COP 31 Interactive negotiation lab — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:58Where do we
- 0:59sit? Here?
- 1:01>> Dear delegates, may I ask you to kindly
- 1:03leave the room so we can start the next
- 1:06event? Thank you very much.
- 3:11>> Hello delegates.
- 3:14The next meeting is about to start.
- 3:19We kindly ask you to leave the room if
- 3:21you are not
- 3:22joining this meeting. Thank you.
- 5:33>> When the technician come I'm going to
- 5:35just tell him to turn it on. Yes.
- 6:05>> Ah ah uno due.
- 10:58>> Okay.
- 13:01>> Okay.
- 15:58>> Ladies and gentlemen, we are
- 16:01waiting a couple of minute more for our
- 16:03participant to join, hopefully, and then
- 16:06we will start our training session.
- 16:08Thank you for your patience.
- 18:15>> It is.
- 18:50>> A warm welcome to everybody. We are
- 18:53ready to start our training session. So
- 18:55welcome to the COP 31 interactive
- 18:59negotiation lab,
- 19:01a side event of the capacity building
- 19:03for negotiator initiative and over the
- 19:08We won't just talk about how the
- 19:11negotiation works.
- 19:13You watch one happen.
- 19:15The objective is not to
- 19:19test what you know,
- 19:21but it's to give you a practical feel or
- 19:23how the process work, understand it,
- 19:26experience it and reflect on it. And
- 19:30without
- 19:31further ado, I would like to pass the
- 19:33floor to Cecilia, our director of the
- 19:37ISEP division that will deliver opening
- 19:40remarks. Thank you very much, Cecilia.
- 19:43>> Thank you very much, Andrea. Good
- 19:45morning and welcome to the capacity
- 19:48building for negotiators, the CB4N
- 19:51interactive negotiation lab.
- 19:53Thank you for making the time to join us
- 19:55during this transition week from week
- 19:57one to week two of the COP. And this is
- 20:00where we are transitioning from the
- 20:02technical phase where the negotiators
- 20:04have been engaging to the political
- 20:06phase where the ministers are arriving
- 20:08and will start taking decisions.
- 20:11At SB 162, parties requested the
- 20:14secretariat to support delegates, in
- 20:16particular young and emerging
- 20:18negotiators in building their capacity
- 20:21to engage in negotiations. The CB 4 N
- 20:24was established in response and reflects
- 20:27our commitments to providing more
- 20:29targeted and practical support to
- 20:31negotiators, particularly from
- 20:33developing countries.
- 20:35Looking ahead, we aim to develop and
- 20:37expand the initiative through regional
- 20:40deployment via the regional
- 20:42collaboration centers.
- 20:44And this will bring capacity closer to
- 20:45countries, allowing us to better
- 20:48understand their specific circumstances
- 20:51and tailor our support to national and
- 20:53regional needs and priorities.
- 20:56So this lab today follows a pilot
- 20:58training in Nairobi in September 2025
- 21:02and this year's webinar series leading
- 21:04up to COP 31.
- 21:06Today you will get to test our knowledge
- 21:09the knowledge yourselves.
- 21:11As our executive secretary said at the
- 21:13launch, inclusive, effective climate
- 21:15negotiations depend on people,
- 21:19on your knowledge, your preparation and
- 21:21confidence to engage meaningfully and
- 21:23constructively.
- 21:25Confidence is hard to gain from reading
- 21:28alone.
- 21:29So today will be a learning by doing
- 21:32experience. You will step into a
- 21:35fictional negotiation
- 21:37and those in negotiating roles will work
- 21:39from a text and role cards and everyone
- 21:42will follow how the language changes
- 21:45from one draft, from one iteration to
- 21:48the next.
- 21:49You will see how informal consultations
- 21:51unfold,
- 21:52how groups take the floor
- 21:54and how compromise is made and found.
- 21:58The exercise is simplified, but the
- 22:00skills are real.
- 22:02Listening,
- 22:03coalition building and finding common
- 22:06ground.
- 22:07We are also at a transition point in the
- 22:10session as I mentioned before.
- 22:12The subsidiary bodies will be wrapping
- 22:14up their work this evening
- 22:17and the COP will be resuming and opening
- 22:20their face for the political face this
- 22:23evening. And next week the process will
- 22:25move to that political level I mentioned
- 22:28where the ministers will really take a
- 22:31leading role.
- 22:32It's a good moment to see how the whole
- 22:34process fits together.
- 22:36To our young and emerging negotiators,
- 22:39thank you for being here.
- 22:41Thanks also to the colleagues and
- 22:42facilitators who prepared this lab.
- 22:46The program is full and exciting, so I
- 22:48will finish here
- 22:50and wish you a very productive learning
- 22:52session and I thank you.
- 23:00>> Thank you very much Cecilia for your
- 23:01opening remarks, for framing our work
- 23:04today, for setting the scene what will
- 23:06be our simulation
- 23:08and let me briefly
- 23:11let me introduce myself Andrea
- 23:13Camponogara, I'm the RCC global
- 23:15coordinator of
- 23:18well I'm the global coordinator of the
- 23:19six regional collaboration centers of
- 23:21the secretariat. I will be your
- 23:23moderator today, so I will guide you
- 23:25through the various
- 23:28session of this training. We have with
- 23:30me
- 23:31several colleagues from the secretariat
- 23:33that will help unpacking the complexity
- 23:36of the of the process.
- 23:39What are we going to do today is to
- 23:44elaborate and to experience
- 23:46three main elements of the negotiation
- 23:48process. So we will have introduction
- 23:51procedural briefing, we will look at the
- 23:53rules, the roles of the various people
- 23:56sitting around the table.
- 23:58We will talk about how to take in the
- 24:00floor, negotiating the text, we will
- 24:02simulate the negotiation, so we have
- 24:04three round of negotiation
- 24:06with
- 24:07short pauses between one round at the
- 24:09hour so to give the possibility to you
- 24:11to make question and to our expert
- 24:13colleagues also to elaborate and deep
- 24:16dive in each of the different element of
- 24:19the negotiation. At the end we will have
- 24:23a huddle, so an attempt to arrive to a
- 24:26compromise and agreed text. We will
- 24:28discuss on are the possible outcomes of
- 24:30a negotiation and we will have all
- 24:32together a debrief. As
- 24:35introduced by anticipated by Cecilia is
- 24:39a simulation, is a test. So please
- 24:42make this environment as informal as you
- 24:45can, as a friendly simulation. So feel
- 24:49free to make any question, don't be shy
- 24:52as an learning opportunity and
- 24:57make it also
- 25:00informative for us because as
- 25:02we said we will continue providing this
- 25:06type of training to parties. It's
- 25:07important to receive your feedback and
- 25:09understand how to improve this type of
- 25:12training.
- 25:15Quick
- 25:16introduction who are the players of the
- 25:17simulation. I have already introduced
- 25:19the facilitators, our colleague
- 25:22who
- 25:23This is actually also in term of layout
- 25:26of the room
- 25:28a real setting of a negotiation.
- 25:30We will have at the head of the table
- 25:32the co-facilitator. We will explain
- 25:34later on who who they are and what is
- 25:37their role supported by the secretariat
- 25:40and negotiation group around the table.
- 25:43So for the simulation we have identified
- 25:47VLDC, G77 in China and the European
- 25:50Union. We also have observer because
- 25:52observer also participate and attend the
- 25:55negotiation. We will
- 25:58explain later on what is their role,
- 25:59what is the opportunity to take the
- 26:01floor.
- 26:10And we have some audience participant
- 26:14which are not active participants, but
- 26:16please feel free to contribute to the
- 26:19discussion session, make your question
- 26:22as
- 26:23and
- 26:24make this exercise meaningful as as
- 26:28yeah meaningful, whatever.
- 26:30Before
- 26:32starting we would to know who you are,
- 26:34where you are from, [snorts]
- 26:35what is your seniority in the
- 26:37negotiation process. It's important for
- 26:39us, as I said also,
- 26:41to plan better the next future
- 26:44interaction. So, please scan the
- 26:47Mentimeter QR code.
- 26:49You will have before you a couple of
- 26:52questions, so it won't take too much.
- 26:55So,
- 26:56which country are you representing at
- 26:58COP 31?
- 27:02Okay.
- 27:03So, we have Central Asia,
- 27:05Switzerland, Europe,
- 27:09El Salvador, and we are in Latin
- 27:11America, North Africa.
- 27:16Asia coming in. Very good. So, we have a
- 27:19good representation of
- 27:21negotiation group that usually sit in
- 27:24the
- 27:25in the rooms.
- 27:27Nepal,
- 27:28very good.
- 27:31Okay.
- 27:32This is great. Great representation of
- 27:34Libya, apparently, given the size of
- 27:37of the word on the screen. Jamaica,
- 27:40thank you for coming.
- 27:43Okay.
- 27:44Dominican Republic, very good. Guinea
- 27:48Equatorial,
- 27:51okay.
- 27:56We're waiting three more respondent.
- 28:03Okay. Maybe we can move to the next one.
- 28:07Have you ever participated in climate
- 28:09negotiation?
- 28:13That's the second question.
- 28:18Not yet. So, the majority has not yet
- 28:23negotiated participated in negotiation
- 28:25or is the first time. This is very good
- 28:27because that's
- 28:29our
- 28:30primary target for this negotiation
- 28:32training. A couple, yes, is a party
- 28:34negotiator.
- 28:36Our our member of a delegation,
- 28:39but not yet a negotiator.
- 28:44Okay.
- 28:45This is nice, but majority doesn't have
- 28:47much experience with negotiation.
- 28:49So,
- 28:52thank you very much. We can move to the
- 28:54next slide.
- 29:03And now, before starting the simulation,
- 29:05we have a technical introduction to the
- 29:08overall process.
- 29:09And for that, I will pass the floor to
- 29:13my friends and colleagues Laurence.
- 29:16And she will
- 29:18frame the overall process, explain
- 29:23about
- 29:24what is a plenaries, what are the
- 29:26negotiation room, informal consultation
- 29:28and bilaterals. You can take the floor
- 29:30from your seat if you want or if you
- 29:32prefer.
- 29:34>> Thanks Andrea.
- 29:36And welcome everybody. My name is
- 29:38Laurence Folliot. I'm an instructor at
- 29:40the session, but I've worked some 30
- 29:44years with the secretariat. I retired
- 29:46two years ago.
- 29:48And my last role in the secretariat was
- 29:51SBI coordinator. So, I worked a lot on
- 29:54this process.
- 29:55And today, I'm going to try to explain
- 29:57you
- 29:58a few notions of of this process, which
- 30:02is a complex one you may have already
- 30:04noticed. So,
- 30:06we start with the different type of
- 30:08meetings. I guess on Monday you were all
- 30:13if you were already in the premises at
- 30:15the opening
- 30:17at the opening plenary of the COP, the
- 30:19CMA, the CMP, the SBI and the SBSTA. So,
- 30:23all five bodies meeting here in Antalya
- 30:28were opening their work at this opening
- 30:30plenaries.
- 30:32Those plenaries are open to all
- 30:35participants
- 30:36um and it's webcast. It's completely
- 30:40public then and they are facilitated by
- 30:43the president for the governing bodies.
- 30:46So the governing bodies, the COP, CMN,
- 30:48CMP and they are facilitated by the SB
- 30:51chairs, the Substa chair, Adonia, and
- 30:54the SBI chair, Julia. I'm sorry, I don't
- 30:56remember the last name.
- 30:58Um so but we'll speak more about
- 31:00facilitator later. Um so they are the
- 31:04ones facilitating their Substa and their
- 31:06SBI.
- 31:08And at the opening, after the governing
- 31:12bodies and the SBs adopted their
- 31:14agendas, they launched work. So what
- 31:17does it mean to launch work? They turn
- 31:19to each and every item on the agenda and
- 31:23decided on how work would be conducted
- 31:26for those items.
- 31:28So sometime they establish
- 31:30informal consultations that you see here
- 31:33on the
- 31:35on the screen. Actually, I don't have my
- 31:37my glasses, so I don't see well what's
- 31:39written on the screen, but they
- 31:40establish either informal consultations
- 31:43that would be co-facilitated by
- 31:45co-facilitators.
- 31:47Um and they also establish contact
- 31:50groups that are co-chairs.
- 31:53Um and sometimes they just take note of
- 31:56the information that was provided under
- 31:59those items.
- 32:01So
- 32:02once the work is launched,
- 32:04the the negotiators, they move in
- 32:06smaller rooms like this one, which is
- 32:09one of the favorite setup for
- 32:11negotiations, the square room where
- 32:13parties can see each other and can
- 32:16exchange their views. Um so that's
- 32:18that's about the setup of of an informal
- 32:21consultation or a contact group.
- 32:24Um
- 32:27yeah, the difference between a contact
- 32:28group and an informal consultations um
- 32:32it's it's a very subtle difference
- 32:34because actually contact group and
- 32:37informal consultations, they are both
- 32:39formal. It's not me who gave this name
- 32:41of informal consultation to be formal,
- 32:43but they are formal. are formal in the
- 32:46process. Um, but informal consultation,
- 32:50they can they can be closed to
- 32:52observers,
- 32:53uh, whereas contact group they are
- 32:55always open.
- 32:56In our process because you know we have
- 32:59principle of transparency,
- 33:00inclusiveness,
- 33:02uh,
- 33:03most informal consultations are open to
- 33:06all, uh, participants, not the media,
- 33:09but observers and parties alike.
- 33:12And those two, um, they have the same
- 33:15mandate to produce text that will be
- 33:18adopted at the end in a plenary because
- 33:21all the work that is being done in those
- 33:23smaller, uh, um,
- 33:25rooms, they have to go back for
- 33:28transparency to the bigger room, to the
- 33:30plenary where the conclusions of the
- 33:33SB's will be adopted, their
- 33:35recommendation for a draft decision will
- 33:38be forwarded to the governing bodies and
- 33:40the governing bodies they will adopt
- 33:42decisions and conclusions.
- 33:46Um, the bilats that you see or or, uh,
- 33:50we have also, um, less formal meetings,
- 33:53so informal meetings, uh,
- 33:56that are not being established by, uh,
- 33:59the bodies themselves, but that but that
- 34:02are being convened by the presiding
- 34:05officers. So, um, bilateral meetings,
- 34:09um,
- 34:10friends of the chairs, informal
- 34:11informal, it's all um, meetings that are
- 34:14used to unlock difficult situations
- 34:18where consensus cannot be reached in a
- 34:21in a in a in a formal meetings like the
- 34:24one where we are today.
- 34:26We are staging an informal consultation
- 34:28here. So when when they cannot come to
- 34:31an agreement in those rooms, sometime it
- 34:33helps to go in a even smaller room or to
- 34:35have bilats to try to unlock a difficult
- 34:39situation. But the same applies,
- 34:42whatever is been agreed in those smaller
- 34:44setup, they have to go back first to the
- 34:47informal consultation and contact group
- 34:50to be
- 34:52heard and and agreed by this bigger
- 34:54group and then
- 34:56to the plenary to be adopted.
- 34:59>> Can I ask
- 35:01>> please.
- 35:02>> Thanks for the answer. No, I only would
- 35:04like to add that
- 35:06okay, I can introduce myself.
- 35:08I'm Gianluca Crispi and I'm a legal
- 35:10officer in the Legal Affairs Division of
- 35:13the Secretariat.
- 35:15So I will make a comment related to the
- 35:17application of the rules of procedure.
- 35:19So the
- 35:21the the COP
- 35:23was requested at COP one to adopt by
- 35:27consensus its rules of procedure. The
- 35:30COP has never been able to do so, but
- 35:33has decided to provisionally apply at
- 35:35every session the rules of procedures
- 35:37with the exception of rule 42, which is
- 35:39the rule on voting.
- 35:42So there are rules of procedure as
- 35:44applied
- 35:45and they are still in a draft form.
- 35:48The rules of procedure apply strictly
- 35:50for plenary meetings of the governing
- 35:53and subsidiary bodies.
- 35:55They don't apply directly to negotiation
- 35:58to
- 35:59to contact groups and informal
- 36:00consultations, but their spirit of
- 36:03transparency, procedural equity and
- 36:05inclusivity do
- 36:07apply also in in those smaller settings.
- 36:11So while for for plenary meetings there
- 36:13are rules on quorum, so a meeting can be
- 36:16open only if a third of the parties
- 36:18present and a plenary can take decision
- 36:21if
- 36:22two thirds of parties are present in the
- 36:25room for smaller negotiations
- 36:29contact groups and informal
- 36:30consultation,
- 36:32it is important that that there is
- 36:34an equitable representation
- 36:37so that the
- 36:38the chairs of the main negotiating
- 36:41groups are in the room.
- 36:43Same for order of speakers. The general
- 36:47practice in the negotiation is that in
- 36:50the order of of of a raising the flag,
- 36:54but groups can also agree on different
- 36:56approaches.
- 36:58Same for point of orders in the plenary
- 37:00room
- 37:03the rules apply strictly in in the
- 37:06consultations. Parties can raise issues
- 37:09of process, but they're not
- 37:12formally considered as as a point of
- 37:14order like in plenaries.
- 37:19>> Thank you.
- 37:21Yes, the the rules of procedures, the
- 37:23draft rules of procedures are they are
- 37:25applied, they are they are the
- 37:27the rules of the game, right?
- 37:30And they have to be followed by all.
- 37:33Now
- 37:35just
- 37:36a little slide to explain how we go from
- 37:40what you hear in the plenary at the
- 37:42opening, those intervention of the
- 37:44groups and parties to the text that are
- 37:47being adopted at the closing.
- 37:50So the as I as I explained you after the
- 37:52opening, they move in smaller setup like
- 37:55contact group or informal consultations
- 37:57where usually at the first meeting again
- 38:00parties and groups they they take the
- 38:03floor to
- 38:05to express express their position on the
- 38:09the issue that is being considered.
- 38:12The co-facilitators that are sitting
- 38:13over there
- 38:15with the help of the secretary, they
- 38:16capture all those interventions
- 38:19after the meeting and they try to put on
- 38:22paper everything that has been said and
- 38:24categorize them
- 38:26according to the topic that was raised.
- 38:29At that stage, of course parties have
- 38:32different positions, so
- 38:35the text is is really like a list, a
- 38:38wish list or a list of options.
- 38:42So the the work of the co-facilitators
- 38:44is very important at that moment
- 38:47um they have to put on paper
- 38:50those options without really forgetting
- 38:52anybody.
- 38:53Everyone who expressed their views, they
- 38:55have to feel that they were listened to
- 38:58and that their what they said matter. Um
- 39:01so they have to capture this and and
- 39:03synthesize this in such a way that
- 39:07when the parties they read um this text
- 39:09after they feel like yes they listen to
- 39:12me. It doesn't mean that it will be
- 39:13captured in the in the final text but at
- 39:15least uh everything uh every voice was
- 39:19heard.
- 39:20So that was the the first meeting. The
- 39:22second meeting it may be that they
- 39:24already uh
- 39:26add a mandate or an agreement from
- 39:28parties to
- 39:30work effectively on a draft text and and
- 39:33uh so they will go from this option
- 39:35paper
- 39:36um to drafting paragraphs.
- 39:40So it will look more like uh a a a a
- 39:43decision or conclusion. Uh we will go uh
- 39:46we will see uh what it looks like later
- 39:49um but with language, with this very
- 39:52specific negotiating language of uh of
- 39:56uh uh um
- 39:58yeah phrasing um the the conclusion of
- 40:00the decisions.
- 40:01Um but because it's still being
- 40:03negotiated, the text that you will see
- 40:06that is stable in those negotiating room
- 40:08um it looks like uh that there are
- 40:10brackets, there are still options. So
- 40:13it's not clean. In our jargon we said um
- 40:16the draft text is not clean. And until
- 40:19all the brackets are being removed and
- 40:21all the options are being uh uh you know
- 40:24selected let's say um nothing is agreed.
- 40:27As we say nothing is agreed until
- 40:29everything is agreed.
- 40:30Um so that's the work of this
- 40:33negotiating group plus the uh
- 40:35co-facilitators to work towards uh a
- 40:38text that would be agreeable to all.
- 40:42Yeah.
- 40:45So now I give back to Andrea.
- 40:48>> Thank you very much. Few words on the
- 40:50code of contact. The process introduce a
- 40:52code of contact that participants sign
- 40:54off at the time of registration. So by
- 40:57that
- 40:58they commit to treat each other with
- 41:00respect and dignity.
- 41:02They commit to maintain a respectful and
- 41:05safe environment during the negotiation.
- 41:08The code of conduct set zero tolerance
- 41:10for harassment including sexual
- 41:12harassment and discrimination.
- 41:15It also set
- 41:17provision for a procedure for events and
- 41:21negotiation itself, how
- 41:24the possibility to take picture, video
- 41:26during negotiation and also a a process
- 41:29for reporting harassment that has been
- 41:32witnessed during the negotiation. Just
- 41:35an introduction, we don't spend more
- 41:37word on that but you can have the full
- 41:39text of the code of contact by scanning
- 41:40the QR code.
- 41:43And so you also commit
- 41:46to treat each
- 41:47each other during this simulation with
- 41:50respect and and dignity even if you
- 41:52didn't sign off for this simulation.
- 41:56So what are we going to do today during
- 41:59our simulation? What is the case that we
- 42:01have before us?
- 42:03You are negotiating a text on national
- 42:06adaptation plan. So you are considering
- 42:09a draft decision on the formulation and
- 42:13implementation of the NAPs.
- 42:15You have already for initially
- 42:17exchanged views on the draft text on on
- 42:21the issue so you have informed the
- 42:23co-facilitator about your position and
- 42:25the co-facilitator produce a first
- 42:28iteration of the text which is the one
- 42:30you will be
- 42:31considering today.
- 42:33The what are the areas of disagreement?
- 42:36The text is not yet agreed. It's just
- 42:38the first time that you are seeing it
- 42:40and you have identified within your
- 42:42negotiation group something that you
- 42:44don't like or something which is not
- 42:46well worded or something that you would
- 42:48like to elaborate in a different way.
- 42:51What are the key areas of disagreement?
- 42:53So progress, how should progress on NAPs
- 42:55and
- 42:56remaining limitation be described in the
- 42:58text?
- 42:59There is issue about the access to
- 43:01support. How strongly should the text
- 43:03express concern about the access to
- 43:07finance, technology transfer and
- 43:08capacity building? There is issue the
- 43:11adequacy of the funding made available
- 43:14for the formulation and implementation
- 43:16of [clears throat]
- 43:18NAPs.
- 43:19Should be the finding described in the
- 43:21text as inadequate or maybe with lighter
- 43:25wording just not yet fully meeting
- 43:28needs?
- 43:29And there is also disagreement on the
- 43:32financial gap. So should be the gap in
- 43:35the text described as significant or
- 43:38just addresses a barrier to effective
- 43:41and timely implementation. So this is
- 43:43what you will be discussing during this
- 43:46simulation.
- 43:50There is no limit
- 43:52to the number of consultation you may
- 43:55have during the the COP, but usually
- 44:00first
- 44:07Yeah, exactly. I was about to come to
- 44:09that.
- 44:10The limit is imposed by of course the
- 44:12availability of room, by the time that
- 44:15you have available. So
- 44:17let's say that practice to have on
- 44:19average four informal consultation per
- 44:22agenda agenda item during week one.
- 44:25And this is where we are. We are now
- 44:27during the informal first informal
- 44:29consultation usually the co-facilitator
- 44:32requests parties to express view on the
- 44:35on the matter. They take note with the
- 44:37support of the secretariat of the view
- 44:40expressed by parties and if parties
- 44:43mandate
- 44:45may request the co-facilitator based on
- 44:47the view expressed to prepare a first
- 44:50draft of the text.
- 44:52With that which is stable to the second
- 44:55informal consultation, and during the
- 44:58second informal consultation, which is
- 45:00where we start our simulation today,
- 45:03the parties have seen the text and are
- 45:06called by the co-facilitator to express
- 45:09view on the text.
- 45:11And the process go on and on on more or
- 45:14less with the same cycle. Second
- 45:17consultation, the co-facilitator
- 45:19based on the view expressed by parties
- 45:22will revise the text, attempted to
- 45:25capture better what they have what they
- 45:28want to see in the draft decision. The
- 45:31text is then finally revised with the
- 45:32support of the secretariat made public
- 45:35on the
- 45:36on the system.
- 45:38And we move to the third consultation
- 45:40where again the party will consider the
- 45:43text, make
- 45:45additional statement, exchange
- 45:47additional view on on the text and so on
- 45:51and so forth. We move to the last one
- 45:53which is the fourth informal
- 45:55consultation which is supposed to arrive
- 45:57to an agreed test. What happen if there
- 46:00is no agreement we will see later on in
- 46:03in the simulation. So today we start
- 46:05from with the first round of simulation
- 46:08from the
- 46:10informal a second informal consultation.
- 46:14On the screen you can see a very
- 46:16simplified condensed test. So just for
- 46:19this simulation the test is usually more
- 46:21complex, more elaborated. It contain
- 46:25more paragraph, but just to give you a
- 46:27structure structure usually the test
- 46:30stuck with a preambular paragraph which
- 46:33is meant to set the scene, to frame the
- 46:36the decision, also recalling previous
- 46:38decisions which are relevant to what you
- 46:41are discussing today.
- 46:42[snorts] And we have identified for this
- 46:45simulation
- 46:46based also on what are the area of
- 46:48disagreement free paragraph
- 46:50that whose word whose wording and
- 46:53language has not been agreed yet and so
- 46:55is still under discussion. Paragraph
- 46:57one, which is on progress,
- 46:59paragraph two, which is on access to
- 47:00support, and then a third paragraph
- 47:03which is on finance and the financial
- 47:06gap.
- 47:08We stop here for a while. We have
- 47:10already provided you a lot of
- 47:12information. We know that the process is
- 47:14complex but
- 47:17is your time now to make question
- 47:20on any of the element that has been
- 47:22introduced that you would like to
- 47:24clarify or not.
- 47:26Over to you.
- 47:28If [snorts] you have any question, yeah,
- 47:30please go ahead.
- 47:35Just just to We didn't start yet our
- 47:38simulation. So this is just a time for
- 47:41asking question on what has been
- 47:42introduced and please.
- 47:45>> Thank you very much.
- 47:47The first things is not a question. Let
- 47:49me say it maybe asking if they if you
- 47:51can send us the presentations, okay?
- 47:54And the second point
- 47:57just to clarify
- 48:02usually who is will take the Let me say
- 48:05it
- 48:06the speech before the first one who will
- 48:08take the the floor after the
- 48:11co-facilitator open the floor.
- 48:15>> Great question. Thank you very much. We
- 48:17will address it later because we will We
- 48:20will have a slide dedicated to the order
- 48:22of
- 48:23speak.
- 48:24So but this is absolutely a good
- 48:26question. Any other question?
- 48:31Everything clear so far? Fantastic then.
- 48:35[snorts] One disclaimer
- 48:37just about this simulation. Any
- 48:39resemblance to actual person or actual
- 48:42events is purely coincidental. So this
- 48:45simulation is not related whatsoever to
- 48:48what is happening in the negotiation
- 48:50room at COP 31
- 48:52just to make it clear.
- 48:54And also [snorts] the text has no
- 48:55connection whatsoever
- 48:57whatsoever which is now negotiating on
- 49:00adaptation. So it's just a pure
- 49:02fictional text to help you with a
- 49:05simulation. And now is simulation time.
- 49:08So
- 49:09we start with that and
- 49:13we will use during
- 49:15after the simulation this
- 49:18buzzer
- 49:20which is not really loud
- 49:24but just to freeze the simulation and
- 49:26introduce element that you are
- 49:30experiencing and clarify and provide
- 49:34a bit more of deep dive description. But
- 49:37with that I will stop and I will hand it
- 49:39over to our co-facilitator and enjoy the
- 49:42first round of the
- 49:44negotiation.
- 49:52>> Good morning colleagues.
- 49:54The informal consultation is now open
- 49:57and as you know
- 49:59as you know parties have already had
- 50:03an initial exchange of views on the
- 50:06on this issue. We will now continue our
- 50:09discussion focusing on the key element
- 50:13relating to progress on national
- 50:15adaptation plans,
- 50:17access to support and adequacy of
- 50:21finance for the formulation and
- 50:23implementation.
- 50:25I would like to invite negotiation
- 50:28groups to take the floor in turns
- 50:32and present their priorities
- 50:35con concerns and any initial suggestions
- 50:38for how this issues could be reflected
- 50:43in the negotiation text.
- 50:47We will hear from all the five groups
- 50:50before taking stock of the discussion
- 50:53and identify the main areas where
- 50:57further work is needed.
- 51:05>> I invite G77 and China to take the
- 51:08floor, followed by the other negotiation
- 51:11groups. Thank you.
- 51:29>> Uh thank you thank you co-facilitators.
- 51:32I have the honor on behalf I have the
- 51:35honor to speak on behalf of the group of
- 51:3777 and China.
- 51:40Uh we acknowledge the important progress
- 51:42made by developing country parties in
- 51:44the formulation and implementation of
- 51:47national adaptation plans. However, we
- 51:50wish to emphasize that this progress
- 51:52should not obscure the significant
- 51:55challenges that developing countries
- 51:57continue to face in translating
- 52:00adaptation planning into effective
- 52:02action.
- 52:03In particular, access to adequate,
- 52:06predictable, and accessible finance,
- 52:09technology transfer, and capacity
- 52:11building remains essential for the
- 52:13successful implementation of NAPs.
- 52:17We believe that the decision must
- 52:19explicitly recognize that the current
- 52:21funding remains inadequate and that a
- 52:23significant financial gap continues to
- 52:26impede effective and timely
- 52:28implementation. We also emphasize that
- 52:31overcoming these challenges cannot be
- 52:33treated as the responsibility of
- 52:35developing countries alone.
- 52:37International support remains
- 52:39indispensable to enabling developing
- 52:42countries to implement their adaptation
- 52:44priorities. We therefore encourage
- 52:47parties to work towards balanced and
- 52:50concise language that recognizes
- 52:52progress while clearly reflecting the
- 52:55persistent implementation barriers and
- 52:57support needs of developing countries.
- 53:00Thank you.
- 53:11>> Thank you, G7 for your intervention.
- 53:15Please any other group that has an
- 53:17intervention can
- 53:19raise their flag and then I'll call them
- 53:21to take the floor.
- 53:37AOSIS, you have the floor.
- 53:43>> Thank you, co-facilitator.
- 53:44I speak on behalf of the Alliance of
- 53:46Small Island States.
- 53:48[snorts] We welcome the progress made in
- 53:51formulation and implementation national
- 53:53adaptation plan.
- 53:55But the progress
- 53:57successful implementation for many of
- 54:00our country, completing a plan is the
- 54:03beginning of the work, not the end of
- 54:05it.
- 54:06Small Island Development State face
- 54:08acute adaptation challenge.
- 54:10We are on the front line of the sea
- 54:13level rise and intensive
- 54:16intensifying storm, biodiversity loss,
- 54:20and deforestations.
- 54:22And we are often have limited
- 54:23institution and financial capacity to
- 54:26respond.
- 54:27Existing funding remain indicate to the
- 54:30meet to meet the adaptation needs of
- 54:34development countries.
- 54:35This is not an administrative
- 54:38convenience. It
- 54:40determine whether adaptation happen in
- 54:43the time.
- 54:44For this reason, the text must retain
- 54:47meaningful reference to the significant
- 54:49financial gaps
- 54:51and its consequence for the timely
- 54:54implementation.
- 54:57We have come to work constructively and
- 54:59AOSIS is ready to be flexible on
- 55:02wording, but the final paragraph must
- 55:05reflect the seriousness of the challenge
- 55:08we faced. The AOSIS
- 55:11adaptation is a matter of survival.
- 55:14NAPs cannot be implemented without
- 55:16predictable and accessible support.
- 55:18Thank you, coastal states.
- 55:27>> Thank you, AOSIS.
- 55:29Um any other group?
- 55:45I like, you have the floor.
- 55:51>> Thank you, chair. Uh I speak on behalf
- 55:53from I like
- 55:55and I want to reiterate that I like
- 55:57supports the the decision that
- 55:59recognizes the progress made
- 56:01in the process to formulate and
- 56:03implement
- 56:04adaptation plans as we believe the
- 56:06adaptation plans are
- 56:08uh
- 56:08vital for in in fighting the climate
- 56:11change.
- 56:12Uh
- 56:13and we also acknowledge the barriers
- 56:16that continue to hold back the
- 56:18implementation
- 56:20as we believe we need to move from
- 56:22planning uh to concrete actions.
- 56:26Um
- 56:27and we believe that the significant
- 56:29progress have been made since the Cancun
- 56:31Adaptation Framework
- 56:33and
- 56:34majority of countries have already
- 56:36submitted an adaptation national
- 56:38adaptation plans
- 56:40and we must now move to concrete
- 56:42actions.
- 56:44Uh
- 56:45however, we have to reiterate that
- 56:50and highlight the
- 56:52important limitations remain mainly on
- 56:55finance,
- 56:56transferring the technology
- 56:59and ensuring capacity building for
- 57:02developing nations.
- 57:04And
- 57:05we believe that the significant
- 57:07financial gap is hindering progress of
- 57:10implementation.
- 57:12Uh
- 57:13and finally,
- 57:14uh
- 57:15uh we believe that
- 57:18it is it is a acute time to act and put
- 57:22our plans into action. Thank you.
- 57:27>> Thank you, I LAC. Your
- 57:30interventions are well noted by the
- 57:32secretariat and will be reflected in the
- 57:35next iteration of the text.
- 57:37Um EU, please take the floor.
- 57:42>> Um thank you so much
- 57:44uh Mr.
- 57:45facilitator um and
- 57:49well uh from our
- 57:51perspective from European Union um first
- 57:55of all um we
- 57:57of course welcome all the progresses
- 58:00uh in the formulation and implementation
- 58:02um
- 58:03of NAPs especially from developing
- 58:06country.
- 58:07Um we also want to recognize that
- 58:09developing countries continue to face
- 58:11challenges in accessing finance and
- 58:13other form of support uh such as
- 58:16what
- 58:17um G77 and China already mentioned the
- 58:20technology. Um
- 58:23we also want to emphasize the value of
- 58:25precise wording that identify the
- 58:27problem without prejudging specific
- 58:30financial commitments.
- 58:32Um
- 58:34and also we would like to indicate
- 58:37openness to language recognizing in
- 58:39inadequate funding and its consequences
- 58:42to implementation of NAPs.
- 58:45Um
- 58:46we also call all the like
- 58:49we we also want to call for
- 58:52you know a precise and concise balance
- 58:54paragraph that reflects the seriousness
- 58:57of the challenge and allow the
- 58:58negotiation to move forward.
- 59:00So that is our standing. Thank you so
- 59:03much.
- 59:07>> Thank you EU for your
- 59:10intervention.
- 59:11Um please LDCs have the floor.
- 59:18>> Thank you,
- 59:19co-facilitator.
- 59:21Um, we acknowledge what our colleagues
- 59:24from G77, AOSIS, and LDC have expressed.
- 59:28And in order to put our plans into
- 59:30action, we would like to emphasize that
- 59:32the preparation of a national adaptation
- 59:34plan is only the first step.
- 59:36Having a plan does not necessarily mean
- 59:38having the resources, institutional
- 59:40capacity, or technical support required
- 59:42to translate it into concrete adaptation
- 59:44actions on the ground.
- 59:46For LDC LDCs, the challenge is not only
- 59:49to formulate comprehensive and
- 59:50country-driven adaptation plans, but
- 59:53also to ensure their effective and
- 59:55timely implementation.
- 59:57In this regard,
- 59:58access to adequate and predictable
- 1:00:00financial resources, technology
- 1:00:02transfer, and capacity building remains
- 1:00:04essential.
- 1:00:06We are particularly concerned that
- 1:00:08current funding levels remain inadequate
- 1:00:10and that a significant financial gap
- 1:00:13continues to undermine the
- 1:00:14implementation of our NAPs.
- 1:00:16We, therefore, believe that the
- 1:00:18negotiation text should also clear
- 1:00:21acknowledge these persistent challenges
- 1:00:24and reflect the particular circumstances
- 1:00:26of countries facing the greatest
- 1:00:28capacity constraints.
- 1:00:29We encourage the parties to maintain
- 1:00:32strong and meaningful language that
- 1:00:34addresses both the formulation and
- 1:00:37implementation of NAPs, ensuring that
- 1:00:39the countries most in need are not left
- 1:00:42behind. Thank you.
- 1:00:47>> Thank you. Thank you, LDCs.
- 1:00:51Is there any other request to take the
- 1:00:53floor?
- 1:01:13Thank you to all the parties for your
- 1:01:16interventions.
- 1:01:18Since I see no other request from you, I
- 1:01:20would give the floor to the observers
- 1:01:23who wants to give an intervention. Thank
- 1:01:26you.
- 1:01:27Please raise your flag and we'll call
- 1:01:29you.
- 1:01:37>> Thank you for the opportunity.
- 1:01:39As a youth observer, I would like to
- 1:01:41welcome to this opportunity to
- 1:01:43contribute the important discussion.
- 1:01:46National adaptation plans are essential
- 1:01:48tools for identifying countries'
- 1:01:50priorities and responding to the impact.
- 1:01:53>> sorry.
- 1:01:54Um I didn't see your flag. Can you
- 1:01:56please raise your flag and then identify
- 1:02:00um which constituency you are
- 1:02:01representing?
- 1:02:03>> Yes.
- 1:02:04I'm from
- 1:02:05Yongo.
- 1:02:08>> Please you have the floor now.
- 1:02:12>> Okay.
- 1:02:13>> Go ahead, please.
- 1:02:15>> Okay.
- 1:02:16So
- 1:02:17uh national adaptation plans are
- 1:02:19essential tools for identifying
- 1:02:21countries' priorities and responding to
- 1:02:23the impacts of climate change. However,
- 1:02:26we must remember that having a plan is
- 1:02:28not enough. What truly matters is the
- 1:02:30implementation on the ground. Young
- 1:02:32people and local communities moving may
- 1:02:35not involve not only through
- 1:02:37consultations but also in decision
- 1:02:39making and implementation process. We
- 1:02:41are not just the generation who will
- 1:02:44face the consequence of climate change.
- 1:02:46We are also part of the solutions. And
- 1:02:49at the same time, we cannot talk about
- 1:02:51effective action without addressing the
- 1:02:53lack of adequate financial resource,
- 1:02:56technology transfer, and capacity
- 1:02:57building, particularly in developing
- 1:03:00countries. From the perspective of young
- 1:03:02people, especially those connected to
- 1:03:04vulnerable territories, adaptation more
- 1:03:07responds to real needs and risks the
- 1:03:09community must affect by climate
- 1:03:11impacts.
- 1:03:13We encourage parties to ensure that this
- 1:03:15decision promotes inclusive
- 1:03:16participation and above all translate
- 1:03:19commitments into concrete action because
- 1:03:21our attention must not be or remain on
- 1:03:24paper. It must reach people, communities
- 1:03:27and territories. Thank you.
- 1:03:46>> Thank you um Yongo.
- 1:03:48Uh parties apologies. I should have
- 1:03:51uh sought your concern
- 1:03:53your consent before giving
- 1:03:55um the floor to the observers. So I want
- 1:03:58to be sure that parties don't have any
- 1:04:01objections to our observers also taking
- 1:04:04the floor and giving us a statement. If
- 1:04:07you have any objection you can raise
- 1:04:08your flag and then tell us. If none then
- 1:04:11we move on and give the floor to the
- 1:04:13rest of the observers to also give us
- 1:04:16their statement.
- 1:04:33Okay.
- 1:04:34I see no objection from parties.
- 1:04:37So in that case um
- 1:04:40observers if you want to take the floor
- 1:04:42please raise your flag and we'll
- 1:04:44continue. Thank you.
- 1:04:55>> Very good. Let's freeze here because
- 1:04:57there is a lot
- 1:04:59to or some element that we did well,
- 1:05:02some other we did not very well but uh
- 1:05:04it's
- 1:05:05simulation is running very
- 1:05:08smoothly. I pass the floor to Laurence
- 1:05:11that will
- 1:05:12uh introduce explain how to take the
- 1:05:15floor and what is the sequence of
- 1:05:18speakers in addressing your question.
- 1:05:23>> Um, so so that there is no wrong or
- 1:05:26right way to to to to talk.
- 1:05:29It it's not a competition,
- 1:05:31but so thank you for all of you who
- 1:05:34raised their flags. So this is those
- 1:05:37name plates here with the name of the
- 1:05:39country or the group you're speaking on
- 1:05:40behalf. We call it a flag.
- 1:05:43Uh in some in some plenaries you you
- 1:05:46really actually have the flags of the
- 1:05:48parties
- 1:05:49against their their their desk.
- 1:05:53So here to take the floor in in this
- 1:05:55type of setup,
- 1:05:57it's not electronically. You really have
- 1:06:00to mechanically raise your flag this
- 1:06:03way. So you put it so so that the
- 1:06:05co-facilitators and the secretariat sees
- 1:06:08who wants to take the floor.
- 1:06:11In in plenary you have a more
- 1:06:12sophisticated
- 1:06:14system where you press the button and
- 1:06:16then it comes red and it appears
- 1:06:19on a list. It appears on the screen of
- 1:06:22the chair and the secretariat. So they
- 1:06:24see who has requested for the floor. The
- 1:06:27first thing is that you don't have to
- 1:06:29wait for the person who is speaking to
- 1:06:32finish before you can raise your floor
- 1:06:34your your your flag, sorry.
- 1:06:37Whenever you want you raise your flag
- 1:06:38and the secretariat sitting next to the
- 1:06:40co-facilitators, they take note of who
- 1:06:43requests for the floor, right? So it can
- 1:06:46be 10 flags raised at the same time.
- 1:06:49They will usually try to take all the
- 1:06:51names in a list and then what is the
- 1:06:55order? It was a question that was asked.
- 1:06:58So in plenary definitely
- 1:07:00it's
- 1:07:01the chair they first take the
- 1:07:04non-overlapping groups or those big
- 1:07:06groups like the G77 and China, the AU,
- 1:07:09the UG,
- 1:07:13what else? EIG. So those are groups
- 1:07:16that are non-overlapping with other
- 1:07:19groups. An overlapping group for example
- 1:07:21would be Aosis, LDC because they belong
- 1:07:24to a
- 1:07:25bigger group, right?
- 1:07:27So
- 1:07:28in plenary, first the non-overlapping
- 1:07:30groups starting with G77 and China, it's
- 1:07:33the biggest group, right? So even if
- 1:07:37AOSIS is raising its flag before G77 and
- 1:07:40China, the chair will wait
- 1:07:42to see the flag of G77 and China
- 1:07:45to give the floor first to G77 and
- 1:07:48China.
- 1:07:50Why? Because when AOSIS then take the
- 1:07:52floor, they can say I support the
- 1:07:55intervention of the G77 and China,
- 1:07:58which you didn't do in this room.
- 1:08:00Actually, none of you did, but in a
- 1:08:02smaller room
- 1:08:05it's up to the room to decide how they
- 1:08:07want the floor to be given. It can be on
- 1:08:10a first-come, first-served basis, but
- 1:08:12usually they tend to follow the rule
- 1:08:14that applies in the plenary. It would be
- 1:08:16then the G77,
- 1:08:19AU, and then we go into the overlapping
- 1:08:23groups. But when another when a smaller
- 1:08:25groups like AOSIS, LDC then takes the
- 1:08:28floor, they have to say I support what
- 1:08:31the G77 said because, you know, it makes
- 1:08:34it even more important,
- 1:08:37a bigger weight what was said because it
- 1:08:40shows that there is coalition, right?
- 1:08:42And then you make you don't repeat what
- 1:08:44the G77 say, but you focus on your
- 1:08:47special circumstances.
- 1:08:51When you speak yeah, the two slides are
- 1:08:54interrelated, but when you speak
- 1:08:56especially in plenary, don't speak too
- 1:08:58fast. Remember, plenary are
- 1:09:02the there is interpretation in all six
- 1:09:06UN languages.
- 1:09:07So the interpreters, they are in their
- 1:09:09little booth, they listen and they
- 1:09:11interpret at the same time. It's
- 1:09:12simultaneous, and very often they don't
- 1:09:15have the text.
- 1:09:17Very often they do have the text in
- 1:09:18plenary, but let's say
- 1:09:21they still have to interpret properly.
- 1:09:23So if you speak too fast, they won't be
- 1:09:25able to interpret properly. So please
- 1:09:29try to keep
- 1:09:31a pace that is understandable for all.
- 1:09:36And
- 1:09:39Yes. So you see that the secretariat
- 1:09:41maintains the list, so you can raise
- 1:09:43your flag. Once you have
- 1:09:45finished your intervention, you put it
- 1:09:47down
- 1:09:49so we know you don't want to speak. And
- 1:09:51then they give the floor to the next
- 1:09:52person.
- 1:09:54And don't forget to
- 1:09:57after the group parties can take the
- 1:09:59floor of course, and they they will say
- 1:10:02if it's like France talking, they will
- 1:10:04say I support what the EU said, right?
- 1:10:08So they they make it strong they they
- 1:10:10they they they they second their
- 1:10:12position, right?
- 1:10:15Also
- 1:10:18I can't read myself now.
- 1:10:23Yes.
- 1:10:26And facilitators they they really at the
- 1:10:29secretariat they take note of everything
- 1:10:31we said because what we explained is
- 1:10:34that once all the position have been
- 1:10:37expressed,
- 1:10:39they have to be captured in a sense in
- 1:10:42in
- 1:10:43to to know how to structure after the
- 1:10:45the draft text.
- 1:10:47Do you have any question on the on this
- 1:10:50order of
- 1:10:52speakers or
- 1:10:54yeah.
- 1:10:55And here you read some intervention
- 1:10:57which is fine. There is a question.
- 1:11:00Yeah.
- 1:11:02Yeah, please.
- 1:11:05>> Hey.
- 1:11:07What if afterwards
- 1:11:10you've met with your national party
- 1:11:14and you recognize that you have [snorts]
- 1:11:17a difference of opinion on what was put
- 1:11:19forward before by the overarching group?
- 1:11:23How is that treated?
- 1:11:25>> Well, this is a good question because no
- 1:11:28you you cannot into the room with a
- 1:11:30different position from your overarching
- 1:11:32group, right? You can have a specific
- 1:11:35circumstance that you want to express,
- 1:11:38but you cannot go I mean you cannot
- 1:11:40really go against your group and that's
- 1:11:42why there is an important meeting that
- 1:11:43was not shown in the negotiation
- 1:11:46pyramid, which are the coordination
- 1:11:49meeting of the groups.
- 1:11:50They meet every day. No, sorry.
- 1:11:54Sorry.
- 1:11:57So so in the coordination group they
- 1:11:59meet every day.
- 1:12:01The G77, the LDC, the Aosis,
- 1:12:04Ailac, etc. etc. They all meet to not
- 1:12:08only reflect on what was said the day
- 1:12:09before, but also speak look at the
- 1:12:12strategy of the way forward and agree on
- 1:12:15their position, on the common position.
- 1:12:18So as I say so for some groups it's very
- 1:12:21complicated
- 1:12:22or for some parties look at Comoros.
- 1:12:24They are LDC, they are Aosis, they are
- 1:12:26Arab group, they are G77
- 1:12:30and they have their special
- 1:12:30circumstances.
- 1:12:32But in the room
- 1:12:35in in the negotiation room
- 1:12:37they have to follow their groups.
- 1:12:39So if they don't agree, what they can
- 1:12:42ask is maybe to suspend the session. So
- 1:12:45they will ask the co-facilitator
- 1:12:47I need a minute please.
- 1:12:48Is it could you please suspend the
- 1:12:50session? I need to talk to my group.
- 1:12:53And usually the co-facilitator will
- 1:12:55agree to say you have three minutes
- 1:12:57and then you can gather in a corner of
- 1:12:59the room and discuss it with your group
- 1:13:01like what you said I don't know. But
- 1:13:04not in front of the other you cannot
- 1:13:06just say I disagree with my group,
- 1:13:08right? Doesn't make sense. So it's
- 1:13:09important you attend all your
- 1:13:11coordination meeting. You follow your
- 1:13:13group. If there is a disagreement
- 1:13:15try to solve it before getting into the
- 1:13:17room.
- 1:13:18If you have a disagreement during the
- 1:13:20the the negotiation ask for a suspension
- 1:13:23to discuss it.
- 1:13:26But that was a good question. Sorry.
- 1:13:34>> Okay. So maybe we can then
- 1:13:38Ah, there is a question here.
- 1:13:42>> Just to understand
- 1:13:44how are co-facilitators selected? Is
- 1:13:46there a process for it? If you can speak
- 1:13:48to it a little bit.
- 1:14:05>> So sorry, I went too fast and
- 1:14:08there was a slide on co-facilitators.
- 1:14:11Yeah, so the co-facilitators, they are
- 1:14:14delegates, right? They can't be
- 1:14:16observers. They have to be from a party
- 1:14:19delegations and they have been
- 1:14:21identified in advance by the chairs and
- 1:14:24the presidency,
- 1:14:27usually on a recommendation by the
- 1:14:29secretariat because the secretariat know
- 1:14:30their negotiators in each of the issues
- 1:14:33and they they propose names
- 1:14:37to the president and
- 1:14:39and the chairs
- 1:14:40of
- 1:14:42of
- 1:14:43of people who could facilitate their
- 1:14:45their item.
- 1:14:46You have to know that, so it's a pair.
- 1:14:49Two two facilitators or two chairs for
- 1:14:53the contact group
- 1:14:54and facilitators for the informal
- 1:14:56consultations and they need to be a
- 1:14:59balance
- 1:15:00geographical
- 1:15:03tree and developed country form a pair
- 1:15:05and also a gender balance.
- 1:15:08Not obligatory in the same group, but in
- 1:15:12the totality of all the groups that have
- 1:15:14been established, you need the balance
- 1:15:16female male equally.
- 1:15:19So it's it's it's a bit complicated.
- 1:15:21It's a bit challenging challenges, let's
- 1:15:23say,
- 1:15:24to reach this
- 1:15:27at least gender balance and geographical
- 1:15:29balance too because
- 1:15:30once Once been identified, the
- 1:15:32secretariat
- 1:15:34sends an email to this person and said,
- 1:15:37we would like to see whether you're
- 1:15:38available and willing
- 1:15:40to facilitate this item.
- 1:15:44And first the person who receive it has
- 1:15:46to ask is it it's head of delegation,
- 1:15:50will it be okay for me to facilitate
- 1:15:52this? And for small delegation it's
- 1:15:55sometime complicated because they say oh
- 1:15:56we don't have enough people to negotiate
- 1:15:58here and and you are a good negotiator
- 1:16:00on that you can facilitate it because
- 1:16:03when you are facilitator you're
- 1:16:04impartial. You have a dual act of
- 1:16:08delegation
- 1:16:09and
- 1:16:10facilitator
- 1:16:12who needs to be there impartially to
- 1:16:14ensure that the process is is followed
- 1:16:17according to the draft rules of
- 1:16:19procedures being applied.
- 1:16:21So it's it's it's a complicated job.
- 1:16:23It's it's not an easy job to have this
- 1:16:25dual function and and you have to find
- 1:16:28the time. You you see you have to attend
- 1:16:30all the meetings, then you have to
- 1:16:33make the work behind the scene of
- 1:16:35compiling all the views, drafting the
- 1:16:37text,
- 1:16:38going in the corridor you know when you
- 1:16:40see that there is a lot of of
- 1:16:43contentious issue.
- 1:16:45They also go as I said in in in in
- 1:16:47ballots or in the corridor try to find a
- 1:16:50way. So they are very busy managing this
- 1:16:53item but at the same time they are
- 1:16:55negotiators for their own delegations on
- 1:16:57other issues.
- 1:16:58So it's not it's not easy.
- 1:17:01But so when once they say yes, then
- 1:17:05when the work is being launched at the
- 1:17:07plenary as I said we organize work. So
- 1:17:10the president says
- 1:17:12for this item NABS
- 1:17:14I will
- 1:17:15establish informal consultation to be to
- 1:17:18be co-facilitated by Mrs. X and Mr. Y.
- 1:17:23I hear no objection it is so decided.
- 1:17:25In my entire career I've never heard
- 1:17:28the room object to the appointment of a
- 1:17:32person to the facilitator.
- 1:17:35So let's say that once have been
- 1:17:37identified, have you heard that? No.
- 1:17:40Um once you have been identified and the
- 1:17:42and the president proposes it in the
- 1:17:44room,
- 1:17:46uh you know that you're going to be very
- 1:17:47busy.
- 1:17:49Thank you. Sorry about missing this
- 1:17:51information.
- 1:17:52>> Thank you very much, Laurence. Any other
- 1:17:53question?
- 1:17:55Sure.
- 1:17:56>> I just wanted to
- 1:17:58uh compliment the the point about the
- 1:18:00co-facilitator. I think Laurence said
- 1:18:03some very important parts about how the
- 1:18:05role,
- 1:18:06but it also could happen that you're
- 1:18:08sitting as a co-facilitator and someone
- 1:18:10from your delegation is still sitting
- 1:18:12across from you
- 1:18:13because it doesn't mean that you're then
- 1:18:16your country is completely taken out of
- 1:18:18the negotiation process. So if you come
- 1:18:21from
- 1:18:22from Colombia, for instance, and you're
- 1:18:24co-facilitating, someone in your
- 1:18:27delegation could still be in the room
- 1:18:29and negotiating on behalf of Colombia.
- 1:18:32So your country does not get completely
- 1:18:34left out of the process. Just wanted to
- 1:18:36compliment with.
- 1:18:38>> Thank you, Walters. I think we are ready
- 1:18:39to start. Can we switch to the
- 1:18:41presentation, please?
- 1:18:44To the presentation.
- 1:18:46Because we are now entering the second
- 1:18:48round of the simulation. So is we are at
- 1:18:51the third informal consultation.
- 1:19:03here we are. The night before they
- 1:19:06publish the text, you have had the
- 1:19:08chance to look at it. In the morning you
- 1:19:10are sitting in a informal consultation
- 1:19:12and what you continue discussing the
- 1:19:15text.
- 1:19:23>> Colleagues, the third informal
- 1:19:25consultation is now open.
- 1:19:28Following our previous exchange, um my
- 1:19:31fellow co-facilitator and I, with the
- 1:19:33support of the secretariat, have
- 1:19:34prepared a revised iteration of the
- 1:19:36text.
- 1:19:37You'll see the draft text that is
- 1:19:42the main points raised during the
- 1:19:43previous consultation.
- 1:19:45Some formulations have been adjusted
- 1:19:47while brackets and alternative options
- 1:19:50have been retained where differences
- 1:19:52still remain.
- 1:19:54I invite groups to consider whether the
- 1:19:56revised language accurately reflect the
- 1:19:59discussions that we have had in our
- 1:20:00previous consultations.
- 1:20:02In particular, we encourage you to
- 1:20:04identify any formulations your group
- 1:20:07could support at this stage, any
- 1:20:09wordings that remains difficult for your
- 1:20:11groups to accept, any brackets or
- 1:20:14alternatives that could be narrowed, and
- 1:20:16any compromised language your group
- 1:20:19would like to propose.
- 1:20:20I am in this consultation
- 1:20:23the third consultation is to clarify the
- 1:20:25remaining differences and explore where
- 1:20:27further convergence may be
- 1:20:29possible.
- 1:20:32So now I invite
- 1:20:34groups to take the floor based on the
- 1:20:36draft text that we have presented. The
- 1:20:39floor is open.
- 1:21:21Apologize if the order was not followed,
- 1:21:24but I saw that G77 had the flag raised
- 1:21:27first.
- 1:21:29Based on that, I give the floor to G77
- 1:21:31and China followed by AILAC.
- 1:21:35G77, you have the floor.
- 1:21:38>> Thank you, co-facilitators. Speaking on
- 1:21:40behalf of the Group of 77 and China. We
- 1:21:42thank you for this consolidated second
- 1:21:44iteration.
- 1:21:45We welcome the streamlined structure and
- 1:21:47the clear recognition across operative
- 1:21:50progress that developing countries
- 1:21:51parties continue to face barriers in
- 1:21:54accessing finance, technology transfer
- 1:21:56and capacity building support.
- 1:21:59In the spirit of compromise, the
- 1:22:00formulation notes with concern in
- 1:22:02operative progress two is acceptable to
- 1:22:05our group provided that operative
- 1:22:07paragraph three retains unambiguous
- 1:22:09language stating that funding remains
- 1:22:12inadequate and that the significant
- 1:22:14financial gap remains a barrier to
- 1:22:17effective and timely implementation.
- 1:22:20As we refine this text, we emphasize two
- 1:22:22essential points. First, all three means
- 1:22:24of implementation, finance, technology
- 1:22:27transfer and capacity building must be
- 1:22:29retained on an equal footing.
- 1:22:32Second, we must avoid any wording that
- 1:22:34shifts the burden of overcoming these
- 1:22:35constraints solely onto developing
- 1:22:37countries without recognizing the
- 1:22:40indispensable role of international
- 1:22:41support.
- 1:22:43With these elements safeguarded, we say
- 1:22:45a clear path towards consensus. Thank
- 1:22:47you.
- 1:22:53>> Thank you G77 for the flexibility shown.
- 1:22:56Um I lack you have the floor.
- 1:23:03>> Co-facilitators, on behalf of
- 1:23:07ILEC,
- 1:23:08first of all, we support
- 1:23:1077 and China group
- 1:23:14as well as we support the move toward a
- 1:23:17more consolidated text and consider
- 1:23:20notes with concern
- 1:23:22a balanced formulation
- 1:23:24for the continuing challenges in
- 1:23:27accessing support. The text must
- 1:23:30contain a clear link between
- 1:23:33indicate funding and
- 1:23:36significant financial gap
- 1:23:39and the consequences of effective and
- 1:23:41timely NAB implementation.
- 1:23:45Uh as well as we encourage uh all groups
- 1:23:48to preserve uh the substance of this
- 1:23:50paragraph
- 1:23:52while keeping the wording conscious,
- 1:23:54practical, and capable of guiding future
- 1:23:58implementation. Thank you.
- 1:24:03>> Thank you, I luck. I just want to remind
- 1:24:05that we have one more informal
- 1:24:07consultation left. Um so just to remind
- 1:24:10that um
- 1:24:11if you can if you can reach a compromise
- 1:24:13on the text um at this session um it
- 1:24:16would be good.
- 1:24:17Um AOSIS, I see your flag. You have the
- 1:24:20floor.
- 1:24:26>> Yes, thank you very much, chair. I would
- 1:24:28like to take the floor on behalf of SIDS
- 1:24:30countries, small um island development
- 1:24:32states.
- 1:24:34Um and the AOSIS delegates um
- 1:24:36acknowledge the progress that has been
- 1:24:38made to this point.
- 1:24:39Um for us it's important that this
- 1:24:41recognition for the need of developing
- 1:24:43countries including SIDS to access
- 1:24:45financing for implementing um national
- 1:24:48adaptation plans regarding finance,
- 1:24:50capacity building, and technology
- 1:24:52transfer.
- 1:24:53Um thus we strongly support the
- 1:24:55formulation note of concern in the
- 1:24:57current draft.
- 1:24:58Um furthermore, it is essential that the
- 1:25:01text must state that funding um is
- 1:25:04inadequate currently and the text must
- 1:25:06show that effective implementation of
- 1:25:08NAP as
- 1:25:09well as the timeliness of NAP is still
- 1:25:12hindered.
- 1:25:13Um the scale of the gap must become
- 1:25:15clear in the text and therefore the
- 1:25:17wording needs to reflect um the scale of
- 1:25:19the problem.
- 1:25:20So we cannot endorse language that
- 1:25:22downplays the seriousness of a financial
- 1:25:24gap on this matter. Thank you very much.
- 1:25:34>> Thank you, AOSIS. LDC, you have the
- 1:25:36floor.
- 1:25:42>> Thank you, co-facilitator.
- 1:25:44I am speaking on behalf of the least
- 1:25:47developed countries group.
- 1:25:49We appreciate the efforts made to
- 1:25:52consolidate this text in version B.
- 1:25:55We welcome the recognition in the
- 1:25:57operative paragraph two that developing
- 1:26:00countries parties continue to face
- 1:26:03persistent challenge in accessing
- 1:26:05finance, technology transfers and
- 1:26:08capacity building support.
- 1:26:10However, we wish to emphasize that for
- 1:26:13LDCs
- 1:26:14access to this support is essential, not
- 1:26:16only to formulate OBNAPs,
- 1:26:19but above all to implement them on the
- 1:26:23on the ground. A completed plan that no
- 1:26:26protects our communities on its own if
- 1:26:29we if we lack the means to execute it.
- 1:26:33Therefore, we considerate
- 1:26:36critical that operative paragraph three
- 1:26:39explicitly
- 1:26:40retains the the recognition that funding
- 1:26:43remains inadequate and that the
- 1:26:47significant financial gaps continues to
- 1:26:50be a direct barriers to effective and
- 1:26:52timely implementation.
- 1:26:55In a constructive spirit and to move
- 1:26:58towards consensus, our group can show
- 1:27:01flexibility by accepting more concise
- 1:27:04wording as well as the use of note with
- 1:27:08concern in paragraph two. Nevertheless,
- 1:27:11this flexibility is contingent upon the
- 1:27:14final text clearly reflecting the severe
- 1:27:17institutional, technical and financial
- 1:27:19capacity constraints
- 1:27:21faced by the countries most in need.
- 1:27:24Thank you.
- 1:27:27>> Thank you LDC for the flexibility
- 1:27:30flexibility shown um and we invite um
- 1:27:33others to to do the same. We encourage
- 1:27:36to consult bilaterally and um
- 1:27:40before fourth fourth informal
- 1:27:42consultation. So thank you colleagues
- 1:27:44before we summarize the discussion.
- 1:27:50Apologies, I did not see the flag. EU,
- 1:27:53you have the floor.
- 1:27:57>> Um, thank you so much co-chairs. Um,
- 1:28:02the
- 1:28:03EU we we can support the this versions
- 1:28:07of the text at a constructive and
- 1:28:09balanced basis for further negotiation.
- 1:28:12We welcome the recognition of the
- 1:28:14progress while acknowledge
- 1:28:17while acknowledging that some limitation
- 1:28:19remain. In particular, we support the
- 1:28:22use of notes with concern to reflect
- 1:28:25the continuing challenges developing
- 1:28:27countries face in accessing finance,
- 1:28:29technology transfer and capacity
- 1:28:31building supports.
- 1:28:33Countries face
- 1:28:37we also recognize that current fundings
- 1:28:39have not fully met to the needs of
- 1:28:42developing countries and that financial
- 1:28:44gap continue to
- 1:28:46constrain effective and timely
- 1:28:48implementation. However, we believe it
- 1:28:50is important that the text accurately
- 1:28:53reflects
- 1:28:54the different funding channels and
- 1:28:55mechanism without implying commitments
- 1:28:58beyond those already agree. We are
- 1:29:01therefore open to concise language that
- 1:29:03clearly acknowledge the challenges and
- 1:29:05their consequences while maintaining
- 1:29:07technical precisions and preserving
- 1:29:10space for conversation. Thank you.
- 1:29:20>> Thank you colleagues. Before we
- 1:29:21summarize the discussion, I would like
- 1:29:23to check whether any party objects to
- 1:29:26hearing brief inputs from observer
- 1:29:29organizations.
- 1:29:34Seeing no objections from the floor,
- 1:29:36we'll now invite up to two observer
- 1:29:38representatives to take the floor for a
- 1:29:41maximum of two minutes each. Please keep
- 1:29:43it brief.
- 1:29:47Yang Go,
- 1:29:48I see your flag.
- 1:29:50You have floor.
- 1:29:53>> Thank you co-facilitator. My name is
- 1:29:54Nishal Baniya from Nepal.
- 1:29:57At home, I'm the chairman of Bagmati
- 1:29:58UNESCO Club and run Himalayan Carbon
- 1:30:00Private Limited. Today I speak on behalf
- 1:30:02of Yango.
- 1:30:03>> sorry. Um
- 1:30:05I see a party requesting the floor.
- 1:30:08Bangladesh.
- 1:30:11>> No, I'm observer.
- 1:30:15>> Okay.
- 1:30:17It's just the flag, I guess. It says
- 1:30:19Bangladesh. Sorry. So you're you're one
- 1:30:20of the observers. Okay, understood.
- 1:30:23Yango, apologies, you have the floor.
- 1:30:27>> Uh today I speak on behalf of Yango, the
- 1:30:30official children and youth constituency
- 1:30:31to UNFCCC.
- 1:30:33Co-facilitator, young people have
- 1:30:35listened carefully and we have heard
- 1:30:37something encouraging. The G77 in China,
- 1:30:40the small island developing states,
- 1:30:42ILEC, the European Union and the least
- 1:30:44developed countries have all said the
- 1:30:46same thing in their own words.
- 1:30:47Real progress has been made and most
- 1:30:49countries now have plans. Serious
- 1:30:51barriers remain in finance, technology
- 1:30:53transfer, and capacity building.
- 1:30:56Current funding is not enough and it is
- 1:30:58time to move from planning to action.
- 1:31:00We ask that the text stays what the room
- 1:31:03has said.
- 1:31:04If every group recognizes that funding
- 1:31:06is inadequate, the decision should not
- 1:31:08use softer words than the parties
- 1:31:11themselves are using. But young people
- 1:31:13want to make it clear, naming the gap is
- 1:31:15not the same as closing it.
- 1:31:17A plan cannot be implemented on support
- 1:31:19that is unpredictable or out of reach.
- 1:31:22In my own country, Nepal,
- 1:31:24adaptation [snorts]
- 1:31:24plan is costed at around $47 billion to
- 1:31:272050.
- 1:31:29And almost all of it depends on
- 1:31:30international support. This August, the
- 1:31:33glacier collapse and a deadly flood in
- 1:31:35Nepal's Rasuwa district down a valley
- 1:31:37that had flooded only 13 months before.
- 1:31:40Finance for that risk had already been
- 1:31:42approved, but approved is not the same
- 1:31:44as arrived.
- 1:31:45For island communities facing rising
- 1:31:47seas and mountain communities facing
- 1:31:50melting ice, delay is not a technical
- 1:31:52detail. It is the difference between a
- 1:31:54plan and a disaster.
- 1:31:56So Yango asks parties to keep three
- 1:31:58things in mind. First, a support must be
- 1:32:00predictable, accessible, and reach the
- 1:32:02ground.
- 1:32:03Adaptation happens in municipalities,
- 1:32:05schools, farms, coastlines, and homes.
- 1:32:09Finance, technology, and capacity
- 1:32:10building should reach local governments
- 1:32:12and the most affected communities, not
- 1:32:14stop at the national level.
- 1:32:16Second, young people must be a part of
- 1:32:18implementation, not only consultation.
- 1:32:20>> Apologies Yango,
- 1:32:22because we are running out of time, we
- 1:32:24would like to we would be grateful if
- 1:32:26you can keep the intervention up to two
- 1:32:29minutes, please.
- 1:32:29>> Sure. Third, let the final paragraph
- 1:32:33carry the honesty of this room. The that
- 1:32:34the financial gap is significant and
- 1:32:36without the predictable and accessible
- 1:32:38support, plans cannot become action.
- 1:32:41Co-facilitator, young people will live
- 1:32:43with the results of this plan for the
- 1:32:44rest of our lives. In 2015, no one will
- 1:32:47remember which verb opened the
- 1:32:48paragraph. They will remember whether
- 1:32:50the help arrived. Let us make sure it
- 1:32:52does and the young people are part of
- 1:32:54making it happening. Thank you.
- 1:33:06>> Thank you Yango for keeping it
- 1:33:09brief.
- 1:33:11I see that Bangladesh in your capacity
- 1:33:13as an observer,
- 1:33:15you have the floor.
- 1:33:20>> Thank you co-facilitators for giving the
- 1:33:21floor. Speaking as an observer from
- 1:33:23Bangladesh, Akanksha on the front lines
- 1:33:25of the climate crisis, national
- 1:33:27adaptation plans are not merely
- 1:33:29technical documents for us. They are a
- 1:33:31blueprint for survival. While we welcome
- 1:33:33the progress in this draft text,
- 1:33:37experience from the countries that have
- 1:33:38already formulated ambitious snaps shows
- 1:33:40that planning without implementation is
- 1:33:42a hollow promise. To ensure that, we
- 1:33:44urge the parties to strengthen three
- 1:33:46critical elements. Firstly, closing the
- 1:33:48implementation finance gap by
- 1:33:50formulating a nap is only the first step
- 1:33:53and developing countries and least
- 1:33:54developed countries are currently
- 1:33:56bearing the
- 1:33:57burnt of adaptation cost out of their
- 1:33:59own national budgets. The text must
- 1:34:01explicitly call for scaled-up,
- 1:34:03predictable, grant-based finance
- 1:34:05especially dedicated to NAP
- 1:34:06implementation. Secondly, embedding
- 1:34:09locally led adaptations. In Bangladesh,
- 1:34:11we have seen firsthand that adaptation
- 1:34:13succeeds when local communities, women,
- 1:34:15youth, and coastal farmers lead the
- 1:34:17design and execution of solutions. We
- 1:34:20urge the parties to include clear
- 1:34:22language mandating developed finance and
- 1:34:24institutional mechanism that channel NAP
- 1:34:26resources. Thirdly, addressing the
- 1:34:28limits to adaptation, rapid onset
- 1:34:30cyclones, and slow onset sea level rise
- 1:34:33and salinity intrusion.
- 1:34:34>> Bangladesh. In your capacity as an
- 1:34:36observer, you have 30 minutes left. We
- 1:34:38really have to 30 seconds left, sorry.
- 1:34:41We really have to close the the
- 1:34:42consultation. So please if you can wrap
- 1:34:46up. Thank you.
- 1:34:47>> The text should recognize the clear
- 1:34:49linkages between the NAP implementation
- 1:34:51and addressing the loss and damage. So
- 1:34:53that's from my side. Thank you,
- 1:34:55co-facilitators.
- 1:34:59>> Thank you.
- 1:35:01I see that parties Aosis want to come
- 1:35:04back.
- 1:35:05I hope this is a bridging proposal to
- 1:35:07move us closer to to an agreement.
- 1:35:11You have the floor, Aosis.
- 1:35:13>> Thank you, co-facilitator. I want to add
- 1:35:15something from our last text
- 1:35:19and say that the text must be clear in
- 1:35:22two points. First, funding might
- 1:35:25indicate. Second, the significant
- 1:35:28financial gap continues to be barriers
- 1:35:31to the effective
- 1:35:33timely implementation of the NAPs.
- 1:35:36Operative paragraph three capture both
- 1:35:39and we want to see them stay.
- 1:35:43For small island developing developing
- 1:35:46state, the scale of the gap matter
- 1:35:50matters. When capacity is
- 1:35:53limited, a gap
- 1:35:56in finance mean plan that sit on on a
- 1:36:00cell inside of become
- 1:36:07you
- 1:36:11Thank you colleagues the exchange has
- 1:36:13helped clarify the level of support for
- 1:36:15the remaining formulations that we will
- 1:36:17work on with the secretariat.
- 1:36:19We have had some willingness to move
- 1:36:21towards more concise language on finance
- 1:36:24for adaptation while differences still
- 1:36:27remain on the financial gap.
- 1:36:31At this stage I now wish to suggest
- 1:36:34parties to also consult bilaterally so
- 1:36:37we can have bridging proposals for our
- 1:36:39next next and final consultation the
- 1:36:42fourth consultation
- 1:36:45and for now the third informal
- 1:36:47consultation is now suspended thank you.
- 1:36:52>> Thank you very much this is really
- 1:36:55fantastic we are learning by mistake.
- 1:37:00So as you have seen before getting into
- 1:37:03the
- 1:37:04description of our element as you have
- 1:37:06seen parties are always given priority
- 1:37:09before observer.
- 1:37:10So even observer write the flag and
- 1:37:12there is another party that immediately
- 1:37:14after rise the flag
- 1:37:16the observer the party get the
- 1:37:18precedence so
- 1:37:20and we are now moving any comment.
- 1:37:25>> Yes yes thank you
- 1:37:26yeah and I must say it's it's not so
- 1:37:28often that observers are being given the
- 1:37:31floor in informal consultation or
- 1:37:33contact groups because of lack of time
- 1:37:36mostly. And when an observer speaks it
- 1:37:39speaks on behalf of its constituency and
- 1:37:42not behalf of his own Bangladesh NGO for
- 1:37:46example would not say I speak on behalf
- 1:37:48of my NGO you speak on behalf of NGO or
- 1:37:52Yogo or
- 1:37:56Bingo where yeah so just to know you you
- 1:38:00you not be able to speak like parties
- 1:38:01can speak on behalf of their own
- 1:38:03parties, but an observer will only speak
- 1:38:05on behalf of its constituency.
- 1:38:09Um
- 1:38:11what?
- 1:38:12Gianluca.
- 1:38:14>> Thanks. Uh
- 1:38:18What should I
- 1:38:20What should I cover here?
- 1:38:31>> Yeah, sorry. Gianluca is multitasking.
- 1:38:34He's also working on some other steps,
- 1:38:36so
- 1:38:36>> the mandate to plus text.
- 1:38:39>> Yeah, they're already they have done the
- 1:38:41it
- 1:38:42it was already a second iteration of the
- 1:38:43text, so we it's from position to text.
- 1:38:46It's just to re-explain.
- 1:38:47>> So the
- 1:38:48uh the practice in the process is that
- 1:38:51uh
- 1:38:53in the in the first consultations
- 1:38:55parties are invited to express their
- 1:38:57views, positions, expectations
- 1:39:01for for the outcomes of of that
- 1:39:04consultation.
- 1:39:05Um normally that that can happen in one
- 1:39:09meeting. Sometimes many parties or group
- 1:39:11of parties want to intervene, so that
- 1:39:14may take also two meetings.
- 1:39:17Uh eventually all parties have expressed
- 1:39:21their views um
- 1:39:23[clears throat]
- 1:39:23and then that's when the the first
- 1:39:28ex efforts to capture all those views in
- 1:39:31a text
- 1:39:33takes place.
- 1:39:34After the meeting the co-facilitators
- 1:39:36with the all the co-chairs with the
- 1:39:38assistance of the secretariat start
- 1:39:40putting together
- 1:39:41the text. Um
- 1:39:44this can have different forms and
- 1:39:47shapes,
- 1:39:49can be
- 1:39:50all those views can be captured as
- 1:39:54bullet points, as a skeleton of a
- 1:39:57decision, can be more fully developed
- 1:40:00text, can have
- 1:40:02options, alternatives.
- 1:40:04Um
- 1:40:06and is developed by by the co-chairs and
- 1:40:08under their own authorities. Parties
- 1:40:11sometimes also send submissions by email
- 1:40:15so that so to be sure that that the
- 1:40:18co-facilitators
- 1:40:20receive the textual proposals
- 1:40:24accurately.
- 1:40:26The text is then put together
- 1:40:28as I said it can be a note can have
- 1:40:31different
- 1:40:33different titles or the nomination can
- 1:40:36be can capture
- 1:40:38can be a a summary, an informal note, a
- 1:40:41draft text and so on. This is
- 1:40:45normally web posted on the secretariat
- 1:40:48website so that parties have the
- 1:40:51possibility to review it and discuss it
- 1:40:54at the at the at the next consultation.
- 1:40:57Normally parties require sufficient time
- 1:41:02to digest the text, to consult
- 1:41:06in their groups and come up with the
- 1:41:09with the positions.
- 1:41:13>> Yeah, thank you. I just wanted to add
- 1:41:15something.
- 1:41:16You know,
- 1:41:18you you will hear the the co-chairs
- 1:41:20often say
- 1:41:21we call on your flexibility.
- 1:41:24It doesn't mean I mean
- 1:41:27the the the text that parties will agree
- 1:41:29upon it doesn't mean that each and
- 1:41:31individual party around the table agrees
- 1:41:33with all the elements in this text, but
- 1:41:36they will show flexibility
- 1:41:39because they they will be negotiating
- 1:41:43some other issues in another room. So
- 1:41:45they will say I show flexibility here,
- 1:41:47so I will get whatever I wanted in the
- 1:41:49other room and that that's how you come
- 1:41:53up with a compromise. It doesn't mean
- 1:41:55that you agree with everything. You have
- 1:41:57a red line as a delegation and and and
- 1:42:00you know that you cannot step over this
- 1:42:02red line, but whatever is on top of the
- 1:42:05red line, you can show some flexibility
- 1:42:08and you have to always go back to your
- 1:42:11capital to know
- 1:42:13how much, how close to the red line you
- 1:42:15will be able to go. But when you see a
- 1:42:17text agreed in a room, it doesn't mean
- 1:42:19that everybody is really
- 1:42:23comfortable with everything.
- 1:42:25Consensus doesn't mean they agree on
- 1:42:28everything. It means that they don't
- 1:42:30object to
- 1:42:32something.
- 1:42:33They can have reservation on something,
- 1:42:35but they they they will show flexibility
- 1:42:39in the spirit of compromise. That's what
- 1:42:42you will hear from them.
- 1:42:43They will they they agree on on the
- 1:42:47the conclusion or the decision that is
- 1:42:49in front of them.
- 1:42:51So it's very important that you know
- 1:42:53your red line, that parties know their
- 1:42:55red line,
- 1:42:56but that they also show that that that
- 1:42:58flexibility and they have to go in the
- 1:43:00corridor and talk to their partners
- 1:43:02because they are not opponents. You
- 1:43:04know, it's not because you're a
- 1:43:05developing country and you don't
- 1:43:07disagree with
- 1:43:09someone from a developed country that
- 1:43:12you cannot talk to each other and and
- 1:43:13try to understand where you're coming
- 1:43:15from. Why is it?
- 1:43:17And and and and try to work towards this
- 1:43:19consensus, this compromise. Thank you.
- 1:43:25>> Continue
- 1:43:26I covered them all.
- 1:43:30No, I I wanted to go back a second
- 1:43:32because I think it's extremely important
- 1:43:34to know where to find the documents. So
- 1:43:36on the UNFCCC website, you will always
- 1:43:39find the current session on top left. So
- 1:43:44if you open the website today, you will
- 1:43:45find COP COP
- 1:43:4831.
- 1:43:51A few months before June, you will find
- 1:43:53SB
- 1:43:5566.
- 1:43:57If you open the page
- 1:44:00now they're going to show it to you
- 1:44:01because it's extremely important to know
- 1:44:03where
- 1:44:04where to find all the documents. So
- 1:44:06you'll find the the conference, the
- 1:44:09current conference. In this case is COP
- 1:44:1131. If you open
- 1:44:13COP 31 top left, you'll find
- 1:44:17the
- 1:44:18the sessions. So COP 31 is is the short
- 1:44:22term for the UN Climate Change
- 1:44:23Conference in Antalya. By this session
- 1:44:27in this conference there are five
- 1:44:28sessions taking place. Three sessions of
- 1:44:31the governing bodies, COP, CMP and CMA,
- 1:44:34and two sessions of the subsidiary
- 1:44:36bodies.
- 1:44:39So here you find the latest documents,
- 1:44:43but so each session has
- 1:44:46is on agenda. For each agenda we have
- 1:44:49the auditorium. If you show the
- 1:44:50auditorium
- 1:44:52if you go down.
- 1:44:58For example, you'll see all the agenda
- 1:45:01items
- 1:45:03and for each agenda items you will find
- 1:45:06the precession documents and then you
- 1:45:09will find also the the various
- 1:45:11iteration. I mean not not not anymore.
- 1:45:14Now there are two distinct web page, one
- 1:45:17for the precession and one for the in
- 1:45:19session. So if you look for the in
- 1:45:22session page, you'll find the various
- 1:45:25iteration of the draft text in the
- 1:45:28corresponding agenda item.
- 1:45:37There was also here the the L documents.
- 1:45:40So basically once once the draft text is
- 1:45:44agreed in the informal consultations or
- 1:45:47contact groups, so so when when parties
- 1:45:50agreed that that text can be forwarded
- 1:45:54to the plenary for
- 1:45:56adoption, for agreement,
- 1:45:59that text gets
- 1:46:02gets turned in in what [snorts] we call
- 1:46:04L documents. L stays for
- 1:46:07limited distribution documents.
- 1:46:10So is a document that that gets
- 1:46:11translated in the six official languages
- 1:46:14of the UN. It has a document symbol. So
- 1:46:17when the document is presented to
- 1:46:19plenary for adoption, that document
- 1:46:22symbol is read out aloud.
- 1:46:26Parties will adopt it by consensus in
- 1:46:28plenary. That documents will have to be
- 1:46:32posted on the website before parties
- 1:46:35will be able to adopt it.
- 1:46:37So sometimes the plenary are are are are
- 1:46:41delayed because the L documents are not
- 1:46:43processed in time.
- 1:46:45So normally
- 1:46:46parties should adopt the L documents
- 1:46:49where they are translated in the six
- 1:46:51official languages, but there are
- 1:46:53situations like it will happen
- 1:46:55today where there are still negotiations
- 1:46:58ongoing. So the L documents will be
- 1:47:00prepared just few like one hour or maybe
- 1:47:03even during the session
- 1:47:06when the final plenary started. In that
- 1:47:10case
- 1:47:11the presiding officer asks the
- 1:47:13indulgence of parties to adopt the L
- 1:47:16documents only in English
- 1:47:18because the other the other versions
- 1:47:20will not be ready
- 1:47:21in time.
- 1:47:24>> Mhm.
- 1:47:27Um
- 1:47:28>> So
- 1:47:30language, verbs.
- 1:47:33Language is super important.
- 1:47:36Parties agree on text. Text captures the
- 1:47:39the
- 1:47:40the views of parties. Parties spend
- 1:47:42hours and hours
- 1:47:44negotiating and agreeing on what they
- 1:47:47want to say. So every verb has a
- 1:47:50different meaning. You'll see here some
- 1:47:53examples. You'll see the modal verbs
- 1:47:56may, should, and shall with their
- 1:47:58different
- 1:47:59legal meaning. May
- 1:48:01is to
- 1:48:03is to express a possibility or a
- 1:48:06permission. Should
- 1:48:08is a is an expectation of something that
- 1:48:11should happen. Shall is used to express
- 1:48:15an obligation.
- 1:48:17There also invitation, request,
- 1:48:22recommendation,
- 1:48:24urge.
- 1:48:25This also represent different level of
- 1:48:29you know how strong the request is. So
- 1:48:32it's from invite, request, recommends to
- 1:48:35urge which is the strongest.
- 1:48:44>> Yes, so that's why in your draft text
- 1:48:46you often see into brackets those
- 1:48:49different option like parties shall,
- 1:48:52should, will and
- 1:48:55this is what parties have to agree upon.
- 1:48:57So sometime you know you spent half an
- 1:48:59hour or more to agree on which correct
- 1:49:03verbs
- 1:49:04agreeable verbs you're going to you're
- 1:49:06going to work with. So you have also
- 1:49:08note which is a very low kind of you
- 1:49:12know okay the the the the cop noted that
- 1:49:15notes or notes with appreciation or
- 1:49:18notes with concern. So it you have a
- 1:49:20full palette of
- 1:49:23verbs that you can use
- 1:49:26depending on the on the level of
- 1:49:28of
- 1:49:29you know
- 1:49:31legally binding or importance that you
- 1:49:33want to
- 1:49:34put to into your text.
- 1:49:38No question?
- 1:49:39One there.
- 1:49:41>> Yes, thank you.
- 1:49:43[snorts] I was wondering if there if you
- 1:49:45have any
- 1:49:46official database kind of
- 1:49:49with
- 1:49:50definitions of those words because words
- 1:49:52can like differ in cultural contexts. So
- 1:49:57I mean those were only a few words of
- 1:49:59many.
- 1:50:01>> The secretariat
- 1:50:03does not have a compilation of official
- 1:50:06verbs or but they exist if you look them
- 1:50:10up online. Maybe we can also share them
- 1:50:12with the participants. There are there
- 1:50:14are some other organization that made
- 1:50:16available a compilation of the most
- 1:50:20commonly used verbs and
- 1:50:23and terms.
- 1:50:28>> Um
- 1:50:28question at the United Nations depending
- 1:50:32on the verb you would also have a
- 1:50:33financial obligation linked to this. So
- 1:50:36basically if it's requests there would
- 1:50:38be a funding line afterwards. Is this
- 1:50:41the same?
- 1:50:42>> It is it is the same it is the same.
- 1:50:46>> We we usually have
- 1:50:48a standard language for financial
- 1:50:50implication that says that activities
- 1:50:53mandated in this decision will be
- 1:50:56undertaken
- 1:50:59in
- 1:51:00subject to availability of funds. And at
- 1:51:03the very end at the closure of the of
- 1:51:06the session the last plenary the
- 1:51:08secretariat will report on all the
- 1:51:11financial implication that the the all
- 1:51:13the cost that are
- 1:51:19depending from associated with all the
- 1:51:21mandated activities. Yeah this is an
- 1:51:23important point that yeah
- 1:51:26you know there are a lot of mandates so
- 1:51:29and for for for the secretariat as well
- 1:51:32but it depends on you know if you say oh
- 1:51:35the SBI agreed to organize a workshop
- 1:51:38well this has a cost so
- 1:51:41that will be done only if there are
- 1:51:44subject to availability of funds yeah.
- 1:51:46>> But also
- 1:51:48during during the negotiation process
- 1:51:50the secretariat is also requested to
- 1:51:52provide the estimate of the budgetary
- 1:51:55implications of the mandates under
- 1:51:58discussion.
- 1:52:00So parties through the co-facilitators
- 1:52:02can request the secretariat to provide
- 1:52:05an estimate
- 1:52:06of
- 1:52:08of anything they are they are they are
- 1:52:10discussing.
- 1:52:12>> Before we close
- 1:52:13I know that we are in a hurry but we we
- 1:52:16we spoke of financial implication so So
- 1:52:19means that there was a substantive
- 1:52:21conclusion of decision adopted that
- 1:52:23parties agreed on a number of activities
- 1:52:26or considering issues etc.
- 1:52:28What happens if parties don't agree?
- 1:52:32After four meetings they still can't
- 1:52:34agree that the text is full of bracket.
- 1:52:36I it comes later. I thought we were
- 1:52:38closing. That's why you put me like
- 1:52:40Okay, so no. So we'll come back later.
- 1:52:46>> [snorts]
- 1:52:49>> So if there is no other Oh, one question
- 1:52:52please. Last one before the next round.
- 1:52:54>> Okay, simply I want to ask during the
- 1:52:58real negotiation sessions
- 1:53:01may we object to the observer to taking
- 1:53:05floor or we have to we have to accept
- 1:53:08and what are the consequences after that
- 1:53:11if we if we're not allowing the observer
- 1:53:14to talk?
- 1:53:15Thank you.
- 1:53:16>> Okay. So thank you for the question. So
- 1:53:19if it's a contact group
- 1:53:21observers are admitted in the contact
- 1:53:24group. Parties cannot object to them
- 1:53:26being in the in the room listening and
- 1:53:29if there is time
- 1:53:31they can take the floor at the end. It's
- 1:53:32like in the plenary.
- 1:53:37It is decided at the upfront of the
- 1:53:39informal consultation whether it will be
- 1:53:41open or closed. In principle it's a SBI
- 1:53:44recommendation the first and if there is
- 1:53:46no contact group established
- 1:53:48but the
- 1:53:50the consideration of an item will be
- 1:53:52done in in informal consultations only.
- 1:53:54The first and the last will be open
- 1:53:57except if one party objects.
- 1:54:01At least one party.
- 1:54:02So because
- 1:54:05I mean the process
- 1:54:08has to be transparent inclusive. It's
- 1:54:10it's the the the the basic the
- 1:54:12foundation of our process.
- 1:54:15In principle the first and the last
- 1:54:18informal consultation will remain open
- 1:54:20to all and if observers are in the room,
- 1:54:23and if time permits, um I'm not sure you
- 1:54:26really need to ask for permission for
- 1:54:29the for the observer to speak. You just
- 1:54:31ask no more parties wants to speak. We
- 1:54:34have a representative from constituency
- 1:54:36one to take the speak. I propose that
- 1:54:38they take the speak. If one party
- 1:54:40objects, then okay, no. But uh
- 1:54:43you know, if you don't want to be the
- 1:54:44fossil of the day, uh usually you leave
- 1:54:48the observer speak because the observer
- 1:54:50speak, but whatever they they say is not
- 1:54:53taken into account in the draft, right?
- 1:54:55It's only what parties say that is taken
- 1:54:57into account in the draft. But they can
- 1:54:59express their position and then they can
- 1:55:02lobby with parties, uh but in the room
- 1:55:05what they say will not be reflected in
- 1:55:07the text, okay?
- 1:55:10>> Thank you very much. In any case, any
- 1:55:12anytime the party object to the presence
- 1:55:14of the observer in the room, the
- 1:55:16observer will be requested to leave the
- 1:55:18room
- 1:55:18in informal consultation as just
- 1:55:20explained by Laurence.
- 1:55:22I have to apologize. We are
- 1:55:24out of time, so we don't have time for
- 1:55:26the last simulation so for the of the
- 1:55:29fourth in the formal consultation.
- 1:55:32But the the situation was that the party
- 1:55:34the group of party didn't agree to a
- 1:55:37final text which was I think EU opposed
- 1:55:40to the proposition of the other
- 1:55:43[laughter]
- 1:55:44group negotiation group to the text. So
- 1:55:46in that case, what happened that the
- 1:55:48co-facilitator invite the party that
- 1:55:51disagree to huddle in the room, so to
- 1:55:55convene in a corner and discuss among
- 1:55:57them
- 1:55:58and see if they can find a solution.
- 1:56:01There is also situation when we are
- 1:56:03running out of time and the there is the
- 1:56:06possibility for parties to work
- 1:56:09overnight in what we call informal
- 1:56:11informals which are not led and
- 1:56:13supported by the secretary usually
- 1:56:15unless requested by parties and is a
- 1:56:17space that the secretary provide to
- 1:56:19parties to work at the extra time with
- 1:56:22the hope that before the final round of
- 1:56:24the consultation they would be able to
- 1:56:27arrive to an agreement. So, what are the
- 1:56:29possible conclusion of the negotiation
- 1:56:32and I will leave it to Gianluca to
- 1:56:33explain.
- 1:56:38>> So,
- 1:56:42parties
- 1:56:43parties negotiate under an an an agenda
- 1:56:46item they have a mandate and work to
- 1:56:49deliver.
- 1:56:51There are instances where parties could
- 1:56:55can can
- 1:56:57can complete their work.
- 1:57:00So, they meet two, three, four times
- 1:57:03during one session and they agree on a
- 1:57:05text.
- 1:57:07In this case, the text can
- 1:57:10gets recommended to the plenary for for
- 1:57:14adoption.
- 1:57:16This is what we call substantive
- 1:57:18outcome. So, when parties agree on
- 1:57:21substance
- 1:57:24at the SB's substantive outcomes are are
- 1:57:28conclusions
- 1:57:29because the SB's can only agree on
- 1:57:31conclusions.
- 1:57:33These conclusions can all can also
- 1:57:35include
- 1:57:36draft text that are recommended to the
- 1:57:39governing bodies for adoptions.
- 1:57:42So, this is for for example this week
- 1:57:46the SB met
- 1:57:49the first week. They worked on draft
- 1:57:51text. Today there there will be the the
- 1:57:54closing plenary of the subsidiary bodies
- 1:57:57and the subsidiary bodies will agree on
- 1:58:00on certain conclusions that have
- 1:58:02attached draft decision that will be
- 1:58:06sent to the COP or to the CMA for
- 1:58:08adoption later tonight or next week.
- 1:58:12So, these are the substantive outcomes.
- 1:58:15There are also situations where parties
- 1:58:17meet, they work intensively, but they
- 1:58:20cannot they cannot finish work.
- 1:58:23They cannot finish the draft text they
- 1:58:26are requested to recommend or they
- 1:58:28cannot
- 1:58:30complete their conclusions. In this
- 1:58:32case, parties can agree on procedural
- 1:58:35conclusions. It's basically an agreement
- 1:58:39to continue work at at the next session
- 1:58:42or at a subsequent session.
- 1:58:45So parties agree to continue work and
- 1:58:47often they do so
- 1:58:49agreeing to continue work on the basis
- 1:58:52of the of the text they they've been
- 1:58:55working at a session.
- 1:58:57So for example today we we if you go to
- 1:58:59the plenary starting at 5:00 you will
- 1:59:02hear that the SBI for example agreed to
- 1:59:05continue work
- 1:59:06at the at the next session on the basis
- 1:59:09of the documents
- 1:59:11linked in that in that procedural
- 1:59:13conclusion. So at the next session work
- 1:59:16will continue not from zero but
- 1:59:19but parties will continue
- 1:59:21considering the draft text
- 1:59:24that they had this time.
- 1:59:27There can also be situation when parties
- 1:59:29cannot even agree on this procedural
- 1:59:32conclusion. They cannot even agree to
- 1:59:33continue work.
- 1:59:36Parties cannot agree on anything.
- 1:59:39In that case so if
- 1:59:42if under a
- 1:59:43certain agenda item there is no
- 1:59:45conclusion at all neither procedural nor
- 1:59:49substantive so in the absence of any
- 1:59:52conclusion or any agreement
- 1:59:55so there will be no outcome from from
- 1:59:58that item. In accordance to rule 16 the
- 2:00:01item will be included automatically in
- 2:00:03the in the agenda of the of the
- 2:00:06subsequent session.
- 2:00:08This is I mean is in red there is the
- 2:00:10cross this is the worst case scenario
- 2:00:13when parties have no agreement. So
- 2:00:16because in this case all work done at
- 2:00:19the session will not be carried over in
- 2:00:22the next session.
- 2:00:24So it means that work at the subsequent
- 2:00:25session will will start without parties
- 2:00:28having in front of them any text. It
- 2:00:31will have to start from scratch, from
- 2:00:33zero again. So, this is the worst case
- 2:00:35scenario
- 2:00:37that that the the presiding officers
- 2:00:41try in every possible
- 2:00:42way to avoid.
- 2:00:45Often the co-facilitators of the
- 2:00:47co-chairs ask the support of the SBI
- 2:00:50chair, of of the subsidiary chair to to
- 2:00:54intervene, to talk to parties, to try
- 2:00:57every possible effort to agree at least
- 2:00:59on procedural conclusions and and to
- 2:01:02save the current draft and and to
- 2:01:05continue at the next session.
- 2:01:07>> Um yeah, yeah. Um I I agree that rule 16
- 2:01:11is really is usually seen as a failure
- 2:01:14of the process, but sometimes you know
- 2:01:17it's better to start from scratch than
- 2:01:19start from a bad bad text. So, in some
- 2:01:22instances starting again from scratch
- 2:01:24maybe better than continuing on a bad
- 2:01:27text. But I hear we need to close.
- 2:01:30You didn't mention this forwarding to
- 2:01:32the governing bodies, which is something
- 2:01:34that happens
- 2:01:35usually at those session that are being
- 2:01:38convened in conjunction with the cops.
- 2:01:41There is a possibility that the SB, if
- 2:01:42they don't finish their their work in
- 2:01:44the week that is for them right now,
- 2:01:47they they they may seek further guidance
- 2:01:49from the presidency.
- 2:01:51It is it is
- 2:01:52not something it's something that should
- 2:01:54be
- 2:01:55not for everything that is not concluded
- 2:01:58because the second week is extremely
- 2:02:00crowded already, but it's really for
- 2:02:02critical issues that need to be agreed
- 2:02:05for the success of the conference or or
- 2:02:07really issues that are very political,
- 2:02:09then they will be
- 2:02:11brought to the second week for further
- 2:02:13guidance by the presidency. Thank you.
- 2:02:15>> Thank you very much. I would have time
- 2:02:17for another round of question and
- 2:02:19answer. I'm sorry, but feel free to send
- 2:02:21us by chat or by email. We'll be happy
- 2:02:23to to provide answer in in writing.
- 2:02:27We will also like to understand if you
- 2:02:30enjoy it, you find it useful.
- 2:02:32It's a format to repeat in future. There
- 2:02:36is a QR code on on the screen. Please
- 2:02:40you can either provide your feedback by
- 2:02:42email or if you want to use the QR code,
- 2:02:45but there is a head of state event which
- 2:02:47after us, so we have to really free the
- 2:02:50room. Thank you very much for your time.
- 2:02:52We would be happy to take a photo group
- 2:02:54outside, of course, if you are available
- 2:02:57for like 5 minutes more and then you
- 2:03:01you can go wherever you want in the cop.
- 2:03:04Thank you very much for being with us
- 2:03:06and many thanks also to the colleagues
- 2:03:08for contributing to this training.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of COP 31 Interactive negotiation lab by UNFCCC Global Climate Action, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 13,508 words across 2,466 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.