53them into these sub 10 Micron little
- 3:55globules okay so I'm going to take my
- 3:57little nanofomer and we're going to
- 3:59emulsify so take a look at this
- 4:08all right emulsification complete
- 4:12nice all right
- 4:15now we have emulsified those oils into
- 4:17tiny little globules probably right at
- 4:1910 microns because I'm that good next
- 4:21what we're going to do is we're going to
- 4:22take a suspension of solids
- 4:25in which case I've got some coffee
- 4:26grounds so I'm going to take some coffee
- 4:28grounds I'm just going to do
- 4:31I'm gonna take those and we're going to
- 4:32suspend it throughout this solution as
- 4:34well we're going to take the nanofomer
- 4:35and we're going to just give it a little
- 4:36mix
- 4:38ooh look at that
- 4:41last we're going to get our
- 4:43effervescence on you know I always have
- 4:46a bottle of this sitting around
- 4:48we're gonna take that we're gonna do
- 4:49that we're gonna do this right here
- 4:54I'm gonna do this right here and now we
- 4:55have effervescence of the gases
- 5:08so that's the visual representation of
- 5:10essentially what espresso is it's a very
- 5:12complex tripartite beverage where you
- 5:15have the emulsified oils you have the
- 5:17suspended solids which can be the fines
- 5:18or the different cell wall fragments and
- 5:20of course you have the effervescent
- 5:22gases inside so all you got to do in
- 5:24order to make this proper espresso is we
- 5:26do a little mixy matchy we're going to
- 5:28take that and
- 5:29we're going to take some of the
- 5:31effervescence and we're gonna
- 5:33oh look at that and then of course now
- 5:36we have our espresso delicious looking
- 5:39it's complex it's got those globules all
- 5:42through it which should give us a really
- 5:44nice texture because of course globules
- 5:46thick Crema that's what matters right
- 5:48yeah
- 5:51delicious
- 5:54all right so Crema here's this here's a
- 5:57definition that I kind of like that
- 5:58that'll help us kind of give a launching
- 6:00off point into uh more specifics about
- 6:02what Crema is espresso foam or Crema in
- 6:04Italian is a biphasic obviously meaning
- 6:07two phases we have gases we have uh
- 6:09liquids biphasic system composed of a
- 6:12gas globules framed within liquid films
- 6:14called lamellae the plural of lamella uh
- 6:17constituted by a water solution of
- 6:19surfactant we're not 100 sure on these
- 6:21surfactants but we know that that's kind
- 6:22of what's holding in place the crema now
- 6:25throughout the sitting process as
- 6:26espresso is sitting there the water
- 6:28leaks out and that's called drainage and
- 6:30this is the initial flattening of that
- 6:32Crema layer so as espresso sits there
- 6:34there is a lot of changes that happen
- 6:36incredibly quickly it starts as a liquid
- 6:38bubbly foam and as it sits it turns into
- 6:41a dry polyhedral foam it's very
- 6:44intriguing as it sits there over time as
- 6:45it dries out and it's just a surfactants
- 6:48kind of holding together that surface
- 6:49area but over time even that dissipates
- 6:52and you have kind of like a crust around
- 6:54the edge of your cup that's incredibly
- 6:56better left of that cell wall fragments
- 6:58and then some of that kind of carbonized
- 7:00type of taste it's kind of gross but I
- 7:03digress what we have with espresso is a
- 7:05quickly fleeting form of beverage that
- 7:07has a lot going on in it and Crema is
- 7:09kind of that topping now what I've thus
- 7:12far neglected to talk about is of course
- 7:14one of the greatest parts of it which is
- 7:16those the gases that fill up the the the
- 7:18the crema itself what gives it that
- 7:20fluffy texture this is the CO2 now I do
- 7:23want to do a brief tangent because I'm
- 7:25sure some of you might be like well
- 7:26that's not proven and you would be
- 7:27correct technically there's not been
- 7:29nearly enough studies the studies are
- 7:31scarce as regards the foam component and
- 7:34espresso now we do have a lot of
- 7:36research as regards the foaming with
- 7:38carbon carbonated foaming like in soft
- 7:41beverages the soft drinks uh beer things
- 7:44like that but when it comes to a coffee
- 7:45we don't have a lot of research at hand
- 7:49and so a lot of this is I guess
- 7:50speculation but there is enough
- 7:52Crossover with these other beverage
- 7:54worlds that we can make a pretty strong
- 7:56assumption that carbon dioxide is indeed
- 7:59what is filling up the crema layer so we
- 8:01have four key events in Crema formation
- 8:04the first thing that we have is the
- 8:06bubble formation which happens with the
- 8:08pressure of that water column going
- 8:10through the puck espresso and arguably
- 8:12those the CO2 coming out and being
- 8:14introduced into our liquid aqueous type
- 8:16solution and we have that lamillae okay
- 8:18so we have the bubble formation and then
- 8:21we have the second thing is the raising
- 8:23of the bubbles and that looks like this
- 8:25right here
- 8:26so kind of like in a Guinness or in a
- 8:28Nitro cold brew you have those bubbles
- 8:29kind of going up to the surface this is
- 8:31a integral step in the process of
- 8:34creating Crema as the criminal layer has
- 8:36stabilized you start to have drainage
- 8:38and this is where the coalescing begins
- 8:41to happen and then eventually you have a
- 8:43collapse of the crema essentially what
- 8:44we have is foam is a coarse dispersion
- 8:46of gas in a liquid continuous phase
- 8:49that's what all of these that steps one
- 8:51through four that's kind of what it
- 8:52coalesces into is this idea of a coarsus
- 8:55version of gases and that's why we have
- 8:57that foam layer of course we have other
- 8:59things in it as I said the Oculus
- 9:01solution which includes the acids and
- 9:02the the fats the proteins all that good
- 9:04stuff we have the cell wall fragments
- 9:07that are scattered about we have the
- 9:08surfactants and the lamellae it's very
- 9:10convoluted very complex and again that's
- 9:13why we can do a longer video but for now
- 9:15just know that it does not mean you have
- 9:19a good shot does not mean you have a bad
- 9:20shot if you have the presence or no
- 9:22presence of Crema it is completely
- 9:24person to person I think it's a little
- 9:26silly that in the world Barista
- 9:28Championship there's still a point for
- 9:30whether or not someone has Crema on
- 9:32their espresso meaning there should be
- 9:33no hole no shallow area where there is
- 9:36Crema now there of course in the
- 9:38stabilization of the crema you want to
- 9:40time and see how long it takes until you
- 9:42see a weakening of the crema and then
- 9:44for persistence the way that you you
- 9:45check that you could you can take a
- 9:47scoop of sugar and put it on top and see
- 9:49how long it can hold the sugar Until It
- 9:51Breaks through but again this is more of
- 9:53a traditional way of understanding Crema
- 9:55this is understanding it based off of a
- 9:57nine bar shot I want to take one final
- 9:59tangent before we we close here now when
- 10:02people talk about traditional espresso
- 10:03they always go back to the nine bar shot
- 10:06but I have a little shocker for you the
- 10:08nine bar shot is not traditional it's
- 10:11not the traditional espresso was made
- 10:13with steam pressure rising up to one or
- 10:15one a half bar back in the early 1800s
- 10:17it was only patented in the late 1800s
- 10:20but we have more than ample precedence
- 10:22of the fact that things were going on as
- 10:23far as espresso creation prior to the
- 10:25patent by moriondo in the late 1800s and
- 10:28then of course in the early 1900s
- 10:30there's a little bit more efficiency
- 10:31steam starts coming along and we get a
- 10:34little bit just a little bit better
- 10:35espresso but in reality it's sub to bar
- 10:37of pressure but then we had espresso
- 10:39savior gaja come through in 1948
- 10:41patenting the lever machine which
- 10:43allowed us to create nine bar of
- 10:45pressure this when we first really
- 10:46started to get stabilized foam on top
- 10:49and this is where espresso has changed
- 10:51forever but over a hundred years we had
- 10:53already been creating espresso we've
- 10:55been creating a concentrated beverage
- 10:56and it it took a big change in 1948 so
- 11:00at that time that was not traditional
- 11:01espresso somehow over the years it has
- 11:03turned the definition has turned and
- 11:05tradition is now going back to 1948
- 11:07forgetting the years before that that's
- 11:10not a bad thing but all this study that
- 11:12has been done is always assuming nine
- 11:14bar shots it's assuming specific styles
- 11:17of espresso it's assuming certain roast
- 11:20profiles it's assuming certain thickness
- 11:22of cremas and in the early studies
- 11:24there's even an assumed density of the
- 11:26of the Crema which is 0.2 to 0.4 I
- 11:29believe grams per milliliter which is an
- 11:32assumption that doesn't necessarily hold
- 11:34true to all forms of coffee all forms of
- 11:37espresso as we talk about in this recent
- 11:39video I linked right here which includes
- 11:41a turbo shot a spro over in all these
- 11:43different ways of making espresso or
- 11:45coffee from an espresso machine so just
- 11:47keep in mind Crema is something that we
- 11:50still have a lot of work to do on and
- 11:51the science Community especially there's
- 11:53a lot more research to be done on
- 11:55espresso specific foam all we know right
- 11:59now is this much and there's this much
- 12:01to be known or or even more so there's a
- 12:04lot of work to be done so keep that in
- 12:05mind what I'm saying here may not age
- 12:07very well there may be a huge
- 12:09breakthrough in a year after the posting
- 12:11of this video so take that into account
- 12:12if you're seeing this in past 2022 okay
- 12:15to conclude I'm going to end with a
- 12:18definition I really like of Crema by
- 12:19Dickinson which is Crema is a metastable
- 12:22foam with a specific lifespan it is
- 12:25effervescent like gaset it comes and
- 12:27goes goes quickly and it is something
- 12:29that can be enjoyed greatly but having a
- 12:32dogmatic understanding of Crema I think
- 12:33is where a mistake has been made and I
- 12:35think we need to loosen up that
- 12:37understanding and know that coffee can
- 12:39be great without any Crema with a lot of
- 12:40Crema with some Crema with whatever that
- 12:43was scraped off Crema
- 12:45give it a try have your own anecdotal
- 12:47experiences try everything essentially
- 12:50is what I'm getting at there's been so
- 12:52much push for a specific style of
- 12:54espresso for so long and it is time now
- 12:56to kind of subvert that and go back to
- 12:58the roots of playing around we have the
- 13:00steam pressure one and a half bar and it
- 13:02went to nine bar and then we had the
- 13:03flat 9 bar but before that we had a
- 13:05descending pressure so obviously there
- 13:07is a loose definition a fluid definition
- 13:09of what espresso actually is we don't
- 13:11need to be dogmatic about any of it so
- 13:13go have fun try light coffees dark
- 13:15coffees don't worry about the crema if
- 13:17you love Crema all you need to know is
- 13:19get a really Darkly roasted coffee also
- 13:21there is no proof that conifera has more
- 13:23inherent Crema formation than arabicus
- 13:26so don't be stuck in just getting
- 13:27Robusta you can play around make Crema
- 13:30on whatever you want just know dark
- 13:32roast fresh coffee is going to give you
- 13:34the most Crema so if that's what you're
- 13:35looking for there you go otherwise don't
- 13:38worry about it there's not even any
- 13:39proof sincerely that it it elevates the
- 13:42the coffee a lot of that is again
- 13:44anecdotal and is experienced person to
- 13:46person as shown in the panel that I
- 13:49linked below anyway that's a lot again
- 13:51if you want more let me know I can do a
- 13:53lot more of an in-depth course on it
- 13:55kind of like some of my old espresso
- 13:56tutorial videos otherwise again hit that
- 13:59like that subscribe if you enjoyed the
- 14:00content hit the Bell notifications for
- 14:02whenever I post videos check out my
- 14:04patreon it helps me a lot to do uh to
- 14:06create better content
- 14:08anyway
- 14:10thank you so much for watching I hope
- 14:12you brew something tasty and cheers
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of CREMA 101: Does Crema Matter? by Lance Hedrick, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 2,690 words across 378 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.